WEBVTT

1
00:00:18.960 --> 00:00:37.840
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. I've got a great one with longtime Bitcoiner Kiara Bickers.

2
00:00:37.840 --> 00:00:51.840
She's also author of a great new addition to the canon of Bitcoin literature, Bitcoin Clarity. Before we dive into the conversation with Kiara, let's check in with GiveBitcoin, who are helping to bring this episode to your ears.

3
00:00:52.180 --> 00:00:55.140
GiveBitcoin has had a great start to its public beta.

4
00:00:55.520 --> 00:01:18.160
Goals for both the number of GIFs and the total amount given were both broken in the holiday season. Founder and CEO Cory Klippsten is building a great team. He's brought on Yan Pritzker as co-founder and CTO. Jan is the author of Inventing Bitcoin and has a lot of experience heading up technology at great startups.

5
00:01:18.160 --> 00:01:39.200
Jan will be joining me next week, in fact on the pod. I'm looking forward to that. And I've been shown some of the exciting progress they've made on the Save Bitcoin app. It's a super simple Bitcoin savings account. You just connect your checking account, set up your automatic fiat to Bitcoin conversions, and you just forget about it. You let the sats stack up, go about your life.

6
00:01:39.440 --> 00:01:45.040
Save Bitcoin is slated to drop toward the end of Q1. I personally can't wait to get it set up. I know I'll

7
00:01:45.240 --> 00:02:06.680
Always have the urge to market buy from time to time, but knowing I've got Save Bitcoin auto-stacking for me, will let me rest easy. Alright, a couple more quick shout-outs today before we dive in. First, my merch partner Nick Ward and Layer One BTC. Nick's put together a fun collection of Citizen Bitcoin merch, including the new Unfuck the Money shirt.

8
00:02:06.680 --> 00:02:25.000
It's a fun and biting critique of this default Keynesian age while still being relatively OPSEC friendly. No mention of Bitcoin on the design. Check out the collection at layer1BTC.com. In the menu, click partners, and then Citizen Bitcoin. Layer one is a great Bitcoin-only business, and sales do support the pod.

9
00:02:25.000 --> 00:02:48.120
And a big thank you to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including the Citizen Bitcoin pod in the LTBN family of great Bitcoin podcasts. If you're listening from the LTBN feed, welcome. I hope to be part of your Bitcoin journey going forward. If you like what you hear, you can find the growing archive of great shows on the web at CitizenBitcoin.world.

10
00:02:48.360 --> 00:03:10.680
Also follow the LTBN on Bitcoin Twitter at the LTB Network. Be sure to subscribe to the LTBN feed for more great Bitcoin content, all in one convenient place. Alright, let's go.

11
00:03:10.760 --> 00:03:18.480
Kiara Bickers is a long-time Bitcoiner. She's one of those Bitcoiners who discovered Austrian economics before she discovered Bitcoin.

12
00:03:19.000 --> 00:03:41.400
She found Austrian economics through listening to Mises Institute podcasts on commutes. She was an intern at Blockstream and has been there ever since. These days, she's working as a systems administrator. She also recently published Bitcoin Clarity, a great overview of Bitcoin as a system. It's full of useful diagrams and illustrations that help visualize the system.

13
00:03:41.400 --> 00:04:00.080
For the first half of the episode, we discuss the Bitcoin system and the book. You'll hear that we run into the problem of describing some of these aspects of the system in words, eventually admitting that the diagrams and visualizations are better. So definitely encourage you to add Bitcoin clarity to your Bitcoin book collection so you can see all these visualizations.

14
00:04:00.460 --> 00:04:07.960
And in the second half of the episode, Kiara and I, we just rap about Bitcoin like you do. It was a lot of fun. Hope you enjoy it too. Here we go.

15
00:04:15.380 --> 00:04:20.760
All right, I'm excited to welcome Kiara Bickers, author of the new book, Bitcoin Clarity, to the show.

16
00:04:20.960 --> 00:04:44.000
How's it going, Kiara? Hey, it's going good. Thanks for having me on your show. Yeah, absolutely. I'm excited for the conversation. I've been through your book. It's really well written. I think it's a good addition to the gl the growing library of Bitcoin books out there. It's different than everything else, kind of stands apart as a really great introduction to how Bitcoin works as a system.

17
00:04:44.000 --> 00:05:02.400
And it's, you know, easy to read. Lots of great illustrations and diagrams to really help visualize the system. So congratulations on the publication. Hey, thank you so much. Like for the year that I was writing it, I was really, you know, thinking to myself how great it was, but it's better to hear from other people. Yeah, it is. It's really good.

18
00:05:02.400 --> 00:05:20.480
You were right about that. Let's so let's start since I think this is is this her your first Bitcoin podcast? I just did one with Bitcoin magazine, and then I used to do Bitcoin podcasts like back in the day, like years ago. Right, right. Okay. Well, first of all, doing Bitcoin podcasts. Right, right.

19
00:05:20.480 --> 00:05:39.400
Okay. Well, it's first time in a while, so let's get your story. How'd you discover Bitcoin? And can you kind of guide us along your rabbit hole journey when you fell in up to writing and publishing Bitcoin clarity? Sure, yeah. So I think I really got brought on by the Ron Paul movement. I understood economics.

20
00:05:39.400 --> 00:06:05.080
I was listening to the Mises Institute podcasts like every day on my way to work. I used to work at Stan at Stanford as a caterer, just like out of high school, and I would drive back and forth, and it was an hour each way. So I would listen to all these economics podcasts, and then I heard about Bitcoin, and I felt that I was sort of ripe for for falling into the rabbit hole at that point because I was young, I had a lot of time on my hands, I understood the value of a different type of money, as it were, right?

21
00:06:05.080 --> 00:06:27.960
And so when was this? This project was 2012, so it was around that time. But like around in the early days of Bitcoin, it was more of like a builder community rather than I don't know, what would you call it? It was a much smaller community, and everyone was interested in building things, right? So when I wanted to learn about Bitcoin, I was asking my friends who went to University of Dallas.

22
00:06:27.960 --> 00:06:52.040
I was like, well, what should I do to learn more about Bitcoin? And obviously they all told told me I should learn how to code. So I learned a little bit of C. I don't know if anyone truly ever learned C, but I attempted and branched out, started doing some development stuff. I did a couple hackathons, one like a Coinbase hackathon, and ultimately I was just ranting about Bitcoin to anyone who would listen for a couple of years.

23
00:06:52.040 --> 00:07:12.720
Yeah, and then I realized there was all this stuff that I didn't know. You know, it was like I didn't know about PGP because I was young and I heard about crypto, and it was so weird to older people in this space because they were like, How have you never heard about PGP, but you heard about Bitcoin? I think it was a little surreal for people in the industry that crypto is getting bigger than cryptography as a whole.

24
00:07:12.720 --> 00:07:32.640
Right. Yeah, so it was really weird for them. And I ended up, I brought like one of the original books by PGP to a Bitcoin event, and I was like waving it in the air, like talking about something. I was, I just rant quite quite often. So I was ranting. And then eventually a guy at the event decided that he should hire me. So then I started working for him as an intern at Blockstream.

25
00:07:32.640 --> 00:07:54.480
Nice. Yeah, and I still worked there. So I started off as an intern and then moved over into system administration. So yeah, it's very much like just been doing Bitcoin stuff for a number of years. Less COVID. Taking advantage of that opportunity. What's that? I said you really took advantage of that opportunity at Blockstream, which is a great place to land in Bitcoin.

26
00:07:54.480 --> 00:08:11.280
Yeah, I mean, it was like a long time. I mean, I've been working there for four years now. So it was a different company four years ago for sure. And the industry was different as well, right? There was only one Bitcoin. There was like no real altcoins that were super popular to speak of.

27
00:08:13.840 --> 00:08:32.080
Yeah, so at the beginning of the book, you talk about finding signal in the noise. So how did you go about finding signal and how successful were you at doing so? Yeah, well, I guess one of the things I learned at Blockstream, because I did have other job offers, right? Is like I was I was on the market and I was hot.

28
00:08:32.080 --> 00:08:53.680
I was like, I need to get a job in this Bitcoin space because I was so into it. And I was pretty much self taught. So I was sort of, you know, going uphill and trying to get a job. But I noticed that when I started working at Blockstream, there was a whole bunch of stuff that I did not know and I would have never learned if I didn't work there. Mostly just around how developers think.

29
00:08:53.680 --> 00:09:14.440
It was never like formal stuff that was like required by the job, but just like when I would go out to lunches with some of the core devs, I would be like, oh, I have never thought like this before. And it was like the just the way they think about systems or, you know, talk, I worked under the chief security officer for a while and the way he would think about adversarial thinking, and there were all these mental models that I was starting to build up.

30
00:09:14.440 --> 00:09:34.120
And I would just like randomly like write them down on occasion. And then eventually I just had so many of these and then the ecosystem was growing at the same time that I was, right? So I was looking at the ecosystem, not understanding a lot about Bitcoin. I think I did mention that you know I came into Bitcoin with this sort of libertarian view viewpoint.

31
00:09:34.120 --> 00:09:53.080
And that is not the only way to look at Bitcoin, but it's one of the most popular ways. Now the problem with that is if you only look at things from a libertarian standpoint, you're missing a lot of the technical understanding that's required for making tough decisions about cryptocurrency, right? So I think the block size debate was a really good example of that.

32
00:09:53.720 --> 00:10:15.320
But I won't get into it too much here. We'll just kind of keep it high level because I get into it in the book quite enough. Yeah, yeah. And we can talk a bit about it. I have some notes about it here. But yeah, we can kind of skim across it. And I want to use this interview to kind of go through your book because I think it'd be good to have an audio version, kind of condensed audio version of you explaining some of these concepts.

33
00:10:15.320 --> 00:10:39.160
And I think you know the there's value in on in looking at Bitcoin as a system, which I think is why you wrote the book. And like you said, people or Bitcoiners tend to approach it as sort of from this libertarian or like kind of as a monetary approach. And we've talked a lot on the podcast about how Bitcoin is you know important as a as a monetary revolution and how that might impact the world.

34
00:10:39.160 --> 00:10:57.760
But it, you know, less often we talk about the system and how it works. And so I think this will be a really valuable interview for all the listeners out there and especially for you know Bitcoin people who are new to Bitcoin. So the Bitcoiners kind of share this with family and friends who are you know just starting to get introduced to Bitcoin and how it works.

35
00:10:57.760 --> 00:11:19.200
So yeah I mean you mentioned the idea of a rabbit hole right and what I wanted to do with the book is I wanted to create a place where people could learn about Bitcoin and actually not have to go into the rabbit. You know like I spent me wanting to learn about Bitcoin resulted in learning how to code for like two years and then coming back to the Bitcoin source code and being like I still don't really understand this.

