Guy Swann: Two Bitcoiners Talking Bitcoin - E96 Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2020-07-30 [00:00:16] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. Now, how's it going out there? All my Bitcoiners from all around the world. Thanks for joining me again for another day here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. Today we sit down with my boy Guy Swann, the guy who's read more about Bitcoin than anyone else you know. [00:00:40] Can't wait to share this one with you guys. It's a lot of fun. But first, let's check in with Swan. Swan continues to grow rapidly. We're really excited to be earning the business and recommendations of great Bitcoiners like Robert Breedlove, Lyn Alden, Max Keiser, and many more. Yan Pritzker and the dev and design team are working on some new features that we're excited to announce soon, so stay tuned to our Twitter account at Swan Bitcoin. [00:01:06] And hey, you have a vested interest in creating new Bitcoiners. And we have a deal for you. You can actually get paid to recruit new Bitcoiners as a member of the Swan Force. Sign up at SwanBitcoin.com slash enlist. You'll get a custom landing page with your picture and a message at the top. You can earn, you will earn 25% of Swan's fees on every purchase made by your referrals when they choose a Swan membership plan. [00:01:32] That's $50 a week or more for three years. [00:01:35] You'll earn that 25% of Swan's fees, of our fees, on your referrals purchases for three years. It's a fantastic deal. You can stack some meaningful sats. [00:01:45] So go to SwanBitcoin.com/slash enlist and sign up. Of course, your referrals will get $10 of Bitcoin as well. Everybody wins. And note, you do not need to be in the United States to join Swan Force. You can sign up US-based customers from anywhere in the world, we'll pay you in sats. It's an awesome deal. Check it out. Big shout out to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network. [00:02:06] Thank you so much for including the Citizen Bitcoin podcast on the feed. Welcome to all of you who are listening on LTBN right now. Let's talk Bitcoin Network. It's definitely worth a subscribe in your podcast app. Check out all the pod a lot of great Bitcoin only pods on there. And you'll also find POV Crypto, which my boy CK hosts along with Ethereum David Hoffman. [00:02:28] And they've been crushing it lately. They have some awesome interviews and episodes out there. Yes, there's some Ethereum talk on it, but it's you know it's fun. It's fun to hear David's perspective. It's fun to listen to you know what Ethereum fans are thinking and what's being built over there. And then hear CK push back on it all as the great Bitcoiner that he is. [00:02:48] So check out POV crypto, it's a lot of fun. And thanks again, LTBN. Alright, let's do this. [00:03:09] He's the creator and host of Bitcoin Audible, one of the most valuable educational resources in Bitcoin. He's also a buddy of mine, and it's always fun to chill and chat about Bitcoin with him for a couple hours. We go all over the place in this one. We talk open source software, privacy, our post truth society. [00:03:28] We go pretty deep on taproot and why it's such an important software upgrade for Bitcoin. We talk about the emerging Bitcoin only industry, and toward the end, we get bullish on price and the official beginning of the next bull run. Let's go. [00:03:54] I listened to one with you and was it? That you pre-posted. Yeah. Keep on that was good, man. And I really liked your recap of the Pomp podcaster show. Did you actually listen to that one? Yeah, I did, man. I actually have well I have 30 minutes left, but I'm yeah, I really like it. [00:04:16] I th I like the format a lot. Did people did you get any feedback on it? Like good feedback on that. A little bit. I've had a number of people who were like who did enjoy it, and then I had a number of people who kind of picked on the fact that I was I was making a podcast responding to someone on another podcast who was making a podcast kind of thing. [00:04:38] I mean, yeah, it is kind of like that that meta like self-reflective thing. But I like it. It's like it's critical. It's criticism. It's and I think it yeah, and I think actually it helps people in this particular case, because Pomp, man, he represents Bitcoin in a lot of on a lot of big stages. [00:04:57] You know, and people listening to your pod are gonna be like revering Bitcoin and who knows where and how in the coming years. And so, like listening to you talk about a better way, you know, to represent Bitcoin is I think super valuable. Yeah, I think there were a couple of questions or a couple of answers that I went into that I think kind of went a little bit too far down a tangent or whatever. [00:05:22] Like I should have been a little bit more focused with it, but I was having such a pain in the ass, like with my video setup and everything. That after I felt like I got a cut, I was like, all right, screw it. I'm just moving on to the next thing. Sometimes, man, you just can't, you just gotta publish because you just don't have time. Editing takes so long, so much time. Yeah, I actually lost three episodes of the podcast out of trying to do that. [00:05:43] Yeah. Because that's kind of tragic. I was on it, took me a whole day. I did the whole thing in a period of in like a two-day period. First, I did it with my Osmo setup and using a logic, my normal recording setup, and then a screen recorder. [00:06:04] So I had video all over the place. I had one on my SD card and then one on my computer, and then the audio is all separate pieces. And that was a bit of a nightmare, but it took me two days to get that like really proper and getting looking the way I wanted. And then I spent like four hours on getting all this stuff right, and it was like, okay, thank God I'm done. [00:06:24] And I went back and did an episode before I went to edit. And then when I sat down to edit it, like every other recording, like every other take just had that through the whole thing, start to finish. And I was like, you gotta be fucking kidding me. [00:06:44] Shit. And I was I almost lost my shit that afternoon. I was like, Oh, hell yeah. I mean, everyone's been there, man. Like you put in hours of work and you lose it. Like, yeah. I mean, that feeling sucks. Oh, it's the worst. I finally got OBS. [00:07:03] OBS. Yeah, man. That was that was what made me finally do OBS, and then it was like two days later, you were like, I'm having trouble with my audio shit. And I was like, All right, well, I tinkered with it now. Maybe I can help you. Yeah. Yeah, OBS is legit. It's open source open source software for the win, man. Dude, seriously though. Seriously. [00:07:21] I can't believe how as simple as it gets and as broad a functionality with something that basically has like four pieces to it. You know? Yeah. Yeah. But it's like just the right four pieces. Yeah, exactly. It does exactly what it needs to do. Open source software, man, it's changing the world. Seriously. [00:07:40] Like one step at a time. It's basically Linux basically runs the internet. Yep. Google, well, you know, Android is was based on open source software that was captured, you know, all the values captured by Google, but you know, it's open source. You can you can build like you know, like what's what's the name of the Android base, strip down Android kind of privacy based software that's out there now that everyone's switching to Mato Dell like made a grammar about it. [00:08:08] I guess that is Android. That's everyone everyone listen everyone listening is like yeah, that one guys, that one that one yeah, so I mean, you know, that and you know, of course, Bitcoin, open source money. [00:08:27] So yeah, I mean, when when open source government, you know, like what's that gonna look like? I think actually the next thing that is gonna finally be open sourced and is going to have a kind of an independent platform that people will be able to levy essentially, is going to be social media. [00:08:48] I think we're overdue for it. I think particularly Bitcoin and Lightning pr present a very incredible tool for re-decentralizing that. But I think we're going to have a protocol for a base standard of kind of social media communication, and it will be kind of like this public square. [00:09:12] And you'll still have services, I think, like Twitter and Facebook and these things that we're used to, but that they'll have this kind of like foundation where there is this subset of things that cross that are cross-compatible, and you can actually post on one and the other at the same time, like like both would be integratable. [00:09:34] But then they'll have their own little thing where like Twitter has this one feature or Facebook has this one, two, three features that aren't part of the protocol. They're just something that you only see on Facebook, kind of like a header tag or something that gives a better, a different format or something. But I actually think I actually think we're not super far out from that. [00:09:54] And there's enough people working on building alternatives and there's enough pressure built right now that I really think that's gonna happen soon. Yeah, I mean, Twitter's working on fingers crossed. Yeah, exactly. I mean, we need that. Nic Carter had a great piece about, I think you read it on on your show, about why we need to you know build an open internet, open social media. [00:10:18] Yeah. After the Twitter hack. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, it Twitter's doing some kind of like they're working toward, I know Jack you know, said put this out as like at least sort of a an ultimate goal. And who knows if he's going to be blocked by the corporate overlords at Twitter. [00:10:37] But I think he he said something about how he wants to build an open API that Twitter will operate on top of. Something like that, right? Yeah that was like six months ago or something yep and i think that's what's in inevitable at some point somebody's going to I bet I bet there are already other people working on it that just aren't there they're they're a random person you know like they're they're just somebody who's got this idea and they're building it at home they're they're the satoshi of the space yeah but it also be would be cool to see square oh graphene graph graphene graphene yeah graphene just [00:11:15] Popped in i was looking it up while you were while you were going off there yeah graphene os based on the android open source project yeah but it would also be cool to see square do the that protocol just because I know you know they've got the capital to really do it and I it would be cool to see someone that big something that big that's already got such a huge platform like Twitter which for all its censorship is one of the least censored of the big one which is a little shocking but low standard I guess right but to [00:11:53] See them actually like moving over to something like that if that's actually possible that would be really cool. Yeah absolutely I mean you know like you gotta you gotta disrupt yourself. I think Jack knows that right I mean he's seen that through history and you know like the whole everybody knows the famous examples you know Kodak invented the digital camera but didn't use it because they didn't want to disrupt their business, right? [00:12:20] You know, it it's you gotta disrupt yourself. So if it's gonna be an open source solution to social media, might as well you know build it and you know run your business on top of it and not risk losing out. You know, the and the other thing is like you know it's really hard to overcome social, like the obviously the network effects of social media networks that are already established. [00:12:46] And that's why I think your what you mentioned earlier is really smart and necessary is you gotta kind of piggyback off those networks as much as you can while the while you're small enough to fly under the radar, you know, kind of like Airbnb did with with Craigslist. You know, they just like spam Craigslist with all of their listings and link back to them. [00:13:07] Stuff like that. Yeah. So let's talk about big sorry, go ahead, man. It's interesting too that like because we have like this open protocol, like the standard of communication, which is the internet, but then we've we're we're constantly doing like next layers of walled gardens again, right? [00:13:29] You know, like like we got this open, decentralized, permissionless internet, but now we have these closed permissioned social groups, exactly these social networks. And I love that the piece that I read by William Vandenberg, the shelling point on shelling points, network effects, and Lindy. [00:13:49] Such a good article. It's still it's still like I mean, it's fresh in my mind. So I've been thinking about a lot recently, but I think it's the best one to explain why like altcoins and shit coins are nonsense. Like it's just not it, it just isn't going to go that way. [00:14:07] But it also talks about it also really alludes to why social media and communication networks end up in monopoly. And it does such a good job of breaking down all of those ideas. And it basically, you know, makes the argument that in the end, open source is