Pierre Rochard: Lightning Network, BIP 157, Loop, Node Launcher and More Citizen Bitcoin · 2019-03-29 [00:00:17] Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're here sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. Alright Bitcoiners, get hyped. I've got Pierre Rochard himself on the pod tonight. [00:00:39] Y'all are in for a treat. A quick shill before we get into it. Check out citizenbitcoin.shop for some cool emoji-based Bitcoin-themed stickers. They look great on top of your nodes. You can pay in Lightning or on-chain with OpenNode. Fiat with Stripe. [00:00:58] Check them out. I think you guys are going to like them. All proceeds for the lightning torch sticker go to BTC Venezuela at BTC on Twitter. They're doing important work on the front lines, spreading Bitcoin awareness and adoption where it matters the very most right now. And stay tuned to this feed. [00:01:16] Next week, I'll be talking with Marty Bent. Got a couple other great interviews lined up after that. Brandon Quittem of the Bitcoin Mycelium Analogy. Really excited to talk to him about his work and got Dan Held lined up as well. [00:01:36] So stay tuned to the Citizen Bitcoin pod and we're going to get you some awesome content over the next few weeks. All right, on to the show. [00:01:53] I think basically all the Bitcoiners who listen to this pod will know who Pierre Rochard is. A co-founder of the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, the website of which all Bitcoiners should read from beginning to end. The co-host of the Noded podcast, one of the best Bitcoin pods out there. And more recently, founder of Lightning Power Users and creator of the Node Launcher. [00:02:16] In this discussion, Pierre and I get into all things Lightning. Hope you all enjoy it. I sure [00:02:21] Did. [00:02:25] Hey, Pierre, how [00:02:26] You doing? Good. How are you? Thanks for having me on. Yeah, I'm doing great, man. I'm really excited about this. I just wanted to start by saying thank you for helping me understand Bitcoin. Sure thing. Yeah, I mean, you've been doing it for a while. So I have this funny little Twitter thread that I want to share with everyone before we start, because I think it's a kind of it illustrates I think a lot of people who are new to Bitcoin are going to identify with this when you get thrown into the rabbit hole and all the noise on [00:03:04] Twitter and Reddit and all over the internet, trying to figure out what's going on and make sense of it. There are a lot of Bitcoiners such as yourself that are kind enough to donate their time to teaching the new—the noobs on each wave of adoption. And so I'm kind of where I'm trying to give back to you and others who did that for me. [00:03:27] So before I actually created the Citizen Bitcoin Twitter account and podcast, and I moved all my Bitcoin Twitter activity over to that, I bothered you a lot from my personal Twitter account. And you almost always answered my noobish questions just very directly and with good information. And I learned a ton. [00:03:47] You always had a link to something on the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute website, for instance. Seem to answer my questions. So I feel compelled to share this particular thread. And it's a bit embarrassing for me, but it's from November 6, 2017. So this is like nine or 10 days before the Bcash hard fork. [00:04:08] And I had asked, you know, why you were, you know, basically a small blocker, while you were against SegWit2x. And you posted a link to something on Michael Goldstein's blog, bitstein.org. [00:04:27] And it was a conversation between you and, or I guess kind of a debate or discussion between you and Gavin Andreessen about the block size limit from like early 2015. So this goes way back. And the thread says, all right, so you post that link. And I was like, thank you. That helps me confirm my hypothesis. [00:04:46] Bitcoin should be the reserve currency and some altcoin should be cash like Bitcoin cash or Litecoin. Right. Which is just ridiculous takeaway from that. Yeah, that's a fair. No, but that's a that's a. Yeah. Well, you might be strawmanning my position, but it's a after reading that piece like that. [00:05:08] I do say that, you know, we'll know the transaction fees are too high if we start seeing an altcoin gain. Subtraction. Substitution. Yeah, that's true. But then you replied, you said, don't confuse Bitcoin the money and Bitcoin the payments network. Cash will be Bitcoin denominated layers like Lightning. [00:05:27] And then this is the embarrassing part. I reply, okay, Lightning Network is a Blockstream project, right? Blockstream is a private company. Is Lightning going to be open source in Bitcoin Core? And you reply, I can't tell if you're trolling me or you just get all your information from R slash BTC. And I was definitely reading RBTC then too, because I was trying to figure out what's going to happen to this fork. [00:05:50] And yeah, I was just too susceptible to the FUD back then, just didn't have enough information and enough context. But I just thought it was really funny and I appreciate you being a sport and educating about Bitcoin and saying things really important. So like I said, trying to do my thing to help out on that front with this next wave that's coming up. [00:06:12] Awesome. Yeah. So, okay. So with that, I want to talk about Lightning with you today. I thought we could kind of dive in to a little history of Lightning and just kind of set the scene. The Lightning Network white paper, which was written by Joseph Poon and Tadge Dryja, dropped on January 14th, 2016. [00:06:38] It's a week or so after Bitcoin's seventh birthday and a little over three years ago now. So do you remember that? And what were your first impressions when you read the proposal? Yeah, I do remember that. And my first impression was, why do we need this? Because the Bitcoin network functions rather well as a payment system. [00:07:00] So this seems superfluous. Now, to give you some context, too, I was working at BitPay in Atlanta at the time. And yeah, it just when I didn't I didn't actually read the paper. What I absorbed was from conversations with other employees at BitPay. [00:07:21] And the impression I was getting without me having done my own research at all, which I definitely should have. I was getting the impression that this would be nice for high-frequency micropayments, weird stuff like that. But if you're just buying your coffee, you can just go on-chain and you don't need to use this weird system. [00:07:45] It's a weird network. And that like basically i also had it confused with the existing payment channels that were available like around that time which was basically unidirectional and not super useful so i did not do my due diligence and if i had i'd like to think that i would have been more bullish on it than I was. [00:08:12] But in any case, it came back on my radar with both the soft forks that were occurring to accommodate Lightning, including SegWit, but also due to the scaling debate. Now, before Lightning really had me persuaded, I had it in mind that there would layer two entities that is, you know, unfortunately, centralized financial institutions that are processing payments, and then [00:08:50] Settling things on the Bitcoin network, kind of like under the gold standard, which I say, unfortunately, because what developed is fractional reserve banking. But there are arguments for why that would not develop with Bitcoin. Even in that scenario in that the cost of final settlement is so low that it would be very easy to also open a bank and go in and compete because there's open access to the backbone of the financial system and you know anyone with an internet connection can can do a bitcoin transaction they don't necessarily have to get approved [00:09:29] By federal reserve or whatever In any case, so once it clicked in my head, I think that, so the first thing that got my attention really on Lightning was when I went on Mainnet and Satoshi's place got traction. [00:09:50] Yeah. And also seeing demo videos from Jack Mahler's about Zap. Yeah, so that was like kind of first quarter 2018, like basically a year ago. Yeah, and then also like Alex Bosworth's tweets where I was like, I don't know what this guy is talking about, but I think that there's something there because he's very pro-Bitcoin and he's like doing highly experimental stuff with this Lightning Network that seems to be finally maturing well enough that people are using on mainnet. [00:10:26] It. So then the ChainCode Labs sponsored a Lightning residency, and I applied to it because the whole point of the residency was that you would learn more about the Lightning Network, and I was curious about learning more about the Lightning Network. And so it was a week-long program here in New York, and basically they had some of the best Lightning protocol developers and application developers come and speak about their perspectives on how it currently functions, how it will function in the future if we put in the hard engineering effort to get [00:11:05] It to function that way. And I left that residency very excited about Lightning because it became clear to me that this was going to be not only crucial for Bitcoin's