1 Year Retrospective and HASH WARS! Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2018-11-16 [00:00:15] Hello, hello, hello, and welcome back to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady. I'm Tommy. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're here sharing our journey, learning Bitcoin. Hoping that it makes your journey a bit easier. We are back in the church, Tommy. This is the second episode recorded at the of the church sessions of the Citizen Bitcoin. [00:00:38] Pretty good sound here, right? Yeah, it sounds alright. [00:00:40] It's comfortable here. Yeah, it is. We are in the basement of a church in Lawrence, Kansas, where Tommy resides. [00:00:48] Well, former church, I should say, now Tommy's home. And we're we sat here for a couple hours before we pressed the record button because we've been caught up in the Bcash drama. Those guys are just going at each other, committing mutual suicide or homicide or I don't know what's going on, but it doesn't look good at this moment. [00:01:08] I don't think the first block has been mined, but Yeah, so one of they were that we're targeted to go it's been what we're how long into it? Yeah, it's we're we're following along. It's you know the I don't think the first block has been mined on separate chains yet. I think they just mined a block that was on the same chain. So that I don't think the split has occurred yet, but it will at any moment. [00:01:29] Kind of keeping an eye on that in the background while we talk. Yeah, and we decided to do that as part of the podcast, wait for that as something to add in to what we're doing, that the fork just kind of cover it while we're doing this podcast. Yeah, so we'll talk a little bit about Bcash and share an article by our friend guy at the Crypto Economy podcast. [00:01:48] Wrote a great article about Bcash looking at the forks and its history and you know its potential future. So we'll share a bit about that. And also this is our 20th episode, Tommy that's right so we thought we'd talk a little bit about yeah we just our journey yeah and we just started by one by one in terms of doing these episodes and part of Brady and I doing these episodes was for us to study and learn and the idea being and I don't know if it's Richard Feynman that said there's somebody similar that the way that you learn is is to teach because if you can't teach it and explain it you don't really know it. [00:02:25] So the idea for each episode is we'd study up and then kind of go from there and then also when we didn't know we basically try to say we don't know. So yeah it is a great way to learn and that's why we started recording them. You know we kind of came into Bitcoin early last year so early 2017 we've been studying Bitcoin for well over a year and a half now getting closer to two years and started recording our conversations I think the first episode was in January this year, right? [00:02:55] Mm-hmm. And we started posting only on YouTube and the first three episodes three episodes are only on YouTube and then we tried out the podcast thing the podcast had a lot more traction than YouTube so we just started doing podcast only. But yeah we've we've covered a lot we've learned a lot what are some of the what I'd like to do for the for the for everybody that maybe is new or just to kind of is just to go through the episodes and what we've covered and just kind of quickly do it. [00:03:25] But I just we've got them titled and so the first episode we did was on Weiss ratings, lightning. And then this was also tied with a with a blog post also, but just understanding Bitcoin vis a vis-a-vis gold and vis a v fiat, which was US dollars in terms of an explanation as to the similarities and differences, primarily the differences with with well actually both. [00:03:50] But so that was the first episode. And Brady, jump in here as we go through. But I just this is pretty extensive once I look at this here. The episode two was tether, the technological S curve, which is Metcalf's law, right? In terms of or is that no not Metcalf? [00:04:08] I don't think so. I don't think they're the same thing. So Metcalf's law is the value of a network. The network network effects. I'm tying the S curve with the network effects. But anyway, it's similar, they're they're related to related, but not specifically the same. But the idea of the technological S curve is that technologies are adopted following sort of an S curve, and it's been demonstrated with many technologies, but especially network based technologies. [00:04:31] Yeah. Hardware wallets. Episode three was the banking committee and crypto hearings at that time there were there were hearings in in in this US base in terms of what was going on with crypto crypto assets. Is that when we had John Giancarlo? John Carlo. [00:04:49] Giancarlo, our hero, and his and he talked about his daughter owning Bitcoin, right? And yeah, so that was that was that was a fun day. Right. So jumping to episode we'll kind of moving through here just so we don't get just to kind of touch on these, but episode four was mining bullish, Bitcoin