BONUS: Brady Talks Bitcoin on the PayPod Podcast Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-01-30 [00:00:04] Welcome to PayPod, the show that features thought-provoking interviews of leaders and entrepreneurs in the payments and financial technology industries. From credit card processing to Bitcoin, we cover it all. So if you want to know what's happening right now in the payments industry, stay tuned. Now, here's your host, Scott Hawksworth. [00:00:26] What's happening, everyone? Scott here, bringing you another episode of PayPod, the Payments Industry Podcast. We have got an excellent show on tap today where we're going to be exploring the historical aspects of Bitcoin, in addition to touching on the economic payments, and other interesting sides of it. [00:00:49] My expert guest in this episode is Brady Swenson, who hosts the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. And in addition to this, he's the director of technology at Rewire.news. So needless to say, he has a lot of insight on this. So we're lucky to have him on the show. Brady, welcome and thanks for joining us. [00:01:09] Hey Scott, thanks so much for asking me. Happy to be here. Excited for this conversation. For sure. Well, to start us off, can you tell us just a little bit about your journey into the world of Bitcoin? What led you to it, and how'd you end up hosting the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast? It definitely is a journey for sure. I think that's the right way to describe it. [00:01:29] And this sort of trope out there that everyone goes back to, the idea of the rabbit hole in Bitcoin. And I think that that idea, the metaphor of Alice in Wonderland and tripping down the rabbit hole and then kind of being in this sort of crazy world, unfamiliar world, is apt. That's why it gets used so often. I also have a very similar story to others, I'm sure, and I've heard it many times myself talking to other people about their Bitcoin stories. [00:01:53] I saw it or heard about it a while back, probably 2013, 2014, something like that. Took a look at it, was like, oh, that's interesting. I even actually set up a Coinbase account that never transferred money into. Like I tried to connect it to my bank account, but I kind of have a smaller local bank, kind of a regional bank, and it wasn't working. [00:02:11] I just kind of gave up. I was like, whatever. Of course, looking back, you're like, oh God, why didn't I just like dying? But then I remember making this kind of mental note like if Bitcoin price ever goes back above its all previous all-time high, I'm gonna take a look at it again. And it was like about a thousand dollars was the all-time high of that kind of 2013-2014 cycle. [00:02:34] And so in early 2017, whenever it went back over 1,000, I, you know, kind of keeping tabs on it just through Twitter. I'd followed a few Bitcoin accounts, and you know, people were talking about again, hey, new all-time high, and Bitcoin's in a new bull cycle after the races. And I was like, okay, this is interesting. Like, this proves a lot of things about about Bitcoin, proves that it's it's you know, still got life, it's still here, resilience and all that. [00:03:00] Yeah, it survived kind of two of these bull bear market cycles, and so the idea that the monetization process of Bitcoin is is going to be kind of following these bull and bear cycles and just kind of keep going up over time, kind of following this adoption s curve. [00:03:20] There's an idea in technology of an adoption S curve. So at the beginning, new entrants will come in, like people who are experts and interested in the in the field and builders will kind of adopt first and then it'll go from there and then until it reaches mass adoption and kind of plateaus at the top of the S curve. And so I just one day at work, I was like, okay, I'm gonna check out Bitcoin again and like really really check it out. [00:03:43] And so much had changed in just a few years. And that was my trip down the rabbit hole. So that was kind of early 2017, and I spent about a month researching YouTube and podcasts and Reddit and Twitter and just consuming everything I could about Bitcoin. [00:04:02] Of course, that led to the altcoins and Ethereum and all the rest and other projects that were popping up. So yeah, it just it just kind of kept going. But I finally got some skin in the game and bought some Bitcoin. And then once you do that, you're in. As Taleb says, you got some skin in the game, and now you have the incentive to learn about it. [00:04:20] So I work from a co-working space. We our company is organization is like a virtual organization, so we're all distributed around the US. And I'm in Lawrence, Kansas, just outside of Kansas City. There's the home of the University of Kansas here, college town. I have a co-working space here and kind of just started talking to it about some of the people here. [00:04:40] My co-host on the show, Tommy, who was also just kind of interested in it right away as soon as I started talking about it, asking questions and got curious. And he went down the rabbit hole