WEBVTT

1
00:00:15.520 --> 00:00:44.640
Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're sharing our journey, learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Hope you all are doing fantastic. It is May 31st, 2019, which means it's time for another basement bulletin episode in which my friend Tommy and I get together in the basement of an old church in Lawrence, Kansas, where Tommy lives to talk about what happened this month in Bitcoin.

2
00:00:44.640 --> 00:01:12.640
One thing that happened this month in Bitcoin is that we got a lot more five-star ratings and reviews for the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We're up to 29 on iTunes now, and I am extremely bullish that we're going to break through that overhead resistance at 30 with authority this week. These ratings really helped me bootstrap this thing, and it's very appreciated if you can take a minute to toss us a five-star rating, and a nice review is major bonus points.

3
00:01:12.640 --> 00:01:31.200
So thanks to everyone who's helped out on that front so far, and thank you to you for doing that this week for us. Alright, our special guest co-host for this month's basement bulletin episode is Ansel Lindner, Bitcoin Maximalist OG and the host of the great Bitcoin and Markets podcast.

4
00:01:31.200 --> 00:01:49.760
You can find Ansel on Twitter at Ansel Lindner, that's A-N-S-E-L-L-I-N-D-N-E-R. And Bitcoin and Markets is at BTCMRKTS. We get into the Bitcoin culture debate. We take a look at macroeconomic trends and consider how they might affect Bitcoin.

5
00:01:49.760 --> 00:02:14.680
We discuss the Peter Schiff versus Safety debate. We talk about this month's rallies in price and mining difficulty. And we talk about the successful 51% attack on Bcash and what we can learn from it as Bitcoiners. Here we go.

6
00:02:15.640 --> 00:02:37.960
Alright, here we are, Tommy and I in the church basement in Lawrence, Kansas. Tommy, how's it going? It's going well. It's going well since earlier this week when we had the tornado come through. We were we were I'm grateful we're we're okay. That was a nasty little beast, and it almost it almost directly hit the town, but fortunately just kind of stayed south and just hit the edge of town and but it was it made for a fun night.

7
00:02:37.960 --> 00:02:59.800
We're joined today to talk about this month in Bitcoin with our guest co-host Ansel Lindner of the Bitcoin and Markets Podcast. We are very fired up to have to have Ansel on the show. How's it going, Ansel? Guys, thanks for inviting me. Yeah, man, of course. It's our pleasure. Glad to have you. All right, let's just get this one out of the way, this first topic out of the way.

8
00:02:59.800 --> 00:03:21.640
The Bitcoin culture war. All right, this this sort of flared up this month. Neil Woodfine posted a thread about basically how Bitcoin is a meritocracy and we need to you know re recognize that and not get caught up in in the you know this idea, these ideas of culture wars and all that.

9
00:03:21.640 --> 00:03:41.640
And you know, this this is sort of a debate that is sort of always kind of low simmer in the community or in and on Twitter, I guess on Bitcoin Twitter, at all times. And every once in a while we have a flare-up, and it seems to for some reason to be like associated with price, you know, either major price declines or major price increases.

10
00:03:41.640 --> 00:04:05.040
You know, get these kind of flare-ups that you know it's like, oh hey, the price is going up. Let's find something to argue about. But it is it's a touchy subject, it's kind of a tricky subject to understand to consider. I myself just stayed out of it on Twitter this past month. I will drop my take, but I'd I'd like to hear from here from from Ansel first.

11
00:04:05.040 --> 00:04:34.960
What do you what's your take on on this culture war debate that happened on Bitcoin Twitter this month? Well, I don't I don't believe there is a Bitcoin culture. I think that there you bring your own bias to this apolitical money. So if you want to there's some people out there that like to be victims and they like to see like oppression everywhere, and you're gonna see that in Bitcoin too, if that's your world outlook.

12
00:04:34.960 --> 00:04:57.200
So I don't I have some specific things to say about Neil's stuff. I think it was spot on, but overall, I it's hey, everybody's welcome in Bitcoin. Go ahead and try to bring your socialism or whatever it is into Bitcoin, that's fine.

13
00:04:57.200 --> 00:05:26.000
But I also have a few things to say about like other things that are simmering. Like you said, that was interesting. You said that it happens with price increases or price declines. And I think a lot of times with the price increase, people get frustrated that maybe their viewpoints aren't front and center.

14
00:05:26.560 --> 00:06:04.840
Some of those things are the socialism versus anarchism or statism that's in Bitcoin. And then there's also this like vegan and carnivore divide that's that's in Bitcoin as well. And I think some of those things can get frustrating. Because the reason why I bring that up is because one of the people that Matt Carrallo in this little debate, he's not well known, but he he is a vegan, and some of the others are well known carnivores, and so it's like just an interesting subcurrent there in all of this

15
00:06:04.840 --> 00:06:43.160
Discussion. Yeah. Tell me what's what's your take? My take is that Bitcoin doesn't care about all this, right? So I mean, I mean the bottom line is it is that if if this is kind of a carryover from from let's say geop geopolitics or DC, the deep state just the whole idea of DC, this is in the United States, or you'd have the EU, and you've got this idea of groups of people influencing the overall outcome of where certain of trying to steer the overall outcome of a particular

16
00:06:43.160 --> 00:07:04.040
Issue or a particular set of a particular situation, and when you've got Bitcoin, it's it's pretty much it's its own algorithm, and it just kind of cruises along. And the whole idea is if if if you want to if you want to change it, then go ahead and try to change the underlying robust structure of it.

17
00:07:04.040 --> 00:07:26.640
But otherwise, you know, you can go ahead and you can go ahead and argue about it all you want or get into it, but it's it's a complete fool's errand. Yeah. So that's kind of my view on it. Well, the whole thing's a fool's errand if anybody's trying to get into all this stuff. Sure. I mean the Matt Caralho certainly has done a lot for Bitcoin in terms in terms of the algorithm the code itself.

