Rodolfo Novak: Keeping Bitcoin Time - E120
Rodolfo Novak, is founder of Coinkite, of the longest running Bitcoin-only companies in the world and makers of beloved products ColdCard, OpenDime and BLOCKCLOCK. We get into Rodolfo's background, the early days of Coinkite and the lastest on Coinkite, entrepreneurship, economics and bitcoin's relationship to time.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. My name is Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there, all my Bitcoiners all around the world? Thank you for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. I know it's been a little while since I've dropped an episode here on the feed.
I do apologize about that. I've got a new schedule that's going to allow me to kind of keep up with the podcasting work while I am also tending to things over at Swan. I will be doing Swan Signal live episodes at swansignalpodcast.com.
That's the audio version. And at youtube.com slash swansignal broadcast live every Wednesday with two fantastic guests. I host those shows, kind of guide those discussions. You'll find those every other week now, every other Wednesday. And same with Citizen Bitcoin. This is going to go to every other week as well. So you'll still get a weekly podcast from me in these two different formats.
One, of course, being a little bit more laid back and chill and just a way to get to know other Bitcoiners in the space. All right, before we dive into this one with Rodolfo Novak, otherwise known as NVK on the interwebs, let's check in with SWAN. So the big news about SWAN is that we've gone international.
Super exciting. We've taken our first steps outside of the US to the wider world, and we are able to support clients through bank wires, making transfers wires and able to make one-time buys. We are rolling out the recurring purchase functionality to everyone internationally.
So if you are out there listening abroad and you want to start stacking with Swan, go ahead and go to swanbitcoin.com and get yourself signed up and we will get you stacking as soon as possible. We've also launched Swan Private in response to increasing demand from high net worth individuals and corporations and trusts and other entities to start stacking on their balance sheets and build generational wealth through this amazing revolutionary new money.
That is at swanbitcoin.com slash private. Check that out. It's our concierge service. We'd love to help guide you on your Bitcoin journey. All right, let's dive into this one with Rodolfo.
Rodolfo Novak is the founder of CoinKite, a company that's been in the space for a long time, maybe the longest lasting Bitcoin-only company in the space. You know, kind of legendary out there for its sort of cypherpunk ethos. Awesome products like the like the open dime and of course the block clock.
Last week, the block clock was all over the place because Jack Dorsey had one in the back of his shot while he was doing some testimony for I think the US Congress. And of course, the 1952 Satoshis per dollar was displayed on the block clock.
And we had some fun with someone trying to figure out what that number meant in Moscow time and that Jack, you know, this proved that Jack was some kind of Russian spy or agent. That was amazing, amazing fun, hilarious. And it was great for the block clock business. So this one was recorded before that happened.
So we don't talk about it, but we do definitely talk about the block clock a lot. It's an awesome little product. I bought one after recording this episode with Rodolfo. So enjoy this one. We're going to dive in right now. Here we go.
So how are you doing man good good this all-time high stuff it's like makes us like really busy oh yeah you're getting lots of orders and stuff it's it's been it's been crazy since since before black friday last year just absolutely mental you still have a pretty is your goal to kind of keep the business like relatively small and manageable like you don't want this thing to be super big so we've grown we've grown we're like 10x growth
In the last the last like since last year since early last year sort of like but you know we don't have the need to grow the team i mean we've grown the team a little bit but like little bit and we just automate everything that we can so like you don't need people yeah that's what you got to do right you got to scale with automation not bodies that's right we can do that man like people have been talking a lot more in clubhouse about cold card you know the wallet conversation comes up all the time one of the right it's like
Every other question yeah i know i know you've been in there a lot yeah so i hear the like you know it's like trezor and ledger are like user friendly and cold card is a little bit more advanced i think i may have even heard you say that what do you agree with that assessment i mean i feel like cold card's pretty easy to use yeah it's pretty easy to use i mean you know half the time i'm just like you know what i don't feel like just arguing me it's like yeah whatever but no i mean like i feel like anybody that can use a hardware wallet can use a cold card right like i mean you use it it's like absolutely like
Easy the only difference is that yeah we the only difference is i guess like we don't make the compromises that they make right so so you can't really use a like a wallet that we make that we validate for you and all that stuff on purpose like we don't want you to share your financial data with us like they do yeah like ledger live for instance yeah or or the other treasure something i forget the name but yeah like it is very easy to use i mean and if anything i actually find it easier with the buttons too like yeah like trying to cycle through
With those two little buttons and yeah i definitely like it better so i push back against that idea when people like put it out there i think i think it's just sort of like people who say that haven't used cold card yeah there's just like a reputation or something that they're like trying that they're just repeating or something you know we have a sort of like a mentality with our products it's like we don't push them hard on on consumers yeah like you know everybody eventually is going to use a cold And then once they use a cold card for Bitcoin, they never really go back.
It's inevitable, right? So we sort of take that approach. It's easier that way. What happens a lot is these noobs who buy a treasure ledger, they use it a little bit, and then they will experiment a cold card. Eventually, they'll move to a cold card, That happens a lot.
Yeah.
So I think I have a Mark II with the nice clicky buttons.
What's the latest on the cold card development? Well, we announced firmware 4.0 yesterday. Yeah, I heard that. That's a biggie. You know, we changed the crypto library. Now we have the same crypto library as Bitcoin Core. So maybe the Wookiee will be happy now.
Love you, yeah.
People need to snap out of this mindset that there is only a single solution for everybody. Because that's completely unrealistic. I mean, just think about banking, right? You know, some people have 10 checking accounts and a savings account and another account in a different bank, right?
Most people just have one checking account and that's what they use for everything. It's just different needs. Each of these solutions will come with different trade-offs, right? And you just sort of have to figure out what makes you happy, what makes you feel safe and sort of go with that.