himself, and we just started having very regular conversations about what we were learning about Bitcoin, trying to figure out is there something to this narrative of Ethereum is gonna flip Bitcoin and take over? [00:05:02] We went through the whole Bitcoin cash and fork thing and trying to figure all that out. And we decided one day that let's let's start recording our conversations, and maybe they'll be helpful for other people, and there'll be a it'll be a good incentive for us to do more research and to make sure that we understand what we're talking about. So we started recording, and we've we've done 20 episodes. [00:05:21] We roughly get to do one about every other week or so, kind of to fit into our schedules, and we just talk about whatever's going on and whatever we've been studying, and we're thinking about branching out into doing interviews with folks since we sort of spent 20 episodes talking about what we think. It's been a great vehicle for us to learn, though, for sure. [00:05:39] Absolutely. I'm curious, real quick, just what to you is the most exciting thing about Bitcoin? You kind of mentioned the rabbit hole, and that is not a story that I haven't heard before. So many folks have that kind of situation with it. You know, oh, I looked at it back in 2014, and then two years later I was like, oh, okay, yeah. [00:05:59] So what what's the most exciting thing about Bitcoin to you? Why have a podcast all about it? I think to me initially, coming from you know the technology side, I've been a computer nerd and excited about the internet since I first saw a computer and first had a dial-up modem that I ran a BBS on when I was a when I was a kid. [00:06:18] I think it was like eight, seven, eight years old before we even had internet access. And so I've always been interested in computers and networking. So that really was the first interesting thing to me was like, wow, this is really cool. How did they solve this double spend problem? How do you have digital scarcity? You know, that idea. And then just kind of beginning to understand how the system worked was super exciting. [00:06:40] But then I got into the economic side of it, and I took a macro and microeconomics class in college, and there was just so much we didn't talk about. We were really kind of spoon-fed the sort of Keynesian ideas that have become accepted among major universities and major governments around the world that this is the way things are, this is the way we operate our economies now, and that governments should have control of the money supply, and that we should use tools like quantitative easing to print money during down cycles to kind of stave off the worst of capitalist market cycles, you know. [00:07:16] And that there's this whole school of thought out there that is counter to that or offers an alternative to that called Austrian economics, was not brought to my attention when I was in college. So learning about the idea of sound money and about the effects that sound money can have on a society and on a on a culture has been fascinating. [00:07:37] I so that right now is what I'm most excited about, and I'm still learning on that front as well. So right on. Now I want to dive into the history of Bitcoin a bit. But first, I've asked several other guests this, and I really do enjoy the different answers I receive. What is Bitcoin? [00:07:56] How would you define or describe it to someone who has no idea? You know, they've been living under a rock and they and they come out and they're like, hey Brady, what's Bitcoin? It is really a hard question to answer because of the rabbit hole effect. There's just so much. I think when someone asks me what it is, typically I want to explain it to them in a way that makes it seem relevant to them, I guess. [00:08:20] And so I really change the answer depending on who I'm talking to. So if it's like one of my friends who's also a tech person, then I'll give them sort of the answer that interested me when I when I first found it. This system is amazing. Check it out. We can create provable digital scarcity, and this is how it works. [00:08:38] If it's somebody who's not technical, but is just curious about what okay, I heard that heard the word Bitcoin on like CNBC or CNN or whatever, and what is it? What's this Bitcoin thing? I typically tell them it's digital money, it's the new money, it's the future of money. And I've been studying it for a while, and I'm I'm really excited about it. I'm gonna continue to work on it and try to develop it. [00:08:58] I think it's gonna be a really good thing for humanity and for the world that we're gonna have this new better money that is not controlled by state. We're gonna have a separation of money and state. And that's kind of the term that I've been using because people understand, especially in in the US, you know, where I am and where people are asking me this question. [00:09:19] So people that understand the idea of separation of church and state and why that was so important to America and kind of the ideals of America. And I think this idea of the separation of money and state is