Robert Allen: Building on Lightning - E94
This week we sit down with Robert Allen - a bitcoiner who has taken the buidl ethos to heart and built the beginnings of the moneda network - a remittance app that uses the lightning network for payment rails. we talk about building on lightning, the future of the lightning net work and We also get into monetary policy, and more.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there, all my bitcoiners from all around the world, wherever you are. Thanks for joining me again for another day here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. Today we sit down with Robert Allen, longtime Bitcoiner and builder, creator of the Moneda Network.
But first, let's check in with Swan. Yan Pritzker and team are working on some new features that we're super excited to announce soon. Stay tuned on our Twitter account, at SwanBitcoin, for some exciting announcements. Now, you are a Bitcoiner. You have a vested interest in creating new Bitcoiners. We have a deal for you. You can actually get paid to recruit new Bitcoiners as a member of the Swan Force. Sign up at swanbitcoin.com slash enlist.
You'll get a custom landing page with your avatar and message at the top, and you'll earn 0.25%, a quarter point of every recurring purchase made by your referrals who are stacking $200 or more per month for three years. And they get $10 of Bitcoin, everybody wins. And you don't need to be in the United States to join the Swan Force.
You can sign up US-based customers from anywhere else in the world and we'll pay you in sats. Alright, let's dive into this one.
This week we sit down with Robert Allen, a Bitcoiner who has taken the Biddle ethos to heart and built the beginnings of the Moneta Network, a remittance app that uses the Lightning Network for payment rails. We talk about building on lightning, the future of lightning, and we get into monetary policy and a lot more.
Hope you all enjoy it. Here we go. All right, man. How's it going, Robert? It's been a rough couple of weeks on my end, man. And I know that you are working on a new product, so I'm guessing it's been kind of the same for you.
Real busy? Yeah, yeah. It's been busier than expected given that we're all still sort of shut in and the world is at a standstill. Yeah, how you been doing with all that, man? Like, is it I guess there's pros and cons. Right. I think that's a good way to look at it.
You know, there's there's been some frustrations for me, just missing friends and community and just sort of that normal part of life has been a little bit disrupted. Although the secondary and tertiary consequences of what governments have been doing around the world are gonna be far worse than anything that would have happened if they had just left it all alone.
I think the quarantine stuff just finally hit me too, in terms of like the social, you know, just isolation. We've been we've been quarantining pretty, I mean, more strictly than most, just because we have some you know health conditions in the house in the family that could that could put put us at more more at risk for sure.
So we have to be a little bit stricter than most, and you know, like who knows the hard thing about it is that you can't run both timelines right you can't a b test it so who knows what would have happened but I absolutely agree with you that the secondary and tertiary effects of this quarantine are gonna be massive huge negative consequences yeah and I understand you know folks have different issues going on like my parents are in their 70s yeah so when when this all first started happening I really was concerned especially for them and you know kind of wondering have I got have I already been exposed to this or you know if I go home to visit them
In Ohio am I gonna be exposing them potentially so I actually postponed a trip to see them partly because I was a little bit concerned about potentially bringing a bug to them. All right well let's say that this was a great start. I mean I love talking about stuff other than Bitcoin so this is good. You know, we get a lot of Bitcoin talk and we're gonna have plenty on this in this episode too.
We can dive in now to talking about those like secondary tertiary effects you know just start by talking about the monetary policy implications. So I mean obviously this is you know these are these are the most relevant probably implications for Bitcoin directly so yeah what do you I mean what do you see happening in the in the next coming you know you know months years as kind of follow-on effects of monetary policy changes.
Well I mean it one other point I want to make before I jump onto that one is just that I think another trend I'm hoping to see continue to happen here is that I think we're gonna see cities probably shrink to some degree given what's been going on. And so I and I think in the end that might ultimately leave us all in a in a more more resilient kind of place.
And so, in other words, like if we have Bitcoiners who have some land, who have some ability to you know, even feed themselves, perhaps, to run a full node, maybe to have a gun or two to protect their family and their property. And that's sort of the trend and the kickback from a lot of what's happened in the last few years here, and specifically with you know COVID, that that ultimately I think could be really positive.
So, in other words, you know, decentralization both of the money system but also of you know of people and of families, so that so that we're not so reliant on governors and politicians deciding how we live our lives and what we can do and what we can't do.
But yeah, I mean, in terms of monetary policy in particular, well, it this is not at all you know unexpected, you know, for me. I think I think I've been on really the sort of Austrian, you know, school of thought train since I guess what maybe 2007 when I started getting interested in Ron Paul, he was really sort of the you know the red pill that that took me down this rabbit hole that ultimately led me to Bitcoin.
