Energy Usage, Time Preference, Petro and Telegram Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2018-02-24 [00:00:00] Welcome back to Citizen Bitcoin, the show where we help you along the path to becoming a sovereign citizen of Bitcoin. I'm Brady. I'm Tommy. And we're back here for episode number five. Wow, five episodes. That's a nice number. [00:00:15] We got a week and we're just we're happy to be at five. We didn't know it. [00:00:19] We just keep going along. The other thing that's pretty good is in terms of coming up with topics. There's never a shortage of topics together. Oh my god, never a shortage of topics when talking about Bitcoin. That's especially when you're just talking once a week. So all right. Well, let's dive into it. You can follow us on Twitter at Citizen Bitcoin. We're also on Medium at Citizen Bitcoin, though I think we're gonna be moving that to Steamit. [00:00:39] That's correct. Why we gotta embrace the crypto. So we're gonna move from medium to steam it. We'll let you all know when that happens. We've also, in addition to the YouTube show, are starting to publish the audio only on as a podcast. So we're now listed on the iTunes podcast catalog. [00:00:58] You can also find us at wherever your whatever wherever your podcast app is. You can listen to the show in your ears only, and we'll be conscious about making sure that yeah, we'll have to pay more attention to make sure we repeat things and not use the cr crotchroid of the of the screen, right? So we'll we'll make an attempt to improve on that. [00:01:19] I'm a big podcast listener myself, so we'll make sure that we get you guys. All right, so jumping straight into this week's news. All right. So Francis Pouliot, who is a Canadian Bitcoiner. He runs a Bitcoin company called Cadillac in in Quebec. [00:01:39] And he has been appearing lately on the World Crypto Network Bitcoin Talk Show. Real smart guy, very thoughtful, and really been enjoying following his his tweets as well. Last on the last Bitcoin talk show, he was talking about how Quebec has a bunch of excess unused hydro power renewable electricity. [00:02:05] That just goes to waste. And let's just read this tweet really quickly. Bitcoin mining thrives on transforming illiquid-wasted electricity in parents already produced, close parent, costly, hard to transport, and unpredictable in supply. For example, hydro, wind, and solar into liquid, censorship resistant, digital gold. [00:02:27] You can private export, transform energy into money, which the basic thing would be transforming energy into Bitcoin, for example. Right. So he gives some examples where so one of the one of the downsides of renewable energy, or one of the difficulties is that it's constantly being produced, right? [00:02:46] Or or not constantly being produced, right? It's well when it is being produced, it's right. When it is being produced, you can't humans don't have control over the wind or when the sun's shining or the clouds are that kind of thing, right? So but we do have control over you know, making the analogy. And the other thing, too, just to right to summarize on that bitcoin mining makes renewable energy cheaper. [00:03:08] Build a hydro dam, wind farm, solar farm. You're producing electricity unpredictably according to random elements, inconsistent demand plus inconsistent supply plus centralized grid equals terrible cost inefficiencies. Yeah, electric electricity supply is illiquid. Right. [00:03:26] So this is what I was saying, right? So the renewable electricity supply is is illiquid, inconsistent demand, plus you have inconsistent supply coming in. Like I said, you don't know when the clouds are gonna come out or when it's gonna you know not rain for a few months and you're and your hydropower goes down. Plus you have a centralized grid, so it's hard to transport some of that renewable energy far away as well. [00:03:49] So there's inefficiency. Well while it happens, if you have if you have a mining capacity, cryptocurrency mining capacity, when you have those situations where there's excess, you can immediately take it and can convert it into something usable, right? As opposed to just having the electricity just yeah, it has to go somewhere, dissipate in the atmosphere just dissipates, and this whole concept of storage, which we can get into later, but the idea is expensive and hard. [00:04:16] Storage is very, very you know expensive as well. Yeah, when you're talking at like you know hydro dam or hydropown levels of electricity, that's a lot of batteries, and it's getting gets pretty expensive to store that stuff. And that's a completely different discussion for for later. You can store it as Bitcoin, you can