All episodes
Episode 69

Andy Edstrom: Investing in Bitcoin

January 30, 202098 min

Andy Edstrom is a wealth manager who has fallen down the bitcoin rabbit hole. He started writing content to justify a small stake in bitcoin for his clients and that turned into the new book “Why Buy Bitcoin” - a great book to recommend to family and friends thinking about an investment in bitcoin. Andy’s history in the finance industry gives him a valuable perspective as one of early adopters of bitcoin from the industry. In this episode we get into that history and perspective, we discuss where the finance industry currently is in terms of moving toward embracing bitcoin as an asset. We talk about monetary maximalism and how bitcoin might change our economy. As any good wealth manager should, Andy has a thorough examination of bitcoin’s risk as an investment in the closing chapters of his book and we discuss them.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. I've got a discussion with Andrew Edstrom, author of the new book, Why Buy Bitcoin, available now on Amazon.

But first we've got our weekly check-in with Swan Bitcoin. Now, if you haven't heard the makers of GiveBitcoin, which launched at the start of the holiday season last year and made a splash as a new way to convert your friends and family from no coiners to wisen toddlers with a one-year escrow in world-class education. The next product from the makers of GiveBitcoin is Swan Bitcoin, and I'm just incredibly excited about this one.

I'm excited because Swan is a Bitcoin-only product focused on one simple goal to help you save as much Bitcoin as you can with low fees and easy recurring buys. That's it. It's focused on doing one job better than any other product, and that's the kind of product I like to hire. You can sign up now for early access to the product, and I really hope you do so.

Just take a few seconds right now, open up your browser, go to Swan Bitcoin.com, that's SWAN Bitcoin.com, and add your email address. That's all it takes. And Swan will be in touch when ready for Bitcoiners like you to help put the new app through its paces.

Swan will be launching soon in 49 states. Sorry again to New York, the bit license sucks.

But seriously, guys, I'd love to show Swan the reach of this podcast. It would be great for the pod if you could just take a few seconds, sign up for early access at SwanBitcoin.com. Thank you so much. Okay, and just a quick shout out to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network. Big love to LTBN for bringing this podcast onto the network.

LTBN has already had great Bitcoin pods like Let's Talk Bitcoin with Adam Levine and Andreas Antonopoulos and what Bitcoin did with Peter McCormack. But it's really improving the feed by adding more Bitcoin pods like Bitcoin and Co with Anita Posh, Weekly Bits from Bitcoin Magazine, select episodes from the Crypto Economy podcast with Guy Swann, and of course this podcast.

There's also one of my fave pods, POV Crypto, which isn't a Bitcoin-only pod, but there are plenty of episodes focused only on Bitcoin, and it's really fun to listen to one of my favorite Bitcoiners, CK Snarks. Take it to the ETHEDS with Gusto on that podcast. So check out the LTBN feed for those Bitcoin pods in one convenient place.

And don't forget that you can find the archive of Citizen Bitcoin Podcasts almost 70 episodes deep now at citizenbitcoin.world. Lots of great episodes to catch up on if you are relatively new here. Alright, let's get this thing going.

Andy Edstrom is a wealth manager who has fallen down the Bitcoin rabbit hole. He started writing content to justify a small stake in Bitcoin for his clients, and that turned into the new book, Why Buy Bitcoin?

It's a great book for family and friends thinking about an investment in Bitcoin. Andy's history in the finance industry gives him a valuable perspective. He's one of the early adopters of Bitcoin from the industry. And in this episode, we get into that history and perspective. We discuss where the finance industry currently is in terms of moving toward embracing Bitcoin as an asset.

We talk about monetary maximalism and how Bitcoin might change our economy. And as any good wealth manager would do, Andy has a thorough examination of Bitcoin's risk as an investment in the closing chapters of his book. And so we discussed them. It was really a pleasure to talk with Andy.

Here we go. Alright, really excited to welcome Andy Edstrom. He's a wealth manager who has recently fallen down the Bitcoin rabbit hole and written a book for his clients originally, but I think it's a great book for all Bitcoiners.

It's called Why Buy Bitcoin. So check it out. Andy, welcome to the show, man. How are you doing? I'm great, Brady. How are you? I'm doing great. I'm doing fantastic. Excited to talk to you today. Congratulations on the book, man. Oh, thank you, man. I'm psyched to talk to you about it. Been a fan of Citizen Bitcoin for a long time.

So yeah, thank you. Yeah, absolutely, man. I when we were doing a pre-interview, you played for me a little clip of me shouting out a review from like last June. You had left a review, and I was like, hey, thanks, Andy Edstrom, for the nice review.

And it was really cool to hear that, man. So you've been listening for a long time. That's right. It was middle of middle of last year, and I was I was deep in the pods, deep in yours. Yours is one of my favorites, and you were. I mean, I'm sure you can talk about you know how the pods developed over time, but but you were at the time where we're still commenting that reviews were helpful, and so I was like, all right, sweet, I'll give him one.

So well deserved. I appreciate it. Thank you. Yeah, I appreciate it. Definitely was helpful back then. Still still is helpful if y'all want to leave a review. I wouldn't mind. And same, if you read Andy's book, you know, and this this goes for any Bitcoin content out there, it's super helpful to leave reviews on podcasts and books, you know, claps on medium articles, share your mod on Twitter, all that stuff.

We are the marketing team for Bitcoin. So we all gotta kinda share the love around. Amen. Yeah. All right, let's dive in, man. You did one pod, and I'll refer people back to this, your first one on the Bitcoin circuit with Colin at the Biko Bitcoin Echo Chamber podcast.

That was a really good episode. Definitely recommend people go back and check that one out if you want some more Andy after this one. So that was good, but I want to dive into your story first because it's you know, you are kind of new to the scene here and I want to get it out to all the listeners out there. You sort of represent the front end of this emerging trend in the fin like finance industry veterans really diving into Bitcoin.

You know, it's it's kind of like slowly then suddenly as Parker Lewis would put it, that this is probably it it's slow now, but I think we'll probably see it really kind of drive you know, a lot more a lot more quickly or in the coming years. What so what prepared you to recognize Bitcoin a little earlier than most of your peers in the financial industry?

Yeah, so that's a new that's a good question. I you're definitely right. I come from the evil finance establishment. I was born in the I was born on the dark side or raised on the dark side. And yeah, how did how what prepared me for it? The short answer is I wasn't very well prepared for it because you know I went to college and I studied economics, and of course it was Keynesian economics.

So I am a default Keynesian like so many others out there, some of whom you've talked to. And then I went to work on Wall Street. So I was sort of you know eyeballs deep in the financial establishment almost from day one working at Goldman Sachs and then subsequently working in private equity and then at a hedge fund and now in wealth management.

So in some respects I was really poorly prepared. I could certainly, you know, I can sort of trace the arc of my you know professional history and kind of how I fell into Bitcoin, if that's if that's helpful. Yeah, let's hear it, man. Okay, cool. So so college in Massachusetts, straight to New York, working at Goldman Sachs, got a front row seat to the making of financial sausage, as they say.

I was not working this is before this is before the financial crisis. I was not working in you know in the mortgage area where some of the really egregious stuff happened. I was working with debt though, I was working in the leverage finance area, specifically the high yield bond and leverage loan, also known as junk bonds and junk loans.

So basically, you know, part of my job was putting helping to put together debt deals to finance leverage buyouts as well as you know, refinancing of debt tranches for companies that that were highly indebted. So I did that for a couple years, and you know, that was like two 2004, 2006.

So decided to move to the private side and the investment side, and I worked for briefly basically for a private equity fund that spun out of the Carlisle Group, which is one of the larger private equity firms around at that time and still today. And then I worked at a at a hedge fund. It was interesting.

I fund called Tenbaum Capital, which is located here in LA and about a five billion dollar fund. And I joined them in 2007. And then in 2008, of course, Lehman Brothers filed bankruptcy and the financial crisis hit. So I got a front row seat to that. And lucky for me, I had joined a firm that had a pretty significant distressed debt investing practice.

So there's plenty to do for a few years there, but I you know sort of cut my teeth on on that as well as doing other types of investing, including private equity and private debt and public bond investing and public stock investing. And then about seven years ago, I was I had you know, I was an associate when I joined Tennebaum and a principal when I left, and I decided to get into the family business, which is my dad and his founding partner founded a firm called Westcap Group.

And we're a wealth manager. I got interested in working with dad. I got interested in working with actual people, because you know, in the investing business, usually if you're an institutional investor, you're you're basically working for faceless institutions. Yes, some of them are pensions and endowments, you know, that benefit actual people, but generally you don't get to meet those people.

So I was keen to work with with actual living people, live people, and I was also excited to grow that business. So so that was my arc. And my first exposure to Bitcoin was 2013. I read an article on The Economist.

