All episodes
Episode 93

Robert Breedlove: Understanding Time, Money and Bitcoin from First Principles (rerun) - E93

July 9, 202082 min

Robert and Brady discuss the synthesis of Robert's bitcoin studies, based on the works of others, most importantly The Bitcoin Standard by Saifedean Ammous. This discussion seeks to evaluate bitcoin and money from first principles.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Hey Bitcoiners, it's Brady. This week I'm going to rerun an episode, a fantastic one from the past. I was not able to get a new episode recorded this week for various reasons. It's been a particularly busy one. But I think this episode is an evergreen one that is a fantastic one to revisit if you've been listening to this feed for a long time and heard it in the middle of last year.

And if you're on the LTBN feed, this episode appeared before Citizen Bitcoin was being broadcast on the LTBN feed. This is episode 52 with Robert Breedlove. It's called Understanding Time, Money and Bitcoin from First Principles.

And it's one of those evergreen episodes. In fact, when people ask me, you know, which of your episodes should I listen to first when they're asking to check out my podcast. I usually point them to this one because it really lays down from the ground and up what money is, how money is a representation of time, and how Bitcoin is the best representation of time and money that we've ever had as human beings.

So it's a fantastic one. I think you'll really enjoy it. And before we dive in, just want to say thank you as always to Swan. Swan's support of this show really makes it possible for me to continue producing great Bitcoin podcast episodes. Thank you so much to the Swan and the incredible team there. Really proud to be a part of what we've got going on at Swan.

Check out SwanBitcoin.com for the best way to accumulate Bitcoin. Let's dive in.

Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Shout out to you wherever you are in the world. I hope you're well. It's a beautiful Friday afternoon here in Lawrence, Kansas. I'm looking forward to a lovely weekend as we welcome the fall season here in the US.

Before we get into today's episode with Robert Breedlove, I want to give a quick shout out to Bitcoin Dash Only.com. Bitcoin Only is an excellent one-stop shop for resources focused explicitly on Bitcoin only. Everything from books, podcasts, including this one, hardware, software, conferences, meetups, and more, that's Bitcoin-only.com.

Bookmark it, use it, share it. Alright, let's get into today's episode.

Robert Breedlove is the founder and CEO of Parallax Digital, an event-driven hedge fund and digital securities consultancy. In this episode, Robert and I discuss the synthesis of his Bitcoin studies based on the works of others, most importantly, the Bitcoin standard by Safedina Moose and others like Matt Ridley's The Rational Optimist, Talib's Skin in the Game, Boyapati's The Bullish Case for Bitcoin, and more.

This discussion seeks to evaluate Bitcoin and money from first principles, and is, I think, a good one to help crystallize your understanding as a Bitcoiner and to share with pre-coiners in your life. If you've been sent here by a friend or family member because you asked them about Bitcoin, you can also check out episode 34 of this podcast with Gigi, 21 Lessons from Down the Bitcoin Rabbit Hole.

It pairs well with this episode as a comprehensive introduction to Bitcoin. Alright, with that, let's dive into the discussion.

Alright, I'm really excited to welcome Robert Breedlove to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast today. How's it going, Robert? I'm good. Thank you for having me. Yeah, man. We met back at the Bitcoin 2019 conference at the rooftop beefsteak, which was just a special night that was really fun, had a good conversation that night.

Would you like to just introduce yourself, what you do, and you know, give us the quick Bitcoin story, how you found Bitcoin, and I'd love to know too if you like studied anything about money and time that we're about to dive into these topics we're about to dive into before you got into Bitcoin, or if you were inspired by Bitcoin and directed by it to study that stuff.

Sure. Yeah, I think that party in San Francisco was awesome. We ate way too much steak, and then I think we had ribeye for dessert as well. Drank some people from me. Rendered fat all over that ribeye was like the perfect dessert. Yeah. Yeah, shout out Christian at CK Snarks and host of the POV Crypto Podcast and at home slice on Twitter for hosting and then cooking up that incredible feast.

Such a good time. Yeah, so quick background on me, I guess, as it relates to today's conversation, is actually as a kid, I was always really fascinated with the stars. I don't know, I just always had a very grand sense of wonder looking up at them. So at about the age of 11 or 12, I started reading everything I could about astrophysics, just trying to understand what the hell it all was.

And that, you know, in retrospect, sort of sparked my interest in physics and time and all these grand concepts that we exist in. Fast forward to college, I have my undergraduate and master's degree in accounting and finance.

I was a CPA for a number of years. Early in my career, I did some tax consulting for high net worth individuals and investment partnerships. I then struck out on the entrepreneurial path and was a CFO for a number of early to mid-stage companies, mostly in the technology sphere.

And then my path into Bitcoin is a little different in that I had heard about it in 14, I had invested a little bit, you know, bought it a couple hundred bucks, sold it a few hundred, thought I was a genius, but never for whatever reason didn't take the time to dig into it and study it and have the light bulb moment.

But in late 16, I actually started studying Ethereum pretty closely, and the concept of smart contracts that you know Ethereum was mostly at that time at least, was based on. And my light bulb moment was the entire, especially after reading like Zabo's piece, which was written in the 90s on smart contracts.

The realization that the entire finance industry is an intermediary function and that it is essentially a smart contract with human beings on top of it. I was like, oh wow, you know, this is this wave of innovation is going to be a really big deal.

So made some heavy investments into Ethereum and Bitcoin and sort of you know some of the top-weighted market cap weighted crypto assets in late 16, early 17, 17 went crazy. And where my money went, my mind followed, and the more closely I studied the space, as I think is true with most people, the more of a Bitcoin maximalist or rationalist I became.

Realizing that Bitcoin stands to capture the vast majority of the value created in this wave of innovation. Then in that process became you know much more studious of money and its history and its origins and whatnot.

You know, diving deep into Austrian economics, and there's this you know realization that sort of emerged that you know money and time are the same thing. I like to say that money is our metaphor for time, and that's sort of inspired some of my recent writings.

Yeah, and that's great. And today we are going to go through the idea of time, money, and bring it all back to Bitcoin. So you've written some great threads on Twitter. Everybody should be following, listening should be following you on Twitter. It's at BreedLove22.

There's a great thread, a re more recent one that's pinned to the profile, and I'll make sure that I get links into the other threads or roles, like unrolls of them at least. So yeah, money as a metaphor for time. Time is the scarcest asset that humans have, you know, arguably until Bitcoin, and that Bitcoin is maybe on par with it at least.

