Nicolas Dorier: Ethics of Money, BTCPay Server, Neutrino, Future of Bitcoin Citizen Bitcoin · 2019-06-07 [00:00:20] Hello and welcome back to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin, and we're sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. What's up out there, Bitcoiners? Glad to have you with me today. It's a beautiful Friday afternoon. [00:00:39] Looking forward to a beautiful weekend. Hope you all have lovely weekends as well. I've got a great one for you to listen to this weekend to fill up some of your weekend with some Bitcoin education. We can all learn from the founder of BTC Pay Server and all around badass Bitcoiner, Nicolas Dorier. [00:00:59] He joined me for this episode. Before we dive in, let's check in on the iTunes reviews market. We got three more five-star ratings this past week and one new review, thanks to iTunes user GoJankees for the very kind review, much appreciated. [00:01:17] And as I predicted, we broke through that resistance at 30. It's a confirmed bull market for Citizen Bitcoin ratings and reviews. Time for you to FOMO in if you haven't yet. These early ratings and reviews are super important to help me bootstrap this thing, and they are very much appreciated. Alright, let's dive into the episode. [00:01:46] Nicolas Dorier is co-founder and VP of Digital Currencies at Metaco, a company providing digital asset management and custody solutions for banks. [00:01:57] And he's the founder of the open source project BTC Pay Server, a self-hosted Bitcoin payment processor that is making BitPay and other custodial Bitcoin payment processors obsolete. In this discussion with Nicola, we talk about the ethics of money in Bitcoin. We get an update on his thoughts about neutrino and SPV wallets in general. [00:02:17] We get into BTC PayServer, of course, and what we can look forward to for it. We get into the state and future of Lightning and Bitcoin in general. And Nicola answers several questions sent from listeners via Twitter. It was a ton of fun to get some to spend some time chatting Bitcoin with Nicola, and I hope you enjoy it as well. [00:02:37] Here we go. How's it going today? Hi, thanks. Good. [00:02:55] Yeah. Yeah, it's good to have you here on the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. A big fan of your work. You are achieved Bitcoin legendary I would say Bitcoin legend status a couple of years a couple of years ago. When you said declared on Twitter that you're going to obsolete BitPay, which is which is just absolutely epic, and we're definitely going to get into that whole story. [00:03:22] But I wanted to start this conversation out, you know, because obviously you're well known for your development work and for for the for BTC PayServer. You're the maintainer of NBITCoin, which is a.NET Bitcoin library. But I'd love to learn about your journey understanding the monetary aspects of Bitcoin, because I haven't heard you talk much about that. [00:03:42] I know you've written about it earlier this year in March. You published a post on Medium about your thoughts on the ethics of money. And I thought it would be fun just to start off with that. Can you talk to us about those ideas and the journey that led you to them? Well so the first time I saw about Bitcoin, I thought it was just a scam, like a kind of startup money. [00:04:08] Then after MTG's crash, I saw that this was still not dead, and that even people that got got scanned by MTGOx still believe in Bitcoin. So I got quite interested in why. So that's when I started learning about Bitcoin on the on the technical aspects. [00:04:28] And when I did learn about it, like at the same time, I was just asking my myself the question like why Bitcoin has be credited at all. Why do we need censorship resistant money? So then after I draw you to what is a good money, what is a bad money, and what's a Satoshi solution for for making good money that he that he found out, and yeah I did I discover, you know, from from the first day I discovered Bitcoin until now I'm always learning new stuff about it. [00:05:06] I read lots of different books about economics books, so like from Mitton Friedman, like as well from Muriel's bar, and like all the all the classic libertarian books, just to understand the term libertarian was basically completely I didn't know at all about it before I learned about Bitcoin. [00:05:35] So it took me a while to reach the point where I kind of understand things, and yeah, I won't once you understand it, you become pretty bullish about Bitcoin basically. Yeah, so had you had you given much thought to money before you got into Bitcoin. No, never. Never. [00:05:53] I didn't even know there was a problem to be fixed. Yeah, I'm the same way. And I mean I mean as some of you, I guess I experienced like problems with banks and money, but you know, you kind of have this attitude where you think it's just the way the world is, and like you don't think there is necessary a solution for it. [00:06:15] So it was my my point before I understood Bitcoin basically. Yeah, I got problems with banks, but okay, I thought it was just how the world is and how it was always like this. So yeah. Yeah, so I call this being a default Keynesian. [00:06:35] Yeah. And it's just the kind of the way it's the way that most of us grow up because we've we've been in this fiat world for quite a few generations now that we live that we're currently in, and yeah, it's just kind of the way the way things are and the way things work, and there's very little time and effort given to teaching or talking about the alternative ideas that are explored in Austrian economics. [00:07:03] And so there's a lot I find that a lot of Bitcoiners I think, well, it seems like most Bitcoiners were default Keynesians before they found Bitcoin and that Bitcoin has been teaching them about money. I really like your term default Keynesian because this concept of default can apply so many points where people just believe about something is true just because it's the way it has always been. [00:07:27] So they are default something. Default socialist default capitalist, default default Keynesian. Yeah, it's exactly the point, yes. Yeah, and it's it's amazing that this is why we talk about the rabbit hole and red pilling or orange pilling as it's come to be known in Bitcoin. [00:07:46] These ideas, because Bitcoin just wakes you up to a lot of different ideas, and it's it's quite an experience for anybody who