And you know, probably many of your listeners know a lot of these things, but to sort of just recap the theory is essentially that you know governments because they have this, they they've seized this ability to control the money supply, it's really difficult for them to not to not use that power.
It it's sort of, you know, if you know the Lord of the Rings trilogy, it is like the ring of power. And so it it seems like it tends to corrupt anyone who controls it. And but the end result of having that power is that you ultimately see, and this has happened obviously many times throughout history, Weimar Germany and many places in Africa, Venezuela, but you end up having a situation where the government debases the currency to the point where it loses all of its value and eventually it goes to zero.
This is the this is the fate of like all fiat currencies in history, basically. I mean, even the reserve, even the global reserve currencies. You know, if they didn't hyperinflate, they just got beat out by a you know, a harder money. Sure. Sorry, good. Right, right. And yeah, so the British pound was kind of the global currency before the dollar.
And now you know the pound is is a shadow of its former self. So I think we're living through that period in in in US history. I mean, I am, I guess I'm almost a little surprised just at the amount of printing that has happened in the last few months. I think if my recollections correct, I think it's somewhere in the neighborhood of six trillion dollars that's been pumped one way or another in into the monetary system, you know, since COVID gave them an excuse to start really doing that.
And so yeah, I mean it's it's criminal, it's it's evil. You know, it's it's theft from savers and retired folk and people who, you know, maybe don't have income anymore. My my parents are kind of in that boat, you know, where thankfully they own their home and they have some investments, but and they'll probably be fine.
But you know, many people in a similar places as as they are are going to struggle and continue to struggle probably more and more as we see higher inflation in just even grocery store prices for example which i've noticed myself already some some hikes on you know on goods there so yeah so but the good news i guess for bitcoin is that you know if the dollar dies sooner than later it's that's pretty bullish for bitcoin and I think in many ways you know this this might ultimately benefit the adoption of Bitcoin and encourage people because I think you know this is sort of
A common saying with within the Bitcoin circles but it's you know people will find Bitcoin when they need it when when it's something that is actually required in their life. And so like in Venezuela you see people who really have you know jumped 100% in because that was the only option they had and so I think we'll see more and more of that in western countries in you know in the next decade.
Yeah absolutely I think you're right on point there that you know people discover Bitcoin or come to Bitcoin when they need it, right? I mean that's sort of the philosophy of any any product or any product or service that you provide. And it's not it's not any different for money and there's lots of competitive you know competing money products obviously out there for Bitcoin.
I think that the you know these monetary this monetary expansion that was sort of unexpected right and is really going to take probably the Fed off of their two percent inflation target, you know, and sort of expose the emperor has no clothes to a lot more people.
So if we see the you know the effects of this in the next year or two, people are going to have their eyes open that they you know do have a need for Bitcoin, even if you're living in the United States and have the benefits of the global reserve currency as your native currency, or if you're in a western country or something with a relatively you know stable economy, you know, those people everywhere will see, hopefully, will have a need for it, and hopefully more and more will see that they have that need for it.
Yeah, yeah, I think so too. Yeah, so you're working on a product that you know fulfills a need that exists right now. And it's you're you're doing some remittance work, right? A remittance product and service over the Lightning Network. Can you tell me like first of all, how or why you picked like this problem to try to solve.
Yeah. So I've been following Lightning. You know, I've obviously been aware of it since you know the white paper, the light and well, there was two papers, but the Joseph Boone paper particularly, I remember reading and finding interesting. It was it was a hard read, a harder read than the Bitcoin white paper.
So I remember struggling a bit to really kind of rock it all and feel comfortable. But you know, long story short, I've been following Lightning and with a with a little bit of skepticism because it it's it's a bit more complex in some ways than just you know simple layer one Bitcoin. So I guess I had a little bit of you know, just sort of stand back and watch and see is this really gonna be workable technology.
But I've been really impressed with what I've seen, especially in the last maybe year or two, in terms of the maturity of the protocol. I've been you know, I've I've dived into the documentation, I've gone through, you know, hook set up you know on the test net and played around a bit with it on there.
I've run some nodes, I've got a model going, I set up a MyNode. So point is like I've I've just been at that, you know, last year in particular, really pushing myself to start to learn and understand the protocol and the and the ecosystem and what's been developing around it. And I'm really excited that I think this this system is ultimately gonna work to scale Bitcoin pretty well.
And I think there are still some pain points you know in terms of questions around you know running watch towers, for example, and some issues with channel rebalancing. And so, you know, it's it's still not quite ready for prime time, I would say, but I'm encouraged to see the progress.
And it's it's amazing also just to see that you've got several well-funded companies that are working together, which is a really awesome thing to see and different implementations and everything. I've mostly just been interested in the Go implementation L and D, but you know, just personally because that one seemed to be the easiest access point.