But it's it is the scarce asset humans have from first principles from from time immemorial. I suppose that may change at some point if we discover immortality, but right now that's a fundamental truth of human nature. And time is part of the definition of money. It's like you said, a metaphor of money. So we need to start here talking about time to understand the nature of money.

So let's dive into time and how it relates to our experience as humans. Yeah, I like I opened my recent piece by saying that time scarcity is our ultimate tyrant. And what I mean by that is that you know, individually the finite lifespan that we all have, right?

We're all mortal, we all have limited on earth. And every decision we make has trade-offs, right? We can't do everything. We can choose to do this, but it's at the expense of not doing everything else. The one liberating force from this tyrant of time scarcity is innovation.

And innovation can be thought of as kind of like the cumulative social learnings within a society that actually allow us that increase our productivity, which allow us to create greater results with the least amount of effort. And it's basically by fostering an environment that contributes to productivity growth that everyone's life becomes better and easier, right?

We less effort needs to be applied to satisfy our wants, needs, and desires. And this is really that is the essence of economics is creating greater results with less efforts. And to do that as people, it's an it's we can only do it basically by specializing and trading.

So that each of us can become really adept at our chosen craft and then rely on others to do the same. And then we by trading, we both benefit from one another's specialized knowledge and capabilities.

So in that process, sort of an emergent property of this trade between people is money, right? We have trade has these sort of inherent problems called the lack of coincidence of wants or what I call the non-coincidence of wants.

In that what you have to trade is not always necessarily desired by the person that has what you want,

Right. So you're trading oranges and they have trucks. Maybe they don't want oranges or you don't have enough, or truck can't be divided deeply enough. So money resolves these issues related to trade. And in that sense, money is this vital lubricant to trade, it allows people to exchange things much more easily across time and space.

And in fact, that's really money at its essence is just that the technology for moving value across time and space. So

Time in that way is in a very like basic sense, it's this grand paradox of nature. So, like we call it the healer of all wounds, but it's also the destroyer of all things, right? And it's in time that all of our human action occurs, and the flow of time itself is the most objective experience we all have, right?

They're all right distributed to us all equally, rich and poor alike. We all have this equality of flow of time, and time scarcity again individually is absolutely scarce as expressed in our limited lifespans, and also collectively as a society, our time scarcity manifests itself as the total time we have to allocate towards serving one another in terms of making goods, providing services, or gaining knowledge.

So, what we call society is the sum of all these services we provide for one another, yeah. And all of these acts necessitate the use of natural resources. So the finite nature of time collectively is the total time we have available to allocate towards production.

Okay, yeah, that makes perfect sense. So that's, I mean, and that's basically the idea of economy is how efficiently we use that time towards serving one another. That's exactly right. And it's very common, you know, we commonly say that gold is scarce or this natural resource is scarce, but ultimately it is time itself that constrains us.

The price of all natural resources throughout history has steadily declined in terms of time necessary to produce them because our productivity continues to increase, right? The more we trade, the more we specialize, the more we learn, the less expensively in terms of time we can produce these natural resources.

Time is really the ultimate bottleneck that we're dealing with in terms of productivity. So we are literally driven to alleviate this time scarcity, and we find ways to do this by you know using natural resources in an in an ever-efficient way.

We just keep we're driven to improve the efficiency of how we use these natural resources, and at the base of which is you know the base resources time itself. Exactly. And I really like a again, gold is good evidence of this fact that the annual new supply flow of gold more or less increases every year, and gold is one of the rarest natural resources on earth.

So to say that any other natural resource is scarce in many practical sense doesn't really make sense because you have here is the rarest natural resource or among the rarest natural resources on earth, and its annual supply flow is increasing. So if that is true, then everything that is less scarce than gold is necessarily even less scarce than time.

Again, the ultimate bottleneck. So

As we like try to liberate ourselves from this tyrant of time scarcity, we're naturally developing trade relationships with one another that give us more free time to specialize and innovate and to increase our productivity further.

So and these it's interesting because this acts of trade they actually form the fabric of society, they interconnect us into these economic networks that increase our productivity because of our inherent comparative advantages, right? We're all born different and unique.

Among everyone, there's this huge diversity of skills, experience, and know-how that nature has sort of given us, and by trading and specializing, we're allowed to take advantage of these comparative advantages, if you will.

That makes it it's really I think an important endeavor, or like it's incumbent upon Bitcoiners to go through this process, which you have done and many Bitcoiners have done, but I think you've done a great job of really distilling it down and making it clear.

From very first principles, we have to understand that you know money is about preserv or making the most of our time. It's about being, yeah, that's it. It's about making the most of our time. And so when you have a money that is not scarce, like time is, and is able to be manipulated and controlled by other humans, they're literally robbing the value of your time from you.

That's exactly right. It's you know, and we'll get into that a little further here, but time theft, right? Anytime you manipulate a money theft, they're stealing time straight out of your back pocket. I like to say that it's very common knowledge.

People always say time is money, you know, like in work or whatever. But I don't know that people necessarily understand that the reciprocal is also true. Money is time. That's exactly it's a reflection of time, essentially. You know, it takes we sacrifice our time, we go to work to generate value and earn money, and then we can then redeem that money for commensurate sacrifices from others.

So literally money is just this token we're we're using to transact our time among one another. Yeah, and among many other red pill moments in Bitcoin, this is probably the most important red pill that Bitcoin serves us, is teaching us what money really is, and that money is time, right?

And that the it everything is at stake. Like the most important thing is at stake here. And that's why Bitcoin is so serious, like and so important. And we need to understand this is not just like a game that we're playing against a banking system or tr a payments network that is better than Visa or PayPal.

This is about taking control of your time. Yes, this is a revolution at the foundational level of economics. You know, the Austrians call this dynamic the division of labor, which is essentially a fancy way of saying that in producing something by individually being able to focus on a smaller piece of that, right?

If we're producing pencils, I can specialize in producing a lead, you can specialize specialize in producing maybe the wood, someone else can specialize in producing the rubber, that each of us can figure out how to do that more cheaply, and then by trading and combining our efforts, we can deliver more pencils per man hour basically than we could creating it entirely ourselves.

