Dan Held: Money, Marketing, Proof of Work and Institutional Adoption Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-05-02 [00:00:13] Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. So how's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Hope you all are doing well. You know, this podcast is all about understanding what's happening here, about achieving clear thinking on this complex subject, about learning how to adapt to the changes that Bitcoin is bringing and will continue to bring about in our world. [00:00:46] And so to that end, I sit down with some great Bitcoiners who have a lot to teach us so that we can learn together. And I'm glad you're here. Got another great one for you today with Dan Held. But before we get to the show, I just want to take a quick second to ask for some readings and reviews. We're stuck at 18 ratings on iTunes now, for instance. [00:01:05] It's been there for a couple of weeks. If this podcast has been helping you on your Bitcoin journey or you've just been enjoying it, I'd really appreciate it if you'd take a moment to leave a rating and or a review on iTunes. Leaving one now helps the visit visibility of the podcast more than it will later. [00:01:25] There's diminishing marginal returns on ratings. So thanks to any listeners out there who can take a second and help me out on that front. Now on to the show. [00:01:45] Quite a while. He's started and worked for Bitcoin companies, and lately he's been taking to Medium to distill what he's learned into articles every Bitcoiner should read. His planting Bitcoin series is a fun and easy read about the creation of Bitcoin. And he's written about how narrative waves help to drive Bitcoin's hype cycles. [00:02:06] He's written about why proof of work is efficient and why Bitcoin's initial distribution of coins was fair. All of those are, of course, linked in the show notes, and you should read them if you haven't yet. It was really cool to get to talk to Dan today, and I hope you all enjoy it. Here's my conversation with Dan. [00:02:26] Alright, Dan, how's it going, man? Doing well. Thanks for having me on. Yeah, really appreciate your time. I know you're busy. So we'll just dive into this. Just for a little bit of background for everyone. Dan's the co-founder of Pix and Shovels, a Bitcoin company. We'll get into well, crypto, I guess a crypto company I should say. [00:02:47] We'll get into the details there. He formerly worked on global data and growth at Uber. He was a project manager for ChangeTip and co-founder of ZeroBlock, which was a crypto portfolio app. It was kind of the blockfolio or Delta of 2013, which was then acquired by blockchain.com, blockchain.info back then. [00:03:05] And that was the first or like one of the first acquisitions of a Bitcoin company, is that right? Technically the second. The first one. Yeah, the first one was Satoshi Dice, or he's a startup. Okay, right on. Yeah, of course. Yeah. So yeah, Dan has been around for a long time. I'm sure most of you know who he is. [00:03:25] He has a lot to teach and share, and I'm glad to be able to bring him on the show today. So I know your Dan, your your Bitcoin history is your story is out there. You all can check out episode 52 of Tales from the Crypt, for instance, to get Dan's full kind of Bitcoin story in detail, so we don't need to go into that today. [00:03:44] But I have to mention that I do love that your first Bitcoin was a Cassacious coin to settle a beer tab. Yeah, it was a good way to bridge the analog to digital world. Digital currencies back in 2012 were a very new topic. So it was a good way for me to kind of conceptualize it. Later down the road, I realized how kind of ridiculous Cassaceous coins are, but and very insecure. [00:04:07] It was still, you know, with back in that day, they were only worth like five or eight bucks, so it wasn't too big of a deal. Yeah, yeah. Well, and look what that friend started for you, which is pretty cool. Exactly. Yeah. So I guess they did, you know, have a little bit of marketing value too back then. I want to dive into kind of the first topic being sort of the nature of money and economics. [00:04:31] This will touch on some stuff from your planting bitcoin series, which of course will be linked in the show notes for everyone. And if you haven't read it yet, you should you should read that. It's a it's a really fun look at at the history of Bitcoin and what Bitcoin is. I've been using this term default Keynesian on the podcast to describe most people in the world who haven't somehow like organically been introduced to the ideas of Austrian economics. [00:04:57] For the most part, Keynesian ideas are taught as kind of the way it is in schools around the world. I know you went to business school. Were you taught about Austrian economics there? Or was it like Bitcoin that led you into Austrian economics? Yeah, they don't teach Austrian economics, I think, at any major university in in the Americas or in the in the United States, you know, to the best of my knowledge, I don't know of any that do. [00:05:21] Granted, I don't vote for the other thing. I think there's a few. I did talk to Ansel Lindner about this. So he in the there's there are some in the economics departments of like three or four universities in out of this entire country that have some Austrian economists on staff, but it's like very, very rare. Yeah. And I'm sure in business school it's basically non-existent. [00:05:41] Yeah, at least you know, where I went to school, Texas AM, there wasn't any sort of coursework around that. You know, granted, Texas AM isn't like an Ivy League school where maybe they have a greater diversity of thought. Yeah, I mean, look, the state and the education system and the financial system are all intertwined and everyone is dancing to the same tune. [00:06:04] I don't think it's advantageous for anyone's career to be prophesizing Austrian School of Economics, given that you're not going to get any research funding by the Federal Reserve, which they dole out millions of that every year. You're not going to be well regarded with your peers. You're not going to be considered legitimate. [00:06:22] So we've totally aligned incentives in our culture to basically promote Keynesian economics, which has a non-data-driven sort of construct in terms of how the system works. It it arrogantly assumes that human beings can control chaotic systems that have a near infinite number of variables. [00:06:47] Yeah, yeah, that makes sense. So I guess that the idea is the idea of money in Keynesian economics is very different than the idea of money in Austrian economics. And Bitcoin is really leading sort of a re-education of people who come into come to understand what Bitcoin is and hold it and learn about it about you know what money is. [00:07:11] Like we just don't really understand what money actually is because I think the Keynesian idea of it is incorrect. I've come to understand that over the past couple of years. Can we talk a little bit about the differences between the Keynesian idea of money and Austrian idea of money? [00:07:30] Yeah, I mean, I would I would say it would be better just to kind of dive into like the most primitive idea of what money should be, right? So you know, I don't know if anyone here has read Nick Zabo's shelling out around some of the most primitive forms of money and how money has evolved through time. [00:07:48] I think it's a great resource and a great place to start in terms of your education process. When you look at the way that I framed it in planting Bitcoin, which I think makes it much easier for people to understand, is that money, at least in the traditional sense, which is you know, some of that has been like shells and beads and then precious metals and then now digital gold with Bitcoin. [00:08:13] Those all have certain genetic characteristics