It totally went over my head, so I ignored it. 2016, read about the Dow hack and you know Ethereum classic fork. Didn't understand that. And 2017 is when I started paying attention because one of my friends pinged me, and I think I took a look at CoinMarketCap or something, and I saw, I don't know, 10 billion or 20 billion in market cap there.

And I was like, okay, well, maybe there's something here. If you know, if someone's ascribing billions of dollars of value to it, then then maybe I should take a closer look. So that's the sort of the short answer to how I first got got to Bitcoin. Certainly I could talk about you know where that went from there and how we got to the book, but but hope I answered your question.

Yeah, yeah. So yeah, I mean 2017, the height of the madness, it's kind of when I came into so I presume, like most people, especially that year, that you got distracted by Ethereum and all of the tokens that were being issued on the Ethereum platform, all of the you know, we're going to change the world.

This is the new internet, we're better than Bitcoin, you know, narratives that were out there. How did you, as a you know, kind of trained investor, you know, especially of other people's money, which requires even extra, you know, even more due diligence perhaps than investing your own money. How did you kind of weigh all of that stuff?

How did you go through the sea of all of those shit coins and evaluate them? Yeah, man, it was it was tough. It was a challenge. I mean, I wish I could say that you know I was always just a bitcoiner and I ignored the noise, you know, and I saw the light for the beginning. No, I did my fair share of alt kind of altcoining.

I'm pretty sure that I never had, I'm pretty sure that well, what so you know, I was first probably buying Bitcoin in the I don't know, 3,000 something range. So it's not like I got it early and made a made a bunch of money on it. I wish I had, but that was not the case. But no, I was I was speculating in a bunch of the altcoins. I was reading about you know various network topologies and consensus mechanisms and you know touring completeness, you know, and you know, efficiency, right?

And DAGs, and oh, this is more efficient system computationally, so it's better than Bitcoin, et cetera, et cetera. So I was I was deep in that, in all that stuff. And it took me, yeah, it took me a few years to, well, I don't know, I guess it probably took me a couple years to come around to higher conviction that Bitcoin was the most interesting, you know, sort of head and shoulders above the rest in terms of the investment opportunity as well as you know, ability to let's say to change the world.

Yeah, it's it's a really interesting journey. It's a very psychologically challenging journey because like you mentioned, the conviction is the thing, right? And I love the term FUD, fear and certainty and doubt, because it's so on point. And as you go through and you kind of you learn about Bitcoin, you listen to the Bitcoiners' arguments, the maximalist arguments on, you know, why Bitcoin is a different thing.

It's in a different league, right? It's got, you know, all of those arguments make sense, but the siren songs of all of these, you know, alternatives to Bitcoin are really alluring, right? And definitely cast a lot of doubt and uncertainty in your mind. And developing that conviction just takes a long time.

I feel like we are lowering the bar to that conviction over the past couple of years with books like yours, a lot more podcasts, a lot more educational material. What did you know find the most useful? And I mean, do you agree that that we're in a better place now than we were in 2017 in terms of the kind of the time to reach conviction about Bitcoin?

Yes, yeah, I definitely agree. And a couple things maybe to say there. The first is there really is no substitute for time. And others you know have realized this before I before I did, but you know, let's say doing doing a hundred hours a week of work and research on Bitcoin, you know, for a month, you know, let's say 400 hours of research or 450 hours of research is not the same as doing one hour, you know, of research each week for a year, right?

In other words, the passage of time and the percolating of ideas in the mind are I think really important to deep understanding of Bitcoin. And I'll say that you know, the narrative of you know, whether it's Ethereum or or any of the other alt projects, the narrative of money that has an intrinsic value or utility value is really appealing unless you have, I guess, studied Austrian economics for a long period of time, and it takes a while, it took me a while really to understand the fact that the best money

Has no intrinsic value or has no value as anything other than money, and until you really get that, until that really sinks in, all the other, you know, all the other stuff, the noise is much more appealing. So that's one comment. And I guess the other thing I'd say is yeah, we're definitely in a better place today.

We're in a better place for a couple reasons. You know, one is there's more and better material. And you know, I saw an opportunity in the market for my book specifically when I wrote it, because at the time there was I felt what was missing in the market was you know, there were some more shorter slash perfunctory, you know, books that didn't cover enough.

And then there were some longer books that were, in my opinion, too long form and risked, you know, turning off some people who are interested in learning. So I was looking for a sweet spot in the middle with my book. So that's one thing. And then of course, the Lindy, I would argue, the Lindy of Bitcoin looks a lot different today than it did, say two years ago, right?

I mean, the narrative, the altcoin narrative is real strong in late 2017, and having come through a cycle since then and having seen Bitcoin, you know, mostly suck the air out of the rest of the crypto market, certainly adds to the fact pattern of the last decade plus that yeah, it already looked, I mean, you could make the argument in retrospect that a few years ago it already looked like Bitcoin was the winner, but now it looks like it more so.

So there's definitely greater conviction with the passage of time. But I yeah, I agree with you that there's there's more and better material coming to market, and you know, I hope to play my small part in that. Yeah, and I think you're right about that. Like the fact that there were, and it's not just that Bitcoin has kind of sucked the air out of the crypto market.

I guess another the other way to put it, the opposite way to put it is that there were so many failed promises from these ICOs and just dead projects that didn't deliver. They raised hundreds of millions, sometimes billions of dollars, and haven't delivered any working product of value. Yeah, I think that's right. And so that's 100% right.

So many projects that just totally failed, basically failed to launch. And then you've got the longer, more established projects or somewhat more established, you know, using Ether as an example, you know, which are still trying to change consensus mechanism, you know, and are still you know, forking every now and then. And they haven't, as you say, they haven't delivered on the promise even of basically re-architecting the consensus mechanism.

So as an investor, as an investor, you're saying, okay, if Bitcoin has won digital, the wit the digital gold category, which you know, fairly clearly it has, then you know, how how is anything that's about to still change itself materially in terms of how it operates gonna hope to compete with that?

And I think it's I think it's really hard. It's gonna have to be something that's much, much better. And this many years into it, it's it's getting more difficult to imagine what that contender or that competitor is. Yeah. Where do you fall on the idea of monetary maximalism?

You know, the idea that we m could sustain an an economy or a market with several different monies. Is that something that you see possible in the long run? Yeah, it's an interesting one. It's it's a little bit hard to say. I would say I'm pretty monetary maximalist in the very long run, with the caveat that, and this is a framework I lay out in the book.

If there's 14 significant characteristics of money, 14 characteristics of good money, no money is gonna score, you know, highly on all of them, and there will be some groups of people or entities, or there will be times when people want to use a certain type of money rather than another.

So I'm never gonna I'm never gonna say, yeah, it's winner take all 100%. I think that, you know, I think Pareto distribution, I think power law makes a lot of sense. I have a certain amount of humility about what the end game looks like and how long it's it's gonna take. I mean, it's when you look through history, you it's sort of amazing that that you've had hegemonic currencies backed by empires, whether it's the US or the UK or Spain or Holland or what have you.

Those things can can can hold their positions for you know a century and or more. And so there's the caveat of you know how long it takes to get to the ultimate end game. I am pretty bullish on Bitcoin's ability to become you know the money and the base currency.

But I also allow for the possibility that you know fiat currencies, various fiat currencies, as well as who knows, other forms of money, whether they're you know, alt currencies, could have some modest monetary premium. It's just that it's gonna be probably orders of magnitude, depending on the case, lower than Bitcoin.

So that's kind of my my thought process, I would say. Yeah, I think that that's a sorry, and it could take it could take a long time, right? Yeah, and I think that that's a very reasoned answer. And I and I think that that's important to stress that you know, these network effects also apply to you know existing fiat monies, like the dollar has massive network effects, right?

And it's gonna take you know a long time to slow those network effects down. The idea of hyper bitcoinization kind of counters that a little bit. You know, it makes it sound like most of the time I've heard people talk about hyper book hyper bitcoinization, it seems that it's kind of and the idea that it's gonna happen very quickly, like over a matter of a few years at some point, there's gonna be this tipping point, and everyone's just gonna, you know, start dumping fiat for Bitcoin, and that's just gonna create this, you know, chain effect that you know it people just are gonna want to

Get out of that money that's you know, hyperinflating and losing its value relative to Bitcoin. So do you think that that tipping point will happen at some point, or do you think it's gonna be more of like a decades-long process? Yeah, it's very possible. I'm humble enough to say that I don't have any conviction on the answer. I mean, I can I can make the case, you know, you look back at 2017 and it felt like, oh, you know, we're going hyper Bitcoinization, you know, right now.

