PoW is Efficient, Information Theory of Money, Tokenizing Securities and Realized Market Cap
Brady and Tommy discuss bitcoin mining energy usage and why Proof of Work is efficient, the information theory of money and the 2018 Baltic Honey Badger conference with takes on Bruce Fenton's tokenizing securities presentation and Nic Carter's Realized Market Cap idea.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're here sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. I'm Tommy. And it's been a couple of weeks since we last sat down to have a chat about the old honey badger, the Bitcoin.
And it's been an eventful couple of weeks. There's been a lot of talk about energy usage on Bitcoin. I think that that's sort of the next mainstream media play, although it's it's gotten plenty of play in the mainstream media. It's I think it's gonna get played up even more over this next you know incoming bull cycle whenever that starts.
So there's good good conversation happening there, and it was also you know one of the main questions I had is on my journey to Bitcoin maximalism is you know what about proof of work and energy usage. My thinking has evolved a lot. We're gonna discuss an article by Dan Held and kind of give our thoughts.
We're gonna talk about another another tweet storm that Dan Held posted in the last couple of weeks about the information theory of money, a book by George Gilder and kind of adapting that theory to Bitcoin. And then the Baltic Honey Badger Conference, Tommy. It's one of the better ones. Happened over in Riga, and yeah, it's probably I think it's probably the best one in terms of the content that comes out of it in a two-day period is just it the quality density is is amazing.
So we'll link to the two days of recordings of speeches and presentations given at the Baltic Honey Badger Conference by some of the most well-known Bitcoiners. And I think we're going to highlight a couple of the presentations that were given there and shout out a couple of a couple of the others that you should definitely check out.
Although I think watching both all of both two days is certainly worth it. So let's dive in, Tommy. Okay. Alright, first up. Bitcoin as digital gold, the information theory of money. So there's a book by George Gilder called The Information Theory of Money, which is worth a skim.
And Dan Held has, which is at Dan Held on Twitter. Of course, he changes his last name to Heddle as a play on Hodel, which, you know, yeah, funny. Good job, Dan. So this is just an interesting idea, I think, and helps can help underscore how important sound money is to an economy and thus a culture, a society.
Money is the basis of our interactions with each other in an economy and a society, and it is essentially the central information utility of the world economy. So it's a medium of exchange, a store of value, unit of count, money is the critical vessel of information about the conditions of markets around the globe and both time and space.
Right. If wealth is knowledge and growth is learning, and both are governed by the science of information, then knowledge expands through testable learning, proceeding through entrepreneurial experiments with outcomes measurable as reliable money, right?
But reliable money is an absolutely critical part of that equation. If you don't have reliable money, if you have money that's being manipulated or double spent. Yeah, double spent, or or or the you know critical aspects of the money are being manipulated by a central authority, then it's not necessarily reliable money.
Sure. One example recently. Yeah.
All information, continuing through the tweet thread, all information is most importantly a surprise. Without surprises, time is low value and boring. Entropic surprises are what lend energy and directionality to time in economies. Creativity always comes as a surprise. Capitalist economies are not equilibrium systems, but dynamic domains of entrepreneurial experiments.
Money should be a standard of measure for the outcomes of these experiments. So analogous to entropy, profit or loss represents surprising or unexpected outcomes, analogous to average temperature and thermodynamics, the real interest rate represents the average returns. So the economy is not chiefly an incentive system, but an information system.
It requires a reliable standard of value rooted in the irreversibility of time. Alright, this is fundamental stuff here, right? This is like breaking down the fundamentals of human trade to the equipment and analy analogizing them to the fundamentals of physics of the universe, right?
Thinking very much from first principles. So in entrepreneurial experiments, the constraint is the scarcity and irreversibility of time. With infinite time, anything is possible, right? Finite time imposes the necessity for choice and prioritization, right?
So time is embodied in interest rates, in budgets, in contracts, and in accounts. But it's also the irreversibility of time that gives value, right? The that puts the constraint that leads to scarcity that forces us to make decisions in one way or another and creates value in the surprise of in surprising information, right?