36
00:11:19.840 --> 00:11:50.160
So like there are first two years I guess and it was just like that over and over and over again right it's like people would be like oh you should learn economics and then you'd like learn all this stuff and then you'd look at Bitcoin and you're like yeah I still don't really understand how it works. So the goal and why I phrase it Bitcoin as a system is because I think using mental models and real world examples, you know, analogies, metaphors, all this stuff, it can really help to get as close to understanding the protocol as possible without having to learn the code and read the code itself.

37
00:11:50.160 --> 00:12:11.760
Sure. Yeah that makes good sense and I think we accompany you've accomplished that well here. One of the first metaphors you use in the book is Bitcoin as a clock and Satoshi refers in a single instance in a comment in the code base the original code base as a time chain and we now call that a blockchain you refer to it as a time chain.

38
00:12:11.760 --> 00:12:34.440
So how does the system maintain its kind of regular roughly 10 minute block intervals, and why is this important to the system? Yeah, I mean, so it's sort of hard to do it just over auditory, right? So the book is super illustrated. But what the goal is of explaining the time chain from my perspective is I want people to understand why the blockchain is trustless, right?

39
00:12:34.440 --> 00:12:52.680
Like why do we want trustlessness and then how do we achieve trustlessness on the blockchain? There's a lot of different ways that I could go with this, like, oh, it's not perfectly decentralized or it's not perfectly trustless. But really the idea of the time chain is that the blockchain doesn't trust a third party sense of time.

40
00:12:52.680 --> 00:13:18.760
So, what the blockchain, if we just look at the blockchain as simply as possible and not call it a blockchain because what does that even mean? We could just call it a ledger, right? What is a ledger need? A ledger needs time to timestamp payments, and it needs more importantly than timestamps, it needs to put transactions in a particular order. Right. So if you make a payment to me and then you make a payment to someone else, we need to be sure that you actually have the money in order to make that second payment and you're not like spending more money than you have.

41
00:13:18.760 --> 00:13:44.600
So the transaction to me needs to come before your secondary transaction. But in a decentralized system, that becomes really hard to do because there's no centralized server to tell when timing actually occurred. So what I do in the book is I explain like how the blockchain regulates time using hash power and you know, keeps the blocks coming at exactly 10-minute intervals, and then how it uses the difficulty level to readjust.

42
00:13:44.600 --> 00:14:04.840
I think visually is a much better way to explain it because it's it can overwhelm people to just sort of get into the words of it. Yeah, that makes sense. Yeah, and I, you know, definitely recommend people picking up a copy of the book and going through because like I said, there's a lot of great illustrations and diagrams of how this all works and makes it really simple and easy to kind of understand.

43
00:14:04.840 --> 00:14:25.200
You can even just kind of skim through the book and read the kind of poll quotes that you've pulled out and highlighted and look at the diagrams in you know, 45 minutes and get a really good sense of what's going on and then kind of dive back into parts that you want to learn more about. Yeah, I mean, I even turned the whole thing into like video content as well, just because some people do better with that than reading.

44
00:14:25.200 --> 00:14:44.400
But I think the reason why I started the chapter on the time chain first is because like the way that I look at Bitcoin is that there's all these, you know, analogies in Bitcoin already, right? Like we have keys, gosh, what's another one? Wallets, addresses. And, you know, people come into Bitcoin, especially like if you think of someone who's maybe older, right?

45
00:14:44.400 --> 00:15:03.760
You have this assumption about what a key is and what a wallet is. You think of them as the ones you already have. And those analogies don't always map to what it is at a technical level. And the same thing goes with blockchain, right? Like, what is a blockchain even mean? Like, why do you have blocks and why do you have a chain are the fundamental questions that I'm trying to get people to understand early on.

46
00:15:03.760 --> 00:15:26.480
And framing it as a time chain, as you mentioned, Satoshi called it a time chain in a comment of the original source code. It makes a lot more sense than blockchain to me, but blockchain is sort of what took off. Yeah. Yeah, just putting all those mental models up front and then getting into the weeds as as we go. But yeah, that's that's sort of the first one that I think reframes the way people think about the blockchain.

47
00:15:26.480 --> 00:15:45.680
Yeah, and it's really interesting to think about, you know, like you mentioned, why that's important to achieve some kind of like decentralized clock. You've got to have the order of the transactions and you cannot have what we kind of what we sometimes refer to as an Oracle or a third party to get to put data into the system.

48
00:15:45.680 --> 00:16:08.040
And I think it's pretty brilliant that so s Satoshi realized that. Like you, this needs to be a self-contained system and without relying on any third party to input like what time it is into the system because that, you know, just gets rid of the idea of trustlessness. Right. And that goes back into like how some of these developers think is that you're juggling so many different variables.

49
00:16:08.360 --> 00:16:27.960
It's just sort of amazing that you could put all of that together and figure it out. I mean even something like the difficulty readjustment being two weeks or approximately every two weeks depending on the input of hash power like all this stuff it seems like just like magic numbers. And like I've heard programmers and stuff say like oh they looked at Bitcoin and thought it was junk when they first looked at it because it's just so weird.

50
00:16:27.960 --> 00:16:54.360
And then like over time you realize how elegant it actually is yeah it's it is really elegant and it it is amazing that Satoshi spent you know and he comments or like wrote in some forum posts about how he spent you know a year or two just working out all of the details of the system and you know putting it down into sort of a spec and then writing it out in code and testing everything out.

51
00:16:54.360 --> 00:17:28.280
And I remember like one of the comments was you know I had to spend time to work out all of the details of the system to make sure they worked and I know that it was you know many times it's been you know sort of pried into an attempted to be hacked by some of the world's greatest hackers and adversarial thinkers and time and time again they would you know people would come up with sort of a way to potentially potentially you know hack the system and they would just you know find a spot in the code where it's like nope you can't do this.

52
00:17:28.280 --> 00:17:48.720
Nope I thought you know I thought about this, and here's the fix for it. And it was just all like almost every single potential hack for the system was thought about ahead of time, and it that's pretty incredible. Yeah, I mean, the amount of foresight that requires is just absolutely insane. Absolute genius, yeah.

53
00:17:48.720 --> 00:18:09.840
So you move on to after you go through a few metaphors of the system, kind of high-level metaphors, you move on to talking about the history of accounting. And one thing I think many Bitcoiners don't really even know about yet or haven't thought much about the history of accounting and the fundamental accounting innovation that Bitcoin represents.

54
00:18:09.840 --> 00:18:33.040
So, can you talk about the evolution of accounting, single double entry accounting, and now with Bitcoin, what we sometimes call triple entry accounting? Yeah, so my motivation for doing this when I was thinking of like individual people that I would want to explain Bitcoin to. I have a couple non-technical friends who are accountants, and I was like, well, they should really be able to understand Bitcoin because it's a ledger, you know.

55
00:18:33.040 --> 00:18:55.760
And how could I bring this and make it accessible for them? Right. And the way that I went about doing that was sort of going backwards in time and thinking about the evolution of accounting as a whole. So that's something that I do throughout the book, is like looking at the evolution of full nodes, looking at the evolution of mining and like just looking at how things have changed from the beginning because Bitcoin's been around for a while now, and accounting has been around for much longer than Bitcoin.

56
00:18:55.760 --> 00:19:14.880
And one of the things that I realized was really interesting going from single entry to double entry. Excuse me, one second. Is that with single entry accounting, you sort of have like this mess of different, like different entries. And it's kind of hard to explain single entry accounting because it really wasn't a system.

57
00:19:14.880 --> 00:19:39.800
It was just like write it down, right? It's like, okay, if you're receiving some like box of goods, you receive you timestamp it, you say what it is and when you like when you got it, and that is so messy. Like multiple, like one entity, one person would probably maintain multiple books. And it was really easy to become fraudulent in that environment because there was no way, like you could easily write things on a list or write things off of a list.

58
00:19:39.800 --> 00:19:59.240
There was no internal method of validation. So without getting into all of double entry accounting, because I think that's probably even more complicated, it was one of the first systems that was able to create a balancing system. So it's like if something comes in on one side, it has to go out on the other side. If something comes in the company, something has to go out.

59
00:19:59.240 --> 00:20:26.440
So it's like if you have, if you want to buy something as a company, you have to use cash to do it. So you write that you spent cash and what you got for that cash. And there's a balancing effect that happens there. So this was the first time that there were other competing methods of accounting that didn't really win out because they were probably more complicated and they didn't happen in huge huge trade areas, like this the double entry accounting sort of happened in Italy where all the trade was booming at the time.

60
00:20:26.440 --> 00:20:45.560
So that's what won out in the end. But the idea was accounting needed a system of internal validation. And it was what was really interesting to me going back and studying this stuff for the book was you know, like there's sort of these innate human laws that we were all acting out in behavior before we articulated it.

61
00:20:45.560 --> 00:21:05.480
And that's kind of what I get at in the book is like the idea that you know a company has to pay back its debts, right? And account a debt was probably the origin of how we even came up with accounting and money as a whole, is that we understood there's sort of this reprocity, reciprocity that has to go back and forth, and we needed a way to track that. And yeah, there's just a whole bunch of ethics involved.

62
00:21:05.480 --> 00:21:25.520
And I there's a guy who I focus on in the book who sort of popularized the double entry accounting method, and you know, going from that to triple entry is really the same thing. So it's like if you understand how double entry accounting was why it was popular, if you understand that it it included a method for internal validation.

63
00:21:25.520 --> 00:22:03.920
So it meant that it was much harder to make fraudulent entries then you can say okay well the blockchain is an isn't isn't as a next step it makes perfect sense because now all you're doing is you're linking the whole history together. So it's like when we talk about the blockchain, most people even just sort of who have only been looking at this for a little while one of the first things they'll hear is like if you were to let's say change one of the addresses or change one of the transactions from a previous block all of the subsequent hashes would change as well right dramatically so you have this immutable record going back for all of the transactions in the economy

64
00:22:04.080 --> 00:22:39.520
Not just you know for one company. So to me it makes it a natural extension and like it I guess it's sort of a black swan event. Yeah you talk you talk about how the that that guy I think he's an Italian guy in like the 16th century. Yeah. Yeah you talk about how double the like that kind of invention of double entry accounting in the way that it provides this internal check on on the balance of the equation so it's harder to you know to make I guess to be fraudulent about the ledger itself.

65
00:22:39.520 --> 00:22:59.640
You talk about how that was like a translation of values into mathematics and I really like that idea, and I think it was accomplished here as well. Like, what are the values that Satoshi's invention instills in the system, like using math exactly that weren't that weren't caught by like double entry accounting?