store that energy as Bitcoin. So you can use that energy to mine Bitcoin, and then you have this asset, liquid asset out of that surplus energy. [00:04:40] So this is happening. And this this is why China became so popular as a mining center because there's lots of excess renewable energy supply there as well. In particular, hydro hydro dams. And so you have a situation where there's a huge amount of capacity, like we're talking about for electricity that was converted into crypto. [00:05:00] Right. Now you have a situation is this gonna come up further with Quebec and Iceland, or can I cover that now? Go ahead, yeah. Yeah, so the other idea is you got a situation right now where Iceland actually has indicated that they're they're they'd be fine with they are fine with mining crypto there. In addition, Quebec said the same thing. [00:05:20] Yeah, and what we're ultimately getting to is there's some of the arguments that are being made just in the general public, and it's just like a hundred percent just Bitcoin is bad, it eats up all this electricity. So therefore it's bad. And then the comparison is to go ahead at a top level and say, it's as much as this particular, you know, the entire country of France or the entire, you know, and the idea of oh my god, it's just terrible, when you actually have a situation where there's excess capacity, and from that standpoint, it's actually utilizing the electricity properly, putting people to work and not wasting it. [00:05:56] So it's the exact opposite of what people are talking about. And it's incentivizing the production of renewable energy. Correct. All right, next. A couple of ICOs that we thought were noteworthy to talk about today. Normally we don't cover ICOs, but these are two big ones, and we can use them to kind of talk about some of the more generic general risks with ICOs. [00:06:15] But this is the very first national cryptocurrency. Venezuelas creating a petro token called the Petro Token because supposedly it's backed by a Venezuela's oil reserves. It's centralized and it sounds good, but the bottom line is that our vote on this is no. [00:06:33] It's I mean, any type of. You can do your own due diligence or whatever, but just our our vote on this is just don't do it. It's if you don't have a decentralization, which we talked about in depth on the last episode, it's not a cryptocurrency in our opinion. And you basically just say goodbye to a lot of the benefits that come with decentralized cryptocurrency. [00:06:56] But anyway, it's very interesting. We are going to probably see other nations follow suit over the over the ensuing years as we go through this Bitcoin and fiat currency sort of battle and transformation so the petroleus headline here, just so we get for the for the podcast yeah the petro hasn't raised a dime yeah so I don't know if we should use dime or I mean I th I guess we're kind of mixing right but anyway dime yeah the point is that there's all this news that the Petro is launched a peso or but anyway it hasn't hasn't done anything hasn't raised any money yet and apparently there's lots of problems with the official website [00:07:34] That was launched for the pre-sale so this is coming from the crack Krakus Chronicles and apparently the word from people inside the country who are interested in this token which is built by the way on the NEM blockchain NEM which is a top 10 cryptocurrency it's a platform so anyway it's apparently had a rather unimpressive launch at this point so that's what we know about the Petro and we'll continue to follow it and mention it if it does anything interesting or important. [00:08:12] The other ICO we want to talk about today is the Telegram ICO which you may have heard about it's raising gajillions of dollars. Yeah we also just so we're clear on this one too is that we vote no we've decided before the show we vote no on this one also. It's another centralized corporate coin. I mean it's it's not it's not something interesting. It is basically it's it's a way for Telegram to raise a bunch of money without going through the you know the stock market explained it's pretty clever for the sponsors the sponsors being the people surrounding the company and also the backers because they have a situation where they're they're receiving better benefits out of this deal than other [00:08:50] People that are there that are that are getting involved. In other words, that we'll get additional compensation we'll just use the term additional compensation as part of this, as opposed to it being unit per unit compensation here on this deal. So there's going to be a public sale of the Telegram tokens. But what has happened so far is an $850 million