And I've been learning Go a bit, so it felt like a good place to start. But anyway, so I you know I've been playing around learning, getting interested in lightning and just looking at it and trying to think about ways that this technology can be used to solve problems in the world.
Had some ideas around basically like a bolt proposal that I'm I'm still thinking through and have you know, published that on my GitHub. Haven't gotten a ton of feedback yet, but it's it's pretty high level still. And that was more around that was more just around realizing that there seem to be some issues with you know, like say you're routing a payment and there's you know five nodes between you and the destination.
Okay, there can be issues with you know just bottlenecks where you just don't have enough liquidity. And so I think I think in the end, we're probably gonna have more of like a hub and spoke model for this to really work well. And so then thinking around that topic, you know, well, maybe we could actually have some you know, some rules of the road essentially, where if you want to be one of these larger routing nodes, these are some additional requirements.
Not that you couldn't use lightning as it is today, obviously without this, but perhaps we could add sort of this you know you know, business class, kind of this this higher grade tier of nodes with some you know guarantees around liquidity and you know making sure that channels are rebalanced and things like that.
So point is that's been something I've been thinking about for a while. But I mean that that's kind of happening naturally though, right? Like I mean, we're kind of seeing that yeah, naturally played out. Yeah, and that's right. That that's the pushback that I've heard from a few folks in the space, and I and I hear that, and it that could be the case that this is more just a matter of time than that we actually need to codify, you know, specifics.
So anyway, so I kind of let that idea I left it on the you know, back burner. And I don't, you know, I don't know how it all came about in terms of this idea for remittances. I mean, I guess, you know, people have been talking about using Bitcoin for remittances since you know, before I got into the space 2013 or before. So it's not a new idea, but I think when I realized that, you know, you can you can pretty easily send small amounts of Bitcoin with Lightning securely and very quickly, and that that might be a useful aspect of this technology for remittances in particular.
It you know, my mind started working on it. And the other thing I've realized is just like sort of more in general, that you know, for hardcore Bitcoiners like you and I, we understand the economic aspect of why we should own Bitcoin and you know, Austrian economics and we understand central banking and all these things.
And you know, to get to the point where you really get that value proposition for holding Bitcoin long term as you know, a hedge against inflation and that sort of thing, that's something that is not probably going to be mainstream anytime soon. I mean, of course, I think we should all work to educate and you know get more and more people on board.
But I was also just kind of hit by this idea that rather than you know trying to convince everyone that Bitcoin is better, maybe we can just show them that Bitcoin is better by building tools that solve real world problems for people today, make their lives better. And so that's really kind of I think what that little spark that got me to realize okay, so here's a real world problem where people are sending money from the United States to Mexico, let's say, on average they're paying about 7% to Western Union or MoneyGram or companies such as those.
With Western Union, if you send $100, they'll actually take 10, for example. And this would be a cash to cash remittance. But you know, cash markets, sort of the gray, gray market, whatever you want to call that economy, is something like 7% of the global economy is cash based. So it's a huge a huge amount of money.
Remittances alone are like 600 billion plus per year. Mexico is over 25 billion or right in that neighborhood. And yeah, so you know, bottom line is I just I see that that that's a huge fee to pay for someone to just send cash from one person to another.
That that's a big pain point. And so perhaps we can use Bitcoin and especially given that we have Lightning now, we might be able to do it in a way that we could reduce the cost significantly. So I'm I'm trying to target like a 4% fee. And you know, of course, it's very early, I'm very early stage in this whole process of really just kind of validating the business model, looking for partners, looking for co-founders and people to work with me, and obviously eventually looking for financing, because too to pull something off like this is gonna require I think probably five five to ten million
Is what I think is a reasonable raise to actually try to roll something out like this in say Mexico and the United States, like a you know, a nationwide kind of rollout. So it's it's an ambitious idea and project. And but you know, I think ultimately someone is gonna do this.
And so and I'm quite frankly a little surprised that no one is actually pushed sooner on something like this. But but you know, because for example, I think, as I said earlier, I think lightning is a little bit clunky today, currently for mainstream use. But in the way that I envision it for for Moneda network, it would basically be a private, we would just make a private version of the Lightning Network.
Yeah, and that that reduces, I think, quite a few of the different attack vectors. You know, if you're not publishing a bunch of information about your channels and capacity, I think you're going to be quite quite likely you'll be less of a target for hacking. Also, you know, you don't have the issue of you have more or less either totally trusted or semi-trusted partners in this network that I'm envisioning.
And so that also reduces a lot of the risk in terms of having to run, you know, you maybe don't even need to worry about watchtowers if you know who you're doing business with. You've got that close relationship. So things like that. I in other words, I think as lightning is today, I think it could work for this use case right now. Whereas Lightning for this like totally decentralized, you know, easy access for anyone to use it kind of network and to know that your payments are going to route 100% of the time.