This is we're going to moon. This is this is happening now, you know, there are wallets out there, you know, can't Coinbase can't open accounts fast enough, everybody's piling in, etc., etc. I could make the case that that's gonna, you know, happen maybe in the next cycle. However, I do have the humility to realize that, and actually it's it's partly interaction with you know, my clients as an example, to realize that there are a lot of people in the world who take time to learn and they are cautious with respect to investing or allocating their capital to something that

Is let's say not new, right? We're more than a decade into into Bitcoin, but let's say relatively new and challenging a much longer and more established order. So yeah, I can imagine a scenario where it takes decades, or I can imagine a scenario where there's a tipping point.

And then the question is, well, what you know, what caused the tipping point? Was it just you know, FOMO plus, as you say, watching watching number go up or inverting it, you know, watching number go down for every other type of money. Or is it some geo, you know, political event, or is it you know, basically some catalyst from central banks like the Fed or larger governments on the fiscal side that that cause a tipping point and basically you know a speculative attack on on fiat, whether it's a dollar or something else.

And so I allow for both those potential outcomes, and either way, the investment thesis for Bitcoin, you know, looks pretty good. And by the way, I'll say that you know, the book, the numbers I sketch out are I allow for a decade long when when I sort of set the price target or I set the upside case from an investment point of view I take a 10 year view and I think the total valuation on 10 years that I use is about 8 trillion and you know that's comes from various buckets whether it's you know taking share from gold or taking share from fiat or taking share from offshore assets

You know or you know slightly demonetizing other stores of value like real estate you know or new uses that either we haven't thought of or are still under construction you know whether it's you know micropayments or things enabled by lightning you know or it's you know it's Abra you know or similar systems whereby you can get synthetic exposure to any asset in the world just by you know holding just by holding Bitcoin as collateral so there's all these there's all these areas of upside and the valuation that I use is the one I laid out.

So that's I don't know some would say that's aggressive some would say that's you know conservative but I think that getting to multiple trillions of value on a 10 year on a 10 year view could either happer happen through bitcoinization or hyper bitcoinization you know or it could hap happen in the form of oh that's one more decade of the evolution of this thing we've already had one decade the second decade will you know could be that much bigger and then maybe in the third decade it happens.

So we'll see we will see, and it's gonna be really fun to watch it happen. It's it's sort of a privilege, I guess, to be here when we look back sort of at the relative beginning of this whole thing, it's gonna be fun to watch. Let's go back to the idea of like that trend of financial professionals, just the finance industry in general learning about and coming to understand Bitcoin.

Is the financial industry moving into Bitcoin? We've been talking about this for a couple of years. We do see more infrastructure in place that would be able to support you know movements of large amounts of capital on the order that these financial institutions deal with. We've got a couple of leaders like ICE and the backed company that that I that ICE owns and has developed, and Fidelity.

Do you think we're gonna see, you know, in this if we have a coming bull run, do you think we're gonna see more interest from the financial industry? Yes. So there's a couple ways to frame that. So there's the examples you laid out, right? There's ICE is the largest exchange company in the world, period, I believe, right?

They own a bunch of stock exchanges, they own New York Stock Exchange. They own a bunch of them in foreign countries as well. So they're a huge player. And then Fidelity, you know, which manages, I don't know, two and a half trillion or something of assets, and then custody is like six or seven trillion, right? Because they got all these 401k programs.

And retirement programs that they that they custody. These are big real players. Now, if I step across the table back to the dark side where I came from from the from the establishment, the financial establishment, you know, I could care less whether a company named Zappo or a company named Bitcoin, you know, has quote unquote qualified custody.

I start to care when Fidelity and the New York Stock Exchange's pair of company, you know, are real. So that's that is definitely in my mind a shift. So that's one thing. Another factor, of course, is is price, as you point out.

And you know, when we take out when we take out the previous all-time high, right? When we're back at above 1920K, that's going to be a catalyst that some people who aren't paying attention now will pay attention to. And then I think the story as well, well, let me back up.

10 years, a decade of the best performing asset, right? That stat came out at the end of 2019. That's important. Mm-hmm. For sure. And I think, yeah, I think the excuses for ignoring it are falling away with time. And I think one way to think about that, by the way, is I, you know, when I think about my clients, some people say, well, you know, how do you how do you how do you pitch your client or how do you explain Bitcoin to your client?

Okay. One thing I sometimes like to do is invert it. I say, okay, look forward into the future. It's, I don't know, 2022 or something. And Bitcoin has, let's say, already you know, plowed through six figures, right, on price. And I'm imagining my conversation with my client, and my client is saying, okay, do we own any Bitcoin?

No, we don't own any book Bitcoin. Oh. So a few years ago it was the it was the best performing asset of the decade, right? Yeah, yeah, that's true. And it was uncorrelated to other assets, right? I mean, it had less than you know 0.2 correlation to the US stock market, foreign developed stock markets, emerging markets, you know, bonds as measured by the Barclays index, gold.

Yeah, yeah, that's right. It had it was not correlated. Oh, and the and the total addressable market was in the 10, you know, tens of trillions of dollars, correct? Yeah, yeah, that's right. Oh, and it it was investable, right? Like there were you know instruments in the market that you could buy. Like you could buy this in my you know, in my account, right?

Yeah, yeah, that's true. Okay, so what am I paying you for? Like what and you know, the answer to that is well, my clients do pay me for other services as well. You know, I do financial planning and give them advice and other stuff, but but if you are a if you are an institutional investor, whether you're a wealth manager acting on behalf of others, or you're you know a fund manager, the number of excuses that you have for ignoring this thing are are are falling away with every day that goes by.

And these are all factors that I think that institutional investors are gonna have to be thinking about very carefully right now. Yeah, absolutely. I think so you that sort of back and forth that we just went through is you talking to other wealth managers about the potential for Bitcoin.

Like you're gonna have a client here in three or four years that is gonna talk to you like this. Is that yeah, that's my that's either me talking to other wealth managers or it's me talking, or maybe it's the client, you know, quizzing me, right? Because, you know, and that's gonna depend on the client. Like I have actually quite a few very sophisticated clients who do read the news and they do pay attention.

And so, you know, I had a client ask me actually a few months ago, he said, Andy, what's the next Amazon? Right? And he didn't, what he meant by that was not literally, you know, like what is the next, you know, web-based retailerslash cloud business. No, he meant what is the next thing.

I don't know if he meant internet native or internet enabled, but he meant what is the next thing that could create, you know, hundreds of billions of dollars or trillions of dollars of market capitalization that is, you know, either off the radar, or hasn't sort of fully been discovered or realized by the market in general.

So yeah, it's it's it's all of the above. It's clients, it's other wealth managers, it's anybody running a fund, you know, anybody running a macro fund, for example, who who has the mandate to trade just about anything out there. And as long as it can be safely custodied, you know, it ought to be on their radar, and they're gonna have to have a good reason for not owning it, you know, in the future, if it if it if it well, regardless of how it performs.

So you have you had an opportunity to talk to other wealth managers and financial advisors about Bitcoin? Are you finding ways to get this book in into their hands as well as your clients? Yeah, I actually, you know, I had a I was actually sort of featured on a on a call that Bitwise did. So Bitwise was one of the companies that is focused on getting, you know, Bitcoin into the hands of investors, including wealth management specifically.

And so basically they set up a call. You know, Hunter, who's the CEO of the company, went through the basic thesis on Bitcoin, and then we kind of did QA at the end of the call. And there were, I think, between four and five hundred you know, wealth managers that called it and listened to the to the spiel.

So yeah, I am, you know, I'm trying to bring the message to others in my in my line of work because I think it's important that they be aware of it. I think it's important that they finally do the work to understand it. And look, some have, but it's I would say the minority.

And yeah, so I'm I'm I'm doing my best to amplify the signal. I think that's great. I think it's really important to get that information out to the finance industry, like we were talking about, like it's kind of a trickle right now. But educating them is, you know, that has this sort of multiplying effect for educating the consumer who might be in investing in them because you know the reach of the financial industry, wealth managers, financial advisors, et cetera, is huge.

And it's getting, you know, there are a lot of people, you know, kind of Gen Xers, you know, older millennials, and then you have course like younger boomers who are kind of looking to retire, you know, in their 50s, trying to think about you know retirement coming up, and it's starting to, you know, get a maybe wanting to get a little bit more aggressive if they're a bit behind, you know, but there's still kind of a 10 or 15 year time horizon to play with.

So if I'm coming to you as somebody like that, you know, I've maybe I've only been contributing to a Roth or a 401k, maxing that out every year, and that's all I've been doing so far. And I'm like, oh God, you know, this is coming up. I really don't want to work for another 30 years. And they come to you, you know, maybe they've heard about Bitcoin, maybe they haven't.