has the curious mind to kind of follow it around. So yeah, so I guess I would like to let just for the listeners, maybe let's just summarize briefly the what you what you've learned about money from Bitcoin. [00:08:14] Just yeah, just maybe just give us a couple of minutes on like what you've learned and how you understand the ethics of money now from your Bitcoin-inspired learning of Austrian economics. So basically, I was pretty inspired by by Rosbar about it, where I don't remember the title of the book. [00:08:38] I'm not good with names. But basically where it defends that ethics can be kind of objective and not necessarily subjective. So I was trying to apply this on the concept of money, what is ethical or what is inethical as a behavior on Bitcoin, and can we reach a kind of in a way that is where there is no subjective bias to you know strongly say okay this decision is ethical [00:09:16] Or not vis-à-vis of bitcoins, and basically the way I think about it is like Bitcoin is money, and which means that everything all things being equal, if you increase one characteristic that makes Bitcoin money, then it's a good thing. [00:09:41] If it's impact one of the characteristics of money of Bitcoin, then it is a bad thing. So what so for first of it, like what is a characteristic of money? So the way I define it is like a characteristic basically is like if you didn't have such a characteristic at all, then money could not at all exist. [00:10:08] So let's take for example, I will say, for example, one of the characteristics is defensibility, that you can defend your money against attack. So it's very easy to prove that it's a characteristic of money, defensibility, even if nobody like tell it like this, because if you could not defend your money, then there will be no money at all, you know, the whole point. [00:10:34] So I made a blog post like recently where I talk more deeper deeper about this, but yeah, the whole idea is like to think about like what is a curve when when there is a new idea of Bitcoin, like to think what characteristic that of money that it improves in the protocol, and be careful to not impact negatively another characteristic, because there is a lot during during the blockchain debate, there has been lots of debate. [00:11:05] For example, should we increase the block size? So [00:11:12] The bad side of increasing the block size, so we with SegWit, we increase the block size, and actually I thought it was an unethical unethical decision. I did at the time of SegWit, I didn't thought about it, but looking back, I think it was quite unethical because by raising the block size, basically you make Bitcoin a little bit less defensible, you know. [00:11:36] Like if you had like three terabytes block size, then Bitcoin, of course, you could not defend yourself against the miners that do whatever rule. So like by by increasing a little bit the size of Bitcoin, then you impact this necessary property of money, this characteristic of money. Right. [00:11:54] So by definition, I would say it's unethical. Of course, it's increase other characteristics of the money. I don't remember how I called it in my article. Like people say, okay, yeah, you've got you've got you've got durability, fungibility, portability, yes, yeah. [00:12:14] So divisibility I was saying like increasing the block size, increase portability because it's become easier to move the money, you know. It takes it takes less fees, and it's true, but when you take one decision that increase one characteristic of money and decrease another, then there is no proper conversation that can be done because like no there is no way to say okay, this characteristic is better than this one. [00:12:40] No, there is no proper way of defining it. So it necessarily gives like you know conflict and people arguing against each other. So I think the best behavior in this case is just to say like your idea is impacting one of the characteristics, it's enough to reject it. So yeah, that's that's what I was thinking about the ethic of money. [00:13:03] And every time there is a new improvement to Bitcoin, like we always need to make sure that it's a net win. Like there is one fundamental characteristic that is improved, then like no other is impacted. Because if another any other is impacted, then another person can make the case that one characteristic is better than another, and you cannot settle this decision basically. [00:13:25] Yeah, that makes sense, and it really gets to the idea of Bitcoin being very conservative in its in the way that it changes and evolves, and it seems to be coming becoming more and more conservative over time, which is you know what I think probably one of the an ethic of Bitcoin, right? [00:13:44] And it corresponds with what you're saying. We any change should have a positive impact on one of these qualities of money and no negative impact on them. Yep. So for example, some other people like Lucas Jr. Say, okay, we should decrease the block size, but I think given my point, it's like unethical as well. [00:14:04] Because if you decrease the block size, imagine that the block size was where one byte, the portability of money will be zero, which means that Bitcoin will not be a money. So by decreasing the block size, you know, you impact this characteristic. So it's as well, you know, negative. [00:14:23] So yeah, like you said, Bitcoin has been very conservative on change. I think that it's conservative because more and more people are using it. But for example, some people say that Bitcoin, the problem with Bitcoin is that Bitcoin is still changed by developers, you know, like developers can make protocol changes, and it will be better to have a fixed money where nobody can make can make any changes. [00:14:51] This is true, but you know, somebody can which which can change the rule, the rule of Bitcoin does not make it does not make the change necessarily unethical, you know, it's a case by case. So, like for example, in the Schnorr Sig improvements or like tap roots or this kind of new improvement of Bitcoin protocol that is coming, like there is no you know negative impact on any other characteristic of money, just a netwin. [00:15:21] And I think some people will oppose the IGI just by the fact that Bitcoin should you know should be stable and should not change. But Bitcoin since they won has always changed, so like it's always something new. But every change needs to be you know evaluated