So this dynamic, this division of labor basically allows us to create time savings. We're doing more with less time, and which is another way of saying we've increased our productivity, and using those time savings, we can either produce the same amount in less time, we can produce a greater, I'm sorry, the same amount in less time, we could produce a greater amount of pencils, say in the same time, or we could choose to use those time savings it generates that the division of labor generates to innovate

Further, right? To find an even cheaper way to make rubber or wood or lead. And so another way that money is time is you can think of it as a reflection of the time savings created by the division of labor. So again, it is like it is a token of the time savings we are creating by specializing in trading.

Right. And in a society that you know it's a recursive sort of phenomenon and it basically increases the availability of time for you know each unit of value that we consume for the whole society. And we all kind of benefit and become more and more productive as as a society we you know achieve through this iteration the civilization that we built now and it yeah yeah it seems clear that you know bitcoin's gonna level take us to the next level and show us how much more efficient we can actually be yeah you know not many

Of us realize it but that is the entire purpose of society to just foster an environment that allows the division of labor to proliferate right we have stable rule of law we have private property rights and in an ideal society we have a stable monetary policy frankly and once people know the rules of the game right and they're they're voluntarily entered into they are reliable over time then smart people figure out how to play the game best but if the rules are constantly changing right if private property rights are subject

To change if monetary policy is being manipulated if the rule of law benefits one group more than it benefits another then you're on you're disabled from playing the game well, right? Could you imagine trying to play if the hands changed every as far as the hand rankings changed every hand?

Like it was just impossible. And we in the US at least, we have relatively stable rule of law. We have superiorly secure private property rights, other than monetary policy, which is itself a violation of private property rights.

Anytime a group can produce new money, right, and give it to a select few, they are violating the private property rights of everyone else. If we think of money as sort of this list of who owns what, right, because money is just a gateway to buy anything else, any other good or service.

If someone can manipulate that list and say, you now have less, I now have more. You know, I, politician, bureaucrat, banker, have newly printed money, you now have less in the form of inflation, basically, they have changed the rules of the game. They are shifting that list in their favor.

And that it just disintegrates society. And we've seen it happen time and time again throughout history, where once a ruler starts to debase its coin, or you know, basically inflate the supply or or reduce the precious metal content in a coinage, people like society starts to fall apart.

No one can rely on the rules of the game anymore, so it's hard for people to cooperate and support this division of labor on which we all depend. Right. And the conceit that the idea that we can improve the function of money with intervention, human intervention and management, is you know, it's it's it's all it it's very human in the sense that it's just beyond what's the word I'm looking for?

It's pompous, it's arrogant, you know. It belies any explanation. Like it well, I we have an explanation for it, I guess, but it is yeah, it it makes everything less efficient, and then we have this you know discovery that humans have made in money that does all of this without any human you know intervention at all.

And just like Hayek said, we had to find a sly roundabout way to take money back for the people, to literally you know take it back from being co-opted. And he didn't know what that was, but he was very prescient. And 30 years later, you know, Satoshi gave us Bitcoin as a way to take money back. Absolutely.

And you know, today it's we're all operating under this illusion that government paper just is money and that without government authority that money couldn't exist, like it's some sort of unique technology. But really I think what contributes to the enigma that is money is sort of twofold.

One, you know, government and central bank, the just put it lightly, they're in bed together, right? So if you go to college today, you can get a PhD in economics at Harvard, right? The top of the line education you can get. You're not going to hear one peep about Austrian economics or the origins of money.

They actually come from this perspective that government is almost like God. It doesn't suffer any opportunity costs. There are no trade-offs to its decisions. It is just the be-all end all of the economic order. And as we know, in reality, that's just it's total bullshit, frankly.

Government is just another entity pursuing its own self-interest. And it just so happened that it's used its monopoly on violence to control the money supply to its own benefit. Which has happened over and over through human history. Yeah. And we can. And you I think you've written some about about this, you know, through your examination of the history of money.

Yeah. That's why. Do you feel like it's oh yeah, okay, let's talk about gold. But do you feel like it's time to dive into money and examine it a little closer now that we've sort of established, I think, the importance of time and it's the impact of stealing that time and by manipulating the money and all of that. Yeah, it flows directly into gold, actually, because the reason gold was decided as money on the free market is because its annual new supply flow is the hardest to increase.

So it's its supply is the hardest to inflate. Said another way, its annual new supply flow most closely reflects that irreversible, irreproducible, impersonal flow of time. So literally, it is the objective measurement system that we used to measure all to everything else, which valuations themselves are inherently subjective.

So you need something objective to measure something that is subjective. And sort of an analogy there is imagine if the meter or the foot, right, were subject to change all the time. How could you build a table? How could you build a house? How could you communicate with other engineers?

If that unit of measurement is subjective or subject to change, it erodes your ability to perform long-term planning, you know, economic or otherwise. And so it is this that that precise deterministic relationship between gold, you know, it's it's basically it's high stock to flow ratio, which is means it's virtually indestructible, it's very rare in the Earth's crust, so it's supply inflates slowly, is most closely reflective historically of time, the you know, absolutely scarce flow

Of time, and that is exactly why gold became money on the free market. The problem with gold specifically is that it's it's physical. Now this gives it advantages and disadvantages. Gold being physical, it is basically when you hold a piece of gold, you have physical possession of gold is 100% equity and zero percent debt.

So said differently, that the possessor of gold is presumed to be its rightful owner. There's no other yeah, it's a bearer asset, exactly. Right, there's no other counterparty to that transaction that can, if I flip you a gold coin, there's no authority in the world that can reverse it or say it didn't happen, or reduce its value, or inflate its ply, or censor the transaction.

It's just it's again 100% asset that I'm transferring to you that no one else can do anything about. So physicality gives gold this self-sovereignty. And in fact, even though we think you know, government money is the money we use today, what actually underpins government and central bank sovereignty are their gold holdings.

That is the reason they are able to monopolize money. That's how they protect their fiat currencies from competition with gold, just by holding, I think central banks hold about 16% of the global gold supply, so they can manipulate the price.

The drawback to gold's physicality is that it's more easy to manipulate, right? We've seen governments confiscate it in the past here in the U.S. There was Executive Order 6102 in the wake of-

Shout out 6102 on Bitcoin and Bitcoin only, Bitcoin Dash only.com. And you know, again, under the threat of violence and/or imprisonment, you had you were forced legally to surrender your gold to the government for fiat currency at a price they determine.

So despite all of the like anti-gold propaganda or the lack of education as to money, it's like all you need to do is look at the actions of government throughout history, and we see that they've they've basically co-opted the prime monetary sovereignty layer of Earth, which is gold.

