Max Hillebrand: Agorism, Open Source, Privacy, Wasabi and Taproot Citizen Bitcoin ยท 2019-11-27 [00:00:21] Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady, and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. It's Thanksgiving week here in the United States, and I want to take the opportunity to say thanks to all of you. [00:00:42] Thanks for listening and thanks for all the support you've given to the podcast this year. I sincerely appreciate you all. And I think we are all thankful for Bitcoin. So deep gratitude to Satoshi for giving us this roundabout way to unfuck our money. Alright, I've got a great conversation with Max Hillebrand, a great Bitcoin educator for you all today. [00:01:05] But before we dive into this one, a word about GiveBitcoin, the sponsor of this episode. Give Bitcoin is the best way to give Bitcoin to pre-coiners in your life for two reasons. One, it's time-locked, so volatility can't scare them into selling. And two, it comes with a world-class Bitcoin education from the likes of Stephan Livera, Matt Odell, Savedina Moose, Yan Pritzker, Michael Karas, and even your boy right here. [00:01:30] I've given some Bitcoin already to my dad, my brother-in-law, as I mentioned on previous episodes, and they had both been reluctant to take that plunge for years. [00:01:39] GiveBitcoin gave them enough peace of mind to get excited about Bitcoin. They're really looking forward to that world-class education. So you should definitely consider gifting some Bitcoin to the precoiners in your life this holiday season. I certainly will be. [00:01:54] So check out GiveBitcoin at givebitcoin.io. Alright, let's go. Max Hillebrand is a prolific Bitcoin educator. [00:02:13] He's able to absorb and synthesize information at an incredible rate. Max is not a coder, but has developed a great high-level understanding of Bitcoin as a system. But he's also done a lot of reading and thinking about political organization, philosophy, and ethics. So we begin our discussion with these topics as they relate to Bitcoin, and then we dive into privacy, coin join wasabi, of course, and much more. [00:02:38] All right, here we go. All right, it is an absolute honor to welcome Max Hillebrand to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. How's it going, Max? [00:02:57] Oh, it is going fantastic. What an what an honor to join a podcast that I've been following for such a long time already. As we said a bit in the previous discussion, in cyberspace, right? We just feel like we know each other already because we both share content and valuable knowledge. And so it's awesome to sit down to you finally in well in person in cyberspace to discuss about all the magical things of Bitcoin. [00:03:19] Yes, it is wonderful. I do feel like I know you very well at this point. You've produced so much content, man, like just hundreds and hundreds of videos. Your website towards liberty.com is full of really just amazing content. It's a whole rabbit hole in and of itself. And we often on the podcast drop the Nakamoto Institute's website as a as a great kind of jumping off point to all kinds of different contents and several different rabbit holes. [00:03:43] But your site is another one that I think needs to be mentioned more often and visited by all of the listeners and Bitcoiners out there. It's full of information about sort of the fundamentals, the political and philosophical sort of fundamentals behind Bitcoin, and that Bitcoin is sort of trying to create or like establish in the world, and you know, by by existing itself. [00:04:08] There's these sort of philosophical and political goals or ideals that have you know been discussed and researched and really solidified over you know jet many generations of you know thought leaders and maybe Bitcoin is kind of giving us a chance to sort of realize those things. [00:04:28] And I thought it would be great to speak with you today about your research and understanding. I know you've you're very well read in in these areas. So yeah, I think it'd be fun to kind of zoom out. And I what's I what I love about you, Max is that you know you've got both sides of the of the coin, right? You sort of have this big broad view of the philosophical political stuff, but you also have just a really kind of great understanding of the details as well, right? [00:04:54] And I think on the podcast that you did recently with Guy Swann on the crypto economy podcast, it was released a couple of weeks ago, was fantastic. And you guys definitely dove into the details and got into the weeds of all the technical stuff that's going on in Bitcoin, and I think that was super useful. And I listened to it twice actually. [00:05:14] So I thought it'd be a nice companion to sort of zoom out and talk about your understanding of all the political and philosophical stuff. So let's just dive in. Let's let's talk about I think the fundamentals behind you know anarchy and agarism, which sort of you know are political philosophies that that fit nicely with Bitcoin is this understanding of natural law. [00:05:36] So could you know talk about this fundamental understanding of natural law, what it is and why it's important. So natural law is this overarching philosophy that is taught by many different schools. So it's it's not something that that can be narrowed down to one, let's say, religion or or one philosophy or one teaching. [00:05:56] It somewhat goes deeper. And the basic understanding is property rights in and of itself. So you know, that individuals have their their ownership into their own physical body, right? Because they're the only one who can move them, and they've so to say homesteaded themselves at birth, so that these individuals can you know, I cannot force you to lift your right arm. [00:06:21] It's impossible for me to do that because you are the only one who has the power to do this. So in in that sense, you do have property rights in your own body. And then we can apply that further that you have property rights in all the tools and resources that you have claimed out of the abundance of nature. And this here in in general then burns down to negative rights. [00:06:44] So it's it's not what you can do, it's what you are not allowed to do. So do not kill, right? Do not take the life of someone else. That is theft. Do not steal the property rights of someone else in the form of physical goods, right? So do not do not take the meat and the beer of someone else. [00:07:05] Then also do not rape, I do not take the sexual consent, and do not trespass, meaning do not break into someone else's house and break his citadel and take that freedom away from them. So these are these are all the negative rights that that are defined in natural law, that that we can discover by reason, right? [00:07:30] By Hans Hermann Hoppe's argumentational ethics. We really have a logical and a sound argument on why these property rights exist, and that any individual has them and has the right to defend them. Right, and that's I mean, sort of the fundamental basis of a lot of moral teaching throughout history. [00:07:50] And then really where we kind of come at odds with natural law and sort of the way the society is organized now is the idea of the state. So where does the idea of the state I mean this idea that you need some sort of entity to enforce natural law has you know it's basically accepted around the world, you know, not by everybody, but it's sort of the way things are now. [00:08:15] Like I talk about default Keynesianism on the on the pot a lot. There's sort of this default statism situation as well. So I guess that's where anarchy comes in, right? This is the idea of like we don't need a state to enforce natural law. Yes, exactly, right? [00:08:34] Because the state, per definition, is an antithesis to natural law. I mean, Mary Rothbard has this great quote that government is a gang of thieves writ large, and that's exactly it, right? They they claim that they have the privilege and the right to take away the property of others without any moral or or philosophical harm to them. [00:08:57] So they are allowed to murder, right? They they can give out death penalties. They are allowed to go assault and take someone else's physical well-being, and for example, put them in prison. They are allowed to trespass, right with imminent domain and all this. They are allowed to coerce and you know, to force you to do something against your own free will, for example, with licensing. [00:09:20] And of course, they're also very much so allowed to steal your property in and of itself, right by by taking away your money through taxation. So these are all thefts that the government claims that they have the right to do, the man-made law. And this is in complete antithesis to natural law, which is universal and inherent and objective and especially non-men-made. [00:09:45] This is not something that that men has defined. This is something that men can discover. Kind of like money, right? Like money is a is a discovery, and men have or states have taken that discovery, basically the I guess the moved money from its natural state, right? [00:10:07] The way that we kind of discovered that technology to solve the quinces of ones, the barter problem, and created like basically said that we are going to now control this technology, control this discovery for our own ends, right? But they'll say publicly that you know we're going to improve the money, we're going you know, so that it'll function better for society and we'll you know reduce the inherent problems of capitalism, the swings, you know, up and down the depressions and the and the booms and bust cycle and all that, we'll be able to control it with this sort of scientific approach to money and economics. [00:10:46] So I definitely see you know a parallel there. Does that does that make sense to you? Oh yes, absolutely. I mean, money is a tool to defend your property rights and you know to hold your property rights in a given asset. Like for example, if you have a gold coin, I mean the direct theft is still rather easy to do, right? [00:11:08] You can just take a five dollar wrench and hit someone and then he will give you his gold coin. So so the physical theft is still present in in that sense, right? But that's inherent with any scarce meat space good. However, what gold defends against very well is against theft through inflation, right? [00:11:27] Because if you increase the money supply, the proportional holdings of any individual dilutes and decreases at the expense of all these individuals holding the money and for the benefit of the selected few who have the power to increase the money supply. Right? So inflation is theft. And a good money is a money that defends against this in this inflation cap. [00:11:49] And of course, Bitcoin does it beautifully by having every user run his own full node and define the money supply to be not greater than 21 million. So so, in this sense, Bitcoin is very a very good defensive tool against theft. And it also uses public private key cryptography in order to defend against the individual theft of the individual big coins, right? [00:12:12] Only he with the knowledge of the private key can spend this UTXO. And that is very much more difficult to coerce and to steal than, for example, a physical gold coin. Yeah. So human societies throughout history tend to evolve from, I guess, sort of an anarchic natural state, a state of nature, toward being more centralized, more statist. [00:12:39] And we've sort of seen that with money as well. [00:12:42] As a market comes to discover the most saleable good in that market, and that good becomes used as