ObiWan Kenobit: Hyperbitcoinization and the Macroeconomic Situation Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-08-22 [00:00:19] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady, and I'm podcasting my journey, learning Bitcoin. Hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again for another episode. Hope you all are doing well this week. I've got a discussion about Bitcoin today with Obi-Wan Kenobit, his first Bitcoin podcast episode. [00:00:45] Obi-Wan is a Bitcoiner. I appreciate and have gotten to know a bit over these last couple of years. Before we get going, quick word about Layer OneBTC.com. Probably know about Nick Ward's Bitcoin business. He's a great designer, putting out shirts, hats, hoodies, mugs, and stickers. There's so many designs to choose from. [00:01:04] You gotta check them out. You can click on partners and choose Citizen Bitcoin to shop for merch that supports this podcast. That's Layer OneBTC with one spelled out. [00:01:16] I'm a proud partner of Nick's and proud to be a partner alongside Stephan Livera and Peter McCormack. You can check out some designs that support their podcast there as well. [00:01:29] Alright, let's go. [00:01:40] ObiWan Kenobit has been into Bitcoin for many years now, and over the past [00:01:45] Year or so, he's been producing some great contributions to the growing library of Bitcoin education content. Particularly his widely read medium post titled Hyper Bitcoinization Winner Takes All, and a series of great threads on Twitter. I have included links to the article and many of his threads in the show notes. And be sure to follow him at Obi-Wan Kenobit, O B I W A N K-E-N-O-B-I-T on Bitcoin Twitter. [00:02:13] Alright, I'm excited to host Obi-Wan for his first Bitcoin podcast. Hope you all enjoy it too. Alright, I'm here today with Obi-Wan Knobitz, a Bitcoiner who I've been following for quite a while on Twitter now, and really appreciate his work. [00:02:36] Welcome to the show, man. Great, thanks for the invitation. Really appreciate it. Yeah, absolutely. I would love to start by hearing your Bitcoin story since this is your first Bitcoin podcast, which I think is awesome. So how did Bitcoin first capture you in its super massive black hole like gravitational pull? [00:02:54] Well, for me, it started actually quite a while ago. I had first heard about Bitcoin during the Silk Road days. A friend of mine had was was sort of going around through the website, was curious about Silk Road, and had mentioned to me there's this new kind of e-money called Bitcoin. [00:03:14] And I sort of looked at it at that time and I was wasn't quite sure what the use cases were other than for you know purchasing things on Silk Road, and just sort of disappeared out of my out of my radar at that point. And then I think a little while later, I came up again, I think it was an article in the New York Times. I think I saw something about the Winkleboss twins talking about Bitcoin. [00:03:36] And so I looked into it at that time and I saw that the price of the coin had gone up ten times between the time that I had looked at it and when the article came out. And even at that time I thought, you know, this doesn't make any sense to me. Why would you know a coin that's used to purchase anything go up in value? I didn't understand the basic principles of Bitcoin. [00:03:58] And then I think it was again in I think during the last bear market that it popped up again on my radar, and this time it was sitting in the hundreds of dollars per coin. And then it piqued my interest, and I said, you know, I think this is something I need to try to understand and look into, at least if not from kind of a macroeconomic perspective, at least from a personal perspective, this may be a an interesting and investment proposition. [00:04:23] And at that time I was looking to invest some money. This is you know, during I think about 2014, 15-ish. And so I looked at it and it was sitting around five or six hundred dollars, and I watched it go up to seven hundred very very short period of time, and I thought, okay, there's something very interesting going on here. [00:04:43] What why are people buying this? What's what's the investment thesis here? And basically took the plunge, opened up, I think it was I can't remember if it was a Kraken or a Coinbase account at that time, and you know, purchased my first Bitcoin, and which was a very nerve-wracking experience. I had no idea what I was doing. You know, how do I secure this? [00:05:02] How do I secure this coin? How do I get it off the exchange? How do I use it? You know, now what do I do? Did you know at that point that you should be getting it off the exchange, or it was that just kind of intuitive, or had you had you read something about that? I well, I had read about at that point I had read about the Mt. Ox hack. And so I was concerned. [00:05:21] And I if I recall correctly, Coinbase at that time was still very young company, as was Kraken. So for me there were there was concern about getting getting the money out of out of the exchange. And I've had kind of personal indirect experience of folks buying you know gold, gold bullion, you know, certificates with the promise of delivery of the actual coin. [00:05:45] And this is back in the late 80s and early 90s, and the coins never showing up. You know, despite you know, placing demands for the coin, the coins never showed up. All you got were interest payments that from that Ponzi scheme at that time. So again, I was concerned, so I thought, you know, how do I get this off? What do I do? And then of course the price collapsed. [00:06:06] Right. And I said, Okay, that's it, it's over, you know, Bitcoin is done. This is this is how Bitcoin this is how Bitcoin forges hodlers right here. Exactly. Yeah, everyone's gotta go through it. Exactly. So I held on to it and then again the price started creeping up, and like most people, you know, the price piques your interest first. [00:06:25] And so I decided to go ahead and purchase some more. And I just kept reading more about Bitcoin, going to Reddit. I at that time I was on Twitter, but not but under a different handle, and so I started kind of peeking around what were people saying about Bitcoin. And initially it was very confusing. I wasn't sure, you know, what what what the real story here was. [00:06:44] So it took a while for me to really start to get a grip of what Bitcoin promised to be, you know, outside of a payment system that I had first heard about. That I started learning about this digital gold thesis and that it was going to it's essentially become this hedge against fiat and potentially the world's reserve currency. [00:07:04] And that again piqued my interest, you know, from an investment perspective. I said this is you know something that I really can't miss out on. Even if it's a small portion of my my net wealth I need to invest I need to purchase more bitcoins and hold on to these and so I started I just started whenever I could you know dollar cost averaging in a little extra money put it into the put it into the exchange and get the bitcoins and eventually I think I stopped actually sort of stopped purchasing right during around the time of the fork I got very concerned and again my knowledge base even at that time would really had not been fleshed out I [00:07:42] Wasn't quite sure what was going to happen with the fork what was going to happen what was going to happen with the Bitcoins you know then we had the China fight at that I think at that time during the summer so I said let's let me just hold off here let's see how this plays out and then well obviously it played out going to 20 almost 2000 a coin which was you know completely unexpected I mean I thought you know I thought kind of a more gradual growth pattern but now in retrospect looking back having studied more about Bitcoin understanding some of the social and psychological things that are happening in the space I mean it may it makes sense [00:08:20] That that we had that massive spike in the price that we had that that we had that bubble I mean it's it really is it's it's social money and it's it's wired to become very responsive to social networks so I think we're gonna see similar things like that happen again in Bitcoin if not necessarily the price you know in in adoption levels and institutional adoption it's you know it's it's