WEBVTT

1
00:00:16.160 --> 00:00:36.160
Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady. And I'm Tommy. And we are here sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. Today we are going to focus on some of the financial aspects of Bitcoin.

2
00:00:36.160 --> 00:00:54.720
We've spent a good deal of time on previous podcasts talking about the technical details of Bitcoin. And on this episode we're going to take a look at Bitcoin Futures, the Bitcoin ETF, the extreme exchange traded fund that's been getting talked about a lot in the Bitcoin news.

3
00:00:54.880 --> 00:01:16.000
We'll take a look at the Lightning Network Reference Rates, something that Nik Bhatia has been working on in a couple of medium posts and out there doing the podcast interview tour. And I think that's that's what we're yeah, those three topics what we're gonna cover today, the kind of financial aspects of Bitcoin and how this all works.

4
00:01:16.000 --> 00:01:39.920
This is more Tommy's area of expertise than mine, whereas my area of expertise in Bitcoin is more on the technical side of things. So I'm gonna turn this over to Tommy to sort of to run the show today. Thanks, Brady. Okay, so what we're gonna do, we're gonna just dive into this and part of it isn't there isn't any specific structure or form, but we ought to be able to hold this together, explain it.

5
00:01:39.920 --> 00:02:13.800
So where I wanna start is we're just gonna go specifically to these ETFs, which are exchange traded funds. It's gonna be specific to Bitcoin. And so what we've got going on right now is is that there's a group of physically backed ETFs, which means in the purest form, whatever the size of the particular fund is, it will be backed Bitcoin for Bitcoin in that particular fund.

6
00:02:13.800 --> 00:02:35.320
By the actual asset itself and not a derivative. Not a derivative. Yeah. And so, and we'll get into the derivative base here in a moment. So what we have as far as we can tell, and this is from Bloomberg at Bloomberg screen, and the source is Bloomberg Intelligence and the SCC.gov.

7
00:02:35.320 --> 00:03:01.800
There's four, let's see, four, six particular physically backed funds. There's the Winkelvoss Bitcoin shares, which was put in place and actually last week was denied. And we'll just jump right into the reason why it was denied, or as we understand it, there were two particular areas on the denial.

8
00:03:03.480 --> 00:03:22.600
One of the areas was the thought that that it could be manipulated pretty easily as it was set, and then the other thought was more a protection from other you know, investors, smaller retail investors, some that might not be sophisticated, understand what was going on.

9
00:03:22.600 --> 00:03:45.920
So understanding that this is a broad brush, but it's our view as to the reason why that that was was was denied. There's five additional funds. There's Bitcoin Investment Trust that was put in place in May sorry, March of 2016, it's been withdrawn for now.

10
00:03:46.160 --> 00:04:04.320
There's a Solid X Bitcoin trust, which is from Solid X, was reformatted, so it's it's sitting there. There's an Inder Index Ether Trust from distributed capital that's been withdrawn for now.

11
00:04:04.320 --> 00:04:25.360
And then there's two that are awaiting approval. One is Bitwise Hold 10 Cryptocurrency Index Fund. Oh, yeah, I heard about this one. It's a top 10 coins, an index of the top 10 crypto coins. And this was filed July 24th, just a few a few days ago.

12
00:04:25.360 --> 00:04:45.200
And the SEDC date is unknown. Now the one that's front and center is this Van X SolidX Bitcoin Trust. It was filed June 5th of 2018, and it's awaiting approval. Allegedly, the date is August 10th as to when this is going to be decided.

13
00:04:45.200 --> 00:05:18.800
Or it could be postponed, right? Right. And so that one that's the one that's on the burner now. So in terms of handicapping, to use a to use a horse racing term, handicapping whether this is going to get get done or not at that point. From what we can tell, is there's there's one aspect of this that that's useful in terms of it possibly getting approved, and that's the fact that it's large sized in terms of making a purchase within this Bitcoin trust.

14
00:05:18.800 --> 00:05:40.440
It's roughly two 200,000 US dollars. Yeah, it's they they limit it by Bitcoin, so it's 25 bitcoins, whatever that equals US dollars. Yeah, so it's 25 bitcoins. Minimum, right? So that's your minimum purchase. Right. So that puts in a category of what you would call high net worth invest in investor or institutional.