kind of a meme and idea that will be easily understood by Americans and one that I think we'll hear a lot more of in the next decade or so. [00:09:39] Okay, so now we've got the setting of what you know, what Bitcoin is, but I want to dive into the history of it. Okay. And it's true that no one really knows the whole story. There's a lot of questions, there's a lot of mystery around it. But can you give us a bit of a history lesson? How did Bitcoin start? [00:09:58] Yeah, this was some fun research. When I first early last year when I first got into Bitcoin, it was really fun to read about the history of it. And there's some really good resources out there on the web to kind of read brief histories of Bitcoin if you're interested. The book of Satoshi is really interesting. It's basically everything Satoshi wrote with context provided, and that was provided a lot of really good history. [00:10:21] And then just going back to the Bitcoin talk forums and reading through old threads, I even got that deep into it. It was really interesting. But basically, the history is you know, Bitcoin, people talk about Bitcoin being the first cryptocurrency, but it's not actually. There was there were predecessors to Bitcoin. They didn't work. So it's correct to say that Bitcoin was is the first working one cryptocurrency. [00:10:40] Yeah, that's gotten traction that works. But David Choum started talking about the idea of e-cash in 1982. He wrote a paper called Blind Signatures for Untraceable Payments. And that was really the beginning right there. So it was way back in 1982. Choum launched a company called Digicache in 1990. [00:11:00] It was based in Amsterdam, and the mission was basically to turn his eCash idea into reality. He raised a bunch of money, and lots of smart people came to work for him, and they couldn't make it work, they couldn't solve the equation to create digitally scarce money. There was the central authority problem, and they made progress on the digital scarcity issue, but never could get it completely solved. [00:11:21] In 1997, Adam Back invented Hashcash, which introduced the idea of proof of work that Bitcoin uses to enforce consensus. And then in 1998, there was a paper released by a man called Wei Dai that detailed his idea for digital currency called B Money. [00:11:42] And that same year, Nick Zabo put out a proposal called BitGold. Both of those projects or those papers, there's plenty of evidence in the Satoshi's white paper that Satoshi was aware of these ideas. So then from 1998, you have 10 years until the white paper comes out, and in between then you had the P2P file sharing revolution, right? [00:12:04] You had Napster in 1989, the BitTorrent Protocol by Bram Cohen was created in 2001. And so that was sort of the final missing piece of the puzzle. A lot of thinking about how to make digitally scarce money was done before 1998. And then the P2P file part of it, the P2P protocol, part of the Bitcoin network, was kind of the final piece of the puzzle. [00:12:28] And so Satoshi, whether it's an individual or a group of people, kind of put all of those pieces together and released the white paper in on Halloween of 2008, and then the code was released. First block was mined in early January 2009. That brings us up to the kind of the start of the Bitcoin network. [00:12:48] You know, just to kind of give a quick summary from then to now, the past 10 years, the first person to interact with Satoshi and to run Bitcoin, at least publicly, and mine besides Satoshi was Hal Finney, who was a cryptographer who was well known in cryptography circles and cypherpunk circles, all of those years. [00:13:06] He's all over the mailing lists that were relevant to the development of Bitcoin for the two decades prior to the launch of Bitcoin. And for that first year, there was no value for Bitcoin. No one had actually traded Bitcoins for another currency, so there was no imputed value for Bitcoin at all. [00:13:25] And there's just in the book of Satoshi that I mentioned, it's just a bunch of builders, you know, people talking and solving problems and writing code and keeping the thing running and working. And then it picked up Steam, and this is what Nick Szabo calls the collectible phase of a money. He's he's kind of identified in an essay called Shelling Out, which I recommend everybody check out. [00:13:46] Nick Szabo's essay Shelling Out is on his blog, unenumerated blog. And it describes the process of creating a new money. And it starts out as this sort of novel, curious collectible, and that's what it was in those first couple of years. And arguably we're sort of transitioning from that now into a store of value phase. [00:14:06] So I think we're sort of still in this curious collectible phase a bit. We've got one foot there and one foot in the next phase of the monetization process. And then someone named Laszlo bought a pizza or two, I think two pizzas in Florida for like 10,000 Bitcoins. Yeah. The most expensive pizza ever now. Exactly. [00:14:26] Someday I think eventually when Bitcoin is fully monetized, it's going to be insane how much those