essentially the path forward because no matter what you do, when you end up with this huge monopoly on a communications network, you'll inevitably run into massive technical debt and the inability to progress forward. [00:14:44] Like you'll just get so bloated and overwhelmed that you won't be able to sustain it. And I think that's kind of the state that we're seeing. Facebook and Google and all of these things, they're fighting it takes them a hundred times the resources to make a move or a change to stay in front, which they do have a hundred times the resources, but still the cost to benefit just isn't there for them anymore, and they're bloated. [00:15:08] And now with censorship and all the other problems coming to a head, I think we're gonna finally start to see them break apart. And we've seen it with an explosion in alternative social media already. I don't think those will be the end game, but I think they're they're simply shining lights on all the cracks. [00:15:29] So but yeah, that that's a I love that God, I love that piece. Neil, listen to it again, actually. Yeah, and you know, I mean one thing that I think could destroy network effect, right? I mean, the power of the network effect could be this, you know, extensive censorship. And I think people are kind of waking up to how important privacy is and how compromised we are by choice. [00:15:54] We've given up so much just for convenience, and people are gonna start. I mean, it's the consequences are coming to a head. And we have been trait tracked and traced and all of our data is out there. And as we move into an increasingly digital age, man, the all of that data is going to be used against us more and more. [00:16:16] Which is why you need defensive technology like Bitcoin and other you know open source robust technologies that are able to stay ahead of hackers who are gonna make you know take advantage of all of that data. It's you know, it's it's just gonna get worse and worse before it gets better. Yeah, we kind of took our habits and our mental framework of the world where we had privacy by default, where there was always a wall or you know, a window you had to open, or you know, we had blinds, we had shades on the car windows, like we just cash, we had cash, we had cash, we had cash. [00:16:48] Like it was always private by default, and then we just kind of assumed like we just ignorantly went into this new space and accepted that I'm the only one looking at this, and then increasingly all of more and more of our lives are getting dumped into the digital world, and then we're realizing that we never had any privacy, like it just was never there. [00:17:11] And suddenly we're paying the price for it, paying the price in a in a major way in a lot of different ways, and censorship is making it even more clear that that risk has always been there, and now it's right in front of our faces. And I think you're right. I think that's gonna be a huge push to people waking up and just realizing the dynamic in this new space. [00:17:31] And I hope, fingers crossed, that we're we're gonna flood in the opposite direction again. Yeah, we gotta hope, man. One of the four you know, I mean, besides network effects of you know that these companies have in their favor, and just the fact that you know, obviously, you know, people are just lazy and indifferent for the lot for the most part, like we've talked about, you know, just now in in terms of their privacy. [00:17:55] Hopefully people will be waking up more and more, but we can't really rely on that, I think. That really concerns me is that we've got you know, basically these companies having absolute influence over the way we think and the way we govern ourselves. [00:18:18] And I don't know what's true anymore, man. I don't know what's true anymore. This pandemic thing has me all I mean, just a great example, right? Like I read what sounds like convincing data on both sides every day, you know? And I understand that like we don't it's hard to know where we are, and the data is you know, it's still relatively early in this thing, maybe I don't know. [00:18:38] But you it's just you who who do you trust? You know, you can't spend all your time doing your own research, right? I mean, you can't read all the source material on everything. It's just not it just can't do it. So you know, you've gotta pick people to trust. And now that we're in this age, you know, the fourth estate is gone, you know, the kind of the gate of the keepers of truth and knowledge, you know, the that the curators, I guess, who were trusted to give us you know as much truth as possible. [00:19:09] I think you know journalism had those sort of ethics, you know, at at least some point in its history. I think journalism was much more trustworthy, but now it's just been completely disrupted and everyone has a megaphone. So what do you how do you tell the truth? I mean, we're in this post-truth age, man. Like that it can stifle progress as well. [00:19:29] Yeah. I totally agree, particularly about like, and I think that's why like about the fact that like you can read convincing evidence and see convincing data on both sides, and you kind of you always have to go back to the source. You're like, so where the hell did they get data A versus data B? [00:19:50] And there's logical arguments for both sides, and there's splits in so many different ways. You know, there's I mean, just look at masks. There's people who think we should have mandatory masks, there's people who think masks are a good idea, but they shouldn't be mandatory. There are people who think masks are stupid and COVID is a joke or a fraud, big conspiracy theory push. [00:20:13] Some kind of false flag, yeah. Yeah, yeah. I mean, just like the number of narratives out there is crazy, but I think therein lies what it's actually doing is doing is exposing the fact that the idea of centralized top-down decision making was stupid from the beginning, because really all of these logical standpoints were always there. [00:20:38] Like the difference of opinion and the difference of views and the difference in priorities, because a lot of it really is a difference in priority. Like one person thinks it's absolutely critical that we be safe and we hunker down in our houses for two years and do nothing, and other people like, no, I want to live my life and I want to take the risk. Yeah, like like I want to have that choice. [00:20:59] And your fear can't control my decisions. Like, I understand that you're scared, I understand that there's risk, and I get it. You know, be safe, but you can't tell me what to do with that. You can't make me stay in my home because you're afraid. Right. But the idea that there's some centralized top-down like decision that can just we can just force on everybody is is negating the idea that there are different priorities and there are different perspectives on this. [00:21:26] It doesn't work anyway. Yeah. I mean, it doesn't work. It doesn't work anyway, right? And what is effective is letting, you know, local you know, people who have skin in the game in their local communities, you know, make decisions because they're incentivized in the right direction to take care of the people that they know that they're around, that they spend their lives, you know, benefiting benefiting them and benefiting from, and you know, it's it's it's just I think this is the direction that Bitcoin is going to incent as well in terms of just the way society is organized. [00:22:02] I think the power of the printing press allowed nation states to, you know, bloat to massive, just completely unsustainable and unproductive sizes. And I think you know, Bitcoin will return power to the people and re you know, remove that printing press power, which is, you know, essentially I think responsible for nation state power at this point. [00:22:26] Yeah, yeah. I totally agree. And I think it's clear that you look from just kind of the general trends of society and just the feelings across most people is that is that we're all collectively slowly realizing that the cost of the state, we're feeling it, whether or not we even consciously are aware of it, that the cost of the state greatly outweighs what it's actually doing in society, like it's its role. [00:22:57] And that's not even considering the fact that they're controlling the money. That's just like that's just like caught, you know, ROI, basically, right? They are it's not ROI. You know. But then you add in the costs and destruction of you know, incalculable of the benefit of the centralization of the printing press. [00:23:20] For all of us, man, for 99% of us, 99 point, probably 9% of us, just get the shaft, man. It's such a Ponzi scheme. It's such the this the ultimate theft in human history in terms of productivity and time and wealth. God, I mean, I when we look back on this age hundred years from now, I just can't imagine that history, I mean I really think it'll be as extreme, you know, as we look at some of you know, some of history's greatest atrocities. [00:23:54] Yeah. I think I totally agree. I literally just tweeted about this like an hour ago. After I went and got my coffee, I was sitting down, I was just thinking about stuff. And I was listening to Masters and Slaves of Money, actually. Again, right. Uh-huh. Such a great one, man. Robert Breedlove on Baya. God, that's so good. [00:24:14] But I actually tweeted something along those lines, but it was something about like in the future when we look back, we'll see the monopoly control over money, like our our current monetary system, forced use of the money, monopoly control over it, and then just insane levels of printing. [00:24:33] It will be as as stupid as the idea that someone would just control what we are allowed to say. It will be as destructive and idiotic as bloodletting to save a sick patient, and it will be seen as absolutely more as immoral as slavery. Like without a doubt. Like it's it's all three of those things all at once. [00:24:53] It's just a horrifically bad idea, and it and it is theft to an astronomical degree and privilege to a small connected monetary and political class. And it's it will be seen as a as a poison stain on society today. [00:25:14] I truly, I truly agree with that. And we're seeing the end of it, man. It's crumbling. It's I you know, I think the final stages of it is is socialism, this idea, the ultimate end. You know, we already have monetary socialism, which started, you know, as soon as we were severed from the from the gold standard in 71, which was the inevitable result of the founding of the Federal Reserve in 1913, which you ranted about in that episode I told you I was listening to earlier. [00:25:42] God, man, creature from Jekyll Island. Like I listened to that recently too. We can go into that if we want. The founding of the Fed and that whole story is just insane. But it's so crazy, man. But yeah, I think we're seeing the end, the inevitable end is is socialism. We have monetary socialism now. We're gonna see UBI, which is socialism. [00:26:01] And it's basically it's it's really it's a bribe, you know. It's like, all right, we've been taking all this money for all about a hundred years, all right? And we've enriched ourselves, and we're just gonna we'll we'll give some back to you now. You know, we're gonna include you. Like it's okay, you can have a piece of this, you know. [00:26:20] The we'll we'll let the cancel out effect you know, be distributed among the society a little bit more evenly. See, see, it's not so bad. It's not so bad, right? Yeah. And people are gonna love it. Yeah. Yep, basically. Basically, they've been sitting, they've they've had the spigot plugged into this giant, glorious, like Playboy mansion pool that they've all been sitting in. [00:26:44] And now everybody realizes that this is happening and everybody else is so destitute and paying the price of having to fill the water up in that pool that they're gonna be like, we'll give everybody a cup of water, and you can enjoy how great it is in this pool with your nice little cup of water. And you'll and you'll remember that we were nice and we gave you this cup of water. [00:27:06] Right. Just as long as you let us keep our pool for a little bit longer. Oh shit. It's it's such a mess, man. It's such a mess. So yeah, let's tell this story about the creature from Jekyll Island, because it's insane. I mean, these these guys literally meet up in the dark of night. They literally JP Morgan. [00:27:26] The guy, JP Morgan, and literally all the names of the banks, those actual people that were the names. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Exactly. And they took extreme measures to you know, not let people know where they were going, or even that they were leaving their homes. [00:27:45] And like they even like had these unmarked like train cars, and they would like switch them. They would like they're like go to a station and like switch to a different track and then attach it to a new train and go in a different direction. I mean, it was just insane subterfuge on like like Hollywood level subterfuge. And they finally all meet at this place in Jekyll Island, and in the dark of night, under the cover of night, they all arrive, you know, in the middle of the night, literally. [00:28:13] And they, you know, put together this bank, the centralized bank, and that they then sell to the country via all the politicians as a way to save you from the banking system, the current banking system, right? [00:28:34] And it was admitted to like later. Like it's not even like you could you could say all day, oh, this is a conspiracy theory, but then like in conversation, like just like six or seven years later, they were like, Oh, well, yeah, yeah. I mean, yeah, and we met and it was it was midnight, and we wrote the bill, blah, blah, blah. [00:28:53] But it's done. So, what the hell are you gonna do about it? Suck it. It's passed. Yeah, yeah. To think that this is and I just this is how I see all of politics. Every time somebody says, Oh, cheap healthcare act, or insurance for everybody act, or the blah blah blah bullshit. [00:29:14] All I hear is the break the bank trust act, written by all the banks to institute a giant central bank where all of them had total and absolute control. That is every time somebody reads me an act or a bill or some other political garbage that says we're gonna fix this. [00:29:32] All I hear is that the major heads of those instant of that industry have gotten together, probably at a very critical time where somebody else is actually coming in and competing with them, and they need to establish their position for the long term, and they've written themselves a monopoly, and they have purchased a politician and a group of lobbyists to sell it as a way to fix their industry because they are screwing it up so badly. [00:29:56] That is what I hear every single time. Yeah, for good reason. With good reason, man. Break the bank trust act. Okay. And that that particular bill centralized all the bank trust into one private institution. And I heard recently that you know these guys are getting like six percent dividends on profits from the from the Federal Reserve. [00:30:19] Is that I mean, is that right? I think I heard that recently. Still to this day, whoever these people who own the bank who have shares in the Federal Reserve are literally making profits off the activities of the bank. It's a private bank. So I haven't been able to really source. I went to this was actually linked to it, it was mentioned and linked to in Masters and Slaves of Money. [00:30:42] So Breed Love was where I was first stumbled upon that. I had no idea there was any dividends involved in the Federal Reserve. I knew there were private owners and that it was like owned by a collective of other member banks, like kind of the Federal Reserve member banks. But the idea that they paid out dividends just shocked me. [00:31:04] I was like, you've got to be kidding me. But they literally pay Federal Reserve, pays itself with its, we print whatever we want accounts, pays itself a basically a management fee, and that fee is delivered out in dividends to its member and private banks that own it. [00:31:25] Like it's it's the individuals that have a stake in it and the member banks of that institution. And good work. Good work, everyone. Good work, everyone. Good work, everybody. Here's your dividend. Well done. We printed lots of money this year. Did a great job. Great job. We employed we employed a lot of economics school graduates. [00:31:46] And we wrote a lot of papers and we appeared in a lot of hearings and we said a lot of big words. Congratulations, guys. Good job. We kept it going another year. Oh shit. Oh man. Oh, what a joke. It's terrible. That's so terrible. [00:32:05] I thought some of the fun to talk about. I had a really fun time talking with Vake about Bitcoin history recently. Oh, I haven't gotten to that one yet. I haven't gotten to that one yet. I do have that one on my list. But yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, and that was such a fun time. And I know that you know, I heard from a few listeners that they really enjoyed that. [00:32:25] And there's, you know, most Bitcoiners are in, you know, a lot of us who are still around now are like 2017 class, you know. I would say like the majority, probably, just because that was such a the you know, it the number of Bitcoiners that are created in every bull run is just increases. So, you know, it's like every generation is bigger and bigger. [00:32:46] So 2017 generation was pretty big. There are a lot of there are a lot of prominent Bitcoiners that are 2017. I mean, you're your class of 2017, right? Yeah, yeah, like March 2017. Yeah, so many people that that was that was that was the year of Bitcoin into the mainstream consciousness. [00:33:07] It was so many people, eyes open to the state of our monetary system. Yeah, absolutely, and thankful for that. Thank you, Bitcoin, thank you, Satoshi. Thank you to all the Bitcoiners who you know carried the torch. And you are one of those, you're one of those people because you're you know, class of 2011, which is just fucking OG, baby. [00:33:28] That's that's OG. That's OG territory for sure. So I mean, you we're just talking like a couple of years after the system launched. All right, what month of 2011 would you say? Do you remember? I don't know. It's actually possible that it was at the very end of 2010. [00:33:49] Because I happened to have met my current wife girlfriend at the time during this exact same period. So I was I was spewing a bunch of nonsense about Bitcoin to her, like in the first months that that we were actually like dating or talking or whatever. [00:34:10] Dude, what an infliction point in your life. Yeah, and we actually seriously, seriously. It was actually January 1st of 2011 that like we started officially dating. That I actually asked her to be my girl. [00:34:30] But I had already I think it would must have been maybe December-ish of 2010, I think. So it was either it it it aligns almost exactly. So I just think of it as like very beginning of 2011 period. I don't know if I bought at that point, but I know I was just I was already discovering it, and I was like sucked in, you know what I mean? [00:34:53] Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I remember you telling me that you know you just you read the re the white paper with your brother and then it was on. It was gone. That was it. That was it. That was all it took. So it wasn't like you, like a lot of people will be like, I read the white paper in 2011, but it wasn't until 2015, 2016, or whatever, until I really started diving down the rabbit hole. [00:35:13] But you were just sucked in right away two years after you know the network even started, which is OG, buddy. So let's I mean, tell me some war stories, man. Like what are some like events in Bitcoin history that you know aren't as well known among Bitcoiners who are relatively new? [00:35:32] You know, we all know Mount Gox. You know, everybody knows Mount Gox that level. Yeah, yeah. I mean, we all know we pretty know that story pretty well at this point, but what kind of like what what debate was going on? I know that there was, you know, like the Gavin Andreessen and Mike Curran stuff happened, got into that a little bit with Vake, but we could flesh that out. [00:35:51] Like what was it was it pretty like from 2011 to 2013 or 14? Was it still was it pretty like you know solid community? It was kind of one group of people because it was so new and young and there weren't you know a bunch of competing altcoins. [00:36:10] You know, there wasn't a bunch of debate really, maybe I don't know, about the you know, how the protocol should be built out. Is was it was that kind of the state of it? Yeah, there wasn't a whole lot of contention among Bitcoiners back then. But I think it was just because there was so much contention with everyone else. [00:36:30] Like Bitcoin required such a defensive line that there wasn't really room for infighting, and also kind of like what do you think of as Bitcoin Twitter? Like, there's actually a pretty small group of like hardcore maximalists. [00:36:48] That's kind of what it felt like back then, except that there was nobody watching or paying attention to it. Like nobody, nobody gave a shit. And it was just this little club of people who had found Bitcoin and suddenly were calling themselves cypherpunks. It's like, yeah, I'm into shit. And they're everybody could just kind of had this joint idea. [00:37:11] And it also we never really had to fight about what Bitcoin was because it was being used so little, and it was so early in like what it actually was that we didn't have to think about 10 years out. We didn't have to think about like what trade-offs are gonna be made in 20 years, or how how is this not going to meet our utopian dreams? [00:37:34] Like it was just like get another guy on board, and that's all you gotta do. Yeah, yeah. But it definitely it definitely felt like this insanely exclusive club where everybody thought we were idiots. Yeah, I mean, if people even knew about you, right? Like if anybody, if if you spoke to someone about it, otherwise they didn't know who you were. [00:37:53] You were being laughed at by the people the few people that saw it and were like, this is a fucking joke. Are you kidding me? Internet money, come on. Dude, it was so hard. Like that was it's it's incredibly hard to be, and it's still it, you know, you still get it today, but it's a totally, totally different, like it's night and day from what it was back then. [00:38:17] But to be so passionate about something and to see it is so important, and to have people just look at you literally like you are retarded when you try to bring it up to them. Like just look at you like oh, even when they're trying to be nice, they they immediately get that tone like, oh, you pathetic, sad little person. [00:38:39] Oh, oh, and you're like you're some kind of crazy conspiracy theorist or whatever, right? Yes, yes. And it's just like, oh well, that's nice. Thank you. Like that's the nice version, and it feels so demeaning. Yeah. And you know, you want so bad to be like, oh freaking told you so. [00:39:02] Right. But you hold that in, you hold that in and you try to be try to be nice when you were treated like crap. But yeah, and that that's still happening a little bit. Yeah, but not nearly. I mean, you know, there's those people are more being it seems to be more being laughed at these days, like the haters, you know, the Peter shifts of the world, like being caricatured and you know, especially by Bitcoiners, of course, but even by you know, like mainstream investors now that are you know getting in on the game, like the host of one of CNBC's most like watched shows, [00:39:41] You know, like a couple of those guys are just like all out big coiners, you know, so it's like financial media's on board, you know, politicians, etc. So you can see feel that transition from you know being laughed at to laughing at the laughers, you know what I mean? Sort of first they laugh at you, right? [00:40:00] Then they fight you, and then you win. So yeah, I mean, I feel like we're firmly entering the fighting stage. Oh, yeah. You know, one thing about like way back in the day, that I wish I had better records of, and I don't know if I would actually be able to find I'm thinking about I didn't take as good like pictures or records of anything, and I tried to take much better records. [00:40:27] I actually have a notion database that I have of just stuff that when things happen in Bitcoin, I just copy a link or copy the picture or something of it, like take a snapshot. And I try to remember, okay, this is an event that happened. Okay, this is this is when this first service showed up. [00:40:46] Because usually I'm just like, oh, that's cool, that's interesting. And a bunch of people are talking about it. And then I like just keep going about my business. But then you realize six months later, you just forget and you don't know how to find it anymore. And you can't just Google search it. It's not easy to find stuff like that. And particularly back in the day, I wish I had kept better records. [00:41:05] I wish I had taken pictures because I kind of knew to some degree, like I believed in the fact that this was going to be massively important, but I don't think I realized just how important or cool it would be to share with somebody that I had to go to like a gas station and use this this like red phone thing that was literally like a phone with a with a swirly cord on it, like in this like red box thing that would allow me to get like these this this like money to like I would deposit money and see [00:41:43] I don't even remember the whole process, but it was crazy, it was absolutely crazy because Mount Gox wasn't people think of it as like this big exchange. It was not an exchange like an exchange was today. It was literally a crappy little nothing website that somebody threw together in PHP code that was utter garbage, was not built to scale at all. [00:42:06] And then Bitcoin went on a tear, and it was the only place to go, and it exploded, it ran away from them so fast they had no idea what to do or what they were doing. I mean, M T O M T O G like Mount Gox, MTGOX, excuse me, was Magic the Gathering online exchange. [00:42:31] It was for a game before you they started doing Bitcoin. It was for a toy, yeah. And it just blew up, and it felt like using