What I like to advocate now, especially after spending a lot of hours on Clubhouse talking to noobs, is like I figure like, you know, I need sort of like a simple answer to a lot of these people, right? To get them their feet wet. So like I normally say, you know, just get a phone wallet, put a little bit of money on it, learn about seeds, right?
Once you do that and you feel comfortable, then you go to that BigQuery security dog guide, you get a harder wallet, you test it and then you send some money to it. Now at least you have the money off the exchange. And then once you do that, then it's like go explore. I mean, there's a million other solutions out there, like different permutations of what you want to do.
Right. Yeah. But at least like their funds are safe or it's safe enough. Right. Right. Right. Yeah. And, you know, and don't listen to the esoteric sort of like impractical attacks and all that stuff. Right. Because, you know, as much as those are possible and stuff like it's, you know, it's.
It's it's most people lose their bitcoin by screwing themselves not by getting robbed right yeah for sure for sure i want to hear more about you man i want to get to know you a little better like you know when did when did you get into computers what was your first computer oof i had what did i had i had i think it was like an amiga no shit i think was an amiga or or maybe yeah memory is failing man yeah it was very early we also my father imported unix to brazil like
His company yeah and this was like in the late 80s i think and yeah and i played with those unix sort of like a terminals that sort of had like a little mini mainframe and like i think yeah man one of those computers had a i remember this was a bit later there was a five no 256 megabyte hard drive spinning disk yeah it was this thick yeah yeah in like inside the machine yeah
It was like the size of like two bricks high yeah yeah that's i mean that must have been a pretty big drive at that point in time oh yeah yeah yeah it was it was like a like a multi-tenant architecture for like like it was like crazy things yeah it was pretty cool yeah that's awesome man i remember our first computer 486 packard bell but what i remember most about it was the right?
Like this was, this was the, this was the like a thing that really hooked me. I was like, holy shit, this is amazing. And not being online felt like useless, right? Except for like computer games, right? I played computer games, but if I was not online, I felt like this, this machine was like totally useless. And even with a 2400 bod modem.
So I remember running BBSs, for instance, I convinced my stepdad to get like a fax line quote unquote back then, so that I'd have a dedicated modem line and yeah i mean did you like play with any of that stuff were you on like usenet or irc oh yeah so so so i was on bbs's at the time right i had my i can't remember what molding i had i think was like maybe 64 bits it was it was like early and it was only bbs is some of those bbs's were connected to others some of them were just was just sort of a bbs
I think i disconnected hey sorry i disconnected i'm back so good yeah so so yeah so i don't know where did I stop? 64 bits. Oh, right. So 64 by the end. Yeah. So we used to, I used to use those BBSs, right. And, some of them were connected to others.
Some of them weren't. And, what was fun is that because the, the phone minutes in Brazil were really expensive when I was a kid. I used to have a 50 foot, copper pair, that I would just like take line or there was a there was an empty apartment under me that had they had a live line just connected you know like total like like bread right just and i'd use it like 24 hours a day like the internet for that line it never came to like like nobody ever complained it was like crazy like year like
A whole a couple years really like i'm just using the phone line yeah just and that that was yeah that's some hacker little shit man yeah we made a my friend and i made a what is it like a like a screensaver and we put it up on aol for downloads it was a windows like three windows three point whatever and it you put a phone book in there and this is just a little asshole thing to do too but you put a phone book in and when your screensaver was on it would just go through and dial
People like just fucking dial people the whole time your screens oh that's great and people would pick it up and you know you have that screeching sound or whatever many years later remember that software from the cult of the black cow that was like back orifice and like no i don't remember this oh those things were so much fun they essentially democratize hacking you needed you needed no skills you just needed to you essentially have like owned their computer right yeah it was fun to put that in the school and like take over the school system oh man yeah we did that once too man that's yeah
Like that was the funnest part the challenging the thing you know like trying to hack the school computers we did a real simple way like they had a just an ascii based login right just a little ascii screen for the network and so we just put a little auto exec file like auto exec.bat file on the computer it would show just a copy of that screen.
It was really easy to simulate. And it would just give an error because there was a limit to the number of connections on the network. And it was really common to get this connection error. And so we just give the connection error and log the username and password. And then we'd come in at the end of the day and we'd have like 10 teachers' username and passwords. Yeah, we used to change the grades and stuff.
We were little brats. I think I almost got kicked out of that school. Anyways. Yeah, too much fun, man. So when did you start tinkering with hardware? Ah it was it was way back to like you know it's just always tinkering around and stuff I was never sort of like I didn't go to school for that or any of that stuff yeah you know I even for the stuff we make like you know I have like people who are much better than I am at the stuff like working with us to make the products we make yeah but it's still fun right
Like oh yeah i mean but that's that is the fun right like yeah it's making hardware is like it's a whole other sort of different universe right then than sort of working on software you know you have like you're bound by physics yeah right like you still have to like you can't just like infinite memory right infinite like Amazon capacity for your servers, none of that stuff.
You still have to make stuff fit in a few kilobytes. It's great that way. Yeah. And you also have to get the stuff manufactured. How does that process work? It's obviously a security sensitive thing when you're dealing with a hardware wallet.
So what is your hardware production stack and what have you done to be able to trust it? So we don't we don't trust it it's kind of like that simple so you know we have sort of like a multi-layer approach right first is that like you know everything that we make is made in canada about 40 minutes from my house right yeah there's the factory there we have a few lines of that factory is ours it's a small little production factory for we like to keep it's sort of small like that.
You know, we have the way we program the chips and the way we sort of do our firmware and things, like we're essentially not trusting them. And, you know, and they are our team, right? So it's like, but we don't trust it because like a rogue employee could try to put something, right? So we don't trust any of that.
