All episodes
Episode 68

Knut Svanholm: Freedom and Hyperbitcoinization

January 23, 202075 min

Knut Svanholm is the author of Sovereignty Through Mathematics. Knut and I talk about how this fiat monstrosity erodes our basic freedoms and how the discovery of absolute scarcity that is bitcoin will restore and protect those freedoms. We talk a bit about lighting and close out by riffing for quite a while on the prospects of hyperbitconization and how it could affect our social order.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. I've got a discussion with Knut Zvanholm, author of Sovereignty Through Mathematics. Another great Bitcoin book that you can get through in a couple hours.

Definitely recommend adding it to your collection. First, we'll check in with Swan Bitcoin, makers of GiveBitcoin and Save Bitcoin. Thanks to Swan for helping bring this episode to you today. Now there's a ton happening behind the scenes at Swan. There's a design upgrade from the live beta of Gibbitcoin.io that's getting ready to launch and go live.

It's looking absolutely fantastic. Watch out for some really fun SATS giveaways from the Swan team in the run up to the Bitcoin 2020 conference, of which Swan is a sponsor.

Work on the Save Bitcoin product is proceeding at a rapid pace. I can't wait till that service is launched. It's a super simple, set it and forget it, Bitcoin auto-stacking savings account, and it looks great.

You can follow along as well on Bitcoin Twitter with the developments that the Swan team are making. Swan is at SwanBitcoin, Give is at Give underscore Bitcoin, and Save is at Save underscore Bitcoin. All right, just a couple more quick shout-outs before we get going. First, my merch partner, Nick Ward, over at LayerOneBTC. Nick's put together a fun collection of Citizen Bitcoin merch. You can find that at LayerOneBTC.com.

In the menu, click partners and then Citizen Bitcoin. The sales of the merch do support the podcast, and layer one is a great Bitcoin-only business, so check it out. And big love to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the Citizen Bitcoin pod in the LTBN family of podcasts. If you're listening from the LTBN feed and you like what you hear, you can find the growing archive of great shows on the web at citizenbitcoin.world.

And follow the LTBN on Bitcoin Twitter at the LTB Network and check out the LTBN feed for some other great Bitcoin podcasts.

Knut Svanholm is the author of Sovereignty Through Mathematics,

Another great brief Bitcoin book that you can add to your collection. It's available on Kindle and in paperback, and it just became available on Audible, narrated by our guy, Guy Swann. It's available for free as well on the crypto economy podcast feed, but of course it'd be nice to throw a few bucks Knut's way for his work.

Knut and I talk about how this fiat monstrosity erodes our basic freedoms and how the discovery of absolute scarcity that is Bitcoin will restore and protect those freedoms. We talk a bit about lightning. We close out by riffing for quite a while on the prospects of hyperbitcoinization and how it could affect our social order.

It's an absolutely great chat. I think you all will enjoy. Here we go. Alright, I'm excited to welcome Knut Svanholm to the podcast, author of Sovereignty Through Mathematics.

How's it going, Knut? Going good. Glad to be on the show. Yeah, man. Been looking forward to this. Yeah, it's been a long time coming. We've been talking about this for a few months now, so I'm glad that we're able to make it happen today. Yeah, me too. And I heard I heard the pod with the Chiara Bickers and I heard the pod with Jan Pritzer.

And first of all, thank you for mentioning my book on that pod. I know Jan likes the book and I'm really happy about that. And I'm looking forward to talking about the same things that you talked to them about in those two pods because I thought yeah, yeah, we'll get into it.

Yeah, we'll get into all that stuff for sure. I'm kind of on a an author kick right now. So I had Andreas Antonopoulos on, he was you know had just published his new book, Internet of Money 3, and then Chiara and Jan and you. So we have a good string of Bitcoin authors on right now.

Oh Andre Andreas was on the show before Chiara. Yeah, yeah, he was on the show just before Christmas, a couple days before Christmas. Oh right. I have to listen to that. It was a good one. Yeah, I he he was my teacher.

I took Oh, that's right. I heard that. Yeah, I took the MOOC in the University of Nicosia in 2006, I believe. What was that all about? How did that go? And he was one of the teachers. That was like an introductionary introduction course to digital currencies.

That was like my first deeper dive into the ra rabbit hole. So how did you how'd you come to take that course? What's what sparked the interest in fifteen must have been the year, yeah. So why did you end up taking it yeah yeah I thought it sounded interesting and I like had a lot of spare time during during my job then so I had some time to do it and I thought why not?

This this is I've I was very curious about the whole thing and I've I had already read up on it quite a bit but I thought this this might be a springboard to something else and then the course went very well and I think I learned a lot and proud to say I was one of the top students they offered scholarships and stuff probably but just because they wanted to sell me the master's course but anyway I thought maybe maybe I could do something with this I and like a year after

The course I was I started writing about Bitcoin because I thought why not try it out to see if I can do something in this see if there's a place for me in this space and I think I found it yeah I think you did too so what what sparked the initial interest though like you signed up for the course obviously you had been reading about it but you know when when did you discover it or like do you remember the moment or the time that you actually like first heard of it and then or maybe sometimes for a lot of people it's you know it's you hear about it several times ignore it or whatever before you really dive in.

How did it happen for you? Yeah, it's a very good question. At the time I was sailing the Atlantic and the like in the c Caribbean and the US East Coast and I had heard heard about it and read about it a bit and I got curious because like a functioning currency on the internet is something that I've ever since I first encountered the internet that it's been like an idea like the can can this actually be

Is this possible or not? The idea enthralled me, so to speak, and of course you have to sort of dive into it to get to know how they got around the double spending problem and everything and like can't every thing in code just be copied an infinite mo amount of times and how does this work?

So yeah, I can't pinpoint an exact point in time where where I discovered Bitcoin so to speak, it's sort of a gradual thing, as I believe it was for most is for most people in it. I love that image of you sailing around the ocean, you know, like falling down the rabbit hole.

