WEBVTT

1
00:00:14.080 --> 00:00:33.760
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there? All my Bitcoiners all around the world. Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance.

2
00:00:33.760 --> 00:00:55.920
This week we sit down with Vake, a longtime Bitcoiner. Many of you will know him from Bitcoin Twitter, and it was a fantastic conversation. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Before we dive into it, let's talk about Swan. You already know Swan is the best place to auto-stack Bitcoin in the United States with low fees and easy setup.

3
00:00:55.920 --> 00:01:14.320
Just connect your bank account, set the amount and frequency of your buys, and rest easy as Swan automatically buys your Bitcoin for you. You can just average out that cost basis over time. Don't worry about the market volatility, just Swan and chill.

4
00:01:14.320 --> 00:01:27.200
You can get started using my ref link, SwanBitcoin.com slash Brady. Get $10 of Bitcoin dropped into your account, and you'll also support the work on this podcast. My work on this podcast.

5
00:01:27.340 --> 00:01:34.800
Really appreciate it. Swan is also making a splash on the Bitcoin content scene with Swan Signal, the other podcast that I host.

6
00:01:35.280 --> 00:01:56.640
We broadcast live every Wednesday on Twitter and on and YouTube, and then we make the audio available on an audio podcast feed at Swan Signal Podcast.com. We just had a show that was amazing with Samson Mao and Parker Lewis. We've got next week Lyn Alden and Jeff Booth, an incredible combination.

7
00:01:56.640 --> 00:02:16.680
You're not gonna want to miss that one. And then Robert Breedlove pairs up with Swan Founder Cory Klippsten. That is sure to be a firecracker. There's they both love to leb. They both love macro and big time thinking. That episode is going to get cosmic as fuck. You're going to want to catch that one. So go to Swan Signal Podcast.com.

8
00:02:16.680 --> 00:02:45.080
Subscribe right now, add it to your Bitcoin rotation. You will not regret it. Go to YouTube.com slash Swan Signal. Hit that subscribe button. It's great stuff. Please, please check it out. There's 20 great shows in the archive already. Okay. Here we go.

9
00:02:45.080 --> 00:03:07.160
Today we sit down with Vake at Vake Garage on Twitter. That's at V-A-K-E-R-A-J. Vake has been around for a long time, and in this one we go back in history and talk about Bitcoin in like the 2013 to 2016 era. There's a lot of fun stuff to cover there, a lot of fun diving back into history.

10
00:03:07.160 --> 00:03:26.200
There'll be some new stuff and stories for a lot of you who like me came in 2017 or later. We talk about Bitcoin in the here and now as well, and we move on to some fun speculation about the coming decade. Get a little cosmic. This is good stuff. It'll pump you up.

11
00:03:26.200 --> 00:03:33.880
It's really fun to dive into Bitcoin's history and hear all of those war stories. Alright, I know you're all gonna love this one. Enjoy

12
00:03:45.040 --> 00:04:05.280
Me about it. Or he asked me about Bitcoin. I was like, oh, listen to this guy's podcast. That's fucking amazing. You have a citizen Bitcoin shirt. I gotta say the logo design is really nice. Yeah, it's on point, right? It's the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. Oh, I hadn't thought of it that terms. I just thought it's you know, it's got it's symmetrical.

13
00:04:05.280 --> 00:04:24.480
It it's it's it's very visually appealing. It's got the sun rising. Exactly. That's that's all Nick Nick Ward, man. Nick is the designer, yeah. And the shirt's good quality too. I like it. So I gotta shout him out for that. Absolutely. Awesome. Okay, well, you're putting out so much content these days.

14
00:04:24.480 --> 00:04:43.120
It's a like a machine. It's it's I'm trying to you know make the machine more efficient as much as possible, and I keep getting asked to make more content, and so I'm trying to figure out where to draw the line because some point you gotta say no to new to new ideas.

15
00:04:43.120 --> 00:05:08.560
But well, I do love the live streams. Like if I'm like scrolling through Twitter or I have to be on YouTube at the time. Yeah, like I just it's just it's something about live, the nature of live things, yeah, like draws you in. Yeah, I think it's almost always to it. I feel like we're really developing like a pretty proper Bitcoin media system, you know, like outside of the traditional mainstream.

16
00:05:08.560 --> 00:05:28.160
There's great stuff that's available, live stuff that's available every day. Yeah. I can't keep up. No, it's just a lot of choice, you know. And you can just kind of pick and choose based on guests and topics that you're interested in, and you know, like your your Bitcoin media consumption definitely changes over time.

17
00:05:28.160 --> 00:05:48.840
I was at the point for about 18 months after I fell in the rabbit hole where I was voraciously consuming everything that fell. There was such a drought back in the day. I guess we talk about more, but man, like 20 before 2017, there was like one podcast I liked.

18
00:05:48.840 --> 00:06:08.600
Yeah. Well, I mean the most of the podcasts like that we love today came out around that time. Yeah, pretty much. Like late 2017. Tales from the Crypts, Stephan Livera, what Bitcoin did was like late. Mine was like really early 2018. And at that point I was just hanging out with my friend Tommy.

19
00:06:08.600 --> 00:06:32.920
I hadn't started interviewing anybody else yet, and it was just sort of a drop in the bucket Bitcoin podcast. Although there's still a few hardcore citizen Bitcoin listeners out there that'll be like, yeah, man, I've listened every I started listening when you were just like chilling with your friend Tommy. Yeah, I've listened to most of yours. I'm if I don't listen to it, I definitely click the download button automatically when I see it come up in the feed.

20
00:06:32.920 --> 00:06:58.920
I do want to make content myself going forward, but I don't want to do just another podcast because I think that that that ground is is already saturated. Saturated, yeah, I know. I'm gonna say different, but I have to think about like what kind of media we're lacking in. Yeah. YouTube is definitely a space where unfortunately the most of the eyeballs are still on like trading, you know, platforms.

21
00:06:58.920 --> 00:07:25.200
If you Google Bitcoin or if you YouTube search Bitcoin, it's like it's garbage. Yeah, yeah. I mean, that's we got Swan Signal going. We're trying to establish an actual Bitcoin channel. We've got a couple shows going there. We've got a Bitcoin fac with Yan Pritzker who's answering Bitcoin. So I hope we're hoping those trying to get those into the algorithm so that when people start asking basic questions, like 85 different questions.

22
00:07:25.200 --> 00:07:44.880
Yeah. Noob noob questions about Bitcoin. We want those to start ranking. Yeah. Yeah. I hand his book out like candy. I mean, like I because if there's something because it's short, it's not too expensive. It's like seven bucks on Amazon. Yeah. I've given multiple copies of his book. It's it's real, it's real simple.

23
00:07:44.880 --> 00:08:04.240
Yeah, no prior knowledge necessary. It's it's a good one. It's a two and a half hour read, guy Swan reads it. Yeah, you know, I mean it's oh yeah, I should do that. Yeah, an audible. Yeah, it's it's great. It's a great, great start. Awesome. All right. I'll probably stop the video just because to make sure it you know probably helps with the bandwidth a little bit.

24
00:08:04.240 --> 00:08:27.680
Okay, sounds good, man. Great. All right. So let's get into your story, dude. I mean, you've been around for a while, like when did you get in? I first heard of Bitcoin in April of 2013, and I was shilling it almost immediately, which probably isn't such a great thing in retrospect.

25
00:08:27.680 --> 00:08:46.720
I think it's it's good to have a little bit of skepticism because there's a lot of scams out there. But yeah, April 2013 was really my introduction to Bitcoin, and that kind of well, we say, you know, how number goes up, draws people in. Yeah. Yeah, so that was April. There were two separate bull runs in 2013.

26
00:08:46.720 --> 00:09:09.320
There was like March, April, May, when I think the price started somewhere around like 15 or 25 bucks, and then it shot to like 250 or something. That's when I first heard about it. It was in the news a little bit. And then there's a separate bowl run. I think in November, November, December, leading to January of 2014, where it shot to $1,200, right?

27
00:09:09.320 --> 00:09:33.080
In a span of like two months. But yeah, that the when it broke $100 when I first heard about it. Prior to then, I was already, you know, basically a libertarian, not super familiar with Austrian economics, but I was aware of it. I was a fan of Ron Paul in 2008, 2012, totally on his end the fed bandwagon.

28
00:09:33.080 --> 00:09:56.600
And I was a supporter of the gold standard. So it made intuitive sense to me. And I think I think the thing, the actual specific thing that I heard about Bitcoin from was I was on YouTube and I saw a video of Jeffrey Tucker. Do you know who he is? Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yep, yeah. So he had a video, I think some interview with him, and it said how Bitcoin will end the nation state, which is yeah, exactly.

29
00:09:56.600 --> 00:10:14.600
Yeah, yeah. If you if you go into YouTube and you search for that, you'll probably see that video. And I mean, I just read that, I was fascinated from the get go, and I just kept searching on YouTube. I think I saw some some interview with Amir Taki on Russia, Russia RT. Is that Russia today? Yeah, Russia, yeah.

30
00:10:14.600 --> 00:10:40.600
Yeah, he was arguing with some other people. Max Keiser is platform. Yep, yeah. It wasn't Max Keiser's show, but it was another show, and he was arguing with somebody else about it. I think he was wearing like a Mozilla shirt in that interview. So I mean I just was fascinated from the get go. And I guess you know, the rest is history. It took me about I didn't buy Bitcoin right away because it I was a believer, I guess you could say, but figure out the technical part was took a little bit of time.

31
00:10:40.600 --> 00:11:03.360
There weren't as many resources then. I was trying to buy on like Bit Instant. That's Charlie Shrim's company, if anybody recalls it. But like that was it was so awful. Like you had to like go to like CVS or Walgreens and because I tried to buy anonymously, and you had to like give them cash and then you had to like fact send some some I don't know, account somewhere and then they'd credit you and it never worked for me.

32
00:11:03.360 --> 00:11:24.160
So eventually I just like gave it in and used Coinbase like six months later. Yeah, yeah. I mean going the privacy route, especially back then is difficult, it's still difficult trying to use BISC or like paying a massive premium at a Bitcoin ATM, which also actually has its own privacy problems too. So all the Bitcoin ATMs I've had to use generally require you to scan your driver's license.

33
00:11:24.160 --> 00:11:42.320
Yep, exactly. And I mean local Bitcoins was good for quite a while there, but I mean you could it would just basically be like a directory of like dealers in your area and you could just like text them or something and meet up. But but I think they've and they've added KYC lately, right?

34
00:11:42.320 --> 00:12:06.480
Yeah, yeah, and local Bitcoins. So now it's it's just yeah, I mean you can still do it, but you have to you know put in all the manual work. And if you if you have if you're in a place where in a or a city where that's a little bit more concentrated, you can find Bitcoiners to trade with, but it's you know, if you're if you're elsewhere, if you're not in a city, then it's gonna be hard to find someone to physically meet up with and trade Bitcoin.

35
00:12:06.480 --> 00:12:28.080
Yep. So back then I guess the first things I read was the Nakamoto Institute. I think Nakamoto Institute's been up their website since like late 2012, maybe or very early 2013. Yeah. Yeah. But there's only you know, I read through all the stuff there probably two or three times over, but there's only so many times you can read the same Pierre's articles, Bitstein's Kraywitz's stuff.