pre-sale, meaning VCs and other accredited investors have put in $850 million, valuing the token so far at around 43 cents. [00:09:21] And the estimation is that they're going to raise another $1.15 billion to come to two a clean $2 billion from a public sale. And that would bring the price of the token up to about $1.43. So all of these accredited investors and VCs have come in and bought at $43 cents. [00:09:41] And the public sale will take that value from 43 cents up to about $1.43 cents per token. Most likely. [00:09:50] So this is all based on information. So the idea is what do we mean about all this? Well, first of all, it's it's centralized, it's not not anywhere near it. It's not really a mining concept. Well, it's a token. [00:10:02] But the idea is, as far as how we're looking at this, is that it kind of ties into earlier shows. You've got to be very careful. We're going to get more into ICOs, but our view on this particular deal, unless you're the VC guy that is doing it, [00:10:17] I mean, if you're one of the VC guys, I'd be all in on this deal. I mean, that's fantastic. This is this is because you basically have no downside in the way this is lined out, which is just genius, right? I think it's fantastic. This is basically no difference than an from an IPO, right? All right. This is this is a quote by Charlie Biel Bill Bilel Bielo Bilello, and he's a manager of inflation rotation fund. [00:10:43] He does a he's a director of research at pension partners. He does a really nice job in the macro markets, particularly as it relates to bonds and you know also equities and just generally macro. But what this says is at zero percent, Bitcoin has a higher two-year yield than government bonds in 16 countries. [00:11:05] So right now, if you've got Swiss two-year bonds, it's the yield is negative point eight three percent. What does that mean? That means actually you get a bill that you have to you have to pay pay for holding those bonds? [00:11:24] For holding those bonds, or when you originally start with it, you pay you have to end up paying paying the actual negative amount on that. So the countries, and I'll just say them really quickly Switzerland, Netherlands, Finland, Germany, Austria, Belgium, Sweden, Ireland, France, Denmark, Slovakia, Spain, Slovenia, Japan, Italy, Portugal. [00:11:48] So basically Europe and Japan. Negative bond yields. All right. So anyway, that and if you just think about that if you're living in this if you live in one of those countries and you're holding government bonds, you'd be better off with Bitcoin for a lot of reasons, not least, or well, certainly not most of which is but the b the bottom line is is it it it throws everything kind of on its head, right? [00:12:09] I mean, did you ever you ever think of a situation where you give somebody money and then you pay them to hold your money? Right, and then we'll just leave it at that. Of course, we're not financial advisors, which we have we should mention on on every show. No, we're not. No, this is a good thing. But these are a man's concept, it just doesn't. You could you could take you know somebody that's not very old and maybe third grade math, and they could figure out pretty yeah, third grade math, that's where you learn arithmetic, right? [00:12:36] You could just third graders, you could teach them that that pretty quickly. That's not very smart. Yeah, so kind of related to that. Saefadine Amus has a tweet thread that is pretty interesting. This guy's basically he's really really good. He's a Bitcoin Max. [00:12:56] Maximalist. He's also Austrian school. He's got a really good what's the name of his book? He's got it down here, Bitcoin Standard. Bitcoin standard, which is a book. We've read it just came out. We'll we'll also that's something I need to read. It's on my list. I'm waiting for it to come out on Audible. Very good, very good reviews. We would actually, just based on what we know about him so far, we would actually recommend that book. [00:13:19] Yeah, he and he's worth following for sure. But this is a interesting thread. He's one of our favorites. Talks about money that appreciates in value, like Bitcoin, and money that depreciates in value like most or if not all fiat currencies at this point. He gives the example of the computer industry having been the victim of decades of deflation that Keynesians, which is John Maynard Keynes, and the sort of antithesis economic approach to Austrian economics. [00:13:52] It the it's the justification, the basis for quantitative easing for printing a lot more money as a way to get out of an economic crisis. And so he says, why would anyone buy a 10-megabyte hard drive for 3500 bucks in 1980 when