underlying security slash transaction finality with high transaction fees. [00:11:31] And also help us avoid this issue of fractional reserve banks or just generally having to rely on a trusted third party and all of the nonsense that comes out of that. But especially I kind of my hobby horse my entire life has been this issue of macroeconomic cycles. [00:11:50] And I subscribe to kind of the Rothbardian Austrian business cycle theory of fractional reserve banking causes business cycles, and then central banking on top of that makes things even worse. And so to me, having the entire payment system be 100% reserve thanks to Lightning sounds extremely appealing and I think would be fantastic for the economy. [00:12:17] Right. So that full reserve is a product of the one-to-one peg between Bitcoin's main chain and then Bitcoin on the Lightning Network because it's all pegged. Yeah, I mean, I could definitely start arguing about semantics and quibbling over which words we use because to me, pegged is not the appropriate term for how the system functions because I would actually, the metaphor I use is that if we have a legal system and you, every [00:12:55] Time you relied on a contract, you needed to go to the courthouse just as a formality, that just would not be a scalable legal system. And the alternative is that you go to the courthouse with your contract when there's a dispute, not when there's no dispute. So that's kind of what, how lightning functions is that It uses the main chain as a Supreme Court that uses smart contracts to determine the outcome of a channel that is in dispute and for its final balance. [00:13:33] Now, so from that perspective, really what's going on is that valid Bitcoin transactions are being held off chain by participants. And these valid Bitcoin transactions could be settled on chain at any point. So I do consider it something beyond pegged because they are fundamentally contracts that are cryptographically enforceable on the Bitcoin network and entirely Bitcoin denominated and really no different than any other contract that's being processed [00:14:11] By the Bitcoin payment system. Yeah, the only difference being that they're unsettled, right? They're just not broadcasted. [00:14:21] Any kind of unsettled transaction, right? So like you could just send me a normal signed transaction that was not broadcasted and then I could sit on it. And so it's like, well, at that point, it's really a matter of time before the coins are transferred. Whereas in a peg system, generally what you have are two different assets that have a fixed exchange rate. [00:14:47] So 16 apples for three oranges. We try to manage the supply and demand of both so that that peg holds so that they're of course yeah but that's just that's just not how lightning functions right right now there are other cryptographic you know or cryptocurrency systems that that do try to do a peg like stable coins die on so that's why i think it's we have to be careful about the terminology we use when describing how lightning works from from kind of a economic perspective but also on the legal perspective. [00:15:21] Yeah, absolutely. I totally appreciate that. Yeah, and that makes sense. [00:15:28] So let's actually, let's dive into a little bit about how Lightning works. We've already kind of gotten in there a little bit. [00:15:36] So the kind of the novelty, I guess, or the innovation in the Lightning Network paper was the idea of bidirectional payment channels, as opposed to the kind of already existing and long, like existed for quite a long time. As far as I know, I don't know exactly when the idea of payment channels came around, The old idea of payment channels was a unidirectional, like you alluded to earlier. [00:15:56] So could you talk a little bit about how a bidirectional payment channel works? Yeah, sure thing. So first we have to start with kind of what the system looked like beforehand. Because if you're just looking at the lightning white paper in a vacuum, you might think that there's, you know, well, I mean, in the lightning white paper, they talk about previous attempts at this. [00:16:23] But if you're thinking about bidirectional channels in a vacuum, it's not obvious how you got to how they're constructed today. And really, it's been a very long evolutionary process that started with Satoshi Nakamoto himself. So in the first version of Bitcoin, he had a system of replacing transactions using what's called an nSequence number. [00:16:52] And so basically the miner would pick the highest of the sequences of this transaction. The problem is that then the miner can choose to say, okay, well, actually, this is a lower sequence, or this lower sequence is the highest sequence, because it's in the favor of whoever I'm favoring. So it was trivially gamed by miners. [00:17:15] And we don't want a trust model based on the miners being able to censor transactions like that. And so in any case, there were further revolutions, Spillman-style payment channels, and then came along CLTV. [00:17:34] I won't get into the nitty-gritty details, but basically there was iteration on how well these payment channels function. And you're right. So with Lightning, you know, the bidirectional flow of funds, I think, is key if you want to have a network that actually is scalable and useful to participants. [00:17:57] Because basically, like, we want to be in a situation where you join the Lightning Network, you open eight channels with random peers, and just because others are doing that, others are opening channels to you as well, so providing inbound liquidity to you. That basically the whole network is kind of a big mesh network, and that you can pretty easily route payments from—with just a few hops. [00:18:30] Or I think, I forget what the number, but there's basically like a probability distribution and you'd want it to be so that like 99.99% of payments happen in like six plus than or equal to six hops or whatever it is. And that's feasible, I think. [00:18:50] And it makes it not too capital intensive. It's kind of the other problem. Really annoying to have a system where basically you have to put in a huge amount of capital, a lot of Bitcoin into a hot wallet that is managing these channels. [00:19:10] And I think that with advances like Atomic Multipath, where basically you can send the same payment through multiple channels, and then they kind of combine each other on the ends of the sending and the receiving. So like innovations like that will make it so that it's not too capital intensive. [00:19:33] And then also the other issue is the autopilot. So the autopilot is automatically opening and closing channels. And if they're very intelligent autopilot, then they should be able to manage the capital effectively so that you don't have too little or too much just based on your spending habits and receiving habits, but that's a ways off. [00:19:56] Yeah. Okay. But you think that that's basically where we're going is like kind of AI assisted autopilot channel management. So that's not manual anymore. Exactly. Yep. And, and we, we have to have that if we want this to scale to like quote unquote mainstream consumers. Now I think that it's very important right now that people do experiment with manually opening and closing channels and not rely too much on today's autopilot. [00:20:26] And I say that because today's autopilot is kind of a first iteration on autopilot and is by no means like something that you should rely on and then just not experiment with. It's there to be experimented with. So definitely try it out. But also experiment with managing your own channels. [00:20:46] Because if we want to create autopilots that, for example, you might have an autopilot that's very different for an exchange versus a merchant versus a routing node versus an end user on his mobile or on his desktop and laptop. So each of those might have a very different autopilot configuration. [00:21:07] And then there's also just going to be competing trade-offs on different autopilots. Do you have, like, do you have a lot of—are you putting a lot of money into it or very little? You know, it's going to behave differently. So all of these things I think are going to have to be derived from users actually manually opening and closing channels and us learning from that, rather than us just—and like, to program an automated system, I think that you have to manually do it first. You know what the pitfalls and opportunities… [00:21:46] Are on the software engineering side of automating the process. Yeah, I've got, you know, I kind of have the same, I guess, idea that Autopilot is just kind of there to test, but it should be used at least a little bit so we know how it's behaving. And so I've got Autopilot set up on one of my Lightning nodes, and it's like all LN big channels, incoming LN big channels is basically what it opened. [00:22:13] I opened eight autopilot channels and there were all various channels from the Ellen Bigg service, all incoming liquidity, obviously. And I kind of was wondering about how that happened. Do services sort of sign up to provide liquidity via autopilot or how does that work right now? [00:22:35] Yeah, so it's really ad hoc. So the, and really right now it's, you