It sounds very romantic. It does, doesn't it? Does and we went to like Cuba and the States like during the same week sometimes, so from Havana to Charleston, South Carolina, and those places are so vastly different and the political systems in each place are vastly different as w as well.

So so you try to you try to figure out what's different differentiates them. And you try to of course everyone is biased in their own particular way, but like I'd seen a lot of countries and I noticed the differences.

And I noticed I tended to come to other conclusions than other Swedes did about places.

Like Havana wasn't really the paradise that many Swedes wanted to frame it as

For me.

I really like Charleston. Well, right before we started recording, we were talking about our Swedish connection. You're obviously from Sweden, as you just mentioned, and my family hails from Sweden, and I've been to visit the ancestral country. It's a beautiful place. But politically, it's very much a socialist country, and it seems to work very well for Sweden in terms of just, you know, happiness and business still thrives there.

How do you approach,

What are your political leanings? And how do you think Bitcoin is going to affect the you know political ideas, the prevailing political ideas of kind of capitalist democracies and socialist democracies? This is very very good question because I think the picture of Sweden that is being marketed to the rest of the world as some form of socialist utopia is very misguided.

Because and th there was a great episode of the Rubin report about this just the other week with two Swedes called Henrik Jonsson and Aron Flam. And the political elite in Sweden hate those guys because they're they two youtubers who have a libertarian sort of libertarian leaning perspective on things and like I go into some parts of this in my book and I've been writing about it in a bit in a potential sequel.

I've been writing 85 pages since I went to vacation in Spain. So I have some stuff coming up. I don't know when it's it's very crude at the moment. But anyway the thing is that like 49 of the 50 biggest Swedish companies like IKEA and Ericsson and all these Volvo and all these big companies they were they began before socialism began in Sweden.

They they started the companies like a hundred years ago the vast my majority of them and we sort of got very rich from a period of very laissez-faire political climate in the country we have low taxes and free market economy early on a guy called Juan Griepen Kana I believe so started the whole thing in the end of the nineteenth century and the Social Democrats didn't really get into power until the like

30s and 40s which is when and they have a bit of a shady story shady backstory with connections to Nazi Germany and everything which is seldom mentioned here because we say that we were neutral during the war which is not entirely historically correct as I'm interesting yeah because we sh we provided Nazi Germany with steel for the tanks and stuff like that and we shipped soldiers by train through Sweden into

Norway German soldiers and after the war had ended we were like unscarred in a way that other European countries were not so we had a head start there and we could thrive in spite of socialism and not because of it and they they basically ruined the economy and we had to devaluate the crown in the in the early nineties and after that there was some privatizing is going on and some some reforms in the country we had like a massive

Like we're one of the most healthy countries in the world and still we had everyone on sick leave because the sick leave benefits were so high and we now we've had a socialist government again for quite some time and I fear we're leaning that way again and there's like really no political force in the country that wants to liberate stuff and like put less control over the population.

There there's like the nationalists on the extreme right and the like the communists on the extreme left and as I see it there's a there's a zero point an orgo if you will and politics are just on the left of on the left of that to more or less extent like I guess I come from a sort of libertarian viewpoint it's people find it a bit extreme but when you di when you dive so deep down into Bitcoin and all this about inflation and how it's I s I tend to think

Of these things from a moral standpoint and like where am I in this question from a moral standpoint really and I believe that there are better ways of cooperating than to coerce people into certain behaviors. I think we could do without coercion a lot more than we do today and I like deregulating stuff deregulations and opening stuff up yeah so I did you come to this libertarian sort of leaning this more Austrian economic approach

To money through Bitcoin or did you was this something that you were exposed to in Sweden before that or or elsewhere in the world I guess yeah I was exposed to it earlier on

First of all I spent couple of years during my childhood in different countries in Africa so I wasn't based in Sweden all the time and then I've been in the merchant navy for quite some time and like been around a lot. And but these these ideas have been like if you're if you have a curious mind you tend to think about things and you try to try to understand the world and what makes it take w what makes certain things work or not.

And I s I sort of had these thoughts before Bitcoin, but Bitcoin got me into Austrian economics and that's sort of refined the whole thing and like put words right on my thoughts. Like I read Human Action by Ludwig von Mises not too long ago and that's that's that sort of hit the nail on the head for me.

I buy most of the arguments in that book, if not all. Well, congratulations on getting through it. I still have Yeah, yeah, I listened to it 36 hours or something. Oh, is it on Audible? Yeah, it is. Audible.

All right, well I'm gonna have to grab that. I wasn't sure. I wasn't aware of that. I guess maybe I remember looking for it and I guess I must have messed that up. But I have a hard copy of it and good luck. It's it's it's a heavy lift. I've kind of been flipping through it. Yeah. So I think I'll be much more likely to get through it on Audible when I can kind of speed it up a little bit.

Yeah, so yeah, I feel like Bitcoiners kinda come around to that. So, you know, Bitcoin red pills us on on money and we sort of a lot of us wake up, you know, to what money really is. And Andreas mentioned on our episode that that's sort of a sign of Western privilege, that we you know we don't really we can live our lives without knowing what money really is, because we've lived in a in a place where the money functions relatively well, you know, compared to places like like Venezuela or where Andreas grew up, like Greece.

And yeah, I mean, you know, I would still argue that you know the money is still you know really harming everyone in the world, despite you know, regardless of where you live, it just sort of happens either very quickly and you can kind of recognize it and be forced to wake up to what money really is that way, or it happens sort of insidiously and slowly, and that's what allows you know these countries to that that produce their own fiat money to sort of keep the veil over what's actually happening, you know.

Like don't don't look at the man behind the curtain kind of situation. Yeah, yeah. It's like it's like a m magician waving the right hand and doing something else with the left hand, and you're not supposed to pay attention to his left hand because he's but all the mainstream media and everything are focusing on issues that aren't really solvable unless you solve the underlying problem, which is always the money and the fact that inflation is theft on a massive scale, and we're all being robbed all the time, and we're being incentivized to

Into destructive behaviors and self-destructive behaviors and all these problems with the environment and everything, they all stem from the overconsumption boom that comes from bad investment, basically. If we could make better use of our time, we would be better off, and we wouldn't have this race to the bottom that everyone's in.