genetic characteristics as money that lead to certain traits of money. So just like any other organism, that genetic code manifests itself via traits, and those traits give it certain parameters as money that will enable it to survive and thrive as a money, and newer monies that have better traits, they are the superior species that will eventually wipe out the other one. [00:08:42] And I believe that Bitcoin, which I can dive into some of those traits here, Bitcoin has the superior traits of a genetics or of a of a species of money. Yeah, and we can go through some of the traits. There's a couple that I want to dive into a little deeper just because I think they're not as obvious, I guess. [00:09:03] Yeah, you let's run down the traits of money. I just think it's always good to review that stuff. And then maybe let's spend a little bit more time on the idea of unforgeable costliness and why that's important for money. Yeah, I think that yeah, we'll start with the kind of basic characteristics or traits of money. [00:09:22] So money has to be useful in terms of you know, it's three primary functions are a store value, medium of exchange, and unit of account. [00:09:31] New monies may or may not. New monies may or [00:09:35] May not fulfill all three. Bitcoin right now is undergoing a early stage in its life cycle as a species of money where it's better suited as a store of value than the medium and medium of exchange and unit of account due to its volatility, which by the way is a good thing. But the other traits of money, you know, for example, a money has to be verifiable. [00:09:58] It has to be, you know, that's why we have those strips in our paper money, as we can easily verify that it is authentic. And with gold as well, there are methods of more expensive and hard to reproduce methods of validating the density of gold so you make sure that you haven't received tungsten or something else. [00:10:16] It must be portable. I'll go through a couple of these. I think you know, digging in too deep on each one might get a little bit tedious. You know, it has to be durable, it has to be divisible. You know, you can slice it down to a dollar, so you can buy a chewing gum pack. It's gotta have an established history or at least share a delusion or share trust in that money. [00:10:39] It's gotta be scarce. If the money is plentiful, then it's not very valuable. And I think this might be a good moment to kind of highlight how scarcity is a little bit, you know, somewhat related to so scarcity is around the quantity being somewhat finite and not unlimited. [00:10:59] And there's a there's a way that it is prevented from being unlimited, which is the unforgeable costiness, which is that money should be costly to produce. Gold mining, the cost to produce an ounce of gold largely is what the value of that gold is when it's sold on the open market, with a small, small margin built in there. [00:11:21] And so as gold becomes more and more valuable, more and more mines are willing to turn on and dig deeper and deeper depths to find the gold. And Bitcoin has a built-in function that mimics this unforgeable costiness. So as Bitcoin's value rises, miners are incentivized to mine and throw more hash power at the network, which therefore brings about greater security. [00:11:48] But by throwing more hash power in the network, that does enable them to mine quicker. However, Bitcoin's algorithm, in layman's terms here, Bitcoin's algorithm detects the additional hash power and reconfigures the difficulty to mine a bitcoin. [00:12:04] In a similar function as to how gold mining becomes more difficult to find as demand increases, Bitcoin's difficulty adjustment essentially does that as well. [00:12:13] So it ensures that the cost to purchase a Bitcoin is nearly the same cost as the cost to mine it. This is useful for many reasons. One is that unforgeable costiness ensures that there's no shortcuts. There's no way for anyone to shortcut the system. And with Bitcoin, you either have to buy it or mine it, and they're very closely equivalent in terms of cost. [00:12:38] And what that means is it's the most fair way to issue a money. Okay. Makes sense. Yeah, so one, it it ensures that the money is unforgeable unforgetably costly. As well, it provides some sort of anchor or measurement in the real world. [00:12:57] There are monies that don't have this forageable costiness factor, and they claim that scarcity will exist, but unless it sorry, I had to move my chair there. Uml unless it is costly to produce, then we cannot also believe that it'll be scarce at a later date. [00:13:19] Is that go ahead. I mean, yeah, with would that be one of the critiques of proof of stake versus proof of work is that proof of stake doesn't have the trait of unforgeable costliness. Yeah, that's that's one great criticism of proof of stake amongst many. [00:13:39] Not sure if anyone's called Ben Davenport's article around the stake in the heart. It's a is about a pair, you know, a page and a half long medium article that came out yesterday that was really great. Highlighted the issues of proof of stake when it comes to taxation and real returns. [00:13:57] So I haven't read it yet. Oh, yeah, it's only a page and a half long, it's really easy, and Ben did a great job of simplifying the issue. Essentially, sweet, you know, the block reward is comprised of inflation or issuance plus transaction fees, and just when you stake your money in a proof of stake system, you're essentially staking to make sure you're keeping up with inflation. [00:14:19] So that's not a real return. You're merely you're really preserving your purchasing power. But you're taking on risk just to just to protect your purchasing power. And even when you take on risk, which which is kind of silly because there's no really there's no real return or reward for the risk that you're taking on. [00:14:38] But in addition to that, you'll also have a negative real return because of the taxes that you have to pay, because that is considered income. All right, yeah. Yeah, so unless the you know that's just for the inflation component of like the block reward. Essentially the inflation component for some proof-of-stake systems is perceived as being the additional value that a network needs in order to protect itself plus the transaction fees. [00:15:07] Your transaction fees, the value that you find from the transaction fees per block in a proof-of-stake system of perpetual inflation, the transaction fee value per block, that percentage has to be higher than your tax on the on the gross return. Otherwise you won't be able to beat inflation. [00:15:28] Yeah, that makes perfect sense. And I hadn't thought about that. So I'll definitely link that article in the show notes and give it a read later tonight. You mentioned that volatility is a good thing. I know well, we kind of got through most of the traits of money just to kind of wrap that up. Censorship resistance is kind of a new trait, I guess, that we're probably adding in. [00:15:48] Kind of or that at least focusing on more, I guess, with Bitcoin, especially after what happened to gold, was done to gold with by the states. Then also that it's programmable and decentralized, which is something new. So to just kind of wrap that up, Bitcoin ranks better than gold or fiat money on all of these traits except for established history, of course. [00:16:16] Gold's obviously got a much longer established history, and on on durability, why why is why does Bitcoin get a moderate durability, whereas gold gets high? Is it just because it's easier to like send send your Bitcoin to like some dead address or like something like that than it is with gold? [00:16:36] There's been a lot of lost Bitcoin. And in the midst of our like most you know, valiant efforts to not lose any, there will always be Bitcoin perpetually being lost. Right. Which