know, we're, we're in like the stone ages and it's, it's funny because, you know, it's just, it's so early. [00:22:55] It's, it's very early for, for lightning. And there's a lot of different people with kind of different theories. Now, some of them state their theories with tremendous confidence. And so you might mistake it as a factual statement or a well-researched analysis of past data when really it's really highly speculative remarks about things that haven't happened yet because it's so early. [00:23:25] And so, you know, there's different like, you know, so you could say, well, LNBig is being really irresponsible because they are, in some cases deliberately, in some cases accidentally, like spamming the network with capacity. And how useful is this capacity? [00:23:44] It's completely out of proportion with the velocity of payments on the network. It clogs up the public announcement network that announces channels and nodes. So it's kind of eating up resources on others and all this criticism. [00:24:04] But really, what if it does make sense to open channels, a bunch of channels today, because on-chain transaction fees are so low? And that these channels might have a lifetime value that is just mind-boggling. And we don't know that today. [00:24:23] And so it's kind of an entrepreneurial risk that they're taking. And I've heard plenty of arguments for and against, but at the end of the day, I don't think that there's a priori way we can state whether this is a good entrepreneurial investment and we'll just have to see what the results are. [00:24:48] What are some of the pros and cons you've heard about LundBIG? Yeah, so the cons are obviously that we don't want a centralized entity to be routing so much of the traffic on Lightning, both because that could possibly degrade privacy, but also because if they go down or if they get hacked or anything like that happens it would cripple an hour. [00:25:16] So I think that I think there's a little bit of catastrophizing there and I'd actually want to see this happen because it would be a good lesson for everyone to learn. My theory is that if a big player like Ellen Big or their descendants or people who come along later who build up big routing nodes or anyone, if they go offline, my theory is that routing fees across the network go up. [00:25:50] The failure of payment routing goes up a little bit, but not significantly. And that the network just heals itself. And that really it's not a catastrophic situation at all. It's just an inconvenience. It's especially an inconvenience because now all those people, let's say Ellen Big did go down, and there's a bunch of people who have channels open with them with capacity in them. [00:26:17] Well, now you have to go force-close all those channels. So force-closing is bad because it takes up more space on the blockchain, and thus it also costs more to do. And so that would kind of be a bad outcome. But if they are responsible and they stay online and they're reliable routers, then they're providing liquidity to the Lightning Network and doing a great service. [00:26:50] Now, I know it's kind of silly for people to think that they're doing the Lightning Network a favor. I don't think anyone should be doing the Lightning Network a favor. Everyone should be trying to profit off of it because that's ultimately, I believe in Adam Smith's invisible hand. So I think that if people who run routing nodes gouge and charge at very high rates on channels connected to them, then the clients will connect and open channels with other routing nodes that are charging less. [00:27:24] Or they'll incentivize routing nodes. Exactly. Yeah, it'll incentivize other routing nodes to come online and undercut them. And provide more liquidity to the network. So I think that it would be good if people charged more on routing fees and that we really shouldn't be worried about the optics of like, oh, lightning was supposed to be free, blah, blah, blah. [00:27:45] Sorry, but those are just idiotic memes. I'm sorry that they were expounded. And, you know, but at the same time, there's truth to it in the sense that off chain will always have lower fees for most payments. Because I think that if you if you look at payments, they fall down on a power law distribution. [00:28:07] So you have, you know, 0.1 percent of payments move probably 80 percent of the value. But the rest of the payments. So that would be on chain. The rest of the payments would be off chain because they're such a value. And the reason that's important is because on-chain you pay per byte. [00:28:26] So you pay by the amount of data that you're consuming on the blockchain. Off-chain you pay by the amount you're sending. So it's a percentage of how much you're sending that you pay because you're consuming liquidity in a certain direction on a channel. Right, right. Makes sense. So are you getting some of the same sort of pushback on Lightning users? [00:28:49] Because I know it's one of the biggest nodes on the network. Do you get feedback from other Bitcoiners about, you know, having 1100 channels open or whatever? No, because there's a different like dynamic with me where basically I only open channels to people who request that I open a channel to them. [00:29:08] Sure. And or if I see that they are a ratting hub themselves. So in that case, I can't imagine they would mind that I open a channel to them. But otherwise, it's all, you know, a lot of people opening channels with me. And so I generally, you know, I want to run a very reliable routing node. [00:29:34] And by doing that, I think I provide a better UX than others who, you know, are publicly advertising themselves as a routing node, but then like consistently offline and not reliable. To have a routing node that, frankly, I'm not the biggest, right? [00:29:55] There's other very big routing nodes that are just, I think that you want to have competition because otherwise it does become centralized. There's definitely been something to opening up channels to people you know or people you know on Twitter and stuff. I would be on the receiving end of more criticism if there weren't so many large routing nodes. [00:30:18] So I think that as long as we continue on this path, it's not like any one of us is critical to the network's functionality. And also, it's not harmful. Now, one of the issues is that we don't have an actuarial assessment of what percentage, like what's Pierre's uptime going to be. [00:30:43] And we could have a problem where essentially if one routing node, not necessarily mine but hypothetically one routing node just turns out to be so reliable that everyone just connects to them and it makes sense from an efficiency perspective because that's how you would minimize routing fees and then they become like... [00:31:08] I can't imagine how you could beat someone on availability when there's such a low barrier to entry, right? Yeah. So I completely agree. So I think that that's why we're not in this scenario. But one could imagine that kind of scenario. [00:31:27] But I also think that that's what drives also that there are so many large routing nodes, is that they do out-compete others on reliability. Now, it's not the hardest thing in the world to do, but also it screens out a lot of other routing nodes. [00:31:47] Yeah, it's not the hardest thing in the world to do yet. But the competition will definitely heat up. And I've been thinking for a while now about trying to get into the routing node game because it's still, like the opportunity is just so, the upside is so immense still because it's still so early. You know well so i think that people will make money by selling things not by from routing fees like i really don't think that i like routing fees will be i don't want to say break even or whatever but i think that all the other ancillary [00:32:25] Services that are around being a routing note will matter more than the routing fees themselves like so for example it's just like something you could sort of like tack on if you're a yeah a bitcoin service yeah then you might like say hey you can also route through our node and maybe make a little bit of change in addition yeah in my case if you go to lightningpowerusers.com you can request that i open a channel with you and provide you with inbound capacity so i charge for that and i'll make way more i have already made way more from that than from routing fees. [00:32:58] So I think that services like that, and I have a laundry list that I want to go through and implement and charge people for because they're useful and it's a scarce resource, and also make them open source, integrate them into BTCPay Server so that others can be doing the same so that we can have a very vibrant ecosystem of routing nodes that are providing for users of the Lightning Network. [00:33:28] Very cool. Very cool. All right. So let's shift focus and talk a bit about a couple of particular challenges that the Lightning Network is facing and a couple of proposed solutions. So first up is the problem of onboarding new users onto the Lightning Network quickly, but also prioritizing self-sovereignty. [00:33:49] And this is the problem that you hope BIP-157, which is also known as Neutrino, will help solve. Can you describe the