What kind of exposure would do you recommend? What and then if you like recommend Bitcoin, how do you make the case to someone who's like, I have no idea what this is? Yeah. Yeah, it depends on the case, I guess. I mean, the short answer is I faced that problem, you know, in the 27 to 2019 period, and I realized that I was gonna have to write it down, you know, and I'm not gonna sort of I'm not gonna convert someone on the first conversation, right?

Sure. However, I do take a portfolio approach. So I look at the at it as a hugely asymmetric trade, right? You could make 10 to 100 times your investment. And then I probability weight it.

And I and I conclude that okay, there's huge potential upside here on on a probability-weighted basis. And then I say what I described before, which is it's low correlation to the rest of the portfolio. It sort of moves to the beat of its own drum. And why is that important? Yeah, I mean, that's like modern portfolio theory 101, that's definitely something that resonates with wealth managers and professional investors, is the holy grail, more or less, investment is something that is uncorrelated to the rest of your portfolio, but still has a huge positive expected

Return. Because even if something has a high positive return, well, if it's correlated to all the other risk assets, if it's correlated to stocks, if it's correlated to real estate, well then when you get a big downturn, like we had a decade ago, more than a decade ago, the global financial crisis, well then it's gonna lose money with everything else, and you risk as an investor the worst possible outcome, which is panic selling the bottom right and we bitcoiners understand this viscerally you don't have to hold bitcoin for very long to get this feeling but imagine it's

Your you know larger portfolio and imagine you are in the position you just described which is someone who's worked for you know decades of their life they've scrimped and saved and they put together a nest egg well yeah the worst thing that can happen to them is you know stock markets down by half okay that happened in you know in 2009 and they panic and sell they just can't take the pain and by the way this is this is you know this is one of the crucial things to realize as an investor is the part of the brain that is activated when this when this occurs

Is not the rational logical prefrontal cortex it's not this part of the brain that we've evolved in recent history right no it's our it's our lizard brain it's those base structures including the amygdala where we feel fear and that part can take over so certainly we don't want to you know have a client take too much risk and then watch the volatility and see the price sink and then panic sell.

However, as part of a broader portfolio bitcoin's really attractive it has those the uncur the uncorrelation the non you know basically low correlation someday it may be even viewed as a safe haven. We've seen hints of that recently, right?

We saw hints of that even this week with respect to you know what's going on with coronavirus. Stock markets basically around the world are down, Bitcoin's doing well. We saw that a little bit with with the Iran situation recently when Bitcoin went up when there were, you know, when it appeared that there was a heightened risk of conflict and risk assets were going down.

So we're starting to see hints of that. I don't know how long that will take. It it could take a while for for Bitcoin to become more of a of a gold like you know, zero to negative correlated asset with respect to other risk assets. But that's interesting to think about. And then it's also really important to think about Bitcoin as hard money.

And what you know, what position in a portfolio does hard money have? Well, in a world where there's too much debt, the debt is increasing, not decreasing. There's not political will to deal with the debt in the normal ways, and we can talk about sort of the menu of options for for how we deal with debt as a society, and where inflation is a real possibility, you know, on a one to two decade timeline, right?

I'm not saying it's gonna happen like you know, next month or next year even. Well, you better have hard money asset, and there aren't that many of them out there, right? There's gold, then there's other precious metals, and then there's digital gold. So Bitcoin has a place in the portfolio on that logic as well.

So what kind of like percentage of portfolios? I know obviously this varies with with clients, but kind of in general, is it you don't need much exposure, right? Because the risk-reward kind of ratio for Bitcoin i is quite high. So you can afford to risk less because the potential reward is so high so much higher, right? Yes.

And, you know, I'm it's different with each client, so you know, I have to be careful about giving sp specifics. But suffice to say that, you know, getting off zero but to a small percentage, you know, one percent or half a percent, that is a very reasonable argument. You know, for a really much more, let's say for a client who has better understanding of the thesis and the potential upside as well as the risks, and has the you know the actual tolerance for let's say volatility or loss, you could go, you could certainly go higher.

You could go to several percentage points. But you know, we're we're starting small. It's a it's a it's an education process, and you know, the biggest the hardest step is getting is getting off of zero and to some small allocation. And then with time, you know, we'll see we'll see if a larger allocation, you know, makes sense.

Sure. So you mentioned Bitcoin's risks, and you spend I think the last three or four chapters of the book like a very responsible wealth manager should, examining the potential risks that Bitcoin has very closely. I think it's this is a very underappreciated, or at least we spend not enough time on this because you know we're we're bullish all in on Bitcoin, and you know, and we love to get on here and just wax about poetic about how you know amazing Bitcoin is going to be and how it's gonna change the world.

And we don't spend enough time you know soberly examining the potential risks. And I think you do a really good job with this at the end of the book, and I thought it would be good to spend some time talking through them here. Yeah, no, it sounds good. I appreciate that. Yeah, you're right that I approached it like a proper investment thesis where you say, okay, what's my upside and how do I quantify that?

And then yeah, how can it all go wrong? Certainly the list of FUD items as you alluded to before is is long. It's possible to address each of them, and all I would say it's it's hard to literally quantify each of them, right?

So I what I don't do in the book is say, yeah, you know, okay, yes, there's a I don't know, there's a 2% chance of a successful 51% attack by a nation state or consortium of nation states within the next decade. So I don't take it to you know to that level of detail.

I try to categorize it in a few categories. There's technical risks, there's political risks, there's economic risks, and then there's sociological and psychological risks. And yeah, I try to spend, I don't know, depending on the risk, I try to spend a page, maybe two on each one to frame them and address the you know the possibility and the probability that that any one of them is gonna is gonna occur.

But look, I mean, there are you know, there's obsolescence risk and there's you know the question of the competitive moat, right? Which really is like can something else you know replace Bitcoin? Okay, pretty unlikely, like we talked about earlier. Probably looked more likely, you know, a couple years ago, but man, tough to unseat the incumbent right now.

Obviously you've got you know internet access, like, you know, if you lose access to the internet, well then Bitcoin's not going to work. Okay, well, if if internet goes down for any significant period of time, then we got bigger problems. And plus, you know, there are lots of smart people around the world who are building things like mesh networks, you know, there's this the satellite, there's basically these redundant systems that that can mitigate this this risk.

It'll at least keep Bitcoin alive, you know. Yeah, exactly. That's right. And that's the you know, I spent some time on the book on this too. I mean, I talked about potential attacks, you know, and what they would look like. The 51% attack is like so remote as to be you know not fully discounted, but but you know, pretty low probability that that that happens.

I think it's a little more interesting to think about you know, partial, let's say lower percentage hash power attacks, right? Like nation state or consortium thereof somehow manages to marshal, you know, a 20% of the network. And so, you know, one out of five blocks basically is getting censored.

What does that do to price? And could you have sort of a spiral that that comes out of that? I mean, that's not impossible, but nevertheless, you know, I talk about the difficulty of surreptitiously, you know, accumulating hash power, plus just the economic logic of there's just more money to be made you know, keeping the thing going rather than trying to attack it both from a capital cost perspective, right?

Like getting the ASIC capacity, plus spending the electricity to attack it on an ongoing basis. So I agree with you. It, you know, very hard to completely to completely destroy it. You know, I address obviously hacking, you know, by breaking the encryption, basically. We do have to worry about quantum.

This is so well understood that A, people are working on it, B, you know, the number of qubits that have been implemented in terms of quantum computing, I think are nowhere near where they need to be. And C, we really need we really need as a society basic encryption to work, because you know, whether it's EC DSA or Schnorr or basically elliptic curve in general, because so much of the internet is powered on that.

So if we lose that ability, the internet's gonna be pretty busted. So that tells you that there are a lot of smart cryptographers that are working on quantum resistant crypto. And the history of crypto in general, I'm talking about cryptography, is that it's the cat and mouse game and it's been going on for decades.

And so far, so far the encryption guys have stayed ahead of the code breakers for the most part. And so there's no real reason, there's no good reason, I don't think, to assume that won't continue. I can't guarantee that it will, but but we have some history there. Yeah, that asymmetric, the asymmetric magic of cryptography, you know, and yeah, you're right.

If we break that, it's you know, it's gonna it's gonna hurt. But yeah, you're there are tons of people who are preparing for such a case, and you know, quantum is you know, I think it's in the popular media kind of overrepresented on how well developed it is at this point and the challenges, the realistic challenges that they're that it faces to become, you know, a sustainable, like like an actually practical you practically useful computing platform.