66
00:22:59.960 --> 00:23:21.080
Yeah, well, so like in in double entry accounting, like I went back and just nerded out and read all of his earlier documentation, Patoli is the guy, right? And the book that he wrote this in was actually a mathematics book. It was it was probably like a textbook for students about math, but for some reason one chapter was about accounting, and that was the chapter that is really famous today.

67
00:23:21.080 --> 00:23:52.200
And in that book, it's just like I mean, we would probably call it sort of like I guess mystical in a way, like or sort of ritualistic. Like the guy has rules for how you should write the cross on your accounting textbooks. Like he like he really believed that this was a this was like a morally righteous thing to do was to be a proper accountant, and to fake your numbers or to fudge your numbers or to cook the books in any way was you know to not be in line with God as he that's how he believed it.

68
00:23:52.200 --> 00:24:12.040
And I just found it so fascinating because although we don't say that anymore, you know, we definitely believe, and you can see it in the ethos of Bitcoiners, that they believe that Bitcoin is the sort of ethically superior thing, and Satoshi made a very good case for that. I mean, he wrapped it in this beautiful story of the collapse of the financial industry, right?

69
00:24:12.040 --> 00:24:39.640
So, as all these governments are getting more and more corrupt and printing money uncontrollably, interest rates are you know as low as they're ever gonna get, it seems it's like how much lower can you possibly lower interest rates? They have no more moves on the chessboard, so they just keep printing and printing money. And he saw this as an ethical issue, it just so obviously. So to cap Bitcoin 21 million really got all those libertarians as the first customers to Bitcoin without sort of bringing religiosity into it.

70
00:24:39.720 --> 00:25:05.600
Yeah, we've talked a lot on the podcast about Bitcoin as a secular religion because there's so much, like you said, there's just this moral aspect to it. It's there's a Bitcoiners believe there's this ethos that the that Bitcoin is a moral imperative, right? It's going to improve the morality of our economy and global commerce and the follow-on effects of that are make make this a moral imperative, right?

71
00:25:05.600 --> 00:25:29.520
And so there's this sort of aspects to the way like religious ideas spread and these memes kind of spread around and morals spread around that are encased in memes. And the way Bitcoin is spreading is like pretty similar to that, you know. No, I would totally agree. I mean, the only thing that I would say is that I don't necessarily I'm not fully convinced that you know anyone is like I let me phrase it a different way.

72
00:25:29.520 --> 00:25:47.840
I'm super I'm very suspicious of people who think that they're really good people. And I think that there's probably a lurking danger in in thinking you're a good person just because you buy Bitcoin. You know, it it it opens up the door for people to pose as really ethical people because they're, you know, Bitcoin fanatics or whatever.

73
00:25:47.840 --> 00:26:09.760
So I don't I don't necessarily think that's a good thing, but nevertheless it's something that's happening. Yeah, righteousness is is a dangerous belief, I guess you could say. And so I think you know, Matt Odell always includes stay humble in his memes or in in his most meme, it's stay humble stack sets. So I think that's important. Don't be righteous about this, but I do see this as as an improvement.

74
00:26:09.760 --> 00:26:34.440
Like you said, like we've translated values into mathematics and the way the way that Bitcoin is written, the mathematics of it in case include you know, prob values that are more beneficial to humanity than the you know, the values of the current system. I guess. I mean, at the very least, I would say that you know, at the time that Bitcoin was created, Bitcoin needed to be created.

75
00:26:34.600 --> 00:26:53.080
Like Bitcoin it was born in an environment where all the currencies were you know inflating, right? And then the all the banks were bailing themselves out with money they had created. It was just super like there there was no doubt that that was an unethical thing to do in my mind. Does that mean that Bitcoin will always be the most ethical choice?

76
00:26:53.080 --> 00:27:16.600
Maybe not. You know, I don't it's it's something that definitely ha had its role in its time, and I think that time is still now, but I'm very skeptical, or I shouldn't say skeptical. I'm just open-minded to the possibility that that could change in the long term. Sure. Yeah, absolutely. You know, we've the idea, you know, that another system could come along, a system for money that's better than Bitcoin is certainly possible.

77
00:27:16.600 --> 00:27:39.160
It's happened over and over again in history. I mean, yeah. Bitcoin is very hard to change, right? So it's like it's really great that it has network effects and that all the infrastructure exists for it, but at the end of the day, it's like you the it's not as private as we would like it to be. And it's very difficult to get it to that point just because it's a blockchain and you can't really update it that well.

78
00:27:39.240 --> 00:27:58.600
Right. Yeah, and we're definitely working on on ways to improve that. But yeah, it's difficult. You know, moving things to the second layers and lightning and moving transactions there will certainly help. And oh yeah, there's other possibilities like Schnorr signatures and stuff that will come in and help help with that. But yeah, it's it's you know, it's impossible.

79
00:27:58.600 --> 00:28:19.680
Like if we not impossible, but there's trade-offs, right? To including privacy in the base layer, you know, in terms of like the audit auditability of the supply, et cetera. Yeah. Okay, so the next section of the book is about transactions and how transactions and blocks are constructed by miners and linked together in the blockchain.

80
00:28:19.680 --> 00:28:39.600
So let's just kind of go through that. Like what are, and this is a phrase that will sort of put people off because they're not going to understand what it means, but you do a good job of explaining it from a high level. What are Merkle trees and why are they used to combine transactions in a block? Hmm. Okay. So again, I do it visually in the book.

81
00:28:39.600 --> 00:28:59.360
So maybe I'll take a different approach, not to totally sidestep your question, but the book is sort of after I talk about the time chain, right? I split the book up and I frame it through the idea of how versus why, right? So the first half of the book is all how the blockchain works, and then the second half is like why. Another portion is sort of like properties of the system.

82
00:28:59.360 --> 00:29:20.400
So to think about this, I'll say it and then hopefully people can think about it visually. But it's like the first half takes you in to the to the blockchain and picks it apart. And then the second half kind of goes outside of that into the existing system. So we would be talking about like banks, markets in that secondary section. So when we go into the blockchain, we kind of want to know what the hell bitcoins are.

83
00:29:20.400 --> 00:29:40.560
You know, like that that seems like a reasonable goal, right? Like what the hell are Bitcoins? To do that to a satisfactory level for what I think is like a like an elementary understanding of Bitcoin or an intermediate understanding of Bitcoin, you want to know what UTXOs are. You want to know what blocks are, and you want to know how transactions are sort of stored in blocks.

84
00:29:40.560 --> 00:29:58.560
And you might ask why that that's something worth knowing. And really simply it's because you want to be able to read that your transactions have confirmed. Right. You want to like that's if you're gonna use Bitcoin, you sort of need to understand like how fees work. So you're not confused when you look at the transactions when you look up blocks and confirm transactions and stuff like that.

85
00:29:58.560 --> 00:30:20.120
So the talking about triple entry accounting or double entry accounting, or ultimately the idea of internal validation in the blockchain. The way the blockchain does that is through hashing and through Merkle trees. Now it's probably yeah, it's I find that a lot of people sort of drone out at this point.

86
00:30:20.120 --> 00:30:32.440
So it's like yeah, yeah, yeah. I remember when I remember when I was explaining this to my boss, I was like, Yeah, I'm gonna explain Bitcoin with mental models instead of code, and it's gonna be really simple. And he's like, Cool, how are you gonna explain hashes? And then like kind of

87
00:30:32.580 --> 00:30:35.500
[unclear]. Right. I was like, oh. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I

88
00:30:35.800 --> 00:31:00.040
Figure that out, huh? Yeah, but I mean, so what I do is I assume that you need to understand what a hash is, I do that visually. I just basically explain that you know it's this one-way function, and I feel ridiculous repeating it verbally because it has to be done visually. But I explain what hashes are and then build up to what a Merkle tree is from there, and ultimately, I think even like probably a fourth grader could understand it once he sees the visuals.

89
00:31:00.120 --> 00:31:23.800
Yeah, absolutely. I agree with that. I was trying to get more at like why all the all the transactions are combined that way, but I think you answered that question too. It's it's so that we can confirm that a transaction's in a block, right? With mathematically confirm it, yeah. The Merkle tree is just an efficient way to organize transactions and then you know, store their their order and be able to validate them very, very quickly.

90
00:31:23.800 --> 00:31:50.000
So we talked about how in double entry accounting it was the first system, or at least one of the first systems to create an internal system of validation. Merkle trees in Bitcoin was another another way to do internal validation, but also efficiently. So it's not enough to just do internal validation, you have to do it efficiently, and once you understand that, it's like, oh, like then I can start explaining sort of more exact advanced concepts because like you mentioned snore signatures and stuff.

91
00:31:50.080 --> 00:32:17.120
It's like what what actually is an improvement to Bitcoin or what's an improvement? Like most improvements are going to be efficiency improvements. Right, right. In this block of transactions, you know, goes out onto the network in this system. How does the system arrive at a consensus about the content of the contents of the blocks, the transactions in each block.

92
00:32:17.120 --> 00:32:43.680
So, okay, so let's see. What you're talking about how do nodes confirm or the consensus rules? Yeah, basically, like how how does the system arrive, like so that everybody agrees on what the ledger states, like the transactions in that block. One of the things that I noticed people were really still having problems with in like the ecosystem is sort of understanding the difference between consensus rules and the consensus like algorithm, right?

93
00:32:43.680 --> 00:33:07.920
So it's like there's proof of work that achieves consensus, but then there's also the consensus rules enforced by full nodes, right? So there's this process by which the full nodes validate transactions and they pass those over to the miners, and the miners you know do proof of work, they do the work on this, you know, add all this data, confirm all the transactions in a block, and then pass that back to the full nodes.

94
00:33:07.920 --> 00:33:27.760
So like it's it's kind of a complicated system. And it's but I think, well, how do I phrase this? I what I wanted to sort out by bringing that up at all, is I wanted people to understand the difference between the two things, right? There's a difference between proof of work that achieves consensus, and there's a difference between consensus rules.

95
00:33:27.760 --> 00:33:54.600
An example of a consensus rule would be you know, Bitcoin's cap at 21 million. That's enforced by full nodes. Why this is important to know is because a couple years ago, it was like I felt that people thought big like miners were in control of Bitcoin for some reason, or even they'll misunderstand like the 51% attack to mean that miners can somehow rewrite consensus rules because the two words are exactly the same, so people conflate them.

96
00:33:54.600 --> 00:34:29.480
Yeah. Yeah. So without getting into the weeds of the process, that was sort of my thinking behind why I decided to include that. Yeah, that makes sense. And I mean, I guess we can kind of explain get into the weeds just a little bit because I think it's helpful. So when a block is discovered, we'll we'll use that word by a miner, which is really just means that there's a you know, a solution to this hashing, you know, puzzle or problem is discovered by a miner, and there's mining nodes all over the world, right?

