All episodes
Episode 92

Obiwan Kenobit: Bitcoin and the Decade of Discontent - E92

July 2, 202069 min

Today we sit down with ObiWan Kenobit. We talk about what he calls the Decade of Discontent ahead of us as we transition through a currency collapse and into a new monetary era based on bitcoin. We talk about history through the lens of generational change guided by the ideas of William Strauss and Neil Howe and we talk about the second anniversary of his viral piece “Hyperbitcoinization: Winner Takes All” - about how the article holds up and any updates he might make to it 2 years on.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I am Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, all my Bitcoiners all around the world? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. Today, we sit down with Obi Wan Kenobit for a fantastic conversation.

But first, let's check in with Swan. You're a Bitcoiner. You should be auto-stacking. Check out what White Rabbit had to say about Swan. I started DCAing with Swan Bitcoin on March 19th, 2020, and I'm up a hair. Give it a hair over 25%.

DCA is stupid easy and the safest way to invest in Bitcoin. I'm confident if I had this when I started investing in 2013, my stack would be multiples larger. That's WhiteRabbitBTC on Twitter. Also, Brian Lockhart, organizer of the Seattle Bitcoin meetup, is stacking with Swan.

He says, I'm a fan of what they're doing and I believe in their approach. Swan solved a problem for me and I think it's a great service. So check it out. Get Stacking with Swan. Sign up at swanbitcoin.com slash Brady to get $10 bonus Bitcoin dropped into your account after you start stacking.

And always, thank you to the LTBN, the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network, for including the Citizen Bitcoin podcast in their feed alongside

Other Bitcoin podcasts like Bitcoin and Co. With Anita Posh, Bitcoin Audible with my boy Guy Swann, and what Bitcoin did with Peter McCormack. Also, shout out to CK Snarks. He hosts co-host the POV crypto podcast. That's a fun one to check out. So get on to the LTBN feed and check out those pods.

Alright, let's get into this episode. Today we sit down with Obi-Wan Kenobit.

We talk about what he calls the decade of discontent ahead of us as we transition through a currency collapse and into a new monetary era based on Bitcoin. We talk about history through the lens of generational change, guided by the ideas of William Strauss and Neil Howe.

And we talk about the second anniversary of his viral piece, Hyper Bitcoinization, Winner Takes All, and how the article holds up and any updates he might make to it two years on. Here we go.

Trying to keep up with all the different unfolding events around the world, even locally, with family. It's just been a pretty crazy 2020 so far. It's, I mean, absolutely insane. You've got this global pandemic and riots in the streets and money printing, you know, just going completely insane.

Recently, I think actually yesterday, late late yesterday, I heard the Fed was going to like basically re-audit the banks and restrict their ability to buyback shares. Do share buybacks. So yeah, there's just more and more intervention happening. Yeah, it's it's it's really interesting. I mean, even just you know, amongst my friends and personally, there a lot of people are are really confused about what's going on.

Why are things happening the way they are? They really have no real handle on on how on what's sort of driving a lot of this. And when I start talking to them about the monetary policy and start talking to them about about Bitcoin, actually I usually bring in Bitcoin to the very end of the conversation.

They're they're just flabbergasted that that we as you know people who've elected our our democratic government are allowing our politicians to operate basically this Ponzi scheme and you know allow them to bail out the banks yet again, bailing out Wall Street and you know, 97 cents of every dollar went in the last stimulus packages went to corporations, and they're just baffled.

They just don't understand why no one else can see that and why is nobody talking about that, you know, in the media. And I was telling them it, it just doesn't get clicks, you know. You know, statues the statues coming down gets clicks. It's true, it's true. And I mean, at what point do you think that you know we Bitcoin and sound monetary policy and all of this kind of reason in this time of madness will start getting clicks.

I mean, I feel at some point the madness will be so extreme that you know, people will actually be motivated to listen out of pain. You know, I think that's a very good point. I mean, if you know, you go back and look at the Great Depression, you know, I've spent some time reading and trying to learn as much as possible about the early 1920s and then the Great the October 29 crash, the Great Depression.

And I think one of the things that you realize is that one of the things you see is that there was a lot there was a lot of blindness, if you will, to the incoming economic catastrophe. All the signs were there. And it wasn't until you know, people were literally were out of jobs, were in in lines for soup kitchens that they realized that there was something horribly wrong with their with the economic system, which is you know, which is unfortunate.

It really takes, you know, you really have to experience it personally, I think for a lot of people before they realize that this is that the system needs to be changed. And in 2008, I think we had this kind of narrow, narrow band of pain, if you will, that was limited sort of to the banks and to people that had recently purchased homes, kind of in that 2000, late 2000 up to 2007, 2008 time period, and those folks are underwater.

But so it's kind of it was sort of limited. But I think what we're coming up to now is potentially much broader. And we're already kind of seeing signs of that, right? With the with the with this COVID-19 and the shutdown and the economic sort of catastrophe that's lo that's slowly unfolding in front of us. Mm-hmm. What is your sense on the upcoming economic and monetary consequences?

We're starting of the you know, printing, the pandemic. We're starting to see kind of the beginnings of it, I think. But it's been masked so far by you know, airdropped money, and you know, to both both the businesses and individuals, a little bit at least. Do you see deflation, inflation happening, and like you know, kind of what time frames do you think?

I think that we're gonna see a little bit of both. We're gonna see, you know, we're gonna see sort of these deleveraging type of events where the stock market does that you know, huge crash, you know, we see equities go down, and then we see the Fed printing and re-inflating that back up again. You know, so we sort of already, you know, since March, we've sort of been through this deleveraging devaluation event and equities, then the Fed intervening and reinflating that bubble again.

I think we're gonna see the sort of this this tug of war between inflationary and deflationary forces, you know, particularly over the next decade and maybe two decades. And Jeff Booth in his book, Price of Tomorrow, you know, really lays out the case for that in the long term that deflation is is the power of deflation through technology is really gonna be a huge sort of gravity well against prices across pretty much everything.

