Matt Odell: Life, Love, and Bitcoin Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2020-04-17 [00:00:17] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin. Hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, my Bitcoiners? Hope you are well. Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin fucking renaissance. [00:00:35] We've got an all-time epic rip with Matt Odell tonight. Matt already held the honor of the longest Citizen Bitcoin app and we beat it tonight. If you haven't listened to the first one from March 2019, you should fire it up right now to prep for this one. You know, or listen to this one and then that one, whatever you want to do. [00:00:55] Matt and I drank some whiskey, just a little bit of whiskey, and we got into it tonight for well over two hours. I think we went for two hours, 20 minutes. It was epic. Great time. I think you're gonna really love it. So we're gonna expedite this one. I'm just gonna ask one simple question. If you aren't auto-stacking with Swan yet, what the fuck are you waiting for? [00:01:16] I think it might be literally the best time to be stacking sats in the history of Bitcoin, except for maybe that first year or two, and those guys aren't hodling anymore. So you know, just get to stacking. And auto-stacking is the way to go. Saves you a lot of psychological fucking fear and damage, you know. Yan Pritzker and team are improving the product every day. [00:01:36] I'm absolutely in awe of them. Just 17 days after the launch, we already have Swan Stackers taking one million dollars worth of sweet sats off the market every year. So get in the damn game, y'all. SwanBitcoin.com. Alright, here we go. [00:01:54] The unedited whiskey rip with my buddy Matt. Enjoy. Oh, damn man. It's been a long week, been a long day. [00:02:14] Been looking forward to this for a while. It's been too long since I sat down with a buddy and drank some whiskey. Just hung out. I missed the bar. Matt, how you doing, man? What's good? Hell yeah. Doing pretty well over here, all things considered, Brady. Happy to be on the pod again. Ah, welcome back, man. [00:02:33] You still have the record for the longest citizen bitcoin episode. And that was really early. It was like the fifth or sixth interview episode. And we went for about 215. You know, it's been Connor Brown got close, but just couldn't quite make it. [00:02:51] It's gonna it's gonna be hard to beat that rip. That was a pretty epic rip. That was a pretty epic one, man. That was one of my favorite conversations. I really enjoyed the weeks that followed that. You were posting running numbers of what was it, me, Pierre, Marty. Yeah. There's someone else in there too. [00:03:10] We were all nut neck and neck. Yeah, yeah. You know, that was kind of the beginning, and like that was it was sort of a dream, you know. Like, hey man, I'd been recording these conversations with my friend Tommy for like a year, you know, and like getting like 30 or 40 downloads an episode, you know. [00:03:28] It was just me and this dude. We were just sitting down and talking Bitcoin. We thought we'd record it and it would kind of be like this forcing function for us to kind of learn more. And after about a year, I was like, all right, you know, am I gonna really do this or not? You know, I'm just I made a list of the 10 people who I wanted to talk to the most, 10 Bitcoiners want to talk to the most. And I was like, if I can get these 10 people on my podcast, I'll be off to the races, you know. [00:03:51] And shit, it's been a little over a year. Opened up a lot of doors and opportunities for me. Got me this job at Swan. So yeah, man, it's been kind of a whirlwind. Crazy. Crazy, man. Bitcoin moves fast. Happy to be part of the origin story. Cheers for that. [00:04:09] Seriously, that man. Hmm. Yeah, that tastes good. What are you drinking over there? I got Jim Beam, man. I'm just rolling like a pleb tonight because I already drank the good stuff. And I haven't bought out for a while. I did a run like earlier this week, and I got three bottles of McAllen 12. [00:04:31] Nice. I was like, okay, I'm good. I was right, I was running, I was running short, and I just was like, I gotta I gotta make a run. And they were doing like the curbside thing. Yeah. So which kind of sucks because you don't get to peruse. So I just went I went for like the Costco style. Just give me three bottles of 12. [00:04:49] Nice, it was just the easiest thing to think of at the time. This is a good one. And like what do you do? You probably have a few favorites. What are your what are your top three whiskies? Well, obviously, McAllen 12 is one of my go-to's. Yeah. You know, it's usually at bars and stuff, so it's it's a very solid, solid scotch. [00:05:13] I had this quarantine, I've already finished a bottle of Talasker Storm, which I really enjoy. Yeah, I love that one. I heard you mention it on one of the episodes, one of the TFTC episodes recently. And I was actually like I that inspired me to finish the bottle that night. My wife and I sat down and put put on a nice fire, got a nice fire going and had a good whiskey, whiskey conversation. [00:05:36] That's a really good one. I really really enjoyed Taliscar in general. And then I really like LaFroy. That's what we had the first the first recording. When you want that peat. When you want that Pete. Yeah, that's that's the ultimate PD experience right there, the little Freud. [00:05:55] Yeah, man, that was fun. We both bought a bottle of the Freud, popped the cork together. That was a good night, man. Yeah, the saying or like the slogan for LaFroig is dividing opinions since whatever, 18, whatever that when they started distilling that stuff. And some I mean you either love it or you hate it, and that's what they mean by you know it's it's like Bitcoin. [00:06:18] It's like yeah, exactly exactly. It's like Bitcoin. It's dividing opinions. I unfortunately though, well, I guess you have some other choices, but you know, fortunately, like LaFroy just sticks to it, doesn't fork off, you know, like the lovers stay with it. You know, there's a lot of alts out there though. [00:06:39] There's a documentary about Scotch that I saw. I think it's on Amazon Prime. Did you watch that? Yeah, I watched that. That was really good, man. You did your drink while you watched it? Of course. Had to, like, I think it's that's the price of admission, right? It was a great, it was a great doc, but I have to say, it it it did like enable my alcoholism a little bit, you know. [00:07:02] Like I like watched it and I was like, I'm doing my part to further the culture. It was like a rewarding kind of thing. Little justification. Huge justification. I actually watched it with my ladies' family because they throw a yearly Scotch dinner party. [00:07:21] It's called fuck, I forget what it is. It's named after Scott Burns Knight. It's a Scottish poet who loves Scotch. Yeah, yeah. And it happens, I think it either I it happens on his birthday every year. And every person they invited like 25 people. [00:07:39] This was like right before corona, too. So they invite 25 people, and each person brings over a bottle of scotch. So we had like 25 delicious scotches, and we were just we watched the documentary during the day, and we started early. That's amazing, and then like all the people started showing up with like bottle after bottle that we like saw in the documentary. [00:08:00] Damn, that's incredible, man. That is a good idea. I'm gonna have to take that idea. It's a great tradition. It's a fantastic tradition. That's amazing, man. Sounds like a good time, and like extra special, extra bonus points that you get to like watch the dock, you know, ahead of time and kind of like transition into the night, man. [00:08:18] So do you guys like cook up a storm too? So you gotta you gotta eat some food if you're gonna be drinking scotch like that. Yeah, it's all Scottish food. Nice. So they like made haggis, and well, it's like you can't make real haggis in America. Okay. There's a banned part of it. I think it's like blood sausage or something. [00:08:38] Oh, right, yeah, yeah. It's like not, it's not FDA or or whatever. Who it's yeah, FDA is the food. The FDA doesn't allow you to do it here. So it's like it's like an alt, it's like an all tag. So we had the all taggus and then shit coin haggis, and then you just have like a bunch of scotch Scottish food, and it's it's a really good time. [00:08:58] It's like Thanksgiving, but but Scottish and lot lots of scotch as you'd expect man shit coin haggis what's going on there I've had some blood sausage before what they call that black black pudding black sausage I don't know it was yeah black pudding black pudding yeah yeah I've had it down in the Caribbean I don't know how it got down there but it was you know I lived in Guyana for a couple years and that that was the thing man it was for special occasions make blood black pudding and it was like you take the casing and fill it up with some random whatever and throw you know put a bunch of blood in there and then [00:09:37] You know it actually tastes pretty good because they put a bunch of like herbs and spices in there it's good shit so there's lots that happened today man you're telling me before we started recording you guys had a bad like unfortunate timing on the on the RHR rip today yeah we recorded RHR and then Marty had a jump on a phone call because we've both been hustling during this during this crisis and while he was on the phone call before he posted the episode BTC pay dropped pay join support which was like huge in the making like we I'm [00:10:15] Super pumped for it and unfortunately purse.io shut down so we missed both of those and then the episode got posted afterwards which is kind of a bummer but at least now we're doing the two week two we're doing two a week a lot of the weeks so now we're gonna have to do one on Monday. Yeah. And just like the first 20 minutes, it'll just be BTC pay. [00:10:36] Nice, nice. Yeah, that's a big drop man. That's a huge deal. I know that they've been working on that for a long time. Are there other I mean widespread implementations of page join yet? Or is this the first like major one that'll get a join join market has pay join? Yep. And Samurai has pay join, but they're not cross-compatible. [00:10:58] You with join market, you can pay join with another join market user, and with Samurai, you can pay join with another Samurai user. And right now, and neither of them right now are compatible with BTC Pay's implementation. BTC Pay, you can pay join with another BTC pay wallet. I thought it was supposed to be standardized, like under BIP21 and well, it looks like a bunch, it looks like a bunch of wallets are gonna add support for BTC Pay's implementation. [00:11:26] Right. Like I know Blockstream helps sponsor Mr. Kooks, who who did the majority of the work, I believe, on Pay join. Shout out Mr. Cooksman. So I imagine we'll see it in Blockstream Green Wallet pretty soon, which is cross-platform mobile. [00:11:45] So that that's like a huge, huge integration. And supposedly blue wallet's gonna integrate it as well. Nice. So yeah, hopefully we see some cross-compatibility here. But regardless, like the beauty of pay join is it looks like a regular transaction, but the inputs come from from both the sender and the receiver. [00:12:07] Usually in a transaction, it just comes from the sender. So because it looks like a regular transaction, but the inputs aren't all from the sender as usual. It basically it destroys that heuristic. If it's used even a decent amount of times. Yeah, it completely destroys the heuristic. [00:12:26] When you look on the chain, you don't know if it's a pay join transaction or not. So you don't know who this, you know, which UTXOs are the senders. So like in chain chain analysis, they call it the common input ownership assumption. So they assume that inputs into a transaction are owned by the same, you know, the same user, right? [00:12:48] Because they almost always are except in a page one transaction or in these new coin join implementations, yeah. Where you obviously have, but in those you have multiple equal equal inputs and multiple equal outputs. So it's like it's kind of obvious that it's a coordinated coin join. [00:13:08] Yeah. Even though you could theoretically do that with yourself and no one would know. Like in Samurai, they have a two-person equal output coin join mode, and they also have a mode that just simulates the two-person. Oh, really? So you could just coin join with yourself, and there's no way to know whether or not a second person was involved there, or it's it's harder to tell if the second person was involved there. [00:13:31] So that's very creative. But with Page join, it looks like just a straight, it looks like the same exact it looks like a regular transaction. Yeah, so if all right, so here's the description from the block stream blog post, because it was like originally conceived by some people who like came together at a like a block stream, you know, like work event or whatever. [00:13:55] They got together for a week and hashed out a bunch of stuff, and like so this is what they say. So if Alice wants to pay Bob one BTC, Alice inputs three Bitcoin into a transaction, Bob inputs five. Alice receives two as her change, and Bob receives six as his change plus the one BTC payment from Alice. [00:14:17] So it breaks that common input ownership heuristic and can be interpreted in many different ways, right? So one way it could be like you know, Alice paying Bob six BTC, inputting a total of ABTC to herself and inputs you know of three and five to BTC to Bob, et cetera. But there's like five or six ways that it could work, and so you can't assume that the inputs are from one person, right? [00:14:39] You can't even easily assume what amount is being paid. Exactly. Yeah. And you don't even know it's a page one transaction to begin with. Right. You don't know, it could be a regular transaction or it could be a page win transaction. Right. I mean, this is huge, right? This is massive. [00:14:57] Like I well, I yeah, I'm super hyped about it. I think you know, chain analysis, this whole idea of spying on the chain and doing all this analysis that they do is it's all based on probabilities. They're they're always they're making an educated guess, usually more you know, more certain than other times, about whether or not a bitcoin transaction, how much money is going from one hand to another if it switches hands, like who who it goes, you know, if it if it's actual payment or if it's a self-payment and watch that flow through the chain, and this completely destroys that heuristic. [00:15:35] And the thing is BTC pay, you know, it's a relatively new project. They just keep hustling and just adding adding new features and refining, and it's it's at this point, it's basically a turnkey merchant solution without a third party, and we've never really had a polished way of doing that. [00:15:56] So now an online merchant can easily enable this. And it's, you know, the main caveat with Pay Join is that the receiver needs to be available. It's it's what they call an interactive protocol. So the data needs to be exchanged off chain to basically facilitate the receiver putting his input into the transaction. [00:16:17] Yeah. So with Samurai, that's handled because it's person to person, right? So if you're in person, you exchange QR codes. And if you're doing it, you know, through Telegram or a messenger service, you can exchange it that way, right? Okay. But with BTC Pay, the merchants already online. [00:16:36] Like they have to keep their storefront on the internet already. So they're always online. So then the only caveat there is they do have to, you know, a lot of people set up BTC Pay so it goes straight to their hardware wallet. Right. They have to keep a small hot wallet to handle these pay joins. Yeah. But they have to do that with Lightning as well if they're accepting Lightning transactions. [00:16:56] So I don't think it's that big of a trade-off. And they have this transmuter in BTC Pay, so you can auto remove from that hot wallet and go to your hardware wallet if if you so choose. Yeah, yeah. So you can just set up some kind of like, you know, trigger whenever you reach a certain amount and send it to your heart, you know, your hardware wallet or offline storage or whatever. [00:17:21] Yeah, so I mean it's not that big of a deal. You know, and that's it's like having a cash, you know, a cash register, right? You have a bunch of cash in your in your register in the till. You know, every day you kind of got to float that to run your business. It's basically the same thing. Yeah, I mean, I would say it's less of a trade-off than lightning. Because you know, light having lightning funds hot, I have a little bit more risk than having them hot in this situation, because you do have to worry about channel closes and stuff like that and make sure your backups are all good. [00:17:50] While this will just be like a traditional seed backup. I mean it's massive. And the thing is BTC pay right now is really big among small merchants that are ideological. So they're well suited. Though those are the types of people that will implement this first. Like you're not gonna see well, first of all, BitPay never would have implemented this. [00:18:14] So this is a perfect example of the value of having an open source stack instead of pay. But like the big merchants, the big merchants, we don't really have big merchants, but let's say we hypothetically had, you know, like an Amazon or someone, they'd be very sl I think they unfortunately be very slow to enable a feature like this, right? [00:18:34] They might think like it'll piss off, you know, whatever jurisdiction they're in, regulation, stuff like that. But the small, the small merchants, they're like the perfect, they're the perfect target market. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, and the fact that it's like gonna be standardized now, essentially. [00:18:53] The reach of BTC pay server and just the you know, its influence in the ecosystem is really just gonna set the standard here. And yeah, if I mean if you get wallets supporting it broadly, merchants, you know, res supporting it broadly, it's gonna become a standard transaction type. [00:19:13] And then yeah, you know, you don't need much volume on chain, you know, using these types of transactions to really destroy chain analysis for everything else. Like, I mean, what would you say? Like, you know, five, 10% even of the chain using pageoins, that's it. Like, you can't really make that assumption anymore. [00:19:32] Yeah, that's exactly what I was gonna say. Maybe five percent. Yeah, you know, the more the merrier, right? But I feel like even five percent would be it would be massive, like you really wouldn't know. Yeah, you'd have to guess because you'd also, yeah, you also still have the ones that are samurai to samurai and join market to join market, and yeah, like the non-BTC pay. Like, hopefully, this you know, this will add a big incentive for wallets to implement it because we don't really have many wallets implementing it right now. [00:20:00] Exactly. Yeah, it's gonna set the standard, it's gonna really drive it forward. And people, I mean, the awareness of page oin, right? That it's gonna, it's gonna bring. I mean, people like even Bitcoiners, like I don't know. I mean, you know, samurai users of privacy advocates know about this, you know, join market. You know, I'm a relatively new Bitcoiner, like I guess I'm you know, kind of entering the ranks of older Bitcoins at this point, it's been two and a half years now, but like I still I didn't know I about join market before like Wasabi and Samurai came around. [00:20:31] Like that's when that's when I first heard about Coinjoins, right? Right. So I think there's like a whole new set of Bitcoiners that are gonna be learning about you know these types of transactions because BTC Pay Server launched it. So no, yeah, I mean just like two and a half years ago. [00:20:49] I think the scaling war really set us back on privacy. People know I've been very outspoken about we need better privacy tools in this space, and I've noticed I've not only have we gotten better privacy tools, have we made we made significant improvement, the attention to privacy has become significantly increased. [00:21:13] Like there's so many more people focused on it right now than were two years ago. Even simple things. You know, like the most basic privacy improvement you can do is use your own node, and no one really talked about that three years ago. Now we have solutions where you can just scan a QR code and connect your node. [00:21:32] We have projects like my node, not all, run in dojo, raspy blitz. Like this is making it very accessible for people to run Electrum servers and connect to their full node and use their full node. That's massive. All these little things are are huge in their own right, but together they're they're massive. [00:21:52] I just installed Dojo on my Nodel. I have a like a Nodel one, and I it was, you know, I looked at every once in a while, you know, I log into the admin and check out the updates, you know, like every couple weeks or something like that. And yesterday I logged in and I saw Dojo was available, and I've been waiting for that for a while. So I was stoked. [00:22:10] I hadn't seen it, like I hadn't been in the telegram group for a while, probably missed it on Twitter. So the first time that I saw that Dojo was finally, you know, was available is just you know log into the admin dashboard and seeing what updates were there. And I was stoked, man. I installed it, fired up Samurai, and I didn't I hadn't used Samurai wallet yet. I wanted to wait until the dojo came out so I could you know run it on my own node, and it's syncing up right now. [00:22:34] It's probably I don't know, this morning I checked it was like block 180,000 or something. You have the original Nodel, right? Yeah, is it the 500 gig or the terabyte? It's the one terabyte. Okay, awesome. So I actually have the 500 gig, so Dojo defaults to Electris as its indexer, right? [00:22:59] That's probably what you have syncing right now. Keto is such a good dude that he he made it so it could work with Electrum X. Not as well, but it works with Electrum X, which doesn't have the space requirement that Electris has. So it works on a he got it to work on the 500 gigabyte novel as well. [00:23:21] This is old hardware, you know he has he has new more expensive hardware. Yeah to backport it which is awesome. But yeah so samurai what's really cool about samurai is you can you can get an Android phone or if you have an Android phone you know you already have one. You install the samurai app and to connect it to your dojo is just a QR code scan. [00:23:42] Yeah it automatically goes through Tor, which is like that's the kind of defaults I want to see right like that is awesome. It allows an average user to basically upgrade to a power user status with very little you know very little technical knowledge needed which is fucking awesome. [00:24:03] And you can also this is the thing I've always said Uncle Jim you can share that QR code with your friends and family. So if they want to use a node but don't want to run their own node it's better to trust you than to trust some random server. So they can just it's as simple as them scanning it or you can send them the QR code by you know telegram or something. [00:24:26] Yeah and they can just scan it that way. So like I have a couple people using my I'm Uncle Jim to a couple. That's awesome. That's fucking awesome, man. I need to get some people in my family using Bitcoin before I can do that. Like I do have a I do have a couple friends who I'm probably gonna I'm gonna do that with. I gave them, you know, like treasures for Christmas and got them all like up to speed and next step, get them on Samurai and start mixing and they can connect to my dojo. [00:24:55] It's great, man. It's amazing. So that was the experience. I you know, I just clicked install on the Nodal dashboard and it fired up. And then you know, there's just an onion address, you load up in your Tor browser, and you click on one of the tabs and you have a QR code, you know, you start up Samurai, create a new wallet, scan the QR code, done. [00:25:20] Everything tours running, connect to your dojo. You just gotta wait for the sync. I send some sats in. They're not showing up yet because the block's not you know, not completely synced up there. That's always like a bit of a nervous moment if you don't know what's happening, right? You know, you don't have a fully synced node, but you're relying on it, and you send, you know, you send some stats there, you're like, it's on chain, you can see it, but fuck, man, it's not here. [00:25:42] I have zero fucking Bitcoin. Where is that shit? Yeah, and even even when you do have it fully synced, because it's it's you know, they're still refining it. There are some times where you have to go into Dojo and rescan your expo. So it's important not to freak out if the balance shows zero. [00:26:02] Yeah. Because it mo more than likely it's there. 99% of the, you know, it's it's gonna be there. It's just your node isn't. And that's something people don't have to ever really think about if they're using someone else's node. You know, if they're using professional node. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. I've had it's happened to me on Wasabi too, you know. [00:26:22] And I don't know, it's like the node gets out of sync or something. Because it, you know, it wasabi will install its own node, right? To run on, like in the background if you want it to. Well, nowadays. Nowadays. Nowadays it does, yeah. But sometimes Wasabi, there's a you know, it's they also have this fill the filters that they're bringing in. [00:26:46] Right. And those filters, I and sometimes it falls out of sync and stuff and can give you weird balance thing. The important thing is always have your backups, whatever software you're using in Bitcoin, always have your backups. And if you think you've got you think you fucked something up, like take a deep breath. [00:27:06] Yeah, and you know, just go at it, don't panic, you know, and just and just go at it from a very methodical approach, and nine times out of ten it'll be there. And if for some reason you did fuck it up, you know, rushing is not gonna help you anyway. You're probably fucked. [00:27:24] So you just you just take a deep breath and just you just do it methodically. I've had a lot of a lot of scares in in my time in Bitcoin. Yeah, yeah, me too, man. And this is where like working as like a software developer, at least in some capacity, comes in handy. Because your entire life is just clicking a button and wondering if you fuck something up, and especially if it's like you know, some kind of live software, you know, if you're like on your own and you don't have a team and you don't have like some like you know, development process, proper development process in place, and you're like doing some kind of fucking hot fix, and you just you have those like push button moments, [00:28:03] You know. It's like if or if you run email campaigns, you've had that too, you know, where you click send, or you know, you got misspellings or something, you don't know which you know, everybody's like who who runs email marketing campaigns is put something out with some like you know like spelling error in the subject line, or like, you know, put one character wrong. So it's like the placeholder, like where it says, you know, it's supposed to be first name is like actually has you know the placeholder itself and some like random character, like a slash in there, and it just that's the thing. [00:28:30] Same thing happens in Bitcoin. And I did this with with Wasabi, I don't know exactly what happened, kind of got out of sync. And you know, I didn't I didn't panic, but it was kind of funny to watch as things kind of came back, my balance, you know, like slowly increase, you know, like the this block came. All right, I had a bit of Bitcoin, this block, you know, 30 blocks later, and that's more Bitcoin and just like watched basically these transactions, this timeline kind of play out in real time in front of my eyes. [00:28:57] Yeah, so you just you gotta stay, take a deep breath, take a walk, get away from your computer, come back with a clear head. And you know, what's cool is like the wasabi guys, the samurai guys, the Nodal guys, like they're all there, you know, somewhere reachable, and they'll you know, help you out. I guess the one exception is one time during 2017, my buddy was using bread wallet on iPhone, because I don't think Blockstream Green was on iPhone yet. [00:29:28] So like the go-to recommendation was bread wallet, but I never really liked bread wallet. But I was, you know, I'm a lifelong Android user, so I also didn't really have strong opinions one way or the other. But he was using breadwallet. And he accidentally sent it to the wrong address as Bitcoin. [00:29:48] He said bread wallet glitched and sent it to an address he's never used before. But like honestly, like everyone who fucks something up, always, you know, people always have excuses. You can never trust that. But anyway, regardless, he sent it to an address that wasn't his. But it was during the fee crisis, and it was a low fee. [00:30:07] So actually he panicked and it worked out for him because he panicked. I'm like going against myself here. He panicked and he immediately called me. And then I recovered his seed in Electrum, and I double spent his fuck up transaction and I recovered it. It was the only time I've ever done a double spent. [00:30:26] It was actually as a Bitcoiner, it was like a pretty it was like a coming of age moment, you know. Yeah, I cannot say that I've done that, man. That's pretty that's pretty bother. Yeah, you've got to. This is something I wanted to bring up, actually. I'm kind of this might take us off topic, but or well, it's time to maybe it's time. Like coin control. [00:30:45] All right. This is another thing I saw in the BTC pay update, right? The BTC Pay wallet introduced some nice coin control features. This is something that, you know, kind of speaking of coming of age as a Bitcoiner, it's one of those things where you know you might have been in Bitcoin for a couple years. And you know, you don't spend much Bitcoin, but when you do, do you think about coin control, right? [00:31:09] Most people don't. Most people have a wallet and it just kind of auto-does that for you, slicks the coins, and well, off they go. You don't have to think about it. Yeah. I mean, a lot of wallets don't even give you the option of coin control. Exactly. Yeah, Treasure's web wallet has no coin control, Ledger's Live has no coin control, and that's what most people use, right? Yeah, exactly. [00:31:28] Yeah, so so I mean, there's a lot of Bitcoiners out there probably listening right now that have no idea even what it is, right? Or how to go about it. So yeah, I mean, what is coin control, man? Like, let's tell let's tell these people, you know, educate some people right now. And why the wallet is really not it, your wallet shows you a single balance. [00:31:48] It says, you know, you have 20 million sats in your wallet. But what you really have in your wallet is you have a collection of transactions, a collection of UTXOs, umspent transaction outputs. And that collection is let's say you have 20 million sats, but you have you have 10 UTXOs in there, and you got those UTXOs from all