only drives up the scarcity. Yeah, I think it's a great thing, which means that people will value it more and that people will be very cognizant of how they handled the money. [00:16:57] And I think at a certain stage there'll be like such a minimal amount of attrition or or loss that you know, we're maybe talking like a Bitcoin in an entire year. Right. Across the whole world. So why you mentioned the volatility was a good thing, and could you expand on that a little bit? Yeah, so Satoshi I would argue is equally as brilliant. [00:17:19] He's a polymath. I use he by the way, because he chose that as P2P foundation profile. He chose you know, he was a polymath in terms of understanding game theory, thermodynamics, computer science, encryption, you know, cryptography. The more and more I read about Satoshi and his early writings and ideas that he had pulled together to create Bitcoin, it was it was fucking amazing. [00:17:45] I mean, this guy wasn't an engineer. In fact, he was probably just a mediocre engineer. This guy was one of the greatest geniuses of our time. He thought long and hard about how to align all these incentives. And so that I think is really, really elegant when we look at his thoughts behind Bitcoins having an events. [00:18:07] So every four years, the amount of the block reward is comprised of the block subsidy, which is the newly issued Bitcoins, those newly issued bitcoins are produced on an exponentially declining curve that eventually ends in the year 2140 when all bitcoins will be produced. So Satoshi, every four years in the algorithms, the Bitcoin subsidy or the block subsidy, the number of bitcoins being minted per block drops in half. [00:18:36] And what that does is it creates a supply shock to where the price of any asset in the world will stay flat if demand equals supply. So if a hundred people want to sell an apple today, one apple, and a hundred people want to buy it, the price will likely stay where it's at. [00:18:56] If a hundred people want to sell an apple today and only 10 want to buy it, then the price is gonna dip. Similarly, if more demand outstrips supply, then the price will increase. So what happens, and what we've seen empirically with 10 years worth of data is that each having an event creates a supply shock to the system, which means that more demands will be chasing less and less Bitcoins that are are hitting the market. [00:19:24] And those bitcoins All right, and even if it's the same demand, like even if the demand stays the same. That's right. Right, like the supply, so yeah, then the price will go up anyway. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, so Tokyo talks about this. The way that he's constructed incentives in the Bitcoin network when it comes to miners and when it comes to users and hodlers or believers, he aligned it very, very elegantly and very simply, which means that the simplicity of the nature of this means that we can understand it and understand how what levers that are pressed to influence certain behavior. [00:19:59] So essentially what happens is, yeah, if demand stays constant and supply drops in half, you know, because miners spend real world dollars to buy their machines and equipment. So when they get those newly received bitcoins in the block that they mined, they're likely gonna sell it to pay for their real world costs. They don't have to, but they're likely to. And so what happens is we've got more demand chasing half of the supply that was formerly in the market, and that causes the price to slowly increase upward. [00:20:27] As the price slowly increases upward, more and more people hear about the price increasing. It increases awareness. As awareness increases, more and more people to buy to take advantage of the pricing price, and hopefully, you know, essentially come for the degenerate trading and stay for the decentralized money. Right. You know, if Bitcoin would stay flat at a dollar for forever and it's super stable or at $10 or $100, you and I probably wouldn't be talking about it right now. [00:20:53] In each of those calculative bubbles, it gains a huge amount of attention, which draws in new hodlers or believers that give the entire ecosystem its lifeblood. It brings in new developers, it brings in businesses that build tools and services. And what happens is these big upswells, we see the boom bust cycle. You have people that come in for the trading, and then there's you know, maybe 10% who actually stick around and are like, wait, this is really cool. [00:21:17] I want to learn more about this. And then there's businesses that get built around servicing. The you know, each time this happens, there's an exponentially higher number of individuals in the space. So essentially Satoshi built an incredible, probably one of the most effective viral loops into the core protocol. [00:21:37] But it not only just brings in new adherents or believers and in resources into the system, it's also I mean, it's also a method to align incentives with miners and to issue new currency. So to get all of these parameters right was incredible. [00:21:56] It's amazing. Something I hadn't thought about before, and I wonder if you have is why do you think Satoshi chose four years? There is, I mean, obviously you could choose any number. I mean, obviously and it's not four years, it's actually in the code, it's a number of blocks, but it roughly is about four years. You could choose any any number of years or whatever. [00:22:18] You could probably even code it to be sort of a smooth, like, you know, reduction from block one to whatever the block height will be in 2140 or whatever. So yeah, why do you think there's this sort of four-year and then it's cut in half and four more years cut in half, four more years cut in half? That's a great question. [00:22:36] And not many people have really even thought about it. I found almost no information as to like why people would hypothesize Satoshi chose four years, and Satoshi never mentioned why he chose four years. Now, you had a great caveat in that it's actually the number of blocks, but for the for the layman here, we'll just say around four years. [00:22:55] I have a unsubstantiated hypothesis. But I have no data. Well, I have a very it's very loosely crafted. But the idea is, you know, look, we elect new leaders every four years in the United States. That is what we give those leaders, and that's what we give them in terms of time to make a difference. [00:23:18] So four years is a nice round number. It's what we give politicians to make a difference. I think that's you know, and coincidentally, Bitcoin lines up with election cycles. Not sure, you know, with planting Bitcoin in season. I cover the moment when Satoshi planted the seed of Bitcoin. [00:23:39] So I think 2008, I think Satoshi chose the month and the day, but I'm not sure about the year. I'm I'm I feel that was more random. So I'm not sure if he meant to time it with election cycles, but Bitcoin does time pretty nicely with election cycle. You know, yeah, it's right between it was right between the end of the Bush 2 administration and the beginning of the Obama administration, just like right in between then during the transition, actually. [00:24:04] In 2016 with Trump, right? Yeah, yeah, 2020 here coming out, which will be a very connected election. So, you know, maybe bonkers. Yeah, maybe, and then I think you know, maybe not this one, but the one the next happening in like 2024, I think it'll be certainly a topic of debate during the presidential elections in the US. [00:24:24] But yeah, I mean that that would be amazing. Yeah, that might have been it. That might have been why four years is a good enough time for people to think about it and plan around it and build and you know, people can catch their breath because we are humans and which are animals, by the way. We aren't