Rui Gomes: Bitcoin, Lightning, Lapps and OpenNode Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-09-13 [00:00:22] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm here sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Warm greetings to you wherever you are in the world today. I'm really glad you're here with me for this discussion with Rui Gomes. Before we dive in, a quick shout out to Layer OneBTC.com. [00:00:43] Layer 1 is your source for the best Bitcoin merch. Nick Ward is the Bitcoiner and designer running the show at this Bitcoin only business. There are so many great designs to choose from. You can get those designs on shirts, hats, hoodies, mugs, and stickers. Click on partners and choose Citizen Bitcoin to shop for merch that supports this podcast. [00:01:04] That's Layer1BTC.com. One is spelled out. [00:01:08] I'm proud to be a partner of Layer 1 alongside Stephan Livera and Peter McCormack. It's a good company to keep. Definitely check out Layer 1. [00:01:17] Alright, let's get into this one. [00:01:27] Rui Gomes is a software developer and Bitcoiner who created Lightning Spin, one of the first Lightning apps to appear on the web. He's worked on the project that became OpenNode from very early days and is now the lead software engineer at OpenNode. So Rui and I discuss his background growing up as a computer nerd, his diving down the Bitcoin rabbit hole, quickly coming up to speed and publishing one of the first lightning apps. [00:01:51] We talk about lightning wallets, the state of the lightning network, and of course, OpenNode. We also consider the complementary roles that OpenNode and BTC Pay Server kind of fill in the Bitcoin ecosystem. Yeah, this episode was full of bullishness about the future of Bitcoin and Lightning Network throughout. I had a great time talking to Rui today. [00:02:11] Really cool dude. Hope you all enjoy it as well. Alright, I'm really excited to have Rui Gomes with me this morning. He's at OpenNode right now. We'll get into his background and everything. [00:02:29] Welcome to the show, Rui. Thank you for having me, Brady. Excited to be on. We've been chatting on Twitter DMs for quite a while. I remember reaching out to you when lightning.spin first launched and chatting about that, and we talked a little bit about a new app that you launched, laps.co, which we'll definitely get into. [00:02:48] But I'd love to just start going way back and would love to hear about how you became a computer nerd like me. Growing up was I was, you know, into computers a bunch and I spent a lot of my time in front of a computer and coding with Pascal and Basic and all that stuff and getting on the internet with modems and that was probably a little before your time, but as you were growing up in Portugal, how'd you get into computers and programming? [00:03:14] Well, I was looking at my father actually is also a bit of a nerd, so he kind of got me into computers from a very early age. And I guess it's just snowballed from there. Started playing around with some computer games, very remember playing with Pokemon on Game Boy emulator on a computer. [00:03:37] Totally legal, by the way. But yeah, it's just snowballed from there, really. I started learning how to code from a very young age just picked it up reading through the code and kinda I was lucky and at the same time kind of unlucky that the first language that I picked up was PHP. [00:03:58] Lucky in the sense that it was very very easy to read and understand what things were were what was happening just reading the code. So and then just picking up things from tutorials online. Unlucky in the sense that back then PHP was a very very hard language for you it was very easy for you to get lost and write very very bad code. [00:04:22] So that kind of happened to me but fortunately later on in my life I ingressed in the computer science in college and kind of you know learned proper software engineering that definitely complemented my my lousy development skills before college and yeah I guess that that was the origin of becoming a nerd and then my story of getting into Bitcoin was much much later than that I just got into Bitcoin not even two years ago actually I first bought a few satoshis back in 2016 but it [00:05:01] Was not until maybe two years ago that Zhuan the CTO of OpenNode brought me on to help with some front end engineering and okay from then I being around Bitcoin maximalists you know all day just makes it very easy for you to go down the Bitcoin rabbit hole and two years later here I am you know yeah yeah so you haven't been in that long and you've I mean accomplished a lot in the ecosystem already which is pretty cool. [00:05:31] So did you start working like you worked for OpenNode as a contractor before you were hired full time? Yeah yeah that was sort of what happened so initially so open was not even a thing yet it was just a project inside a design agency where open it was actually born and they brought me on to help them implement the initial MVP so they had things designed and mostly aligned up but they needed some help to get things out the door quickly so you know Joao knew me and I was actually working at the same co-working space then [00:06:09] Nice we were working at the same co-working space so he just he knew that I was doing a lot of front end back then and he just brought me on to help them with that and from then from you know I was lucky that now or even last year there's so much information that if you really want to get down the rabbit hole it's very easy for you to quickly get up to speed you know so I just read a lot of books listened to a lot of podcasts you know was on Twitter and that really helped me get up to speed and learn the Bitcoin way very fast obviously as well as having [00:06:48] A very Bitcoin like focused team which is also very helpful if you have any questions you can easily get the answers. Yep exactly so did you kind of start getting into economics and economic and monetary ideas through Bitcoin, or had you kind of thought about this stuff before you got into Bitcoin? [00:07:11] Not much. You know, I've I've always been very aware of my of the current economic situation, but I've never really thought why it was that way, right? So I was aware of the things that were going on, but I've never asked the exactly why things were the way they were. [00:07:31] So after getting into Bitcoin, I started by learning Bitcoin technically. So the first book I read was Andreas Antonopillo's Mastering Bitcoin. So that was my first introduction into Bitcoin, so a very technical-minded introduction where you it doesn't even talk much about actual economics. [00:07:53] And after really understanding the basics and I moved on to Cyfidine's the Bitcoin standard, yeah, which really put made helped me put everything into perspective, right? So it helped me understand both the technical aspects of Bitcoin and also the monetary policy and economic aspects of Bitcoin. [00:08:16] And then obviously being on Bitcoin Twitter and going to conferences really solidified those opinions that I have about Bitcoin and the world and the economics and all of that. Yeah, Savadine's book is is a wonderful introduction to Bitcoin economics and it it's amazing how Bitcoin is like this real-world example that's helping people learn about what money really is and kind of undoing and re-educating you know, people just one at a time as you get into Bitcoin, you fall down that rabbit hole and for most people coming in [00:08:54] These days who aren't like you know, Austrian economists and gold bugs or cypherpunks who had been working on digital money and studied money, the new people coming in, including me when I came in in 2017, just you know haven't thought about that stuff before, and Bitcoin's gives us this real world example of what it really is and you know allows you to start studying and understanding what's going on. [00:09:19] That's like kind of like this mass awakening that's happening. I don't remember having any conversations with my friends or my family at all about economics and monetary policy. But it seems like for the past two years, if I spend more than one hour talking with any given person, chances are very high that we're going to end up talking about monetary policy and Bitcoin and all of that. [00:09:46] Yeah, man, same. Yeah, I've had to lay off. I mean, I you know, when I first fell down the rabbit hole, you're just so passionate about everything and that like you literally don't want to talk about anything else, and so you steer every conversation possible toward Bitcoin as soon as possible. And then after a while, everyone around you just gets so annoyed with it that you're just like have to lay off. [00:10:06] And then you're just kind of looking for new people to talk with about it. So yeah, I'm I'm in the same situation. Yes, and that's you know that's how it spreads a sustainable way of conversation. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. And yeah, I definitely agree about the Mastering Bitcoin book as well. [00:10:24] And that's the first book I read too, because I kind of came to it having been a web developer for most of my career, and now I'm more sort of like project management, but that's that's what I first dove into and to understand the system because I was so curious about it after I finally felt filled on the rabbit hole. And he just announced along with Roast Beef and Renee Picard that they're going to be writing Mastering Lightning. [00:10:48] Any thoughts on the prospects for that book. Oh I'm very very excited for for that book in in particular because most of my projects and obviously my main thing which is open node are very very lightning network focused so it will definitely be very helpful for me as a developer as because there I'm sure that I will learn a lot even knowing mostly how the lightning network works I'm sure there will be a lot of details in that book that will be very very helpful and also just for bringing more developers into the lightning [00:11:27] Network ecosystem you know the more people that understand the lightning network and understand exactly what you can do with it in particular the fact that transactions are instant settle instantly and also you can transact as little as one Satoshi even less than a Satoshi if you really want to I'm sure that will that that will bring in a lot more developers with a lot of cool ideas and I think that's exactly what we need right now now that lightning is getting more and more mature it's time for developers really starting time for them to really start to come [00:12:05] Up with these ingenious ideas that will bring interest from Bitcoiners to actually set up their lightning wallets and start using the lightning network and the lightning network apps that people come up with. Yeah. And it seems that lightning is much more accessible in terms of development. [00:12:25] Like there's a there's a much like wider piece of the developer community, the wider developer developer community that would will be able to and like quickly pick up coding with Lightning as opposed to like the base layer, which is sort of this arcane art for a protocol development. [00:12:45] Yeah, so what has been your experience absolutely yeah I know you made you made yeah you made lightning spin. I think lightning spin was one of the first lightning apps to go live that I remember. Maybe along with like Satoshi's place absolutely one of the yeah it was one of the first few ones it was not the first I believe it's kind of it's been almost two years so memory kind of fails me but I believe the first one was something like y'all's then Satoshi's place and lightning spin came next something like that bid refill somewhere in the middle but yeah it was definitely one of the first [00:13:23] Few ones and I was not in Bitcoin I may might have been in Bitcoin for like three four months and when I came up with lightning spin because as you were saying lightning the lightning network really makes it easy for you as a regular developer to develop apps that accept Bitcoin without really having to dive deep into how exactly blocks the blockchain works what exactly do I need to accept the Bitcoin payment how many confirmations what exactly is the mempool how how does everything work I just want to accept a payment right and lightning network really makes that a [00:14:01] Much easier process because it abstracts away a lot of that complexity. Most APIs of lightning Nodes, whether that is L and D or C Lightning, they give you very, very easy ways for you to just create an invoice for a given amount, and then they will let you know when that invoice is paid. [00:14:20] And there is no like middle ground, the invoice is either paid or it's not paid. So it's much easier for you as a developer to work with that. There are still obviously some edge cases, some invoices that get stuck and HCLCs. But yeah, things are getting much much better now that the network is maturing, and it will it will it's definitely much easier for someone to pick up payments with the lightning network as opposed to Bitcoin. [00:14:48] That's why I'm so excited to see the applications that people people come up with now that they don't have to really dive deep into understanding Bitcoin very, very well. They can just focus on their ideas and their actual application and just let the lightning network do its thing and they just have to actually accept the payments. [00:15:09] So yeah. Yeah, I remember you know in the early days of Lightning, which is just a couple years ago now, there it was there were lots of like routing failures and stuff. The network wasn't nearly as robust as it is today. The number of channels open, number of nodes on the network were small, and so you'd have to really basically for a while you had to open up channels directly with the nodes you wanted to interact with, and the routing was was difficult. [00:15:39] But these days I've been able to use the lightning network, you know, for just kind of testing purposes, really, and very, very rarely run into routing failures now. Yeah, I can't remember having a lightning payment failing in the last you know few months. [00:15:57] Whereas in the beginning when Lightning spin first launched, so for those of you that don't know, Lightning Spin it was kind of a very simplified roulette where you could send in a thousand Satoshis, which at the time was like eight US dollar cents, and you would spin the wheel, and if you won, you could get your earnings back, your winnings back. [00:16:21] And if you think about it, that concept inside a lightning network is kind of tricky to do because if you're sending in a thousand Satoshis in the channel, you can't really easily receive two thousand back because of the way channels work and channel balancing and stuff. So and especially in the beginning when the network was very, very fragmented and people didn't have a lot of inbound capacity. [00:16:44] There were none of these services now that that allow you to receive inbound capacity, like Breeze and Bitrefield that they're calling it Lightning Service Providers. I really like that name. But yeah, at the time it was very, very hard and it was very challenging explaining to everyone why exactly can't you withdraw your winnings. [00:17:08] But I remember I've I in the meantime I've sold Lightning Spin, but I remember the first couple months that I was running it. It was I didn't get nearly as many support requests from people asking why they couldn't withdraw their earnings, so which goes to show that even six months ago the network was very, very much more solid than it was a year ago, and now it's even better with all these services that are that you can easily use to buy incoming liquidity. [00:17:42] Yeah, Breezewallet is a nice innovation and I think we'll see more lightning wallets doing what they're doing but they'll as soon as you install the app and you know the filters are downloaded and you're connected to the network you get they they open a channel to you so you have incoming liquidity right away yeah so that's that's really nice user experience for sure yeah I think that's yeah that's the way to go right now having someone create the incoming liquidity so you don't have as a user you don't have to worry about it and you just have your you load up your [00:18:21] Lightning wallet with an on-chain transaction and you can even create a your Breeze wallet or install your Breeze wallet and receive money instantly on lightning you don't even have to start with an on-chain transaction exactly because they open a channel from them to you so you can instantly just send a lightning transaction to the Breeze wallet you just created without ever going on-chain and that is really really cool very excited to see where that the breeze wallet team is going to end up I think they're they're going to be very very successful in the space absolutely yeah I think so too yeah [00:18:59] Resolving those UX issues and just making things you know as simple as Cash App is for dollars you know and speaking of Cash App like we'll we'll probably see a lightning wallet come to Cash App at some point in the nearish future I hope and any any experience any wallet that creates a very simple beautiful user experience is just going to be huge for adoption. [00:19:22] I would also like to shout out to Sats app on that Casa put out Sats app recently and a couple weeks ago open it up to the general public so that anyone, even if you don't have a Casa node, you can use SATSAP to work on the Lightning Network. And you can also connect it to if you have a Casa node, connect it to your home, home node and work, you know, in in a self-sovereign way directly through your own node and not trust any third party or any other node which is very cool. [00:19:52] And UX on that is great. Yeah, I haven't had the chance to use SATSAP yet, but yeah, it looks very, very good from what I've seen online. I'm actually using the Zap wallet by Jack Balars, and that's connected to my node back home. So it's also a very, very similar experience, but it works with any kind of node using L and D. [00:20:15] So if anyone's using or hosting their own node