Basis and Stable Coins, Hodl Waves, Global Fiat Debt Record Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2018-04-21 [00:00:20] Alright, we are back. Welcome back to another episode of Citizen Bitcoin, the show where we help guide you along that path to becoming a good citizen of Bitcoin. I'm Brady. I'm Tommy. And we've got a little show for you today. We're gonna talk about some some news. [00:00:40] We're also gonna spend some time, we'll look at the price like we usually do, and we're also gonna spend some time talking about stable coins and this news about a coin called Basis that raised $133 million from a bunch of venture capitalists all over the world. And also some pretty big you know, some Stanley Druckenmiller was in there, and the thing about Stanley Druckenmiller is he's known historically as being an extraordinarily astute investor. [00:01:06] Yeah, we had Bane Capital in there, Andreeson Horowitz. It was a long list of a hundred different different things. Stanley Druckenmiller being in there is kind of a big deal. Yeah. Alright, I don't know anything about him, so we'll we'll hear more about Stanley from Tommy, because that's why that's why Tommy's here. Alright, so you can find us on Medium at Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter at Citizen Bitcoin. [00:01:25] Also, we're on YouTube. We have an audio-only version of the show. Publishes a podcast. You can find it on iTunes or wherever you listen to your your podcasts. All right, we're gonna start out here with a Bluebird Bloomberg article reporting some news that world debt has hit a record 164 trillion dollars. [00:01:47] This is global debt. This is two hundred and twenty five percent of global gross domestic product. So what you know, what happened in in two thousand eight with the financial crisis and there was a lot of subprime debt out there, and that sort of those chickens came home to roost. [00:02:06] Right. Lesson wasn't really learned. Well it well, it was actually delayed. Not only was the lesson not learned, it was it was at this point the whole sector that's involved with that that got bailed out. It's as if that nothing happened to them, so they're not even they're not even concerned about where we are right now to a great degree. [00:02:27] Sure. So you know, and I don't want to make another point about the debt. At that at that point in time, the debt was the from the switch to Bush over over to over to Obama, it was about right around ten trillion, and you I'm talking the US component of this. [00:02:47] And now now it's over twenty trillion. So it it doubled under the Obama administration, understanding that Congress is there, and so it's the whole DC situation. I mean so the whole group and now you have a Americans tend to give way too much credit and blame to presidents for exactly exactly. [00:03:06] So they they were you know, right. So it it was doubled, and now you and now you have a situation where there's a focus on deficits, and it's kind of like well, wait a minute, the debt the debt doubled. I mean, that's a big deal going from you know, doubling the debt from ten million to over ten trillion to over twenty trillion, and that's a component of this this number one one sixty-four trillion. [00:03:29] And at the same time, printing a lot of money through various quantitative easing cycles. Three of them, QE three. There isn't but there there was not a QE4, but some of the things that happened were were similar to what that that situation. So basically what I'm seeing here is that kind of the path that the US has chosen to follow in terms of monetary policy is being replicated around the world. [00:03:52] This is a global issue now, you know, for the global for the economy as a whole. So the entire global public public and private debt is now 225% or more than twice as much as the global gross domestic product. So the GDP and this is more anecdotal, but I used to try to follow it and look at it, and for the longest time we were 50, 60 percent US. [00:04:17] Okay, I understand we probably know we're we're covering the globe here, but on the just as a proxy to look at it, the US was you know, sixty-five percent right around in there, and then all of a sudden, when we had in 08-09, next thing we know, it's it's over 100% now. And I don't know the exact number, but I know it's over 100%. [00:04:38] And so all right. Well, the just another you know, signal that maybe it's time to think about hedging with a decentralized store of value that has a fixed monetary policy. [00:04:57] Just a thought. All right, moving on. Oh yeah, so Pierre Rochard had a tweet that I thought he's one of the m one of the guys that runs the Nakamoto Institute and very knowledgeable about monetary policy, Austrian economics and Bitcoin. [00:05:17] So