Yan Pritzker: The Money Red Pill, Bitcoin Tech and Swan Bitcoin Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2020-01-16 [00:00:22] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. I've got a discussion with Yan Pritzker, author of Inventing Bitcoin and co-founder, CTO of Swan Bitcoin for you all today. Now you might ask, what is Swan Bitcoin? [00:00:41] I haven't heard of that yet. Well, Swan Bitcoin is the new name and brand for the umbrella company that will be home to the Give Bitcoin and Save Bitcoin products. Now, Swan Bitcoin, the brand is inspired by the work of Nassim Taleb and the idea that Bitcoin is what Taleb calls a black swan, which is a rare and unpredictable outlier event with extreme impact. [00:01:00] And if that doesn't describe Bitcoin, I don't know what does. [00:01:03] Bitcoin is the biggest black swan event in recent human history. Now, I'm a Taleb fan, and I know founder, CEO Cory Klippsten is a Taleb fan. I know a lot of Bitcoiners are. I love this branding for the Umbrella Company. Now, be sure to continue to keep GiveBitcoin in your mind as you're looking for birthday, bar mitzvah, graduation, Valentine's Day gifts. [00:01:24] You know, show your love with some Bitcoin. You know maybe your partner doesn't quite appreciate what bitcoin is yet but use give bitcoin to give them some of that education and you know bring them up to hodler status in a year by the time next valentine's day rolls around you know they'll be very appreciative and know exactly how much to value that bitcoin that you gave them make sure you also follow save bitcoin on twitter at save underscore bitcoin [00:01:45] To keep up with the latest as we approach the launch of that dead simple set it and forget it auto stacking straight from your bank account to the Bitcoin ledger Bitcoin savings account your Bitcoin savings account it's gonna be awesome all right a couple quick shout-outs today before we move on first my merch partner Nick Ward at Layer1BTC go to layer1btc.com click partners and then citizenbitcoin check out the merch collection that supports this podcast and also a big thank you to the Let's Talk Bitcoin network for including the Citizen Bitcoin pod in the LTBN family of great Bitcoin podcasts if you're listening on the LTBN feed I welcome to you I hope to be part of your Bitcoin journey going forward. [00:02:21] Now if you like what you hear you can find a growing archive of great shows on the web at citizenbitcoin.world and please do follow LTBN on Bitcoin Twitter at the LTB network and subscribe to the LTBN feed for more great Bitcoin content all in one place. Alright let's go [00:02:45] All right I'm excited to welcome Yan Pritzker author of Inventing Bitcoin and CTO of Swan Bitcoin the new umbrella company for give Bitcoin and the soon to launch save Bitcoin. Welcome Jan How's it going man? Thanks I'm really happy to be here really excited. Thanks for having me on. [00:03:04] Absolutely man I'm excited for the conversation too okay let's let's start you have a really interesting personal history and I think it's really relevant to Bitcoin you immigrated from the former Soviet Union to the US so what were the circumstances and like motivations to make that move and how might the existence of Bitcoin have made a difference for you and the people of Russia at that time yeah I think so when I was seven, my family moved from the former Soviet Union to the United States. [00:03:36] You know, life in the Soviet Union was not easy. I mean, I was a kid, so I didn't know as much about what life should be like. And neither did my parents really, because the flow of information into the Soviet Union was very, very limited. So we didn't really know what America was like, you know, what other things were out there. But we were we're living in a very, you know, a socialist economy, right? [00:03:57] So there were shortages everywhere. We had to stand in line for things, and you pretty much just stood in line whenever you saw a line and you just took whatever was available that day, and there was a very big black market for trading goods that people actually needed. And then, you know, my parents I think felt that was something wrong with the situation. [00:04:16] And also after Chernobyl happened, which was in 1986, yeah, they started getting the idea that like, you know, this is not a maybe not the best country to be living in. I don't know if you saw that series that just came out, but it was kind of like illustrating all the cover-ups that the government went through to kind of say everything was just fine even though people were dying. Yeah, I did see that it was crazy. [00:04:37] It was a very like you know, controlling environment, as as those some places tend to be. So in 1989 we finally were able to leave. There was a period of time where people were not able to leave because I mean essentially the government didn't want anybody coming in and out. But in eighty nine that was a little bit relaxed and we were able to leave. [00:04:56] Although when we left, we were only able to exchange some of our money. So we had Soviet rubles, which were kind of, you know, basically like Venezuelan Boulevards are today, garbage currency that nobody else really wanted. It worked internally to the country because all the prices were fixed, but outside of the Soviet Union, nobody wanted those rubles. [00:05:15] So the government actually exchanged $100 dollars per person worth of currency. Wow. Then that's what we left with, right? So that's like, you know, that's what real capital controls look like, and that's something that I think a lot of folks here in America don't really understand. And so like when we had to leave, we couldn't really take our wealth with us. [00:05:33] We had some suitcases with some junk that we try to sell, and then you know, $100 per person. So that's that's it. That's what we got. I mean, that's crazy. I mean, that's you know essentially all your wealth that you have to give up and just start completely over from scratch. Right. And that's that's I think the problem that Bitcoin solves that a lot of people don't understand. [00:05:54] Like that's to me, you know, aside from all the sort of problems we have with inflation and all that kind of stuff in the first world, the real problem Bitcoin solves, I think, is like capital controls, right? The ability to say, this money is mine, this is my wealth, and I want to take it with me if I if I want to leave. Because not allowing people to take their wealth with them is a form of oppression, and that basically keeps people inside of these authoritarian regimes. [00:06:19] And that's what really got me interested in Bitcoin. Once I really understood what it was, I saw it as a type of freedom money, right? I could, you know, imagine if my family had Bitcoin in in Soviet Union 25 years prior, and we were building up this little stash, even if it was like a dollar a month, right? Yeah. We started to have this pot of wealth that is actually portable. [00:06:37] And that gives you options. You know, you can leave a country that's failing if you have those options. But if you're completely tied down to the whims of the government and what they do with the currency and how they manage the economy, you know, you're in a bad place. You don't have your freedom if you don't have your money. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, that's yeah, your money is really the w the representation of your will. [00:06:58] It's the representation of your choices, the ability to make those choices. And so yeah, it's it's essentially you know, it's it's almost more fundamental to freedom than even the f the freedom of speech. It's it's I guess it's really a form of speech. Yeah, I would totally agree with that. I think especially in the you know quote unquote democracy where you're supposed to vote, if we really look at how voting works, you're not really voting for like an arbitrary pool of people. [00:07:24] You're voting for people that were pre-selected by money. So if you're not able to even you know spend that money to exercise your your economic power or whether you know whether it be for political candidates or for stuff you buy at the store, right? To like indicate that you're interested in one type of product versus another, you're you're basically losing the freedom to make personal choices. [00:07:44] And so yeah money's absolutely fundamental to that and that's that's why Bitcoin is so important. Yeah absolutely. Were you how old were you when you came over? I was I was seven. I was like seven and a half. So you're pretty young. Cool. All right. Yeah yeah so most of this I actually you know a lot of this what I know is not from my memory but rather from asking my parents about how it was and also from researching online. [00:08:06] And I really only started doing that once I got into Bitcoin because I never you know I never thought about this stuff growing up and never thought about money or how freedom and money interact. I was kind of I briefly was kind of libertarian leaning in college and I went to a few meetups and stuff but I never really got into it. I never really thought about like what is that link between freedom and money. [00:08:26] Yeah me neither man. Me neither and I talk about that on the pod all the time. And yeah it's increasingly Bitcoiners are like that. They're being taught what money really is by Bitcoin itself. It I remember doing a poll a while back and asking Bitcoiners if they had learned about Austrian economic ideas before or after they got into Bitcoin and it was almost exactly it was exactly split. [00:08:52] Two-thirds of the answers, and it was like you know, statistically significant because it was like over three thousand answers, right? So yeah, 66% said that they were found out about what money really is in Austrian economic ideas after getting into Bitcoin, 33% before. And I, you know, if I would have asked that question five years ago, I think it would have been flipped or maybe even like 80 20 the other way. [00:09:13] Yeah, I think that's absolutely interesting. I was running a similar poll on Twitter about like whether people had an economics background or technology background and whether they understood or didn't understand Bitcoin at first. And you know, I'm a technology guy and I didn't have any economics background getting into Bitcoin. And I heard about Bitcoin in 2011 and 2013, and both times did not actually like understand what it was or research it. [00:09:34] It wasn't until 2016 that I dove in. And I found that this was actually a common pattern. People who had a technology background saw it as a tech play, thought it was interesting, didn't think much of it. People with like a strong background in economics, or even people who are like gold bugs who had some understanding of what sound money looks like, they actually had an easier time seeing Bitcoin. [00:09:54] Now I think a lot of other people like me and other people who don't necessarily have that economics background are coming in and they're coming in with this you know with a blank slate on economics and they're seeing like oh Bitcoin works despite that people say deflationary money can't work, blah blah blah. [00:10:12] Like it's it's working and it's growing, and you know, nothing really explains that really well except for the Austrian school. So I definitely think that's something that's worth studying, and I'm only just kind of diving in myself. Signed up for Safe Dean's course, highly recommend that. I'm only about halfway through, super behind, but it's been really fun. [00:10:31] Yeah, it's a lot to keep up with. I was in the first cohort and yeah, I couldn't quite keep up with all the reading. So I might go through the course again, I think. Yeah, I'm going through at my own pace because it's just you know, I have too much going on to be able to go weekly, but I think it's a good it's a good