Sound money then with Bitcoin is also irreversible in time and set in stone in in time on the on the blockchain. So the blockchain is literally a chain of blocks over time that are set in stone and irreversible, all right?
So it's it's you know, protecting and securing that sound money and that monetary policy in with the irreversibility of time. So gold achieves irreversibility through its chemistry and its time based entropy of extraction, meaning it takes time and energy to extract it from the earth.
So Bitcoin offers the similar irreversibility through complex mathematics and software, so it's a lot more efficient, and it's based you know, based on time-stamped public chain of blocks. So basically, if you kind of subscribe or believe George Gilder's information theory of money, then Bitcoin is the perfect instantiation of money because it is information that is enshrined in strong mathematics and ordered very you know forever
Permanently and rooted in time irreversibly.
Right. Right. Yeah. Well,
Bitcoin in particular always go to the it goes to the longest chain all the way to the longest chain. Yeah, yep. So that's that's Dan Held's kind of application of Bitcoin's should we explain should we exrophies mentioned in there a couple times for for our listeners.
Should we explain what that actually means? Oh, yeah. So entropy is like is just another word for chaos or disorder. Yeah. Alright. So let's take a look at another art an article by Dan Held. Of course that that was a little tweet storm. I'll link to that in the show notes.
This article is titled Proof of Work is Efficient. Alright, and there's also been a couple other articles that have come out in the last couple of weeks that I'll link to as well in the show notes. One by Hass McCook on the called The Cost and Sustainability of Bitcoin.
This is a report, the most thorough report that's been produced that looks at the cost and sustainability of Bitcoin mining. This is an update as of August 2018, and it was published this pat in the past couple of weeks. I'll link to that as well.
Certainly worth looking at. But Dan's article on medium is a is a bit more easy to digest, I think a bit more straightforward. I would definitely recommend reading that. This is a this is a question that comes up usually you know within the first few questions from any person new to Bitcoin, right?
Because they'll have heard it and it's and it's kind of a sensational thing. Uses more energy than Ireland, will use more energy than the Earth produces by 2020, which is which is just hilarious. But yeah, you've seen these headlines in mainstream media and scaring scaring people who consider themselves environmentalists.
We haven't we haven't heard a lot about it in the mainstream media lately. It's just because Bitcoin's just not a phenot a phenomenon phenomenon like it was. Right. Yeah, because of the price. But the price will go back on another bull run at some point, and I think that this energy usage argument is go is gonna continue, it's gonna persist.
So,
I was concerned about it too when I first found out about Bitcoin, and I've thought a lot about it, read a lot about it, and I've sort of evolved from being concerned about comparing the amount of energy that Bitcoin is using to alternative systems of money, like fiat money or gold.
And that's what that's what Dan does in part in this article, and what Has McCook does in his research. The conclusions are that as of right now, Bitcoin's not using or is is using energy more efficiently than other types of money, like the systems that support fiat money and the and the system that supports you know using gold as a store of value.
That being you know mainly gold gold mining and recycling and extraction, all that stuff. So that's kind of where we're at now. Like the idea that Bitcoin is extremely inefficient in terms of money is incorrect. It's you know more efficient than gold, it's more efficient than fiat if you count you know the systems that enforce and support fiat's monies.
And of course, if you then incorporate the inefficiencies in that are created in the economy by using you know hundreds of different kinds of fiat monies all over the world, then Bitcoin is much more efficient. And that is that is good. That's I mean that's good to understand and research, but I'm less concerned about the amount of energy that Bitcoin's using in general.
And I feel I'm not gonna be. Yeah, yeah. Why why what was your thinking when you first were confronted with the you know the argument that Bitcoin is is is extremely wasteful. Well, part part of it is is that you sit there and say it's the entire country or France.