97
00:34:29.480 --> 00:35:00.760
And so that solution is then like sent out to that network of nodes, and so there's this a peer-to-peer network of nodes. And that was kind of the final bit piece of the puzzle for Bitcoin that Satoshi needed. You know, we had all of this the ideas of proof of the idea of proof of work was out there, all of these this cryptography, like math was available, but then BitTorrent sort of provided the last piece of the puzzle, this peer-to-peer network, which was needed to you know provide that decentralization, the attempt at decentralization or approximation of it, right?

98
00:35:00.920 --> 00:35:20.080
So that solution then is sent out to the network of nodes. Well, it's the solution to the problem and it includes like a bunch of transactions that have been made in the last 10 minutes or so on the network, right? And that's one.

99
00:35:20.080 --> 00:35:45.280
What's that? No, go on. Yeah, okay. So that block is sent out the solution to the kind of that problem, which is like hashing some bit of the previous block, and that's included at the at the in the header or the top of the block, and then all the transactions. And that goes out to the network of full nodes, which process that and say and apply those consensus rules and say, okay, this meets all of the rules that we've agreed upon.

100
00:35:45.280 --> 00:36:03.760
We have consensus about, and it's cool, it's good. This block is good. And then it then this is like the miners just start working on the next block, right? It's something like that. Yeah, it's totally something like that. Now, what I would say is the problem that I think you just ran into is like, oh my god, that's like overly complicated to explain verbally.

101
00:36:03.760 --> 00:36:27.120
And it's kind of like every time, every time you think you're about to explain something, you have to go, uh-but because like wait, do I need to start with something else? You know, like talk to you about mining it unless I've like one of the problems that because I explained Bitcoin to a lot of people so that I could it would help me write the book, but it's like you know, hashing is done a certain way with full nodes, and then it's used another way with miners.

102
00:36:27.120 --> 00:36:49.440
So it's like if you don't explain that, then people don't get it. You're it's like they just their eyes just sort of gloss over. Or like we'll use the term finding for finding a solution, but then afterwards we're calling it winning or or like or a solution. So like which one is it, right? And what I tried to do in the book is I tried to visually show, okay, this is what we mean by finding, this is what we mean by winning.

103
00:36:49.440 --> 00:37:10.360
And it's like it's sort of this game, right? And like drawing out, like knowing what order to put things in ended up being, I think the most valuable piece. Yeah, yeah. And it, you know, like we're running into this like over and over again in talking about the book because it is such a visual book. And so it's hard to, you know, go through the system.

104
00:37:10.360 --> 00:37:29.320
Like, and that's why you wrote the book, right? So yeah, like I basically sketched out everything on note cards for the entire time I was writing the book, and then I had an artist redo it. And even that process was I was like, actually, you know, this has to be slightly different, otherwise it means something totally different.

105
00:37:29.320 --> 00:37:49.400
And like we talked about mining, but then it's like, oh, well, we have to show where in the block the solution goes in order for it to sort of make sense. It just gets super complicated. That's why I'm hesitant to talk about it and in getting too much in the weeds, right? At a high level, I would say, you know, Bitcoin started off with only one type of node, right?

106
00:37:49.400 --> 00:38:17.960
It was a network of homogeneous nodes. And with that understanding, it's like you don't have to think about full nodes and miners, like it just sort of worked, right? And what was the process then? It was like the process then was well, full like nodes did everything, and what they did was they they burned electricity to as a proof as a it's funny because like people say proof of work like it's a buzzword, but really all it's doing is it's it's doing work as a form of a proof, right?

107
00:38:17.960 --> 00:38:45.440
Proof of work, eh? You know, so it's like it's like if you actually think about it, it's like, oh, okay, so it's using the amount of electricity going into the function as a measure of the work. And then that's distinctly different than the way hashes are used in terms of internal validation because the hashes there are used as a way to show, well, you'd have to understand hashes, but ultimately a hash function allows any data to go in and come out unique, right?

108
00:38:45.440 --> 00:39:09.200
So if you put that exact data in, you'll always get that same output. And then you can use that as a way to like prove that that transaction is that transaction. So yeah, it's like it's just hard. It's just a hard system to talk about. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I like the I think we can talk about the evolution of nodes, because like you said, it started out as every node was both a miner and a verifier.

109
00:39:09.200 --> 00:39:29.920
And this is back when, you know, it was we were able, or you know, people at the that were running nodes early in the system were able to mine with a you know a CPU, a regular computer. Right. So that meant that if you were running Bitcoin at all, you were mining. Right. It's like I wasn't in Bitcoin at that time, but that's the way Bitcoin was.

110
00:39:29.920 --> 00:39:51.600
And then I hear stories from like Greg Maxwell or whatever about how people at Wikipedia were were like you could tell they had their their Bitcoin client on because their internet connection would be so bad. And you'd be like, you need to turn it off in order to like do a call. That's funny. Yeah, so back then people were just you know using able-to-use CPUs.

111
00:39:51.600 --> 00:40:12.960
Every node on the system was doing the same thing. So how did the separation or like the emergence of these two different types of nodes happen? Like why did that happen? Well, it happened because of just like financial incentive. Right? It's like, oh, I can make more money by like I can make more money by using graphics cards.

112
00:40:12.960 --> 00:40:31.000
Graphic cards are everywhere, cool. Like that's what I'll do then. And then the next level was, oh, I could make more money by using FPGAs because they're like more dedicated to solving like they're they're more efficient at solving this particular problem, the hash, the hash problem. Oh, I can you know use ASICs, which are even more efficient.

113
00:40:31.000 --> 00:40:49.800
So it was always just a financial incentive that evolved the system. Right. And you know, it it's interesting to say that the system has like it's interesting that the system evolves more naturally than it can be changed. Like it's so hard to push updates to the to Bitcoin, but it does have a sort of natural evolution to it.

114
00:40:49.880 --> 00:41:19.160
Yeah, so it was literally just the fact that people running full node like couldn't mine anymore, right? The mining hardware was specialized and expensive and became industrialized. Where so that the person who was just like using Bitcoin as you know on the network and not you know not able to invest in these expensive ASICs and run their own like mining system, like you said, it became industrialized.

115
00:41:19.160 --> 00:41:37.320
Just you know, can just for running this this verification node then like the mining stuff kind of got stripped out. Well, I mean the mining the capacity to mine was in what was called like Bitcoin, what was the it was it was not called Bitcoin Core at the time, it was called the client was called something else, I can't recall. Like WX Bitcoin or something like that.

116
00:41:37.320 --> 00:41:56.680
Yeah, something like that, right? So it's like whatever the original Bitcoin client was, it was the only one that you could really use to run Bitcoin. It had the capacity to mine, and then eventually it was no longer capable of mining because the difficulty was too high. And that stayed in the code base for a long time, and then eventually it was like, well, why bother keeping it here because it it doesn't work?

117
00:41:56.680 --> 00:42:19.200
So we might as well just like remove it for efficiency's sake, and that's what separated full nodes for miners. Now, there's talk about removing the wallet functionality, and I think some full node implement implementations have done this to sort of parse it out further, but I mean, I don't really know if that's necessary, but yeah, it's it's one of the things I think about is like how much how much do people really need to know, right?

118
00:42:19.200 --> 00:42:46.160
Because if my goal is to get people to not fall down the rabbit hole and simply to say, I'm interested in Bitcoin, how much do I need to know in order to use it? You know, it's like you do you really need to know that much about it. It's it it gets hard when you start to talk about altcoins, right? Because, or forks for that matter. It's like if someone is telling you, if I were to come up to you and say, like, hey, I have this new quantum resistant altcoin, how would you have any way of knowing if I was telling you the truth?

119
00:42:46.160 --> 00:43:07.120
Right. Like you don't. And it's what I find really funny is that like, okay, we built this trustless system called Bitcoin, or Satoshi built this, and now I everyone has to rely that I'm telling you the truth about what it is, because no one has any way of knowing for themselves. And what I try to do in the book is I try not to give people my conclusions about big what Bitcoin is, right?

120
00:43:07.120 --> 00:43:29.520
Like it was, I don't want to say it was frustrating to me, but it was a little bit weird that like a lot of the Bitcoin books to me feel very hypey. It's like, yeah, this is the future, yeah, this is super ethical, like we're doing really great. And it's sort of that be humble thing. It's like what I want is I want people to be able to go through the book, Bitcoin Clarity and say, this is something I'm interested in, this is why, or that this is something that I think is total garbage, this is why.

121
00:43:29.520 --> 00:43:55.040
Like I want people to be able to come with their own conclusions, you know, with their capacity for independent thought and not just like tell them everything about what my conclusions are. So I try to really hold that back. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And you know, I think the audience for the book as you're describing is probably a little different than the audience of this podcast, at least right now, because you know, most of the listeners are down the rabbit hole at this point.

122
00:43:55.040 --> 00:44:33.080
You wouldn't find this podcast, like this podcast lives in the rabbit hole, you know and so yeah yeah so you know I'm kind of getting in like I think it's okay to get in the weeds a little bit here but I totally hear you that the intention for the book the audience the intended audience is you know not necessarily the people who are in the rabbit hole already but people who maybe don't even want to go down it and just want to understand the system you know I mean to be fair like that was my to that was my initial audience for the book but the book has been selling to Bitcoiners almost exclusively so it's kind of like you know I made it the goal to reach people who are not yet fully interested in Bitcoin but the problem is is like how the hell do

123
00:44:33.080 --> 00:45:01.160
You reach them? Right? Because the only people that you are the people that already are interested in Bitcoin. So yeah it's sort of like that was my intention but that's not necessarily how it worked out. And you know I'll still make attempts to try and reach that audience but they're much harder to reach. Yeah and I think part of that is just timing because right now we're still sort of in this bear market and the attention of you know people new to bit to Bitcoin is just like people new to Bitcoin is just very like low.

124
00:45:01.160 --> 00:45:28.440
That stream is very low right now. Yeah and as that like the next cycle we're about to go through the halving and that typically starts driving an increase in price as we at least we've seen that a couple of times in the past we don't know for sure if that's going to happen again this time but we can kind of predict based on past the past that that might happen which then brings in a bunch of new people right so right now we've got a you know it's only Bitcoiners buying this book only Bitcoiners listening to this podcast.

125
00:45:28.440 --> 00:45:47.760
Exactly but that'll change the audience will change you know over the next year or two, probably. No, I totally agree. Yeah, yeah. So let's talk a little bit about light clients, because this is another type of kind of node, I guess, and why like why those developed we and how they're different from full nodes.