And eventually it'll bring bring in things like healthcare. And we haven't really seen healthcare prices come down. In fact, we've seen the opposite. But if you look at the underlying you know, you look at what's going on in technology, that's specifically for healthcare, healthcare technology, healthcare IT. I think that over the next decade we're gonna start seeing some pretty significant innovation, which is gonna try to bring those prices down.

But again, you know, you're you're fighting against a machine like Medicare or the government, which is subsidizing health care or insurance companies, which have, you know, it's the largest lobby in the United States. They're gonna be fighting those forces by trying to raise premiums, limit access to care, you know, preserve their status quo and preserve their their their profit centers.

I think we're gonna see a little bit of a little bit of both. We're gonna see both deflation and inflation. But I think as we kind of come close to the end of this decade, and if the central banks continue printing, they continue doing, you know, they're they're trying to meet their mandate, trying to beat inflation plus two percent inflation, we're really gonna see I think that's when you know we start to see that inflationary pockets pop up.

You know, they'll be in food, perhaps. It'll be and in things like health care. Initially, we'll start to see inflation inflation pop up in areas where it's not obvious that it's inflation. So, for example, you know, high net worth individuals may only have access to certain types of credit that allows them to buy, you know, big ticket items such as a home.

I think we're already kind of seeing that now where banks are tightening credit policies for lending, particularly in you know for home for home mortgages, and they're you know canceling or they're not opening lines of credits anymore. I think Bank of America a few weeks ago closed all new lines of credits. The ones that are there they they left open, but the newer ones, they're they're not opening any lines of credit just because of the degree of uncertainty.

So I think we're gonna see kind of things like that where housing, you know, paradoxically prices go up in certain areas because you know, a certain number of people have access to cash, access to credit, I should say. They're able to invest locally, they're able to buy up, you know, apartments, condos, you know, rental income, and that's just solely based on their ability to get access to credit.

Yeah, and so, you know, okay, let me just lay this out for listeners. There is a fantastic thread. And, and you know, side notes, Obi-Wan puts together awesome threads on Twitter, some of the highest quality stuff that's available out there. So if you're not following yet, definitely follow at Obi-Wan Kenobit, also one of my favorite handles on Twitter.

Recently put together a thread called The Decade of Discontent. And we're starting to get into some of the ideas from that thread now. You talk about the idea of a liquidity trap. Can you explain what that idea is and then you know, like the consequences of being caught in one.

So the sort of the driving force behind that is central banks providing a liquidity to the banking system and you know ultimately to corporations through a variety of mechanisms, you know, whether that be through lending, whether that be through you know special purpose vehicles that allows the central banks to purchase ETFs, corporate bonds.

And basically, what what it's really expressing, the liquidity trap is expressing sort of a concept of moral hazard, that if corporations, zombie corporations, know that corporations that have very little to no profit can barely service their debt, they know that the central bank, that the Federal Reserve is available to backstop any losses, they're going to continue operating as is.

They're not going to reform their practices, they're not going to try to become profitable, you know, not roll up into other companies or go bankrupt, which many of these probably should. And what ends up happening is that as you continue providing this sort of a backstop, you can encourage more, you encourage more risk.

So if I know that the central bank is going to be there for me and willing to pour in trillions of dollars, then I'm gonna go out and you know, raise some more debt, add more debt to my books, and continue operating as is. So what ends up happening is that you increasingly sort of calcify the system and create a whole swath of the economy, which is entirely dependent on a central bank providing liquidity.

Yeah, it's a it's a tough spiral. And as we, you know, you were alluding to already, the people who will suffer from this are not you know, sort of at the top of close to the banking system, right? Close to the to the Fed with the money printing. These 32 big banks, as the Fed calls them, that they're you know, they're limiting, I guess, their stock buybacks and stuff.

Those are the banks that work basically directly with the Fed and often, you know, get a lot of that money to distribute out to corporations and individuals. It's not gonna be the people who are associated with those banks or have close relations, relationships with those banks, the corporations, the very rich who are going to suffer.

It's going to be people who are poor, middle class, are going to increasingly see the effects of inflation and causing, you know, therefore some social unrest. Do you think then that you know that that's kind of our fate here in the in the next decade? More and kind of constant civil unrest sort of peaking and ebbing at certain times, but but never going away completely.

Yeah, I think that yeah, it actually might be helpful for your listeners to kind of let's take a step back. And for folks that have not read Neil Howe's book, The Fourth Turning, he so he kind of creates an interesting framework. So just kind of a brief summary of his book.

It's a very it's a very good book, I highly recommend it. He re looks at history through the lens of generational changes. And he has different names for different types of generations. Some are nomads, some are prophets, some are heroes. But he kind of has a sort of an 88-year-old, about 88-year cycle that he describes.

And I'll just kind of briefly go through that cycle. And I'm actually going to start at the end of the cycle. So so the end of the cycle is the crisis, sort of the winter, if you will. And we were recently, the most recent crisis or period that we went through was in the West in the Western civilization was about 1920s to about 1946.

So basically kind of spanning, spanning the roaring part of the roaring twenties, the crash of 29, depression, and then World War II. And usually during this time, most people are they're sort of seeking leadership. Folks are looking for a community because things have broken down.

They're looking for ways to rebuild institutions that have failed them. This is kind of a time period where where again folks are looking to close wealth gaps and generally ends with some sort of global reorganization and historically it's been a conflict, physical war. So after that period, then we come into what's called what what Neil calls the high, H-I-G-H, the high Period.

And that's sort of the spring. And recently, so that was about 1946, end of World War II period to about mid-1960s. And during that time, you get a really strong sense of community, strong sense of family. Institutions are trusted. Most people, when they graduate from college, would like to go work for a big government, they like to go work for a big company.

There's safety in income, pension plan, health care. There's more wealth equality. And actually, if you go back and you look at wealth equality and gaps during that time period, they're usually the smallest during this whole cycle. And then you have gender gap narrows, so it's more family-oriented.

And you know, recently in the 40s and 50s, we had less women in the workforce at that time. After the this high period, you come into the third cycle, which is the summer, which is called the awakening, and it kind of it is sounds just like what it is. It's the awakening, it's summertime. You know, it was this is about the mid-1960s to the mid-1980s, and there you see sort of the hippie movement, spiritual awakening, people looking inward, and they're sort of rejecting you know what their parents did during the high during the rebuilding of the country and re-establishing institutions.