dinosaurs, and lightning network. [00:05:09] Oh, yeah, Bitcoin dinosaurs. That was fun. This is actually a really good episode because what we did is we went through all the times and the values were certain experts and quotes or status said that Bitcoin was dead, and we walked through all of them. I mean, some were as low as eighty dollars. [00:05:28] There was some that were like a matter of cents, weren't they? Yeah, there was somebody like Nurial got in there so early. Yeah, Nurial Muriel Rubini, and then the you know, he he was in early declaring it dead, which he continues to do to this day. And then we also well there were several in there, but there was there were some death declarations yesterday when we went down a thousand bucks in in value per coin. [00:05:53] Yeah, we may touch on the price just to g just a little bit later in the episode. If we have time, we may touch on the price in terms of the technical dynamics a little bit. So episode five was energy usage, the concept of time preference, petro and telegram. Mm-hmm. Those are all very important topics. And the petro, we you know, we weighed in on that in terms of the skepticism with respect to the shit coin centrality. [00:06:19] Time preference. I mean, let's just kind of review this is like this will be a good way to kind of review what we've learned along the way and what's happened over the past year. But the idea of time preference is really important concept to understand. I think one thing that's really great about Bitcoin is helping people learn about the idea of time preference. [00:06:37] Having a low time preference means that you're willing to spend money now and forgo it later. Right. Well, the other part too, the example of the and this is I believe it's in the Bitcoin standard or or the marshmallow test, which is you put a kid in a room that obviously they have to love marshmallows, most kids do, but let's say you put a six-year-old in a room and say, Here here's a mar here's a marshmallow. [00:07:01] If you can wait for 15 minutes, when we're done, you'll get two marshmallows. Right. So the idea of time preference is somebody has a t high time preference, the kid's gonna eat the marshmallow right away, and at the end of it, he doesn't get a second. A low time preference would be patiently waiting and then getting two two marshmallows at the end. Oh, right. I had it wrong the first time. Yeah. [00:07:19] It's the other way around. So high time preferences right now, and low time preferences, willing to willing to wait. Time isn't really a big deal. Right. And earn more later on, right? And so Bitcoin and deflationary monies encourage a lower time preference. Correct. Than patience. Than inflationary, you know, credit-based fiat currencies, right? [00:07:39] So that's an important concept for sure. Yeah, so that so that takes us now. We're we're at episode six, March 14th. We there were two articles they were opposing, which we covered. One was Bitcoin is ridiculous, bock chain is dangerous, and then the other other article was the bullish case for Bitcoin. So yeah, BJ Boyapati's great article on the bullish case for Bitcoin. [00:08:01] Yeah, and we so we juxtaposed the two of those. It wasn't the Bitcoin is dangerous article was in a mainstream publication too, right? Like Forbes or something. Yeah, and it was pretty easy to well, at least in our opinion, it was pretty easy to rebuff that one. In fact, it was it was like a layup to use basketball terms and terms article. A lot of that, I mean that mainstream FUD about Bitcoin, you know, the fear uncertainty, doubt type content that's out there is almost always just very shallow understanding of what's really going on. [00:08:33] So it's I remember being pretty encouraged by being able to just rebut those those arguments so easily because we had you know learned enough to understand. It was so awesome that we found it that it was actually it was a lot of fun, actually. Which most of the stuff is is we enjoyed, or we wouldn't be doing it. [00:08:54] Episode seven, the Bitcoin standard, Bitcoin scaling and side chains, and the whole point here is is that Safadin Amus's book, The Bitcoin Standard, which we highly recommend as a fundamental foundation. It's a it's a it's a trate, right? [00:09:13] Or even more than that, right? Yeah. Yeah. It it's it's an important read for sure. And one of the foundational books of understanding what Bitcoin is for especially from the economic perspective, and then you could read mastering Bitcoin for the technical side. Or the Internet of Money Volumes One and Two, also get into the technical side more. [00:09:32] I would recommend the internet the Internet of Money Volumes One and Two for more for people who are non non technical people. There's a kind of a laid laid description of the technical side of Bitcoin. Mastering Bitcoin definitely gets into the weeds. If you're a technical person, read that for sure. Yeah, and we've been talking a lot this year about Bitcoin scaling and last year the fork off in August from Bitcoin Cash, the large block approach versus Bitcoin, the smaller block, more