So the again, the physicality of gold gives it these distinct advantages that it has its own sovereignty, but it's also the flip side of that is that it is more easy to confiscate, harder to transport, harder to secure, things of that nature.

It's also harder to verify. The pro the verification process itself centralizes over time. It's expensive to verify that you know you have atomically pure gold. It has it has what Zabo calls unforgeable costliness. Gold does. I mean, it's because you it's unforgeable, it's you can't transmute any material or you know into gold, although it's been tried, and people have said that they could for a long time, which is also basically what altcoiners are.

Yeah, so verification is key, and one of the you know aspects of Bitcoin definitely beats beats gold in is that it's cheap to verify. You know, you can run a fly for very cheap. Coinage started for that very reason, right? Gold is difficult to say or verify, like you don't know how pure it is, you don't know necessarily the weight.

So the public stamp basically of whatever ruler's face they put on a coin was verifying that this is one ounce of gold or this is whatever weight of gold. And then that sort of moved the trust into the public sphere, which was then violated inevitably by rulers over time, right?

They would continue issuing these coins that say it's one ounce of gold, but they themselves would you know engage in a practice called coin clipping, where they would periodically gather all the coins of the citizens, melt them down, re reissue them, still saying it's a gold coin with one ounce of gold in it, but it would in fact have say 0.9 ounces of gold, and they would clip off 10% of the value for themselves, like keeping the precious metal content for themselves.

So this is, and that was you know, one of the earliest versions of inflation where you saw public rulers siphoning wealth off of their citizenry through monetary inflation. So this transitions well into the idea of sovereignty.

And yeah, you want to take it take us through the idea of sovereignty as it relates to money in Bitcoin? Yeah, yeah. So again, gold is self-sovereign in the sense that it's a bearer asset, its credibility and value as money are derived from the combined sovereignty of all the self-interested individuals exercising free choice in the marketplace.

If we really think about that word sovereignty, it means the authority to act as you see fit, basically, the authority and capability. So when people and you know deciding in a free market, freely decide that gold is money, through sort of a game theoretic process, they are imbuing that commodity, gold in this case, with their collective sovereignty.

That's what gives physical gold this self sovereign dimension. And you know, in that way, I like to say that gold was it's the monetary materialization of popular sovereignty, which is what you know the founding principle of this country, frankly, right? Of the democratic system, that each individual should be able to decide what rules are best for them, and then the kind of majority rules, right?

Which is what free market is. Right in principle, but not practice. Exactly. So found on the principle, but you know, Andrew Jackson, which is a Tennessean, an early American president, called him the American Lion. He fought tooth and nail against the reinstantiation of central banks because they it had been seen what central banking had done in Europe in the past, and it was a large reason for the United States rebelling and succeeding from England.

Yeah, and you know, just kind of human nature over time. I think it took three attempts before the central bank in the United States was established, and it was it was after Jackson's presidency, but this is not like a new thing. We're all not just like waking up saying, hey, central banking doesn't work, and you know, identifying it as a it's really the last bastion of socialism in the free world, frankly.

You have centrally planned money. We would not accept this in any other industry on earth. So why do we tolerate it with money? But the stakes are just so high because if you control the money supply, you control everyone, right? Right, and the United States today is kind of the central bank of the world, they have I think what the guys wrote in this new book, the little little Bitcoin book they call the dollar hegemony, where because we have this disproportionate advantage in which all currencies are basically you know, we central bank controls Swift,

We control the payment network, etc. Etc. We are able to inflate the supply of money and tax the globe effectively to benefit the United States at the expense of everyone else. So that's sort of a long tangent, but basically, the sovereign in that respect, if we think of the sovereignty of gold, which central banks still hold today, actually provides the sovereignty of this country and the central bank.

They're actually usurping the sovereignty from physical gold for themselves to then in turn used to wield over people, right? And say you can't own gold, you have to use these dollars, you have to pay taxes on these dollars. It's a very perverse situation.

And I don't, you know, a few people realize it, but today gold in that sense is still sort of prime money. Gold is the main thing because central banks they still settle in gold, right? Right, and when you make a payment in gold, because it's a 100% asset, 0% liability, it's the only way to finally extinguish a debt.

So if you pay someone in dollars to pay a debt, you that person that receives the money still has to trust in the currency issuer that they're not going to inflate the supply, they're not gonna deauthorize the hundred dollar bills or whatever you give them. There's still a liability associated with that money, but it's only with gold or other bearer assets that there is no counterparty risk, and that's a very important point when it comes to money.

It's that's absolutely vital. And I'm just gonna do a little shout out to Jack Mallers from the Zap team, the leader of the Zap team. He announced this week that they've created a service called Olympus that onboards people onto Lightning Network with from Fiat in about five seconds.

Maybe you take a minute but the actual like process itself once you have entered your debit card and pressed a button you in about five seconds you get a lightning wallet and can spend it right away. At his talk at Bitcoin twenty nineteen Jack talked about the incredible innovation of lightning the zero to one moment of lightning is that we've created near instant final settlement with lightning because we have a bearer asset that settles instantly and is you know pegged one to one to the blockchain can be can be finally settled to the blockchain at any

Moment so it's just as good as as final settlement is it's it's amazing so that that's the innovation Lightning brought so yeah I think that Jack deserves a shout out and congrats to the Zap team and like you're just you guys are just killing it. Like I think it's super important what what they released this week. Yeah that is a totally amazing we you know without jumping ahead of ourselves that is never happened or we've never had an instantly settleable self common asset which is just un amazing so yeah okay back on back on track but I w definitely wanted to pause for that so

I going back into that and then we hit this sort of flows into Bitcoin and that whether we realize it or not, and I think this is at the root of so many problems in society and culture is that we have surrendered our individual sovereignty to these unaccountable institutions like central banks and governments.

And in doing so, we're giving up conscious control over our lives, over our time, right? If you think of money again as just a technology for moving value across time and space, we can think of fiat currency as having a technology backdoor.

It literally allows the issuer, the government, the central bank, to pull value out of it persistently all the time. Yeah. If someone can pull value out of your money,

You are they are literally extending your working life, right? You have to work more to get to retirement or get to whatever you're aiming for economically. And in this like this institutionalized system of time theft is it's a scourge on humanity. Institutionalized system of time theft.