different places, or you know, you got four of them from one place and five of them from the other. [00:32:19] When if you don't use coin control, your wallet will automatically all have different selection algorithms, but your your wallet will automatically select some of these UTXOs and put them on the input side of your transaction. Then it'll pay whoever you're paying, and then your change will come back to a new new transaction, creating a new UTXO. [00:32:39] Yeah, and that's what we were talking about earlier, the common input ownership heuristic. All those inputs are assumed to be owned by the same person. So if two UTXOs in your wallet get combined to form a transaction, or even worse, let's say five or six, depending on on what happens there. [00:32:59] All of those transactions are linked together, and all the previous transactions that resulted in those four or five UTXOs are also linked. So you have to be very careful about which UTXO you spent. Yeah, and one of the issues is, you know, wallets haven't had strong coin control interfaces, right? [00:33:23] Like it's very, first of all, it's a very difficult concept for people to grok. So it's even more difficult to build a UX that makes it, you know, usable. Like just to be frank. Right now, like Electrum has coin control, Wasabi has coin control, Samurai has coin control, BTC Pay just added coin control. [00:33:46] I don't think green wallet, green wallet does not have coin control. No. Green wallet lets you make a ton of accounts. You can make as many accounts as you want. So my coin control in Green Wallet is I have like 50 green wallets. I like then say, and you can label each one. So like every time I take a I like create a new account every time I receive a transaction, which is ridiculous. [00:34:09] Yeah. But that's you know, that's what you have to do. So it's very important. People have to pay attention to which UTXOs they're combining. The other element here is in high fee environments, the more UTXOs on the input side, the higher your fee. So that's counterintuitive. What that means is if you're taking your privacy into account and you're not trying to combine your UTXOs, you end up with a higher fee. [00:34:34] So in the in the high fee environment of 2017, we saw a lot of people recommending combining all of your UTXOs into a single UTXO for future spending, that would be a cheaper fee. But that has really bad privacy implications. So that's one of the issues we have with these coin selection algorithms. What do they prioritize? [00:34:53] Do they prioritize fee savings? That's what a lot of them do. But should they prioritize privacy? But how would the wallet know if they're sacrificing your privacy or not? A lot of times the issue is something external. You know, you received it from a KYC source, you received it from your employer that you don't, you know, want to show the rest of your transactions to. [00:35:13] It becomes a very convoluted thing. But ideally, what we will see, and this is what Samurai has been working on, they have a new coin coin selection. Not only does Samurai have very strong coin control UX, like it's it's you can you can pick and label the key is labeling too. [00:35:33] Samurai and Wasabi, you can label your UTXOs. And in in Rossabi, it's nice because they actually force you to label them. So they like get you into the habit of fucking doing it. Because if you don't label them, you forget real quick where the especially if you come back like two years later, like where those UTXOs are. [00:35:51] But anyway, Samurai is working on one that basically uses your full node and does like a mini chain analysis on yourself. And that's how it's select how it's gonna select. Because I think that's cool. We can't ever imagine, they'll never be, there'll probably never be more than one percent of Bitcoiners who manually do their coin selection. [00:36:12] Right. It's just too, it's too convoluted, it's and it's too overwhelming. Like people just won't grok it, they won't do it, and that's why so many wallets just ignore it. Yeah, yeah. So I we need better coin selection algorithms, and it's not, but it's not an easy. We had a whole podcast with Andrew Chow about this. [00:36:33] Like it's not an easy there's no easy solution, and probably different wallets will prioritize different things. Another thing to mention in this whole conversation is that L and D still does not have any coin control. If you use L and D as your lightning wallet, it has no coin control. [00:36:52] I'm pretty sure C Lightning does. I'm not sure about Eclair, but L and D does not have any, and that's a little bit frustrating as someone who likes coin control. How do you approach labeling? You know, it's kind of like file folder structure. There's like probably, you know, it's it's sort of a personal choice kind of thing, personal preference. [00:37:11] But how do you approach it? I'm more of a paranoid person than other people. So I imagine I weigh two things. I need the label to be as descriptive as possible, right? [00:37:31] So that in like a year or whatever, I'll know what I was talking about. You know, you can't just like yeah, you can't just do some bullshit real like top of the head kind of labeling. But at the same time, I worry like if if the wallet labels get compromised somehow, then I'm contributing metadata to my transactions. [00:37:55] Yes, right. So I try and keep it. I don't want to dox your labeling approach either. So like let's be careful about this. I well, I mean, like labels should never get exposed. And it that would be like a pretty bad situation. You might your keys might be a risk. But there are certain situations where the labels might be taken depending on which app you're using, and the and the actual Bitcoin aren't. [00:38:21] So I try and keep it descriptive yet discreet. I know that's like a really shitty answer, but you gotta find a personal, you gotta find a personal balance. And I would say lean to more descriptive than discrete. Yeah. You know, because you don't want to be in a situation. I've been in that situation plenty of times where like two years later, I'm like, I have no idea what this UTXO is. [00:38:44] Yeah. No idea where that came from. That is just a shot in the dark. You know? It's ridiculous. Yeah, it I mean, I could imagine there's some Bitcoiners out there that have put together their own like kind of cipher for labeling, right? Like you know, you might get access to labels and it's just some like random mix of letters and numbers and shit, and like they have like a cipher written out with their, you know, like their their backups, you know, their their key phrase backups and everything, their 12 words, 24 words, and next to it, they have this some like crazy little cipher, and they're and then it [00:39:22] You know, they're like kind of have it you know in their RAM in their brain and they can apply it right in real time. Like that's that's the kind of big corner I can imagine. Like there's you know, maybe maybe Peter Todd or somebody like that, you know, approaches labeling with that. Well, I mean, one of the nice things about something like Whirlpool is that after you go through Whirlpool, there that that's a pretty general label, right? [00:39:51] Yeah, like it's just a world there, these are your post-whirlpool transactions, yeah. So that it that definitely having a tool like that, lessens the burden. Like back in the day when you didn't have that that kind of tool, like you had it it was more important to know exactly which UTXO is which, but as long as you don't combine your UTXOs before you go into the coin join, and then you remix a bunch of times, in general, like the labeling at that point doesn't matter as much. [00:40:23] Yeah, fair enough. That makes sense. Yeah, I'm looking forward to adding Whirlpool into my coin join rotation. It's just been Wasabi up until now. And I'm starting to do more and more. [00:40:35] Like I kind of had approached it like, you know, there's X amount has been KYC'd, pretty much everything at first. [00:40:43] I've got a you know, found some approaches like ATMs and stuff that you can like kind of get some non-KYC Bitcoin, but that's hard, you know. Just a lot more accessible. So I started out like just testing this stuff out with small amounts of Bitcoin. And slowly, as I become comfortable with it, started you know mixing more and more. [00:41:05] I wonder if this BTC pay like pay join thing, there'll be some kind of implementation of coin mixing, like just dedicated coin mixing functionality in BTC pay. So you're not like having to transact to a merchant, you know, to perform a pay join. [00:41:26] Like I wonder if they're they're gonna have some kind of like whirlpool like implementation within the package itself. Yeah, I mean that would that would be awesome. Yeah, you know, pay join doesn't replace pay join is supplemental to one of these like coordinated rounds, like a like a whirlpool coin join where you have like a coordinator and a bunch of equal outputs because the thing is if you KYC, first of all, you're always better off not KYC. [00:41:58] But yes, you are correct, especially in America, it's very hard to get non-KYC. And obviously you can get a lot more volume if you go through KYC. Yeah, but you know, Coinjoin doesn't fix that KYC taint. It's it just lessens its effect a little bit, you know, and it it it basically means that they probably can't easily track your past and future transactions, but they know you bought Bitcoin, right? [00:42:30] They know the amount of how much Bitcoin you bought it and when you bought it. So if we have my guess is like what like 90% of new users are coming in through KYC. Yeah. If you're in that kind of situation and you're pay joining and both parties are on KYC sides and stuff, even if you don't know the exact amount that has been transacted there or which UTXOs, you know, you know you'll know all about the UTXOs ahead of time, first of all, before the transaction, right? [00:43:04] And you can make a lot more deductions there. So you so it's really a combination approach. You have things like pay join, and then you have other tools like these coordinated coin joins and these two-person coin joins and stuff like that. So you need all of them together. It's not a it's not a one size, it's not like there's no silver bullet here. [00:43:24] Right, right. Yeah. I mean, it makes sense as much as possible, right? And we've got other things on the horizon, Taproot and Schnorr and all that. That's it's gonna help like obscure this stuff even more. It would be nice to have a more user-friendly and more liquid non-KYC, you know, exchange. [00:43:48] But you know, like it's just it's impossible to grow to any meaningful size and you know, continue being continue functioning in, you know nations that have this you know KYC AML type laws so I don't know I mean what I think is I think this is like a growing pains so I think I think early on it was it was relatively easy to get non-KYC Bitcoin you can still mine and mining is the is the best way to get it in terms of privacy so even if you're paying a higher electricity cost [00:44:27] And you're losing like 30% compared to if you bought it on like a Cash App or a Swan or something yeah you're paying that 30% privacy premium is basically how I look at it. But long term five years something like that five 10 years we're gonna see the Bitcoin economy switch to a more circular economy. [00:44:46] We're gonna see people instead of instead of selling they'll be spending and instead of buying they'll be earning Bitcoin run a small small shop and you run BTC pay and that's how people are going to get Bitcoin without KYC. So right now this middle ground is like where we're very vulnerable I think and where a lot of people are going through KYC but that'll open it up once we move to a circular economy. [00:45:08] Yeah earning man earnings key [00:45:13] Man that in that future just a few months ago that you know every almost every podcast that you'd listen to would have some kind of speculation or at least the ones I did because I love asking this question talking about this stuff about where we're going you know, and we've got all kinds of you know, a range of speculation people would, you know, like Gigi and Bitcoin Tina, like five years hybrid Bitcoinization, you know. [00:45:41] Most people kind of fell into the 10 to 15 year range for it to at least begin, and maybe it would take a while to play out. Some people are even more like, you know, I guess you'd call it bearish, you know, 20, 30 years. But I think, I mean, obviously the game has completely changed in just in the past few months. We're we're watching it play out like we have been saying it would for years now, you know. [00:46:06] It's kind of amazing. Like I don't know if I've really processed fully how incredible our I guess narrative is being being incredibly justified right now and backed up. Like I, you know, I don't want to say I told you so, but I do, you know, when I say I told you so. [00:46:29] It's it's hard, it I don't want to say it right now because there's a lot of suffering going on. In 2008, the future was sort of laid. There is just you can't go back to any kind of semblance of you know monetary responsibility, right? [00:46:49] I think maybe you could go back to 1971 and that's when it was laid. But in 2008, there was like an absolute commitment to we're just gonna print whatever we need to get out of this. And now it's just open policy, right? This idea of monetary modern monetary theory, MMT, you know, just people representatives of the Fed coming out and say we're gonna do whatever we need to do or whatever we can, whatever's possible, or anything's possible, we're gonna do whatever we can. [00:47:15] We've already printed trillions of dollars. We're airdropping money to people. There's a now a bill in Congress that proposes something like two on the order of $2,000 a month to every American until we get back to 60% population to employment ratio. [00:47:36] And who knows when that might happen. They should do bigger. They should do $5,000 a month per person. That's about a trillion a month. I mean, why not? I mean, why not? Look, if they're gonna print, if they're gonna print all this fucking money, like cut all this bureaucracy bullshit and just direct deposit five thousand, don't put any restrictions on it. [00:47:58] You can spend on whatever you want. There's no income restrictions. Every single person in America gets it. 5,000 direct deposited, bang. That's it. You don't need any of the bureaucracy, any of the corruption. If you're gonna if you're gonna ruin this currency to begin with, you might as well just ruin it efficiently. Exactly. Go out with a bang, right? [00:48:18] I mean, you could go the other way too. Just stop, just stop taxing people. I mean, just print the money that yeah, why? Just print the money that we need to run the government and just don't have any taxes. I mean, you know, it's it's basically the same thing. It's just the flip side of this UBI situation that we're in. And if you think about it, if you print the a printing is like a perfectly proportional tax without any overhead whatsoever. [00:48:45] Because if you have more money, it affects you more than if you have less money. Yeah. So it's you know, it's compared to this like completely convoluted system we currently have. You might you may as well. Yeah, but I'll tell you one thing. A lot of Bitcoiners, myself included, have been expecting a lot of this stuff, and I agree with you that you know it's definitely not time for told just overgloating because a lot of people are hurting. [00:49:17] But we I mean I did not did not expect, first of all, definitely didn't expect a pandemic to happen at the same time to fuel it. And I did not think it was gonna