some random, some kid in his basement made a thing and figured out how to allow people to put money on it. [00:42:50] And I remember like in the early days, like I had to when because I would do it, there was the something about the process was go to a physical location in my area, use the red phone thingy, then I would have an account that I could then transfer to Dewalla, which was another random service, and then DeWala would let me deposit into Mount Gox. [00:43:13] And that was how you got money to the exchange. It required a drive in the car, a fee, transfer and a couple of day wait, and a transfer and a couple of day wait, and I think fees on both of those until it landed in Mount Gox. And it just all felt so squirt. [00:43:32] I mean, if anything that you have done on the internet that felt ghetto and like you were in some dark, shady corner, and there was like a garbage bag next to you in the alleyway, like anything that has ever felt like that on the internet, that is kind of what it felt like to you. Most of the things around Bitcoin then. [00:43:50] It was just all utter basic. I mean, websites weren't even updated to kind of look like today. It was it was like everybody just did the like like when you go to a website that hasn't changed since like the late 90s, it still has that like Windows classic look. Yeah. That was even like pretty common. [00:44:09] It was like barely barely people using everything was like inline CSS, it was like you know, table table stuff, like divs weren't even being used and shit. It was table based. Yeah, yeah. People threw up their websites without even using WordPress. They just typed in HTML code and it was just a little bit of a. Oh yeah, WordPress was if that I mean if it was even around, that was super early. [00:44:28] Jed McCaleb, that's who it was. Jed McCaleb. He had he started the Magic the Gathering online trading thing, and when like that, I guess I think that like shut down, like it was dormant for a while, and then he read about Bitcoin on Slashdot and you know turned the domain into the quote unquote exchange. [00:44:55] Yep. So crazy. Yeah, and then so it was I think it was March 2011, right around the time you were falling down the rabbit hole that it was sold to Marco Pellis. So yeah, I mean that wow, so I was getting on right when Carpellis was turning that into a sham. [00:45:19] Yeah, yeah. I mean, so what when did when did Mt. Gox happen? It was like two 2013, something like that. That was when it that was when it blew up and everything went sideways. Yeah, late 2013. Oh, yeah, here it is. Trading suspended, Bitcoin missing 2014. Yeah, so that's when it happened. Early 2014. [00:45:38] They issued the press release. A bug in the Bitcoin software makes it possible for someone to use the Bitcoin network out to alter transaction details to make it seem like sending a bitcoins to a Bitcoin wallet did not occur when in fact it did occur. Since the transaction appears as if it had not proceeded correctly, the Bitcoins may be reset. Mountgox is working with the Bitcoin core development team and others to mitigate the issue. [00:45:56] So they blamed it on the Bitcoin. They blamed it on Bitcoin. They blamed it on transaction malleability when the reality was that they weren't running a node. That's what it was. Because if they're running a node, they would have known. They would have known. They would have they checked their node, that's not an issue. What transaction malleability allowed them to do was to just alter the transaction ID of a transaction, like of a withdrawal transaction. [00:46:22] And then basically it's it's like being able to modify your receipt without it editing any of the data on the receipt so that they'll check by a new fake receipt number in their database and be like, oh, I don't see this receipt number. I'm sorry, let me reissue your refund. And then somebody keeps coming into the store, changing just the receipt number and getting a refund over and over and over again because all they're checking is the receipt number. [00:46:47] Yeah, and rather than the full transaction, which you could just check on a block explore. Like they did they could they could have just had it API to blockchain.info or something. Well, no, they neither ran a node and they neither checked it. They just decided they were going to check the ID and that was it. And of course, they get robbed blind. [00:47:07] If, of course, that's what happened. I'm I still kind of think it was an inside job, but maybe [00:47:17] It's insane. You know, you know. And then Roger Veer goes in there and like reassures everyone that everything's kosher. I liked Roger. Like, like I was a big fan of Roger, he was a huge supporter back then. And I know I mean I don't like I have a hard time with it because I'm sure he had freaking 10,000 Bitcoin or whatever, you know, in Mt. [00:47:44] Gox. He did it to get his coins, he didn't get it to get his coins off the exchange. No questions asked. That's what happened. But I had seen the writing on the wall previously, and like for three months there were everybody was like, dude, something is up, something is not right, my withdrawal isn't happening, something is wrong. [00:48:06] We got like people talking about like Willy Bot and stuff, like I don't think it had that name yet, but there was a lot of indication that there was fake volume and just all kind I mean everything was just looking shady as hell. And then Roger came out with that video of everybody's shit is safe looking like he had a gun to his head, reading clearly something next to the screen. [00:48:28] And I was like, dude. That was that was that was when I knew Mt. Gox was gone. I was like, because we'd already had like there had already been hacks, they were just smaller, you know, they weren't the big companies, but it was regular. I mean, if you think like today or like the chaos around Bitcoin now is was volatile, like there were hacks all the time, and every one of them resulted in 20% dips in the price. [00:48:55] Like now you have a hack and the Bitcoin doesn't even know. Like the Bitcoin price doesn't give two shits. And back then, everything was detrimental to Bitcoin, and everything. It was, I mean, it was volatile, like nobody's business. It was just constant chaos. And Roger posted that video. [00:49:16] I was like, dude, you gotta be kidding. It was just it was just downhill from there. Very sad day. Very sad day. One of the first examples of kill your heroes, right? Right, exactly. I was just gonna say, so who are some of the other like early Bitcoin heroes who were slayed? Hearn eventually. [00:49:34] Definitely Hearn. You know, Mike Mike Hearn was somebody that I followed pretty closely. Gavin, definitely Gavin. I had a lot of respect for Gavin too because he was a really good, he was really he did such a good job of cleaning up the code base. I think he was a better quote unquote programmer than Satoshi, like in the sense that he could see 200 lines of code and be like, you could do this in 40. [00:50:02] And in fact, that was like all of the first a lot of the first iterations of the actual core client were just that. It was just deleting code, like crazy deleting and rewriting, deleting and rewriting. And so I always thought it was great to have like Gavin on the project, and I watched tons of his talks or whatever because he would get into the technical stuff, which I could not grasp at all at the time, and he did a decent job of explaining it, and he was really soft-spoken, and he seemed like somebody who would be [00:50:40] Good to be in charge of it because he wasn't all out there and telling people what to do and all this stuff. He just seemed kind of doing his own thing, you know, and literally. And Satoshi thought Satoshi thought so too, right? Yeah, it's kind of it's kind of what I like about Peter Wella's kind of mentality, you know. [00:51:01] He kind of does his own thing, he's he's pretty soft spoken, he's not all out in the limelight and all that stuff. He just does the work. Yeah and but then when Gavin Gavin didn't get his way with the block size debate, and people started pushing back, and it was clearly it was like Gavin and Mike leading the block size increase. [00:51:26] Yep. And a lot of people in the group in in the developers were like, no, this I mean this introduces huge risk here, here, and here like these are major trade-offs. And when it was clear that he just wasn't changing people's minds, but he had kind of been dead set on and I was following it before it really turned into a Reddit fest of idiocy. [00:51:55] When and that was actually one of the big things that made me question I hadn't read very many good arguments. I was I was a little worried, I was a little confused just to why it was so contentious at the time, because I wasn't quite following the arguments. But when Gavin basically didn't get his way, and then he went to Reddit and was like this is this is terrible, they're going to kill Bitcoin. [00:52:22] Like he just he was the one that said, This is fine. I'm going to go to all the plebs, and I'm going to make them attack you. He turned it into this huge social and political fight by just moving the conversation from the developers to social media. [00:52:41] Okay. And then at least in in my experience, that was when I first saw it. And I was like, wait, what the hell? And then suddenly, suddenly it was a Twitter fight. And you there's no, you know, like how Twitter fights go. Like, there's no discourse. Yeah. I saw the end, I saw the end of it, but the end of the block size debate, right? [00:53:01] The culmination of it, which ended up in the fork of Bitcoin Cash. And Gavin had proposed several forks, and I think had one in the game, right? Classic, I think, something whatever it was. Yeah, in the mix, yeah, if I'm not mistaken. And it just totally shut the bed when it when it forked, yeah, like literally stopped working. [00:53:23] But that was actually the point where I suddenly saw how damaging this form of changing the protocol could actually be. Like, because I mean, I was already like hardcore libertarian slash anarchists or whatever, and I saw, you know, centralized control and like the social sphere as something that was incredibly inefficient, and the idea is actually to mitigate kind of the collective ignorance of people by building systems that don't rely on or that actually benefit from our self-interest, that actually benefit from our ignorance so that we can [00:54:01] Basically react like it's the knowledge problem, right? It's like money and prices. You want to be able to react and align your behavior with this vast pool of knowledge, even though there's no way you could ever know what the giant that what all this knowledge is. So that's like kind of the whole goal. And then as soon as I turned saw this turn into politics, I was like, and I think it was Gregory Maxwell was talking about how he mentioned something in a Reddit post about how unbelievably dangerous to turn this into turn protocol changes into political squabbles. [00:54:36] And that just rang so true with me. I was like, holy shit, if this is what Bitcoin ends up being, we fixed nothing. Like nothing has changed. We are gonna be in the same shit show of just like all you have to do is convince people that inflation is good for investment, and like we're right back in the same thing. [00:54:58] And I was like, this can't be how it changes, even if if that is a good change, this can't be how it happens, or it's it's undermining what I find fascinating and beautiful about Bitcoin. Yeah. So what I mean, what were the alternative m modes of change, you know, that were being debated? [00:55:21] I mean, the you know, previously it was just you know, coders on GitHub submitting PRs and evaluating code and all that, and I know that that's what Greg Gregory Maxwell wanted, you know, it to continue being, but eventually there's you know a lot of other and there's other parties, right, that are that have skin in the game besides the devs. [00:55:41] There's the minor the miners, the users, the node operators, and the companies, you know, that are that are Bitcoin-based, right? So, you know, it was destined to become political at some point with the you know, all these competing parties with different incentives. [00:56:00] The game theory only only goes so far. So I mean, the actual code changes were going to become political. But there were some attempted changes to the way that co code changes would occur, right? Like I know that there were like like minor flagging BIPs and stuff like that. [00:56:20] So was there sort of do you remember that discussion happening and what were the there were a couple different alternatives, I think. And what did you think of them back then? Originally I was actually really on board with the idea of increasing the block size. I think that's kind of the default assumption is that oh we're we have a cap on transactions, let's have it do more transactions, right? [00:56:47] You know, like that just if you don't think about it very hard, that's the answer. And I had a problem. I was like, why is it that these people that I respect and I know are incredibly intelligent? Why are they so vehemently against this? Because even Satoshi was was like kind of flippantly, he put it in there seemingly as like a to toss it in without any code review as a you know a spam, anti-spam measure, right? [00:57:15] Yeah, seemingly at least that he didn't really explain why he put it in there, but that was sort of the assumption, I think. And that was used in the you know, all throughout the block size debate. The comments from Satoshi that like you know, we can just raise it later when we need to. Yeah. And I think it was I think Satoshi had particularly like if you read the white paper and a lot of his early conversations and stuff, is that Satoshi was well aware that there were like I mean, obviously he was well aware, but that there were really important trade-offs, and there were more more specifically, there were very hard limitations of the [00:57:54] Protocol, but he just kind of had these vague ideas that he was just kind of pushing out on like future development and stuff that like what as long as we get this to work now the way it is, we can sort that shit out later. And one of those things was definitely scalability because I mean the first response to the white paper on the mailing list if you read it scale was that this is a great, this is a really cool and clever idea, but this shit's not gonna you're never gonna make this a global payment system. [00:58:24] Like that doesn't make any sense. And Satoshi's basically like, well, yeah, I get it, but like we'll we'll figure that out later. Like, in a sense, that was kind of his general position. Well, yeah, I mean, it it's you'd have to have a crystal ball, really. I mean, I think Satoshi game gamed out so much, right? But and he and it seems like Soshi was a relatively limited programmer, right? [00:58:46] I mean, compared to the coders that we have, you know, on Bitcoin Core now. And like you said, Gavin, you know, was probably a better coder even back then. So yeah, I think it's terms of like sc like scalability, which is a code issue, a code problem, and a protocol problem. You know, I don't I think maybe his, you know, sort of forecasting ability was limited as compared to his brilliance on like just setting up the system and the game theory, etc. [00:59:13] Yeah. Yeah, and I find it funny that he's actually the originator of basically most of the ideas that we are still relying on to scale Bitcoin. I mean, payment channels were something that he laid out right at the beginning. I mean, like right at the beginning. And he said, I think there's a whole lot of things that we can do with this, you know, down the road and expanding on these ideas. [00:59:36] And I think he was getting alluding to the fact that we could have payment channels that could potentially could be bridged, that these these are tools that could be used to build other things. He just never figured out how or exactly why. I mean, in fact, I don't think he ever actually worked out how you could have it so that only the final state of a payment channel was used to because his description of it or explanation of it was that only during a cooperative situation would during a during a cooperative close would it require one transaction to [01:00:14] Settle the 10,000 transactions or whatever over the payment channel history. But without that, if it was contested, well then you literally have to post every transaction in series that happened on the channel to make it actually make the blockchain submit the final one as the correct one. [01:00:34] Right. But he was very much you know prominent in like pushing that idea that like I think there's something here, we just have to sort this out, and maybe there's some sort of a solution in proofs or this, that or the other. So I thought which was used in the eventual solution to scale to scale as a payment network. [01:00:53] Yep. On Lightning, yeah. It's the basis of lightning. Yeah. The beautiful the god I remember reading the lightning white paper when that dropped in 20, what was it, 2015? And trying so hard. I had to read it like a couple of times, and it was one of those ones that like I had to take a Ibuprofen like halfway through and then like then sit back down and do it again. [01:01:15] Because trying to imagine like trying to picture in my head, like it was our I was I literally staring at that freaking screen, trying to make sense of what the hell it was doing. But that clever little circle of updating the new state with the key that releases the old state, but letting the insurance contract on it ride, like updating the insurance every single time, and then leaving that with a window where the key for the last transaction could negate it, just blew [01:01:53] My mind. Like that was I thought that was as clever and fascinating of a system as Bitcoin was when I first saw it. Like that's such a brilliant use of the incentive structure within just one little two of two contract. Yeah. All of this stuff was just so fucking fascinating. [01:02:12] These there's these like little microeconomic experiences, experiments of how to force cooperation and always have an exit for the cooperative party for the honest party. That's what Bitcoin is on a macro scale, and that's what lightning is on a micro scale. That's amazing. [01:02:30] Poon and Dreja shout out like seriously. I was got absolutely brilliant. Man. Well, I mean, because like speaking of tech, right? Like you could we're up to lightning now. We kind of walked from the past and made a couple of stops on memory lane there, and we moved into kind of the tech transition as well. [01:02:56] Let's talk some taproot, man. Like you've got the hashtag in your Twitter, you know, Twitter handle now, hashtag taproot2020. So I did the same. And you know, want to try to spread that that idea around that you know, we need to get we need to get this thing going, right? So why is why is Taproot so important to get out you know sooner than later I genuinely think that like I still want a lot of new development and new features to come to the Bitcoin chain like on-chain that obviously would require soft forks but [01:03:36] As far as ossification of the code goes I think if we got taproot I would be okay with ossifying after that if we couldn't get anything else in because I think what's increasingly going to happen is that contracts and signatures and the scripts that are involved in these things and the encumbrances of you know attaching a public key to or signing with a hash of some other data or some other secret or the output of some other program or something into [01:04:15] The signature of a transaction I think those things are going to become so widespread that it's important that we make those as efficient private and capable as possible absolutely and right now you basically have to tell the Bitcoin chain all of the possible scripts you have to write this huge tree and you have to publish this whole tree to the Bitcoin blockchain, which means it cost a fortune. [01:04:48] Like it's a massive data hog. And more importantly, not only is it a data hog that's expensive for the person issuing the transaction, but it's also a huge burden on the computation of validating the chain. Yes. Like if you ever like after you get to like multi-sig and like lightning network and all of these transactions, if you like while you're syncing up a node, you know, all the empty blocks up to like you know block 200,000 or something like that go in like an hour. [01:05:18] They like it just plows through all of them. And then it starts to slow down for another 200,000 when blocks are kind of full and you're getting full like one megabyte blocks and stuff, and we're kind of getting to that period where transactions are really heavy. But then you kind of get into the complex transactions, and those last blocks just your computer has to churn, you know, like it really slows down as time goes on because transactions are getting more and more complex. [01:05:47] Taproot is both a huge boost to the validation, it's a huge efficiency and cost savings to the chain in not having to publish all of that scripting data, not having to tell the chain all of the crap that you're doing behind it. [01:06:06] And it's a huge benefit to privacy because you're not showing all of that explicit, all of those explicit paths in the transaction or the multi-sig or the lightning channel or whatever the hell it is you're doing to the transparent public blockchain. You're using it for the one for the very thing that it's supposed to be used for, securing the monetary policy, period, and securing the monetary policy and the ownership of the coins. [01:06:34] And you don't have to show who's owning it, or who has the signature power, or who has the backup and the insurance clause in that signature power. You don't need any of that. [01:06:48] Turns all of that into a single public key and a single signature. It hides all of it with mast with the Merkalized abstract abstract syntax trees, blah blah. The where you create this off of the transaction, off of the chain, everything, you create this tree of possible paths that you have, of the multi-sig contracts, of like in the lightning case, you have the cooperative close potential, the insurance close potential, and the punishment clause. [01:07:21] Like you have these three different branches. Well, you put all that together and you give the root hash of all of that and mix that with the signatures and produce one public key and one signature, and it looks identical to any other one-to-one transaction on the chain. [01:07:40] Period. You see none of it, and therefore also you have to validate none of it. You just check the check the hash. Boom. You just validation becomes so freaking cheap. And the ability, like like the things that you can do with that are you just open up a whole new world, and you can really start to breaking down like one UTXO into ownership of many different parties. [01:08:09] You really simplify splicing in and splicing out of light, like all the lightning channel opening, closing, splicing, looping, all of that shit becomes so much easier. More private. More private. Lightning network goes completely dark. You can't even use a lightning network explorer anymore. [01:08:28] You can't look at the chain and know what's lightning and what's not. Which kind of sucks, but it's awesome. You know. So I just think what's funny is that it actually doesn't come with the usual trade-offs. Usually, you know, you get one benefit at the cost of something else, or you know, it takes a little bit longer to validate, but you get all these great features in the transaction, or you get all these awesome features, but it costs a little bit more in data. [01:08:58] Like usually there's always something that is the negative side of it, and Taproot has managed to almost have no negative. The like I think the only thing is that to do a certain type of transaction or or to differentiate it, it takes like one bit, like literally one bit or one byte. [01:09:18] I can't remember what it was, and they had to decide where and how exactly to put in that byte to kind of mitigate that one thing. And that was actually contentious, believe it or not, to figure out how to manage that one tiny little difference. Love it. But that it's it's just it's just good across the board, better for efficiency, better for the block space, and better for privacy. [01:09:41] And if we can get that into the Bitcoin code base, I think what we can do with that opens up enough possibility that Bitcoin could work almost indefinitely with a layer two and layer three protocols and be incredibly secure, not open us up to all these new risks, and still be pretty damn feature rich and get back enough privacy at the base layer to enable privacy for the normal retail payment system for for a global payment [01:10:19] System yeah yeah that's so awesome man I mean it there are can you give us a couple examples of proposals that you know are really are reliant on the Taproot software well the I'm not sure if signature aggregation because it's got schnor signatures is kind of the base of Taproot so it's like BIP 1 39 140 141 I can't remember I can't remember what the numbers are but it's like three of them in one taproot and then the verification and then Schnorr signatures. [01:10:56] And mast I think is in there too but mast is one of the yeah and so kind of the really all the proposals that are wait a second is the is the vault actually a consequence of do you know the callback function like the vaults is that from a different opcode is that from see oh god I should have read about this again recently I have to begin to since [01:11:34] I read mastering bitcoin that's been taken years so I put I put most of that information aside the details of the opcodes anyway. Yeah I think I think really the big the big benefit to Taproot, I don't think is any even a specific proposal. It's just that everything that we're doing now can be made more efficient. [01:11:55] Like multi-sig, like right now, multi-sig is like a huge burden, but it's kind of becoming the standard. Like, I don't like to have anything, any large amount that's not behind multi-sig. I don't even like the idea of relying on one hardware wallet anymore for my security. Like, particularly if, you know, like with the ledger privacy dump and like I've got this new one Cobalt Cobo Vault. [01:12:17] I'm not sure if you've played with that one yet. I haven't hit, but it's really cool looking, but you know, I don't a hundred percent sure if I trust it. Like, they're a new company, you know. Like, I don't I don't know of anybody who's reviewed the firmware and stuff in these things. Like, it could be a honeypot, you know, they could be trying to steal a bunch of people's Bitcoin. So, but it's okay to use it in like a multi-sig. [01:12:37] You know, I don't have to trust that hardware wallet. I'm splitting up that trust among multiple if I do a two of three multi-sig. And that's getting easier. You got like Casa, you got like Blockstream Green, you've got a caravan and all these things that are making this much easier to basically sign with multiple keys, just kind of swap those suckers in and out and hit it, hit approve, hit approve, hit approve, and you know, you've got a signature. [01:13:01] Because of that, the our the new security standard is a giant bloat on the chain. And of course, obviously it's a privacy giveaway that you know, you have a multi-sig, and Taproot natively has threshold signatures, which are ex basically the same thing, just done with Schnorr signatures and kind of a different mechanism. [01:13:27] But it's multi-sig. It's multi-sig with one signature. Again, all of the all of the tracking of multi-sig outputs and stuff on the chain, you're getting to see is like, oh, look, all these people are. Here's all the multi-sigs that are related to lightning. Here are all the multi-sigs that appear to be somebody's savings account. [01:13:48] And maybe even they can connect it to like services can easily connect it to. No, shut up. Shut up, alarm. Okay. But that taproot just hides all of this. I want people to see as little data as possible when they're looking at the blockchain. [01:14:09] I actually like even though the efficiency is great, it really is. And particularly like in validation and stuff, because as someone who [01:14:21] Someone's talking to someone out the window. This is I think we've got delivery here. Hold on a second. This is organic security, meet space security. I gotta get my I gotta get my gun just in case my security alarm went off. [01:14:38] One minute, second. [01:14:46] False alarm. Nobody's here to murder me. Take all your Bitcoin. Which which they couldn't because I was deleting, I was I was I had my hammer out ready to destroy my transitor. Distributed multi-sig, right? Yep, can't do it. I was saying on Twitter, you know, you gotta have signs like you have security signs out there, you know, like this house protected by you know ADC or whatever the security company is called. [01:15:08] Who went out there it says protected by distributed multi-sig, you know? Suppose somebody comes up to your house for the five dollar range attack and be like, ah, move on to the next Bitcoiner. This guy's got multi-sig. No, I don't really feel like kidnapping him and dragging him around to various locations to crack this. [01:15:27] Oh, Jesus. So that's why it's important, guys. Get on the multi-sig before this thing moons, you know. I mean, this thing goes to two 200 300k. Like, you're gonna make sure you have your and a little bit of money in Bitcoin can turn into a lot of money so quickly when things get out of control, that you suddenly it becomes it it became it becomes completely apparent, like like freakishly apparent how not good your security is when you had an account that was like maybe it's only a thousand bucks or whatever, and then suddenly it's like 11 grand. [01:16:05] And you're like, whoo, whoo hoo who okay. Like if if you know, this and you got a hurricane on the out in the water or whatever right now, out in the Atlantic, and you're like, holy crap, if if this floods, I think I would lose all of it right now. Like, I don't have a proper backup, I don't have another key in another place. [01:16:24] And it just feels really, really good when you really focus and get your stuff behind multiple keys, and you know you're protected in a way that like if my house burned down right now, or if I was kidnapped, like I have just enough of a key, but not enough of a key that I could always get it back with time and going to another location, but I wouldn't have I wouldn't lose it, but neither would I be able to give it to someone else. [01:16:56] You know what I mean? Like, like I could be kidnapped and I would just be like, you would have to shoot me. I would be like, I can I can read you the seed of one of my multi-sigs, but like all I have is that I have the one key of my multi-sig. Like I can't give you my Bitcoin, and it's like you're just gonna have to shoot me, or you're gonna have to take me to the bank and the thing, you know, like take me to this other location, just like you were saying. [01:17:17] And it's comforting, even though it probably means they're gonna shoot me. I mean, why there's no no point unless they're just a psychopathic murderer, yeah. Most people are just in it for the money. You know, there's there's some major consequences just to murdering people. [01:17:36] You gotta you most people aren't aren't ready for that. And that one, you know, it's hard, it's yeah, like I said, it's hard to get away with murder, and it will always it'll stay that way. Yeah, especially in an age of decreasing privacy. Yeah, yeah. See, that's that's like that's kind of that horrible trade-off of privacy. [01:17:56] It's like you want bad guys to get caught, but you don't want it's like that trade-off does exist, but obviously, I think without a doubt, the benefits of privacy, yeah. I think the idea of independence and privacy actually discourages the mentality that creates criminality and like and murders and stuff like the I like sound money and personal responsibility. [01:18:22] I think I think so much of the mentality that leads to criminality and stuff is that I'm entitled to your stuff, is that like I'm I'm hopeless and there's I'm not even in control of my own life. Like, so much of it is is an attempt to control something when you feel like you have no control. [01:18:43] And I think sound money, the or or I guess poisonous money, controlled and corrupted money, is such a source of that sort of thing spreading throughout society, and you actually kind of see that is when you get to these times when society is bloated and full of debt and all of these are things are going awry, you get exactly a huge explosion in that sort of mentality in criminal behavior and violent behavior and all of this stuff. [01:19:13] So I think you can't really separate those two, even though in the short term it appears that privacy and independence and the ability to be anonymous or whatever, all of those things may benefit criminality in the short term. I think in the long term it kind of gets at the root of what causes criminality. There was an era before crime fighting, you know, relied on killing your privacy. [01:19:40] There, I mean, you know, the before so you know, good old-fashioned police work can happen again, right? And you know, even with Taproot, the you know, the blockchain is still monitored monitorable and you can, you know, still pseudonymous. It's going to hide the details of contracts and et cetera, which is good, but it's not gonna hide identities necessarily. [01:20:01] You know, and even even if the lightning network goes dark, it's still gonna be hard to route massive amounts of money over it. So, you know, if you're gonna be doing some engaging in some huge, you know, international like arms deal or something like that, you know, you're not gonna be doing it on lightning. So yeah, it's a whole lot better for them to use the banking system and Deutsche Bank right now to get that done. [01:20:27] Of course. But there's there's something really interesting, actually, in this this kind of little bit going too far down this topic, but that I think it's in the crypto anarchist manifesto. I don't know if it's the crypto anarchist or the cypherpunk manifesto, one of the manifestos, talks about how an anonymous system is not a secret system, and that it's about allowing the parties involved to disclose explicitly what they want to disclose to the world, what they want the public to know, but [01:21:06] That they simply have the option of remaining private, whereas a secret system is one where nobody knows, where where you're doing something that you think is wrong or bad, and you don't want you don't want anyone to know it, like it's it's your privilege, it's your access. [01:21:24] But that's kind of in the fascinating thing about something like lightning is that the transactions are private between you and who you're transacting with. So the old-fashioned police work will be going to the person you had a transaction with, and if it's was indeed one to hurt somebody or do something terrible or evil or traffic and human trafficking or something like that, it's it's the same as transmitting Yeah, it's the same as transmitting a big old bag of cash to the person who you're hiring to murder somebody. [01:21:53] Exactly, exactly. The real world associations between the two parties is are going to be there. Yeah. But back to taproot. This this is a tangent from Taproot. But one of the big things that there's the signature aggregation, which is another massive both privacy and efficiency improvement, where like it will take aggregation and batching of transactions to this whole other level where now rather than having a public key for [01:22:31] Or a signature and key for every individual output, you can actually combine them all into a single key. So me, you, Corey, Jan, we could all have a transaction where we were batching together, and usually we would have to have we would have to sign every single UTXO. [01:22:52] Well, we can sign and add all of our signatures together, like literally like a linear, like an algebraic just adding them together, and then sit that one signature, that one block of information with all of our UTXOs. And not only does it mean that nobody can tell who owns which one, like there's no explicit signature for these four, one signature for these two, blah, blah, blah. [01:23:18] Like, there's no none of those connections, but there's only one piece of data. There's one 200 bit, whatever the whatever the size is, signature block for all of the UTXOs. And this can go to thousands and thousands of them. And that is huge. And obviously without Schnorr and Taproot, not even possible. [01:23:38] This is step one to getting there. And then the other one is L2, the improvement to Lightning Network that will hugely simplify the process of updating channels. In fact, there was one I haven't read it yet, but somebody was talking about the process of moving funds into and out of a lightning channel. [01:24:05] Man, I'm I know I have that saved in my list somewhere. I probably need to do a guy's take on this because this one was already blowing my mind. But I think I had something to do I think it was something that was enabled by L2 but it was basically like on the fly adding of money to a channel when you had not enough liquidity that basically didn't really alter that much from the normal updating of a channel like like it was just incredibly easy and incredibly fast and I mean that that fixes so many routing I mean that makes routing just so much better right [01:24:43] Basically solves any routing issues and it's almost like it like it is it like an automatic pull kind of situation from like can you obviously Bitcoin's push but could you how where does it get the liquidity I guess from a different UTXO. Okay it's wrapping in a different UTXO which is not any different from splicing or anything. [01:25:08] It's just that rather than closing and reopening the channel you're just you're you're just rewriting this the current one with the new UTXO in it. Yeah and boom you've got that liquidity. So do you have to create a channel with like a list of you know UTXOs that are available to splice in or something like that. [01:25:28] I don't know. I don't know that deep yet but I'm I'm going into it because I just saved it as guy definitely definitely read into and watch this preferably before you go on citizen Bitcoin so you can talk about it. But yeah, well, I gave you two days heads up, so hey, it's not your fault. [01:25:50] Man. All right, so Taproot, man. Tapper we gotta get Tavroot in there sooner than later. You know, of course we want to it it's been on a BIP for quite a while. And of course the devs are extremely conservative and responsible with pushing out even soft forks, which you know appropriately so. [01:26:12] But you know, it's it's getting pretty mature, I feel at this point in doable this year. And what do you think then of like the future of soft forks? You know, like how many more softworks are we gonna get in on the protocol before you know we're already ossified on hard forking? That's done. [01:26:31] So do you think like will it be to a point where the community will not accept soft forks anymore in the same way that you know we have we are refusing to accept hard forks from you know the block size limit debate onward? Yeah, I don't know. I think ossification is just kind of going to happen, you know, you know, like like concreting this protocol is basically an inevitability at some point. [01:27:00] Yeah. And I would like to see something where soft forks were just kind of open-ended, where the activation period was basically indefinite in the sense that like IPv6 is a is kind of my thinking about a comparison here, is that we've been implementing IPv6 over IPv4. [01:27:28] We're still using IPv4. But been trying to implement IPv6 for Jesus, 15 years? I don't like it. It just seems like extremely long time. But it's still really not, it hasn't flipped. We're still like when I look at my address, I've got an IPv4 address. [01:27:47] You know, like but if we actually get Softworks down the road, I think we're two or three away before it gets so difficult that we need like a 20-year activation period, kind of like IPv6. But that just to leave it there, to just be like, this is just here. [01:28:07] If you want to run this, and if you think this is good for the software, like signal it, like and run the software that allows it to be possible, but it just doesn't activate until we've got 90%. Yeah. And if we're it's five years later, if it were 73%, we just wait. [01:28:26] Right. Just wait. And it does nothing. It's just dormant. Nobody looks at it, nobody talks about it, nobody verifies it. If a transaction came in, like if somebody forced activate it or something, it would verify it, but not until you get 90% or whatever is it strictly activated for that client. And it gives the option of somebody who wants to do a more strict or more like push a little bit harder and get activation to run a client that's compatible with it, but it just allows us to take our time as needed because I think it's going to get increasingly more difficult. [01:29:01] And that's also why I think we should just kind of push on taproot right now. Yeah, is that it's still small. We're like Bitcoin is still really small. The community is still pretty damn small, [01:29:16] Like the number of nodes is still pretty small. Like it's never, it's not the longer we wait, the harder it is to get it in. Right. And you know, we've got two and a half years, almost three years of development already. And it's only like you know, 500 lines of code, which is within a block that isn't like that doesn't change the other consensus code, you know. [01:29:35] It's like a derivative of like just signatures. So I think the risk is low enough and the change is so uncontentious that it's like let's just kind of push and get this one in so that we can start working on the next one because we've kind of bricked all of the work with L2 with signature aggregation with all these other things that are coming down the line. [01:29:59] I think there's like five or six really that are kind of dependent on this, and none of that can happen until we get to Aperate. So I think it makes sense that we just kind of push now while we've got the opportunity, because it's going to get so much harder after you know, if we have two more bull markets, you know, if we have this post-halving turns out to have another huge hype wave, and then we go into another halving and that happens again. [01:30:23] If this is actually the cycle of Bitcoin, and this is something that we can kind of expect to happen in the future, it's gonna be freaking hard. Yeah, right. To do this later on. So take the opportunity while we got it. Yeah, it makes sense to me, man. Makes sense to me. [01:30:42] So what it what's your price target, bro? For this run. What are you thinking? Like six figures at minimum? Minimum. Minimum. I think it's going to be. I think we're underestimating. I think because this last huge run-up was actually subdued from the previous one. [01:31:05] I think I think it's natural too to expect that it will be less, like as time goes on. Yeah. But the I think we're all gonna underestimate. I think the multiples have decreased with every run, you know, they've almost halved every run. So it's like 50 two runs ago, 50x and 20x in this last run. [01:31:23] So even if it's 10x, that's 200k. I almost feel like, you know, it's like 100k is gonna be the 10k of this run, you know. Yeah. It and everyone's gonna be like, okay, 100k, that's that's big number, right? And I think he'll be selling at 100k. [01:31:43] But the just mere fact that it crosses 100k just triggers so much attention that you know it just pushes back through it and has a you know another like six-week blow off top, you know. And that that would be that would be it, you know, a half half of the increase of the last run. [01:32:04] You know, then you go five X the next run, that's a million dollar Bitcoin. Yeah, close to it. So I don't know. The I think that this one is going to I try to look at it as the at the scale of the problem that needs to be solved, and the degree in which this is going to get progressively worse as time goes on. [01:32:27] And you know, a hundred thousand dollar Bitcoin is only like what was it, like 1.8 trillion dollar market cap or something like that. Yeah, I think one trillion is is at 55k. It's the trillion dollar market cap. So yeah, it's about right. Yeah. [01:32:46] That's small in comparison to the problem. There's a few tech companies that have a market cap of a trillion dollars, or yeah. Exactly. Exactly. Apple hit a trillion or whatever it was. Yeah. And I think they were the first in the I think the first of the first. I think so, yeah. [01:33:04] Yeah. But that that there's why, like, and again, the problem being solved is trillions being spent all over the place. I mean, the Fed just printed collectively between deficits of the US government, the Fed adding to the balance sheet, like that's six trillion, something like seven trillion right there. [01:33:28] Just just yeah, just there in a matter of months. Yeah. 1.8 trillion dollars is nothing for Bitcoin. And I think once it becomes a trillion dollar market, so many people are going to be looking at it that are that have that connection and that amount of capital. Like it becomes important in that sphere. [01:33:48] Yeah, and I think it's gonna be a game changer. I think it's gonna be huge. I think that's I think this bull this market is or this this bull run is going to really surprise a lot of people. I think we're underestimating. Yeah, I could see that. I mean, you know, you break all time previous all-time high leg up to 55k, 100 trillion dollar market cap fires off a whole nother round of attention, leg up to 100k, 100k fires off one round of, you know, it's just like it keeps going, and then you know, then you're starting to rival the gold market cap, which is you know, gonna you know, getting close enough, you're gonna get your large percentage of it. [01:34:25] You know, that's gonna drive all kinds of talk and attention. And I think the you know, the big narrative will be, you know, the digital gold, which you know it are it really already is for most investors. That's the that's the thesis for you know big time traditional legacy system, you know, macro investors. [01:34:43] And that's you know, that's just gonna it's gonna be the heyday, right? It's gonna be digital gold. And then maybe the next run it'll be, you know, replacing the new reserve currency. Maybe they'll start taking that seriously, you know. But yeah, you gotta go through the steps. That the narrative is though, start challenging big or gold's market cap boom. [01:35:04] Like that's that's where you can really go nuts, right? Yeah, that's where that's where the underestimation I think happened, and things can just go crazy. Yeah, and I think we've got the technology with lightning finally coming into its own and kind of realizing its place. With an article I just read the other day, another one that I just loved was Lightning as a retail payment system. [01:35:25] It compares the global, the current global payments and settlement networks with what if we just took Bitcoin and Lightning as they are today and replaced the infrastructure of our payment systems. What would it look like? How do you compare the costs and you know trade-offs of the two? [01:35:46] And there's just so much benefit and so much cost savings just in using lightning and Bitcoin as settlement and payment rails. Yeah. Yeah. And I think, and you're looking at something that has to be necessarily has to be a three or four trillion dollar marketplace. [01:36:05] But I think we're gonna have, I think we're gonna have an infrastructure inversion pretty soon. I think the biggest use case for lightning will be in retail payments for dollars. It will be what Strike is doing, and Cash App will start doing it. I think Square will get into that. Where look, you can settle this payment immediately across all of these borders. [01:36:28] And it costs you a penny to do it, or half a percent or a tenth of a percent or whatever the hell it is. And you sent dollars from here to there, and nobody has to know that they're using Bitcoin, but that the company has set themselves up with a giant liquid lightning position. [01:36:49] They are managing channels, they are managed, they have created a liquidity market. We have derivatives that are hedged with lightning settlements that happen instantly, so people can hedge a retail payment across the border, like like they hedge huge business payments on Forex. So that they're not playing the currency game, but instead they're playing the, you know, they're doing business, you know, like the value of the transaction. [01:37:13] Lightning allows that to happen instantly. You don't have to wait for settlement if you have that capital there to have it. Instant settlement is the you know the real revolution, that the invention, right? Like, whereas, you know, Bitcoin, the real invention is digital scarcity, you know, the revolution, the revolutionary idea and accomplishment there. [01:37:31] Lightning is instant settlement. It's never been done before. And then simultaneously, to do that without the walled gardens, you're speaking a compatible language that now PayPal, Venmo, Sirius, the like ATM networks, like Cash App, like all of these services, they're all walled gardens, they're all intranets. [01:37:55] And lightning would prevent present them with an internet, an internet of money to go back and forth between all of them without having to go back to the bank, without having to wait until business hours to settle, without having to issue a Fed wire. Like now there's instant settlement, and they're all speaking the same language. [01:38:14] They're now that they just moved from the intranet age and to the internet age. And anybody can become a payment service. LNBP BP, baby, LNP. The LNPB, the new TCP IP. And the barrier is just nothing. [01:38:32] It's like right now the barrier is a freaking banking license. It requires tens of millions of dollars in like a bond for insurance. It requires years of dealing with regulators and getting permission and like just nightmarish on across the board. But that lightning is just run a node, couple hundred bucks. [01:38:54] And suddenly you can be a payment service app on a global space on the internet. It will be the I used to have to set up an ATT giant soul infrastructure spanning the whole country. And now, boom, I can just set up a website. I think I think we are about to see that shift that happened from the old ATT like monopoly to the anybody can set up a website, anybody can design a service, and nobody has to ask anybody's permission that we saw on the internet and communication. [01:39:25] We are about to witness that in money and finance. I think it's gonna be absolutely huge, and people are totally underestimating what it's gonna mean. Oh yeah, absolutely, man. It's gonna be amazing. And if that happens, then it only makes sense that Bitcoin becomes a global reserve currency. [01:39:46] So it's it's you know, like Bitcoin is inevitable. You know, you know. We keep coming back to this, and like you want to stay humble, right? It's it's hard, man. It's hard when you see the possibility, and then you understand network effects and you know, just all of the borders and barriers that Bitcoin breaks down, how much more efficient it is. [01:40:15] So you have this massive efficiency gain, you have insane network effects that can't be achieved by you know, just legacy systems that are just terribly inefficient. It's it's inevitable, it's gonna happen. It's gonna happen. An open permissionless network is simply an open source, an open source, open access, permissionless network that anybody can build and innovate on is better. [01:40:44] Bitcoin is going to beat out closed, permissioned, hierarchical walled gardens. [01:40:49] At the end of the day, it just always going to be the case. Yeah, we've seen it too many times in history, and we have got a perfect example of that happening all over again. And it's like, do you really not want to be hedged in that? Do you not want to be invested a little bit in that? Are you really gonna bet on the closed walled permissioned gardens? [01:41:08] Because that's not that's not my I doubt it. I really doubt it. I'm certain I'm certainly not betting on them. No, we were so two little quotes that came up. One is Preston Pysh, and these are both from Swan Signal. Preston Pysh said that you know, the chance that Bitcoin reaches escape velocity on this next