it's its own new phenomena. [00:08:48] I think we're we're fortunate we're we're watching money, hard money, you know, forming before our very eyes we which is probably once in a generational or even lifetime experience. Yeah, absolutely. It's it's phenomenal, it's amazing. And it's like I mentioned, you know, in at the beginning, and that it's like this super massive black hole of gravitational pull, and you know, you just kind of barely get caught by that gravitational pull, and inevitably you just sort of circle and circling it closer and closer and closer and just kind of go down that that black hole and it's it is I think a zero-to-one moment that probably won't happen [00:09:26] Again, or if it does, it'll be a long time from now. Just because the network effects of money, you know, means that it stays around for a long time. Let's oh go ahead. Go ahead. Right, and if you know, if the sort of the digital goal thesis does take hold and we you know we go from that, you know, the store value all the way up to the unit of account use of Bitcoin, then I think we're looking at you know more than generations, multi-generational, maybe even hundreds of years, very similar, very similar to what you know what gold became over thousands of years, but obviously over a shorter, shorter time span. [00:10:03] So we may be looking at you know a change in the way we where our economies work and our relationship with money that lasts many generations. Yeah, I completely agree. And gold did last for thousands of years. We kept coming back to it as the best money that we could find, had the highest stock to flow ratio, it didn't tarnish et cetera. [00:10:27] And there were moments of course the kind of some of the downsides of gold, like the fact that it's has a centralization risk. That kept happening over and over again with coin clipping all the way back into the Roman Empire, there was centralized coin clipping operations and policies that were going that were implemented that would debase the money, and then you know you'd have the falling out of that that that policy, and then eventually we'd find a way to kind of re-establish a more strict gold standard, and those economies and societies would flourish and the kind of whole process happens over and over again. [00:11:04] But now we have a money that you know fixes some of the downsides of gold, especially when we're talking about like global economies, global scale economy. And so yeah, it certainly could be around for a very long time. Right. Absolutely. Yeah. So let's let's dive into this to the macroeconomic situation right now. [00:11:23] I know that this is something that you follow closely and study. You've got some amazing threads on Twitter that are super useful for people who are sort of new to underst to trying to understand monetary policy and macroeconomics. We have negative interest rates in important economies all over the world, Europe, Japan very famously you know has negative interest rates and owned the central bank in Japan owns like 70 or 80 percent of all like ETFs and equities in Japan. [00:11:56] And at this point it seems inevitable that you know all global economies, since we're sort of in this kind of Keynesian paradigm now, it's just the way things are, that's this is just gonna keep happening. So do central banks have any other option at this point, or are we just, you know, it's it we're past the point of no return? [00:12:21] I think we're very close to the path to the point of no return. A lot of this sort of if you go back, you know, 10, 20 years, really the root of where we are today is probably back in the 1980s, in part due to banking deregulation. And that led to in part the dot com boom and bust and then the subsequent financial crisis beginning in 2008. [00:12:42] And if you look at what what specifically like the Federal Reserve did in in conjunction and coordinating with the European Central Bank, they initiated rounds of QE doing performing large scale asset purchases and essentially committing themselves to trillions of dollars of basically debt, debt debt credit and purchases. [00:13:07] And when we saw the Fed attempting to tighten some of these these loose policies, you saw the U.S. Stock market started to crumble a bit. There's sort of unease in the macroeconomic indicators, and basically showed us that the Fed cannot back off what it's already committed to. [00:13:28] There I think I think I posted in a in a Twitter thread a few months ago that the Fed really part of its mandate is to make sure that stock prices go up. I mean that's that was part of the mandate during the 2008 after the 2008 crisis. [00:13:47] And if you look at And is also how sorry to interrupt, but also how Japan ended up owning so much of its stock market. Exactly, yeah. And so you know, I think that we're we're at a point where the Fed can't back off. Central banks can't back off, and now they're now talking about you know negative interest rate policies. [00:14:07] You know, new IMF has proposed this new two this e-money scheme, which basically would allow it to allow it to charge interest on savings deposits. But you know it's interesting the so these I these concepts of using deposit or savings and as as investment vehicles or even as to charge is not new. [00:14:30] If you go back and look at some of the early writings of the Federal Reserve, Benjamin Strong, I think he was the federal governor of New York at the time, was very interested in having Americans d increase their savings deposits in banks so that banks could utilize that money for their own investment purposes. [00:14:50] So this sort of the concept of making use of the public's money and charging the public for the use of money through negative interest rate policies, I think is going to catch on. It's now become part of the public discourse. I remember when I first heard about it a few years ago it was shocking. You know, when you see articles, you know, academic scholarly articles talking about going below the zero bound and then Alan Greenspan saying that, well zero is just a number you know we can do whatever we want. [00:15:20] You know initially shocking but now it's become part of the conversation. You know, we're we're going to have negative interest rates. It I think the Fed the Federal Reserve and the cent other central banks have no choice. Outside of that then we're talking about a very large scale pretty abrupt collapse in in equity values and large scale bankruptcies. [00:15:47] And I think they're gonna try whatever they can to preserve what they have. Unfortunately ultimately resulting in another another financial crisis. Yeah. And we've certainly seen the presidents pushing on Twitter, pushing the Federal Reserve to act, citing, you know, these negative interest rate policies in Europe, saying, hey, we've got to compete. [00:16:11] Where's the Federal Reserve? They're kind of letting us down basically. We're gonna we're gonna lose to the rest of the world if we don't follow the same path. So the writing writing does seem to be on the wall. Right. And I and I think I saw I saw that tweet from the president, I think it was yesterday or day before, and sort of this political pressure on what is supposedly an independent institution, it's it's real. [00:16:37] I mean the political pressure has always been there. The Federal Reserve has always you know been been open to suggestions from the from the US government. So I don't think that it's a completely independent institution. But but I think what Trump is really pointing out is that there really are you know there are going to be you know issues for the economy in the near future. [00:16:58] I think that he's trying whatever he can to prevent that but at the same time I think it's adding fuel to the fire. I think you're gonna see a larger drop you know potentially more policies that are very restrictive that again punish the public. [00:17:17] I think I posted something from the Dallas Federal Reserve about the 2008 crisis, how it really is multiple trillions of dollars beyond what was reported that have actually come out of the wealth of the public. [00:17:34] Yeah I think you said it was some or the article that you posted said it was something like the actions taken after the 2008 financial crisis cost US public $14 trillion. That sounds lost wealth. Exactly, yeah. So the yeah exactly 14 I think