be this quick and hard. And we have we like, yes, unemployment is very high, but like markets didn't fall that much before they started doing it. [00:49:41] You know, they just fucking they like closed the economy, which was like self-inflicted at all-time highs, mind you, right? Generational all-time highs, and then they just immediately just like let the gatling canids loose, you know. Like that's insane. No, like no pause. [00:50:00] No pause at all. Like it's just here's what we gotta do. I mean, we it's the 2008 playbook, you know, 10x, 100x. And you know, I was actually talking with Marty and Connor on a Swan Signal episode of a couple weeks ago, and you know, they're talking about like if if they're able to paper over this again, right? [00:50:20] If this works like one more time, and you know, somehow the economy sort of revives without too much crazy inflation happening, and then you know, you get another cycle running. And you know, you're you're another eight to ten years or 12 years away from another order of magnitude of printing, right? [00:50:42] 2008 was like on the order of like hundreds and hundreds of billions. This now we're looking at trillions, you know, tens of trillions of dollars possibly. You know, Corey talks about I haven't read this directly, but he quotes this like this number because the US dollar is also backstopping because it's a global reserve currency, you know, all kinds of assets and debt all around the world. [00:51:10] And so if we're trying to prevent a global economic meltdown, we're gonna have to print on the order of 45, 40, you know, 50 trillion dollars to backstop all of the debt that's out there in you in the US dollar terms. It's insane to think about. Unfathomable. Unfathomable. Even if it's even if that number's a ridiculous number and it ends up being 20, yeah, who fucking cares? [00:51:34] It's the same. And but that's the thing, you know, which is fucked up. But if they're gonna exploit, you know, and it's short-term thinking, it's very high time preference. If they're gonna, if they're gonna print, the beauty of printing in a crisis like this, if you print like 5,000 a month, is that you're basically you tax the whole world. [00:51:58] Yeah, only Americans benefit, but you tax the whole world, which is fucked up because I've over the last couple of years I've become much more of a global citizen. I have friends now all over the world, yeah, and I love them all. They're all my brothers and sisters, and but they're just gonna get fucked in that way more than Americans will get fucked. [00:52:16] It and then eventually, like we will abuse our reserve currency status. But then hopefully, you know, Bitcoin becomes the reserve. Right. And then we all share in that benefit. I mean, the narrative that'll come out then is just you know, Bitcoin is the humane money. Bitcoin respects, you know, your humanity without any prejudice. [00:52:38] You know, this is a neutral money. The United States dollar is benefiting the United States citizens and the and you know, the United States governments, and you know, proportionally, like, let's not put it on just you know the normal US citizen, right? The average guy and average average gal, like it's benefiting the 1%, the 0.01, you know, 0.1% to 0.01%. [00:53:04] Like they are, because of the cancelon effect getting the most benefit out of this printing of money. And that will become more and more understood, right? Around the world. I think it's pretty well understood amongst. But if if if we printed it directly, direct deposit, $5,000 per person, yeah, sure. [00:53:25] Then you'd still have the cantilon effect, but you would you would have it you would have it against the rest of the world, right? Right, exactly like the average American would get five thousand dollars. That's right. It's just it's funny that these things are being floated seriously, and as far as I'm concerned, if they're gonna do it, like I would like a direct deposit. [00:53:51] Yeah, it's like if it if if that's gonna be if that's gonna be the game plan anyway, if we're gonna print 20 trillion anyway, if we're gonna flood money into the market, unfathomable level of money, just direct deposit me. Like, yeah, yeah. I mean, I don't know, man. [00:54:10] Do you like what once you start putting it that way? It's like do you have some kind of moral obligation to try to, you know, somehow spread that wealth around because it's you know, just the printing of all that money at the expense of the rest of the world, and just to benefit Americans who you know could use that that airdropped money, obviously, like you gotta pay your you know, pay your bills and your living expenses and stuff, but there's plenty like they're giving five thousand dollars a month or two thousand, whatever it is, they're airdropping money to individuals making less than a hundred and thirty thousand dollars a year. [00:54:45] You know, that's to a lot of the country that's a significant amount of money. I mean it's it's not as much in like New York and California and stuff. No, they're like the cutoff for this 1,200 is 99k. I thought it was 130. It at 75k, it goes down 100 every $5 or something like that. [00:55:06] Oh no, no, it's it goes it goes down five dollars every $100. So when you hit $99K, you get nothing. If you have if you make like $95K, you get like $80 or something. So here's where I got it. This is the new bill that's been proposed. Oh yeah, this is the this is the other bill. Okay, yeah, but I'm talking about the card the current one. [00:55:25] The CARES Act is what you're talking about. That's the thing. Yeah, but like then you gotta enforce then you add all these loopholes and stuff. Like you just you should just give it to everyone, and you know, if you're if you're a really rich person, like five thousand dollars isn't that much to you. You know, and if if you're if if you if you need the money more, then it's all it's it's a lot of money to you, you know, and you and then you don't have the overhead. [00:55:49] You don't even have to you don't even have to deal with it. But yeah, obviously everything this country does benefits the super rich. You know, our politicians are bought and paid for. My moral my moral bonus is that I try and make the Bitcoin ecosystem better and try and help with education. [00:56:09] And I try I try to get people involved in Bitcoin now, before I expect it to I expect the number to go up and it to be you know less advantageous to get in at a later date. Like I think people that get into Bitcoin in 10 years will still be better off for it. Right. But the sooner you get in the better. [00:56:28] That that's how I look at it. And then on the other side, like just try and be a good person. You know, like I like for instance, during this whole mess, I wasn't just complaining about the government response. Like I was organizing mask shipments into like for nurses and stuff, getting them directly to nurses. [00:56:49] Because New York got hit really hard, and our government fucking shot the bed. Both our local government and the federal government shot the bed here. And to this day, they still are there still are a running shortages. I have 900 more masks coming in. I paid for them all out of pocket, you know. And it's it's those little things, you know. [00:57:08] It's like you just you have to you have to give back, but that's just that's a personal preference. That's something you have to decide, decide on your own. You know how you want to proceed there. I you're not gonna solve the world. You just gotta be like just be a you know, just be kind, you know. [00:57:29] Yeah, man. Be kind. Think about your fellow human, be humble, not naive, don't be naive. Yeah, don't be a cuck. Yeah. But be kind. I mean, you can be you can be smart, you can be wise, you can be paranoid, yeah. [00:57:49] You can be all these things, you can be, you know, you can print, you can protect. But you know, you can also be kind and think about the broader community in the broader world. You know, you gotta I think that comes from, you know, the ethos of personal responsibility, right? That's the root. [00:58:08] Take care of yourself, get your shit in order for yourself, get your shit in order for your family, for your friends, and then you move out to your community, move out to the, you know, the world from there. It's like these concentric circles, but you know, Bitcoin really we I talk about this all the time. And you know, I just I think I mentioned this on on the Swan podcast with you last week. [00:58:30] We wrote this we wrote this chapter. Actually no it wasn't with you. It was with it was last week with with Will and Phil, Will Reeves and Phil Geiger. Chapter Yeah, yeah. Fucking dropping that the fold card game changer. We can talk about that in a little bit but chapter five of the Give Bitcoin like guy or like book that we're writing is called the optimism of Bitcoin. [00:58:54] And it's main mainly about how this ethos of personal responsibility, this ethos of shifting your time preference from short, you know short time time preference to long time preference changes you fundamentally, right? It changes a person. I think there are plenty of Bitcoiners out there that especially kind of early Bitcoiners that saw the meaning of Bitcoin before most people were already there. [00:59:19] You know they already kind of understood this stuff innately the kind of stoic approach to life you know be humble and take care of your yourself and etc. And we're thinking longer time preference kind of ways. I wasn't one of those people. I think there's lots of Bitcoiners now, you know, in kind of recently joined that have had their approach to life and to their personal self change, you know, kind of fundamentally. [00:59:48] And it's all from this this very basic difference between fiat money and sound money. And it's I think changing people one by one, and will as it you know grows and expands as number goes up and Bitcoin becomes more widely adopted, it's it's gonna lead to this societal change to what I call the big, you know, the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance that we're in right now, the Bitcoin Renaissance that we're looking forward to. [01:00:14] And I think that's you know, that's what it's based on that ethos of personal responsibility, long-term thinking. That's it. Our society has been drained of all personal responsibility, right? Right? So pretty much everyone that comes into Bitcoin comes in, at least in the Western world, comes in with a huge paradigm shift in how they have to think about things. [01:00:40] Everything is on them. There's there's no customer support line for you to call. There's no one to hold your hand. You know, you're in it for yourself and you have to take care of yourself. And like you said earlier, like there is a hierarchy, you know, like that's how I look at it. Like I'm selfish for my family and my my close friends first. [01:00:58] And then once I have that house in order, then I move out and I try and help as many other people as I can reason within reason. But yeah, there's a huge shift. You know, one of the one of the things I liked about Bitcoin was that element of personal responsibility. But I think for most people, they're gonna come into this and they're gonna have to learn how to think that way. [01:01:19] And it is a very fundamental way, it's it's a very fundamental different way of thinking, going from lack of personal responsibility to personal responsibility. And we have to understand, especially if you're educating people in this space, like you have to understand that that is a process that will take time. [01:01:39] And that's why it's important that there's training wheels. There's a lot of ways for them to come in on training wheels. Yeah. Instead of just just diving headfirst in. But I personally I'm a huge fan of diving headfirst in within reason. Hell yeah. You dive in, you know, don't put too much money on the line and just fucking go for it and see what happens. [01:01:59] You just need a little skin in the game to be incentivized to dive in. And I've heard I've heard it told so many times. The you know, the experience of diving down the rabbit hole is once you get that little bit of hook, you know, like you put a little skin in the game and you're incentivized to just like consume YouTube videos, read blog posts, read books, listen to podcasts, and then you just don't want to do anything else for months and months, and you know, in some cases like us, years and years, right? [01:02:29] And you just want you're consumed by it completely. You understand the that it's basically the most important thing that you could work on that exists in the world right now. Goddamn, that is such a massive motivation to wake up in the morning and you know, like you said, it starts with yourself and then it and then your family, you know, you're stacking for your family, stacking for yourself, and then you are incentivized and like motivated to get out there and talk about this thing and educate people and spread this this knowledge, the this kind of insight [01:03:07] That you found. This it's amazing, man. It's such a privilege to be here and at kind of the relative beginning here. And you know, while this community is still pretty small and get to know all the movers and shakers and the people who are building the future. It's it's a privilege. Well, what I think is funny is if you talk to Bitcoiners, that everyone got in late. [01:03:28] Doesn't matter what year they got in, everyone thinks they got in late. We're massively early still. You know, the way I frame it is I came in [01:03:41] As a relatively young kid, you know, I was like 23. I was disillusioned with the world, I was disenfranchised. Bitcoin gave me hope, and Bitcoiners gave me hope. Yeah, just like the mental model of thinking. Like I would never call myself a cyberpunk, but I aspire to be one. [01:04:03] You know, like the whole ethos of the space is something that I aspire to be a part of. And it just it just gives me hope. Like in a world in a world that everything seems to be going wrong and that all the wrong decisions are being taken, it just makes me optimistic. [01:04:25] And that's why there's there's no, I mean, I've struggled to I haven't actually to be honest, I haven't really tried to make money in the Bitcoin space. And it's let me be freer. But like I really just want it to be my life, right? [01:04:45] Like, I just want every like fuck the fiat job, just get rid of it, and just fucking go. And like this recession might be that turning point. We shall see. But but that has been the case for like a long time. It's just slowly consumed more and more of my thought processes to the point where like now I have to like act like actively turn off my Bitcoin, like mine. [01:05:09] Yeah, you know, I got it. So you can so you could be present with you know your friends and family, and you know, and I don't just like Matt, stop bringing it back to Bitcoin every five minutes. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. I you know the when I first found out the rabbit hole, like I literally every conversation that I had, I could not help myself, you know, just couldn't. [01:05:29] I was just like searching for an in to bring up Bitcoin. And I at some point, you know, after a few months, just was like, ah, just stop. I can't do it. And I you know, like I hear you say, you they gotta be motivated, right? They gotta be motivated now. So I'm not gonna go out in in like in real life motivated noobs. [01:05:49] That's my target market, motivated noobs. Exactly. The motivated noobs. Yeah, I'm not gonna go out there in meat space. I just don't talk about it anymore. If somebody's motivated enough to ask me about it, because they they all know, they all know I'm into Bitcoin. So if somebody wants to know about it, they come and ask me, and I'm happy to obviously talk about it. [01:06:08] That's how I approach in meat space. That's how I approach it. Yeah, or like at least like non-bitcoin meat space. The way I approach it is they all know they all know me as the Bitcoin guy. The way I look at everything I do, the podcast, tweets and stuff. My target market is the Bitcoin guy of every individual group. [01:06:28] Yes, right? Exactly. Like, let's all be the best Bitcoin guy we can be. And that includes not going ridiculous on it, like show lightly. Like, when they're ready, they will know to come to you and they will ask you. Actually, I have one friend who I was super proud of, installed Bitcoin Core, backed up his seed, and transferred it to Bitcoin Core and just stored it for like two years until the 2017 run happened. [01:07:00] And then he was always super anti-Bitcoin, which is why he didn't want to tell me about it. Like he would always give me shit about it. And then when we were like near the top, I stopped being humble, which is why it's important. That's why I always say stay humble, stay humble. And I tried to rub it in his face or whatever. And he's like, Matt, I've had Bitcoin since 2015. [01:07:20] And I was so proud of him. I was so proud that he like went through all the steps like on his own. But yeah, I love I love helping newcomers. And it just it make every time someone says thank you, it makes me really happy. That's basically it's like a dopamine hit to be to be to be completely honest, you know. [01:07:39] It's not completely selfless. It is it is a dopamine hit. It is absolutely man. It is. I mean, I think it's there because we love it so much, man. We believe in it so much, there's so much conviction, you know. So let's let's a few weeks ago that massive, so when this coronavirus stuff kind of first became real to Americans, there was a massive, you know, price drop in Bitcoin, everything, every equity. [01:08:12] Bloody Thursday. Yeah, yeah. March 12th, I think it was. And master ray candle goes down to like 3800. You know, you've been around for a long time. You've been through this, you know. You know, what was what was your what was your reaction? How did you feel? We've never been through that. [01:08:31] Yeah. There was a pandemic going on and everything was crashing. Yes. That was a special kick you in the balls kind of experience. Yeah. Yeah. Did I consider selling? No, I never I but I had that gut-wrenching, you know, thing in my stomach, and like I got kicked in the balls. [01:08:53] Like I absolutely got kicked in the balls. I didn't like rush to any decisions. I didn't have any money on exchanges, so I wasn't worried about that. You know, not your keys, not your coins. Yeah. I had my keys safely away, and I was like, you know, I basically come to the zen point where you know, we're either right or we're wrong. [01:09:13] Yeah, it's there's nothing I can do about that now. Yeah. I have I hate leverage. I think leverage kills 99% of people, you know. Like if you try and trade, 99% of people are gonna are gonna lose lose more money than if they just dollar cost average spin. [01:09:32] You know, there is the one percent that'll do better. But I have absolutely leveraged my life onto Bitcoin. Like, you know, it it doesn't at this point I'm in and let's go. So in that in that respect, I was I was cool, but it it was I'll tell you one thing, I panic sold my stocks. Yeah, I definitely did panic sell stuff. [01:09:53] Which is hilarious because I have way more Bitcoin, but I panicked like I panic sold my stocks and I didn't consider and I actually, you know, it's like a longtime sports fan. I actually was convinced that I caused the Bitcoin price drop because I had said to my dad the market had fallen first, right? [01:10:16] The market had like two horrible days in a row. Yeah. And they were predicting like ridiculous death numbers and stuff. And you know, from our perspective, like a lot of people thought the market was healthy. But we've always thought the markets were like a house of cards, just like all the traditional markets. That the SP was like a propped up bubble. [01:10:34] So it didn't take much to trigger me. So I see all that falling down. I panic sell. And I turned to my dad, on the phone with my dad, and I'm like, you know, Bitcoin was only down one percent today. Not bad. Not bad. That's pretty good. You know, that's pretty bullish. And I like I said it to him, and then like three hours later, we were down like 50%. [01:10:55] Yeah. So it was like it was like the famous jinx when you're like watching your favorite team. Didn't you didn't you buy in and then Bitcoin like you lost like half your net worth or something like that, or half your half your Bitcoin worth? Like what like soon after you bought in? When I first got it, 2013. [01:11:13] So I discovered Bitcoin in 2012, but I was kind of no no corner about it, you know, which I don't think is like that bad of a position to come in on it. You come in and I'm like, I came in kind of anti-state, but anti-state in the defeatist way. Like I thought the state was overreaching, but that they would win all the time. [01:11:34] Yeah. I looked at Bitcoin, I looked at specifically like the Silk Road, someone told me about the Silk Road, and I was like, this is never gonna work. And then I but I kept paying attention to it, and I kept trying to figure out how it wouldn't work. I was like threat modeling it. I was like trying. If I had all the money in the world, if I was the US government, how would I kill it? [01:11:55] Yeah. Right. And I'm like going through all this stuff. And 2013 had two massive spikes. It had the first spike to 250 that fell to like 58. And then it had the spike from there to like 1100. 1100 was like a fake price. It was only on like Mount Gox for like one day. [01:12:15] You couldn't even trade on Mount Gox for real. You lost your money if you were there. Yeah. But like then it went from 1100 to 150. And so, like, that's the first man. That first up and down was like it like primed me. I didn't like put that much money in. [01:12:34] I was like fresh out of school. I didn't really like I had I had minimal debt, I had you know money on the side. And I but I put in like I put in like a little bit of it, yeah, and my money went up and then it went way down. [01:12:55] And then that next bubble is what killed me. When we were at like 150, I was in the hole, man. I was just like I at that point, I was like, because I didn't buy on the way up that much, it was on the way down that killed me. [01:13:17] Did you sell some? It no, no, it was all the fake, it was it was the same thing that happened this time on the way to 3500, where you keep thinking, oh, it'll bounce to 13 or 14. It's over, the bear market's over, and then I would buy more, right? Yeah, so by the time so I caught they call it catching the falling knife. [01:13:38] Yeah like the price of whatever asset you're trying to buy keeps going down, and you think it's bottom, you keep calling bottom prematurely. Yeah. And I did that like crazy that that run. Yeah. So by the time we got to the bottom at like 150, I wasn't buying. Yeah. I was overextended. [01:13:58] And you know, like stay humble stack sets doesn't come from nowhere. Like I fucking got burned hard. Like I didn't sell, but like I learned my lesson. Like it got it, it it got burned into me. At 150, I was just like holding myself. I was like, my dad's gonna be like, for the rest of my life, my dad was gonna be like, you were completely wrong in that one, Matt. [01:14:19] Weren't you? Right. And this is the this is that time period where you're new, right? And you're like, you know, falling down that rabbit hole, and you're it's like you're falling in love, and so you just want to talk about it. It's like a new relationship, it's like a new girlfriend, you know, you just want to talk about it all the time. So all your friends know you're in, right? At this point, like it oh, I mean, you can't shut up about it, yeah. [01:14:42] Right? Like, no, I was like a dick at when it was like a thousand dollars, like you know, whatever. I was a dick. Yeah, I was young, I was I was not humble, yeah. And yeah, I that it's it's just it it it did I do wholeheartedly think that the majority of newcomers come in on the big run ups. [01:15:09] They probably I mean you can I don't think you can ever buy enough Bitcoin, but they can they perceive they haven't bought enough Bitcoin on the way up and they try and time the bottom down, and that's where most of them get burned, and then some survive that and continue, and that's basically I think 95% of people's stories, which is like the same as my story. [01:15:32] And the key there is when you're down, you tend to learn more because you try and justify your investment. Yeah. Right. So like nothing incentivized me more to dive down the rabbit hole and like learn and use and like play around with this shit than perceiving to I lost all that money on paper, right? [01:15:56] But like perceiving I lost all that money, I think is like really important. It it like really it really makes you learn. And also when the price is cheaper, you're more you're willing to send some Bitcoin into a wallet to fuck around with it because it's like not worth that much in comparison to where you've reserved it at, you know. [01:16:17] Yeah, but I mean there's like this is where hodlers earn their stripes and like earn the I don't know, like you earn be the rewards. Yeah, that's what I was looking for. You earn the rewards, all right? Because you're down to 150. There's plenty of people that said, fuck this, fuck it. [01:16:36] This is bullshit. I'm out. They rage quit, they capitulate. We have the bear whale. They're done, they're just done. But then the other way, you know, what hodlers do is you just steal your reserve, and you're like, all right, I'm gonna figure this thing out. I'm gonna understand what has lost me all this money on paper, and learn it and study it and talk about it with other Bitcoiners and seek seek education and wisdom, right? [01:17:06] In those in those moments where you're just getting absolutely just demolished and just you're all the pain, you know, the psychological suffering that you're feeling. And that's that's where hodlers really earn it, man. That's where they earn these gains. All the early guys like that are still around, that was a lot of pain you go through, a lot of fear. [01:17:27] And like, you know, if you if you got the stomach to handle that, then you know cheers to you. I mean, the crazy thing is it's always been that way. Yeah, like the earlier cycles were the most ridiculous cycles. I can't imagine watching it go from 50 cents to $30 back down to $2. [01:17:47] Yeah, right. You know, like that must have been fucking insane. When you're passing around tens of thousands of Bitcoin. Yeah. I mean, for some reason, Satoshi chose to do this hard four-year cycle where it cuts in half supply instead of doing something gradual like some of the altcoins do. [01:18:08] It's gonna result in these, and it's a scarce asset, it's an inherently scarce asset. It's gonna result in these boom bust cycles constantly over time. They will mellow out probably with liquidity. But it is, you know, and it's kind of it's kind of amazing because I think humans aren't low time preference by design. [01:18:32] So having it happen so drastically makes it more of a almost viral marketing event than if it was gradual. If it was gradual, it's like you're just boiling a frog in water. No one wants to talk about that. But it's like the frog explodes in the water every four years, you know, then that might be more interesting. [01:18:52] It definitely is more interesting. There's no doubt about that. Yeah, and I mean the cycles are becoming less extreme in terms of you know the multiples of price fluctuations. Which makes it easier to stomach. [01:19:13] So I think like every cycle becoming a hodler becomes a little easier, maybe, you know. But the numbers get bigger. Yeah, the numbers get bigger, that's for sure. The numbers in in terms of like meaningful money definitely get bigger. [01:19:32] And man, like people out there, the normies that just don't know what's happening here. And they're just they're ecstatic about this this airdrop money, you know. This is they support this, it's the right thing to do. [01:19:50] This is can't this is the Keynesian ideology, right? It's it's the Keynesian mistake, like flaw. You are justified, you know. There's this academic tradition that justifies bailing out, you know, everybody mostly, you know, it started out with corporations, now we're just giving it straight to average Americans, which you know, I think is actually the twelve hundred dollars is just it's like a bullshit handwave gesture. [01:20:21] I saw somebody say that it was a bribe, it was a bribe to not like riot in the streets. That's exactly what it was. That's exactly what it was. It was it, it's not as if you compare it to what the major corporations are gonna get out of this and what the ultra-rich are gonna get out of this, it's fucking pennies, is what it's right. [01:20:41] Right. So then there's there's this academic justification, this tradition that justifies this this action. And it's easy to sell. It's easy to sell because you can just say, look, we this is what we can do. We can help you right now, right? We're we're gonna we're gonna we're not gonna let these corporations fail. [01:21:00] We're not gonna let this what should happen, this malinvestment sort of play out, and all of these these people who have just gambled and made bad investments, you know, get punished by the open market, by the free market, like they should. And they're not gonna learn their lesson. What they're gonna learn is that the government's gonna bail them out every time that they do this. [01:21:22] And so they're incentivized to continue doing it. That's the moral hazard, right? And that's what Keynesianism does. Keynes was actually more responsible than these economists that that run the world now, run the global monetary system. He actually said, you know, when things get better after you've kind of rescued the economy and stopped the worst of the boom bust cycle that that kind of is inherent to capitalism, then you've got to reduce the monetary supply on the other side, right? [01:21:51] That's the countercycle measure. That that shit doesn't happen. That's not politically popular. It never possible. That was like exactly a nice idea in theory. Exactly. I mean, it wasn't. Don't quote me out of context, Bitcoiners. None of it was a good idea, but that that particular aspect was never gonna happen. [01:22:09] You can never reduce the supply unless you want to just it unless maybe if politicians, which I'm not advocating for this idea, it's probably a horrible idea, but if they had like a 20-year term or something that lowered their time preference, I don't know how that were that that might not actually lower their time preference because then they'd have no incentive to perform well at all. [01:22:30] Yeah if they had a 20. If their like kid was forced to live in the society at the medium income or something. Yes. You know, if there was, then maybe the m money supply would get reduced. But as it stands now, they have the incentive to do short-term thinking that benefits them short term for their reelection cycle. [01:22:53] And you're you're never gonna get that. No, it's not politically popular to do that. Exactly. And representatives in Congress are on you know a two-year cycle, right? I mean, they're they're running constantly for office, and they're definitely going to vote for something like the CARES Act and whatever this thing is called trying to pass it. [01:23:12] The names are so fucked