I don't know, we're a few years out, I think, before we're gonna get to that point where it's that robust. Sure. But yeah, so that's that's a little bit about kind of how I came to the idea and where I'm headed with it, but early early stage for sure. Yeah, yeah. So okay, well, we haven't, I don't think we mentioned the name of the product yet or service.
Moneda.network is the website, Moneta Network. Does Moneda mean money in like another language or something, or is like yeah, how'd you come with that? Currency in Spanish. Currency, yeah. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. So and your your first sort of target market is Mexico. So awesome.
That makes sense. Like, so can you tell me like what's what's a user experience like? I mean, we've we sort of talked about kind of the back ends and the you know mechanics with lightning and bitcoin. But if I want to send some money to my friend in Mexico, what would I have to do? Sure.
So there's there's lots of companies that are targeting you know different types of remittances. With this project. I think the lowest hanging fruit would be a cash to cash remittance. And so the process would be we're gonna build a user application. So the user app would be essentially the way that the person in the United States would connect to their friend or family member, let's say in Mexico.
So similar to perhaps like Venmo, where you have your contacts in there. So you know, you'd be able to essentially pull up the app, you know, click on you know, Juan in Mexico, let's say, perhaps, and schedule a hundred dollar cash remittance to him. And so from there, then you would be able to select and you know, I think one of the bigger challenges with this is gonna be this next step, but getting retail locations involved is gonna be of course very important.
So ideally I'm I'm looking to try to partner with perhaps 7-Eleven. They have a lot of locations in the United States and in Mexico. So that would be, I think the best and first option if we can make that happen. But yeah, so you'd walk into an you know, you'd have a map giving you different options for local 7EL1s where you can drop off the cash, pick the closest one or the most convenient one, you walk in, hand the teller $100.
He's gonna have an either we build this into their existing point of sale system, or perhaps we would need to basically just you know issue tablets. But you know, there's very low cost Android tablets that you can buy. I was checking on Amazon, like $30, $40, $50, something in that range per tablet.
Very reasonable. It shouldn't be cost prohibitive to actually just give those to retail locations if you need to do it. But yeah, so the you know, the clerk is gonna press a couple buttons basically, like you know, validating that the payment's been received and just double checking, perhaps like that the payment code you know matches with what he's got in his record.
And then he's gonna hit a button that ultimately routes the payment, and then from there, you know, essentially you're gonna have a lightning node in the US and a lightning node in Mexico. And so, and then the lightning node operators are gonna need to have a business relationship with 7-Eleven. So 7-Eleven is obviously you know, taking the cash, and then they're gonna have to send a bank transfer, probably like let's say once a day to settle up what they owe.
So of course, we'll need some liquidity to make all this work, both in terms of Bitcoin and probably cash on the city. To like sustain remittances for a day. Yes, exactly. Yeah, at least one day, or probably maybe even more than that, just to make sure that you don't ever run into an issue where you, you know, let's say you get a spike and you normally send in 10,000 a day, and one day you get 20,000 worth of remittances.
So, you know, you won't have a cushion probably in terms of liquidity. But so yeah, that's that's that's the process of the United States side. And then so the lightning payment is sent to Mexico. That lightning node would then ping 7-Eleven and let them know that a payment's been received for this person, you know, for whoever the destination the payee is.
And then, you know, on his end, he's gonna the payee's gonna have an app, same the same application. He's gonna see, oh, hey, I've got $100 that was sent to me. I'm gonna and I can go to any of these 7-Elevens, walk in, scan this QR code, they'll give me the cash in peso. So that's that's the process. I mean, it would be pretty similar to Western Union, but I'm hoping to make it even more intuitive and user friendly because a lot of these older systems like Western Unions are they they feel pretty dinosaur esque when you when you actually look at them and deal with that.
Yeah, I've used Western Union quite a bit to send or send payments abroad. And one, it's crazy expensive, and two, you can you can use their website but their website is terrible user experience sucks. So yeah, I mean eventually do you envision you know a way to just send some cash from my phone without like having to go into 7 Eleven.
Could I like pre-fund you know, like a Moneda wallet or something like that, and then like schedule out payments? Yeah, I mean that would be I think for probably further down the line in my my thinking, just because like for example, there's a newer startup called Zoom XOOM, they were acquired by PayPal.
So they make it easy for you to send basically from your PayPal or or from a bank account to a cash payment in Mexico. So in other words, I guess I just I feel like the cash to cash thing is is probably the lowest hanging fruit because it's got the highest the highest premium to do it currently, and there's still a lot of folks who are you know working cash jobs.