Now they're more focused on on the individual, and that's the that's kind of a time of the awakening. There's a break of the family unit and you know a little more individualism, and then finally, and with sort of the third turning is called the unraveling, and this is the fall, and this would be about the mid 1980s to about 2008, 2010 ish.

And their individualism is the strongest. There's a strong mistrust of institutions, there are huge wealth inequality. You know, we see what what we normally trusted back in the 50s and 60s, 50s and 60s, we no longer trust those institutions and begin to look for ways to you know recreate recreate sort of society, recreate different types of organizations that are more suited for the for the new generation.

So we're now kind of in that next phase, the fourth phase, you know, again back to back to the beginning. We're in the crisis, which is about a 22 year period. I think Neil Howe describes it from about 2008 to 2020 30 ish. And during this time, exactly as you said, we're gonna see social unrest, we're gonna see people questioning wealth inequality, looking for ways to close wealth gaps.

And some of those are maybe misdirected. You'll see things like you know, tax the rich, eat the rich. You're going to see folks tearing down statues. I mean, that's that's an expression of sort of this idea of disassembling the old institutions. You know, whether or not they have any, you know, really any particular meaning at it's sort of a, I guess what I'm saying is sort of a subconscious attack against institutions, even though there's a current sort of a social crisis, if you will, and they're saying, well, you know, statues are are these statues represent XYZ, but really the subtext here is that it's breaking down the whole concept

Of the old institutions, no matter what era they're from. The idea is just to break these things down. So I think we're gonna see that we're gonna see different forms of social unrest over the next 10 years. We're also gonna see you know attempts at reorganizing as well. But it really things won't come, I think, to a conclusion until everybody is on board with one mission.

And that's what happened in in the 1940s, you know, through the Great Depression, and then finally with World War II, when the country came together, many countries came together, you know, the entire West against the Axis powers came together. I think that's the kind of culminating event that we're going to see at the end of this decade or into the early 30s, where there's one specific event that brings everybody together.

And it may not be a physical war. I think things have, you know, we've had sort of opportunities, if you will, for other types of conflict. It could be cyber war, it could be you know, biological conflict, like a pandemic, it could even be you know, folks deciding that we're done, we're we're no longer going to be subjected to these authoritarian states which have come up which have risen in the in the last 10 years, and they start resisting them.

Yeah, wow, it's it's a lot to take in and a lot to compliment you know, contemplate facing. I know a lot of Bitcoiners are sort of 30s, 40s, kind of middle-aged edge Gen Xers and older millennials and you know, starting families or young families, and it's scary to think about entering a time like this when you have you know little ones to take care of, take care of and maybe aging parents to consider as well.

So one aspect that sort of gives me a little bit of fear to a specific aspect is the idea that some of that hatred and discontent will be turned toward Bitcoiners. I think that if there's some kind of you know organic uprising of this sort of hate the rich, an aspect of that hate the rich sort of emergence would be a part of it focused on Bitcoiners.

I think the government then would latch on to that, right? As a way to sort of discredit Bitcoin as an alternative and try to just you know make it so distrust in it, right? And distrust in Bitcoiners. One way that I see this starting to happen, and these are friends and family of mine that have sort of pushed back against my Bitcoinism, I guess you could call it, with the idea that hey, you are you know kind of a part of this Ponzi scheme that and you're going to benefit if Bitcoin does well in the future.

You're you know closer to the sort of the printing of the money, closer to the beginning of the supply curve, and you're just gonna benefit from it and become rich, and you'll be fine, you'll be happy, and all these other people will be suffering who haven't had a chance to get Bitcoin because they're you know don't have they're poor or they don't have enough money or they're in a country where it's you know harder or more difficult to access, etc.

It's almost like the cancel-on effect you know, of fiat money, but applied to Bitcoiners. Now, I obviously disagree with this, and Udi Wertheimer and Gigi on the Swan Signal show recently got into this idea too, and Cory Klippsten sort of did a great job of kind of debunking that FUD.

But do you see that as a potential problem among other obviously, you know, other FUD that will still be there, the environment, etc. But does that concern you? Yeah, I think we're already starting to sort of see that. Jerome Powell brought up, mentioned Bitcoin last year during one of his meetings, one of the meetings with the Congress.

And I think President Trump shortly afterwards, you know, said Bitcoin's made from thin air and it's not really worth anything. And I and I, you know, I might sort of get the sense sort of the undercurrent is sort of unfavorable towards Bitcoin. But I also think that we're still so early in terms of market share, mind share, that it's not going to be an issue yet.

I think folks who are looking at people who've gotten into Bitcoin you know over the last 10 plus years, and think that you know I'm it's too late for me to participate, too late for me to learn about Bitcoin or you know, purchase a few SATs. I think that that that's that that's a sort of the I think the wrong way of looking at it.

The we're still very early along the adoption curve, and people purchasing Bitcoin almost anywhere before a million dollars in USD terms will still be early. I think there's plenty of opportunity to become involved in Bitcoin, whether if it's just hold just hodling or whether if it's you know contributing through discussion and writing.

But I do see that you know, as the price of Bitcoin rises and as central banks continue printing money, I think we're gonna see some pushback from from the you from the US government. It it has have the US, it is the world's reserve currency, so we're gonna get pushback on that.

And particularly, I think if we start to see other nation states begin to openly mine Bitcoin. I think I saw a brief report that Venezuela was going to start accepting some sort of I'm not sure if it was Bitcoin, but accepting crypto payments.

You know, I'm sure there are Venezuelans who are mining Bitcoin and perhaps even some government officials on the side doing it.

I think once we get a couple of nation states openly mining Bitcoin, sort of beginning sort of that global hash rate war, then we'll start to see some pushback. And I think Bitcoiners should be prepared for that. There's going to be a pushback, you know, from the government, and there'll be a pushback from friends and family who say, well, now you're dealing in potentially illegal money.

