WEBVTT

1
00:00:22.960 --> 00:00:47.680
Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. So hey Bitcoiners. Hope you all are doing well out there. Enjoying life, learning some Bitcoin, thinking about and working toward a better Bitcoin future for all of us.

2
00:00:47.680 --> 00:01:14.400
The Citizen Bitcoin pod is all about understanding what's happening here, about clear thinking and learning how to adapt to the changes Bitcoin is bringing and will continue to bring about. I'm glad you're all here. Today, before we get to the show, I want to take a second to beg for some ratings and reviews. We're stuck on 13 ratings on iTunes, so if you have an iTunes account and a spare minute, there's diminishing marginal returns on ratings, so leaving one now helps more than later.

3
00:01:14.400 --> 00:01:20.640
So thanks to any listeners out there who can help us on that front. Alright, on to the show.

4
00:01:29.920 --> 00:01:39.840
I've got Marty Bent on the pod today. Uncle Marty is the host of Tales from the Crypt and co-host with Matt Odell of the Rabbit Hole Recap episodes.

5
00:01:40.640 --> 00:02:03.560
TFTC is one of, if not the best Bitcoin podcast out there. It's absolutely a favorite of mine. Marty is also the author of Marty's Bent, the best daily Bitcoin newsletter available. So if you're not subscribed to either or both, TFTC and Marty's Bent, check out Marty's profile on Twitter and get the link to subscribe to both of those.

6
00:02:03.560 --> 00:02:27.160
I think Marty's pretty much been killing it. And on the episode, I begin by embarrassing him with some praise like this for a little while. Then we get into talking about Bitcoin education, content creation, how it has evolved and where it's going. We talk about his history working in the financial industry and about how Bitcoin will change the financial financial industry in the future.

7
00:02:27.160 --> 00:02:46.120
We talk about price for a little bit because there's been some interesting price action lately, and why not? We talk about energy fud and Bitcoin. And just in Marty talks about his vision of a Bitcoin future 50 years from now. It was a ton of fun.

8
00:02:46.120 --> 00:03:02.600
Really respect Marty and what he's doing. Really appreciate you coming on the pod, Marty, and looking forward to meeting you in person this summer out in San Francisco at Bitcoin 2019. All right, guys. I hope you enjoy it. Here's my interview with Marty Bent.

9
00:03:06.360 --> 00:03:28.680
Hey Marty, how's it going? Going great, Brady. Thanks for having me, man. Yeah, we had a bit of tough technical difficulty there. My first I guess being bitten by the tech gremlins and the podcast recording business. But I'm glad it happened with you because you're so gracious and kind. It's it's a problem I know all too well.

10
00:03:28.680 --> 00:03:51.920
But we got there, we fought through. I think we've earned a beer. I'm I got one from a local brewery here, a little IPA. Gonna sip on while we chat Bitcoin today. Oh, yeah. I've got I've got some mineral water today. I've been recording for the past three days and have been drinking way too much this early on in the week.

11
00:03:52.080 --> 00:04:10.160
I'm taking a night off today. I know I promised I would drink with you, but I had a sneak interview yesterday where I was forced to drink whiskey. I it that happens, man, and I totally get it. This is a daytime pod. We'll have a drinking pod at some point, I'm sure. It'll happen. All right, so thanks so much for joining me on the podcast.

12
00:04:10.160 --> 00:04:32.560
I had a great time with your partner in crime, Matt Odell. And he's of course, as you well know, he's he's great. He's a real asset to TFTC. Yeah, he's he's awesome. He had he told me he had a really good time recording with you, so I'm very much looking forward to this to this conversation. And yeah, he's what we really love what we have going on in Rabbit Hole Recap and everything beyond that.

13
00:04:32.560 --> 00:04:59.520
Yeah, man, you guys keep up the good work. Keep it up, Matt. Shout out to Matt Odell. All right, so let's start with embarrassing you a little bit about what you've built here with Marty's Bent and TFTC. Like many good products, Marty's Bent, your daily newsletter came into being as a like a means to solve your own problem, which was mainly that your family and friends kept asking you about Bitcoin, and to save some time, you started the bent.

14
00:04:59.520 --> 00:05:20.240
And then in taking that simple step, it's led to the creation of one of, if not the best, Bitcoin podcast out there. So my first hardball question for you is how does it feel to be the most loved Bitcoiner in the world? I'm watching. I would not say I'm the most loved Bitcoiner in the world.

15
00:05:20.240 --> 00:05:44.760
I'm just happy to have found a spot in this this weird part of the internet trying to educate people about sound money and the potential for for native digital currency as we move into the information age. Absolutely one of the most like you know must-listen podcasts out there. It's always been like since it basically since I found it, one of those like I'm gonna listen as soon as possible, as soon as it drops.

16
00:05:44.760 --> 00:06:04.440
So when you agreed to come onto the pod, I did a little poll. Asked Bitcoiners to choose their favorite nickname for you. And Uncle Marty came in the overwhelming favorite of 246 votes. We had a lot of nicknames down in the comments too.

17
00:06:04.440 --> 00:06:32.120
But of course, your bo your boy came in second. Freaking freaking chief came in third. That was one I just like made up and threw on there. But I kind of like it. I like the Yeah, the freaking chief. It just kind of rolls up the tongue nicely. And then Brandon Quittem on that same day, I think, had a really good fun thread about your the favorite bentism and like everybody kind of chimed in with you know your your favorite, your kind of sayings that come out a lot.

18
00:06:32.120 --> 00:06:51.320
My favorite is let's dive into that, and I've totally appropriated it. I think it's a great It's a great easy segue. It is. It is. And it's it's always kind of funny to be like, oh yeah, when Marty says that you know you're on for you're in for something good. So what like what have you learned about kind of developing your style as an interviewer?

19
00:06:51.320 --> 00:07:13.080
What have you learned about how like how your style, I guess how you describe your style, how you think about your style, and maybe can you share a few of the more memorable episodes in TFDC history? Yeah for you as a host. Yeah. No, it's been it's been a fun experience. Like you said, as a product Marty's Bent and now TFTC as well.