36
00:12:28.080 --> 00:12:53.720
Yep. Search for new content. It was it was honestly like a drought back then. Yeah. It's like Andreas Nakamoto Institute and then like Nigzabo's blog. Oh, I used to thirst over new Andreas videos every time he dropped something I'd watch them three times. Yeah. I can't really watch his content anymore, but this is the devotion, this just utter devotion that Bitcoin inspires, and it's it's like you literally cannot get enough.

37
00:12:53.720 --> 00:13:12.280
Like I was saying at the top, like, you know, for 18 months, I was voraciously consuming every single Bitcoin podcast that came out, no matter what. It was one like 1.8 or 2xing through these things, like just you couldn't miss one, couldn't get enough. And like yeah, my my listing habits have changed, you know.

38
00:13:12.280 --> 00:13:34.280
Now once you come up to a certain speed, then you just kind of start, you know, cherry picking certain episodes that you want to like kind of you know level up on, but you don't need to listen to it all anymore. Yeah, I will say that I did believe in I wasn't I will I did believe in the fast cheap narrative, so I did wasn't necessarily that like perfectly knowledgeable of Bitcoin.

39
00:13:34.280 --> 00:13:54.680
I didn't really get a lot of the trade-offs involved in scaling on chain. But when the block size of war started heat up, and then you start thinking about a little more and you hear the contrary perspectives, then you start to think a little more. Also, you know, Gavin was a lot back back then, Gavin Andreessen was the guy you'd hear on a lot of podcasts and stuff.

40
00:13:54.680 --> 00:14:13.400
Like he was on you know what Twit is this week in tech. It's a pretty popular tech podcast, you know. Yep, you'd see him there, you'd see him on other podcasts. He was kind of the public face of Bitcoin, and he was obviously, as we know, in in favor of bigger blocks, so my default position. He was still in control of the repo at the time.

41
00:14:13.400 --> 00:14:36.800
I mean, he had a you know, as far as I understand, because I wasn't around then, but he had a pretty stellar reputation among Bitcoiners. Like he was well respected. Yeah, he's I mean he comes off as a very soft-spoken, humble guy. Yeah. And probably to some extent he is. I mean, he's not, you know, as nearly loud and aggressive as say Craig Wright or Roger Veer.

42
00:14:36.800 --> 00:14:56.960
Yeah. But I mean, I think he was he's he's been proven to be wrong about you know the block size issue. And I think, yeah, the repo, he had control of the repo until what, like shortly after the Craig Wright incident. That's when they basically I don't know if he surrendered his key or he or they took it from him. Yeah, basically it was taken from him as far as I understand.

43
00:14:56.960 --> 00:15:15.680
And like yeah, it was sort of the up and coming new guard of Bitcoin Core. Because you know, Gavin and Mike Hearn sort of represented this you know, kind of directly handed, you know, power handed directly down from Satoshi. And so had that sort of swag.

44
00:15:15.680 --> 00:15:33.920
And there was a you know, a new crop of Bitcoiners who didn't necessarily have the kind of direct contact with Satoshi, but they you know had they were very convicted about not increasing the block size and scaling through layers.

45
00:15:33.920 --> 00:15:52.720
But that was just you know hard to see, and this was the like block size was like the easy the easy way out. And like even Matt Odell in a recent episode, I think it was you know a rabbit hole recap episode, was talking about how you know he was a big blocker at first too. Like it just seemed easy and the right the way out. Let's just get this done, you know.

46
00:15:52.720 --> 00:16:30.280
Yeah, I mean I remember I look back at some of the texts and emails and other chats that I had with friends back in in 2013 when I was trying to show Bitcoin to them and one of the things I incorrectly told them was that it was cheaper than like say credit cards and that that was another argument in favor of it which obviously now I realize is wrong but actually we were saying about Hearn and Gavin being the old guard yeah just to push back on that a little bit if you if you look at I can't I don't know exactly where but Greg Maxwell has actually kind of debunked that idea a little bit and that Hearn and Gavin were the public faces of Bitcoin.

47
00:16:30.600 --> 00:16:50.040
But that really since 2010 11 it was other people doing the hard work on the on the code base or the Bitcoin core code base. So Peter Wula, Maxwell, Luke Dash Jr, you know the usual names and that they were actually the ones writing the code and then I don't know if Gavin was just out there taking the credit for it.

48
00:16:50.040 --> 00:17:28.440
Yeah because he was the one showing up on podcasts. Right but that really the technical the technical community was always against larger block sizes it's just that there was this guy out appearing out on all the on the media saying otherwise right yeah and then they're you know then there were those guys started attacking the kind of the technical crew by you know kind of saying there was like this consolidation of Bitcoin core maintainers like top Bitcoin core contributors you know at certain companies namely blockstream

49
00:17:28.520 --> 00:17:47.040
And then there was this you know plan to create the side chain and sell access to the sidechain and so the big the small blocks narrative was really just a marketing ploy to solidify the business model of blockstream.

50
00:17:47.040 --> 00:18:09.440
So do you do you remember that that sort of narrative emerging and what did you think? Yeah, I don't recall exactly when Blockstream was founded, but this debate predates Blockstream without a doubt. I mean it's the first indication. So my first year to two years of Bitcoin, I was not even aware of like the block size debate.

51
00:18:09.440 --> 00:18:28.800
I didn't even know it was like a thing. Yeah. I mean I knew that there was a block size limit, but I know there was actually contention about it. I don't think I became aware of it until maybe 2015. Right. When the XT debate started heating up. And what when what year was Mike Rate Hearn's rage quit? That might have been 2016, I think.

52
00:18:28.800 --> 00:18:47.200
Let's look it up real quick. So if I recall correctly, the way it went was first was Bitcoin XT, where they were gonna do 20 megabyte block sizes, and then they said, okay, we'll compromise, and they cut down to two megabytes, and somewhere in this time was the Hong Kong meeting.

53
00:18:47.200 --> 00:19:12.880
Where there was I think the scaling Bitcoin conference, right? There's a home it was in Hong Kong, and Adam back as a compromise proposed like a 248 plan. And ever since then, that's been thrown in our faces like oh, well, Adam Back promised two megabytes, then four megabytes and eight megabytes, and then you know you reneged on that promise, which to which I would say Adam Back doesn't get to negotiate on back of all of us.

54
00:19:12.960 --> 00:19:37.640
Right. Right. Exactly. The people have to adopt it. And so he didn't even get it. Mike Ern was Mike Kern was January 14th, 2016 is when he published the end of the Bitcoin experiment. So by that point, XT had failed, and then Bitcoin Classic, which was the follow-up compromise where they said, okay, we'll do a two megabyte block size.

55
00:19:37.640 --> 00:19:59.480
That failed too, and then they say, okay, we'll just go balls to the wall, and we'll just Bitcoin Unlimited was the next one they proposed, which was obviously as the name implies, no block size limit. And then I think all this was like this was from 2015 to 2017, and then obviously the hard fork was was twenty August 1st, 2017.

56
00:19:59.480 --> 00:20:21.080
Right when they finally said screw it, we'll fork off. Right. The S2X fork that and that had a coding error and just completely died on the attempted fork at the time. Yeah, so so I think the S2X was SegWit 2X for everyone out there was proposed in April or May of 2017.

57
00:20:21.080 --> 00:20:41.400
I still remember waking up from work one day and it was it was during consensus, right? The consensus conference in New York, right? The New York agreement as it was called came to be called. Barry Silbert, right, got everybody in a room, and he's like, Okay, we're all gonna do this hard fork, we're gonna implement SegWit, and then we're gonna do the hard fork like three, four months later.

58
00:20:41.400 --> 00:21:02.720
Right. And I remember it being announced, and you could I bet if I looked back on my Twitter back then, I launched into a screen, I'm like, who the fuck is this guy to just announce this to just collect people in a room and announce it? Like if they could do that, just thinking conceptually, if they could do that, where they could gather a bunch of business leaders in a room, a bunch of CEOs, and hard fork Bitcoin.

59
00:21:02.720 --> 00:21:27.280
What does that apply about its censorship or that it's immutability? It's it's decentralization. They could just always do it again, except they could implement blacklists or something else. Yep. So it really didn't matter what the New York agreement was, the particulars that came out of it. It was just the idea that these this group of people could get together in a room in New York and then come out and announce this is what will happen with Bitcoin.

60
00:21:27.360 --> 00:21:50.640
Yep. And it was everybody. Yeah. DCG, right? Which is very silver's company. Yeah. Digital currency group, Coinbase, Zappo, BitPay. It was every major company outside of, except for Blockstream, I think at that time was the only company that did not agree to it, which actually is kind of ironic because they I think DCG is one of their investors.

61
00:21:50.640 --> 00:22:10.800
So they kind of went against one of their one of their investors to oppose that that agreement. Yeah. And then weren't so obviously Seg that was in April and May of 2017. SegWit was integrated on August 1st, and that's the same day that Bitcoin Cash forked off.

62
00:22:10.800 --> 00:22:29.520
Right. And then there was that little interim period between August 1st and I think November 15th of 2017 when the 2x hard fork was going to happen, and that's when so I think from April that summer of 2017 was the SegWit UASF, right?

63
00:22:29.520 --> 00:22:49.040
UASF. UASF, the user activated soft fork. Everybody put it in their profile. Myself included for a little bit. I tried to, as a joke, I was at a baseball game that summer and I tried to start a UASF chat, and everyone stared at me.

64
00:22:49.520 --> 00:23:08.360
What the heck does that mean? They're like everyone, everyone you know, besides Bitcoin, is like United States Air Force, United States Air Force, what yeah. And then and then No2X was from like August to November, right? And we had Samson Mao was putting out his hats. Yeah. Which I bought one of them. I never did. You can still buy one.

65
00:23:08.920 --> 00:23:39.080
They're they're on his hat store. I think it's Axillion.com, which by the way, I was on there yesterday and it's freaking hilarious because it's like it's like you know, tongue in cheek taking itself super seriously as like this global fashion brand. It's pretty funny. You should check it out. Okay, yeah, I'll do that. And then so the there was the futures for for the SegWit 2x4 trading on Bitfinex, and I think was trading it like generally around 0.15 of BTC.

66
00:23:39.080 --> 00:24:01.720
Yeah. Which so a lot of people were like eager for it to happen. Yeah. Right? Like I remember I think Mr. Hoddle and like Shinobi were like, yeah, we'll just like we'll just dump it and increase our stack by like 15%. Yeah, exactly. But it just never went through a thing like three days before they canceled it. Yeah. That was the battle of 2017. But really, it's the culmination of like four or five years of arguments, maybe even longer.

67
00:24:01.720 --> 00:24:26.680
I mean, if I guess if you go back to They say they they say that all these debates that we have today are literally just rehashes of stuff that was debated on Bitcoin talk in 2009, 10, 11. Yeah, I think I think there was even if I remember correctly, there was even a post about it in a thread like in 2009, like you know, just a couple of months after after the code was released.

68
00:24:26.680 --> 00:24:46.720
I think if I have read this post before, and I know it took me it take me a moment to go back and find it, but somebody brought up, hey, you know, what happens when it was it was pretty soon, because I guess a few months block size at limit hadn't even existed yet. Stoshi sort of tossed it in there, you know, late 2009, I think, maybe early 2010.