And I haven't had a chance to listen to the to the Swan podcast. I'd love to check that out. But I'm curious how on how

They were thinking to sort of sort of deflect the criticisms. But I think it's still going to be, even though we can deflect the criticisms with logical arguments, the United States will government or other governments may take illogical positions against Bitcoin because Bitcoin does threaten their ability to print money.

Yeah, absolutely. I think the best argument against this and pushback against it is the idea that, hey, you know, this is the same as any other investment, right? You know, you getting in early takes risk. It's it's difficult to you know build that conviction.

It takes a long time of edge, you know, long time to educate yourself, lots of hours of dedication to understanding what's going on here to build that conviction. And you know, most people who bought Bitcoin early, you know, sold it at some point when they thought they were, you know, cashing out with an incredible 2x, 5x, 10x return, you know. So I think that that's you know, it's it's like a stock that people got in early, and you know, that's you can't begrudge people being able to see into the future, peer into the future a little bit, and take the risk of be you know being an early adopter.

And yeah, I mean that's I think probably the most understandable and relatable kind of answer to that question that you know most Americans will get. But I think yeah, I think the governments and large corporations and banks really pushing on that idea that this is an unfair money, right?

I mean, one of the most I guess potent political tools is, and we see Trump use this all the time, and other politicians who pretty much every politician will push back on an idea that's like if they will push back on their criticisms by deflecting it and putting that criticism onto someone else, right?

Or something else. And so I could see the government in general saying, okay, hey, yeah, we have this super unfair money, okay. So we recognize that we're gonna respond to that argument by saying, but look at Bitcoin. You want to talk about unfair money? Look at Bitcoin, you know, that kind of thing. Right. Yeah, it's and you know, I would not be surprised if that were the case where Bitcoin becomes the fall guy or they attempt to make Bitcoin the fall guy for their own for their own their own errors and their own mistakes.

But it but I think that still now Bitcoin is still too small to do that. And it here's a kind of interesting way to look at it is that when Jerome Powell talked about Bitcoin, it's actually very interesting the way he talked about it. He he just said it's not, you know, it's it's it's not used for currency, it's not used as a currency, it's not used for payments.

He said it's not really used for anything except as a store of value. Which I thought was very interesting because he sort of in a way deflects that potential attack, that line of attack against Bitcoin. That Bitcoin is not, you know, quote unquote a currency, but it's just a store value, it's like digital gold.

Right. And that and that sort of thesis may be maybe sort of the best way to, you know, when I when I talk to people about Bitcoin, that's what I say. It's a currency hedge, it's a store, it's a store of value. You know, at some point in the future, you know, you'll be able to, you know, use it to exchange it for for things that you want to buy, and then you know, one day in the future you'll you'll be paid in Satoshis.

So I always like to talk about Bitcoin initially as a store value, as a hedge against the current fiat fiasco. And that seems to seems to resonate a little bit more. You know, instead of you know, maybe if you're gold bugs, you know, hey, you know, 50% in gold, 50% in Bitcoin, or if you know you're not a believer in gold, you know, go 100% into Bitcoin.

That's kind of the thesis that I take. And I and I'm thinking that that's sort of people who are investing in Bitcoin outside of Bitcoiners, sort of these financial services that are developing around it, are really looking at it, as you said, as more an investment opportunity and sort of like digital gold.

Yeah, I agree with that. I think that's the best narrative. I think it's a great narrative for Bitcoin that it's digital gold in this particular time. As we're seeing the beginnings of a possible currency collapse, you know, competing as an alternative currency could invite, as we're discussing here, this kind of you know, undue criticism that could lead to sort of you know, a mass pushback, you know, from people who are listening to the government corporations and listening to those criticisms and kind of taking them on face and not really digging deeper.

I think yeah, the digital gold narrative is great. And I think as in this cycle, Bitcoin will have the potential to rival Bitcoin gold's market cap. And that will just, I mean, that's gonna be the entire focus of this particular cycle is you know, Bitcoin's approaching gold's market cap, it's eating into gold's market caps 50% of gold, it's 75% of gold, et cetera, as we go.

So it's just gonna be absolutely entrenched in the next few years, we're just gonna hear Bitcoin's digital gold over and over again. So I think that is a good outcome. Let's let's talk a little bit about having Bitcoin in a particular situation like this, right? I mean, this is the first time that we've had you know, the potential collapse of a global reserve currency, and had this sort of independent, non-sovereign alternative.

Do you think that that might kind of soften the blow at all? Or do you think it's really just sort of there and then in the aftermath is when you know Bitcoin will kind of help us pick up the pieces, maybe in a quicker fashion than we would have otherwise? Yeah, I mean that's that's that's a fascinating you know scenario that be interesting to see how that plays out.

One of the things that I like to the way I look at it is that over the next sort of decade or so, as we see central banks, you know, continuing printing money, we're gonna see these pockets of inflation hyperinflation even and not necessarily only in the United States but you know outside we're gonna see currencies collapse like in Lebanon you know in Venezuela we've already seen it we're gonna see probably other countries under duress sort of as they're seeking US dollars you know the with a shortage in the euro dollar they're gonna be seeking US dollars and having a hard time finding that and in order to make up for the lack of US dollars to

Service their debt they're gonna have to sell off assets or devalue their own currencies. So I think that you we're gonna see sort of this whole multiple sequence variations of that sequence of events over the next 10 years some significant and some you know relatively you know sort of temporary crises that are solved by by the Federal Reserve doing doing currency swaps but with in terms of Bitcoin so what we have I guess at the end of this time period if we look at the US US dollar and it's sort of at at the potential end of its reserve currency status

You know according to Ray Dalio we're sort of at that at that cusp of that where it could potentially lose its reserve currency status and it and it makes sense I mean the US has been running a negative trade balance for many many years. You know we're pretty much a debtor nation and our debt is is pretty much close to an all-time high both in private debt and national public debt I think if we look at you look at the total debt in the US, it's about the total debt.

So this is adding sort of the public national debt, and you add private debt, you know, we're talking about 276, 270% of the GDP so we're kind of at that cusp where the currency could lose its reserve status. I think that as we you know move to the next 10 years or so, we're gonna see potential other other sort of pretenders to the throne, if you will, attempt to fill that gap.