basically there's two solutions to when when debt gets out of control like this, and it's either to default on the debt and reset or take your medicine as as as they say. Or inflate, which means to print more money, right? And we know what they'll do. They'll inflate because that's what that's what they have chosen to do over and over again throughout recent monetary policy history. [00:05:41] This is why we Bitcoin. Right. And it's a situation we've mentioned it before, and people that are familiar with monetary history, it it happened in in Germany in the 20s in the in the early topics. [00:05:55] Yep. Yeah, you can Google Google Weimar Republican and read that story. Yeah. So next up. This is some really great, really lovely beautiful data analysis about the Bitcoin UTXO set, which UTXO is the unspent transaction outputs, and that's the type of ledger. [00:06:21] What exactly does that mean again? An unspent trend, yeah, an unspent transaction output is is the literally all of the Bitcoin on the Bitcoin ledger is defined by the number of unspent transaction outputs. So when there's an a transa a Bitcoin transaction, there's always an output, right? [00:06:39] And it could be some change, for instance, in the transaction that's returning back to the purchaser. Whatever it is, whatever the amount is, there'll be an unspent transaction output. If I give you know a Bitcoin, then you'll have a UTXO and unspent transaction output with your private key on the Bitcoin ledger. [00:06:59] Okay, okay. If I give if I send somebody a Bitcoin, I get some change back. Let's say like I give somebody a Bitcoin and I need you know three tenths of a Bitcoin back and change, then the merchant that I gave that Bitcoin to would have 0.7 Bitcoin as an unspent transaction output, and I would have 0.3. And that's so all of all of the Bitcoin that's on the ledger is defined as an unspent transaction output. [00:07:23] Okay. That's just the type of ledger that Bitcoin uses. Alright. Alright, so what this shows here, and for those on the podcast, this of course will be linked in the show notes. But it's a chart of a lot of many colors ranging from like dark kind of hot reds and oranges and yellows up to cool blues at the top. The blues and greens represent UTXOs that have not moved for many years. [00:07:48] So the green on this chart is two to three years, and then the blue is the oldest more than five years, UTXOs that are more than five years old. And then down the red is less than a day, or you know, and then one day to one week, and so there's a range here of increasing increasing amounts of time. And so what this chart shows is during rallies, the amount the amount of time that Bitcoin has been held typically decreases. [00:08:16] Each UTXO has been held typically decreases, and during what this article has called hodl waves, and this this article writes about three different time periods in the hodl waves. [00:08:31] Hodl is hold on for dear life. [00:08:34] Right. And that's a retroactive application, but it really was that when we talked about that on another show, right? It was so it wasn't misspelling. It just means when it's HODL, it just means hold. Or holding. It's a misspelling of hold from a drunken forum post at before, but just in case people were wondering what HODL meant, that's what I'm gonna do. [00:08:54] Hold on for dear life. Just you hit the Bitcoin, you hold it. Right. So during these hodls, you can see the an increase in the length of UTXO sets. So more green and blue, those regions growing means people have been holding on to that bitcoin for months and then years. And those those UTXOs have not moved on the ledger at all. [00:09:16] And so this this these graphs just show the three different hodls that we've had so far. The Genesis HODL in 2009, 2008, 2009, the HODL of 2011, which was after the first kind of crash of Bitcoin when it peaked at $33 in late 2010, early 2011. [00:09:37] And then the Great HODL of 2014, which has been the longest yet, each one has been progressively longer. And so we're probably in the midst of another one right now, unless this rally is not quite over, maybe we're just on a little break, and we'll see if we're in a longer term bear markets or it's just w in terms and we'll talk about the price in a second, but at least it's it's been doing okay in terms of crashing through the floor. [00:10:01] I mean, in terms of people being concerned that it was gonna go down dramatically, keep step you know, step functioning downward. Right. It's not the case at all right now. So this is some interesting data to go to sort through and look at and kind of understand. So we'll have that in the show notes. I need I actually need to read that. I've been traveling, so I wasn't able to get a look at this. [00:10:21] It's looking like good stuff. All right, we'll take a look next at the price. So here is the Bitcoin USD chart. This is the bit stamp exchange. We're looking at the daily chart. These are daily candles, and we're going back to November of last year, all right, through the peak of the rally at 1906 or so, and what has been the subsequent sell-off. [00:10:47] So from so from last week's show, it's looking like it's holding up okay. It's right right around. Remember last week's show we were well, you were gonna go back a little, but we were saying okay, 6500 right in the mid 6,000 is is was looking like a floor, and then if it moved up around eight, so you're kind of spot on with that, right? [00:11:07] Yeah, so these lines, these downtrend lines here have been pretty true. We've got the long, of course, the long-term uptrend line here, the floor that has that is happening. Which is at 6,500, 6,000 to 6,500. Yeah, it's slowly increasing right now. Yeah, but right now it's at about it's getting close to bottom line. [00:11:28] It's actually getting really close to 7,000 now. So the bottom line that from talking from previously, so it's looking the number in terms of breaking through on the bottom side is is 7,000 now. So that's we're gonna take a look at at basis. Now Basecoin, which rebranded to Basis and announced their massive round of funding from you know, it was really a who's who of venture capitalists all over the world. [00:11:57] They raised a hundred and thirty-three million dollars to build a stable coin. A stable coin is a currency or a coin that is engineered through various ways to be pegged to a stable asset. [00:12:17] Like it could be a fiat like like the US dollar, it could be some other stable relatively stable asset. Right. Well, just for me, it's almost like it's an oxymoron. Because how how how is anything in life stable? I mean, you know, how does anything just go on or anything in the market? Yeah, well, relatively stable, like re more s more stable than Bitcoin price. [00:12:37] But m more stable than Bitcoin price. But if but they're not looking at it from the other way. If if you if you're in Bitcoin, right, and you're just talking in terms of I'm I've I'm in Bitcoin. Right. Bitcoin's not volatile. If you're in Bitcoin, right? One one Bitcoin equals one Bitcoin. [00:12:55] One Bitcoin's one Bitcoin. One satoshi is one Satoshi. So then if you sit there and you're in Bitcoin and look at it against the against the dollar over the past couple years, you'd say, oh my god, the dollar, you know, in terms of its value, vis-a-vis the Bitcoin, it's really volatile. In fact, it's volatile with the with a big negative, you know, downside. [00:13:14] So that's the other context we need to take here when when you when you look at that, right? Sure. So but the stor the story that they're telling is that Bitcoin price is volatile, which makes it unusable as a currency. And so they want to become a central bank on the blockchain, an algorithmic central bank, and they're going to use an out this algorithm, which yeah, let me just kind of get into a little bit more of the detail. [00:13:45] Which will consist of tr of managing three tokens. All right. So there'll be three core tokens in basis. Basis itself, which is the name the name the token called basis, which is a USD pegged cryptocurrency that people can buy and sell or exchange for goods. So it's supposed to be pegged to the US dollar. [00:14:05] There will be bond tokens, basis basis bond tokens that are sold during m times when basis is forced to contract its supply. And then there'll be share tokens, which will be used to give pay out dividends. [00:14:21] They'll go to buyback bonds when basis needs to adjust its price accordingly [00:14:28] And it'll and if once all bondholders are paid out, then it will go to the share to the shareholders. So people who should hold shares. What does this sound like? I mean, it sounds like a central bank to me, right? Yeah. It's an algorithmic central bank. So it's a central bank. So the other thing, right? Is that well that who who's who's doing that? It's it's so they're basically saying it's it's a corporation. [00:14:48] I mean, it's a corporation, but they but it's basically said like you're thinking it's a computer that that controls it, but it's actually a corporation that ultimately sets it up. So this is centralized. Ultimately, yeah, because it's run by a corporation, right? So e even though they're white and I did read through the white paper. Okay, is it is it pre-mined? [00:15:06] Is these pre-mines? Well, I mean, they didn't they give so those those private investors, the money that they raised, right? The money that they raised, they gave the basis share tokens, I presume, to those to those people who ra who have invested in the in the company, right? [00:15:25] How is this different than Ripple? Yeah, I mean it's it's fundamentally Ripple, which is a which is a venture capital, yeah, pre-mined centralized co coin or whatever you want to call it. No, that's a coin, this is a token. So Ripple was made to improve the speed and I guess efficiency, cost efficiency of bank transfers, international bank transfers, right? [00:15:54] So one of the main differences is this is this is a coin that's aiming to be a global currency with a global algorithmic, you know, central bank so it's a little different in that sense, but it's the same in the sense that it's it's a corp it's the central corporate centralized corporation. They they do pay a lot of lip service in the white paper to being decentralized. [00:16:17] They say that it's important to be decentralized, and they talk about how they're going to go about doing that. But when you have a CEO and you have a corporate a private corporation that controls this entity, it's not decentralized. Certainly not the way the Bitcoin is. You know, and the other part of it is it seems like a big number, 133 million, but when you look at all the players here, it it's just a diverse it's a for me. [00:16:41] I look at it from the standpoint of okay, why not go into this? If it takes off, great, that'll be huge. Otherwise, it's not gonna be that big of a loss. But you know, so they're just taking a shot. Yeah, and so if you look at the white paper, it's very clear that they are trying to create a cryptocurrency, a Keynesian cryptocurrency, whereas Bitcoin isn't is you know based on Austrian economic monetary policy. [00:17:01] Well, a bit bit and the other thing to recall, just to reiterate, Bitcoin started from just the white paper. Yeah. There was there were no investors involved. [00:17:10] People weren't going around going like, okay, this is how it was going to work [00:17:13] And we're gonna give discounts and we're gonna pre you know pre-set all this stuff, and you're gonna get, you know, a bunch of money, you know, like this or or Telegram and some of the other. I mean it grew organically, yeah. And so yeah, now the other thing, the other thing too, and with respect to these network effects, and I mentioned Telegram, which I probably shouldn't, because I threw them in the same bucket as basis coin, because it could be a situation in the network effects, and somehow at the end of this, with and I'm switching over to Telegram, but it could be a situation where these tokens are going to end up having some value for people to utilize them on the network or the system. [00:17:51] But the axe I have to grind with Telegram is they they raise so much money, and when you look at it from the standpoint of how it was all set up, and the and it was one of these situations where the people in early in early on the deal got all these extra extraordinary benefits, and you know, relative to what would be a normal investment. [00:18:13] Yep. Right. Yeah, yeah. So I think, you know, and Pomplian Pomp, Pompliano at Pomp on Twitter, he tweeted about about basis that you know someone is going to create a tokenized central bank or cryptocurrency central bank like basis, and it's going to be valuable, right? [00:18:36] And so my tweet back was, you know, in the end, it's going to come down to some probably something like Bitcoin, which is you know decentralized and organically grown. So the whole point is, right, right. And Bitcoin and it's organically grown versus something like this, which is a centralized entity that governments might feel more comfortable adopting because they feel like they can exert more control over it, for instance, and that's gonna kind of be the final battle in the end. [00:19:02] Maybe maybe it's not gonna be Bitcoin versus the US dollar. Maybe the final battle is gonna be Bitcoin versus a centralized, you know, Keynesian. Well, well, the other the other part, well, the other part of it is we really don't know because in a lot of cases, you have a situation where methods or structures or or the general way that business is done now is being applied into these particular markets and situations, and it could be something that the actual structure and idea of trying to shove whatever it's almost backwards. [00:19:35] You're sitting there saying, Well, we've got the central bank, we need this basis coin, and we're gonna go ahead and make it, you know, instead of flowing through, you know, and seeing how it works with the technology and how that fits together. So that's there's that aspect also, because we don't know how this is ultimately gonna, you know, how this is ultimately gonna shake out, and then look at it from the standpoint that that if it is Bitcoin, well, that's kind of the point right now, or some people are saying, Oh my, you know, my lord, you know, 20 2022 or 2024, it bitcoin's gonna be worth five hundred thousand dollars. [00:20:08] Well, that's that's the case we're talking about here. What we just talked about. If it becomes more or less accepted as for larger transfer payments and situations that that central banks are doing, yeah, then as a consequence, it is going to be worth a lot of money. The issue is that the way it's set up, if you're trying to if you're trying to but but just to interrupt real quickly, sure. [00:20:30] It's gonna be worth a lot of money to the people who have invested in early, right? Yeah. Not to us who are using it, because it it's not it's not a deflationary store of value like big like Bitcoin is. Well, that's exactly that's exactly right. That's that's a great point. Yeah, and I was I was going on on one of my my my it wasn't really a rant, but I was getting a little bit carried away, so I'm glad you pulled me back from the ledge. [00:20:52] Well, yeah, so I mean there's a there's it's basically basis is basically the Keynesian version of Bitcoin, the centralized Keynesian version of Bitcoin. It doesn't change much from what's been going on. If you read the Bitcoin standard, which we talked about last week, and you know you buy those arguments, you believe in those arguments, then this is you know just not an option. [00:21:14] If you if we truly do believe in the idea of a stable good not no sorry not stable a what's the word they use sound a sound money than robust right a sound a sound money that has real value that doesn't that can't be inflated away by printing more of it easily then that's I mean Bitcoin's the only option so [00:21:43] To talk about the because i think it's okay to be concerned about the volatility of the Bitcoin price right and it it does harm its use as a currency because if it's so volatile and I get paid in Bitcoin and it goes down at 30% in a month maybe I can't make my rent well but it went but it went down thirty it went down 30% in US dollars vis-a-vis what right well in US dollars so I mean saying like right now since most of the world is running on US dollars as a unit of account so I have to pay my rent in US dollars and have to buy my groceries in US dollars. [00:22:15] It's not a great as a currency now. I totally agree and that's but that's the big argument or something yeah the point is right the point is what Pierre Rochard is saying here right and stable Bitcoin won't come until after hyper Bitcoin is hyper Bitcoinization. And that's the process of Bitcoin becoming the unit of account right and the global currency. [00:22:37] And that it it has happened in the past with with the dollar and it's borrowed this this phrase is is borrowed from the phrase dollarization, which certain countries have have gone through this process of dollarization where their native currencies have inflated so much that they've had to base rebase their economy on a more stable, valuable store of value in currency. [00:23:01] They've chosen the dollar, so that economy is said to have dollarized, right? Same thing will happen or you know is may happen. May happen, I guess, with with Bitcoin, and that process is called hyper bitcoinization, and it happens very quickly once you get to a certain kind of tipping point. Pierre Rochard and the Nakamoto Institute are sort of the at the vanguard of pushing this idea this theory of hyper bitcoinization, and that we're he says that we're several orders of magnitude away from hyper bitcoinization happening, right? [00:23:34] So there's probably a decade or more left of this volatile price appreciation over time, and once you reach that point where it's being used, as it it will become more stable and therefore much more useful as a currency. You know, I just thought of this. The other thing that's interesting is is it is that you and all these naysayers on Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies in general, the altcoins, which were naysayers on on most of those, but you know, but not not Bitcoin, but Bitcoin specifically. [00:24:02] But you have a situation where you've got all these naysayers and then they're turning around saying, hey, let's put 133 million in this basis coin. Now I'm not saying the person the people that are you know investing that are are naysayers, but but I don't know, you would think they're probably naysayers to Bitcoin, but part of it is that there's no way for them to extract any economic profit out of a Bitcoin deal. [00:24:24] Or or they want to, or they would want to make money off both sides of the deal, right? Because if we're a decade or more away from hyper bitcoinization, and we have no idea how far away we are or not, right? Yeah, right. But let's say we don't even know if it's a good thing. It's a long, let's