properly, basically. [00:15:40] It's it's a case by case, you know, it's case by case, and everybody needs to do the work, not only the developers. Right. And maybe this is a good time to get into this question, which I was gonna get into later, but I think this is a good segue for it. [00:15:59] One of my listeners on Twitter asked me to follow up with you about your thoughts on Neutrino, full-time Bitcoin on Twitter. And I know you did an episode of Block Digest with Shinobi and Pierre, where you guys hashed out your ideas on neutrino. [00:16:20] And in that episode, you seem to kind of come around to supporting Pierre's sort of limited use case for neutrino, which is just to speed up onboarding to the Lightning Network when using his node launcher. But you still seem to gener generally think that SPV wallets for full-time use are bad for self-sovereignty, and even worse than like custodial wallets in that sense. [00:16:41] Is that still what you feel? And can you give us an update on where you're at with neutrino? Yes. So I talked a little bit about neutrino because I will talk about some case I think that makes sense, but you're totally right that my my my main complain with neutrino, actually it's not really neutrino. [00:17:03] It's the fact that wallets that will depend on neutrino most of the time they will follow proof of work. And when you are user, you know, that follow proof of work, then you gain you give just a little bit more of power to miners, you know, just a little bit more level range. [00:17:24] And I think that it's pretty bad things, because we saw that miners don't ever have the best interest of the of the users. And I mean, if if a group of people like, you know, if they can change the rule without at any whims, then then you are back to what the Fed is doing, except that you have some anonymous people that make monetary decisions. [00:17:52] So it's way worse than the USD in this impact. So my my main complaint about neutrino is that people using it and following the most proof of work, they are basically making Bitcoin a little bit just a little bit more weaker, you know. And the more people do this, the weaker Bitcoin gets to attacks by miners. [00:18:13] And some people make the point that as an individual, it's less risky to follow proof of work than to follow some random node. And I perfectly agree with this. Indeed, as an individual, it's way less risky to just follow proof of work. That's perfectly true. [00:18:34] But in the case where you follow an individual person, you know, an a specific chain, at least you don't endanger you know Bitcoin as a whole. So like the you know, this is this conflict because between what is good for the individual and what is good for Bitcoin, and in this case, the two contradict each others, and I think it's not a good thing. [00:18:58] So that's interest that's interesting because Bitcoin, you know, we generally applaud Bitcoin for being driven by you know self-interest, the incentives of self-interest, and maybe this is an a spot where that doesn't necessarily happen with Bitcoin in your in your opinion. [00:19:23] That sorry sorry, Sarian? Yeah, well, we gener like we as Bitcoiners we generally kind of applaud Bitcoin for being driven by self-interest, human self-interest, right? Like those in s the w your yep the incentives are aligned so that you do what is best for you and therefore it's best for Bitcoin. [00:19:42] Yeah. And so this is kind this is one time where I th like one maybe the only time that I can think of that I've heard that I the idea expressed that maybe this is there's a sticking point between the two because the self in your self-interested incentive is to just go ahead and use SP like use neutrino or Bloom filters as opposed to connecting to someone else's like a custodian's full node and operating on a custodial wallet, right? [00:20:11] But you're saying that this is like operating with the with Bloom filters is is not necessarily good for Bitcoin as a whole in terms of like the long long term self-sovereignty. I at one point I made the point where it's better for a user to rely on a custodial than running neutrino. [00:20:31] Because my point is always the same by using a custodial, at least the custodial is running a full node. So like okay, by running a custodial, yeah, you endanger yourself, but you don't endanger me, you know. So if you use SPV following proof of work, then if everybody does that in ten years. [00:20:51] So also in ten years, you know, like the this attack of by miners have have been rejected because like Bitcoin community is still very, you know, ideological. But as Bitcoin grow, it won't be like this forever. And like if in 10 years there is a miners that try again, you know, like most of people, you know, will be default Bitcoiner and not understand why you know Bitcoin succeed and why it's like this. [00:21:21] And if the miners decide something, they will say, okay, yes, just follow. And because just it will be less ideological. But there is still I mean, all is not lost because I think that's neutrino is actually not as user-friendly as if you just trust you know somebody else to give you your your wallets. [00:21:47] Of course, if you use, for example, Electrum, you know, you leak your wall wallets and it's two chain analysis, which is not good either. But you know, at least you don't follow the miners. And electron, for example, is way more easy to use than SPV because SPV you always have this you know kind of synchronization time that is paying in the ass and you know on mobile, especially. [00:22:16] So I'm kind of happy with this in the sense, you know, that it's still harder to trust the miners than to trust to trust a centralized block explorer. But you the only reason why I'm not against neutrino completely is there is some people that are using it right, and the only example that comes to my mind right now is is a wasabi wallet. [00:22:41] So when you use WhatsApp wallets, the person who decides what is the right chain is Wasabi, it's a coordinator, however, like Wazabi never learn new addresses, and I think it's the best of the both worlds, and it's the reason why I'm not completely against neutrino either I think there is some good case like this that can be done. [00:23:06] Yeah so yeah I think wasab is doing nice and I think there is also another good point that can be made is the case where you have a kind of community node like for example one