the estimate was six trillion and then it was essentially double that to almost 14 tr 14 trillion dollars. [00:17:58] Yeah it's amazing. Yeah it's it it's absolutely phenomenal and the sad thing is that most of the American public and probably a lot of the w western countries look to central banks for for salvation they're they're they're going to be looking to them for lower interest rates for cheaper credit universal basic income socialistic type policies so that they can afford their you know d daily cost of living yeah my friend Ben Printis who was on the show a couple episodes ago called it looking to the arsonist to save you from the fire. [00:18:35] Right. Yes exactly. Yeah and I think I've I refer to it as sort of like a growing or or increasing global supermax that you know an economic supermax that's basically imprisoning incarcerating the public unbeknownst to them. Yeah that makes that makes good sense to me so where like how did we get here? [00:18:56] What is the history that got us here at least in this instance of money centralization like it like we talked about earlier it's happened over and over again throughout human history because you know who can resist the power to control the money no but like very few people pr possibly and there's certainly far more that they just can't resist that temptation. [00:19:19] But in this particular cycle, how how did we get here? Where did it start? Well I think I think I think I think I mentioned that it's I think it really started back in the 1970s. I mean, when Nixon released us from the gold standard, essentially abandoning the Bretton Woods accord, then we unleashed essentially the printing machines and started deregulating banking and allowed banks and governments to control the money supply. [00:19:52] I think that's really sort of the source of a lot of the issues that we have today. Then in the 80s we had banking deregulation and followed by a whole sort of slew of sort of economic quote unquote innovations that favored bankers, favored those who were close to the money spigot, so to speak. [00:20:12] And unfortunately that that left a lot of the public behind, leading to wage stagnation, income gaps, wealthy inequality, and really an unfair playing field that just really favors the banking institutions and those folks close to close to the close to the banks. [00:20:31] So I really think that the getting off a gold standard or commodity standard was the was the initiating event for all of this. Yeah, and I guess you could probably go back even farther to say that you know what made 1971 possible was the creation of the Federal Reserve in 1913. [00:20:53] Right. And then we were kind of on a path toward ending the gold the yeah, the gold standard in nineteen seventy one. I think I've seen some charts where we sort of slowly marched up in terms of like the amount of dollars per you know unit of gold in reserve kind of slowly marched up over time ever since the since nineteen thirteen and then just skyrockets after nineteen seventy one. [00:21:21] Yeah I think I agree I think that the issue is the gold standard was attacked very early on back in the eighteen hundreds. I mean if you look at we actually had before the Federal Reserve we actually had kind of a pseudo Federal Reserve kind of a first version you know version 0.1 if you will with the second national bank and the bank attempted to was essentially printing money and President Jackson was opposed to the printing of money really wanted to stay with the gold standard actually think that time we're at the bimetallic standard and essentially you know conflict [00:22:00] Occurred between the bank and the government and it led to a few mini recessions during that time and I think that set the stage you know in the in the late 1800s for the formation of the federal Federal Reserve in the in the 1900s. Banker bank the banking institutions at that time saw how powerful what power they had by being able to print money that they could actually turn the hand to the government. [00:22:26] And that led to the formation of the Federal Reserve you know supposedly to supposedly to limit and mitigate banking crises but in fact it really was about controlling the money supply and then like you said you know initially the gold was pegged and I think it was about twenty dollars or so to a dollar to twenty twenty dollars an ounce. [00:22:49] And then in the nineteen thirties it was adjusted to thirty-five dollars an ounce. And then by by the nineteen sixties, the citizens were or were not at that point they were allowed not allowed to own gold, but only by non-redeemable gold certificates. And then in 71 Nixon suspended the gold's convertibility to US dollars. [00:23:12] I think that that would that there were a lot of issues behind that. I mean, there was the issues of stagflation, you know, run, a potential run potential run on the U.S. Gold reserves. And then I think in 1965, President Charles de Gaulle threatened to return to the you know true gold standard at that time and wanted and wanted payment from the US in gold. [00:23:34] Right. And we just kind of realized that that wasn't possible anymore because we did kind of we just didn't have the amount of gold in reserve to cover the amount of dollars and money that we had printed. So I can't kind of just gave up on it out of out of I guess capitulation to that reality. [00:23:54] Right, right. That that was the biggest fear was the devaluation and deflation. Yeah, exactly. Well, you know, some people tried, but that that temptation to have that power to print money proved too great. And of course, there was the sort of academic justification that was provided by you know certain economists in like the Keynesian school. [00:24:18] And to be fair to Keynes, you know, he wrote about you know that the idea that government should take control of the money supply in times of economic crisis to try to kind of blunt the effects of recessions, economic recessions as they come. And he said that you know, when the economy recovers, you need to basically undo those measures in good times so that you can kind of bring interest rates back up and you know not inflate them. [00:24:50] You know, that way you can kind of undo the inflation. But that second part never happens is the problem. Right, exactly. The second part never happens. I think once you introduce sort of the weakness in the system, we sort of end up going to the least common denominator. And you know, and greed takes over. You know, once you realize you can print money at will, generate returns from essentially zero. [00:25:14] You can subjugate subjugate the public, and there's really no reason to return to you know a standard that forces you to really think long term about the consequences of the of the actions of the government or or whoever's in charge of the monetary supply. Yeah, and if you go to WTF, what the fuck happened in 1971.com, WTF happened in 1971.com, Ben and Colin from the Bitcoin Echo Chamber podcast have put together a compilation of graphs that just show you know these obvious inflection [00:25:52] Points in on all kinds of metrics in 1971. How productivity continued to increase, but compensation completely separated from it, how the savings rates started to decrease at that point, how there was an increase in in economic inequality, the consumer price index went parabolic. [00:26:17] So all of these economic metrics that have inflection points very obviously in 1971 make really really drive this point home. And I definitely suggest checking that stuff out. I know I definitely will. Yeah. Yeah, it's good stuff. Well, I know I mean you're going to be familiar with them because I think you've used a lot of these in threads, but for the readers in particular. [00:26:45] So, [00:26:45] Then why does Bitcoin matter? What is the opportunity that Bitcoin presents here and why is it a better money even obviously than fiat and even than gold. Well, I think that won one of the things that I mentioned in one of my threads in Bitcoin versus gold. There are a few key things that gold lacks, I think, for for money for against a hedge as fiat. [00:27:09] So one is that gold obviously, you know, re requires a fairly it's difficult to transport, it can be seized at borders, it's hard to verify. You know, do we know what is sitting inside of central bank vaults? Even for the