It there's a ton of challenges there. Agreed. And plus there's there's components of the I mean you know the EC DSA you know probably gets broken first but you know harder to break SHA 256 so you know you'll probably have you could have some period in which in which you can't sort of sign transactions but but nevertheless the history is intact so there may be some warning time or there may be some reaction time basically even if there is a it is an attack you know before implementation let's say of quantum resistant you know basically a hard fork of some quantum resistant system into Bitcoin so yeah I

Don't lose too much sleep over that one but yeah you know there's centralization obviously and I break centralization down into several different areas I mean obviously you've got mining capacity you've got node operators you've got you know owners of bitcoins you know because if if the whales are too concentrated you know maybe they can they can wreak havoc on the system you know you got concentration among software devs you know the mining pools rather than the miners themselves the second layer you know exchanges and businesses like I do you know I worry a little bit about

You know concentration of accounts that you know Coinbase or what have you and the ISPs but when you think of when I think about the history of the internet and I think about where we are today you know I just think about 10 years of the thing hasn't been getting more concentrated over the last decade right it's been it's been getting all these things have gotten more and more distributed and more and more decentralized and the cost of you know crucially the cost of operating a node has been coming down I do think we'll we'll get to a place where you know everybody or a large portion of the population has a node on their

Mobile device and that'll be great and that'll be the realization of the notion that keeping the blockchain as small as possible and as simple as possible allows for the greatest decentralization and most robustness and strongest ability of yeah of nodes to resist attack by you know by other groups in the network so so look I mean that's the technical that's most of the technical risks you know political risks that's the next section you got government attacks and that can take that can take

Various forms I am pretty persuaded this is interesting too right when you talk about Bitcoin versus the altcoin universe I mean I think the mandate for innovation is pretty strong yes many of our politicians are Luddites yes many of them don't understand the benefit of innovation but by and large I think most of them do I think most of them realize that the biggest companies in the world are all American and they're all internet based you know with rare exception and if the if there's a narrative behind web 3.0 right and decentralizing the

Internet which by the way I believe is a possibility right I would like to see the internet re-architected you know will it happen with the you know, based on some Turing complete, you know, altcoin. I don't know. But regardless, I think it's all in the same pool of innovation is important, and Bitcoin is part of that innovation.

And the history of prohibition, you know, people definitely do worry about, oh, it's gonna be illegal. It's gonna become illegal in the US or it's gonna become illegal in some other parts of the world. And man, the history of prohibition is ugly, right? Especially in this country. You talk about alcohol prohibition, that was big that led to the rise of organized crime, and it didn't even stick anyway, right?

Like you can't, when people want to use a product or a service, and I think clearly people are gonna want to use sound money, especially in a potential future inflationary world. Well, you know, attempting to take it away from them is going to be difficult. Not least because in America at least, a lot of those people own own guns.

Shout out probably to Ragnar, who's working that angle. So yeah, it's gonna be hard, I think, for for the for the state to basically make it illegal. Now, there could be a period of prohibition. This, by the way, is one of my personal motivations, okay.

I think Bitcoin survives prohibition and eventually breaks prohibition if it happens. But you know what? I'd rather not live through prohibition. Okay. I'd rather get this thing widely distributed in as many hands as possible so that enough of the population here and in other countries understands it, understands its value, and basically is active and present in the political process and discussion if and when that conversation happens, you know, either in the next bull run

Or the one after that, when governments finally have their you know had had their panic moment about oh this thing is big and real, you know, and it's trillion dollar plus valuation and it it it may be disruptive. So that's so that's on the political side.

You know, you got terrorism and criminals, you got all the usual mainstream media FUD. That's that is both real and an opportunity, right? The story of the mainstream media FUD is the reason that when I talk with some clients about it, or when I initially talked to them about it, they said, oh, Bitcoin, and the you know, and they talk about dark markets, you know, or money laundering, you know, things of that nature.

And that is the prevailing narrative still with most of the population, I believe. It's certainly the you know, been the prevailing narrative with with my clients. And some of that is generational, right? I have plenty of boomer clients. So yeah, that that is a narrative that is common, but but man, when you run the numbers, and I had this in the book, right?

The UN itself estimates global money laundering is on the order of 800 billion to two trillion dollars, right? Which itself is multiples of the entire value of the Bitcoin network. And we know that happens in dollars mostly, right? The best thing I shout out, shout out Steve Manuchin.

Shout out to Steve Jucian, that's right. Exactly. And man, it's I have cli I've had a client ask me, yeah, about you know committing a crime, you know, with Bitcoin, and I said, you know, please please use physical dollars. Much less traceable than than Bitcoin.

The one the over 1 trillion dollars worth of hundred dollar bills that are outside the US's borders, right? This is the Federal Reserve's own estimates. Those probably aren't used to buy to buy bread and milk in developing countries.

Yes, some some people use them legitimately as store of value, but but yeah, you know, what what can those dollars be used for? So it's all relative. So I think it's you know, the it's incumbent on the person arguing that you know Bitcoin is criminal money. It's an it's incumbent on them to prove that you know that Bitcoin is used for crime more than the dollar is used for crime.

And I haven't seen any you know convincing evidence of that. So yeah, so there's there's you know what else is there? Economic risks. I mean, there's there's obviously the volatility. You know, I talk about the 14 characteristics of good money. I differentiate between short-term volatility and long term volatility.

Sure. Certainly short-term volatility makes Bitcoin a less usable medium of exchange today, but as we think, the volatility will decrease with time. And if we end up in an inflationary environment, then people will worry less about the short term volatility and care more about the long term you know the long term volatility, i.e.

The loss of value for for dollars and fiat over time. There's market manipulation. That's an interesting one, I think, for for institutional investors, and that is an ongoing issue i think the strongest argument there is you look at to commodity markets whether it's gold or any other and you say you know no global commodity you know whether bitcoin gold or oil or anything else is unmanipulated so it's really it's only a matter of degree and I think with the more time that goes by the less manipulated probably the Bitcoin market will

Be so so time is on our side on that one and when it comes to market market manipulation I mean it a lot of that is a factor of centralization of the actual ownership of the asset right so I guess if like compared to like it's much easier to manipulate an asset that is less well distributed right because you can if it's more of it's in the hands of a few people then it's more vulnerable to manipulation how does that express I mean how does manipulation happen in in Bitcoin how do we see see that play out yeah I think that well one obvious one this was actually highlighted I think in in the

Bitwise report that got released I don't know middle of last year or something is you just see transaction volumes as reported by the Bitcoin and crypto exchanges and some of the numbers are just clearly you know ridiculous right like it's it's it appears to be wash trading. Well it's either wash trading right one party selling to another party and they're and they're both you know effectively the same the same party just trying to show volume, or the exchanges are just lying.

And it's a range of behavior, I think, among the exchanges. You know, the ones that are domiciled in the US and or generally tend to take a compliant view in whatever jurisdiction they operate, you know, we can probably believe their volumes more than we can believe the volumes reported by exchanges that are in either weaker jurisdictions or are you know moving around jurisdiction to jurisdiction and jurisdiction shopping or have basically you know made no claims about let's say legitimacy

And compliance. So I think that's I think that's the main the main piece of it. Yeah. Yeah. Do we see like so some of the traders call this the inverse BART pattern where it looks like some whale dumps a bunch of Bitcoin and then you know lets the price sort of stabilize at some you know lower lower price and then just buys it all back up again, the same amount back up again to you know basically increase their Bitcoin holdings by you know five, ten percent.

Yeah. Does that happen? Yeah, I mean, you know, I honestly I sort of assume in some respects I assume the worst, right? What do we know? Well, we do know that early adopters, you know, whales basically have had decent chunks of this stuff. That's one thing we know.

The other thing we know is there are certain venues, maybe without calling any out by name where you can use high leverage and there are jurisdictions that are let's say off the beaten path. Right. And so you know, we know that in those, first of all, on those exchanges where there is high leverage, you know, you can a sizable trade can basically push the price and cause a cascade of liquidations, right?

Which causes a significant move. So we know those things can happen and therefore they probably do happen. And not only probably do because they can, but also because I think about you know, you mentioned the manipulator side. I'm thinking of the other side too, which is you know, if you're a leveraged, basically if you can trade on 20x or 50x or 100x leverage, that's gonna trade that's gonna attract a decent amount of people who just like to gamble, right?

Right. Humans like to gamble, some more than others, but there's enough of us on the planet that if you had if you know some small percentage of the global population of adults can either log in direct or hop on a VPN and get access to huge leverage on a you know on a highly volatile asset, well they're gonna play around.

So there's gonna be demand for that and yeah, the large traders can can take advantage of that. Sure. Makes sense. Yeah. So anyway, I you know, I guess, you know, going back to the some of the major risks, you know, there's the narrative, obviously.

There's you know, there's sort of there's naysayers in the media and I cover, you know, comments by you know, whatever, Warren Buffett and Jamie Diamond and Charlie Munger and all these guys. And you just have to remember these comments they will stall this, you know, they will stall adoption, right?