pizzas cost. So that was kind of the first the first transaction. Now we have a in kind of an imputed USD to Bitcoin exchange rate. Mt. Gox was created as the first sort of big major Bitcoin exchange. And then Mount Gox collapsed. [00:14:45] And that initiated the big bear market of 2014, 2015. And there was really just one major exchange at that point. And now we're in a bear market in which we have hundreds of exchanges. It's just a lot different now. So there's a lot of building that happened during that quiet down price time where the media is not paying attention to it because you know Bitcoin's been written off, the price is down, it's dead. [00:15:09] Tons of work happened in that period of time that laid the foundation for the big bull run in price in 2017. And so now we're going through the same cycle again, and developers at Bitcoin-based companies don't have all these fires to put out because there's millions of people rushing in to buy Bitcoin, and they've got to, you know, all of a sudden support all of these volume and these people, and the network is being stressed and fees are rising and all that. [00:15:37] During this quiet time, lots of building is happening. I think most notably Lightning Network, which we can talk about later, but that's going to fuel the next rise in price and the next wave of adoption. That is awesome. Thank you, Brady. It's so interesting how you can see the cyclical nature of things and combine that with how it's like crossing these thresholds and these phases of Bitcoin. [00:15:59] And I'm interested, I think we all are to see how things progress into the future. But I want to real quick go back to Satoshi Nakamoto. Because there's a thought that it might not be an individual. It might have been a group of people that are going by this name. Are there any theories as to who Satoshi is or who they are? [00:16:21] And what are some that you've heard? Yeah, this is a topic of conversation that happens on the web for sure. And there's there's places you can go and you can find those conversations. And I have definitely participated in them. I think I've kind of come to this point where I don't really want to publicly speculate anymore because you know they decided to be anonymous for a reason, and so I kind of want to respect that. [00:16:44] But generally I'll say it seems pretty obvious that they were a person or group of people who deeply understood the history of the effort to create a digitally scarce currency and were able to pull all of those things together. I am pretty sure it was probably a group of at least two or or three people. [00:17:06] It was a lot of work and there was an incredible coder. So, you know, the people who are around on the boards and stuff in the early days are good candidates. The people I mentioned when we did the kind of history review that were writing these papers back in the late 90s, and all of those guys that were on the cypherpunk mailing list, I think that's probably the pool of people that Satoshi would have to come from, just based on what was produced, you know. [00:17:31] Right, process of elimination at the very least. Yeah, exactly. So I think it's a fascinating thing, and no matter who it is or who they are, they did some fantastic work and really changed the world, I think. Absolutely. Absolutely. So, you know, we were talking about Bitcoin and how it sort of you know had this ramping up in 2017, and then now, you know, this last year, the price has come back down to Earth. [00:17:57] Do you think that the ramping up and this return, was it all just media hype driven, and that's just the results of it, or or were there other factors at work? This is a typical hype cycle that we're following. And so there's an underlying adoption curve. I mentioned it earlier the technological adoption S curve, which has been demonstrated with the adoption of hundreds and thousands of technologies over the past century. [00:18:23] So it's a phenomenon that is proven out through time. And I think that there's sort of this technological adoption backbone to the Bitcoin price. I think we're following the price up that adoption curve. But it's gonna be a messy sort of up and down roller coastery ride along that kind of backbone, right? [00:18:41] So sometimes we're gonna be way above it, sometimes we're gonna be below it, and Bitcoin price will be undervalued, and that's just the nature of hype cycles and just the way markets work in general, and the monetization of a new asset works. So I think that this is just this cycle will continue, these kind of bull and bear cycles as we kind of ride that S curve of adoption up. [00:19:02] And it's you know, we're still really early. You know, there are estimates that you know, somewhere around two to five percent of people of adult humans own Bitcoin right now. So we're still pretty early in the adoption phase. I want to shift gears a little bit. You had mentioned in terms of where Bitcoin is now and a little bit on to where it's going in the future, and we've actually had an episode all about this, which is the Lightning Network. [00:19:27] And