18
00:07:26.640 --> 00:08:04.800
He's can he's one of the sure main core contributors and one of the youngest and you know better hash is a great improvement for you know for sorry for mining pools and the ability for individual miners in those pools to kind of to be able to create their own blocks but he's he also I mean I think his main concern is that this toxic culture is driving talent away that Bitcoin could use to you know thrive right and improve and that

19
00:08:04.800 --> 00:08:43.040
That could that is a risk to Bitcoin growing into being the best version of what it could you know of itself in the future right and you know I get that and I get like being passionate about that that idea and I agree that there are people out there that are you know just like unnecessarily mean in expressing their opinions all right and that's I get that I mean I am not that that way I don't like to operate that way I'm I don't like seeing people operate that way but you just block those people right just block them like if you don't want to hear from them just block them on Twitter it's easy this is you know I think bringing

20
00:08:43.040 --> 00:09:01.240
It up and talking about it is one thing but like the way Matt, you know, sort of lashed out at Samson and you know it's is he was very shamey and very judgy. I don't know. It just it sounded a lot like the kind of thing the thing he was kind of criticizing to me, right? Well, right.

21
00:09:01.240 --> 00:09:20.840
And to me, the answer is not let's go out and like talk about hash this out on Twitter and in in a public forum. Just block those people that you don't want to, you know, hear from. You don't like their the way that they interact. Right. Well, the other part of it is in some cases it it makes no there's no it doesn't make any sense to just argue with a brick wall, right?

22
00:09:20.840 --> 00:09:48.120
I guess the other point with that I that it's great that that's a great comment, but and the other part of it is this whole concept of driving people away, right? Well, is that just an anecdotal comment? I mean, is is he saying that okay? Well, last month 42 developers were driven away because of this discussion. Yeah, in his thread he talks about how it's anecdotal, like it's people who he has interacted with and have they have left Bitcoin because of the toxic culture, you know.

23
00:09:48.120 --> 00:10:17.240
Okay, well, how many does it really I mean the idea is well, since it so if it's a situation where he's saying this and he can actually say, oh my god, you know, forty-seven percent of all the future developers and producers with respect to Bitcoin have gone away. You know, that's what the other thing I don't like when you get into this type of situation where it's whatever you call it a culture war and it's it's completely subjective, is it be there's no fact set behind it?

24
00:10:17.240 --> 00:10:39.400
Yeah. I mean, what's his what's what are his facts? I don't I don't buy it either because they can be anonymous, you know. Like if you feel personally attacked, like somebody has some personal issue with you. Just make an anonymous account. Like who's this Voldemort person that came out with Mimblewimble?

25
00:10:39.400 --> 00:11:00.800
Nobody knows. Who's Satoshi? Nobody knows. Like, just make an anonymous that's exactly right. Yeah. Just make just make an anonymous account. And if you're like, if you the reason why they're they're all up in arms is because like the Bcash stuff, too, they did their ideas sucked.

26
00:11:00.800 --> 00:11:23.360
And so the big the big wigs, the big world class protocol developers, didn't which Matt Corrallo is one of them, but they didn't want to listen to the B cachers, and so they thought that they were being antagonized, or they're you know, whatever the wording is.

27
00:11:23.360 --> 00:11:46.720
So yeah, it's just be anonymous and I don't buy the argument that developers getting pushed out. That that's another thing. This all started with Suna from Token Daily, yeah, and Lee Lee Kuen. I don't know how you pronounce her last name, and they were talking, they started talking about Ethereum.

28
00:11:46.720 --> 00:12:07.200
Well, they they recently also have talked about how Ethereum has hotter guys. I'm not kidding you. This was like a week before this whole thing broke up, yeah, broke out. They were both like going back and forth about how oh Ethereum has all the hot guys and stuff, and then they talk about how women I mean, this Buterin guys are leader.

29
00:12:07.200 --> 00:12:27.440
Are they what are they kidding? I mean and so Suna was talking about how all these top oh, she said bright Ethereum core developers, exactly where was her quote. And I was like, where are they? Show me one. Show me show me a anecdotal, yeah.

30
00:12:27.440 --> 00:12:55.080
Yeah, show me a pedigreed Ethereum developer that wanted to be on Bitcoin. So, anyways. Well, what about this guy, Mike Dudas, D U D A S? Was he involved too? I thought I saw him on a stream. He runs the block. Preston Byrne, where he was bringing up Preston Bernard commented about this whole concept of leave the, you know, kind of, and I'm I'm just generalizing, but let's leave this you know social stuff out of out of Bitcoin, you know.

31
00:12:56.440 --> 00:13:15.720
Yeah. Yeah, the Mike Dudas stuff came at the tail end, and it was just funny, I thought. Good. Yeah, well, this this topic is not gonna go away. And it'll be you know, it it has and will continue to be around for years to come.

32
00:13:15.720 --> 00:13:38.600
There's I think my last kind of underline is there's a lot at stake here too, right? So these things get hot, things get heated, things get emotional, because Bitcoin is attempting something that is you know a revolution, basically, a world changer.

33
00:13:38.600 --> 00:14:04.920
And this is nothing less than one half of every economic transaction in the globe involves money, and Bitcoin is attempting to reinvent it. And there are massive stakes for you know people individually, just in terms of their own wealth, but also idealistically in terms of the way they want the world to be and the you know the changes that we hope Bitcoin can bring about for society in general.

34
00:14:04.920 --> 00:14:43.040
So it's you know, it's important to react in some sometimes very vigorously to dang ideas that are dangerous to that mission to that end goal that we sort of all share in some way shape or form so that I think that kind of underlies a lot of the you know rise in emotions on Bitcoin Twitter from time to time so I think there's just like an immune system can overreact in in your body you know bitcoin's immune system can it can overreact and people get unnecessarily mean and I and I hear that and it sucks block

35
00:14:43.040 --> 00:15:06.960
Those people and you know maybe make make your feed a little bit more in line with the way you like to interact with people you know so those tools I get I get visions of how I talk to my kids about this type of stuff I mean it shouldn't it be common sense for people to block other people or not listen to meanies that talk to them.