69
00:24:46.960 --> 00:25:06.080
And I do remember within a couple of months, like, hey, this block size limit could be a problem in the future. And Satoshi was just like, Oh, yeah, that's okay, we'll just increase it when we need to. You know, it's just it's just a spam cap for now. Yeah, I mean, Satoshi is is should be respected, but not worshipped.

70
00:25:06.080 --> 00:25:25.280
Yeah, exactly. Yeah. I mean, I think he was heroes. I think he was human, liable to mistakes just like anyone else. He was, I mean, this is super early, 2009, 10. I don't think that the first mining pool, right, was was slush pool, right? Yes. Ever. And that had it not emerged until maybe late 2010, 2011.

71
00:25:25.280 --> 00:25:46.320
So he hadn't he didn't have the opportunity to see the emergence of mining pools and some of the centralization risks there. Yeah. Yeah, so I mean, Satoshi, he he can make mistakes. We all we all saw everyone knows about Hal's post about how he doesn't think it'll scale on chain and that ultimately there will be banks, and that'll be one of the scaling methods.

72
00:25:46.320 --> 00:26:10.720
So I mean I agree with a lot of that. But really, Bitcoin Talk.org, if you think about it, that's a that site is a treasure trove. I think I came personally a little too late for it. In the sense that when I got in in 2013, our Bitcoin Reddit was the was the dominant platform. And then I think Bitcoin Twitter, I don't know, specific date, but it's really emerged more since like 2016, right?

73
00:26:10.720 --> 00:26:28.720
Yeah. Yeah, so but Bitcoin Talk.org was was the place, and it's you know, it's a treasure trove because if you think of Bitcoin or Satoshi is Jesus, let's say a Jesus type figure, that's where he did a lot of his writing, and that's where his early disciples all posted. Right.

74
00:26:28.720 --> 00:26:49.160
Yep. I mean, I hope that somebody like is archiving it because there's a lot of valuable threads on there about the early days and what people thought. I believe Nakamoto Institute is mirroring it and has a copy. At Nakamoto Institute.org. And there's a book called The Book of Satoshi.

75
00:26:49.160 --> 00:27:07.640
Yeah. Which is literally just all of the writings available from Satoshi, including some private emails that had been made public until the publication of the book, which is like 18 months ago, I think. That book is fascinating. Oh, the book is Satoshi Right by by Phil Champagne.

76
00:27:07.640 --> 00:27:25.800
Yes, I think that's correct. Yeah, I bought a copy of that book. I went to I've only ever been to two Bitcoin conferences, although I will be at BitBlock Boom next month. Nice. And in 2015, January 2015, I went to TNA B C Miami, the North American Bitcoin conference in Miami, and he was there.

77
00:27:25.800 --> 00:28:04.200
He's selling a copy of it, so yeah, I bought a signed copy of that from him. Yeah, I love it. It's a great book. It's a great book. It's almost like it's almost like the New Testament of Bitcoin, or maybe the old testament of Bitcoin. Yeah, he just goes through all Satoshi's writings and kind of gives a little bit of context. Yes. Fantastic. I have it on Audible, and it's something I'll throw throw it on every once in a while, like working out in the yard or something, and just like listen to some some the you know the original writings, and there's you know, like you mentioned earlier, there's a lot of there's very prescient you know ideas expressed in these books, but there's also you know the limitation, like you couldn't

78
00:28:04.520 --> 00:28:31.440
Couldn't see the future that has unfolded. And I would, you know, I think the idea that that Bitcoin will scale in layers makes sense. I'm not sure that Satoshi was, you know, well versed in in you know layered protocol development necessarily and yeah you know the and those kinds of things which is why you know it's has attracted the people that we need to sort of take take it to the next level.

79
00:28:31.440 --> 00:28:48.000
Yeah I mean he was only around for two years right I mean yeah I mean if we talk about the debut of the network on January 3 2009 and then he was gone by was it December 2010 or January 2011 that his last post was I could yeah look it up on

80
00:28:51.520 --> 00:29:12.320
It was right after Gavin Andreessen went to the CIA. Yep December 13th 2010 was his last post. Yeah yeah Gavin and will Gavin will visit the CIAA posts on April 27th 2011. And oh I don't see that one I see the last one December 12th 2010.

81
00:29:12.320 --> 00:29:41.920
Yeah okay yeah but yeah that's when Gavin posted that he was gonna visit the CIA and I think that was the end of it. Yeah. I don't know if that's necessarily the impetus and I don't want to blame Gavin for doing that because let's be forgotten the CI was going to find out about it one way or another. Of course of course so yeah way to try to present it in a you know in a in a good light that this is something that is not a threat to it's not a threat to like you know CIA investigations etc.

82
00:29:41.920 --> 00:30:01.080
Yeah. You know I mean and if the CIA could shut it down then what's the point, right? It was all for naught, but luckily he built a robust system. And then so yeah, his his la one of his last posts, right, was the December 11th, 2010. Satoshi wrote, it would have been nice to get this attention in any other context.

83
00:30:01.080 --> 00:30:23.080
WikiLeaks has kicked the Hornet's nest and the swarm is headed towards us. So it's very clear that he was maybe getting a little panicky. And bounced. Yep. Another post on Bitcoin Talk.org. I'll tell you what, I read this. This is from November 24th, 2013. This is by a guy under the under the pseudonym RPTLA.

84
00:30:23.080 --> 00:30:42.680
RPI E T I L A. I don't know if he's still active, but I remember reading this in November of 2013, and he basically just laid out that he thought the price of Bitcoin would be the millions within four years from then, which has proven me wrong. But I mean I swear to God, I read that and I was like, I just turned super bullish immediately.

85
00:30:43.560 --> 00:31:02.680
Base he took the price increases from prior to then, so 2009 to 13, and he just extrapolated it out. Which to be fair, there I mean, even though the price since then through today is still been tremendous, it hasn't been quite at that speed on a percentage basis, right?

86
00:31:02.680 --> 00:31:21.720
But but I mean just reading that, I was like, holy shit, I gotta get into this. Yeah, and so did you did you try any mining back then? It was still possible. 2013, I feel like maybe I mean I don't have an ASIC or anything, yeah.

87
00:31:21.720 --> 00:31:43.080
I don't know if if mining on my laptop would have been feasible. I think maybe 2011 or 12 would have been the very last year could have done that, but no, I never mind. Always bought, just bought and stored. I mean, my method of cold storage has changed over the years. I mean, back back then there was no hardware wallets, right? The treasure was the first hardware wallet, if I recall correctly.

88
00:31:43.080 --> 00:32:11.440
I don't know exactly, I think that debuted maybe 2014, 2015. So back then I was using paper wallets, which is something I don't really recommend people do now. There was bitaddress.org, which was you're you just you just you go to the site and you would you would move your mouse around or you type in some mumbo jumbo numbers on your on your keyboard, which would add entropy, and then it would generate a paper wallet and you could print it.

89
00:32:11.440 --> 00:32:29.840
And I put a lot of money on that, and in retrospect, I realized man, that was really stupid. Yeah. If there was if there was a malicious code on there, all my money would be gone. Right, right. Yeah, I mean what about Bitcoin Core? Were you using the Bitcoin Core wallet? No, it took me it took me a couple years to learn to run a node, dude.

90
00:32:29.840 --> 00:33:00.800
I was I didn't it actually was the block size debate that taught me about the importance of running a node because actually before that I wasn't really for the first couple years, I wasn't really knowledgeable what a node was. Right. It was it was it was the debate, the block or the debate. So in some sense, the block size debate taught people about the things they didn't know, running a node, decentralization, trade-off risks, the risks of centralization creeping into the system.

91
00:33:00.800 --> 00:33:27.760
Yeah. So it it was very beneficial in some sense. Even worse, not only did I use paper wallets to store everything, I was I was I was in the school at the time and I was printing them off of the school printer. Yeah. In my own. Luckily I've moved all the money from there, but but yeah, there's there's a lot of mistakes I made in the early days.

92
00:33:27.920 --> 00:33:53.720
I guess it's part of learning. Were you fortunate enough to not lose any or much Bitcoin? I'm very fortunate. I've I've lost I have never been hacked to this date. I have lost a c I've lost a couple. I was trying to dump some BCH for BTC a couple years ago and I sent it to like a bad address or something trying to do Shapeshift and so I screwed that up, lost a few thousand bucks that way.

93
00:33:53.720 --> 00:34:11.880
And actually I got fished a little bit just like a few months ago. I had a friend who I know from the old I used to attend the Miami Bitcoin meetups back in the day. And I had a friend from there who like messaged me on Telegram asking like he does some OTC trading.

94
00:34:11.880 --> 00:34:35.320
So he asked me if I could front him some BTC, and I send it to him, and then later it turned out that it was not him. That was just a few hundred bucks. So I've lost a little bit here and there, but by and large I've I've I've missed the big mistakes. I never had money on Gox. I mean frankly, Gox Gox collapsed in I think it was February, March 2014, something like that.

95
00:34:35.480 --> 00:34:57.240
Yeah, exactly. Yeah, around then, but if you were on our Bitcoin regularly, you were people hearing people complain about it going back to at least like eight, nine months beforehand. So the signs were there. So I never had my money on Gox, never put money on Quadriga or or even Bitfinex or any of those other ones that got hacked.

96
00:34:57.240 --> 00:35:17.280
So yeah, I dodged all all the all the major bullets. I mean, really cold storage is beautiful. Yeah, so I mean you were you weren't interested in trying to trade for these emerging shit coins like Litecoin and I never I've never understood. I've never understood the day trading mentality. Yeah. It's maybe I just didn't have enough time on my hands.

97
00:35:17.280 --> 00:35:36.560
Yeah. Right. I mean, it does it does take an insane amount of time. It's 24-7 global market. Like you just can't stay on top of it. And totally totally illiquid markets, too. You know. Yeah. I'd never call people trade, but there's people out there that are compulsive gambling addicts, so it's yeah, same thing.

98
00:35:36.560 --> 00:36:05.280
It is hard, you know, to look at well. I remember you know, I came in in early 2017, so I was watching the camp the absolute mania, you know, and you know, people like all the Ethereum heads like you know, bragging about their like you know, gajillion X gains from the from buying into you know the early whatever the pre-sale the Ethereum presale and everything and yeah as well as still started yeah in 2015 I think.

99
00:36:05.280 --> 00:36:28.160
Yeah, right. So that was kind of the first big, you know, gain, Bitcoin gain if you're you know using BTC as your unit of account when you're trading this stuff. And so yeah, I mean I bought in to you know the next Ethereums like like Cardano, which I swear is like just an insane marketing machine like a Cardano and EOS and those and the like, you know.

100
00:36:28.560 --> 00:36:48.880
They're beautiful websites, you know, like credential, you know, advisors and people working on the projects, and they just raise so much money, and all they do now is is travel the world and release you know announcements and road maps and hardly anything ever gets done of any consequence.

101
00:36:48.880 --> 00:37:07.800
Yeah. And people are still just waiting. Like now you see them on ready on crypto crypto Twitter. Some of these things are up 300% against Bitcoin this year. Which, and w which if you look at the, you know, you zoom out and you look, that's they're still 90 plus percent down against Bitcoin. You know, I mean, look at Ripple, dude.

102
00:37:07.800 --> 00:37:29.080
Ripple was founded, I think, in 2013. Yeah. Literally, they have it's just been a series of them announcing banking partnership after banking partnership after banking partnership. You know, Yadia Yada Bank of Malaysia is adopting is adopt is signing well. What they do is they do this real clever trick where they this company is signing a contract with Ripple Labs.