126
00:45:47.760 --> 00:46:10.400
Yeah, so like there's so much confusion, or at least there has been so much confusion about like what a full node is, right? Like basically, like there's at the time that full nodes had removed their capacity to mine, right? And then there was distinctly miners, and then there were full nodes. People would say things like, oh, a full node is is something that keeps a record of all the transactions.

127
00:46:10.400 --> 00:46:37.600
But that's not exactly true because you can enable pruning, right? So it's like if you have pruning enabled, then it validates the transactions as they're coming in, but it doesn't store the whole blockchain, right? So there's sort of all these nuances, and I tried to make my definitions fit those nuances as as as close as possible. But getting into to SPV or light clients, it was like in the early days of Bitcoin, there was this push to really scale Bitcoin so more people could use it.

128
00:46:37.600 --> 00:47:01.680
And the idea was is like, okay, well, you don't really need to validate every single transaction, right? Like maybe if you just valid, all you really want to know is if your transaction is included in a block, right? So if you know that your transaction is included, that's good enough. Now, what the argument was between developers at that point was sort of like, well, if you're creating an if if you're creating a new type of node, you're creating a new type of user.

129
00:47:01.680 --> 00:47:32.840
Perhaps you could call them like a secondary class of users because they're not fully validating transactions anymore. And this was the thinking at the time, right? And how many people actually run full nodes today? It's very, very few. Most people don't even use as like we're talking about light clients, but most people don't even use them. And so it's just what like clients were was a way to continue to allow people to validate some of their transactions, specifically just the transaction they were interested in using property of Merkle Trees, and then still know that that transaction was confirmed in a block.

130
00:47:33.000 --> 00:47:54.360
The problem with this was is that like you know, the block could be not the not valid. So there were people who actually probably thought the transaction was confirmed and then it wasn't. How detrimental that was to those people, you know, we'll never really know. There's not like a Bitcoin support desk that takes all these calls. Right. It would, you know, so it and I'm sure people would hate it if that existed anyway.

131
00:47:54.600 --> 00:48:20.440
But yeah, so the idea was is that people wanted the developers wanted to scale Bitcoin into mobile, so they created a type of client that would allow that was that that wasn't as heavy duty and that could do validation faster because it was doing less of the validation. The result of that is that you sort of created this secondary class of user, but really no one very few people go out and try to find strictly SPV wallets.

132
00:48:20.440 --> 00:48:47.160
I mean, I don't I can't say that with a ton of confidence, but just based on the type of wallets that people use, which is you know, exchanges, you know, it's like it's right, yeah. I was even sort of hesitant to talk about about SPV because I was like, well, what the hell? No one uses these, and I think there's only like three or four that are really used and maintained, and yeah, it's just it wallets have their own problem in that wallets aren't profitable.

133
00:48:47.160 --> 00:49:06.120
So the second that you get a good wallet, you have it it's really difficult to be sure that they'll stick around as a company for the long haul. And you know, if you're hodling and you're not moving your money that much, it's kind of like right, yeah. I mean, people are using hardware wallets, but yeah, different topics. So, anyway, those aren't used for trying those aren't used for transacting, though.

134
00:49:06.120 --> 00:49:25.040
Yeah, and exactly. Again, it's about timing. Like Bitcoin is, you know, since holdler hodlers or holders understand the process of monetization now. You know, it's the economic, you know, economically rational decision is just a hold at this point as we're going through that monetization process.

135
00:49:25.040 --> 00:49:47.920
So there's no economic incentive to build and you know use wallets because there's just not that many people using it at this point, except for hardware wallets, which are used for holding Bitcoin. Yeah, like long term. Yeah, so it was a it was like a heated debate at the time, but like now it sort of seems like, well, it doesn't kind of silly to have wasted energy on it because like people don't know the difference and people don't seem to really care.

136
00:49:47.920 --> 00:50:14.720
So I think I think that's a struggle when you're doing like it's a struggle I seem to see with the protocol level developers is like, you know, they can only think the way they know how to think. And they think in terms of how do we get people to actually use the properties of the system? And you could make an argument, and this was an argument that people have made in the past, although it's less popular now, is like you're not actually using Bitcoin trustlessly unless you're running your own full node.

137
00:50:14.720 --> 00:50:33.120
Now people are less likely to say that now because most people don't use full nodes, and that's probably okay, but it's like you're actually you're you are trusting a third party every time you use someone else's full node to conduct your transaction. Or even when you verify your transaction on a block explorer that's pulling from someone else's full node.

138
00:50:33.120 --> 00:50:55.360
So there's all this, it there's all this effort that's gone into building a trustless system, but it turns out trust is really valuable because it comes with convenience. So yeah, and it it's kind of hard to say, like, I'm really glad Bitcoin exists, and I'm really glad we have this trustless base layer. But I do understand that there is values on having trust layers on top of that.

139
00:50:55.440 --> 00:51:15.080
Yeah, exactly. And you know, the people who are not running their own full nodes and are verifying from other full nodes are, I mean, they're basically trusting the network of full nodes who are doing direct verification to be verifying correctly. And often like a particular node, right?

140
00:51:15.080 --> 00:51:36.040
So I guess there's this it is a better, and the way you put it in the book is like you separate out the word less, so it's like trust less, like you're trusting less than you know, the this you know centralized fiat system that we have now. And I think that's an important distinction. It's not completely trustless, but we can trust the system less than we do the current, you know, regime, I guess.

141
00:51:36.040 --> 00:52:02.680
Yeah, and what may be like an interesting story for people in the rabbit hole is sort of like, you know, why wasn't Bitcoin invented sooner? And a lot of really smart people who understood cryptography believed that it wasn't possible because you know, decentralization in its ideological form, like full decentralization, would would not it it would be something slightly different than what we have now because Bitcoin relies on game theory in order to work, right?

142
00:52:02.680 --> 00:52:27.080
And like I think the way people were thinking about decentralization early on was not relying on game theory. So they're like, oh, because nodes are spread all over all over the world, it's impossible to be fully decentralized because there's no central source of time. And I even mentioned in the book that Peter Todd came really close to sort of under like creating Bitcoin as a teenager in one of these platforms, but he's like, oh, but that's impossible because XYZ, right?

143
00:52:27.080 --> 00:53:01.040
And it was sort of just like the understood the how do you put it? The can the like industry understanding at the time was like that it wasn't possible because of certain reasons. And so Satoshi just said, well, we don't need to do fully decentralized, we can do an approximation of decentralization using game theory, you know, having these having this system called proof of work and then you know burning electricity and all this stuff and regulating hash power regulating block timing with hash power, we create this decentralized clock, and that's like we call it elegant, but it's also super complicated.

144
00:53:01.040 --> 00:53:19.760
But yeah, that's to me it's it's interesting to hear people's stories about why they didn't think decentralization was possible. Yeah. Well, you mentioned game theory there, and like the game theory that is inherent in the system is really fundamental to how the system is governed, right?

145
00:53:19.760 --> 00:53:41.840
And I wanted to talk a bit about governance because you get into that in the properties of the system section of the book. So can we talk a bit about game theory? Like how like what exactly are some of the important parts of Bitcoin's game theory, and then we can get into governments, like, you know, how are decisions made, you know, BIPs, Bitcoin improvement pro proposals and you know, those kind of things, yeah.

146
00:53:41.840 --> 00:54:05.920
Yeah, so fees I think is a really interesting thing to talk about because they're really misunderstood, right? And like I could talk about the game theory of mining, but let's just do fees because that's like more controversial. Nobody likes fees. Okay, I can save that with total confidence. Nobody likes fees, fees because we associate them with bank fees, but we understand that in order to have a working system, you sort of have to pay for it.

147
00:54:05.920 --> 00:54:24.560
But we all have this like averse reaction to the idea of a fee specifically because like bank fees are just like totally usury, right? They just like completely rape you. And they they put you in all these situations where they're adding on fees for like no reason just because they need more profits, and it's like it's not it's certainly not because the bank needs them.

148
00:54:24.560 --> 00:54:45.240
Okay, like the banks can print money. So yeah, it's like when it with Bitcoin, you have to think about how the network could be taken down, right? And one of the or made unusable. So you have to think about all the different ways that Bitcoin could be broken, right? And one of the ways you could break it is you could let's say you could mine empty blocks.

149
00:54:45.240 --> 00:55:09.000
So if you join the network as a miner, you could just mine empty blocks, which means people aren't their transactions aren't being processed, that would be a form of attack, or you could flood the network with with transactions so that you know it's impossible to get your transaction included in a block because there's all these nonsense little transactions in it, right? So the way that you prevent the spamming of the network to happen is you make a monetary incentive inflicted.

150
00:55:09.000 --> 00:55:27.880
So it's like if I if if transactions cost a fee, now you're disincentivized for creating a or spamming the network. Right. So that'd be one way to think about like game theory. Game theory is such a loaded term, but it's sort of just like incentives, like how do we incentivize and how do we disincentivize, right?

151
00:55:27.880 --> 00:55:46.760
Like the miners do this really important job for the network, being they add security to the network, they secure the blockchain, they also process transactions, right? So it's like how do we incentivize them doing that, especially because they have to pay electricity to do it? Well, we have to reward them with this thing called Bitcoin, and then Bitcoins have to be valuable in order for them to do it.

152
00:55:46.760 --> 00:56:07.960
So it's sort of like this self-fulfilling prof like prophecy where it creates valuable bitcoins because someone's willing to spend money to produce them, and there's little stuff like that. Like, let's see, what's another one with fees? Like spamming the network is sort of a terrible thing, and like, yeah, I think those are those are two good examples.

153
00:56:07.960 --> 00:56:30.160
Yeah, and speaking of spamming the network, right? Satoshi added, and we can talk a little bit about block size here just because it's fun to get into. Satoshi added a block size limit, right? And that had the effect of the code base, right? And he was added later. Right. It wasn't a yeah, it was added almost two years later, I think, is sort of like he didn't even like discuss it, right?

154
00:56:30.160 --> 00:56:48.640
He just kind of threw it in there in one of the versions and released it. Well, one other tangent that I should mention here is that a lot of the times changes aren't talked about publicly. So, like, because the because the code base is open source and anyone can read it, the last thing you want to do is be like, hey, I just fixed this bug right here.

155
00:56:48.640 --> 00:57:10.240
You know, like a lot of the times bugs will get fixed silently because it's better to do it silently than to broadcast it. Sure, yeah, that makes sense. Yeah. So do you think Satoshi then saw the unlimited block size as a bug? Do you think it was I mean, I know the explanation was we're gonna put in this this limit to avoid spamming the network is like another reason to avoid spamming the network?