at home, and you want a very easy way and actually very, very thoughtful experience of using Lightning connected to your home own node, you might consider Zap wallet. It works very, very well for my experience. [00:20:33] I've been using it for the past few months, and it it's one of the better one of the best lightning wallets for ship. Yeah, absolutely. Obviously, it it just doesn't run on your phone yet, but I think they have something in the works for that. They might have might they might have shipped a version that runs on your phone. I'm just I don't I just don't know because I'm using the one that connects to your phone to your node back home. [00:20:57] Yeah, there is actually a mobile version now for both iOS and Android. And the Android story is pretty cool because they have they were just focusing on an iOS version just for because of capacity on the team and knowledge that was there on the team. I think Jack was familiar with with the iOS system ecosystem. [00:21:17] And then there was this this guy that I think he was somewhere in Europe who sort of quietly for several months built an Android version based on the iOS code that was on GitHub. And just like one day emails or drops into the forums, or I think maybe on GitHub actually in the comments, like, hey, I've got an Android version, and it just like dropped out like a gift to the Zap team, which is pretty cool. [00:21:38] Yeah, I've heard the story it's actually very fun. Yeah, that's just the wonders of open source that we get to experience in Bitcoin every day. It's definitely fun. It's amazing, yeah. So I've I got the Zap wallet connected to my NoDle node at home. So I've got Satsap connected to Casa node and Zap connected to my Nodal and kind of testing all these things out, and it's just amazing how far we've come in such a short amount of time. [00:22:06] The user experience is really good now. And it's just gonna keep getting better. Yeah, absolutely. The Nodd team is also killing it. I really like where they're going and they're partnering with Samurai. So also they will have their own node that you can connect with with your samurai wallet. [00:22:25] So things are starting to really pick up with your personal no thing, and I really like that because I think if you're not running your own full node, you're not really using Bitcoin, right? So I'm really excited that there are a lot of companies working on making it as easy as possible to get your own node up and running. [00:22:44] I'm actually running my own custom thing, and it can be challenging at times if you don't really know what you're doing. Or if you don't have the time to invest to really get your configuration going and get your setup working properly and if you can just pay some company a few hundred dollars and they will ship you they will ship you a fully working box that you can just put put your n in your closet and you'll be up and running in a few minutes. [00:23:16] I think that's absolutely the way to go and that's exactly how we'll get people to actually run their own nodes. Because if you're if we're expecting everyone to really go through the trouble of getting the parts together for a computer or it will be very challenging. Oh yeah. Well now we have tools like Pierre's node launcher that kind of help you with that but I think still the Nautil solution or something like the Casa node is more appropriate than maybe repurposing an old laptop that's really not made to run 247 so it will work but I think [00:23:54] Having the little node is a it's a more pleasant experience for for the end user. Yeah and it's a it's amazing value. You know you get it's one click updates for for both the Noddle and the Casa node. They're they're teams who know what they're doing, it's their job. I mean it's just you know you're outsourcing just like specialization in the way capitalism works. [00:24:15] We all specialize and so you're outsourcing the maintenance of your Bitcoin and lightning nodes to a team that specializes in in that work and yeah for $300 a year as a gold member of CASA for instance, you get to take advantage of their multi-sig service. You get a CASA node and the software is updated regularly. [00:24:37] I can you know manually decide if I want to accept the updates, so I you know still get to make that choice and w if I want to, I just click once on the browser interface and you know my nodes is software is updated. And then of course you have the SATSAP, so you have a mobile wallet that connects to your own node. [00:24:55] 's similar experience. There's you know you're you're really buying not just this hardware, but you're buying continuous software updates, one-click software updates. So yeah, it's a it's just a both are great services at this point. I definitely see things kind of moving toward that direction. Yeah, that's absolutely a lot of value for the amount you're paying. [00:25:17] I've got to know the Nautil team and they're really you know heads down working on making a very, very good product. And I'm sure the CASA team is also the same way because it it really takes a lot of effort to create experiences that are simple, you know, just because they're sim more more often than not, a simple experience takes a lot more work than the than a similar one that looks a lot more complex, you know. [00:25:47] So yeah, a lot of respect that goes out for for both of those teams. Absolutely. All right, let's talk about open node. You're a lead software engineer there, and I call open node the stripe for bitcoin. That it that's the I would just Yeah. I that that's the immediate experience that I thought of when I used OpenNode. [00:26:11] I when it when I saw it, I immediately like actually installed WordPress and WooCommerce just so I could hook up OpenNode and see what the experience was like and made some stickers and sold a few. So I actually got to as an you know use the experience as an e-commerce provider. [00:26:29] And it was just like setting up an e-commerce system with or nonprofit donation system as I have in the past with Stripe. Super easy, you know, and if you if you want to get into the API side of things and kind of customize things, there's a great simple use API, awesome documentation. And then of course there's plugins for the major e-commerce platform. [00:26:48] So I used the WooCommerce plugin when I made mine. So as a web developer I immediately understood the mission and value of OpenNode. So yeah like what is it what is like for open node or work to work for OpenNode. What's you know the kind of the mission of the company the ethos of the company. Well it's it's been great. [00:27:06] So as I mentioned before OpenNode was the first Bitcoin company that I work for and it's been an absolutely amazing experience to go ride this wave with the rest of the team. Everyone's you know very heads down working and we're all a team of Bitcoin maximists with that really just want to see the Bitcoin ecosystem expand and grow and bring on no coiners to the Bitcoin economy. [00:27:33] So yeah it's been it's been absolutely great. Our our company's ethos is really to be the easiest way for anyone to accept Bitcoin. We're trying to do that by providing a delightful experience that anyone can easily sign up without having to really know much about Bitcoin. [00:27:52] You can sign up at OpenNode.co and just you know use any any one of our plugins we have plugins for WooCommerce, Rust the shop we have we recently announced our partnership with Shopify, so we're now an official Shopify partner. That's a big deal. Yeah, it was it was very very nice to get on that ecosystem because before us there there are other bitcoin payment processors in the Shopify ecosystem. [00:28:20] But because it's a very closed ecosystem, because obviously Shopify is a private company, it's hard to get in. So it took us quite a while to get in. But now that we're in, we're we're proud to be the only Bitcoin-only solution that's on Shopify. We accept SegWit and we accept Lightning Network. [00:28:41] So we're excited to have that be available for for our Shopify merchants. That's really the ethos of the company, just to be the easiest way for any business to accept Bitcoin. We also have this feature where we instantly exchange your Bitcoin for fiat at the time of your transaction. [00:29:00] So as soon as you receive Bitcoin, we will exchange it for fiat, and that's our way to get regular businesses onto the Bitcoin economy, even if they don't keep the Bitcoin and the Satoshis will circulate from one hodler to the other. So they're still making you know the economy, the Bitcoin economy stronger, and they're still in a way part of this Bitcoin ecosystem. [00:29:25] And we're our mission is that maybe eventually we will convince them to leave a certain percentage of their holdings in actual Bitcoin, and then once their suppliers accept Bitcoin, they can use that to pay their suppliers and they just keep more Bitcoin just because they see the value appreciate over time. [00:29:47] So yeah, we want them to our first goal is to bring all those businesses onto the Bitcoin economy, and