I truly believe these things. I do too, I do too. Let's dive into that a little bit more. I love that phrase that you just used. We're incentivized into self-destructive behavior. And I think that that's true on a personal level, and like you also mentioned on a on a you know more of a kind of a macroeconomic scale as well.

We are incentivized to build businesses that are obviously like you know, very short-term short-time preference. They are they are living for the quarterly returns, right? So that they can show some sort of growth, some over quarter over quarter growth, so that their stock price will increase, so that they can take out more debt to do the same thing again the next quarter and you know just add infinitum.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. And the biggest companies, they don't even need to make profit at all. They just need to have their stock pumped. The stock price pumped, and it's it's very skewed, and it it cuts out the little guy from from competition competing with the bigger ones at all levels where like the thing is this it's such a skewed thing.

The I wrote a bit about the cantalon effect. I find that very interesting too in the in the follow-up to sovereignty. Started diving a bit deeper into that. And that's a really interesting thing. Is this thinker from like 500 years ago that noticed that inflation always benefits the source first and those closest to the source after that, and those who are the furthest away from the source, they pay for the whole ordeal.

Yeah, so put it in a in a modern context, here in the United States, that would be like you know, the Federal Reserve or the big banks printing money. Because you know, banks also print money here, obviously, which is something that most people don't understand, but but by you know, leveraging assets in you know they're by law legally required to I don't know exactly what it is now, but in before 2008, some of the bigger banks were leveraged 30 times.

So they were holding in reserve assets there were one thirtieth of the assets that they were that they were claiming that they had, right? They were just creating this money out of thin air. Exactly. Hey kids, look up fractional reserve lending and what it is and what it is. Just look it up.

Trust me on this one. Yeah, yeah. It's one of those one of those phrases, and this is this kind of goes back to the sort of the idea of the cover-up, but the this there's this sort of there's an entire industry that's built around you know, covering this whole thing up, right? It starts with this academic tradition this academic tradition of Keynesianism, and you know, we have this monoculture of economic thought.

We go to universities, you know, ninety-nine percent of universities in the world have no meaningful academic you know curriculum on Austrian economics. It's all this you know idea of Keynesian economics. Yeah, exactly. I think I finally during the last months here, I think I finally grasped the idea behind Keynesianism, the way it's supposed to work.

Like i if if your goal is to have as many transactions per time unit as possible, you can see why Keynesians want the money supply to increase, ever increase because that will incentivize people to spend more. And in if they had if all those purchases would have been investments, the idea would work.

But but since the speed is more important than the actual value of the transaction, the incentives are skewed so that people buy frivolous things instead of like building the fishing rod to catch more fish, which is which is the usual Rothbardian method metaphor here.

You follow me on this. Yeah, I oh yeah, absolutely, absolutely. Yeah, and it's you mentioned this earlier, I want to go back to this phrase too. You said that it encourages us to create company produce companies that we don't need and cuts out the little guy. And I think that gets to this idea that I is really important to me, it really resonates with me, I should say, is that you know, this sort of Keynesian age, this fiat age that we're living in, doesn't allow the little guy, as you called it, to really perfect your art, to become an artisan, to become a crafter of the and pursue the art that you really really inspire you, right?

And we have this idea of a renaissance man, and that idea is you know, a person who was you know broadly studied and able to pursue so many different a broad array of interests very deeply, and to be to become you know a person who really has this deep understanding of the human condition and the way the world works, and we just don't see that now.

No, no, exactly. And like before all this talk about gender equality and stuff, like in the back in the 50s, a family could survive on one guy's salary, and that those were usually families of five or eight children, and like now we have one and a half children in the and both parents have to work their asses off and just to just to put food on the table in very many places.

And like, well, of course, living standards has big are better because of techno technological improvement. And if you look at this this wonderful website, what happened in 1971, I guess you've seen it. Yeah, we're I think we're on we're on like a streak now of like seven episodes in a row that that website's been mentioned.

So there was an obvious an obvious need for the very simple genius of that website. Yeah. It is a genius website because as production has gone up by like 246% while salaries are the basically the same. And it's it's like we put in more and more hours for less and less for less and less all the time.

So and this is the reason we're being robbed. It's as simple as that. It is as simple as that. And you know, I think trying to get this message out there is a little difficult because people have been so well, people are skeptical of it, right?

They're like, oh that's crazy, like that's not actually happening. Like I don't, you know, I'm not being robbed, I don't feel I don't see that happening. You know, it it's it happens so it happens just slowly enough that it's hard for people to really perceive. Yeah, but most people are very reluctant to think outside of the current paradigm.

And I think this has been true for all social systems that we have we've had. Like no one was questioning the king in the our feudal days. We still have a king, by the way. But it we're getting people to think outside the box requires them to like leave their comfort zone.

And that scares a lot of people, I think. So education is key here, and we should just be diligent and keep on keep on spreading the message and try to not sound too crazy while doing it. Which is the hard part.

It's the hard part. Yeah, yeah. Excel CR. Yeah. Well, I wonder if I often wonder if Satoshi really, you know, game this out. Soshi seems to have really thought about so much of this, and the system, the game theory of the system is so expertly crafted that it it almost seems that it's likely that Satoshi it is, yeah, it's amazing.

It thought of everything. So it seems likely that he probably thought of the fact that you know, in order for this thing to catch on, you can't rely on education alone, right? You can't rely on people being curious enough to learn this and figure it out. Because we've you know had the Austrian tradition around for 150 years or so, and we've had politicians, you know, preach and shout from the rooftops that this is what's happening.

You know, we are getting robbed. We need should audit the Fed, we should, you know, so that we can see what's happening and all these things. But it doesn't make a difference. It doesn't because like you said, yeah, there's this overwhelming sort of glacial force to the toward the pr prevailing paradigm.