they can just wait 30 years and you can buy it for pennies and it's the size of a thumbnail, right? [00:14:12] That is is ridiculous because obviously people have been buying computers for all of those years, right? And the reason is that humans have a high time preference in general, right? Which means that people prefer present over future consumption. Like we don't want to delay the gratification. And that's mainly because you know, we're we're mortal, we're gonna die at some point, the future is uncertain, so we want to consume now, not later for the most part, right? [00:14:38] And so he goes on to talk about how money that depreciates in value over time, like like fiat currency, which let's say he he mentions here as an example, a currency that depreciates three percent per year means that it will its value will cut in half in 23 years, right? [00:14:56] So you're kind of incentivized to have an even higher time preference, right? You're incentivized to borrow money for major expenses and live and live your life in debt. That's that's the economic behavior incentivizes. Whereas in a world where we have money that appreciates three percent per year, it would double in 23 years. [00:15:15] The value of our money would double in 23 years. So it would it would not eliminate human high time preference, but it would tend to lower it a little bit. People would save more because that money's gonna go up in value, and they wouldn't spend so frivolously. We'd have a more sustainable, right sustainable growth as opposed to sort of like debt-driven mania growths and lots of kind of ups and downs. [00:15:36] Well, it's just it's really simplistic from the standpoint of like a savings account. It used to be when I had a paper audit, you know, and understand just this is completely anecdotal, but you could go down to the Passbook Savings account and you'd actually get interest. You could look in there and see that you're actually earning interest on your on your money, and you'd see it would grow, and you'd say, Well, I'm not sure exactly what I'm gonna do with the money right now, but I know if I put it in my savings account, I'll I'll get more money from that. [00:16:00] Well, right now, I mean, you put it somebody goes and puts it in a savings account. It's kind of like, first of all, they're probably going to charge you if you do something wrong. They're not going to be very kind to you. They're probably going to charge you to open it up, and it's kind of like, well, annual feature. I'm better off just spending the money. Why even bother with even trying to save it because it's it's actually a detriment. [00:16:18] Yeah. So an important concept to think about and consider when valuing Bitcoin versus fiat currency. And here is Ansel Lindner, who has also a good follow on Twitter and has a great podcast called Bitcoin and Markets that I recommend you check out if you're into podcasts. [00:16:37] And he kind of summarizes it here. If Tom, you want to read it? He says sound money is a true risk-free rate of return. Post hyper bitcoinization, the value of Bitcoin will increase with global productivity. Right. All their investments will have to compete with the three to five percent appreciation of Bitcoin, incentivizing sustainable growth and financial literacy. [00:17:01] Right now, understanding this is Ansel's theory, right? Yep. And it yeah, so anyway, I thought it was a good sum-up of Sayyidine's thread here. So, all right, next. Preeti Cassie Reddy, Cassaretti, had a great tweet that we wanted to share with everyone. Umineer, has some very good situation she puts up on Twitter. [00:17:26] So she says, we need to stop calling blockchains just as some new technology instead, think of them as movements. And she lists five movements. So movements from a centralized world to a decentralized world, from a world of nations to a world of sovereignty, personal sovereignty, a world that's coordinated, to a world that is collaborative, from a world that's regulated to a world that's self-enforcing, from a world that's opaque to a world that's more transparent. [00:17:54] And all of these, all of these movements are enforced or you know, sped up or made possible by the use of Bitcoin. I thought that was really. We like that. We both actually retweeted that without we when we had the show, we didn't realize we both liked that and it came up again for the show, so we decided why not? [00:18:17] Yep. Alright, Monday was President's Day, a banking holiday in the United States. Right, and it's actually the combination of Abe Lincoln's birthday, right? February 12th. George Washington. George Washington February 22nd, which was actually yesterday. So It was on