our second goal is to actually make them part of the Bitcoin circular economy, you know, for them to actually use Bitcoin themselves. So yeah, it's a long road, but yeah, we're we're excited to be in this mission for sure. [00:30:09] Yeah, that makes sense. And like the when you mentioned the kind of auto conversion to fiat, I and I think you hit on this, but just to kind of follow up more specifically, the immediate thought I had was is there a way to easily allow the merchant to just keep like five percent in Bitcoin, you know, and liquidate the rest of it and kind of hold it as a as a store of value. [00:30:30] Is that a part of the UI experience now or just like on the roadmap? It is not a part of the experience right now, just because you know we're we're not it's too early. We think it's a bit too early for that, but and it's also a an UI challenge that we'll have to it will take some time for us to really think through an experience that will make sense for for our merchants, but but it's definitely something that's in our roadmap. [00:30:57] It's actually part of our long-term vision that we enable all these businesses to be part of the Bitcoin circular economy. So not only we allow them to keep a certain percentage of their holdings in Bitcoin, we also have plan to have this all these educational material that helps them understand why they should withdraw their Bitcoin holdings through their own wallets and what wallets make sense for them, and how can they use their wallets to pay their suppliers and how can they safely keep their Bitcoin in long-term storage? [00:31:32] So we plan to be an all-in-one solution that not only helps you accept Bitcoin, it helps you convert what you need into fiat, but also teaches you what to do with the rest of it and how to safely hold it for the long term. I love that. And I think that's a just a fantastic example to other Bitcoin companies that you're making education part of your product. [00:31:57] And I, you know, I've I've been talking a lot on this podcast about and the and it's the reason why I started this podcast is that we really need to step up our game in terms of Bitcoin education. There's a lot out there that's available, and it's certainly developed a lot over the past couple of years. That you know, kind of people bringing things together and making it a little bit more easy, easily understood or easily digestible for newcomers. [00:32:21] And like you said, you know, when you came in a couple of years ago, you were able to quickly get up to speed, books, podcasts, Twitter, and so that that's formula for learning Bitcoin is there. But having that touch point with a company you're working for, your payment processor, encouraging like, hey, you know, here's what Bitcoin's really all about, and here's how you can you know take advantage of these other properties of Bitcoin. [00:32:46] It's not just you know a way to accept an online payment and then you know cash it out to fiat. It's this whole you know idea and new financial system. And I think that that's just a great example to other Bitcoin companies, really important. Yeah, absolutely. We're trying to pave the way. There are certainly other Bitcoin companies that do invest a lot in education. [00:33:05] Yeah, and we're true, we're trying to be on the forefront of that. Actually, our most recent hire was Nik Bhatia. He's on Twitter at time value of BTC, and he's been such a great asset to have in our team. We just added two articles to our blog just explaining exactly what is a blockchain and why blockchain technology is not really a thing and why our vision is solely focused on Bitcoin. [00:33:33] So we're we're just now starting this education process that I was just mentioning, but we're definitely going to be expanding on that and helping our customers understand what is Bitcoin, why they should hold it and how they should hold it. It's definitely going to be a process, and some people will just not care about it. [00:33:55] But we hope that at least a certain percentage of our our customers do care about it and become part of this Bitcoin ecosystem the right way because it's very very easy to get lost in all the BS and all the crazy talk about well about altcoins and all that. [00:34:13] So we're trying to you know be real and actually teach people the right way. Yeah, so you know, open note is dedicated to being a bitcoin only company, right? Like no prospects for dealing with altcoins in the future. Yeah, yeah. We're it was our our vision from the beginning was to be a Bitcoin-only company. [00:34:33] Yeah, and when we started in the beginning of last year, the ICO craze was still going on. It it had toned down, but it was still going on. It's very clear now that ICOs won't be making a comeback, but we've been Bitcoin only from the very beginning, and we plan to stay this way just because it's so much easier for us as a company to think through think about a delightful experience if we just use Bitcoin. [00:35:03] It's much easier than have to think about all these altcoins and how do we differentiate about them and how do we teach our our our audience about all these altcoins? It's much easier if we just focus on Bitcoin and if we just have this one mission that is very clear. [00:35:22] I think it helps us as a company and it certainly helps our our customers as well. Yeah. By not having their their own customers because our customers are merchants and the merchant customers that go through our checkout experience that are trying to pay for for example the stickers that you've created it's much easier for them if they just see, okay this is a Bitcoin checkout I have to pay with Bitcoin. [00:35:45] If you see a bunch of altcoins you don't know what Bitcoin cash is, you don't know what Ethereum is, you get very confused very easily. You have to make a lot of choices and that kind of defeats the purpose of having you know a simplified payment processor that's the easiest way to accept Bitcoin. [00:36:03] So yeah that's why we're Bitcoin only. Yeah it's a it's a distraction on every side. You know it's a distraction for you know OpenNode and other companies who are trying to support the ecosystem because you know you have absolutely as well as the regulatory issues. So yeah there's a lot there's a lot of altcoins that are not in a very well defined space legally talking and we just don't want to expose our our merchants to those risks. [00:36:33] So I think being Bitcoin only is definitely the way to go and you're starting to see a big wave of companies going going that ways Drezor just this week announced their Bitcoin only firmware and I think a lot of other companies are are planning to do exactly the same now that the ICO craze is over or almost over. [00:36:52] Yeah, it's it we're seeing the monetary shelling point network you know, that that's described by Austrian economists that you know we money is is has these kind of network effects and will all sort of converge on one one money and we s we're seeing that happen now with you know although I don't like the Bitcoin dominance metric, you know, you have to take it liquidity into account and stuff. [00:37:15] So the basic Bitcoin dominance metric is you know back up to like 70% or something. But if you take liquidity into account, it's somewhere closer to like 90% of like liquid cryptocurrency is is is in Bitcoin. So we're seeing that that shelling point at work right now, I think. It's absolutely beautiful to see. [00:37:35] And it actually was it happened a lot faster than we were expecting back when we started. We were one of the few Bitcoin only companies. Certain we're still the only Bitcoin only payment processor that I know of, but it's we weren't certainly expecting all these other companies to become Bitcoin only in just the span of a year. [00:37:56] So when when we try to project five years from now, we can certainly see 90 plus percent of all companies on the quote unquote crypto space being Bitcoin only. And that's that's very exciting as a Bitcoiner personally. [00:38:14] That's that's very exciting to see. And it's certainly that shelling point that we all talk about. And it's it's it's crazy how it all happened in the span of a year. So I'm excited to see where what the future brings us. Yeah, it I'm starting to sort of agree more and more with Bitcoin Tina. [00:38:34] He's really kind of pushing this idea that this is just gonna happen way faster than most of us think. That the fact that this is sort of like layers and layers of exponential technologies kind of culminating in this this new money that that so you have the network effects of money, the network effects of the web and of you know just mobile technology and all that sort of combining together and we'll see this sort of skyrocketing exponential increase at some point once we get to that that kind of part of the S curve of adoption. [00:39:09] And maybe it you know it does seem to be happening faster than I would have assumed it was, and maybe we're looking more at like a five to ten year time frame than a like you know, twenty to thirty year time frame at