20
00:07:13.080 --> 00:07:42.880
It sort of grew out of my need to disperse information to people close to me. And I wanted to do it in a way like I was lucky enough to work at Barstool Sports, but before I worked there, I was a big fan, big stoolie, still am today. And just love the way they sort of approach media and developing an audience and making a subject that I like growing up sports, approachable and funny and something like that I wanted to go check out every day.

21
00:07:42.880 --> 00:08:20.880
Yeah. So I thought about trying to apply that a similar voice similar like packaging for Bitcoin is as you know been around long if you even dive into the space for a week you know how how daunting it can be to try to understand everything. So for for a lot of people just diving into technical documents and listening to very technical podcasts very technical YouTube is is not always the easiest way to learn so I thought I would cater to somebody who wanted to learn from from a person with like a voice a little rough around the edges and sort of bringing their

22
00:08:20.880 --> 00:08:39.200
Own flair to it so that's what I try to do is just like the voice I try to be like the voice in the audience that I perceive I have's head of like how they would think of it like if they weren't even if they didn't have to articulate to somebody in person they're just thinking through it in their head. It's like almost like a daily rant.

23
00:08:39.520 --> 00:09:08.200
And then yeah obviously Uncle Marty freaks and that stuff has just been a sort of natural natural progression of Marty Bent and whoever the hell he is. Right. Yeah, it's and you kind of got into this a little bit about like you can the state of Bitcoin education or just kind of more broadly like Bitcoin content production and memes and tweets and you know everything that's included in that.

24
00:09:08.440 --> 00:09:32.600
And how Bitcoin, along with all its other network effects, also has this kind of network effect that isn't talked about so much, but it this network effect that incentivize it incentivizes new cohorts of Bitcoin educators and content creators with every wave of adoption. So any thoughts about like the next few years and kind of long term about how like Bitcoin education or content production might might change with the next wave of adoption.

25
00:09:32.680 --> 00:10:11.080
It's a good question. I just I just think there so again like like what we're basically getting at here is that there's multiple ways through which to learn and multiple ways through which people like to learn. So I just think I have like a niche sort of market and each voice speaking to a certain audience and there are other types of audience who learn in different ways that may not be as receptive to Marty's bent but maybe more receptive to another newer content creator that sort of strikes a chord with the way in which they learn so I just think again

26
00:10:11.320 --> 00:10:29.960
Like we say in all aspects of Bitcoin it's early days and there's a large pie out there for the taking and that's the way I see it is like education and content around this will just begin to cater to different types of audiences and different types of tendencies and stuff like that.

27
00:10:29.960 --> 00:10:56.480
So a good example is last night Tim Poole was talking about the Gizmodo article that I wrote about this morning. I didn't know that he posted that video before I wrote the Bent this morning, but it's actually funny to see. He talked about it too last night, but he's somebody with with a different type of audience, more like indie journalism, geopolitical world events type of audience, and he's introducing Bitcoin to them by putting down an article and stuff like that.

28
00:10:56.480 --> 00:11:14.720
So I just think as Bitcoin continues to survive and persist, and it's just not as it is the like we say, it's the mind virus as Pomps as Pomps says the virus is spreading and spread to different type of content creators and different mediums through which different types of learners learn.

29
00:11:14.720 --> 00:11:35.040
Yeah, it's just it's it's all and it's all organic, all incentivized just you know by the protocol and the incentive structure of the protocol itself, you know, because we're all, as we're holders, obviously incentivized to make sure that Bitcoin grows in the best way that it possibly can. And it just kind of happens organically then over with each wave of adoption, just keeps getting bigger, bigger.

30
00:11:35.040 --> 00:12:04.880
And the exciting thing I think for like Bitcoin education and content creators right now is that with this next wave, I think you're really gonna get into a territory where like you can build an actual like make an actual living or build a lifestyle business or maybe even the starting the start of a really big business eventually over the next decade or two to teach you know the right way, you know, the big the Bitcoin right methods, all the techniques and the ideas that you need to know, you know, to understand Bitcoin and not get wrecked, I guess.

31
00:12:04.880 --> 00:12:23.920
Yeah, no. That's what I mean. That's a big topic of Tales from the Crypt is that Bitcoin, like if it's ever gonna attain mass adoption, needs sort of a mental rewiring of the framework of society. It's it's and it's again like it's daunting, it's confusing when you first get into it.

32
00:12:23.920 --> 00:12:43.640
Journey for me has been years up to this point. I'm still learning every day. And yeah like you said, that's I mean that's sort of the view I have is slowly just show up every day, show up every week with content and as you're putting that out, sort of build better tools around that, which I'm working on now.

33
00:12:43.640 --> 00:13:21.720
But yeah I think the most important important thing for me is just showing up every day and trying to get better and like you said, like sort of curate what I believe is is what people should be focusing on. So that's what I try to do with the bent and a lot of people are talking about price or some SEC story about ICOs I try to focus on something having to do a Bitcoin fundamentals whether rather be whether it be hash rate or a certain pull request or something cool that someone's building on lightning just try to signal boost things that I don't think are

34
00:13:21.720 --> 00:13:51.240
Getting enough attention and curate that that education process a little bit. Yeah and that's something that's totally you know inspired me you know in this in this podcast too is to I think it's just really valuable that to focus on the fundamentals and you know how the name of the Citizen Bitcoin podcast came from the idea of being a good citizen of Bitcoin, you know and we're dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin and trying to help people understand like what's happening here and how it's going to change you know our lives in so many ways.

35
00:13:51.480 --> 00:14:13.680
So it's there's just so much like you said to sort of relearn in under a sound money system like big socioeconomic system like Bitcoin and it's gonna and it's global too, of course. So yeah, so I think it's gonna be really important. And I you know I think TFTC is in a good position to kind of help it's got a lot of credibility, you know.

36
00:14:13.680 --> 00:14:34.560
And I think over time everything will kind of filter back down once once people go through the necessary learning process. You know, it comes down to like hardcore Bitcoin education. And I think that that's what will be the most demanded, you know, in the in the longer run. So yeah, I think you're in a good spot. All right, so yeah, absolutely.