Monday. James and Lop, a bank holiday. [00:18:36] A Bitcoin core engineer, engineer at BitGo, a cypherpunk and all-around kind of Twitter thought leader, Bitcoin thought leader, posted up that today's a holiday in America, the banks and markets have closed. Meanwhile, Bitcoin soldiers on with over one billion transmitted and seven billion traded today. [00:18:57] And Bitcoin Uptime.com shows that the Bitcoin network has been functional 99.992086, 890% of the time since the inception on January 3rd of 2009. So that's over nine years now. The Bitcoin network has been up basically 100% of the time. [00:19:15] Yeah, we'll just do a little plug because we've talked about it before, but the concept of the Lindy effect, right? And as it relates to non-perishable or technology and the I the and the idea is is that the longer something is in place, the likelihood of it continuing in in blocks, you know, or of time go going forward is is increases or or is gr is greater the longer it's been around. [00:19:39] So and so Bitcoin's been around a little over nine years. I think even the second oldest cryptocurrency, like Dogecoin is you know, the second oldest cryptocurrency that's still like actually active is I think Dogecoin's maybe seven years old, getting close to seven years old. So yeah, it's got at least two years on basically every cryptocurrency and seven or eight on on most of them that exist. [00:20:02] So all right, so I thought I would you know this take this for yeah, this is the history of Bitcoin from 2009 to 2018 on a YouTube here. We're gonna cover a little bit on this right now. So yeah, this is just I thought it would it would go well with talking about how Bitcoin's been around for nine years. [00:20:22] Sure. And another one of Bitcoin's network effects that helps separate it from the re from the crowd, right? Which is the quality and size of the development community that is has been building and supporting Bitcoin for the past nine years. And this is you know, a federation that's of developers that's sort of loosely connected through lots of different organizations through the internet's using GitHub, they collaborate and so forth. [00:20:52] There is no central, you know, group that is responsible for coding Bitcoin. But this is a great visualization on the birth of Bitcoin here, way back in the day, and you can see back in two October 2009. [00:21:11] Here's the stand-in for Satoshi Nakamoto right here. And one of the other early Bitcoin developers. And as we I mean, the whole visualization takes 10 minutes. It's about it's about a minute per year, but I'll just kind of jump forward and you can see that there's been a lot more people coming on coming onto the project. [00:21:31] For the people on the podcast, it's a situation where if you're interested, we'll have it in the show links and you can actually pull it. [00:21:37] It's about 10 minutes. And what it's showing is just the exp the expansion and growth of Bitcoin through the time period. It's actually pretty cool. It's a cool visualization. Well, of course, we think it's cooler, we wouldn't have it on the show, but it but even having said that it we think it's pretty cool. But you can see the advancement of the complexity of the structure of Bitcoin itself and there's just the number of people that have you know been contributing to the other. [00:22:02] The other thing that's important about this too is when you visualize this and look like look at this, you under it helps understand the underlying protocol and infrastructure of Bitcoin, you know, as it relates to from a top-down standpoint. Some people like within the last month or so, some people being the Bitcoin dinosaurs coming out and saying Bitcoin's done, you know, there's nothing there, and looking at it strictly as as a currency with no underlying type of robustness. [00:22:33] So thank you to all of the brilliant engineers, coders, developers out there who have donated time and energy and expertise to the development of Bitcoin. All of us hodlers. The other thing that happens with this video is it shows the updates on the new releases on Bitcoin too as it goes through an ad. [00:22:54] So we'll have a link to that. You can check it out and look at it a little bit more closely, but it's it's interesting to watch the different players come in and out of the game over the years and watch the code base grow. Cool. So let me pause that before we move on. Alright, next. One quick note that I wanted to give to everyone out there, and I was just kind of giddy when I found this. [00:23:17] It was late Christmas morning. Nick Szabo, who is well, I don't even know how to describe him. He's maybe he's old-time cypherpunk from