What's genius about Bitcoin is that we have number go up, right? So the these price cycles, the hype cycles that happen because of the foresight of the four-year cycle, right? You know, some people stop and ask, which is a very good question.

Why do we have these these four-year halvings, right? Why don't we just have a very smooth linear adjustment over 140 years, right? Because we could just easily do that. This is math, and every block we could just decrease it by a some tiny percentage, you know, for 140 years. Yeah, this is one of the more one of the theories I write about in the book, and I'm not as sure about this as some of the other stuff, but I think he deliberately put in the four-year halving cycle just in order to trigger these hype cycles.

And if he did, if if this is planned beforehand, it's really a genius move because it's the perfect onboarding mechanism. And it's it's that thing, that very thing that's that is the underlying mechanism mechanism that makes us sit here and talk today, I believe.

Yes, we wouldn't have done this if we had hadn't had the that volatility and that's crit the crazy stuff that's been going on in the in the Bitcoin space. Yeah, I agree 100%. And that that's that's one of the key mathematical functions, right? Is is the four-year halvings and you know, it creates the hype cycle and then the you know the kind of the de-hype cycle, I guess you could call it.

I don't know if there's a word for de-hype. But yeah, it's you know i those are important too. Yeah, the D hype, the D hype is I would call it a period for contemplation and like for learning and for onboarding people to let the idea sink a bit in in in the users and like to make them during the lows you can acquire some more and you can learn some more about it, and you can like get into all these get to know all these ideas and why they're there and why they're important and what what the potential of this

Thing really is. Yeah, 100% agree. Yeah. I hadn't actually thought about that before until just now. But I've always thought about the importance of the hype cycle to bring in attention and onboard a bunch of new people, and then you know, some of those will stick around. That kind of creates the new sort of floor that is the kind of the hodlers of last resort, so that when you know as price goes down, you kind of hit that 85-90% drop and it sort of just stops there.

It's it's a bit above the you know the previous high, right? So that's that's the floor, you know. Yeah, it's a purging mechanism too. It's yeah. It it's it flushes out the weak ends and makes the whole thing more robust and l long term, I believe.

Yeah, and it also allows, you know, the builders to continue to build on the infrastructure, the educators to continue to build out the educational material that will be used for the next hype cycle to help decrease, you know, the chances that someone's gonna fall into the shit coin traps, right?

Yeah, exactly. And you need the developers need time to figure stuff out this things like this the like the thoughts that are put into the system they need to be really well thought through and so so I need I think these these dips or whatever you may call them the floors that go on and go on and go on they they are very necessary for the whole system to thrive long term yeah both the highs and the lows are very important so so the four year cycle

The four year halvings one of the key mathematical functions in the code base and you know it's in the title of your book Sovereignty through mathematics what are some of the other mathematic math functions in the code base that produce this sort of beautiful game theory I think fees are underrated like Chiara was onto this as well like block space needs to cost something like to put something in a block like everyone knows who knows about the halvings and can see can if you can

Imagine the a hundred and forty year thing playing out 140 year scheme playing out in the future you see that the it needs to happen gradually the transition to a fee market driving the whole thing.

And so fees will go up for every halving and that that is why the things like the lightning network are so important as well. We need and it's it's a good thing that this is a slow process and it takes four years because it's like an incubator for for good ideas.

You need we can build on top of this thing when we have these periods before the halvings because the fee market will take over and will be very expensive to send Bitcoin to someone on chain in the future. There's like no way around that. Right and if we want it to grow which everyone wants we need to build on top of it we need to find other solutions like the night lightning network.

Speaking of the Lightning Network I can add torch bearer to my to my C V now. I got the Lightning Network torch this morning Oh the second torch that Hodlnut started? Yeah the second torch. And I think I can proudly say that I've been endorsed by not only Yan Pritzker but also Hodlonoth.

So I'm very happy about that. And I had a chat with him yesterday we had so much fun making fun of Peter

Very meta discussion there but yeah I really love the shit posting culture there on Twitter. So much fun to just be in this it's surreal. Right? It is it's so much fun. It's just yeah it's such a privilege when you stop and kind of sit back and think about it to be here at the beginning of this what w what we all think will be you know an absolutely epical change in the trajectory of humanity.

You know, akin to like things short of it. Yeah, like like you know, maybe like 10,000 years ago when we you know started you know the agricultural revolution. Maybe you have to go back to something like that. It's it's it's such a incredible paradigm shift. That only took five thousand years.

Right. Anyway, I have to tell you about this torch thing because I tell me about it, yeah. Yeah, I tweeted about wanting the torch yesterday evening just before I went to bed. So like I'm going to bed soon. Bus if anyone wants to give me that torch. Go ahead. And the morning after I got like I got it from what's he called?

Marty McFly. He he wanted to give me the torch because he liked my book. So a happy moment there. The thing was I was on my way to work and there's a there's a car ferry that takes eleven minutes from one side to the other.

I live in an island. So I got the torch on the ferry. So I had to receive it and send it away to someone else before the ferry hit the other berth on the other side. So you did it on you did it on the go.

Why do I get it right now? So was what yeah, but I got it at work. What did you use? What did you use to do the transactions? Just blue wallets. Yeah, nice. Yeah, works works for me. It worked on the ferry.

Exactly. Yeah, it's it it works on the go. And it's getting it's getting up there again. I saw it was like through you know, four or five hundred thousand sats already. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's getting there. I wonder where it'll end up this time. It's the first time around I paid three million sats.

Oh you had the torch the first time around? Yeah fine it I think I was like number 160 or 170 to have it. So it was up really high and you know at that point it was that was almost a year ago I guess. It was like it was like last February. And so yeah you know the lightning work was was just a m a lot a lot less developed at that point and so being able to route three million sats across the network was pretty difficult so you'd have to we had to we had to prepare for it to receive it and have enough incoming liquidity and then enough outgoing liquidity to send it out and yeah I tried to get it but no no one no one

Noticed me back then. Yeah you had to you had to make some noise. It was hard to get but it was it was a lot of fun. Cool that's that's exciting.