I think it's really interesting because from a traditional payments perspective and a function of how Bitcoin as a store of value could really take off and really be applicable to consumers and businesses. A lot of people seem to think that the key is Lightning Network and that this is how Bitcoin can really break into the payment space. [00:19:52] Do you agree? And what are your thoughts on it? Yeah, I do agree. I think that Lightning Network is extremely exciting. No matter what, the key to payments with Bitcoin is a second layer solution of some kind. The base layer was very clearly not designed for payments, despite the title of the white paper, which Bitcoin Cash proponents will always three-faced the title of the white paper. [00:20:14] It's a peer-to-peer digital cash, peer-to-peer cash. I think Satoshi gamed out that like, you know, at the beginning, this was going to be this sort of curious collectible thing, and that the only real use case you'd have at the beginning, because it's not a store of value, it has no value yet. It hasn't existed for long enough for people to trust it at all. So the only use that you're going to have for these mined bitcoins is to trade them with other people, like cash. [00:20:37] So you have to present it to the world in a way that is usable. You can't say, like, hey, guess what? Let's wait. And in 10 years, this will start to be a store of value. And in like 20 years, it'll turn into a great digital cash, a great medium of exchange, you know. And then eventually in 30 or 40 years, we'll be the global unit of account. Let's do it. [00:20:56] That's not going to happen. So despite the title of the white paper, the system, if you look at it, was designed to compete with central banking and central banks like Swift and systems that are responsible for settlement of large amounts. That's what the base layer is for. And so we'll see payment solutions developed just like Visa is a higher level solution on top of Swift and central banking and things like that. [00:21:21] So the payment protocol needs to happen above the base layer. And that definitely is the case. So right now, Lightning Network is the best layer two payment solution protocol that is being developed. And there are lots of very talented people working on this. There's really exciting developments happening with Lightning Network. [00:21:40] It's it seems to be gaining traction. The new protocol specification 1.1 is being worked on right now, which is really exciting. It's going to really resolve a lot of the major kind of hurdles that were realized. 1.0 spec kind of got out into the wild. And I think there's just gonna be a lot of very quick advancement in Lightning Network technology over the next five years. [00:22:05] And I think it will win as sort of the most used payment layer on top of the Bitcoin network. As you were answering that, it just got me thinking: do you think it's possible that when it comes to Bitcoin or Lightning Network, that there will be a credit type solution within that? [00:22:24] And I obviously I don't know the intricacies of the Lightning Network as well as as as you and some of these other great guests I've had, but do you see that as a potential credit component to it as part of Bitcoin and the Lightning Network? Yeah, and I think some kind of credit solution could be developed on top of Bitcoin using the Lightning Network for sure. [00:22:43] Well, maybe not using the Lightning Network as I'm thinking about it, because the Lightning Network is is pegged one-to-one to the main chain. Right. That's the hurdle, is it's like I think a credit solution could be like a separate protocol outside of the Lightning Network that's built on top of the main chain. Because of that one to one peg, the Lightning Network is trading Bitcoin back and forth. [00:23:06] It's just not yet settled to the main chain. Right, right. And so it'll almost would be like another layer. You would have this separate credit layer, and then it would get settled, I guess, through the lightning network and then settled on on up the chain to Bitcoin. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. I don't think the Lightning Network would support a credit system thinking through it like that. [00:23:25] Yeah, it's for cash, it's for payments using Bitcoin for sure. Yeah, and I think this is just a great example of some of the challenges and creative solutions that are going to need to be developed as Bitcoin and the Lightning Network and cryptocurrencies in general continue to evolve because we've talked about consumer behavior on this podcast before, where you have consumers that are are used to using things like credit, and not everything is is cash or currency, you know. [00:23:53] They want to get reward points. Ways in which that can connect with these new types of digital currencies. That is something that if you can solve that, that'd be pretty good, I think. That'd be pretty awesome. And you know, there might be a way to do it that I just, you know, I'm not thinking of off the top of my head here, but it's gonna be amazing to see what happens with