this point. So it's pretty exciting. Yeah, absolutely. I think five to ten years is a reasonable timeline for us to maybe not go through hyper bitcoinization, but for us to see a large volume of adoption, I think a human being is we use we usually overestimate in the short term and underestimate in the long term. [00:39:43] So I think if we are actually projecting over five to ten years, we'll definitely see a huge amount of adoption. Bitcoin is just ten years old right now, and it went from being nothing to what it is today. So if you think about it, if we extrapolate from today to ten years from now, it will absolutely be crazy. [00:40:04] So I'm very excited to be in this space so early on to be able to witness all of that going forward. It's kind of like, you know, having been a computer nerd growing up, I'm sure you'll appreciate this too. But I see it as like you know, a second chance to experience the creation of something like the internet. And I, you know, been really interested in studying the history of the internet and how it was born, and then you know, when I was you know, in my teens the web was was born and that was just absolutely fascinating to watch and so it's really cool later on like to be a part of you know this brand new technology that's emerging and new money that's [00:40:42] Monetizing. It's really exciting. It absolutely is I think I've kind of missed the growth phase of the internet just because I wasn't like an adult working into space I was just you know in my teens and studying in college so I kind of missed the boat being a professional working in the space but just being someone working in the space and having the company that I work for paving the way and actually enjoying the growth that the whole space is is going through is absolutely insane and I'm very very excited to see where things go and I think yeah if we if [00:41:20] We play our cars right and if companies start adopting the latest and greatest scaling technologies such as you know just s things as simple as batching and think lightning network obviously maturing and being used in more and more production environments it's going to you know ease in the scaling of the of the whole network to a lot more people and it will maybe not be as crazy as 2017 was yeah hopefully. [00:41:51] Yeah hopefully and I agree that's always been my prognosis but I you know who knows there's there's a whole lot of people out there to take advantage of, I guess, but I think we have a lot more of that, like we talked about that education infrastructure now to kind of point people in the right direction and keep them you know from going astray into scams and projects that are promising something they can never deliver. [00:42:17] So and I and I should give a shout out at this point to my friend 6102 on on Twitter. Bitcoin.com is a great resource to look at the growth of Bitcoin only companies. He does a great job curating businesses and projects that are dedicated to being Bitcoin only. And so that's a great resource for everyone to check out. [00:42:38] Absolutely. I was actually just talking with with him yesterday, so it's funny how you mentioned it. But yeah, it's one of my favorite resources. If you're looking for no BS websites, platforms, companies, podcasts, events, meetups, all kinds of things. That is absolutely a great, great platform because it really he does a great job at curating away all of the things that are in this gray area of talking about Bitcoin, but also talking about scammy ICO, so they kind of lure you in with the presumption that you're going to be talking about Bitcoin, but then [00:43:16] It's an entirely different thing. So I think that the work that he's doing is an absolute godsend, and I really appreciate the his website as as usual. Yeah, and it's well designed and easy to use on mobile, so it's definitely worth checking out and bookmarking and having at hand as as we move forward with this exciting Bitcoin ecosystem development and everything. [00:43:39] So I think since we've been talking about Bitcoin's monetization process, and then we're transitioning from this curious collectible, as Nick Zabo describes it that for cypherpunks and tech nerds, into this serious global self-sovereign store of value, where it's kind of at the point where we are now. That there's an incentive not to spend Bitcoin and just hold it right now, obviously. [00:44:00] There's the tax problem as well, and the fact that you know it's going to appreciate greatly in value probably over the next five to ten years. Every Bitcoin transaction is a tax event. That's one I think that's under discussed as a as a reason for people not to spend because once you do that a few times and then tax season comes around, you're like, oh god, you know, and like you have to you know account for all that stuff if you know want to stay in the good graces of the government. [00:44:25] So there's like these incentives that are kind of against spending Bitcoin right now. And many think it'll be years before Bitcoin becomes widely adopted as a medium of exchange, and LN as a means of exchange. So what are you what are you guys is thinking about this at OpenNode? Like, why is now the right time to start building this business? [00:44:45] Well, we are not exactly sure that this is the right time. We might be too early, we might be too late. But hopefully this is a good time to be working on this. But I think you know, most people are not spending Bitcoin because obviously there's the appreciation issue that I don't want to spend something that is most likely going to appreciate over the next few few years, and also the tax implications. [00:45:12] But I think there's definitely a good amount, a good amount of people actually spending Bitcoin, whether that is because they actually get paid in Bitcoin, so they earn Bitcoin. There are a lot of people in that situation. Or they're just you know OG hodlers that have way too much Bitcoin and they just want to spend some of it because it just makes sense for them. [00:45:34] So I think it's it's there's still a substantial amount of people actually spending Bitcoin that it makes sense for us to start working on this. And you can see that there are a lot of companies that are thriving in this space, whether that is BitPay, even if we want to hate them, they're they're making a lot of money and they're processing a lot of Bitcoin for companies. [00:45:58] And there's companies like BitRefield that sell all kinds of things in the way of gift cards and vouchers and things like that. So I think there's still enough people spending Bitcoin that you can make a business out of it right now, and obviously you're you're preparing everything, the infrastructure that you need, the personnel, the edict the education material, you're preparing all of that for when the majority of people actually start spending Bitcoin, whether that is five to ten years from now, there's still a lot of work to be to be done for us to be ready to be mainstream [00:46:36] Payments. You know, we're not definitely we're definitely not ready to replace Visa, but if we start with with this niche use cases of people that get paid in Bitcoin, people that have way too much Bitcoin and they just want to spend a little amount of it. If we start with this use case, it will allow us as a company to prepare ourselves for when the actual mass adoption begins. [00:47:03] Because if you just start preparing when when the adoption is there, you're too late. So I think it's better if we're too early than we're too late. The only issue is that if we are way too early, we might not make it until the adoption is here. But I think I think the neat niche use cases will will be definitely enough to sustain all the ecosystem until more people start accepting Bitcoin. [00:47:33] Yeah, I agree with that. Or or spending their Bitcoin actually. Yeah, yeah, I totally agree with that. Yeah, and you have to be established and have a reputation and have your technology you know well tested and in and ready for the kind of battle tested and ready for the big wave coming at you. [00:47:52] And so yeah, I think it makes sense. Plus, you guys have an investor that is really dedicated to Bitcoin and the long-term vision. And so, you know, we'll I think he's Tim and I'm speaking of Tim Draper, he's you know willing to probably you know kind of float the company along until that adoption comes, whether it's sooner or later. [00:48:11] Yeah, it's been great having him as a Tim Draper as an investor. He definitely understood understood our vision from day one. He never questioned the fact that we were a Bitcoin only company and there were a lot of investors that were pushing us that way, and they couldn't wrap their heads around of why we wouldn't be adding other coins and why we wouldn't be at accepting offers from altcoins to pay us in exchange for accepting their their altcoin in our platform. [00:48:43] So it's definitely been great to have an investor that you don't have to argue about silly things like that. And yeah, and I think there are definitely more people spending