156
00:57:10.240 --> 00:57:29.600
Because back then, like there weren't like fees were really low, right? Because the block subsidy, the reward was quite the incentive to, you know, it was it was plenty, like you didn't really need fees. The miners were getting 50 Bitcoin per block, right? So at that point, yeah.

157
00:57:29.680 --> 00:57:53.840
Yeah, so the segue is is like okay, I was talking about fees and how people hate fees. Really, if you what I wanted to do in the book in this portion where I talk about fees and block size, is I want to make people love fees as odd as that sounds. It's sort of like you need fees in order for for the blockchain to work long term because the block reward, or as I would call it the block subsidy, it's intentionally diminished every happening, right?

158
00:57:53.840 --> 00:58:17.960
Which means that eventually we won't have one. Now it it's way, way, way in the future, but if you really like Bitcoin and you want to like pass Bitcoin on to your children and grandchildren, and I know people who are doing that, you know, this should sort of be on the top of your priority list is to make sure that this doesn't change. Or at least maybe for people to understand this, because when they misunderstand this, they do stupid things and say fees are terrible, which in reality on Bitcoin they're really great.

159
00:58:18.280 --> 00:58:41.880
So as of as the subsidy diminishes, we have less incentive for the miners, right? So miners are doing this altruistic job where it would be altruistic if they didn't have a reward. They're doing this job of burning electricity, off-chain resources with the reward of on-chain resources. Their current on-train resource is Bitcoin in the form of a subsidy or a reward and fees.

160
00:58:41.880 --> 00:59:02.360
Now, eventually the subsidy will run out and it will have to rely entirely on fees. So, you know, how do you how does how does it how does a blockchain work or how does a Bitcoin blockchain work? You know, in a world without a subsidy. And that means block needs to be full and people need to pay higher fees.

161
00:59:02.360 --> 00:59:22.200
So when you accept this, you know, in your heart of hearts to be true, you say, well, Bitcoin has to be really valuable in order for this to work. And it has to be the layer of like huge settlements, not necessarily like the micropayments. The idea of using Bitcoin for micropayments doesn't work in that in that vision of the future in Bitcoin.

162
00:59:22.200 --> 00:59:53.200
It doesn't. Which is sort of unfortunate because people misunderstood the properties of the system early on. As you mentioned, fees were quite low. So when fees were low, people were like, oh, micropayments. Like I can sell blog posts for a fraction of a cent. But no, like that doesn't maybe you could make you know divisible payments on lightning, because you can make like a very, very, very small, like a fraction of a Bitcoin payment on Lightning, but you can't do final settlement on the blockchain because then you'll get a fee that is more expensive than the payment you made.

163
00:59:53.200 --> 01:00:15.200
Right. So sure. Yeah. So understanding that talking about the block size, Satoshi implemented this one megabyte block size or two megabyte block size, excuse me, right? Is one or it's two now, but it's it was one then. So we need blocks to probably be full in the future. And you know, for whatever reason, people are terrified to say that because reasons.

164
01:00:15.200 --> 01:00:39.040
I honestly don't know. But to me, it's like I think it's like Luke Jr. And you know, for better or for worse, this guy's actually advocating for the block size to be lower. Right. Yeah, because I guess he is assuming that there are many people out there that want to run a full node, but they can't because the whatever resource computation or band you know, internet bandwidth is limiting them from being able to do that.

165
01:00:39.040 --> 01:00:59.600
So smaller block sizes will encourage more node use, and I'm not sure that that's the case, you know. I mean, that might be the case. For me, I look at it as another form of scarcity, right? So I look at yes, Bitcoin has capped at 21 million, but also the blockchain space on the blockchain should be scarce.

166
01:00:59.600 --> 01:01:18.560
So every time you make a payment, you are bidding for your transaction to be included in the next block. In order for space in the block to be valuable, you know, it's got to be scarce. If you have unlimited block size, well, then like kind of like you if you could just fit as many transactions as you want in there, the properties of it's just it just doesn't work long term.

167
01:01:18.560 --> 01:01:41.480
It might work in the short term, but it doesn't work in the long term. Exactly. Yeah, yeah. And I think in the long term, like people are worried about not being able to use Bitcoin for payments, and then you know, that preventing Bitcoin from becoming that. It's like now I'm just gonna why these money is to me, Bitcoin evolved in a time where there were so many different opportunities for payments.

168
01:01:41.480 --> 01:02:02.360
You know, like if I want to make a payment to you, I can use Venmo, I can use banks, I could use PayPal, and all of those rely on the underlying dollar, right? It's it's like the dollar is so easy to make payments in. What I don't what I don't have is I don't have a scarce, you know, I don't have a scarce form of potential currency.

169
01:02:02.360 --> 01:02:32.120
Right. And yes, Bitcoin is super volatile, but it's just so bad at making payments that to think that you can compete against like Visa, PayPal, Venmo is so naive. It's like that's not what the blockchain is good at. Yeah. I mean, at this point, I absolutely agree with you, but just thinking about a future, right, where Bitcoin could become a form of currency, like a global currency that's used for payments as well as for storing value.

170
01:02:32.120 --> 01:02:56.680
Like how could that how could that be possible in a world where we have high fees on the blockchain to you know to transact? And I think that we're working toward that now, like you mentioned with Lightning Network. And you know, you also mentioned that like one downside would be like you could transact on the on a lightning network with a tiny transaction, a very low fee very quickly, but then you when you settle to the blockchain, like the fee is high there.

171
01:02:56.680 --> 01:03:21.040
And I think what has to happen then is to make that possible is you like you've gotta make a lot of transactions, right? On Lightning in order to make the settlement eventually like worthwhile, I guess. Yeah, I mean, an example is like, you know, if you've ever used one of those apps where they're like, oh, you get a discount every time you use our app or something, and then eventually you collect points, and they like mail you a gift card or something.

172
01:03:21.200 --> 01:03:44.400
It's like it's not really worth it for them to mail you a gift card unless you have at least 10 bucks. Right, right. Whatever the equivalent will be in the future for Bitcoin is sort of like up in the air. But you know, it's it's hard to predict what the long-term the long long-term uses for Bitcoin will be. Like, 'cause there are a lot of like competing cryptocurrencies that, you know, will do certain things better.

173
01:03:44.400 --> 01:04:06.160
There there's not a doubt in my mind that that wouldn't be the case. And also, it's so easy to make a fiat currency. Like it's I think Bitcoin should have the capacity to make payments better than it currently makes them. Like, sure, like that's definitely that there's no doubt that that adds value. But, you know, I don't love making payments in Bitcoin.

174
01:04:06.160 --> 01:04:24.480
I would rather make payments in cash. And I would rather just hold Bitcoin because it there's also like tax implications and all this stuff. So yeah, I mean it's possible, like and I would be rooting for a world where you could use Bitcoin more easily. But I'm skeptical because cash is so freaking easy.

175
01:04:24.480 --> 01:04:48.240
It's so easy. Yeah, yeah. And it would have to be like I think a better way to look at it, so I'm not just like negative about Bitcoin, is like I think a better way to look at it is Bitcoin is a fallback system in case the existing system fails. Right? Yeah, right. Yeah. So it's like the Federal Reserve and governments all around the world are are printing all this money, which in a way is to their detriment, but it's also to their benefit.

176
01:04:48.240 --> 01:05:07.080
And it's like double-edged sword, right? Because the more money the they print, the more power they have because they can just buy whatever. And you know, I'm I'm not in a world where Bitcoin was the most dominant currency, it would mean that all the governments were in some serious disarray. Right. Yeah, I agree with that.

177
01:05:07.080 --> 01:05:25.400
And you know, I guess there are plenty of Bitcoiners who think that's going to be the case, and probably stemming from the fact that there are a lot of libertarians in Bitcoin and gold bugs who have been predicting, you know, the fall of the fiat currency regime for a long time. But you know, central banks have been able to kick that can down the road.

178
01:05:25.400 --> 01:05:58.600
And as you also mentioned earlier, like, you know, they're getting to the point where there's not really many plays left because interest rates are actually negative in 30 plus countries around the world now. And yeah, and so that just seems untenable over the long run. And so if Bitcoin becomes like the backup, I think there's ways that it could be used as a payment system, batching transactions on the settlement layer, like you know, hundreds of thousands of like lightning closures could be batched in a you know Schnorr transaction on the base layer or something like that, and the fees for settlement divided up.

179
01:05:58.600 --> 01:06:21.880
And you know, so I think there's like solutions to using Bitcoin in the future, but I do agree that like right now it doesn't make any sense, and like holding is the only way to go and the only economically rational choice. And you know, I think it's gonna just take time, decades and decades, you know, I don't know the order of decades. I think the way to phrase it is like because we all rely on the dollar, we're very acutely aware of its problems.

180
01:06:21.880 --> 01:06:53.760
You know, it's like we all know that like the dollar, like when I went to the grocery 20 years ago, I could buy a lot more groceries than I could buy today, right? And we all know that that's a problem. But if we all relied on Bitcoin, we would immediately become aware of the problems with Bitcoin. And like the problem with Bitcoin is that, yeah, you can't do payments, you know, and in a way, it's so capitalistic that if fees were really high, only people moving a ton of money and paying high fee, well, not a ton of money, but anyone who's willing to pay high fees would be the people who got included in the block.

181
01:06:53.760 --> 01:07:15.440
So you'd have to wait a huge amount of time for your transaction to be processed. Like that's a pain point. In a way that like using a credit card or a debit card doesn't happen. Also, you know, loaning money is a lot inter it's a lot easier for banks to do when they're printing it. So it's like interest rates are really low, which means that you could you could start a business and buy and like you know, make this huge loan.

182
01:07:15.440 --> 01:07:36.880
You can buy a house and get all this debt for really, really cheap because the money is being printed. If we were relying on Bitcoin, everyone it I one of the problems I see is like, okay, well, you're holding all this Bitcoin. Imagine trying to invest in a company where you're holding all this Bitcoin and you're thinking, well, should I invest in this company or should I just hold my Bitcoin?

183
01:07:36.880 --> 01:07:57.760
Right. So that could be potential stalls in an economy if it ever came to fully relying on Bitcoin. So I think Bitcoin is really great as a measure, like the what is it? The Austrians sort of talked about this, Austrian economists would say, like, well, currency should be a measure of scarcity, and the dollar is not a good measure of scarcity.

184
01:07:57.760 --> 01:08:21.680
I think Bitcoin is a is sort of a better measure of scarcity, but the problem with that is people don't know what Bitcoin is. So it's like, okay, Bitcoin's scarce, which is great, and it would help us measure scarce resources in the world, but nobody understands Bitcoin, so they speculate on it, and the price is so volatile. So, in an ideal world, you know, Bitcoin, if everyone thought about Bitcoin the way you and I did, it would be different.