way back in the day. Coined the term smart contracts, wrote about the idea of smart contracts in the late 90s, developed what is the precursor of Bitcoin called Bit Gold in 2007. [00:23:40] And Bitcoin was obviously based a lot on his ideas and thinking. So he's sort of a mentor of mine and somebody who I who I admire. Right, likewise. Well, and then and so what he what he put together here is is an archive of research and writings. [00:23:58] Yeah, Nick didn't put it together himself actually. Nick didn't put this together, but it's extraordinary but he's he tweeted it out. Yeah, he didn't put it together. Okay, yeah, there's a link here. Anyway, it's it's Oh, I see a lot of reading, lots of history here to go through. Super interesting. And I can't wait to dive in. [00:24:16] There's a wide vr wide variety. And then it's also chronological. It also has, and for example, let's see, Cyberpunk mailing list, notable people, notable events, notable organizations, notable projects, and so on. So it's just the history of cypherpunks and they're thinking going back to the 70s and link for that as well. [00:24:38] So yeah, check that out. All right, let's take a quick look at the price. All right, here we go. We gotta we gotta see what's going on with with Brady's rockets. Oh, yeah, the rocket. Oh, well, since we started the show, Bitcoin prices down a couple hundred bucks, back below 10,000. So we had a sell-off here. There's no rockets this week. When we're gonna get to the rockets there, Tommy. [00:24:56] I'm not gonna disappoint you like that. So you can see that we this wick touched almost perfectly on this horizontal resistance line that we had dropped. So we knew that there was gonna be resistance here. The question was how is the price going to respond once we hit this level? The answer is in. We got rejected pretty hard pretty soundly from that from that level. [00:25:16] There's a sell off. We're looking to stay above this. So you're teaching me here, are we looking at another, what is that called? A cup and handle. Yeah, we talked about last week about a cup and handle. So this idea there's a cup here. Once you reach back to this previous high, right, where there was previous resistance. Sure. You'll get that resistance again. [00:25:35] There'll be another sell-off, and then what happens at this point, turn it into the formation of a cup and handle is a rally after a short sell-off and a handle forming. Oh, you said it right there again. That was good. So now we're gonna look for Bitcoin's price to stay above this red line. This ascending line here, break out of this finally after after another try, maybe go up and then break out of this descending line that goes back a couple of months at this point, and move on up from there. [00:26:05] And again, hit resistance at these particular levels, and maybe what will happen is something that looks sort of like excuse me. Something that's sort of like up resistance, down, support. Because previous previous resistance tends to become new support. So resistance, new support. [00:26:24] Alright, we'll try it again, breakthrough the second time, resistance, new support, try it again, break through the second time, resistance, new support, and so forth, and kind of work its way up over the next couple of months. Okay. Alright, and so the rocket path that we talked about last week. All right. Has a similar idea, except I didn't draw in dips back down to previous resistance. [00:26:47] I just kind of drew in a horizontal resistance here. And you can see what's happened is we've gone up and down. So this rocket is definitely fallen out of the air and basically exploded. And has too good, but it's not too bad. It's not too bad. You still have time because it's you got many, we got quite a few days before that other that other rocket. [00:27:06] We got about a week. I love this rocket too. We got a we got about a week to get up here. So anyway, we'll we'll take a look at it again and we'll see if I just like to tease them you guys a little bit, okay. Optimistic rocket path works out or not. Alright, well, we were gonna get into some other stuff, but I think we're up, we're at time. [00:27:24] We'll save it for we'll save it for another week. Yep, and I think like we said, we yeah, we covered quite a bit, and then if anybody ever wants anything they want us to cover, just let us know. Rate and review on iTunes, if you're into the podcast thing, subscribe and leave us a comment on YouTube if you're into that. [00:27:43] Check us out on Twitter. I'm Brady at B Swin. I'm Tommy at Canon's Call. And we are Citizen Bitcoin. Thanks so much for joining us, and we'll see you next week. See you next week. Thank you.