36
00:15:07.440 --> 00:15:25.600
Yeah I mean the answer is yes yes just don't talk you know I if if my daughter came home and told me somebody was being a jerk I'd just be like yeah don't just ignore them don't interact with that person anymore you know all right that's enough of that we went for a lot a way longer than I wanted to but you know I'm gonna I'm glad we covered it that was good.

37
00:15:25.600 --> 00:15:48.280
Yeah. So next topic I saw a post that was a screenshot of a Bloomberg terminal I actually I think I saw this in the Bitcoin and markets Discord server and it shows the Fed funds futures effective Fed funds futures rates for the next about 10 months or so 12 months in the United States, right.

38
00:15:48.280 --> 00:16:12.360
And there is an over 50% probability of rate cuts as soon as September of this year. And the futures are pegging are pegging a probability of a rate cut in by like June of next year in June 2020 up a 95% likelihood.

39
00:16:12.360 --> 00:16:34.120
And with you know zero percent chances of hikes over the coming months. So it looks like we're heading for more rate cuts. You know, potential quantitative easing, additional quantitative easing measures may not be far behind that, especially if the economy starts really turning downward.

40
00:16:34.120 --> 00:16:56.760
So we're in this interesting moment on from a macroeconomic perspective, that we have sort of an economy that's that's showing signs of slowing down and maybe entering into some kind of a recession. And then what happened, you know, what centralized governments are going to do around the world in reaction to that, and then we have the Bitcoin halving sometime next May.

41
00:16:56.760 --> 00:17:18.040
So it's a really interesting period. And Ansel, I was wondering what you kind of think about this the setup that we're that we have now with this macro economic setup for Bitcoin. Well, I kind of feel like the Fed is flailing. I remember that this was back when Janet Yellen was still around.

42
00:17:18.040 --> 00:17:39.480
She talked about algorithmic algorithmically setting the Fed funds rate. And if they would have followed a certain well-known algorithm, I can't remember the name now, that it would have been drastically negative, like negative four percent or something. And I think they they really want to get there.

43
00:17:39.480 --> 00:18:00.880
And that I think that will like to them that's that'll fix all our problems. If there's a crisis, they need to go negative, and that will that will fix the problems. So I think in the next crisis we will be negative. That will be a time for Bitcoin to shine.

44
00:18:00.880 --> 00:18:19.520
But the question is whether or not like this flight to safety, are people gonna go to the dollar? Are they gonna go to gold or they're gonna go to Bitcoin? Those are like the three competitors in my mind. Ethereum is not a competitor.

45
00:18:19.520 --> 00:18:51.760
You know, all of these other coins are not competitors to this specific use case. So yeah, that's that's an interesting question. Probably they'll still go to the dollar. Unless something breaks, then they'll I think the eventually the central banks will go back to gold because they can't they own all the gold and they they can't stand thinking about going to a Bitcoin standard, so yeah, that's kind of my outlook.

46
00:18:51.760 --> 00:19:28.320
So you think that central banks will may end up going back to a gold standard around the world or just buying buying up more gold? A gold standard, yeah. Yeah, because I think I mean the international system is so broken right now. And in the next crisis, you know, it was the dot com, then it was the real estate, and now it's like this sovereign debt crisis, so it's really gonna affect currencies and entire countries, like nations could default on a massive scale.

47
00:19:28.320 --> 00:20:06.360
So what will they go back to I think that or will they go back to gold I think I think they will just out of necessity because no one will trust their currencies and how does does a hyperinflation come before that I don't know but I think there's in the next 10 years there's going to be some a massive reckoning for most fiat currencies out in there in the world yeah it's fascinating to think about Tommy what do you think well I'm just gonna put it in the context of coming up to we're in the third year in the U.S.

48
00:20:06.600 --> 00:20:45.240
We got the I'm just gonna talk initially about the U.S. Market I'm gonna sprinkle in some global stuff right but in the U.S. We're in the third year of a presidential administration with Trump next year is going to be an election year into 2020 right so my my view is typically going into an election year you have a situation at least historically that the Fed supports who who's ever in power so that would that would lead me to believe that we're gonna have rate cuts we have the ability to have some rate cuts just because the Fed moved up several times and already in in from Obama

49
00:20:45.240 --> 00:21:13.200
To Trump I think there were six I don't have it exactly but I think it was six but about a half a dozen increases so they have the ability to cut rates a little bit without you know without going negative and in terms of the current environment, you've got the 10-year signaling that that we're we're we're in a tough period because it's looking like it's moving, gonna go below 2%, 200 basis points in with a one handle on it, right?

50
00:21:13.200 --> 00:21:51.360
So that that that tells you that we're we're in an area where we're slowing down. And then the within the that's yield on a 10-year treasury, U.S. Treasury. Yes, yield on a 10-year, and that's usually that's usually considered a bellwether. And then the other thing that happens is, and I haven't looked at it recently, but the real the bellwether in terms of going into a recession is typically you look at the 10-year minus the two-year, and you have a situation where if that actually gets to the point where the two-year interest rate is higher than than the 10-year,

51
00:21:51.360 --> 00:22:11.360
Then that's called a yield curve inversion, and typically that's an indicator of a recessionary downturn, at least historically. So we're very close to that right now. It's been bouncing. It did go, I believe in December it it went negative a little bit, and then you had a situation where the Fed, the Fed and the U.S.

52
00:22:11.360 --> 00:22:31.200
Helped, you know, helped out so that the markets, the markets came back again. So that's one indicator. And then with respect to the global markets, there are already 10 trillion dollars worth of negative yielding bonds, right? So you already have negative yielding bonds in in the world going on right now.

53
00:22:31.200 --> 00:22:54.720
So that's that's not you know, that's not a very, you know, that's obviously not very good. Then you have a situation as to what to Ansel's point, what whether the US Fed would be able to get away with you know, they would definitely, to his point, I think I agree. They definitely would like to go to go to net be able to go to negative rates just because there's a zero bound.