I love that. And it is if you really think about what time theft is, you know, I there's there's a big history there, let's just say in humanity, people stealing time from others. So I'll let you draw your own conclusions as to what that might be, but it the realization, I think, is that human action is the essence of sovereignty.

And if we're going to improve our lives, it's not going to come from the government. No one's gonna do it for you. You have to do it yourself. You have to make decisions in the free market for yourself that benefit you, and that again, the beautiful thing about a free market is that in pursuing your own self-interest, you can actually create and further the collective interest through the division of labor and productivity.

So against this usurpation of our individual sovereignty by government, thankfully, it's such an amazing time to be alive. We have now we have hope in the emergence of this innovation called the internet. And I like to think of the internet as this universal exchange engine for knowledge.

It's already democratized so many aspects of our lives, and I think you know, I believe it's gonna continue doing so. And frankly, Bitcoin, which is can be thought of as the latest layer in the internet. The internet itself is this stack of open source protocols for moving information, and Bitcoin is basically the fifth layer in that stack that does the exact same thing, except it moves value instead of just information.

And Lightning would be the sixth layer then

On top of that. Exactly, yes, that's exactly right. So, like coming into the 21st century, you know, right out of the gate, we had this huge the Great Recession in 2008, which is just the latest expression of the problems that fiat money creates and exacerbates, this boom and bust business cycle.

A good analogy there is like it, you know, fiat currency is like a drug to the economy, right? You inject all this artificial liquidity, which is just redistributing claims on productive assets. You're not adding any new value to an economy when you print money.

Right? Just everyone needs to get that through their head. When you print money and give it to a few at the expense of the many, you've just shifted control over productive assets. Japan is a great example of this, right? They've been in stagflation for over two decades. They've been in perpetual quantitative easing, and all that's happened as a result is the government now owns, I think 70% of their ETFs.

So they're the canary in the coal mine for this whole experiment and fiat monetary policy. And every other advanced economy in the world is headed in the same direction. So again, coming to the 21st century, we had this really nasty recession right out of the gate. And you know, thankfully, this the godhead of Bitcoin, this genius Satoshi Nakamoto, mysterious guy, gal, or people, whoever they are,

Ingeniously put together, pulled together these two key inceptors for a digital hard money, like a digital self-sovereign money. And the first was gold, using gold as a guiding element, which again is this ancient prevailing monetary sovereignty layer of Earth, it represented an unmanipulable money supply, which is key.

Again, like the rule of law or private property rights, it needs to be something that people can't manipulate, because if they can, they will, right? Human greed is is inevitably inevitably takes hold. And then the internet, yeah, it's irresistible. And then the internet itself, which again is this ultimate engine of exchange, provides this global interconnectivity, which is for you know a digital hard money is global liquidity.

So by combining and building upon the economic properties of gold, its unminutable money supply, and the internet, global interconnectivity, Bitcoin is this momentous monetary innovation. He Satoshi has created a money that has achieved the divisibility, portability, durability, and recognizability of information, and he has combined it with the absolute scarcity of time, which is even you know superior even to the supply of gold, its representation of time.

So it is in the same way that the internet gives us this freedom to kind of express and absorb ideas and knowledge without obstruction, which has impacted so many aspects of our lives. Bitcoin gives us the freedom to express and receive value in a hard money that cannot be stopped or manipulated.

So this is truly one of the greatest inventions of our lives. Yeah, it's it's going to usher in the Bitcoin renaissance. Just as gold pay, you know, the Florin and the Ducat as Michael Goldstein mentioned on last week's podcast, drove the renaissance of Europe in the 15 and 1600s.

This return to a self-sovereign bearer asset, basically the ideal form of money that we could conceive of at this point in human history, the most efficient. We will see a boon to the society of humans on this planet that we haven't seen maybe probably ever just because we have so much innovation stacked up at this point, 500 years after the European Renaissance, that that there's just potential waiting to be unleashed and Bitcoin's going to unleash it.

I completely agree. And again, the arc of human commercial history, if you will. Say we've been having money roughly 5,000 years. The first 4900 of those we used free market money. Whatever ver whatever version that came in, whether it was seashells or cattle or salt, you know, ultimately gold, once the globe became sufficiently interconnected with telecommunications technology and such.

Umly the pat we have to always remember like you gotta zoom out. A lot of people say zoom out, and I love that phrase because zoom out to see that only the past 100 of 5,000 years have we had this weird, illusory, surreptitious time thieving money we call fiat currency.

So yeah, exactly. Like, I mean, there were governments and central authorities in the past that would coin clip and debase the money, but it was not this utterly unbacked fiat, completely fiat government money that we have now. They this is the first time in human history that we've taken it completely away from the idea of gold, the money supply of gold.

Like you know, it just doesn't need like there's no like reference rate. Last thing when they we have severed the skin in the game, right? Severed the skin in the game, yeah. Incentives and disincentives that maintain a free market equilibrium or shelling point to a form of money, which gold was that has been artificially severed and manipulated.

We can now produce gold or produce fiat currency at zero cost, but then the government can turn around and sell it. Say they produce it at five cents or two cents and they're selling it at a dollar, right? That skin in the game is necessary for most natural systems to operate to function well, and we have broken that in money today.

And I think Bitcoin is just a reversion to the natural order of things, right? We're reverting back to hard money. So it's yeah, again, really exciting time to be alive. Yeah, and this particular moment is is interesting, and I think we'll look back on it you know, in a bit from a Bitcoin future as an important inflection point in Bitcoin's history because we're about to go through a halving in you know, April or May of next year, it looks like that will reduce gold's inflation rate to I'm sorry, reduce Bitcoin's inflation rate to that of gold's, roughly.

For so we'll for the first time ever have, you know, direct competition with gold for the hardest asset on the planet. And then in 2024, the for the first time in human history we'll have a hard asset that's that's you know a lot less than gold's inflation rate.

That's correct. Yeah, I think for the listeners, the inflation rate's sort of commonly understood, and I think it's easiest to think of monetary hardness is defined by the stock to flow ratio, which is just the inverse of the inflation rate. So gold today, I think it's stock-to-flow ratio, which is the highest of any monetary metal is around 55 to 60.

As you alluded to in May 2020 or shortly thereafter after Bitcoin's next halving, it will be right around the same around 55 to 60. And then in the next halving in 2024, it will double again. So we will be in completely uncharted waters with a monetary asset that has a stock to flow ratio twice that of gold.