Now, you know, I guess the pushback in my mind on that is given what's happened with COVID, you know, that there's definitely going to be more and more of a sort of a clamp down in one way or other on cash. And so that's that's a little bit of something that would need to be monitored. But I mean, longer term, yeah, I think the longer term idea would be that yeah, you give people multiple ways to get funds into this application, you know, Bitcoin being obviously a very easy one to start with initially.
Because you know, they could even hold a lightning balance, perhaps, and then have the ability to send that. But you know, the thing that I've also found to be, I think, true is you know, for people who are working, like let's say you're working in the United States as a maid or a waitress or something, and you're making 20,000, 30,000 a year, perhaps, right?
And you're sending five or ten thousand of that to your family, you don't really have the bandwidth to spend the time to learn about Bitcoin, perhaps. And then secondly, even if you do understand it, like can you take can you deal with the volatility risk of hey, I put $100 into this lightning network, you know, Bitcoin balance, and now the price of Bitcoin has dropped 10%, and now I've got to send the money home.
And now, you know, so I guess I'm a little a little hesitant in that sense that I think we really need to make it easier for people to send one stable, I mean, again, we obviously relatively stable, but one stable national currency for another one, and to just be able to do that and serve that purpose because that's the that's the service they're looking for, as opposed to trying to get them to you know to be onboarded into some new service that doesn't even maybe resonate with with their needs, yeah.
But yeah, I mean, longer term, I would like to make it easier for folks to fund with other options for sure. And I think in terms of the mechanics of how this would all work, I'm I'm thinking that the best approach is actually to I guess, well, basically to make this a gift card purchase.
And so essentially on you know, on the legal side, this is not going to be a cash remittance in the traditional sense. This is going to be someone buying a cash gift card voucher and then sending that gift card voucher. So, in doing that, we can 100% legally not have to deal with and jump through a bunch of hoops in terms of AML and KYC.
And I'm still looking, I have some questions about the Mexican side to make sure that it's totally copacetic and safe to do there. But my understanding in the States is that you know there's tons of companies using gift cards. This is a very you know, very above board and common practice, and so why not you know use the tool that's gonna be the lowest you know kind of barrier to entry and you know that sort of thing.
So have you looked at Paxful? Yeah, I'm familiar with Paxful is actually on their website today. I from what I've seen with Paxville, I think they're just doing buying and selling of Bitcoin, and they kind of help people arrange that whole situation. So I think it's a great business. It seems like you know, I've actually met the main the main guy Ray Rebus way back in probably 2014, 2015 in in New York.
He was showing up at BitDevs for a while there, and I was going to that meetup as well. So I yeah, I like what they're doing, but I don't really see that as competing with what what my view is. Oh, yeah, no, I don't think it's competing. I was just brought it up because they but they also you know started their whole business by using gift cards, yeah.
The gift card rails basically that was already existing and it like you know was one of those like genius hacks to bootstrap their business. Yeah, you know, okay. Yeah. I was I guess I wasn't as familiar with that that aspect, so that's interesting to hear. Yeah, there are other startups too, like Liberty X in the United States. They just rolled out or they are rolling out a service where you can buy Bitcoin using essentially a gift card voucher type setup in all sorts of locations.
You walk in, hand some cash. I've already tried it out with a small amount of Bitcoin just to feel it out. But so yeah, so people other folks are doing things in this direction, but I think what what I'm really focusing on again is like what's the end user experience and what is a pain point for an average person who's maybe not into Bitcoin or you know, going to be into it anytime soon, but how can we make their lives better?
And then, you know, and my hope would be like you eventually if if you've you know really grabbed a big market share, a piece of this pie for mittens, then you can start to educate people. You can you can have you know free educational services and other things that you can provide to get them on board into Bitcoin to explain the value. And so in that sense, I think it ultimately I probably want to get to the point where we've essentially you know kind of you know disintermediate ourselves to the point where we actually even change the business model, and then you maybe turn it into like a Bitcoin bank of some sort where you're providing banking services and you know less of the remittances.
But of course, that's that's like five, 10 years down. But sure. And when Bitcoin becomes, you know, more of a medium of exchange and unit of account, yeah. Yeah, it makes sense exactly. Yeah, yeah. So how did you how'd you get into Bitcoin anyway? How long have you been in? Like how did this happen? I know you know you had got the Austrian economics background, so a lot of people come to Bitcoin, you know, through that.
Either you either you know it before, and so Bitcoin makes sense to you, or you know, you come into Bitcoin some other way, usually because number goes up or something, and you learn you learn why it's better money and about Austrian economics. But what's your particular story? Yeah, so I, as I said earlier, you know, I got really interested in Ron Paul's presidential bid and you know, did a little bit of canvassing for him in New York City at that time.