you know forcing function to really start looking at the biggest thing. [00:10:50] Start up life though. Yes. Okay, so I want to go back. When you mentioned that your parents well you were talking to your parents about Bitcoin. So what do they think about Bitcoin? Well, they they understand, I think more than most people of their age. They they kind of like got the idea about the freedom money, and my dad's actually bought some Bitcoin on my on my edging or egging or whatever that is. [00:11:18] He you know, he's a technology guy too, so he kind of looked at it as an interesting distributed system. And when I explained to him, you know, this is kind of like a new digital money, but nobody's in charge. There's a whole bunch of computers. He was really interested in just how it worked. I think that's that's what got him excited. My mom is, you know, she's she's relatively passive on this stuff, but they both embrace my my you know career in the space. [00:11:41] I think they they trust me. They see that I have a lot of interest and passion for this. And I think that's the most important thing is that Bitcoin it is it is a passion project for a lot of people. I think a lot of people see Bitcoin as a big force of good in the world, despite all the bad media headlines that you sometimes get, right? [00:12:00] I think all of us that are actually in Bitcoin who have actually studied it and who've actually interacted with other Bitcoiners, we know that there's a lot more to it than meets the eye, and that's why we're doing it, right? And I think that my parents definitely saw that. Yeah, you get that sense when you fall down the rabbit hole, you're like, oh wow, there's so much going on here. And then it just leads to a you know, an education or even a re-education on so many topics. [00:12:21] You know, like we talked about, obviously economics and money, but even beyond that, you know, all the tech, what what is peer-to-peer networking? What is you know, what is proof of work and what is the idea of digital scarcity? How does that actually happen? And then yeah, it just goes on from there. The follow-on effects of true scarcity, personal responsibility, you know, and I've talked about this on the pod too. [00:12:43] It it's kind of changed my habits as a person. And I, you know, think longer term, you know, I'm less short my my time preferences has shifted. And yeah, the follow-on effects of that is I've it's funny because I've gotten really annoyed at like spending small amounts of money now. Like I used to just, you know, okay, this is 20 bucks, I don't care, but now I'm like, oh, this is like why are we paying for this? [00:13:04] Do we really need this? And should I just think some stats instead? It's just it definitely changes the way you're you're you're thinking, and you know, delaying delaying frivolous purchases, like you know, it's it's essentially a high interest paying, well, you know, it's not it's not interest, but you used to be able to keep money in a bank account and it would grow at some, you know, at some rate, or or even a bond or something. [00:13:25] But nowadays that's not that's gone. So people aren't used to the idea of saving anymore. They're like, you know, if you have money, you spend it, or or you throw it in the stock market or whatever, like that. But that's you know, that's risky. But with Bitcoin, I think of it now as like I can actually save this money, you know, it's an actual savings account. It actually grows or at least stores its value. [00:13:45] So now I can defer my purchases and you know save up for something nicer. I've done that too. I started keeping track of like you know, I'll go out to a bar or something, and instead of buying like three beers, I'll just drink like one beer and drink it slowly and enjoy playing darts and foosball. And I'll say, like, all right, that's seven dollars saved, I'll stick it on a spreadsheet at the end of the month. I add that to my you know, my SATS buy. [00:14:04] And yeah, and not only that, so like that's just a good example. Now I'm drinking less, right? You know, you know, I'm like, I've I started I've taken care of myself just just from thinking longer term, right? Taking better care of myself. You know, I've become I've actually started procrastinating less. Used to be a huge procrastinator. [00:14:24] I still am, but you know, I'm working on that habit. And it's yeah. I want to say I started progressing procrastinating less because I feel like more motivated to make money so I can stack SATS, especially right now because of what's you know, the potential opportunity, you know. And going back to your point that you just made, like moving the way the m the money is now, negative interest rates and easy money really does encourage people to like you know put their money into something that will, you know, grow in value because the money itself is not growing in value. [00:14:56] So you know, like you mentioned, stock markets, real estate art, something that's actually scarce. You know, the money's not scarce anymore. And so that's I mean it's not only risky, but it's like leading to this fundamental change in the nature of our economy and the way things work. It it's it's you know leads to these large bubbles, and it's you know, bas it's unsafe and it and it it creates an economy where value accrues to the top. [00:15:21] And if you look at the and I, you know, I mentioned this every podcast, it seems now. Shout out to Ben Prentice and what WTF happened in 1971 and call in at the Bitcoin yeah, Bitcoin Echo Chamber too. Yeah, yeah. So those guys put that that productivity chart, right? Go to that site, look at all the charts. But the one that always sticks to me is productivity. [00:15:41] It just go it, you know, going up in tandem until 1971, and they split off, wages just go flat line, productivity continues to rise. It's you know, it's it's theft of our increasing productivity, our time and our ingenuity. Yep, yeah. And all that money is accruing, you know, to people who are asset owners, people who have equities and stuff like that. [00:16:01] But how long is that going to go on for? You know, we have all this massive printing of money, we have you know, not QE, QE, infinity, whatever's going on right now. And a lot of people don't realize this is happening. And I didn't, you know, I didn't know this was happening either. Like, even up until recently, I heard about QE. I didn't understand what it was. I didn't understand what had been going on since 2008. [00:16:21] And then you have, you know, like with Trump yelling the stock markets at all-time highs, this is amazing, I did this. It's like, well, yeah, but we also quadrupled our money supply. So, you know, it's like the president has a lot less to do with it than the central bank, I would argue, that that is making money so easy to acquire for the people who have access to it, right? [00:16:41] The people at the top who can take out those very low interest loans and just you know pump up their own stock price. That's that's what's happening, and I don't think most people understand that. And I also think that people don't get that we're living in a new type of monetary regime that actually is an experiment. People say that Bitcoin is an experiment, but you know, goldback money only ended in 1971. [00:17:01] Yep. So that's a pretty recent development in our in our history, and that's that's an experiment. We're living in a big experiment. Bitcoin is like it's yeah, it's like we were saying Bitcoin is deprogramming us, it's like waking us up to what money really is. It's yeah, and it's it is, it makes you ask questions, right? I think that's that's the best thing about Bitcoin is that it's it is a rabbit hole, and it's it's a forcing function, like you once you have Bitcoin in your possession, you really want to understand what it is that you just bought, like why is this number going up? [00:17:31] Why is it not dying? Like everybody keeps saying that it's dead, but it just doesn't seem to die. What is what is happening here? And then you have to ask yourself questions about what is the nature of money. And that's something that most people aren't prepared to deal with. I think it's like something you don't want to think about. Money works day to day, at least in America here. [00:17:49] Like you go to you know, go to a store, you spend your dollar, it works, it's fine, it appears stable. Because most people aren't used to thinking about m long time horizons. They're not looking at their dollars and saying, okay, what could this dollar buy me 10 years from now or 10 years ago? They're using a day-to-day, and maybe they have some memory that prices seem to have doubled in the last couple of years, but they don't really know how that happened, why that happened. [00:18:11] It's like normal life. Yeah. So waking up from this life and saying, wait a minute, it doesn't have to be this way, that's like that's a big deal, right? It's it's a different type of thinking, and it is really something that Bitcoin stimulates. Yeah, yeah. So you're you know, you're right. You're getting at this idea that it's not just about spreading knowledge, the knowledge of what money really is and this alternative idea of what money is. [00:18:36] It's also this kind of deep psychological and emotional effect on people, and it's as a result, it's inspiring this kind of zealous devotion to the cause of spreading the knowledge. Yeah, I mean, I think like for me, it's all about freedom, right? I always I try to I'm always trying to work on something that will kind of make a dent and you know, leave a legacy, something that will make change the world for the better. [00:18:58] I know it sounds kind of corny, but like I want the world to be better for my children, right? And that's that's why I work on Bitcoin, because I think that it does change things in a big way. It frees people from oppressive regimes, it gives people freedom with their money, their thoughts, their lives, their you know, where they live. [00:19:16] Like these things need to be a part of the world we live in because it's either that or we're gonna head down a very dark path. And that's another thing I think people don't get, is that money is going digital, it's not like a question, it's just a it's just really more of a matter of time, right? Like I don't think anybody's it's not a controversial idea to say that maybe 50 years from now, like all money will be digital, right? [00:19:36] All transactions will be digital. Except for some really, really fringe you know stuff that's happening in the black market with like you know, gold or diamonds or maybe Bitcoin, right? And the Amish community. Yeah, Amish community. But I mean, most people day to day, they're gonna go digital, and it's not even gonna be because they're forced into it. It's just gonna be a convenience thing. Yeah, like most people use credit cards because of convenience, they use Apple Pay because of convenience, and this convenience thinking will drive all of us into digital money. [00:20:03] And then the question is what is that good, right? Is it good that we have digital money? Well, it is very convenient, but it also means that every single transaction is now tracked, cataloged, monitored, surveilled, and possibly censored, right? Like we have legal cannabis here in Illinois, just went legal, but I can't go to the store and buy it with my credit card. [00:20:24] So there's already censorship there, right? So the only reason I can buy cannabis today is because cash exists. So what happens when cash goes away? What else can I not access, right? And now you're completely at the whims of the powers that be that determine the laws, and they're not always aligned with what you might want as an individual. Yeah, absolutely. [00:20:42] Yeah, and the trend is absolutely clear. Like you mentioned that we're moving to digital money for digital age, and that