money regularly. [00:12:51] And then we sort of see this trend toward trying to control that money, towards centralizing it, the power of that money. So how can like how you know Bitcoin promises that we might be able to sort of take back control and decentralize that control of money again and kind of return it more to it toward its natural state? [00:13:17] What is the power of Bitcoin in your mind to be able to do that to our kind of political system as well? Yes, I think we are truly here in somewhat a spiral, right? [00:13:28] That's the pendulum always swinging from left to right [00:13:32] And upwards. In the sense that nobody likes to be raped. So that is kind of the default. [00:13:39] And people defend themselves against this kind of theft. [00:13:42] But eventually, you know, we get a bit complicit and we get comfortable and we lower our defenses. And then you know, after we are kind of lulified, thieves come in and take our stuff. And then we kind of tolerate this because, well, it's convenient, right? It's the status quo, you know, it's for the children, it's for the greater good. [00:14:02] And we get kind of brainwashed into accepting this this servitude and the slavery until there is a point where where the tyrant is so so oppressive and you know rapes you every single day that you're kind of fed up with it and then when the when the cost of this slavery is so extraordinarily high that the cost of defense you know is is much more justified and much more worth it that then you actually use tools of defense and weapons in order to reclaim your property rights and you know don't get trampled upon and you know we've seen that I think for example [00:14:40] With something the like the American Revolution right we had just extraordinary taxation by the British Empire and then a bunch of individuals were like no fuck you this is mine and I will not give it to you and come and take it and that then you know sparked the American Revolution where these freedom fighters stated and claimed their property rights and no longer got trampled upon and of course then that that led to a beautiful you know state which over more over longer period of time you know we again got lullified and got comfortable with the servitude and now we have the American Empire which is [00:15:18] Infinitely more tyrannical than the British Empire was back in the days. And I think Bitcoin now is that is that cry of freedom again to be no you will not get my property this is mine and you can you can claim it over my dead body and you know with a beautiful peaceful revolution as Bitcoin is so far at least it it has been a great success that individuals can defend themselves without bloodshed right without becoming violent in the physical realm, simply by using cryptography and other brilliant tools as defense. [00:15:53] Yeah. So do you think that this this revolution will remain peaceful? And in the idea of let's talk a little bit because I think this idea fits in there in in here as well, is the idea of agorism. Agorism is sort of I guess a form of anarchy, is that right? [00:16:14] Yes, I would I would say so it's it's maybe applied anarchy. So ag the agora is the Greek word for marketplace. But but it's much more than just a marketplace, it's a place where people and individuals come together freely and voluntarily, right? So so a family dinner is is the agora, for example. [00:16:34] And but agorism also contain entails anarchy, right? So it's a place without coercive rulers, right? Where we have peaceful and consensually agreed upon rules that that everyone follows. And then very important in agorism is the last A called action. So this is not a theoretical you know, sit together and talk about it, but this is actually apply it and engage only with those who respect freedom and property and selectively you know kick out those coercers who try to steal and rape others, and then build a local community, [00:17:13] A second realm, so to say, for individuals who have opted out of coercion and agree to see the benefits in mutual beneficial exchange. So agorism is is this threefold the agora, an anarchy, and in action. Okay, that's great. [00:17:31] So, how do you think I mean I guess so you in your mind we're building like Bitcoin represents this sort of second realm as you as you called it, right? Yes, exactly. So the first realm is a realm of coercion and of theft where some artificial ruler claims to have the right to take from others. [00:17:52] And the second realm is for those who who despise this coercion and voluntarily opt out into a different system that is in the sense not necessarily based on on natural law philosophy in general, or let's say explicitly, at least that's Smarklow did not talk about this in in his book, but definitely one without coercion, where individuals can engage freely and without attribution to their actions. [00:18:22] So it's it's I would say a mixture of natural law and crypto anarchy. So in this agora in this sort of second realm, how do we enforce these natural laws, right? These these agreed upon rules without a state. Of course, the state will say that we need to have this sort of judicial system, this system of punishment to enforce these natural laws on behalf of the society. [00:18:48] In this sort of anarchic agora second realm, how are those laws enforced? I think Bitcoin is the perfect example for this. It i you do it yourself, right? You run your own full node. First, you did you download the software and you compile it, right? So you define step by step exactly what the consensus or what the rules are, right? [00:19:11] And you yourself make sure or like set out what exactly what rules exactly to follow. Then at the second step, you connect to a network and you find other peers who have exactly the same consensus rules as you, right? So that is when you build your agora, when you build the second realm. [00:19:31] And ultimately, if there is a if there is someone who breaks your rules that you have defined, then you go out and kick him from the network, right? If if someone proposes nonsense like Bcash, you simply disconnect from them and you block their IP address and you never ever talk to them again. [00:19:50] You ostracize them, right? You simply ignore them. And you do that yourself. You don't beg for permission of a central third party to please enforce these laws on you, but you take it into your own responsibility. So, how does that translate to meet sp- you know, meat space like rules and laws and natural laws, right? [00:20:09] So the you know, you shouldn't kill or rape. It's it's a lot it's a little bit harder to write just like disconnect from someone who's like in your physical presence without having to you know impose your some kind of violence upon them, right? Oh yes, yes, absolutely. [00:20:28] So Bitcoin solves this beautifully in cyberspace, but it's a whole other problem to solve this in in meet space. And but here I think the principle is the same, right? Take responsibility for this, speak up. If you see someone stealing, then slap them, right? And make sure that they give back the property rights. [00:20:47] If you see someone raping another individual, then step in and stop the entire process. Right. So don't call the police and try to offload this responsibility because you cannot offload this karmic debt of seeing evil and being complicit by inaction, by by not stopping something that you know deeply and truthfully that is horrific. [00:21:10] And so ultimately it's it's be gone, right? And then of course there are different ways that we can structure this more let's say adequately, that the that we you know find a consensus amongst peers on you know what the rules are and if someone actually broke the rules. [00:21:29] So it's it's in that sense similar to how to how Bitcoin does it again, but applied to meat space. So for example, if if you build your citadel, right? Clearly define up front what the rules are. And anyone who wants to enter the citadel has to acknowledge that these are the rules and that and to promise that he will uphold the rules, and also acknowledge that if he breaks the rules, that he has to face some form of penalty. [00:21:54] Now the penalty might be ostracization, right? That he just gets kicked out of the citadel and is not allowed to come back. It might be something like you know a monetary payment. It might also be that he has to put an upfront bond. So let's say you have to put one Bitcoin in a multi-sig, that then and only then are you allowed to enter the citadel. [00:22:15] Or you might have some form of insurance or voucher system, that you can only enter the citadel if an already member of the citadel vouches for the for this individual coming in. So in that sense, you know, there are many, many, many countless different strategies, and ultimately I have no clue which one is a good strategy, and that is why we need to have this anarchy, right? [00:22:37] That we can experiment with these different rules sets that are voluntarily agreed upon to ultimately find something that that works. Yeah, because I mean that starts that sounds like the beginning of a state, you know, obviously to me. But what I do the idea I do like that makes sense for sort of a middle ground between this, you know, like the pendulum that we were talking about, swinging back and forth between sort of anarchy, peer anarchy and this you know oppressive centralized state statism that we're kind of find ourselves in in now, is is this idea that Michael Goldstein talked about on an episode of this podcast [00:23:15] That will, you know, this Bitcoin future will sort of create this decentralized network of political experimentation, right? So we might call them citadels right now, but there'll be some sort of geographic region where this, you know, this specific approach to organizing society is being tried. [00:23:36] And then over here in this other space, it's it's something, you know, there's a different approach, maybe slightly different or very different. But those sort of competing alternatives, political and societal organizational alternatives, are you know going to mutually improve one another and also give individuals a lot of choice, a large range of choice on how they want to, you know, engage with society. [00:24:02] Yes, exactly, absolutely. And I would just like to emphasize again what what anarchy actually means. I mean, it it comes from the Greek and which is the prefix meaning without or the absence of, and then the Greek noun archon, which means external master or external ruler. So anarchy does not mean no rules. [00:24:22] Quite on the contrary, it means no rulers, no one to enforce rules upon you without your consent. So in an anarchic system, we absolutely most definitely have rules. But the important thing is that they are agreed upon, that they are consensual, right? There are they're very, very strict Bitcoin consensus rules, and they are written in code and they they are there, right? [00:24:45] If you if you try to spend a UTXO without the correct signature, you break the rules. So they're clearly rules defined in Bitcoin. And in these meat space citadels, we will also have very clear defined rules. But the major difference that makes a citadel not a state is that every single individual in the citadel agrees to the set of rules, which in the state you cannot, right? [00:25:10] You have never agreed to any single of the rules that any government or state forces upon you. You've never done a signature saying, okay, I agree to every of the millions and billions of rules that are forced upon you. No. And that is what makes the state a state. It's