54
00:22:54.720 --> 00:23:32.920
And if they if they hit that zero bound, they they they have nothing to it's like pushing on a string, right? So so what so so where are we with that in terms of Bitcoin? I think the jury's out I don't really know what what actually happens with Bitcoin in a downturn because we haven't seen it in it and the two the two views I have on it are are that it's either it's either going to be a store of value so more more people are going to say okay well I need to put my some of my my funds into Bitcoin or it's a situation where you're gonna have a global market liquidity

55
00:23:32.920 --> 00:24:04.920
Issue where it's going to cause you know like the same thing as a riding rising tide lifts all boats. Well if it's the other way where the tide's going down maybe Bitcoin's all boats. Yeah so Bitcoin gets dragged down with it. So that's kind of my view. So yeah and we haven't seen this happen yet Bitcoin was born in early 2009 so you know and it was there wasn't even a US dollar to Bitcoin transfer rate at that point.

56
00:24:05.160 --> 00:24:43.880
That wasn't that didn't come until two years later when the recession kind of got staved off. Right and remember that the downturn was that was a down the downturn period but the actual lehman and the downturn was September of 2008. Right. Yeah so this is the first possi you know potential recessionary period that that Bitcoin will really be kind of alive and trading for and yeah so either people are going to look at it as a safe haven asset to take money out of equities markets that will be tanking and putting it into gold or dollars or Bitcoin or it'll be seen as a risky asset

57
00:24:44.120 --> 00:25:22.560
Or or like you know where people will basically take out all the money that they have in crypto assets and bitcoin in general and put it into you know gold or dollars as well right and answer jump in here Ansel because because I've I've seen recently where I've I saw two comments on Twitter and they're just something that's germane to this discussion where Draper Tim Draper supposedly was possibly and I just say that because I'm not sure this is this has been confirmed by other sources was advising Argentina to potentially consider Bitcoin

58
00:25:22.560 --> 00:26:00.880
As their currency and then separately I believe I read a tweet I think it was Max Keiser that was claiming that Turkey may be considering using Bitcoin you know as a reserve currency which would actually accelerate everything that we're talking about here. So that no I didn't see those two particular things it wouldn't surprise me some of the smaller economies that would do something like that or at least start buying Bitcoin I've seen countries starting to talk

59
00:26:00.880 --> 00:26:18.920
About offering Bitcoin what would it be bitcoin sovereign Bitcoin bonds I haven't seen that okay yeah like some of the real small countries like Tajikistan and some other ones they're talking about doing sovereign Bitcoin bonds. So yeah, that it's out there.

60
00:26:18.920 --> 00:26:38.040
It's being talked about. At the highest levels, they're well aware of it so that's one reason why I say they'll go back to a gold standard, because they the big countries won't want to lose their seniorage. You know, they don't want to lose control over the money.

61
00:26:38.040 --> 00:27:04.120
So one of the things too, I was thinking about when Brady was talking there is oh lost my train of thought. Let me just jump in on Bulgaria. You know, Bulgaria actually has Bitcoin because they this is going back like four or five or six or eight years, but they see some, and I think they've got like what is it three or four billion dollars worth of Bitcoin or something?

62
00:27:04.120 --> 00:27:24.280
I mean, so that's just that's just a side note, but they they they got a hold of some and kept it in their in their central bank. So yeah, I think that it was 200,000 bitcoins, and I think they seized it from BTCE exchange or something like that. Cool.

63
00:27:24.280 --> 00:27:51.560
Gosh, I had a I had a comment about oh, about when people flee to safety, they also have to sell assets to meet liabilities. So that's one of the bad things that people are talking about that would hurt Bitcoin because these investors would sell their Bitcoin to meet their other tanking liabilities, and so that could be a real bad thing.

64
00:27:51.560 --> 00:28:18.240
At the same time, man, I would just hold on, I would declare bankruptcy if I had to and just hold on to my Bitcoin. That's of course the big boys won't do that. Yeah, yeah. That's yeah, and that just that's perfect because it dovetails right into the rising tide or or the other the or goes the other way where you everything gets runs aground where it's a liquidity, you know, that's the market liquidity issue.

65
00:28:18.240 --> 00:28:40.160
So in other words, all of a sudden somebody's got maybe 25% of their asset. I'm just using an argument you know, argument or a case. And they've got like you said, little liabilities, or they've got loans out, and all of a sudden, you know, it starts to just drain cash from the market, so people have to have to dump their Bitcoin to take care of the other liabilities, right?

66
00:28:40.160 --> 00:29:05.280
If they're if they aren't in a position to be able to declare bankruptcy or whatever. All right. That goes. Sorry, that goes into why the dollar will rally. But then it you know, then you have the whole atmosphere of quantitative easing. So not only are they gonna cut rates, probably take rates negative more than we could ever imagine, I believe.

67
00:29:05.280 --> 00:29:26.000
It's gonna be solid numbers, whole number negatives. That they're gonna pump a lot of QE into the system as well. So what will be the net effect on the dollar? I don't know. It could stay right where it's at because there's deflationary forces and inflationary forces balanced out.

68
00:29:26.000 --> 00:29:59.120
But they'll lose control somewhere on one side of the equation, they'll lose control, and we'll see which side that is. Which which side would be better for Bitcoin. Gosh. Probably the inflationary side would I mean the inflationary side you wouldn't have so much of a l liquidity crisis and people could buy Bitcoin with that inflated currency.

69
00:29:59.120 --> 00:30:25.960
So that would be better than a deflationary. But at the same time, which one maybe the deflationary crisis actually speeds up Bitcoin adoption. I don't know. I don't know. Yeah, and you get into the whole issue of asset deflation vis-a-vis, you know, consumer product deflation, you know, that whole that whole issue.

70
00:30:25.960 --> 00:30:50.280
So we could talk about it for hours. Yeah, the trade war is really interesting to for me because you know, the China thing, my favorite saying is no one wins a trade war. And that if we have a financial crisis during a like the heat of a trade war, things can go into real war pretty quickly.

71
00:30:50.280 --> 00:31:11.160
I don't think there'll be a nuclear war or a world war, but there could be some significant proxy wars out there and maybe even I mean stuff like Mexico, Trump is talking tough on Mexico now, so it it just seems to be getting worse and not getting better.

72
00:31:11.160 --> 00:31:30.200
Yeah. In that respect. Well, it's gonna be a fascinating couple of years on all levels and Bitcoin is a part of this global macroeconomic dance now, and it'll be fascinating to see how it how it is affected by the next few years.

73
00:31:30.200 --> 00:31:54.800
All right, so another big topic from May 2019 in Bitcoin has been this just incredibly rapid rally in the price. So we had the we hit bottom around thirty-two hundred. We touched 9,000 very, very briefly for just like maybe a minute or two yesterday before there was significant cell pressure above 9k.

74
00:31:54.800 --> 00:32:28.080
And we're back down at about 8500 now. So yeah, we've we've seen what 2x increase in price plus 2x plus increase in price in this pat in the past month. This is if you look at and I'll put this in the show notes, but plan B on Twitter at 100 trillion USD, I think it is, has a chart that shows the 200-week moving average, how far above the price the Bitcoin price is above the 200-week moving average.

75
00:32:28.080 --> 00:32:48.720
And if you look at the last cycle, we it took us from the time we were in in this sort of this green band, which is sort of three three and a half X or so the 200-week moving average, hit the bottom at about basically touched the 200-week moving average, and it took us a year and a half to get back into this green green band.

76
00:32:48.720 --> 00:33:12.400
We have already reached this green color on plan B's 200-week moving average chart. And we are only about you know five months away for from from the bottom on on that chart instead of a year and a half. So we're over a year ahead of schedule according, you know, if we look at at the last cycle as a barometer.

77
00:33:12.400 --> 00:33:31.640
You know, and it's it's making me wonder as you know, is this is this rally too like too much too fast? Or is this something you know a reflection of fundamental differences between Bitcoin now and Bitcoin in like you know 2015, 2016?

78
00:33:31.640 --> 00:33:47.560
Is that to me? Yeah. Yeah, I think each each different or each rally has been different. One of the aspects that people don't talk about is how just blatantly manipulated the Mt. Gox bubble was.

79
00:33:47.660 --> 00:34:00.040
And everyone draws those nice, smooth curves on their long-term charts to show how we'll be at 10 million by 2100 or something. And

80
00:34:01.240 --> 00:34:21.720
I think that's just you know, based off this manipulated Mt. Gox price. And af everything after that, during that that particular bear market was unwinding of all of that manipulation. So I don't I don't think we really have anything solid to go on.

81
00:34:21.720 --> 00:34:40.280
I love this plan B's charts. I think it's the stock to flow stuff is is spot on. But looking at this time frame before happenings, it's you know, it it's more art than science for sure.

82
00:34:43.480 --> 00:35:11.400
Yeah, yeah, it is. Well it does seem that the majority of people, there's like there's like this consensus around the idea that this cycle is going to match the last cycle in some way, shape, or form. And that we're you know, we're gonna see in this there there are major differences between you know fundamental differences between Bitcoin now and the ecosystem now than you know, kind of the bottom of the bear market in 2015, 2016.

83
00:35:11.400 --> 00:35:36.560
We have far more on and off ramps, we have far you know much more user-friendly wallets and hardware wallets and long-term storage and much more you know content out there about what Bitcoin is and how to learn about it, you know, from from books to podcasts to blogs to Bitcoin Twitter, which didn't really exist the at least not in the way it does now, you know, four years ago.

84
00:35:36.560 --> 00:36:14.720
And so yeah, this could just be a reflection of that thing, you know, and we hit the bottom and we're gonna bounce back a lot faster than we did in the previous bear market because of all these you know differences in these fundamental factors. Yeah, and I think the other the other part that's embedded in this that maybe isn't stated, but if you really believe that Metcalf's law is underlying, you know, the network effects of net Metcalf's law are in play here, then you're a person's view looking at this, and maybe it's not stated very often, but your view is

85
00:36:14.720 --> 00:36:34.400
That you get you go to a bottom and then you start to go the other way. So your your view is if at least my view is is that the idea is if it's going along the path of Metcalf's law, then you're likely going to exceed the previous all-time high, and you're kind of going from there, right? So that's I think that's that's a key key point.

86
00:36:34.400 --> 00:36:55.680
I for a long time I thought that the cycles were gonna speed up. And then we had drop from 6,000 down to 3,000. And I was like, oh man, I guess maybe I was wrong, and it's going to lengthen, right? So in between the all-time highs, the peaks will lengthen and max out at four years or something.

87
00:36:55.680 --> 00:37:15.000
But maybe that's wrong. Maybe we break the all-time high and we go to 30,000 and then we crash down back down to 10,000. And we don't, we don't know. It's uncharted territory. I just I think one of the key lessons for people to remember is that price can't go up in a straight line.

88
00:37:15.000 --> 00:37:33.080
So it's gonna expect volatility and don't have buy more Bitcoin than you're willing to lose or whatever that's saying is. Exactly. Yeah. Does saying do yeah, do your own research and don't invest more than you're willing to lose. Yeah.

89
00:37:33.080 --> 00:37:52.040
Because you won't be able to sleep and it'll cause too much anxiety. Because this is a volatile process. The mon the process of monetizing the monetization of Bitcoin is definitely a volatile process. And also another volatile process that is related to the price volatility as well is mining difficulty.

90
00:37:52.040 --> 00:38:10.840
And we reached a mining an all-time high in mining difficulty again. Matched it from I guess it was like middle of 2018. Is that right, Ansel? The previous all-time high in mining difficulty? Yeah, was in September of 2018. Yeah, September of 2018.

91
00:38:10.840 --> 00:38:36.040
So not we're what eight months later, and mining difficulty is back up there again. So what do you think this means for for Bitcoin, Ansel? Well, I think it's a good sign, of course. I've been waiting and waiting for a large increase in difficulty and hash rate because we had this idle hash rate around, right?

92
00:38:36.040 --> 00:38:56.160
If we're below the all-time high hash rate, then we have this, that means we have idle hash rate. And with the price pumping, you would expect the hash rate to somewhat follow the price, but we have had a about a 3x increase in price and only about a 50% increase in hash rate.

93
00:38:56.160 --> 00:39:09.760
And I've been really thinking about it a lot and all that. I think that the miners were mainly hedged. So sorry, my son is screaming. No worries. They just got home. So the

94
00:39:13.040 --> 00:39:45.680
I think the miners were hedged. You know, they have they negotiate long-term contracts for their their electricity, and they might even sell bitcoins on the futures markets at certain prices. So I think it just took a while for the hash rate to pick up. But this does to me, this does signal that the entire market has definitely broken out of the bear market and we are turning around, even though it sounds funny where we hit $9,000 and to talk about the bear market still.

95
00:39:45.680 --> 00:40:13.680
But what happens if we drop down to four? Everyone's gonna be saying we're back in the bear market. So I do think we're out of the bear market, and this is just another sign of that. Yeah, and we've got a it seems like we'd be due some kind of pullback in in the coming weeks and months after having gone up so quickly, but it is reassuring to see the hash rate follow finally, you know, and it was an 11% increase, right?

96
00:40:14.000 --> 00:40:37.720
Yes. This past increase, which is is that how does that rank historically in terms of two week increases in in mining difficulty? It's up there. Yeah, it's pretty high, right? Not not the biggest. There's been 20% increases, but it's definitely it's definitely in the top, say, ten percent of increases probably.

97
00:40:37.720 --> 00:41:04.680
Right. And the idea one idea that I just wanted to note here, since it's related, is the idea that hash power follows price and not the other way around. And it's an idea that lots of people get confused about. You see it especially in the mainstream media a lot, and I think even like like JP Morgan and some other big banks and stuff, we're talking about how Bitcoin has an inherent or sorry, this I love this this phrase, it's so funny.

98
00:41:04.680 --> 00:41:27.000
This it has intrinsic value based on the cost of mining a bitcoin, right? Which is just backwards. And so it's just important to understand that idea. And Ansel, you probably have you can probably explain this pretty well. Oh why it's important. Yeah, the Yeah, definitely hash power follows price.

99
00:41:27.000 --> 00:41:53.080
I mean, there there's two different ways that you can well, three different ways you can get Bitcoin. You can mine it, you can buy it, or you can earn it. And earning is probably the cheapest. Mining is the second cheapest. Honestly, I think mining is the second cheapest way to get it. And then buying it is the third, but there is you know a lot of difficulty involved with with mining it.

100
00:41:53.080 --> 00:42:11.800
So but yeah, definitely the mining is chasing Bitcoin. It's not that the price is chasing like how much it costs to mine. Because it if if I if I spent ten thousand dollars on a Bitcoin today to mine it and I wanted to go and s sell it for ten thousand, no one would buy it from me.

101
00:42:11.800 --> 00:42:31.600
So definitely price is it's price is the all-import metric. So that that idea of it's it's be well and it's because people is the higher the price goes right the more more people spend money to put the equipment in place to increase the hash right exactly.

102
00:42:31.600 --> 00:43:10.320
I mean it's that simple right yeah yeah and over the last three months or so I mean just imagine all the profits being made in mining it's it's crazy. So and it does take a while to spin up spin up those mining facilities so that's another thing the price will outpace the hash rate so you we talked about when the all-time high in hash rate was in September of 18 right that was nine months after the all-time high or 10 months and so it took all that time for that the huge gigantic

103
00:43:10.320 --> 00:43:48.320
Train that is mining to slow down and actually turn around so yeah mining takes a while to stop and it takes a while to get going again well yeah and if we just look if you just look at it simplistically let's say let's say some people are sitting around let's say in a group is sitting around trying to decide when to deploy more money into into bitcoin or bitcoin mining just specifically right so we hit 9,000 so if we're just at a full stop you'd have to go out and you say okay we're gonna spend 10 million dollars and go out and buy mining equipment we're gonna

104
00:43:48.320 --> 00:44:26.360
Start mining well if you look at the steps to be able to do that first of all you have to you have to come up with your basic what whatever it is your procurement schedule or your schedule as to where you what you're gonna do where you're gonna put it you're gonna have to acquire all the equipment you add all that together right and but by the time you it's probably gonna take you what six months before you could go into a full blown operation yeah yeah something like that just just to acquire the miners if there's excess hash power sitting around that won't take that long but if you're having to buy all new

105
00:44:26.360 --> 00:45:04.360
Equipment to spin something up just to get the equipment probably yeah two or three months I'm I'm not an expert in that side of things so but I would expect that it'd be significant not like next week you can be up and running sort of thing that's that's correct well I have some experience just with process processes and engineering and construction as it relates to that right but so I all I'm saying is if it's just not like you and I we can all decide we're gonna start mining and if we're gonna go ahead and do it let's call it de novo where we're gonna go get the equipment and put it all

106
00:45:04.360 --> 00:45:36.160
Together so we have something over the long term it's it's gonna take some time to put that all in place. It's not like we're gonna be able to do it in two weeks. And it may be three months where you initially start or whatever but by the time you're flat out you're probably at least you know let's call it it's gonna cut it's gonna be months. Maybe possibly big I would say that the Bitcoin mining is different than other industrial presses though because really it's just a matter of buying you know buying and having computers shipped to you and then hooking them up.

107
00:45:36.160 --> 00:45:55.680
So I think I think getting a mining operation set up is like more of a matter of weeks than than months, probably. But that's just my uneducated assumptions and opinion or like ideas about it because I've I've not done it. So I mean on a bigger operation, you have to get tied into the bottom of the code. Yeah, it depends on obviously the size of the operation.

108
00:45:56.240 --> 00:46:16.160
I guess what I'm talking about is a larger operation in terms of if we're sitting, you know, I understand we got I got us off the subject a little bit. I mean, in terms of more anecdotal here. All I'm saying is a larger scale operation. If I'm in my basement and I want to mine Bitcoin, I could probably go on eBay and get a Bitcoin miner, and I can do it tomorrow afternoon by like six o'clock or something.

109
00:46:16.320 --> 00:46:41.120
Sure. But if you're doing some type of substantial operation, I think it's a matter of months, so it's more longer. That's all. Yeah. I think that helps tie it together what we were talking about. Yeah, and then you know, the idea that that Bitcoin has any intrinsic value anyway is is probably incorrect. There was an article this month by Connor Brown titled Bitcoin Does Not Have Any Intrinsic Value, and that's a good thing.

110
00:46:41.120 --> 00:47:02.000
There was a debate between Peter Schiff, the gold bug, and Save Edina Moose, the author of the Bitcoin Standard, earlier this month also. And this was a big point of contention between the two of them. And you know Peter Schiff was throwing out this argument that Bitcoin has no intrinsic value.

111
00:47:02.000 --> 00:47:20.160
And you know, we have JP Morgan trying to find some intrinsic value by saying that Bitcoin is given intrinsic intrinsic intrinsic value by the cost of mining, and they've they've made the mistake that they were thinking that price follows hash power and not that you know, but that's but it's actually the other way around.

112
00:47:20.160 --> 00:47:40.520
This sort of drive to try to find some intrinsic value in Bitcoin is interesting to me, and I think it's just an old idea. It's just it's just an kind of an archaic idea. It doesn't apply to this new kind of digital money that we have created, right? So if Bitcoin like like gold might have some intrinsic value in the sense that it we can use it for electronics, we can use it for jewelry, things like that, right?

113
00:47:40.520 --> 00:48:10.200
You can't use Bitcoin for anything else besides money. And that's a good thing because Bitcoin is was created to be money, and so its monetary premium is 100%. It is money, right? And gold's monetary premium is a large part of the value of gold. You know, but the idea that lots of economists have kind of put forth throughout the history of the study of economics, that in order for a commodity or an item to become money, it has to have some intrinsic value first, right?

114
00:48:10.280 --> 00:48:31.320
Does not apply to Bitcoin. And the fact that there's just so many people out there that keep trying to force this issue is is interesting, is funny to me. And I just think this month that kind of that idea was completely obliterated by Connor Brown art Connor Brown's article and Safadine's arguments in the debate with Peter Schiff.

115
00:48:31.320 --> 00:48:53.320
And you know, value is subjective, and this is another idea from from Austrian economics. It's not it's not objective. And so you know, Peter Schiff was making the argument that value is objective and gold has objective value, intrinsic value and Bitcoin doesn't. But that's not the case. Value is subjective, and something only has value if we you know think it does.

116
00:48:53.320 --> 00:49:04.600
And so therefore it's completely subjective to each individual individual market actor's ideas of what is valuable and not, right? What are your thoughts on that, Anselm?

117
00:49:07.560 --> 00:49:28.800
Oh, Ansel might have might have had to take off. Let's see. No, sorry. My kids were screaming. Yeah, there I think people get this word intrinsic mixed up with like utility. So there is no such thing as intrinsic value at all.

118
00:49:28.800 --> 00:49:48.080
And nothing has intrinsic value. All value is 100% individual. Like I might value a minivan more than I value a Ferrari. But the market, the clearing price on the market, the Ferrari is much higher than the minivan.

119
00:49:49.040 --> 00:50:11.760
So at all value subjective, there is no intrinsic value, but there is utility value. And I think it's interesting that gold, you know, the very first artifact, gold artifact that we have is from about 4,000 BC. And it was a bead, which was used as money.

120
00:50:11.760 --> 00:50:32.640
So there's this regression theorem in Austrian economics that you trace back this you know, the value of gold to this utility value, but there is no like historical or archaeological record before gold was money. So we don't know if that ever that time ever existed.

121
00:50:32.640 --> 00:50:52.560
Okay. Yeah. Yeah. That's just my two cents. That makes sense. Yeah, I just was gonna I just was gonna add here, it it seems to me from the standpoint of Bitcoin that fiat currency, you've got the issue of fiat currency.

122
00:50:52.560 --> 00:51:16.040
You got the three, right? You got fiat currency, you got gold, you got Bitcoin. It seems to me that there's enough going on, enough issues related to fiat currency that to try to just take and pick pick a fight with both gold and fiat currency. I think we're better served to just gold is more complementary to Bitcoin than fiat currency.

123
00:51:16.040 --> 00:51:39.160
So I my view is if you're gonna pick a fight, you just go ahead and pick a fight with fiat currency for now and kind of just leave gold leave gold alone. That's just my view. So it doesn't make a sense any sense to me to pick a fight with everybody right now. So yeah. Well, it's it's much easier to teach or to make that distinction between fiat and Bitcoin and gold.

124
00:51:39.160 --> 00:52:00.440
It's it's harder when you talk about gold versus Bitcoin to for people to grasp that. So yeah, I agree that the first step is the difference between fiat and gold. Yeah, and I also think in terms of adoption are people thinking just starting to warm up or thinking a little bit better.

125
00:52:00.440 --> 00:52:25.480
If they let's say if they have a view that's because some people initially have a little bit of a negative view because Bitcoin is new, and just could because of the mainstream media and some of the things that have happened. And so that's the other the other point that leads into my idea of just saying, hey, why don't we just concentrate on fiat for now? Yeah, I mean, in this case, the reason this debate happened is not because Bitcoiners were picking on gold, it's because you know Peter Schiff the Goldbug was picking on Bitcoin.

126
00:52:25.480 --> 00:52:48.640
And you know, he has he has a he has a company, he has bags, you know, he has gold bags that he's gotta he's got to defend and shill out in the public market and all of his clients you know gold as gold bags as well. So he definitely has a business interest in arguing that Bitcoin is not the new gold and you should not move your money from gold to Bitcoin.

127
00:52:48.640 --> 00:53:08.560
So in that case, yeah, of course Bitcoin has got to stand up and defend it. Well he's been around forever with this whole thing too, so yeah. Yeah, and that debate made it. I get I get that whole part of it. I that debate made it pretty clear that he's you know, he's doesn't have answers to the arguments that he's trying to.

128
00:53:08.720 --> 00:53:27.840
He just kept reclaiming them over. I wonder how hedged Peter Schiff is. I wonder how much Bitcoin Peter Schiff has. Based on based on that debate, it seems like he doesn't he hasn't bought much Bitcoin yet. So we'll see. I don't know. Maybe he has. I don't know. But he has gold cufflinks. He does have the gold cufflinks.

129
00:53:27.840 --> 00:53:47.040
He can use those, that gold as something else. That's yeah, that's that was one of his big points was oh my look, gold can be used for cuff links. I thought that was funny. Yeah, that was hilarious. And yeah, that that screenshot of him like holding his cuff links up to the camera. Good stuff, man.

130
00:53:47.040 --> 00:54:08.160
I'm gonna have to catch the rest of that. I just saw snapshots of it, but I'll make sure I do that. Good stuff. All right, let's finish up with a little bit of time on B cash, just because you know it is it is relevant to Bitcoin. There are lessons to be learned for Bitcoiners in this 51% attack that was carried out on Bitcoin Cash this month.

131
00:54:08.620 --> 00:54:10.940
This is, you know,

132
00:54:11.520 --> 00:54:49.640
It really exposes the risks of this approach to just hard fork every six months. You know, and endless hard forking as a as an approach to upgrade the protocol just doesn't make I mean it's it's it's super risky. It's an attack vector, it kills the Lindy effect and it creates this kind of political mess where you know there's private communications between two b BCH miners to try to get control of some of these previously like there was a change in in the protocol in the scheduled hard fork that was going to

133
00:54:49.640 --> 00:55:28.040
Allow miners to get access to some SegWit coins that were previously like unspendable because of like basically a protocol rule that they had put into the BCH protocol before this hard fork was actually removing that rule and thus making them spendable again so bct.btc.top and btc.com were working together to and planning to take in to basically take control of those of those coins that there was also an unknown anonymous person out there that thought they would do the same thing had the same idea and

134
00:55:28.360 --> 00:56:06.360
When the that person started trying to spend these coins that became spendable after that hard fork and the first block after that hard fork the miners were like nope we're not gonna let that happen and basically because they controlled more than 50 you know more than 51% of the of the hash power on BCH were able to reorg the a couple of blocks in their favor and it it was it's just I'll post a great thread to that was written by by guy swan of the crypto economy podcast that kind of details all this stuff and he also links to some other material that you can read more

135
00:56:06.360 --> 00:56:24.480
About it. But yeah, it this is this is what happens when you use planned hard forks as upgrades as an upgrade path. It's what happens when hash rate drops enough that you know a couple of miners can get together and do this kind of thing on a chain.

136
00:56:24.480 --> 00:56:53.120
So Ansel, do you have any reaction to this whole mess that Bitcoin Cash got itself into? Yeah, not just that, but nodes, right? It it shows that you don't want miners in control. The nodes on Bitcoin would have stopped this because well they couldn't technically stop the 51% attack, but they they could have said that block was invalid from the first in the first place or something, you know.

137
00:56:53.120 --> 00:57:12.000
So when you do the hard fork route, you end up centralizing more and more and more, and this is the end result. It it'll continue to get worse, not better. And all of the fork coins will go down the same route, all the altcoins will go down the same route.

138
00:57:12.000 --> 00:57:35.360
I mean, there there's just nothing substantial or productive behind 99.9% of the altcoins. So this is just an example of that. Yep, absolutely. All right, I think that's it for this week's immediate or this month. Does anybody have any last thoughts about this month in Bitcoin?

139
00:57:35.360 --> 00:57:54.560
This is Tom. I don't I don't have any last thoughts. I just want to thank Ansel for joining us. So yeah, thanks guys. This was fun. Sorry, my kids came in. They came home halfway through and they were screaming in the other thing. It's actually a bonus. We're very family-oriented here on Citizen Bitcoin.

140
00:57:54.560 --> 00:58:13.720
So that's totally cool. Thank God my dog didn't start barking. So Yeah, I heard Brady's kids. We was that that was you talking to about the Bitcoin Rabbi book. Yeah, that was Bitcoin Money together and had a little book club session. Put it tagged it at the end of the podcast with the Bitcoin Rabbi.

141
00:58:13.720 --> 00:58:32.920
Yeah, yeah, that was a lot of that was a lot of fantastic. So yeah, we're family friendly here. We like to have some the some background noise with the don't sweat that at all. In fact, it's encouraged here, citizen Bitcoin. All right, Ansel, yes, I'd like to echo that. Thank you so much for joining us and talking today. It was a lot of fun to have you. That's it.

142
00:58:32.920 --> 00:58:51.720
That wraps up this this month in Bitcoin, May 2019. Thanks for joining us. Take care, everyone.

143
00:58:51.720 --> 00:59:09.720
All right, Bitcoiners, thanks for joining us for this month's basement bulletin episode. Don't forget to follow Ansel at Ansel Lindner. That's A N-S-E-L-I-N-D-N-E-R. And subscribe to the Bitcoin and Markets podcast for the best weekly updates on Bitcoin fundamentals and price technicals.

144
00:59:09.720 --> 00:59:28.200
You can also subscribe to the Bitcoin and Markets weekly email updates. They are super useful and chock full of data and analysis. Highly recommend those. You can find those at Bitcoin and Markets.com. You can follow Tommy at Canon's Call and me at Citizen Bitcoin. And please do leave a rating and review for the pod.

145
00:59:28.200 --> 00:59:44.440
That's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