corresponds with you know, that this is sort of like a generational shift, right? It just makes sense to millennials and the younger Gen Xers that discover Bitcoin that we're gonna have digital money for digital natives and just makes sense to them. [00:21:01] So this seems like largely a generational shift. Do you think that'll play into Bitcoin's adoption timeline? Yeah, I definitely believe in that. I really like what so there is Dan Teppiero, he's Smacro investor, gold guy. And he's been going around and kind of like explaining Bitcoin to people in his world, and he said that pretty much everybody over 50 just like doesn't really want to look at it. [00:21:24] It's very rare. Under 30, they're like all into it, under 40. And then like if depending on where you are in between that age range, it's kind of a gray sliding scale as to whether you're even receptive to the idea of Bitcoin. And so I definitely think there's a generational component, just like it's hard for my grandparents to use email, but it's not it's easy for my parents. [00:21:43] It's a little bit harder for my parents to do texting, although now they're pretty good at it. It was hard initially. There's different types of technology that are adopted by different generations. And we already see that in Bitcoin. If you look at you know what millennials are buying. I mean, blind millennials aren't buying gold by and large. Like they don't they don't care about gold. It's a foreign object, it doesn't make any sense in in the digital age. [00:22:04] So for them, and or for us, I mean I'm a millennial, I'm I'm on the borderline. It's more of a recognition that we are living in a digital society. Like I grew up with PayPal and Venmo and all these things. I understand digital money. It's completely normal to me. So for me, it's just a question of which digital money is it the one that's controlled by the banks or the one that's the freedom money. [00:22:24] And being that, you know, I'm into freedom, seems like the freedom money is the better one, right? And I think more and more people will realize that once given that option staring them in the face. And I do think that affects the timeline. I think that's you know, it's gonna be me, it's gonna be my children, and those are the people who are gonna adopt Bitcoin. And so, you know, Bitcoin's adoption is kind of it's two things, right? [00:22:46] One is necessity. Like if you live in Venezuela and it doesn't matter how old you are, if you see that your neighbors are like surviving by mining Bitcoin or something, then maybe you're gonna look into that. Right. But if you live in America, it's Bitcoin's basically a luxury good for for you in America. It's an investment, it's a speculation, it's not like it's not life and death, right? [00:23:04] So for most Americans the cell is like you can make money on this, the number go up. And that's fine, right? That's that gives value to Bitcoin and that helps people all over the world who are in in worse circumstances. But I think for for first world countries like like in the USA, it's gonna be very much the younger people that start embracing Bitcoin because they're just their mind is more flexible, they're more open to new ideas, and they're more willing to question the status quo, especially when the status quo doesn't look so good for them. [00:23:33] Yeah. And I think another I mean, and we're on to this you know, with the idea of save Bitcoin, that product and service that's going to come out soon from Swan Bitcoin, it's in the in the first world, it's not it's becoming not just a speculation, but more understood as a savings technology for people in the first world. [00:23:52] Yeah, I would definitely agree with that. I think that's something that people have realized slowly over time. You see a lot of early Bitcoiners think of Bitcoin as a payments technology because initially it looked like that, right? It had really cheap fees because nobody was using it, and all that kind of stuff. And if you really look at Bitcoin, what is the invention of Bitcoin? [00:24:11] It's not fast payments. We already had that. The invention is digital scarcity. And what is digital scarcity enable? It enables the idea that that it's something that people would desire, that they would actually commit value to, and know that their value commitment isn't gonna be eroded by inflation. And the more people that realize that Bitcoin is that one thing that is digital that is also scarce, the more they want to buy it because they see that other people are buying it, right? [00:24:36] And it's just that it's a r it's a reflexive, recursive kind of effect. So I do think people are starting to re recognize Bitcoin as a savings vehicle. I mean, much like gold, right? Like you can you can have some money in gold, but you're not gonna go to the grocery store and buy goods with gold, and you're certainly not gonna send gold online to anybody. So the idea of Bitcoin is that you have this thing that's kind of like in between a cash and a gold, right? [00:25:02] Because as a as a store of value, you're buying it because it's scarce, and then you may or may not transact with it. Maybe you're gonna sit on it for 30 years, right? Maybe you'll pass it on to your grandkids, and maybe they'll use it in the future. Or maybe they're only gonna use it for really, really large purchases, like buying a house, right? We don't know what the actual use cases of Bitcoin will look like, but I think it's pretty clear that we can look at it as a savings technology as a way to squirrel away value in a way that can't be eroded. [00:25:27] And then as you need that in the future, you dip into that pot and you take out that value. And if it need if you need to leave the country or move somewhere, and you know, you don't you don't have to worry about capital controls, you don't have to worry about any of that. You now have true portable wealth. It's really censorship resistant, really seizure proof, and all of that kind of stuff. [00:25:47] Self-sovereign, self-sovereign money. Self-sovereign. You know, new people to Bitcoin will look at the price and they'll be like, Are you freaking crazy? Like this is not a savings technology. It's it's lost 85% of its value in the last two years. What are you talking about? But if you look at it on more like a 10-year time scale, if you think about it as like a 10-year certificate of deposit, right? [00:26:06] Then Yeah, it's the best performing asset of the last decade. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. Well, I mean, obviously we don't know that that if it's gonna repeat that same performance, but if our, you know, at the very least, we know that it's not being eroded by inflation, right? I think people used to give, you know, bonds as like like I got a bond for my barn mitza, right? [00:26:25] It was, I think at the time paying, you know, five or more percent. And so, like I held it for however long, 10 years or whatever it was, right? Nowadays you can't even really gift bonds anymore, right? And you can't, there's no real savings vehicle you can give to somebody who's coming of age to say, like, here, hold on to this for a while. It makes no sense. [00:26:44] All it does is lose value. Right. So what are you gonna do? Bitcoin fixes this. Yeah, Bitcoin fixes this. That's right. I mean, you want to give them something that that retains its value. And if it grows, then that's great. But at the very least, it can't be eroded by any governments or external events or third parties. You know that this thing is yours. This is a true piece of digital scarcity that you own and you alone, and I think that's that's pretty amazing. [00:27:07] Yeah, absolutely. How do you think governments will react? If you know, if and when like down the road, Bitcoin replaces gold as the preferred store of value. What will governments do? Do you think? Well, this is I mean, this is a big question, right? But I think we're already starting to see some of the effects of this. [00:27:25] We've already had Bitcoin debated on the floor of Congress. Yeah. And I think there's two camps here. One, you have people realizing that Bitcoin is unstoppable. They've literally, you know, said that, right? Like the chairman of the banking committee, Mike Crapo said, like Bitcoin is an unstoppable global force, global force. [00:27:45] You know, we can't do it. We can't do anything about it. And so they're seeing it as like something to embrace, right? Because if we can't stop it, then we might as well join it. Bitcoin can end up being a huge force of good for this country, right? It's it could bring jobs, we have mining jobs, we have Texas becoming a major mining hub now. And you know, all those jobs that you know certain presidents promised in the coal industry. [00:28:08] Well, maybe coal mining is not really like the future. Maybe Bitcoin mining is the future, and that's what we're gonna bring in the jobs, right? And won't wouldn't that be funny if that's what brought jobs to into America? But you know, if they see that as an unstoppable force, they're gonna have to embrace it. And I think the other side of it is that you have people like Sherman who wants to basically shut it down. [00:28:29] Well, that's also validating Bitcoin as something that's scary and powerful, right? It's it's actually challenging people in the government to think about what money is, how money works, and where we derive our our value from. And the thing is, if they try to shut it down in any way and they fail, what is that gonna do to Bitcoin? [00:28:49] That's just gonna make it ten times stronger. Everybody's gonna know about it. It's gonna be a massive strice and defect where everybody who never heard about Bitcoin now is all of a sudden you know asking questions. It's just like when Trump tweeted about it, he said, I don't like Bitcoin, but he tweeted it to 60 million followers. Oh, it's happened over and over. It's happened over and over and over in Bitcoin center. Right, it doesn't matter what you say about Bitcoin. [00:29:07] Mount Gox lost everyone's money, you know, on Bitcoin in it. And then it immediately went up to a thousand dollars a coin, you know. Exactly. Or like China banned it, right? China banned it how many times now? Yeah, five, seven times. Yeah. Every time the price just goes up. So it's just they're reinforcing Bitcoin's core value proposition, which is that it is got is money outside of government, it's separation of money and state. [00:29:27] And so anytime states interfere with Bitcoin and fail, it's just reinforcing that value proposition and driving adoption. So I think it's absolutely great. I would love more tax on Bitcoin, and you know, it's it's just gonna start to permeate everything, and at some point it's just gonna be the countries that are wise enough are gonna accept it and say, okay, this is the new reality. [00:29:47] And you know, maybe we put it on our balance sheet as a central bank. Maybe we encourage Bitcoin companies to set up shop in our country, bring in jobs. This is the future as I see it. It's just gonna be a matter of time. Yeah. Do you think I mean the fact that we've seen the chairman of the Federal Reserve refer to Bitcoin as a savings technology like gold? [00:30:06] We've seen Bitcoin debated on the floor of Congress. Thanks to Libra for bringing that up, by the way. You know, we had we had the phrase, you know, there's Bitcoin and there's shitcoin, which is one of my favorite things in the whole world that that was amazing. Yeah, amazing. Patrick McHenry. Shout out to Patrick McHenry. Thank you guys. It was Warren Davidson that said the shitcoin thing, but then Patrick. [00:30:24] Oh, sorry, yes, yeah. Patrick McHenry was even more amazing. He said Bitcoin's an unstoppable force. Yes, yes, yes, yes. Shout out to both of those guys. Yeah, that's amazing. So I mean, we're seeing these politicians in the most influential country in the