say it's a relatively long time. That's a big window for a stable cryptocurrency to come in and say, hey, we're much more useful as a currency, as a medium of exchange because we're stable, right? [00:24:48] To come in and say that and then be adopted by corporations. Well, but maybe but payments governments. [00:24:56] Do you think somebody would put like $22 billion in stablecoin? [00:25:03] No, I mean, but I mean that's I mean that's what what they're really talking about in terms of the size that we're talking about this in terms of and then we get into the Lindy. I think maybe collectively effect maybe collectively they might. Well, but in terms of the Alindi effect, if if you're if you're really studies that got into this and you were in a room with people, unless somebody wasn't really doing their diligence and you're gonna put 22 billion in, let's say, for example, wouldn't you think it would make more sense to put it in Bitcoin? [00:25:28] Well, yeah, and that that's the other the other kind of Because Bitcoin's been around over nine years. No. The other debate that these two coins are on opposite sides of are you know, there's a lot of people saying that you have to progress from collectible to store of value to you know to medium of exchange to unit of account, and that's sort of the way that that monetary goods progress in history. [00:25:48] And there are other people like Roger Veer who say that you know you start out as a medium of exchange first, right? Right? Yeah, yeah, I have a thing about Roger, I guess. But that that it happens in a different order and the medium of exchange comes first. So basis is betting on that on that as well. So where's Bcash in this whole thing with what involved with that with with Roger? [00:26:10] Yeah, B cash has has actually pumped up a bit this past week. It did a little bit. I don't know what's going on with that. I missed it. I was traveling, I was I was doing real world stuff. So Donald McIntyre. One last comment. Oh, nice. Let's check that out. Okay, so but we can go through this and then why don't we That's okay. [00:26:30] I can I can edit that. So Donald McIntyre. Oh my god, Microsoft, you suck. [00:26:45] I'm just gonna start from here so I can make that all right. So Donald McIntyre with the last comments of the day, tweeted yesterday that a stable coin, either one requires the whole global economy to be in a stable equilibrium, which I think is a little bit of sarcasm, right? [00:27:04] Two is not trust minimized because it uses a counterparty, in this case the basis corporation. Three, violates property rights, or four, defies the laws of physics and nature. Before we started the show, we pulled this tweet up to read, and we were like, I wonder exactly what he means about violating property rights. Yeah, so Donald was kind enough. [00:27:23] So what we did is is we just said because we kind of thought we knew, but we said curious to and this ties into us from an education standpoint, wanting to learn, right? Because we're you know and by the way, on this we that we'll change our change our view if if it's it's something where we get new information because we're just learning here along with everybody else. [00:27:43] Curious to have more detail on violates property rights. Is it seized? You know what we just said is it's seizure of property, right? And so it's a situation where he came back and said he responded pretty quickly, which is great, and thank you, Donald. When central banks issue base currency to stabilize its value, they dilute the value of existing stock in the hands of the public and the value of contracts denominated in that currency. [00:28:12] For example, salaries, bonds, private debt, accounts payable, accounts receivable, etc. Or and so on. So you've got you've got that issue with with the well, that's kind of ties to the central bank, you know, or or you know, somebody outside of the actual currency doing something with it. [00:28:31] In other words, it's it's centralized at that point if you've got that going on. Yep. Right. And I love the defies the law laws of physics and nature. I just like general. The old violates a natural law. So that's our little bits on stable coins and versus Bitcoin and trying to figure out what's going on there. [00:28:50] And we need to we need to study them more, you know. We need to study them more, but clearly our initial view on them isn't isn't very high. And just because we don't see it as as being good enough because it's it's centralized, I think ultimately, right? Yeah. So that's it for our episode. [00:29:08] Today's episode is Citizen Bitcoin. I'm Brady. I'm Tommy. And we're glad that you could join us. We'll see you next time. And thank you very much. We're glad we were able to do this. So it's good. Take care