not the existence of rules, it's the existence of aggressively enforced rules. [00:25:33] Yeah, that makes sense. And so maybe in a Bitcoin future, you know, if I like the idea of, you know, I have to, in order to gain entry into the citadel and be part of that community, I put a certain amount of Bitcoin into a multi-sig address, and at the you know, if I violate the rules of the citadel, or the you know the natural laws, the some of that bitcoin is taken, right? [00:26:03] That seems like a very like a nonviolent way to enforce an agreed upon set of rules. Now, if I if I decide that I don't agree with those rules anymore, right, and I want to go live in a different citadel, or I just want to kind of be out in free space on my own and you know maybe try to start recruiting some other people to live the way that I want to, then I could just take my you know take my Bitcoin and leave, right? [00:26:28] As soon as I leave the walls of the CITEL or the you know the geographical borders of the citadel. Exactly. And I think one of the perfect examples here is another beautiful software project, the BISC decentralized exchange, right? A self-hosted exchange. Every user who downloads the BISC client downloads again the rules of this protocol. [00:26:49] And by running it, he voluntarily agrees to apply by these rules. And then if you engage in a trade, you first lock up your Bitcoin as a collateral, right? You know, as a as a bounty, so to say, into this two of three multi-signature. That in the case that you break the rules, you lose something, right? [00:27:11] You have skin in the game, and you agree to this beforehand, right? And then once you have the skin in the game, and once you have this collateral up front, you engage with the peer-to-peer trade and you do the fiat payment or shitcoin payment. And then ultimately, when everything works out, both parties, the seller and the buyer, agree, and they put two signatures onto this deposit to then get back the Bitcoin of the trade as well as the security deposit. [00:27:39] And the beautiful thing is it works during the entire big BISC experiments in the early days Spit Square, I think 2014 it was started or 13 or 14, not one single malicious theft has occurred, right? Because there was always this upfront cost of if you try to cheat, not only is is there a possibility that you lose, it is actually written in code, right? [00:28:05] The arbitrator will sign this two of three signature or or UTXO, and then you will lose your Bitcoin. And this just means that there has never happened, that that a malicious user has successfully stolen property off a BISC trait simply by using this two of three multi-signature, which is one of the most powerful tools we have in Bitcoin. [00:28:27] It's amazing. So I think a lot of the hesitation of people, like when I talked about Bitcoin with my friends, and then if the conversation kind of follows into where we are, where we're talking about now, like the political philosophical implications of what Bitcoin could could mean for the future, there's a lot of discomfort, invariably. [00:28:53] And you know, I think I went through some of like negotiating that discomfort myself. And there are you know increasing amounts of Bitcoiners who are coming to Bitcoin and sort of discovering Austrian economics and discovering the ideas of anarchy and agorism. [00:29:12] And so there's a lot of discomfort confronting these ideas that are you know, basically like in a lot of senses the opposite of the default Keynesian default statism sort of lives that we've been leading, right? [00:29:31] And I think the discomfort really is rooted in this idea of personal responsibility, right? A sovereign individual to me means you know, in large part it means personal responsibility. And I think the way that we've been living in this statist world is the opposite of that, right? [00:29:52] We don't take personal responsibility for the defense of our money, for the defense of our person, for the defense of the natural laws or the rules that we want to live by. So there's a lot of there's this discomfort, right? [00:30:11] How do you think, you know, we as a collective whole of humanity that have been sort of living this way, and this this kind of glacial force that toward this this way of living, how do we turn that around? I mean, I you know we have Bitcoin sort of just like as this tiny little David versus the Goliath of this way of living. [00:30:33] Oh, absolutely. And maybe to quote Benjamin Franklin here, those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety, and they will lose both, right? And that is the state where we are. We have this convenience, right, of being quote unquote protected by the state, right? [00:30:55] And the status quo that everyone seems to follow. But the issue here is that if you get lulled into this obedience, then you do lose your safety, right? You are being stolen from, and you especially lose your liberty. No longer are free to do whichever you please. That does not harm any others. So in that sense, there there's definitely this this lullification, right? [00:31:17] You get used to it. You get you know get used to the shackles of your slavery. And because it's normal, right? Everyone does it, it does not seem to be wrong anymore. And it's and I think there are not very many individuals who value liberty above anything else. [00:31:37] I think it has always been a niche of a of a couple percentage points of individuals compared to the global society that are willing to incur great costs and great risks in order to claim their liberties. The individuals who fought in the American Revolution, they had to put up with a tremendous risk, and countless of them died because of them claiming their liberty. [00:32:00] But for these individuals, it was liberty or death. There is no other option. And thus I also think that, like I'm not one to a big proponent of the mass adoption of Bitcoin. Because I think if we wait for the masses, quote unquote, whoever that collective is, we will wait forever, right? [00:32:21] And the beauty of Bitcoin is that it does not need the masses. Bitcoin is a tool for individuals. If you individually want to defend yourself both against the theft of inflation and direct theft, then you can today, since 2009 run the Bitcoin protocol and claim your defense in this in this regard. [00:32:41] And so I personally always seek to build tools and to educate not the masses but individuals because these are the ones who actually will end up using this technology. So will we ever end up with mass adoption? Well, I think we can make a compelling economic argument that those individuals who do not defend themselves against inflation lose and thus you know their wealth diminishes and their resources diminish. [00:33:08] And those individuals who do defend themselves again in their property rights and in their capital, thus having more resources at their disposal. So I would say that there's definitely a tendency to use tools of defense, but I still think that it it's it's only very few individuals who actually occur the cost of ostracizing and breaking the status quo that that we Bitcoiners choose yeah I'm I'm going I'm quiet because I'm going I'm feeling that discomfort right now that I was just speaking of [00:33:46] You know really sitting down and speaking with you about the way that things may change for me it has you know the idea of Bitcoin has really awakened me to the way that I think humans are meant to live right which what we're talking about right now and I got there through I mean I obviously wasn't my initial the reason that I got into Bitcoin in the first place it wasn't because I understood all this it's taken me two years to [00:34:25] Really digest all this and kind of understand the implications of Bitcoin on you know the way I want to live my life and sort of make opening up this this whole that's why we call that's why we talk about the rabbit hole and the red pill it's sort of opening up this this whole way of existence that didn't seem like even an option or didn't even hadn't even occurred to me really how do you think like this but let's put aside the idea of mass adoption or whatever and I you know totally agree with you that you know Bitcoin is meant for the individuals to you know create sovereign individuals and allow that as a kind of an option to opt out into that second realm. [00:35:01] And that makes a lot of sense to me. So how do you think that Bitcoin changes individuals? Like once we an individual is introduced to Bitcoin and you know learns about it and sort of goes down the rabbit hole, the proverbial rabbit hole. [00:35:21] How has it changed you or how do you see it changing other Bitcoiners that you know and interact with? Well, you know, there there's on one side there's theory, right? There you can read thousands of books of Murray Rothbard or or you know other great thinkers of liberty. [00:35:40] And you know but this is just knowledge, right? This is this is knowledge that others can share with you and that you can accumulate until then ultimately you well understand it. You really come to an understanding that yes, voluntary exchange is a net benefit for everyone involved, even for the weaker party who is who is marginally worse at every task, like division of labor and voluntary exchange of the goods produced is beneficial for anyone. [00:36:13] But it is theory, right? It is it is in the realm of possibilities and in ideas, and Ludwig van Mises talks a lot about the power of ideas, and he he's absolutely right on this one. But what Bitcoin is, is that it is applied theory, right? It is it is not just you know us sitting sitting in chairs smoking a cigar, drinking whiskey and talking about it, it's us actually doing it, right? [00:36:40] And this application of the understood knowledge is what actually brings out the wisdom. And this is where Bitcoin is so unique that it it is this applied theory of self-defense and individual rights. And because it is applied, because you can actually see it, you can look through the looking glass and experience it for yourself. [00:37:03] That this is a system that is not just theoretically sound, but it is applicable in everyday life. And I think that is why Bitcoin is such a powerful red pill, because it is actual wisdom, it is applied truth. Yeah, I agree with you completely. It's this real-world instantiation of these ideals. [00:37:21] And exactly you can, you know, read or speak theory until you're red in the face, right? And it's but it's impossible to really get through to most people, I think, unless you have this very real practical way to show somebody to demonstrate exactly how it's supposed to be, right? [00:37:48] And that's exactly what Bitcoin is. I think we also have other examples of that, of course. You know, the internet, the idea, the idea of open source, which I know is really important to you. These are sort of like Bitcoin and open source software, sort of like these decentralized defense technologies, right? [00:38:09] And I think it that is really the key difference between you know, like the American revolution, which required the defense technologies were you know, the internet didn't exist, and so the way we defended ourselves, you know, was on a very specific spot, you know, place on a battlefield, and you know, marched toward each other and shot each other and you know, whoever had the you know least the lowest death count were you're considered the winners. [00:38:38] And those you know, wars lasted for years and years, like you said, were incredibly costly in terms of life and resources and everything and