world and the country that you know has control over the money that's the global standard for the monetary base for the whole world. [00:30:45] You know, to me that signals like that's optimistic development for me that signals that we might have this kind of peaceful transition or relatively peaceful transition. I know that like the US government and other governments that make their own money are not going to give that up lightly, obviously, and that there's going to be a battle, but seeing that happen, that debate happen within that kind of you know democratic context makes me hopeful that the battle will happen in the political realm and not the physical realm, right? [00:31:16] Yeah. And I, you know, I think that there is a world where Bitcoin doesn't necessarily replace the dollar, but ends up being like gold, right? Like nobody's trying to shut down gold, even though there's seven trillion dollars worth of value parked in there. That's a lot of money. Yep. But it's possible that the US government is friendly to Bitcoin. It brings in jobs, it lets people save, you know, and then if they want to spend, turn that into dollars and spend it later, that's fine. [00:31:38] So I'm a little bit skeptical around like people who say hyper bitcoinization is gonna happen in the sense that Bitcoin replaces all money. Even though it's it looks to me like a better money than than you know the US dollar and other things like that, I think the power of national governments is very strong. And are you I don't think we're gonna see the you know the US government just like lay down its arms and say, okay, yeah, we're not gonna collect taxes in US dollars anymore. [00:32:01] Yeah. It just seems like relatively far-fetched. I mean, I could be wrong. But I see it more like Bitcoin is that kind of freedom money, it's a separate savings vehicle, yeah, and people are saving in it and people are storing their wealth in it. And it doesn't really threaten governments that much. I mean, I think it works nicely alongside governments, it may help them shrink a little bit. [00:32:21] But you know, the at the end of the day, like we have things on the horizon, like the MMT crowd who wants to just print money to infinity, and if and if they do that, then they're gonna find themselves in trouble. Yep. But if they're responsible and they you know figure out how to how to scale things back, then maybe these two things can co coexist. I don't know. Yeah. Yeah, that I think that's those are the kind of two outcomes is if yeah, if governments do not rein things in, and you know, safety says that the best option for governments is to go back on a gold standard, you know, if if they want to compete with Bitcoin. [00:32:53] But if they don't and they just continue to print money, like this this MMT like economic ideology is is proposing, then eventually over time, you know, as hyperinflation takes over, you know, or even not hyperinflation, but just like pretty quick inflation, it doesn't have to be super super bad, you know. [00:33:13] Then we have you know this alternative sitting in you know waiting in the wings, and as Bitcoin supply rate decreases, right? That you know the volatility will decrease, and as the adoption increases, if we you know, if if Bitcoin replaces gold as a store of value, or even just competes with it on the same level as the store value, then you know, we have a much like a better incentive as as holders of Bitcoin to start spending it. [00:33:37] One, it's gonna be demanded more because it's a better money by you know producers of goods and services. But also it's you know the upside of potential you know increase in in dollar value of Bitcoin is gonna be a lot less at that point. Yeah, I would agree with that. I think we're gonna see some of that happening, and we don't know what the time scale for this kind of like infinite printing of money is or how long really the current regime is sustainable for. [00:34:03] You know, I mean people have been predicting the collapse of this whole system for a long time. But you know, we keep pumping the stock market and you know everything's going up and up and up and up, and you know, this this could last another 50 years, I think easily. And then if that happens, then we need to be prepared for that, and we just need to be building up this you know inflation resistant savings vehicle so we can be prepared for these environments where if we think we have you know a million dollars today, that's not really a million dollars anymore in 10 years. [00:34:31] Right, exactly. So it's like you need to be looking at looking at different ways to save that wealth, or or a thousand dollars, you know, really what whatever it is that you have, like protect your wealth, right? Yeah, we are we are living in an experiment, like I said, we don't know that any of this is sustainable or or when it'll end. [00:34:49] Yeah, we've got these competing experiments now, and it's it's gonna be a fascinating battle to watch. But the cool thing is that we have the choice now, right? Exactly. We have a true free market competition for money, yep. And may the better money win. Absolutely. I do think that it's gonna take a while for Bitcoin to really be ready to onboard that many people, too, right? [00:35:08] We need to think about what that looks like, quote unquote scalability. How do people like start earning Bitcoin, circular economies, whatever it may be, that that actually gets us to the point where Bitcoin is an everyday currency. Because it it it very well could happen that that never happens, right? It could, like I said, it could happen that Bitcoin is a savings account, you've got your your wealth parked in it, and you know, that's all it is. [00:35:29] That could happen and that could still make it a major, major dent in the world. Or we could go to the next level. And it's I think it's gonna depend a little bit on what's happening outside of Bitcoin as well. Yeah, I think we're I mean I am pretty certain we're gonna go to that next level. I'm just uncertain exactly on the time frame, you know. Yeah, but I think the truth of sound money will exert itself over time, even if governments try to compete. [00:35:51] There's still the you know, the I guess inefficiency of having multiple national currencies to take into account and having versus having one global currency that's you know borderless and you know much much more frictionless, etc. So there's other advantages that Bitcoin will have as it matures over over a national currency, you know. [00:36:13] But cool, you know, other people will can I mean people will always continue to print easy money, like it's whether on its nations or people, because people can just do it now. You know, there's there's yeah, I mean, there's a thousand different altcoins. It's exactly it's it's the it's the highest like you know, difficulty to reward scam in the world. [00:36:31] You know, so it'll continue. I mean they're yeah, they're really out of control with that stuff. But I think that's another thing is that ri is education, right? I mean, I think when we had like the first major fork of Bitcoin, people were a little bit confused, then we had a second fork, then we had a third fork, and now we have a dozen forks. Yep. I don't think it's confusing anymore. I think it's pretty obvious. [00:36:49] Or at least for us that are in the space, I think we still have some ways to go to educate the general public on why you know a Bitcoin fork is not the same thing as Bitcoin. And that's a big question that people ask. But like I've been sort of really coming back to it as a market phenomenon, right? And saying, look, if any of these were similar to Bitcoin, why are they worth so much less? [00:37:11] Like there's there's no reason for Bitcoin Cash to be worth less than three percent of Bitcoin if it's like the same thing, right? Right. So it's clearly not the same thing by a long shot, by like, you know, 97 to 3 or 98 to 2, it's not not the same thing. So but why? And that thing that makes people ask questions about money. What are the characteristics of money? [00:37:30] And we have to come back to that. Bitcoin is the invention of digital scarcity. I really love this. I don't have the exact quote by but Knut Swanholm, who just wrote Sovereign Teacher Mathematics of Bitcoin, really great Bitcoin primer. And in this in this Bitcoin book, he he talks about that Bitcoin is the invention of digital scarcity, and so the idea that you can just reproduce it, that that is in and of itself you know counterfactual to the f the invention, right? [00:37:59] So any fork of Bitcoin isn't scarce. There's no scarcity of forks. There's a you can make as many forks as you want, but there's only one Bitcoin. And I think it's gonna take people a while to realize that. Yeah, I'm gonna have Knut on the pod next week, actually. So that's a little preview. I love his book. Yeah, me too. All right, let's switch up gears from talking about money. [00:38:18] Let's dive back into tech. We talked about how you got into tech when you after you'd come over here, studied it, started working in tech. So when was that? I mean, did you study it in college and have you been in tech your whole career? I actually got into tech really early on. [00:38:37] My dad thankfully bought me a computer when I was eight years old. So as soon as we moved here, like pretty much he he hustled on some side jobs, saved up enough money to buy a Commodore 64. Nice, which was a really early classic. It was great. I had a bunch of games, and I actually started learning basic programming. And at the time there was a children's magazine where they would used to publish programs. [00:38:56] You could like type in a program from this magazine into your computer and you'd have a little game. So I did a little bit of that, and then towards junior high, I already started coding for real, like more serious stuff. And so yeah, I just grew up coding a lot and went to school for computer science because it seemed to be the thing to do with when you have a background like mine. But I already knew a lot going in, so I kind of slacked off in college, honestly. [00:39:21] Same. But what I did do, yeah, I mean, I think I but you know, what I did do in college, I was really good is I worked at a bunch of companies that were like on campus, tech startups or or tech companies of different kinds. So I got a lot of real world experience, and then I just came out of school and just went into like doing startups and got so caught up in in doing startups that I basically missed Bitcoin because I was just doing other stuff and I was just not paying attention. [00:39:45] That's like the exact same story as me, man. I was just all into tech and I just wanted to I'd started college but realized that I just wanted to go out to Silicon Valley or something and start working in tech. And I was working in tech already, very you know, working for companies. I was like you know, consulting, I started working for a government agency in Topeka, Kansas. [00:40:07] I started like you know, built their first website, wrote this like Medicare supplement premium comparison app. It was like the first in the country, open sourced it back then. This is like like late n very late 90s. Sent it around to like other agencies in other states and they started using it. It was kind of crazy. And I was like, all right, dad, I want to go and do this, you know. [00:40:28] I want to I want to get out of here and go like just work in tech, I'm gonna drop out. And he's like, No, man, you can't drop out. I've worked really, really, really hard to save up money to pay your way through college. You gotta get your degree, it's gonna it's gonna be you're you're five committed now. Yeah, exactly. And I was like, why don't you just save all that money? And you know, he's like, yeah, the degree is really important, you know, and it was like his dream to put me