layperson, you know, the coin that you have in your hand, you know, what is the how do you verify that coin that it's actually you know the 99.9% gold that you've purchased. [00:27:34] I think that those are those are challenges that that gold has had and will will continue to have. Gold has been seized, and we've seen that happen here in the United States. Yeah, despite the fact that the US Constitution describes you know money as as coins, gold and silver, you know, we don't have that anymore. [00:27:52] So I think from from that perspective, I see Bitcoin as better money. Is it one is that it's it is not as seizable, and I don't think it's in terms of crossing borders, no one's gonna take your bitcoins off of your computer or even you can memorize your your seed and just cross right across. [00:28:13] So from that perspective I think Bitcoin is definitely better money and there and I think that you look at as what Bitcoin is going to do more so than gold so goal I mean Bitcoin itself is is programmable. [00:28:31] You know gold is not I mean we can do bank settlement and we can do micropayments and smart contracts I think there's a lot that's still inherent in Bitcoin that we're not going to be able to you know use gold as money for example. Yeah. Would you would you even define fiat as it is today as money I've been I wouldn't and we can get into to why but I'd like to hear your thoughts first but I've been tweeting this kind of trying to kind of push this meme that Bitcoin is money and fiat is not to describe to kind of the general population who may not [00:29:09] Know that you know kind of coming into Bitcoin and trying to understand put it in very simple terms that like what we have now is not even money and that Bitcoin is teaching us what money really is. Right I agree with you I don't think fiat is money. I think fiat is currency but as in terms of money if we if it was backed by gold or Bitcoin then I would consider it you know it's currency backed by money. [00:29:33] Fiat really is debt. I mean it's just you're where there are keyboard entries on computers generated by central banks and banks there really is nothing backing it other than the force of law and the threat of violence and legal decree. So from I agree with you I think that fiat is not money whereas you know things like gold has been money, you know silver has been money, metal other metals like nickel and copper and even even rhistones and these glass beads you know in you know hundreds of years ago but I think that today's [00:30:11] Money is essentially debt. I mean if you returned all the fiat you'd have nothing left. Yeah, exactly. Yeah that's cool. I think there was a mate one of the major moments for me kind of the major sort of eye opening slash red pill moments for me in Bitcoin was the moment I kind of realized the difference between money and currency. [00:30:33] And you know there's Bitcoin skeptics out there, no coiners that will diss bit co big Bitcoin for not being backed by anything, right? Whereas you know gold is I guess backed by its I don't know just it its own nature, its own chemical nature and the f and the stock to flow ratio that is I guess natural stock to flow ratio of gold. [00:31:00] And that currency used to be backed then you know by gold which was used as money. What makes Bitcoin money? Like what is it backed by do you think or like what what makes Bitcoin money while fiat is not? Well I think there's one I think that is a couple of things one is Bitcoin has social consensus we have you know applied computational resources to secure the network and I think those are two key components of what makes Bitcoin money we've given it value and we've seen that value increase over time I [00:31:38] Think those are the probably what I would say the key characteristics of what gives Bitcoin the characteristics of money. [00:31:45] Not necessarily characteristics of currency yet, but that of money similar to gold. And I think Plan B has this wonderful stock-to-flow model, which shows that Bitcoin is becoming money. [00:31:59] And I think those those those that's what I how I would probably think about how Bitcoin has become money over time is really primarily through social consensus and computational resources. Yeah, so the expending of the resources, the energy that's used in proof of work mining process is essential to sort of create this bridge between the real world, the physical world, and this digital world. [00:32:27] So it's it's not like exactly like Bitcoin is backed by the energy expenditure, but it it is almost, it's almost like it's it's sort of backed by that energy expenditure, by the cost to create the Bitcoin. There is this real real cost to it. Right. And if you think about like think about gold, we're unable to reproduce gold or not reproduce it. [00:32:48] We're unable to recreate gold from taking another metal and converting it, or even being able to extract gold from the oceans. You know, there's there's a lot of gold in the oceans. So the difficulty, if you will, in extracting the gold from from the ground or from the water makes it very valuable. And I think we have similar similar paradigm in Bitcoin. [00:33:09] It's very it's difficult to secure it. And that difficulty makes it valuable. And as we add more computational resources to the network, it becomes even harder and harder to reverse, so to speak, right? It becomes harder and harder to break and becomes much more secure, which I think is a great feedback loop for for the average person to see this money grow from essentially zero to where we are now by adding you know computational resources, by using energy, by having entire industries develop around the concept of Bitcoin. [00:33:43] And I think that that is really giving its val creating its value. The harder the money becomes, the more difficult it is to attack it w will makes it makes it very similar in that sense to gold. It just becomes almost impossible to replicate. You can't you cannot transmute you know nickel to gold, and you can't transmute you can't transmute another coin to Bitcoin. [00:34:08] Right. I just I just remember the term that Nick Zabo used, Nick Zabo uses to describe this idea, unforgeable costliness. And I'll link to the essay where he talks about the importance of unforgeable costliness to Bitcoin. So it's kind of a combination of the unforgeable costliness and the scarcity of Bitcoin, which is very similar to gold in that sense that sort of makes it money. [00:34:34] While fiat is has no unforgeable costliness, it's literally you know, entries in some database somewhere and takes a few keystrokes to create billions of dollars, you know. And then obviously it's you know the opposite of scarce at this point. It's it's increasing in its availability and abundance. [00:34:55] The scarcity piece, I think that's that that's extremely important too. I mean, you look at the stock to flow model and the issuance and the cap supply, sort of all those rules, if you will, around Bitcoin, they're sort of like the physics of Bitcoin. Just like gold has its chemical properties, Bitcoin has its own as well. [00:35:15] And I think those are key characteristics that are in vast sort of contradistinction to what fiat is. And kind of one of the ways I like to think of it is like you mentioned fiat, you know, there really takes no, there's really no cost in developing it. Fiat fiat is sort of like Newtonian physics. [00:35:34] It really, and the economics of fiat is a lot like Newtonian physics, in that we look at the interaction of objects at a distance. Whereas, you know, we look at Austrian economics and Bitcoin in particular, we're really trying to understand the forces between part of particle to particle, like between individuals. [00:35:53] And I think once you understand that that how economies work is through individual interactions, you realize that things like fiat and Keynesian economics will never be able to grasp what an economy can do or what an economy does, and attempting to attempting to manipulate the economy will basically result in malinvestment, cycle business you know, all all sorts of business cycles with boom and bust cycles, and then and [00:36:32] I'm sorry, lost my train of thought there. No, it's all good. Yeah, and it's I think it's important to know that like even on sound money, those boom and bust cycles will still happen. They're