There's so much happening this year, I believe.

I have a very good feeling about this year. When it comes Oh yeah this is gonna be the year of lightning. Yeah it's gonna be the year of everything. Yeah I like that all right I going back I had another one to talk about another math function to talk about that I that I think is you know obviously genius the difficulty adjustment and you write about this in the book so yeah what do you think is you know the genius of the difficulty adjustment that is that it just works.

I mean it the network has been up for eleven years and it works sort of flawlessly. I mean sometimes there's like three blocks in ten minutes, but it evens out if you look at it from a if you zoom out for a bit. And like the to me there's nothing wrong with it. And I there's a chapter about proof of work in in my book and I think newcomers have a hard time wrapping their head around what's proof of work is and what it does.

And like whenever you hear something about a more environmentally friendly or a more effective type of proof of work, you're missing the whole point. And that's let's like read up, please on this.

Because the sacrifice is the entire thing.

That's the important thing. And I believe the sacrifice of energy. Yeah, the sacrifice of energy, exactly. Yeah. You prove that you believe in this system of unbelief. Yeah.

Something like that. Yeah, yeah. Well and I think the difficulty adjustment is also responsible for the fact that Bitcoin has absolute scarcity, right? Because without the difficulty adjustments, all you'd have to do is just you know, any innovation in in mining then would just, you know, in inflate the monetary base.

So that's was an absolute must for this to work. Yeah, definitely. And like the most underrated part about it I think is the consensus rules and how how new improvements are implemented and the h the high thresholds to get over in order to in order to change the system.

That aspect has been overlooked and it's been smeared by all these charlatan bullshit people you know you know I mean oh yeah I know you mean you don't have to mention the name like there's so much misinformation in general in the world and like it's hard it's hard to like separate the bullshit from from what's real and it it takes a lot of effort for anyone who wants wants to do

That but like don't trust verify is a very good approach to anything really if you don't know don't trust authority don't make your own opinion and like try to make it as little of an opinion as possible and try to try to separate the facts from the from fiction okay alright well we got disconnected there just for a little bit but we're back on track hotel wifi and copenhagan maybe maybe hit and miss sometimes like it like it is all over the world.

I've heard you talk about this before on some other podcasts but I thought we it would be fun to get into this because it's it's a really fun topic. So do you think hyper bitcoinization will happen? Yeah I do. In but I'm very unsure about the time scale. Yeah.

But I think i it it's like everything else in in Bitcoin, it's very binary. It's either all or nothing. There's no like in betweens. Like if if the experiment works, because it is still an experiment. It could fail for reasons we don't know about. We have to be humble about it.

Like it's I wouldn't throw myself out there under a bus and say that this is there's a hundred percent chance that hyper bitcoinization will happen. But if if it continues to work, I think it's inevitable in the long run. And I don't know this time scale, and I think no one does, and no one can know the time scale because you don't know how fast or slow the entire human population of the earth will like how long it takes for them to

To really adapt to a new idea such as this. But the but I think it will happen. What do you think will be like the cause of hyp hyper bitcoinization, right? Because like you have the I obviously the idea of inflation and this fiat age sort of driving you know devaluing one currency where the deflation deflationary aspects of Bitcoin will kind of increase its value over time.

We talk about number go up. Do you think it's literally just the kind of the difference in terms of the two monetary properties, the properties of these two monetary options? Or does it have something to do with you know, like Andreas was talking about like the convenience of using Bitcoin can never match the convenience of a of a centralized kind of fiat money in that yeah, you know, these fiat monies will hyperinflate and go away, but then you can just create new fiat monies, and you know, those will always be more convenient because they're centralized, and therefore there'll always

Be fiat money around. Hmm. I think I have to slightly disagree with Andreas here. Yeah, me too. Say that like I was when I was in Riga at that conference, Baltic Honey Bad year a couple of months ago, I sold books for like ten dollars each.

And I received payment in all sorts of ways, from barter to fiat to on chain and to lightning. And I would say that lightning is the best and easiest and most convenient way to pay someone there is. But the thing is the convenience of payments is a Keynesian red herring.

Because this is not this is not what the revolution is about. The revolution will not be centralized. And the thing is I've been trying I've been trying to put words on this, and I have an outline of an idea for a chapter in the new book. And it goes something like if the cost of producing money is lower than everything else, every other price will go up.

The price of everything else would go up. And that is what we see now. There are but a few products that are actually becoming cheaper to produce at a at a higher rate than money is becoming cheaper to produce. Right. And that's simply because there's like such deflationary forces because of productivity that it's actually like outpacing the inflationary forces.

Yeah like like what's it called the Moore's Law forget Moore's Law exactly. Yeah I was thinking about Metkov's law but Moore's Law is the word I'm looking for and that has been working for so and so many years and it's it's slowly it it's not as powerful as it used to be but that's that that that what went faster than the decline of the value of the money but on the other end of that spectrum you have Bitcoin which is which is more expensive and harder to produce than any other good in the long run which

Will make the prices of everything else go down in terms of Bitcoin including all the fiat money so you have on on one end you have money that is cheap and easy to produce and you can produce it as at an ever increasing rate that will lead to ever increasing prices and the only ones really benefiting from that are the ones closest to the inflationary source and their friends and if if money is really really expensive

To produce and really hard to produce everyone else will benefit because everyone holding that type of money will saving saving it up will will benefit from that from every other price going down. Make any sense? Yeah, yeah, it makes perfect sense. And I really like I haven't heard it described in that in that way before, but I le I really like that.

No, I try to formulate it in to frame it in a different way here. And it's really hard to wrap your head around because imagining a world in which all prices go down is hard. Because it's so surreal. Like what do you mean if I just own a tiny amount of Bitcoin, I will one day be able to afford whatever I could ever imagine.

I mean like i it's it's very it's a very tricky thought to get your head around. But this is what I this is what I see the curves pointing at, you know, the hockey stick curves from one going down to hell and one going to some form of Shangri La on the other side.