caused a lot of misery for a long time. But I think the difference now, and again, that's kind of the discomfort factor. Another one of the things that we're feeling kind of uncomfortable about the idea of the fear that comes from the idea of kind of seizing your liberty back and taking it back. [00:39:07] The difference now though is that we have these sort of decentralized technologies, and Nic Carter's recent piece that you sort of alluded to earlier, this most peaceful revolution. I think that's what allows for a peaceful revolution, right? Or a more peaceful revolution, is that we have these technologies, these defensive technologies now that will allow us to claim our liberty at much less physical risk. [00:39:34] Exactly. The cost of defense has drastically decreased, right? And that is that is the entire ethos of crypto anarchy. For example, private public key cryptography, right? It is a trivial cost, almost non-existent, to compute a private key, a random number, and then do some elliptical curve compute computation to generate the public key. [00:39:54] And you can prove knowledge of the private key, for example, with a signature without revealing the private key in and of itself. And the cost of doing that is almost zero, right? It's it's you can flip a coin and do the calculation by hand if you want to. It's as easy as that. But to reverse the computation, right, to take the public key and compute the private key is so exponentially, unbelievably more difficult that even the sun does not produce enough energy in order to you know to do this computation. [00:40:26] It is it is unbelievably a powerful asymmetry of power. Very easy to defend, exponentially costly to attack. And that is the ethos that Bitcoin is built upon. [00:40:39] It's unbelievably easy to run your own full node. You can do it on a Raspberry Pi [00:40:44] If you can get for a couple bucks, right? But in order to attack you, right? You first need to break for direct theft private public key cryptography, which we've just established is pretty much impossible. And then second, you have to coerce every single full node user to change the rules. And that is unbelievably difficult, especially because a Bitcoin full node can be run by any individual without attributing themselves, right? [00:41:09] It's completely private system, and you can run it over Tor, you know, getting the blocks over satellite or or whatever. So the cost of defense has drastically decreased. And this makes this liberty more accessible, more approachable to more individuals who previously thought that the defense was too costly, and thus they did not defend themselves. [00:41:30] So in that sense, Bitcoin is a phenomenal tool to enable more individuals to defend themselves. Now I still think that many individuals still say that this cost is too much, right? Because you know you get ostracized for you by your community for breaking the status quo, you don't quote unquote pay your fair share and all this, right? [00:41:51] So there's definitely still risk and cost involved, but ultimately it is a lot, lot lower with Bitcoin, and thus more individuals have the power or or at least the option to def to defend themselves. Yeah, and I think the fact that these technologies are decentralized also makes them much harder to attack, not just the cryptography, but the decentralization matters as well it's a lot harder to you know take down Bitcoin network because there's you know ostensibly millions of us all over the world there's a hundred thousand nodes you know tens of ten thousand plus that are that are publicly [00:42:29] You know declared out there all over the world same thing with open source software right open source is has yeah go ahead and right so decentralization another word for that is just individual responsibility right you download the software you verify it and you run it right and you enforce the software what whatever is defined in so so in that sense it's the decentralization is so powerful because it is individuals and acting and it's not a trusted custodial central third party it is actual individuals claiming their sovereignty and applying it in their everyday [00:43:07] Life exactly yeah yeah and there's just I mean so much so many of these technologies available through the open source ethos and community and it's open source is has won over closed source and we're you know very slowly but very surely evolving toward a world where all of the best software is going to be open source is open source and we can we can live on our our digital lives on completely open source software at this point exactly, [00:43:46] Absolutely right and maybe here we can drill down on a topic that I find absolutely fascinating, and that is the aspect of scarcity which which I've actually written my bachelor's thesis about it because it's just such a phenomenal the thing. Basically scarcity is the underlying reason why we need property rights. [00:44:05] So scarcity means that there are limited quantity of resources that are exclusive, meaning, right? If if we have a tree, then either Alice can use it to build a house or Bob can use it to build a boat, right? There is no possibility that Alice and Bob can use the same log of wood in order to produce two different goods. [00:44:30] So the quantity is limited and it is exclusive, and so there's a potential conflict over who can control these resources, and thus we need rules in order to allocate these resources and to define who can use what. And that is you know either a complete tyranny, right, where a ruler class decides on where these resources are allocated, right? [00:44:52] That is the state, or it is individuals where they can homestead these abundant goods and then you know, as first users do with them as they please. That is liberty, that is anarchy. But very importantly, this only applies to scarce resources, right? And they are also non-scarce resources, meaning that they're either abundance so that anyone can use them, or that they are non-exclusive. [00:45:19] And powerful non-scarce good is speech, right? The words that I speak right now, I do not sacrifice them, I do not give them up, right? I give them to you, the audience, and you can accumulate these non-scarce resources, but I retain the knowledge myself. So because it is not exclusive, yeah. [00:45:41] Exactly, and therefore, we do not we do not need property rights in order to allocate these non-scarce resources, because anyone who would ever want them can have them, right? And that is the ethos of open source. This is not property rights of the individual who has created or articulated this knowledge, but the knowledge itself is in the public domain. [00:46:02] It is a comments that anyone can use, and that is free and open source software. Right, you can you can download the source code, you can it's inspect the source code, and you can do whatever you want with it, because it is it is neither the property of the individual who has created it, and it's also not the property of the individual who uses it. [00:46:21] It is not property, it is comments, it is a non-scarce abundance and non-exclusive good. [00:46:30] Yeah, that makes I mean that makes perfect sense to me. And that's why that's why open source is winning, right? And that's why it works, because it's it's true, it's right, it's correct, and it produces a better quality product in the end. [00:46:49] Exactly, and I would say that is because it is coherent with natural law principles, right? Because it does not harm others, it does not take away from others, like in the like in quote unquote intellectual property rights do, right? For example, if if I say, okay, I've written this piece of software and nobody's allowed to use it, and if someone uses it, then I can you know extract the fine from them. [00:47:12] I can use government power in order to steal that money from them, then I am the aggressor, right? If if I want to force others who have who've come to my knowledge to not use it and extract some resources from them, that is the aggression, right? That is the evil so open source is thus in accordance to not stealing right then it's it's in accordance to giving away what is what is abundant because nobody is harmed and seeing that through logically to the end yeah and the you know the alternative [00:47:50] I guess view to that is the idea of closed source and you know I think Microsoft you know back in the day although what's ironic is that Microsoft is totally embraced or not totally but has embraced more open source a bit more but the you know Bill Gates and early Microsoft really represented the argument of closed source software and the main thrust of the argument is simply that if you can't profit from the your your work right the knowledge that you have you know used to produce [00:48:29] This practical good the software then you will have no innovation right I think we've seen very clearly that that open in the open source movement that that's just not the case [00:48:44] Exactly yeah right absolutely and it is because individuals have the opportunity to collaborate together in order to create more advanced ideas and to you know spitball against each other here and you know someone proposes something others review it and they improve it and it's it's this collaborative sharing of knowledge. [00:49:04] So to discover a more condensed version of the truth and apply to software to discover software that is rid of bugs and that actually does very efficiently what it seeks out to do. So you know, because it's it's this full realization of the immense power of ideas that are non-scarce, so to you know allocate resources and in this sense developer time more efficiently. [00:49:31] Yeah, and there are still very profitable businesses that are built on open source software because there are you know non-scarce services and goods that you can create that utilize that open source software, you know. I think cold card wallet is a really good example, right? That's using a lot of open source technology. [00:49:49] It's so like even the schematics for physically producing that good is has been released by Nopara and it's out there, like it's open source. However, you know, CoinKite and is still selling a lot of cold cards, right? And the services that come along with that, like Wasabi. [00:50:10] Yes, yeah, yes, exactly. But but but on this sense, right, that the physical cold card itself, the individual unit, that is of course scarce, right? Either I hold it or you, right? And we cannot use it at the same time, both. So so they are selling scarce goods, but they are sharing the ideas on how they have produced this scarce good. [00:50:29] Right. And you know, I think another phenomenal example is is Wasabi wallet or or other coin joint providers. So here we have absolutely 100% free and open source software, the Wasabi wallet client and back-end server itself, but the added service, the extra benefit of coordinating a coin joint where individuals collaborate together to batch their transactions in a privacy-preserving manner. [00:50:56] That in and of itself is exclusive, right? There's only a limited amount of peers that can be in this coin join, and wasabi it's 100. And so this is exclusive, right? Either Alice joins or Bob. [00:51:09] It cannot be 200 people joining at the same time. [00:51:13] And because it is exclusive, it is scarce, right? And so there is a need to allocate these resources of who can partake in the coin join. And thus there's a price for it, right? Because that is an efficient way of allocating the resource. Right, right. Well, this is a good segue into talking about