problem you're seeing as the operator of Lightning Power Users Node and the node launcher that has you supporting BIP-157? [00:34:11] Yeah, so right now the UX with the node launcher is that you open the application and Bitcoin, the full node has to sync before you can use the Lightning network. So typically that'll take anywhere from like six hours to two weeks based on the person's internet connection because the Bitcoin full node has to do what's called initial block download. [00:34:36] Initial block download starts with the Genesis block in 2009 and then processes more than 500,000 blocks subsequent to that. That they are all following the consensus rules that are implemented in the implementation that you are using of the Bitcoin protocol. [00:34:59] So that process takes a while. Mostly, usually the bottleneck is people's bandwidth. So if you're on fiber and you have a very good Internet connection, then your bottleneck will generally be your hard drive or your CPU. Yeah. [00:35:18] Now, or your RAM. So basically the Node Launcher, yeah, so that's what ends up taking so long. And people will kind of get frustrated and go online and find a custodial wallet like Blue Wallet and sign up for that and then instantly be using the Lightning Network using a custodial wallet that is centralized. [00:35:46] And they might think that they're using the Lightning Network, but they're not really using the Lightning Network. They're using a service that is using the Lightning Network, which we can debate about. But anyway. It's the spectrum of self-sovereignty and all that. Yeah, but I'm dissatisfied with this situation for one simple reason, is that I don't think it has to be this way. [00:36:08] What I think that we could have with the Node Launcher is you download the Node Launcher, you open it, and it uses a light client technology called BIP-157 or Neutrino. And this light client technology would over Tor connect to my light client server and allow them to allow the node launcher user to be on Lightning in a matter of minutes using the light client as the backend. [00:36:39] Now, at the same time, the full Bitcoin node does start syncing. And when the full Bitcoin node is finished syncing, then the LND with the Lightning node will restart and use the full node as the backend instead of the Litecoin. [00:36:58] So what this allows us is to have a rapid onboarding while also having the user progress to a trustless state of affairs. In between that time, so while the initial block download is happening, and the user's client is, or I guess, LND is connected to your full node, right? [00:37:23] Correct. Or a full node that's serving up block filters. 150, yeah. Filters, yeah. So they'll get the filters from you. And that basically is like a representation of what's in a block. Correct. So, yeah, what the filter allows you to do is that, so basically my Bitcoin full node server sends your like client a filter and you can cryptographically query that filter using a transaction that you are looking for. [00:37:54] And if the transaction is in that filter, it'll just return true. And then you'll go and download the full block and then get the actual transaction out of the block. Now, so the benefit being that you only have to download the blocks that have your transactions, right? Exactly, yeah. Okay, cool. And so—so this is—BIP-157 is an improvement on the current SPV or light client protocol that we use now, which is BIP-37 mostly, for the most part, I guess. [00:38:28] Right. That's the most common. And from what I understand, the main differences are, there's a big privacy difference because in BIP-157, your server is sending the filter to you to kind of query. And in BIP-37, it's the opposite. The client says, hey, these transactions are what I'm interested in or these addresses are what I'm interested in. [00:38:51] And it tries to obscure that a little bit with some randomness, but it doesn't really work that well? That's correct. Okay. Broadly speaking, yeah. [00:39:04] The privacy aspect is a problem. I also just think that the cost on full nodes is a problem too. It's less expensive for the full node to have to generate the its filters once and send them to clients and to have to be you know yeah oh yeah that makes it just makes a lot more sense yeah so what are the chances that this is gonna get merged into core it sounds like it's gaining gaining steam right now yeah 100% cool yeah it's just a matter of time yep okay awesome so yeah [00:39:42] I mean and the reason it's 100% frankly that the creator of the pull requests who also was one of the creators of the 157 itself Jim Poston is just a fantastic software engineer and his his code is just spotless and well I mean there's There's been feedback on it, obviously, as with any software. [00:40:05] But in terms of on relative quality, like it's extremely high quality software engineering and it makes it very easy for the maintainers and the other contributors to Bitcoin Core to feel confident that they can merge this in. And now there is the only blocker to getting this merged in would have been if it was on by default, which had opposition to that. [00:40:32] So it is off by default and you have to manually turn it on and to be able to surf up the filters. But I think that's a perfectly acceptable state of view. Yeah. So you can just you can opt in to provide neutrino filters to like lines. That makes sense. Yeah. Well, I'm looking forward to that, and I will be a neutrino filter provider. [00:40:57] All right. So the next second issue facing Lightning I want to talk about is incoming liquidity, all right, inbound capacity. I know, like you've mentioned already, you've been helping early adopters on the Lightning Network with this issue. You have a service, and I think there's, what was the other one, BitRefill maybe, that offered service as well yeah it's their services called Thor and then last week or was it this week I can't keep track of time now Lightning Labs came out with loop right yeah and that's what I wanted to talk about so Lightning Loop will [00:41:36] Basically well yeah you want to do you want to describe your understanding of how of how Lightning Loop is supposed to yeah yeah so basically let's say you are a merchant that is receiving Bitcoin for and selling goods or services. You're using BTC pay server and you're using LND inside of BTC pay server. [00:41:58] And so people are able to have just a fantastic checkout experience. And the problem you're having is that you're having your—so let's say Lightning Power Users opens a channel with you, and that way you have inbound capacity for satoshis. You get orders that come in. As they come in, you have less and less inbound capacity and more and more outbound capacity. So what, Loop will allow you to do is—now one thing you could do would be like, all right, let's close the channel… [00:42:36] With pierre with lightning power users and let's have him open a new one so that we reset things basically and when we close the channel the funds on-chain. Anything that was still inbound capacity goes back to me, but ideally, we would close it when it's 100% on your end. [00:42:57] And then I open a channel with more inbound capacity too. So that's two on-chain transactions, right? What Loop allows you to do is do that in one on-chain transaction by doing what's called a reverse submarine swap. So I'm glad they came up name because it was a bit hard to. [00:43:18] But basically the idea is that there will be more off-chain payments that happen, but one less on-chain transaction where basically I would... So let me get this straight. So basically you, the merchant, now have a bunch of outbound capacity. [00:43:41] So you send that outbound capacity to the loop server, and then you'll have an on-chain transaction, and it's atomic, so there's no chance of them cheating you. And then you have an on-chain transaction paying you those funds on-chain. [00:44:00] And now the channel only has inbound capacity for you, the merchant, because you consumed all of the outbound capacity, sending it to Lightning Power users. Then sent it that routed that payment to the loop server that is doing the atomic swab on chain. [00:44:19] So you added more off chain payments, but you got rid of one on chain transaction, which is a big win. And is yet another. So those are the two options I just described. There's a third one where basically you try to rebalance between your channels, merchant, right? [00:44:41] Because they're just, their problem is that they're only getting it in one direction. For routing nodes that are sending and receiving in both directions, they have more opportunities where they're trying to rebalance between their own channels. And so basically, there's a Python script out there that allows you to say, all right, I want less inbound capacity on this channel and more inbound capacity on this channel. [00:45:09] Let's try to find a route that will make that happen. Very cool. Now, I haven't used it systematically yet, and I'd really like to, but when I used it ad hoc, just manually typing things in and kind of poking at it, I ended up paying a lot in routing fees because I think that it's basically the case that for the large routing nodes, are