103
00:37:29.080 --> 00:37:48.600
And so they they publicly announce it, the price of XRP pumps, which they're not adopting XRP, they're just doing some arrangement with Ripple Labs. And then obviously Ripple Labs is continually selling XRP from their stash. I mean it's it's such an obvious marketing ploy.

104
00:37:48.600 --> 00:38:07.880
Yeah, we're and so every year, every month or so you'll hear about a new partnership. And there's a guy who's I don't necessarily recommend his reading, so he's anti-BTC also. But there's someone on Twitter called Trolly McTrollface. He has a website where he's gone into Ripple's marketing

105
00:38:10.600 --> 00:38:39.160
On, and he's like he's gone through all their old partnerships, and then like if you go and call or you follow up these partnerships that were signed, you know, several months or years ago, almost all of them fizzled out. Right, exactly. And a lot of these partnerships are just like an agreement to a very small agreement to like test using Ripple as an international payment rail with like a million dollars or some tiny drop in the bucket, right?

106
00:38:39.160 --> 00:38:58.560
Yeah, and so they're perform they're performing like a month-long test where they're gonna send some send some money back and forth over over Ripple, and then it's just like, oh, okay, this is not that great. Okay, bye-bye. You know, so even though he hates Bitcoin too, I do think his blog's worth reading. It's TR0LY.com.

107
00:38:58.560 --> 00:39:16.880
Trolly McTroll face blog. And he's got he's got post after post just dissecting Ripple. And here's one it's Ripple only had one real client in 2017. Ripple's Little Secret, X Rapid, which is one of their products, uses Swift.

108
00:39:16.880 --> 00:39:36.000
Yeah. Ripple Net isn't a network and never will be, building a fraud case, Ripple's public relations tricks, ripple's circular business model. So it's like Ripple sells XRP, Ripple pays another company to become a partner, ripple pays new partner to tell everyone it's using Ripple, right?

109
00:39:36.000 --> 00:39:56.880
So that's why you see all the Twitter posts and the blog posting. Such and such bank, it's always some bank, it's never like Bank of America, it's always like some bank you've never heard of in like a foreign country, yeah. You know, like you know, Yad Yada Bank and Indonesia, right? And then the XRP goes up on the news as investors pile onto the coin and then they dump it.

110
00:39:56.880 --> 00:40:15.520
And that's a that's that's very similar to I mean EOS. EOS, I guess, kind of copied the Ethereum model. Now it's happening on DeFi. You know, just these singles. Well, DeFi is an attempt to repump Ethereum. Yeah, it is in my opinion.

111
00:40:16.160 --> 00:40:54.280
It is. It's yeah, it's just another the next iteration of you know Ethereum's purpose in the world. And then of course EOS's creator was was what's the name Jed was it Jed McCaleb no no just so Jed McCaleb was so Jed McCaleb has his own history EOS was Daniel Larimer who first did BitShares and then he left BitShares and that's obviously like trend to zero to start Steemit which was the social media blockchain company and then he left that to do EOS

112
00:40:54.360 --> 00:41:14.760
I guess EOS is the most successful one right now because it's still multi-billion dollars and market capitalization. Yep yep maybe like final stop I mean just ride that for so many years decades if you wanted to yeah no he he's he's made out like a bandit he's probably in my sense the him and Jed McCaleb are the two most successful scammers.

113
00:41:14.760 --> 00:41:40.520
McCaleb started Mountgox right and there's basically I don't want to say evidence but there's a well actually yeah evidence there's evidence that he handed over to Mark Carpellas already in the red he gave it to Mark Carpellos for free. Yeah but it was already who hands a company off for free if it's worth something he was trying to get out before the before the thing blew up.

114
00:41:40.520 --> 00:42:00.720
The Bonzi scheme was up yeah so Mark Rapelos is you know he he's not exactly the brightest guy but I don't think his heart was in the wrong place. And he came in and realized pretty soon that there's a lot of money missing and then and then things just slowly got worse until it blew up yeah so then Jay McCaleb went and started Ripple.

115
00:42:00.720 --> 00:42:21.520
Yep. Which he 20 billion dollars. 20 billion dollars worth of tokens, example tokens as of and then and then he got out of that, and now he's on Stellar. So both these guys have shown an ab amazing ability to just pivot from one project to the next. And they'll always get out of the last one before the last one blows up.

116
00:42:21.520 --> 00:42:50.880
Yeah. Right. Yep. So they start something new. So those guys are two very experienced scammers. Charles Hoskinson, the Cardano guy was a part of the Ethereum founding team. And apparently now he's mad that when people on interviews when they book him for interviews, they refer to him as Ethereum co-founder and not Cardano co-founder because they're you know the journals is plumbing his old scam, not his new scam.

117
00:42:50.880 --> 00:43:17.040
He's like, Yeah, please, please mention Cardano. He had a little rant on Twitter the other day. He and he just portrays you know this this jet-setting lifestyle and makes himself you know, styles himself as this sort of you know renaissance man who is you know on on par with you know the greatest minds of the Renaissance era.

118
00:43:17.040 --> 00:43:53.360
He names his projects after these people. And the ADA itself is named after Ada Lovelace, you know, like one of the greatest, you know, original programmers. Okay. Back in the days. She she worked with Babbage, Charles Babbage in England, and you know, as a woman didn't get the recognition she deserved until you know quite recently, but she was writing code for an imaginary machine that Charles Babbage had written out in on paper, and was you know, using logic to write you know if-then statements and loops, etc.

119
00:43:53.680 --> 00:44:31.720
That would that would accomplish you know actual code without having the benefit of executing it and seeing errors et cetera and yeah so absolutely when was this like what year with like error with like 18 let's see Babbage this is a long time ago oh wow so that's like even before the any kind of computers existed she was writing code yeah she was writing code this was Babbage lived until October 1871 so it was sometimes probably you know sometime in the 1850s to this 1870s he created he was you know Babbage created the first mechanical computer

120
00:44:31.720 --> 00:45:06.600
That eventually led to more complex electronic designs it's called Babbage's analytical analytical engine and he and Ada Lovelace worked closely with him writing code and her you know her cur her code that's written out in in logic form essentially is still persists and has been replicated in sort of virtual environments it's pretty pretty pretty awesome stuff amazing man I feel so I feel terrible for the people that make these amazing contributions and they never get to live to see the outcome of what they developed.

121
00:45:06.600 --> 00:45:29.720
Right? Yeah it's just absolutely looking ahead toward the future and you know I it would be amazing for her to have you know somehow time traveled to this time to see what she she began yeah I mean maybe in some sense we are living the same thing where we're building something that will produce dividends after our lifetime.

122
00:45:29.720 --> 00:46:07.600
Yeah, absolutely. I have I have absolutely no doubt that we are we are in the midst of the beginning, you know, the 18 you know the 1850s, 70s, 90s of this Bitcoin era. It's the very beginning, and we have no idea what kind of world it will build, but we have this sort of inkling that it will be something fantastic and you know it really just draws our attention and because of that conviction you know just drives this insatiable inspiration to work on this as much as possible.

123
00:46:07.600 --> 00:46:27.760
And in that sense, Bitcoin sort of you know inspires and incentivizes the people that it needs, the minds that it needs to move it forward and make it better and adopt. So I'm a little selfish. I would I would like to see some of these things in my lifetime, you know.

124
00:46:29.040 --> 00:46:57.760
I agree, and then you know, the benefit that we have you know, that the early comp you know computer leaders and pioneers did not have is that we've had you know 50 years of the of Moore's Law and we're benefiting from insane network effects, you know, as you know, the network effects of the internet itself and the networks effects of money combining to create something that can I think move far faster than any of us could anticipate.

125
00:46:57.760 --> 00:47:17.760
So I do we also have some benefits. Obviously, information moves at light speed now. Yes. Anything that is known on one side of the globe can instantly instantly be you know, realized the other side. We can communicate over the internet. Yeah. Also I think that we're also entering an era where there's less war.

126
00:47:17.760 --> 00:47:56.200
It doesn't feel like it, but the wars are smaller than they once were. And there was more isolated and concentrated. Yeah. I mean, I don't know. Forgive me if if somebody's listening to this in 20 years and World War III has happened, but there is some benefit to yeah, having less, you know, small wars and I think it's also because the images of war can be transmitted a little easier that that I guess maybe there's some like pushback against like I don't think I don't think you can have a Holocaust in this day and age because well, yeah, I mean China's trying to just I

127
00:47:56.200 --> 00:48:18.760
I take my words back already. I don't still with the Uyghur people. Yeah, and we have this information, but you know, it's like what can we do because China is such a you know global power on par with the United States, arguably at this point. Well, the Holocaust Holocaust was I mean I don't think most Americans knew it was happening until after World War II ended, right?

128
00:48:18.760 --> 00:48:38.040
Exactly, yeah. Like, do you have you seen Banded Brothers? Yes, yeah, right. Remember that episode towards the end where they stumble across the Auschwitz or something and they're like, what the hell is this? Yeah. They didn't realize it was happening the whole time. So right now we can we can transmit information rapidly across the globe. I think free trade is a great thing.

129
00:48:38.040 --> 00:48:58.680
Unfortunately we've had a little bit of a turn away from it under the current administration, but I think the ability to produce goods in one part of the globe and sell another allows for a lot more global integration. And there was an economist, I think it was Bastiat, but it might have been somebody else who wrote that when goods don't cross borders, armies surely will.

130
00:48:59.000 --> 00:49:19.360
So what he was saying is that yeah, when we have free trade, you're less likely to engage in a in a in a conflict with somebody that you're engaged in trade with. So that's contributed somewhat. And I and I think Bitcoin certainly you know moves the needle in that direction being a non-sovereign global currency.

131
00:49:19.840 --> 00:49:40.320
Kind of rem removes the nation states you know aspects of a money. You know, the global reserve currencies that we've had over the past five or six hundred years have been attached to nation states in various forms of gold standards and fiats, fiat money standards.

132
00:49:40.320 --> 00:50:00.800
But yeah, you know remove the political implications of you know having the reserve currency as your native currency. Obviously, the United States benefits tremendously from you know, in terms of you know global and international control by being the global standard, the global reserve currency.

133
00:50:00.800 --> 00:50:23.920
So you could argue that a lot of our intervention in the Middle East has been an impetus to keep the oil trade on a dollar standard. Right. Yeah. Yep. So you know, because I guess if if oil is sold in dollars, that keeps the dollar value high and allows us to kind of maintain our global reserve status.

134
00:50:23.920 --> 00:50:44.160
Yeah. And we're at a point now where there's so much debt, global debt denominated in US dollars, that the you know, despite the fact that we're printing a bunch of money, there'll actually be a deflationary effect for a while as all of this, you know, debt and this dollar debt gets unwound around around the globe.

135
00:50:44.160 --> 00:51:05.320
There'll be demand for dollars to try to settle those debts as as best as possible. And once, you know, once that unwinding happens, then it you know, then it's that demand starts to dry up and then you know inflation you know kind of happens in earnest. So it's going to be a sight to see.