conservative, no hard fork approach to scaling, with SegWit and a layer two solution lightning network and other potential layer two solutions. [00:10:08] We've seen that happen you know throughout this year, Lightning Network developing, segueed adoption increasing, and here we are down the road from the first hard fork. You know. If you have a protocol that was born from a hard fork and has a bunch of users and believers who believe that hard forking is the right way to upgrade a protocol, then you're just gonna continue to get hard forks on a regular basis. [00:10:36] And in fact, that's what they that's their their plan roadmap for upgrading the protocol. And here today we have a contentious check in see what's going on with with this B cache. Yeah looks like there's been some blocks mined. There's a there's a split in the in the chains now. [00:10:55] So we've had the first block mined by the S V. Which is Satoshi's vision. That's Craig Wright. Craig Wright's and then we got the other side which is ABC which is Roger Veer, right? Roger Veer is citing on the A B C. So what happens to B cash when this splits, so you'll have ABC, S V, I'm just talking hypothetically. [00:11:18] Yeah, those will be the two main What happens to B cash original. So I don't know if who will claim the BCH ticker symbol. They're gonna fight over it. So maybe we'll have two different ticker symbols now. I've seen B S Oh so what happens is is that in this I'm just also doing this because I don't know and I and for people listening. [00:11:38] So what put potentially happens is you got ABC and S V is as is the fork are going into this two. So what would happen is is is BCH or the original bit cache would go with one of those? Yeah I think so yeah so I think separate. Yeah I it I don't know exactly how it's gonna play out. [00:11:58] I mean if I think that the implementation that ends up winning the most I guess I mean well the B cachers will say the implementation that has the most hash power should win. Because they're they're basically this is good. No, that makes sense to me. [00:12:17] I mean, they're they're basically it's part of the reason why we did the podcast during this, we were able to today. So yeah, they're basically of a of the mind that that miners you know can basically dictate the path the upgrade path of Bitcoin or Bitcoin Cash in this case, and that they should be able to, and that was kind of one of their one of their ideas. [00:12:39] And then the USAF, the user activate or the UASF, sorry, the user-activated soft fork was a pushback against that idea that no miners are not completely in control of how we upgrade Bitcoin. Users who run nodes, validate validating nodes, are have a voice and have a say, and they united against the miners and the businesses, and eventually won because their point being the user activated software crew, their point was that miners want to mine the chain that users want to use, right? [00:13:13] They want to mine that they want to go where the where the economic activity is. And that's what the beautiful thing about Nakamoto consensus and this idea of a shelling point, right? Which is where we arrive through the dynamic of the system at an agreement on what Bitcoin is, it is so important, so beautiful. [00:13:33] It's it's so it works. And so the UASF showed that there was a shelling point that that process involved the validating nodes. And the B cachers say that validating nodes are worthless and that only miners really have an impact because they have the hash rate. [00:13:52] Right. And so now what we see is this this whole idea that they they've developed is called the hash wars. Today's the hash wars, right? And so Craig Wright and Bitcoin SV, they are bringing hash power to the network, and they have nodes that are you know running on crazy big expensive machines so that they can mine massive blocks and push out try to overwhelm overwhelm, right? [00:14:18] Roger and ABC. Right. And that's obviously a much more centralized vision of the shelling point process, the Nakamoto consensus process. Right. I you know, so they the I should say correct, not right. I meant R-I-G-H-T, but not but correct. [00:14:36] Yeah, so all right. So what what all right? So there's that that I think that was important, so it's great. So we're up to we covered episode eight, we covered basis and stable coins, hodl waves, and global global fiat debt record. In fact, the fact that that kept we reached a global fiat debt record in April 2018. [00:15:00] Talked about stable coins, yeah, and those hodl waves. I remember that that was pretty it was a cool graphical representation of how of people hodling Bitcoin over time, especially during bear cycles and then spending it or trading it away during during bull cycles. Right. And then the next episode we covered Ethereum. [00:15:19] Is it a secure is it secure? And the idea of that episode actually, what we what we took the position on in terms of this is part of a process of how we how we look at this and learning this is we took the position that that you could argue it you could argue it either way, and it could possibly come out either way. [00:15:39] And jump in here, Brady. But our our fundamental position was that if you really look at it, it it is a security in terms of the way it was. Yeah, and this was before the SEC came out and said that they declared it not a security. Not a security, but our position was hey, it can go either way. And if you were gonna ask us in terms of how we would define it, and it's really because it was a pre mine. [00:16:00] Yeah, it was centralized under the Ethereum Foundation. I would say it was certainly a security at the time it was born and created. The SEC argument was that yes, it probably was a security, but then it became decentralized, and at the moment is you know decentralized enough to not be a security. [00:16:21] The other thing too, just to recall, right, is there was a significant amount of lobbying and pressure from Silicon Valley because they made they're heavily invested, right? They were completely they they completely went with Ethereum from the standpoint of our underlying a lot of their projects. [00:16:40] So at least that was our our opinion. And then, you know, in in the question, is it secure? You know, we talked about the fact that it's Turing complete smart contract platform, meaning that there's you can run loops in your scripts on Ethereum, and that introduces a lot of much more attacks, what we call an attack surface or or the chance for error or major problems would be much greater with a Turing complete scripting language on a blockchain like that. [00:17:17] And sure enough, I mean it didn't take long for it to happen. The DAO, the decentralized autonomous organization that was raising thirty million dollars for the by the Ethereum Foundation, basically when Ethereum launched, that smart contract was hacked, and that's when Ethereum decided to roll back the chain. [00:17:39] And so it's not it's not immutable. [00:17:42] They incurred that moral hazard when they decided to roll back the chain. [00:17:47] And so anyway, there's just that those major, major differences between Ethereum and Bitcoin, especially if you're looking to build a global economy on the back of a trusted money. [00:17:57] You don't want to have, this is why Satoshi- [00:18:01] It has to be completely above reproach. Meaning the case with Bitcoin right now is that it it's it's never been there's never been any type of issue with respect to this. Yeah. And understanding it it within a specific exchange having nothing to do with underlying Bitcoin. There have been hacks, but it didn't have anything to do with Bitcoin itself. [00:18:24] Right. So we did Ethereum. Well we did Ethereum in the next one, reading the technical foundation of Bitcoin maximalism, which you which is something that that that was done. Oh yeah, that's that was an episode that I did when you were in New York and we couldn't get a connection, right? That was good. Yeah, so I read through three Twitter threads that described the technical foundation of Bitcoin maximalism, which is essentially that network protocols tend toward one, which we talk about a lot on this podcast, right? [00:18:52] TCP IP still talk about that. One you want to be on the you want to use a network protocol that everyone else is using, network effects, Metcaps' law, all that, so it tends toward one. And if there's gonna be one winner, and then you just need to answer the question all right, who's ahead? Who's win who's gonna win? Who's most likely to win? And then you have your own, you know, an easy way to make your investment choice if you're looking at cryptocurrencies to buy. [00:19:16] So and then the next this is episode 11 was EOS, Bcash, Lightning, and Satoshi's place. Satoshi's place, yeah. And well, the main thing we were saying at this point about Bcash is is just and it's just in the in the summary is that our research showed that ten times more B cash coins are hottled than spent. [00:19:38] Right. Whereas with Bitcoin spending versus hodling is a one to one. So what that would say to you is is that Bitcoin is is more solid, more robust, more decentralized. It's being used more in a as as a medium of exchange even than Bcash, and the whole story and narrative for Bcash is that they forked off and are increasing the block size so that they can maintain the medium of exchange for low fee use case, but this research showed that they're not it's not being used for that. [00:20:13] It's being it's being used as a speculation even more so than Bitcoin. All right, another then the next episode was a reading on hyper bitcoinization, winner takes all by Obi-Wan Kenobit. Yeah, Obi Wan Kenobit. Yeah, he wrote a great article about hyperbitcoinization. And I read it and did some analysis or some commentary at the end of it. [00:20:35] Yep. Yeah, then episode we're at episode 13. Bitcoin marches on. We covered Schnur signatures, better hash, and then do you had a comment about just the importance of awareness and personal safety covered on that? Oh yeah, that was in response to J Jameson Lop's personal attacks on Bitcoin holders, and then of course Schnorr signatures, and we talked about innovations that are happening during the bear market, right? [00:21:01] For Bitcoin. And that's an important important thing is to understand that these kind of bear market times, engineers are are heads down building and fueling up for the next price rise and mania cycle. Then the episode 14 ETFs, futures and L N R R which was a lightning network reference rate I idea by Nick Latia. [00:21:26] We covered that, and then going to the next episode, why Bitcoin is different and what's up with Bitmain. And Bitmoin Bitmain continues at that point there was discussion of a of a IPO at Bitmain, and there was and it's continued to and our view on it was that the situation was very fluid and had it some negative connotations at the time, and that which is which is continued since we talked about that in the middle of August. [00:21:59] So it's a situation where Bitmain still has significant in fact it's even gotten worse since then, since I think in terms of the situation. Oh yeah, and they yep, and we've learned a lot more since then too, and we covered on the show a bit. Yeah, Jihan is now out, actually, is the latest news. And we had discussed at the time not out completely, but out of power and recall decision making power has been removed. [00:22:20] Right, and be recalled a bit main made the decision a year ago, August, so that would have been 2017, with with respect to Bitcoin and the Bcash hard fork, they decided, they being the bit main side, decided to get rid of their Bitcoin and go in with B cash rather than Bitcoin in terms of predominant proportion of what they were doing, which was a bad, which ended up being a bad choice. [00:22:49] I just saw on Twitter that Bitmain moved three hundred thousand B cash to an exchange. So that's an interesting development, and apparently we're about two blocks away from the split happening. Okay. Well, the interesting thing about the three hundred thousand moving, and this is just a total observation that may or may not be true, but just generally you would think, well, why the heck would they do that? [00:23:13] Well, given the it could be that they actually need the cash to run what's going, need the actual real money, real fiat money to run and pay people and do what they're doing or whatever they're doing. You know, that and that's just a guess, but it's an educated guess. [00:23:31] Okay, [00:23:37] We're here, I think. A reading a reminder of for when the Idiot C returns by Eric Wall. So we had another Brady reading that it covered it was guy swan, a host of crypto economy, Guy Swann. Got yeah, he came on and did some commentary with me. It was a reading of a of a thread about the ICO mania and looking back at it, and it was titled a reminder for when the IDC Returns by Eric Wall on Twitter, yeah. [00:24:05] And then going and we'll move through quickly the last ones because these are recent, but then episode 17 full nodes, Jimmy versus Roger, which actually we got a lot of play on that on the people recall on the cruise ship the Winkelvoss stable coin and the final boss of Bitcoin again. The final boss of Bitcoin. He doesn't yeah. The head of the BIS is who we call the function. [00:24:24] Yeah, he's the final boss. The bank of inter bank for the biggest. From your game from your game that I never played, you know, but but yeah, some from gaming. Episode thirteen, proof of work is efficient. Information theory episode eighteen. Yeah. Eighteen September twenty eighth. Proof of work. Proof of work is efficient. Information theory of money and tokenization of securities and realized market cap. [00:24:46] We covered that on that episode. And then the most recent episode, stable coins, institutional custody, and DOS. And I think one of the key things just institutional custody and how critical that is with respect to moving Bitcoin forward in particular. So yeah. It's been quite the journey this past year. [00:25:05] It's gonna be an amazing year next year. Bitcoin's in just such a great spot compared to where it was in its lows of the last cycle. Lot of infrastructure built and the on ramps are there. The institutional custody has come online in the past six months or so. [00:25:26] So we've seen we've seen a lot of a lot of development happen, and it's it's been a it's been kind of a quiet time in terms of price and interest in Bitcoin in terms of like mainstream interest. That'll all change when the price run the next price run comes whenever that happens. [00:25:45] Yeah, so anyway, that I think that was we've accomplished a lot, and I've really enjoyed Brady. It's been good. I've learned I've learned a lot. Thanks to everyone out there who has subscribed to the podcast and listened to some of our episodes. Really appreciates you taking the time to do that. [00:26:05] I hope it's been helpful for you too. All over the world in over a hundred countries have been downloaded and it's pretty cool. So yeah, so we just thought we thought it was we don't really as you people that listen to the podcast, we don't spend a lot of time. We were very present, present minded, and you know, so but I thought it was important at a at a mark like that of we both did at a mark of the twentieth episode to cover that because it's actually we looked at it and it's actually pretty expansive what we've covered. [00:26:34] Yeah. So back to the topic of the day, the B cash fork. Yeah, what's going on now? So it's it's still happening. I'm gonna look up what B cash is trading at right now. Yeah, it's it's dumped recently quite a bit the past few minutes, down to about oh six six of a Bitcoin. [00:26:56] It's a dropped down from point oh eight of a Bitcoin. So it's dropped about twelve twelve percent for the day. There's a great article that we'll link in the show notes by the crypto economy. Called, and I love this title, How many forks does it take to get to the center of Satoshi's vision? [00:27:19] A playoff of that old com play off that old commercial for Titsy Roll Pops, you know, you get the how do you get how many leaks does it take to give the center of titsy roll pop? How many forks does it take to give the center of Satoshi's vision? It's a great look at and a pretty comprehensive look at the history of Bitcoin Cash, why it exists, how it came about, and the series of hard forks that's gone through in in the short time that it's it's been alive now, just over a year and a couple of months. [00:27:48] That's got the whole the whole layout. And you know, the ser the series of kind of concerning events over the past few months. There's lots b I just definitely recommend going through it and checking it out. You know, and the last paragraph I think is is worth highlighting about why about the difference between Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash, right? [00:28:14] So if you read through this whole article, you'll you see a lot of the differences, but in the last paragraph he says, and I think it sums it up well, he says, Maybe there will be a clear winner in the coming chain war, and BCH will live on to continue its bizarre and messy experiment in quote social media governance governance. [00:28:32] But I will be holding Bitcoin, where the idea of making breaking alterations to the core layer is now considered a hopeless cause, where consensus rules are not a rolling six-month agreement. I will hold the first and still only digital currency that stands to be a pillar of immutability, serving its role, whether I choose to follow development, stay up to date on mining disagreements, or even know who the quote community leaders are. [00:28:56] The revolution of Bitcoin isn't in finding the right blockchain governments, it's in having a shelling point of monetary policy outside of any governance at all. A system that has a so a social scalability that makes consensus a default, regardless of the endless subjective and socio-political differences between us. [00:29:15] A true digital gold that has the potential to last through generations and the life or death of every developer, leader, or company that ever gets involved. If Google were to go up and smoke tomorrow, no one would worry whether the internet would survive. This is the vision that I have for Bitcoin. And I like to think that that was Satoshi's vision too. [00:29:34] I think that's a really good summary to sum it up and just the difference between you know Bitcoin and everything else. So thanks for that article. We'll link to it in the show notes. And you know, thanks again for listening. I think that's all we have for today. Yeah, I didn't well didn't we want to just touch on maybe well, and then we can drop it if you think we should just touch on just the fact that Bitcoin's kind of near bottom on price, and just maybe touch on that for a minute. [00:30:00] Yeah, sure. Yesterday Just so we should explain what we think. Sure, yeah. So yesterday Bitcoin crashed from about sixty three hundred all the way down to fifty three hundred. I think it's back up a little bit now, but not much, maybe fifty four hundred, fifty five hundred range, dipped below the hundred billion dollar market cap level, which we've kind of been watching as a sort of well, we know that there are certain institutions that require. [00:30:29] Yeah, we understand right, and we covered yeah, we understand that 100 100 billion i is the level at which the crossover point, which big institutions can then invest, as we under which has been. Big institutions can't invest in an asset unless it's worth over 100 billion dollars. [00:30:48] Otherwise they consider it too small. Right. Right. So so the so the I so the idea so the idea is it once Bitcoin crossed over that level, and then when we had the big run up, then it was like, okay, it's well past a hundred billion. Well now you have a situation where it's below that level. Just barely, but it's hovering there. But it's hovering there, so then you get the question if if in fact we drop a little bit further from the on the on the price of Bitcoin, and let's say that as an example, that market cap level becomes ninety-five billion, so it's five billion below the hundred billion threshold. [00:31:23] Is that gonna be enough to keep it? Yeah, institutions ought to not only keep them from investing, but institution may say, you know what, we're gonna have to, we're gonna have to. We went in here to the Bitcoin, we're gonna have to sell, so it causes another a potential leg down. We don't know, but that's just one thing to be bringing up. Yeah, it seems I mean, that seems like it would be a pretty silly choice to make. [00:31:45] I agree. But yeah, and this is not like some law or something. Is there this is like a self-imposed sort of threat to the other. Well, the other part of it is typically on some cases this may be looked at you know quarterly or or something where that's not on you know, in other words, somebody may be looking at it as a consequence of a review, let's say of fourth quarter performance, because we're in the fourth quarter right now, let's say in January sometime. [00:32:06] Yeah, if this continues or now no understanding that we're yeah, go ahead. But this is a new low for Bitcoin in 2018. So this is the lowest you know per coin price in US dollar terms that Bitcoin has been in 2018. Another indicator, technical indicator that traders use, it's called the RSI or the relative strength index. [00:32:25] Yes. And it's the relative strength index indicator has never been lower in Bitcoin's history. And I did not know this. Yeah, which mean than it is than it was yesterday. That is an indicator used to if it's low, say say that an asset is is far is really oversold. [00:32:46] So according to that technical indicator, Bitcoin is the most oversold it's ever been. By oversold trader means that it's it's time to buy that. It's been sold too much at this point. It's time to start buying. And we're also running up against you know some long-term kind of trend lines on these on these charts. [00:33:07] There's one that has served as support and resistance in the past that is at about 4800 right now. So it kind of that's kind of the next catch on the tech that from the technical analysis perspective. And if we you know go below 4800, then you know, it could be going down even further. [00:33:27] Tone Vays, who's a trader and does a bunch of ta stuff and has a podcast YouTube whatever he's pretty popular on Twitter has been calling for like 3,000 something you know 3200 Bitcoin for a long time. But and just so everybody on the just previous we've mentioned this we discuss this as part of just understanding what's going on with Bitcoin from the standpoint of any type of investment we're not recommending any this is just our views from or actually our observations based on what you staying on top of this. [00:33:56] So you have to make your own call on it's you know on this so we're just trying to provide color or or flavor it's like just color I use the term color analysis or a fuel it's like watching it's like watching a you know a soccer game or something and it's that's a great way to put you know like you're you kind of analyze you judge by the score kind of base what's going on right so this is sort of the we're watching we're watching the score on a day to be day to day basis is kind of drama but this you know this is one you know if you're if you choose to invest only invest what you are are comfortable or are like able to lose because this [00:34:34] Is a very speculative asset all that you better be comfortable saying yeah exactly if you and if you put too much money into Bitcoin this kind of price action is just gonna you're gonna panic sell and you're gonna add a loss. And you need you're gonna because it's gonna stress you out because it's too much money. You need to put in money where it doesn't an to the point where it doesn't stress you out and you can hold on for we're not talking about years at a time which is a long term thing you know yeah yeah so yeah that's just it's good to point that's a good well that's the other observation too. [00:35:02] Maybe we end up on this. But there was some discussion going on about oh my god, look at Bitcoin's stable now. And it was in the mid six thousands, right? Sixty five hundred, sixty-four hundred. And there was actually a point where somebody measured back to the beginning of the year and said Bitcoin is is more stable than the US Nasdaq stocking. [00:35:24] Yeah. More less volatile is a better way to put it. Yeah. Less volatile. And so it's actually and then all of a sudden we have this happen where it just drops through the floor. And it's like, oh wait a minute, that's Bitcoin. Yeah. And it could have had something to do with this whole Bitcoin Cash fork today. Could have been bitmain selling more of its Bitcoin. We don't know. [00:35:43] Who knows? But there's just su such low buy volume right now that you know it doesn't take a whole lot to move the price. So anyway, it's it's an interesting interesting time. Maybe this is the bottom, maybe it's not, maybe crypto winner. Maybe that the I tweeted yesterday that maybe the honey badger popped out, saw shadow and predicted another six months of crypto winter. [00:36:06] That's a reference to a silly holiday we have in the United States. Called Groundhog Day. Thanks everybody. This Tommy appreciate you all listening. Take care everyone.