I was actually I had just graduated from Ohio State University and moved to New York. Didn't really have a lot of options for career at that point. I was an English major, so you know what do you what do you do with that? Oh man, so was I so I feel you there. So yeah, so I moved to New York and it was teaching with the New York City Teaching Fellows program.
And that was very eye-opening. I went from you know, kind of indoctrinated, sort of traditional liberal to pretty pretty you know red pilled within maybe two years or less. Just you know, essentially feeling like a prison guard was my job as more of like a prison guard than a teacher. But anyway, so found Ron Paul, you know, fell down that rabbit hole.
I read some books by by Peter Schiff and ended up I was going to work, so my dad was retiring, he was a financial advisor in Ohio. At the time he was about ready to retire. I was gonna I decided, you know, I don't want to do this teaching thing anymore. This is this is not for me. So I his brokerage firm sponsored me.
I studied and passed the 7 and 66 exam. So I was a registered licensed stockbroker in New York City. Very briefly worked for you know, like just a really skeezy, like literally for I think one or two days is the only amount of time I was at this company. But you know, it was kind of like Wolf of Wall Street type setup where they're obviously scamming people, and I had a very bad feeling.
But then I found a job shortly after that with with Peter Schiff, actually working for Shift Gold. It's now called, or sorry, it was called Euro Pacific Battles, now it's called Shift Gold. Oh man, there's so many listeners who are so triggered right now. They're like, oh shit, this guy's Peter Schiff. Yeah, so you know, I so I worked with for him for four years.
Good experience, you know, great, great overall time working for Peter. I have a lot of good memories, and yeah, I mean I have a lot of good things to say about Peter. Obviously, I have differences when it comes to Bitcoin, right? But yeah, so around 2011, actually, I went up to Porcupine Freedom Festival in New Hampshire with some buddies, and I saw some folks using Bitcoin to my forever shame, and you know, here it is the pain in my pocketbook.
I just totally ignored it. I thought, you know, and I was a little bit programmed by the gold bug camp. So I thought, well, you know, money has to be a physical thing, and this digital thing could never work. And plus, I you know, in my defense and the defense of a lot of folks, you know, digital scarcity, the idea that you could have a digital item or asset that that couldn't just be copied and pasted, you know, like like an MP3 was a new concept, and I didn't take the time, sadly, to dig enough into it to really understand.
So that was you know, 2011. That was you know, I basically didn't really think about Bitcoin much until I saw it in the news. So number go up, of course, works for everybody. So 2013, the price is pumping, and I'm thinking to myself, how is this thing that is a total scam and could never work? How is the price still going up? Like, what's the deal here?
So then I finally, you know, looked up the white paper and read that, and it made made sense. And I could see, you know, logically that hey, this actually seems like it could all work. And then I you know watched a bunch of videos and read articles and just kind of fell down the rabbit hole. A lot of Andreas Antonopoulos content was one of one of the ways I got kind of pulled in.
Also, the let's talk Bitcoin network of shows, and so yeah, so I pretty quickly fell into it all and became obsessed, and then I started getting into mining. But you know, like a lot a lot of people, I mean I didn't I didn't make a lot of money from it, but I bought like a butterfly labs miner and I had some GPU mining going on.
So I was mining Litecoin and some other stuff as well. With my my brother and I did it in in New York City. But you know, our electricity costs were really high. Then we send it, we ended up sending our mining gear and setting it up to my well, drove it and set it up in Ohio at my parents' farm.
You know, I'd have to like call my dad and try to get him to go down and fix it for me and like you know, try to hide him, and he's all confused. It just didn't work. We kept having problems, and so eventually just that that it that was shut down and I sold the gear. Sadly, but but yeah, that was the beginning of it. And then from then like trial by fire, man.
I mean, big coiners, bitcoiners who go in from from like you know, just being like white paper and trying to understand from the money per perspective, but then you go into mining. Like that's those are the real hardcore, like that's that's the other tunnel of the rabbit hole that most of us don't go through. Yeah, yeah. And it was challenging because you know, I've always been pretty good with computers, but I was not a computer science major.
I wasn't really very comfortable with like command line and all that stuff. So, you know, I'm going online, like it's you know, at that time it looked like like magical spells, you know. I'm like finding our put this spell in and put this spell in. Yeah, copy paste, copy paste. I don't know what it's doing, but I'm I'm reciting the magic words.
Yes, yeah, so that that was a fun, crazy time. And yeah, and then from there, you know, like a lot of people, it's also a bit sad to admit it, but you know, I was a pretty I've I've been hardcore on on the Bitcoin you know, side really since I got in.
But of course, like a lot of folks have started looking at these other projects and then hearing, you know, arguments from people like Andreas where he would talk about how it's gonna be, you know, Becky Sue is gonna have a coin that she sells at school. It might Becky coin. Yeah, somehow like that seemed to make sense to me.