I think they're probably a natural part of free markets, but it seems that the manipulation would like leads to a risk of like a heightened effects almost. [00:36:56] And the idea that Keynes had was that we should use government should use monetary policy as a way to sort of blunt those effects. And I think sometimes it might like in 2000 like the 2008 crisis, you know, after it, like the quantitative easing stuff kind of seemed to work, right? But it's sort of this sleight of hand that we're just kicking the can down the road, passing along that debt to future gener generations. [00:37:20] And meanwhile, this process has the side effect of you know, the Cantillian effect of enriching the already rich because they're closer to the money spigot than the average Joe. Right. Yeah, I mean that I think that's that that's the unfortunate side effect of fiat economies. [00:37:42] You know, and again manipulating the interest rate, for example, yeah, or or printing more money, so to speak, you know, results in malinvestment, just favors the cap sort of the cronies, the crony capital and those close to the closest to the banking industry. [00:38:01] Right, right. Okay, so let's get into hyper bitcoinization. You published an article in Medium, it was a little over a year ago, in June of last year. It was very widely read. It's called hyper bitcoinization, winner takes all. So let's just start with the basics. Hyper bitcoinization is a term coined, I think it was coined by Daniel Krauwitz in a 2014 Nakamoto Institute Post. [00:38:26] I think it was the first time maybe it was used that that I could find anyway. So what does hyperbitcoinization mean? So I think in his definition, he he described it as sort of a voluntary transition from one currency to another, from an in from an inferior currency to a superior currency. [00:38:45] And I think he said that it's it's more of an adoption of individual acts rather than a single monopolist that games the system. So there there isn't a central authority deciding that we're going to you know accept Bitcoin as our as our as our money. [00:39:03] And I and then think he goes on to talk about how it essentially sort of Bitcoin as good money eventually displaces bad money like fiat. Right. Okay. So the process of hyper bitcoinization starts, of course, with the birth of Bitcoin on January 3rd, 2009. [00:39:26] And then in your article, you analogize the process of Bitcoin's growth to the process of crystallization in nature. And I love the analogy. Can we just kind of walk through it carefully and describe this analogy to the listeners? Sure. So I think I the model that I use was sort of the classic crystal growth model, which is a very generic model. [00:39:51] I mean, crystals have many different ways of growing. They're not the curves that I that I presented in the article are not as always smooth, but I think it gets the idea across that you know, for for these small individual crystals to form a large crystal aggregate requires energy and requires a series of events to occur, otherwise the crystal aggregate falls apart. [00:40:13] And one of those, the key key portion is what's what I call the nucleation. And in nucleation, key things are are occurring in the same Bitcoin, you're having you know exchanges develop, you know, miners are adding computational resources to the network. People are beginning to take interest in the in Bitcoin. [00:40:34] And that nucleation event essentially adds energy to the system. And what it does is that individual aggregates of these little crystals start to come together and they form larger aggregates. And as crystals form larger aggregates and the individual molecules join, the energy state of the system is actually much more secure. [00:40:55] So it's better for each individual crystal to be part of the growing crystal than to live independently. [00:41:01] And that's where I see Bitcoin following a similar path, where initially we see just basically Bitcoin as a trinket, as a novel, interesting idea prior to this sort of, prior to this nucleation event. [00:41:19] And then as these other things begin to occur, we had Mt. Gox, we had Silk Road, and then eventually the other exchanges, and then folks in Silicon Valley and cryptographic circles beginning to purchase Bitcoin. I think early on in the days, somebody had created a Bitcoin spigot, if I recall the term correctly, where they were giving away Bitcoins, things like that all add to the faucet. [00:41:46] Yeah, that we're all where all that adds to the energy of the system and stabilizes essentially the crystal. [00:41:56] And I think that we're sort of moving along that curve [00:42:01] Just probably in the mid to late nucleation phase, which is the most critical, I think one of the most critical parts of Bitcoin's Bitcoin adoption and Bitcoin's growth. If we can get past this phase over the next just say five to ten years, I think we're going to see Bitcoin grow very fast, very rapidly, and just like in a crystallization model, that it's more beneficial to adopt Bitcoin than it would be to abandon it. [00:42:27] Exactly, yeah. So there's this on the graph, which I'll definitely link to this article in the show notes for everyone to take a look at. But in the graph, there's this sort of bell curve at the beginning. And then there's an so there's like this blue line is a bell curve, and that represents the equilibration and nucleation phases of crystallization. And then there's this red S curve, and we've talked about the idea of the kind of technological adoption S curve a lot on this podcast. [00:42:51] There's many examples throughout the past you know 100 or so years. I probably go back even farther, but of technologies that kind of follow this S curve of early adopters and this sort of flat line at the beginning, and then a very steep kind of increase toward the main phase of adoption, and then it flats flattens out again for the laggards who adopt later on. [00:43:15] So there's this point though where the bell curve of nucleation in in the crystallization process sort of crosses over with this S curve. And that's sort of the inflection point where the pace of growth really takes off. The crystal really grows into the kind of the large structure that it becomes. [00:43:36] And so you think that right now, like you we're we went we're probably kind of still in the nucleation phase and kind of building up these sort of like you say, exchange the 2.0 exchanges, subsequent layers, like the Lightning Network, and then industry industry use, the finance industry coming in, maybe the kind of the retail industry using it more often. [00:44:00] So that that might be like the next five to ten years before we hit this inflection point and the crystallization process sort of takes off. Yeah, I think so. I mean it it's in it's a I think it's a gross estimate, but that I think it's still we're still about five to ten years out before we hit any sort of meaningful tipping point. And again, if you look at the other curve that I posted in the article, it shows you know the what real technologies, you know, real curves look like for other technologies. [00:44:25] And you can see for a lot of them, you know, some are vertical, near vertical, you know, others have pauses, they'll have little plateaus before they take off again. And I'm and I'm sure you know Bitcoin will will have its own unique kind of growth curve. But I think we are still about five to ten years out before we start to really see before we get to that tipping point and see Bitcoin grow rapidly. [00:44:47] And I think the rapid growth will be will be reflected in the price. We're gonna see the price go up significantly. You know, and as other participants add fiat into the system, you know, not just retail, but then once we get institute family offices, institutions, and eventually, you know, banking type of institutions participate, I think we'll see the price just climb. [00:45:14] Yeah, so let's get into the numbers then and you dive into it in the article. You give a kind of a rough estimate on the global money base and the idea of how much value Bitcoin would have to absorb during this hybrid Bitcoinization process. So can we give some idea of these numbers and what that results in in terms of Bitcoin price? [00:45:38] Sure. So one one of the things that I think a lot of the models miss out on or don't