person in your family has a node and like your family connect to it or like imagine that you trust somebody in the community and you decide to use their node basically it's what we are doing when you are using wasabi wallet you know we trust that no para I won't do something stupid like you know fork into Bitcoin Cash or something like this. [00:23:38] Right. So I think it's this kind of delegated trust is is also good as long as people don't follow miners. There is but there is one good point I saw that I think it was Johnson Law that pointed to me. When I said that better to use custodial wallet than SQV wallets he he got a very fair point where he said today miners are more centralized than exchanges there is lots of exchanges around the world but you know very f fewer miners he said in the future when [00:24:16] Regulation will be harder and harder and the you know cost of making an exchange become higher we might have the centralization of exchange app happening around the world and like miners on the other hand might become more decentralized. So it's a it's it's also a good point that's that that that that he has done yeah. [00:24:37] Yeah. Yeah, and it's so there's this interesting tension between self-sovereignty of owning your own keys and holding your own keys, and the self-sovereignty, sort of long-term self-sovereignty of the network in terms of being able the network being able to resist basically take over by the miners. [00:24:58] Yes, yeah, the two are kind of yeah, kinda in opposition in a sense. Yeah, it's interesting. Well, we will continue to obviously follow it and talk about it, and we'll see how it all plays out. There is also this concept what I call like you know systemic risk and localized risk. [00:25:21] So [00:25:24] Another way of seeing this debate, this my point is like in a sense when you are trusting miners, you are building a small systemic risk, you know, like it builds up with time, you know. You don't see it, it just builds up, you just don't see it. And one day when it will hit, like it will do massive damage across the whole ecosystem. [00:25:48] While if you trust, imagine imagine for example that people some people trust a block explorer, and this block explorer is trying to defraud people into you know doing fake confirmations. [00:26:07] In this case, like there there is a localized you know damage. So such damage cannot like you know bring down the world ecosystem because there is so many of you know different people that we like block explorers, and even the damage will be limited. Like even a block explorer, the only thing a block explorer can do is like to give you false confirmations. [00:26:31] And to you cannot really make profit out of it. [00:26:34] It's like kind of very targeted type of attack. [00:26:37] So it's it's not that bad either. In all case, I think people should just validate all the rules. Yeah, yeah. The best case is run your run a full node, connect to your full node from your phone and be a sovereign citizen of Bitcoin. Yes, yeah. That that's my expectation, and that that's also why a bit I did BTC pay in a sense, because if you want to use BTCP, there is no way to use Btcpay with with a block explorer. [00:27:06] You need to run a node, and I think I hope to incentivize like people to you know run full node just because they cannot do something else. Yes, yeah. Alright, well let's let's talk about BTC Pay server then. I'll set it up a little bit. On August 17th, 2017, BitPay posted a blog, a blog post and posted it to Twitter. [00:27:31] And it was titled What Bitcore Users Need to Know to Be Ready for SegWit Activation. And Nicola replied to this with this is lies, my trust in you is broken, I will make you obsolete. Which which is is just amazing. [00:27:49] I love I love the just the open, very clear declaration. And then the fact that you know in a very cypherpunk fashion wrote the code to make that happen. And that code is is BTC pay server. So let's start with what were BitPay lying about in this blog post. [00:28:12] So they they were they were kind of saying hiding the problem to the merchants. Basically they were saying that B2X at the time this fork of Bitcoin is just an update of Bitcoin and that's the way things are. And [00:28:30] Yeah I think I was very fan of BitPay actually for a long time. I was using Copay as my main wallet. I really like BitPay service I advise to lots of customers to use it. So like when I saw the that they tried to do you know to lie to the merchants to say okay Bitcoin will become like this it's just an upgrade and you have to do nothing or like you have to update but don't worry. [00:28:58] I feel it was crossing the border of ethical lines and I understood there was also a very big problem in Bitcoin in the way that you know Bitcoin core is nice but people rarely build application on top of Bitcoin core because Bitcoin core is very hard to use there the API for using Bitcoin core is kind of shit and there is a lot of drawback around it there's a lot of legacy stuff going on. [00:29:29] So like there was not really very good you know infrastructure layer you know between Bitcoin core and people building services and the result of it is that people you know just depend on third on a third party like BitPay that did the hard work. [00:29:47] So my my idea was like if I do BTC pay will provide this kind of infrastructure layer on which you know other business can build upon without relying on third party services basically right right so were you using BitPay at the time for your work you work are you still working with with Metaco yes I'm still working with Metacoya yeah okay but yeah I was I was also using BitPay for some of our internal projects yeah right okay so yeah you were pretty like intimately familiar so you're using it personally recommending it to like other Bitcoiners and friends and then [00:30:25] Also using it professionally yes so also the fact the fact that also I was using it professionally was a very deep impact in the design of BTCP because so BitPay did a lot of open source work where the for example the plugins they did and like even the people I advised to were using this kind of plugins and code that has already been done by BitPay and so when I did BTCP basically I cannot like recode everything of my customers you know it's it would have taken way too much time but instead [00:31:04] I can just replicate the API of BitPay and then just fork their