Well, we're Ireland. I think Ireland was the France. They had France and their team. Yeah, they had France, they had Ireland, but they had France also. That was the one I like to pick is is France just because I pick on France. But But under that notion, what you're basically saying is so what we're doing is we're just gonna go ahead and put all the Bitcoin miners in France and then everybody else in France, you know, it's gonna be in the dark, and not you know, so so the way I always conceptually looked at it is you had the mining was happening in in places where there was less expensive energy and where the energy wasn't you know wasn't
Being utilized. So if in the case of hydropower you had a situation where these dams were running and it just it's just natural, you got the water running and you've got a dam and you're able to capture that energy. And so if if it wasn't used, it's out out in the middle of nowhere, and so if they're not able able to put the transmission into a transmission line to take it somewhere, right it's just sitting there and it's and it's not being utilized at all.
Yeah. So I visualized it from that standpoint early on. And so Yeah, you had a good intuitive understanding of that. And something that I've come to understand is the way that like Bitcoin incentivizes the usage of the cheapest electricity. What is the cheapest electricity right now, right?
It's well it's it's waste, it's what it's electricity that would otherwise be generated and wasted, right? Because it's because the cost of it then is zero. Right. Essentially, and it and held Held had an interesting table in in his in his medium write-up, and he and it's something I know quite quite a bit about because I've I've visited bauxite mines and bauxite facilities, but in the terms of production and bauxite is the mineral that gets turned into aluminum, right?
Aluminum, right? And so the aluminum facilities weren't located in France. They weren't in a lot of cases weren't located in in in regular, they were located where you had a low cost you know a lot of times where you had low cost power so aluminum smelting turning bauxite into aluminum is really expensive or really energy intensive right very energy intensive in fact one of the examples in the United States now I'm just this is anecdotal I'm just thinking about this yeah but there were some in the United States they're producing aluminum out in the northwest at a facility out there and now that I'm thinking about it that
Was a low cost electricity area where they were where they were operating these smelters and come to find out what are we what have we had going on in the United States there's been Bitcoin mining going on in the northwest right out in the area where they have low cost electrical you know electricity it's mostly hydropow stuff up there right and so like take the case of hydropower right so one of the problems that hydropower generation has is that you can't just turn it on or off and it's not a continuous sort it's not continuous in the sense of like you can't control we don't have control over the flow of the water entirely like you
Can build dams and control flows and things like that but you know it depends on the on functions of nature on and things that happen right so you might be having you know have it a ton of energy coming because you had a rainy week right and you're producing more than is being used so what do you do with that excess energy if you're a hydrodam right and this is why this is why China was had so many miners too there was a bunch of hydropower in China that was literally not the demand was too low.
And it was just being wasted. It was being just let go. Like it was just not being used. It was being generated but not used. So Bitcoiner Bitcoin miners would set up shop, plug in, take that excess energy, and store that energy as Bitcoin. Save it for later. Right. Same thing with like like you were pointing out with the aluminum.
All right. So and Dan Held points out, there are because it's such an energy intensive process like Bitcoin mining is, it was actually profitable to take the bauxite out of the ground somewhere else, ship it to a place that has extremely low or no energy cost because you're using wasted energy and turn it into aluminum.
Right. So it there's there's analogies to this in the past. Right. And so so the so the other way way you could look at it, since we're on this topic and we're just kind of stream of consciousness talking about it, not that bad, but just talking through it is the idea is is maybe what the idea is is the calculation should be, let's find all these places in the world that that there is unused electrical capacity, calculate that number and compare it to the projected or where where Bitcoin's projected usage is and see what happens or where that lays out, whether there's a there's
A shortfall or there's excess you know, in terms of how that lines up, right? And then go at it from the argument rather than saying, oh my god, you know, it next thing we know it's gonna be the entire continent of Africa, you know, and then and then the second component of this is very important is just the efficiency of the overall mining, because there's there's more than one, you know, there's more than one component going on here as to how we're calculating this.
So if the mining, the ability to mine it, utilizing like you know, the newer models use electricity to get the same less electricity to get the same amount of hash power. Yeah, or or you know, improve on the hash power, then you're not going to use as much.