take into account is what happens when Bitcoin goes from digital gold, you know, which has a certain value to a medium of exchange and a unit of account. So I think that Bitcoin's valuation potentially is much larger than we're accounting for at this time. [00:46:02] And part of the exercise that I went through was to try to capture some of those numbers. And the numbers are not 100% accurate and they're you know based in 2018 dollars. But ultimately my guess, and I'll say guess or conclusion is that one dollar will become one Satoshi will have the purchasing power of one dollar, two thousand eighteen dollars. [00:46:26] And I think that I look at that as taking into account you know some degree of inflation. You know, there's going to be there there's going to be not just the accounting for the sort of the store value thesis, but also the use of Bitcoin as money. And you know, whether that's you know a hundred million dollars per coin or fifty million dollars per coin or even ten, I think Bitcoin at that point has succeeded and will have deplaced displaced fiat from from we'll have displaced fiat and we'll be using Bitcoin and Satoshis as our as our money. [00:46:58] Yeah, and so at some point, you know, comparing or pricing Bitcoin in dollars kind of becomes you know meaningless and kind of progressively meaningless as hyper bitcoinization takes effect if it does. Then we just kind of start looking at perch the idea of purchasing power, I guess. [00:47:18] Exactly. And that's that's where I that's what I was trying to. I think I don't think I quite emphasize that in the article, but I think in subsequent discussions on Twitter, I had mentioned that you know what we're looking at is not necessarily, you know, you'll be able to exchange you know your your one Bitcoin for 100 million US dollars or 10 million US dollars. [00:47:37] But that but that that's the purchasing power. And I think we have to take into account that there's going to be some degree of deflation. So the purchasing power of your of your Bitcoin is not only going to you know increase because it's taking yeah it's it's subsuming fiat value, but also that it's a deflationary it's a deflationary money and so your purchasing power over time is going to go up. [00:48:00] Yeah. And also purchasing power will go up because deflation as a result of Bitcoin taking the monetary premium away from a lot of these assets, you know, and that we see it a lot in real estate I think is one of the best examples where there's you know these I've talked about this before on the on the show there's these these like condos in midtown Manhattan or whatever that kind of go basically unused or all over the world in kind of these hot these the kind of hot spots for the rich to travel to they they keep these houses huge houses millions of dollar houses and condos all over the world and part of it is for them to you know travel and spend a couple weeks at or whatever but [00:48:38] Mainly it's really a way to just get rid of cash which is you know going down in value and being inflated away the purchasing power of it and storing it in something that's actually scarce real estate you know so I think that that there will be an effect there too. Right and I think that you know you'll have a I think the public finally will have an opportunity to store store its value in its money as opposed to like you said you know trying to export export its cash into things like real estate or other types of collectibles. [00:49:09] I think what what Bitcoin does is it really levels the playing field. It doesn't make it necessarily you know fair fair so to speak it's not going to socially redistribute money to everybody. It's it really just creates a more fair and level playing field for people to participate in the economy without fearing that their money is going to be you know stolen from them by the by the government or or through inflation. [00:49:32] Kind of the way I like to think of it is that fiat uses its money monopoly to raise prices, Bitcoin will use its monopoly to lower them. And I think that that gives that gives folks the opportunity to store their ear their hard work you know in their cash. [00:49:51] I'll give you an example so I have I have a colleague who who wanted to purchase a house and so he had initial seed money of about a hundred thousand dollars in cash ten years ago and his plan was to each year save 10,000 more so that by the end of 10 years he'd have a total of 2000 to purchase purchase a home. [00:50:10] Well what he didn't take into account was that that initial 1000 dollars was going to lose two percent per year. Right. And that each 10k that he put in per year was also going to follow a similar curve. So by the time he got to the end of his 10 years, he had 200 quote unquote 2000 in cash in his bank account but the value the purchasing power had substantially dropped and asset price and real estate prices in his area had skyrocketed. [00:50:36] So his 2000 house was now worth 4000. [00:50:47] Yeah, and this is the kind of this is the way that when you have a deflationary money like Bitcoin, or at least one that's stable and not being inflated, this is the kind of economic action that you spur, right? You think longer term, you think about saving your money so that you can purchase something without going into debt. [00:51:10] Whereas with inflationary money, it's the opposite. It encourages and incentivizes people to spend, spend, spend right away and get rid of that cash because it's just going to go down in value over time. Well the other assets you're interested in purchasing are going up in price. Right. And I think that fiat does that, it it really forces you to spend your money and the and the entire system has been constructed to force you to spend. [00:51:34] Yeah, when you start targeting inflation at 2%, you know, what or ultimately whatever the number is, it's actually much, much more than that. I think I shared a shared a chart that healthcare costs, educational costs are skyrocketing. Medical costs are skyrocketing, and those are hidden sources of inflation. [00:51:53] So the 2% per year is really it's a red herring number. The reality is that inflation for most working people is much, much higher than that. About 20, 25 years ago, you could work as a manager at McDonald's, put a little bit of money away in your 401k, put some money off into this into savings, you know, send your kids to public school, and eventually buy a house. [00:52:18] That you can't do that today as a manager at McDonald's. You'd have to work two and a half jobs to even just get by. So I think that that sort of this the concept of inflation and spending money it's basically forced upon us by by the central banks' map machinations and their and their policies. [00:52:39] And Bitcoin gives us a chance to leave that system and allow hardworking people to save their money for the future. It's amazing. I mean, and that's where we are now. And this is the choice that we're making. We're gonna vote with with our money. We're gonna vote with our dollars. So if we're gonna vote with by buying Bitcoin, and that's how we that's how we vote for the a change in this system. [00:53:03] And I think when people really study what's going on and learn, and I think the kind of Bitcoin education industry is sort of being born right now, and I think we'll see demand for some you know education services that help people understand what's going on here because as you said kind of at the beginning, that the it's really confusing process. [00:53:27] It's a lot, it's really time consuming to try to sort everything out because it's happened so haphazardly and organically on the web. But we kind of see everything sort of coalescing now, and we see a lot more podcasts, we see people pulling together all kinds of great resources, offering courses, great books, great articles, Twitter threads, and content that's really focusing people's attention on what really matters here. [00:53:52] And that's this kind of monetary policy revolution that we're seeing. I want to go back just to make one quick point for people, because you get this pushback on sort of the inflation of prices and the consumer price index. There's certain goods that have decreased in price over time, and they're mostly like technologies, they're mostly like like TVs, computers, cell phones, all that stuff. [00:54:18] They