And it keeps doubling from there. You know and then frankly when the last Bitcoin is produced sometime in the mid 22nd century, that's it. There is no more Bitcoin. It is absolutely scarce. It's done it has a stock to flow ratio of infinity. And you know that is it's just really hard to imagine the impact of that on society.

Yeah. Yeah it'll be hard to imagine it's gonna be some kind of like Star Trek world or something. You know we'll be roaming the stars with basically you know abundant you know resources and time and energy and technology will just be exponential advancement upon exponential advancement we'll be yeah we'll be out there among the stars that that you were looking up at and daydreaming about as a boy and you know I was the same way man I was the same way.

Yeah I you know I hope we get there I think a simple way to relate this to people that are new is that you know we're used to today prices going up every year, which is that is taxation via inflation. I think I mean again it's sort of the smoke and mirrors thing where you don't realize you just think it's the natural order of things, right?

Oh, prices just increase. I don't know, my health insurance goes up, food cost goes up, gas goes up every year, I'm making the same but spending more. That is the shadow tax we call inflation. But that is not normal. Money again, as we become more productive as a society, we can produce more good, more goods or services per unit of time, prices should naturally decline, right?

And in fact, that's what they did when we had hard money standard around the world. Prices of things decline as we become more productive. So this has you know, just you can just ask anyone like would you prefer to live in a world where prices increase every year, or would you prefer to live in a world where prices decrease every year?

And you know, naturally people want prices to decrease, it makes your life better, but it also has this interesting effect that it makes you think longer term, right? It actually what they call the Austrians call time preference, it lowers your time preference. Because if I know I can buy the car, you know, next year 10% less than it is this year, then I'm gonna think more about saving my money and deferring my consumption so that I can get it more cheaply next year.

And if when you spur savings in that way, you're actually creating the bedrock for investment as well, because that saved capital is reinvested into productive projects that are expected to generate a return in excess of the productivity gains that are inherent to the hard money society.

So that like it is so deeply ingrained in our mental machinery and our attitude on life, the way we think about and approach reality, you know, Bitcoin literally stands to transform that. And you know, one of the things we touched on the Great Recession a little bit and how fiat currency fed into that, but another important aspect of money is that it is this it's an economy's informational utility, meaning that it is the it's a touchstone to measure the value of time that went

Into creating something, you know, a good service or knowledge even in combination with the time savings that it's expected to enable in the future, right? So if I buy a hunting rifle, I'm the price of that rifle is a reflection of how much more productive it makes me at hunting.

How many more deer can I kill per hour using that rifle than I can using a rock? All right, that is the price of that rifle. So when you manipulate a money supply, and there's a like a backdoor as there's in fiat currency, the objectivity of this informational utility that money is is compromised.

It distorts the price signal, and this makes, you know, as entrepreneurs are trying to plan for their business or their lives, this makes their economic calculations less reliable and just distorts the price signals. And if you think of the price signal as sort of the navigational instruments that a pilot would use to fly a plane, that's what entrepreneurs use to guide their actions in an economy.

And when you distort that, you cause people to overborrow, misallocate capital, and ultimately waste time. So by taking that opportunity away, that opportunity for a centralized entity to manipulate price signals, you increase the clarity for entrepreneurs through through time and space to be able to operate and plan over longer time horizons.

And that itself drives innovation and it reduces and mitigates this boom and bust business cycle that again we think is the natural order of things, but it's total bullshit. It's created by central bank monetary policy. So I think that's very exciting as well. Because you know, you just see people living so much in this world, paycheck to paycheck, and they feel like like you know, slaves to the system, and in in some ways they kind of are because they're having time stolen out of their back pocket constantly and surreptitiously.

So to just imagine a world where prices are declining every year, the economy as a whole is less debt centric, you know, or what is global debt to GDP today? 300% or something, it's it's doesn't make sense. It sounds about right. It's messy. And it's not, I mean, it's just accelerating.

All these things that people know, right? People know that debt is bad. People know that savings is good. People know that being long term oriented is better than short term. These are all natural intuitions or inclinations, but for some reason we've completely ignored them at the macroeconomic level. And again, like Bitcoin just pulls us back into reality.

Yeah, I mean, we've ignored them because of Keynesianism and the monoculture of thought that it has perpetrated and perpetuated around the world. And it's yeah, it's just spread that idea. And now we have I yeah, I like to say Austrian economics has sort of survived this Keynesian Armageddon, you know, as this critique.

But it's only been sort of kept alive by just a very small group of people around the world. And with Bitcoin, we have a real world real world implementation of the Austrian ideas of money that we've been talking about this whole episode, and that is what is showing us what real money is because you know we are generations into this, several generations into this kind of fiat world.

And we you know, I agree that we have those intuitions, but they're disappearing. Like, you know, the those ideas that I heard my grandparents speak about, you know, don't like our my parents' generation, you know, lived basically a debt life.

And we're you know, my generation is kind of the zenials, the older millennials are really experiencing, you know, what it's like to live page paycheck to paycheck and go into debt, you know, student debt, mortgage debt, you know, credit cards, and you try to play that game where you know pay off your credit card every month, but that doesn't always happen, especially when you know realities of life sit in and you want to have a family and you got kids and they want to, you know, do all sorts of things, and it those costs go up maybe a little faster than then you can, you know, increase your paycheck, and so or something happens, you know, health a health thing.

I mean there's just life happens. And once that sort of starts to snowball with the money that we have, we don't, you know, when you're living that way, you don't have access to like a way to store your wealth. So you're just living literally paycheck to paycheck as a you know a debt slave for I mean I don't want to be like over overly harsh, I mean, because and ignore like the absolutely terrible history of you know physical slavery in this world and particularly in this country, but there is another phenomenon called debt slavery that is not as physically directly physical, but it's it's you

Know essentially the same thing. It's kind of spiritually spiritual slavery, sort of a yeah. I agree with you. Like we've made a lot of progress as people, right? We don't have as much, say, physical slavery in the world. But even though we've made progress doesn't mean we're we've reached the pinnacle of what we can do.

And this form of debt slavery, it it's just a very much more shadowy, less hard to observe, kind of like the nature of economics itself, right? All these things are invisible, which makes them sort of hard to communicate or abstractions. And that stealthiness, I think is what's been taken advantage of by central bankers, right?

The enigma related to money and how oh, we're gonna control it, and we understand it all, you know, in our nice robes and suits, and don't worry about it, we'll figure it out. And everyone else is just left, you know, paying fucking tab. That's not cool. It's not as bad as physical bondage, but it's not as good as we can be either.