Like if if Charlie Mumminger calls Bitcoin, you know, rat poison squared or whatever he called it, yeah, institutional investors and average people care about that statement, but it kind of only delays the inevitable. And when you layer on the second level of thinking and you realize that all these guys who have huge stakes in the existing financial system, right, especially the guys who have stakes in the banks, right?

I mean, you know, any bank CEO is gonna talk badly about Bitcoin. You know, Munger and Buffett, I think last looked at the Berkshire holdings, you know, they they held something like $50 billion worth of you know Bank of American Wells Fargo stock. So all these guys have have skin in the game.

You know, I talk about Howard Marks. Howard Marks, really smart investor, runs or is chairman of Oak Tree Capital here in LA, big alternative asset manager. You know, he basically came out against it and then he changed his mind. And I give him credit for changing his mind. I also observed that his funds and his firm and his investment strategy are probably less exposed to competition and downside, you know, from Bitcoin than say the banking industry.

So it's all kind of a piece, right? It all it all fits a pattern with respect to who has the most to lose in terms of market share and business, you know, and revenue and market cap from Bitcoin's success. Those are the guys, and it's mostly guys, you know, who are gonna be who are gonna be talking about it negatively.

Now and it's yeah, go ahead. It's also just one second, but there's almost like a lot of these people too, one, like just talking about it, right? Like these people with large megaphones, just talking about it helps Bitcoin in some regard. Like people are gonna listen to that and be like, all right, Jamie Diamond, I respect him. And you know, I'm I'm gonna follow his opinion for the most part, right?

But you know, they're talking about Bitcoin, and that means something as well. So I that's also a signal, just the fact that like the you know, the chairman of Goldman Sachs has to come out, or JP Morgan, sorry, has to come out and talk about Bitcoin because it's actually something that he needs to consider. It's like important enough for him to consider is also a signal, I think, too.

So you know, yeah, there seems to be a bit of a stress and effect to some of these the some of this FUD and these negative events that that happen around Bitcoin. I agree a hundred percent. And moreover, you layer on the sort of larger trust narrative, right? You look at the stats, I've got a few in the book on you know, trust in government, trust in Congress, trust in Wall Street.

I mean, you know, it it was funny. I and I discussed this on the other pod, so I won't get into it here, but when I wrote the book, I thought real hard about, you know, how much can I talk about or how much am I willing to say that's negative about either Goldman or the banking industry or particular individuals. I mean, I thought about liability and I thought about getting sued, and then I realized, you know, these guys, rightly so.

You know, the banking industry and the leadership thereof are so untrusted and disliked that they don't need, you know, I don't know, ex CEO of Goldman Sachs doesn't need the bad press of you know, suing some small time wealth manager slash author, you know, for for bringing to light the behavior of the banking system.

So no doubt the general level of trust in financial institutions and government in general, coupled with establishment players, you know, like like the ones we just talked about, you know, talking bad about Bitcoin, coupled with, oh, it hasn't failed yet. Oh, look, you know, yeah, the price is down off the peak, but you know, it it cratered and now it's come back and it's still not dead.

Hmm. Maybe there's something to this thing. Maybe I should pay attention to it. Maybe the powers that be that I don't trust as much as I used to, say, before the financial crisis. Maybe they're trying to pull the wool over my eyes, and maybe I ought to pay attention to this thing. Maybe they're accumulating while they while they talk about there's a definitely an incentive to do that.

Use your megaphone to try to drive down price and stack your sets. Absolutely. Absolutely there is. Yeah. So another, you know, another big piece of FUD I think is environmental. That one is real, at least as in terms of adoption, and it plays into, you know, altcoins, for example, plays into proof of stake coins.

I've been working on exploring this one. I touch on it in the book. And I think for an intelligent, you know, reader or listener or investor, I think it's useful to talk about unit cost of production and you know what what Bitcoin is doing basically to the renewable energy market.

And I think the pretty compelling argument is, you know, it's been said that Bitcoin is the first global market for energy because electricity is transmittable over, you know, 100 miles or 200 miles, but not over thousands of miles. So there are plenty of cases of stranded assets.

These are stranded source of energy in the world that are not near population centers. And many of those are renewable, right? It's hydro in China. It's geothermal in Iceland. I mean, yes, there are people in Iceland, but there's only like 300,000 of them, right? So there's no way that the local population can use all that energy.

There are, you know, windy parts of the world that are not next to cities. There are sunny parts of the world that are not next to cities, right? Large parts of Africa, you know, Morocco, place adjacent to the Sahara. And so when people talk about, you know, use of energy, basically in Bitcoin, yes, there's no doubt that there's some dirty coal being consumed.

I think the coin is it coin shares has a has a report on mining that they put out periodically. I don't know if it's annual or every six months, that suggests that maybe the majority of energy usage in Bitcoin today is already renewable. And why that matters is because renewable, the advancement of renewable technologies depends on the cost being lowered, and the cost being lowered depends on better RD budgets and better RD budgets for companies that make solar panels, right?

That make wind farms, depend on higher volume of production. So the story with you know renewable energies, and you can if anybody who's talking to somebody about energy usage in Bitcoin, you know, invoke Tesla, right? Brilliantly, Elon Musk managed to get basically government subsidy for every Tesla car, you know, that he sells.

So you know, every every green-minded wealthy person in West LA who wants to go spend whatever 80 grand on a Tesla, you know, 10 grand of that comes from the government, or at least it used to be the case. I don't know if it still is subsidized. What's the you know so what's the logic for that? Why do governments do that?

Well, the idea is that if you can increase unit production of say solar cells, well, that will allow you to reduce, you know, well, to reduce the cost per unit of energy produced or increase the efficiency. So if solar cells, you know, used to be 2% efficient, right?

If 2% of the energy that hit that cell was actually harnessed, well, then we got to 5% and 10% and higher than that. And so if Bitcoin allows for previously stranded sources of energy to come online, and if that if the form of that energy is those remote sources, whether it's hydro or solar or wind, that's actually going to increase the units of solar panels that are sold, of wind turbines that are sold, which should over time reduce the cost of production of these forms of technology and energy and should actually potentially allow them to

Become competitive with non-renewable, dirty fossil fuels. That takes time. And it's harder to think about and understand that because you know, at the proximate you know, question is oh, well, are they are they burning coal or are they or are they using solar? But but that's I think is the way to think about capital cost and RD cost and actually making these renewable forms of energy competitive in the long run.

Because, you know, I'm all in favor, honestly, of taxing externalities, right? I'm in favor of taxing carbon, and I'm in favor of the consumer basically bearing the fully loaded cost, including pollution and carbon, you know, of whatever energy they consume. The problem with that is, as you know, you've got large emerging countries, China, India.

These guys have to lift their populations out of poverty by any means necessary. And they don't have the luxury of thinking 10, 20 years you know, into the future when it comes to you know global warming or climate change. Oh, and by the way, you know, the industrial, the already industrialized rich countries like the US, like UK, like Europe, like Japan, we already got to crank out a bunch of you know carbon earlier in our development cycles.

So unless we, you know, basically pay these developing countries effectively a lot, a lot of money, a lot of value to make up for that, you know, disparity in development over long periods of time. Well, you're gonna have an awfully hard time convincing them basically to take the action that's required to effectively tax carbon.

So yeah, I think I think all these factors are really relevant to the to the environmental discussion. And then of course, there's also the fact that you got you know guys like upstream data that are shipping what they call skiffs, which are containers that have Bitcoin miners, they send them to the wellhead, you know, the gas that would have just got released into the atmosphere rather than flared, you know, you can use it to mine Bitcoin.

So there's a lot of there's a lot of cool stuff going on, I think, in the in the environmental area. And we all just have to do our best to educate people on it. Yeah, shout out to Steve Barber, who's building and running upstream data. And there was an episode quite a ways back at this point with Steve. But if you want to go back and look in the archive, Steve talks about his business capturing excess energy that would otherwise just be flared off into the atmosphere and turning it into Bitcoin and hashes on the network.

Yeah, I mean I think all of that is really important. That's definitely a kind of a first line of attack from a lot of people. I mean, I hear it all the time when I talk to friends and acquaintances about Bitcoin, they hear them in into Bitcoin and they talk about you know the insane amount of energy that it takes to mine for Bitcoin and you know, if you it's it's it it is kind of a difficult conversation to have because you can't there's layers as you were talking about to understanding why you need to burn that energy in the first place, and how

You know what what it's producing, right? Which is the first absolutely scarce money in the history of humanity. And then you have to talk about why that's important. And so I think being able to respond, like, look, we're incentivizing renewable energy, right? The development of renewable renewable energy is is a really important point to make.