decrease in value over time, and that's kind of a counter argument. Like, oh, we have some some services and goods that are increasing in price, we have some that are decreasing, so your argument doesn't really hold that fiat money leads to like these you know increases in prices across the board. But I think it's important to note for people who kind of push back against you when you're talking about Bitcoin in that way, is that it's amazing that these kind of these technologies, they're these exponential technologies, like that started, you know, I think the best example is the transistor itself. [00:54:52] They decrease in price despite the inflationary, you know, pushes forces of fiat money. Yeah, and there's probably some interesting, you know, nuances there. I mean, I think in part, a lot of those you'd look at that, like automobile manufacturing, computers, and there's a few other sort of mostly tech related items. [00:55:12] I mean, you a lot of those are industries where you have network effects. You have Moore's Law, you know, you have efficiencies in manufacturing. Many of those have been outsourced and sent overseas to where you have cheaper labor, cheaper manufacturing, you know, and less tariffs, so to speak. [00:55:32] So I think they're they're that's a bit nuanced and to some extent you know, the argument you're just based on looking at those graphs may be true, but you really look at the day-to-day impact of inflationary policies. Well, what really what really hurts people the most, it's their medical expenses, their credit card debt, it's their you know educational expenses. [00:55:57] I mean that hits their pop pocketbooks first. Whereas these other items are more discretionary items like you know, computers and a new car or whatnot. Those are discretionary items and we've seen those prices drop, but really it's that the items that we need to live with, you know, we need we need our we need good food, we need healthy food, we need access to medical care, access to education, all those have gone up in in price. [00:56:22] And I think I shared on on the graph, I shared a graph on in one of my threads about healthcare, and it shows that the cost of healthcare in the United States has gone up substantially, but a big part of that is administrative costs. That that that much of the increase in costs has not gone to the healthcare providers, but really to middlemen. [00:56:44] And it's and it's those, I think it's whenever you have government involved in in in a in areas like healthcare or education, you just introduce huge administrative costs and basically rent seekers who are able to extract money from the system. Whereas you look at technologies like you know, computers, cell phones and whatnot, there you have much more closer to real capitalistic endeavors and they're looking for ways to reduce costs to ex to remove administrative you know quote unquote costs out of those and increase the value of what they're outputting. [00:57:20] So you know, a ten dollar com a thousand dollar computer twenty years ago looks vastly different today. You're getting a lot more for your money. Whereas in healthcare it's the opposite. You're you're you're getting a lot like you're getting a lot less for your money today. There's some people out there that think this idea of hyper bitcoinization is is a scary prospect, one that would lead possibly to currency wars, global instability, wrecked economies. [00:57:47] Do you think it's probable that hyper bitcoinization would go that way? And how might hyper Bitcoinization happen organically and kind of less violently? What will it be like for both us as individuals and for larger kind of national and global economies? [00:58:06] Well, I think that it's it's unknown whether it'll happen overnight or what whether it'll happen gradually. It really is going to be dependent on what central banks around the world do and how they handled this next set of crises over the next 10 to 20 years. You know, are they going to continue printing money and propping up the economies by purchasing assets? [00:58:28] You know, is the entire world going to look like look like the Japanese economy? And maybe if it does over the next 10 years, then Bitcoin can sort of gradually make its way into the economy and take over. Or is it going to be a rapid hyperinflation type of event like we've seen in in Venezuela or or in Germany in the 1930s where you know Bitcoin needs to step in? [00:58:52] I don't know what the answer to that is. I think it could potentially go either way. That's really interesting. Yeah, regardless, I think my my thoughts are that I think you know, Bitcoin people that are afraid of Bitcoin becoming you know our standard or our money, one of the arguments they make is that well, it's you know we're it's deflationary. [00:59:14] Well, that's actually a good thing. You look back in the 1800s in the United States when we are in the biometallic standard, you know, we saw prices fall over a hundred year period. You know, the a loaf of bread was about the same price that as it was in the beginning beginning of the eighteen hundreds and at the end of the eighteen hundreds. I think actually prices actually fell during that time period for about twenty percent, despite the fact that there were a few wars in there where we printed money. [00:59:40] So from that perspective, we have historical context where we know that deflationary money is good. I mean, during the 1800s, during this sort of deflationary period, I mean we I think safe it talks about this a lot, that a lot of what we have today was invented at that time. [00:59:59] You know, you really look back at the you think about the internet. Okay, we think about the internet as as as forming out of experiments at DARPA in the 1970s. Well, let's actually go back further. Maybe we already had the internet back in the 1800s with the invention of the telegraph. You know, the invention of the telegraph is basically was the internet. [01:00:17] It collapsed time and space, information was able to be exchanged much much more quickly. And back in those days, people used used the telegraph to communicate with each other. They played games, they played checkers over the telegraph. There was, you know, quote unquote online dating through the telegraph. [01:00:37] So you really look at a lot of the innovations we had back then with steam, electricity, the telegraph, all that came out of that deflationary period. So I think that with Bitcoin, we're gonna see another round, if you will, of massive innovation, you know, once once we're in a sound and with sound money in a sound economy. [01:00:59] So that that that's one of the things that I tried to explain to folks in real life that you know having a deflationary money is actually a good thing. You know, it it will spur, it will spur innovation, it will allow people to purchase homes, it'll affect individuals, allowing them to save their money without fear of government seizure through inflation, allow businesses to grow just as they did in the 1800s. [01:01:26] You know, we had massive innovation and huge, huge working businesses in the eighteen hundreds under the gold standard, and we can do that again with Bitcoin. I love it. I love it. It's it's a beautiful vision, and I hope we can get there. There's there's hope now. There's hope now that we can. [01:01:45] Yeah, and I think that one one thing that most folks feel is that you know if we stay with fiat, it would we'll just stay the course. The way I look at it is if we stay with fiat, we'll probably end up living in in citadels, fiat citadels. The war the fiat feeds the war and welfare state. [01:02:03] It really favors those closest to the money spigot. And we're very much like late-stage Athens, high time preference live living. You know, we have wealth inequality, we're in a constant state of warfare. And unless we have a path out, I think we're going to see society become much more fragmented. [01:02:26] Tribalism, and I think we're already starting to see part of that now in a in our politics and so you know Bitcoin offers us a path out of that instead of going down that path, you know, making the war making the welfare state more socialistic, more kind of a bright big brother type of institution. [01:02:46] And one of the main arguments that people will point out against deflationary money, they'll