plugin and it would just work. So that's what I did basically. Oh nice so you just took the BitPay API documentation and we're like all right here's all of the endpoints I need to make and yes and yeah and then it makes it easy for any BitPay customer to adopt thus speeding up the obsoleting of BitPay. [00:31:30] Yeah, and like you know, it's it was also good because you don't have to make as much documentation. You can just tell that tell people to take the documentation of BitPay. So you know when you are a one guy development team, you know, you need to you need to be very careful to you know not spread too thin and you know take as much of things that have already been developed. [00:31:56] Right. So you built the first version of BTC Pay server by yourself then? Yes, yeah, yeah. Okay, awesome. I they I had some early air from from a guy though that helped me to make the first checkout page of BTC Pay. [00:32:17] I long time I didn't see, so I completely forgot his his name though. But except this yeah for a long time I was alone yeah. Yeah, but it's gained some steam, so since since you launched it, you gather you've seen adoption from both merchants and then developers came on board to help support you and the open source project. [00:32:43] Who are some of the more like well-known merchants that are using BTC pay server right now and maybe some of the developers that have been really dedicating time to the project? So right now the main developers are Cooks K-U-K-K-S in the on Twitter is Mr. [00:33:02] Cooks and R Q MR Cooks. So yeah, he's a very big contributor like in terms of code, he's like doing lots lots of lots of hits and he has lots of projects that right now we didn't document it too much that are coming that are very awesome. [00:33:22] I think I we gotta we gotta hear more, we gotta hear more about these. Well, like one of these projects, for example, right now is called BTC transmuter. It's kind of a plug-in service to BTCP where you can automate your money. So you can say, for example, every time that my wallet receives at least 0.5 Bitcoin, then forward it to an exchange and place place or sell order, for example. [00:33:47] And you can do this. Nice. And it did it, but like right now it's kind of very beta, so like we don't spread it too much. But it did this kind of stuff. He's doing also a way to open the you know all the function. So right now in BTCP we only expose the invoice API to create invoice. [00:34:07] But he's working on a project to open up BTCP where you will be able basically to operate BTCP just via an API instead of you know using a browser. So it's it will it will be very cool because it means that people can build SPA application or lots of different stuff on top of BTCP without you know impacting our source code. [00:34:31] Could that plugin also like automate forwarding to like a Wasabi wallet address for the case? Yeah, so so that yeah we will take time so right now it's already possible actually because WhatsApp wallet expose zip up of the wallets. So actually you can say, okay, when you resave when you receive 0.5 bitcoin on this hot wallet, then forward it to Wasabi. [00:34:56] Or actually, even even without the BTC transmuter, you can just copy paste the zip up of WhatsApp wallets inside BTCP, and every time a customer pay you it goes directly to the WhatsApp. You can do this as well. Nice. That's great. So yeah, cooks is very very very big contributor. [00:35:15] There is also Rockstar Dev. Rockstar Dev is doing a ton of stuff on the UI and UX port. Like if if the checkout page works so well, is thanks to him. Like we I cannot he's one he's one of the first contributors that joined me, basically. [00:35:36] And yeah, basically, I'm very bad in HTML, CSS, JavaScript, and basically he worked a lot on all of this. So it's and there is and a very important guy as well is Pavelnex, also known as Bitcoin Shirt. [00:35:55] Yeah, yeah. So Bitcoin shirt has been very doing an house, he's not a developer, but he did an awesome job as a I would say marketing community manager guy. So like you know, he he kind of managed to like make lots of different guides to help the community, you know, to guide them to do to do things, and like for example, the Luna Node installed that everybody right now is using. [00:36:25] Basically, it's him with one guy of Luna Node that was piloting it. So like it's thanks to him that the this community can grow and develop a lot. There is lots of other contributors like Britt Kelly that is working that puts the trans effects for translation on on on place and doing some some work some works on around testing. [00:36:49] Yes, so so many people right now, and like it's it's very enjoyable to see. It is, it's really wonderful. It's people, I mean, people are coming on because they recognize that it's an important project for Bitcoin. I forgot Jeff as well. Yeah. [00:37:08] Oh what about what about merchants? So who are some some people who are using BTCP? So the biggest one I think is I think it's CoinCord Mike. So like it's kind of a service a bit like Bitrefill only on Canada. [00:37:26] So Mike has been I think he has been the first big merchant to come to BtCP. And I was so happy because Mike basically is like kind of a guinea pig of BtCP where if there is a bug you can be sure that he will be the guy to step into it. [00:37:47] And because yeah he he has all those with he his setup is so special that he has all this weird weird setup and the beginning of BTC pay basically it was me him and Rockstar Dev on the on the on the Slack you know three people on the Slack talking to each other like oh there is this bug you need to fix and I fix it and I make a new release and no iterating very fast like this. [00:38:13] It's it has been the first merchant and I think it's maybe the biggest one I guess. So yeah it's there there has been as well at the time there was how it's called along mining wait I Bitcoin shot actually has a page where store using BTCP. [00:38:36] Once again, I check I check on I think on Bitcoin on Bitcoin shot website there is actually a list of big guys ah cheaper. Cheaper, like they sell you know plain tickets, they are using it. I think maybe it's the maybe maybe they're the biggest one actually. [00:38:55] I'm thinking there's this page I will I will give you later, but like you search BTCP stores on Google, like the first result to refined a page of Bitcoin shirt that listed lots of different you