But here's the interesting thing. So what happens, you know, will another country, will China, for example, I think is the primary primary country though, which may take over US's the US's position as a world superpower, only superpower. You know, would China's currency become the world's reserve currency.

I think there has to be a lot of trust for that to happen. If you look at what happened back in the 1940s, the United States had built up a huge amount of global trust. Between the 19 late 1900s to about 1940s, the United States was there to support its allies you know through lending, through selling them goods and services during the first world war, participating in the first world war, and then subsequently in World War during the World War II era, the US built up a lot of goodwill.

And not only goodwill during the time of the war, but even post-World War II with with some of the reconstruction programs and you know forgiving forgiving debt as well, right? So with the US had an opportunity to build up a huge amount of goodwill, and I think that really played in played in played a big part in the in the US dollar becoming the reserve currency.

And secondly, and sort of the sub subtext of this is that the US at that point had pretty much had most of the most of the gold. You know, they've been hoarding, they've been getting gold in from the from the late 1920s through the 1930s, you know, in part through what through the World War I effort, Britain was paying and France were paying the US basically in gold.

And then back in the 1940s, you had the same thing. So the US had a huge amount of gold. So they sort of had this base of money.

They had most of the gold.

And so the reserve currency was was ultimately based on that. Now we're kind of in a in a very odd situation where we have fiat money really not really based on anything. So, you know, are we going to be able to return to some sort of sound money as post-USD?

And I think that's where Bitcoin has a very unique value proposition to pretty much almost every country. With Bitcoin, you potentially are going to avoid the whole concept of the Triffin's paradox of Trippin's dilemma, where the reserve currency company eventually country eventually becomes sort of insolvent, if you will, over a period of time.

Bitcoin as a non-sovereign money allows really any nation state to participate in mining Bitcoin and supporting Bitcoin.

And so I think that, you know, if if cool mines prevail, and we have some you know really deep thinking about this, particularly at the sort of the nation level, nation-state level, you know, once this crisis passes, I'm hoping that folks will see that Bitcoin does have the opportunity to does create opportunities for every country to participate in a in a relatively fair economic paradigm.

And for those countries that want to participate even more, if you will, they can apply hash power and capture more bitcoins. Can you just quickly kind of define and explain what tri a Triffen dilemma is for our listeners? I think that that's it's it's a really important concept for Bitcoiners to understand right now.

And I think it's not widely recognized, at least under that name. Sure. So it just really briefly, it's it describes how a country that has that is the holds the world's reserve currency, the US dollar at this time, eventually runs a negative trade balance.

And as other countries essentially use the US dollar for any type of most transactions in the in the world now, I think it's about 50, 60 percent, that over time the country runs a runs basically runs a trade balance, runs a negative trade balance and basically it it sort of threatens the reserve currency and probably I'm rambling here right now, but but basically it sort of threatens a reserve currency and eventually the country itself, the US becomes a debtor

Nation. A lot of its supply chains are exported out to other countries for cheaper labor. And in what and so that's and then the country has to run up a huge amount of debt, and that cycle just keeps repeating itself. Yeah. And I, you know, we're seeing it happen in real time. And it was you know, you can just go on Wikipedia and read through the history of the Triffin Dilemma, and I think it'll have a good sort of basis to understand it.

And I think you'll hear this term more and more over the coming decade. Interesting idea that Max Keiser has been talking about is this coming global hash war, right? Which is sort of b essentially the idea of hyper bitcoinization.

So I wanted to kind of switch toward to that topic, you know, kind of use this as a segue, because you I think probably your most well-known and widely read article is hyper bitcoinization winner takes all, which I saw on your Twitter stream that you it was basically about two years ago now that you published that.

Yeah, so the idea of the hash war is that you know, exactly that what it sounds like is that governments are going to start really ramping up mining efforts once they, you know, see that Bitcoin is not dead yet again, and that's you know, the sit the writing on the wall with the US dollar, potential currency war that would follow that, that you know, Bitcoin is here as a non-sovereign, independent, you know, apolitical option, that's they'll start, you know, just rushing to get as much as they can.

And the best way, you know, probably the best way for a sovereign to gain Bitcoin is to is to mine it. It's the most anonymous and you know, arguably, you know, you don't have to like procure it from another sovereign or you know, holder directly. So he says, you know, that this will kind of escalate quickly, like the idea of hybrid Bitcoinization, and that it will drive up both the security of the coin and the price.

Yeah, I think I came across as I didn't read the article, I saw his tweet about that, but I that that seems to make sense I mean as you know as countries look to countries look to the US for for not only global leadership and military security but also for financial leadership and financial security and with the US running you know running these deficits and I don't see these deficits getting any smaller I think they're going to get larger and accelerate you know over the next 10 to 20 years and what ends up happening is that it sort of ties everybody into a currency that potentially

Could fail and bring down the entire financial system you know or or at the very least you know create financial havoc for a good 10 15 20 years and I think you know as as a reserve currency comes to its end you know there are these countries will start looking for alternatives and especially smaller emerging market company countries they're they're going to be looking at things like Bitcoin potentially doing their own sort of digital you know central bank digital coins or other cryptographic coins to support their own currencies support their own support their own

Economies my sense is that my sense is that in the sort of the global financial markets there's there is a lot of concern about the US dollar's ability to support the economy particularly through a crisis like this when you have a lot of countries just you know absolutely dependent on US dollars to manage and to run their economy.

And they have to service their debt in US dollars, right? So if you're you're you have debt, it has to be serviced in in US dollars. You want to buy oil, it has to be done in US dollars. So somehow you need to access that money. And if there's a euro dollar shortage, you know, where where are you going to get your your once once you run out of your US dollar reserves in in your country, where are you gonna get that?

You have to sell off assets, you have to take on more debt. So I think that is you know, a particular definitely a particular vexing issue for a lot of countries. And you know, if the US dollar starts to starts to lose value, then in order to sort of balance out your own currency and to and to encourage your you know encourage your own exports and make your exports competitive, you have to devalue your own currency.