Lightning Network over the next few years. [00:24:17] It's gonna be kind of an explosion of innovation and ideas that will take hold, and I'm I'm sure we'll be surprised many times. Do you think there will be another cryptocurrency that will emerge and truly challenge Bitcoin? We've heard about Ethereum and we've heard about so many different cryptos that have popped up, these ICOs that some might say out of control at certain points. [00:24:40] So I'm curious, you know, that there's these folks in in Bitcoin that are the Bitcoin maximalists that are that are like it's Bitcoin and nothing else. Where do you fall on that? What do you think? Yeah, I fall in the maximalist sort of camp, I think. And that was definitely a journey for me too. [00:24:58] I want to keep an open mind, obviously, but to me, there's two sort of pillars of Bitcoin maximalism. The first one is technical, and that's that network protocols tend toward one. So we tend to converge around one network protocol or one set of network protocols. And we saw that with the internet. There were lots of alternative proposals for protocols to TCP IP, right? [00:25:20] And TCP IP one. And the reason that network protocols kind of tend toward one is because we all want to be on the same network. That's where the value is. We don't want to be on separate isolated networks using different protocols. So network protocols tend toward one. And then the other one is economic. I kind of learned this one by reading the Bitcoin standard by Say Fedina Moose, which came out last year and is a great read to give people economic foundation for Bitcoin's monetary policy of a limited supply. [00:25:48] The economic pillar is that market chosen money also tends toward one. And if we look at the history of human markets, participants in a market are able to freely choose a money to use in that market, they'll tend toward one money because that's again the most efficient. It's a network effect as well. [00:26:07] Like we want to be using the same money so that it's spendable everywhere and spendable with all the merchants, right? We don't want to have a bunch of different coins that we have to, you know, it's inefficient to transfer between them. So we're sort of in the situation now with with fiat money that every nation has this currency and there's all this inefficiency because of that. [00:26:26] It's kind of like the whole the story of the Tower of Babel, where God strikes down on humanity and separates everyone with different languages, and then it takes a long time to kind of like all converge under one kind of universal language, which we're sort of moving toward now. And markets do the same thing. In human history, it's mostly been converged on gold because it doesn't tarnish, you know, so all the gold that we've mined, almost all the gold we've mined in history is still extant on the surface of the earth. [00:26:55] It stands over time, stands the test of time. But also it's hard money, it's hard to get out of the ground, and we've had this very consistent inflation rate of gold of a couple percent for a long, long time to rely on, right? So it kind of sets its own monetary policy based on how difficult it is to get out of the ground. It's progressively more difficult as we sort of get the low-hanging fruit of the gold out of the ground. [00:27:17] And the whole Bitcoin mining process sort of mimics that Bitcoin has become this digital gold, which is often referred to and was designed to be that way. And so because network protocols tend toward one, and because market chosen money tends toward one, and because Bitcoin has a big lead in so many ways, it's been around the longest, been working for the longest, so it has something called the Lindy effect in its favor, which is just the idea that something that's been around for a long time will continue to be around for a long time. [00:27:47] So the longer it's around, the longer we can expect it to persist. And then we have the developer network effects, we have the best developers, the smartest minds working on Bitcoin. We have this sort of community effect where every kind of bull cycle, we add on this new cohort of people. And I was part of the 2017 cohort that will just learn everything they can about Bitcoin and then share it with other people. [00:28:09] And so when attention shift, you know, kind of picks back up when the price is picking back up, we're all here to educate the next cohort and so forth. So all of these network effects combined with those two pillars make me think that Bitcoin is probably not going to be beaten. Absolutely. And I even to that network effect, I'd add just the business side of things and the traditional financial market side of things, you know, governments and these kinds of things, Bitcoin has that lead. [00:28:38] It's one of those things where when you start having businesses involved and you start having politicians and governments talking about you know how they'll regulate it and things like that, that's so big in terms of legitimacy and its lastingness. And so it's a very compelling argument that Bitcoin's not