And yeah, so then everything gets bagged here. The serenoms of the bag go into secure elements of the code cards and then we ship worldwide that way. And the facility is secure and it's direct, right? It's like from us to a consumer, which is really, really cool.
For people that don't know, it's like they come in these security bags that are tamper-avident. Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's cool. And is that where you got the name CoinKite? Like these little security bags, like these little kites flying out there?
No. So CoinKite is almost 10 years old. It's about that. Oh, shit. Yeah. Amazing. Yeah. We started way, way back then with Bitcoin debit cards. These were the first Bitcoin debit cards in the market, like way back then.
I didn't know this history. That's awesome. Yeah. We made payment terminals. I don't have one here. And we had them all over the world and stuff. But, you know, it was like payments for Bitcoin in like 2013 kind of thing. Like, right, right. Kind of like silly, right? Well, that's what everybody was thinking it was about, right?
Because, I mean, that's just kind of how it started. Yeah. The first use case for it. Yeah. So then, I don't know. I can't remember. I think it's because like the CoinKite thing was like based on like you have this string was sort of representing like your funds in the blockchain blah blah blah I can't remember but that's kind of how the company name came about gotcha that makes sense yeah yeah I always envision these awesome like little tamper evident bags sort of like flying around and when I when I hear the name it makes sense yeah
Yeah so you what was the next product open dimes after that no so we essentially were like big goal before big goal okay we had like a full sort of wallet system there was about like four billion dollars worth of bitcoin in it wow and we were like the back end of a bunch of exchanges i think even bitmax had had like some of their their back end with us in those days and then we were like okay it's like we don't want to we want to offer bitcoin like custodial even or semi-custodial whatever anymore this is not a business i want to be in yeah you
Know so then so then at that time you know we were sort of like looking to maybe license our hsms our hardware security modules for for servers and stuff so we closed down the service you know people sort of like we draw it and sort of bye bye i don't want to deal with like services anymore and we launched open dime and then and then and after that we're like okay we need a hard wallet i don't like the ones on the market so we sort of launched one for ourselves and then it was enough interest that we sort of decided to sell it yeah so when did the first cold card drop i
Think it might have been 2017 20 yeah i think might have been 2017 yeah that sounds about right that's that's when i attention and yeah because i think open dime is 2015 maybe i don't know man it's like the time in in bitcoin is sort of like moving like you know like we've been in this space for like over a decade now so it's like a completely losing sense of time and space yeah man like forgetting stuff and like it's just yeah i mean i guess that's what happens when you start getting old and losing and
Memory deteriorates. Yeah. And there is something about Bitcoin. It's just like, it's, it's crazy. Time either seems to like be really like slow or things are just happening like crazy fast. Like through a bear market, it's just like, you know, you, you've got to just like hunker down and build and like, just kind of stop watching price for months at a time.
And just, but then the bear market things or bull market things just seem to happen so fast and customers coming in you can't keep up with it news is dropping all the time and just the time never boring never boring right like it's just it just never stops yeah and then everyone just goes away yeah no it is crazy like i mean there is a lot of people who are not around anymore right like it's like but like thousands of people that i haven't seen in in ages right right you know some of them will ping from time to time some of them will show up on clubhouse after you know years yeah it's it's interesting i
Mean yeah once you get to a certain point right and i was actually going to ask you this you get to a certain point you've been in bitcoin for a long time and you're i mean you're one of the ogs that's really been involved in the space intimately and for such a long time and you obviously have this you know you've built up some some money from this thing appreciating and being in pretty early and there's a massive incentive just to be like, I'm out, you know, at least for a while.
Like there's just, there's so much that goes on. It takes a lot of like, like mental and like just even emotional, like capacity to be in this space that people just be like, all right, I don't have to do this anymore. You know? Yeah. But what are you going to do? Like, are you going to sip margaritas?
Like, like you need something to do, right? Like there are lots of people that just want to sip margaritas for a while and sit on the beach. Right. Like, but yeah, I mean, I agree with you. I'm more of like a, I want to do something kind of person. Yeah, no, it's like, you know, my hobby is like making the stuff we've made and it's like, but I don't believe in making things without profit, right.
Like for the market. So like, you know, it is surprisingly rewarding and fun to create a profitable business. Right. Like I, it's great. Like, you know, and you can do man. Yeah and then you get to create stuff right like with with budgets with constraints and sort of like yeah anyways that that's sort of like what i love to do yeah it's a massive challenge to build a profitable business and like sustain it over time it's probably one of the most rewarding challenges there is that i can that i can think of you know yeah so block
Clocks you got one back there you've got the original it's got the little flippy like number things you know like old school like train stations you know it makes that clicking sound and everything it's it's really fucking cool like did i heard you say on clubhouse you like source those from from somewhere yeah so it's pretty cool i wanted that those flip type digits i couldn't find those in any scale right okay and then and then in our research we found this factory in poland that makes the last like they're essentially the last professional grade sort
Of like electromagnetic digits like this type yeah and they make from tiny ones all the way to like a foot high big digits right yeah and because there's a lot of like train stations in europe and in asia that still have those yeah and they don't want to retrofit them so anyway so so we found this factory they can actually make them in like volume right like and these are rated for 100 million actuations no shit that's crazy the real deal like these these are the same digits that are on the station kind of thing yeah i love them they're just like so nostalgic for a lot of people right and they're just they're so unique like
I love the noise yes let's see if i can let's see if i can play it hang on let me press some buttons here let me put in party mode it has a pair a party mode yeah hang on party mode
Oh man that's so satisfying it's so fast too it is and we're running it slow like yeah oh yeah these things because because they run on magnets right like you can like it's like you just turn it on it just snaps right in yeah it's pretty it's pretty cool it's beautiful technology man yeah it is yeah so and then you've got the okay so the original block clock like that's not being made anymore right like that's no no supply no more supply we made we made a few batches people who bought it bought
It they're serialized you know we made them as like a 10-year anniversary of bitcoin yeah that was sort of like the goal and then and then that's it i mean like we had a couple requests to make it like you know if somebody really wants it we can we can make it how do you call it like like on demand it's just a fortune that's all because it's like a one-off, right?