This is what it's all about for me. If if if money is the asset, the thing that is most expensive to produce, everything else will go down in price in comparison with it. Yeah, I love that. I have yeah, I haven't heard that framing before. I think that's really useful too.

Yeah, and I think you know talking about like the problem, I guess, or the competition, the future competition, the outcomes of that competition between fiat and Bitcoin in the future that Andreas was pointing out. I've been thinking a lot about that since I had you know had that podcast episode with him.

And I couldn't really formulate it on the spot there, but I you know can and can get it out there now. The complexity of this decentralized network comparative to a centralized payment system, it can be abstracted away. And it is being abstracted away, as we are seeing in in the development of UIs and UXs for the Lightning Network.

And if you look at the kind of the corollary the internet to Bitcoin, those like there were centralized networks back then that were you know offered, I guess, and those didn't win because they were too closed off, provided much less value than the decentralized alternative.

And the internet was was difficult to use, but all of that complexity got abstracted away over the decades. And here we are with a you know access to the you know wealth of information that's on the internet you know at our thumbs and fingertips in our pockets. Unimaginable 30 years ago.

Completely unimaginable 30 years ago. Right. And this is what's so fascinating because when things are so unimaginable during a certain time period or paradigm, you it's very hard to imagine benefits for everyone at scale like that.

And this is why I think most people believe this to be a fantasy, the hyper Bitcoinization, and they they find it not so plausible. But I really think it is in whatever way it happens, it's it's definitely a good thing. And right now, like we're we're not competing with fiat.

I think fiat is a is a completely different beast, and it has nothing to do with what's what Bitcoin makes people do. I mean having Bitcoin is is an insurance policy against all these thieves trying to rob you of your of the value of the fruits of your labor, if you will.

Like if you have Bitcoin, you can you don't need you don't need to spend whatever you don't need to run around in the hamster's wheel all day and like you can you can save the value of your labor for later use and not only can you save it but if it works and if we continue to onboard more people and more value I mean you could onboard the entire world but you can still enlarge the network by adding more value to it, more fruits of more more labor from more people.

So so it's it's a self-fulfilling prophecy and it grows and grows and grows and it's unstoppable, I believe. And it's an unstoppable force. It's just too ex Yeah, it's just too exciting to not think about. Yeah, I know it's it's absolutely enthralls us, just takes over our brains and yeah, and I encourage everyone to challenge these arguments because they sound far-fetched and like very out there thoughts, but I'd like to hear a good counter argument to it, because I really don't see an end point to this.

Like if you if you can funnel all the all the work, all the labor put in by all the people at all times into a specific pie. Kalle Rosenbaum calls it the world's first digital pie. I really like that. Like you have to split up the pie.

Well if if everything is in that, everyone benefits from it because the pie is so huge. It's a lot more fair, it's a much more fair system than this kind of you know fiat monstrosity that we've built. And like even if there's no robbery involved.

Right. Yeah, it's fair. It's it's there's a neutral a neutral judge, and that's you know why you title your book Sovereignty Through Mathematics. You know, we're not seeking sovereignty or like the you know the blessing of some nation state or government or corporation to say, here is your freedom, right?

We will protect it for you. That doesn't need to happen, right? We don't have to trust any nation state or any third party to protect our freedom, to make sure the system is fair. We can trust mathematics. Of course, there are there are always levels of that, like levels of security and route levels of privacy. And you there are always trade-offs.

Andreas talks a lot about this a lot, but the there are of course you can have them on your phone, you can have hardware wallets, you can have three out of five multi-sig, you whatever coin join lightning network. You can layer this into and you can understand the source code and verify the entire thing yourself, or you can choose to trust like you always have to trust someone, and there's always a trade-off somewhere that a time trade-off.

How much effort you put into security. And but on the whole, the system is so much more elegant and so much more pure and morally morally correct. Or it's it's a system that doesn't require oh I'm losing my train of thought here.

But no, I think what you were getting at, you know, is an important point, right? There's obviously layers of a trust or like a spectrum of trust. You know, the products or the you know services and the software that you use to execute your transactions, you need to trust that you know, that those are not going to rob your money. You know, and we have we have protections against that.

We have open source software that, you know, the longer that it's that open source software is around, the more people who d developers who are contributing to it and who are reviewing the code, you know, imbue that that code, that software, that service with more trust, it's more trustworthy. And so we can, you know, as a community build the software to execute transactions and on on the blockchain itself, that are much more you know trustworthy over time as they as they grow and those projects you know grow in in terms of the number of people involved, right, that are doing the review for you.

Because I you know I can't go on GitHub and review the code you know line by line for every single you know Bitcoin product that I use, right? So yeah, but once the point is once it gets to the blockchain, right? It is a fair system. There's nobody saying, Okay, we're gonna print more money or okay, this transaction, you know, can't go through, etc.

Etc. Yeah, yeah. Exactly. One thought that I had to go back to is you know, the idea you know, what what will happen in the future with this competition between fiat and Bitcoin? And will hyperbitcoinization happen or will fiat always be around in some way, shape or form, always kind of come back from the dead.

And you know, I think that that can happen. Obviously, we can create fiat monies with a blockchain, you know. There's several examples of that. I would say re like Ripple is a fiat money. I would say that if it ever comes to pass, this this Facebook money, Libra would be a sort of fiat money that's sort of decreed by some central authority.

I'm sure we'll see governments and central banks come out with some kind of digital money effective. Of course, but that has in my mind that has nothing to do with Bitcoin. No, I agree. I agree. And like even if Andreas would probably disagree, but I well he might. It sounds like he might, but yeah, they're related in that they share some part of the history, but the main value proposition of Bitcoin is is the scarcity aspect, a scarcity ensured by decentralization.

Yeah, I have a theory expressed in the new book I'm writing. I'm still working on it, but it's something it's not really my thought from the beginning. Even even Halfin mentioned this, and it's about it's about trying to duplicate Bitcoin is is a fool's game because like scarcity was the one thing.