up, the CARES Act, right? The Earn It Act, you know. Yes. It's so Orwellian, man, the Patriot Act. Fuck. Yeah, it's double speak, man. I mean, it's just it is peak empire, peak fiat, and thank God for big you know for Bitcoin, right? [01:23:34] Like if I bel you know, we have a way out. Otherwise, you know, once once this can can't be kicked down the road anymore and the hyperinflation, the reality of what this monetary policy, man, it we would be fucked. It would be middle ages again. [01:23:52] It would be absolutely fucked. We have we have you know a parachute. Can I can I pivot us to a more positive topic? Please. Please. So you tried out juggernaut by John Cantrell. Yeah, yeah. [01:24:11] Yeah, I did. So John Cantrell. I met John Cantrell when he what was that thing called? Satoshi's treasure, right? Yeah, we were on the same, we were running the team together. Yeah, yeah. I mean these things sort of like you know, they start out with this big bang and everyone's into it. [01:24:34] Is that shit still going on? Yeah, I actually looked it up. John talking to John reminded me about it, and it's still going, but there's you know it's a small number of like that shit was hard, you know. Those those puzzles were fucking hard. So there's there's only I mean I think it drove away most people because there were supposed to be like ready to the listeners who don't know, it's like a ready player one idea with like Bitcoin prizes hidden around the world. [01:24:57] Yeah, and then if you finish in first place, I think you got like a million dollars worth of Bitcoin. But it wasn't it supposed to be pegged at like $4,000, so it's actually probably more than that now. Yeah, well they apparently bought all the Bitcoin at $4,000 or thereabouts. And so they had a million dollars worth of Bitcoin at $4,000 or two million. [01:25:19] Yeah. So definitely a big incentive, big prize, and it was really cool idea. It was ready player one with Bitcoin as a as a prize. But yeah, this the puzzles were super hard. And you know, people have a life like once you once the psych excitement dies down, you know, the reaction. Me too. [01:25:37] Yeah. Me too, yeah. You do you see they sold out? They have like a Tezos one now, too. No shit. God damn it, Eric. Like all the all the good things in this space, man. God damn it crazy. Well, anyway, so John Cantrell was the first one to get the first clue in the Satoshi's treasure hunt. [01:25:59] And he got it in this, like, you know, kind of clever, but in retrospect obvious little hack. And so I wrote I wrote to you and Marty, and I was like, hey, this looks like fun. You know, you guys have some pull. And it would be fun to like team up and just recruit a baller team and see if we can you know make this thing happen. [01:26:24] And we got cont and John Kentrell on the team. I was a big coup. We got some like you know, really smart, smart people on the team that have kind of done these these sorts of internet based digital you know treasure hunts before. It's a very hacker-based community, right? That you know does these kind of hunts. And they they're run, you know, they're they're common, you know, relatively common. [01:26:46] Like it's just not in aberration. Like these people come from the from you know groups that just like teams that do these things. So Marty came up with a great name. It was the Avengers, the god damn it, Raw Solbreak. [01:27:09] So it was like what was his name? Dread Pirate Roberts, right? It was the DPR Avengers. There you go. The DPR Avengers, the DPR Avengers, yeah. Yeah, I'm starting to get a little drunk, so the brain's working a little slower. Apologies, listeners. You can you know put this up, bump bump up the speed a couple a couple notches. [01:27:28] So DPR Avengers, and we got John Kentrell in the team, and that's where I met him. That was Satoshi Stoshers was pretty cool, but that was a long time ago. Stayed in touch with him, and he was having a hard time finding some people to beta test this thing, which I think which I find a little weird. Like he, you know, reached out to several like Slack groups and stuff, lightning based Slack groups, and had a hard time finding beta testers. [01:27:52] I think maybe it was because you had to be running 0.90, you know, version of lightning, and you had to have the key send stuff enabled, right? So I got into the Nodel, you know, I SSH, you know, as root into the Nodel and added this key send flag and upgraded to 0.90. [01:28:11] And I messaged him like, hey, you know, I'm ready. And he's got this really cool thing. It's called Juggernaut, and it's unstoppable messaging using lightning. You pay a few sats, and then it uses keysend for these invoiceless payments. So you can just send and receive sats without having to generate invoices, which I think is the cool thing. [01:28:29] Like I haven't played with that. So you can send messages and payments. And if you send a message, yeah, it is a payment, right? It well, you made it. The message itself is actually a lightning payment, right? You pay sats to route the messages through the you know messenger routers, the lightning routes that you take. [01:28:50] And you can send you can set the maximum that you're willing to pay to route your message, and if it's like a very important message or whatever, you can jack that up. I paid sub Satoshis as well, so it goes down to Millisatoshis, right? On this and supports sub Satoshis, which I think was cool. [01:29:09] It was also a first for me. So I paid 0.42 Satoshis to route a message at one point. And then yeah, you can you can request a payment, you can send a payment, you can receive payments, and it's all invoiceless. Super seamless. Very cool. Very cool. [01:29:28] You gotta try it out. Yeah. I have not tried it out yet. I saw it in that same in-between period when between the RHR recording and dropping. It does look cool. I there's something similar called Sphinx by the Nodal crew and the guy's name is is escaping me but they have a partner in that and with that it's this it's pretty it sounds like it's pretty much the same idea but when you load the mobile app it connects you to your own Nodal [01:30:06] Cloud instance yeah if you don't have your own node you can use it nice which is an interesting idea but yeah I look we're building this like incentivized onion routed network yep it should be interesting to see if like a message platform really does take steam there in terms of key send yes I'm pretty excited about it but I you know I'm a little wishy-washy in general on the idea that we're gonna have you know known public keys that don't rotate or anything yeah and [01:30:44] We receive payments to them it seems a step backwards in the press yeah it seems like a privacy issue but people should realize like if you're posting a lightning invoice anyway your public keys in there yeah so it doesn't really matter if you use key send or not. So in that in that respect, key send is like a strict improvement, just in UX. [01:31:06] True. Yeah. Oh, it's far better, right? It's a lot less. I mean, it's a lot more like cash. You can just hand it over. Yeah, you like the invoice in the real world when you're using cash is just you know, you owe me five bucks in that. $25. You know, and in this app, you can do that. [01:31:26] You can you can send a request. You can basically say the equivalent of, you know, you owe me a thousand sats and then get it paid or not. And you can also just give it to someone without them asking you for it, you know. So it's like, here's five bucks. It was cool, man. It was cool. I sent 21 sats to John. I was like, Satoshi would be proud, man. [01:31:45] It was it was well made. That's awesome. I'm glad to hear it. I like John a lot. So I do super bad. I look I look forward to testing it out. I feel a little bad because I kind of doxxed his his app, but like I kind of pre like launched it before he had a chance to like kind of do it himself. [01:32:03] So the other tester that he got for was Open Noms, who I know you have a lot of respect for me too. Absolutely. Yeah, and I saw Open Noms tweeted out. Like he took a screenshot of Juggernaut, tweeted it out, said, Hey, John's looking for beta testers. [01:32:21] You should help him out. And so I saw that and I was like, all right, well, I guess it's open season, I'm gonna do the same thing. I took a screenshot, posted it, tagged tagged you and a few others. And it, you know, that that tweet kind of got some traction. And I checked in, I was like, did you get any new beta testers off that? And he's like, Yeah, a few people reached out. [01:32:40] He's like, you kind of you kind of incent like created a like a faux launch there, though. And I was like, dude, I'm sorry. You know, I saw OpenNom's tweet, and so I just kind of followed suit, and he just laughed. He's like, Yeah, I'm just I'll I'll release it on Monday at this point. So hopefully y'all can try it out. [01:32:59] You do have to be running the latest version of L and D and have Keysend enabled. So I feel like with with open source software, you know, it's and all press is I in general, all press is good press, but especially with open source software. [01:33:19] He he's he'll he'll get more contributors because of it, and I'll get more testers and users. Yeah, so I think it's I think it's a net benefit for everyone. Yeah, I ran into a bug, you know, like you would expect. So I think more testers are beneficial, you know. Yeah. [01:33:39] I wanted to ask you about graphene. I've been curious about this. I know you've been talking about it. It's been a kick. Yeah. So how's it going? I mean, last time I heard you talk about it was like a month ago or something. I like it. You said you're using it as your daily driver. Are you still doing that? [01:33:57] Yeah, but like I don't go many places right now. Sure. Yeah, I have been using it as my daily driver. I'm using it with a Pixel 3a, which is probably more budget for me. I tend to use like one of the newer Samsung phones. [01:34:17] I'm still on an SE myself. The Pixel 3A is nice because it is like $300. It's like $2.99 most places. So it's it's a nice little starter phone. And it feels more expensive than it is. [01:34:36] It's you know, it's clearly not flagship, but it it it feels more way more expensive than $300. And the software runs fantastic. Literally, my only drawback is is camera. It's it's a combination of the Pixel 3A camera just being worse hardware. [01:34:56] Yeah. And also that the software is I you I use all open source software on my graphene phone. And open source camera apps are not anywhere near competitive. You know, they do all this like HDR stuff now where they're like combining multiple shots to make a better picture. [01:35:18] The open source isn't there yet. So so picture quality is worse in terms of the camera. Everything else is very workable as a as a daily driver. There's like a there's there's a couple things, you know, like you don't have paid apps. What about what about Twitter? [01:35:37] Is there like a Twitter Twitter interface? I just do the browser-based Twitter. Yeah. And it but it you could presumably, so they they have this open source version of Play Store called F-Droid, and it's only open source apps. And then within F-Droid, and also because it's Android, you can download an APK directly, like a an installable application file directly from a website. [01:36:06] In FDroid, there's also a store called Aurora Store. And Aurora Store is a mirror of Google Play with anonymized accounts. Like you don't actually sign in with a Google account. Nice. So that you can use with any free app that's on Google Play. Obviously, it's ideal that you only use open source apps, but if you absolutely need an app that's only on Google Play and it's not a paid app, you can get it that way. [01:36:31] But they have like a fully functioning, they have like a hardened Chromium browser in there, which is like the open source version of Chrome. And so all those web apps work really well. Like a lot of a lot of these guys have moved over to like web. You don't even need an app anymore. Yeah, it kind of seems that's where things are going on mobile is away from away from apps. [01:36:53] And just to get back to the core, like the reason graphing is cool is because it's a fork of Android that is privacy focused, so it has no Google services whatsoever. So in a world where your choices are like Apple or Android or no phone, obviously no phone is is best in terms of surveillance, but I can't do that. [01:37:15] I fully admit that. So graphene is like a really nice trade-off balance because you can run pretty much any Android app and you don't have any of the Google spyware just like hooking in there. And right now they're like talking about all this increased surveillance measures because of using coronavirus as an excuse, just like they did with 9-11. [01:37:35] Yeah. And so now more than ever, I think it's important to prioritize your pro privacy here. So you think the camera's the biggest trade-off? Yeah, I might buy like one of those point and shoots. Yeah. Because I use a camera for work. [01:37:54] Yeah. So that makes sense. So yeah, web apps and F Droid. So I hadn't heard about Aurora before. Like, how do they pull that off, man? Like, how do they mirror all this shit? I don't know. And I don't make any promises that that'll be around for I don't know how long it's been around. [01:38:13] Yeah, yeah. But it exists and it works. I tested it out. It does work. You can download pretty much any free app through there. And you're good to go. So that's so that's fucking awesome. And in terms of signal works great, telegram works great, Twitter. [01:38:37] I do through the browser. You know, Telegram has the open source app, so you're good. Signals direct APK. All the you start to appreciate the direct the direct APK download is a very liberating experience. You just get it straight from the from the source. Is Aurora kind of like Napster for APKs? [01:38:57] Like is it peer-to-peer? No, no, it's like a property Google Play. Yeah, it's super centralized. Yeah. It just works. I don't know. I haven't really looked into it. I don't I don't use any. I tested it, but I don't use any Aurora apps. I mean, look, all the all the good Bitcoin apps you should be able to either download on F Droid or APK. [01:39:18] Like Lightning, Zeus is on F Droid. Yeah. So you could just manage your node right through Zeus on your graphene phone. You don't have to worry about it. Samurai wallet, you can download the APK directly from their website. Nice. No problem whatsoever. So like there's really no need. [01:39:37] The things like might hurt you, is like, oh, you're used to banking on your phone, like banking apps. Like, that's probably not gonna happen. You could do that on the web though, too, probably. I mean, yeah, you can like I said, mobile, right? But like you're not gonna be able to use the app. You might have issues with like a Venmo or something like that. [01:39:56] I haven't tested it. The way I look at it is if you need to have those other apps, the apps that are inherently KYC'd. It's best to have like another phone or another like a tablet or something, and you run the apps on that. Yeah, like that's like your KYC device. [01:40:16] Right. And then you have, and then you have the one that's like your daily driver that you like walk around with and stuff. And that's actually probably better in terms of mind frame and keeping yourself sane as well. Yeah, because like one thing I do, I don't, and I pride myself on replying to people on Twitter and answering DMs and stuff. All my notifications are off. [01:40:35] I don't I don't do the notification thing. You can't, I'm not cool with people just taking my attention away. Yeah, yeah. That's another like issue of freedom and sovereignty, right? Like