And that's what I really you know hope in my work to help people wake up to so we can do better than this. We touched on that severance of skin in the game and what that does as far as encouraging people to be more short-term, more debt-oriented, driving the boom and bust business cycle.

And I'd like to explain that a little further for people that don't maybe know what skin in the game is. So it's a concept by Nassim Taleb, who is my favorite author, totally brilliant guy. He actually has a book under that title, which is his latest. But essentially it's this balance of incentives and disincentives that that maintain harmony in the natural system.

With gold, for instance, the cost necessary to extract it from the earth is what gives it that skin in the game. So if it cost me a thousand dollars per ounce to extract gold from the earth, then I will and say the market price of gold is eleven hundred dollars.

I am incentivized to mine it until marginal my marginal cost equals my marginal revenue, right? Right up until I'm mining gold at a profit of you know one thousand nine hundred or one hundred and ninety-nine dollars and ninety-nine cents. If I'm making one penny on that, there is an incentive to mine gold.

So that is what that's what establishes it as hard money. There's a balance of the disincentive cost to mine it with the incentive, which is the market price. So this gave this difficulty or cost associated with mining, that's what gives gold its skin in the game. For Bitcoin, and this is where people get really confused because they think it's oh, it's just magic internet money, it's not connected to reality.

It is in fact connected to reality in a more fundamental way than any form of money we've ever had. In this ingenious composite of what Satoshi called proof of work energy expenditure, basically the energy necessary to try and solve each the solution to each block of transactions, which is the cost, it's like the cost of gold mining necessary to procure the Bitcoin.

So with this combination of proof of work energy expenditure, which is a form of skin in the game, and then the incentives related to it, this competition among miners to solve this puzzle, which is sort of an instant instantiation of game theory. Satoshi was able to digitize physical scarcity or digitized scarcity overall.

So, in this sense, what Bitcoin's blockchain or more accurately its time chain is it's like a bridge between physical and digital reality. We've never seen anything like this. It's it's really amazing. So in that perspective, you know, the value of mining both gold and bitcoin is the unforgeable costliness that each represents, which is is Zabo's term for the representation of the time and energy and effort that went into producing it that cannot be forged, right?

Unlike with fiat currency, it's proof of the time sacrificed to produce gold or bitcoin, which is in turn redeemable for the time of others. And if you break this leg, this peg to the reality of time, money fails. And that's and just if you don't believe me, look at the history of fiat currency.

I think the average fiat currency throughout history has a lifespan of 27 years. The best performing is the British pound, which is only depreciated 99 and a half percent over the past 317 years. And it's totally asin on what we're being forced to use today.

So Bitcoin, by being imbued with this new property of digital scarcity, it preserves the advantages of gold's physicality, which gave itself sovereignty, which gives it irreversible transactions or final settlement, but it eliminates the disadvantages of gold's physicality, and that it was more easy, more easy, easily confiscated.

It was very expensive to safeguard, it has high settlement costs, right? You can't really pay for your coffee with gold coins, it's not super practical. So, and then also this innovation of Bitcoin and that it digitized scarcity, but also makes it totally weightless and intangible, and potentially like the last evolution in monetary technology we ever see.

As it's a total bit the Bitcoin network itself, it's totally impersonal, it's widely distributed, no one can control it. It's a self-sovereign monetary network, and it's already got a market cap above 200 billion dollars, which is equal to you know, basically this again, the skin in the game going into it.

So And that's just the first 10 years. Like big Bitcoin, I tweeted this the other day. Bitcoin is is a precocious fifth grader right now. You know? It's early. Yeah. It is early, and then you know, just for reference, I think the hash rate just passed a hundred exahashes.

Yeah. I think it may have fallen back down a little bit below a hundred, but it definitely surpassed a hundred for a while for the first time ever. It's right around there. You know, that's right around there, yeah. But it's right around 100. Just to give again the newcomers kind of a sense. When it was when it hit its prior all-time high USD price of almost $20,000 in December of 17, I think the hash rate was at twelve or thirteen exahashes.

So we're talking about the skin in the game security budget for Bitcoin has increased eight X since its prior all-time high. And that is a proxy for the security of the network, which itself is a proxy for its its utility as a store of value. So yeah, he's a precocious fifth grader, and he's about to get people and hit puberty and get really nasty.

So I'm excited to see it happen. Gear up for the fight and then rebel from the parents and you know go its own way and lead us all with it with him.

Yeah. This is great, man. I think this is really useful to examine to me the most fundamental question, the most important question when a pre-coiner starts becoming interested in Bitcoin is you've got to understand what money is really is and like what we're dealing with here, what Bitcoin is.

To understand what Bitcoin is, you have to understand what money is. To understand what money is, you have to understand the value of time and all these things that we've examined here from first principles. That you know, the school of Austrian economics has preserved this this sort of insight, this wisdom for us over the past hundred, hundred and fifty years through this Keynesian time.

And now we come can use those first principles and those that the praxeology, which is the idea of studying human action and economics from from first principles. So you need to be able you need to go through this, and I think this episode will be very helpful for Bitcoiners to share with pre-coiner friends.

I think you can combine this one with the episode with Gigi, 21 lessons from down the Bitcoin Rabbit Hole, where we go through 21 lessons that he's that Gigi learned going down the Bitcoin rabbit hole. So I think the two of those can combined together are a wonderful introduction to Bitcoin, and you'll be you know far ahead of the game if you take a few hours and listen to those two episodes.

You know, so share this with your pre-coiner friends for sure. I think you touched on the Austrian school, and I am a huge fan. Again, for the listeners, there is Keynesian economics, which is effectively central bank propaganda.

It's been around for a couple hundred years. It's totally bunk. I mean, do your own research, but I think the consensus is there. And then there's the Austrian school of economics, which is the culmination of all ancient wisdom in the world related to economics. Literally, all of humanity's knowledge throughout all of time is condensed into this one school.

And I'm really what there's something bigger going on here. I can't really put my finger on it, but I'll try to say it. I feel like there is this resurgence of ancient wisdom in the world in general.

You know, we've seen yoga, say, spreading around the world, right,

Coming to the West. We see things like Aeryvetic medicine and say like the paleo diet or these carnivore diets. So we're really getting back to our roots in so many dimensions as a people. And I think a lot of it's driven by the digital age, right?