going to get overtaken. [00:28:58] Yeah. Yeah, I think it makes sense. And it took me a while to get there too. I during the bull run last year, bought my share of you know, altcoins, kind of buying into the idea that, hey, this is Bitcoin, but it's proof of stake, and maybe proof of stake's better than proof of work, so I better hedge in case I'm wrong and in case I'm not understanding this correctly, and those kinds of things. [00:29:18] But once I was able to, and the podcast really helped me think through this. I think if you go back to the beginning of our show, there's this kind of evolution of Tommy and I, our understanding going from all right, we got to hedge our bets here just in case we because we don't really understand what's going on, to really seeing the big picture and like, okay, this does make sense, you know, the idea of maximalism, here's all the arguments, they make sense, and we just sort of make them over 20 episodes in the podcast. [00:29:42] And so here we are now. For sure. That's the beauty of a podcast in general, I think, is as you just go through and have episodes. Even now, you know, I've done these series of Bitcoin episodes, and it's broadening my understanding. And I don't think about Bitcoin now the way I did when I first had my first guest talking about it. [00:30:00] I think that's a brilliant thing with podcasts is that they're always developing and changing, and they can help change you. Yep, that's true. They're pretty cool. Okay, we've got a segment that we like to end with, and it's our fast five questions. Rapid fire. Brady, are you ready? All right, I'm ready. Let's do it. Okay. Make a prediction about the future of Bitcoin that you expect will happen in the next 12 to 24 months. [00:30:24] I think we'll see the beginning of another bull cycle in price. And I think that there'll be big differences between this cycle and the last one. The main being that the ICO altcoin fork mania will be largely subdued compared to this past cycle, and that I think that it'll be replaced with a focus on Bitcoin education. [00:30:46] Just like learning about Bitcoin. This is the one that matters, and we need more people to learn about it. If you're interested, let's do it. That's my hope anyway. It might be a little optimistic, but we'll see. So bottom line, you expect it's gonna be another bull cycle, but it's not gonna be maybe quite as zany in some in some ways. [00:31:06] A little more measured. Yeah, I think the ICO mania and the altcoin mania, it's very obvious that those coins got way overvalued even compared to Bitcoin. The fact that Dogecoin, which was a meme, like Yeah, I think that came out of the fact that there just wasn't a lot of knowledge about like the stuff we just talked about. You know, people hadn't thought through or had the time to think through or had access to that kind of information about why there's probably just gonna be one internet money, probably. [00:31:32] Sure. There's not gonna be a bajillion internet monies that are that are big, and it's mostly gonna accrue to one, 99% or 90% at least, you know, is gonna accrue toward one currency, if not 100. And there's good reasons for that, and I think that those ideas will be out there more. I think that there's a lot being developed in this bear market right now, this quiet period, to help educate people who are curious about Bitcoin in the next bull cycle when that attention comes back. [00:31:57] So the more knowledge that's out there in this next bull cycle will lead to a saner bull market. For sure, for sure. What's one cool piece of technology, either payments or fintech related or not, but unrelated to Bitcoin that you came across recently that impressed you? A payment app that I have started using recently called Cash App. [00:32:19] Cash App. Yeah, Cash App. Really like Cash App a lot. I'm a big fan from a product perspective. It's gorgeous. The UI is simple. It's easy to use. I like kind of the rewards or whatever that they call them the boosts, I think. Those are pretty cool. Been saving some money using the Cash App. And there is a tangential like connection to Bitcoin here because cash you can buy Bitcoin through the Cash App now. [00:32:42] And Jack Dorsey is a cypherpunk from his early days. So he used to be on those cypherpunk mailing list that Satoshi used and Exabo and Wadeye and those guys. And so he's I think he's a Bitcoin maximalist. And the only cryptocurrency you can buy through the Cash App is Bitcoin. So I think that they'll probably add Lightning Network support. [00:33:02] And with the UI and UX like greatness of that app, I could see it becoming a super popular lightning network wallet too. In the next five years, most people around the world will make a purchase with either Bitcoin, Apple Pay, or some other thing. Which one and why? [00:33:21] I think it's gonna take a bit longer than five years for payment with Bitcoin to really take hold. I think there's a lot of reasons for that. You know, this is a gonna be a decades long process, and there's obviously a lot of kind of momentum behind fiat currencies in the institutions