someone else can just own your attention if you just let people let them pop in there all the time. [01:40:54] Yeah, so what do you do about like what do you do for email? Are you using web-based email? Do you have an app? I know you use some kind of like yeah. Two to note is great. And you can see they have a direct A, they have a direct APK. [01:41:14] Okay, nice. And they actually so one of the issues with some of these apps, signal included, is that the notifications, you can have issues with the notifications because the way these apps, most of these apps do notifications is through Google Cloud Messaging, GCM, I think they call it, which is a Google service that automatically pushes the notification to your phone in a very low battery intensive way. [01:41:49] And the issue is if you're constantly pulling notifications, like it's gonna hurt your battery. Yeah. So these open source apps have to they have to be developed in a way that they can handle that environment. So like Telegram and Tuda Nota are actually they have their own open source implementations of it's not Google, it's not Google Cloud Messaging, but they have a way of they basically like always keep the app running in low power mode to pull notifications for. [01:42:20] So you do have issues with some of the other apps, but for my email, TutaNode is good. And honestly, the way my relationship with email isn't I need to know right away. My relationship with email is I'm checking that thing at certain times and I'm seeing what emails are in my inbox. [01:42:42] Yeah, it's not like I need to be notified like absolutely when it when it's when it's happening. And telegram notifications work really well. And you know, for whatever it's worth, more of my conversations are on. It's like telegram and keybase now or the majority of my conversations. [01:43:00] So I have Proton Mail, and one of the things I don't like about it is they don't have calendaring. Does Tutanota have calendar calendaring on it? Like if you get I sent you an invite and you accepted it, like where does that go? I accept I accepted in my Google calendar, like a surveillance plug. All right, on your like on your like laptop or something. [01:43:20] Yeah, I think I think Tuta added calendar support recently. Okay. I haven't transitioned to it yet. Yeah. That's nice. Like, yeah, I Google Calendar is like is like one of my Achilles heels. [01:43:40] I try and do the same thing. I can't find any I can't find anything that's like relatively respects privacy to replace it. Yeah, it's a it's a weird, it's and I a lot of times I'll go without it. Like I won't I won't actually add things. [01:43:58] I'll like add things to I have like a paper calendar. Yeah, okay, like I'll add things to like the like the actual like I figure you know like something like this, like we're doing it through Zoom. Yeah. Probably going through Chinese servers, you know. It's gonna be public anyway though. Yeah, it's gonna be public anyway. [01:44:17] Like it doesn't matter that it's on my Google Calendar. Right. But I'm I'm very I'm actively aware about what I put on and what I don't put on. That makes sense. So I think next level then would be like Snowden style, where you have like a physical kill switch for your microphone, and like you open up your phone and take out your GPS device and shit like that. [01:44:38] Have you thought about any of that and go in that direction? I mean, no, I think I ideally you have nothing. Right? You go you go phone less. Isn't that what Janine does? Yeah, that's what Janine does. I yeah, I respect that, man. I can't I respect the hell out of it. I can't do it. [01:44:57] Yeah, I am you know it's reliant. It's a personal computer in my pocket. I the trade-off is is not there yet for me. I could you know you maybe one day, but right now, specifically where I am at work and stuff, like I need this device. [01:45:21] So I try and just limit the downsides as much as possible and be actively aware about it. Like I do leave my phone when I go places sometimes, yeah. And people should do that more. You know, people are attached to it, people don't realize it's not too many hops from a phone that's always in your pocket or your hand to a chip that is embedded in your skin. [01:45:46] Like there's not that many hops there, like they're tracking your location, they're tracking every message you make. Yeah, like they we're we're pretty close. We're pretty close to the chip as it is for sure, man. Yeah. I mean I have started doing that, like when I'm done with work for the day and it's family time. [01:46:08] I just I plug my phone in, it's ready to charge back up anyway, it needs to be charged back up anyway, and I just leave it, you know, in a corner of my bedroom and just like don't touch it again until ideally the next morning, right? It's hard to do, you know, it's hard to do. Like you wanna you wanna you feel the pull, like you feel it. [01:46:27] I feel it. Like I want to go check Twitter. Like I, you know, if I post a tweet right before like put my phone down, I'm thinking about that thing for a couple hours. Like, you know, who's responded? Like how many how did how did you know what did it do to get a bunch of likes and retweets like all different security? You know what I mean? Like it's that dopamine, it is, man. [01:46:47] Totally is. It's like a drug. So what what do you do, man? You like, all right, you're you're saying you need a camera for work and all that stuff. I've never heard you talk about this. I don't know if you want to or not, but what do you do? It's the one it's the one thing I've been good about. Yeah, gonna I'm not gonna stop now. I'm not I my my obsec has been positive on that front. [01:47:08] Yeah, hopefully I won't be doing it for much longer, so it'll be irrelevant anyway. Yeah, that's that's I was trying to just basically squeeze out. You know, I New York doesn't fit me. Yeah, and I've been I just been trying to, but the money's good, so I'm just been trying to squeeze out till the to the next recession was basically the plan. [01:47:36] So we might be on the verge of it, or it might be like another five years or something. Yeah, but I'll tell you one thing like [01:47:46] This all this shit like has has hastened that that decision, just in general, like city life, like the all the benefits of New York City, became negatives in a pandemic situation. Hardcore, yeah. It's it's like fragile, antifragile, right? [01:48:06] Yeah, yeah. So it definitely made me think like my plan is to go, I'm gonna go to, you know, I'm I'm I'm on I'm on land. I just want to like be out, be out in the in nature, and just yeah, I want to be I want to be a Bitcoin mountain man, you know. That's the dream. [01:48:27] That's what I'm working towards. You're mountains or beach, I guess it sounds like mountains. Well, no, I said mountain man because that that's what Vitalik used as derogatory slur to Bitcoin. No shit. I didn't know about this one. He's like Bitcoin or mounted men running full nodes, you know, it's like the meme. He's like the meme he created. [01:48:45] Or just to stereotype us. So that's what I said, but like it doesn't have to be necessarily mountains, it's just that kind that idea, right? It's like, you know, build your own citadel, like be, you know, on like 60 acres or something like that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I hadn't heard this mountain man thing. Was this like before or after Maximalist? [01:49:06] Was this like pre-maximalists? Because that's the one that stuck. I think it was around the same time. I'm not I'm not quite sure. I'd I'd have to look it up. But it was it was a funny one because I didn't think it was derogatory. And also like no shit. Me neither. It you know, it's just ridiculous this idea that you're gonna downplay the importance of full nodes. [01:49:30] Like there are plenty of people, and I 100%, you know, I'm not one of those people that denies it. There's plenty of people that overstate the value of full nodes. Yeah, okay. But the ability for each individual to connect to the Bitcoin network in an extremely trust minimized way, yeah. [01:49:50] One of the most integral parts of the whole thing. I don't I don't think full nodes can force change, but they can stop change and they can give you a way to access the network in a trust minimized way. And that that's the important thing there. And it's important that anyone can run it, and it's important, you know, Tor's not perfect, but it's important that anyone can run it through Tor because you don't want to dox your IP address and your location and your internet traffic, depending on where you live. [01:50:22] Yeah, and that's why I love things like samurai and nautil that just make that easy, man. Just turn clean, you know, click a checkbox and click a button and you're on tour what did you oh what I was I had a question for you and I forget what it was now so let me think here yeah that one's gone so you talking about like moving out in the lands you know like getting out of the city in in a future that you think about like how do you define success like what would what would be in 10 15 20 [01:51:01] Years from now like you would look back and be like yeah satisfied this is my life's been successful since I was you know whatever in 2020 [01:51:12] It's a very deep question well it's it's time for a deep question man we've let me I'm gonna pour some more yeah me too pour some more whiskey well you know it'd be nice if Bitcoin was successful kind of tied myself to that shift yeah it'd be nice but you know it's family it's just a comfortable life like life is short life is fucking short like the funniest thing about Bitcoin is that so many people pretend they own more than they own yeah that they're richer than they are and so [01:51:51] Many people believe other people are richer than they are even if they don't say they're everyone always assumes you have more Bitcoin than you have. Trace mayor yeah but but like with Trace, he portrayed that, right? Yeah. But like even like people that I talk to about when I when I like show Bitcoin at like Thanksgiving or something, like everyone assumes I have more big first of all, the question is always how much Bitcoin do you have? [01:52:18] And I always tell them not enough. And as soon as I say that, they assume high. That's like the goal, right? And that's never what it's really been about. Like it's you know, I've always been very conservative. Just like with my money and my lifestyle and everything. [01:52:40] And but I like to take risks at the same time. So I like to be conservative risks. I don't know. It's it's weird. But like in moderation, you take it in moderation. And like the goal in life is to just like enjoy the short time we have. Like you for the short time you have, and you try and like be the best person you can be, corny as fuck. [01:53:02] And I'll probably, if if we're gonna be quite honest, hopefully, you know, if there's not like some tragic accident where I like I die younger, I'll be like 60 years old. Like I'll be out on my porch barbecuing. And I'll say to myself, I'll be like, was this all worth it, Matt? [01:53:23] Like, did it work out? And I'll make it, I'll make a decision then. I don't know. Like, I right now I'm I feel fulfilled. Let me put it that way. I feel fulfilled right now, and I think it's just like a constant thing that you have to constantly ask yourself, like, am I wasting this short time? Like, is there am I just dealing with bullshit all day? [01:53:43] Am I not happy? Am I, you know, all these little things, like they add up. Like you gotta be, if you don't take care of yourself, if you don't take care of the people around you, like no one else is going to. And you just have to, you just have to, you know, one step at a time, but you get you gotta realize like it's short. [01:54:03] It's it's really fucking short life. No shit, man. It really is. So I'm 40 now. And I hadn't I hadn't been affected by that by the number for ever I mean ever, you know. [01:54:21] And when I turned 40, like it didn't really affect me like right right around my birthday or anything. I was just like, whatever, it's on the birthday, no big deal. But kind of as I have gone through the year, I'm about I'm coming up on another birthday. I you know, that there's the milestone, man. Like, you know, humans are the big numbers affect us, you know. [01:54:41] It happens in Bitcoin with price and everything too, you know. And I've been thinking about it, I've been feeling it a little bit, you know. It's like a lot of my life is in my past at this point. It's pretty significant chunk of time when it comes to a human lifetime. At the same time, it's not that much time, it's a fucking blip, you know, on the on the timeline, the grander scale. [01:55:01] Yeah, the thing that's really getting to me now is my kids. So talk about a short time, right? You want to talk about short times, but when you really gotta make the most. Your kids really only look to you fully, you know, like you're you know, kind of their son, you know, like by sun, I mean like the star at the center of their their solar system, you know, for 10, 12 years, and then it's you know, increasingly friends and who are influencing them, and they're you know, becoming their own person, and that's [01:55:40] The you know, I have a daughter who's eight, and that's coming, that's coming close, man it's getting close and I saw this commercial for Disney. I was at the gym, I was in the locker room, there's TV in there, and I saw this commercial. This dad was sitting on the edge of a bed, and his daughter was packing up to go to college, and he's looking on his phone at pictures from when he when she was a little girl, you know, and she comes up to him and like kind of leans into him, they're like cheek to cheek, you know, and she's looking at the pictures and stuff, it's like this really sweet moment. [01:56:17] And man, I just was like, fuck, I've already got emptiness syndrome, like right now. Like I, you know, I'm it it makes me, I don't know, man. It's the short time, right? So to me, when I'm looking back, I will want to like make sure that I maximize the presence for moments like that because life is short, right? [01:56:41] I don't I want to be with my kids for moments that matter as much as I can right now because that's that that's what's that's what's valuable to me. So this quarantine thing has had this interesting effect, right? Of bringing family closer together, even though you're separated, right? [01:57:01] So I mean by you know, by that I mean family, like you know, parents and siblings and aunts and uncles. I got a call from my uncle that I you know hadn't talked to in a long time. Is your family doing the Zoom thing? Yeah, we had we had dinner together on Zoom the other day. How weird is that? Like it's just weird in in in a good way. [01:57:21] Yeah, I've had I've had Zooms with like 20, 30 cousins from around the world. Yeah, honestly, if there wasn't a pandemic, I couldn't see them anyway. Like in Australia and shit. But everyone's reaching out. Yeah, all of a sudden everyone is doing like these massive video chat calls. [01:57:40] And it's actually pretty it's pretty fantastic. It is pretty fantastic. And I'm you know, it's pretty interesting. I wonder if that'll continue afterwards. Like if we no, I don't think it will. I don't think it's going to use pessimistic. Well, I just don't, I mean, I'm being realistic, I think. I just don't think it will, you know. I think people will go back. [01:57:58] I so let me, I mean, let me back check on that a little bit. Because I think I do think things are gonna change kind of fundamentally. I think that this is going to kind of spur a movement back toward community and family. [01:58:17] I think what we're seeing in this greater