privacy. [00:51:34] I think privacy is something that I sort of had get had given up on before Bitcoin. Even though I knew that cryptography existed, etc. You know, after the Snowden revelations, I was sort of resigned to the fact that we're just going to be living in this, you know, era of forced, you know, utter transparency, robbed of all privacy effectively. [00:52:01] And honestly, that was a I mean, that was a terrible feeling. It was a very it was very defeating, created this sort of sense of hopelessness. Yeah, a future that I didn't want to live in or to bring children into, or you know, I felt like there was no reason to really can like to fight against it. [00:52:24] It was just too too much strong of a force. The NSA was just too strong and too big, and there was nothing that could stop it. The fact that Bitcoin has persisted for almost 11 years now, using cryptography and a peer-to-peer network, and the idea of the ideas of decentralization and open source has really proven that these technologies can be used to in the face of such massive power to rob you of your privacy. [00:53:01] Do you think privacy is one of those natural laws, a right to privacy? And if so, how does that sort of fit into the idea of theft? I guess you know it would be stealing of privacy, right? Well, I think privacy is more a tool in order to defend because privacy fundamentally breaks the UDA loop, which is which is a quite interesting concept. [00:53:24] Basically it's it says that humans in in any situation act in the following way. First, you observe what is around you, right? You accumulate knowledge. Then you orient yourself based on your surroundings, right? You try to understand the knowledge that you've accumulated, then you decide what to do, right? [00:53:43] You formulate a strategy based on that understanding. And ultimately, you act, right? And you do whatever you want to do in the surroundings. This is a general schema, but it can be applied to people stealing, right? So you observe someone doing an act and you orient yourself, right? [00:54:04] You put it into context, and you decide that this that this act by the other individual was wrong, and so you steal from him, right? So, for example, the government observes that you have income of a specific quantity, and they orient it, right? They they put it into context, and they decide, okay, 50% of that I will steal. [00:54:25] And then they act, knocking on your door with guns in hand, threatening yourself and your family, so that they get their 50% of what is rightfully yours. And so, how do we break against that? And that is where the idea of crypto anarchy comes in to you know to occult, to hide, to break the observation and the orientation. [00:54:46] And we do that by privacy, right? So if you earn your wealth in a way that nobody can observe you doing, right? Then nobody can orient and put this into context because they don't know that you have earned something or how much you have earned, and thus they can also not decide and act on how much to steal from you, because they don't even know about it in the first place. [00:55:08] And that is where privacy comes in. It breaks the UDA loop at the very root, it breaks the observation and the orientation of your action. And that is privacy in general, right? If you can selectively reveal whom you tell about your actions, you also select on who can you know enforce something based on that. [00:55:27] And that is where privacy comes in. For I wouldn't say that privacy in inherently is like an explicit right. I think it's just it's it is inherent in individual free action to not share everything with everyone, but you can just not tell someone a thought that you have in your mind. [00:55:47] But but that is like that that is that that is encompassed in in individual freedom in general. It is just a status quote, but it is definitely a tool in order to defend yourself, right? And then the state will say that privacy is also a tool to violate others, right? [00:56:07] Because if we can't observe how someone is making money, we you know may not know that they're doing it in ways that that will hurt others or are you know is actively hurting others. Exactly, right? The same concept applies. If you want to steal from someone, the way you should go about it, well, of course you shouldn't, but the way you would go about it is to try not to be observed. [00:56:31] I you try to sneak into someone's house and then steal. You don't drink on the door and you know attribute yourself with this. You want to you want to make this in secret. So absolutely thieves use good technology, right? Thieves use shoes so they can run better, they use cars so they can drive faster, the and of course they use guns in order to you know and instract their force. [00:56:55] And ultimately also they will use privacy tools because it is a good tool, it is useful to achieve the goal. And of course, for a thief, the goal is to you know falsefully and wrongfully accumulate property, but this doesn't mean that the tool in and of itself is bad, because you can use the same tool in order to defend yourself. [00:57:13] Right. That makes sense. And it goes back to the quote that you cited earlier. I think it was Benjamin Franklin, right? So a person who gives up liberty in exchange for security, you know, deserves neither and will get deserves neither. Is that what it is and we'll get neither? Deserves neither and lose both. Yeah, deserves neither and loses both. [00:57:34] Right. And that's I mean, that's the answer to that to that question, right? And that's where that's what Franklin was Franklin was exactly answering is you know, hey, we need transparency in order to enforce these natural laws, right? Otherwise if we if we you know don't if we can't see the actions of criminals, we won't be able to enforce these laws. [00:57:55] And he's like, no, there's that's a slippery slope, and it'll just lead to an eradication of your privacy and liberty. Yes, exactly, right? We that there are infinite possibilities of things that can go wrong and individuals who can steal from you. There are infinite ways that that can happen. [00:58:14] And if you get scared by that possibility, so that you know want to gain convenience and the quote unquote security of not you know living in this infinite realm of possibility and you give up essential liberties in order to get some you know some of that security back some of that how do you call it some of that certainty right that oh okay I know every I know what everyone is doing so if someone is malicious then I will find out before he can actually act. [00:58:45] But of course that's an impossibility right it's it it can never happen that you have the infinite resources and infinite knowledge to then you know find out exactly if someone is going to steal from you. There will always be malicious actors who find a way around your your defense of knowledge and then to give up liberties for this is in my opinion a major flaw in strategy yeah that's a good way to put it all right I want to ask you about about this idea of you know that I've [00:59:23] Been talking about on the podcast recently with Gigi and Hass and it's come up basically in every I think episode since then this idea of the parallels between religion and the way Bitcoin is spreading and sort of inspiring individuals to adopt principles inherent to the truth of sound money and openness, open source and decentralization. [00:59:47] So I know I was reading through the materials on your site, Towards Liberty.com, and after the political and philosophical works, there's a bit of reference reference to resources that are more metaphysical, mystical, religious. So I know that you've been studying these topics. [01:00:06] Do you see what do you think about the idea of the parallels between the way a religion works and spreads and the way Bitcoin is working and spreading? Yeah, so so that's that's what I meant earlier with with that natural law goes goes beyond religion. We can find these teachings of don't steal and harm others in in most any religion. [01:00:28] We see it in Christianity, we see it in Hinduism, we see it in Islam, we see it in Hermeticism and Gnosticism, Rosicrucianism, Freemasonry. There they're countless religions that have inklings of this teaching. And in that sense, of course, Bitcoin does as well. Bitcoin is being part of maybe the crypto anarchist religion. [01:00:47] Basically it's individuals defending their their own rights, right and to you know agree to not harm others. And in this sense, Bitcoin is part of this broader range of many religions trying to teach you know this this way of life, this is mental framework. [01:01:09] And here again I think Bitcoin is such such an effective way of teaching this because it is applied in the real world. Right? It's it's not just you know, the theory and the gospel that that we go to church to be spread, but it's [01:01:26] Something that we can experience as a very individual level. [01:01:30] Like a in that we can experience as a direct conversation with God in and of itself. Like not through a middleman of a priest spreading the gospel. No, but by you running your own full node and thus experiencing firsthand the power of sovereignty and of freedom. And in that sense, Bitcoin is a very very pure and a very direct way of conversing with the divine. [01:01:52] That's fascinating. Yeah. As a you know alternative sort of implementation, I guess you could say, of religion of Christianity, for instance, let's say the Roman Catholic Church is sort of this kind of statist implementation of Christianity. And in that you know, tradition, there is a Pope, and the Pope is the only individual who has a direct connection to God and every and everything flows down from that person, right? [01:02:24] Whereas, you know, maybe a let a more decentralized version of Christianity would be like Gnosticism, which kind of has this idea that you know God is within you and you have this personal connection to God, and there's no like this sort of formalized religion is you know actually antithetical to the way that you should experience Christianity. [01:02:47] Yeah, so I that that seems that that makes sense. The idea that you know Bitcoin is decentralized and individual, and we have this sort of you know this we're sovereign. We have our own sovereign connection to our our to our value, to the store, you know, the time that we've stored on the time battery that is Bitcoin. [01:03:11] Yes, exactly. Right. And in that sense it's it's very direct, it's it's applicable to everyday life and experienceable by by anyone. And that that makes it a very I think a very effective way of teaching. And that is one of the great strengths of Bitcoin, right? [01:03:33] That and I think that's also one of the reasons why it it's it's it's such an effective red pill, right? That that once you take a taste of you know permissionless freedom of transaction, that that because you've actually experienced it, you don't necessarily have to understand it, but you've experienced it, right? [01:03:51] You've reached this this level of gnosis of like applied understanding. And that goes very, very deep. And then once once you have experiences, you're like, what the fuck did I just do? Like this is awesome, but what the hell? And then you start falling down the rabbit hole, and then you're intrigued into finding out more about what exactly you know is is happening here also on the philosophical and theoretical level. [01:04:18] And that's then where you go into Austrian economics and to cypherpunk philosophy into the cryptography and the code to try to grasp the you know