through college. [00:40:49] So I ended up just majoring in English so I could read books. I mean, there was no web curriculum at that point, you know. Yeah. I kind of wish I went back and majored into something else at this point because well, you know, who knows what my career would have been like without that degree, but I you know it was it was interesting. I learned a bunch of stuff. It's not like what you learn in school with computer science is very like low-level stuff that you don't really use in real life. [00:41:10] Like we learned how to build a computer from scratch, which is fun, and I learned a ton doing that, but did I ever use that skill? No. And now you have kids that are going to like these boot camps for 12 weeks and they're just as good, you know, coming out as I mean, they need help, they need onboarding and they need to have some real world experience, but you know, do you need a four-year degree to code? Not not really. [00:41:29] No. But I think it's you know, it's there's a difference between computer science and development or computer engineering. And I think of myself much more as a kind of product engineer, somebody who just builds stuff. And I'm more interested in in the user experience and how people interact with products than I am in in the code per se. And I think that yeah, you don't need you don't necessarily need to be a computer science major to do that. [00:41:52] Absolutely. But it was, you know, it was fun. Yeah, I don't know what it's what's gonna happen to colleges because the tuition costs are getting so crazy. And like I said, you could pay like twelve or fifteen grand and get the same thing from a vocational boot camp or even self-study if you're motivated enough. Yeah. So yeah, unknown. If you're into Bitcoin, just you know, go through safety's class and then go to Biddle Bootcamp or or the like and boom, you're done. [00:42:16] You know, take Jimmy Song's class. That's I actually did that when I got into Bitcoin. Took Jimmy Song's programming Bitcoin class, and that was a that was a fun class because it was super challenging. He would lecture for five minutes and then like for the next five minutes you'd have to write code to do what he just taught you about. So it was like super. [00:42:34] I mean, I'm a good coder, and it was tough for me to keep up with the class. It was like boom, boom, boom, you know, five minutes, five minutes, just alternate, and then and he said it was like a semester worth of education in two days, and it's it's legit. It's like it's very intense. It's what school should be like, yeah. Because you're really forced to learn, you know, you can't just slack off. [00:42:52] Yeah, that's awesome. Yeah. So you've been in tech for a long time. You know, you probably kind of studied the history or just aware of it through osmosis of the internet, development of the protocols, all that stuff. So we had TCP IP in the 70s, SMTP in the 80s, and others, HTTP in the early 90s, then we had in the early 2000s, BitTorrent and Tor. [00:43:14] And the Bitcoin protocol is built on top of all of these things. We're watching the emergence of the Lightning Protocol now. What do you think we can glean about the future of the Bitcoin and Lightning protocols from the history of you know these other networking protocols? That's a great question. [00:43:32] Let me we're gonna have to edit this out because I need to go and plug my computer in. Okay, no worries. And then I will answer the question. No problem. Unless you want to keep this on for you know a more realistic view of what life is like interviewing people where's my unplugged in their laptop. Where's my plugin? Same thing actually happened to Andreas when we were recording. [00:43:52] Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, cool. I'm gonna do a shout out. He's like, Someone bring me my power card. It's pretty funny. Yeah, I'm gonna I still have to listen to that one. I'm so behind on Bitcoin pods right now, it's unbelievable. There's so many minutes. There's so many. And yeah. Hold on, let me get a power cable here. [00:44:27] Okay. See if we're back. Oh. All right, testing, testing. Okay, I think we're back online. Okay, gotcha. Awesome. Yeah, so the question was about history of internet protocols and how that relates to Bitcoin. [00:44:52] Right, right. Yeah, so I think it's really interesting to look at you know, TCP IP in particular, which is essentially the protocol underlying the entire internet stack. And it hasn't changed much since it's been released, and that's because it doesn't do that much. TCP IP basically defines like packets, which are just you know little bits of information traveling between computers, and it essentially tells us what those packets should look like and how they should behave and how computers should make sure that they're getting the right packets and all that kind of stuff. [00:45:21] And by keeping the protocol relatively low surface area, right? That enabled other things to be built as layers on top of it. So when we talk about email or the web, these are all protocols built on top of TCP IP that didn't have to really go in and see T CPAP and change it because TCP IP is just a messaging definition protocol, right? [00:45:43] Just saying, here's how we communicate. And then we will build the next layer. Here's how we communicate when we do web. Here's how we communicate when we do email, right? We change, we have different ways of doing that. So I see a similar thing with Bitcoin, where Bitcoin surface area should be extremely small. Bitcoin is about defining scarcity, right? [00:46:04] Here's how we ensure that the money is scarce. Here's how we ensure that transactions are properly propagated. Here's how we know that blocks are authentic and not counterfeited. We have these things defined in the protocol, right? But once we get to other types of functionality, that's where we can build layers, and that's how I see the lightning network, right? [00:46:23] So the lightning network, for example, is a nice way to transact quickly, more privately, but we don't necessarily have to go and modify Bitcoin in order to build Lightning. Or at least we had we have to make one minor change, which is to get SegWit in. Right. But my understanding was Lightning was actually possible even without SegWit, it's just a lot better with SegWit. [00:46:45] Yep, yep. But essentially, you know, we're building these layers. And so when we build a layered system, when the with computer engineering, we're almost always building layered systems because layers enable us to do different things with different layers and optimize each layer for its own you know best use case. So Bitcoin base layer is absolutely optimized for immutability. [00:47:06] We don't want it to change. We need to know that our money is actually hard, is actually sound, is actually immutable. And so that's like critical, right? And then other layers might be about being fast, more private, more secure, not secure, but security is at the base layer, but you know, different properties that we make trade-offs with, right? And also it enables a lot more experimentation because with Lightning, we have at least, I think three different competing implementations. [00:47:31] With Bitcoin there are other implementations besides Bitcoin core but they have to be so extremely backwards compatible that it's not common for people to run other implementations just because there are more risks of bugs. Whereas with Lightning, no problem. You want to experiment you want to define new features in one client that's not compatible with another client well that's you know that's something you could do and you can experiment and then those implementations can agree on standards as as they emerge. [00:47:54] But yeah I absolutely see a parallel between internet protocol development and lightning and Bitcoin. Yeah. And this guy I mean goes back to the fork war debates and you know it's like Bitcoiners were shouting from the rooftops like this is how we you know develop protocols man. [00:48:13] There it's we have 50 years of history to show that we do we do a layered approach and here's why and trying to cram everything on the base layer and make the base layer do all things is just you know impossible it's inefficient and it's just not you know going to be viable long term and you're going to lose to us because you know we're taking the correct approach to engineering these protocols. [00:48:34] Yeah and I think there's a really interesting talk I almost wrote an article on this one time but I haven't done it there's a talk called simple made easy I believe it's called do you know about that one no I don't Richard Hickey I think so he talks about how people conflate these two concepts of simple and easy like increasing the block size is very easy you go into the code and you just like change a variable super easy right but the thing is that it's not simple because the there's a lot of side effects to doing that right you have to think about what are the incentives that you change, for example, in the ways that fees are are done, right? [00:49:05] Because the reason we have fees on Bitcoin is because block space is scarce. We need the scarcity of block space for Bitcoin to be sustainable past the era when when block rewards you know shrink. So that's really important, right? And what other effects are you having? Are you creating more centralization? Because now miners have to be closer together in order to communicate blocks quickly enough with each other. [00:49:28] So you have all these like second-order effects from increasing the block size, and even though it looks like a simple change and it's way easier to go in and change your variable than it is to implement something like SegWit, simple is not always, you know, and easy aren't always the same thing. So SegWit, it looks complicated, but it actually reduces it doesn't sort of have these second-order complex effects that that increasing the block size does. [00:49:53] So I think that's that's something really critical. And a lot of people who are debating for these things may not have the background in development to make that assessment correctly. They don't understand trade-offs as well. And for them, it's like I mean you literally see people posting this. How hard is it to change a freaking variable to increase the block size? Yeah, it's really not hard. [00:50:12] I can go in, it's really easy. You go in there and edit the number. Yeah, but what are you affecting? And you're affecting an entire universe that's based on this concept of immutable sound money, and not only that, you're creating a second coin, by the way, by doing that, right? Let's not let's not forget what what a hard fork actually is. You're creating a new coin, you have to give everybody accept this new coin as the real truth, otherwise you have two coins, right? [00:50:33] And that's exactly what we have. You're fighting all the network effects of the protocols themselves and the money. You know, it's right. It's it's and then what kind of precedent does that set? If if we're saying this is sound money and we can go in and like change arbitrary things about the sound money, change its you know, incentive structures on a whim, it's not sound money, it's not it's not immutable. [00:50:52] That these these are the promises of Bitcoin. Immutability is the promise, scarcity is the promise. By by creating a new coin and saying this is this is a new Bitcoin, then you're you're literally breaking those promises. So people didn't really understand that as enough. Yeah, and do you think because of that the that you know immutability's promise? [00:51:11] Does that mean that we only have one chance of this? One chance at creating a digital scarce money. I mean, put aside the fact that like, you know, the idea that there's some catastrophic thing that might you know damage Bitcoin that we have to