136
00:51:05.320 --> 00:51:37.560
It's gonna be so crazy to see what happens. I mean I don't assume maybe sometimes the next few years if maybe if stock to flow is true or even if it isn't if the next bull run and Bitcoin happens next few years it's really interesting to see how people react. Like you know we all know that typical happens all your friends you told about and they ignored it they all start texting you right and they say oh hey hey so still got any of that Bitcoin right yeah yeah yeah the one trillion dollar market cap happens at about $55,000 per coin.

137
00:51:38.040 --> 00:52:16.040
That's a big round number that you know puts Bitcoin in a new league right I mean I remember when we passed the billion dollar market cap or I'm sorry the hundred billion dollar market cap and that was a big deal during the 2017 run because there are a lot of institutions that have a minimum you know asset market cap before they can consider putting money you know into you know portion of their portfolio into an asset and so that was kind of a big deal but then you cross the trillion dollar market cap and you know then it's like okay this is a serious global player as an asset and then you know it's just

138
00:52:16.360 --> 00:52:54.880
200 some thousand dollars per coin and you're challenging gold's market cap and then you know it's just what what do you do at that point? I mean you can absolutely as a as a nation state as a massive you know, fund of any kind that's is managing money for let's say like you know 401ks or massive unions or or universities you absolutely must you know fiduciary responsibility to have some exposure to that asset so yeah you know also from a psychological perspective your average person I

139
00:52:54.880 --> 00:53:32.960
Guess okay that isn't into Bitcoin they are aware there was some crypto boom in 2017 maybe they didn't pay a lot of attention to it I'm guessing a lot of them don't remember the 2013 boom at all so they're where there was something happened in 2017 where crypto's price went up a lot I say crypto because they don't really know the detail behind it they know Bitcoin is the most prominent one but there's more than one but if they hear it again and this happens again yeah like psychologically how does a person ignore that right yeah there's pr there's friends I've been telling to buy Bitcoin for seven years now and they still haven't

140
00:53:32.960 --> 00:53:54.400
Gotten in and so they've seen a couple bull runs now I don't know how they deny it another time. Exactly yeah third time it's just like you okay I was wrong you know this is this is real and I should take a serious look at it. There's also a thing where like if I if I tell somebody to buy Bitcoin multiple times it's the okay well he's a kook so don't listen to him.

141
00:53:54.400 --> 00:54:13.120
But if they hear about on the news and then they hear it from somebody else and after you know a few points of contact it it that's people are social creatures and they kind of go with what the crowd does. Right. So if you hear from multiple angles that's when I guess the light bulb goes off hey I gotta get into this thing.

142
00:54:13.120 --> 00:54:33.240
Yep. Yeah and I think selling Bitcoin, I mean selling Bitcoin is this is you know, as as Cory Klippsten, our founder at Swan says, this is the greatest, you know, consumer asset in the history of the world. At least I mean it's certainly the greatest consumer asset on the internet in the history of the internet.

143
00:54:33.240 --> 00:54:56.920
You know, and so being in a position to sell it is is is fantastic. I think it's a great it's a great business model. It already is you know, because we actually have a decent number of hodlers now, versus like you know, the last kind of bear cycle when it was like 2015, the drags are getting 300, you know, 300s down there.

144
00:54:56.920 --> 00:55:15.080
Oh, it went lower in in October of 2015. I remember it dipped under 200. So this was when in 20 January 2014, right? It hit a peak of like 1200. Yeah, that was the peak of that bull run. And in the next year and a half was just brutal. Yeah, it split slowly down.

145
00:55:15.080 --> 00:55:45.240
And I mean, I still remember, yeah, it bottomed out on a little under 200 in October 2015, and then it kind of started picking up back from there. I mean, the number of hodlers of last resort with faith that this was gonna, you know, go through another run at that point was minuscule. And now, you know, we've we've got a crew, a lot pretty large crew of people who are selling it, marketing it, you know, on ramps that are focused on Bitcoin only and you know, aren't so much content.

146
00:55:45.240 --> 00:56:03.880
I mean so much. So I know I was telling you this earlier, but like back in 20 before the current batch of podcasts, so before your podcast, Stephon Rivera, TFTC, etc. Etc. There was there was in 2013, 14, 15, 16, there was almost nothing.

147
00:56:03.880 --> 00:56:42.160
There was let's talk bitcoin with Andreas, and you can't really rely on that because Andreas and his other two co-hosts would chill other stuff then. It was really just bitcoin uncensored which was chris rose yeah christeros and juncts yeah and johnsith yeah i mean they and i mean they're they were not coming from an austrian sound money angle at all yeah but i mean the i mean i don't know if you ever listened to they have archives their podcast up somewhere it's it's actually pretty fun to listen to but yeah i agree i've been quite a few and they were they were hilarious dudes it was like the howard stern of bitcoin you could say like they

148
00:56:42.160 --> 00:57:20.160
Were interviewing prostitutes and drug dealers yeah because their their thesis was that bitcoin is for censorship resistance right and so the people that benefit from the most are people that can't use the modern banking system so that'd be people in sex industry drug industry what else some things that the government try to crack down on general yeah it was a very reverent show yeah i mean if you're if you're listening and you're relatively relatively new 2017 2018 class maybe even 2019 or whatever check out christa rose and junsith and bitcoin

149
00:57:20.160 --> 00:57:58.480
Uncensored and just have a little like have a little fun going back and listening to that stuff it's oh yeah that show is a great marker fist at the time i actually met them probably a year before they started the podcast yeah because i was living in miami at the time and they were they were running the miami bitcoin meetups so i met them like 2014 mid 2014 and then they started the podcast like a year later but yeah, they would they're they would they kind of went that that sort of underground economy black market route yeah but also they had the other thing they were doing was debunking the private blockchain narrative which was very

150
00:57:58.480 --> 00:58:21.080
Strong back then so I mean these companies have all faded out but there used to be R3 Sev do it was a private blockchain company that basically created a consortium of all these banks and so they had like Goldman Sachs and Bank of America and Wacovia, they're all part of this consortium that R37 has been together to create a private blockchain that were they would use to settle transactions.

151
00:58:21.080 --> 00:58:43.320
That was the dominant narrative at the time. There was also digital asset holdings, so this was a startup created by who or whose CEO was Blythe Masters. She was she's ex-JP Morgan, and I think she was very prominent in like the subprime business in the early 2000s, and then she left J.D.

152
00:58:43.400 --> 00:59:02.600
Morgan to start this company, which is a private blockchain company. I haven't even heard from them in years, it's probably fizzled out. Then, oh, there was an episode of Bitcoin Censored where they interviewed this. This is probably one of their more most well-known episodes. Everybody should listen to it. They interviewed this girl named Perry Ann Boring.

153
00:59:02.600 --> 00:59:26.280
She is the CEO of something at the Blockchain Council, which is a lobby group on in Washington, DC for the blockchain Bitcoin industry, and they have her on, and it's clue she has no clue what a blockchain. It's it's apparent that she has no clue what a blockchain is. Like she's arguing, they they get her on the record saying that Swift and ACH are blockchains.

154
00:59:26.280 --> 00:59:55.040
So at that point, like back in 2014, 1516, like the term blockchain was just totally being muddled. I'm talking separate from, I mean, all coins are one thing, especially if they're proof of work-based. They exist, and I mean, there's arguments against them, but they are blockchains. But there was a pro the whole private blockchain concept where there was it was going to be completely centralized, run by a company, but there was going to be some amorphous benefit, which I have no clue what distinguishes it from a database.

155
00:59:55.040 --> 01:00:23.920
But that was a prominent narrative that's thankfully died out. And you don't really hear it anymore. So really now it's just Bitcoin versus altcoins. Yeah. I mean hopefully proof of stake will someday die out. I don't know if they're Ethereum will just stop talking about that someday. Yeah it was you know it was like an the next sort of Ethereum thing before DeFi right was the well they said it from the beginning from the very beginning they said proof of wake work is wasteful it's environmentally damaging.

156
01:00:23.920 --> 01:00:45.120
Yeah so we're gonna do this proof of stake scheme. And I mean that you know is Vlad Zam fear is he's one of the Vlad yeah he's he supposedly had conjured up the idea of it and I mean for years now they've said it's just around the corner just around the corner just around the corner. Yeah and now their ETH 2.0 is is supposed to happen soon it's it's it's literally just a series of shifting narratives.

157
01:00:45.280 --> 01:01:23.280
Sharding and which is just a hilarious name they're gonna shard everything out. And then you know the ICOs so I mean these are all the different narratives of Ethereum world computer ICOs internet 3.0 if you go on there yeah yeah if you go on the Ethereum foundation's YouTube one of their very first videos marketing Bitcoin or marketing Ethereum is is that Ethereum is is the internet 3.0 and if I'm I'm I'm actually on their their their YouTube page

158
01:01:23.280 --> 01:01:41.640
Right now. It's it's so ridiculously like overhyped like it makes it seem as though Ethereum is just gonna do everything. Yeah like it's it's it's a they the they a world computer was was the term it was gonna do everything for you. Right. Yeah. It was gonna handle payments, it was gonna process all your data. You didn't do anything you just turn it on or something. I don't know.

159
01:01:41.640 --> 01:02:03.400
Yeah it was gonna be it was going to be place or run on top of TCP IP and make everything better for whatever reason because every single piece of data would be archived on the Ethereum blockchain and there for you know just everyone to access at any at any given time and yeah it's good skill no problem.

160
01:02:03.400 --> 01:02:27.560
You know blockchains are not for running an inner entire internet upon it's not an internet database of a database for the entire internet no that does not work. You know it's like it's useful for money and you know maybe some other curious collectibles if you want to have your own blockchain for that but digital scarcity and that's about it.

161
01:02:27.720 --> 01:02:48.360
That's about it. I mean I think we're always gonna be facing this kind of issue where it's very cheap to make a blockchain right all you have to do is fork an existing one and then you can include your little pre-mine and then and then it's really your only expenses are marketing. Yeah. So I mean people have to get burned and so I'm I'm not optimistic in the near term that all coins are going to die out.

162
01:02:48.360 --> 01:03:23.280
Like some people seem to think that the next bull run is going to be Bitcoin only but I'm I think that the people have to understand that the things that we know very few people outside of us in our circle knows. Exactly. So you gotta imagine the your grandma or someone like that getting in and then they're getting all these marketing flyers and yeah and I mean I mean I do hope that we siphon off and save a larger percentage of new coiners then were then were you know siphoned off and saved as Bitcoin only relatively quickly in the last run.

163
01:03:23.600 --> 01:03:44.480
But yeah I mean you know these these altcoins they their only purpose is to you know for traders to pump and dump and make more Bitcoin. That's it. Yeah that's what they do. And you know there's gonna be plenty of people who fall prey to this marketing and it's good. I'll granite their marketing efforts aren't good and then that's where they work.

164
01:03:44.480 --> 01:04:05.680
And they're gonna bring a bunch of people in to their little cultish marketing practices and they're going to pump up the price versus BTC and they're going to dump on them. And you know that's it. I mean that's the way it's gonna work. It's gonna happen. You can't you know it's hard to say I mean there's something about maybe it's just human nature that we're attracted to the idea of getting rich quick.

165
01:04:05.680 --> 01:04:39.520
Yeah no yeah for sure for sure it's you know I even I was talking I was talking you know one of our internal team like just kind of chats today and we were saying yeah you know Cardano and a couple others are up you know three or four hundred percent against Bitcoin in the past few months and then we looked at the you know zoomed out link to the full chart and it's still 90% down versus Bitcoin but but you know you look at that 30 you know 300 400% pump and you're like eh you know I wouldn't mind like like you know tripling my Bitcoin that would be nice.