Bitcoin than the majority of Bitcoiners would realize. Yeah. Because if you're in in a mindset of just buying and hop holding, and maybe you buy once a day, once a week, once a month, it's hard for you to realize that there are other people that are in entirely different mindsets. [00:49:11] If I get paid in Bitcoin, I have to spend some, even if I don't want to. I have to spend I have to spend Bitcoin because it's just it's how I pay my bills. So for people like that, or people that have been in the space for for a long time, or people that are in economies that regular payment processors don't work that well, or for donations and for all kinds of things. [00:49:37] People are are spending a good amount of Bitcoin. So I think that that is only going to increase, and it's going to definitely be a challenge to keep up with the space. But it's it's a good thing that we have started and we're we're preparing for this next wave of growth. [00:49:56] Absolutely, yeah. So let's talk about some of your competition or you know, the compliment businesses. You might look at them both ways, actually. And we talked about BitPay already. And then you know, it was I can't remember it was maybe a couple years ago or a year and a half ago or something. [00:50:15] Nicola Dorrier famously declared that he would make BitPay obsolete by building an open source version that sort of mimics the BitPay API so that those customers could easily switch to this kind of open source alternative. So do you think that open node and BC BTC pay server project are like complimentary competing, some a little of both? [00:50:36] How do you guys kind of fit into the ecosystem? Well, I think they serve quite different target demographics. And we are personally, everyone in our company is a big fan of BTC Pay Server. It's an absolute delightful project to see grow and to see people actually using it in the wild. [00:50:56] It's absolutely great. Every time we go and see something we want to buy using Bitcoin using BTC Pay Server, it's always a delightful experience. And we don't think of them as competitors because we're more focused on being bringing no coiner businesses to Bitcoin and being bringing on larger and larger businesses. [00:51:16] And obviously, as our company grows, that's been happening more and more frequently, such as becoming Shopify partners, as I mentioned before. That only happened because our company, you know, kept on growing and we kept on improving our product and improving our sales process to be able to close partnerships like that. [00:51:37] So we see our target demographic be a little bit different than BTC Pay Servers. And something that might help differentiate our products even further is that OpenNode had to implement KYC. It it just happened not even a month ago. [00:51:57] We implemented KYC in our platform, obviously not because it was our choice, because as Bitcoiners, we definitely see why KYC is definitely not a great thing to have. Yeah, but it's just it was just a legal requirement that we had to comply with, you know, it's actually the law. So because of that, we used the fact that we are now a compliant platform to really tackle more and more larger and larger businesses. [00:52:25] So the Shopify partnership was just announced a week after after we became fully compliant platform, and now that we are, we're just trying to reach out to a lot of big businesses, blue chip brands that everyone hearing or listening to this podcast, and all their friends and all their families they've heard above. [00:52:45] And companies that we weren't in the table with before, but they actually told us our legal compliance and accounting teams won't touch on this with a 10-foot poll until you know things are actually very, very clear and in in a compliance sense in a in a legal sense, right? So it took it took us a long time to make the switch to become a fully compliant platform. [00:53:09] But now that we did, we're we're just going to use that to bring on more and more businesses into the lightning network and into the Bitcoin economy. Using that as an advantage, as weird as it sounds. And I think if you look at the status quo of Bitcoin payments right now, it's mostly BitPay, maybe Coin Payments, CoinGate. [00:53:36] And that's that's the status quo right now. And I think we as a company can do much, much better than that by just being again a Bitcoin-only solution, being pro-Bitcoin, not engaging in the anti-Bitcoin side of things. It's not that hard to be, you know, a good actor in the Bitcoin space, just don't engage in every action against the Bitcoin network. [00:53:57] So I think we can change the status quo, and our option was to you know, just give up and shut the company down if we didn't want to implement KYC, but we chose to embrace it and use that to just become a better actor in the space and actually be a good payment processor. [00:54:19] Because if you think about it, the payment processors have been you know bad actors in every space since the four decades now. So it started with PayPal, just randomly shuts people's account down. And then when we move to Bitcoin, the first and most well-known payment processor is BitPay, that is also a terrible actor in the space. [00:54:41] They they just recently blocked withdrawals for the Hong Kong foundation. Yeah, they they couldn't withdraw their the donations they were getting in Bitcoin. So if we look at that, we really want to change the status quo, and we really want to show people that we can there there can be a Bitcoin payment processor or just a payment processor processor in general, that's not a complete nuisance to use. [00:55:08] And yeah, so regarding BTC PayServer, we recommend everyone that's you know technically minded or privacy aware. We recommend absolutely go ahead and use BTC PayServer. They have plugins for most of the platforms that we also have plugins for. [00:55:27] So it's really a question of what is your what is the thing that you value the most? Is it self-sovereignty? Is it privacy, or is it ease of use and maintainability? And do you want to focus first and foremost on your business first and let someone else handle payments for you? Or do you want to you know invest a little bit more time in payments and you want to be a little bit bit more hands-on with that, then you should go ahead and use BTC pay server absolutely. [00:55:55] But yeah, I think I think there they are definitely complementary solutions, not in the sense that you could use both at the same time, even you could, but I don't think that many people are doing that. But they are complimentary in the sense that depending on the things that you value the most, you have good options available to you. [00:56:15] BDC Bay Server, an absolutely fantastic option for privacy focused individuals and open mode more focused towards the business side of things and trying to be a more enterprise grade payment processor that's really hands off. You let us take care of your payments and you handle your business, which is what you do best. [00:56:37] So yeah, I think they they work great together. Yeah, they're not I we don't consider them to be competitors. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. That's the way I see it too. And if you hadn't if you guys hadn't done a KYC the Bitcoin only payment service, like someone else would have done it, you know. So when you're kind of faced with that decision, I think, you know, the path you guys chose, like, hey, let's do this so that we can, you know, do it right and we do a bitcoin only and also you know, focus on educating people about self-sovereignty. [00:57:08] And I know you guys have like you can you could withdraw on Lightning Network or you can withdraw on chain at any time, and you can also schedule like a weekly withdrawal that you guys should like I guess probably compile into one on-chain transaction. So and you can do that for free. [00:57:27] Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, so when it comes to touch on the KYC point again, you're absolutely right. We did get some backlash as we were expecting from the community, yeah. But we also saw a lot of reactions exactly like yours, that people that understood that this was not a business decision. [00:57:47] This is just the law and it's the way things have to be. And we're taking taking that to our advantage in in the best way we can. And yeah, we're we're we offer lightning network withdrawals for free. So we handle the cost of that for you. [00:58:07] We paid a transaction fee, even though the transaction fees on the lightning network are very, very cheap for now. And we also offered you to you can set up a Bitcoin address, and every Monday, every Monday morning we will send you all your open node funds to your own wallet for free also. [00:58:25] And yeah, we batch all of those transactions to try to minimize the amount of transactions we're sending to a blockchain. Right. And if you want, we also we also offer you an on-demand Bitcoin on-chain withdrawal, but that has a cost so we just so we can pay for the network fees. [00:58:44] Right, right. Awesome. I