Less electricity, more hash power. Yeah. You know, and so that's kind of the real way to look at it. But you know, it's it's and hash power efficiency is decreasing. Like the advances in hash power per per unit of energy in Bitcoin mining hardware is decreasing. And at some point, right?
So, like you asked the question, when will the energy used for proof of work stop growing, right? And it is decreasing in its in its in its arc, in its arc, the curve is decreasing. But if you think about it, and here's Drew of Bonsall in is quoted in Dan Held's article here.
When will energy used for proof of work stop growing? Precisely when enough energy producers have started doing proof of work directly, that the marginal return from burning a kilowatt hour of energy through proof of work equals the marginal return from selling that kilowatt hour to the grid, right?
So once your marginal return for using energy to generate Bitcoin starts to equal the marginal return for selling that energy back to the grid, which is your alternative, then the premium on proof of work is reduced to zero, right? So that it that's when it will stop growing.
And Drew Ban Bonsall suggests that I suspect proof of work will will use between one to ten percent of the world's energy when this equilibrium is reached. So obviously it's not going to you can't extrapolate the trend right now, and it's not going to continue to use the same amount of energy. The rate is decreasing.
But what we're getting for this is an extremely secure, censorship resistant, permissionless money system, settlement system that, you know, in this in the past year or so has settled something like one and a half trillion dollars between counterparties, right? And we did that all for about four and a half billion dollars in mining costs.
Seems completely worth it to me. Especially when you start to can consider the benefits of sound money. One single global sound money. And I don't think I know, I know that we don't understand the con the consequences of a global sound money because we've never had one in human history, right?
So Bitcoin is the first technology, money technology that can become the single global currency that our economy is based on. And the inefficiencies that we'll get with that Bitcoin will get rid of by replacing all of the various fiat currencies that we have around the world are are hard to imagine.
Yeah, but that's a whole different, yeah, definitely. But then the idea is that there's a whole different there's a side of that that's not gonna not gonna agree to that. Sure, that's fine. But I'm my point is the consequences like Austrian ec economics and economists have thought about the potential consequences or benefits, I guess, benefits of sound money for a long time, right?
But we've never actually experimented with it in reality. If some of those ideas come to pass and you have the a culture based on a money that is freely inflatable that is flating over time, right? You have a different set of incentives and rewards for that culture, you know, in that society.
That society kind of develops certain habits and certain values, right? And then if you have a sound money society, which there have been pockets in history that we can look at, but in in the end, money centrally controlled money always gets inflated. And we haven't been able central centrally controlled money has not been able to resist being inflated at some point over time.
But you have a kind of little glimpses like the Renaissance, for instance, and Seyfa Dina Moose talks about this in the Bitcoin standard, where Rome was there were some emperors in Rome that really bel understood the value of sound money and made sure that that the gold that was being used by the realm was not you know inflated or decreased in value by by coin clipping and other practices like that.
And you know, coincidentally or or not, you have this era of human history that was extremely productive. Well, and that's what happened in you know the history of the coins, right? They c they they started they started adding another element in with the you know, they let's put it this way, they reduced the purity.
Yeah. Coin clipping, I think is what the practice was called, right? What they called it coin clipping. I enlightened what the water is. That's what he called it in the book. Okay. Well, that's what it yeah, I didn't know there was an actual term for it. I the way I looked at it is more metallurgically. They put I think they added more silver or other elements in and just a trade out so that it oh over over the centuries, yeah as you move forward from whatever it would be.
And the same thing has happened with US coins too, right? I mean, weren't nickels actually had nickel content in them for a while and quarters actually had silver content. Well silver Mercury dimes, silver was silver. Yeah. Yeah, and a nickel was actually nickel. Right. And then they started knocking, you know, and then I think it's actually dependent I don't know where the price is right now, but there you know, there was just for a second on that, just because it w there was a point where the actual value of the nickel with the nickel content was greater than nickel.