166
01:04:39.520 --> 01:05:01.480
You know and it's everybody's susceptible to it you know yeah I mean you can't that thought that cannot escape your head it's it's got to be there. And so it's just hard to resist those things because the you know, eventually you can't, it might maybe you get lucky that one time, but you try it again and again and you get wrecked. And you want to put in, you're like, okay, I'm only gonna put in 10% of my stack.

167
01:05:01.480 --> 01:05:22.280
Just you know, just to gamble a little bit, it works. All right, I'm gonna put in half my stack and I'm gonna just I'm really gonna nail it. I'm gonna be a whale, you know. I'm gonna I'm going for 21 Bitcoin, I'm going for a hundred Bitcoin wrecked. You know, you get leverage on it. It's just it's just the same old story. I think people have to understand that trading is like poker.

168
01:05:22.280 --> 01:05:41.080
Exactly for every winner, there's a loser, but it's not as a whole, it's not actually a productive thing. Right. Yep, absolutely. And the winners tend to be like one or two percent. Because training does have a role in terms of price discovery, so it's good to have trading and markets. Liquidity, liquidity is there, and so that there's good that's good.

169
01:05:41.080 --> 01:06:04.280
But for every winner, there's a loser, and the winners are people who they're gonna they're better than you. I mean, this it's as simple. Like if I go to Vegas, every time I go to Vegas, I lose money because I'm sitting at a table with people that are better than me. And when you're trading, there's people out there that are better than you, and you might get lucky here and there, but chances are you're going to lose your money.

170
01:06:04.280 --> 01:06:23.880
Yeah, now the all the argument against is some people say, Well, the crypto economy is up, so I've made my trading. But the reality is you would have made money even if you held. Right. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Everybody, everybody did great. Everybody was a awesome trader and amazing in 2017. Just fucking everyone killed it.

171
01:06:23.880 --> 01:06:55.840
We're all awesome. Everybody's a genius in a bull market. Yeah. And then and then the tax bill comes and you're like, oh, and then you have to sell off that Bitcoin profits, and you know, yeah, it's just and people, you know, the average noob doesn't even think about that kind of stuff, doesn't take them into account. They don't understand, you know, how to you know set you know set limits, sell limits and protect and hedge, and you know, they're just setting market orders and hoping that they get hit, and you know, just it's just it's it's a whole game.

172
01:06:55.840 --> 01:07:22.800
If you if you sit down at the table and in the first five minutes you don't spot the sucker, you are the sucker. So I mean it's just sitting down with a bunch of sharks and just don't do it. Just don't do it. Yeah, people just want to get rich. I mean, I when I was a kid, you know, you'd have these little magazines, and in the back there'd be ads for like, oh, send 50 bucks his address to PO box, and we'll send you like something that will teach you how to get rich quick.

173
01:07:22.800 --> 01:07:54.320
Right. Yeah. I fell for once or twice, and then you learn. Yeah, you learn by you know putting your hand on the stove and burning yourself. It's like the twit the Twitter hacker last week, man. This guy, this guy gets access to you know, a dozen of the most powerful accounts on the prop the world's most consequential you know social network, and you know, just decides to throw up some shitty little, you know, you send me a thousand dollars of Bitcoin, I'll send you back two thousand dollars of Bitcoin scam.

174
01:07:54.320 --> 01:08:14.960
Uh-huh. You know, for it. That's an old scam. It's still people fell for it, yeah. And it's yeah, I mean it's just the simplest scam possible. Yeah, so how much did he get in that address? I think it ended up being like 180k. Oh wow. That some people theorize though that he was maybe sending himself money just to pump up the number or something, right?

175
01:08:14.960 --> 01:08:40.520
I think that's I think that's kind of common practice when when scammers run that sort of a scam. They they you know kind of seed the wallet with a certain number of Bitcoin to make it look like if people are actually doing it. But yeah, I mean it's just kind of it was kind of amateur hour so I think the people who you know people or person who pulled that off was just like shocked that they did and didn't know what to do.

176
01:08:40.920 --> 01:08:44.840
Yeah it's it it's incredible. Fiat money has made people so stupid

177
01:08:47.560 --> 01:09:13.720
That's what it does. Fiat ultimately it it it encourages stupidity. Yeah yeah that and socialism but you know Bitcoin I mean it's so precious like there's only so much you feel like you have to you become like miserly like like Ebony's or Scrooge like you don't want to let up enough SAT so you so you become much more skeptical about all the things that are you know thrown your way all the quote unquote opportunities.

178
01:09:14.040 --> 01:09:52.200
Yeah you know you're everyone's gonna have a time preference but you think very carefully about what's in need versus nice to have and yeah and so it it creates a incentivizes an economy where you know it's governed by collective economic self-interest and that only works if your economic self-interest in regards to your money actually incentivizes you to hold it and think carefully about how you spend it if your money if your money incentivizes you to spend it on whatever the hell you can that actually has some hard value some

179
01:09:52.520 --> 01:10:10.680
Some like actual natural scarcity to it then you're just you're just gonna you're just gonna spend and debt becomes the with money. I mean, yeah. I mean, I think Pierre Pierre Richard has talked a lot about this and some others, but but it's it we basically turn into economy of degenerate gamblers because we can't just hold money.

180
01:10:10.680 --> 01:10:28.880
So everyone's spending their money in stocks, real estate, everyone's searching for the newest thing. I had you know, I work in I'm currently in medicine, I'm a family medicine resident. And one of my old surgery tenies, I told him like a year ago about Bitcoin. So he's a surgeon, so he obviously has a free income.

181
01:10:28.880 --> 01:10:49.200
And so I saw him again this like about a few weeks ago, a year later, and I said, Hey, did you ever like take me up on that on that advice? And he's like, No, you know, I put my money in this in this like startup, and yeah, you can see like the look on his face, and it's like he's like you can see like he's already like down or something, you know.

182
01:10:49.200 --> 01:11:07.360
It's just people not encouraged exactly. He yeah, people are always trying to find the next big thing because you can't hold on to your money. You can't hold on to your cash, can't rely on it. So yeah, I mean you're so this was the doctor, right? Yep, yeah, yeah, he's a general surgeon. Right. So okay.

183
01:11:07.360 --> 01:11:28.560
So here's a great example, right? He's a general surgeon, but he's and he's get he's making money and he gets paid, and he sees that his money is losing value by two percent or more because that's just kind of the re the reported target percentage. But we actually know through like shadow stats and other services, like the inflation rate isn't is actually higher than that over, especially over the past few years.

184
01:11:28.560 --> 01:11:53.760
So your money is losing value as it's just sitting there in cash. So you're like, okay, I am a smart individual and I'm earning this money with hard work, so I'm going to find a way to actually increase the value of that money over time and generate wealth. Okay, so now I need to become you know, either find, I have to research and find somebody I actually trust to with with my money to you know increase this wealth.

185
01:11:53.760 --> 01:12:22.840
But most likely, if I'm a smart individual like that, I don't want to trust somebody with my money. So I'm gonna learn it myself. And I remember as a kid, my stepdad was a nephrologist, he was a doctor. And he spent hours and hours and hours watching cable TV about finances and reading books and like developing his own models and just you know trying to you know turn his a nephrologist, like right, yes, hours and hours and hours, exactly.

186
01:12:22.840 --> 01:12:41.400
And that then that had to happen because money was unnatural money that was being artificially controlled, arbitrarily controlled by a few people to benefit the you know, natural treasury and the 21 banks that are closest to the Federal Reserve. Like that's it.

187
01:12:41.400 --> 01:13:02.120
And how well then that's we spread that across the entire economy. And we have had we have been robbed of a future that would have been incredible with the deflationary technologies that we have you know, at this point in time. We be we'd be living like Star Trek now. Yeah, essentially, like, you know, it's hard to explain this.

188
01:13:02.120 --> 01:13:24.360
I try to tell this to like people are socialists, but like if not for the last century of statism, so fiat money, warfare, the welfare state, you know, all the all the social pro social welfare programs have gone along with it. We would be so far ahead technologically, such that even the poorest person would be better off than the richest person today.

189
01:13:24.360 --> 01:13:43.800
So a good example is I tell people I like to say that even the poorest person I today is better off than John D. Rockefeller. John D. Rockefeller is the wealthiest person in human history. He owned at his peak, like his personal net worth was one to two percent of all the money in America. Even Jeff Bezos today isn't at that wealthy.

190
01:13:43.800 --> 01:14:03.520
He's wealthier probably more in in in nominal terms, but not in real inflation adjusted terms. Right. But John D. Rockefeller did not have pretty much the poorest people on earth live better than Johnny Rockefeller. He didn't have TV. I'm not sure if he had radio. Radio might have been towards the end of his life.

191
01:14:04.080 --> 01:14:24.400
Probably probably had a telegraph. Yeah. Didn't have internet, computers, smartphones, none of that stuff. He probably had a lot of servants. Maybe I don't know if they had refrigeration was common in his time. He he lived from late 1800s to very early 1900s. But I mean, pretty much the average, even poor person was better than say.

192
01:14:24.400 --> 01:14:45.040
I mean, maybe not a homeless person, but even in medicine, I mean, I'll tell you what, if a homeless person walks into an emergency room right now and they're having a heart attack, there's no question of costs. They're taken to the cath lab to have a stent put in their heart. But in 195, the sitting president of the United States, Dwight D.

193
01:14:45.040 --> 01:15:11.280
Eisenhower had a heart attack. You know what they gave him? Aspirin. That's it. That was his treatment. That was a cutting edge treatment in 1955. Yeah. So the living standards have increased over this time, but they have they would have increased so much faster. Right. It's really about increasing the rate of economic growth such that even the poor people in the future are better than off than the rich people today.

194
01:15:11.280 --> 01:15:37.240
We need to focus on growing the pie as opposed to cutting up the pie into different slices. Yeah. That's the problem with socialists, is they're so obsessed with with cutting the pie in a different way that they're that they're actually shrinking the pie. Yeah. I mean, this is, and we think of like you know monetary policy and financial responsibility and these ideas of like managing debt and stuff like that.

195
01:15:37.320 --> 01:16:03.080
We think of these as sort of conservative political ideas. At least you know they were a couple decades ago or something. But you know, even Nixon when he took this took us off the gold standard and Milton Friedman, you know, five or six years before that coined the phrase phrase, you know, we're all Keynesians now, that you know at that point the monetary policy differences between the parties really just kind of ended.

196
01:16:03.080 --> 01:16:37.000
You know, like you know Ron Paul kind of made a push and for auditing the Fed and you know Clinton w made a made a deal about reducing the deficit and balancing the budget and all that stuff. But lip service to that stuff. But we are we're completely you know beyond that now through the looking glass to completely embracing you know like target targeted inflation and absolutely just like word for word admitted by representatives of the Federal Reserve that the you know we have infinite cash we will do whatever it takes.

197
01:16:37.480 --> 01:16:58.280
So yeah I mean we've we have monetary socialism now as as as policy. And there's no growth of government as far as as long as money is infinite then then no way stopping socialism because they can spread more. Right. UBI becomes a thing and you know obviously like free com you know national free healthcare will become the next thing.