pretty efficient so you're often you know maybe better off opening a channel with an on-chain transaction then trying to use them to rebalance [00:45:47] …your channels because they are paying or charging competitive routing fees. It's really cool that that's, like, that that's already the case at this early stage. Yeah. Now I, I—that was anecdotal. Like it might—if I start collecting data and I see that, like, oh no, it's not the case—like I definitely want, in either case, I want to come out with a Medium post kind of describing this, but I just haven't gotten around to it. I've got a long—longer—yeah, I can imagine. I can imagine. So the, the Loop technology then is going to be mostly, or at least like, there's, there's kind of two, two versions… [00:46:25] Of it or two I guess aspects of loop There's a loop out and loop in. And loop out is what they launched for testing last week. And that's mostly going to be useful for merchants or people who are receiving on the Lightning Network so that they can get inbound capacity again. And this kind of technology and the fact that even this is possible is a really good signal. [00:46:51] Because it just basically reinforces all of the claims that these problems that Lightning Network is facing are coding problems and math problems. We can figure this stuff out and automate it. And the Lightning Network that we have five, 10 years from now is going to be much less manual, much more automated, all kind of written into software and put behind a beautiful user interface. [00:47:20] Yeah, that's exactly right. And I became persuaded of that at the Lightning Residency when we were kind of talking about the current challenges and then the opportunities that are ahead for adapting and evolving the protocol. And we're already seeing changes that are just making it better. [00:47:39] And I think we've barely scratched the surface. I think that by the time, you know, let's say in like 20 years when I think I'm fairly confident that Lightning will be very widely used and widely accepted as a payments network, that it will just be a very lean and efficient machine that functions in a completely automated manner. [00:48:06] And we're just hugely benefiting from all that automation. Liquidity, yeah. So, like, there, I, I don't know what the economics end up looking like, but yeah, I—my, my controversial, hot take is that every Bitcoin UTXO that is in existence will be on Lightning, and there really won't be anyone, holding BTC that's not on, on Lightning. Oh, really? The whole, like the whole system will move to the second layer? Every, every UTXO that, yeah, that someone—have been moved onto… [unclear] [00:48:44] From the chain, and put onto an off-chain transaction. Right, and there'll still be plenty of on-chain transactions happening to support mining. Right, it'll just be inputs or closing channels, outputs or opening channels. Interesting, which kind of makes sense if you look at the analogy of TCP IP and BTCLN. [00:49:04] Yep. Because basically everything happens over IP, you know yeah yeah yeah makes sense awesome that's super exciting i love that vision of the future and i'm on board i'm here for it all right so let's talk a bit about a bit more about your experience personal experience you know building the node launcher and lightning power users one of our listeners wanted me to ask you because he's a bitcoiner who is learning to code right now. [00:49:40] And I think that's kind of a trend, which is cool. I know Justin Moon talked about this or talks about, I've heard him talk about a couple of times that, you know, he kind of made the assumption that he was going to kind of go out and teach coders about Bitcoin. And the market kind of came back and said, nope, actually Bitcoiners want to learn how to code from you. [00:49:59] It's the other way around. Yeah. And that just, I see that happening too, anecdotally around me. So he wanted me to ask you if you could talk about your transition from like what you were doing before which I think was like accounting work yep yeah into coding like when did you start learning to code what resources did you use any tips or advice that you have for Bitcoiners who are looking to start coding yeah absolutely so I went to college and got a bachelor's and master's degree in accounting. [00:50:33] And then I worked at Deloitte in auditing, well, doing performing attestation services for new issuances of securitization deals. And this was like after the financial crisis and all that. So it wasn't as cool as before. But in any case, I started learning how to code kind of the summer between graduating from grad school and going to Deloitte where I wanted to write Bitcoin accounting software. [00:51:03] I was already interested in Bitcoin. And as an accountant, it was like, when people have like a real estate background or a financial services background, like they'll be like, oh, let's put real estate on the blockchain or let's put securities on the blockchain. Or if they have like a medical background, they're like, oh, let's put medical records on the blockchain. [00:51:23] But I just had an accounting background. So I was like, oh, let's put Bitcoin into accounting software. And I think that ultimately that was a much more pragmatic approach. So I went on Codecademy and I learned Python, my first steps in Python from their tutorials. [00:51:44] And then I went through a tutorial on how to use Flask, which is a Python web framework. And when I created my first interactive application that used a SQL database, Flask, and then like front end like HTML and CSS, I was like, wow, I just created a web page. [00:52:04] And I can pretty much do anything with this combination of tools because that's really any web service is just that. It's a website, a web server, and a database. Now, obviously, there's a bunch of fancy crap that you can add to it to make it web scale. But in any case, I got very hooked onto software development and also just wanted to learn more about advanced topics like object-oriented programming, functional programming, and all these different theories that have come out with relational [00:52:42] Databases. [00:52:47] Anyway, I got fascinated by that world, but I spent a lot of time banging my head against things because software development is that. Here's a problem. Overcome it. [00:53:05] Here's the next problem. Overcome it. Here's the next problem. Overcome it. Now, ideally, it takes you less and less time to figure out a problem because you get better at how to figure out a problem. So in any case, there are better websites now than Codecademy. But I would still recommend Python as someone's first language. [00:53:26] I would still recommend Flask as someone's first web framework. And then for their SQL database, I'd recommend PostgreSQL. And then there's a Python library called SQLAlchemy, which allows you to connect your web application with your SQL database. [00:53:46] And that's the stack I would recommend to anyone that's new because it's so powerful. And I also wrote a Medium post called, let's see, Understanding the Technical Side of Bitcoin. Because so now this this starts out with like how to use the command line how to use git how to use like the bitcoin command line so like bitcoin cli how to use the lightning cli and then also then how to start learning how to program because i think that like some familiarity with the command line is is helpful i [00:54:24] Would argue that people should not get too much familiarity with the command line. Otherwise, they lose touch with the users. I've seen that happen a lot with developers, but I don't want to name names. And yeah, I mean, I don't like the command line. So I love graphical user interfaces, and that's why I created the node launcher so that I wouldn't have to use the command line to do what I was doing. [00:54:47] And so that's where I would recommend learning how to code, is something like Codecademy. Justin Moon actually has a different recommendation than Codecademy; I'd have to hunt that down. But in any case, the only problem with Codecademy now—I think everything is paywalled because they got so popular. But this is an area where I think it makes sense to invest money in learning things. It's like, invest in yourself. And I strongly believe that. I've bought too many $100 programming books… [unclear] [00:55:25] Really enjoying them and getting a lot from them. So I've never regretted spending money on software development education. And Cook Academy is pretty reasonable. And so it's a bit of boot camp with Justin. Yeah. And I mean, the cost is going to be recouped because obviously demand just keeps rising. [00:55:47] Yeah. I mean, like there's the career aspect of it, like you could make more money if you were programming. [00:55:56] Personal improvement and like your ability to create your own personal projects on the side on the weekend that then like you're contributing to the ecosystem and you're helping improve Bitcoin, which you might be invested in financially. So or ideologically. [00:56:14] Right. And so there is kind of an aspect of like people wanting to learn how to program because they want to help. Not necessarily even because they're trying to like advance their own career or