But the point is is that yeah, they were clipped. Yeah. The pennies were clipped too, because they used to be copper. Right and those got clipped also. Yeah. Yeah. So you know, it's well, and also to that point, it used to be after that you had a silver certificate, that you could, you know, you had a direct direct trade into that that tied to silver.
Right. And when that got kind of out of whack, then they then then that it was decided that they weren't gonna tie that anymore in terms of the central bank wasn't gonna gonna tie that anymore. Yeah. So they clipped that and quotes clip clipped that also. So it I mean it turns out when you sit down to think about it, proof of work is actually an incredibly efficient way to secure sound money, digital sound money, digitally scarce sound money.
Yeah, it's it's it's certainly not wasteful and we'll we'll see how it goes. I it and it it's not gonna take over and use all the world's energy and burn up the planet. That's that's a at least as far as we can tell right now.
Fair enough. Okay, so let's talk about the Baltic Honey Badger Conference. Okay. So this is a conference that's held by the Hoddle Hoddle Exchange. It's put on by the Hotel Exchange in Riga every year. Two-day conference.
A lot of the big name Bitcoiners were there that that you'll know from Twitter and YouTube and Medium and who you're learning from as well as us. Eric Voskell, Matt Carrallo, Jameson Lopp, Vortex, Adam Back, Peter Todd, Nic Carter, all Elizabeth Stark, let's see who else is on the on the list here.
Giacomo, Zuko, Eric Lombroso. Yeah, so we've got you know a lot of a lot of the Bitcoiners that you know about and learn from were at the conference. The two two YouTube videos, one for each day.
The comments have nice timestamps, timestamp links for each presentation, so you can kind of pick and choose what you want to listen to. You know, if you have the time, I suggest just going through the whole thing in order. Day one, day two, tons of information there.
We're gonna pick a couple that stood out to us. Tommy really dug the talk from Bruce Fenton about tokenizing securities. And you and I have been talking about this idea for a long time, but kind of back and forth. I've been pretty skeptical about the need for a blockchain in in the security tokenizing process.
Why not just use a trusted third party? Bruce Fenton's talk though is a really good kind of answer to that question. We're gonna talk about that, and then also Nic Carter, his talk on why market cap is a bad metric and his kind of proposed replacement of market cap, I thought was interesting.
So, Tommy, you want to talk a bit about Bruce Fenton's yes presentation? So this will be in the show notes, but I'm gonna try to distill this down, you know, in terms of the I idea here is in the area of security tokens. And so you know, there's a the whole area is is okay if it's a token ICO, is it actually a security as to how that's set up?
These security tokens, and jump in here, Brady. I was looking at this before where I just said okay, security tokens, I'm skeptical about this, and you then you've got utility tokens, and I said, Okay, well, a utility token, I think you can pretty much say or argue in most cases that that's not a security.
What we're looking at here in security tokens is literally taking a stock. By security we mean like a stock, right? So, like Apple stock is a security that you would own. Right. So the idea is taking that instead of having a certificate or a piece of paper, where we'd have a token and a blockchain that would control the scarcity or the supply of that security.
Right, and so right, right. And so the so the idea is is that actually as it being a certificate, if you step back and look at it, you say, Well, wait a second, this is a security token. And if it's just representing a certificate, then it's just almost a ledger or it's a confirmation of what's going on or a trail or a tracking, you know, of what's going on.
So it seems to make a lot of sense. And so the goal of Bruce's talk is why stocks and securities are foundation for global commerce. And we're going to get into this real quickly how ledgers work now and why why Bitcoiners are free market economists and just generally people in this area which would be Wall Street and institutional investors should you know should care about this.
So
What he what he got to here is understanding the problems and how ledgers currently work is key to addressing some major points people often ask about the value of blockchain or a token and why a database can't be used. Right. Which is always which has been my you know the kind of criticism that made sense to me too.
So you know why we have trusted third parties now for securities exchanges you know like New York Stock Exchange, Nasdaq, we have exchanges set up those are those are central or trusted third parties. They have a centralized database ledger that keeps track of the ownership right of all of these securities.