So not only that, but let's talk about how you know the effects of that of carbon on the atmosphere and on the on the planet, the potential like environmental effects. Let's compare that to the effects that the fiat money regime has had on the planet, on society, psychology, politics, like the you know, just funding you know, basically endless war, even though we don't have wars on the, you know, sort of concentration scale of you know, like World War One and Two.

We just don't fight wars in the same way, but we've had ongoing wars for decades and decades. And that's you know, those the military is, you know, largely funded by debt that's able to be created, because of, you know, the control of the money supply. So all of those things need to be taken into consideration. So I would argue, you know, that the production of or like the shift from of society from the use of a fiat money or easy money to sound money is more important than the shift from a society that is using you know fossil fuels to renewables.

But the cool thing is with Bitcoin, we get to do both. Yeah, that's right. Exactly. Bitcoin fixes this and fixes that. Yeah, these are these are discussions it's so hard. It's so hard to, you know, basically get people down the rabbit hole. It's hard. It's so hard to, as as Cory Klippsten says to red pill people.

And we're all doing our best to figure out ways, good ways of doing it. Certainly it doesn't help that our educational institutions don't teach any of this stuff, right? Like I got the usual Keynesian tropes and treatment in college.

So yeah, we just we all have to do our best to come up with as many angles of attack and as many exposures, you know, and repetition matters. You know, that's what I try one of the things I try to do with the book is find a place in the market, which was neither a very simple book that didn't tell enough, nor a hugely complex and long you know, tone that was going to turn people off or that people wouldn't get through.

But I try to find a balance of covering you know most of the major bases in terms of basics on what of is money with a little history but not too much history, you know, the basics of how well the bigger picture in terms of debt and the economy overall. And you know, you sort of alluded to that a moment ago.

I mean, we can we can go into the bigger picture if that's something we you know you want to talk about, but also you know, the basics of Bitcoin and how it works, and then yeah, the upside and the downside risks and that's our goal is try to is try to educate bit by bit little by little. We each do what we can.

Yeah, I think I'd love to jump into another topic about like talking about you write in the book really well about in a concise way about the history that sort of led up to this moment and created the need for Bitcoin.

I think it it would be interesting to hear your thoughts on how would a Bitcoin-based economy change the ways that we deal with debt as a as a society, and then like thus, you know, how would it change the way that we develop businesses and grow an economy?

You know, that here I hear some concerns leveled against Bitcoin about you know deflationary spirals and inability to grow the economy without you know maintaining some level of inflation, those kind of Keynesian ideas. How yeah, how would Bitcoin and sound money economy change the way that we you know operate on an economic and site level?

Yeah, that's that's interesting to think about. So I do think that the equilibrium, if such a concept exists, the equilibrium level of debt would be lower. Because certainly if you can lower interest rates and print money and basically incentivize people to incur debt, which is exactly what has happened.

Negative interest rates. Exactly. We'll pay you to take out loans. That's right. Pay you to borrow bizarre, you know, over $10 trillion of debt globally with the negative interest rate. That would be so yeah, the level of debt would, I would think, be significantly lower.

There would be less reliance on use of various assets as you know, store of value or monetary asset. So yeah, yeah. So definitely less people would buy real estate you know, just to basically hold an inf a somewhat inflation proof asset.

I think that obviously the power of central banks would be curtailed. That's that's that's a clear one. With respect to you know deflation risk, yeah, there was something about econ 101 and the you know the fear of the fear of deflation that was you know hammered into all of us, at least that was my experience.

Deflation is not a bad thing if it comes from economic advancement and lowering in the cost of production of goods and services, right? We see that in technology is like you know, Moore's law is the is the obvious case, where computing power and the devices that we use have gotten better, faster, cheaper, smaller, more portable.

But it extends really to all goods and services in the economy. And so all else equal, if your cost of food goes down or your cost of any other consumption good goes down, well that makes you wealthier. Deflation is problematic if there's too much debt and sadly, you know, that is where we are in the world today.

Which is yeah which is why we you know there's no other choice at this point is just make you know create more of it. That's right. There's no other choice. It's like the you know it's like the junkie you know once he's addicted you got two options you can take away the stuff and he goes through withdrawal and that's really painful.

And perhaps dice. And perhaps dies exactly or exactly or you just keep feeding him more and more and it is more and more because the effect you know as you dose higher you know wears off you have to keep dosing higher basically to get the same quote unquote short term benefit and then perhaps dice and then perhaps dies and look when I when and that that's a very that's a very good point and that's the you know the ethical perspective I take on on something like Bitcoin.

You talk about hyper bitcoinization and there's various you know there's various gradations of success levels or or levels of Bitcoin reaching its potential right quote unquote potential and even if Bitcoin just provides a competitive system that puts imposes a little more discipline on the existing system the world will be better off.

And it the world will especially be better off if let's say you get the hyper bitcoinization you know scenario that you mentioned well man we're it better happen sooner rather than later right because the more debt that accumulates over longer periods of time the more ugly is going to be the crack up boom as they say as the Austrians say and so man you'd be better off getting getting off the junk sooner rather than later yeah yeah do you think that how would building businesses change because you know the way the businesses are built now is based on so much

Easily attainable debt is that I mean I guess you could say it's necessary to the modern economy that we've built now because that's the way it has been built but could we still build you know a an economy that is I guess productive to the point that we have grown accustomed to right the same the same sort of the same sort of I guess amenities and comfort and etc is that do can we can we have that with a with a sound money economy you know or not I

Guess yeah I absolutely think we can because if if the market if a free market or a more or less free market you know for money or otherwise would allow you know would trend toward let's say optimal productivity overall well then anything that takes us away from that natural equilibrium is inefficient and results in misallocation of capital, right?

Right. And obviously, obviously we have huge misallocations of capital. Okay. Right. You know, maybe there may be no better example than the education market in the US. Okay. Today, one and a half trillion dollars approximately of education debt, right? College debt, and there were so many people who borrowed large amounts of money to fund educations that turned out to be basically unproductive, right?

I mean, certainly I'm a big believer that anyone who has the ability and the talent to benefit from hedge higher education should have access. But when you look at the facts and circumstances, you see that a lot of people didn't even graduate, right? The graduation rate, I had the stat in the book, I can't remember what it is, but it's something like the six year, not the four-year graduation, right?

But like the six-year graduation rate for four-profit colleges is like, I don't know, 30% or something. Wow. It's pretty abysmal. Don't quote me on that. It's in the book. But so, yeah, so obviously people borrowed too much to get their educations, and they're not seeing an economic payoff. So that's what's known as I mean, effectively bad debt, right?

Would we have had that bad debt incurred you know, if if interest rates and money supply weren't so manipulated? I doubt it. There's also you know, an interesting thing to think about is entrepreneurship versus incumbent companies. We know that most historically most or much of the dynamism of the US economy comes from startups.

We also know that it's be it's become arguably hard. Well, in some ways it's become easier to launch a startup because you know, you got cloud services that can be bought you know, piecemeal rather than having a large capital expenditure up front. So that's one thing that's helped startups.

However, large incumbent companies that have captured government and have their lobbyists working for them and implementing, you know, restrictions and regulations that make it harder for small companies to comply and compete. Those large companies have seen their profit margins move to historical aberration levels, basically, right?

Corporate profits as a percent of revenue are higher now than they've ever been in the history of the US. What does that tell us? Well, it tells us that probably those are those markets have become less competitive and you've got more monopoly and oligopoly dynamics. So I guess what I can say is empirically, under the current system where money is heavily manipulated, we observe more and more industries that have become more consolidated and where startups probably have a harder time competing than they otherwise would have.

Yeah, so I guess we'd have we'd have an economy that is, well, one fairer perhaps, at least gives a better, a better chance to innovators to succeed and see that they're see their business ideas grow and be sustained over time so that they would have a chance to eventually compete in the market on a more in a more level way.

But also a lot less businesses and investments that are useless or unproductive, right? So I guess we just have a much more efficient economy in terms of product production of actual usable assets that are you know helpful to society, right?

Yeah, I agree. And it's and it's you know, you think about time preference and you think about consumption economy and keeping up with the Joneses, and yeah, I just wonder if, you know, if I couldn't finance my car purchase for zero dollars down and I couldn't buy my house, you know, for 10% down payment or 20% down payment, and my neighbor couldn't do that either, that would be okay.

I wouldn't, right? Like if the guy across the street buys a Maserati, you know, today, it makes me think, well, why don't I buy one too? But if you know, if those sort of if those credit based, debt-based expenditures that in my opinion, you know, don't don't really bring that much benefit to the consumer, that those were a little harder, maybe that wouldn't be the end of the world.