198
01:16:58.280 --> 01:17:18.320
It's just you know that will last. That will work and it'll be obviously politically popular. I wouldn't be surprised if we got another airdrop of Trump bucks, you know, in the next in the next few months. You want to maybe you want to do it a little bit closer to the election day, you know, so it's fresh in people's minds. But that's literally bribing people for votes.

199
01:17:18.320 --> 01:17:50.080
And it'll work. You know, until it doesn't. And the inevitable end of any fiat money, as we know, taught by history is hyperinflation. And that that will happen. And now we have this non sovereign alternative to you know, whatever sort of Frankenstein's monster of money they try to come up with to the you know the nation states try to come up with and agree upon in like a Bretton Woods 2024, 25.

200
01:17:50.080 --> 01:18:10.160
You know, so it'll be some kind of bank or like you know, maybe it'll include some gold and other assets. And they'll try. They'll try to create some new global reserve asset. But we'll have Bitcoin and where will the trust be right? Money is about trust. Where will the trust be? Will it be with these governments coming together to rescue the rest of the world?

201
01:18:10.160 --> 01:18:28.960
Or is it going to be in this non sovereign, very stable, you know, very trustworthy protocol for money on the internet, that are that it's already preferred by, you know, the next generation to really come into power, the millennials.

202
01:18:28.960 --> 01:18:59.520
Yeah. We have an escape badge now. Yeah. Yeah, we have a way out. Yeah, exactly. But it's terrifying. I mean I mean there there's a lot of damage that can be done between now and then just 'cause as a dependency grows and I mean we're s kind of seeing this today with all the riots and protests, we're we're just seeing a generation of people that are totally disaffected where their their wage growth has been stunted and then so they're they're kind of washy on against the system, but they don't really know where to direct their anger.

203
01:18:59.520 --> 01:19:26.040
Yes. So they're sort of directing its businessmen as opposed to you know the central banks and the state that are sort of perpetuating this. I mean, Starbucks is not the reason why you're poor. Right. It's the Fed. Exactly. It's the Fed. Yeah. And you can be mad at Starbucks and you can be mad at the big banks because they are getting the you know, the lion's share of that money, or at least they're getting it at lower interest rates than you are.

204
01:19:26.040 --> 01:19:50.600
So they're just they're just taking that cut without doing absolutely anything. It's the ultimate middleman scam. Yeah. You know, but yeah, we've got to get, I mean, this is our chance. This is Bitcoiners' chance to really get out there. And we've been talking, you know, kind of internally and amongst other Bitcoiners, like you know, this idea of Bitcoin marketing that Dan Held is really pushing, but there's you know, pushback against that idea.

205
01:19:50.600 --> 01:20:16.520
I'm all for it. Like, I think that you know, Bitcoin, there is Bitcoin marketing such a thing. It's us out there promoting it collectively. I don't think there's a central marketing department or a CEO or a CMO or anything like that, obviously. But you know, us just getting out there and talking about why Bitcoin is important and better is I think a distributed organic marketing, a form of a form of distributed organic marketing.

206
01:20:16.520 --> 01:20:48.560
And we need to get people out there in the mainstream media more and more talking about these things, these fundamental, you know, fundamentally teach people about what money is. That's the most important thing. That's the tip of the rabbit hole is what money really is. And if you teach people that and teach people how money, you know, this unnatural money that we have now is robbing them of their time and productivity over, you know, insidiously over decades.

207
01:20:48.560 --> 01:21:14.320
And then we have this, you know, alternative option that will actually, you know, benefit you over those decades. Your your wealth will grow over time. Then you know, I think the case is made, and you gotta get some, and then the just the flywheels is going. So yeah, and you also mentioned that like fiat money allows large companies to borrow at lower interest rates.

208
01:21:14.320 --> 01:21:40.400
I mean, this this has a lot of that that that point alone has a lot of native consequences, like it allows Google and Apple and the other major tech companies to just buy up lots of startups. Yep. And I mean, a lot of times when they buy them up, they end up mismanaging them, but they can afford to do that because they have access to cheap credit. Right. Or I mean, another alternative which people may not realize is that you know, in a lot of, you know, when I was a kid, I was a really big comic book nerd and still in to some extent.

209
01:21:40.400 --> 01:22:08.240
But like one of the things that's happening lately in the comic book world is you know, Disney about 10 years ago bought Marvel, and since then the quality of the actual Marvel comics has gone downhill because they just hired a bunch of woke people to write all the comics. Right. Right. So I mean, just as an example, people people, if you're not really in that world, might not realize it, but like Iron Man, they've replaced him with a younger, like teenage African-American girls in New Iron Man.

210
01:22:08.240 --> 01:22:30.840
They've they've raised basically they've raced and gender swapped all the characters. It's kind of crazy. But they can only do that because Disney doesn't really, you know, they're a major corporation, they don't really need the revenue. Whereas Marvel was once upon a time a smaller company that had to rely on on readers to actually satisfy, you know, write good stories.

211
01:22:31.160 --> 01:22:56.280
You know, back when I was a kid, but you know, that era's gone. So it's it's it has all these manifestations in in areas that you can't even imagine. They say housing, you know, you build a house nowadays and it's built with like you know, crappy you know pieces like you know, the wood and all the floorboard and stuff, it's all made of low quality stuff because you know they're just trying to skip corners.

212
01:22:56.280 --> 01:23:19.320
Yep. Yeah, because I mean otherwise it's too expensive to buy. Yeah, there's shrinkflation, everything you buy. You know, if you get like a thing of ice cream from the store, yeah, it's smaller than what it was, you know, a few decades back. It everything is shrinkflation is what they call it. Yep, yep. Yeah. I mean, that makes sense too. And like I had a new house was built a couple blocks away from me by a good friend of mine, and I'm you know, really happy for him.

213
01:23:19.320 --> 01:23:38.200
He's getting into that game. He's he's you know, been a contractor in construction for a long time, and he's finally like, you know, heading the project and building his house and selling it. And it's essentially the same house that I live in, but my house is, you know, like what is it now, like 18 years old.

214
01:23:38.200 --> 01:23:58.440
You know, and this house that he built is their asking price is twice as much as mine. I mean, it's just you know, it's been 18 years, and I and I'm just like Flabbergas. I'm like, I can't believe that a house in this neighborhood is selling for that price. And then I mean, here's going back to what we were just talking about. The zombie firms, right?

215
01:23:58.440 --> 01:24:18.000
Like it allows Apple and these big companies to invest in companies that you know aren't necessarily worth investing in or worth keeping around. So there's this great graph that I got from WTF happened in 1971.com, and it's it's titled the US rising share of companies with debt servicing costs that are higher than profits.

216
01:24:18.000 --> 01:24:50.720
So these are these are termed zombie firms. All right. And so this is the percent of companies that fit this description in the United States. So we're talking like negligible zero to one per 1% through the 90s. Starts going up after the 2001 financial crisis, hits about 2% just before 2008, and just drastically start like goes parabolic essentially, up to almost 20% of companies in 2020 are have debt servicing costs that are higher than profits.

217
01:24:50.720 --> 01:25:13.280
And the only way that you can keep these firms alive is money printing. And you gotta have that money go somewhere, and so it gets invested in these shitty companies that should be left to die and be replaced, you know, in the ashes, rising from the ashes, companies that better serve the market in and in more efficient ways.

218
01:25:13.280 --> 01:25:41.200
But that that doesn't happen, you know. And people forget that when a company goes bankrupt, it's not like you know, all the assets die. The building is sold off and somebody else can use it, all of the capital equipment is sold off and somebody else can use it. So in essence, it gets reorganized. Now, there may be some unemployment, but that in essence in a free market at least balances it out because wages will adjust such that new job opportunities will become more feasible.

219
01:25:41.200 --> 01:26:00.920
Right. So basically the economy just restructures it from a poor investment in a bad company into more making other better quality investments more feasible. But you don't see that reorganization occurring because the old firm is kept propped up. Exactly. That reminds me of the Cash for Clunkers program.

220
01:26:00.920 --> 01:26:26.600
Do you remember that? That was under Obama. I do. Like yeah, he was buying people's he was using federal money to subsidize people to trade in their old car and then they would destroy it. And then they could you could use that cover to a new towards a new car. So what that does was because people were able to they were just basically getting rid of the old cars, it actually kept the price of used cars up artificially.

221
01:26:26.600 --> 01:26:44.920
So a lot of poor people who couldn't afford to buy a new car one way or another, they typically buy used cars, right? But they couldn't afford to because the supply was dried up. So it actually harmed poor people, but you never heard about that in the news because it was touted as a way it's essentially an auto industry bailout.

222
01:26:44.920 --> 01:27:16.920
But you it's it's a way of just preventing reorganization of capital. Yep. And the economy to more productive uses. Exactly. And we're seeing that everywhere it's getting worse. Yep. Yep. And the and the forest I mean you know the natural cycle there's there's these sort of forest fires that will you know burn down these these older companies and make available resources to be reincorporated into a new businesses that better serve the market more efficiently.

223
01:27:16.920 --> 01:27:38.200
But you keep all of that detritus around and you know when the fire finally does come it's going to be that much more extreme, you know and harder to recover from. So it's basically with the business cycle in Austrian theory now everything is going bankrupt at the same time, whereas with in sound money, companies go bankrupt at different times.

224
01:27:38.200 --> 01:28:16.400
So there isn't these sudden depressions and then followed by big booms and another depression. It's it's more steady. Yep, exactly. And I, you know, I hope that this is the future that we have to look forward to is you know, based on an economy based on natural money that will reward you know ingenuity and product market fit, customer service, and create a world where we have we have to spend a lot less time to procure the necessities of a quality human

225
01:28:16.400 --> 01:28:41.840
Life, and therefore we get to spend a lot more time on our passions and our you know the artisre artisanry that that we want to pursue and develop, and we'll see you know human ingenuity flourish and all kinds of you know arts, works of arts and wonder and technology that will take us to the stars and live that Star Trek life, man, that you were talking about at the beginning of our conversation, right?

226
01:28:41.840 --> 01:29:19.920
Oh, yeah, that'll be incredible. I mean, I think we'll you know we'll make huge advances in medicine, art, pretty much every field. Yeah, so much, it's just all the waste will just be squeezed out of the system. There's so much waste. I see it in my line of work where there's just a ton of waste, you know, and people know that the healthcare system is kind of it's it's it's sort of a bubble in some sense, where it's not it's not it's not built on consumer value, it's built on like checking boxes and just sort of delivering some service

227
01:29:20.160 --> 01:29:41.880
But not really solving the underlying problems, and unfortunately, it's kind of perpetuated itself over time. And we see in lots of industries outside of healthcare. I mean, education is just a giant bubble where we're, I mean, the student loan crisis is basically a manifestation of cheap credit being extended to students, right?

228
01:29:41.880 --> 01:30:10.760
Right. The government and it g provides guaranteed loans to the students, so we have to now the colleges respond by raising tuition because they know that you can borrow against the government no matter how high their tuition is, and then it creates a cycle where the government has to increase the loan amounts and then tuition rises, and then that's why the cost of college education has just risen exponentially over the last 50 years, and we have like I don't know, several trillion dollars in student loan debt.

229
01:30:10.760 --> 01:30:30.760
That's another bubble waiting to burst. Yeah, absolutely. The everything bubble waiting to burst. Yeah. And there's gonna be pain and suffering, and I feel for that. I have empathy and sympathy for everyone who's going to be suffering from what's to come.