I think just because it was so different from the way the world was currently working that it sounded enticing and like this brave new world, right? But you know, of course, I'm firmly in the camp that you know, network effects make a big difference in terms of money working or not.
And so anyway, I got a little bit into Ethereum. I had some Ethereum at one point. I did I bought on the crowd sale, I did make good money on that. So I can't be too you know, salty about it, although at this point I'm I'm very disappointed in that entire project. I think it's failed. And you know, and again, I this has been a journey for a lot of people.
So look, if you were what did you think like what sorry to pause there, we'll come back to it. What did you think was like what was your hope for Ethereum and then w and how did it not like be fulfilled, get fulfilled. Yeah, yeah. I think I you know, I got sucked into this idea that that smart contracting would be just super revolutionary and that we're gonna be able to, you know, everything you do is gonna have a smart contract attached, you know.
So you know, you're gonna rent a home and you're gonna walk up to the door and scan some code and some tokens gonna get transferred, and then you're gonna have access. And yeah, you know, so all those sorts of things. And I think in the end, like I still think some of those ideas are interesting and maybe could ultimately be useful or utilized or implemented potentially.
But you know, it's like it's like with any new thing going from idea to actually implementing it in the real world is is an as a whole you know other set of challenges and hurdles. And so it's easy to dream big, it's a lot harder to actually write good code and then build out a service and all of that.
And yeah, so I you know, like I liked these ideas of like, you know, a programmable will and you know, and some of these these ideas, and I and again, I still think they're interesting. But I think really what changed for me with Ethereum is more so the fact the realization that it's really not a decentralized project.
You know, when when they when the DAO hack happened, that was to me probably like the death knell in my mind where it really just kind of all I was like, oh right, so just a handful of people can make a decision, yeah, and this this immutable quote, you know, chain is gonna just be rolled back and they're gonna do what they want. And so that that really made me realize that it was a lot of talk and that in in practice that this this project is not really decentralized.
And then I think to make it even more to pulling me further in that direction is just the also the realization that you know trying to scale on chain with this giant amount of data in the base blockchain is not really a workable idea. And I think too, it's like if Moore's law and all of these trends were really firmly intact into the future for another 10 or 20 years.
Maybe that could have worked. But it looks like, and I even remember one of the organizers of Bittev's, like, you know, talking about how Moore's law was dying, and like I'm like, you know, part of my brain's like, it can't be true. And like, no, no, no, it's being cynical, but it does look like that is in fact the case. That we're definitely seeing a slowdown here in terms of the you know the increases in in storage, storage and RAM and all that stuff.
And so, yeah, so I think Ethereum you know, is interesting in concept in some ways, but I think it's a bit naive. And I and just like I was naive at that point and didn't really understand software development, you know, since since those early days, you know, in the last five years, I've dived into software pretty heavily.
And you know, I've written code in Python and JavaScript pretty heavily, websites, some web applications, front-end, back end, you know, I've worked with databases, I've worked with Docker, I've worked with, you know, I mean, I've kind of run the gamut. And doing all of that and struggling and learning, and you know, it's taught me a lot that software development is not easy, and also that if you try to do too much in any given, like, you know, say you're building a program out and you, you know, you don't you don't break it apart into into kind of self-contained pieces, or you know, like say microservices, for example, where you have
Different aspects of your program working kind of independently. If you don't do those sorts of things, you end up with spaghetti code, you end up with huge headaches, and you ultimately have software that doesn't scale and doesn't work. And so those realizations have led me further into the Bitcoin camp where I've realized the wisdom of you know the core devs and the people who really stuck to their guns and said, no, we are not gonna scale on chain.
This is not sustainable, this is not a good approach yep and you know, it hurt in the short term but good engineering it's is is you know it's not about the easy solution today it's about thinking long term and how to build systems that are actually really robust and reliable so yeah I mean the whole ethos of Ethereum was just like an like antithetical to money which needs to be if you're trying to build a money that's going to you know power a civilization for decades or centuries right you don't need to like worry about scaling for coffee purchases in the next 18 months you know what I mean
Like and think thank goodness for the for the core devs who like I mean those I think early shepherds of the code base and like you know if you go back to some of the drama that that happened when you know the early days of the of the block size debate sure you know and my current rage quitting and getting Gavin Andreessen and like I mean there was a that was not necessarily like that was tenuous times for Bitcoin right because I mean those guys that really pushed for keeping the you know the block size where it was and the reason making that case were not the guys
That had the quote unquote sort of power or prestige you know on the project it was it was kind of the up and comer new guys that really kind of was like you know made that case yeah that's very true and you know like a lot of folks I was a little torn during that whole time because you know, being more naive and less experienced in software it at that point, you know, it was the arguments for well, hey, we just increased the block size, it's simple, and then we, you know, we don't we don't slow ourselves down th those those arguments on the face on the surface seem somewhat reasonable.