And then we launched the little guy, the mini. We wanted to make one that everybody can afford kind of thing. Yeah, yeah. I don't have one yet, but I definitely need one. So I don't know. I don't know why I haven't pulled the trigger yet. But the stats per dollar is pretty sick I see behind you. So 1,770.
What other display modes are there on it? So you can do, you know, there's a million things. You can do, you know, hang on a second here. Obviously price. Hang on. Okay. There you go. Market capitalization.
Nice. And you can change it to white. Nice. Hang on. Yeah. You can change it so that it's like reverse display. Yeah. And you can have like lights on the back. Sort of like different colors, you know? Yeah, I've seen that.
Like people have in the background with new blocks coming in and it starts flashing. That's right. Look at that market cap, man. $1.1 trillion. Yeah, that's right. That's crazy. That's right. So, yeah. So there is a bunch of like data options there. And we wanted to make it weird as well, right?
Like not just like, you know, a computer display or like an OLED display kind of thing. So if you want an OLED display, just look at the data on your computer. Right. Yeah. So then for this one, we use the ink. Yeah. Yeah. I can tell. The resolution is amazing on it. It is pretty cool. And you have QRs for open dimes.
Yes. Yeah. You can slide an open dime right into the side of it, like a USB port or something. Oh, look at here. I have one. Or like a SD card or something. Yeah. There you go. See that's that's just rad i don't know if that one is initialized that's rad though we'll see if it shows up oh i so this would be sick i played a poker game one time where i mean we had chips and we were playing with some cash too but we had some open dimes and people would every once in a while throw out like on the big pots throw some open dimes onto the middle of the table you know nice like like poker chips oh man
That was so sick if just be like you know prove you know exactly how much is on there and i have to trust somebody to say it pop it in so i'm definitely going to do that at some point like poker game with a bunch of open dimes and a block clock mini sitting there yeah i yeah it's the open dime stuff it's a lot of fun it's once people sort of like figure out how how they should use it like for themselves yeah it's like it's it's it's a lot of fun yeah they're they're really fun they're punk sort of vibe and cachet to it for sure all your products do man you guys
Have this like you know this this cypherpunk vibe to like the design and kind of just the ethos of production ethos you guys use too yeah it's like you know we make stuff for ourselves and hopefully people buy it and use it too that's sort of the mentality yeah right that's the best way to do it man that's the best way to do it all right so tell me what you're gonna what you're gonna do once we hit a million blocks you just make you're gonna have a new addition by then i imagine yeah well so so remember right for the price is it's number go down really right because what really matter is sat's parity of course yeah yeah so so the final
Goal is to make a device that's just one digit right yeah exactly it's one set per dollar one set or one set per penny that's right yeah exactly and no but we are all set up right like i don't know if i do i have yen on mine no what we do is we show we can show scientific notation and we can show like sure there's lots of like currencies in the world that are really fucked so like we've already sort of worked through it i was thinking about the number of blocks though but that's that's a long time away like let's see what probably another seven years or something like that yeah we would to
Scientific notation. Yeah. And who knows, maybe by then we just launch a new clock. If we find another technology that's interesting, like just different to show stuff, you know, we'll probably make something else again. Actually, I guess you have enough spots there. You just have to get rid of the, the key. Like where it says set instead of stats for dollar blocks, the block height or whatever.
There is seven digits, right? Yeah. Right. Right. I just wasn't counting the, the far left where it's like, you got a little key there. But yeah, key you just know it was block height so that would totally work that's classic man nice nice so what do you what do you think about like where we're at now like not just bitcoin but the world like economics for let's just start here when did you start learning about what money really is like the truth about the economy you know i think like i
I came to bitcoin for the tech and i stayed for the returns right yeah it's like yeah no i mean my number go down yeah like you know honestly speaking it's like you know i was like like economically illiterate right like when i first got into like learn about bitcoin right yeah yeah and at that time of And then like a bit after I learned about Bitcoin, I was working in this time series search engine with a bunch of finance people as a startup at that time.
You know, and sort of like just soaking in all that, all these guys who like literally came from trading.
And then sort of like, you know, sort of understanding Bitcoin, understanding economics and sort of like just sort of like doing, it's like, you know, it's like doing an economics PhD, you know what I mean? Like fast. For real. For real, right? Just because, you know, Bitcoin humbles you, right? Until you understand the incentives.
But better, right? It's better because if you get an economics PhD, it pays. Because it pays. And if you get an economics PhD, for life. You're going to end up working in like a federal reserve and you're going to be the last one to buy Bitcoin on the planet. And it's going to cost you a lot of money. Yeah. It's a, I mean, it's about like understanding your bags, right?
Like it's supposed to try to understand the macro. You know what I mean? It's like, I don't care what's happening in the world or how they see economics or anything. I just wouldn't understand like the Austrian principles in Bitcoin and then all that matters to my bags exactly exactly yeah i mean it's all about time frame right and this is exactly what austrian economics teaches us like we need money that can last for the long term it gives you that like long-term perspective did it like did it did it change you in any way i mean let me talk oh yeah yeah i mean completely right like
I you know like i've lowered a time preference on everything in my life right like yeah it's like it starts from like the cheaper clothes you buy to like not giving a shit about like all the noise in the world you know like and it's just like you start appreciating like the future right like because you can price the future that's the main thing about bitcoin right is the first tool that that really gives us a an adulterated like way of, of opportunity cost calculation.
Right. Like how are you going to, how are you going to calculate opportunity costs? Right. When like, you know, fiat is essentially going to shit. So you're supposed to spend it. Right.