run is vastly underestimated. [01:41:32] Yeah. Right. And he's not saying that it's absolutely gonna happen, but the chance of it happening is absolutely underestimated. And by escape velocity, he means no turning back, like no more bear markets. Like Bitcoin just goes up and up and up, you know, in a in a staggered way, of course, but the curved, it it's it's it's the S curve. You reach the asymptote of the S curve and it's escape velocity. [01:41:53] Right. And the other one from yesterday, Lyn Alden and Jeff Booth were talking about, you know, like I asked him about the percentage. It was it was amazing, man. Jeez, Lyn Alden is a freaking genius. And Jeff Booth, of course, the three reasons or whatever why investing in Bitcoin or whatever. [01:42:12] I've already got a little bit of it done, but I'm getting back to it after we it's a great one, man. It's a great one. And yeah, so I asked him about the percentage of portfolio investment that would be like prudent or whatever, you know, and of course it depends on like the age of the investor. And they talked about how you know wealth creation, you want to narrow your focus, your investment, and you know, like a younger kid who's looking for wealth creation might want to bet a lot more. [01:42:38] You know, and then we start talking about like a like a big investor like Paul Tudor Jones put in like something like he said a little over one percent of his billions into Bitcoin. You know, that's that's like a prudent investment. And you know, Jeff Jeff Booth is like, you're negligent if you don't have you know Bitcoin in your portfolio. You know, and he said he's like he's like if you know should have you know more than one percent you know, and it was just you know, it was great. [01:43:05] But I'm sitting here thinking, and you know, Lynn Otley was talking also about like it it depends on your emotional capacity and conviction in the protocol, right? Because it's gonna be super volatile, and we all know this, right? We all we've all spent years developing conviction. I'm sitting here thinking like I was born in the book. [01:43:24] I am you now. You only I am so I'm so inherited like over relatively overinvested in Bitcoin, you know, compared to this advice. But I'm zen as fuck, man. You know, yeah, dude. I'm zen as fuck. I it does not bother me at all. It's totally okay. Like, I don't like I see it, and I mean I get excited when it dips. [01:43:45] Like, and I talk about this on the show, it's like people like were freaking out, and like and I admit I had like two or three minutes of like what the hell is happening? And I went hunting for quantum computer on Google, like to like somebody break something here. And I found none of it, and then I was I was I haven't been that excited in ages. [01:44:04] And I managed to buy them up at like 4k. I was that was the that was the birth of Swan Signal Live too. Because the next day it was like a Thursday, just like massive red candle, everyone freaking out down to three, you know, 3.8k, I think is where bottom. And you I we I called you guys up or like message you guys up, is like you and Vallis and Hass and Gigi. [01:44:28] I was like, we gotta go live, man. We gotta go live, we gotta talk, we gotta talk to the big coiners. We gotta talk to the big coiners tomorrow morning. So exciting. It's straight up Zen. Like, I don't it's just kind of part of life now. Like it's not even I don't know, I've been with it so long, it's not it just it just gets me to refocus when I do things, you know. [01:44:50] It just means like, oh, I'll I'll take it easy here, or well, I'll I'll buy and save during this period. Okay, now's a good time to relinquish some of it to do that thing that I've been meaning to do, like that sort of thing. But if I'm not 98% invested, I get nervous. You know, if I'm like, if I'm like down to 90, I'm like, shit, I got too much in the bank. [01:45:11] Like, I gotta get this hell out of here. It's just flips. Like, like once you, it's that's what happens. You're through the looking glass, right? You know, you go from being just nervous as fuck, like, is this, you know, is this thing gonna fail? You know, you watch the 30% dip, you're like, I'm losing all my money. This thing's going to zero. You just freak out. I remember those days. Yeah. Like, you know, and I'm I'm just like, I'm on a, you know, Matt Odell talks about how he was like just absolutely, you know, like shamed by his friends, and like his dad was giving him shit, you know, and stuff. [01:45:40] And he just like he was like, I'm I'm gonna, I'm you know, develop that conviction, and we all hang on through these bear markets, and it's just man, it's it's the opposite of what everyone's feeling when they don't know what's going on. You get excited by the dips, you look at you know, you know, you have money sitting in a savings account, you have money invested in stonks. [01:46:04] No, what are you doing? What are you doing? You're gonna buy it, you're gonna buy a new house with a couple extra bedrooms? No, fuck no. I'm fine, I'm good. I'm Bitcoin, you know. It's like solid, yo. I remember when I keep driving, I'm gonna keep driving this you know, 2002 clunker. I don't care. I'm in it, I'm in it to win it, baby. [01:46:24] All in God, I still got that absolute piece of crap car, specifically because of that. I'm literally 2002 clunker, I got a 1989 clunker, yeah. And I will drive that thing until it dies. Oh my god. [01:46:43] It will just break. I will have to leave it on the side of the road whenever it whenever I'm forced to buy something new. But it's funny, like during 2017 when it was kind of coming into like everybody's consciousness and suddenly all the annoyance that I had been in like everybody's ears like by the way, Bitcoin, you should check out Bitcoin. [01:47:08] I finally had like friends like wow, it looks like like Bitcoin's really doing a thing. Are you are you getting to where you're ready to sell? Like when are you gonna sell? Right, right. And I've I would be like, oh no, you still don't get it. Right? There's there is no sell. [01:47:28] Like, like I'm not like Bitcoin sats are my safe haven. Like there, I'm I am divesting from the dollar. Yeah, it'll probably peak, and yeah, we'll probably find ourselves in another bear market, but I'm divesting, not investing. Like I'm I'm getting out of the old and safely positioning myself in the new. [01:47:52] There is no sell. There's no going back. Period. It's just done. Yeah, I mean, I wouldn't be surprised if you can start, you know, just buying a lot more in Bitcoin, large assets in Bitcoin over this next run. So like I you know, hopefully you don't even need to be able to do that. Oh, I totally think so. If you're you know, I mean, I actually put out a poll. [01:48:14] I was like, so Bitcoin, you know, moons this run. What are you gonna do? Are you just gonna hodl on ride or die? Or are you gonna chip a piece off, you know, and you know, for whatever you live your life. And it was about half and half. About half and half. [01:48:33] So you know, there's Bitcoiners out there, and that makes sense, man. Everyone's got a time preference, you know. You know, we're not fucking gonna hoard, right? Deflationary spiral from hoarding does not exist. It's a lie because we, you know, maybe you want to do something, right? Maybe you want to buy a new house. Maybe you want to take your kids on a fucking around the world, you know, like adventure that you will never be able to do because they're gonna grow up in the next few years. [01:48:58] You know what I mean? Yeah, at the end of the day at the end of the day, like our two most scarce assets, our two most scarce resources are Bitcoin and time. Right. Like and Bitcoin is just a means to an end. It's it's we need to fix the imbalance of imbalances of society and we need to be able to allocate and communicate our resources and our value to make our lives better. [01:49:25] Like so at the end of the day like I can't wait until the rest of my life is over. Like I like the whole point is to be able to live the life that I want to live. And you know I've already like like I've leaned on Bitcoin to make this podcast happen. I couldn't spend my life doing bullshit that I didn't want to do anymore that I didn't care about. [01:49:47] And I was so passionate about this that I was just like I had to start something and I had to do it. And the wife was just like do it you know like like like make it happen. Like I know it's that important to you so let's let's do it together. I'll I'll help and we'll we'll work together and make it happen. And you did it's awesome and I love it. [01:50:08] I like I mean it sucks to think that like I had to sell to manage that but I don't regret it because it was the reason I had Bitcoin so I could devote to Bitcoin. Yeah, yeah. Exactly. So I don't know. I don't know. It's plus, man. You have to pay for your time you have to you have to get your time back out of it. Exactly. This is even, you know, this is the next step to skin in the game, right? [01:50:30] You buy some Bitcoin to get some skin in the game, but you want to get what Robert Brelo would call soul in the game. Yeah, you spend all your time, right? You devote your life, your your you know, non-family working life to Bitcoin. And I know there's a lot of people out there that really want to make that happen. And the Bitcoin only industry is you know is burgeoning, it's growing, it's it's you know, this is just the beginning. [01:50:54] And you know, you guys are gonna be you know, ripe for the picking. Bitcoin companies are gonna be growing and looking for talent, and they're gonna be looking for bitcoiners. That's what that's what we do at Swan. We look for Bitcoiners. Like you want to work at Swan, well, you gotta be a Bitcoiner first, yeah. And then we look at you know, your skills and talent in other in other areas, right? [01:51:14] And what we need, but like, you know, the this is you're not only part of a revolution, but you are building a resume for an industry that is going to explode. So just keep going, just keep going. Yeah, yeah. I'm I'm not going anywhere. [01:51:34] I got none else to do. Okay, this is just what I do now. So exactly. Well, if I didn't record it, I'd still be doing it, right? Exactly. They just hit record. Yeah, yeah. I mean, this is just two Bitcoiners talking bitcoin. And so this whole podcast is just two Bitcoiners talking bitcoin. [01:51:52] Oh, yeah. You know, just people like to listen to that. That should be the new name. Two to two people talking bitcoin. Yeah, two Bitcoiners talking bitcoin. It's a little long, but could be like a subtitle, maybe. I don't know. Citizen Bitcoin, two Bitcoiners talkers talking bitcoin. There are too many Bitcoins in this title. [01:52:12] I like the Dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance, man. I'm gonna stick with that. It's a little bit more poetic. I dig it. Whatever, shit all over my idea. I don't care. Nah, man. I appreciate your input. Oh good fun. Man, all right. I do have some other shit to do. I gotta get back to work. [01:52:32] Really? How? I do. I have a few things to do to get done today. Thanks today. Yeah. A few things to do. I know you got something to read, I'm sure. Yep. I'm gonna finish my I'm gonna finish this BitMax's research Bitcoin software activation methodology that I'm reading through right now. And then get back to the recording for the day. [01:52:50] The guy who's read more about Bitcoin than anyone else you know. Young Zo! All right, bro. This is good talking, man. Yeah, man. Take care. Enjoy it as always. Take it easy, dude. [01:53:13] Thanks to Guy for joining me. Find him on Twitter at the cryptoconomy at the C-R-Y-P-T-O-C-O-N-O-M-Y. And find his show Bitcoin Audible at Bitcoin Audible on Twitter. And I'm at citizenbitcoin on the Bitcoin Twitter. [01:53:31] The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. Share this one out with your family and friends. Shout me out on Twitter, me and Guy, let us know what you liked. Share it with your crew on Twitter, the Bitcoiners out there. You know, let them know that that that you like this, or let me know something that you'd like to see improved, or new another guest you'd like to see me get on the show. [01:53:52] I'd love to hear from all of you out there. My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm also at Citizen Bitcoin on Telegram. You can find me in both places. Thanks again to Swan Bitcoin for sponsoring this episode and to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the Citizen Bitcoin in the podcast eed. Check out my merchandise shop at layer1btc.com. Click on partners and then citizenbitcoin. [01:54:11] There's cool stuff there to check out. And check out the podcast I've created for Swan, the Swan Signal Podcast. It's an audio archive of our weekly Swan Signal Live broadcasts. We have a pair of Bitcoiners on for a compelling discussion. I think it's a unique format in the space and deserves a spot in your rotation. Check it out and see if you agree with me at swansignalpodcast.com. [01:54:34] If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. Like I said, my DMs are always open on Twitter, and I'm at Citizen Bitcoin on Telegram. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.