anything like that although that's a very nice side effect of wanting to help true true so have you dabbled in using like actually coding up websites to accept lightning payments i mean did you get oh yeah so custom coded all that stuff on on the front page of lightningpowerusers.com right yeah so that That is some very artisanal, hand-woven [00:56:52] Software development on my end. Yeah, I wrote all that. I learned a lot doing that. And I want to teach others about what I've learned. So I'm going to be doing training sessions. One is going to be before the Consensus Conference here in New York in May. [00:57:11] On Saturday, I'll be teaching developers, but also people who are interested in becoming developers. Light on the code and very heavy on the Lightning concepts, and like—because the Lightning LND, from Lightning Labs comes with a very nice API that you can program against. So you don't even really need to know that much about software development to use this, because you can get a lot done with a few lines of code. Yeah. So as long as you can read English and understand, like, kind of what a for loop does, then I think that, you can definitely fit in at one of these, and… [00:57:51] Yeah, there's—once, once you've kind of figured it out, it's pretty easy to code up integrations for sending and receiving Lightning payments. Well, knock on wood, I haven't gotten hacked yet, so I don't know about the security side. I'm not a security expert by any means, but I haven't had my money drained out of my—yeah, yeah, which is, you know, probably a testament to—yeah, absolutely. [00:58:21] They put a lot of effort in making sure that the Lightning Node implementations are robust versus network adversaries and not open to bugs or vulnerabilities. But who knows, like there could end up being some. So far, the only vulnerabilities have been kind of denial of service attacks using up resources. [00:58:45] Haven't heard of any kind of like we were able to take a bunch of Bitcoin out of someone's channel. Right. Just taking some nodes down. I think that happened like middle of last year, like a couple hundred nodes got taken down from a denial of service attack, basically. Which obviously we should take seriously, but it didn't cause a loss of funds as far as I know. [00:59:05] Right, right. OK. Two questions left. [00:59:14] First, just to kind of wrap up on Lightning, obviously, besides BIP-157, what do you think are some of the most important features or capabilities that Lightning can add over the next year or two? Well, so in terms of base layer improvements, BIP-157 is technically it's not part of it's not a change to the Bitcoin protocol in the sense of like the consensus rules like CLTV and CSV and SegWit were. [00:59:44] But I do think that there are other base protocol improvements that will be happening. So there's one—will enable eltoo, which is basically an alternative model for how to enforce these Lightning contracts. And the advantage of this model is that it doesn't have a punishment component to it. The disadvantage is that it requires a soft fork to add an opcode. And I think that we'll eventually see that happen. I don't know the exact timing on it because it's still being discussed. And then on the… [01:00:23] Signature side, Schnorr is going to be an improvement and being able to do Schnorr with signature aggregation is also going to be an improvement in terms of the economics of Lightning. So we've got that to look forward to. [01:00:42] But on the Lightning side, we've got Wumbo, which is going to be so that two nodes can opt in to open a channel of arbitrary size. So you could have a 500 Bitcoin channel between two massive exchanges, and they're just shifting balances back and forth. That'd be really cool. [01:01:02] Wumbo, and then... Is that like a dual-funded channel then? So dual funded channel is also a thing that's going to be in the next iteration of the Lightning protocol in 1.1. But it's not, yeah, they're not tied together, but they're coming out together. [01:01:22] And the other thing will be, I briefly mentioned Atomic Multipath, which is basically that you can send one payment and it can be routed through different routes. That will allow you to minimize your routing fee and also help you avoid imbalancing your channels too much. [01:01:43] That's kind of like how IP works too, right? So it's almost a more true version of payments as packets, I guess. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, okay, cool. Yeah, so I think that those already are going to be huge. Now, there's also going to be additions to the implementations themselves So, for example, for LND, they're going to be coming out with a better system for monitoring your node, which is basically going to provide a bunch of real-time data that then you can consume in a structured manner. [01:02:18] So that's exciting for people who are running routing nodes and trying to get all this data together. Then the other, the other aspects of it are kind of the—like I think that there's a bunch of small low-hanging fruit that can be picked. So for example, one of my frustrations has been the inconsistency in naming things. And so I think they're—like simple things, like pubkey is pub_key or one word, pubkey. It's not consistent across the ecosystem. I think that things like that kind of need… [01:02:56] To find an equilibrium where it helps developers be more productive. And, yeah, I think that there's a lot of people experimenting with Lightning applications, Lightning games, and trying to use the Lightning protocol in new and novel ways, which is exciting. [01:03:19] I think that's where, like, the creativity of, you know, the next killer app. We don't know what the next lightning trust chain is going to be, but it's just going to like emerge from the ecosystem because there's so many smart people who are creative people working on different projects that it's just, you know, a matter of the odds. [01:03:41] And then in terms of like wider lightning adoption, I think that's just going to be the consequence of the Bitcoin price coming up. So we saw during past bull markets, what happens is that people who bought Bitcoin before the bull market started, they suddenly have this wealth effect where they want to go spend Bitcoin because they made a big value appreciation. [01:04:07] So they could go on an exchange and sell their Bitcoin and then go spend the fiat. Or more conveniently and with better privacy, they can just spend the Bitcoin directly with a merchant using either on-chain or off-chain. I think that that's going to lead to more velocity on the Lightning Network. [01:04:27] And on top of that, the base layer blocks are almost full at this point. So I think that with the next full market, blocks will be full. And there will be a lot of fee pressure. And that's going to drive even more people onto the Lightning Network. And yeah, so I think that it's got a very exciting 18 months ahead of it. [01:04:48] That's awesome. All right. So let's really expand the time horizon for the last question. Yeah. Let's say 50 years from now, what does a Bitcoin future look like to you? Oh, man, it's so utopian. So, yeah, I think that, first of all, all fiat currencies have been entirely replaced by Bitcoin. [01:05:11] BTC is basically the only unit of account, medium exchange, that is used. It has deflated assets that were stores of value like housing or paintings and whatever because now it just makes more sense to store your value in BTC. And then on the payments side everyone's using Lightning. [01:05:37] Very few if any are using on-chain. And Lightning is just a like almost a kind of, I don't know how to say it without sounding like religious about it, but it would just be such a nice public service, like a big utility essentially, because it's this open source decentralized network that dramatically lowers the transaction costs of human commerce. [01:06:12] And so now you have people able to send payments from anywhere in the world to anywhere else instantly at a very low fee with no middlemen, which is like that's the vision we were all working towards from the beginning. Right. And so that, I think, is just going to be a huge boon to humanity, even if you take out the sound money from the equation. [01:06:36] So you combine the two, the sound money and the just fantastic economics of this payments network. And I think that the next 50 years are going to be looked at as kind of a renaissance, like a rebirth of human optimism and creativity and prosperity. [01:06:58] The Bitcoin renaissance. Exactly. Talked with Ansel Lindner about that a few episodes ago. After the dark ages of modernity, where we had crackheads littering the streets and just a kind of degrading of society, of politics, of morals. [01:07:20] But anyway, yeah, I'm excited about the next 50 years. So am I. What do you think? How does Bitcoin, I mean, that's sort of the economic impact. How does Bitcoin affect sociopolitics in your mind? How do we organize society in a Bitcoin world? Well, I think that that's downstream of economics. [01:07:42] Yeah, definitely. In the sense that I think the reason things have gotten as bad as they have is because the economics of fiat actually made sense. Where