Gigi: 21 Lessons from Down the Bitcoin Rabbit Hole Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-05-23 [00:00:17] Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin, and we're sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. So what's up out there, Bitcoiners? Hope you all are doing well out there in Bitcoin Land. [00:00:35] I have got another epic one for you today. Gigi at DureGG on Twitter. And I went for over two hours going through the 21 lessons Bitcoin has taught him, and it was a freaking blast. I think you all are going to love this one. Before we dive in, a quick appeal to rate and review the pod on iTunes or wherever else you can rate and review the pod. [00:00:59] We're up to 26 ratings on iTunes now, and if you appreciate what we're doing here, a five-star rating and review is really right now the best way to support the show. These early ratings and reviews are really important to help me bootstrap this thing, so it's very much appreciated if you can take a moment to do that for us. [00:01:18] Alright. You should also take a moment to prepare yourself. [00:01:23] So, here we go. Let's dive down the rabbit hole with Gigi. [00:01:40] Gigi has contributed some great writing to the internet's growing library of [00:01:45] Bitcoin education content. He's written about Bitcoin's energy consumption, about cryptography, and his idea of Bitcoin's gravity. He's also written up the 21 lessons Bitcoin has taught him. These lessons were originally published on Medium, but have been given a new home this past week at 21lessons.com, complete with an Alice in Wonderland rabbit hole theme and applicable quotes from the book for each lesson. [00:02:12] These lessons are a fantastic summary of Gigi's Bitcoin rabbit hole journey thus far and will be familiar to many of you. I think this is a really useful and fun recap of the Bitcoin rabbit hole journey in general, and also a great episode to share with the Bitcoin noobs in your life. [00:02:43] All right. Hello, Gigi, and welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. [00:02:47] Hey Brady, thanks for having me. Yeah, absolutely. I'm really glad to have you. You just launched a new website. Well, the content has been out on Medium for a while, but you just packaged it up into a beautiful Alice in Wonderland rabbit hole themed journey through the lessons you've learned in Bitcoin. [00:03:09] It's at 21lessons.com. It looks great, by the way, and the content, of course, is amazing. Thanks. Yeah, I tried to package it up a bit differently because the medium posts just got really long. And I tried to just cut it up and have something in one place. [00:03:27] And my plan is also to work on that continuously, so I also added like more links to dive deeper down the rabbit hole. And I'm currently trying to build up a library especially focused on you know, not exactly like the total freshmen, total newbies, but if you're interested and you started to fall down the rabbit hole that you have something you can go to and dive deeper and hopefully it will be somewhat of I know it's ironic, but a trusted resource with you know content that stood out over time, just articles that were not shared for just the one or two [00:04:06] Days after they were published that they are still that that are still good in a way. Yeah, absolutely. And that that's something I think about a lot is like finding someone that you trust to learn from. And you know, I think our experience as Bitcoiners, you know, falling down the rabbit hole and going through that whole however long it takes people, three months, six months, a year. [00:04:28] I mean it goes on forever, but just kind of that first initial you know, achieving that initial understanding of what's going on, is you know, you have you have to find you have to the process of figuring out who to trust, really, because yeah, it is ironic, you're right, because we're talking about a trustless, you know, form of money and value transfer, or at least trust minimized, as you point out. [00:04:51] Nothing is actually trustless, and we'll we'll talk about that here in a little bit. But yeah, you have to find somebody that keep a group of people or content that you trust. And for instance, Andreas Antonopoulos has built up you know a long time a lot of content over a long period of time, has proven that he has a deep understanding of what's going on, has proven that he's you know a good person who is trustworthy, you know, worthy of that trust. [00:05:17] And that's why a lot of people I think gravitate toward Andreas when they first find Bitcoin. But I think you're right. And then this is, I think, gonna be a good another good trusted source for the recently the recently rabbit holed. Yeah, I hope so. And don't get me wrong, I don't think there should be like one trusted resource. [00:05:40] I think there should be many and it should be kind of distributed. And I think we're on our way to have that like there's the Nakamodo Institute, and there are new sites popping up all the time, and there are some, you know, just people, individuals that are quite trusted in a way because they're just they have high integrity and they didn't sell out, at least not yet. [00:05:59] Right. And I think the more you know the more entry points there are the better, and I think also everyone has their own spin on it. Some go very deep in economics and some are just you know born Austrians and look at Bitcoin through the economic lens, and others are just coders since they were 12 and just dive very deep into all the code. [00:06:23] And yeah, I don't know where where I'll be going yet, but I'm sure it it will be a little bit different than what everyone else does. Yeah, it's it's it's it's kind of like an open source education system too that goes along a kind of parallel with Bitcoin's open source software. [00:06:42] Every everything's organic, it's permissionless. Anybody can you know start teaching about Bitcoin and do it their own way. So I think you're right, we'll end up with a very diverse distributed library of content of all types of media to teach about Bitcoin. [00:07:00] Yeah, I hope so. It's exciting in any case. It's great to see what people are doing. Alright, so I think we should just dive into the 21 lessons that you've put together for Bitcoin. And they're grouped into three chapters. And you know, some of the listeners will have certainly read this on read these on Medium. [00:07:21] The three posts on Medium correspond to the three chapters here on 21 lessons.com. Chapter one is philosophy, chapter two is economics, chapter three is technology. Each has seven lessons for a total of 21 lessons. Of course that calls the calls calls back to the 21 million you know bitcoins that will be mined by the by the year 2140. [00:07:46] And I assume that was probably intentional. Yeah, it it was intentional. It that's also why I kinda had to force myself through that and actually come up with 21 things, so it was a nice way to force myself to finish the series. [00:08:06] Yeah, yeah. Yeah. As you said, I tried to structure it in three things because I just knew from the get-go that it would be too much otherwise. It's it's the three medium posts are very long as it is, but I yeah, I just had to come up with some chapters in a way, and I landed on philosophy economics and the technical things that Bitcoin is about. [00:08:38] But I mean there there could be other lenses to just look at Bitcoin, and I think that's why it's so fascinating because I think about how to best look at Bitcoin a lot, and I really like the biology analogy as well, like Bitcoin as a living system, so to speak, and they're definitely huge social aspects as well. [00:09:02] And philosophy, economics and technology are just the three I landed on, and I tried to group the lessons in those three categories, but it it's it's not exactly easy because everything is so interconnected, and yeah, the lessons they they are also a bit interconnected. [00:09:23] If you'd like we can just start with the first one and go through it a bit. Yeah, let's go through it a bit. So, chapter one is philosophy, and the first lesson is is titled Immutability and Change. So what's the what's the crux of this lesson here that you're trying to get to? [00:09:42] Yeah, so I ask myself like how would you go about if you want to change Bitcoin? You know, like can Bitcoin be changed, and that's that's kind of a weird question to ask from the get-go because it it is about immutability and it's it's about immutability of the letter. [00:10:02] And there is a weird interplay of immutability and change because the software changes all the time, and you know I try to explore the question a bit as well. How can software, which is very changeable in a way, create digital information which is virtually immutable, and already you're diving down the rabbit hole quite deeply because it you end up asking yourself questions like how could Bitcoin be stopped and can Bitcoin be corrupted and so on and so forth. [00:10:35] And I think one really awesome way to think about it is to think Bitcoin as as Hasu said think of it as an automated social contract. So the software isn't even like the software is just the embodiment of what everyone sees Bitcoin as in a way. [00:10:56] And I think people realized it quite early and Ralph Merkwell said that very beautifully and I have his quote in the in the first lesson where he says that Bitcoin is the first example of a new form of life and it's it's really a living organism and that also points out its resilience because he also says like if if nuclear war destroys half of the planet it would still go on and it it wouldn't be corrupted. [00:11:22] And I think that's really interesting and my conclusion of that of all of that is that you know if you see Bitcoin as a living organism and if you understand it deeply enough then you kind of have to come to the conclusion that it it will go on and I think what I wrote is the heartbeat of the Bitcoin network will outlast all of ours which is quite a thought because you know I'm I'm still kind of young and to think that Bitcoin will still go on after I'm dead it's it's it's quite awe inspiring. [00:11:55] So bit you conclude with and each of these lessons is basically wrapped up into a single sentence of what the lesson that this you know what Bitcoin has taught you in this case and here you wrap it up with Bitcoin taught me that it won't change I will. Yeah and huge shout out to Marty Bend because I think in one of the very first episodes of Tales from the Crypt I wasn't able to find the episode exactly, but I know that he said something along the lines like these protocols will change us more than we will change it. [00:12:28] And he is stuck to this theme for a couple of episodes and he still talks about it. And that's where that came from. And also a shout out to Brandon Quittem. I just can't talk about Bitcoin without mentioning him because he beautifully made the connection to the fungi kin kingdom and wrote a three-part series. [00:12:47] I think the third part isn't released yet, but the first one was Bitcoin as a decentralized organism where he focused on mycelium, like the fungi on the structure network. And the second one was Bitcoin as a social creature. And I think those are really nice ways to think about it. Yeah. And like you said, I conclude every lesson with what I have learned from Bitcoin, and I just want to stress also again that all of that is just a distillation of what I've learned and it's a personal reflection, so it shouldn't be taking us this is definitely what you will learn when you go into Bitcoin or anything like that. [00:13:21] It's just my way of looking at things. Right, right. And just for a note for listeners, the April twelfth episode of Citizen Bitcoin was with Brandon Quittem and we got deep into the his Bitcoin fungi analogy, and that was a really fun episode. So I definitely recommend Yeah, it was a great episode. Yeah. [00:13:40] Okay, so next lesson. You know I was I was I wasn't tempted I was tempted well before we go to the second lesson actually, I was tempted to go down a little rabbit hole already on this first one. Because I've been doing I've been doing a lot of thinking about the social la this idea of a social layer and like the code, the technical or code layer of Bitcoin. [00:14:03] And it was definitely it was you know spurred by Hasu's article that you cite, and also by Brandon's article that Bitcoin is a social organism. I think I've after several kind of back and forths on Twitter with many different Bitcoiners and on Discord and just talking about it in general with people, I think I've come to the conclusion that I feel like the word social is a is a little trouble problematic for some people because I don't think it's precise enough. [00:14:33] I think that Bitcoin is an economic contract, but but you know, economics is also a social creature, right? It's like a it's like a particular kind of a social creature. But I do think that the precision here is important because there's a lot of context, like the idea the phrase social contract is really comes from and has its origins in political philosophy and political thought. [00:14:57] And so the idea of a social contract to me implies a lot more politics and like social, like a lot more political kind of interaction than does economic interaction. What I and I you know, and I can also see like, yeah, well, you know, all the debates about like consensus algorithm and how you know the Bitcoin core code and all of that are political debates in essence, right? [00:15:24] Because there's there's lots of politics that go involved to convincing each other