robots, so he I think very fundamentally understood how humans think. [00:24:45] And so I think four years is a good amount of time to where if someone got wrecked as well during the boom bus cycle, yeah they might feel inclined to get buyback in again. You know scar like time heals all wounds. So I think yeah and I guess if you would have done if you would have done like a smooth sort of decrease in supply from the Genesis block on through to however long he wanted to be distributing Bitcoin's hundred you know 132 years then you wouldn't have the supply shock right and maybe you wouldn't be driving the sort of cycles the kind of writing the hype cycles like maybe the [00:25:23] Hype cycles are necessary for adoption I guess because it's just kind of a like you say a fact of non-robotic humans, you know, the emotional hype cycles and so that's probably yeah a good reason to play along with that too. Yeah totally. Yeah it's the supply shock a gradual supply mechanism while seems to be elegant for computer science or for you know economists and see you know computer scientists they don't fundamentally understand humans though right which it makes sense doesn't matter how cool your code is because that code event eventually is interacting with the human in some fashion. [00:26:01] Yeah and it seems to that would be sort of the you know as a coder myself seems to be kind of the initial solution that would present itself like this makes sense we'll just we'll just make it gradual or like perfectly even from this point in time to this point in time. But yeah, to actually have resisted that and thought through it and chosen in a different path just really shows the genius of the incentive structure of Bitcoin. [00:26:30] Yeah, totally. It was a an incredibly delicate balancing act between all the different market participants. Yeah. So one of the aspects of the adopt the hype cycles that I think actually you and I tweeted about this briefly last month. [00:26:51] You had tweeted about how badass Bitcoin's growth has been over just 10 years with a pseudonymous founder and no marketing budget. And then I replied that I think Bitcoin actually does have a marketing budget in a sense in the form of future returns for hodlers who are incentivized to educate and market about Bitcoin. [00:27:10] And that during every wave, just like we get new developers and you know and new hodlers on every wave of adoption, content creators and educators and marketers are sort of hired to teach and preach Bitcoin, and that's you know, here we are right now doing just that. You've worked at Uber and you've seen like a global company's marketing machine in full effect. [00:27:33] What's different about like that centralized approach to marketing and this sort of decentralized marketing machine that Bitcoin has created as part of its in in incentive structure? Yeah, that's a great question. So for if you approach marketing from like a really macro perspective, you have organic and paid channels. And so channels being certain like content platforms to attract users. [00:27:56] So that could be that could be direct messaging, that could be out of home, which is billboards, and those that annoying spam mail you get in your in your your mailbox, or that could be Facebook ads, which is social, so you get Facebook, Twitter, and then you have search, which would be like Google search or App Store search, now that Apple and Google both have search store ads. [00:28:23] You've got multiple channels to acquire users through. You're trying to acquire those users because you hypothesize that their value or their LTB, their lifetime value will be greater than the cost to acquire them, or the cost to acquire the user, plus the organic users that you get in terms of incrementality will equal or be less than your LTV. [00:28:48] That's sort of the magical calculation as well, you make more money from the user than you will it'll cost to acquire them. So when we think about different channels, you know, we can talk about there's a lot of like very growth hacky organic ways. For example, Airbnb went on to Craigslist and cross-posted their ads on Craigslist in their very early days, which is against Craigslist terms of service, and I think they got sued, but might have paid a small fine for it, but it gave them the visibility and the initial traction that they needed to launch Airbnb. [00:29:23] That's an example of like organic move fast and break things. Yeah, exactly. An organic growth hack where you find an opportunity and exploit it to gain visibility with your target market for your product. Similarly, I have an example from back in 2013 when the Silk Road was busted by the by the feds, the FBI started to move the money from the Silk Road wallets. [00:29:48] And so I saw that activity happening really quickly. I reached out to Wall Street Journal and Forbes and Wired, and I went, Hey, by the way, the money is moving. Here's the blockchain. [00:30:00] URL for that address. [00:30:03] Because blockchainfo.info is a block explorer, and that special URL had that unique address. So I knew a bunch of traffic was about to hit that page. And so what I did is I then went and on blockchain.info, if you send money to another blockchain, or if you send money from blockchain.info wallet to any other wallet, you can attach a small message. [00:30:29] Now that message is not on the blockchain, it is only visible on blockchain. So what I started to do is I started to throw pennies for my personal account. I threw pennies at the FBI's wallet. And with each one of those penny transactions, I had a little message that said download zero block, the number one app for Bitcoin enthusiasts. [00:30:52] And so I think I threw like 50 cents at the FBI. You know, I'm throwing little pennies at them. And I got a thousand installs that day. That's amazing. [00:31:07] And it's not like I ran this up, saw it and I was like, oh shit, this would be a really cool idea. I think like TechCrunch actually picked it up as a strategy because it was really, really unique. They were like, someone's throwing pennies at the FBI. Yeah, that's amazing. And so 50 cents per thousand installs is pretty is pretty good customer acquisition. [00:31:27] Yeah, that's very good. Yeah, so you know, you can look at like I guess you could call that a page strategy if you really wanted to, but yeah, so you can have a mix of organic strategies, but but growth marketing typically, especially in tech is is more in reference to paid acquisition. So it's about allocating spend or marketing spend across multiple channels and allocating that effectively, not only in terms of your conversion rates, so you're gonna want to deploy capital with Google search ads and you're gonna A-B test different language to make sure that that language converts users. [00:32:02] For example, will buy Bitcoin or buy Litecoin convert more users that are searching for certain queries. So that's a for example that the copy you would test. So spending marketing dollars is all about efficiency. Now, there are certain channels that are very unique in terms of their efficiency and their stickiness. [00:32:23] So, you know, you can acquire users through any channel you'd like, but if you're not acquiring users that have a high affinity for your product, it's not likely they're gonna stick around. So they might churn really quickly. For example, let's say I have copy that says, hey, get a thousand dollars if you use this app, and then they download the app and they find they don't get a thousand dollars. [00:32:43] Well, yeah, I acquired user for cheap, but they're not gonna stick around. Similarly, yeah, the early traction for Uber's products was with millennials. Now, once all the millennials were tapped out in terms of, you know, almost every millennial had taken an Uber by X point in time, then Uber had to go after other