that run them. And it's not going to be a clean and easy process. [00:33:40] So I think it's going to take decades. In five years, I would say that people more people are using Cash App than Apple Pay. It's device independent. It'll work on Android and iOS. So it's got that going for it. The UX and UI is just as good as Apple Pay. You can use it with a debit card so it works with existing tech. [00:33:59] Yeah. So I'm I guess I'm pretty bullish on Cash App. Yeah. Are you sure you're not on their payroll? No, I'm just kidding. I'm not. I'm not. Jack, you might want to give me a little kickback here. Yeah. What's one piece of advice you have for someone considering investing in Bitcoin or getting involved with building a business or technology around Bitcoin? [00:34:19] Yeah, I think the number one piece of advice is to understand Bitcoin. Especially if you're going to invest in it as a speculative asset, you need to have enough of an understanding to know that this is a very long-term investment, right? Like I said, at least decades. So you need to understand enough to have that kind of decades-long horizon in mind because otherwise you're just going to sell when this price, you know, volatility will force it out of you eventually. [00:34:49] So I think it's some kind of basic understanding like of the idea like I'm going to invest for a long time and just kind of hold on to it and see what happens with this. [00:34:57] And once you do that, it'll incentivize you to learn more. [00:35:01] Same thing with starting a business or technology around Bitcoin. Yeah, you just gotta learn. Start with start with education. So jump down the rabbit hole, enjoy that process. It's a super fun journey, and then be on your way and get started building. Last one, what's the best business advice you've ever received and from whom? So I like the idea of strong opinions weekly held, which comes from a Stanford professor named Paul Sappho. [00:35:27] And I came across this when during the Bitcoin rabbit hole journey, there were some traders that that were passing this idea around in their day-to-day trading processes, they you know, kind of try to use this idea of strong opinions weekly held. So they'll be really convicted about a position and see it through. [00:35:46] But if the charts tell them something different, then they're going to change their mind. So it's weekly held. And it's it's a really interesting idea, especially when you're working in an environment of incomplete information, which I think every entrepreneur is, right? So the idea is develop conviction with the information that you have, but be ready to change your mind when new information comes in. [00:36:07] And I think that's the best advice I can think of that I receive for business stuff. So I think that's fantastic advice in business, I think just in life. I think there's so many people out here who who, you know, they have their convictions and then they just double down if they're presented with new information that would contradict it. [00:36:26] And that's not the way they can be passionate about what you believe in. That's great. Passion's great, you know, have convictions. But if you look at the data or the evidence and it says no, then be willing to maybe walk it back a little bit. Absolutely. And I think I apply the same thing to the idea of Bitcoin maximum. I think there's some maximalists out there that are just strong opinions, strongly held. [00:36:46] But this is a new thing, and there's gonna be a lot of new information coming our way over the next many years as this plays out, and you just gotta have a strong opinion and make the best decision you can, but be willing to change your minds. Absolutely. Brady, I wanted to thank you so so much for joining me today. [00:37:05] I thought this was a fantastic discussion we had. I had a lot of fun, Scott. Thanks for inviting me on. It was great. Absolutely. And where can folks go if they want to hear your podcast, if they want to connect with you, where should they go? Yeah, you can just search Citizen Bitcoin in your podcast app. Our website for the podcast is citizenbitcoin.world.wrd. [00:37:25] Got one of those new fancy domain extensions. Oh, yeah, nice. Yeah, I'm on Twitter at at BSwen, B S W E N. Tommy is on Twitter at Canon's Call. He also tweets about Bitcoin quite a bit, and Citizen Bitcoin is just at Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter. Awesome. Thanks again, Brady. [00:37:44] All right, thanks, Scott. Take care. Well, that's it for our show today. Thank you so much for listening. And if you like what we do here, don't forget to rate and review us on iTunes or whatever your preferred podcast listening platform is. We'll be back with another episode very soon. [00:38:03] Thank you for listening to another episode of PayPod, brought to you by Soar Payments. Soar Payments is a leading merchant services provider for e-commerce, high risk and hard to place businesses. If you'd like to get the latest PayPod episode sent to you automatically, subscribe to the show via iTunes or Stitcher, or visit Sorpay.com/slash podcast.