So so I tried I phrase it like this something like this that absolute mass mathematical scarcity achieved by consensus in a sufficiently decentralized dips distributed network was a discovery rather than an invention. It could not it cannot be achieved again by a network made up of participants aware of this discovery, since the very thing discovered was resistance to replic replicability itself.

Right. That's how I phrase it right now. That makes that's a great way to phrase it. Yeah, that makes perfect sense. I hope that someone challenges me on that because I really I don't buy the other arguments. Just don't work for me. But like we discovered a resistance to replicability on the internet.

We could only do that once.

If you duplicate these experiments in any s way or form way, shape or form, you take the air out of the balloon. So the It's tautologically false, right? Yeah, if you discover repli a anti replicable system to replicate it would you know to be to just delegitimize the entire idea itself.

Exact exactly well put as we go f as we go forward, I mean you know even if these other fiat monies can be produced or you know forks of Bitcoin can be produced you know the trust in those monies will be completely broken over time, right? It's once Bitcoin is out there and people see that this is better money and come to understand why it's better money through the actual use of it itself through the experience of it not through the you know the theoretical approach or academic understanding of it they're actually seeing it then the trust in this you know you know old kind of money that was used as a

System of control is going to be broken and then you know hybrid Bitcoinization at that point is complete because anytime someone tries to propose this you know centralized fiat kind of money and go back to that everyone will be like nah you we were there already you know we figured that one out and you're not gonna pull the wool over our eyes again. Yeah but the thing is I think calling Bitcoin money is sort of a derogatory term because Bitcoin is so much more than money.

Like everything, everything that has been called money in the past, including gold by the way, has always been affected by a price change of that very thing. So if people value gold more, that this is something safe it in brings up a lot like the stability of the gold prices because when the price goes up the stock to flow doesn't change that much because it's still very hard to find new gold and stuff like that and with Bitcoin you have an absolute limit to it and it doesn't matter how how much effort you put into it the system just thrives off of the effort

Put in by the miners and if miners really like this is we come back to the difficulty adjustment as you mentioned before the beauty of the system is like nothing like this ever existed before and scarcity framed in this way is a completely new beast and it it would be as I said derogatory to call it money because money is something we associate with we don't associate term money with storing value and we don't as we don't associate it with something to emancipate us if you will a

Tool we don't we don't see it as a tool enough I think and this is why we it's so misunderstood what it is and you can't really understand Bitcoin before you understand money because you don't know what you can't really tell the difference and but when you do you see it as a completely different beast it's not money it's Bitcoin it's it's yes it's a different piece altogether.

It's like comparing a zero to a one. It's it's not comparing like a bike to a car. It's way more than that. This is like this is comparing a skateboard to a wormhole thing. Like

It's a different universe. Yeah, we here in the states we have the been carried away there. No, it's okay. We call it a whole different ball game is is kind of the phrase we use to say that. But even that's we too weak for what we're trying to get at here.

But all right, well let's finish up with this with the discussion since we're kinda still talking about hyper bitcoinization that that idea. What are the downstream effects of hyper bitcoinization and what are the consequences for you know personal freedom, p political organization, you know, laws, etc. Like the way that our that we actually organize our society.

Yeah, in a perfect world, and the way we all want it to play out, I think is like the nation states fading away like like religions did sort of in secular democracies. They faded away from their power positions.

And like I'm reading the sovereign individual right now on Audible, I'm listening to it. And they're on to the Roman Empire and the fact that it never really died. It's just sort of faded away over a very long time. Yeah.

But they still try to enforce Roman stuff for hundreds and hundreds of years after after the last emperor, and like a similar thing will happen to everything. Because I think this is bigger than anyone can imagine at this point in time and we can't really we can't really see what it will do.

But I'm back to that thing with everything getting cheaper in comparison to the money. It's it's a very hard thing to wrap your head around. Because you believe the resources of the earth to be scarce and like an an abundance of stuff wouldn't really work.

But the thing is with Bitcoin you wouldn't even want to spend them because you know that they're they will be worth more tomorrow and that will it it will sort of save the resources at the same time as making them abundant if that makes any sense yeah yeah it does make sense because we'll we'll be you know more careful about how we're spending the resource of our time our saved time right yeah yeah and I think it will free up time and like when Greta Turnberg me mentions like fantasies of perpetual growth she's very wrong in one way but she's very right in one way

Like growth in the sense we think of growth right now in the fiat currency system i it's that's not sustainable but in a in a sound money system it is sustainable because it just reflects the effort put in and like I see a future where people work less and less and they don't really care about like because most people don't want to drown in stuff and own like a billion houses.

They and a billion cars. They they what they want to leave they want to live nice comfortable lives with not too much hassle to they want they want they want time they want time to do what they want to do and pursue what they want to pursue yeah but right now they're not incentivized to strive for time that they really don't s they're not incentivized.

We're not incentivized to be in the driver's seats of our own lives. We're supposed to sit in the back of the bus and shut up where whatever that bus takes us. And like if you want to be in the driver's seat instead and like take a break whenever you want th this is the thing. Hopefully it will lead to a world in which people have to work less for in order to sustain themselves.

Yeah a world of a world of independence and not dependence a world of like interdependence and not and not you know kind of top down decrees from some central authority yeah so a more decentralized political system you know I don't know political is probably the wrong word but you know social system

As the there's the objective reality and there's the subjective how you subjectively experience reality th those are two very different things and but there's also a third thing called the intersubjective reality which are our which is what what made humans take over the earth if you will because th this is what made us able to organize in groups of over hundred fifty individuals.

So like organizations that are bigger than that are just because we at the same time believe in the same fictional thing, like a corporation or a religion or a nation or whatever, or even money. All of these things are intersubjective fantasies and constructs that that we believe at the same time.

But they're not real. They're not really real. They're not part of the objective reality that we all have to. I mean nature is cruel. Yeah. When when it comes to like reality will always be treat you in real ways, and these intersubjective fantasies they may seem very real, and this is what made us able to conquer the earth, but it's also our greatest flaw because while it while it has benefited humankind on from the perspective of large group, it has not really been that benefici beneficial for the individual

And the individual's freedoms and their the opportunities that each individual has for for governing their own lives. I think one of the things I always think back to is Michael Goldstein on the episode this of this podcast. I asked him a similar question and he he said that there will be these these regions of political experimentation all around the world, and you can just sort of you know migrate to the you know the region that you sort of most want to live in, right?