Trading stocks or like equities in general is like, you know, you have to learn how to be a trader essentially and go full time on that instead of doing something productive in your life.
You know, like what are you going to go like real estate? You know, you have to really have some form of like reasonable, like accumulation of capital to get in that game. Yeah. And it's inaccessible to so many people because. Exactly. So, so it's just like, it's, I like this idea of investments being simple, right?
And you being able to just sort of make, make a future calculation that is like that, that a farmer can make. Right. Like Bitcoin is for farmers. It's like you understand very sort of natural principles and they're just very innate.
Very instinctively, you can accept Bitcoin principles because they're just so compatible with nature. Nature, it's all that there is. It's economic actors right like if the lion doesn't get up to go hunt it doesn't eat it dies right but at the same time like there is conservation of energy right so like i'm also gonna just lay in the sun yeah you know i'm not gonna do useless stuff i'm not gonna go create a defy a lion defy because like you know i'm wasting energy right like therefore i need to go hunt for more food like
Sooner than like it's all this economic calculation that's really cool it's like through free market right and like bitcoin sort of like puts us back into that state yeah yeah i mean you're totally right like it's the free the free market idea like i so when i was you know growing up learning about economics i went to college and like just took a couple basic economics courses and stuff kind of the ideas that were given to me were like, interestingly, kind of socialist, right?
Like, oh, yeah, like, socialist, socialist, right? So it's, it's like, you know, you're supposed to be here learning about economics. And like, you know, you think you're going to be talking about like free market capitalism and, and like how all those, you know, free markets work and stuff. But you know, you start learning about like, monetary policy manipulation and trying to like, even out, you know, wealth inequality, and it's just it's fascinating like this is not what i would like the way this shit's supposed to work right like it's i mean all day once is to centrally plan everything and centrally control everything that that's not free market
Yeah exactly like i mean it's not even close it's like but you know like like this is all a reflection of its people right like i mean reality is it's not like i'm not a subscriber of like a master conspiracy of why we have like centralized mmt and all this shit right no this is what people want people want free shit free services and they don't want to fucking pay for it right like it is really that simple so like what is a politician to do if he wants to get re-elected well we're gonna give you some free shit right like and you create a cycle and but but the thing is too
Like you know people with like a lot of capital accumulated already like they they need the loopholes right and so you create essentially two classes of people in the world the capitalized and the undercapitalized but you know what the other capitalized i mean that's kind of what they want too so it's it's not like a black and white sort of you know oh poor poor people kind of thing it's like that's what you want you keep on voting for these morons yeah it's it's interesting too i kind of have the same feeling like i don't think there's this mass conspiracy i think there's certainly some people who
Know what's going on and know what they're doing but i think there's also a lot of people who have like this this you know their hearts in the right place or whatever like they want to try to solve this wealth inequality and give you know try to give money more money to the poor or whatever, like kind of build the middle class through all this like economic engineering.
And, you know, people will point back to, you know, like the 40s, 50s, 60s when the, you know, wealth and equality started going down. But you guys were stealing shit from Europe. Like, it's like, but that's the thing, right? I mean, like, you know, this idea of the American middle class in the suburbs, the corvette in the garage. I mean, like, that's literally the blood of children, right?
Like from other countries, right? Like, it's a, this is all a fallacy, really. You know, the thing is, equality doesn't need fixing. People are unequal, right? Some people are stronger. Some people are not strong. You know, some people are good at numbers.
Some people are good at, I don't know, painting the walls with poop. It's like people are different and they will produce different amounts of value to society, right? You know fixing poverty may be a worthy go or or you know but then you know that's what charity is for right like i mean that that's like it's kind of like how all this champagne socialists right like they always want to like more taxes and this and that it's like listen if you're so concerned about homelessness why don't you fill up with like your house with people like you have room in your house yeah
Well the paradox is like unwittingly or whatever even if they're like i was trying to say like their heart's in the right place right the it all stems from the broken money honestly like that's where it comes from right because like you know poverty is this cycle of poverty is just completely enforced by the money which you know like you said keeps the money with the capitalized people and their families and concentrates it there and then all of us you know plebs have like 70 of americans have like less than a thousand dollars in savings right yeah like what's gonna happen what's gonna happen but see it's all like
Time preference and mallocity of capital and that's the other effect that's the other effect it has yeah right so it's like you have mallocation of capital and everything right like they're building like large roads that go nowhere, right? Like so that somebody else can make money building another subdivision somewhere. You know, you have all this money being funneled into like, you know, a hedge fund game, right?
Because that makes sense. I mean, they're smart and they're doing what the money system tells them to do, right? That's what the signals that the market send them with like, it's like the government created, like you have the system created by a government that people chose, right? Okay, how do we game it? It's that simple.
But then it's like at the same time, it's like you have a population that's more interested in buying. I guarantee you most of low-income people have bigger TVs than I do. It's like they have better TVs than I do.
Why? Why are you buying those big TVs? It's like go do something else, spend the money on something else. All dying of diabetes, right? I mean, I agree with you, right? But I think these social outcomes stem from the money, right?
The time preference- Oh, 100%. Yes. Time preference is influenced. I mean, like we were talking about, it changed the way we approach life in the future, right? So if you have this fiat money and all the corporations have this incentive to just spin profits every quarter and have planned obsolescence of all our products so every year or whatever.
And it's like, it completely changes the mentality of the populace. It passes on down, right? Yeah. I mean, for people listening, I mean, if you want to start understanding like quote unquote inequality and sort of time preference and sort of like this kind of stuff, I highly recommend reading Thomas Sowell.