complete holistic and very fractal nature of Bitcoin. Yeah. So what what technologies are you most excited about coming up for Bitcoin that are on on the horizon for Bitcoin? [01:04:43] Taproot. That is just a behemoth of an upgrade. It is it is so all-encompassing, it is it it it improves Bitcoin on so many many levels. And you know, after a lot of research, I still have not found any major downsides other than of course changing the protocol, which is always a risk. [01:05:02] But but basically the beauty of Taproot is that we commit less data onto the time chain, right? We reveal less information to the entire network of peers, and of course anyone observing that network. So we reduce the observation of what is actually going on while still retaining the complete audibility of the entire Bitcoin protocol. [01:05:26] So you know, a good example for this is is how multi-signatures are done right now is you put into the commitment script three public keys, and then in the redeem script in the witness script, you put on, for example, two signatures, and now every full node verifies that these two signatures are part of the three public keys, and also of the multi-sig script saying that it is a two of three multi-signature. [01:05:51] But this this kind of puts the verification of the of the multi-sig scheme onto the external full nodes, right? And every full node needs to observe and verify that this is actually a proper spending of the multi-sig. And that is great, it is unbelievably powerful, but with Taproot, we can do better. [01:06:12] Why? Because it uses Schnorr signatures, and Schnorr signatures is a linear scheme, and this enables something called aggregation. So basically, we take three public keys and in a non communicative or non interactive way, we aggregate three individual public keys into one aggregated public key, and we commit only this one aggregated public key onto the timechain as the commitment of who can spend that money. [01:06:40] What do you what do you mean by non-interactive? Basically, you if Alice, Bob, and Charlie have their three individual public keys, all that they need to know is the three public keys. And so that is one round of communication, right? Alice sends her public key to Bob and Charlie, Bob to Charlie and Alice, and Charlie to Alice and Bob. [01:07:00] Right. And as soon as they have all the public keys, they can create the aggregated public key without any additional rounds of communication. Okay, gotcha. And that is contrary to how you produce a signature for this. Because here you have three steps of interaction where you where you exchange nonce commitments and nonces and then finally the signature. [01:07:22] So this is a multi-round communication step between Alice, Bob, and Charlie. But basically, what they can do is they can you know, for example, take three signatures, or in a more advanced scheme, even two signatures, and they can aggregate two signatures into one aggregated signature. So they take two of their individual private keys, they produce a individual signature or two individual signatures over the same message, and then they take these two signatures and aggregate them into one aggregated signature. [01:07:56] And that's what's given it to the time chain. Exactly. And for any full node, to have the aggregated public key and the aggregated signature is enough to verify that whatever was behind this one single public key was computed as valid in this aggregated signature. [01:08:15] So we still have full verification. It is impossible to produce a signature, like let's say to take one individual private key to produce one individual signature and then produce a valid two of three multi or moose signature. That is impossible. It's cryptographically not doable. [01:08:34] So you can only produce a valid signature if all the individual private public keys or private keys that are committed to in the aggregate public key have agreed to them. So we still have full verification, but with much less commitment to the time chain. Just one public key and just one signature. [01:08:53] That's I mean it's kind of the best of both worlds, right? And we've been looking for a way to improve privacy on the base layer without harming auditability. And Taproot seems to do that. Exactly. We take away the attribution and the observation that this is a that this is a multi-sig scheme. [01:09:12] In the old incumbent system, we see, okay, three public keys, two signatures. This is clearly a two-of-three multi-signature. With Taproot, all you see is one public key and one signature. And you have no clue if that is actually one individual public key and signature, or a two-of-three signature, or a five-of-five signature. [01:09:31] It is impossible to tell. [01:09:34] Yeah, and so like I guess I should say that it's increasing the privacy of your sort of business dealings, your economic interactions. But it doesn't necessarily change the like anonymity or pseudonymity of the network. But yeah, the privacy in the sense of what the hell you're doing with your Bitcoin, especially when you're interacting with you know many other parties at the same time. [01:10:00] So I think that that's a big improvement in in in privacy of your of the way that you're using your money. Exactly, exactly. And you know, another another cool thing that you can do is you can have a script so a more advanced more advanced spending condition, more advanced than just one single public key. [01:10:24] And you have several of these spending conditions. So for example, you know, for your for your cold stash, you say, okay, I want to have a two or three multi-signature as the basic spending condition, right? That most certainly I will use. But in the case that something happens, let's say after one year, I want to be able to have a one of three signatures where I control all these keys. [01:10:48] And maybe I also want to have that after two years, my family has a three of five multi-signature so that they you know can spend this in this in the case something happens. And after five years, that's the very worst case. I want to have a one of two multi-signature that two lawyers you know control and they have some other agreements with the lawyers when they or how they can sign. [01:11:12] And we can take all these individual spending conditions and we put them into a Merkle tree. So so we hash them individually together, and then we commit in one single hash to every single spending condition that we've laid out. And what we do with this Merkle route that commits to all of these scripts is that we tweak it onto the public key. [01:11:37] And so tweaking is just basically multiplication. Very simple math formula. But what this gives us is a tweaked public key. And that tweaked public key looks indistinguishable to a single public key or to an aggregated multi-signature public key. [01:11:56] And we can commit then this tweak public key onto the time chain and you know put a UTXO onto. And then if we want to spend it, we can use one of these scripts. And we can reveal, let's say if you know it's it's it's the family case, so it's a three or five multi-signature, which in the case of Taproot would of course be a single public key again. [01:12:19] But we take this three or five multi-signature, and we put the witness script of this three or five multi-signature onto the time chain, together with a Merkle proof that proves that this specific script was part of the Merkle route that was to committed to that, was tweaked into the public key. [01:12:38] So we have a proof that at the time of funding this UTXO, this script was a correct and a valid spending condition of this coin. But the beautiful thing is we do not reveal about all the other spending conditions, so it's it's it does not reveal that there was the two of three multi-signature or there was the one of two multi-signature with the lawyers, and that is completely hidden into the hash itself and not possible to find out for an outset observer, but again, we still have full verification that the spending condition that was actually used was committed to at the time of funding the Bitcoin UTXO. [01:13:16] That's amazing, and all of this is possible, taper it's possible with software. Yes, exactly. It was not yet much discussion on which exact activation method was used. Maybe it's gonna be BIP 8, so that there is you know a time, a flag day where it will be active. [01:13:38] Because again, it is a software, we don't break any rules, so we're gonna do it. The question is just how do we coordinate so that the upgrade mechanism is smooth? But but ultimately I'm I hope that we reach consensus amongst this and have a swift activation because it truly is a powerful tool. [01:13:56] It's amazing. How about on the lightning network? What are you excited about in terms of upgrades and upcoming improvements? Tap root again. What is the lightning network based on? Yeah, it's based on a two of two multi-signature, right? Right. And it that can be optimized. [01:14:16] That's the basic channel agreement is a two of two multi-signature, right? Exactly. And so that gets more efficient, more private. So you no longer know that you're opening or closing in a cooperative way a lightning channel. It's just a single pub key and signature. That is phenomenal. And another thing that is that is in my opinion the most exciting thing about Tabroot, and it can be used in Lightning Network as well, is the concept of adapter signatures. [01:14:41] And basically what this does, it's it's the same method as hashed time-locked contracts that are currently already used in the Lightning Network. So we have a secret, the hash pre-image, just a random piece of data, then we commit to the secret by hashing it that reveals the hash digest itself. [01:14:59] Then we commit the secret in a Bitcoin script. Sorry, we commit this hash into a Bitcoin script, and at a later point in time, we reveal the secret, right? We reveal the pre-image, and based on that revelation of the previously committed secret, something happens. For example, the route in the lightning network succeeds. [01:15:20] So we build a route of several hash hash digests, and then as soon as the secret is revealed, everyone gets paid. So this is the basic concept. And we can do the same functionality-wise with adapter signatures. So we take a secret and we commit to the secret, but we don't commit to it by hashing, but we commit to it by tweaking the public key, similar to how Taproot is tweaked. [01:15:47] Okay. And so this tweaked public key is a commitment to the secret. And at a later point in time, we reveal the secret, but not by revealing a hash pre-image, but by producing a signature with the tweaked private key. So we take the same secret, we tweak our private key, and then we sign a message with that. [01:16:08] And this message to not to everyone, but only to one who who knows about this this thing happening and who has some other secret, he can find out about this adapter secret in the adapter signature, and then do something with this secret. So we can do the same again in Lightning Network, that we build a quote unquote hash time log contract chain of routes, but instead of using hashes, we use public keys, and instead of using a pre-image, we use the signature. [01:16:39] And again, this gives us plausible deniability because all that everyone sees is a public key and signature, and it's unclear that this is actually this adapter signature, that this has the functionality of an HTLC, which again breaks the observation. And this makes Lightning Network much more efficient and much more private. [01:16:58] But one additional thing outside of the Lightning Network that is is so monumentally huge is atomic UTXO swaps. So when you talk about UTXO swaps, most of the time we think of shitcoin gambling, like you atomically swap your Bitcoin to another chain and get a shitcoin for it. [01:17:19] And you know that that is nice and all if you want to gamble, but I'm interested in privacy, and atomic UTXO swaps are an unbelievable powerful privacy weapon. So the basic functionality is that there are Alice and Bob, and Alice has a UTXO, and Bob has a UTXO. [01:17:38] And now they want to swap their UTXO atomically. So Alice puts her coin into a two of two Moosec adapter secret public key. And Bob also puts his coin into a completely different multi-signature you know special construction. [01:17:58] So we have two setup transactions. Alice puts her money onto the line, and Bob in a different second transaction, put his money onto the line. And then when Alice takes the output that Bob has created in the second transaction, then she she can take that money and spend it to whatever output she wants, probably her own public key. [01:18:20] But by the act of her spending it in the signature itself, she reveals to Bob and only to Bob the secret that Bob needs in order to take the output of the first transaction that Alice has committed to. So basically, Alice has the input of one transaction and she gets the output of the second transaction. [01:18:42] Okay, and Bob has the input of the second transaction, but he gets the output of the first. Is that that's possible now, or with that's going to be possible with Taproot? It is possible already today with using elliptical curve adapter, elliptic curve digital signature algorithm, so ECD is A what Bitcoin is using currently, that also has the same functionality. [01:19:06] But because ECD is A is not linear, it is much more complex, more rounds of communication, and there is no security proof. With Schnorr signature, everything gets easier. So all of these advanced signature crypto tricks become a lot more easy and the proven secure with Schnorr. So the full power will be released with Schnorr, although we can already do it today. [01:19:30] And I assume that Schnorr and Taproot will also improve the coin join process. In a very minor way, yes, and in the way of batch verification. So that is the scalability of full note, right? The ability to verify every transaction improves here. [01:19:50] Because what so if there are, for example, in a coin joint transaction, there are let's say 200 inputs, and so there are 200 public keys and 200 signatures. Instead of verifying one public key, one signature, the next public key, and the signature and the next public key, and so to make 200 signature verification computations, what we do is we aggregate, or sorry, not aggregate, we batch all the public keys, and we batch all the signatures, and then we do one computation of the batched signature with the batch public key. [01:20:28] And this batched verification is only valid if all the individual signatures are valid. So it becomes more efficient to verify you know large quantities of signatures. But that is, as of now, the only way that a coin join in and of itself improves. What we can do, however, is we can do atomic swaps into and out of a coin join. [01:20:53] Because the problem right now is if Alice buys her coins on a KYC exchange and she begs for permission to stack her SATS and reveals her identity with that, and then she does a coin join with that UTXO, then the KYC exchange knows that Alice did the coin join, right? And that is attribution again. [01:21:10] The exchange does not know which output Alice has received out of the coin join, [01:21:16] But the exchange knows that Alice was part of the coin join. And so what we can do is that instead of Alice going into a coin join directly, Alice can do an atomic swap with, for example, Bob, where Alice sends her individual coin and Bob gets that individual coin in the transaction. [01:21:36] And Alice gets the output not in a regular transaction, but actually in a coin join of itself. So this way Alice gets the anonymity set of an equal value coin joint transaction without actually revealing that she was part of this round because her individual UTXO that is tied to her identity just had a single pub key single signature, one UTXO transaction. [01:22:01] Yeah, but doesn't batching in store signature Schnorr signatures also allow like improve or like I guess decrease the ability of a KYC exchange to see that I was part of a coin join transaction, right? Because everything is there in one signature instead of the you know the 200 signatures that we're talking about before, we batch that all into one, and then it just looks like a regular single single sign transaction. [01:22:29] That is something called cross-input signature aggregation. And although it is unbelievably awesome, and I'm so so happy that we found this, but it will not be included in the Taproot software, because it is a much more encompassing change to the consensus rules. But basically, what it does is that so in a coin join transaction, there are let's say 200 inputs, right? [01:22:54] So 200 individual public keys in 200 individual UTXOs, right, that come from different transactions. So we still see which UTXO is being spent, right? So so a bit different to what you said, we would still see that Alice's coin is part of the coin join, right? [01:23:12] Because the UTXO itself, with the transaction output reference to the previous transaction, that is included in the transaction. However, what we can do is that all of these 200 peers collaborate together in a multi-round communication process in order to create a aggregated signature, and this aggregated signature is valid only if all of the 200 individual public keys have produced a valid signature in this aggregated process. [01:23:46] So we have 200 inputs but only one signature, right? And this this means that it is a lot, lot, lot cheaper to do a coin join, right? Because a signature, instead of having 200 signatures, which are huge, right? Twice as large as the input reference itself, we only have one signature. [01:24:06] And so this means that a coin join is the most efficient and the cheapest way of transacting Bitcoin, right? Because if you have a transaction with one input and one output, this one input has one signature, right? So one input pays for the whole entire signature. But if we have 200 inputs and only one signature, then every input only pays one two hundredth of that signature. [01:24:33] So per input, it's much cheaper to have this private coin joint transaction. And privacy will be default. I was under the impression that we'd be getting that with Schnorr/slash Taproot. But you're you're selling that you're saying that that's not gonna that's not the case. It is a feature that is possible only with Schnorr signatures. [01:24:53] Right. But in this first soft fork activation, we get the tabroot functionality. And that does not that does not define the consensus rules to have this cross-input signature aggregation, right? Because taproot stays within one UTXO. [01:25:11] Every single UTXO has one taproot proof. Sure. And so in that sense, it's it's a less crazy change to the protocol, right? Because if if we say that one input, like or 200 inputs now only have one witness program, that is a massive change to the consensus rule. [01:25:31] So there we need to do a lot more research, a lot more you know peer review on of especially also the code, because this will change the functionality of consensus quite drastically, and consensus is a fickle thing. So we need to be careful not to break anything here. That is first and foremost. [01:25:50] So I'll I like it that this is separate because it truly is a whole other bag of forums that we can open here. It makes sense, it makes sense. All right, man. This has been a great conversation. I've got to get home and get to bed. I really appreciate your time. I think it's exciting. [01:26:10] You're a very impressive Bitcoiner man. Like you've it's amazing how how much breadth and depth you've been able to achieve, and I think it's great what you're contributing to the to the scene. And all while not not being a coder. So I think that that's great. [01:26:30] I think that should serve as inspiration to all of the non-coding Bitcoiners out there that you can dive in and understand this the system at a higher level than the code level and still be able to really contribute to the development of the code and what's going on. Exactly. [01:26:48] Real man, this is this is so important to emphasize. Like I'm a complete noob when it comes to coding. I just tried bare script a couple days ago and miserably failed. So you know, this Bitcoin is such an all-encompassing behemoth that we don't need to have like C developers who like crazy shit on the on the code base. [01:27:11] I mean that is a very powerful skill, but again, division of labor, right? Even if you cannot code, you can do stuff that others cannot. And by you focusing on the things and the tasks that you are good at doing, the others will have a very like they can focus their time on coding. Right. So for example, for me, it was first and foremost education, and same as you are doing here with this podcast, that's something that anyone can do. [01:27:35] Like if you if you have a skill of talking and you know of having a well and a prolific voice and prolific speech, that's great. I know, but then there are like the nerd coders who don't get their mouth open to explain anything right so so they won't make podcasts and hour long videos explaining this stuff but they build awesome shit right or or then also just bug reports i mean like if you're a user of software if you find an issue report it hopefully like most likely the devs don't know about the bug and then you know they they can find it they can look for it that they can fix it so buffer is some [01:28:14] Little tiny things you know and it a lot of times those things like especially with small things smaller bugs they just don't get reported because someone just assumes well okay that's just a tiny little bug I'm sure it's been reported right it's it's it's just it's a trivial thing to fix and I'm sure it it's it's obvious and I'm sure it's been reported but that's that happens right that every every single person that that sees that bug and experiences that bug thinks the same way and you know it's it's important to go and just go into GitHub or go into the Slack or IRC or a telegram channel for that particular software and just you know say hey I [01:28:52] Found this minor bug and you know it it'll very likely a lot of times you'll be the first one to report it. Exactly absolutely and you know another thing is is is feature requests. I mean I've I've seen that with with many of the projects that I've collaborated just as one example was Sabi Ballet. I mean I've been using the wallet like before like it was it it was in beta and it it's it's just such a beautiful like software and I saw so much great potential but I was like the current version is shit. [01:29:21] Like we need to improve this. And then I can you know I can I can talk with the developers and be like okay so this is a problem like I would like this to be fixed I would like to have this functionality I think this should be here in the buy and all that and the beautiful thing is with open source software is that you can you can tell the coders what to do and if they agree with you they will build it right yeah so so you can become like the product manager of the software and you can you can you can manifest the software to according to your vision by convincing the developers to build them and that is just so I mean I mean that is like one of the [01:29:59] Many reasons why I love wasabi wallet so much because it it it's like it's like it's like my child right I've I've contributed so much to just the high level conceptual idea and so many countless features that I personally wanted are now in the software not just not because I was sitting at home like oh okay I wish that was there but oh my I can't code so I cannot develop it. [01:30:20] No but because I was active and I told the developers hey look this is how we can improve it. I think this will make it better if you agree please build it right and that just made it made it phenomenal to contribute and to actually see the software improve and that just makes the joy of using free software infinitely better so if you're a user of free software you should also be a contributor I agree completely and the team at Wasabi found your contribution so valuable that you are in t in Taiwan with them now on a sprint right and they wanted you there because you've like you said effectively [01:30:58] Become sort of the UX UI product manager type guy that that's on the team now yeah, exactly. And it, I mean like I love working in cyberspace, it's phenomenal. But but now for for the last month, we've been here with with Nopara, Adam Fiscor, David Molnard, Lucas Antibero, for for the entire month, and several other Wasabika's have joined us in the early month as well. [01:31:22] And it is it is just unbelievably what we've achieved in this month. What like the next release version 0.10 or 1.1.10 is gonna be a behemoth. Like we have Bitcoin Core integration, we have upgraded Avalonia, now the UI framework. [01:31:41] Now we have notifications, we have multi-wallet support, we have countless buck fixes, we have improved the BIP 158 block filters, faster syncing time. It's it's it's just unbelievably what we can achieve together, collaborating on this free software project. And you know, it goes for all other software projects as well. [01:32:00] You know, I personally love like my Wasabi, my cold cart, my BISC, my BTC pay, my model, and all that. And that is why I contribute to these projects because I first and foremost need these weapons of self-defense. But if you use other pieces of software, then contribute to that. Like for example, I don't know, like something like Zap. You have not done a single contribution to Zap, yet I still use it, right? [01:32:20] And it's a lovely project that deserves every single support. So you know, scratch your own itch. The software that you use every day, make sure that it works, and share the process that you've made with others so that they can have the improved versions as well. Yeah, and this is the process that I've talked about on the pod before. [01:32:39] When you get into Bitcoin, you know, the first step is learn. The second step is educate, and the third step is build. And I think you as Bitcoiners, we sort of walk along that path. And you know, it might you know it might not be, you know, educating publicly, like publishing podcasts or videos or or articles or whatever, but you know, just educating your friends and family. [01:33:03] You know, you just need to educate five, ten people you know, for this thing to grow like wildfire and go viral. Like each Bitcoiner just needs to do that. And then the next step is, you know, once you have learned and you've learned more by teaching others, then you are you know have a lot of value built up there. There's you know, it's still very early, so there's still the educated Bitcoiner who's able to teach and has a relatively deep understanding of what's going on here is is still very scarce, a scarce item out or a scarce resource in the world. [01:33:34] And so, you know, going out and just becoming a part of these open source projects, just just get you know, pick one and go out there and get on the GitHub and read through all of the issue queue and the discussions that are happening, go on the Slack and just kind of be a part of it and hang out and see what's happening. And you'll be surprised how quickly you'll be able to contribute. [01:33:56] And that contribution will be incredibly valued by the rest of the team that's working on it. Oh, oh, seriously, absolutely you're spot on there. You know, engage with the devs so you see where what the current happening is, see what problem there is, and find your niche in the project. Most certainly, again, division of labor, there's always something that you can do that will help the project as just alone because others don't have to do it. [01:34:20] I mean, you know, one thing that probably like most people can do is typo fixes. Both, you know, in the source code you know, documentation like comments in the code itself. No, there are a bunch of typos in there. Or for example, in the documentation. And I mean, here I can give a shout out to the Wasabi Wallet documentation, docs.wasami wallet.io. [01:34:40] Here we even have a bounty for for typos. So we have a monthly budget of 15 million satoshis roughly every single month that goes out to contributors of the documentation. So you know anyone who comes along and fixes a couple typos, I will throw you a couple stats. Right. So so this is a like documentation is very easy for non-coders to contribute to because again you use the software you know where the pain points are you know the questions that you had initially and hopefully you found out the answers right so so you can do an FAQ and just you know answer one question and that is a major major addition to the documentation and just by you sitting down and writing this in [01:35:18] Like 10 minutes a hundreds if not thousands of other peers will find this knowledge valuable and it will it will solve their problem hopefully so documentation is is a is another great way to collaborate. Yeah and another one is user support you know if you're using the products regularly and you have a you know good understanding of it and if you're hanging out in whatever forum users come to get support soft in telegram or slack or something discord sometimes if you're hanging out in that in that scene then you're going to see all the questions that come in you're gonna see the answers to them right so you can either add those answers to the documentation or [01:35:56] You can both add those answers to the documentation and then you know if you're hanging out there you'll see those questions come up again you know like three weeks later somebody's just downloaded the product and they're you know experiencing the same issues that the person had three weeks ago who was brand new to the product then and you'll have now a page on the documentation that you can refer them to and you can you know, kind of be there as a as a you know kind of a helpful presence and you relieve that duty, relieve the devs of that duty so they can go focus on on building the product. [01:36:25] And that's that's a huge help. I've seen quite a few Bitcoiners jump in on various products and sort of take that role on. And the more the more kind of support you know volunteer supporters there are out there, the less work it'll be for each one of those other supporters and for all the devs that are there as well. [01:36:43] So that's another role that you can fill. Absolutely. And as you point out, it's division of labor, right? Every question that you answer, the devs don't have to answer. And so they can focus more on coding, which is the skill that they are marginally superior on, right? So absolutely. And you know it's it's it's funny because I did that peer support for a long, long time for all these projects. [01:37:03] And what I just find so unbelievably awesome is that when a peer asks me a question and I give him the answer, and then a couple of weeks later, another peer comes into the chat and asks the same question, and I see that individual who've I have taught the answer, teach it now himself. I guess actually f forwarding that knowledge because he is understood. [01:37:23] That just always like it brings tears to my eyes that that it's it's such an awesome collaborative project. And you know, sharing your knowledge and to decrease the knowledge differential amongst peers is invaluable. I again because you don't sacrifice anything, you still retain the knowledge if you share it. But because the other peers are now smarter as well. [01:37:42] Again, we have more productive peers in our network, we have greater division of labor, and we can ultimately build more awesome shit. So be active in any way that you can. Absolutely agree, man. I've seen that happen over and over again as well. And it it happens and it works, and it's you know, it's not just just dive in and try. [01:38:01] It's hard. The hardest part is getting started. It might seem intimidating, but it's really not. So once you once you dive in, it's it's actually really fun and rewarding to be a to be a part of that. So yeah, Max, you're an inspiration, man, to me, and I and I know to many other Bitcoiners. Really appreciate your time and talking with me today. [01:38:21] I think it was an awesome conversation. Keep up the great work, man. Well, well, thank you very much, Brady. I can really give back the compliment. Again, man, like education is so vitally important, and it is it's such a great work to share your knowledge to decrease the knowledge differential amongst your peers. So any podcast out there and citizen bitcoin really is is a phenomenal. [01:38:41] It's it really is funny because I found your podcast, I think like after the second episode or so. I've been listening religiously to every episode. So thanks very much for for hosting the great conversations and for sharing the knowledge. And of course for the invitation here to come on. It was a great discussion. Thank you very much. Absolutely, man. [01:38:59] I appreciate you being here, and I really appreciate you listening too and for the kind words. All right, man. I think that's it for today. Take care and hope to meet you sometime in person sometime soon. Yeah, meat space is nice, right? Would like to smell you. That that'd be good. I will do the same and enjoy it. [01:39:19] I would listen that that one took me off guard, man. I appreciate that. All right, man. Take care. Yeah, see you too. Bye-bye. [01:39:36] All right, that was a great time, and I knew it would be. Max is a unique mind in this space, and it was a blast to talk with him today. Let us know what questions arose for you while listening today. You can tag Max at Hillibrand Max. That's at H I L L E B R A N D M A X, and myself at Citizen Bitcoin. [01:39:56] You can support the podcast by sharing it on Bitcoin Twitter or with your family and friends this holiday weekend in the US. You can send them some Bitcoin and Bitcoin Education with GiveBitcoin. Tell them to subscribe to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast as well, and we'll help you turn them into wise and toddlers. Alright, before I go, my open source shout out for this week is naturally Wasabi Wallet. [01:40:19] Wasabi is an open source, non-custodial, privacy-focused Bitcoin wallet with coin control features, tour integration, and built-in trustless coin shuffling with mathematically provable anonymity. [01:40:32] I use Wasabi and can confirm that it's very simple to get your Bitcoin into a coin join with a high anonymity set. [01:40:38] Max has led the development of comprehensive documentation and video series to answer all your questions. So check the show notes for those. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.