So it becomes sort of a vicious cycle. It's part of the Triffin's paradox, that you know there's a sort of sort of this constant rebalancing of the current of currencies based on the reserve the reserve currencies debt level and what they're doing with what what they're doing with their money. So I so I can definitely see where you have small countries begin to mine Bitcoin and yeah and use it maybe not initially as a currency but as a hedge.

You know, let's right now let's mine some bitcoins and start you know start hoarding them. Yeah. It is mind blowing to think that we're on the precipice of this already, and you know, I really do think that this pandemic and the associated monetary response has really pulled this future forward.

So let's let's look at hyperbitcoinization when it takes all it's been two years. What's how do you think the article is holding up? Do you have any sort of amendments that you would make to the article two years on? Yeah, you know, I've been thinking about that. I wanted to do an amendment last year, but I didn't. I you know and I'm reluctant to actually change anything in the article.

If I do make any sort of changes, if you will, it'll be with a second independent article. So I'm just gonna let this let this one stand. It's not perfect. I know there are a couple of areas that I wish I had clarified my thinking, particularly around the use of financial instruments in the calculation.

You know, I sort of glossed over it a little bit more than I had intended to. And another area I wish I had included was more talking about central bank policies and central bank printing. That I wish I had included. And it's in it's interesting, I think those two sort of balance themselves out.

So including the financial instruments like derivatives and futures and whatnot, you know, you can argue that well, those really don't have any value, if you will, in terms of money. But my thoughts were I wanted to include those because what I wanted to was look at is what what what would be the ultimate value for Bitcoin if it was the only instrument that we could use in the entire planet.

So there'd be no no derivatives, no futures contracts, you know, and no no options and things like that. Obviously, you know, potentially unrealistic, but I wanted to see what the potential value, what Bitcoin's potential value could be. But even if you subtract subtract out that from the equation, you know, we're looking at a Bitcoin in the tens of millions of dollars in potential value.

But now you add back in what the central banks are doing, and they're diluting the value of the US dollar, the Fed is. And you know, so in 2018 terms, you know, we can almost argue that, well, in you know, in 22, 30 years, you know, you've already lost from 2018 terms, you know, at least, you know, just in 2% inflation, you've lost, you know, 20 to 30, even 40% by the time you know Bitcoin becomes the world's currency.

And then you add on top of that all the printing that's going on, trillions of dollars, you know, instantaneously. You can see in not in in 2018 terms that Bitcoin could easily get into the 10, 20, 30 million dollar range and potentially even more.

It's crazy, man. It's crazy talk. It's all crazy talk, you know, it totally is. You know, it's all it's all sci-fi. It's bizarre. Well, what's interesting, what's interesting is after that article came out. I know I know I got a lot of pushback on the number, the 100 million.

But the conversation shifted from 100,000 to millions. Right. You know, it was interesting to see that that conversation evolve over the year, that you know, it went from you know, Bitcoin's gonna get to 100,000 to now Bitcoin is it's a million is inevitable.

Yeah. And I think with plan B's model, that sort of reinforced that that that that that thinking that there's there's huge potential here. I think his model, his stock to flow and the second version that he did, this the S2FX, or that was the third version. I think those really confirmed a lot of you know, added added some more a little more more rigorous mathematics to it.

Right. Yeah. Yeah it's an impressive model the s2f x model in particular really spoke to me and I think added sort of another layer of I guess almost justification of the previous model fascinating stuff and I would love to talk to him about it at some point but he's he's done a good job of you know explaining it and spreading the word and I think he's you know his it's he makes a very complicated model very approachable so I do appreciate that yeah yeah so in the article and you know we talked about this last year and I'll definitely link to

Our previous episode our first episode which by the way was for a very long time one of the top you know two or three episodes on this podcast feed and you know really only dropped out of the top ten once started streaming this on the Let's Talk Bitcoin network and numbers really kind of jumped up so there's sort of a before and after it's not really fair to compare anymore but it was a very well received episode and you know I really appreciate you coming back and I think you're in terms of the podcast world Bitcoin podcast world is you know kind of underrepresented I would love to hear some of the other podcasters out there have you on and have some discussions also we talked about

Like I said we talked about this then but I find this analogy fascinating because there's you know I love analogies for understanding complex topics we have no shortage of them in Bitcoin you know the mushroom analogy of Brandon Quiddams Dan Held compared it to sort of a tree and planting a tree and growing.

There's lots of biological, other biological analogies as well. And yours, comparing it to the process of crystallization is unique, and I hadn't seen it before or since discussed. First of all, is this something, and I may have asked this before, but I can't remember. Is this does this come out of like your professional work, this idea, or just you know, maybe maybe just kind of a side fascination with this particular biological, I guess, or not really biological, but natural process.

It was more of a side aside fascination, if you will. While I was writing the article, I spent some time looking at different types of models, and I, you know, I came across sort of the came across this, and I thought this is a very interesting way to sort of express how things grow, particularly networked, particularly networked processes.

You know, how do network processes grow and you know what makes them become exponential, what makes them achieve exponential growth? And if you look at the crystal, the crystal method, the crystallization process, it's it's very similar to that. You have this initial sort of nucleation phase where not much seems to be going on, you're adding a lot of energy into the system, you know, you're forming a few bonds between you know different different crystal molecules, but then at some point there's this tipping point where you don't have to add the energy in anymore.

It just starts forming the bonds, you know, not as much energy. It starts forming bonds automatically, very rapidly, exponentially, and then becomes you know much stronger than some of its parts. And that, you know, you look at things like social networks, you look at you look, you know, the social networks like Facebook or even early on, even let's even start before that, you know, AOL, MySpace, Napster, you know, then you know, Facebook, and so forth and so on, those all kind of follow this similar model where initially there's there's some initial user growth, not much is growing on, but then eventually over time, as

The users sort of connect to each other, the network explodes. And I think that's what's that's what I really liked about this model. It really helps sort of sort of solidify my thoughts around what was going on with Bitcoin, you know, because we have so many different facets of Bitcoin. We have you know, the users, we have miners, we have note, you know, people folks that are running nodes, exchanges, you know, then we have financial institutions, you know, who are sort of maybe early on in the game, like Fidelity was early on, kind of got involved in that nucleation event event by sort of you know mining mining different types of coins, including Bitcoin, but spreading

That that news, right? Spreading that information to other financial institutions that were interested in the space. So I think all those things sort of added up and have sort of propelled Bitcoin along this path. And once once we get past the tipping point, it's almost inevitable that you know the crystal itself will will form, you know, all the bonds will form, you know, you just can't stop it.