say I mean actually it's like the only argument I hear. They'll say that deflationary money incentivizes hoarding and people won't spend it. And it'll just then if people aren't spending any money, then there's no demand and it'll crash the economy, right? [01:03:06] That why that idea is has been debunked thoroughly. Maybe we can talk a little bit about about why that's just wrong. Yeah. You know, and again, it I think you we have to go back and we have historical precedent for much of this. You know, we look at the investment the amount of investment that was made during the eighteen hundreds, you know, in the United States and Western Europe under the gold standard, we clearly see that there was a huge investment in industrial growth during that time. [01:03:37] Even agricultural industrial growth during that time. And we'll we'll we'll see that again in Bitcoin. And people will hoard Bitcoin, sure they will, just like people hoarded gold in those days. But you know, when interest rates without being manipulated by central banks, when interest rates became favorable, you know, folks were were willing to part with their money. [01:03:58] And I think we'll see we'll see that happen again. Much more natural kind of ebb and flow of money in the hands of people and companies. And, you know, again, without interference from central banks, I think we'll have, you know, economies that work that works for industrialists and economies that work for individuals. [01:04:20] Yeah, and yeah, people have needs, you know, people are gonna spend money. That you have to have food, you have to have a house, healthcare education, all those things that we've talked about. There are needs in your life, and you know, you only have a certain amount of time on this world. So you're not just gonna hoard forever. There's very few people who will choose to do that. Even though we have like characters in Dickens novels that kind of, you know, k caricature that that idea of a hoarder or whatever and a miser living on basically nothing and just hoarding all their money. [01:04:48] That that doesn't really exist in any like meaningful number across humanity, as far as, you know, my in my experience anyway. Exactly. Yeah, I think that's you know, that's that's an argument that that that folks opposed to Bitcoin use a lot is is the is the hoarding argument. [01:05:09] But like you said, I think that you know people have have their own personal needs, they have the desi things they need to purchase, purchase a house, a car, send send their kids to school, whatnot. So my money will flow. I don't I don't think that's gonna be an issue. I think that's that's a red herring argument. Yeah. All right. What might prevent hybrid Bitcoinization from happening. [01:05:30] Well, I suppose if all the central banks and governments decided to decide to stop their their economic manipulations and return to a gold standard, that might be you know one one potential path. But I don't see I don't see that really happening. [01:05:50] I think that particularly with gold, I know Safety and has argued that this potentially could be you know something that would stop Bitcoin from being adopted as as a sort of the bitco as a Bitcoin standard. But I don't see central banks being that forthright and wanting to do that. [01:06:09] They're they they want to preserve their power, they're they're institutionalized, and they really think that they're saving the world. So I don't think from that perspective we'll see gold coming back as a standard and stopping Bitcoin because gold again is still seizable, still can be censored, has been censored in the past, difficult to verify, and so on. [01:06:33] So I really think that we're we're at a point in in society in our history where something like Bitcoin is very much needed to return power to the people to defund governments, reduce their power, reduce their their sort of their big brother their big brother powers and their invasion of our personal privacy. [01:06:59] So I think that we're already past that point and Bitcoin has a very, very good chance of becoming our money for the future. Awesome. This has been a great conversation. Really appreciate you taking the time in. I got one more kind of fun question for you. I love your handle. [01:07:18] I think it's one of my favorites on Bitcoin Twitter. I love Obi Wan Kenobi as a character. So are you a big Star Wars fan? Yes, big Star Wars fan, mostly the original the original trilogy. Yeah exactly yeah no big big Star Wars fan. [01:07:36] You know just the st I think the stories that that Luke was told they they really reflect sort of our sort of the stories of the hero the personal journey of the hero. And I think he took he drew a lot from Joseph Campbell's books, The Hero's Journey. And I really really enjoyed you know seeing that. [01:07:57] I mean they're very simplistic stories, but they really speak to a lot of people about having hope you know about going on this you know journey of discovery and then learning more and then at the end learning more about yourself. Ultimately that I think that's what those those movies really taught a lot taught showed that you know an individual character can learn a lot about himself by going through this herald is kind of a good analogy between you know the sort of journey that Bitcoin is on itself as a as a network and [01:08:31] Luke, you know, [01:08:32] There's this giant empire that's sort of taking control of the universe and it has sort of this will to power that has kind of overwhelmed the universe. And then you have Luke and the Jedi who sort of represent this will to empower, you know, to empower people, these these ideals of kind of goodness and encouraging the development of this kind of community spirit of uplifting humans instead of you know having power over them. [01:09:03] And then Bitcoin is is the shot, the Death Star shot that Luke launches. Right, you know, it sort of begins the fall of the empire. Right. I mean and I think that you know from that that you know and what I love about the Obi-Wan character is sort of his you know his his wisdom and little dry little dry humor there, you know, mixed in with it. [01:09:30] And a little bit of his, you know, he's he wasn't really he's not a flashy character. He's just he's just a regular guy, he's just a guy living in a cave. Yeah. And maybe Obi-Wan's a good kind of analogy or metaphor for for Satoshi. Could be absolutely, yeah. [01:09:49] Absolutely. Alright, man, I love it. Look forward to you know talking more on Discord and on Twitter and you know, just being being here with you on this you know, sort of dawn of the of the Bitcoin Renaissance. You know, what a time, man. No, definitely. I think we're we're blessed to be here. [01:10:08] You know, to be able to participate in in Bitcoin, to even just you know, have a few people read the threads. For me is you know, it's if I can reach one person, you know, out of all of the threads I posted, one person goes out and says, Okay, I believe in this and I'm gonna get my Bitcoin. [01:10:27] Then I think I've accomplished what I what I set out to do. Oh, yeah, I'm sure you've you've inspired more than one person already and will continue to do so, man. So thanks and keep it up. Definitely. Thanks. I really appreciate it. Yep, take care. Alright. [01:10:52] All right, I had a great time as always. I think Obi-Wan has achieved a deep understanding of Bitcoin and what's going on here, and I think he does a great job putting that understanding into words to help teach us all. So let us know what you thought about this conversation. What questions arose for you while listening today? [01:11:13] Let us know on Bitcoin Twitter. Obi-Wan is at Obi-Wan Kenobit, and I am at Citizen Bitcoin. If you appreciate the podcast, you can give back and help me bootstrap this thing by sharing the episode on Bitcoin Twitter. You can recommend the pod to friends and family that are asking you about Bitcoin, and leaving a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, starring on Spotify. [01:11:37] You can also visit layer1btc.com and grab yourself some citizen Bitcoin merch. I really, really deeply appreciate all your support. The growth of the podcast is really humbling. It's been a ton of fun. Thanks for joining me on this journey. That's it for this one. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.