about how Bitcoin should be. And so yeah, I think that the other way to look at it though is that what Bitcoin is is actually an economic shelling point of individuals in a free market agreeing, arriving at a shelling point about what the best money is to use for that free market, right? [00:15:50] And that so the fundamentally the process that that's driving that agreement is the qualities of sound money and not the qualities of a particular person's debate skills or persuasive skills etc. You know yeah I think you're absolutely right and there's a lot of a lot to unpack here and I th I agree with everything you said but I think what's what what you what you said in the beginning is worth pointing out again that all of the analogies we have so far they fall short like I think that Bitcoin is something new entirely and I d I just think we [00:16:28] Lack the we lack precise words and we lack precise analogies or I don't think there are any analogies as of yet that really help you I mean they all help you to make sense of it but none of them are precise by any stretch of the imagination. And I think also the whole like for example the block size debate and just deciding politically and by argumentation what bitcoin is I think it also leaves out the point that there are a lot of people I think at least that are just not interested in all of these debates at all at all and there's like the tiny tiny tiny minority who is talking about it. [00:17:05] And I'm sure there are many people who are just not interested in all of that at all and they just run their run the software run their notes and I think that's also why hard forks are so extremely problem problematic because you can you know the you just can't be sure that people will be on board there are so many reasons why people won't be on board. [00:17:29] It's it might be just out of ignorance and laziness and maybe the majority will just continue running their notes. So you know what I mean? It's it's it's really complicated in a way. It is absolutely complicated. It's not only it's yeah it's not only political and social. [00:17:45] There are so many things involved. It's a can of worms. [00:17:49] Yeah, it's it is, it absolutely is. Okay. Lesson two is titled is about scarcity. Oh sorry. Exactly. And that that that relates the second lesson already relates to what you said about the shelling point of sound money in a way, because people figured out over the course of history what what is valuable or or what value actually is and it relates to scarcity. [00:18:16] And I tried to write about it a little bit. And it's I think it's an interesting topic for multiple reasons. First of all, that people figured this out long, long ago. That we have like yeah, there are some things that that we value and they are scarce, and there are other things that are very valuable but are not as scarce, and there's the relationship of the diamond and water paradox as well. [00:18:48] But I'm already getting ahead of myself in the in this in the in the in the scarcity lesson, I was reflecting on that technological progress is generally leading to abundance, and we're doing away with scarce things. So so far technological progress progress made everything more abundant. [00:19:11] And it's interesting in a way that Bitcoin is a you know it's it's an awesome technology in itself, and it's it's a very advanced technology in my opinion, and it creates scarcity. And I have the quote of Cyfidin in there here. I'm not sure if it's in the in the Bitcoin standard, but it's it's from one of his presentations, and he says only two things are generally scarce now, time and Bitcoin. [00:19:35] And that's also something to think about. And what I what I found kind of funny in a way that is that if you understand how Bitcoin works, it produces scarcity by just copying things wildly. And that's that's a nice paradox again, because it just replicates itself, it replicates the letter, it it does copying all the time, and you know also transactional and block propagation is just a bunch of copying all the time. [00:20:00] Yep, it's true. And it creates something scarce in the process. So so yeah, Bitcoin taught me that, and it it also taught me what what real scarcity is. So that was lesson two. That's that quote by Safidine, only two things are genuinely scarce, time and Bitcoin. That idea is really, really important. [00:20:21] In terms of the you know the consequences or ramifications of what Bitcoin will do for us as people and as a s as individuals and as a society. And Messier Mohammedov gets into this on an episode of Tales from the Crypt, where Yeah, it's an awesome episode. [00:20:39] Yeah, and it's it's really important. And it's something I've been using a lot lately with people who are you know new to Bitcoin and asking me about it. But the only thing in the like in the world that's really genuinely scarce besides Bitcoin is time. And we've been trading our time, our effort, and our our work for a money that is absolutely not scarce and is easily made more of it is easily made. [00:21:02] And so it's just a really a fundamentally bad deal for people to trade your time and effort for something that is that which is ex extremely scarce for something that is absolutely not scarce at all so yeah yeah exactly I and this episode it it's so great so everyone should listen to it and I'm I'm as I said I'm in the process of trying to build up a library and that's definitely a an episode that's that's already in there because it's just such a great way of thinking about things and it it also makes clear the downsides of you know working for [00:21:40] Fiat currency in a way that you just over time the work you put in isn't just valued anymore and it's it's a great thought yeah yeah all right lesson three is about replication and locality so again we're coming from the idea that Bitcoin is creating scarcity through replication and that idea then leads to what is what is the like leads to the question of like what is locality essentially or where where are we right now in this distributed system is there really the idea of locality does it actually exist in a distributed system. [00:22:18] Yeah exactly and I think Peter von Walkenburg said that beautifully that you know there are no bitcoins in a way and it's it's really a nice exercise to ask yourself like where are your bitcoins or where is your transaction or you know even where is the ledger for example and I think especially regulation will have to deal with with that and I think also Andreas talks about that in some of his talks that if you if you take your receipt phrase for example or your letter or whatever your your access to your bitcoins with you, are you actually transferring money? [00:22:52] If you know go through through customs and immigration or through an airport. There's always this form to fill out do you carry more than ten thousand dollars with you or whatever? And you know, if if you're a whale and you have your letter in your pocket, what are you actually doing? It's not it's not an easy thing to answer because the answer to it is non-trivial. [00:23:12] In a way, you know that there really aren't any bitcoins and you just have some private keys that a allows you to move the bitcoins. But even even that is just it's it's not correct in a way because you have you have the yeah, you have the power to create new UTXOs in a way. [00:23:35] So the technology the technicalities they it it on on the realest of levels it doesn't even make sense to talk about bitcoins. That's that's something weird. So what are we actually saying when you when when we're saying you know I have a Bitcoin or I have a couple of Satoshis? [00:23:53] It's it's kind of nonsensical and I'll be yeah it will be exciting to watch what kind of regulations and laws and whatnot people will attempt to make to yeah work with this new reality. And I try to expand upon that in in another thing I wrote which is it's called the magic dust of cryptography. [00:24:16] It's it's kinda short. And I think you know, with Bitcoin it's it's kinda it's already really weird, but it's not as weird as if you go into strong encryption, because in Bitcoin, you just sign a couple of things and that's it. But it's really an interesting question to ask yourself as well. [00:24:37] If you have, for example, important documentary passport or something in additional form and it's encrypted with strong cryptography. Do you actually have it with you? You know, it's there are some weird questions this new world opens up. And yeah, the conclusion of the third lesson is that Bitcoin taught me that locality is tricky business. [00:24:56] I put it. Yeah, that's perfectly put. It is. [00:25:02] And it's just another one of those ideas that are just mind-bending and lots of rabbit holes to go down and will probably contribute to our movement toward a true global economy and thus ideas of some sort of a global way to administer justice and the rule of law in a global economy. [00:25:27] So there'll be political implications that follow for sure. [00:25:31] Yeah, exactly. Because also this this non-locality, in a way, it is part of Bitcoin's resilience because you know, local laws just never they will never apply. It's it's really hard to stop something that is non-local. And I thought that's interesting. [00:25:50] All right, lesson four the problem of identity. Yeah, the problem of identity. So that's that's a play on yeah, and a philosophical essay, which is called What is it like to be a Dad? [00:26:10] And I think it it's Nic Carter who wrote an article who it's called What Is It Like to Be a Bitcoin? It was then published as Bitcoin's Existential Crisis. But I like the original title even more because it's a nice question to ask yourself, you know, what is it like to be a Bitcoin? [00:26:31] And I wrote this problem of identity when there was a lot of talk going on in the Bitcoin community of you know forks, potential forks, and then you know the whole V cash debacle happened, and it's it explores some questions if you can even define identity in a fully decentralized system in a way. [00:26:57] And it's it's an old idea, it's also because again the software, for example, changes all the time, and that leads back to a very old idea, which is the ship of Theseus, which is basically if you the idea if you replace planks of a ship one at a time, and you'll end up you'll end up with a new ship over time. [00:27:21] Is it still the original ship or is it a new ship if you replace everything bit by bit? And we're doing that to the Bitcoin software, and so it's kind of weird to think about the identity of Bitcoin. And Metodelbock points out that the only thing that's really that has a fixed identity is the ledger and the historical record of UTXOs, and I tend to agree. [00:27:42] And I think other questions of identity can never be fully answered if the system is is truly leaderless and decentralized, because you will have to answer or try to answer the question of what is Bitcoin, the system in perpetuity. And so Bitcoin taught me that the that decentralization contradicts identity in a way if as if if something is sufficiently decentralized. [00:28:12] Excellent. Alright, lesson five, an immaculate conception. Yeah. And this is this is the origin story, the origin story of Bitcoin. And it's it's this is you know an homage to the Christian idea of the birth of Jesus Christ, right? [00:28:30] Where the Immaculate Conception is the idea that that Mary was impregnated with G with baby Jesus you know, without a human father. And this was called the Immaculate Conception. Exactly. And there the idea in Bitcoin is that Bitcoin was born in a way that can never be recreated. [00:28:52] Like it's just th it was a one-time event that cannot happen again. And that's kind of being proven out with all the forks that have attempted to become better Bitcoins over the past year. Yeah, exactly. And again, shout out to Marty Bend who talked about it a lot and it's it it took me a long while to understand this actually, how important that is and Marty talks about narratives. [00:29:19] A lot of people talk about narratives in the space all the time and it took me quite a long time to realize that this is actually a feature and a very important one at that and you would have to replicate it or even surpass it if you want to if you if you would if if you would like to surpass Bitcoin, like do a new project and do something that is 10x better. [00:29:42] I think also the origin story has to be 10x better in a way. And it's it asks the question of yeah, how was Bitcoin conceived or or created and I also explore what came before it. A little bit at least. And Jimmy Song put it nicely. [00:30:01] I think I have his quote in in there as well, which he said in one of his articles that one of the greatest things that Satoshi did was to disappear. And it's it's really important to think about that because also Satoshi pointed out that the only reason why previous projects failed was because there were always hats that the governments or other powerful entities were able to cut off. [00:30:29] And so if you really want to have a decentralized system that can't be shut down, you also need to have something like an immaculate conception and disappear as a father, so to speak. And so yeah, I conclude this lesson with Bitcoin taught me that narratives are important because I really think they are, and I also think that this origin story is so fascinating that a lot of people are drawn to Bitcoin purely because of it. [00:30:55] And I think everyone would like to know who Satoshi is. And or at least if you first hear about it, a lot of people would like to know. Yeah. Yeah, I