So yeah I'm curious about what his answer is to that. Well, he he gets into he talks and then he talks about programmable money in capital markets, but we're going to jump to the next in this next point. Securities tokens will include many scams and many low quality offerings. If a securities token revolution occurs, it may bring it with a large number of fraudulent and low quality offerings, just like the ICO wave.
However, legitimate securities themselves are part of key part of economics. Uh-huh. Sure. And then do should I read this von Meis' thing, or you think it I'll just read it real quickly. A stock market is critical to the existence of capitalism and private property.
For it means there is a functioning market in the exchange of private titles to the means of production. There can be no genuine private ownership of capital without stock market. There can be no true socialism if such a market exists. And I guess the point with the point with that, this whole statement by Ludwig von Meissen is just the idea of this back and forth or the trading or the exchanging of these titles.
That's what we get at with a particular digital digital aspect or what would be a security token underpinning this. It's fundamental to everything. It's capitalism, right? Fundamental capitalism is the ability to trade the private ownership of the means of production. And then Bruce Bruce has has established himself in this area very strongly.
He talks about his history in here in a couple slides in here in very good. He grew up, his parents were traders. He grew up in the in the grew up with it in the trading rooms and all that. Had pink sheets when he was a kid. So
He makes a key key point, which it's two points. That the fact that what makes money good and what makes an agreement good, and the fact that a security is not not a currency. And what makes good money good, durability, portability, scarcity, acceptability, uniformity, and divisibility, which are all aspects specific.
Actually, Bitcoin's a perfect example of it has all these attributes, and then what, and this is the part of the security aspect of it. The security token specifically, what makes an agreement good, the terms of the agreement, and the enforceability of the agreement. Sure. Right?
And so and then okay, that's covered, and then we'll go down to the slide. So he jumped, he he takes that enforceability and security, right? And he he created a security using Bitcoin open dime.
So he he has this video that he links to and it's it's tweet number 30 in this in the in this tweet storm. So he takes an open dime, puts some Bitcoin on it, takes a pen, writes out a contract, security, and basically basically like links the enforceability of the contract to the existence of this UTXO on the blockchain.
And Bitcoin, like blockchain doesn't know anything about it. It's sort of like it's just a UTXO, but it's on it it's attached to this open dime, and whoever has that open dime, which is like a little thumb drive. If you haven't seen what an open dime is, it's like a tiny, tiny thumb drive that it is secure, kind of like a like a ledger NOS or a Trezor wallet but they're they're sort of more they're cheaper to make and so they're they're more just kind of usable and tradable so whoever has this open dime has the ownership rights to the security that is described
On a piece of paper that was that Bruce Fenton wrote out so and then he also points out that Overstock.com has issued securities in a similar way and so it's been done it's been done and you can use Bitcoin you can use any you know kind of any blockchain but you can use bitcoin to secure tokenized securities there's also the prospects of side chains and Paul Stork launched the first his first sidechain he's been working on for a long time sidechain one this past week it's something something we can look at in a in a future episode but that
Also could be a place where you know tokenized securities could exist and live on the blockchain and enforced by the by the base chain well the other and just to add to the open diamond he did this on a and I watched it what this has been a while back but and this is this will be in the show notes you'll be able to get to this pretty easily or you can go into Bruce's at Bruce Fenton in terms of this this is a recent thread we're going through but the whole thing took like 25 minutes in other words the actual explaining go all the way through but him actually creating a security didn't take hardly any time at all yep and I think the other the
Other comment that I would have here too, in terms of using Bitcoin, since you're dealing with a security, the idea of using Bitcoin as the place to issue, you know, to have the actual securities, the actual protocol on I think it's very, very solid just given the fact that you know, the Lindy effect and how long Bitcoin's been around from the standpoint of it being completely secure.
Yeah, yeah. So yeah, so that's interesting. You know, and in in a future global economy based on Bitcoin, it would make sense in terms of liquidity and you know, usability and user experience to trade other assets besides just just the money itself you know on the same blockchain or at least secured by the same base layer, maybe on a second layer secured by the same base layer.