know web merchants that are adopting it. [00:39:14] Frankly speaking, I cannot keep track of it anymore. Like the only one I can keep track is basically the one that complained directly on the chat on btcp.org and that you know give us but but bug report. Yeah, those early adopters are super important for getting you know a new project bootstrapped. [00:39:36] So it's a shout out to all those guys. The early adopter basically it's they are they are really the most important because they really care about things. You know, if it doesn't work, they really care. And in general, they understand that you know it's an open source project. [00:39:57] So they are less harsh as if for example it was already mainstream people. So yeah, they mike, for example, definitely like had a huge impact on BTCP and like the spread of BTCP. Yeah, it's it's like you know this kind of we're all in this together spirit of open source software, and the early adopters are certainly part of that equation to make it all work. [00:40:23] So it's good stuff. Yep. A couple other Twitter listeners, listeners on Twitter asked me to ask you about some live coding videos, or or just some not necessarily live, but either live or recorded videos about coding with P coding BTC pay server itself and coding with apps with BT BTC pay server, explaining about how you go about fixing issues and implementing features. [00:40:53] Matt Pays asked if you guys would ever go on Twitch and do a live stream. And Eskey asked about more BTC paid dev videos because he learned so much about the first one. So do you have anything, any thoughts on on that? Yeah, actually I think it's a good idea. I always wanted to do it. Just like I missed time. [00:41:12] And like it just actually it's not really time, it just I need to take my mic and say correctly and like take the time of starting Twitch. But I think it's a good idea. People were asking or doing it at the same time as Rockstar Dev. I really like Rockstar Dev, but the thing is that like when I develop, basically it's a conversation between me and me. [00:41:35] So it's so many things that come to my head, and I cannot communicate with somebody else at the same time, basically. I'm kind of asocial during my development time. Yeah, yeah, fair. So I can do it, but I think it will be more alone if I do it. [00:41:55] Right on. And Steve Barber wanted me to ask you whose business model you plan to disrupt next. Ah so there is one service that I'm I'm really tempted to, but I'm still wondering. It's so recently I you had the new had the news about local bitcoin that stopped accepting cash, like doing cash trades. [00:42:23] Basically I used local bitcoin a lot, and it was only for cash trade, so basically the only reason why I'm using local bitcoin like just disappeared. And I was trying to find some good, you know, some good alternative. [00:42:42] So some people the some people you know said hotel loader or like or bisque, but you know all those solutions I didn't see the easy way and the most important the free way that local bitcoin was doing. [00:43:00] You know, when you're you're you're using local bitcoin website, you can search for your area and see directly the advertisement without having to sign up, and you can discuss with the you know the person putting the ads without having to pay anything. And as far as I've seen, like all the other different service like BISC or other order don't allow this as easily as it was for local Bitcoin. [00:43:26] So yeah, I the you know I'm very fan of developing stuff that I use myself, right? And like I think that's you know a service specialized in cash trading for Bitcoin, I think is very important, and now that local Bitcoin is gone, it's there is you know how do you call that that empty space. [00:43:55] Alright, I want to talk about Lightning Network with you for a little bit. What is what's your assessment of Lightning Network up to this point? And related to that, Carlos asked on Twitter if you could talk about your thoughts on micropayments and where we are now with their use. [00:44:15] I mean lightning is going well in the sense that it's in improving slowly but surely. I wished that some implementation, especially LND will take less time developing more features and more time stabilizing their code source because so I as you know BTC pay is l is used right now by thousands of merchants, and I got so many, you know, like Gocha, like crash of specifically LND, that takes so much of my time. [00:44:49] I just hope that you know the software become more stable instead of adding more features. But I'm very impressed by the way it has gone. Like so many, you know, business are are are building on top of lightning. [00:45:09] Everybody is learning at the same time, you know, it's like a new technology, so like it need you know, people try new things and see what works. So that that's pretty cool. I think that one thing that is missing is automatic automated payments, like you know, mostly payments or stuff like this. [00:45:28] And also for micro payment, I think it's very important that micropayment. I think Julie is trying to improve on this, but you know, where when you when you pay some service like five cents or something like this, you don't want to have to click on a button saying yes, I confirm and putting your pin code or like you know doing this kind of security thing. [00:45:51] What you want is like you know, to click one button say, Okay, this service, I allow this service to draw money, for example, for 10 USD max, and then as the service is playing, or as you are consuming the service, then the money you know get withdraw time by time. [00:46:09] I hope that this specific use case developed because frankly speaking, just the payment case, like what we are doing with Bitcoin is not super interesting. I think it's it's something that we need to do, but it's not the most interesting thing we can do in terms of micropayments. [00:46:31] Yeah, that makes sense. Yeah, the and the automated payments thing is something that needs to get developed. And I think people there are people working on it. And I agree completely. Yeah, go ahead. So one one guy that I saw the map so made a demo on that. I don't know if you know Mandeldock on on Twitter. [00:46:50] So yes. Yeah, it's so it's this guy that is in Tokyo, by the way, is doing lots of games around lining, you know, experimenting stuff. And he showed me like recently a small game