want to talk about laps.co L A PBS.co. This is a site that you launched recently. And I thought it was cool that you asked me to give it a test, beta, a beta ride, a beta test a few days before you launched it. [00:59:03] It's great. It's a site where you can pay one Satoshi to vote up a lightning app. And there's a new set of lightning apps every week, and then there's like an all-time listing as well. Was this like a personal project of yours or something that you did for open node? [00:59:23] So so laps is is a personal project that I've just been working on nights and weekends. It it started with it actually started with a newsletter. So laps.co used to be a newsletter that showcased the showcase new Lightning apps every week. [00:59:41] It started around maybe January, February this year. And the plan all along was to eventually build it up to be an actual platform. I just didn't have enough time to do it. And just recently in the past couple months, I focused more on putting up the actual time necessary to code it up and get it, you know, to the state that it is today. [01:00:04] And yeah, it's just a way to improve Lightning apps discoverability because just because I have developed Lightning Spin and I had some other small projects developed in the past year or so. And what I noticed was that I was lucky because I could I didn't have any Twitter following before and I do have a small following now, but I'll always manage to get someone with a large audience to retweet or maybe talk about my projects, which helped a lot in making sure that the projects were actually used. [01:00:40] And I found out that a lot of people were developing really good apps, you know, even if they are just proof of concepts, they're really fun to play with once or twice and just try out different lightning payment models. And they weren't getting much attention because you know, if you don't have an audience, you'd really it's very hard for you to find a way for people to actually try out your your lightning app. [01:01:05] So laps.co is just a way to improve discoverability. So if you're a bitcoiner, if you're a lightning network user and you want to try out different things every week, you can just head over to laps.co and see what's on showcase this week. You can navigate through an all-time listing of the apps that were the most upvoted, and there I have a few things in the works for for the platform. [01:01:32] Obviously, I want to give you an easier way to you as an user, an easier way to search and navigate through all the apps. And it's just been running for two weeks now, and I think maybe 15 apps have been featured. There's quite a bit of a backlog now because I don't want to showcase dozens of apps in a single day. [01:01:54] But eventually I want to build better search functionality and filtering functionality functionality so you can filter by. I want to use to try out apps that use microtransactions, or I want to try out apps that do this or do that. So yeah, there's still a lot of things that can be built into the platform. [01:02:13] But I think as long as it helps people to get the laps that they developed, and laps is short for lightning apps, by the way, for those of you that don't know. But yeah, it's just a way for people to level the playing field for all kinds of developers. It whether you have an audience or not, you with laps. [01:02:35] I hope the goal is that even if you don't have any audience at all, you can build something on the side and just submit it and have people try it out and engage and ask you questions and suggest new features and all that. Because some people just don't want to build audience, they build audiences, they don't want to be on Twitter all day. [01:02:57] They just want to build cool things on the site, or maybe they just want to you know dedicate a whole month of building something without having to worry how to market it or how to make people actually use it. And if we improve the discoverability of Lightning apps, I think in general, the whole space is going to improve as a result of that because if you see a lightning app that you want to use, you're more inclined to go through the effort of figuring out what lightning wallet you should use and actually setting it up so you could try that specific lap out. [01:03:31] And now that you have the Lightning Wallet installed and set up, you're much more inclined to try out other Lightning Network apps and help other people get onboarded using the same Lightning wallet as you, or maybe you find out that there's a better one and you know write something about it. And I think it will help adoption for sure. [01:03:51] If we give developers a platform to expose and show their their creations out to the public. So so we'll see. It's very, very fresh still, but I'm excited to see what people will publish in the platform for sure. [01:04:09] Yeah, I think it's a really cool concept to have a cure a directory curated by the crowd. And by requiring a once Toshi vote, you know, or once Toshi payment per vote, you know that it's Bitcoiners that are making the votes, which is cool. Yeah, absolutely. There's also this a similar platform in a way, which is Lightning Network Stores. [01:04:33] So if you're looking for places, actual stores that mostly ship physical products to you, but they also features all all kinds of stores. You can also head over to Lightning Networkstores.com. They have a huge selection of stores that are accepting Lightning right now. [01:04:51] I'm trying to make laptop co a little bit different in in the sense that it's mostly focused towards actual applications that usually feature some kind of cool way to use the lightning network, whether that is HODL invoices or sending my microtransactions, you know, Satoshi amount one Satoshi worth of transactions, and it's more focused towards use cases like that. [01:05:21] But if you're looking for just stores in general to buy stickers or stuff like that, Lightning Network Stores is also a great resource. And there's also Lightninghood.com, which is a platform that has all kinds of things lightning, news, stores, platforms, games. [01:05:40] So that's also worth checking out. So there are a lot of people working on discoverability in the space, which I think is very, very important. Yeah, absolutely. Let's shift gears to talking about lightning more broadly. What are a few of Lightning, the Lightning Protocol's kind of biggest and most immediate challenges right now that you see from your vantage point at OpenNode? [01:06:06] And what upcoming Lightning Network developments are you excited about that might address those challenges? I think one of the first things that was a big challenge in the space was backups, and that was recently mostly fixed with static channel backups. [01:06:24] So now you have an easy way to recover your lightning funds if you happen to lose the device that you were using for your lightning node or if the hard drive breaks for some reason. So that was something that was very big in this space, I think. [01:06:44] And now it's just a question of adoption and just refining the protocol and having the network grow and grow because the larger the network gets the more stable it will also become and the easier it will be to for developers to see where things are moving and to address issues that come up with the way things are growing if the network gets too centralized or too so sparse that you can establish connections easily and I think the biggest thing that could happen to lightning which is not a requirement for it to work at all but it [01:07:22] Would be very very cool if it happened is L2 ELTO which is a protocol and let's put it in a way it's kind of like a new version of lightning that builds on top of lightning and it kind of eliminates a lot of the issues that there are with lightning so if you've heard of things like watchtowers that are necessary to make sure they're not channel breaches L2 kind of solves that very elegantly it it unfortunately requires some new opcodes so we'll see when that happens or if if that happens [01:08:00] That but that would be a very very cool development in the space and I think for now the thing that we would like the most is that more and more people start accepting lightning and more and more people start using lightning maybe start with small amounts of money, obviously. The protocol is still very, very new. [01:08:19] And just recently we had a CVE that people actually exploited just a few days ago. So yeah, people actually need to be careful out there. But as long as you're playing with small amount of money, always Bitcoin that you can't afford to lose. You should I would encourage you to actually go ahead and use Lightning Network, the Lightning Network to experiment with laps to buy things online, whether that is just a sticker or a shirt or a cap, something like that. [01:08:53] Because the more people use it, the more people get familiar with it, the easier it will be for everyone to accept this as a scaling solution and to make the network grow, which will be again better for the