So maybe there's a way to do this with with Lightning Network. I'm sure there is a way to do this with Lightning Network. I know Lightning Network has a more advanced sort of smart contract scripting abilities. So I think you know, maybe you could open up different, you know, and the other thing we probably should emphasize, and we probably should provide this example because I think it's an excellent one from that you've got a centralized third party that's handling these securities in these documents now, right?
Yeah. So there's an example, there were millions of shares that were almost destroyed by Hurricane Sandy. They were found 1.3 million in soaked securities were literal paper documents, right? Paper documents were found in a in a vault in New York.
And it took a year and a half of specialists in secure rooms with water vacuums and dryers to recover these shares. Yeah. So and the value was over one trillion dollars worth of shares. So you think about that, right? Yeah, I think that's an important point that he makes is like the current system's insane.
Like it's so complicated at this point. I mean, so you know, yeah, I mean, that is right. I mean, you have a situation. And then the whole the Dole Foods example where there was like Yeah, go ahead with that one, because that was actually I was actually shocked by that example. Yeah, but there were a ton more outstanding shares than than like d basically Dole Foods lost track of how many shares they had outstanding, and there were actually instead of like 24 million shares, we're actually like 30 some million shares.
I'll get the I'll go to the specific. There was it was they it was in the low 30s, yeah. Million shares, and then they came out and they said, Oh, wait a minute. Right. We don't have 36 million shares outstanding. There's claims that came in. We have 49 million shares outstanding, right?
Yeah. So can you imagine sitting in a company and you're the CEO, let's say you're the C I'm the you're the CEO, I'm the CFO or any employee that has shares. No, what I'm saying is in terms of you're you're like supposed to you gotta report to your cause Dole at one point I think it I don't know where it was in a public company, I guess it some of these go in and out these food companies.
But so you're let's just give an example, public company. So you're going through whatever an event is, and you're like, okay, we need to we need to go ahead and we're gonna do a change of control or something, and we'll just we gotta get these these shares in. And you've thought all along you had 36 million shares outstanding, but then all of a sudden there there's legitimate claims of shares of 49 million.
Yeah, so everybody's shares are diluted by 33% or so 30 some percent.
And you sit there and say, you know, well, how could that even possibly happen?
And then somebody comes in and says, Hey man, you know, how did you do this? And you say, Hey, I'm the CEO, I don't know. This company's been around for 40 years. I had no idea that there were that many shares, right? But that's not the right answer. But I mean, that's crazy. It's crazy. So then Nic Carter had a presentation as well about Bitcoin as an economic system, the economic aspects of Bitcoin.
And he talked about the idea of a realized market cap as opposed to the idea of market cap, right? So the market cap is simply the like supply times the price, and that gives you the market cap. And that's you know, coin market cap.com, and the market cap is you know cited on CNBC and used by pretty much everyone as like the value of a particular currency, cryptocurrency.
But Nic Carter says that that is sort of a misleading misleading number, especially when you're using it to measure cryptocurrencies that are not used very much. Okay. And so his idea of realized cap is that you the cumulative price or the cap is based on the cost of a UTXO when it last moved, or an unspent transaction output when it last moved.
So for instance, if there's a UTXO that someone's been holding on to for five years, you he would price it, the realized cap would price it at the cost the or its price five years ago when it when it last moved, right?
And so if you use that method to measure the value of Bitcoin, right now the market cap is about $115 billion. With the realized market cap, it's about $88 billion, as of as of you know a couple days ago when Nick made this presentation. But the interesting thing is when you used realized cap on altcoins like Bcash and Ripple and others that are not used very often, and there's there's UTXOs that haven't moved for a very long time for in terms of you know relative to the existence of that currency, then like the market cap for some of these
Altcoins, especially and then you just kind of go down the list, went from like tens of millions or hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars to a mere fraction, one percent or two percent of that value. And so the realized market cap is pri it is giving a better, a more accurate view of the actual value of that cryptocurrency in terms of its being used than the market cap does.