You know, without other than shattering the entire system, you know, you can't stop it. It's beautiful. I love it. All right, so my next question for you is the tipping point, right? This is sort of the point right after you know the everything's been established and the user growth just starts to go parabolic.

Right now, or you know, maybe maybe not even right now, but there's this period that you call the micro bubbles. Maybe that's what we're in right now in your interpretation. Is that is that correct? Like we're still in this kind of series of micro bubbles. Yes. Yeah. Okay. And then comes larger, longer term bubbles. Like, what's the difference in your mind between micro bubbles and bubbles in this in this process?

So in the micro bubbles are sort of these these waves that we have had over the last well since Bitcoin's inception, spikes up and down. They're you know relatively limited in terms of height and duration, if you will. I think that you know, once we get past the tipping point, we're gonna see much significantly larger, longer bubbles.

They may look less like bubbles to us, but I think we'll see, you know, Bitcoin once it cracks that $1 million mark, then it'll drop down, you know, make it'll make a correction, but then we'll start to see another wave of adoption and price increasing shortly afterwards.

At that point, you know, I think we'll start to see sort of what we've talked about earlier, the nation states, larger organizations getting involved in Bitcoin. So I think these these micro bubbles, you know, between you know 10,000, like I think what was it, last thousand? The previous one then went down to about four or five hundred, then we you know jumped to twenty thousand.

Just in just in absolute terms, you know, when you're look talking about you know swings of a hundred thousand dollars, you know, they're they're gonna look pretty small. Okay, yeah, okay, I get it. Do you think then in the next few years, considering or if you agree that the you know kind of future of Bitcoin has sort of been pulled forward by our current situation?

Do you think that we might have the ability or the potential, I should say, to reach the tipping point in the next few years in this cycle. I know Preston Pysh thinks that that might be possible. We've talked about that recently also on this one signal podcast. He said that he thinks there's a you know a much better chance than it's you know given credit for currently kind of estimated by the general population, even among Bitcoiners, that we reach escape velocity, you know, in this next three to five year cycle.

You know, I'm inclined to agree with him. I think that the I think that the central banks are now fighting a losing battle. They're not going to be able to return back to the 2% inflation, I mean to meet that 2% inflation mandate.

I think we're gonna see huge amounts of printing, huge accrual of debt. So I think that we can definitely see Bitcoin you know suddenly take off, if you will. And again, we're sort of, you know, I think if Jeff Booth also describes, we're in this, you know, we're in this the rate of change is accelerating, you know, the rate of change itself is accelerating.

And over the next 10 years, you know, we look at things in very linearly, but I think we have to understand that things are happening exponentially. And you almost look at 2020 so far as a perfect example of exponential change and things are just happening so quickly. So I do see that you know there's a potential within the next five to ten years, we could see Bitcoin really take off.

Yeah. All right. Well, let's bring it back to the end of your decade of discontent thread. Perhaps we see hyperbitcoinization, you know, in the next five, 10 years, let's say. What does the world look like after? We had talked a little bit earlier about sort of Bitcoin being there to pick up the pieces and help us, you know, be the foundation of a of a new economy.

What does that look like? Bitcoin is a different kind of money. It's fundamentally different. The fact that it's non-sovereign and nation states have used as their you know a main tool of control, the ability to print the money. You know, that and large armies, and I think you know, those are those two are obviously correlated in my mind anyway.

So what do you think that future looks like? I mean, it's do nation states sort of dissolve and we are left with or build up from those sort of the ashes of the nation states, you know, smaller regional organizations and governments, municipalities, etc.

Yeah, I think that I think that one to kind of take one step back. I think what first has to happen is we've got to lose lose confidence, if you will, or even governments, politicians themselves lose confidence in central banks and central bank policies. I think that that's an important step. You know, once that that mandate's been taken away and central banks' authority has been reduced and their ability to just you know print money has been has been limited.

I think that's going to be an important first step for nation states to take. But post let's say post that time period, I think we'll see Bitcoin be taken up as as the world's reserve currency. Initially it'll be used for you know global settlement. Then over time we'll start seeing it as a medium of exchange and as we develop you know secondary tertiary layers on the protocol you know we can definitely see it as being used in everyday usage you know through phone through through our phones so I mean I do see it sort of practical you know both kind of fun from as a financial underpinning

Of the global economy to you know buying coffee that I definitely can see that happening but I think there's going to be a transition period if you look at any of the reserve currencies that have sort of collapsed and they're never never really you know collapse one day it's just it's taken time even the when the British pound sort of was was swapped out for the US dollar you know that took about 20 years.

It started really around in the 1920s after around World War I and World War II sorry around World War I and post-World War I Britain basically lost a substantial amount of its gold reserves to the United States to pay for the efforts of the war and then the reparation issues around that also significantly impacted its currency but that took about you know 20 years or so before the US took US dollar was decided to become the world's reserve currency with the Bretton Woods agreement so I think we're gonna see something similar play out with Bitcoin that initially you know the world

Is still gonna operate on the US dollar, like just like the British pound, it hasn't gone anywhere. It's still around the US will still operate in the world on the US dollar. But the underpinnings of all of that fiat system will actually have something. There'll be sound money there. And then over time, you know, we can migrate and people can make the decision to migrate to using Bitcoin only as opposed to using a currency proxy currency for it.