We have the world's library at our fingertips, and it's changing how we perceive our lives. And that we no longer are fully reliant on science and modern knowledge, but we're actually gaining this huge respect for ancient wisdom.

So I really think you know Bitcoin is just another embodiment of that as this resurgence of ancient wisdom in the world. And it's extremely exciting. Yeah, that's a really interesting bit there because I think you're right, and I hadn't thought about it exactly in that way.

I think part of it is that you know, we have grown so much, or at least maybe not that's that's not the right word, but we have discovered so much in terms of technology and scientific understanding of our universe and our condition. It's happened so quickly that our monkey brains have a hard time w with you know living in this sort of unprecedented time.

Yeah, and so I guess looking back to times that were not like this, for how humans, you know, achieved their potential, maximum potential, it makes sense because we're not I mean we're not evolved for the world we're living in right now.

So looking back to the way people ate, ranging from you know, like like the keto, the keto diet, paleo diets, so those those kinds of ideas to the way people exercised, yoga, tai chi, combat sports, ancient combat s combat sports, things like that, ancient games, chess go, you know, these kinds of practices that people are studying more and more are are taking us back to those roots of human wisdom from times that were a lot different than the way we're living now.

And I think that makes a lot of sense. Exactly. I forget who said it, but I might be paraphrasing, but the things we make in turn make us, right? The buildings create the tools we use, they in turn shape us, our only evolution. And you know, in this modern digital age, it's just been accelerated to a way that we've we've never seen before.

So it is very exciting, and then I think to maybe kind of bring it full circle and look at time itself, is bit basically at its really high fundamental level is Bitcoin has a supply that's more closely aligned with this prime economic reality that we all deal with of time scarcity, right?

Bitcoin is the first absolutely scarce monetary technology in history. Time is the only absolutely scarce experiential element in the world, right? So we now have a metaphor for time that is very closely, if not almost perfectly reflective of time itself.

So I think in this sense, I like to say that Bitcoin is slowly but surely undermining gold's role as prime money. As a result of that, you know, all fiat currencies, which are again derive their sovereignty from the gold holdings of central banks, they're gonna gradually slip and fall into Bitcoin, and ultimately gold itself being less perfectly reflective of time will its value will collapse into Bitcoin as well.

And the word undermine it literally means to dig under fortifications to collapse them. I like to think that Satoshi designed Bitcoin especially and specifically to dig deeper into this fundamental reality of time and basically you know become more closely aligned with time and gold to undermine its role as prime money and collapse its value, literally.

So, you know, again, time is this objective anchor to our world of you know, ceaselessly shifting subjective valuations. Bitcoin is basically the best tool for that. It lets us freeze our time savings as a store of value, it makes our time savings liquid as a medium of exchange, and it maintains a money supply that's as closely reflective of the impersonal passage of time as possible as a hard money.

Right. You know, gold did great, but Bitcoin is near perfect in this regard. And the other thing that is interesting about it is that Bitcoin, so at its core, Bitcoin is a tool for saving time, and that it allows us to save the time we you know, and value we create by sacrificing our time working and producing, things like that.

And it also lets protect that time from money supply manipulators because it can't be manipulated, right? Like gold. Another layer to that, I think Bitcoin is also a time-saving technology in that it it promises to reduce the money, the capital, and the life we waste in warfare.

Yeah, few people realize this, but it is it is quantitatively true. You can look at the United Nations statistics on you know per capita death and warfare. The century of central banking was the century of total war. Our per capita death and warfare quadrupled in the past 100 years.

Yeah, I mean, one of the one of the main drivers of one of the main drivers of money printing is to fund armies, the massive costs of armies to fight wars. And that's been true far back, yeah. Absolutely. And again, you know, this country specifically is the imperialist boss of the world, we rely on it heavily.

So I think by removing the funding mechanism for warfare, we're gonna create more human time in the sense of just more people alive. And then you've got more living people being more productive, thinking longer term, you know, able to play by these rules that are fixed and unmanipulable.

It just ushers in a society like we can hardly imagine. I mean, this is an invention as momentous as say antiseptic or electricity or the internet, you know, that either extend our lifespans individually or enhance our productivity and our time savings collectively.

Yeah, and like even beyond those three examples, you know, antiseptics is helping us preserve health, electricity is an incredible productivity enhancer increaser by orders of magnitude, and then the internet is a way to enhance our information sharing by orders of magnitude. But even beyond all three, even more important than all three of those is an innovation that allows us to take back our time, an enhancement of our time, basically.

Yeah, and that's it's just even more fundamental than all those. So that's that's what it is amazing here. I mean, we're we're looking at and dealing with and living through and talking about on Twitter and in podcasts and Medium and YouTube, and we're we're talking about an experiencing this absolutely singular moment in human history, all the way back to the beginning, to now and probably for a long, long time into the future.

So it's it's Bitcoin is expanding our relationship with time in the sense that it's extending our you know, extending our life expectancies by reducing warfare in the long run. It lowers our time preferences and it increases our productivity. You know, I think in that respect, Bitcoin is the greatest promise we have to liberate ourselves from time scarcity, eliminate time theft via inflation, which is again a legally enforced injustice.

People need to really see that for what it is. And it reinvigorates our individual sovereignty. And, you know, taken together, again, back to Zabbo, this concept of social scalability that allows us to just build a bigger and more robust society.

And that's just really fucking exciting. Sounds amazing, man. I think we'll mic drop it right there. This was a hell of an episode. You know, it's it's been great to get to know you. I'm looking forward to hanging out again next time we're at a conference together or something. Robert, thanks so much for coming on, man.

It's been an absolute pleasure. I really enjoyed this one. Brady, thank you so much. Had a great time. Umbert for his time. Thanks to the giants on whose shoulders this discussion stands.

Safadine Hayek, Mises, Rothbard, the entire Austrian School of Economics crew. Through thanks to Nigzabo and other cypherpunks who thought critically about the nature of money and how to build a better money using the internet and cryptography.

They created a real-world instantiation of these ideas that the Austrian School of Economics has been collecting and curating and moving forward over the past century or so. We owe you all a great debt of gratitude for helping us reach a true understanding of money from first principles.

You can find me on Twitter, at CitizenBitcoin.

If you have any questions, you can email me citizenbitcoin at pm.me. Remember to check out Bitcoin Dash Only.com, bookmark it, use it, share it with other Bitcoiners and precoiners in your life.

All right, with that, I am out. Take care out there, bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.

Thank you.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Downloads