mean and narratives absolutely are important. And Dan Held has a great article called Quantum Narratives that looks at sort of the and I think Nic Carter has also done some work on this, sort of visualizing the various narratives that have sort of encapsulated Bitcoin and become memes to describe Bitcoin. [00:31:25] So I will link to all that stuff in the show notes. This is this series is an absolute gold mine of really well-chosen reference material and quotations. So that that's super helpful, I think, to people who are relatively new and trying to get a grasp on what's going on here. Thanks, yeah. [00:31:45] Also makes me think of the last episode of Game of Thrones. Tyrion Lannister, he's he's standing before like all the lords and ladies of Western, so like what are left of them anyway. And he's like, he's like, How like what's the most important thing in the world? What's the most powerful thing in the world? Yeah. And he's like, it's not money, it's not armies, it's stories, you know. [00:32:06] And there's no better story in cryptocurrency than Bitcoin, and I just don't see how you can you know, I don't see how you could improve upon it. Yeah, exactly. And again, I think it's it's it's really important. A lot of people underestimate it, because there are still projects in the space that people find interesting, but you know, they could be easily shut down if you just round up the development team or the one or two leaders. [00:32:31] And I think, you know, it's really hard to do that in Bitcoin. Okay, lesson six is is titled The Power of Free Speech. Can you take us through that? Yeah, sure. So that was also one of my like bulk moments. And it was actually thanks to an article written by Budia. [00:32:52] I don't have the title of the article on the top of my head, but he mentioned that you know like every aspect of Bitcoin is text, and thus it's equivalent to speech. And in the US there is also legal precedent for that. So in the US you as long as you have the first amendment, you just can't outlaw code because there's legal precedent that said that code is speech and it can't be outlawed. [00:33:16] And there are some interesting developments on that also with, you know, now people are 3D printing guns and three 3D printing other other things. And you can make the same argument there, and it has been made, and for example, Cody Wilson came out with the Liberator code book and just took the code of the 3D printed gun that was yeah, he got into some legal trouble because people were of the opinion that it's illegal to distribute it online, so he just put it in a book and published it by Amazon, and there's nothing you can do about it because it would be restricting speech, you know. [00:33:51] And it's the same for Bitcoin in a way. And yeah, at least in in countries where you have what like countries that respect free speech, Bitcoin is basically it's really hard to outlaw and make illegal. [00:34:11] And yeah, that was a light bulb moment for me because in the essence the question you would have to ask yourself is how do how would you criminalize or ban or prosecute an idea, you know? You end up in in really weird territory because if you ban speech and also in in in Bitcoin, you have it's just information in a way, and you can represent it however you want. [00:34:36] I know Andreas had in one of his talks using emojis to decode or to encode and decode Bitcoin transactions, for example. And we have QR codes, we have emojis, we have addresses, and you can also just use numbers to encode everything and so on. And this leads, you know, if if something if information is banned, you can also come up in a way to encode it as a number, and then you have suddenly illegal numbers, or you can even encode it as prime numbers, and then you have illegal prime numbers, and everything gets nonsensical really quickly. [00:35:04] So the conclusion of this lesson was that Bitcoin taught me that in a free society, free speech and free software are are unstoppable, and I really believe that. So I absolutely believe that too, and I think it's it's you know absolutely important. This is one of the foundations that Bitcoin itself is built on. [00:35:23] Later in the in the lessons, you talk about how Bitcoin is a kind of a foundation, a rock upon which we're building a new a new global transfer of wealth, system to transfer wealth and value around. And one of the foundations that Bitcoin is built on is this idea of free speech, and that idea has been fundamental to the United States Constitution and many other you know nations around the world as well, and it would be absurd in an effort for a nation state to control or ban Bitcoin in some way to basically turn its back [00:36:02] On that fundamental freedom. So it's it is it's it's important, it's an important aspect of Bitcoin. I'm sure that will there will be fights about it, and just like there will be, or there are right now with the defense defense distributed in Cody Wilson in the United States. So we may have to defend defend Bitcoin on this on this basis, but it is absolutely defensible, and we'll do so if we have to. [00:36:25] Yeah, well said. Yeah, and lesson seven then is the is titled this is the last lesson in the chapter, the philosophy chapter, The Limits of Knowledge. Yeah, the limits of knowledge. So that was I wrote it kind of out of necessity because I was trying, you know, I fell down the rabbit hole quite a while ago, and I'm and I'm still trying to figure everything out, you know. [00:36:48] You know, I'm I you know I'm still in free fall. And I just I just had to put it in there in a way because it's related to a philosophical thought that is it even possible to know everything in a way or to figure out how nature works and so on. And the question I ask myself is can any one person fully understand Bitcoin and all of its aspects in a way? [00:37:13] And it also touches on just the basic fact I would say that learning about all the fundamentals of Bitcoin is bloody hard. And Jameson Love tweeted out I don't know when it was but he tweeted that no one has found the bottom of the Bitcoin rabbit hole yet. [00:37:33] And I think that's true. So it yeah, following down that a rabbit hole is just humbling experience, or at least it was for me. And I concluded the lesson with Bitcoin taught me that I know very little about almost anything. And yeah, it taught me that the rabbit hole is bottomless in a way. [00:37:53] Well, it'll it Matt Odell always says stay humble, stack sats. That's his that's his sort of motto. Right. And Bitcoin will will humble you over and over and over again, which is which is which is good in a good way, in a good way. I think that's a great wrap up of the kind of philosophical ideas that surround Bitcoin, a great introduction. [00:38:17] User like listeners who are kind of new to Bitcoin, I mean this is you know, go through and read, read this, you know, this chapter and go through the down the rabbit hole links that are at the end of each chapter, and you'll just have an an excellent introduction to sort of the mind-bending philosophical implications of Bitcoin. [00:38:37] It's it's a lot of fun to get into for sure. Okay, so it was a lot of fun for me at least. [00:38:47] Yeah, I think it's it's a bit of blast. I mean, I it's the it's the most fun I've had in a long time. Alright, chapter two, economics. So now we're gonna shift into the economic sort of the economic nature of Bitcoin and then it and its implications too for our global economy. [00:39:11] Yeah, so economics. Well, I want to start out with just acknowledging that I don't have a deep background in economics, and I'm I'm trying to get one, but it's still an ongoing process. And but just from the get-go I can say that Bitcoin taught me more about money than I ever thought I would need to know. [00:39:33] And that's also where I start the chapter, which is lesson eight, which is titled Financial Ignorance, and I kind of had to face my own financial ignorance. And I quickly realized that in order to understand the new monetary system, you have to get acquainted with the old one. [00:39:53] And so I yeah, just began asking my myself questions like many before me that went into Bitcoin, and it's it was basically how does the banking system work, how how does the stock market work, what is fiat money, and why why is there so much debt and stuff like that. [00:40:14] And yeah, it it was quite awe-inspiring in a way to find out how all of this works. And I know that that I'm not alone, like I went through Twitter and just tried to find other people that went through the same process and I have found a couple of tweets that just acknowledged as well, even from people that work into finance that once you go into Bitcoin you just really learn what money is and learn about the history and money and so on and so forth. [00:40:46] Yep. And I started reading all the economics books that are recommended by Bitcoiners, like Miser's human action and so on. And Nisa's also acknowledged, for example, that economics is a living thing and it's not exactly an an exact science. [00:41:05] So I think that's fascinating as well, and it goes back to the idea of examining Bitcoin through a biological lens in a way, like as a living system, and then you have economics as a living system, Bitcoin as a living system, and all of it is entangled and it's it's kinda kinda hard to make sense of it as at first. [00:41:25] And another th another quote I have in there is from Robert Kiyasaki, which I think is really interesting because he he mentioned in one of his talks that we're not allowed to learn about money in school and I found it to be very true because I have a long formal education, quite a good education behind me, and I never learned about money or the history of money at all, and also not about personal finance or anything like that. [00:41:51] So yeah, the financial ignorance lesson was basically just facing my own financial ignorance. And I don't remember how I concluded the section. I don't have the I don't have it from the top of my head. You'll have to read it for me. [00:42:10] Yeah, you concluded a Bitcoin taught me to look behind the curtain and face my financial ignorance. Ah yeah, exactly. Yeah, and I, you know, I have the exact same experience. And I use this phrase on the podcast all the time. So many of us are default Keynesians because we are basically only fed that sort of economic idea in schools. [00:42:34] And you know on not and even then like you know not until you know like like university level schooling there's there's basically no financial education in terms of just like how to manage money and why savings important what money is in if you study economics. Even yeah even if you study economics. And you know the I economics is not like Keynesian economics is not really about or and like and academic economics in general is not really about well not economic not economic academics in general but Keynesian economic academics which is pretty much all of economic academics. [00:43:12] There's a there's a you know the Austrian school exists but it's not certainly not very well represented in American universities and probably the same likewise around the world. Yeah the that kind of economics is really just complexity like a bunch of complexity that's unnecessary unnecessary complexity that is created because human some people have taken this power to print money and set interest rates kind of from the free market and thus created this idea that hey we can study this system and [00:43:50] Learn about it and manage it effectively with these you know with this kind of central control, the central authority. And then all so all this you know academic sort of institutions started you know studying you know all the aspects of how an economy works and all of that is unnecessary if you have a sound money like Bitcoin or or like or like gold in the past. [00:44:14] Yeah, and I think I think just from from common sense perspective in a way at least that's the experience I had. Again, I don't have a deep background in economics, at least not yet. I'm I'm working on it. But as a in a common sense way, I think the Austrian viewpoint makes way more sense than the Keynesian viewpoint. [00:44:35] And also history shows that you know in the end sound money wins out. And there's also a reason, for example, why nation states hoard gold still and so on. So it's it's quite a bit to think about. Yeah. Yep. All right, and that leads us nicely into the next lesson, lesson nine, which is inflation. [00:44:58] Yeah. So yeah, economics one on one, right? So yeah, I mean I try to just look at everything at the basics again. And I ask myself, you know, what exactly is inflation and why do things get more expensive over time? [00:45:21] And I also looked at some hyperinflation episodes that some countries live through, which I recommend everyone to do because it's just endlessly fascinating. And yeah, history teaches a bunch of lessons there. And if you think that hyperinflation can't happen in your country, just you know, look at Weimar Germany and look at any country that suffered through hyperinflation. [00:45:47] They all thought it can't happen in their country, and most countries were you know they were prosperous before. And yeah, I have a I have a bunch of quotes in there from Henry Haslitt and Friedrich Hayek and so on. And one of Hyek I really like is that the mild and steady inflation that that it just cannot help, it can only lead to outright inflation. [00:46:12] And I have a background in computer science and a little bit of physics, and I think it's really important to understand exponentials in especially in