like hard fork away to resolve that problem, like some you know, 51% attack and we have to, you know, brick everyone's ASICs by switching to a new you know, hash algorithm or something. [00:51:33] Put that aside, but do you think we have like one chance at this if we somehow you know fail to maintain the scarcity or immutability, then we just kind of like I guess tainted the whole project or the idea. Well, I mean, I think that kind of yes, but I also think that it's that like there's there's almost no way we can screw this up because to screw this up, we would have to kind of like all agree that we're gonna toss this thing away and make this other new thing and all switch to it, and then that new thing is has to have these like problems in it, right? [00:52:04] The nature of Bitcoin being immutable is not from the code, it's from the people who run these nodes, right? It's that people who are merchants or exchanges or service providers, like they run a node and that node tells them what Bitcoin is. And so I think that's the most baked in thing we have about the protocol. [00:52:23] And so we yes, we have one chance of getting scarcity right because if we have the cats out of the bag, people know how Bitcoin works. There's already been a thousand other alts. It's very easy for anybody to start one. But the one chance we have is on this particular thing that's attracted all the attention and all the liquidity and all the developers and all the merchants, right? [00:52:43] Like it's got all these network effects. And so to say that we throw that away and start a new, it's almost like saying that the scarcity is actually reproducible. And so just by doing that, I think we break that promise. That's that's how I feel about it. And I think, like you said, if there's a bug, and that bug is is absolutely like catastrophic, then everybody will switch to a new code base and they will continue to enforce that the rules of Bitcoin with this bug fixed. [00:53:09] But I think also the nature of the way that the system is engineered makes it hard for having a bug like that. Because remember, Bitcoin has been developed through a series of soft forks, it's a series of backwards compatible changes, essentially, right? So we even have people running old versions of clients. So if there's a bug in a new version, we still have all these people running old ones and it just it continues to function just fine. [00:53:30] And as far as we know, there aren't any catastrophic bugs in the current one. So things go on as normal, right? As long as that's that's true. And having nice, a nice like stratification of people running different versions on the network helps actually ensure that we don't have any like one version dominating with with a catastrophic bug in it. [00:53:48] Whereas if you look at something like Ethereum, where they're like, okay, everybody has to hard fork, everybody has to upgrade their client. Oh, by the way, it's happening on New Year's Day. Good luck. And you know, this kind of like this kind of mentality essentially ensures that people are are programmed to just accept whatever new thing is coming out. They have to stay up with the system. [00:54:07] And if they do that, then they're just essentially programmed to take any new changes, and one day that new change will include some kind of catastrophic bug. It's already included inflation problems, and you know, I don't want to get too deep in the Ethereum side, but but that's what I see as kind of like governance by hard forks that all all it does is program people to accept blindly whatever changes are forced down to them. [00:54:27] Whereas with Bitcoin, you know, you could take your your time to upgrade, there's no rush. Everything's backwards compatible. So, you know, take your time. And this is what we see in SegWit. I mean, we have like what, 60% or something like that penetration of SegWit. Oh, it's been almost two years, I think. Yeah. How long has it been? It's been a while. Yeah, two and a half. [00:54:45] Two and a half years or so. It was like mid twenty August 2017, I think. August 2017, right? So that just demonstrates that people in Bitcoin are super conservative. They they upgrade slowly as they need to, and it's it's it's totally optional. You're not coerced into upgrading by by somebody saying do this on New Year's Day or you're you're you're no longer part of the system. [00:55:08] Yep, yeah. No, I don't I don't want to get us, you know, off track onto Ethereum very much, but I do have one question there. You know, since you're like application developer product guy, you know, and I and I heard on John Vallis's podcast, I heard you say that you kind of when you discovered Bitcoin, kind of checked out ETH too, because the narrative there was that Ethereum was kind of more developer-friendly for application developers. [00:55:33] So taking that sort of experience and then applying it to what we have with Lightning now, do you think that we'll continue to see this sort of like movement of application developers from Ethereum over to Lightning? I think we might. I mean, if people aren't super religious about it, I think that what Ethereum did really well was they marketed their developing like they marketed two developers really well. [00:55:59] When I saw their website and it showed me 100 lines of code you can implement your own bank, that's pretty cool. Okay, so you look at it as that as a developer who's who's ever done any kind of distributed system and you know how hard distributed systems are, especially financial ones, and here's this thing that's promising you 100 lines of code and you're done. It looks very attractive. And I think they made the language very friendly. [00:56:18] They did a lot of things right on that side. So that caused a lot of developers to flock in and start developing. But I think we're you have to look at what the underlying system is. Is it actually money? Like if you're buying if you're building a quote unquote DeFi, you know, decentralized finance application, is the thing that you're transacting with actually money? [00:56:37] I would argue no. I don't think Ethereum has monetary properties. And then, you know, is it going to scale? Again, I would argue no. There's a problem fundamental to trying to do like world computation on this on the scale with something that's it's supposed to be a permissionless system where like any kind of computer can join. And we're finding that out. But it's no, it's not every kind of computer. [00:56:57] You have to have this massively powered thing running AWS to make it work, right? So that's kind of where I where I see it. And I think that people are going to migrate more to Bitcoin development. I think that Bitcoin takes things a lot slower. So whereas if you're kind of like wanting to do blockchain today and you want to like quote unquote do blockchain stuff, make a blockchain game, you go to Ethereum and you program your game, and it like looks like it works. [00:57:24] Until, of course, you get like a hundred users, and then right like we've had with crypto keys. Yeah. Yeah. Like it just totally clogged the system, right? Whereas you also have people now starting to make lightning-based games where they're making just a traditional game. It's not quote unquote decentralized, but the most important part of it that is decentralized is right. [00:57:43] That's the money. So you go to a game, and inside of the game, there's like a lightning QR code, and you can pay lightning to open a door in the game or buy in-game items or whatever. Like that makes sense, right? You have money inside of the game. So I think that's what we're going to see. We're going to see more development on Bitcoin. I do think that Bitcoin as an application platform is behind just with the tooling and stuff because it's just not as friendly, right? [00:58:08] And but I think we're getting there with Lightning. It's becoming a lot friendlier. It doesn't look as sexy as Solidity does. But then when you start doing Solidity, which is the Ethereum language, and you realize that, oh, there's all these security issues, scalability issues, the things not money, then all you're doing is prototyping anyway. So I think sooner or later people will realize this. [00:58:28] Yeah, I mean, there were some of the most experienced Solidity coders on the parity team, which is you know one of the Ethereum's like most, I think it might be Ethereum's most used wallet, have made several mistakes over the years that have been catastrophic to people's money. So they've cost hundreds of millions of dollars, yeah. Yeah, yeah. And I think they're abandoning it now. [00:58:47] Yeah, yeah, exactly. It's just so volatile in that world over there. And you mentioned Lightning Gaming, there's just so much awesome development on that front. And I think Lightnight is gonna be really cool. It's like a Fortnite clone on top of Lightning. Oh cool, I haven't even seen that. Yeah. So you like frag somebody and you earn sets as you go. [00:59:05] And like on the leaderboard instead of like points for your team, you actually like can cash out Satoshis. It's pretty cool. Yeah, I think we're I think that we're super early to apps and Ethereum rushed it a little bit. They they kind of said, okay, this is done, like we have a blockchain app platform go and build, and then billions of dollars are poured in and stuff was built, and then there's no users and the platform doesn't really work the way it was promised. [00:59:29] Whereas with Bitcoin, I think there is a future there, but it is early. And I think it's legitimately early in the sense that it may be five or ten years before we have really, really like world-class applications built on Bitcoin. But they will be built then on the right platform because they were will be built around something that is actually considered money by people. So it's useless to pay people in something that's not money. [00:59:50] That's that's kind of what we saw in a lot of these systems, like you have bat, you know, the basic attention token where they wanted to pay people for attention. And that's a not a bad idea, right? But if you're paying people with a token that they then have to sell for money, well then that token's not gonna have any value because that's then you know, people just dump it. [01:00:08] So that's what we're kind of I think people are starting to realize that you have to build stuff on money. And that Bitcoin's scalability is not about transactions per second. Bitcoin scalability is about value settled per second. So if I can settle a billion dollars in a single Bitcoin transaction, then it's extremely scalable. [01:00:28] I don't need to necessarily have it do 10,000 transactions a second because no base monetary system does that, right? Yep. All money is layered, even even modern like fiat money is layered. You're not when you pay a visa transaction, you're not moving money around. Yeah, you're this is an IOU that's settled way later and batches, right? [01:00:46] Right, yeah. The further down the stack you go, it's just all batched up into larger and larger transactions. Exactly. And that goes back to the idea of layering and batching and stuff that we know from engineering from for many years, and is intuitive if you really think about it. Like, how are you going to have something that does you know 100,000 transactions per second that also runs on everybody's computer all over the world? [01:01:05] It just doesn't make like it makes no sense. If you're if you have any engineering background, you should it should be an immediate red flag when somebody promises you that especially if it's not centralized platform all running in one data center. Yeah, exactly. A little bit earlier we were talking about conveniences, especially like when it comes to payments with money and you know how how money is becoming more and more convenient. [01:01:25] Cash is kind of inconvenient. We're