basically the US dollar had to have a monetary policy that was just good enough to stay afloat versus gold, but otherwise could print as much as it wanted, right? [01:08:04] As much as it wants. And so the reason it can do that is because of the much lower transaction costs of dealing with the U.S. Dollar than with physical gold. So once we do away with that with Bitcoin and Bitcoin kind of replaces the dollar, I think that it changes the economics of sovereign nations. [01:08:29] In the sense that now they no longer have the ability to abuse seniorage to provide, you know, essentially an inflation tax that takes from people who hold their currency in order to subsidize politically connected or or I mean, they might be subsidizing like legitimate social programs. [01:08:52] Right. Like that are voted for by the populace and popular. But in any case, it removes that inflation tax and makes it so that the government now has to go and get the revenues by an actual tax, right? An actual income tax or consumption tax or property tax or whatever it is. [01:09:15] And they can no longer rely on the seignorage from the currency debasement. So that's kind of on that end of the monetary equation. On the payment side of the equation, we have a dramatic change in the flow of information in the payment system. Today, and specifically in the US, the banking system has total and complete visibility into all financial transactions that are moving money around except for $100 bills, except for actual physical cash. [01:09:50] Right. Right. And so that means that they have been deputized by governments in order to enforce these anti money laundering laws. And basically anti money like money laundering itself, in my opinion, like it doesn't really make sense that it is a crime. [01:10:10] I think that what you're doing that's related to the money is a crime. So like if you are trafficking slaves, then that's the crime. I think that the money like aspect of it is is just a convenient way of getting them in jail. Right. [01:10:28] And I don't think that's how a just society should function. And I don't think that's how an honest legal system should function. I think an honest legal system should punish people for immoral or unjust things or violations of other people's property rights. Or abhorrent acts that they've committed. [01:10:47] I think that people should be punished for the bad that they've done, not for, oh, here's this bureaucratically convenient way that we can get them on a technicality. Because I think that taking that shortcut is corrosive to the legitimacy of judicial institutions and is corrosive to the law and jurisprudence. [01:11:11] So I think that To the extent that Bitcoin makes it so that we remove all the payments from third parties, then governments can no longer abuse third parties by either deputizing them as law enforcement or by having the ability to easily get the data because courts have ruled that there's no reasonable expectation of privacy from using a financial institution, which I think on its face is absurd. [01:11:44] If you're using a financial institution, you should have a reasonable expectation of privacy. They should protect your data from others. But there's kind of a principal agent problem, right? Where it's more profitable for them not to. And the government, it's more convenient for them not to. [01:12:05] And so judges have ruled that way. I think that it is, from a legal perspective, kind of an abomination and a huge disappointment that we've gone in this direction in society. And we need to restore, frankly, what our founding fathers and many, many people since lost their lives for or put their lives at risk for, which is the protection of our property from a government that is trying to raise money in unjust ways so [01:12:43] Like there's, you know, all sorts of provisions in the Bill of Rights. But the very important one, I think it's the Fourth Amendment, right? Which is against, search and seizure. That, you know—so in any case, what Lightning allows us to do is remove the third parties. So then now, if they want to get records regarding payments, they have to come to your home and actually serve a search warrant. That is a much higher—it's more difficult… [01:13:21] To get one than to get one on a bank, right? Because of that presumption of privacy, you do have the presumption of privacy in your private home. And then they have to seize your computer. Now, maybe it's encrypted. So now they have to maybe get your password, but that's, You know, as we saw with the Apple iPhone and the controversy with the FBI around that, it's not a given that you have to give your password either because of your right to not self-incriminate. [01:13:48] So the bank, they don't they're not going to plead the fifth for you. That's something only you can do. And so by moving all of your payments data back to your personal effects and your personal belongings, now not only do you have the protection from the expectation of privacy, but you also have Fifth Amendment protection and the right to not incriminate yourself. [01:14:15] So you withholding your password could arguably fall into that. Now, maybe they'll get tested and whatnot. But in any case, what that means is that it dramatically changes the economics of actual taxation. Because almost all money laundering is for tax evasion. [01:14:34] Almost none of it is for terrorism, obviously. Like, how much money do terrorists have? Like, they don't even need that much money. They're hijacking a plane and crashing it. Anyway, so that's trivial. Drug dealing is bigger, but I also think all drugs should be legalized. [01:14:53] And also, if we actually looked at who's doing the most drug trafficking, I wouldn't be totally surprised if there's a lot of state actors involved who otherwise crack down on money laundering, but they themselves are doing quite a bit of money laundering. In any case... [01:15:15] Yeah, I don't have any concrete evidence of it, and I don't necessarily want any evidence of it just for my own life. But in any case, I think that... So put aside the terrorism, the drugs, and all the terrible things that get listed by politicians and by bureaucrats, the real issue with money laundering is tax evasion. [01:15:39] And if with Bitcoin, if at equilibrium, well, we have more people who have more financial privacy, and thus they are able to evade more taxes—now I'm not saying anyone should evade taxes, because if you get caught there are dire consequences, and I wouldn't want that for you personally or for your family or for your finances. Like, the IRS has ways of catching people who evade taxes. My argument is that [unclear] are more expensive than the current way of just getting all your bank records from your bank. [01:16:13] So to the extent that at equilibrium, we have more tax evasion. And the higher taxes are, the more tax evasion we have. So now I think that governments are becoming in a very difficult position where they can no longer rely on the inflation tax and their ability to tax people has been diminished due to the increase in privacy. [01:16:39] And now they are in a position where they have to actually provide services. They actually have to have legitimacy so that their ability to tax is not completely impaired. So that, you know, people will actually say, hey, it's good to pay your taxes because we get fantastic services from these organizations. [01:17:03] And we're happy to voluntarily pay our taxes, even though, well, while it's illegal, we could evade our taxes relatively easily. Right. And so, yeah, it means that governments have to be more accountable. And I think that, yes, whether you're a Democrat or Republican, a conservative, a libertarian or liberal or progressive, you should. [01:17:28] Everyone should want accountable government. Right. What we don't want, everyone doesn't want authoritarian government that is unaccountable, that does whatever it wants, right? That's what we don't want as a society. That's what we all don't want. [01:17:46] Yeah, it seems self-evident to me. And so if you are a progressive that wants government to have a big role, then it is government's responsibility to demonstrate to the population that it can take on a big role and execute its functions in an efficient manner that provides the services that everyone wants at a cost that is appropriate and legitimate. [01:18:09] So I think that to that extent, we'll see governments become better institutions. And if they don't become better institutions, then they become institutions that are diminished in power and importance and have to advocate their role to private sector institutions. And so I think that we'll see small tyrannical governments that are, you know, kind of like back in the day, you would have like, you know, princes that have a little amount of territory and they're they're kind of jerks. [01:18:42] But that's why they don't become very big and they don't have a lot of power. On the other hand, like we might also have very large, powerful democracies like, you know, Scandinavian countries where like everyone gets along and everyone is going for a common purpose. Or Singapore is kind of like this as well. [01:19:02] Now, they've been accused of having some