And I think, you know, like a lot of folks, I was kind of on the fence for a bit. I mean, thankfully, I think really what ultimately struck me was just that, like, okay, so you've got a few developers that seemed pretty talented who were on that camp, but then you had you know, marketing guys like Roger Vare, and like I mean, am I gonna listen to Gregory Maxwell or Roger Vare when it comes to engineering.
You know, it's thankfully I was able to just realize like, okay, so the ball the vast majority of the good engineers who are actually building Bitcoin are saying we need to do it this way. You know what? I don't totally understand that, and I feel a little bit frustrated, but I'm gonna trust them. I'm gonna and so that was where ultimately, thankfully, I sold my Bitcoin cash, probably made a decent amount even compared to where it is today when everything's forked, I sold out and haven't been worried about that project really since.
And but you know, and in the end, I think it ultimately like I would it's frustrating, but it's better to live in a world where people can have differences and just you know go their separate ways, work on their projects and you know, fork off, if you will. And so that's you know, it's frustrating, but it's a better world than a world where people are fighting each other and killing each other.
And so yeah, I mean that's that's one of the benefits of how this all works is this consensus can can happen organically and people can question it and leave and then come back. And so for any Bitcoin cash folks out there who are watching, be cashers, you know, come back. There are none of them. I'm pretty sure maybe one or two.
Sorry if there are a couple of you guys out there. I mean, there's probably you know, there's probably a handful of people who are, you know, on both sides of the tracks, but you they they they know very well where where I stand anyway. Sure. But go ahead, sorry. No, no, I was just saying, you know, come come back. It's it's never too late to admit that you made a mistake. I've made plenty of mistakes during my time in in the world of Bitcoin.
You know, lost money on an exchange. I don't need to get into that, but you know, yeah, I mean shit shit happens, but we gotta keep persevering moving on. And I'm just I feel excited to be a part of this project in whatever way I can to further Bitcoin. And so that's really where where my passion is is doing what I can to try to help push it forward.
So well, I really appreciate that, man, and congratulations on you know the launching of your product project. I wish you, you know, the best success best of success. And if anybody out there is listening, you know, I'm sure that there are people who are lap developers and just interested in getting involved in a Bitcoin project. Reach out to Robert.
Contact info will be in the show notes. Man, thank you so much for your time. This has been a lot of fun talking and looking forward to you know, just staying in touch and maybe we can work together on Bitcoiners best a little bit too. We're gonna try to revive that project. Yeah, I'm I'm looking forward to that. I've been a little distracted since you got me access, but I'm I'm ready to make some time commitment to it.
So yeah, we've got a we've got a second breath of air here. Everybody on the project kind of got it launched and made a bad a big push to launch it, and then everybody else kind of like had to go back to what they were doing. You know, Swan was starting up, and I know that Pablo and a couple other guys involved, like you know, had stuff that they had to go get done, but now we're sort of all kind of coming back and saying, okay, I've got a little bit of attention to spend on this, and thank you for kind of jumping into we got some things coming.
I think it's gonna make it a lot easier for you guys to submit new content to Bitcoiners best. So I'm gonna start talking about it again. I know it's been a few months. All right, man. Take care. Absolutely. Cheers byks to Robert for joining me.
Find him on Twitter at Satoshi Sound at S-A-T-O-S-H-I-S-O-U-N-D, and I'm at citizenbitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. Share this one with your family and friends. Start making some new bitcoiners. Again at the top, I mentioned SwanForce at SwanBitcoin.com slash enlist.
Start making some Bitcoin for recruiting new Bitcoiners. Thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring this episode and to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast in their feed. You can check out my merchandise shop at layer1btc.com. Click on partners and then citizenbitcoin. There's cool stuff to check out there, including some opsec friendly stuff.
And also check out the podcast I've created for Swan, the Swan Signal Podcast. It's an audio archive of our weekly Swan Signal live broadcasts. It's a couple of Bitcoiners. We match up Bitcoiners for very compelling discussions. It's a unique option in the Bitcoin content space. So I encourage you to check it out. You can subscribe at Swan Signal Podcast.com.
If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at citizenbitcoin on telegram and keybase. My email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
This week we sit down with Robert Allen - a bitcoiner who has taken the buidl ethos to heart and built the beginnings of the moneda network - a remittance app that uses the lightning network for payment rails. we talk about building on lightning, the future of the lightning net work and We also get into monetary policy, and more.
Citizen Bitcoin Layer One merch collection
Swan Bitcoin - Buy bitcoin with your bank account
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek
Links