Thomas Sowell has some of the most digestible in my opinion well-written like economic books you know he's he's a little like a little too sort of like kinsian for my taste not austrian enough but but he's it's like solid read right like it's really it's it's really it's really good read yeah like it's like people people have a lot more freedom than they think they do right it's just that nobody wants pain right
Once you sort of embrace the pain like you know you produce yeah yeah it's yeah it totally it's the personal responsibility thing and it's an idea like all right you know people will hear this hear this idea or hear us talking about this and think it's you know like all right these guys with their privilege are sitting up there talking about how easy it is you just got to get off your ass and go work and you shouldn't buy this big tv right or whatever and you know they they have like access to all of this stuff or whatever it's yeah go ahead no go ahead go ahead so so like you
Look at like in in canada right they start giving everybody a two thousand dollar check without no questions asked right for the pandemic sure like you can't hire people to do like to do like stuff that they would make between three and four thousand so they rather make half and stay home yeah doing nothing right like but but it's just very telling of the people yeah you know it's like it's like i feel like the people get too absolved of sort of like their feelings it's not like you can't like like but i think it's also So I think it's also kind of hopeless, right?
Like there's this sense of hopelessness. Totally. Like, you know, even if you like work three jobs and you're working your ass off, you feel like you're getting nowhere. So it's like, why the fuck do I do this? Yeah, that's right. You can't save. I mean, saving should be simple, right? You put the money under the mattress and then like 20 years later or 30 years later, right? Like you buy a house or you retire or whatever.
That's how it used to be, right? Yeah. Now you need a PhD in finance to sort of figure out which derivative you're supposed to like to go long or short on right right right right or being or being the right reddit or be at the right you know dinner at some like fancy ass place in New York I mean you're totally right so yeah obviously there's people who are going to be like lazy compared to other people or whatever and prefer not to work but I think a lot of it is there are some really fucking hard-working people out there oh yeah just can't make it happen because the money you know just fucks them from the beginning they just have they just keep on getting screwed yeah yeah it's like the system is stacked against them right yeah exactly yeah
Bitcoin fixes that bitcoin fixes that man so what happens in your like in in your view to like the way that society organizes itself in in this Bitcoin future. Like people are, people have the freedom to like save and don't have to have a PhD in finance and can actually like maybe do something that they want to do.
After putting in 10 years of hard work, they get to, they have some savings and they get to do something they want to do. They have capital, right? So how does that change the way we organize ourselves in society? Do you think? I think, I think, you know, somebody was saying, it's like, you know, a lot of stupid ideas won't be funded anymore, right? It's like, I think the malolocation of capital is underappreciated as how bad it is today.
And I think a lot of that sort of like diminishes, right? I mean, you can look at this like all the way to hyper-briconized world, you know, where like, you know, real estate is only utility value. There is no store of value in real estate anymore. There is no store of value in equities anymore. It's only utility value.
And but you know people are still gonna need to eat people are still gonna need to fix cancer people are still gonna need to you know put people in mars right so so those ideas will be funded right it's just that people are probably not going to be funding like instagram right like like this kind of stupidity like it just won't be that valuable right because Like when you do opportunity cost calculation, I doubt that Instagram in that universe is going to provide the same returns than just doing nothing.
I don't know, man. People fucking love Instagram. Well, you know, if they had less shit to show off or fake show off, right? Yeah, maybe it would be as useful, right? Yeah. That's right. Yeah, man. Yeah i mean i guess you know things will get a little bit more localized right like people will be able to be more in tune with their with their government because like you can't if you take away the printing press you take away the ability of the government to or the even the incentive of the government to just like metastasize
And grow to be massive Just like you're concentrating wealth into a few hands, you're concentrating political power and legal power into a few hands, right? I think you make a much more meritocratic society, right? And because people are making better opportunity cost calculations, right?
You know, they're less likely to pollute, right? Like they're less likely because like people are more future oriented, right? Is the outlook on everything, right? Like, you know, cities will probably plan better for the future, right? Like, because they don't want to deal with capital costs that will sort of like make them spend at the wrong time, right?
You're going to have like people, like for example, you know, instead of making like revamping all the street signs in a city for an ungodly amount of money, right? They're going to look for better, cheaper suppliers. Yeah. You know, it's like so all these little things, even if we don't get too crazy, right, just just the fixing of opportunity costs and all these tiny little things in your life, in your everyday life, they change like they add up to massive things.
Right. Just imagine the last amount of garbage a household would produce if people just buy less stuff because they rather save. Right so it's like less garbage right right like garbage collection becomes cheaper taxes in the city go down right like yeah it's kind of fascinating once you start to add all these tiny little things like how much he adds to yeah i mean if you combine like jeff booth talks about this if you combine exponentially you know exponential technology that's deflationary right like the tv right like you know you can you can get those giant ass tvs for like 500 bucks now going
Down in price. That's because we have exponentially advancing technology. And that stuff's going down in price despite inflation, which is why all that shit. So you combine that with deflationary money and you can fulfill all the basic needs of humans pretty, if we switch to Bitcoin, let's say in the next decade or two, combine that with the force of exponential technologies.
So, you know, in a future like that, where, you know, basic needs are kind of taken care of with much less work or effort from humans. I mean, what do we do, man? We have like 5 billion people who have all this time on their hands. I mean, seriously, like governments are super inefficient, right?
So like, you know, it costs like 70 cents, 80 cents on the dollar to deliver a program. Yeah. Right. So like once you remove that, great. Yeah. I mean, it's cheaper to there is no moochies in between you and the poor person, right? Like there's nobody like, like taking a cut on every single solution.