he he made like a you know battle game where every time you take a kick, like you pay some Satoshi. [00:47:11] And the UX if he made on mobile, I think it's it was quite awesome. But it basically, the fighting game happened on the computer, but like the two phones are like used to you know pay every time you take a punch. So like when you take a punch on your phone, you see like you know the Satoshi going away. [00:47:31] And I think I think he's like the really the only one right now that experimented on this code this type of use case, and yeah, I think he should you should definitely look at what he's doing. I think he's like the one that is experimenting the stuff at the edge right now, and interesting stuff on top of lining. [00:47:54] That is awesome. Yeah, we're definitely gonna keep an eye on that. [00:48:01] How about Bitcoin in general? What new developments are you interested in seeing come to fruition and why? I mean, I guess I guess I mean the base on the base layer, yeah. On the base layer, so on the base layer, I'm very you know, I'm very hyped about snorkel 6 and tap roots. [00:48:24] So what one reason is that it will make some improvement as well as on the layer two. So I don't I don't have a I myself actually I'm not an expert in the protocol on on layer two. [00:48:44] But what one example why I'm for example excited about about Schnorr 6 is that it will give some kind of incentive for people to do coin joints to save fees, which is very very good for privacy. So I'm very excited about what can happen with this. [00:49:04] I think like we might so I think it was like Peter Will that said I don't remember the source, but he he calculated that if everybody was using a Schnorr SIG from now we might save maybe 30%, you know, of capacity, which is not that big, you know, it's not it's not a big deal. [00:49:31] But actually it's missing the point that Schnorr sig with I think we change the way that we are using Bitcoin. It's not like people will use Bitcoin like they did yesterday once you know Schnorzig happened. Because when you're using Schnorr sig, basically you have a kind of incentive to like you know, coin join with other people to consolidate your UTXO and pay less fees. [00:49:57] So I think it will change the way people are using Bitcoin, and especially big services that are taking lots of space on the blockchain. So yeah, I'm very interested in this. I was also also very interested about Taproot and GraphFoot, but I don't remember why like like when I saw the I saw the proposal as a proposal, I was very excited about it. [00:50:28] But frankly speaking, I'm not too, you know, I'm not too close to the base layer anymore. So like it's not the type of thing that I'm focusing every day these days, so it get out of my mind. But I am I am excited about what the core team is doing right now. And like I said, very importantly, what they are doing is always you know net win. [00:50:50] Like, you know, they they there is no impact on any other characteristic of money of Bitcoin. So that is very important. Yeah, and I think the main benefit, or at least the one that I understand the most for Taproot is the is privacy gained on like more complicated scripts, script transactions. [00:51:15] So that you don't have to reveal all the details, you only have to you know execute a certain branch of a particular tree. Yes, I yeah, yeah, I know I remember why I was loving it, but so long time ago I was working on on tumble bits, and actually with taproots, so in Tumble when you're doing a tumble bit transaction, actually there is some kind of information that that is leaking some information to other people that show that you did a tumble bits, you know, operation. [00:51:49] And I was very excited because this hides this kind of data as well. But well, Tumblebeat didn't work that much, so it's yeah. But I'm still happy for for you know, in the best case scenario, if both party are agreement with each other, they don't need to reveal the wall script, and I think it's pretty good things as well. [00:52:10] But I'm less excited about that than about what can be built on top of it. And I completely forgot I remember seeing very interesting use case, but like it's out of my mind right now. No problem, no problem. [00:52:29] All right. I've got a couple random questions that I got from Twitter for you. Brandon Quittem wants to know if you enjoy eating gourmet mushrooms yet. The last time he's the last time he spoke you spoke with you, you said that your wife had to remind you to eat mushrooms because they represent Bitcoin. [00:52:54] Yeah, that's true. I in general I don't like vegetable. You know, I'm kind of meat pizza and sushi guy. Yeah, and so when my wife is making mushroom and I don't want to you know I remember his archical about mushroom and how Bitcoin is mushroom, so I eat my mushroom. [00:53:14] Hey, mushrooms are good for you, man. Brandon Brandt ask Brandon all about them next time you see him and talk to him. That's an awesome article. I really love it. Me too. And then Koji Higashi asked me to ask you about your favorite anime characters. I know you're in Tokyo these days. [00:53:33] Are you into anime? Yeah, so yeah, right now I the only anime I'm I'm seeing, and I it's like every week for like five years or more. I don't know. It's one piece. So I really like One Piece. But the anime character I like the most. [00:53:54] I really like Luffy in in One Piece. I like this guy. Another one. Yeah, another one I liked was L in in Death Note. That's a very good character. I like it. Nice. [00:54:12] Yeah, I don't know anime, but Koji, that's that one's for you. Yeah, Luffy in in One Piece is kind of you know funny character that don't take himself seriously, that is a bit stupid, but is he kinda like you know the guy that wants to become the king of pirates? [00:54:31] It's very fun anime, I like it. L in Death Not is kind of Death Not is a kind of like detective kind of story, and like the one guy can basically kill everybody just by knowing their name and writing it in a you know in a note. [00:54:51] And there is this guy that is anonymous that is killed called L, and he wants to keep his anonymous, you know, his name anonymous to not be killed, and he's kind of very smart detective. So yeah, I really like this character as well. Awesome. That sounds like two great characters. I'm gonna have to check it out. All right. [00:55:10] So Nicola, what does this is the final question. Invite you to you know get a little cosmic if you feel like it. What does a Bitcoin future look like to you in 50 years? That's that's a difficult one, you know. [00:55:30] The space is is changing so much. So [00:55:37] In 50 years. So I don't think I don't think that big Bitcoin will ever replace chat currency. I think that locally speaking, like you know, like stores, like you know, retails, I think cash will always be the most you know practical way of paying stuff, except if you are really like in a you know dystopian country like Venezuela, you know, except in this situation. [00:56:08] I don't think that Bitcoin will you know disrupt this. I don't see even in 50 years, I don't see Bitcoin disrupting this. However, what I think will happen is that Bitcoin has a near monopoly on payment on internet. [00:56:28] Like what can be possible is that credit card paying by credit card on internet will just disappear. Like there is no point of using a credit card on internet anymore. And I think it will be a pretty big fit, especially that now you know the world is more and more connected and like everybody's on internet. [00:56:48] Like more and more of the GDP and like you know, it's like internet commerce. So I think that's Bitcoin will be the king, you know, and like way more spread than PayPal, way more spread than Stripe and way more spread than credit card, any credit card payment system that exists. [00:57:09] But I don't I don't believe that it can beat fiat at the retailer level. Right. So you do you don't think that like commerce, like the internet in general won't take over like just kind of street level merchants, day-to-day commerce. [00:57:30] You think that we'll still have like paper money and coin money and stuff and cash via cash that people use? Yeah, yeah, I think it's very hard because you know, Bitcoin by the fact that it's a decentralized currency, you cannot beat the user experience and the simplicity of this method of payments, you know, like for people that try you know win money. [00:57:56] Like for example, when I'm taking the subway in Tokyo, I'm using like Suika card. You cannot do something more efficient than this. And even in 50 years, I don't I don't think that Bitcoin can beat those kind of centralized solutions. [00:58:15] The only [00:58:20] Reason it can bite it, beat it, is if the country becomes dystopian and you know, like Venezuela or Argentina, then people like don't trust at all their Fed money and then start choosing Bitcoin. But you know, it's kinda I don't I don't think it's still like kind of the you know extreme case. [00:58:43] So most of countries I know don't experience impair reflection, and even if they do it, you know, they don't do it all at the same time either. So yeah, I'm not I'm not turbulent Bitcoin on this aspect. Yeah. We are we are entering into sort of unprecedented territory in terms of kind of the macroeconomic scene though. [00:59:06] Lots of printing of money, this quantitative easing experiments are starting to just I mean basically once you've done it once, you kind of create this moral hazard that you just gotta continue to print more money because you know you already did it once. So it's gonna, you know, you should do it again for the people now who need it or whatever. [00:59:28] So that that's gonna continue to happen. We're already seeing negative, you know, negative interest rates. So these policies really only only move in one direction. And yeah, maybe eventually get to hyperinflation, you know, globally. I think it will it will reach one point at one at one point it will reach a critical, you know level where people are fed up with it. [00:59:54] When people will be fed up with it, of course they will use Bitcoin, of course they will, you know take where their wealth into Bitcoin. Of course, government will try to stop them from doing this. Then they will be in perinflation, there will be misery, they will be like all the shit that you see in Venezuela. [01:00:13] Then once the you know power is down, then it will, you know, come back again. And when things get better, like people will come back to Fiat money because it's more practical. So yeah, y you know, it's like it's like some countries are are are like for example Germany is like a country that is more cash oriented of than some other country like France, for example. [01:00:44] And more and very often some of this reason is just because, you know, like for for German, the i last imperial inflation is not so far away, you know, it's like one generation away. So but like in in one generation, you know, the kids don't know at all what is hyperinflation, so like they will be more drawn to fiat money. [01:01:10] And one day they will be in perinflation that will happen again because of what you were talking about. Then they will go to Bitcoin and then it will restabilize again, and then it's a cycle, you know, they retrust it and blow up again. And I don't think it anything can break this cycle, but at least with Bitcoin, you know, you can you can escape in some way. [01:01:32] It's the it's the safety valve, it's the backup option. So yeah, yeah, like you're sure that as long as you have Bitcoin, you can go anywhere in the planet and kind of you know come back, come back, you know, bring back your wealth here. Even if if it's a bit pain in the ass, you know you can do it. [01:01:52] So it's it's kind of like you know, peace of mind that whatever can happen, you can survive. Yeah, Matt Odell calls it wealth insurance. Yes, I think that's a very good, very good way of putting it. Yeah, it does. Alright, well, thanks for your time today, Nicola. Really enjoy talking to you, getting to know you a little bit, and you know, just keep up the great work, man. [01:02:15] Thanks a lot. Alright, take care. Bye. That was great. Thanks again to Nicola for his time. I know Bitcoiners really appreciate hearing from the great devs in the space. [01:02:34] You can follow Nicola on Twitter at Nicolas Dorier, that's at N-I-C-O-L-A-S, D-O-R-I-E-R. You can follow me at citizenbitcoin. And please do let us know on Twitter if you have any questions or comments that arose for you during this episode. [01:02:52] I would love to continue the discussion with you all there. One last reminder to leave a rating review for us. The FOMO is coming. Get in early, guys. Alright, that's it for this week. Until next time. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.