network and everyone using it in general. So I don't know if there are many things that I would consider to be broken. [01:09:15] Right now, the network functions fairly well. We'll we'll probably have growing, growing pains as any network has when growing from one person to hundreds and then thousands and then hundreds of thousands and then millions of people using a network. But I'm sure we will be able to address all of those. [01:09:36] And there are so many brilliant, talented people working on on the protocol level over at Logstream, over at Lightning Labs, over at Async. So I think we shouldn't be worried about it. But as a user as a Bitcoiner, I would just encourage you not to be worried about it and just try it out with a small amount of money if you're averse to risk, as you should be in this case, and just experiment with it, have fun. [01:10:07] It's it's very satisfying to be able to send one Satoshi instantly to anyone and it's very very private as well because the person receiving the satoshi doesn't know where it came from it has no way of knowing actually that's built into the protocol so yeah give it a try yeah and we should all remember that that the protocol is still in beta technically right now so yeah absolutely and there there are limits in place in the actual protocol to prevent people from putting in a lot of money unfortunately that hasn't quite worked out the way they wanted with people like LNB [01:10:46] Putting all maybe a million dollars worth of bitcoin into the network yeah but yeah I think people will be reckless like that and that's fine as long as they accept the risk they're taking and I as long as you follow the latest updates and you keep your node updated and you will be mostly fine. [01:11:09] It's not like people are losing money every day. It was just that one TV was promptly caught in time and this the warning for you to update your node has been out for quite a maybe a couple weeks it's obviously not a good thing but you it's not is no reason for you to be scared of using the lightning network I think it's an example of a growing pain like you mentioned it's a new protocol and yeah absolutely this stuff I mean it's good it's good that this stuff happens and you want this stuff to happen earlier than later. [01:11:40] Yeah absolutely and you still now you could see that there are a lot of products building on top of LND, and there were a lot of people that had to, you know, overnight implement the L and D update or just see lightning update because the more companies that are using these nodes, the more the more you know, surface area of exposure you have for these kinds of things to happen. [01:12:07] So yeah, it's much better that it happens early than rather than later for sure. Yeah. So you're going to Riga this weekend for the Honey Badger conference the that Hodl Hoddle puts on every year, and it's always it's you know, from the past been a fantastic, one of the you know best Bitcoin conferences in the world. [01:12:31] What are you gonna be talking about there? So yeah, I'll be I'll I'll be flying into Riga tomorrow. It will be my first time in that conference in particular. I've heard great, great things about it, so I'm very, very excited. And I'm going to be on a panel about payment processing with Nicola Doryer from the BTC Pay Server team, the guy that actually started BTC Pay Server. [01:12:55] And we're we're just going to be talking about payment processing in Bitcoin, and I think I'm not exactly sure what we be what we'll be talking about, but I'm sure things like KYC will come up and just payment processing in general, intermediaries, middlemen, things that really differentiate the open source BTC pay server approach and the more enterprise business approach of open node. [01:13:22] And I think it'll be very, very interesting, and it will be a very good discussion to have. Yeah, absolutely. We'll have a good time there, man. It there are a lot a lot of great Bitcoiners there. I know I had a great time at the Bitcoin 2019 conference in San Francisco earlier this year. And it's it's just so much fun getting to meet all these people that you've been working with remotely over the web and hang out with them and just it's it's a cool feeling. [01:13:49] It feels it'll I think one thing I also noticed when I was at the San Francisco conference is it I think it kind of reinforces the feeling of like that we're still really early, you know, in this thing. As we were talking about, you know, it's only been 10 years. Things are definitely ramping up in terms of like the speed of progress and everything, but it's also still pretty early at the same time. [01:14:12] So it's an interesting time to be around and I think you might get that feeling, you're like, because everyone in it'll feel like everyone in Bitcoin is there. Yeah, absolutely. I was actually in the Bitcoin 2019 conference, so it was you there. Yeah. So yeah, it it was it was so good to see all these Bitcoiners that I was talking with all for the past year, finally see them in person and get to meet them and just and just talk Bitcoin, you know, and also Bitcoin 2019 was a very good conference, I feel like, because it gave you the chance to actually experience [01:14:50] All of these Bitcoin experience, like the pinball machines that you could play with lightning and all those fun things. It was really really it was very, very well put together. So yeah, congrats to the Bitcoin magazine team. It was a great, great conference. [01:15:09] I got to meet your CEO, Afnan and hung out with him for a little bit, but I didn't know that you were there too, otherwise I definitely would have tried to find you. Yeah, I think I think our whole team was there, but Okay. Yeah, maybe maybe next year for sure. Yeah if you're around. Yeah, I will be there. I already got my ticket about the day after. [01:15:27] Nice. Yeah. Hopefully I'll I'll be there too. Right on. Yeah, I'm very, very excited for that. They they just keep putting out great, great content on their website now that they're again another company that switched to being Bitcoin only, so it's great to see they also coming up with one of the best conferences in the space. [01:15:47] And I'm very excited for this Riga conference because I've heard that Balticani Badger is like one of the best, if not the best, conference in the space. So I'm very, very excited for that. Yeah, I'm gonna try to make it there next year. I'm gonna try to do Bitcoin 2020, BitBlock Boom, and then the Honey Badger conference, Baltic Honey Badger. [01:16:07] So I think that that's kind of the top three for me, a couple here in the US that are easier easier for me to get to. I've missed BitBlock Bloom this year, but I've heard that it was also great, so kind of missed out on that one. But I guess it can always be traveling, actually got to get some work done. For real, yeah, exactly. So yeah. [01:16:26] There are too many conferences, too little time. I know, I know. There's too little time. There's so much going on and so much you want to do. And like, you know, I think a lot of us are in the same position. I mean you're you know, you're working at open node now, which is great, so you're in Bitcoin full-time, but there are a lot of Bitcoiners out there that are still working, you know, full-time fiat world jobs and trying to get hired by Bitcoin. [01:16:48] So you know, more and more people as this is one of the great things about Bitcoin is that it's sort of as it monetizes, you know, it literally hires educators, developers, service providers to work for it and help it grow. And I just think it's really cool. So there's gonna be you know new waves of people getting hired by Bitcoin every bull run that we go on. [01:17:10] I hope so. And I hope those conferences, those companies have budgets for conferences so we can all get together a couple of times per year, get to know each other, they'll be very excited for that. Yeah, man. Well, enjoy the conference. Hope the great work at OpenNode. It was really fun to get to talk to you for a while here, and I'll see you on Bitcoin Twitter. Thank you for having me. [01:17:28] It was great talking. All right, it was really fun to chat with Rui today. He's such a cool guy, and it's impressive what he's been able to contribute to Bitcoin in such a short amount of time. I'm sure that you guys have got thoughts, questions that arose from our discussion today. [01:17:50] Yeah, please do follow up with us on Bitcoin Twitter. Rui is at 8Bit Gomez. That's the number 8 B I T G O M E S. And I am at Citizen Bitcoin. Just in general, it's super helpful for you to share the show with followers on Twitter. Tag Rui and myself. Let us know why you found today's episode valuable. [01:18:10] We'd love to hear it. I've got a couple great Bitcoiners lined up for the next couple of weeks. So be sure to hit that subscribe button in your podcast app right now if you haven't yet, you're not gonna want to miss those. Alright, that's it for this one. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world, [01:18:44] And I'm gonna be a little bit of a good idea.