37
00:14:34.560 --> 00:14:58.800
So I want to kind of switch focus a little bit and talk about finance and markets and stuff with you a little bit because I know you worked in the financial sector. You talk about how your work in the financial sector helped you see the value in Bitcoin and how you think Bitcoin will affect or change the finance industry like in the kind of short, medium, long term.

38
00:14:58.880 --> 00:15:17.120
Yeah. So I did I went to college in Chicago at DePaul University and I studied economics while there, and luckily being in Chicago sort of afforded me to get a good internship at a managed futures fund on the west side of the city, Dearborn Capital Management. Okay.

39
00:15:17.120 --> 00:15:48.960
So junior and senior year, I sort of worked at the fund almost full time and was able to take my classes and stuff like that while getting my economics degree and then worked there for for a year and a and a little bit after I graduated and basically it was three years that I was there. We were again we were a managed features fund, so and then we were a fund of fund, so basically just in layman terms, like like an investment fund that invested in a bunch of other funds and indexed them together.

40
00:15:48.960 --> 00:16:27.160
Yeah. So my job as an analyst was to sort of meet with all these other what we call it CTAs, mostly, commodity trading advisors and dissect their strategies, their quant strategies, what they were doing. And I was part of the portfolio management team, so I was working under their chief investment officer. And yeah, so my job was basically to do to analyze these funds, meet with the their chief investment officers to understand their trading models, and then on top of that, I wrote the commentaries for the fund, which meant I had to follow world markets and sort of understand what was going on in them

41
00:16:27.240 --> 00:16:48.120
And the markets we trade in particular were precious metals, grains, currencies, stock indices and treasuries. So a lot of my job with following or writing commentary for currency markets in particular was trying to stop saying in particular my wife's calling.

42
00:16:48.120 --> 00:17:09.640
So if I stop mid in particular, it's because I'm pissed at myself. But when like having to follow currency markets forced me to sort of follow central banks around the world and their policies and what they were doing, and I already sort of had an inclination that these people had no idea what they were doing after 2008.

43
00:17:09.720 --> 00:17:38.520
I was a senior in high school and had a sort of what the hell just happened moment, and that's why I pursued my economics degree. Then when I was working at the fund and sort of having to follow these central banks pretty a lot more intently than your than your average onlooker would have to. I just sort of noticed their inconsistency and basically complete lack of control they have had over the markets compared to what they perceived they could control.

44
00:17:38.520 --> 00:18:03.760
And at the same time I was learning I was falling down the Bitcoin rabbit hole, and it just sort of really clicked for me in that moment when I was early 20s, 1920. I was just like, this doesn't make any sense in Bitcoin. It just it just makes sense to me. Like to think that we're moving into the information age, to think that a digital currency would exist, it just seems like a no-brainer.

45
00:18:03.760 --> 00:18:34.880
And Bitcoin at this point seems to have the best chance of being successful in that endeavor. Yeah, absolutely. So that's I mean, that's interesting that you saw and it's cool that it happened to you at a pretty young age. Like that's that's awesome. To have had some serious experience in the industry for a couple of just you know, just a couple of years really, and at the kind of the beginning of your career, for lack of a better word, I guess, you know, this sort of replacement for your industry comes along, you know.

46
00:18:34.880 --> 00:18:53.760
Yeah, and you can just kind of jump jump shit. Yeah, well, yeah, and I guess we can get into the second half of your question, which I did not answer. Yeah, I was just like, well, how it'll affect finance and yeah, moving in the future. Like honestly, like I can't even c pro probably comprehend how it will will affect finance.

47
00:18:53.760 --> 00:19:13.040
I think it will open markets. I think it will do incredible things to sort of unleash innovation and capitalism like we haven't seen in a while, because I would argue our system is somewhat socialist today. Like the bank bat bailouts in particular, I would are goddamn it, I gotta stop saying in particular.

48
00:19:13.040 --> 00:19:43.880
The bank bailouts. I'll drink every time you say it in particular. The bank bailouts were were a very socialist act in my my opinion. And Bitcoin, if we if a Bitcoin standard ever does come to fruition would would not let that happen and would would let would separate the we from the chaff in a lot more in a very very direct way where we're now we're allowed to sort of hide inefficiencies in the market with money.

49
00:19:43.880 --> 00:20:07.560
Right. Yep, yeah, absolutely. And it's just at kind of several levels as as I'm coming to understand too, because you know, this Bitcoin has turned my thinking around in a in a lot of ways as well, remapped my thinking, I guess is a more accurate way to put it, especially about economics, and you know, then of course everything kind of falls from that, like politics and so you know, just the way society is organized.

50
00:20:07.560 --> 00:20:26.200
And it's it's kind of amazing to think about how we have this the political ramifications, even from what will you know basically the new socioeconomic operating system that Bitcoin is kind of installing in humanity right now?

51
00:20:26.200 --> 00:20:44.760
And so it's gonna go obvious. I think it'll happen kind of maybe first in the financial sector because it's kind of being used as money first, but the downstream effects are gonna be decades in kind of rolling out and in developments. And it'll be interesting to see what happens.

52
00:20:44.840 --> 00:21:03.880
Yeah, that's what it's like the main question that's always in my mind is like how how does this get adopted, how does it spread? Does it spread? Does apathy stop it? And that's I'm under the belief that it can go w one of many ways.

53
00:21:03.880 --> 00:21:28.960
There's there's many many ways in which Bitcoin adoption can come to the world. But I do think people trying to preserve their wealth in countries where the governments or the state or some other entity is trying to confiscate it in mass in perpetuity, we'll we will see a lot of adoption there first.

54
00:21:28.960 --> 00:21:48.400
Yeah. So on kind of the this idea of Bitcoin maximalism, there's kind of two aspects to it. There's sort of this technical side or technical argument for it. But then there's the monetary argument for it. So like on the monetary Bitcoin maximum maximalism spectrum, where would you place yourself?