185
01:08:21.680 --> 01:08:42.760
Yeah, but because the world is the way it is, it's sort of like, God, I don't know. I don't know. It's yeah, terrifying to rely on Bitcoin long term. Yeah. And you know, I think over time, the way people think about Bitcoin is going to change or might change based on what happens with the with this fiat regime.

186
01:08:42.760 --> 01:09:21.000
And like you mentioned, like the idea of using Bitcoin to invest in a company, you know, the is you know, using Bitcoin to invest in a company is not as appealing as using fiat, especially like right now in this current day and age. But because fiat like encourages the misallocation of resources because it's it's printed and so you know on the scarce then moving like once that catches up with the system, and you know, it it happens, you know, every you know, so often that that misallocation of resources leads to these giant bubbles

187
01:09:21.080 --> 01:09:41.400
And the bubbles pop and then we have this economic recession, et cetera. If there's this sort of parallel economy that's being built with Bitcoin, the investment prospects, right, with using Bitcoin, like really forces you, because it's scarce and valuable to evaluate your investment decisions, I guess, more more critically.

188
01:09:41.400 --> 01:10:03.000
And so there's it prevents that misallocation of resources or at least lessens that misallocation of resources. Yeah. That's true. And it's but I guess the hard part is like how many like sometimes I think about this just because I'm a weird person who thinks about this. I'm like, how much of the world that that we have actually is reliant on the fact that there's a misallocation of resources in the economy?

189
01:10:03.000 --> 01:10:23.120
Like Amazon's never been profitable, right? Because they always reinvest all their money. So it's like, is the I order everything from Amazon? Like I don't shop anywhere. Everything I get is from Amazon and it's next day shipping. Is that something that I'll no longer have the privilege of using in a world without, you know, without the success of the US dollar? Maybe.

190
01:10:23.120 --> 01:10:39.520
Yeah, that's true. Maybe so. Yeah. I mean, I hadn't considered that, so I don't think I have any like ideas in reaction at the moment. I'd have to think about that some more. Yeah, that's a good one to chew on for sure.

191
01:10:39.700 --> 01:10:43.840
There's a lot of innovation that comes through the capitalist misallocation of resources. Like

192
01:10:43.920 --> 01:11:07.360
How many companies in the Silicon Valley have, you know, they invest, like why combinator, right? They invest in all these companies because they have so much money they don't know what to do with it. And then a few of them work, right? In a world where you can't do that, the only the people who have a track record for success would get more money. So, you know, it's like super easy to raise money in the valley, but if if we didn't have the dollar, that wouldn't be the case anymore.

193
01:11:07.360 --> 01:11:30.720
You'd have to, you'd have to show some like serious success, or you'd have to do like cash flow businesses that you know didn't require a huge amount of ca capital up front. Yeah, but there were eras in human history where money was not so easily printed, and those eras do correspond to you know, like what we call renaissances or golden ages or whatever, yeah.

194
01:11:30.720 --> 01:11:54.800
Variously named like that. And I guess like what is the reason that might be? And I and I think it's because it the idea of like being able to throw a bunch of fiat at a bunch of different ideas and kind of picking the best, which you know, is this kind of Darwinian approach to capitalism that is maybe enabled you know, more so by the fiat by fiat regimes.

195
01:11:54.800 --> 01:12:32.920
I think it's balanced by the quality of businesses that are able to be developed with a scarce money right the that the more sustainable and long lasting businesses are created in that world than they are in in a fiat world maybe I'm not certain I'm not certain of that I'd have to think about that yeah it's sort of like new territory I haven't thought about that a ton I did what what crossed my mind though is you know how we're sort of in a like as a US I assume you're in the US too right yeah yeah so from from my perspective and this is like we can talk about we've already

196
01:12:32.920 --> 01:13:11.640
Talked about how like the Federal Reserve is sort of messing with our our our currency and that's one way to look at the economy but another way to look at the economy is thinking well the US is globally dominant because it it messes with its currency right it's like because the US is this this world reserve currency that makes the country as a whole much stronger and then we sort of get involved in these proxy wars or maybe that's not the right term for it but an example would be like how many like how many countries rely on the companies of the US right and the companies in the of the US rely on the cheapness of the US dollar.

197
01:13:11.640 --> 01:13:32.240
Yep. So it it's like I hesitate to criticize something when it's so complicated like I definitely there are things that are immoral right and that's you can criticize that but it's just the economy's so complicated and I hate to be dismissive of that portion of it because yeah like thinking about how much our lives would change.

198
01:13:32.240 --> 01:13:59.280
And bit Bitcoin is sort of joke about this, right? It's like, oh, we'd be in like underground in some citadel or something like that. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, it is. And I, you know, there are definitely people like Austrian school, you know, people like economists in the Austrian school, Safidine, in particular, who's applied those sort of Austrian thoughts and ideals to Bitcoin.

199
01:13:59.280 --> 01:14:17.680
Talk about how that's like future, like a possible Bitcoin based economy could possibly work. And I think again, like, you know, potentially businesses that are more sustainable, long-term sustainable could emerge and be supported.

200
01:14:17.840 --> 01:14:42.560
That that's would be more that environment would be more encouraging of those types of businesses, because the value of people's time, right, is not being siphoned off by this printing of money. And so people are more free to sort of explore their preferred sorts of like wealth generation, right?

201
01:14:42.560 --> 01:15:02.720
And able to like m have some time to really master their craft, as opposed to this fiat regime where like the graph that I come back to all the time, and it's there's a bunch of graphs like this on the WTF happened in 1971.com site.

202
01:15:02.720 --> 01:15:24.560
It's that graph of productivity, right? Which is rising from the from 1900 to 1971, in lockstep with wages, right? So productivity and wages lockstep. And in 1971, like wages basically flatten and productivity goes off on the same trajectory, right?

203
01:15:24.560 --> 01:15:49.400
And so the that money is literally being stolen, right? And we've talked about like Robert Breedlove talks about how this is time theft, right? The time is literally being stolen from us. And so yeah, like it's an unfair system, however, like can whatever conveniences it gives to us, like it really just rewards those corporations, right?

204
01:15:49.400 --> 01:16:17.240
That are enabled by this fiat system, and all that money kind of accrues toward that wealth kind of accrues toward the top, and us plebs are are like kind of left to sort of scramble because our productivity is not being rewarded anymore, you know. Okay, so at the risk of total totally taking a deviation from this topic, I would say that one of the things that Austrians, Keynesianists, and even the Chicago school, like Milton Freeman, right?

205
01:16:17.240 --> 01:16:38.760
Like one thing that they all sort of have in common, which I don't think people realize, is this idea that growth is good, right? Like everyone is trying to get the economy to grow. Keynesianists believe, well, if you just throw more money at the problem, we'll get growth. The like Milton Freeman kind of lead, it's like, okay, well, if you lower the interest rates, then you'll get some growth.

206
01:16:38.760 --> 01:17:00.040
And the Austrians believe, well, you know, maybe saving is okay because that'll mean we'll get growth later, but everyone wants growth, and the reason why you want growth is because if you have a really large amount of shit created, then it's easy to share, right? It's like if you're getting 10%, I think China was is still at like 8% growth, which is sort of like low for them historically in the past like 10-20 years.

207
01:17:00.040 --> 01:17:24.240
If you get a lot of growth, everyone can rise, right? But in a world where you don't have that sort of growth, which is what potentially could happen if we relied on Bitcoin, where because you don't have the criminality of you know, just like you know, money not backed by scarcity, it would mean that maybe you'd return to sort of this era of people valuing things other than you know, materialism.

208
01:17:24.240 --> 01:17:43.920
It's like maybe people actually take up crafts again and like learn to paint and learn to do art and not just focus on like, well, let's create this new SaaS company and like we're gonna get to we're gonna get all this growth and we're gonna get all these users and we're gonna exit for this fat amount of money so that we could buy a slightly nicer house. Right. Yeah, I mean, I guess you're right.

209
01:17:43.920 --> 01:18:16.240
And like the question is like like what kind of shit do we want to produce, right? Like do we want do we want like a world that's just like throwing out a bunch of crap that we don't need, like just spewing it out and encouraging right? It's like what do you need? How many Bitcoiners love to talk about what scams are? Like every altcoin is a scam, but you know that how many Bitcoin binary traders are advertising on Facebook now, like those are definitely scams, and they all stand in front of some luxury vehicle signaling that they have an excessive amount of wealth to display, right?

210
01:18:16.240 --> 01:18:45.920
Like that's a sickness in our culture. And if big if relying on Bitcoin could sort of wipe that off and kick like remove the ego from people, I mean that would be a great outcome. It would be painful, but it would be great. Yeah. Yeah. I and I am definitely on the side of what if there is some kind of transition to a Bitcoin-based economy, you know, like I was talking to Andreas on a couple a couple episodes a couple episodes ago, and you know, he doesn't think that Bitcoin will replace fiat, right?

211
01:18:45.920 --> 01:19:06.520
He thinks that there'll be just sort of this parallel Bitcoin economy that i exists for people to opt out of like the extreme cases of the failures of fiat regimes, right? Venezuel is a Yes, exactly. And it's there as a backup option, right? For people in those in those situations.

212
01:19:06.840 --> 01:19:30.040
But there are also other Bitcoiners that you know kind of believe in this, they're monetary maximalists, right? They believe then that sound money will win, right? Just because of the nature of sound money, the truth of sound money. Be at to be adversarial to that belief. I mean, even Hayek, when he predicted private money, which is fairly close to what Bitcoin is.

213
01:19:30.040 --> 01:19:49.880
I mean, he couldn't have predicted blockchains, right? But when he predicted private money, he thought that it would be the most stable of currencies to win. So, you know, there's sort of this nitpicking that goes on among Bitcoiners where they're like, well, we'll take this idea from the Austrians and we'll take this idea from whoever else, and we'll like say that you know, this is definitely the future.

214
01:19:49.880 --> 01:20:12.360
But yeah, I'm definit I'm more skeptical. I don't know. I'm I'm not ready to say that it would be a good world if Bitcoin was if everyone had to rely on Bitcoin is sort of the theme of this, right? Yeah, and I think that's healthy to have that skepticism and to stay humble about about that. And I think you're right that and I'm certainly part of this, you know.

215
01:20:12.360 --> 01:20:30.680
I have a strong belief in the kind of future that Bitcoin would create for us. And so I appreciate like the dose of skepticism. Yeah, and I think it's I think it's important to say, you know, stay humble about what this could mean for the future of the world.