Sure, sure. Yeah, so okay. I think wow, I think we've hit everything on my on my list. I think this is a really great conversation. I did have a note here to talk a bit about the having. And this kind of goes back, I think to this is I guess we could probably categorize this as a perhaps a political risk or maybe a tech or a technical risk, maybe a little bit of both.

Yeah. So I know you have a kind of a unique perspective about the having and a vulnerability that might arise every four years for Bitcoin. Yeah. So yeah, I think you know, I was playing around on Twitter and I think it was a thread maybe with Eric Wall, and we're and somebody was talking about the having, obviously, and someone was talking about is that priced in, right?

The per the perennial question is the having priced in or not. And this is not a discussion of you know, efficient markets hypothesis, right? This is not a question of do I think that Bitcoin is fairly priced or is everything priced in? Obviously not, right? Obviously, I think Bitcoin is severely underpriced, and I think it's you know, maybe the best asymmetric trade opportunity I ever see in my lifetime.

So so I'm not saying anything about the fair price. What I am wondering though is I am wondering if the halving itself is a fundamental event that should, in theory, you know, be positive for the price. And I'll I'll tell you why. So imagine you mentioned you know, political attack or government attack.

Imagine I am a government or a consortium of governments and I'm thinking about trying to take down or attack or or you know impair the Bitcoin network. How would I do that and when would I do that? Well, you know, when the price falls enough, right? If you get a bear market and hash power comes offline, that's probably a good time to attack the market all else or to attack Bitcoin all SQL.

And I'm not necessarily talking about a 51% attack, it could just be a minority attack where you're you know censoring censoring transactions or mining empty blocks or what have you. And so we don't know when market downturns or price downturns like that will happen, but we do know when the block reward will reliably come down.

And we're living in an era where you know the subsidy, the inflation component of the block reward is basically it, right? The miners, yes, they collect transaction fees, but transaction fees today are such a small percentage of the total reward that they're basically immaterial. So in theory, governments could attack Bitcoin any time that it's weak and the price is down, and therefore the hash power falls because miners come offline.

But if I'm a miner and I'm no expert on the mining industry, but you know, broad strokes, I think you know, there are a few things we can say. Like, let's say I am a miner and I'm planning for the future and it's a year from the halving. And let's say I buy an ant miner and I expect to have a useful life of, I don't know, 18 to 24 months.

Well, then I'm budgeting my capital costs, you know, plus my energy and my all my other expenditures on the idea that I'm gonna mine a lot of bitcoins, you know, I'm gonna mine 12 and a half bitcoins per block until the halving, and then I'm only gonna get six and a quarter. So probably I'm gonna be significantly profitable in that initial period before the halving, but then after the halving, I'm like lucky to break even, basically, or make a modest profit.

Well, if I'm an attacker and I know that there's going to be that event where the reward falls, I can probably assume that some portion significant portion of the mining, you know, the hash power has basically budgeted for near zero profit or you know, let's say zero or borderline break-even on a gross basis right after the halving.

So that might be the optimal time to attack the network because I can sort of tip those guys who are marginally profitable on a gross basis into negative profitability, they pull their hash power, and you know, there's more likelihood that you get sort of that that spiral occurring. I'm not saying it would happen.

What I am saying is that the halving is the one time when I as an attacker I can prepare and you know, basically be certain that there are probably going to be more marginally profitable miners on the network that I can kind of push out of the way. And because it probably takes time to accumulate hash power to perpetrate an attack.

You know, yes, governments can theoretically be accumulating hash power so that they're ready to pounce, you know, when the price is low and when the market's already weak and when there are miners who are sort of on the bubble or on the cusp. But if they can instead plan a hint ahead for a point when they know the you know there'll be more weakness potentially, or there'll be more marginal miners, then that's when they ought to attack.

So the moment we get past that, you know, having event, and there is no attack, maybe we can breathe a little more easily about okay, you know, chances are we passed that point of weakness and we're probably good for the next you know four years until the next halving. So that's kind of the hypothesis. You know, I've I've tried to engage a couple people in debate on Twitter on it, and nobody's taken the bait.

But but I think it's interesting to think about it as there as therefore being an event that is fundamental, like it should affect price. That's not to say that it will. Sure, that makes sense. Yeah, I would love to hear any thoughts out there that listeners have to the Andy's ideas there and throw them on Twitter.

Andy is is at Edstrom Andrew. Is that right? That's right. Last name, first name, Edstrom Andrew. Yeah, E D S T R O M A N D R E W. And yeah, it would be fun to have that conversation and get it going. And I think it's an interesting idea. So let's maybe get some of those mining experts out there.

I'll I'll maybe I'll try to get that going too and tag a few people to see what they have to say. Try to get them to crawl out of the woodwork. They're a secretive bunch. Yeah, yeah. You know, they they do important work, but they are definitely more behind the scenes. They there's only a few that are really out making consistent noise on Twitter. But so those those voices are very valuable because there's not that many of them.

Yeah. Yeah, so I think this was awesome conversation. I really appreciate your time, man. You've obviously, you know, really come up to speed on Bitcoin, know your stuff. Grab Andy's book, Why Buy Bitcoin. And, you know, I think it's a great you know, you look, you've got your mom or dad, brother, sister, aunt, uncle, who are looking to, you know, invest safer retirements, and looking for some upside.

And, you know, you're a Bitcoiner, right? So you, you know, we've got all kinds of books and resources to give them, but there isn't really one until now that was really focused on making the case to invest in Bitcoin in particular, right? From a wealth manager written in that voice, speaking to potential, you know, investors and savers who are looking to retire, you know, relatively soon.

And you know, even if you're you know, not r looking to retire relatively soon, that's even better, right? Like you got you know you even more time to let that investment grow. And I think it's it's important to think about this, you know, make sure that you stress that this is a long term investment. We talk about that all the time.

You know, this is a decades kind of horizontal investment here. This is not something to get rich quick. It's a as as Lop puts it brilliantly, Bitcoin is not a get rich quick scheme. It's a don't get poor slowly scheme. Yeah, I think that's I think that's spot on, and I appreciate appreciate that perspective, Brady.

Been a blast talking with you about it. I'll make one promise to the reader, which is I'm better at writing than I am at talking. So I don't know, man. You do a pretty great job. I think you're a little too humble in that regard, but you are a very good writer as well. So you'll enjoy the book, check it out, add it to your collection.

Andy, thanks for joining me today, man. Looking forward to talking more offline and getting to know you better and talking some big talking bitcoin some more. Likewise, Brady, thanks so much, man. This is a blast. All right.

Thanks to Andy for joining me for a fun discussion. Let us know your thoughts and questions about the episode. Andy is at edstrom andrew. That's at ed S T R O M A N D R E W. And I am at Citizen Bitcoin on the Bitcoin Twitter. And that's really the best way to support the podcast.

Share it out on Bitcoin Twitter. Let us know a favorite quote that you had, or you know, something you didn't like even. And also share it out with your family and friends. The podcast website is the citizenbitcoin.world. And thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring this episode. Please do go to Swan Bitcoin.com, sign up for early access.

It'll mean a lot to me and the pod to show you know the reach and the impact that this podcast can have for my sponsors. And check out the LTBN, the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network. Thanks to them for including the Citizen Bitcoin podcast in the feed. And you can also check out my merch store at layer1btc.com.

Click on partners and click on Citizen Bitcoin. There's some cool designs in there. If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. I'd love to hear from you. My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at CitizenBitcoin on Telegram and Keybase as well. And my email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me.

This week's open source shout-out is Libitcoin.

Libbitcoin was the second full implementation of Bitcoin after the original client. It was announced on July 21st, 2011.

It was created by a community of open source developers led by Amir Taki and Luke Dasher. Now it's headed up by Eric Voscule.

Libbitcoin has many tools like a wallet, encrypted messaging, blockchain query service, and of course a Bitcoin full node.

You can learn more about Libitcoin at Libitcoin.info. That's Lib Bitcoin.info. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care of their Bitcoiners wherever you happen to be in the world.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Andy Edstrom is a wealth manager who has fallen down the bitcoin rabbit hole. He started writing content to justify a small stake in bitcoin for his clients and that turned into the new book “Why Buy Bitcoin” - a great book to recommend to family and friends thinking about an investment in bitcoin. Andy’s history in the finance industry gives him a valuable perspective as one of early adopters of bitcoin from the industry. In this episode we get into that history and perspective, we discuss where the finance industry currently is in terms of moving toward embracing bitcoin as an asset. We talk about monetary maximalism and how bitcoin might change our economy. As any good wealth manager should, Andy has a thorough examination of bitcoin’s risk as an investment in the closing chapters of his book and we discuss them.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast

Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop

Citizen Bitcoin Layer One merch collection

Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek

Links from the episode:

Andy on Twitter

Andy's website

Andy's book on Amazon

Downloads