55
00:21:48.400 --> 00:22:15.360
Like at the low end of the Pareto distribution is like, you know, 80% of value accrues to Bitcoin to the top end, you know, 100% or 99 plus or whatever of the monetary premium of human money is becomes backed by Bitcoin. Like where do you kind of end up on that spectrum? I assume you identify with the kind of term Bitcoin maximalism, but we're trying to have a deeper conversation here about it in like because it's it's not like you know an either-or sort of thing.

56
00:22:15.360 --> 00:22:43.120
There's a lot of ideas and contained in the I in the phrase Bitcoin maximalism. Yeah, Bitcoin maximalism, the goddamn slander that Vitalik painted on us. Yeah, so I don't know. I feel like after 80%, it's like just it's an interesting debate, but we really won't know until time plays out.

57
00:22:43.200 --> 00:23:21.400
Yeah, we actually see what comes into reality. But I'm I'm also a strong believer that as long as there's a greater fool out there willing to fall for an all coin scam, they they will continue to happen and just naturally because that's gonna be occurring, like it will obviously eat away at the percentage of Bitcoin's overall overall market cap but then again I go back and forth through my head and then I'm like okay this is the condition now that we've lived under in this first decade but how many cycles of this can we have before people wise up and realize like oh Bitcoin's Lindy it's

58
00:23:21.400 --> 00:23:42.120
Hash rate and blah blah blah is enough that it's almost impossible to get fooled by an altcoin. Like I could definitely see that happening as well at some point in the next few decades. And the argument for Bitcoin taking over a hundred percent of the total addressable market I could definitely see that happening.

59
00:23:42.360 --> 00:24:18.760
I do think the term monetary maximalist is more important where if you have a market of free monies competing for each other you're likely that the likelihood that the market will coalesce on the soundest and best money out of that competition is is very high so I'm a I'm a big believer in that theory so if we do have truly open and free money markets I do believe Bitcoin is at this moment in the digital currency space the best and the one most likely to win out.

60
00:24:18.760 --> 00:24:41.720
Yeah yeah I totally agree and did you see that medium post by this guy JP goes by he's at JP Thor on Twitter. It was the volume weighted market cap idea where he went through and adjusted the market caps of coins all from top to bottom by their volume.

61
00:24:42.200 --> 00:25:02.480
Yes. Yes and we saw like the results were basically Bitcoin's sort of been hovering between 80 and 85% of the market or dominance or whatever. So I think that's a I mean just a much closer, you know, but much better way to measure the dominance if you're gonna use that word of a cryptocurrency.

62
00:25:02.480 --> 00:25:28.080
And so it's somewhere in that Pareto, and I and I guess it'll probably just kind of like move slowly toward 100% over the next few decades or whatever, and as people wise up, you know? Yeah, it's yeah. And we're on Twitter a lot, so it's easy to get caught up in the noise that a lot of accounts are allowed to build up around like these altcoin projects.

63
00:25:28.080 --> 00:26:00.640
And sometimes what I think Bitcoiners and people in the crypto space in general lose sight of is that it's still a very small niche space and our like cat fights within that even smaller niche space on Bitcoin Twitter is really not indicative of the overall market. So I do think like those metrics like that which prove that nobody's using most of these blockchains outside of Bitcoin is is is is a good sign and more indicative of the truth.

64
00:26:00.640 --> 00:26:18.800
Yeah. Yeah. All right, so I know you don't talk price much, and we don't talk price much on this podcast too, but the price action has been kind of interesting the last few days. What are your any thoughts on like you know, have we hit the bottom?

65
00:26:18.800 --> 00:26:44.120
You know, are we gonna just like what what do you think the price is gonna do in the near term here? I don't know. I think it reminds me of like 2015, 2016 seems like like a warning pump to me. I think we'll definitely drift lower over the next couple weeks to a lot. But this feels like one of those like warning pumps like hey, like a tremor of like a volcano eruption that happens in a few months.

66
00:26:44.120 --> 00:27:05.640
Like, from like a market's perspective. I just thought it was interesting that it happened on the first day of the quarter. I don't know what that signals, but I think maybe somebody got the okay signal to buy a bunch of Bitcoin starting Q2, 2019. So that could be a reason why the price spiked up a bit.

67
00:27:05.640 --> 00:27:25.640
From hearing rumors that it was just one big buy that really drove a lot of the volume. Yeah, there was an article about it, I think at Reuters. That there was this one guy that said he basically authorized a hundred million dollars of buying across three exchanges.

68
00:27:25.640 --> 00:27:52.280
I think it was I might think it was Coinbase Kraken and Bitstamp. Yeah. And it just like that basically drove the pump. Yeah. But it but it showed how how ill not ill liquid, but how how fickle the order books are, especially like watching the BitMEX wrecked Twitter account the other night, just watching people get margin called for like 15 minutes straight.

69
00:27:52.280 --> 00:28:28.480
It's crazy that to think of how relatively small Bitcoin is from a from a global markets perspective. And that's like a hundred million dollars. It sounds a lot like a lot to us, but when you're talking about these big funds, that's really it's it's not when you're talking about all the funds in aggregate, it's not that not that much right so think if that could cause this candle if there was an institutional investor induced FOMO and you have all these funds racing to get in that that would be a crazy crazy price action to watch.

70
00:28:28.480 --> 00:28:52.240
Yeah and I and I think the timing was obviously intended like you said first day of the quarter we just like cross through this major downtrend line and so all the traders are watching for a big candle or in one way or the other right either are we going to get denied again or are we just gonna break through with authority and so yeah then you know that there's gonna be a lot of a lot of the traders and speculators are going to pile on on top of your money.

71
00:28:52.240 --> 00:29:30.960
So yeah. Yeah. Yeah I've been watching the moving averages I just like to watch the weekly charts and I just look at the simple moving averages because it's it's kind of amazing how similar we're looking right now in like kind of early 2019 to the middle of the bear market in 2015 or like toward the end of it I guess but the so the price the price first was like supported by the 200 week moving average and then the 50 week moving average cross crosses down over after the like toward the end of the bear market crosses down over the 100 weekly moving average and that both happened about happened

72
00:29:30.960 --> 00:29:58.720
Like two months ago for us. So now what's gonna happen at least what happened in 2015 is we got re we get rejected by that 50 week moving average go back down get caught by the 200 week moving average again and then it's off to the races. So it looks if it follows that same pattern then it's you know maybe like three to six months of or maybe yeah maybe about three ish months of another like kind of like drift back down to the 200 weekly moving average is like that's like 37 and 3800 and then boom back off again.

73
00:29:58.720 --> 00:30:17.480
So that's kind of what I'm watching. Yeah. No it's crazy again going back to a lot of the noise like if you look at some of these charts not necessarily the price charts what I like to look at is like days destroyed and like more UTXO analysis.

74
00:30:17.480 --> 00:30:38.760
I think I wrote about it on Monday. So when you see like the amount the percentage of UTXOs over one year old growing like above 50% of all UTXOs it's a good sign that that the bear market is is sort of ending and people are are back in like accumulation hodl phase.

75
00:30:38.760 --> 00:31:17.320
Yeah the like the HODL waves visualization which is really cool hot visualization of like how old UTXOs are. Yeah. That's actually I was talking to like a fun manager earlier this week at a meetup and asking them that question like are you guys taking any of this like chain data into into consideration because it's been pretty cool to watch again past performance is not indicative of future results but this is just one of the few cool things that Bitcoin enables that could sort of revolutionize even like quant algorithms and stuff like that if you're if you're taking the blockchain

76
00:31:17.320 --> 00:31:36.400
And the price data into into account at the same time. Yep absolutely yeah the transparency into the blockchain is revolutionary for for finance industry and just like the kind the efficiency of all of the financial apparatus, I guess, can be can be updated.

77
00:31:36.480 --> 00:32:04.400
Yeah. No, it's just obviously right now, we're in the Bitcoin is bad phase from these guys. I think with the products like Fidelity and backed starting to roll out. These people become these people. I'm sorry. This industry will become more open to experimenting and working with this technology, the open source technology in particular.

78
00:32:04.400 --> 00:32:23.440
God damn it. The open source technology. And it'll be we're not at the point yet, but it will be fun to see once they're the sort of force to reckon with Bitcoin being a thing that's here to stay. Yeah. Okay. So next topic.

79
00:32:23.440 --> 00:32:42.160
And this is kind of this is gonna get into what you wrote about in the bent today. And I know you kind of mentioned it a little bit earlier. In response to that article in where was it, the Washington Post or Wall Street Journal? What was it? Gad No, is it in gadget? Sorry. I didn't have it pulled up.

80
00:32:42.160 --> 00:33:02.160
Gizmodo, right? Yeah, this gizmodo piece here. I've got it pulled up now by Matt Novak. Yeah, and so you know, just a typical, you know, like let's say we've we've heard it like ever basically every year, since Bitcoin is born. We're still hearing it's it's the same sort of litany of FUD.

81
00:33:02.160 --> 00:33:28.600
But the one that sort of triggers you the most, or at least has been lately, it seems, is energy, the energy FUD. And it triggers me too, and it's a tough one to fight because like on face, Bitcoin does use a lot of energy. And like if you don't take some time to think about like this fact or learn about where the energy comes from or why it's important to Bitcoin, why it's important that we use that energy, it seems that maybe it's bad.

82
00:33:28.600 --> 00:33:49.000
And it kind of takes a lot of a lot of time to understand all that stuff. So it's just really easy and then the people can you know those who spread it they can jump straight into climate catastrophizing and fear mongering and dramatize their energy FUD. And you had a great riff on this like last week in the rabbit hole recap, kind of toward the end of the episode.

83
00:33:49.400 --> 00:34:22.040
And then you d really distilled it in today's bent. So can you sort of give us your energy FUD smackdown and then maybe then maybe dive let's kind of dive into the particulars a little bit the particulars in particular. Particulars in particular yeah so this is a hot topic of contention that really pisses me off when people misrepresented because I do think I honestly do think that Bitcoin mining as an industry presents a very unique opportunity that has not existed for the world because there's finally an incentive to innovate in these places.

84
00:34:22.040 --> 00:34:55.800
So it's threefold in my mind. The first where it helps out is it untaps previously unused renewable energy sources like hydroelectric and geothermal be and wind being the most popular and the most remote so throughout history these energy sources have gone unused because one there's nobody out there to use it on location and then two if you were able to harness it out there it's just very hard to transport to the cities which are far away from these energy sources.

85
00:34:55.800 --> 00:35:19.840
So now that Bitcoin mining exists sort of presents a unique opportunity because Bitcoin miners are always looking for the cheapest form of energy. And what they're finding in a lot of cases is that the cheapest form are these untapped renewable energy sources that nobody's using. So they're going out there and they're using clean energy to mine Bitcoin because it just so happens to be the cheapest.

86
00:35:19.840 --> 00:35:45.280
I believe these types of energies have been underutilized in the past. And the fact that Bitcoin miners are out there harnessing this energy, building technology to make it as efficient as possible, it presents an opportunity to innovate around renewable energies and figure out ways in which to bring them to the masses.

87
00:35:45.280 --> 00:36:23.680
So just because there's people tinkering out there, maybe through economics and trial and error, they'll find ways to harness and transfer this renewable energy. It's not a foregone conclusion that they will, it presents a possibility now that there's people out there working on it. And then it's better that they use those renewable energies than fossil fuels, which are more expensive, which leads you to the second part of the threefold argument, which is it makes fossil fuel consumption and more particularly the extraction of those fossil fuels more

88
00:36:23.680 --> 00:36:52.000
Efficient because what you have is a similar situation with these fossil fuels, is that they're in remote areas too, but they're easier to transport with piping systems, though those piping systems still have limitations as well. And that forces these on-site drilling companies to have to release some natural gas and methane into the atmosphere because they aren're unable to transport all of it to the cities.

89
00:36:52.000 --> 00:37:16.920
And so this presents an opportunity for Bitcoin miners to show up to these energy facilities to say, hey, if you guys want to keep production going and don't want to worry about releasing too much methane into the atmosphere, we'll cap that methane and we'll use it if you sell it to us for like half a cent a kilowatt hour or a cent a kilowatt hour under your average Bitcoin under your average energy price that Bitcoin miners are paying.

90
00:37:16.920 --> 00:37:40.120
Right. So it makes these on-site drilling sites more efficient, and when you release those gases into the atmosphere, it's actually 30 times worse for the environment then than harnessing them and using them like a combustible engine.

91
00:37:40.120 --> 00:38:01.480
So it just makes it so we're polluting the environment less. Like there's a lot of talk about saving the environment, and this opportunity presents itself right in front of us. Like, hey, you want to be more efficient? You don't like fossil fuels, you don't like people just flaring gas into the atmosphere. Well, here's an incentive to cap that, and it's it's works it out for everybody.

92
00:38:01.480 --> 00:38:20.520
The oil drillers are allowed to keep production on, they're not polluting the atmosphere, and they're able to make some money while doing it because they would sell energy, which they just release for no money at all, and they're able to sell it for half a cent a kilowatt hour, so they make a little money. Number two, the Bitcoin miners are obviously making money.

93
00:38:20.520 --> 00:38:55.760
And then the last of the three-fold argument that I've been making is that like energy facilities, they have they have their own problems, like in big cities too, where they have costs that they have to weigh. So people only use energy facilities, like their most used time, like the most active times are early in the morning where people are up brushing their teeth, getting their kids ready for school, and then when everybody gets home from work and school, dinner, TV, and then after everybody goes to bed, the energy shuts off.

94
00:38:55.760 --> 00:39:21.040
And overnight, these these facilities have to weigh the cost of like, do we just keep it running or do we shut it down and turn it back on in the morning? And sometimes what we find is these energy facilities will try to create like a net zero energy consumption by doing some roundabout thing. Like, for instance, they'll push a bunch of water up a hill using a cart and they'll move down a hill that will capture that water.

95
00:39:21.040 --> 00:39:46.640
So they're basically have a net zero energy expansion. So they're just trying to keep it even. So instead of doing something wacky like that, they can just plug a couple Bitcoin miners in and liquidate that liquid gold or that digital gold to cover the cost of those energy costs overnight instead of having to turn it off and turn it back on, which has which has others other costs.

96
00:39:46.640 --> 00:40:07.600
So, yeah, so do you think that energy producers will basically be incentivized to kind of almost at some point have to add Bitcoin mining operations just to increase the efficiency of their business? I mean, I think I think they'll come to this conclusion naturally.

97
00:40:07.600 --> 00:40:28.240
It's just they they just need it shown to them. And I think what things like Steve Barber at Upstream Data are doing in Alberta, Canada is exactly what we need is some wily entrepreneur to be like, hey, most people don't realize this can happen. I'm gonna go make the thing that can make it happen. And once these producers see it, they're gonna be like, holy shit, this is a no-brainer.

98
00:40:28.240 --> 00:40:49.880
And I think in that Wall Street Journal article that basically mentioned Steve Barber, what he's doing in Alberta, the natural gas company that he set this up for said it has the lowest cost on the market. He's pretty the owner of that well is pretty confident in saying that's a product of being able to mine Bitcoin with that with that cap gas.

99
00:40:50.200 --> 00:41:17.240
That's awesome. And it's it's kind of incredible that Bitcoin, like it makes fossil fuel extraction cleaner, but in the process it also incentivizes cheaper renewable energy to that will eventually replace the fossil fuel industry. So it's it's kind of like making fossil fuels more like cleaner and more efficient while also hastening like our move from fossil fuels.

100
00:41:17.240 --> 00:41:41.880
And so like your your other point in the bent, like at the end here, the in summation is like, you know, you yeah, we're using energy here, but if we have like the benefits of a world built on a sound monetary system are so huge that even if we weren't like incentivizing renewables and making fossil fuels you know practices cleaner and more efficient, it would still be worth it, right?

101
00:41:41.880 --> 00:42:07.080
Yeah. No, that's I mean, that's when you bring the economic argument into it. And I recorded a podcast yesterday with Parker Lewis, and we spoke a lot about this, and we mentioned your Guido Holtzman's book, The Ethics of Money Production, and at a certain point in that book, he describes the malinvestment enabled by by easy monetary policy.

102
00:42:07.080 --> 00:42:45.280
So you have people making investments that otherwise under sound monetary policy probably wouldn't get funded, and you're therefore sort of wasting resources and capital on things that that aren't worthwhile probably wouldn't be considered as worthwhile on a sound money standard right yeah all right so let's talk a little bit then about why bitcoin needs to expend electricity for mining like why why do we need proof of work when it uses so much energy what's important about the actual energy usage that to Bitcoin like what's

103
00:42:45.280 --> 00:43:23.520
Important about that electricity usage to Bitcoin I mean it's in it's in the name proof of work like you have to prove that you did work that you solved the SHA 256 hash function a certain amount of times or not a certain amount of times that you proved a hash below the difficulty and that like that's why Adam back created hash cash in the first place was to just create a cost for spammers sort of disincentivize them to spam his email box by making

104
00:43:23.520 --> 00:43:42.320
Them do a little proof of work first which is exp expend energy so in Bitcoin if anybody were just able to prove what's going on like without using proof of work you'd probably get people people overriding the ledger and stuff like that.

105
00:43:42.320 --> 00:44:02.440
So proof of work basically makes it so you're you're you're proving that you did a certain amount of work at a given point in time and that gets embedded in the blockchain. And to do that, you have to run an algorithm on a certain chip right now, ASICs with Bitcoin, and that that takes energy.

106
00:44:02.440 --> 00:44:23.160
So it's and it's the one of the costs associated with having a sound distributed digital cash. Yeah, I think like Zabo calls it, Nickzabo calls it unforgeable costliness. Yeah. Yeah, proof of work. I'm I'm a big proponent of proof of work over proof of stake.