216
01:20:30.680 --> 01:21:09.040
And there's just like you said, there's just so much complexity. There's so much just possibility of outcomes in a in a few in the future that it's it's it's impossible to predict the future and i think where bitcoiners are is is really you know i think there's certainly some conviction about what will happen but i think a lot of it is hope too you know of what bitcoin could mean because there's a lot of you know kind of desperation and you know people just sick of this

217
01:21:09.040 --> 01:21:47.440
Existing system this fiat regime because it doesn't it doesn't reward them you know what i would say is that okay so i don't know if this is hmm how do i phrase this so some exchanges are known to call you up if you are over the age of 35 and attempting to create an account because that's actually a really good indicator of fraud people who are over the age of 35 don't tend to invest in cryptocurrency so you know when you think about the potential for bitcoin long term taking that into account you'd say well it's really gonna be a generational thing right is like do millennials gen Xers convince every subsequent generation

218
01:21:47.440 --> 01:22:06.320
That Bitcoin is better than gold it seems like that's the case for us you know but if we if that can if that trend continues that would be a really positive thing for Bitcoin because I in the early days of Bitcoin people used to say well like oh you know if if Bitcoin just expands to this country or that country then Bitcoin has this huge potential.

219
01:22:06.320 --> 01:22:29.200
But I've tried to explain this to the older generation and it's really hard. You know and they are set in their ways and you know all the neurosci all the psychology studies and stuff will tell you that people generally don't change their beliefs at after 45, right? And that's being a little generous. So I do think there's potential, but I guess that would be the mission there is trying to get young people interested in cryptocurrency.

220
01:22:29.200 --> 01:22:49.720
And I the reason why millennials are so into Bitcoin is because I mean we got so screwed in the economy. Like millennials really graduated high school around the time that the economy collapsed. So there's no like, gosh, when my parents went to school, it was $500 a semester and they got multiple job offers without a college degree.

221
01:22:49.720 --> 01:23:14.520
You know, it just like completely different world, right? And millennials are definitely struggling. So I think there's more of that vitriolic disdain for the existing systems because they were so screwed by it. Exactly. Yeah. And I think you're right. Yeah, I think that that experience will inform changes in beliefs over, you know, generationally.

222
01:23:14.520 --> 01:23:42.440
And I think Satoshi seemed to another thing that Satoshi seemed to foresee was that you know, a possible move to a Bitcoin-based economy would take a long time. Like, you know, the subsidy doesn't run out for 120 years, right? Or 200 and 40 years. So yeah, it's it's something that is you know on the order of decades to come out or to like sort of emerge, I guess.

223
01:23:42.440 --> 01:24:00.440
And that's a generational thing. Yeah, definitely. And I mean, what you're doing with the podcast and what I'm trying to do with the book is really say, at least from my perspective, I'm thinking, you know, how can I make the transition? How could I reduce the hype and bring it as close as close to reality as possible?

224
01:24:00.440 --> 01:24:11.480
Like, yes, Bitcoin is really cool, yes, Bitcoin is really great, but how I think the problem that I faced was like, oh, sorry, I have to buzz someone now. No worries.

225
01:24:16.800 --> 01:24:37.040
There we go with another one of those Amazon deliveries. But yeah, so the problem I faced was like, you know, I when you spend two years, like how do I relate this and actually make it an eloquent way to say it? It's like when I spent two years learning about Bitcoin, I became a more invested Bitcoiner because I had done work, right?

226
01:24:37.040 --> 01:25:02.480
It's like because I invested so much time into learning about something, it means that I cared about it more and I developed more biases towards it. Now, if Bitcoin were more simple, you know, to understand, and if it didn't require sort of dedicating your life to creating a podcast or getting a job in the industry, I think you would see a little bit more rationality and less like blind speculation.

227
01:25:02.560 --> 01:25:38.240
Sure. Yeah, that makes sense. And I mean, I guess we're all incentivized now because of the time we've put in and you know the fact that we own Bitcoin to hope and work toward a future where Bitcoin is more you is is used more. Yeah, and you know, I think like you mentioned, like you're comparing this podcast to sort of the more rational and conservative and I guess less less hyped and reasonable approach of your book.

228
01:25:38.240 --> 01:26:00.360
You know, this podcast, I am part of that scene, like that is I you know, my intro, I talk about, I say welcome to the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance, you know. And yeah, and we talk about a lot about you know the future that the Bitcoin we hope will provide for us. And you know, I admit that I obviously don't know that nobody can know the future.

229
01:26:00.360 --> 01:26:21.480
But it's it's a hope. You can have a better idea about it, you know. So it's like of course, you I guess I'm I'm paraphrasing someone else's quote, but the best way to predict the future is to build it, right? So it's like I include you in the less hype scene because you're actually building something, so you have a reason to believe that that would be the outcome because you're contributing to it.

230
01:26:21.480 --> 01:26:41.160
Now, that's not necessarily the case. Like, like I said, when I was in Bitcoin in the earlier, like in the when Bitcoin was newer, it was so much of a builder community, everyone was building something. Now, what I learned is a lot of the shit that I built had vulnerabilities in the underlying libraries, and I had to pull it off the store immediately because I was like, Oh my god, I'm building crap, you know.

231
01:26:41.160 --> 01:27:07.240
And I was like, maybe I should do something else because it was like this, it was so complicated to actually like create good stuff, like secure is what I mean by good here. It's really difficult to actually make secure stuff, and so much of the infrastructure in this space isn't secure, it's a whole nother problem where people don't like to hear about the insecurities of their products or the vulnerabilities in their products, and you know, for for even just people like me, I have a hard time.

232
01:27:07.240 --> 01:27:31.080
Like, what are you supposed to do? Read the code base of everything you use, right? You know, so it it goes back to that idea of like a trustless environment, but you have to rely on trust at some point. Like I have to trust the core devs to build a good a good product so that I can trust that because I can't validate it myself, and then it goes you have to think about that for every single wallet you use, because the properties of the system allow your funds to just be stolen.

233
01:27:31.080 --> 01:27:52.160
And gosh, there was a vulnerability in one wallet that everything looked normal, and it said, Hey, do you want to do an update? And then you'd be like, Yeah, I'll update. And then the second you update and then you make a transaction, it takes all of your funds and then funnels it to some you know hacker's account. So it was just literally like the first transaction that you made after the update stole everything in your wallet.

234
01:27:52.480 --> 01:28:15.040
Oh man. Yeah. That's wouldn't have known that unless you happen to go to Bitcoin Reddit and see the top post, you know, like that's insane. And it's just insane. Like the industry is super, super difficult to make good stuff. Yeah. Yeah, that's definitely a risk. And I, you know, I certainly don't look at code of all of the Bitcoin products that I use.

235
01:28:15.040 --> 01:28:37.600
You know, at the most, like I might, you know, verify with PGP the source of a particular binary executable. But you know, that's I'm probably like less than one percent of Bitcoiners are doing even that, you know. That would have been the case. I think it was like Bitcoin Diamond or something. There was like a fork of Bitcoin after Bitcoin Cash, there was a series of forks if it came really trendy.

236
01:28:37.600 --> 01:29:07.920
And it was like, I don't know if I think it was Bitcoin Diamond or something like that. Basically, some like new Bitcoin fork said, Well, screw Bitcoin, we're forking off, we're gonna start our own wallet and all this stuff. They released their wallet, everyone downloaded it who wanted to collect their you know coins on that chain, and then it was like, Oh, unless you validated the binary, the whole thing was like a whole bunch of people got like like basically wallets with exploits in them because of the way they downloaded them, they were already built, right?

237
01:29:07.920 --> 01:29:31.800
And they're like, oh, sorry, but it's like it's unless someone comes and reads that blog post, no one's gonna know, right? So I guess it's just there's just so much stuff, and it's hard going back to the idea of the signal versus the noise, right? There's a lot of noise in the Bitcoin and cryptocurrency space, and when you have something of value to say, it's hard to cut across that.

238
01:29:31.800 --> 01:30:02.440
So vulnerabilities and stuff aren't that popular. And that's a lot, I mean, a lot of things aren't popular, which is why they have to be said through anonymous accounts. Yeah, it's true. It's absolutely true. And you know, like you said, that there is value in trust. And over time, the you know, honest parties involved in the system, building products for the system, will gain trust because they have you know shown over time that they're able, you know, trustworthy.

239
01:30:02.440 --> 01:30:23.400
And yeah, so we have a trustless system that's of money, right? But all of the products that use that money or enable the use of that money are just as much just as trusted as you know the services that we use in a fiat world. Yep. I mean, the good thing is is that like we don't have the central point of failure that the dollar has, right?

240
01:30:23.400 --> 01:30:41.720
Because that's just all relying on the Federal Reserve. But yeah, and that's a big that's a big thing. Like I wouldn't be dismissive of that. I think so. Oh, sure, absolutely about how like you know, having this all having a backup system for the existing economy is is way more than I ever could have asked for.

241
01:30:43.080 --> 01:31:03.080
Yeah, it's it's a potential revolution, a potential renaissance, you might say it's a potential renaissance. Yeah, that doesn't sell as well. That's true. This has been a lot of fun. I've had a ton of fun talking. You know, I love the first half of the episode, kind of going through the book and talking about the system.

242
01:31:03.080 --> 01:31:26.560
But this last half, just you know, talking about Bitcoin and hanging out has been a lot of fun too. Yeah. So I appreciate your time. I'm looking forward to sharing this with the crew. I'll put it up this week. So look out for that. And you know, keep up the great work and thanks for joining me. Hey, thanks a bunch. Talk to you later.

243
01:31:26.560 --> 01:31:46.880
All right, that was a great time as always. You know, I love talking Bitcoin with Bitcoiners. I hope you all enjoyed it as well. Thank you, Kiara, for your time. And I hope all of you will let us know your thoughts, questions about the episode. Let us know a favorite bit or something you disagreed with on Bitcoin Twitter. Kiara is at Kiara Bickers.

244
01:31:46.880 --> 01:32:05.360
I am at citizenbitcoin. And that is really the best way to support the podcast by sharing it on Bitcoin Twitter. And also with your family and friends. You can share the podcast website. It's citizenbitcoin.world. And check out layer1btc.com for the Citizen Bitcoin merch collection.

245
01:32:05.360 --> 01:32:29.440
Thanks again to GiveBitcoin for sponsoring this episode and to LTBN, the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network, for distributing the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast to their amazing audience of Bitcoiners. If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out. I'd love to hear from you. My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at Citizen Bitcoin on Telegram and Keybase, and my email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me.

246
01:32:29.440 --> 01:32:49.040
This week's open source shout out goes to MyNode. MyNode aims to be the easiest way to run a dedicated, easy to use Bitcoin node and lightning wallet. By combining the best open source software with our user interface, management and monitoring software, you can easily, safely, and securely use Bitcoin and Lightning.

247
01:32:49.040 --> 01:32:59.680
Check out MyNode at MyNodeBTC.com. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