issues with authoritarianism. But by and large, the government is competent and efficient and thus people are willing to give it a lot of responsibility. That's fine. That sounds perfectly reasonable to me, Pierre. [01:19:21] That's almost too reasonable, actually. That sounds, in this day and age of political rhetoric, maybe the most reasonable thing I've heard in a long time. Yeah, and our politics is really spun out of control. And I try not to keep up with it too much, but I do occasionally see things, whether you know it's tweets that i see or clips from cable news and i think to myself we are very fortunate right now that the people who are going to be most undermined by bitcoin are so [01:19:59] Distracted yes yeah it's true we're sort of flying under the flying under the radar still even though completely under the radar and let's keep in mind like even even at the end of with the massive bull market. Everyone in the political realm was so distracted that they didn't really think about Bitcoin much at all. [01:20:22] And so as long as it stays that way, then we're just not going to see legislation go through that tries to ban Bitcoin or anything like that. Yeah. Yep. And we just got to keep our heads down and keep working and grinding this thing out. And it's coming along and it's super exciting. I think we can wrap it up and end it right there. [01:20:43] Is there anything that you'd like to share with the listeners before we? Yeah, absolutely. So go to my, well, go to lightningpowerusers.com. On the left, you'll see install Juul. [01:21:01] Click that button and it'll take you to my Medium post. There is a guide on how to get yourself set up on the Bitcoin and Lightning network. And work through that tutorial. Read it carefully. Every sentence is in there for a reason. And it's because someone's tripped up on it before. And right now, you know, it's still kind of an involved process. [01:21:25] But I'm still working on the Node Launcher. I'm iterating. The next version is going to be even simpler. It's going to continue to get simpler and faster. So keep an eye out for improvements. Check out my Twitter account, @pierre_rochard. I'm very excited about where I'm going with the node launcher and then if you need some inbound capacity go to lightningpowerusers.com and have me open the channel to you Absolutely, and visit satoshinakamotoinstitute.org and read it from start to finish if you haven't yet, just make it like a goal to read a post a [01:22:03] Day or a week or something and just get through all of that between that page and like jamesonlops slash Bitcoin. I think he actually has a better domain name, Bitcoin.page. Those two websites will basically teach you everything you know about Bitcoin. Yeah. And speaking of the Nakamoto Institute, we're having the second annual dinner for the Nakamoto Institute in Dallas. [01:22:27] It's going to be not part of, but adjacent to the BitLock Boom Conference. And the BitLock Boom Conference I went to last year and spoke at, and it was just a fantastic, very well-organized conference in Dallas, Texas. This year, it's August 17th and 18th. [01:22:47] The Nagama Institute annual dinner will be on the evening of the 16th, so on Friday before the conference. At the conference will be Tone Vase, Jimmy Song, St. Ferdinand Moose, myself, Michael Goldstein, Marty Bett, Peter McCormack, Justin Moon, a bunch of people that, frankly, there's also new people that you should meet because there's a lot of people that are kind of, they're not under the radar, but they're not as big of a loud mouse as we are on Twitter. [01:23:23] But they're more intelligent than we are, and so you definitely want to meet them. So I highly recommend going to BitBlockBoom conference, sorry, BitBlockBoom.com and get yourself tickets to the conference. Ask Michael Goldstein about going to the Nakamoto Institute dinner. [01:23:42] He'll get you set up for that. And then tickets seem to be going up in price. So right now, general admission ticket is $270. And yeah. Well, there's a hard cap, right? On the number of tickets. Yeah, there is. [01:24:01] There's only 125 that will be sold. So get in on that presale. Use the promo code SNI so that we get credit for that and help support the Nakamura Institute. So yeah, I'm looking forward to that. It's going to be a lot of fun. It was so much fun last year. We were like up until 3 a.m. At the hotel bar, drunk and talking about monetary economics. [01:24:23] With Safedine. That's where you want to be at in August. I'm thinking really hard about driving down there trying to figure out the logistics. We just bought tickets for the Bitcoin 2019 conference in San Francisco in June. I'll be there as well. Definitely all you listeners out there, go to that conference as well. [01:24:43] I'll be speaking about Lightning. [01:24:46] And that actually, [01:24:49] I don't know if this is public yet, but it will be public soon enough. There's going to be a bus that's going to drive from LA to San Francisco and then back to LA. It did before the conference and then after the conference, it's going to be an eight hour bus ride. It's going to be a bunch of Bitcoiners and, I think, you know, Brecky on Twitter. [01:25:13] Yeah. Yeah. So he's helping organize it. It's going to be a lot of fun. That sounds pretty great. All right. Well, yeah, it's going to be open to the public. About Bitcoin until 3 a.m. In San Francisco, Pierre. Absolutely. Absolutely. All right. I'm looking forward to that. And I'm going to try super hard to get down to Bitblog Boom 2. [01:25:33] I think I'm going to make it happen. I just got to arrange some personal matters to get down there. Fair enough. But yeah. All right. Thank you so much, Pierre. This was super fun. It's really cool to go from trolling you on Twitter with RBTC bullshit to sitting here talking to you for an hour and a half about Bitcoin just two years later. [01:25:55] It's amazing. Thank you for joining me. Just let it be like a, you know, maybe a example, I guess, to all the listeners out there that, you know, you just got to keep plugging away, keep reading, keep listening and do what you can to learn. Bitcoin will, you know, pay you back. [01:26:14] It incentivizes you to learn about it and to And that's one of the amazing, you know, kind of aspects of its incentive structure. It's just it's a marvel. Every, you know, angle that you look at, the incentive structure is there to help Bitcoin grow and help Bitcoin help humanity, I guess, for, you know, to get right down to it. [01:26:36] Yeah. And thanks for joining the Bitcoin Core Cult, sponsored by Blockstream AXA. Definitely go get your stickers and yeah, work for the lizard people I did get my Blockstream sticker with a lightning node that I set up with the command line early last year and it's proudly sitting on my desk You're completely brainwashed I'm totally brainwashed. [01:27:02] Well, actually today I was in Discord chat with Guy Swann of the Cryptoconomy Podcast, and he and I were talking—listen to your episode with, Stephan Livera and Michael Goldstein, and you guys had kind of joking about the church, like a Church of Bitcoin or Church of Satoshi. So we bought the—he bought the domain name churchofsatoshi.com, and we just went off for like a good 15 minutes on all of the amazing possibilities of the Church of Satoshi, which is just gonna happen. Yeah, I mean like what I was saying with the Bill of Rights, if we get… [01:27:40] The freedom of exercising whatever religion you want, if we get under that umbrella, then all Bitcoin-related regulations now have to come under a different level of judicial review called strict scrutiny, which would be fantastic for us, because now the government would have to really prove that every law is absolutely necessary and that there's no other way of doing things. [01:28:05] So that's very exciting. And I hope that, I mean, frankly, if the weirdos at Scientology can cover religion, we should be able to as well. Yeah, absolutely. And then any of the education slash evangelism that we do with the Church of Satoshi would be completely tax-free, of course. [01:28:29] I think that our Bitcoin gains should also be tax-free, thing to justify. It might be a harder sell. Maybe we'll get there. Alright, well thanks again Pierre and I'm looking forward to meeting you soon. Hope you have a great weekend. Sure thing. Thanks for having me on. Alright, goodnight. Bye. [01:28:55] Well that was fun. I hope you all enjoyed it as well. If you got this far, chances are you liked the show and if that's the moments to rate the Citizen Bitcoin pod wherever you get your podcasts, if you can. We're just getting going and every review right now counts for like 10 later on. So I'm 10 times more thankful if you can do that for us at this point in time. [01:29:18] Thanks to Randy McMillan, Dracius32, and Jimmy Dell for leaving very nice reviews this past week. We really, really appreciate it. Thank you guys. And thank you for joining us for this episode with Pierre Rochard from all over the world. Bitcoin is truly global, even for this little podcast. We're building something amazing here, everyone, and I'm really glad you guys are here. All right, take care out there, Bitcoiners. [01:29:59] Thank you.