Wow. It's a lot to think about, man. It's a lot to consider. And we as Bitcoiners have been you know thinking about this potential future for quite a while and the fact that it's staring us in the face right now is really just it's kind of hard to believe. I anytime I have conversations with other Bitcoiners, you know, every week now, I am just kind of blown away all over again because it's actually happening, the situation that Bitcoin was really born out of and then you know potentially here to help us you know not prevent but have an

Option a hedge against you know this type of a situation it's it's a bit drawdropping and mind blowing to me. Yeah absolutely I mean I think that this is probably one of the first times in in history where we're making the sort of transition from sound money to fiat now to potentially another sound money system you know we're definitely living through very interesting times and I think historical times and the next next 20 years are definitely gonna be very telling but yeah it is absolutely fascinating to see Bitcoin go from basically a collectible you know token you know to

You know the world into the discussion of the r world's reserve currency within a matter of a just a decade. Yeah. It's just absolutely it's just just mind boggling that in 10 years. It's amazing. It's ridiculous. Which is why, you know, saying that it could actually achieve, you know, something at least close to a world reserve currency in the next 10 years is not completely out of the realm of possibility, right?

You know, the situation we're facing now, you know, considering that especially man, you know, if if Bitcoin is like a precocious 11 year old now, like it could be, you know, just like a beastly Michael Phelps or Tiger Woods or Michael Jordan. All of them put together yeah.

Or all of them put together exactly. Yeah I think you know go ahead. I think that you know one of the key innovation here and or and what Satoshi did with the hard cap supply and the digital scarcity. I mean I think that really goes that really that really is underpins a lot of what Bitcoin is about.

Hard cap supply and you know the and the controlled issuance the predictability I mean these are all things that we don't have today in money right the these we don't have a hard cap supply we have infinite cash we can print whenever we want and I think that sort of with almost like Bitcoin is sort of like austerity it's built in austerity it's built in laws and kind of physics of money if you will you know we can't just randomly change some universal constant to fit our to meet our needs or desires we have to follow

Along with with Bitcoin's rule set and I think that's the that the a lot of people don't get that don't quite understand that even when you try to explain it to them like this is what Bitcoin's about they say well the government can just print money. Well like well but no let me explain why that's not a good thing but yeah and it's absolutely amazing that you know Bitcoin has you know in in a matter of years you know standing up on the global stage and you know for now holding its own it's amazing if you're listening to this you are living through historic times and I think if you know look back 10 20

Years from now it'll be astonishing that we were here this early and I think there'll be a tremendous sense of pride maybe that we were here and did at least something to try to help people understand this and you know bring this this this future world this potential future world about in the you know most peaceful and you know best way possible yep absolutely I mean I think I think that's the key thing is that you know Bitcoin is is is Bitcoin is money for a peaceful transition

You know and if if there's gonna be a war let it be let it be a hash war exactly absolutely well said man well I really appreciate your time can't wait to share this with with all the listeners and congratulations on a two year anniversary it would be fun to see a second edition so maybe that maybe that'll come out at some point yeah I've got a few things that I'm working on a couple of another a couple of long threads and a couple of articles but I'd love to revisit that article again and write it write a follow up.

Do you have a place where you have collected all of your threads that's easily shareable? I have not I did last early in the year I kind of did a thread of threads. Uh-huh. I believe I published it in the first week of January. But I'm I'm actually going to I'm looking for a place to export all of my writings onto my own website.

Okay. So looking for looking for a place where I can put all my articles there. And I'll still share them on Twitter, Medium and other other outlets, but I really want to establish my own website and just have everything recorded there. So if anybody wants to go back and reference, you know, different threads, different articles, it'll all be in one place.

Nice. You've got the makings of a book here man. That that's that's also been another another another item another an item to tick off on my list here that I would like to write a book. I'm sort of struggling with the format. I'm sure your maybe your listeners know or don't know but you know I've been doing the letters to Satoshi.

Yes I love this. The dear Satoshi. So I actually have been thinking about publishing that first. Nice. So I have a whole bunch of letters to Satoshi that I have not posted on Twitter because of length. So so though I actually might do that first and then follow up with a book that's more kind of focused on on on the sort of the financial the financial aspects and the global macroeconomic issues that Bitcoin addresses.

I really love that format the letters to Satoshi and I don't know if you've ever entertained this thought but it just popped into my head it would be pretty amazing if Satoshi himself or herself or their self were out there you know reading those threads and those letters and those posts. Like, oh, this one's written straight to me.

That'd be pretty cool. Yeah. Alright, man. We'll drop it there and again, really appreciate your time. Hope you have a great day. Thanks. You too. Take care.

Thanks to Obi Wan for joining me today. You can find him on Twitter at Obi Wan Kenobit. That's O-B-I-W-A-N-K-E-N-O-B-I-T. And I am at Citizen Bitcoin on the Bitcoin Twitter. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. Share this one with your family and friends, share it with your Bitcoiners on Twitter.

I love it when you guys tweet out these episodes. Sometimes you throw in a quote. It's really great. It helps me a ton, and I you know makes me smile every time I see it. So I love that stuff. Keep it coming. Thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring this episode and to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the podcast in their feed.

Check out my merch shop at layer1btc.com. You can check out partners and then citizen Bitcoin, cool stuff there. Check out the unfuck the money design. Check out the strategically applied toxicity design. I think it's deployed sat strategically applied toxicity. Alright, both of those are relatively op sec friendly shirts.

And there's also some citizen Bitcoin branded stuff. Check it out. And take a look at the podcast that we're making for Swan, the Swan Signal Podcast. It's an audio archive of our weekly Swan Signal live broadcasts. We put those out on YouTube and Twitter. And we publish the audio as a podcast at Swan Signal Podcast.com.

You're a fan of Bitcoin Podcasts. I know you're gonna love this one too. It is a fantastic production. We pair up great Bitcoiners for you know compelling discussions. I think you should add it to your rotation. Give it a shot. Alright, if you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. My DMs are open on Twitter. I am Citizen Bitcoin on Telegram.

All right, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Today we sit down with ObiWan Kenobit. We talk about what he calls the Decade of Discontent ahead of us as we transition through a currency collapse and into a new monetary era based on bitcoin. We talk about history through the lens of generational change guided by the ideas of William Strauss and Neil Howe and we talk about the second anniversary of his viral piece “Hyperbitcoinization: Winner Takes All” - about how the article holds up and any updates he might make to it 2 years on.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast

Citizen Bitcoin Layer One merch collection

Bitcoiner's Best

Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek

Obiwan on Twitter

Downloads