107
00:44:23.160 --> 00:44:44.760
I don't think proof of stake is compatible at all with a protocol looking to be a sound money. Right, because you can if you can buy enough stake, you can control the network. Where in Bitcoin you can buy as much Bitcoin as you want, but the nodes still decide consensus. And even if you spend a lot of money to buy a lot of miners, you're still competing with the rest of the market as well.

108
00:44:44.760 --> 00:45:13.000
So it's more level playing field there. Whereas proof of stake, I guess you're competing with other stakers to a certain extent, but it's a lot less of a barrier to entry to take over a large portion of the consensus part of your protocol. Yeah, exactly. It d it almost it doesn't have the sort of I like the analogy that proof of work is kind of laying layers of amber on top of the blockchain, you know, on top of your transactions, basically.

109
00:45:13.000 --> 00:45:34.440
And I think that that analogy came from Naval on his episode with Tim Ferris and Nigzabo. He kept using this analogy of every block that comes in is kind of another layer on this ball of amber that is Bitcoin. And you know, the transactions toward the middle of that ball of amber are that much more secure because of all of this actual work that happened.

110
00:45:34.440 --> 00:45:55.520
None of that exists in proof of stake, you know. So there's that opens all kinds of attack, giant attack surface that proof of work doesn't have. Yeah, and it's just like, and I'm a big keep it simple, stupid guy. Like it just makes more sense. Like anything in life, like a like a like a proverb.

111
00:45:55.520 --> 00:46:17.360
I don't even know if it's a proverb, like stuff takes like good stuff takes hard work, and like Bitcoin, if we want to sound money, like to think it's not gonna involve expending a certain amount of energy and doing things doing things the correct and hard way sometimes is it's just acidine.

112
00:46:17.440 --> 00:46:44.240
Yeah, there's that kind of intuition that there's just no free lunch, you know. Like you just that doesn't make any sense. It's that that can't be possible. Yeah. I'm with you on that for sure. Okay. I got two questions left for you to wrap things up. First, I know you're pretty well read and would love to hear like your top five or seven or whatever kind of Bitcoin book recommendations for Bitcoiners.

113
00:46:44.320 --> 00:47:07.280
Yeah, I mean, sovereign individuals the go-to. I'm working through that one right now. It is really special. I mean, this is I mean, it's gonna sound like I don't want to not disingenuous, but it's like almost like a road script at this point, but it is true. Like these books are foundational to my way of thinking.

114
00:47:07.280 --> 00:47:27.600
So like Nassim Taleb Incerto series, particularly fooled by randomness and the Black Swan. I think are great great books to read to sort of understand long long-term thinking and risk in the long term.

115
00:47:27.600 --> 00:47:48.600
And Bitcoin wise, yeah, like the sovereign individual, I think is prolific in the how prescient it was in many areas, not even just Bitcoin. Mastering Bitcoin, if you want to understand it from a technical sense, is a great resource as well.

116
00:47:48.600 --> 00:48:09.080
The Bitcoin standard, obviously. I think actually Parker Lewis gave some great advice yesterday. Is that yeah, whenever I have somebody new that wants to talk to me about Bitcoin and make them read the Bitcoin standard first, and after having read that, if they had more questions, then we'll jump into it like in full.

117
00:48:09.080 --> 00:48:37.480
The Bitcoin standard, obviously. My bookshelf now. That's a good pol that's a good policy, just be like, hey, read the Bitcoin standard, and then let's talk more. Yeah. I think that that's that's where people really need, I think, the kind of the I don't know, I guess a red pill for lack of a better phrase, or the orange pill or the black pill, whatever color it is these days.

118
00:48:37.480 --> 00:49:08.120
I have no idea what color it is these days. Yeah, it's is is on the economic side. Because we're all, as I've been kind of using this term on basically every episode of the podcast recently, is we're all default Keynesians. Like we all sort of grow up with this idea of Keynesianism, unless you have like parents or some other person in your life at a young age that will kind of you know expose you to those alternative ideas on economics, you're you're gonna get Keynesianism in the schooling system all over the world, basically.

119
00:49:08.200 --> 00:49:46.400
Yeah, it's pretty sad state of the topic of economics at an academic level in the US and I'm gonna say in particular in the US in particular it's the only experience I've had with the academics and or excuse me economics in academia but yeah no I think the Bitcoin standard i is a great sort of quick read on getting a sort of Austrian view on the world and how it relates to money and money it's funny I got a four four year degree in

120
00:49:46.400 --> 00:50:04.880
Economics and really didn't dive into what money is or the function of money is at all. Yeah. It's a fat that's amazing. It was all it was all like basically learning about the layers above the actual money. You know yeah.

121
00:50:04.880 --> 00:50:31.040
That's a really good list. And it's pretty similar to my list. I would throw in the book of Satoshi too which I love on Audible it's just all of Satoshi's like writing so it starts with the white paper but then it goes basically all of his forum posts and his emails so it also has batches of emails that were privately exchanged and later like given to the Soshi Nakamoto Institute for publication or whatever.

122
00:50:31.360 --> 00:50:51.480
And there's some like original letters in that book as well that hadn't appeared anywhere else until the publication of that book. It's on Audible of course you can get it I think paper back too but it's a fun one to throw on like at night while I'm falling asleep and just listen to 15 or 20 minutes of it. Right. And that's another resource, the Nakamoto Institute.

123
00:50:51.480 --> 00:51:11.400
Go read the complete Satoshi. It's crazy to be able to go back and read that stuff. It's a weird it's a weird luxury we're afforded in this age. Yeah. Francis Puliot found a forum post of like the first Bitcoin code that was sent anybody.

124
00:51:11.400 --> 00:51:29.560
Yeah. Yeah, it was from like November of 2008. Kind. And the comments in there are are just fun to read. Like I downloaded the code which is also available on the Nakamoto Institute dot org. And that's that's where I downloaded it and read through the scripts.

125
00:51:29.560 --> 00:51:47.720
There's just three scripts there that made the kind of the first draft of the Bitcoin code that that he the Satoshi ever shared. And it's funny to see him like thinking out in the code like in the comments of the code. Yeah. And that's where the that's where the time chain was mentioned. So we've got a we've got time the whole time chain thing now.

126
00:51:47.720 --> 00:52:07.960
Yeah. All right I've been really enjoying this question. It allows people to get cosmic which you know I've I've enjoyed as an aspect of your show all you know for the last year and a half or so. And so it's always fun. Fifty years from now, what is a Bitcoin future look like to you?

127
00:52:09.640 --> 00:52:28.200
50 years from now, what is a Bitcoin? So that'll be twenty sixty nine nice. Yeah what is a Bitcoin I want to end it on a good note but I do always have the Utopia ver versus dystopia argument in my mind.

128
00:52:28.200 --> 00:53:00.320
Like are we Bitcoin lead to a world where things are more extreme or or a world where people are able to have a savings vehicle through which to save wealth and build capital for the future. So as an optimist I believe in in the latter of those two so not yeah full on utopia but optimistic so I think I'm trying to think of like fifty years from now from like a government perspective like what were governments look like.

129
00:53:00.320 --> 00:53:24.960
I think that's like the better yeah like yeah for sure. Like how is it a how is it affected society. And I and I bet it's like more less boring or excuse me more boring less exciting than we expect it to be. I bet it's just like an acidic sort of this is the way Bitcoin sign guy described it on on Tales from the Crypt that Bitcoin's very acidic and it just sort of will seep into everything.

130
00:53:24.960 --> 00:54:03.680
And I think that's happening naturally. So in 50 years I hope I have an optimistic view of the world in which people are able to save their capital in a vehicle that is that is not exposed to inflation nor the whims of 12 people sitting in the room and I think that'll enable a sort of shifting of a mindset from a mindset mindset of society driven by conspicuous consumption thinking paycheck to paycheck quarter to quarter to one that thinks longer term and again like going back to the environment so like building a sustainable

131
00:54:03.680 --> 00:54:21.920
Future for for humanity and doing cool things like going to space. I don't think we'll be all in space in 50 years, but I think we'll have the system which will enable us to think longer term and make those those those jumps that we want to as a society.

132
00:54:21.920 --> 00:54:42.040
It's beautiful. I love it. And I like to I also ha like to think about how Bitcoin could be adapted or changed to or upgraded I guess to be used in an interplanetary environment. There's been some really cool kind of ideas thrown around about that on Medium and Twitter.

133
00:54:42.040 --> 00:55:20.040
See that do you have you read have you read about some of that stuff? Yeah so we would have to like extend the block time or have like a side chain with like hour long blocks or multi-day blocks stuff like that. Depending on how far out we get but it's totally possible. We could also use quantum computing right so if there's like if you have entangled qubits you entangle them on Earth, send some qubits up to Mars when the qubits change on Earth they're gonna instantly change on Mars it's not they're not you know they don't have to follow basically the laws of physics or at least the speed of light limitation that we would have otherwise to communicate the block information so

134
00:55:20.040 --> 00:55:40.440
If that if that actually became possible it'd be really interesting to have just like you know a bunch of machines a bunch of quantum machines on earth a bunch of quantum nodes I guess on earth that sort of propagate the information to a bunch of other quantum nodes on Mars and it I think that that would be interesting if that would work like that could work.

135
00:55:40.440 --> 00:56:00.120
Maybe in fifty years maybe we'll have that tech. Maybe that'd be dope. We have too many people that believe the world's gonna end in 12 years. So we need to we need more hopeful thinkers thinking about quantum machines on Earth and Mars and communicating. I think thinking big like that is is optimistic and good for people.

136
00:56:00.120 --> 00:56:22.240
Yeah, I do too. That's what I love about Elon Musk. And he gets he gets a bunch of you know static from a lot of people on Twitter. There's the whole you know, the test the whole Tesla Q crowd, the whole Tesla's gonna go bankrupt crowd and you know that he's not I guess it doesn't fit their idea of what a CEO should be or the SEC's idea of what a CEO should be either.

137
00:56:22.240 --> 00:56:44.240
And he just doesn't you know he doesn't care, but he's freaking optimistic and he's like, I'm gonna choose to believe in this you know the possibility of this future, and if that's gonna happen, we've we've got to get our asses to work right now, you know. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. All right, you got any parting shots or shills to share with all the Bitcoiners listening around the world right now.

138
00:56:44.240 --> 00:57:05.360
Yeah. I mean, if you guys like what we're doing, just let us know. We're if you guys like the bent and tales from the crypt, let me know. And if I mean if you're apprehensive about something in Bitcoin or have any questions, please feel free to DM me.

139
00:57:05.360 --> 00:57:28.240
I try to get to as many of those as possible. And then yeah, just again, this is a crazy time to be alive. This is a crazy technology to be around and definitely approach it with some humility. It's it's it's it's taught me a lot of very hard lessons that I'm that I'm happy to have learned.

140
00:57:28.240 --> 00:57:47.840
Awesome, man. I'm looking forward to seeing you out at Bitcoin 2019, the conference in San Francisco in kind of toward the end of June. It's gonna be fun to meet a bunch of Bitcoiners in person, including you. And you know, maybe we can do that drinking drinking pod together in person, maybe you and me and Matt or something.

141
00:57:47.840 --> 00:57:59.680
And get cosmic yeah for a little for a little while out there in person. That'd be fun. We'll definitely make that happen. Sweet. That'd be great. All right, thanks again, man, for your time. I appreciate it. Keep up the great work.

142
00:58:00.540 --> 00:58:02.860
And take care. Thanks again for having me on, dude.

143
00:58:09.920 --> 00:58:31.040
Thanks again to Marty for making time to join me on the pod. That dude is doing great work spreading Bitcoin knowledge and bringing Bitcoiners together. One last plea before I go to log into iTunes, if you have an account, and rate and review the Citizen Bitcoin pod. If you have found it to be valuable to your Bitcoin journey.

144
00:58:31.960 --> 00:59:00.760
And follow me on Twitter at Citizen Bitcoin. Follow Marty at Marty Bent. And follow Tales from the Crypt at TFTC21. And with that, good night, and take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