this space, and that's basically what the term steady growth means, you know. And if you have a steady growth of like it no matter the percentage, it's always an exponential. [00:46:34] And just understanding that it it's it's inherently unstable, you know. It it just steady growth can never be unstable, and it never is. And it in in any in any physical system, you either have a catastrophic collapse or you have an S-curve where it levels out. And so yeah, thinking about inflation as exponential growth helped me to understand what's happening there. [00:46:58] And you know, we have the situation now in Venezuela, which is currently suffering from hyperinflation and it has an inflation rate of like a million percent or something, and the money is basically worthless. And I also linked through to the list of historical currencies in Wikipedia, which also everyone should check out because there are there are a bunch, and it just shows that it will inevitably happen over a long enough period of time, you know. [00:47:26] Like any money that inflates will will [00:47:29] Be replaced by another money. So either that or it will [00:47:34] Hyperinflate. And so the lesson there is basically that monies that inflate die, in my opinion, at least. And also safety in the Bitcoin standard has a nice quote in there that if you can inflate the money supply as a government, it's really hard to resist this power and this temptation. [00:47:57] And he says that history has shown that governments will inevitably succumb to the temptation of inflate inflating the money supply. And yeah, if you look at history, that's definitely true. And yeah, I also bringing it back to Bitcoin. I ask myself how and why is Bitcoin different? [00:48:17] And what I think is so fascinating about Bitcoin, that it's it's in a way it's basically rooted in the laws of physics, like it's rooted in the thermodynamics. And in in contrast to currencies managed by the government, it's it it yeah, it takes the loss of thermodynamics and produces scarcity by utilizing the loss of thermodynamics. [00:48:42] And I think that's fascinating thought. And so yeah, the conclusion of this one is that Bitcoin taught me that bitcoin taught me about the hidden tax of inflation and the catastrophe of hyperinflation. Yeah, and it's an utterly you know, incipient tax, too, because it's and you call it you know, here a hidden tax, and it's obfuscated behind every single transaction that's made in the economy because money's half of that transaction. [00:49:13] There's a good or a service, and there's money on the other side. So there's you know, takes those kind of two components to create a transaction. And so if you have you know if you're messing with the fundamentals of half of every single economic transaction, there's obviously going to be effects, and it's really going to be hard to kind of understand those effects or you know, when you're just like on a day-to-day basis for an average individual. [00:49:40] You know, it it's yeah, exactly. It's hard to understand. And it's also so hard, it's it's it's also so hard to see because you know, you as you said, you don't feel it on a day-to-day basis. But if you look at what's happening over the span of like 10 years or 20 years, right, which isn't a terribly long time, like if you plan your career or plan your family or whatever, like 10, 20 years is something that you actually can plan for, and people do plan for. [00:50:08] And if you just think about saving in in field currency, like half of your value will be gone. And thus half of the work you put in will be gone, and half of the time you spend at work will be gone. Which then leads to the problem. It is, yeah. And that of course then leads to the problem that people who do have extra wealth and value that they want to store, they can't store it with butt with money because it's going to be inflated away and it's not a good deal for them. [00:50:35] So they're gonna put it into some other, you know, like relatively scarce asset like real estate, for instance. And so it'll drive up prices of real estate and make it harder for you know people who with with less income to find homes that are adequate or whatever exactly place where they want to be. Yeah. [00:50:54] So there's all kinds of implications that follow the hidden tax of inflation, which will and like you said you know it's inevitably led to the death of the of the currency in one form or another sometimes hyperinflation but I think there's a number out there and I can't remember exactly what it is but there's like an average lifespan of sovereign fiat currencies and it's it's like a matter of decades. [00:51:17] I think it's it's like something like 50 years or something. Yeah. Yeah something like that. Yeah. So it will die at some point. No no fiat currency is live forever. Yeah exactly. Alright lesson 10 is about value. I think this is a really important one. Yeah. Let's talk about it. Yeah. Yeah I already talked about it again in the first lesson I went ahead of myself. [00:51:39] And yeah I explored the question like why do we value some things more than others? And this leads to the paradox of value. Again like why are diamonds valuable and like before industrial times diamonds were completely useless. They were just nice to look at you know but you don't you did not have like diamond grinders or like an diamond machinery and the paradox of value asked the question why are diamonds valuable and water is cheap because you know water is definitely has more intrinsic value than diamonds. [00:52:16] You can't eat diamonds but you can't drink water and you will die quite quickly if you don't drink water for two or three days. And so this this leads to the question like is the value purely subjective or not? And I also try to ask myself something along the lines of how valuable will Bitcoin get or where does Bitcoin's value come from? [00:52:38] And those are not exactly easy questions to answer. But what became clear to me, and again, I have to highly recommend Safe Dean's book, The Bitcoin Standard, because the first couple of chapters are purely about the gold standard in a way. And as you said, Bitcoin is like a monetary shelling point like gold was. [00:53:03] And I wholeheartedly agree. And I think it's fascinating to look at Bitcoin through the lens of value, because it emulates all the good properties that gold had and gold still has. [00:53:20] And yeah, in addition to that, it's more like gold on steroids because it has so many properties that gold doesn't have. And all the flaws that gold has, Bitcoin tries to eradicate. And so Bitcoin, in a way, it has all the properties that you need of something that a valuable good needs to have. [00:53:41] And so in summary, in a way, it's extremely rare. It's really hard to produce. It can't be replaced, which I think is also important. And it's worth thinking about because, you know, if you lose your private key, if you burn coins, they just can't be replaced. So it will get even more scarce over time because people will inevitably lose access to private keys or will die or, you know, if you burn coins on accident and so on. [00:54:10] And yeah, it also is the best tool for value transfer [00:54:15] Across borders to date and everyone who ever needed to use bitcoin for for anything sort of real in a way knows that because try trying to haul a bunch of code bars across a border is really not that easy but sending a bitcoin transaction really is easy in comparison right and also it's virtually resistant to censorship and confiscation which I think will become more and more important as Bitcoin grows. [00:54:42] And yeah all of that's just taught me that that value even though it it might be subjective it's by no means arbitrary. So there's a reason why gold is valuable and people value it. There's also a reason why Bitcoin has value and people value it. Yeah absolutely and there was a debate between Safadine and Peter Schiff. [00:55:05] I think it was earlier this week. Yeah yeah and this was a major point of contention like like Safadine was just like almost speechless that he was having to like like debate this point with Peter Schiff. But Peter Schiff was making the argument that value is objective that there's intrinsic value to things and that gold has intrinsic value and Bitcoin doesn't and this you know you hear this argument from from lots of people in kind of the cane you know that are in the canes well sort of entrenched in the Keynesian ideas and it's just it's just not the case. [00:55:41] We have like the val the value of goods is is determined by our reasoning by individual humans saying like yes that's valuable to me. No that's not valuable to me etc etc and how valuable it is and money is there as as the intermediary to sort of define the value of any good or service relative to any other good or service. [00:56:03] And that's what it does so amazingly well. And that and you know, when you start, like we talked about just a moment ago, when you start messing with it and trying to control it and centralize control and power of the money, and it just reduces the efficiency of money to determine those relative values. [00:56:22] Listening to the debate between Peter Schiff and Safety Namus was quite eye-opening and fascinating because it really drove home the central point of misunderstanding, and it was for me kind of painful to listen in on these 90 minutes and Peter Schiff just not moving an inch and not also not you know he he wasn't able to cite any future value of Bitcoin where he might reconsider his position, which I also thought interesting. [00:57:00] But what you said about the monetary premium, I just want to go down this tiny rabbit hole a little bit because I think what's really fascinating and also important to understand is that gold has its value of mostly because of like the most of the value of gold is because of its monetary premium and not because of its industrial usage or anything like that. [00:57:24] And what is so cool about Bitcoin is that it's just 100% monetary premium in a way. And there is a nice article about it, it came out recently. I think the title was Bitcoin has no intrinsic value, and that's good for something along those lines. Yeah, Connor Connor Brown. Exactly, Connor Brown. [00:57:43] Yeah, and that that talks about that, and I think it's an important point to understand and it's related to the value lesson, yeah. Yep, absolutely. So it's definitely an important one to understand because it it's if you don't understand the value is subjective, then you'll have a hard time understanding why Bitcoin could have any value. [00:58:04] Lesson eleven is simply titled money, and it gets to that question. What is money? And we've yeah, we've talked about it. Yeah. Yeah. We've talked about it now already, and yeah, basically the question like what is money and who is in charge of our money. [00:58:23] And yeah, I tried to explore the question. You know, what does the introduction of a new stateless money do to our existing systems in a way. But you know, you could I think you could write a book about it. So the lesson is kind of short. And I picked out a quote by Satoshi because I think it's it's really nice to think about it in that way. [00:58:49] And it's the quote where he said that Bitcoin is more like a precious precious metal. And instead of the supply changing to keep the value the same, the supply is predetermined and the value changes. And that's really important just to understand Bitcoin and its value and the price. And yeah, I would argue we are still in the process of price discovery, and I think it will go on for quite a while still. [00:59:13] And I also have a quote in there from from Ron Paul, which you just said verbatim like five minutes ago, that money is one half of every commercial transaction, and that's also important to understand, like what what money is and what money is for yeah, Bitcoin taught me what money is in a way. [00:59:33] Oh yeah, I didn't even realize it. I was basically paraphrasing this quote, but yeah, he says, Ron Paul says, you know, money is half of every commercial transaction, and therefore we're talking about an awesome power, one that flies under the cover of night. It's the power to weave illusions that appear real as long as they last, which is a very poetic and beautiful way to put it. [00:59:55] And we should also shout out who you also include in this in this lesson is Nick Zabo's brilliant article or blog post or whatever you want to call it, essay called Shelling Out the Origins of Money, which is a must-read for every bitcoiner. [01:00:13] Yeah, exactly. And that's also the what the next lesson is about. The lesson twelve is about the history and downfall of money. And yeah, highly recommend reading through Nick Salmo's blog, as every every everyone else in Bitcoin recommends as well. I think you can't go wrong there. He's he's a genius in my book, and yeah, yeah, all of his articles are great. [01:00:37] And I'm again as I said in the beginning, I try to build up somewhat of a library currently, and I'm just re-re-reading some pieces and trying to organize all the content. And yeah, it's just very fascinating to read through Nick Sava's articles. So again, shout out to Nick, he's doing great work. [01:00:58] And so yeah, lesson twelve. [01:01:03] Shelling out talks about it really nicely. It's it it asks the question how how did we yeah, how did we arrive at money in the first place? And Shelling out talks about the use of shells and other things that are rare, and that it's already interesting to think about it in a way. [01:01:23] That you know, people that lived in the mountain used