So yeah, like, I mean, you know, humans are going to be humans, right? Like people are not going to like stop killing each other or, or like, or start inventing stuff. Like we're just going to keep on being who we are. But, but at least we're going to be able to sort of like calculate the future, right like as a as a an actual dollar amount right or a bitcoin amount and make make better decisions yeah i mean i guess you just start working on shit like you know 50-year architectural projects because because you can and because you know you people people can come together and have capital to do it
And like you know it's fun it's interesting to like contribute to like some you know legacy building or establishing project like that's what humans want to do right and that would be much more satisfying i think to a lot of people than flipping hamburgers and fiat food yeah you definitely see it's like either either lasting things or appropriately disposable things that are sort of just like recyclable so so like you know who knows maybe we figure out a way of like making buildings in a day do you know what i mean with like just some like prefab slabs of something that's like fully recyclable and then as that city sort of maybe move somewhere else like you just take it down transport
It exactly it's just it's like i'm not i'm not sure i subscribe to like the lasting building sort of theory anymore as much like i think like it's just like it's like human ingenuity would just sort of like keep on making things with less material more efficient and sort of like cheaper right like everything right yeah are you by chance like a like a space nerd do you ever do you think about space travel i mean we're like it's not it's a reality it's not reality yeah would you ever would you ever like go
Like travel to the moon or go to oh yeah i mean like whenever they have like you know like a nice weekend trip to the moon i'm in yeah yeah but it's yeah i don't spend too much time on that. Was it Dhruv who wrote that interplanetary Bitcoin article?
Yeah. So good, man. I don't spend a lot of time on that. It's pretty cool. I love that there's Bitcoiners spending time on all the things Bitcoin, right? Everything, yeah. And it just all gets studied and figured out because it's so fucking fascinating. And that particular article is amazing. Have you thought about, like, you know, Gigi writes about Bitcoin in time.
Yeah. It's interesting, right? Like block time, do you think that becomes, I mean, it's, I don't know. So, Drew also writes about how, like, over a long period of time, block time is super accurate, right? But do you think people would actually use it in the short term just because it's, like, variable compared to the time we use it?
I make clocks based on block time. Right that's what i'm asking you like so no so block time is very interesting right because yeah time in a sense like like practical timekeeping right not not like theoretical or or or like you know bitcoin time block time its resolution is plus minus 30 minutes right so it's like from from essentially 10 minutes to about 40 minutes so it's very doable it's very useful and once contracts contracts
Are digitized right like with dlcs or something they start sort of like being settled on blocks right you make sign it will make sense to have block time sure that makes because like and contracts are like one of the most sort of in humans, right? It's like, it's an interaction between two people.
And as that becomes sort of like the norm, not the exception, right? I mean, you will have like, you know, block time as part of society. Like, I mean, I can definitely see that. Yeah, it's definitely something cool. I don't nerd out too much about that.
I nerded out enough about the radios and Bitcoin stuff, but like, yeah, it's like there is so many, so many avenues you can nerd out in Bitcoin. That's exactly. Yeah, exactly. There's not enough time in the day. I like that idea, though, right? Like contracts could be sort of the gateway into using block time in other ways, too, because like you'd be like, oh, you know, I pay off my house a block seven hundred thousand or something like that.
Well, the debt, your mortgage is going to probably be your house will be collateralized on a DLC contract eventually. Right. I mean, that's bound to happen. Your mortgage, it'll be like a 100,000 block mortgage. Yeah, and what's really cool about this is that you could, in an essence, eventually have...
I don't know how the enforcement of this will happen in the real world, like physical world, because a house is not metaphysical, it's physical. And all the blocks, the blockchain stuff is metaphysical. Right? So there is a gap there on how do you enforce with guns, right?
House ownership. But, but you could have like, financial products where, you know, you have a pool, of, of capital. So essentially micro loans that amounts to the amount that you need to buy a house. Right. And that's how you take your, your, your loan, on, on DLC contract.
Right. Like, I mean, I, I can see that happening like not too far from now, maybe not for a house, but definitely for other things. And then you'll be on a block contract. Right. Right. Right. Right. Yeah, so DLCs are definitely interesting and they're starting to happen now. I saw a couple days ago tokens being minted on RGB.
I think there's a wallet that you can download on TestFlight on iOS. It's called MyCitadel. And people are creating tokens like it's command line for now for the creation of them but you can use this wallet to trade them back and forth atomic finance is gonna is is building some cool shit with dlcs so i mean is this kind of the birth of like more financialized products built on top of bitcoin do you think well so it's like i've always said this right i mean ethereum exists because there is a market for financialized products, right?
I mean, that's never going to go away. That's what the people want, right? The people want something and they're going to make it happen, even if it's in a shitty platform. Sure. I think people are going to be less willing to gamble their money in these contracts, especially for overly financialized stuff, just because holding Bitcoin is going to probably pay off better with less risk.
But there is definitely a market. And we should definitely address that market, right? I really like the DDSC stuff. SureBits is working on some stuff like that. And these things, like, I mean, forget about, like, sort of, like, the brain fart defy stuff, the way that they describe it, or, you know, all the NFT crap.
And I'm talking about, like, useful today things. Like, for example, creating a Bitcoin collateralized loan, effects between currency pairs, right? Like you need these things today, right? So as we can codify them like in Bitcoin, right?
They'll be used and they'll be very useful because they are cheaper than existing solutions by like financial instruments, right? It really is a needed thing. Yeah. And yeah i mean i you know shit will move over to bitcoin like the atomic finance guys actually came from ethereum and they you know they saw they tried they messed with lightning they're like oh this is just as easy to build on as you know as ethereum but it's actually like a platform that might be around for a while you know like you're minting nfts on the ethereum blockchain or you know longer
Term contracts or something who fucking knows if that thing is going to be around, right? Like in 10 years, five years. I mean, yeah. The problem is like Ethereum is essentially a honeypot for sucker money and people willing to take advantage of sucker money. Right. I mean, it's amazing the influxes of sucker money that they have, but, you know, like all this, the second wave of DeFi stupid is like probably 10 times smaller than the ICO stupid.