age cohorts like baby boomers. [00:33:04] So their affinity for products like Uber is less, and Uber's gonna have to spend more money, and they're gonna, and those those baby boomers may not use Uber as much as a millenni. So, in terms of different channels, you have to think about how to allocate the spend in the most efficient manner, optimize your content to for maximum impact, and then you're gonna have to recognize that over time it's gonna either become more expensive or like your users eventually become lower, lower quality. [00:33:31] Bitcoin has a really unique marketing channel that it uses, and that's called referrals or virality. That would be the most appropriate marketing channel to kind of that that's the primary marketing channel that Bitcoin operates in. And so I used to sit on Rider Growth, which was onboarding engagement and virality. [00:33:52] So those are the three sub teams. And so I sat with that team for over a year at Uber. I was essentially a PMM on that team. So I sat with the PMs on that team. I was part of the road mapping process where we go and evaluate different projects that we could do to optimize. [00:34:12] So onboarding is install to first trip, engagement is recurring trips, and then virality is increasing the propensity for people to share the product with their friends, and we incentivize that through a give get model where we give you a free ride and your friend gets a ride if you share the product. [00:34:30] So Bitcoin largely is a referral mechanism because as when you buy Bitcoin, as the value goes up, now you're financially well, value goes up, and A, you're gonna brag about it, or at least a lot of people will, which isn't good opse. I wouldn't recommend it. But humans are humans built. [00:34:49] So as the value goes up, everyone tells the friends about it. And coincidentally, they're also benefiting from prophesizing their coin because the more they talk about it, right? You know, there's a certain amount of impressions that your friends are getting from you, not a first impression or anything like that, but just repeated language that they hear from you about Bitcoin. [00:35:09] And if the value continues to increase, they get FOMO, and then they'll buy in, and you've essentially now earned more return on your Bitcoin because you've stoked demand. Right. And once the user is in, the chances, like it seems this way with Bitcoin, the chances that they stick around over the long run are good enough to create these sort of cohorts of hodlers that really drive Bitcoin's adoption over time. [00:35:42] So a lot a lot of you know, a lot of people from 2017 left and they're like, oh, this sucks, this is stupid. And I lost a bunch of money and they're gonna be burned. But there's plenty of us, and I me included, that are part of that sort of class of 2017, you know, that have stuck around and you know, gone through this spare market, and maybe we're at the bottom now and getting ready for the next bull run. [00:36:06] And we're now, you know, kind of taking up the mantle of you know content creating and marketing and that continuing that viral loop. So yeah, it's it's just it's fascinating. Do you think that do you think that Bitcoin will have to compete against like corporate currencies or like you know, blockchainified like dollars, you know, like like a like a Fed coin or something? [00:36:32] And against sort of these other types of centralized marketing efforts, you know, like like you know, search advertising and social network advertising and things like that in the future. Oh, yeah, totally. I mean, we saw the first wave of that really occurring with like ICOs that had significant marketing budgets. You know, EOS was taking out advertisements in square was it New York Square Times? [00:36:58] Yeah, and [00:36:59] That was pretty incredible to see. That's right. Yeah, and then and then I think Facebook banned several large people all banned advertisements for crypto assets due to the highly scammy nature of ICOs. Yeah, will Bitcoin compete with other currencies, both corporate and federal or state currencies? [00:37:25] Yes. And they're gonna have to compete with the huge marketing engines that they have. And yeah, I think you know, Bitcoin, due to its survivability, how for how long it's been around, you know, sort of the Coca-Cola of cryptocurrencies. A lot of people just think Bitcoin is the only cryptocurrency. [00:37:44] Most people they're gonna go with what they have the highest brand awareness with, which is Bitcoin. Especially as Bitcoin continues to survive and continues to outperform many other crypto assets. If you look at Bitcoin's returns since exchange listing compared to all other crypto assets, it beats them all by a magnitude, including Ethereum. [00:38:03] So I think people largely, you know, when they evaluate performance, they look at like 2016 through now, and I'm like, I'm not sure if that's you know, two and a half years is not an appropriate appropriate time frame, especially since there's a wave of altcoins in 2014. That that being the longest data set that we have, it'd be prudent if we use that. [00:38:21] Anyways, so you know, Bitcoin has fended off various waves of other competing ideologies or cryptocurrencies. The next wave will be one of the will be very, very large. But as Bitcoin survives, it's each wave of these competing narratives, its core narrative becomes stronger and the believers in it become stronger as well. [00:38:45] The hodlers propensity to hodl and to continue to buy and prophesize it will increase. Essentially, Bitcoin's meme and Bitcoin's core ideology is the strongest out of any other currency in the world, whether that be fiat or cryptocurrency. So, you know, sort of monotheist versus polytheist. [00:39:05] You're not going to be able to convince a Bitcoiner to go switch over to something else once they become a Bitcoiner. Yeah. I sort of feel like Bitcoin has a very strong authenticity to its brand because it's there is no centralized marketing, you know, or or corporation that's kind of running the show. [00:39:28] It's you are you're trusting, you know, your friend that told you about Bitcoin or your brother or whatever, your family member that kind of that talked to you about it for the first time, introduced you to it, your friend who gave you a Cassatious coin for a bar tab, you know. And then there's this the fact that there's no central like authority or like I guess central like organization or entity that's benefiting from this marketing, right? [00:39:57] It's kind of the whole any any hodler is benefiting from us kind of virally marketing it gives it this authenticity that I think might give it a big advantage over you know a Fed coin that's trying to get people to use its wallet. Yeah, Bitcoin has a you know, as it continues to survive and as people become more aware of how it works, it's hard to ignore how authentic it is. [00:40:20] It's basically as transparent as can be. What's nice is that since there's no central marketing team, then the marketing message can be super diverse, which means that more and more people can A B test what language is working. And then you see breakout moments where someone really, really finds a good narrative. [00:40:39] And when they do that, that individual not only increases the propagation of Bitcoin's narrative, individual or team or whoever comes together to craft this narrative. An example might be the Bitcoin standard. They also monetarily benefit from it. So essentially Bitcoin has hired a bunch of freelancers to help the market and to help market its product. [00:41:01] Yep. And there's more about this idea on Dan's medium article called Quantum Narratives, which is also going to be linked in the show notes about the idea of like how narratives come and go in Bitcoin and how they affect the cycle we've been talking about. So I'm looking I'm looking at time. [00:41:19] I want to move on because I have a cut two other topics I want to try to squeeze in before I know you have to press on. So next I want to talk about proof of work, and you've written a great piece called Proof of Work is efficient, which I refer back to a lot because I like the number one pushback I get when I'm talking to friends or family who find out that I'm into Bitcoin and like they finally decide to like engage in a conversation about it. [00:41:47] They'll always come and ask eventually. I don't, I'm not super pushy about it. I just kind of let people know, and then they come and ask me when they're ready. But it's the idea of Bitcoin mining and then proof of work is wasteful, right? It's an easy, quick conclusion to make when you're kind of just first presented with like how Bitcoin mining works and what proof of work is without really understanding what it's for, right? [00:42:10] And how it works. But there are people who dive in and study it closely and still come away with the conclusion that proof of work is wasteful. Like one of the most well-known critics is Alex DeVries. Can you explain his critique and sort of your smackdown of that FUD that you write about in the in the in that article? [00:42:31] Yeah, I mean, look, like working at Uber, like we were constantly pushed to be data-driven. We worked with some of the top data scientists in the world. A hundred billion dollar company resided, you know, essentially survive off the decisions that we made. We're not a bunch of fucking researchers. And actually, Alex is a bit intellectually dishonest, and I think that's an appropriate term to use because he fully recognized the flaws in his arguments, but refuses to, I think he understands his flaws but refuses to acknowledge other flaws. [00:43:03] But any data scientist in the world would be like this is a joke. So I just find it like it's an intellectually dishonest because he propagates that narrative with purposely faulty data that the most cursory sort of you know glance would you would figure out like, oh wait a second. [00:43:24] You plugged it in as a variable? It's absurd. Yeah. So, you know, you know, I guess I can start with sort of the way that I present proof of work. So again, proof of work has multiple purposes. One is unforgeable costiness of the new units of the currency. [00:43:43] The other one is that it it continually protects the tip of the network, the tip of the blockchain, and all historical transactions by using energy to create a thermodynamic sort of layer to permanently seal those transactions in time. Some people have referred to it as amber or layers of amber. [00:44:04] Yeah. So proof of work has its dual purpose. And I think a lot of people forget that. They just look at it as a method to protect the network. And so the TLDR is like, yeah, the whole world is made up of energy. Thermodynamics dictates this. [00:44:23] Everything requires energy. When I'm speaking right now, that's energy. When you walk, when you talk, when you use a car, everything requires energy in the entire universe. [00:44:35] So, one is that we have to expend energy to do anything. [00:44:37] And so all things require energy. Two is that you know, work as classically defined is essentially the cost of energy to do something. And what proof of work does is it takes electricity in the real world and a processor, and it uses that to verify or essentially cement Bitcoin's record or its blockchain and cement all those transactions as concretely as possible. [00:45:09] And so what's great about that is that Bitcoin uses real world energy, and there's no way to fake that energy used. To essentially build a wall of energy around its ledger in the digital world. So, you know, in the real world, we would never fault anyone for building walls or vaults or defensive mechanisms to protect things that we care about. [00:45:35] It's entirely intuitive. Fort Knox. Four knocks, your gate, your door, your lock, car lock, everything. All of those things are defensive mechanisms. And no one would ever be like, oh my God, you wasted so much energy building that door lock. Said no one ever. Right. So to protect a new financial system and to protect that ledger, which you know isn't protected by guns or anything else, Satoshi took the most fundamental commodity of the universe, which is energy, and used that to transmute energy into digital gold and to transmute energy into a wall of energy around Bitcoin's [00:46:13] Ledger to where the only way to tear down that wall is the exact same cost it took to put that wall up. And there's no way around it based on the laws of physics. There isn't there is no shortcut. There's no shortcut in the universe. There's no amount of technological advancement you cannot beat physics. [00:46:34] Right. So it is I mean it is literally the most efficient way that that we could devise to create this sort of protection around a very valuable ledger. Right? I mean that's why titled it proof of work is efficient not only for that but it also triggers the hell out of all of the pseudoscientific individuals like Alex Defries and Vitalik Buterin. [00:47:01] Yeah. So another one that I get then as a follow-up is all right fine so you like let's just grant that you have you know you need to use proof of work in order to have unforgeable costiness and security and secure the ledger and all the other reasons we need proof of work b to solve the in part the Byzantine Generals problem. [00:47:23] But like it's just growing and growing and growing, and it's never going to stop growing, and it's just going to take over, like, you know, use like all this like 99% of the energy of our civilization, which is just ridiculous on face, like just you know, in common sense, like that just doesn't make any sense that that would actually happen. [00:47:42] Do you like can we predict or like what are the best predictions out there, I guess, about how much of our total energy output as a civilization that Bitcoin proof of work mining would eventually consume. Let's just let's just assume that like Bitcoin it becomes like the world reserve currency. [00:48:00] How how much energy could proof of work mining use. Yeah, that's a good question. And Drew Bansall from Unchained Capital, he's a really brilliant guy in the space, also an ex-physicist. So I actually find those people to I think be some of the ones who understand Bitcoin the most rather than computer scientists. [00:48:20] No offense, by the way. I find I love working with engineers. He calls that the Nakamoto point, and you know, we're essentially it's like the max max percentage of the world's electricity that's used to secure Bitcoin's ledger. He estimates it between, I forget off the top of my head, but I think around like five or ten percent of the or maybe even higher of the world's total electricity. [00:48:49] I think though, before we take that metric out of context, we must look at the other energy costs for other networks. For example, like the world's existing financial system or gold mining. So, you know, I think I think when we look at how much data will be stored on Bitcoin's ledger, you know, if Bitcoin's ledger becomes not only you know, not only financial data, but maybe like the world's records that are compressed and compressed and then eventually stored or rooted in Bitcoin's blockchain, you know, it might consume what some might perceive as a large [00:49:28] Amount of energy, but considering that it replaces X amount of institutions in the world like the Federal Reserve, all the banks or most of the banks, maybe even court system courts or you know it's not going to replace courts as a whole, but it might replace some functions of a court. And so in any capitalist system, the new more efficient system replaces more inefficient old ones. [00:49:52] And typically that new system requires a large amount of energy as well. It doesn't energy consumption by itself is not a bad thing. In fact if we look at the world's GDP over time, it is has an extremely high correlation to energy consumption which is entirely intuitive. [00:50:11] As we build greater and greater machines and greater civilization we require require more energy to do it. So energy consumption in and of itself is not a bad thing. [00:50:24] If you really want to go up down the virtue signaling rabbit hole and you want to evaluate if you want to evaluate each in this you know each consumption of electricity based on its origins of where that electricity was created which by the way no one does for any fucking other thing in their life they're not looking and they're not like no one's looking at their you know their hippie blanket and going, hey, how much electricity was required to build this blanket? [00:50:49] No, no one does that. Or how much was required for their boy milk or anything else? Like, who cares? But you know, if people want to go down a virtue signaling rabbit hole and criticize Bitcoin at a fundamental level of like, okay, sure, it's electricity usage is efficient, it's more and it uses less electricity than the existing financial system, but where is that electricity being created from? [00:51:09] Which, by the way, that's called moving the goalposts. If you I think who was it? There was a research report done by CoinShares, and they found that 78% of Bitcoin mining electricity usage was generated through renewables, which is greater than many other types of industries. [00:51:33] So I think that's a full refuge. Like the natural gas venting and flaming off and stuff. I think I saw Steve Bar Steve Barber tweet yesterday that there's just an enormous amount of vented natural gas that Bitcoin mining can can go after. [00:51:53] And it's just like that's a great point. I forgot to highlight that, you know. As Nic Carter puts it, it's like if you pour, you know, a glass you pour water over the globe, and if you had a huge glass of water and you poured it over the earth and you see how it fit in all the nooks and crannies, Bitcoin mining intuitively and through very, very simple incentives, searches for the cheapest electricity across the world, which typically means it's going to Bitcoin miners will gravitate towards areas that have been wasting energy. [00:52:25] Which, as you mentioned, the like flare methane and other sorts of energy where maybe they built a hydroelectric dam, but the demand never came. So at a minimum, Bitcoin is taking wasted electricity and making something of it, which is magnificent because that energy was just going to waste before. [00:52:43] So the concerns that Bitcoin will displace my my usage of my Christmas tree lights or my car is absurd. Bitcoin doesn't want to compete for more expensive use cases of electricity. It wants to compete for the lowest possible use case of electricity, which is using it for Bitcoin mining. [00:53:02] Those resources can be stranded. [00:53:05] For example, like Iceland or the middle of Alaska. So Bitcoin doesn't compete at all with the electricity usage that you and I use. Yeah, Bitcoin mining can be done anywhere, which is why the sort of pouring the analogy or the visualization of pouring water over a globe and it's settling in the lowest points makes perfect sense because it you can mine Bitcoin anywhere. [00:53:25] And you have value, you don't have to transport that electricity to any end user or anything. You just take the electricity that's gonna be otherwise wasted and then turn it, you know, store it as as Bitcoin. That's a great way to put it. And there's there's other other analogies as well to make this a little bit more tangible for people. [00:53:45] The prime minister, I think of the like prime minister for industry in Iceland said that Iceland, we have all these great geothermal trapped electricity sources, but we can't export it because as we pipe that electricity down the wire to other countries, we would lose all of it through the transmission process. What they do is they import bauxite, which is raw aluminum ore, and they export aluminum. [00:54:10] A large portion of aluminum's cost is the pure energy in the form of electricity to refine it, refine that bauxite ore. So, really, aluminum, you know, electric Iceland is using bauxite to transmute their electricity into aluminum. Similarly, Bitcoin uses electricity to transmit that into digital gold. [00:54:31] Then finally, a turdomister told me about this analogy where he said that you know, back in the day out in the West, you know, back in the cowboy days, you know, alcohol was a great method for one pain relief and entertainment, but as well, it was a good way to transmute grains and fruits into something more durable, more divisible, higherly more higher concentration and more use cases. [00:54:58] That's also something that transmutes something larger and something more compressed and usable. Yeah. Yeah, so there's just no, I mean, there's once you sit and think about it and talk through it all, the proof of work is efficient. And it actually is incentivizing more efficient production of energy for energy production companies, and it's also incentivizing sort of a move to you know, like kind of hard distant and hard to reach renewable energy. [00:55:31] And like because just because it makes those those businesses more viable, they have another revenue stream that they can use and you know, survive and actually run their their operation. Yeah, and I think you know, I've largely just had to defend proof of work, but if you if you want to extrapolate what happens in the future, let's say Bitcoin mining is a 200 billion dollar a year or $50 billion a year industry, you've just kind of radically reshaped how the hunt for cheap electricity will look like. [00:56:04] It's a financial incentive to find and generate cheaper and cheaper sources of electricity, which is a net benefit for all humankind. Absolutely. All right, we have a few minutes left. I'm gonna see if we can squeeze these a couple a couple more questions in. Let's talk about institutional investors in Bitcoin. [00:56:23] And I know your company, Pix and Shovels, is focused on building tools for institutional investors. And I saw you tweet a Fidelity report today, a research report, this survey of 400 US institutional investors that said that 22% already have exposure to digital assets, 47% view digital assets as having a place in their portfolios. [00:56:47] And Turtam Easter's Adamant Capital released a report a couple of weeks ago titled Bitcoin and Heavy Accumulation. I know kind of with your position in the industry with picks and shovels, you might have some insight in into this too that that that the rest of us don't have. What's your sense on where institutions are in terms of acquiring Bitcoin? [00:57:09] Yeah, and a quick clarification the company is Pix and Shovels, but our product is called interchange. So I just wanted to make sure that everyone knew that. That can be found in the internet. Yeah, and what and interchange is asset management, crypto asset management? Well, so not not really. What the interchange does is we reconcile portfolio data for large institutional service providers. [00:57:32] So a fund admin is a crypto hedge fund accountant, and what they do is they need to reconcile that crypto hedge funds portfolio data across banks, blockchains, and exchanges. So we wrangle all that data together, sanitize it, standardize it, reconcile it, and enable them to adjust that for their reporting. [00:57:51] Cool. Yeah, yeah. So that's what we do. So it does give us a really good visibility across the space as to what how much interest is coming in and how much money is moving through. You know, I think that we're in a really, really exciting time to where institutions needed certain things built before they could jump in. [00:58:11] They needed institutional grade custody, they needed trading and surveillance engines, surveillance meaning making sure wash trading doesn't occur on these exchanges. They need a better exchange engine throughput, being able to you know handle really, really intense, highly volatile time periods. [00:58:30] They needed different types of financial instruments. So all of these had to be put into place. But the way that I analogize it is that essentially it's like a play where all of the actresses and actors have been put in place, the orchestra has now been put into the pit, the conductor being the market, you know, and the backdrop's been set, the conductor being the market, all it has to do is just start a few key movements and then the play begins. [00:58:59] So right now we're seeing a trickle of institutional interest. I think as these as the play becomes, you know, everything's perfectly put in place, then I think the market will be ready again. And I think that will also probably occur along some catalyst moments. I think 2020 is going to be very exciting because not only do we have a havening event, which is the supply shock event, we also have millions of people looking at all these charts that analysts in the space have created, which essentially indicate that now's a great accumulation period, and people will become more and more confident as Bitcoin's price goes up, that we're through the bear market, [00:59:37] Which will mean more money coming in, and then we have the Havanian event, which decreases the supply. In conjunction with that, I think there's a I don't have any data to back this up, but I think just based on how much time it's taken and just general gut feeling that 2020 seems to be a good year for Bitcoin ETF, which means that now trillions of dollars in 401ks can go by Bitcoin, and that is a massive, huge moment for the space because right now the entire the in Bitcoin's entire run has been a bunch of people wiring money to shady exchanges and buying Bitcoin, and now they can buy it through their Fidelity or TD [01:00:15] Ameritrade or Robin Hood account, which is huge. Magnitudes difference. So I'm I'm really excited. I couldn't be more excited than where we are now. I mean, who the hell knew if Bitcoin was gonna survive back in the day? Especially, I mean 2015 bear market, that was brutal. Bitcoin's price hit 180 dollars. [01:00:36] And I had sold my company you know back in December 2013 when the price was really high, and so definitely had a what what you know wide swing of emotions when it came to seeing the rise and fall of the price. So yeah, that 2017 was my third boom bus cycle because I was also in the one in March 2013 as well. [01:00:58] So, you know, it's I've been through a lot, but I consider Bitcoin's survivability, it survived a civil war, other competing narratives. It's attractiveness as a gold 2.0 for institutional money is fantastic. We'll see if institutional money buys it into the other narratives like world computers. [01:01:17] I'm not sure if those are as appetizing as goal 2.0, especially given the mac the backdrop of potentially a macro world you know sell-off event. Let's say 2020 Bitcoin starting to skyrocket a few times. Let's say Bitcoin goes up 10% three days in a row, and the mainstream markets drop 5%, which would be that's a very big drop. [01:01:37] Then the meme that Bitcoin is the risk-off trade may begin. So everything's lined up, and I'm I'm super bullish super long. Of course I'm a hodler, I'm not a day trader, so you know other people might be able to make more money trading before then, but I'm just gonna hodl. So it I think that's the more you're gonna get a lot more sleep at night. [01:01:58] Let the let the project yeah, enjoy enjoy your life and let Bitcoin let the let Bitcoin do its work for you while you're sleeping and you know spending time with your family and friends and enjoying life. So let's I'm gonna finish with this question. What is a Bitcoin future look like to you in 50 years? [01:02:17] Yeah, so I think my pres I think Bitcoin hitting between 100 trillion and 200 trillion market cap is entirely plausible. I think that future brings around a lot of good things for humankind. One is a realignment of a sent of incentives in the money supply, which I think would drastically impact everything in society from government budgets to how people perceive debt. [01:02:44] I think we have a bad consumerism culture. I'm very much I'm very much a capitalist, but I think our debt-fueled culture has increased our consumerism, which has also increased our sort of depression and unhappiness in life as we try to find purpose in our things rather than you know storing our energy and time into money and using that for more productive things to build product, you know, things that last in the world. [01:03:08] As people know, yeah, a lot of the devices that you buy have planned obsolescence, which means that they decay over time versus a monetary system that's built on top of Bitcoin I think the incentives are better aligned to where things are built to last I think people think more into the future have a lower time preference for their money I think that early Bitcoin accumulators or aka investors or hodlers will be some of the greatest investors of all time they will have dealt to the most volatile asset in human history they will have seen so far into the future that their ability to allocate capital after that point [01:03:46] Into other types of assets that will be very efficient due to their ability to weather volatility and to see large macro trends that take a long time and the way that they built their mental models in order to interpret Bitcoin's success profitability. Yeah I love that hadn't thought about that but Bitcoin is through its volatility is just basically forging great investors of the future and not just giving them the mental models and the kind of wherewithal to be able to withstand that kind of volatility and think long term it's also providing them with the resources [01:04:24] To do that eventually so that's awesome. Yeah hodlers may be the best investors in human history. I love it. That's awesome. It's a great note to end on thanks again for your time man. I'll let you go I know you have other things to get to are you going to be at Bitcoin 2019 out in San Francisco? That's where it's it's in your neck of the woods, right? [01:04:44] Yeah I'll be speaking there I haven't picked my topic yet, but I'm thinking around doing it around Bitcoin security model, which is my next article. Oh, sweet. Awesome. Well, I will be there as well, so I'll I'll seek you out and shake your hand and be good to get to know meet you in person. Yeah, maybe we'll do another podcast over a beer in person. [01:05:04] That'd be amazing. Yeah. I'll I'll try I'm trying to cook something up that get it get a group together that would be a lot of fun, I think. So maybe I'll reach out to you. All right, man. I appreciate it. Take care and talk to you next time. Thanks for having me. Cheers. Bye. [01:05:26] All right, that was a good time. Let me and Dan know what you thought about that discussion and any questions that might have arisen for you. You can ask us on Twitter. Dan is at Dan Held at D A N H E L D. And I am at Citizen Bitcoin. And one last reminder, plea to log into iTunes and rate and review the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. [01:05:49] If you are still listening, you probably enjoyed the episode. And it would be a huge difference to me and to the visibility of the podcast if you just take a minute and leave a five-star review and a rating is is bonus points. So thanks if you can do that for me. And that's it for this episode. [01:06:09] Until next time, take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world,