The social system that you must have to do. Yeah, I believe I buy that totally. Yeah. At the air at the airport. They can take my toothpaste, but they can't take my twenty-four words. Exactly. And yeah. That that is such a paradigm shift. We haven't just realized it yet. But we can cross any border with any amount of money in our heads.

And people don't know this yet. But we need to get the message out because this is this is changing everything. That's amazing. And I think we can just r stop it right there, man. Like this is changing everything. And we need to get the message out. I think that that's exactly you know, the takeaway from this podcast.

And man, I really appreciate your time. Appreciate your efforts in getting that message out there, and I'm really excited to check out the follow-up. So I'm I was excited to hear that that's happening. Yeah, yeah. I was on vacation for like a month during Christmas here. So I promised myself to exercise every day and write a write for an hour every day.

And I can happily say that I wrote for an hour every day. The exercise thing didn't work out as well. But anyway. Something is coming and like like I said, this this is this seems like a good year on every level.

It's gonna be an amazing year. I am super excited, I'm bullish as ever. Can't wait to for this next this next hype cycle to come and we are ready. With Bitcoiners are ready. We've had our heads down, we've been building, we've been writing, we've been recording, and yeah, I think we're ready for this next wave and it's gonna be it's gonna be bonkers, but it's gonna be fun.

Are you going to any conferences this year by any chance? I'll definitely be at Bitcoin twenty twenty. It's in about eight like ten weeks, just ten weeks away. In San Francisco. Where is that? San Francisco, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I'm not going to that one. I'll I'll I think I'll I'll probably be attending two here in Europe.

Really thinking going to the value of Bitcoin conference in Munich in June. And then of course the honey badger thing. Yeah. I think I have some some stuff coming up there. So really excited about that. Oh exciting that is great. Yeah. I feel like I need to make Riga happen this year.

I feel like it's sort of a pilgrimage that that the most devoted Bitcoiners will should make at least once in their life kind of thing I it's surreal experience. I've never been in a room with total strangers that I felt like I knew everyone

Yeah totally new experience. I will so I'm gonna try to make that one happen. I gotta save up a little bit of my dirty fiat so I can make that happen but it'll be a good use of it for sure. Yeah to r to wrap things up I'd just like to give a shout out to everyone I've interacted with the for the last six months on Twitter and everything.

Everyone's been so kind to me and like like this the Bitcoin community and the Twitter community there is they're just the best all of them. Just love them all. And me too. Shout out Bitcoin Twitter. Keep keeping never change.

Keep doing what you're doing. Yeah you are you know who you are all the shit posters and all the all the authors and all the artists did you see that sculpture? Oh my god, that was amazing. Yeah, I dropped my jaw like it says sovereignty through mathematics on the side.

Yeah, isn't that amazing? And I was like, what? What is happening? Yeah, that's most amazing thing. So great. Yeah, there's some amazing art coming out of this space. Yeah, yeah. It's it's amazing. It's beautiful. Keep doing what you guys are doing. You're here at the beginning of this Bitcoin Renaissance, and you'll be looking back in 30, 40 years with a tremendous sense of satisfaction for what you have been doing in these early days of Bitcoin to spread the spread the word and the knowledge about what's happening here.

Yeah, it's gratifying already at scales unimaginable. I mean like fall down this rabbit hole because it's not a rabbit hole at all, it's a honey buddy's den. That's true. And you will get bitten, but it's worth it.

You'll be bitten and infected by an idea that will not leave your brain, a mind virus that will not leave your brain for the rest of your life, I'm pretty sure. And you will be an outsider for a while, but you're if you're one of us, you're one of us. And it's the best community there is. I agree completely.

All right, good night, Knut. Enjoy Copenhagen. Hope you get some chance to have some fun while you're there and not not just work all the time. Yeah, we'll we'll see to that. And thank you so much for inviting me on and having this little chat. Keep doing what you're doing. I enjoy it a lot.

That's the plan, man. Alright, take care. Yeah, see you in Riga. Bye. Thanks to Knut for joining me for a fun discussion. Let us know your thoughts and questions about the episode. Knut is at Knut Zvan Holm.

Let's at K-N-U-T S-V-A-N-H-O-L-M. And I am at Citizen Bitcoin on the Bitcoin Twitter. And that is really the best way to support the podcast, sharing it out on Bitcoin Twitter. You can also share it with your family and friends. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. And check out layer1btc.com for the Citizen Bitcoin merch collection.

Thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring the episode and to LTBN, the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network, for distributing the Citizen Bitcoin podcast to their amazing audience. If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at CitizenBitcoin on Telegram and Keybase. And my email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me.

This week's open source shout-out is BTC Pay Server. BTC Pay was born when Nicola Dorier tweeted to BitPay on August 17th, 2017, that he would make them obsolete after betraying Bitcoiners' trust. BTC Pay is now one of the most important open source Bitcoin projects. BTC Pay is integrations in many of the top e-commerce platforms and also includes a built-in point of sale app for brick and mortar retailers.

It's secure, private, censorship resistant, absolutely free, and just improving at an incredibly rapid pace. You can support the project at btcpayserver.org/slash donate. Thanks for supporting open source Bitcoin projects. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world, you're not going to be able to do that.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Knut Svanholm is the author of Sovereignty Through Mathematics. Knut and I talk about how this fiat monstrosity erodes our basic freedoms and how the discovery of absolute scarcity that is bitcoin will restore and protect those freedoms. We talk a bit about lightning and close out by riffing for quite a while on the prospects of hyperbitconization and how it could affect our social order.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast

Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop

Citizen Bitcoin Layer One merch collection

Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek

Links from the episode:

Sovereignty Through Mathematics

Knut on Twitter

Downloads