15
00:05:40.440 --> 00:06:02.360
And what does that really mean? Well, typically what that means is it's in a different category, such these investors are considered sophisticated. So less likely to be taken advantage of. Right. And so the idea with that is okay, hey, the investors can only really you know, these are big chunks in terms of the minimum amount.

16
00:06:02.360 --> 00:06:25.880
So therefore the investor that would put money in would clearly understand or make an assessment as to whether they feel the situation could be manipulated. And then the other idea is because they're sophisticated, then likely they're not going to be taken advantage of just because of the thought in terms of their understanding of what they're you know, what they would be looking at.

17
00:06:25.880 --> 00:06:45.960
And that was one of the big reasons that the SEC denied cited for denying the Winkelvas filing. It was because they were concerned about retail investors not being sophisticated enough or there not being enough education out you know available for retail investors to really know what they're buying.

18
00:06:45.960 --> 00:07:06.440
So that might solve that problem. And isn't I think we looked at the other day when we were when we were talking about this and researching a little bit, isn't Van Eck owned by the CBOE or SIBO? Right. That's that's how I understand that's how I understand it. I mean and see what I don't know for sure, I think so, but we just want to make sure on this.

19
00:07:06.600 --> 00:07:43.360
Well, yeah, that's why you were telling me last week that you're and I don't yeah, so so that that's that's how we understand it. And so there's a tie there, actually. There's a guy named Gensler, right, that's involved with that. And he used to be with Goldman. And so you have a situation with this also where there's a there's a it's more going with the traditional traditional type of line or or or setup in terms of how the SEC can potentially get comfortable with particular fund or or their actual backers.

20
00:07:43.360 --> 00:08:01.600
Right. So that's the physically the physically backed. The other thing that's should be pointed out here also in terms of these funds. And this ties into to how how gold gold was looked at and this little segue into futures.

21
00:08:01.600 --> 00:08:20.320
Well before we go into the futures though, should we talk about the derivatives based or derivatives? That's that's what I was. That's you're going into okay, gotcha. So what I say that'll segue. So the segue is is that within these ETFs, right? The segue is also to derivatives-based ETFs. Because they're based on futures, which is a derivative of Bitcoin.

22
00:08:20.320 --> 00:08:49.280
Correct. Gotcha. So as far as we can tell, there's let's see, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight. About twenty or so. Oh twenty or so. And of these, of these twenty. What twelve have been withdrawn? Yeah, and awaiting approval. There's the one the two that are that are sitting there with an SEC date, that the closest one to now, I should say.

23
00:08:49.920 --> 00:09:27.960
I mean in terms of the in the in the future here, the next in the barrel. Granite shares Bitcoin ETF and granite shares short bitcoin etf which was filed december 15th 2017 it's a futures derivative based and they're they're targeted september 15th and 2018 both of those for SEC in terms of what's going to go on with those two so basically the situation with those just looking at it is it looks to me like you can either go long or short by buying into those right and then same thing with Direxion which has an approval date of the of the

24
00:09:28.040 --> 00:09:53.960
21st so not even a week after granite shares and they have a 2x bear 2x bull 1 and a half x bull 1.25x bull so it so I guess that means you can like like the 2x bear means you could like two times leverage your short. Yeah so you can double down right and you can either go or you can two times leverage the other way and then there's some more modified like one and a quarter and a one and a half time levered.

25
00:09:53.960 --> 00:10:32.440
So those and those are direxion which I have no clue who Direxion is and we'll look into it more but it's clearly I don't know they've done those it appears like they must have done the work or they would not have an SEC date with respect to what's going on there so what so so the situation with with these is that and then this is kind of I was tying it tying to gold so on on a future just to explain a future very simplistically is let's say that you wanted to let's

26
00:10:32.440 --> 00:10:53.680
Say it's six, let's say it's three months out. So let's say you want to go ahead and lock in what the price is on a certain date known in the future as to where where you were going to be on on the price of something on the price, unless you choose US dollar per Bitcoin, you would be able to go ahead and buy that ahead of time.

27
00:10:53.680 --> 00:11:17.600
So there'd be a price for that dependent on where Bitcoin what or Bitcoin is. So if Bitcoin's at like eight thousand dollars, you'd be able to buy you know that going forward, you could say in three months, I want to buy it at $8,000, or you want to say at three months, I want to buy it at $9,000, or it could be the other way, and there would be a price related to that.

28
00:11:17.600 --> 00:11:38.800
Well, obviously, if it was maybe not obvious to some people, but the idea is not to me. So if it's eight thousand dollars right now, and you got an option to buy it at nine thousand dollars in in three months, right, and it was still eight thousand dollars, you wouldn't exercise your option to buy Bitcoin at that price.

29
00:11:38.800 --> 00:11:58.400
Okay, sure. Now the other part of it is if somehow it was ten thousand dollars, you would go ahead and option option to go ahead and you go ahead and take that, right? Because you're gonna save a thousand dollars on the spot. Or well, you're gonna get a thousand, you're you're gonna get, you know, you're you're at nine thousand, that's what you hold at that date.

30
00:11:58.400 --> 00:12:27.840
Okay. If it's ten thousand, you go ahead and say, I'm exercising and you make a thousand dollars. I see. Okay. Okay. Now the aspect of this that's important, and I think this also ties to the physically backed index. But what's important here, and I use the example of gold, is that it used to be on gold that you could go ahead and say, All right, I want to buy some gold in the future at a certain price.

31
00:12:27.840 --> 00:12:47.640
So you could sit there and say, let's say gold it's 1200 and 1280 an ounce, let's say 1300 an ounce. I don't know exactly where it is right now, but that's roughly right. So you wanted to do the same thing. You'd say, okay, it's 1300 an ounce, and in three months I want to buy it at 1500 an ounce.

32
00:12:47.640 --> 00:13:07.720
Okay. Well, with gold, it used to be you had the you had the option at that point to either take delivery of the gold or take the take the cash. So that's what they're talking about when they say physically backed funds. So in a physically backed funds, I could take delivery of the actual Bitcoin.

33
00:13:07.880 --> 00:13:42.200
Well, this is something we're gonna have to figure out on on future shows. I think the reason why they have it physically backed is so people understand that there's no counterparty risk. In other words, it's physically backed, so it's not like they're always up upping the dollar value amount, right? So they're basically saying you're secure because we're Bitcoin for Bitcoin, so you don't ever have to worry about all of a sudden Bitcoin going up three times, and we had US dollars in there, and then all of a sudden the fund goes defunct because we didn't match it to the underlying asset.

34
00:13:42.200 --> 00:14:01.320
But are those funds actually like holding the Bitcoin on behalf of the purchasers, the investors, or are they if I if I buy Bitcoin through one of these ETFs, one of these physically backed ETFs, would I be able to hold my private keys on a hardware wallet for Bitcoin or not?

35
00:14:01.640 --> 00:14:23.520
I think the answer is no, and I think that's what the that's what the issue is, is it's physically backed, and I think the reason for this that it's physically backed is what I already explained. So that you're you're you're you're in Bitcoin, it's all Bitcoin based, and sure. And you probably should look at it from the standpoint of I bought five, you know, I bought twenty-five Bitcoin, that's what I've got.

36
00:14:23.520 --> 00:14:59.760
Right. It's the same with gold. I bought gold, I bought X ounces of gold, and then I can translate it into whatever it is, if it's Euros or US dollars or whatever. Right. And that's that's a key key issue here because what happened with gold over time is they made it to the point where if if you went ahead and bought a future, they the person that was paying out to you could either take the option of saying, Okay, you bought a hundred ounces of gold at at one thousand three hundred dollars an ounce is what your price is.

37
00:14:59.760 --> 00:15:20.000
Let's just use that as a well, let's just say it's two thousand dollars, just so we're so even number, yeah. An even number. So we say it's two thousand, so I owe I owe you I owe you a thousand ounces of gold, right? Did I say yeah, it's a thousand, right? So I said I owe you a thousand ounces of gold, or I could sit there and have the option to pay you in cash.

38
00:15:20.080 --> 00:15:43.760
200,000 bucks or whatever it is. To be two million. Two million bucks. Yeah, two million. Yeah, so it'd be two million. Yeah. So so they could either, but let's say you really wanted the gold, right? So you're like, well, wait a minute, I had the option. Well, they stopped that. So I think it's important to understand this here because it's a situation where Bitcoin really really takes off, and you're in the fund and you're thinking, you're like, oh my gosh, this is great.

39
00:15:43.760 --> 00:16:05.160
I got twenty-five Bitcoin. Yep. And let's say, let's say you want to just I want to take them. I want I want 'em. Okay. I want and I want to physically hold them myself. You want to exercise one of the fundamental benefits of Bitcoin, which is you know becoming a sovereign citizen. Right. But so instead you have a situation where they say, Well, you can just stay, you can just stay in the fund.

40
00:16:05.160 --> 00:16:24.520
We've got your 25 Bitcoin, and then you're riding along that way. Well, if you're comfortable doing that, you know, that that's fine, but it's something to be, you know, it's something to be you know pointed out here. So there still is so with derivatives backed ETF, then you'd have the counterparty risk of the institution that is offering the futures.

41
00:16:24.760 --> 00:16:46.760
You're not buying Bitcoin directly, you're you're actually two steps away from the Bitcoin, basically. If you're a physically backed ETF, then you're you're still one step away from Bitcoin. So it's basically like buying on an exchange, a big current crypto exchange right now, like on Coinbase or Bitstamp or something. Because those guys are holding the Bitcoin, they're holding the private keys, not me.

42
00:16:47.080 --> 00:17:14.200
Right, right. And that gets back to a situation where, for example, somebody we've had Brady and I have had both had people ask us, basically saying, We want we want to buy Bitcoin and we want to physically hold it ourselves. Right. Okay. And the issue is, and we're not talking about somebody buying like a couple hundred dollars, maybe somebody wants to buy 10,000 or or 25,000, let's say 20,000 worth of Bitcoin, but they're new to it, right?

43
00:17:14.200 --> 00:17:32.280
Well, you start explaining to them, well, you know, well, what about these exchange? You know, somebody will say, What about these exchange hacks? How's that really work? And you say, Well, Bitcoin is is has it hasn't been Bitcoin, it's actually the exchange. And then they say, Well, what if I want to hold it myself?

44
00:17:32.280 --> 00:17:50.640
Then you start going through the steps, right? You say, Well, okay, you have to buy it, and that you're better at going through this than I am. But why don't you just walk through what you would have to do? Well, yeah, you let's say you buy it on Bitstamp, you buy coin big or Bitcoin on Bitstamp. Let's say you buy three Bitcoins, so that would be like $24,000.

45
00:17:50.640 --> 00:18:10.080
Right. And somebody wants to buy it and hold it for ten years. So then you'd want to hold it in a in a cold in cold storage in a hardware wallet. So you'd buy a hardware wallet, like a ledger or a treasure, Trezor, and then you'd have your you create an address with your with Trezor.

46
00:18:10.080 --> 00:18:48.640
You know, you'd have to you'd have to create first of all, you'd have to create the private keys and write down your backup your backup phrase, right? So it's actually not that hard, it's a few minutes. And then you have your address associated with that private key that is safe on your device, and then you just go sign into Bitstamp and transfer the Bitcoin to that address, and then now the Bitcoin is on on a UTXO and on the blockchain block that is right that is signed by your private key that is safe in your hardware

47
00:18:48.640 --> 00:19:16.720
Wallet. So that's that's how happens. And it sounds, it does like when you talk about it to tell somebody and they're like, oh man, this is crazy, you know. Right, right. So yeah, so you just think in terms of somebody not that hard. That's actually you know, just unfamiliar with it, right? Well, you know, it's kind of like you get to the point where you start talking about the public and private key, yeah, and then talk and then the other thing is is that God forbid if they sit there and say, Well, what about the security of it?

48
00:19:16.720 --> 00:19:38.920
And you say, Well, to be extra cautious, you probably should use a VPN, you know, and then also to use two-factor authentication. Or, you know, if you want to not have KYC done to your big to your Bitcoin, then you should use a local Bitcoins, and you know, that's a whole other level of arrangement. Which we don't, you know, which which is just a situation where it's kind of like although I think local bitcoins is doing KYC now, actually.

49
00:19:39.160 --> 00:20:17.160
Yeah, which you know, know your customer, which okay, it's all fine and well, but the but but the bottom, you know, which is how you do it. But the bottom line just gets to the aspect of how do you hold it yourself so so you've got a hold of it, yeah. It's not like somebody if they if they get scared to death, like my mother-in-law did one time, and I think this was one of the situations with the market went down and bought bought a bunch of when gold was like at 550 or something, she went and bought like you know, it wasn't a boatload, but bought like 10 or 20 gold coins at the local shop, you know, and felt happy

50
00:20:17.160 --> 00:20:40.760
About it, put it in her safety deposit box, right? Well, people understand that. Like, okay, I go buy the gold coins, I have in my hand, I put them in safety deposit box, okay. I can do that, but you know, this is a different type of situation. But we just wanted to cover that on the show just to give a feel for that, because you would usually you're able to explain somebody pretty easily.

51
00:20:40.760 --> 00:20:59.640
It's just like, yeah, you go buy the bitcoin, you go, you know, you just go buy it, you put an application in, you're done, right? Well, it's not that it's not that simple. Yeah. It it is in practice more simple than it sounds, right? You know, but it's just people have to get over that hump. And you know, I actually somebody was talking to me about it the other day.

52
00:20:59.640 --> 00:21:18.640
They were they're like, Well, you know, you know a lot about Bitcoin, and you know, if you're listening to this podcast, you probably get this too. You're you're one of those Bitcoin people in in your sphere of friends and family. So, you know, you know a lot about Bitcoin. How you know, how do I buy Bitcoin? I was like, well, you know, you can you can go to an exchange, Coinbase, Bitstamp, blah, blah, blah.

53
00:21:18.880 --> 00:21:43.920
Well, I tried Coinbase and it was just it was just too confusing. I'm like, okay, you know, like it's not really that confusing. But maybe we could sit down together and do it. You know, but if somebody's if somebody is I you know, I would presume he's probably confused by you know, having to give pictures of his driver's license or something like that on that step, you know, because that's an uncommon step to create an account on a website.

54
00:21:43.920 --> 00:22:11.600
You know, but yeah, it it's it's being a web programmer, a web designer for most of my career, I know very well how UX is you have to keep it incredibly simple, incredibly simple. And you know, three or four or five strange steps to hold your own Bitcoin is a big deal, even though if you've done it yourself, you know it's it's not as hard as it sounds.

55
00:22:11.840 --> 00:22:33.280
Right. Well, but and then the you know the other part of it is just to say, okay, go on Coinbase. Yeah. And go ahead and then you but but the then the idea is is that w we're just being prudent about it because of the exchange hack piece of it, is that you don't in that particular case, you honest to God don't hold it.

56
00:22:33.280 --> 00:22:58.000
Yeah, you don't. You really don't you have a promise from from that company that they have your Bitcoin and so they may not always have your Bitcoin. So yeah, it's a similar to a situation of if people remember Lehman Brothers, you know, that was Lehman was you know a broker that held a lot of stuff for people and also, you know, and so it was a that was a mess.

57
00:22:58.000 --> 00:23:18.600
Yeah. Something that we kind of that we forgot to mention, we were talking about the Winkelvoss ETF that was denied last week. One of the commissioners, I think there's five commissioners on the SEC, right? One of the commissioners, Hester Pierce, wrote a very in-depth long dissent of the opinion. Right, I mean by the way, I need to I need to read that.

58
00:23:18.600 --> 00:23:39.080
I will read that. I haven't read it yet. But the conclusion, you can just skip down to the conclusion and we'll just we'll look at it now. But she is basically saying that the commission's denial deprives investors of a choice whether or not to buy or avoid Bitcoin, right?

59
00:23:39.080 --> 00:24:17.160
Bitcoin may succeed, it may fail, but the SEC is not well positioned to assess the likelihood of either outcome for Bitcoin or any other crypto asset. Many investors have expressed interest in gaining exposure to Bitcoin, and a subset of these investors would prefer to gain exposure without owning Bitcoin directly. And so she dissents because she thinks that the commission's decision to deny the Winkelvoss filing is having the SEC play the role of gatekeeper of innovation, which is a role very different from the her idea of what the SEC's mission is of protecting investors, fostering

60
00:24:17.160 --> 00:24:35.960
Capital formation, facilitating fair, orderly, and efficient markets. So there was a strongly worded dissension of that decision, and we shall see what happens. What is your sense of how important an ETF would be to Bitcoin? Like, do you think it's really that important?

61
00:24:35.960 --> 00:25:13.360
Do you think there are, as as Commissioner Pierce says here, you know, how big of this is this subset of investors that would prefer to get exposure without owning a direct market. My opinion is I think it's it's very important to the US market. Yeah. I think in terms of Bitcoin itself, I think you I would put it I'm not a lawyer, but I would I would put in the category of immaterial just because some of the people looking at this in the US, the way I view it, are they myopic because 90% of what's going on with Bitcoin is not in the US.

62
00:25:13.360 --> 00:25:33.280
Yeah. So it's a situation where it's critically important in the US. Some that are in the US market that are really pushing crypto, you know, cryptocurrencies and crypto assets are looking at it like, oh my gosh, you know, once the US approves this, then Bitcoin's gonna skyrocket.

63
00:25:33.520 --> 00:25:52.560
Yeah. And well that didn't definitely didn't happen with futures. And people were saying that with futures too. Well and so I you know and I think it's a situation where we're it it this is really a at the at the root a technology and there's a structure and a technology built being built here.

64
00:25:52.560 --> 00:25:59.360
And you do have the aspect that the cryptocurrency as aspect and the store of value aspect.

65
00:25:59.880 --> 00:26:14.240
But from the standpoint of what's going on specifically with these ETFs, I don't think it's, at this juncture, large enough size to impact it dramatically. I think it's very positive.

66
00:26:14.480 --> 00:26:33.720
I think it's important to look through all, you know, look through all this. But what you have is you got a situation with Bitcoin where Bitcoin is unregulated. Yep. And it's it's and it's just by the nature of how it's been set up. Well, it's unregulated by well by the government directly is what you mean, right?

67
00:26:33.720 --> 00:27:03.320
No, but it's regulated it's regulated by its code. Well, but I think algorithms and all that. Yeah, but what I'm saying, right. I mean, Bitcoin on its own, but you know, it's on its own. Right. And it has all the characteristics inherent within Bitcoin. Yep. But from the outside from the standpoint of Bitcoin, it's sitting there as a you know, and it with its nodes, its entire network, software, the all the infrastructure, it's sitting there, but with respect to any outside entity, it's not it's unregulated.

68
00:27:03.320 --> 00:27:25.400
Yeah, what you what you have here is you have a situation where you've got entities trying to slap things onto Bitcoin. Yeah, my sense is that it's not important for Bitcoin to have an ETF, but it's important for these people who are proposing or these corporate companies that are proposing ETFs to have a Bitcoin ETF.

69
00:27:25.400 --> 00:27:45.640
It's important for the companies. They're gonna make a lot of money off of running a Bitcoin ETF. Maybe it's they they might, sure. And maybe it's a good signal for or it's a signal that's interpreted as a good or positive signal to traditional investors. I think it I think it I think it absolutely is, you know, it it absolutely is a good signal.

70
00:27:45.640 --> 00:28:05.720
I'm just saying the initial, you know, this initial part of it, in terms of size-wise, relative, you know, you're talking the US market, and you know, which is yeah, as we understand it, less than you know, ten percent or less of the global market. And then you have a situation where that starts to work to play out.

71
00:28:05.720 --> 00:28:34.400
But I mean, if i if you're really a hedge fund hitter and you start looking at this stuff and you want to go into Bitcoin, you basically figure out how to how to buy the big this is my opinion okay you figure out how how to buy the Bitcoin and hold it yourself I think I agree that's why I'm not that you know I it's not important to me that Bitcoin gets an ETF it's I don't think it's important to Bitcoin that there's an ETF in the United States.

72
00:28:34.400 --> 00:29:12.400
Bitcoin will keep going and doing its thing it's separate from the traditional financial system in the US or otherwise around the world bitcoin doesn't need it there might there might be some investors that will prefer to buy Bitcoin through an ETF and you know more power to them if if they that's what they want to do and there's an ETF available but you know that's kind of my sense part of it is is that you know thinking you know like my my what my metallurgy professor told me when I went to college you know you need to you really need to think when you can't figure something out yeah you have to go back to basics think one thing just

73
00:29:12.400 --> 00:29:37.840
Start one thing and then go back to the very root of it and go step by step. And if you really look at an ETF, a physically backed ETF, and you're a hedge fund manager and you look at it, if you're looking to trade in and a vehicle to trade in and trade out fine. But if you're looking a vehicle to hold over the long term yeah it looks to me like that's not the optimal vehicle that you'd want to have it in.

74
00:29:37.840 --> 00:30:03.560
Correct. Yep. Alright cool so let's talk about let's shift topics to this idea of the lightning network reference rate right that was proposed by Nik Bhatia. He wrote about this in a couple articles on Medium, and he's been talking about it on Twitter, and like I've mentioned earlier, he's been on a couple of podcasts that I've listened to talking about this idea in a little bit more depth.

75
00:30:04.440 --> 00:30:31.160
His handle on Twitter is at time value of BTC. And the idea is that we could use the fees that nodes earn from routing payments on the Lightning Network to establish a base interest rate or reference rate for Bitcoin, right?

76
00:30:31.480 --> 00:31:01.640
So HTLCs, hash time lot contracts are basically the currency of the Lightning Network. Those kind of move around all over the place on Lightning Network back and forth, and then you can close out those HTLCs and settle them to the main chain. So his idea is that there's basically two important properties that from HTLCs that eliminate reliance on trusted third parties.

77
00:31:01.640 --> 00:31:19.880
So there first the contracts have an embedded call option on the counterparty's Bitcoin, which dissuades theft, you can just settle it to the blockchain. And the contracts have an expiration, which prevents balances to be held in limbo forever. So if somebody does nothing with their HTLC, then eventually it will expire and settle, right?

78
00:31:20.200 --> 00:31:44.840
So this basically means that Bitcoin stake to Lightning is the most unique income producing asset in all of monetary history because it's income with zero counterparty risk. So you can earn fees as a node operator on the Lightning Network through the transmission and routing of HTLCs with no counterparty risk.

79
00:31:46.480 --> 00:32:17.920
So what what are your thoughts about this? I'm very I'm very skeptical about it. Yeah. We need to read it. I'm extraordinarily skeptical about it. The main reason is because he he ties it to Lightning. And I really need to think about it more because this idea of setting a reference rate, you know, it I'm I'm wondering if the idea is is being taken from central banks and that whole idea and mindset of that.

80
00:32:17.920 --> 00:32:36.400
And it seems to me that this rate or whatever's being discussed should be based off of Bitcoin itself rather than some layer two application. So I don't see but Bitcoin on the Lightning Network is Bitcoin still. It's pegged one to one to the main chain.

81
00:32:36.400 --> 00:32:57.840
So it's it's not like it's some lesser version of Bitcoin. It's but what we're doing, but what we're doing and what we're doing in the Lightning Network, right, is is we're buying coffee, right? Or we're we're Yeah, but it's still Bitcoin being used to purchase. So let's say I got I want to do I want to borrow a hundred bitcoin.

82
00:32:57.840 --> 00:33:18.080
Uh-huh. The n the lightning network, how many bitcoin does it have on it right now? Just crossed a hundred last week. Yeah. So I mean But it's growing very quickly. But it's a hundred times, I mean, it's a hundred times. So a hundred times eight thousand. So he's talking a market of you know.

83
00:33:18.080 --> 00:33:42.120
Yeah. So my whole point is is that you know, come talk to me when this thing is like the 100 million dollars. So he definitely is saying that, like he agrees with you that this is gonna take time, and but the cool thing about it is like right now we have capital markets are based on this idea of a of a reference rate, and usually it's like a US treasury, like a five-year treasury.

84
00:33:42.360 --> 00:34:00.520
So you might be able to get like a Walmart corporate bond for like five year treasury rate plus 0.6% or something like that, right? And or there's a light specific, it's a specific market that's set. It's the Fed. You have a Fed you have a Fed reference rate, and then the banks, there's a group of banks that belong to the Fed, right?

85
00:34:00.520 --> 00:34:21.080
Right. There's a there's a there's a prime rate. Yeah, there's there's a prime rate that's set. And so it's con you know, it's central it's effectively centrally controlled, right? So you're right. So then what happens is Walmart or somebody wants to borrow, they they rank what the credit worthiness of that, you know, what the counterparty risk of Walmart is.

86
00:34:21.080 --> 00:34:43.320
Sure. And then they price it off of this. And then there's also LIBOR, London Interbank Offered Rate, or LIBOR, Libor. Which is the same type of thing. Yeah, and it's set by a small group of banks or whatever, relatively small group of banks. Right. So so the cool thing about this idea though is that we could create a reference rate that is cryptographically provable.

87
00:34:43.320 --> 00:35:05.400
So it's mat or mathematically provable. So if we could create an algorithm and a protocol that would figure out like monitor fees on nodes, right? It would be like, all right, how much did you collect today in your node or whatever? Gather that information. This is this is when this when is this gonna happen? Oh, it could be it could be years from it could be two a couple years from now or something, but it's cool to think about right now.

88
00:35:05.400 --> 00:35:31.120
You know, I mean, why don't I just why why don't I just go ahead and figure out a way to dependent on the jurisdiction you're in why don't I figure out a way to just get get into the business of lending Bitcoin to people. Well I don't think that I think this is a thought experiment about a potential future where Bitcoin is the global reserve currency.

89
00:35:31.120 --> 00:36:02.800
Okay. And we want to build a new capital market based on Bitcoin. And now this this could be a more fair way to establish a reference rate that's not centrally controlled. Right. So it would that that a way to establish a reference rate a lend a base lending rate for capital markets in Bitcoin that is true to the nature of Bitcoin the distributed nature of Bitcoin as opposed to the centralized nature of the of the current way that the financial system establishes a reference rate.

90
00:36:03.040 --> 00:36:30.080
Well so is is this going to be so this is going to be Bitcoin borrowed so somebody's gonna borrow Bitcoin on through the lightning? Maybe not through lightning but the but we would use lightning to establish the reference rate. So but you I mean maybe somebody would so what happens if if we get futures and so it so you got it in the lightning network and then all of a sudden with Bitcoin it's different than the forward curve for the for the Bitcoin price.

91
00:36:30.080 --> 00:36:48.400
I don't want to then you wouldn't you know that and I guess the other part of it is is that if you're actually are we talking actually in Bitcoin right so we shouldn't be thinking about other currencies right we shouldn't be thinking about this this is assuming that that Bitcoin is the a reserve currency, yeah. Right.

92
00:36:48.400 --> 00:37:09.000
Yep. Anyway, I think I guess where I'd come out is I need to read it some more. I'm very, very skeptical about it just because the main the main thing is is is it because right now it's it's like it doesn't, you know. I'm looking at I'm looking kind of incredulous about this, but to Brady.

93
00:37:09.000 --> 00:37:32.120
But so you know I don't know, I just got to think about it more, and the main reason is for me is a couple things. It's like the size, and then the other part of it. I'm trying to figure out how you set a reference rate on on Bitcoin off a network that's doing transactions that are basically retail-based transactions that have nothing to do with longevity.

94
00:37:32.120 --> 00:37:51.000
Cool. Well, we thought we'd cover this just because the other thing too is is that he was really fired up about it, and I and I'm really skeptical about it, and we think it's important on the show because him and I have a tendency to be fanboys on everything, and we kind of agree. So I'll also cover this also. Yeah, it's true.

95
00:37:51.000 --> 00:38:10.680
I'll just I'll just close up by by quoting this because I think it helps kind of clarify exactly what Nik Bhatia is talking about. But so he says that fees in Lightning Network can be attributed to two components time value and security risk premium.

96
00:38:10.680 --> 00:38:35.480
Fees compensate the leasing of Bitcoin, which translates into time value. Positive interest rates should attract capital and competition. But Lightning Network node operators investing capital are not doing so purely risk-free. They're taking a variety of risks, most notably the risk of using hot wallets to stake liquidity to the network. Therefore, interest rates will vary between nodes due to different security practices captured here by the catch-all variable security risk premium.

97
00:38:35.480 --> 00:38:55.760
So the rate equals time value plus security risk premium. So the time value is essentially like the fees that nodes are getting and then whatever the agreed upon you know market rate is for the security risk premium which will change over time for sure.

98
00:38:55.760 --> 00:39:34.000
Oh it definitely would change. Yeah yeah anyway so it's an interesting thought experiment for a future based on a global economy based on Bitcoin and you can check that out at time value on BTC is Nik Bhatia's Twitter handle find that there he's got links to his medium articles from his Twitter account so definitely something interesting to check out so I think that's it for today's show do you have any closing thoughts no my clo well my closing thought closing thought is on the reference rate and Nick's stuff he put together yeah it's it's a situation where I need to le read it more specifically I'm not normally so skeptical but it's

99
00:39:34.000 --> 00:40:12.080
Just and part of this is just given the size of the given market right now and then some of the concepts I'm having a hard time connecting on so yeah so Tommy's gonna be doing some more looking into that thank you so much for joining us again today Bitcoin keeps marching on and it's an exciting time to be in the space thank you for spending time learning about Bitcoin it's gonna pay off in dividends many times over in the coming years we believe and well I think I think that's it we'll see you next time

100
00:40:12.160 --> 00:40:14.560
Thanks again thank you take care

101
00:40:28.320 --> 00:40:28.640
Of the