And it's so easy to, and this is why we always talk about how the market cap is not a great indicator, a great number, because it's it's easy to manipulate. Like we could create a cryptocurrency with a supply of a gajillion coins, right? And then I sell you one of those tokens, one of those coins, for one US dollar, right?
Now we have a market cap of one gajillion dollars, you know. But that's obviously not reflective of the actual value of that cryptocurrency. So with the revised market and with the revised cap, that UTXO would be priced at one basically one dollar. Well, does it I mean part of the that's the only transaction, the price of the transaction that you've got to do?
Well, that's a happy ad, right? But I mean, the other if you look at you know, if you look in the case of just real quickly, Ripple and Litecoin. Yeah, and their supply relative to Bitcoin, and so a lot of people don't realize or XRP ripple, it's a ripple XRP, but you want my friend.
They don't they don't real they don't realize how much outstanding supply is there, right? How much that can come in and dilute the whole yeah, and it's like Litecoin is four times Bitcoin, right? It's it's mirrored after Bitcoin or very similar characteristic to Bitcoin, right? Except that Litecoin is four X, it's over eighty eighty million shares.
Yeah. That can come in that can come into play over time. Yeah. So anyway, I just thought I thought it was an interesting take and a way to kind of evaluate the landscape, realized market cap. I think it's real good. Yeah, so that's from Nic Carter. There's some other great presentations in here.
Mentioned a lot of those those names at the top of the show. Gave presentations or sat on panels at the Honey Badger conference. Check those out in the show notes, watch them, learn, you know, learn Bitcoin, teach Bitcoin, test Bitcoin, build Bitcoin. That's my mantra. Sort of the trying to walk up that ladder of taking taking ownership and helping build Bitcoin.
First you gotta learn it, then you can teach it, then you can test it, then you can build it. If you can get, you know, there's not that many people that that get to the top of that hierarchy. But just trying to learn as much I can just make it a goal, make it into goal. I enjoy I enjoy it. The whole topic is fast, the whole area is fascinating. Absolutely fascinating.
All right, fellow citizens of Bitcoin, that's all we have today for the show. Thanks, everybody. Please do leave us a review. We've got a couple of reviews on iTunes, and it definitely helps. I notice when a when a review comes in, there's a big bump in downloads. So I guess I guess that means Apple's probably using those reviews to determine when to show you know our podcast to others who might be interested in it.
New people might be interested in it, so please do leave a review on iTunes or if there's other areas that you want us to cover or push into or let us know and we'll definitely cover it. Yep. All right, that's it for today. We'll talk to you all next time. Thanks everybody.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
Brady and Tommy discuss bitcoin mining energy usage and why Proof of Work is efficient, the information theory of money and the 2018 Baltic Honey Badger conference with takes on Bruce Fenton’s tokenizing securities presentation and Nic Carter’s Realized Market Cap idea.
Links from the show below.
Fascinated by bitcoin? Confused? Overwhelmed? We feel you. Follow us for useful breakdowns of news, the social & economic implications of bitcoin and breakdowns about how the system works. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of bitcoin and we’re sharing our journey learning bitcoin hoping it makes yours a bit easier.
Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter: https://twitter.com/citizenbitcoin
Citizen Bitcoin Podcast: https://citizenbitcoin.world
Citizen Bitcoin on Medium: https://medium.com/@citizenbitco
Links from the show:
2018 Baltic Honey Badger Conference Day 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=66ZoGUAnY9s
2018 Baltic Honey Badger Conference Day 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2WXxgZ8h-0
Dan Held on The Information Theory of Money: https://twitter.com/danheld/status/1044631693062066177
“Proof of Work is Efficient” by Dan Held: https://medium.com/@danhedl/pow-is-efficient-aa3d442754d3
Bruce Fenton on tokenizing securities: https://twitter.com/brucefenton/status/1043833386257854464