seashells, and people that lived close to the sea where seashells are abundant, they used something else, like let's say mountain crystals or feathers from from a bird that are not nearby, and so on and so forth. [01:01:42] So it's it's really interesting how how all of that worked in the past. And I tried to answer the question, how did we get from coins made of gold and silver to paper money? And yeah, it's an exploration of the history of money and also an exploration of fiat money. [01:02:03] It's it's interesting to look at the history. Yeah, humans just arrived at the shelling point that gold and silver is best used to store value. And one of the first coins was actually made of a gold and silver mix, and that was like almost 3,000 years ago or so, and it's the Lydian electron coin, and it was just fascinating to read up on that and just learn about all what happened afterwards because people are smart, and if you know everyone's a scammer, yeah. [01:02:40] And people yeah, they started just clipping those coins, like if you if you have a coin made out of silver or gold, you can just clip away the edges, and that's a practice known as coin shaving, and that's why coins still have those ridges on the side, so that you can see if someone shaved it off. [01:03:01] And yeah, I stumbled upon quite a few interesting things. So, for example, the origin of the dollar is also in there, and I'm a native German speaker, so it was fun for me to read through that and how the Joachim Stala which is the a Tala is just someone who lives in the country and in the valley of Sankt Joachim they made the first silver coins and that's how thala evolved into dollar and that's where the name dollar comes from and the first paper money introduced was just [01:03:40] Certificates for the silver dollar and it says so on the on the notes on the certificates and just looking at these notes is yeah it's really fascinating how how all of that evolved and on the on the first silver dollar certificates it's it still says payable to the bearer on demand so it's a bare asset but you can just still go to the bank and get your actually valuable things like the silver coins and yeah we had them gold certificates and everything else and yeah also included there the abolishment of the gold standard in 71 and [01:04:18] Yeah in in a way it was just interesting for me to learn about all that and find out that you know it was a very very long slide of hand that yeah had its conclusion in 1971 you I and I'm not saying it was done on purpose from the get-go it was just like no we have we have all this paper money now and people use it and yeah what if we just did away with the base reality of gold, and yeah, we can do a lot of things with the new power of printing money. [01:04:53] And so yeah, in a way, Bitcoin taught me a lot about the history of money. And I also said like the as I said, the greatest slide of hand in the history of economics, which is fiat currency. Yeah. And I'm sure there are a lot of people out there that are like that may have heard that and are thinking to themselves, no man, it was totally on purpose, you know, it was totally planned out. [01:05:16] I'm sure I'm sure that there's like some kind of middle ground, but you know, like you said, people are smart, and you know, I'm sure I'm pretty confident that there was some forethought of you know, hey, the more control we can get over the money the better. So maybe let's start by doing this. [01:05:34] And it ended up, you know, you know, that was the Federal Reserve in the early 1900s, I think it was like 1913 or something, and it ended up just you know 60 years later, resulting in the suspension of the gold standard in the United States. So yeah, sure. And if you if you want to know, I mean a lot of things were done on purpose for sure, but I'm I my comment was more directed at I'm not sure if the basic idea of introducing certificates was already the first step that led us to the research. [01:06:09] And if you I mean it's after reading the creature from Chuck Hill Island, it's undeniable that there was a lot of cons conspiracy going on and that it was pre-meditated. And so yeah, I recommend this book as well if you're interested in the birth of the Federal Reserve. There's a the creator from Chach Hill Isle. [01:06:29] It's good. There's yeah, that's a great book. And there's also another one called The Tower of Basel, which is about the Bank for International Settlements, which is sort of the central bank of central banks in the in the world, and is another important institution to understand and is arguably as I think Safadine put it, the final boss of Bitcoin. [01:06:55] I haven't read the book yet, but I agree that it's the final boss. Yeah, I agree with Safe. And you also mentioned just wanna just wanted to give credit and you know maybe direct people toward this great great blog post. Sure. You said everyone's a scammer, which was an homage to or shout out to Michael Goldstein's essay of that name, Everyone's a Scammer, on the Nakamoto Institute website. [01:07:19] So yeah, check that out. It's a it's a good an an important read for Bitcoiners if you haven't read it yet. Yeah, it's a really good one. Okay, so next is th fractional re fractional reserve insanity. Yeah yeah, I already titled that one, because I think it's insane. [01:07:40] If you learn about that, it's it's really insane. And what was surprising to me is just that everything is hidden behind charging, you know. And the basics of it are really simple. And it's just made out to be really complicated. And once you fight through all that and you kinda understand what's what's really going on, it's just insane. [01:08:01] It's really insane that banks are allowed to do that and I mean no wonder that we have Pablo since the system is unstable in my opinion. And yeah, the I try to figure out how their fractional reserve system works or how fractional reserve banking works and yeah, that led me to the money multiplier effect and how how banks can actually turn your hundred dollar bill into a thousand dollars easily and yeah try to answer questions like why can't banks lend out money that they don't have and all of that and it's [01:08:39] I have a nice rant in there by Gotfree Bloom which I recommend everyone listens to he just goes on a rant that if someone else would do it it would be called counterfeiting and if banks do it it's called quantitative easing and so on and so forth and it's it's very entertaining and I of course agree with his viewpoint and just the idea that banks loan out your money and just keep a fraction is is insane to me in a way because I mean that's also the idea where the bank the idea of the bank round comes from if everyone would just try to pull out the money it it will pull away [01:09:17] The curtain and everyone would see that the emperor has no clothes so to speak and to bring it back to Bitcoin I think that's yeah what's so amazing about Bitcoin is that the final supply is fixed and it's so easily auditable by everyone right now. And it I mean there is now talk going on between Bitcoiners about would it be possible or like would it even make sense to have a fractional reserve on Bitcoin. [01:09:46] I don't think it would make sense but if it would happen then I think it wouldn't be that big of a threat because the base layer just cannot be inflated away and you can always just audit it for yourself and use everything like set up everything in a way that you have full control over everything you do. [01:10:08] And I think that's yeah, that's important and a nice insight. And so yeah, but then in conclusion, Bitcoin taught me that fractional reserve banking is pure insanity. Yeah, it I need to study fractional reserve banking more. I just I don't understand how it evolved to be a common practice because it does seem completely insane and like just an absolutely like uncontrolled way of almost un almost almost uncontrolled way of printing money. [01:10:37] And yeah, and I and I understand a little bit. I'm starting to kind of put together put it together a little bit, and I and I talked with this with JP on the last episode or two episodes ago, kind of about this idea and you know, there there are certainly some Austrians and I know Ansel Lindner, a friend of mine who does the Bitcoin and Markets podcast also has mentioned this before, like and JP is the same way as they're not fundamentally against the idea of fractional reserve banking, but they're against the idea of like, you know, doing it in a system that's completely not audib a way that's completely not auditable. [01:11:14] And so JP was talking about creating like some side chains where you could sort of fract do some fractional reserve banking stuff on the side chain with a to with a sidechain token, and then but have it like, you know, backed by Bitcoin and you can people who are sort of operating on that side chain economically always have a path out. [01:11:36] They can go back to real, you know, to one-to-one Bitcoin at any time. And I like I don't understand exactly how that would work. But yeah, but I mean th it seems like people who have a better understanding of like f you know, financial practices and that kind of thing do seem to think that it would be possible to kind of form something like that in the future on top of Bitcoin. [01:12:02] And so maybe it will happen. But like like we like it like you noted, it will be based on Bitcoin and ultimately auditable and you know transparent. So that's the fundamental difference. Yeah, let's let's see what happens. I'm I'm not convinced that fractional reserve banking will in the end have more Bitcoin, but we'll see. [01:12:24] Maybe on higher layers. But then again, I don't think it will be as problematic as the current system is. Alright. Final lesson in the economics chapter is sound money, which we've definitely spent some time talking about, but we can underline what makes the sound money here and why it's important. [01:12:46] Yeah, so yeah, what is sound money? So that that's that's basically one of the questions this tries to answer. And yeah, I mean Bitcoin is still very young and it's still very volatile, but it is sound money in my opinion, and I think also in safety's opinion, and everyone else who has like an Austrian maximalist viewpoint on Bitcoin. [01:13:11] And I dive quite deep into the idea of the stock to flow ratio, and I calculated the stock-to-flow ratio of Bitcoin into the future, and the interesting thing is that everything is predetermined because it's just algorithm algorithm the algorithm fixes it. [01:13:33] Like you know, the and I have Bitcoin supply from lane there as well, but it's important to point out that there is no formula behind that because it's it's not fixed by this formula, but it's fixed by consensus code. And again, I think it comes back to what I said previously. [01:13:54] It's really hard for people to understand exponentials, and thus it's also really hard for people to understand logarithmic functions. Our brain is just not made for it, you know. We can't make sense of ten exponential steps, but we can easily make sense of ten linear steps, and so we don't have any intuitive understanding. [01:14:12] And yeah, Bitcoin's money supply, as I said, is predetermined and asymptotically going to 21 millions and just realizing that and just projecting Bitcoin's hardness in a way, or that the how sound bitcoin will get into the future is is quite interesting. [01:14:36] And with the next Hellmanning, we will be pretty much on par with gold. And after that, since just the flow of Bitcoin it gets cut in half again, it will just skyrocket and it will be the hardest money ever created starting in early 2024. [01:14:56] And that's very interesting to think about it because because I think it will make headlines. Oh, sure. And I think the media will pick up on it, and I think it will shake up some gold bucks, and you know, suddenly gold isn't the best thing to store your wealth in anymore, in a way. And that's how I see it, at least. [01:15:16] And it's probably already the case that gold is not the best way to store your your wealth. Yeah, depending on depending on your your time preference, right? Like if you're but I think if you're thinking at least like a decade or more into the future in terms of s of storing your wealth at this point in time, yeah, Bitcoin makes a lot more sense to gold than gold to me. And you know, if Bitcoin hasn't eaten up gold's market cap by 2024, then there's literally no argument left, you know, because it's it's actually harder money at that point. [01:15:45] Yeah, yeah. And shout out to plan B on Twitter, like at 100 trillion USD. I'm not sure if I mixed up the name and the handle now, but he he wrote an excellent piece of looking at Bitcoin through the lens of the stock to flow ratio and calculating the value of Bitcoin through a stock to flow ratio model. [01:16:08] Highly recommend this article. It it extends this idea quite a bit. Yeah, it that model is very compelling and very interesting to study. And plan B was also on an episode recently of Stephan Livera's podcast, which was also really good. So check out his work and that episode. [01:16:30] Yeah. And so in conclusion, of this lesson, Bitcoin taught me that sound money is essential. And I also recommend the work done by Young Gudo Guzman. And he wrote the Ethics of Money Production and a highly recommended book as well. [01:16:51] And I also think the that's one aspect that's that's not highlighted enough is that no matter how hard you try to create more bitcoin more bitcoin, it will it will always fail. [01:17:09] And it's kind of like a universal money limit. That's that's how I thought of it. And is I also made the connection of you know relativity because we have in the physical universe a similar phenomenon where you no matter how much energy you try to expand to go faster like if you're in a rocket ship and you want to go faster and faster still yeah you will never reach the speed of light because yeah you will get heavier and it will just be an asymptotic curve and you will never reach light speed in actuality and it's similar in bitcoin mining no matter how much energy you expend [01:17:48] To try to mine more bitcoin thanks to the difficulty adjustment it will always be for nothing in a way you know it's I mean it's not for nothing but you won't be able to get more Bitcoin out of the earth so to speak and that's also something safe dean talks about a lot because if we would like to we could get more gold you know mining the oceans doing asteroid mining and so on and so forth. [01:18:10] And with Bitcoin it's just not possible. That's yeah quite something to think about. Yeah that's an I mean the difficulty adjustment is sort of a stroke of genius. And I think you get into that don't you in the in the next chapter, chapter three technology. Yeah so I couldn't remember if it was in if it was in here or if it's it was in your article about Bitcoin's gravity that you compare the difficulty adjustment to the Einstein Einstein's equation. [01:18:42] Yeah it's it's it's in I think it's in the last economic lesson in Summer Money, but I have the difficulty adjustment also also in the technology chapter because I think at least have it in the screenshot of the version one code of Bitcoin, something like that. [01:19:01] And yeah, the technology is the last chapter and the third part of this trilogy. And it's it starts out with looking at the strength in numbers. And as anyone in Bitcoin knows, there is this very syndromeris motto used by Bitcoiners and it it it pops up well almost everywhere if you look for it. [01:19:25] And it's Latin for strength in numbers. And so I start with that one because I think it's important to understand just how insanely big the numbers are that bitcoin security is based upon. And this lesson explores the question of like why why is Bitcoin secure in the first place? [01:19:47] And that's that's a complicated question. And there is some work on on Bitcoin security model and it's it's not it's like Bitcoin security is not just based in strength in numbers, it's way more complicated than that. And yeah, I recommend also checking out JW Eleman's Bitcoin's threat model. [01:20:08] That I think that's a nice place to just get an overview of how you could attack Bitcoin and how Bitcoin yeah deals with all those threats in a way. But big numbers are a big part of it. And I start out with just getting into the size of numbers and it's really hard to make sense of them. [01:20:28] Again, it's it's related to the idea again that the human brain it just isn't made to make sense of exponentials. And if you look at millions and billions in trillions, for example, I have the example of a billion seconds, million seconds and a trillion seconds. And a million seconds ago was one and a half weeks and a billion seconds was like 32 years ago, but a trillion seconds, which doesn't sound that much more, is you know, 21,000 years ago. [01:20:57] And it it gets big really quickly. That's that's 10 to the power of six, ten to the power of nine, ten to the power of twelve. So it doesn't it doesn't sound like much, but it gets big really quickly. And that's basically the idea. That's the idea of all of computational security, almost all of it. I mean there there are other other things like information theoretical security, but public key cryptography and other there's the stuff that Bitcoin is built on. [01:21:22] That's the root of that idea. And SHA 256 is just very, very strong. And Satoshi pointed that out as well. He had in one of his posts he compared it to MD5 and Shawnee, and he said it's it's not an incremental step from those two. It's you know, it's a huge exponential step, and he said that it can last several decades, and there might be some breakthrough. [01:21:45] And you know, people talk about quantum computation, for example. And yeah, I mean with quantum computers you can break some things, and there are some algorithms that could be used to break public key cryptography, but you know, we shouldn't focus too much about the future threats if we have real threats to deal with right now, and there are ways around it as well. [01:22:12] And yeah, I just explore how big how big the key space is and how big two to the power of 200 sixty-five is and just how hard it is to prove to brute force 200 65 bit key. [01:22:32] And I have a quote in there from Buschnaya, which I think is really interesting. It it loops back to the idea that Bitcoin is based in physics and thermodynamics. Because if you actually want to brute force Bitcoin private key, you would have to use something else than a computer, at least a computer that we know and understand currently. [01:22:54] And Bruce Schneider has Bruce Schneier has a nice quote. He says that these numbers have nothing to do with the technology of the devices, they are the maximums that thermodynamics will allow. And they strongly they strongly imply that brute force attacks are just infeasible until computers are built from something other than matter and occupy something other than space. [01:23:17] Because if you actually if you actually calculate what you would need to build to brute force a key this big, you know, you basically take a couple of suns, and you need to build the perfect computer chips, but the computer needs to be as as big as the solar system, and you need a couple of million suns to power it, and then you maybe have a chance, you know. [01:23:40] But it's just not so the number the number of possibilities which I think is this is probably for me at least the best way to try to understand or to make sense of it, is there's literally it's the number of possibilities are far larger than the number of atoms in the observable universe. [01:24:00] Which you know Yeah, by far, which is hard, you know. Like at least something that you could sort of like maybe get your our primitive human monkey brains around. That's insane. That's yeah, it's a big big number. Yeah, maybe, but then but then again, you know, it's it's so so so hard to make sense of all that because there are no no really useful mental exercises that will tell you how many univers how many atoms are in the universe or how many atoms are in anything really. [01:24:28] I mean there is for example, if you ask people, are there mere are there more glasses of water in all of the Earth's oceans, or are there more atoms in one glass of water? It's just mind-boggling to think about that there are more atoms in one glass of water than there are more glasses of water in all oceans combined. [01:24:50] And it just tells you how small atoms are. So yeah, for me it was just interesting to reflect on the fact that so much of our modern world is is built on the on trying to find a very very tiny needle in a really really large haystack. [01:25:08] And that's basically what a lot of cryptography is built up on. So yeah, Bitcoin taught me that there's strength in numbers. Strength in massive numbers, and that's why this whole system works. Alright. Lesson 16 and lesson two in the in the third chapter technology is titled Reflections on Don't Trust Verify. [01:25:31] Yeah, that's that's a play on one of Ken Thompson Ken Thompson's papers, and he wrote a paper which is called Reflections on Trusting Trust. And it looks at the an interesting trick you can play with computers and compilers. [01:25:50] So if you're if you're into programming or if you if you know anything about how how programs are made, you basically have have another special program which takes the more or less human readable form of a program and compiles it to something that machines can read and execute and that's that's called a compiler and can can Thompson show that there is a way to put a Trojan horse into a compiler that it's pretty that is pretty much undetectable so it's really hard to trust your compiler and by extension it's really hard to trust your computer and I think it's important to reflect on that because [01:26:28] In Bitcoin we have the motto of don't trust verify and of course I'm a fan of that and you should always verify if you can and you should never trust anyone and again everyone's a scammer so just don't trust people that's that's the most important thing but but again it's really hard to verify everything from scratch and it's kind of like a chicken and egg problem and the problem with bootstrapping software code and Bitcoin is really really good at that and a lot of smart people are working on solutions to that and there's Gideon for example which was developed by Bitcoin developers and there is also geeks [01:27:07] Which is G UIX which is another yeah another system which helps to fight this bootstrapping problem so the idea is that you always build everything from scratch in a way from from just you have two or three tiny things that you know you can trust and you build everything based upon of that that's the main idea and yeah, it's an interesting thing. [01:27:31] There are a lot of rabbit holes to go down there if you're into technology and programming and computers and so on. And there I also have a piece in there about stealthy hardware Troyans. So you can even attack computers at at the chip level and do some built-in Troyan horses in the chip level that you basically can't detect as of yet, or they're really really hard to detect, let's put it that way. [01:27:57] So yeah, again, Bitcoin taught me to trust but not to verify and yeah, trust is very tricky business again in Bitcoin. All right, the next chapter our next lesson is lesson seventeen, telling time takes work. This is a really interesting one to think about. [01:28:16] Yeah, that's a very interesting one. And that's I that's that's another one of my life bulb moments. So I think I had like three or four of those just for proof of work alone. So proof of work is something that's that's really hard to understand. And I was at a point where I was like, okay, now I get it. [01:28:37] Now I now I really understand what proof of work does and all the yeah, how to what it relates and why it's here and what problem it solves. And then I read this piece by sorry if I butcher the name, Grisha Trubetskoy. I hope I didn't fuck that up too much. It's pretty close. [01:28:55] But he wrote he he wrote a piece. He wrote a piece that's called Proof of Work is a decentralized clock. And that's an awesome read. So everyone should read that. And my my lesson of telling time takes work builds up on that piece. So yeah, if you look at the white paper, it's it mentions this quite explicitly. [01:29:17] So Satoshi, for example, says in the white paper that the network time stamps transactions. And that's already, you know, it's a it's a time-stamping server, so it's a decentralized clock in a way. And yeah, it's it's just interesting to think about proof of work in that way because you kind of need an authority that tells the time, even though it's imprecise and the proof of work clock is imprecise. [01:29:42] I mean, you have you know, like one second is approximately every 10 minutes, but it's not not precise, it's it's probabilistic, but it's good enough for it to work, and yeah, we have to lock time in a way that tells everyone what's going on currently in the system. [01:30:02] And yeah, it's it was really interesting to look at it on that way. And I also have another piece on proof of work which relates to Bitcoin's energy consumption, because that's also something that a lot of people have a hard time figuring out. [01:30:20] And my main takeaway of this lesson is that understanding proof of work just takes time, you know, and it's very counterintuitive. And I tried to write about that a bit. And yeah, in in this instance, Bitcoin taught me that telling time is is really tricky, especially if you're radically decentralized, like and I think in some of the like in the one of the earliest known draft of the Bitcoin code, Satoshi in in the comments referred to the what we call the blockchain as the time chain. [01:30:56] And yeah, it was a time stamping server in his mind. It was mostly like to keep track of time, yeah. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah, the time chain is to find one, and shout out to Udi Waldheimer, who had an awesome Twitch thread one night where he discovered that and he was so excited for the first time. [01:31:16] Because I was excited as well. I thought it was Francis Cooler, actually. Yeah, I think it was Francis. Ah, there was Francis. Oh yeah. Yeah, yeah. I highly highly possible. But there was a week or two where we had a bunch of things. I think Francis Francis had the original like thread. And I've I'm pretty sure he was like, you know, it was like he said he was at a bar and doing it on it and like tweeting all this stuff on his phone, and it it was just a hilarious thread. [01:31:41] And he was like, he was like tweeting in all cap all caps and getting super excited. And then Uti ch Udi changed his name to Uti Time Chamber time chainer or something like that. Yeah, exactly. Time chain. That's how I got it mixed up. That was fun. Understanding how time works in proof of work is is is interesting. [01:32:03] And yeah, it you can't have it's not again, it's not objective or absolute. It's kind of subjective because it's designed to work all over the world, and you know, time is like we you know we use time zones to try to get around the problem of relativity on on Earth, and you know you can't really do that in this massive global decentralized system, so you've got to sort of approximate the time and proof of work does a really good job of doing that. [01:32:31] Yeah. Yeah. So the next lesson 18. Move slowly and don't break things. This is a shout-out. Yeah, that's a play on the move fast and break things. Yeah, shout out Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook. Mark? [01:32:50] Yeah. [01:32:55] He's that working for sure. Yeah. It's it's just funny to see this ethos pop up, especially in the other projects, I think. And it's it's fun to reflect on or it's important to reflect on what is actually built with Bitcoin and it was for me also important to just realize that this is something different and it's you know it has to be done properly. [01:33:24] And it's yeah, Bitcoin is just different by design, you know. Move fast and break things is still how much of the tech world operates. And I in my recent jobs and I yeah, I worked in tech for quite a long time. It it was always the motto in a way, you know, it it doesn't matter too much, just iterate, iterate, move fast, break things, and yeah, we'll fix it later. [01:33:48] And with Bitcoin you just can't do that, and you have to do everything very deliberately and also just by nature slowly, because that's that again it it points back to Bitcoin res Bitcoin's resilience because it's so resistant to change because everyone has to you know you cannot force anyone to adopt a change, or you cannot force anyone to update their notes and yeah, I to loop back to what you're always saying on the podcast, you know, you want to help everyone to become a sovereign citizen of Bitcoin. [01:34:23] I think just the fact that this is a network of nodes and each node is run by sovereign individual in a way, it it's all plays together in this idea that you because of that you have to move slowly and don't break things because there's no central authority to force updates or anything like that. [01:34:44] And yeah, so Toshi alluded to that very early on when he said that the nature of Bitcoin is such that once version one was released, the core design was set in stone for the rest of its lifetime. And understanding that is really really important to understand Bitcoin, in my opinion, and understanding that fully immediately leads you to the properties of resilience and anti-fragility and also the interplay of Bitcoin's social layer and its technical layer. [01:35:14] So yeah, and since monetary systems are adversarial by nature, we kind of have to do it differently than the tech world does everything, in my opinion. And so yeah, Bitcoin taught me that moving slowly it's actually a feature and not a bug. And you know, there's like Ethereum, I think, sort of adapted or adopted this idea of move fast and break things. [01:35:37] I think Vitalik may have actually like said that like almost like word for word or whatever, that that's a that's you know, whereas Bitcoin is kind of old and archaic and slow and a dinosaur, Ethereum is this sort of new nimble you know alternative that's going to grow much faster because we don't have this, we're not we don't have this sort of like cyberpunk protocol developer mentality of like moving super slow and making sure that we don't have any breaking changes and testing everything like you know, just absolutely thoroughly and that kind of rigor. [01:36:12] And yeah, so there's there's a big difference between between Ethereum and Bitcoin in that way. And it makes, you know, if you think about it, when you're building a new like the basis of a new financial system, and you're talking about right, you know, what is right now, and a market cap's probably somewhere around like 150 billion or 130 billion. [01:36:30] I don't know exactly where it's at right now, but it's a lot of money, even right now. There's a lot of money stored on the system. And so yeah, you've got to take your time. So it's it's more akin to like engineering, you know, like spacecraft or something like that, than it is to building a website. Yeah, exactly. [01:36:49] Yeah, it's it's like nuclear reactor level grade engineering. And to look back to what you said, the different engineering mindsets, I think it's also worth pointing out that this is actually a very, very old idea. The Bible already has the parable of the wise and the foolish builder, and the wise builder builds his houses on on a rock, and the foolish builder you know builds it on quicksand basically. [01:37:18] And I would argue that move fast and breaks things is you know, like building on sand because it it won't last. And I think if you really want to build something that's still has a use in in from future generations and over the next decades or even hundreds of years, you have to build on the on really really solid foundations. [01:37:42] And I would argue that Bitcoin is the rock in that sense, it is the solid foundation, and I would also argue that one of the smartest people in engineering are working on getting that as right as we can. I was about to say exactly right, but I don't think that's possible. [01:38:00] But they're really careful about things, and it's also part of the value proposition of Bitcoin, you know, that it it doesn't change and it's immutable. The ledger is immutable, and that it's it's just solid and works. And I think that's really important. Absolutely to grasp. Yeah. All right, lesson 19. [01:38:18] Privacy is not dead. And this is you know, this one I love I love the title of this one. Yeah. And I've talked, I think about this on the podcast before, but there were, you know, there was a time like, well, before Bitcoin, you know, I had basically given up that we would be able to have privacy anymore, you know. [01:38:39] Anything that any data that was, you know, ever touched a c an internet enabled computer or was transferred over the web and stored on some remote server somewhere is ha you should you know should be considered not private. Like it's you know going to be publicly available at some point in the future. [01:38:59] There's databases of you know all kinds of like passwords and address, you know, physical addresses and you know, work histories and just all kinds of all kinds of data about our activity and our lives that are available on the dark web that have been scoured from hacked databases and put together. [01:39:18] And you know, it was pretty a pretty grim future that that I figured that we were all facing that involved this this kind of surveillance state that we had built, you know, the double edged sword, the sort of Damocles story, and each tech you know, all human technologies sort of have can cut both ways. [01:39:37] And the internet has unleashed incredible you know productivity and innovation and has been a great thing for humanity in so many ways, but it's also created the foundation of this you know surveillance state, basically, and enabled it. Yeah. [01:39:56] So again, I went through the same process as you did, and I still think that we're on the edge in a way, but Bitcoin gives me a lot of hope and just yeah, everyone who's really excited about Bitcoin shares certain values around privacy as well, usually. And I had similar thoughts, and I still sometimes have similar thoughts than you that we're heading straight to hell and towards a totalitarian future where everyone is surveilled. [01:40:25] And there are some people that argue that it won't be that big of a problem, you know, if like everyone's data is out in the open then you know everyone kinda is in the same boat and there there won't be any embarrassing things anymore to blackmail people or whatever. But I think I think that that gets it wrong, and I think privacy is insanely important and it's crucial, and that's also why why it's a human right. [01:40:50] And it's I think that privacy is also needed for in for you in order to think properly in a way because if you're always surveilled, you will self-censor yourself and you will not allow yourself to express thoughts freely. And I so again, same as you. [01:41:10] When I when I really fell deep into the Bitcoin rabbit hole and I saw that people manage to be completely private online in a way, or as private as you can be, let's put it that way. It gave me a lot of hope, and that's also why why I'm saying here that privacy is not bad. And I explore what Bitcoin can teach us in regards to privacy and just the fact that Satoshi was able to remain private, like he no still nobody knows who Satoshi is. [01:41:40] Even if some people say they're but I don't want to go into that. And yeah, it's still I mean it's by no means by no means easy to escape the surveillance state. But privacy is a life, and I experienced this myself, and I for example, Matt as well, Matt Odell, shout-out again. [01:42:04] He's a huge privacy advocate, and he's really good at protecting his privacy, and I try to be as well. I made a conscious decision like three or four years ago to remove my online footprint or reduce it at least as much as possible. And it's possible if you know what you're doing, and it already worked for me. [01:42:25] I'm I'm I plan to write about that as well because it's really funny now. Since I went dark, just all the advertisement doesn't work for me anymore, and now I get really weird advertisements, it's really funny. Like you know, the internet seems to think that I'm a I'm a 87-year-old lady or something, so it's that's me. [01:42:45] It really works, and privacy is not bad. And I didn't go into Bitcoin privacy too deeply, even though that's a topic I want to explore in the future because it's very important, and there are a lot of exciting things happening. I mean, we have Coinjoin now in Wasabi, and Whirlpool is just going online in Samurai wallet, and Schnora signatures are coming and so on and so forth. [01:43:08] So that's definitely worth exploring as well. And I plan to you know provide links in the future to dive down this rabbit hole more deeply. But in essence, this lesson is about that everyone should remember that privacy is a fundamental human right, and people should just yeah, they they should respect everyone else's right to privacy but they should also take action to protect their own privacy and it's it's essential for a healthy society in my opinion. [01:43:37] And yeah as long as people exercise and defend these rights the battle for privacy is far from over and yeah Bitcoin taught me that privacy is not that's nice to have that ray of hope and definitely one of the many many reasons that I have become a Bitcoiner is that it's given me this hope that you know we can regain some privacy from that surveillance state and still retain you know all the good aspects of the internet and the and what it brings to us so it's pretty awesome. [01:44:12] Alright we are getting close lesson 20 cypherpunks right yeah it's I didn't realize that this is yeah podcasts always take longer than you think talking through things it takes a lot longer than reading through them and everything but yeah we are we're getting up to like yeah I know it took me it took me a while to write it but I was just like ah 21 lessons we'll go through it easy. [01:44:40] Yeah right hour hour and 42 minutes later. So maybe tell everyone before I had go go like 2x on that one. Yeah most people do 2x on my episodes they're they're often pretty long. I think Matt O Dell and I went for about two hours and 15 minutes. That's the current longest episode. We're getting close we're getting close. [01:44:59] Okay I'll try to beat it. Alright so lesson 20 is cyberpunks write code. Yeah, I think that's also a very important lesson, especially for me, because yeah, I'm a developer, and it's really easy to just bitch about things and not write the code, you know. [01:45:19] And it's it's it's kind of ironic because the last couple of months I basically I wrote articles, but I intend to write code very very soon, and I already did a little bit, and I it's just my current circumstances made it kind of hard, and writing writing text was easier than writing code because I just I don't have internet all the time and just a very shitty laptop, so just typing typing text is easier for me. [01:45:43] And yeah, the cyberpunks write code, it explores the roots of the cypherpunk movement, and even Satoshi stood on the shoulders of giants, you know. I mean, again, he's he's a genius in my book, but it wouldn't be possible without the work that a lot of smart people make before him. [01:46:04] And I tried to explore what we can learn from that and what is the ethos of the cyberpunk movement. And it was really funny. I also saw in in human action Ludwig van Mises has a nice quote in there which relates to that in a way. I'll just read it right now. [01:46:24] He says that he who only wishes and hopes does not interfere actively with the course of events and with the shaping of his own. And I thought it's really funny to have that in in human action, which is not related to cypherpunks at all. But but it's yeah, I just found it worth pointing out that Bitcoin is a technology and it was really built. [01:46:49] And Satoshi is sat down and wrote the code, and he he went beyond his his wishes and hopes, and he actually implemented it. And he also mentioned that he kind of had to do that. Like one of his earlier posts is that he had to write the code before so that he could convince himself that he could solve every problem. [01:47:09] And he wrote the white paper actually after he brought the code. And that's a very cypherpunkian idea. And I think it's also important to point out that the idea of Bitcoin it has