moving to digital payments because of that. On the Andreas episode, he I asked him if Bitcoin could ever catch up in convenience with you know centralized money, right? And he said absolutely not. He said that decentralized tech could never match centralized check for convenience. [01:01:46] I'm not sure I agree with that. I was wondering what you thought about that. I mean, you know, down the road. Yeah, I don't see it as an all or nothing in terms of centralized or decentralized. For example, you could use your visa card and then pay your bill in Bitcoin, right? Like that could be a future. So the visa is fully centralized and the payments are fully centralized, and that would be one future, right? [01:02:08] Another future would be the lightning network where it actually develops into something very robust with a lot of with a lot of liquidity. We solve all these kind of like UX problems, because it's rough around the edges. Let's let's be real. It's it's really hard to onboard into Lightning right now. And I fully expect that will be the case for a little while until we figure out all these things. But yeah, another future is we use lightning and we do a lot of lightning transactions, then we do like a batch settlement, or maybe we never settle. [01:02:31] Maybe lightning is is so good we stay on lightning and it's a circular economy. Like there's a lot of different ways to attack this. And I'm kind of the mind that a hybrid solution, just like we talked about layers, a hybrid solution with a decentralized base layer of money and a centralized or semi-centralized layers above that could work. I mean, there's no reason why PayPal couldn't be transacting with Bitcoin, right? [01:02:52] Yeah. It's it's all about what like our convenience versus trust. If we can settle with PayPal once a day and we feel good about that, they're allowing us to withdraw once a day or something like that, then maybe that's what it is, right? Sure. Maybe they have lightning withdrawals. So there's there could be a lot of ways that this shakes out, and I don't think looking at Bitcoin as you know, Bitcoin's base layer as the thing that's supposed to scale to this like consumer payment use case is the right approach. [01:03:19] It just yes, that won't happen. I don't think that there's any future where that happens. But having some kind of layered approach, I think does make sense, whether it is centralized or decentralized. Yeah. Yeah, I think that Bitcoin can through great engineering design, you know, become nearly as convenient. And through the you know, the series of trade-offs as you the systems that we have now. [01:03:40] And once you get on Lightning, you know, sometimes the experience is incredible. It's almost as good as you know using Apple Pay or something. But yeah, I mean once you're on, it's it's great. I think I think once we have watch you know support where you can wave a watch in front of a payment terminal and like everything's completely abstracted away for you, then it'll be great. [01:03:58] It'll be just like Apple Pay. There won't be yeah, there's no reason for users to know that they're using Lightning. Right, right. So we're not there yet. That's that's the thing. Yeah, yeah, it's only a couple years old. One one place where I think convenience the convenience trade off concerns me a little bit is the convenience of holding your keys versus you know having somebody custody your keys. [01:04:18] I'm not sure that that could ever be like self-custody could ever be as convenient as you know a custodial solution. We're definitely making progress on that end. You know, I use I use Casa's multi sig, and that interface is really nice. It was you know pretty simple for me to set up, but it's not nearly as simple as just going into Coinbase and buying some Coinbase and having it sit there. [01:04:40] Yeah, I mean again, I think it's there's some innovations that we haven't really seen yet that may come. I mean, for example, you go two years ago before Casa even came out. I don't think I personally never thought about it, the idea of like a seedless setup where you just like launch an app and everything just works for you. Like you don't have to worry about backing up a seed. Yep. I think that's a really cool idea. [01:04:58] There's like social backup where you can distribute seeds, you know, to your friends and it could be done behind the scenes, it could be fully encrypted, they won't know that what they got. Like there's so many innovations around the corner. I think we're gonna see more of that. And I do think we're gonna we're gonna get to the point where the custodial and not Casoto experiences are very close. [01:05:17] I'm not writing them off just yet. I don't think I think that we're like in you know 1990s internet here where like everything is super cumbersome and weird. Yeah. At the same time, however, like, you know, in the 90s, the internet was kind of a French phenomenon. It was a bunch of geeks, and we were willing to put up with the internet being weird and email being hard to use. But with Bitcoin, we have this weird pressure because it's in the media all the time and it's like $20,000. [01:05:40] And so everybody's like, okay, this is this crazy new thing. It's going through the roof, and okay, I try to use it, and oh my god, it's so horrible. The user experience is just so horrible. It's true. So we have an impedance mismatch between the hype and the where we are with the technology. But we're making huge strides. I mean, Casa or what Unchained is doing, the all the multi-sig stuff is making life easier. [01:06:00] Is just not where it is, where it needs to be with the polished UX. I think we're gonna get there. It's just a matter of time. Yeah, yeah. All right, let's finish up talking about some of your work. Of course you've written inventing Bitcoin, and I think inventing Bitcoins, you know, is the best overview of Bitcoin as a system for new coiners. And I think that's what you intended it to be. [01:06:19] Yeah. Yes. When I'm asked about, you know, like what first to read to learn about Bitcoin, I go to the little Bitcoin book just because it's so short and it doesn't go. But then if that kind of hooks them, I recommend inventing Bitcoin to learn about the system. And then I always push people toward the bullish case for Bitcoin to kind of describe how money works and how it should actually work and you know, why I buy Bitcoin, right? [01:06:43] And then you know, you can do that one too. Yeah, me too. And I think that's just sort of like you know, like a gateway drug for the rest of it, like Bitcoin standard, and then you're in, you know. So that's sort of my little canon for new coiners. After you sold reverb, I know you're working at reverb like you mentioned, and last year reverb was acquired by Etsy, right? [01:07:07] Yeah, that's right. I actually left right before, well not right before, but about a year ahead of that acquisition. So I left in 2018. But by that time we were pretty big. We were like 150 or so employees and doing like 600 million in sales. So I felt like the company was in a good place. And I was just at, you know, I was just so into Bitcoin that I couldn't do both jobs well, right? [01:07:30] Okay. I couldn't like be I couldn't be at reverb but also be focused on Bitcoin, and I decided that you know, after five or six years at that point, that company was in a good place and I could actually focus a little bit on Bitcoin. And you know, I just thought that that was the way that could make a difference in the world more than reverb, even though I love reverb and I loved bringing music to people's homes and you know, spreading music through the world. [01:07:52] That that felt good for a while, but now I want to spread sound money through the world. Yeah, right, right. So yeah, you had some time after reverb then to focus on Bitcoin. And obviously with your tech background, there was there was lots of ways you can contribute on that front. Why'd you decide to go the route of adding to the educational media in the space? [01:08:13] Well, I didn't know what I was gonna do when I left reverb, I just knew I wanted to do Bitcoin. Or really, to be honest, I just knew I wanted to do crypto. I wasn't yet a Bitcoin maximalist. I got I got into Bitcoin like I said, I knew about it from 2011 and 2013, but by 2016, Ethereum was so loud that when I got off of Reverb, I just started researching all of that stuff and had a phase where I basically looked at every single point out there, look at Bitcoin, looked at Ethereum, and then finally came back to Bitcoin understanding, having understood, you know, that Bitcoin is more of a this kind of like sound money, freedom money play. [01:08:46] And yeah, I didn't know what I was gonna do, but I started giving talks at high school as I had some friends who were high school teachers. My wife's a high school teacher. So I started going out to high schools giving talks and started writing notes for these talks and really quickly turned those notes into essays, and those essays started looking like chapters, and then I realized that what I'd written is half of a book. [01:09:06] Yeah. So I started kind of like polishing that up. I really felt that what I was doing a lot was repeating myself to my friends, and I didn't have a great way to pitch Bitcoin. I was awkward at explaining it. And writing the book really helped me formulate those thoughts and put them into a concrete order and you know, Bitcoin is very circular, it's very difficult to say, you know, how do you explain Bitcoin? [01:09:28] Do you start with mining? Do you start with hashing? Do you start with you know digital signatures? Do you start with, you know, where did where did it come from? So I used the book to hone my way of thinking about Bitcoin. Of course I consumed tons of pods and tons of other books while I was doing it, and it helped me to develop my own internal understanding even better. [01:09:49] And I also was consulting for a while, just different Bitcoin companies and kind of like more on the technology infrastructure side. And so when the book finally came out, that's when I decided I was just gonna kind of leave my consulting gigs and work just exclusively in the education sector because I thought that was the biggest way to make an impact, right? [01:10:09] To actually make to bring more people into Bitcoin is really what we should be doing right now. A lot of people are building cool apps, and I think that's great, but it's so early. I mean, if we if we really look at kind of zooming out, maybe half a percent of humanity has Bitcoin. So we're building apps for the 0.5%, which is fine. [01:10:28] They need the apps, they need the wallets, they need the maybe they need the lending products and all that kind of stuff. But yeah, I mean, education is is the biggest thing we can do to bring more people on, and that's why I'm focusing on it. Yeah, absolutely. And I guess it makes sense while you've recently jumped on board with Give Bitcoin. You joined CEO Cory Klippsten, came on as co-founder and CTO. [01:10:51] It makes sense because the goals of the Give Bitcoin and Save Bitcoin apps are the stated goals are to bring in the next 21 million or at least bring in 21 million new Bitcoiners. Right, we want to be the best on-ramp, you know, for Bitcoin. Right. And it's not just being an on-ramp, because there's lots of those, right? [01:11:12] And I think this is probably what really brought you in, but there's an education component with the services. Yeah, well, I really bucket that with on-ramping because when you put people in Bitcoin and don't tell them what it is or how to use it or what they should do next, then you haven't really done them a service. I've you know I've onboarded a lot of people myself, just like once one on one, red pilling people, giving them their first Bitcoin in their wallets. [01:11:35] Like it's such such a painful process. I mean it's fun, don't get me wrong, but it's painful in the sense that it's not scalable. I can't go around and do this to every person I meet. And it's also very like confrontational to like be like, hey, let me give you some Bitcoin right now. Let's go. We're gonna learn about this. It's like it's a lot, it's a lot to deal with. So I really love the idea that you know you buy your Bitcoin or you are gifted your Bitcoin, and then we drip you some knowledge, right? [01:12:00] Like here's a little bit about what what money is. Here's a little bit about what Bitcoin is and why it's different from the money you might be used to. These are things that people need to consume on their own time and digest, and it's way easier that way than if you're trying to kind of like you know do a five minute cram session on what you just sent them to their wallet and like they forgot to back up their keys or they they didn't they forgot about your Bitcoin entirely and deleted their phone, deleted their app on their phone when they when they upgraded. [01:12:26] Like this stuff has happened to me. So I totally sympathize with onboarding new coiners and that's why I thought Corey's idea was was great and something very needed here. How is GiveBitcoin providing education? And like who's involved in putting that education stuff together? Yeah, so we have a number of different folks from the Bitcoin space, people like Safadine and Stephan Livera, Matt Odell, people who are basically advisors who help us with our curriculum. [01:12:53] We have our head of education Matt Ruby, who's really good at kind of collating all this stuff and coming up with the with the content. And then we all work together to make sure that it's it's good. It's something we can be proud of that we can actually give to a new coiner and have them read through it and be engaged. Besides the written content, we're also putting together some videos, and maybe maybe we'll even have some interactive stuff. [01:13:14] We'll see. I think we're open to anything that helps people to understand what Bitcoin is and get on board. So the give product is custodial and you guys delay the I guess the time delay, the gifts for one year, is it always one year now? [01:13:33] I know that there was an option at first. Yeah, we decided to eliminate the option. That was part of like me coming on board is I'm I'm like a hardcore simplicity kind of like proponent. I love to slash features. Yeah. So I came in, I'm like, no, delete this, delete this, delete this. But yeah, I love I love simple products. [01:13:51] So yeah, we're custodial for the first year where the money's escrowed in a licensed and regulated custodian. They handle funds for companies like Bittrex and Binance. And I don't you know I don't love custodianship, but we have to be realistic. When we onboard somebody like my mom or my grandma, they're not going to be able to take personal custody of the Bitcoin. [01:14:13] Not yet, right? And that's kind of our goal. Our goal is to educate people on how and why they should take custody. But to expect somebody who's been gifted like a tiny amount of Bitcoin, whether it be like 10 or 50 dollars, to actually go through the effort of setting up their own wallet, not understanding it, or perhaps not even being able to understand it if they're at a certain age or a certain you know, level of experience with technology. [01:14:34] We can't expect that. I think a lot of hardcore Bitcoiners will want everybody to go fully self-sovereign right away, but we have to be absolutely realistic. So we encourage them to do that and we teach them how to do that on the way on their journey, right? So we drip them this information, we start to give them onboarding emails, and eventually they will learn how to do this and when their time lock is up, which is you know a year from from when the coin was gifted, then we will absolutely handhold them and help them take personal custody. [01:15:02] And the nice thing is if we wait a year, we might even see new developments in wallets to make it way easier, like what we saw with Casa. I mean, who knows what Casa is gonna look like a year from now? It may be so easy that we just stop doing custodial entirely. I'd be more than happy to do that if I felt like people didn't have to go through all these like crazy steps to understand how to custody their own Bitcoin, make it safe for backup from theft, from getting hit by a bus, what happens to their account, you know, if nobody can access it. [01:15:29] Yeah. Like these are real questions for beginners. And let's keep in mind that most people use a single password across all their websites. That's that's where we're at today. So expecting them to understand the level of security required to secure Bitcoin is a little bit unrealistic. And that's why we ask roll. And then after that, we teach, and then they take custody. [01:15:48] Yeah. Yeah, and it helps the people who are receiving these gifts really avoid some of those common new coin mistakes like you're saying. Like, I mean, to just to name a couple, like panic selling is a huge one. Panic selling, yeah. If they buy if they have it on Coinbase, this is a common one, right? Panic selling or trading for another coin. Yeah. [01:16:06] And this is why I don't like I don't send people. I used to send people to Coinbase, I thought it was a good user experience. Now I just send people square. That's you know, until we have safe Bitcoin, that's gonna be my onboarding mechanism because it's it's easy. You open up an app and you hit a button, right? And there's no shit coins. There's no shit coins. That that's the thing, right? It has to be as simple as you see a number, you press a button, and you're done. [01:16:26] Yeah. And if it's not that simple, then we haven't done our job. So that's that's where we're at. If you present people with all these other coins, and it's not because I'm religious about Bitcoin, it's because I'm a market realist. I understand the value of Bitcoin as a scarce resource. I don't understand the value of these other things, and I definitely don't want to have my mom try to ask me questions about why she should or should not buy Litecoin or Ethereum or why it went down 90% and when she should sell it. [01:16:51] Like these are ridiculous questions. This is just confusion for newbies, and I'm very sad that Coinbase went that way. And that they're even offering people money to learn about these other coins, right? I mean, it's it's a bad way to get on people onboarded. But that's their business model, so that's fine. Our business model is to really focus on Bitcoin, to be absolutely pure to that ideology and to keep to teach people why they should value their gift, right? [01:17:16] We don't care if they hear about other coins, they most people haven't, right? If you talk about people in the like on the street, most of them have heard about Bitcoin, almost none of them have heard about Ethereum. They have a very dilute like delusional kind of or or skewed view of the of the universe when we look at Twitter because there's all this debate with Bitcoin, Ethereum, Bitcoin Cash. [01:17:36] Your average person on the street has never heard of these things. So why even show it to them? Show them Bitcoin, let them onboard to Bitcoin. Yes, that's what it is. The mind share dominance for Bitcoin is so huge, right? I mean, the market cap dominant. Yes, yeah, yeah, it's massive. I think it's like 99 to 1. If if that I think it's 99.9. Yeah, I mean, honestly. [01:17:55] Yeah, yeah. So what what are the latest developments that are in progress right now? What can we expect from give and what's save gonna look like in the when it launches? Yeah, we're we're kind of thinking through save right now. We want to make sure that we do offer a non-custodial option if we can. I think for saving, there's absolutely no reason that people should go custodial unless they want to, right? [01:18:18] If they want to like tell their mom to get onto save and have help her do a custodial account, totally cool. We'll support that. But we are definitely thinking through how we can best do a non-custodial version, a straight to wallet purchase type of flow, minimize the amount of KYC required. I mean, there's a lot of stuff that you have to do because of regulations. Yeah, you know, honestly, it sucks. [01:18:38] I think AYC is absolutely horrible. I think it's it's you know, it creates massive honey pots of user information, but it's what the government wants us to do. So we have to play by the rules since we're the in the United States. And so, yeah, we're looking at different partners and different opportunities to do that properly. And also making sure that the user experience is absolutely slick. [01:18:57] So we're working with a designer to kind of really polish it up, making sure that there's no pickups in the process. Same thing with Give. We're kind of like just polishing up the flow, making sure it's as simple as possible and ensuring that people have a great experience. Whether they choose to go custodial or not, we need to make sure that they have that experience that's absolutely stellar investing class. [01:19:20] Yeah, so the differentiator then for both the products is going to be like the education, the sense of community, and just the absolute dedication to Bitcoin. That's what I'm hearing. Yeah, I think that's that's really what it is. And I think the level of focus enables us to be super lean, right? We have we can have a small surface area for the product. [01:19:38] We can have really tight user experience, we can have good marketing that's really, really focused on Bitcoin. And without distractions, we should be able to make this a very good product for both customers and for us internally, right? Because when you're only supporting one coin, then you're worrying about that one coin's characteristics, how to secure it, how to store it, how to onboard people. [01:20:00] I think we're gonna deliver a better experience than a company that's focused on many coins. Yeah, absolutely, man. I'm really excited about Save and what Give is doing, and you guys keep up the great work, man. Thank you, I appreciate that. Alright, thanks for joining me today. Take care. It was a great pleasure. Thanks. All right, bye. Bye. [01:20:24] Thanks to Jan for joining me for a fun discussion. I'm excited about the work those guys are doing at Swan Bitcoin with the give and save products. Let us know your thoughts and questions about the episode. Jan is at SKWP on Twitter. I am at Citizen Bitcoin. And that's really the best way to support the podcast, sharing it out on Bitcoin Twitter. Let us know what you thought, questions you had, parts you liked. [01:20:45] You can share it with your family and friends, of course, too. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. And check out layer1btc.com for the CitizenBitcoin merch collection. Thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring the episode and to LTBN for distributing the podcast on their amazing feed for Bitcoin content. [01:21:05] If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. Always happy to talk to y'all. My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at CitizenBitcoin on Telegram and Keybase. And my email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me. This week's open source shout out goes to Raspibolt. Raspibolt is built by Staticus, a longtime Bitcoin builder. [01:21:24] It's software to make setting up a Bitcoin and lightning node on a Raspberry Pi. Very easy. RaspbiBolt 2 just landed and it works on a Raspberry Pi 4 and it works with hardware wallets, which is very cool. It's a very fun project. Get your hands a little dirty on the hardware and software side of running Bitcoin and Lightning. Find out about Raspibolt at staticus.github.io slash raspibolt. [01:21:47] Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.