230
01:30:30.760 --> 01:30:49.000
And I, you know, that's why we're out here, man, doing our thing to try to say, hey, there we have a safety hatch, you know, build one whatever size you can, or hop into somebody else's and just be ready. Hopefully that will help blunt the pain that you're about to experience.

231
01:30:49.000 --> 01:31:27.120
Gold bugs have been talking about this for decades, and it never seems to the big one, the big crack up boom never seems to come to fruition. But my God, I can't imagine that we're too too much further away from it at this point. All the writings on the wall, the signs are there. And I think just the presence of Bitcoin itself will will sort of hasten it along as as Bitcoin sort of siphons off that that easy shitty money and yeah one of the criticisms of Austrians one of the criticism of Austrians is that you know they predicted 10 out of the last five recessions

232
01:31:27.200 --> 01:32:05.360
Yeah right so that like you know Austrians forever have been predicting the breakup of the fiat money standard yep and to some extent that's true I mean you've been hearing for decades now guys like Ron Paul Tom Woods others before them that you know this is gonna collapse any day now and it hasn't but the reason why is because we haven't had a good alternative so the system could perpetuate itself because we couldn't escape it now we can escape it there's an escape hatch we have a way to get out and so there's there's you know we have a much better system evolving in front of us and hopefully that'll kind of push the system

233
01:32:05.360 --> 01:32:43.440
To collapse a little sooner because I don't want to go through this another 20 30 years. Yeah Bitcoin will siphon that's that off slowly but surely gradually then suddenly and that S curve of adoption that we see happen over and over and over for technologies will happen for this monetary technology and at that point it's it's game on Bitcoin is is here on the global stage and I you know I just don't see how fiat monies can compete even if even if governments try to you know reinstitute some kind of gold standard you know the trust has been broken

234
01:32:43.600 --> 01:33:14.200
There's a new kid on the block that works and has proven to work for decades, and but by that point, and you know, like I said, the generation coming up behind behind the boomers and the Gen Xers, the largest generation since the boomers, the millennials will or digital natives will you know have much more innate trust in a digitally native money than any generation that has come before.

235
01:33:14.200 --> 01:33:49.320
So yeah, I mean there will be that iPhone moment, you know, like I mean there were smartphones before the iPhone, the Blackberry, the most prominent of them, but there was that iPhone moment where everybody started piling into it, starting, I think that was 2007 when the iPhone debuted. And then pretty much now everybody has a smartphone. Yeah, it's kind of interesting to think like you know, when will that iPhone moment come for Bitcoin when everybody just sort of I mean it might not be a device like that that makes it easy, but it'll be just a spreading of the just the consciousness that people need to get into this thing before it's too late for them.

236
01:33:49.320 --> 01:34:15.080
And it could, you know, the I think I kind of agree with Bitcoin Tina. You've had him on the podcast before, right? Oh yeah. Yeah, yeah. He I mean he I think he makes a very good point that this could happen. Actually, I haven't had him on this podcast. I did only briefly in a 2019 Bitcoin sort of like episode where it had a bunch of people on, but he has been on Swan Signal Live just a you know a few weeks ago, so you'll find that there.

237
01:34:15.080 --> 01:34:42.760
Oh, you know what? Yeah, I think I have it saved in my queue, but I haven't listened to that one yet. Yeah. Yeah, he makes a point that this'll this will probably happen. This could happen very much faster than even the internet adoption because the internet there's no specific benefit. I mean, there there's benefits to adopting the internet earlier, right? But you know, you there's no financial reward for being getting into the internet and adopting email in 1994 as opposed to 1998.

238
01:34:42.760 --> 01:35:03.520
You didn't financially benefit. But Bitcoin, the earlier you get in, the better. So that could lead an impetus to where you have to you adopt it much faster. Because everybody wants to get in before it's too late. Yep. Yep. I mean, we could this could be done in two, ten years, you know.

239
01:35:03.520 --> 01:35:27.440
Exactly. Or could take the rest of our lives. I don't know. I try I try to temper my expectations because well, I mean, we underestimate, you know, short term and overestimate long term. Or overestimate long short term, it's the other way around. Yeah. But yeah, I you know, it's it is something that I think will happen grant very suddenly at some point, and who knows how far away we are from that point.

240
01:35:27.440 --> 01:35:52.800
But I definitely think that the you know what has transpired over the past few months has brought that date forward a significantly. So Bitcoiners hang on, this is our time. You know, buckle down, get your ducks in a row. You know, make sure that you have your shit in multi-sig, you know, make sure you have your your like mixed stash.

241
01:35:52.800 --> 01:36:16.800
You know, just get all that stuff done right now and start shilling, just start softly shilling. If you I mean, I know a lot of you have already, but now it's time to double down and revisit and say, like, hey, you know, family, like I'm looking out for you. I'm not crazy. This thing is a hedge, it's an insurance policy against all of this scary shit that's happening.

242
01:36:16.800 --> 01:36:42.840
People feel the fear, and fear works as a motivator. So get out there and use, you know, leverage that fear to get friends and family on board just with a bit of a little bit 1%, 2%. Just get a little bit of exposure. That's all it will take to really it's really help if this thing does just you know S curve up and go parabolic.

243
01:36:43.000 --> 01:37:05.880
300,000 sats per person, right? That's you know if you take 21 million divided by seven billion sound less than 30 bucks. Yep that's like I mean yeah you put in a hundred bucks and you're gonna be triple the you know average amount of sats per person. You know that's all it takes right now. Exactly. But then you know what always happens is no matter how much I swear to God no matter how much Bitcoin you have you always want more.

244
01:37:05.880 --> 01:37:44.040
It never ends. Yeah it never ends I mean greed is a natural human in you know instinct and emotion and so Bitcoin Bitcoin plays off that benefits from that you know so and what I think is a beautiful thing about Bitcoin is that you take greed and collect you know economic self-interest but then you look at economic self-interest on a social on a societal level collectively and it creates something beautiful it creates you know an efficient economy that will

245
01:37:44.200 --> 01:38:02.240
You know create a deflationary efficient economy that will help all of us become you know more affluent and have more time to do what we want to do etc. So it's it's amazing and that that's how greed is supposed to work on a on a grand level. Mm-hmm. Absolutely do. Yeah.

246
01:38:02.480 --> 01:38:23.600
Yeah. Couldn't have said it better. All right, dude. Let's drop it right there. That was a great rip. We went for like over an hour and a half. Can't wait to share this one. I think everyone's gonna really love it. Absolutely dude yeah, thanks for doing all you do. Thank you. Appreciate it, man. And hey, I'm super excited when when we fired up the video at the beginning of the chat and you had a Citizen Bitcoin shirt on.

247
01:38:23.600 --> 01:38:42.000
That's the first time that's happened. Fucking love it. Y'all can y'all can do the same. Check out Nick Ward's layer one btc.com. Yeah, I mean some citizen Bitcoin gear there. I'm wearing the shirt right now until you're very comfortable. It's it's just the cotton is is feels really nice.

248
01:38:42.000 --> 01:39:01.840
The logo, Brady, your logo is beautiful. It's just so simplistic. But I like a lot. Oh man, I've had people ask me in public about it. I shell Bitcoin to somebody. Yeah, I wore it to I was telling you a war to a bank and the teller there asked me about it. And I got to shell Bitcoin a little bit to them.

249
01:39:01.840 --> 01:39:23.120
So it starts conversations. There you go, man. Start some conversations. There you go. Like and Nick Ward, you know, props to you, and Nick designed the logo. I absolutely love it too. It's it's the inspiration is the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. And so you'll see the sort of sun with the Bitcoin at the center rising over the horizon.

250
01:39:23.120 --> 01:39:45.680
And that's where we're at, man. We're at we're we're here at the beginning. We're all privileged to be here at the beginning, and I think when we look back 20 years from now, we'll all be really proud to have been here and together and we'll have lasting friendships. You know, I want to go to a Bitcoin conference in 20 years with all with all of y'all and just kind of sit down and look back and shoot the shit about the early days.

251
01:39:45.680 --> 01:40:04.520
It's gonna be a good time. I love it. Yeah, although I will say there will be a little bit bittersweet to this because as the movement grows bigger, there will be a lot of new people. So we mean as as anything gets bigger, it's like they kind of begin to a band before they become popular.

252
01:40:04.520 --> 01:40:22.680
Exactly. They become popular, and there's a thousand you know, thousands or millions of new fans. The original voices do get diluted. That's kind of part of the that's part of the journey. Yeah, true. True that, true that that'll happen. That'll happen. All right, bro. I'll see you out. I'll see you out on Bitcoin Twitter, man.

253
01:40:22.680 --> 01:40:41.080
Appreciate it. Yes, absolutely. Man, take care. All right, bye-bye. All right, thanks to Vake for joining me. Man, it was a great conversation. I really appreciate your time.

254
01:40:41.080 --> 01:41:00.840
You can find him on Bitcoin Twitter at Bakerage at V A K E R A J. I'm at Citizen Bitcoin. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. As in the renaissance that will be spreading around the world when we adopt Bitcoin as our global reserve currency.

255
01:41:00.840 --> 01:41:19.480
Share this one with your family and friends, share it with all of your friends on Bitcoin Twitter. You know, share it out there, tell them you love the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. Let's get this thing spreading. Give us a give me a review, a rating on Apple Podcasts. Keep those coming in. I see those trickling in front now, every once in a while.

256
01:41:19.480 --> 01:41:44.840
I don't really ask for them anymore, but I love seeing them come in. And you know, might as well ask now. Go through a couple of reviews out there for me. It does help as we get this pump going, as we wait, you know, for this for this next bull run. The price is coiling tight right now. We're gonna see some action, the volatility will return one way or the other, but eventually the trend is going to go up, and as number goes up, attention comes in.

257
01:41:45.200 --> 01:42:05.280
Let's make the citizen bitcoin right up there at the top of the feed when people start adding Bitcoin podcasts to their podcast feeds. Alright, thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring this episode and to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the Citizen Bitcoin podcast in the feed. Check out my merchandise shop at layer1bdc.com.

258
01:42:05.280 --> 01:42:27.040
Hey, Vake had on a Citizen Bitcoin shirt, and I was freaking thrilled to see that. That was so cool. There's also some OPSEC friendly designs there, like the Unfuck the Money shirt and the strategically applied toxicity shirt. That's SAT, right? For for short. Apply sat a strategically applied toxicity to all those shitcoin scammers.

259
01:42:27.040 --> 01:42:45.360
Alright, we're not just, you know, like completely toxic to anybody without any discretion. Not no indiscriminate toxicity here. We strategically apply it where needed to protect people from falling scam to shit coin. I'm sorry, falling prey to shitcoin scams.

260
01:42:45.360 --> 01:43:05.440
So check out layer1btc.com. Click on partners and then citizenbitcoin, you'll find my collection there. Check out the podcast, like I noted at the top that we created for Swan, Swan Signal Podcast. You can find it at Swan Signal Podcast.com. Go hit subscribe on that right now. Alright, if you have any questions for me, would love to talk to you.

261
01:43:05.440 --> 01:43:29.680
Reach out to me in my DMs. That's the easiest way to find me, and I'll respond fastest there. You can also find me at Citizen Bitcoin on Telegram. My address, my email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