been around for a very long time. And in the Cypherpunk manifesto, Eric Hughes points out that the cypherpunks are dedicated to building an anonymous systems, and they are yeah, they're trying to build systems and defend the right to privacy with cryptography. [01:47:43] And he also talks about electronic money a lot in the cypherpunk manifesto. So if you haven't read it, just read it, it's it's really short, and it's insane to read through that. And now we live in a world where we have Bitcoin and just look back on the years before Bitcoin yeah, where this was written, where all of it was written, and just realized that yeah, cyberpunks write code, and Satoshi undoubtedly was a cypherpunk, and that's what what Bitcoin taught me as well that cypherpunks write code. [01:48:14] Yeah, cyberpunks are pretty badass, you know, like they are impressive group with who have basically you know formulated a plan, a goal, which you know is pretty well stated in in the manifesto, and have you know in a decentralized organic way, made it happen over the past few decades. [01:48:41] And yeah, you know, a lot of people don't realize that the Bitcoin you know was isn't the first cryptocurrency. Like there have been other cryptocurrencies that were attempted well before Bitcoin was released. Yeah. You know, but they and like Satoshi said, all had you know, some sort of father figure. They didn't they weren't immaculately conceived, they were all they all had a some some sort of central authority that for you know and the reason that they had the central authorities that basically the s the system couldn't be we didn't know a way to build it without a central authority, essentially, is all all the kind of iterations of cryptocurrencies [01:49:19] Or attempts before Bitcoin. And Satoshi found a way to decentralize the system and use this kind of new peer-to-peer networking technology that had been developed the decade before with Napster and BitTorrent and all that to make this happen in a decentralized way. [01:49:38] And that was what needed to happen in order to make it work. So it's amazing. All right. Lesson 21, we have arrived. Metaphors for Bitcoin's future. Yeah, so as it just said, you know, Bitcoin builds up on previous technology and especially peer-to-peer networks like BitTorrent and so on. [01:50:04] I think also if you if you really want to get deep into it, understanding BitTurrent and also its history is really, really important. And yeah, I'll I hope that I'll be done soon with my resources section and then I'll have some resources on on BitTorrent as well. There are some some great works on exploring the history of previous technologies like BitTorrent and also the internet and so on. [01:50:30] And so in the in the last lesson, I asked myself, where is everything heading and what what can we tell right now and what metaphors might be useful to explore Bitcoin's future or two to better understand where things are going. And yeah, also what can we learn from the past. And I stumbled upon a TED talk by Jeff Bezos in he gave it in 2003. [01:50:54] He used electricity as a meth metaphor for the web's future. And that was at a time where just the web as we know it now almost didn't exist in our school really early days. And it it it was interesting to look at that and just look at a visionary as we know now, Jeff Bezos was quite successful in his endeavor of building things on the web. [01:51:21] And yeah, I did it okay, I think. And I just looked at that and was like, yeah, using electricity and which is a previous network technology as a metaphor works really well. And I think everyone who lived through the internet and is into Bitcoin, you see so many parallels that you just can't ignore it. [01:51:42] And I try to look at the internet as a metaphor for Bitcoin's future. And you can see just by looking at the numbers and looking at the growth, that yeah, everything seems to be going exponentially again, and I think there are good reasons for that. And as as I see it, Bitcoin is an exponential technology built up on other exponential technologies. [01:52:10] And I think the network effects just multiply, and there are so many things that work together. And Trace Mayer talks about it really well. He explores the seven network effects of Bitcoin and I think it's speculation, merchant adoption, consumer adoption, security, developer mind share, financialization and adoption. [01:52:34] I think it's a it's adoption as a world reserve currency. And all of that kind of works together, you know, and we I think it's so fascinating to see that in real time. And I think there there might be even I mean those seven they they group it together really nicely, but just to pick out some examples, there are so many developments happening on layer two, for example, like Lightning Network is the development there is just crazy. [01:52:57] It's it's insane how fast everything's evolving. And also still our devices they get smaller, they get faster, they get m more memory and networks get faster and so on and so forth. We now have five G going online, we have phones that are powerful enough to run full nodes. We have so many developments in so so many directions, it's it's kinda insane to look at it from this perspective. [01:53:21] And we have you know, we have big institutions moving in, we have serious investors looking at Bitcoin from a monetary perspective. I think it's just a matter of time until big banks and also countries move in and so on and so forth, and all of that just works together to create those network effects. [01:53:40] And I don't think it's it's a stretch to say we can at least speculate where things are going. And I think the internet is a is a good yeah, point of reference in a way. Like the internet in in the early 90s, and to see how things develop from there is a good point of reference to speculate how Bitcoin will look in the future. [01:54:04] So yeah, that's that's what what this is about. And I really like the William Gibson quote which is the future is already here, it's just not even it's just not very evenly distributed. And I think that's true. If you're into Bitcoin, then it it's kind of insane what you can do already, and people are collaborating very easily all over the world, and you just can send money back and forth without even knowing the name or the face of anyone. [01:54:30] It's just you can even send lightning invoices around and you can pay for someone's meal or for someone's book or for someone's whatever he's shopping online without knowing anything about them. It's it's just like you know, hey, I really want to read this book, but I can't afford it. I already put in my shipping address and everything. Can someone please pay pay me this invoice? [01:54:49] And you'll just put post the invoice somewhere, someone is kind enough to pay it for you. That's it. That's if that's that's not the future. That's we're already living in this future, just nobody knows about it yet. And yeah, I think the future is just beginning. So that's that's about 8,000 people on the Lightning Network that can participate, you know, they could pay that that invoice right now. [01:55:08] At least eight at least 8,000 nodes anyway. And yeah, so that's it's very early. It's exciting to be part of Bitcoin at this point in its evolution. You know, I grew up, I went to high school, I graduated from high school in 97, so in the mid-90s, when the inner very early days of the internet, I was I was in high school, and you know, even before like before we even got like dial up accounts for AOL or whatever, a copy serve, I was running BBS software, which was like direct dial. [01:55:42] So I my friend would have a modem on his computer, he'd direct dial and over to my computer and the software would serve up you know some ASCII text on a screen and we'd play games and share files and stuff like that. So you know I it was fun to be right, it was so fun. It was fun to be a part of that you know early evolution of the internet and then to see it happening again now with Bitcoin and being a part of it is truly just you know it's it's kind of a it's kind of like reliving that really formative part of my kind of childhood years on the early internet days and it's it's just a lot of fun. [01:56:17] Yeah, it it is for me as well. I think we're about the same age, and it's it's really funny to see it again. The only the only difference I would like to find out is that I think everything is happening way faster now. And in the in the in the last lesson I have a screenshot of the internet or like I compare the topology of the internet from 1982 versus 2005. [01:56:45] And that's that's just that's quite a long time span. And as a comparison, I have it looks very similar, but it's the lightning network and it's January versus December. Yeah. Everything's moving so quickly. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, sorry, 2018. [01:57:05] And it's just insane to you know to think about that. And as as everyone who is into Bitcoin knows, just trying to keep up with the developments is a full-time job. And I don't think it's possible. Like I try and I yeah, I just try to keep up 24-7, and it's so so hard to do. [01:57:28] So I can't even wait to see how how where we will be in like two, three, four, five years' time. Oh, okay. You popped back in. Welcome back. Ah, sorry. I was just I was just saying it I can't wait to see where we are going in two or three or four or five years in Bitcoin because everything is just happening so fast. [01:57:52] Oh yeah, it's it's going to be an amazing the next decade's going to be mind-boggling. And you're right, it it is happening way faster than the internet happened because it's built on top of the internet. The internet's already there, so the infrastructure for the internet for the for Bitcoin to you know spread very quickly is is there and so it makes sense that it would happen a lot more quickly. [01:58:12] Yeah, and so it's it's going to be an incredible decade to be a part of Bitcoin and watch it spread and grow and help teach new users and about what's going on here and bring them into Bitcoin. Yeah, it's gonna be exciting for sure. [01:58:35] All right, well that was 21 lessons of Bitcoin in philosophy, economics, technology. Gigi, you've put together a really nice kind of like second tier, like like 201 level sort of course, an overview, a syllabus to go through. [01:58:54] There's tons of material. I think it probably took me about you know, a couple hours to read through everything. But there's probably you know another 20 or 30 hours of content to that links off from it that you cite. So I think it's a really great place to kind of level up if you've you know recently joined, fallen down that rabbit hole and have some kind of the cursory beginnings going. [01:59:19] This is a great place to start leveling up and becoming you know full-fledged sovereign citizen of Bitcoin. [01:59:31] Yeah, nicely put and again thanks for having me. And I as I mentioned in in the introduction of the 21 lessons, I plan to go even deeper down the rabbit hole in the next couple of months. So I hope to expand on on some of the lessons in the future. [01:59:49] And I just I just hope that it's a nice place for people to yeah jump jump into it, as you said, if you know a little bit about Bitcoin and just want to go a little bit deeper. And if if anyone finds any mistakes or has any suggestions, just hit me up on Twitter or contact me wherever I'm quite easy to reach. [02:00:10] And all of it is also on GitHub. So if you if you know your way around there, you can just create a pull request or create an issue. And yeah, that's basically it. So I hope to expand on that. And who knows, who knows what will come of it. I'm thinking about maybe even expanding on the philosophical ideas and maybe even writing a book about that, but I have no experience in that. [02:00:32] So if if anyone can help me with that, I'll I'd be I'd be happy to hear from you. So if you if you know anything about writing a book, either self-publishing or or if you are an editor or something, I'll be happy to hear from you. How can people best get in touch with you? Twitter? Probably. Yeah, Twitter is best. [02:00:50] Twitter is best and everything follows from there. So I'm there G GG on Twitter, D E R G I G I. And I have my own websites and my conduct contact information is there. It's just my Twitter handle.com. Alright. Awesome. Thanks, man. This was wonderful. It was really nice to get to speak with you. [02:01:09] And it's been nice to get to know you over Twitter and Discord through Satoshi's treasure a little bit, which has been fun to play. You know, I'm just I think what the work you're doing is is is great. So thanks for spending some time with me today, and take care. Thanks for having me. Take care, everybody. [02:01:27] Alright, bye-bye. Alright, that was a really fun one for me. I hope you all enjoyed it as well. Gigi and I went for almost the record length in Citizen Bitcoin history. [02:01:45] Mato Dell at two hours and fifteen minutes still holds that honor, but Gigi and I didn't have LaFroy to fuel us on this particular episode, so I think we did pretty well. You should follow Gigi on Twitter at DerG at D E R G I G I. I'm at citizenbitcoin. And one last ask to log into iTunes and rate and review the Citizen Bitcoin pod if you found it to be valuable to your rabbit hole journey. [02:02:12] If you're listening now, you probably have. You made it through the whole episode. That's awesome. Take a couple minutes and rate and review the pod. It'll really help us out. Alright, that's it. Until next time. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.