trend is just a breakdown of the massive kind of state governments, these empires, right? This massive centralization of powers. And you know, the first thing that's gonna really crack that is the money, and that's happening right now, and we've got this alternative. [01:58:36] And when you have the separation of money and state, you really limit the power of the state, right? I mean, printing of the money is fucking incredible source of power, it's massive. Right, and it has been that way through history. And that's why, you know, people have you know, dictators, kings, presidents, just central authorities throughout history have sought to control the printing of money because it's, you know, the mayor Amschel Ross Rothschild quote, right? [01:59:06] Like give me control of the money and I care not who makes the laws, you know. That's where the power is, and this is a zero to one moment, epical moment in human history where we have a money that's resistant to centralization, and it's gonna change everything. And I think, you know, this this pandemic has hastened this move on the money front, the monetary front. [01:59:32] But I think it may be also hastening this kind of transition to this society that is going to be a consequence of having a decentralized money, right? It's gonna be more local and community-based and family-based. So maybe maybe it is gonna change. [01:59:51] Maybe it won't go back, man. Well, I'll tell you, it's it's interesting watching it was such a sudden shift to everyone being like video producers at home and stuff. [02:00:09] Yeah. So like like Jimmy Kimmel and all these big shows, SNL and stuff, they're all doing shows like through video chat on people's computers, like in their homes. Yeah. And when you see, so it like really highlights like what a move to like a digital focused economy looks like, right? [02:00:31] Yes. And all of a sudden you quickly see the pain points of relying on traditional financial systems for that, right? Like if you're you know, if you're a content producer or an e-commerce store in India, you can immediately accept payments from around the world in a cash like way with Bitcoin. [02:00:53] You might be restricted if you try and use PayPal or Venmo or something. I like Venmo definitely doesn't support India. I know Cash App doesn't. Libra probably won't if it ever launches. And so you immediately see why that need exists. [02:01:11] Yeah. For censorship resistant digital money. So I wonder if it if it hastens that. Definitely like central bank actions are going to hasten that. Yeah. I think people have some people have gotten red pill from this event that they, you know, they realize how inept everything is and how corrupt it is. [02:01:34] So that will probably hasten things. Further moves to digital, like I think I've been using Jitsi, which is an open source competitor to Zoom. Yeah. And I have a feeling like lots of devs have used it as well. And so it'll probably get a ton of contributions. [02:01:53] Yeah. Like during during and after this quarantine period. Like little things like that will see improvements. You know, maybe a move back from cities. I'm not sure if the localism thing is gonna happen. Yeah. I do think it's gonna happen long term. You know, I call it citadels. [02:02:13] I'm not sure how much it's gonna hasten it now. People say, like, oh, we should manufacture more things at home, look at like the issues now. But as soon as the crisis dissipates, like you can save 10 cents if you do it in China instead. [02:02:31] Like you probably are gonna do that. Like all the incentives are set up still for low time for high time preference. So that that probably won't change. And when it does move back, hate to hate to break it to people, but a lot of that's gonna be automated, is as what I is what I imagine is gonna happen, which is you know not ideal, but at least it's local. [02:02:58] Yeah, I don't know, man. Like this is kind of what I was thinking when I was when you said I was being pessimistic, right? Like there's this is another example of Lindy effect, you know. Like we've been living this way for for quite a while, a lot, you know, so at least several generations. This urbanizate urbanization trend has been happening, and I think it's gonna take a while to reverse it. [02:03:22] But this is a bit of a glimpse, right? Like, you know, we're not I don't think we're gonna go back to working necessarily like in cubicles and offices, I think you know, as much, right? I think there's gonna be a little push, like it's the beginning of a push away from that. We've we've been seeing a trend toward remote work anyway, but there are more types of work, I think that are obviously able to be done remotely now. [02:03:47] And you know, I'll be interested to see like how employers react if they if they think that like you know productivity was was sufficient enough to like justify letting people work from home. And going back to my kid, the kid thing, right? Like I am happy to be back at home. [02:04:06] I you know, I've been working in a co-working space since my son turned one, and I was just like, you know, my kids were little and I just got interrupted constantly, like literally banging on the door, you know, like the door be locked, banging on the door, and like you just you feel bad, like you don't wanna make your son sit out there banging on the door and not like open it and be like, hey, what's up? [02:04:25] You know, and so I moved to a co-working space, but I'm coming back now, my kids are older, and you know, they under they understand I gotta work, and then when I got it got some time, you know, I pop out or I open the door and say, Hey, why don't you come in here and hang out, you know, do your you know, read or color whatever you're doing, do your tablet and hang out with me. [02:04:46] And it's just it's great. I don't know if I'm gonna go back to my co-working space, you know. Like I just I think that will definitely be that's gonna be a paradigm shift. Like these companies are spending so much money on rent. [02:05:06] For sure. Yeah, and they can they can cut that cost, and in a lot of times, a lot of times the employee will be more efficient if if they're working from home. They don't have to do their commute, you know. The average commute in America is an hour and a half, I think each way. [02:05:25] That's fucked up, which is insane. A lot of times you're sitting in traffic and stuff, which is great for the podcast industry, true, but it's not great for productivity. So even if they just downsize by half, if they did if they downsize by half and they have half their employees, you know, work from home and half work in the in the office, or maybe even have them switch, you know, like one week you work in the office, one week you don't. [02:05:54] They can save so much money. And they save money in a way that allows them to be flexible in downtimes, yeah. Like we're in right now. And no one wanted to pull the trigger on it. And also in a lot of industries like banking and stuff, you had all these compliance issues that basically wouldn't let you have work from home. [02:06:13] Yeah. And they had to relax all of those issues. Like they had to allow, like there's things in banking that you're you were never allowed to do outside of the office. You had to be like, and now they're letting people do it through VPNs, like private VPNs, you know, through the office servers. It's interesting. I wonder how much will change and how much will go back to how to how it was before. [02:06:37] But I do I do think that I mean, I think the real estate market right now is going to it's gonna have an issue, just in general. We shall see. I mean, if you if you if people stop, you know, if like half the workforce starts working from home, you need half the office space, like what the fuck, right? [02:06:56] We work right now. We work was basically like this massively leverage long real estate play, yeah. And they're fucking hurting right now. We should we'll we'll see how that works out. Airbnb, man. Like all the whole travel industry, obviously. But we work was special because they like legit took all that risk on themselves. [02:07:18] Airbnb like outsourced the risk and took a very true, yeah. Very true. It's the smarter play. Yeah, it is the smarter play, that's for sure. Like we work is legit on leases, they're on like leases all throughout the world. Just massive amounts of office space, basically, like landlords just outsource their risk to WeWork, but they didn't realize like in this situation, we work's just like well, I have renting three floors from you and I can't pay my rent. [02:07:45] So what are you gonna do about it? You're gonna you're gonna kick me out? Right. This is what I'm thinking. This is what I'm saying, though. Like, we're just at the beginning of this economically speaking. Like the kinds of debt-based like liquidations that we're gonna see because companies have been so overextended or just made the wrong bets, and you know, everyone's overextended. [02:08:08] You know, it's the company, it's the employees, it's the tenants, it's the landlords, it's everybody. We're incentivized to live on debt, man. Like, yeah, that's the smart play in this in this monetary policy world. No one has savings. I mean, very few, obviously, some do, but I mean long term it's not a smart play, but we can't just like it's not just the economy's not just gonna turn back on. [02:08:34] I'm I'm I'm trying to check my biases because I've been calling for like a global financial collapse for like seven years now, yeah. You know, like it's it's it's been a long time. I've been wrong for a while. So I'm trying to check my biases because you know, maybe they just like print their way out of it, and like for with five years, we just hit all-time highs. [02:08:58] Yeah, but it doesn't it doesn't seem like it a I don't like are people gonna go to restaurants immediately? Like it's not just us, it's not just the state that tells you it's a lockdown, right? Like the state could lift it, but like people aren't gonna just start immediately going out and going to places and resuming their behaviors, especially if they're unemployed. [02:09:22] They if they need the money, then they're even it's they're gonna even be tighter about it. So it's it's gonna be a slow process, and there's gonna be like lots of knock on effects. And as we said earlier, I don't think the economy was healthy to begin with. So I'm I'm a bit concerned, just in general. [02:09:40] I always knew it was gonna happen, but I never wished for it to happen yeah and it's it's it's it's more worrisome than I expected like when I thought about how it was gonna be like living through I thought I thought it was gonna be well I didn't think we were gonna have like a pandemic and all everything all in combined like I didn't think we're gonna have like a global lockdown into that's the thing right that's the difference right this is not just a normal fiat driven economic bubble right this is a combination of the everything bubble like we've been talking about like in 2008 it was mostly real estate you [02:10:18] Know all of these ridiculous you know subprime loans that were rolled into this these shitty fucking investments but given you know a ratings by these fucking rating agencies that were in bed with the fucking banks and mortgage companies right like that that was that was shitty that was that was fucked up and it led to some some tough times we printed our way out of that shit but this is different we have a fucking global pandemic we have the entire economy basically shut down of the world it's around the world around the fucking world plus we have an everything bubble on our hands [02:10:57] Right you know we've seen memes through the years on Bitcoin Twitter that you know bitcoin is the pin right it's gonna pop the everything bubble but you know this it's a pandemic and Bitcoin is the parachute like I think that's the right that's the right metaphor now. [02:11:17] You know, this is the bubble's gonna pop and we're gonna be just fucking thrown out into into into the air, into the atmosphere, and we're gonna be able to pull that parachute, you know, pull that fucking rope and hopefully have a bit of a softer landing than we'd have without it. [02:11:36] I mean, it's it's still it's not gonna, I don't think it's gonna be smooth transition in in any you know any respect. But Pomp had it wrong the whole time. The virus is spreading, but Bitcoin is the cure. Fuck yes. I've been saying that forever, man. Bitcoin is not the virus, Bitcoin is the cure. [02:11:55] And I've seen that on Twitter too. But now it's like a little bit cult-ish. A little bit cult-ish, but Bitcoin won't won't cure the pandemic, but it's the cure, yeah, it's the cure to this, you know, the cure in general. Yeah, to this to the illness, the disease that has been precipitated by this this fiat system we're we're in. [02:12:18] But now we have this it'll help push us in the right direction. It's not like silver. Right. Yeah, exactly. But I do love the fact that now we have this literal virus that is yeah, man. That palm's metaphor has been flipped on its head. But anyway, man, it's it's crazy. [02:12:37] I am I am bullish on Bitcoin. I'm hopeful because of Bitcoin. This is a time for Bitcoiners to shine, right? We've been waiting. Well, I wouldn't say we've been waiting for this to happen. That was the wrong way to put it, but we have been preparing for something like this to happen. [02:12:56] And we are now called upon to take what we've learned, to stay humble, and to you know, educate the world about this this fallback option that we have been learning about for years now. Yeah, cheers, cheers to that. [02:13:14] Cheers, Matt. Appreciate this conversation, man. Love everybody thoroughly enjoyed it. [02:13:19] Yeah. [02:13:29] Thanks to Matt for joining me. That was an oasis in this epidemic. Really appreciated that. Really enjoyed it. Share this one out, Bitcoiners. Share the love. Let Matt and me know your thoughts about this episode. Matt is at Matt underscore Odell for the 0.3% of you who aren't following him yet. [02:13:53] I am at Citizen Bitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. Share this one with family and friends. It'll trip them the fuck out. Maybe it'll tip them over into that rabbit hole. This is the little cake and drink at the bottom of the rabbit hole that'll get them into Wonderland. [02:14:17] Thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring this episode and to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the Citizen Bitcoin podcast in their feed. You should check out my merch store at layer1btc.com. Alright, you all gotta support Nick Ward there. He's a great Bitcoiner, great designer. [02:14:36] Click on partners and then Citizen Bitcoin. Got a lot of cool stuff there, including my favorite, the unfuck the money design. Grab that t shirt, it's rad, rock it out, and you know, these days it's more apropos than ever. Check out the podcast of Creative for Swan. [02:14:55] Every week we host Swan Signal Live on Wednesdays, a couple of Bitcoiners, myself and Cory Klippsten, founder of Swan. We get on, you know, get on Twitter and rap about Bitcoin, and then the audio is published as a podcast at Swan Signal Podcast.com. [02:15:14] So go there and subscribe now. Matt was on that one with John Carvalho last week. We've had Marty and Connor on together. We've had a lot of great shows already. I think we're five episodes in. Go to SwanSignal Podcast.com, subscribe now. And if you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. [02:15:35] My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at citizenbitcoin on telegram and keybase. My email address is citizenbitcoin at pm.me. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.