It so it seems like people are learning their lesson right and sort of like and the network is sort of like plateauing sort of like or diminishing you even see less ethereum noise nowadays on on twitter and things like that it's like i just don't see as much aside from the current sort of like nft crap which is tiny right it's like it's not even that that much money on it so it seems like given enough time and enough money lost like people tend to learn their lessons but hey don't ever underestimate a crowd yeah exactly i
Mean if it's going to be done it's going to be if people want it it's going to be done i think nfts will be a thing man i think it'll be around for a while like i think people like trading shit and they're gonna like find they're going to assign value to owning the original. I think it's going to happen. It's just so dumb. I agree with you, man.
I agree with you, but I think it's going to happen. What they want is DRM. It's just that they can't make themselves say it. I would understand. If they said we've put DRM on the blockchain so that you control the exposure of the art, there is actual scarcity on the art.
It's like it is stupid in my view, but hey, at least it's economical, right? Like it makes economic sense. Now, like the NFT shit is just like absolutely stupid. Yeah, I agree. I totally agree with you, man. But they're going to do it. People are going to do it, man. People are going to do it. It'll, you know, it's a massive bubble and it'll blow up, but there will be people who do it.
I think it'll just be like, you know, push to the margins and it'll be kind of a collectible thing. The way I like to see the world now, like since Bitcoin became a bit bigger in the last few years, it's like there is economic relevant things to Bitcoin. There is economic irrelevant things to Bitcoin. Right. Are they noisy? Are they going to make people money?
Whatever. Sure. They probably will. Right. Like, yeah. But they are economically irrelevant to Bitcoin. Right. So to me, it's like Bitcoin is this like noise canceling headphones. You know you put it on and it's just like it's just quiets all the stuff that's economically irrelevant yeah that's amazing just like boom boom that's it yeah it's a nice heartbeat like you're back in the womb and here's the blocks beating yeah yeah that's awesome man all right this has been a great conversation man i'm gonna let you go and get back to work building your amazing shit and it was it was good to hang
Out all right dude it was it was fun it was a good time man all right take care take care all right man thank you that was a good time i really do appreciate it my pleasure yeah i'll drop it i'll drop it tomorrow yeah that'll be fun i'll probably see you on clubhouse as well that's right yeah i'll i'll turn it on at some point it's great right yeah it's like the clubhouse thing is weird it's like it gave me a renewed appreciation for the noobs which i had sort of like kind of like forgotten about in a way I, you know, cause like I stopped doing the Bitcoin meetups like in 2013, like I
Ended them because the Ethereum people started to come in. Yeah. And so overrun them. And then sort of just like, it was a slow sort of like, like departure from dealing with noobs. Yeah. What I love about like the clubhouse is like, it's like this like visceral direct interaction with people who are so fucking like, like blank about this stuff.
Right. Right. It gives perspective. It does get quite repetitive though. Like it's just like over and over and over again. So I think I think we're going to have to start doing like more planned rooms and like, you know, I definitely burnt out the bit. Like I've, I've taken. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Me too. But you know, like it's, it's interesting.
Like these people, like waves of people kind of come in, it's like, you take a couple of weeks off and then other people come in and there's always, you know, people in these cafe Bitcoin rooms, like holding it down and answering You know, it's just like people get burnt out. They come back a couple weeks later. So like I, you know, I've been back on a little bit more because I took a couple weeks off.
And it's, it's a, yeah, it's, it's a cool platform. I find that the smaller stages and like, and like it being a bit more like rough on the people who are asking like lazy asshole questions sort of like really makes the experience more, more reasonable. It's like, you know, when, when people just fucking ask something like, how does Bitcoin fix inequality?
It's like, doesn't, like, remove. That's it. It's like engaging with these people, just like, it poisons things. And then it just becomes like, Jesus, this is the 10th time I talk about something dumb. Yeah, yeah. As opposed to like, you know, how do I store my big questions? If I don't mind answering that, like, a hundred times, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
I totally get that, man. All right, dude. All right, dude. I'm gonna jump. Yeah, me too. Take care. Take care.
Thanks to Rodolfo for joining me for this conversation. It's a ton of fun. You'll find Rodolfo on Twitter at NVK. You'll find me on Twitter at CitizenBitcoin. Again, you can subscribe to this podcast at CitizenBitcoin.world if you're not already. And head over to SwansignalPodcast.com and subscribe to my other show.
Again, I'll be doing this one every other week and I'll be doing Swan Signal Live, the other two weeks of the month. So you'll be able to get one podcast every week from me. Stay in the two pods a week. We've got so much going on at Swan. So thanks for understanding. And, you know, thanks for your loyalty for listening to this podcast for, you know, a lot of you have been around since the beginning at, you know, 2018 and then 2019 when I started interviewing other Bitcoiners.
So it's been a long, it's been a fun ride and it's a lot of fun to record both of these shows. So I hope to see you over on Swan Signal Live. Of course, you can, like it's in the name, it's a live show. So you can head over to youtube.com slash swan signal and join us live. We do those every Wednesday, usually in the afternoons, 2pm Eastern, 11am Pacific, sometimes in the evenings.
So watch out for those subscribe, turn on notifications. And we have a lot of fun in live chats over there. So let me know what you thought about this episode on Twitter again at citizen Bitcoin. Take care of their Bitcoiners wherever you happen to be in the world.
Thank you.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
Rodolfo Novak, is founder of Coinkite, of the longest running Bitcoin-only companies in the world and makers of beloved products ColdCard, OpenDime and BLOCKCLOCK. We get into Rodolfo's background, the early days of Coinkite and the lastest on Coinkite, entrepreneurship, economics and bitcoin's relationship to time.
Citizen Bitcoin Layer One merch collection
Swan Bitcoin - Buy bitcoin with your bank account
Party Alchemy - Charcuterie and Cocktails
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek