Hass McCook: Mining, Energy and Bitcoin as a Secular Religion
Hass McCook is a civil engineer and project manager of major public and private infrastructure and large-scale residential projects and a devoted bitcoin evangelist. In this episode we discuss energy and the business of mining, we compare the environmental and social impacts of gold and bitcoin mining and then we consider Hass’ most recent work analogizing the broader bitcoin idea to the idea of a secular religion. Thus far we’ve laughed as we’ve discussed this idea with tounge in cheek but I can see a future where a secular bitcoin religion grows and spreads as a means of spreading the traditions and values of holders around the world.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. What is up, Bitcoiners? I just started off this morning in the best way possible with a chat about Bitcoin with a great Bitcoiner, Hass McCook, and this is a great one.
But before we dive into it, I want to talk to you about the Bitcoin Core Project. This is the free and open source software project that started it all. Bitcoin Core is the descendant of the original implementation that Satoshi released on SourceForge on January 9th, 2009, just six days after the Genesis block was mined.
In 2018, there were 3,274 commits to the Bitcoin Core repository by 194 contributors, some of the finest mines in the world.
The users of Bitcoin Core only accept transactions for that blockchain, making it the Bitcoin blockchain that everyone else wants to use. It is these users who keep Bitcoin decentralized. They individually run their own Bitcoin Core full nodes, and each of those full nodes separately follows the exact same rules to decide which blockchain is valid.
You can contribute to the Bitcoin Core project by submitting bug reports, providing text support to other users, providing translations for the user interface, writing documentation, or, of course, by writing and testing code for the client. Thank you to all the Bitcoiners
Contributing to the project, and especially the developers building this world changing software. Alright, with that, let's dive into this week's episode with Hass McCook.
Hass McCook is a civil engineer and project manager of major public and private infrastructure and large scale residential projects. And of course, a devoted Bitcoin evangelist. His work studying and comparing Bitcoin and gold mining have been a major contribution to the growing canon of Bitcoin educational material.
In this episode, we discuss energy and the business of mining. We compare the environmental and social impacts of gold in Bitcoin mining, and then we consider Haas's most recent work, analogizing the broader Bitcoin idea to the idea of a secular religion. Thus far, we've laughed as we've discussed this idea with tongue in cheek, but I can see a future where a secular Bitcoin religion grows and spreads as a means of spreading the traditions and values of hodlers around the world.
This section of the episode will build on the basic ideas Gigi and I discussed in the previous episode. It seems Haas helped guide Gigi on his revelatory experience in Riga. And in this episode, we flesh out these ideas with Friar Haas. Okay.
Settle in and enjoy this one. Here we go. Alright, I'm very excited to welcome Friar Hass, Hass McCook to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast today. How's it going, Friar Haas?
Alright, it's going fantastic. I've been waiting all day to all day to hang out. So I picked up Adam Meister, the Bitcoin Meister from the airport this morning, and we're getting ready for Sydney Bitcoin Week next week, so it should be a great time. Excellent, man. Lots of Bitcoin stuff happening as always.
Yeah, so first a little anecdote about you and me because this I think this was cool, and I was thinking about this yesterday, and I remembered that I passed the lightning torch to you what seems like ages ago, but I think it was only like six months ago. Yeah, I think it was sometime round about March or April.
So yeah, you're right. Probably about six months ago. It does, it it feels like it's almost like dog years, feels like about you know four years ago. It does. Yeah, so that was a fun night. I had the I remember being quite excited about it and thought it was cool. Just a really great test of the lightning network.
You know, and we got some pretty big transactions there toward the end. I think the transaction I sent to you was three million sats. Yeah, I think it was a three million. Yeah, three million. Yeah. Yeah. I wanted to take the torch earlier, but I was afraid to fuck it up.
Because I didn't have a have a note, I was too technologically illiterate. So thank God for Pierre Rochard. As soon as I got that one-click node up and running, installed Zap. Took the torch from you, held it for maybe 30 seconds, and passed it on swiftly as as the lightning network intended.
That was a that was a good ritual that we went through there as a test of our faith in the lightning network. Well, they say the strength of the believers comes from their faith in each other. So I don't even think that the chain got robbed.
Did it? Maybe once and someone tipped in to start it to start it back up. Yeah, somebody did run off with the funds, and then eventually came back and apologized after being shamed on Twitter. Yeah, it's a reputation game. You gotta you gotta be low time preference.
Yeah, absolutely. All right. Well, we've already made a lot of allusions to religion here at the at the beginning, and we're d definitely going to get into it because I know you've been thinking a lot about Bitcoin in a religious context. And of course, just at the top, before we drive off, you know, some Bitcoiners who are devoted atheists, you know, I'm right there in that same camp with you, but that's not what we're talking about here.
We're talking about applying a kind of general idea of what a religion is, not in the you know, Christian sense or the you know the established religions of the world. We're talking about it in a very kind of basic sense, right? Oh yeah, absolutely. So all the definitions I give of religion will be 100% secular in in nature.
So we'll get more into that later. How was Riga man? I hear that you guys had a great time. Tell me about your experience there. Well Riga was the best. It was the for me it was the first Bitcoin conference I've been to in in about five years, actually. The last one I went to was Vegas Bitcoin Week in 2014.
And I caught up with with Kex Key from Bull Bitcoin at the end. He was he was there in Vegas. So Riga was a great time. I happened upon a young gentleman by the name of Gigi. He's he's like a brother to me now.
I don't even know his real name, but the people call him Gigi. So so what do they what do they say the proverbial the a rose by any other name would would sell us smell as sweet so I managed to hang out with with Gigi over lunch with Alex Svetsky and Sahara Breen was also with us in Riga.
And this lunch ended up going for about four hours. And during this lunch I did what I do best and I pontificated about Bitcoin religion and resonated very deeply at the at the lunch table. And that was the last time I saw Gigi in person.
That would have I think been on the on the second last day of the conference, but a couple of days later the messages started going back and forth you know in the midst of you know Gigi's religious experience and that bond has been permanently solidified and the same with with many other bonds formed on on that trip that will be a mainstay of my yearly calendar going forward.
A lot of passionate people and a lot of religious people and they they don't even know it yet. But they will after hanging out with us for a couple of hours, or you know, just depends on on if you're if you play it, you know, 1.x speed or not. Probably get it done in 40 minutes.
Excellent. Kind of you know, a speed mass, which I'm sure that there were many Christians back in the day sitting through these in you know interminable mass rituals in Roman Catholic times, like wish they could like 1.8x that shit. Well, yeah, well that that's the thing to keep up you know with your religion.
Like you gotta you gotta go to mass from time to time and I go to I go to mass every time I listen to a Stephan Livera podcast and you know boost my knowledge and further myself. So there's there's another analogy for you. Awesome, yeah. Riga sounds amazing. I'm gonna have to try my hardest to make it there next year.
Everybody should. It's fun for the whole family. Love it. All right, so let's dive into your first sort of effort to contribute to Bitcoin education. That was in the field of energy and mining. And you know, I we haven't talked a whole lot about m mining on this podcast, and I think it's an underappreciated aspect of the Bitcoin network, especially among among hodlers who don't have any experience with mining, and I think that's the case for most hodlers.
I did speak with Steve Barber about the mining process, but that was that episode was mostly about the energy needed to perform the mining process. So I'd like to hear more from you about the business of mining. What is it like to be a Bitcoin miner? So I think you know, being the religious Bitcoin fundamentalist I am, I like to use things in in their absolute most simple, oversimplified form.
So everybody basically knows about you know the business of Bitcoin mining. They they just don't know it yet. So, in terms of like a business point of view, so so thinking like a business analyst here, the Bitcoin industry and how like entrepreneurial decision making goes on is identical to the commodities industry, like gold miners, copper miners, whatever.
But the gold and you know, and you know, jet just general commodities, their industry cycles can last can last years, and switch on and switch off time isn't really instant. Whereas with Bitcoin mining, the cycles are fortnightly, or to be you know more accurate, you know, whenever you know 2140 or whatever number is blocks occurs and the difficulty changes, and turn on and turn off time is is instant.
So but in terms of other like decision making aspects, it'd be identical, just far far more dynamic. If I am a Bitcoin miner and I have to make these economic calculations, right, about whether or not to turn my miner on or off. Is that calculation relatively simple?
Just a couple of variables that I have to assess, or it is is it more complicated than it seems to me? No, no, super simple. And I've even got my model up for free, it's on medium. But there's like seven or eight like assumptions that you have to fill in. And just like you know, any analyst at an investment bank, you know, provides a company valuation, you know, based on you know what their view of future financial statements are, you know, discounted back to the future, blah blah blah blah blah, you know, yeah, yeah, every analyst will will spit out a different result.
Same thing same thing with these with bitcoin's economic inputs and drivers so the main things you know that the miner has to consider is opex or operational expenditure what it costs to keep the lights on or in this case keep the keep the rigs going capex which is capital expenditure on you know acquiring the rigs and where to house them all that kind of stuff they need to consider they need to forecast what the what the change in difficulty will be to do their to do their capex planning they need to worry about
The you know key key metrics dollar dollar per giga hash watts per giga hash so on and so forth but the outlook is bleak for for most miners yeah so it's I mean is it the closest to a perfectly competitive market that we have on the planet at this point probably at this point yes but still not perfect things will never ever be perfect or some people claim they'll never ever be perfect but I think in a in a future time past our lifetimes probably closer to 2140 it will effectively be perfect so
What I mean by perfect competition so there's nine criteria so perfect competition is the simplest way to explain competition to people all basic economics classes teach perfect competition because it just it just trims all the all the fat and you can just focus your attention on the on the broad general principles then you can get into you know monopolistic competition blah blah blah blah blah but effectively perfect competition here are the here are the here are the requirements all products that are produced are identical
So bitcoin satisfies that one that the fact factors of mob sorry factors of production are perfectly mobile so you can you can pretty easily move your rigs around the world move your money around the world go to favorable jurisdictions it wouldn't be wouldn't be that difficult to do the barriers to entry of entering or exiting are quite low if you can you can assemble a good team like the guys can't remember their name could have been could have been layer one who've just raised some big money I
Think 50 million from from peter field they're getting a group of hardware engineers together to you know bring bring mining back to Texas and outcompete Bitmain so the barrier to entry isn't that high like 50 million sounds like a lot of money but you know 50 million is is relatively easy to find you know when when you when you're talking trillions of fake money right yeah and you come from an engineering background so a meat space engineering background yeah so 50 million dollars for a large project infrastructure project
Like that is probably you know relatively small in that world absolutely like with like have a look at Uber, for example. Look at how much money is wasted on on bullshit like that. So like you think you know it's it's it's difficult to find 50 million bucks, the barriers to entry very low.
So other other requirements are that there's guaranteed property rights, and the blockchain offers the ultimate guarantee on property rights. You know, that there's a there's a lot of buyers and sellers in the market. So there's there's various you know ideals.
You can check that check that out more in my readings. It's been a long time since I've since I've talked about this kind of stuff. But currently Bitcoin satisfies about six of the nine criteria and will will eventually will eventually satisfy all nine or or close to.
So the interesting thing about that is that means in in in the long term in a perfectly competitive environment, the profit is zero. You know, or like it's it's impossible to gain competitive advantage because everything is identical. So the only way to maintain a competitive advantage in such a market is to either be a cost leader where you do things the cheapest, or or an innovation leader.
You do things the best way. And that'll be the fate of most mining companies. You will see big miners you know come and go. It's it's a very brutal place to try to compete in and predict not just volatile price, volatile hash rate.
Does that worry you at all? Does that concern you that the competition is so fierce that it will just you know the people interested in potentially mining on the Bitcoin network will just you know not bother? No, I think at that point, the pie will be so big and people will be so invested in it, they're probably probably happy to take a point oh one percent of their wealth hit per year contributing to mining.
Just to make sure the golden goose doesn't die. Like I can see that being an incentive, and I can see the market producing products that incentivizes such behavior. So for example, Cost are now incentivizing people to check on their nodes every day. Yeah, that's a ritual that I share with my family in the mornings before we as we're getting ready for school.
One of the little rituals we do is I set my phone on the table and the kids will touch the little heartbeat thing, watch it go through, and their favorite day of the week is Friday when we get the confetti or Thursday or Friday, one of those days. After we've gotten five out of six of the hearts.
And yeah, so it's it's been a great sort of entry point to allow them to ask questions about Bitcoin, and you know, I think my son says Satoshis like three times a day right now. Yeah, you may may may keys be upon him as as we say.
Love it. Okay. One more question about mining, which may, you know, of course lead to lead us more. But what do you think about the future of mining? Obviously, mining has become an industry at this point. You know, the $50 million dollar infrastructure infrastructure project in Texas is indicative of that. And Bitmain sort of led the way on that front.
What do you think the future of mining is? Do you think it's going to remain like the domain of large industry? Do you think it's going to become a bit more decentralized? Like, do you see people running miners powered by their Tesla power walls with solar panels on the roof and contributing to some some mining pool?
In a very, very, very competitive environment, there's this thing called the rule of three or four. So you'll always have three to four major brands that take up like eighty percent of the market, and twenty percent smaller brands making up the rest.
So if you can just you know think about like different you know product niches. You've got you know, have a look at the smartphones. There's like three or four big ones that take up the majority of the market share, and then then there's the stragglers. So what I see happening in in the Bitcoin world is eight to ten completely vertically and horizontally integrated mining companies that make their own hardware, generate their own power, mine their own Bitcoin, have their own OTC desks and brokerages, have their own wallets, have their own Casa-like service, have you
Know cloud mining for their you know, Casa equivalent members. So there'll be eight to ten of those, making up eighty percent of the network, and 20% will be all of us stragglers at home, or just just people that have figured out you know how to capture energy remotely and stuff, and it's it's worthwhile for them to mine on their own.
All really boils down to you know how cheap can you get your energy for. Right. And how how much like wasted energy is there out there in the in the conventional energy production world? More than enough to power Bitcoin probably at 20x this hash rate.
Amazing. Yeah, and that's I mean that's the cheapest energy, right? Because that's basically free. It's it's being expended anyway into the atmosphere or and however it might happen. I guess energy like energy loss in transmission, etc. That's that's you know, Bitcoin incentivizes the capture of all of that.
Yeah, and there's no such thing as free energy. You discussed that with Gigi the other day. Everything everything needs to come at a cost, and that cost is energy. So this is just it's not even free. It's it's it's loss. Your your your you know, you're stupid to not try to recover it.
Yeah. Because you're paying to produce it, so that's that's lost. If it's not used, it's it's money wasted. A hash saved is a hash earned. Yeah, basically. So in your mind, like what analogy do you tend to use to describe the Bitcoin's hash rate?
I think Dan Held uses the analogy of like a wall, that the hash rate just builds up this giant like defensive wall over time that is you know harder and harder and harder to scale as the block gets deeper into the network. I see it as a more pragmatic thing.
So I see it as a guy. I've got a billion dollars and I want to buy some Bitcoin. Do I spend a billion dollars now on an exchange? Maybe let's use smaller number. Do I do I buy my Bitcoin off exchange for you know X million dollars?
Or do I invest this X million dollars with the expectation to buy more bitcoins than I could have bought today? If the answer is yes, I can earn more Bitcoin by mining, they will start mining. And because of that competitive dynamic, hash rate will like will effectively keep keep going up until miners stop making profit.
Sure. And it's very rare that miners don't make profit, and when they do, you know, the whole death spiral fud comes out. But I think I maybe did a podcast with with Stephan Livera very very early. It might have been episode 12.
Yep. We're about to go into the death spiral, and I said, Look, when there's commodity price crashes, there's usually like upheaval that lasts for like two to three commodity cycles. So we'll shake the market, it'll take you know two to three years for the for the market to stabilize.
I remember telling him it's the same thing in Bitcoin, it's gonna take two to three difficulty changes, so this will all blow over in six weeks. And lo and behold, no death spiral, and it all blew over in six weeks. So in the six weeks, they were very punishing for for miners that were, you know, mining for seven cent electricity, and they were just out of the game and you know, the floor was short up by the people that you know pay four cents for electricity.
There's a profit incentive behind every business and that's and that's where the hash rate really does come from. It does definitely follow the price. Yeah, I was just gonna ask that. That's the relationship between mining and hash rate and price. And it's almost like sort of similar to that stock to flow chart that plan B is made famous at this point, that you know, will sort of like outrun the mean and then it'll kinda crash back down, but there's this sort of backbone that you know we'll always kind of drawn to like a magnet between hash rate and price.
Yeah, basically, so so for me, like as a as a pretty good approximator, I found that the hundred period EMA on the on the one week chart has been a very good indicator of historic mining costs.
So yeah, that would that would be kind of the backbone that we go above or below. You're looking maybe like sixty, six hundred bucks to mine a coin. And that sounds about right. Yeah, and price is about eight thousand. You'd see like the hash rate drop a tiny bit and plateau for a bit, until the price got a little bit of a kick, or until you know, new new equipment ships that's that's cheaper per per giga hash or or whatever.
So the hash rate can can continue to increase in a in a bear in a bear market, but it does hit its limit eventually. Sure, makes sense. But yeah, if you look at that hundred period EMA on on the one week on the one week chart, so that's effectively the two-year exponential moving average.
Like this thing moves pretty slowly, no volatility in it. Yeah, that that's around six and a half grand. And the true believers are praying for it to just come back down to that nice six and a half grand, that'd be great. Yeah, yeah. Stack some cheap sets. Yeah, definitely having ages.
Yeah, no. Alright, let's switch into a related topic. But you I watched your talk at Riga, and I think it's important to kind of get this stuff out there because I don't think it's appreciated. So is gold a shit coin, Hass? Yes and no.
Like, look, I'm not gonna disagree with Peter Schiff. Industrial uses, like gold bulletproof. Love it. Nuke proof even. So it'll survive a nuclear bomb, but will remain radioactive anywhere between one day and six months, depending on what radioactive isotopes it releases.
So so in terms of it being good, rock hard, useful for industry, gold, amazing. Everything else, shitcoin. But when it comes to comparing gold to Bitcoin, oh yeah as a monetary thing, I think it only has industrial value. So I've got Bitcoin teen has got me on board with that hypothesis.
I think gold's only worth its its use in industry in in the long term. Right. So putting it up against Bitcoin, I'd say gold is a shit coin. Yeah, so monetarily speaking, but then you also go into all of the other factors that make gold worse than Bitcoin, right?
And obviously we have we have you know, Bitcoin's a better monetary policy, its stock to flow ratio is going to be lower, it's gonna match gold's next year, it's gonna be lower by 2024. It's cheaper to verify, much cheaper to verify, easier to verify, much easier to send around the world, etc. It's more divisible. So yeah, we you know we've got all of those benefits or advantages on from for Bitcoin over gold, but then you have to look at the extraction process, the mining process between the two, have vast differences as well.
Very vast, and very similar at the same time, identical, like I've told you. It's identical to you know, gold mining just on just on turbo with this with you know two supercharges. Gold when they were first like during during the gold rushes and all of that kind of stuff, it was very basic, you know, literally picks and shovels, panning for gold, relatively easy to find.
Same thing with Bitcoin, you could, you know, mine 50 Bitcoin solo mining on your laptop, easy. But then, you know, as times went on to now effectively mine gold, you've got to be like Barrack Gold or BHP or one of those huge gold giants. At the same time, if you want to run a profitable mine, you've got to be pretty big.
Yeah, and so what I mean, what are the environmental ramifications of the gold mining process as compared to the Bitcoin mining process? And you've you've studied this, I think, more than anybody I know. Any Bitcoiner I know that's that's out there publicly and publishing this material. That that was my first you know, kind of introduction to you and your work was your studying of the environmental impact between between the two processes.
So where do I even start? So should I start with the environmental impact or the social impact? Let's start with the let's start with the social impact. Okay. So gold has a lot of blood on its hands. Thousands of years of blood, in fact.
You know, from from the pharaohs all the way to even now modern times, slave labor mining gold. So all of the all of the large genocides that happened in in in Latin America, you know, thanks to Pizarro and the and the conquistadors thirst and search search for gold.
You know, Native American populations wiped out during the California gold rushes, South Africa's another example. The you know the pursuit of gold and mining gold as an act in its in its own right is is a terrible terrible thing.
And no one's had to be enslaved to mine bitcoin. Depends if you're a computer ethicist. I suppose ASICs are being used as as slave labor, but other than that, no slave labor in in Bitcoin. A computer ethicist?
Yeah, somebody that believes, you know, that computers have feelings and need to be you know, yeah. Considered. I mean, I could see us getting toward to that point, it's you know, with the development of AI, etc. You know, but have you seen this dog that that Boston dynamics dog?
That thing's freaky, man. Oh, yeah. But yeah, there is ethics at play. You know, torturing that dog and keep knocking it over and all that kind of stuff. So we'll be an interesting future for sure. Yeah, I mean that that video footage I think will be fodder for future AIs to get a little pissed off at us.
Of course, though there's plenty of fodder on that front, I would imagine. But I mean, yeah, I mean an ASIC is just you know running this same hash algorithm over and over and over and over again. I you know it's it's cu it's it's interesting to think about whether or not some form of consciousness could spring from that. That the Bitcoin mining network could, you know, have some sort of consciousness.
No, I believe it already does. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, definitely. We'll leave that, we'll leave that to the back end, we'll leave that to the back end of the show. Alright, sweet. That sounds good. Alright, so let's get into the environmental differences then. So so we're talking about ASICs sitting running a code.
So yeah, the ASICs do need power to run run this code. For now, Bitcoin's powered by the grid. Where all these mines are, who's running them, no one really knows. So there's there's some good research. That you know gives results that span the gamut.
So one research, one piece of research out of out of Cambridge, estimated that 25% of the Bitcoin network runs on renewables. CoinShares reports that it's up to 78%. I believe the answer is probably closer to 25%.
But yeah, as you can see, Bitcoin is now already drawing in renewable investment. So give it another 15 years max, and Bitcoin will be running on 100% renewable simply because it's the in the economic interests of the miners. Like they won't become bleeding hearts and say we've got to use wind to save the environment.
They'll say no, like we've got a we've got to use wind because we have a fiduciary duty to the shareholders. Right, which is the only sustainable way to you know, lasting way to create you know change, right? I mean it's you can try to legislate it, but it doesn't work. I'm just using wind in this example because this example, this particular one was wind, but I can see like nuclear cities developing, you know, kind of like Chernobyl before it before it's blew its top.
Yeah. You know, you have a nuclear city that's just decked out with with Bitcoin mines, and mining companies can headquarter there for extremely low rent as you know as risk money, so to say. So I think as there's more innovation in in in nuclear energy, this is somewhere where where places like China and Russia that have far less regulation on on projects like this can really possibly eat eat North America's lunch and well the West in general, including Europe as well, Australia, New
Zealand. The layer one mining operation that's being set up in Texas that you mentioned earlier, Peter Thiel is invested in. Do you know what how the is that gonna be a wind powered mining operation, or do you know what what resources they're going to use to create energy there? Yeah, no, that that that that'll be wind out there in Texas.
Yeah. Let me okay, cool. So I mean that that entire operation is going to be renewable based. Yeah, so it's it's grid wind. So they'll just be plugging in to the grid effectively. And you know, the subsection of the grid would be hundred percent wind, wind grid.
Gotcha. So they're not building their own wind farms. Oh, they'd have to build their own so this is just a civil engineer speaking. Uh huh. To draw from the grid for for that level of equipment. You'll probably have to do quite a bit of civil works, substation works, transformer works.
So there's there's millions in it to bring to actually get the power off the grid ready for something your ASICs to plug into. Sure. So that's that's where a lot of development dollars would have gone, but the site might already be might already have all of its electrical infrastructure, you know, in place, and they just need you know 50 million for for for what's it called startup capex and you know burn for their stuff, like I did read they're getting an RD team.
So so yeah, it's fifty dot fifty million is easy to raise because unfortunately, also doesn't really go a far away these days. Sadly enough. All right, so let's talk a little bit more about gold, the gold mining process. I know that there's some like environmental impacts, yeah.
Okay, so gold. We don't pull a lot of it out of the ground every year. We pull like we only pull a couple of couple of thousand tons out. Effectively, we pull out all of the all of the world's gold that we pull out every year can fit in your in your typical 60 square meter one-bed apartment.
So would that be like in in the US for your US listeners, maybe like something like 550 or 600 square feet? Right. Some tiny typical apartment, floor to ceiling, that's it. That's all the gold we produce. I've heard that the total stock that we have on on the planet that we've mined over thousands of years is something like three or four Olympic swimming pools.
Yeah, the anecdote that I hear, or the comparison that I hear, that you could fit all of the all of the world's mined gold under the Eiffel Tower, under the big wow. So for this little for this little condo's worth of gold, we need to break apart 1,000 great pyramids of geezer worth of rock.
Soaked with like 500,000 or yeah, five hundred thousand tons of cyanide. Jesus in four hundred thousand Olympic swimming pools worth of water. 400,000. Yeah. So for a little wedding ring, like a little 10 gram wedding ring, you're getting about 20 bathtubs of water, a kilo and a half of cyanide, and a dump truck of rock.
Wow. So that's what I always tell people. Forget about the wedding ring. Just sign a message in the blockchain showing your your permanent eternal love. Save the environment, drop gold, melt it down by sats. I love it. I love it. When we can make use of all that gold and industrial uses when we you know turn our eyes to the heavens and start colonizing the solar system, etc.
I'm sure there'll be plenty of uses on on spacecraft and the kinds of electronics that we want to use in space that are resilient to radiation, etc. Yeah, and look one one thing I touched on, I didn't touch on rather, is that the grid has potential to improve.
Gold mining is what it is. Like you gotta break rock and you gotta soak it in cyanide, and you gotta soak it in cyanide because cyanide is safer than mercury. And the illegal miners will still use mercury highly unfortunately. They don't have they don't have very long life expectancy.
If it's not a if it's not a mine accident, it'll be premature death from from toxicity. Yeah, and that's a terrible way to go, mercury poisoning. Oh yeah. Yeah. So so like I'd I'd recommend everyone look through the archives and have a look at my my talk from from Riga and it really will it'll it'll open it'll open your eyes and on on your on your note about you know materials we can use in space that resist radiation and all that gold beautiful material
Yep radiation and you can spin out eight kilometers of wire from an ounce of gold. Gold's amazing. It's wow. Yeah, I can see why people want it for 4,000 years. Great, great little product.
Coat coat everything, gold leaf, you know, or lead leaf. Either way, gold will lose all of its monetary value. So you know, you know use it as much as you want in industry, it'll be cheap. That's wonderful. Yet another you know, follow-on effect of moving to a Bitcoin standard on a on a global basis.
Free up a lot of that that gold to use for you know better in better ways, because we don't need it for money anymore. Yep, absolutely. And look as a you know, again, as a as a meat space engineer that that studied material science, like cheaper gold will yield far cooler stuff for civilization.
Yes, absolutely. Alright, I'm ready. Let's dive into your latest thinking. This is this is hot off the presses of Hass Friar Hass's mind here. Bitcoin as a religion, and we've been talking about this joking about this as Bitcoiners for a while now.
The talking about being, you know, Satoshi bless you and may Bitcoin remain irrever, you know, irreverent to your hopes and dreams or whatever. You know, like just little memes here and there that definitely have religious connotations, and I think most of us sort of chuckle at it.
It's kind of tongue-in-cheek. But I think you're fleshing it out as a more useful and fuller analogy for us to understand sort of the social aspects of Bitcoin. So let's let's dive into it, man. Where do you want to start? Where where does where does one even start?
So so basically I don't think anyone should be upset about being called a cult member, and from from this point on I am going all in and completely completely embracing the term religious Bitcoin religious zealot.
And it's and it's not a bad term, and you'll learn why over the over the course of this chat. So to me, and according to the to Miriam Webster and Oxford Dictionaries, Religion is is purely a belief system which you hold deeply and devoutly.
And you know that's one definition in its own right. There's there's nothing about you know practices or rituals or anything in that definition. And then there's another definition that says, you know, a set of principles, whether institutional or not, that that you that you live by.
And as as far as I'm concerned, by those definitions, Bitcoin is my religion. And you know, during during sort of my spiritual event where I reached my zen, the you know, the same way Gigi did in Riga, it it became apparent to me that religion really is a very very deep aspect of Bitcoin and its organic growth and I believe it's it's grown extremely similarly to how the traditional
Religions grew and spread. Yeah and I mean we're only we're only 10 in ten years in here and we're already seeing the you know evidence that the idea that was given to us in the white paper and then formalized in operational code on January 3rd 2009 has grown in ten and a half years to this global religious movement right we that we as Bitcoiners have devoted ourselves you know to varying
Degrees but a lot of us you know and I think I would argue eventually most of us to basically like every spare moment that we have it's almost like Bitcoin is you know the mining process is capturing that sort of excess energy and turning it into hash rate you know the Bitcoin mind virus or meme or that's at the center the heart of this this whole this whole thing that's happening is literally sucking away every like excess brain cycle out of Bitcoiners and turning it to bettering the Bitcoin network to spreading
The good word to learning more about this and yeah, evangelizing, right the does this not meet the definition of religion of deeply deeply held beliefs that that high like the person is highly devoted to? Yeah. So so why does a why does an off open you know open source software developer even even work?
For me, I think that's almost you can almost consider that a spiritual religious offering. You know, an act of an act of selflessness in service of the community. Sure. Yeah, I mean the same way that you know monks throughout the centuries have devoted their lives to transcribing and understanding religious texts.
Yeah, absolutely, and that's probably here we go. Here's a religious analogy for you. There's all of our our self-funded podcasters, the monks transcribing and aggregating all the all the information, the religious texts for us. Yeah. And spreading it through the audio format as opposed to you know paper and ink.
Oh no, it it's it's going out in in all formats. For sure. It's it's it's a church now. People just have to have to not be scared to embrace it because look, the vast majority of people in Bitcoin at this point now are people that believe in its message, and to still be here after all this time requires probably a level of discipline demanded of by the traditional religions.
Yeah, that's a great way to put it. You know, I talk about like the process of forging a hodler, and it you know, for many, it's for some people it's it's almost instant. Like there's there's this epiphany moments. And I think I heard you say on John Vallis's podcast, Bitcoin Rapid Fire, that you read the abstract of the white paper and we're all in, right?
But okay, so I was I was all in, but forging a holder takes takes far far more. There can be no glory without pain. There can be no reward without suffering. Right. So the fires do need to be forged in in the bear.
So so my story basically, I was all in financially, at the top. I bought the top all in financially. And then later on sort of became all in effectively effectively socially.
I was the Bitcoin guy ranting and raving on about Bitcoin, and you know, the price was was cratering. So I'll so I'll put you in a bit more a bit more context. So a tiny bit of humble bragging here, but you know, coming out of university leading up to my my MBA, you probably could have probably could have called me a typical type A overachieving sociopath.
So always had high expectations on me, got into uni early, did multiple degrees, blah blah blah, blah blah blah blah. Finished an MBA at Oxford, October 2013. Next week will be my six year anniversary. The first Bitcoin I got was like 700 bucks, and then every day it went up like a hundred and fifty bucks, and only really started to get in at the very very top.
So I dealt with the crash, had to go back, you know, for for graduation, didn't really look for a job, wasn't interested in anything but Bitcoin. It was impossible to monetize. You know, went back to graduation, almost embarrassed. You know, to tell all these you know, type A's that are working in investment banks and all that, you know, what have you been doing for the past couple of months?
I've been looking at Bitcoin. Wait, isn't that that scam thing? Didn't that you know, didn't that exchange get hacked, all that kind of stuff? So deeply embarrassing, even even to face people, and it went on and it went on and it went on, and I had my own rabbit hole moment in in the Alice in Wonderland garden itself.
So I was I was sitting in the in the Master's Garden at Christ Church in Oxford. That was that was where I was studying. So Lewis Carroll taught the dean's daughter Alice math. So I was sitting in there. I go there every August and spend three three three four days there.
So August 2016, I had gone there, I was I was down on my luck. I was looking to recover some of my Bitcoin money, so I took a very low leverage Bitcoin long which went under underwater, but I was happy to hold it underwater. Bitfinex got hacked, got forced liquidated, took a haircut.
They promised to make everyone whole. I thought these guys are going out of business. Took my haircut, ran, and had the sort of breakdown epiphany in late August, and it was at that point I was truly all in to the point of willingness to die for Bitcoin and the official reversion to the natural way of Bitcoin and like almost almost declaring Bitcoin my religion.
Yeah, that's amazing, man. That's profound. I was telling Adam on the show this morning, I spent one thousand days in the red. That's biblical, man. You can only really truly so, even in traditional languages, have a look at the people that all turn to God you know, after going to jail and all that kind of stuff.
Sometimes it takes a tragedy in your life to look for to look to look for something to look for that meaning. And even though effectively Bitcoin did cause a lot of destruction for my life and mental health at the time, like I'm telling you, it was it was three brutal years. You know, m mockery you know, from like it's very embarrassing to you know face mockery from the un the unbelievers.
You know, so a lot of people that say all this you know religion stuff, this passion stuff is bullshit, they need to they need to come and hold Bitcoin for you know at least two bears. Yeah. And then you can say happy to die for Bitcoin.
Yes. So that's where I personally stand. So I think you wanted to talk about how how I can analogize that and fit Bitcoin into my life as a as a religious framework. Yeah, let's hear it. Alright. So basically, every religion has core set of beliefs, principles, and you know, practices.
We'll call them practices more than more than rituals. Well, you know, rituals is fine as well. So my daily daily ritual is checking my carcinome, sending the heartbeat. And I have a I have a an automated daily practice, which is I use Alex Svetsky's Amber app and I've got a daily recurring buy.
I stay away from the seven deadly sins. So what I mean is I stay away you know from greed you know by you know by by not trading by slowly DCAing you know by you know by being being sensible I stay away from gluttony you know we've cut we've got you know the carnivore diet you know stay away from from sloth keeping active like you'll you'll notice a lot of these a lot of these messages pop up in the Bitcoin world
Don't be greedy don't gamble train eat well you'll find a lot of bitcoiners already have this regimented discipline inside them and if that's not religious discipline like like I don't know how to describe it like it does require a lot of discipline you know almost to you know to if you're a true believer in the church you your life is 100% discipline and you know emotional discipline, physical discipline, cyber security discipline.
Like the like I can go on for hours and hours about the analogies I can draw with with Bitcoin as a religious framework. But onto onto the beliefs. You know, we all believe in you know uncensored money, we all believe in unconfiscatability, we all believe in trust minimization, we all believe in freedom, lack of censorship.
So so those are all core beliefs that that are built into to Bitcoin itself as a system and through its community. Yeah, and let's I mean there's a couple couple other seven deadly sins that you didn't mention, but I can think of good analogies to Bitcoin. That's fine. Like you like the religion's still gotta be fun if people you want people to join.
I agree with that. We can let lust go. And in and in terms of wrath, wrath is is acceptable under the jurisprudence, and some sects would would even encourage it towards altcoiners and shit coiners and no coiners. So wrath, okay in in some cases.
Okay. What about envy? Don't like don't envy the gains of shit coiners. No, no. Don't envy the stacking of your of your brothers, stack what you can and you'll be at the Citadel, you'll be fine. That's why they call it stacking stats for salvation. Right. You stack and you'll be saved.
So I've also another big concept in religion is the concept of the hereafter, and I love that concept. So what is the what is the hereafter? So different religions have different interpretations of hereafter. So, like the Abrahamic religions, heaven and hell. You know, you've got the concepts of you know achieving nirvana, the pure secular secular atheistic view is we're all energy anyway.
So whether you're buried or cre cremated or whatever, like you are just going to be dissipated into the world's pool of energy, and your energy is going to be redistributed. So that's that's different you know definitions of hereafter. For me, in my religion, the hereafter is the post-hyper bitcoinized world.
And just before the hereafter, you've you've always got judgment day, and you know my my judgment day, or the possibly other Bitcoin believers is judgment day is is the is the economic reckoning, the fiat, the fiat economic reckoning, the collapse of fiat will be the last day.
You know, a lot of people tell me it's not gonna be as brutal as you know, one day everyone's gonna wake up and shit's gonna hit the fan. But I'll remind them that once upon a time we all woke up on a Monday and Lehman brothers were out of business. Sure, yeah, and like you know, everything was good on Friday. Monday morning, Lehman brothers woke up bankrupt.
Yeah, and that happens. That was just the first domino to fall. Right. So the next one, I don't think it's gonna be a domino. I think the next one is the last one, it's the last day, and if you're getting stacking sats and being disciplined and remaining humble, you will have your reward in the hereafter, and you'll be raptured on the last day.
Raptured into the citadels. Raptured anywhere. At least they're not holding. Yeah, at least they'll have Bitcoin. They'll have something to get them going. Right. And yeah, we're a pretty charitable community. I'm pretty sure the whales will fork out for pleb accommodations in the citadels.
Well, I certainly hope so. But I get my fucking citadels no matter what, as a civil engineer because they need someone to hold down the roads and the fucking the sewage and the urban sanitation. So being the citadels knee deep in shit. So so you know where to find me.
Yeah, I mean we don't need to rely on human beneficence and in philanthropy. You know, it the market will take care of itself, human needs and you know we'll we'll provide Bitcoin for those who are willing to contribute to the you know the infrastructure of the world that we need to maintain our certain lifestyle, etc.
You know, and the other thing is I was thinking it was you know, Bitcoin itself inspires discipline, right? It's it's not just a spiritual inspiration like you would have with traditional religions that we would think we would think of, you know. You have this sort of idea of the hereafter, and you're you're inspired by that idea to devote a lot of time of your life and sometimes your entire lives to you know writing down or making copies of your spiritual text, etc.
But with Bitcoin, there's also an economic inspiration because we have this the sound money, the effects of sound money inspire us economically speaking to you know become more likely to save, to be more disciplined, become more productive, to be healthier in general, and all of those things contribute to making you a better human, right?
And that's an economic incentive, not just a spiritual incentive. True, but that's that's why Bitcoin is just so beautiful. Yes. It's only the second charity. So I view Bitcoin as a charity, by the way. And this is why I view it as a charity. So with anybody who stacks SATs daily, you are creating a permanent, hard, stable floor to the price.
And this price is permanently sloping upwards, sometimes gently, sometimes fiercely. And the more stackers there are, and the harder the floor is, the more circular economies can start growing. And that's probably the best the best act of charity you can do is enable the unbanked to have a circular economy.
So so stacks acts provide stability, and as the world improves, so will so will your bank balance. So Bitcoin's only the second second charity in history to do that. The second charity? The original the Clinton Foundation.
Gotcha. Yeah. I mean, there's there are plenty of charities like that. There are plenty of examples like that around the world that yeah, charities that are charity and name only. So you so you could say Bitcoin is a pay-to-play charity.
Yeah, I love that. What do you think about this idea of the immaculate conception of Bitcoin perfect so I can mate when it comes to Bitcoin I can analogize it with anything so I can use you know the Immaculate Conception as an analogy you know I didn't I didn't use it like well I didn't document it you can use the direct revelations from God in the cases of Moses and Muhammad so in that case
The blockchain existed just in the ether and it channeled its message through its messenger Satoshi who wrote down the recitation fired it up into a computer and off she went and the Bitcoin blockchain knows all sees all is omnipotent in enforcing its rules and is omnipresent running across its network of nodes and I call every node a day in a deity in
Its own right so I'm coined the term that the Bitcoin network is an MMO PG a massive multiplayer online oh damn I already forgot the acronym poly polyumberate.
There you go. So so you've got you've got mono monotheism, you've got you know you've got polyumbrites Bitcoin is an MMO PG. Yeah, so that that's that of that yeah, that's of course is a play on MMORPG, massive multiplayer online role-playing games, but this is massively multi-peer online polyumvirate god, mm-O-p-g.
Yeah, and we are engaged in financial warcraft. So it's close enough. I love it, man. I love it. Yeah, and I'm I'm excited for you to drop. I know you're working on a formalization of this you're gonna and you're gonna publish it at some point, and I'm I'm looking forward to that to draw because I want to see the conversations that this inspires on Bitcoin Twitter.
I hope that all of you listeners out there who I'm sure have plenty of opinions and thoughts about this discussion that we've just had, in particular the religion portion, let's hear about it on Bitcoin Twitter. I want to I want to talk more about this, flesh this idea out and hear what you all have to say. All right, Hass.
Do you have anything else to wrap it up, man? Anything that we missed, any details that we missed in our to kind of add to your your religious analogy here. Yeah, I've just got a question or maybe a request. I don't know, just a throwaway comment for what it's worth to the I just want you to sit back and have a think because because I've found and I was speaking speaking of about this on on rapid fire the other week to get success in life, or for me personally, my my benchmark for
Success is is finding something you can you can proudly stand for and believe in. And you've got to stand for something and you've gotta believe in something. And for me, I say why not believe in in something verifiable unforgeable uncorruptible like Bitcoin and I want you to you know have a have a look inside yourselves and think is this something that you're you're willing to stand for something something to fight for something to even die for and
And I think when you look at it in in that term you'll you'll understand you'll understand a lot more about how passionate you know the subscribers to the traditional religions can be when they're making their trouble. Yeah and this is a religion that's fundamentally different from all that have come before it this is a religion that is based on science that's based on math that like you said is you know can actually use these absolutes that are often used in traditional religions because you know math is does have
Absolutes the this this exists in in the world of science and math absolutes and guarantees do not exist in the you know the spiritual realm of traditional religions but I'd have to also say that Bitcoin is a very decentralized religion with as many sects as you'd like with as many shepherds and preachers as as you'd like and the beautiful thing about Bitcoin is it facilitates all ideologies because bitcoin bitcoin is simply is simply monetized energy and energy is nature and
And energy is is life and therefore bitcoin is also nature and life so don't stand don't stand in front of nature and you'll have an okay time i love it man sounds great i really enjoyed this conversation i think there's a lot more to discuss i think this is a great kind of jumping off point into this new way to understand and approach bitcoin it's I think yeah I think it's there there's a lot of fruit in the future to pick from this particular anal
Tr analogy for all of us bitcoiners and I think it will you know be actually useful and to think about Bitcoin in this way as you as you've said to sit back and have a think and about how this idea this meme has spread and propagated around the world and is kind of slowly building up into a religion I mean the religion I think a Gigi said this on last week on on this podcast you know fundamentally a religion is just an idea that's spread across the entire world yeah and also just if they could just have what's it called just
Some some awareness about how how they've already found their practices and beliefs starting to get molded by Bitcoin you'll find a lot of them have started becoming a more dis more disciplined in you know in what they you know aim drink consume all that kind of stuff so yeah, I don't believe it's a it's a far cry at all.
And for me personally Bitcoin is everything. The cause of my problems.
Yeah, yeah, like you said, we're reborn from the from the fires from the pits of struggle. Thanks, man. I really appreciate it for your time. You should probably get to bed. I know it's late there, it's early here. Just another example of the global nature of this movement.
Dedication, hard work, dedication, and loyalty to the game. The dedicated rise early and go to bed late after a long productive day. It's all good. All right then, Brady. Thanks a lot for having us and keys be upon you. Keys be upon you.
Alright, alright, alright. That was a fun one with Haas. I always appreciate a good discussion about Bitcoin mining, and it is indeed eye-opening to consider the vast improvements Bitcoin mining makes on the gold mining process. And the discussion about considering the comparison of the aspects of a secular religion to the spreading Bitcoin idea are profound.
And I think, as I said at the top of this episode, I can see a future where a secular Bitcoin religion grows and spreads as a means of propagating the traditions and values of hodlers to others around the world. I'm sure you have something to say about this episode. Share it out on Bitcoin Twitter with your thoughts.
Tag has at Friar Hass. That's at F R I A R H A S S and myself at Citizen Bitcoin. We'd love to continue the discussion with you there. It's a trip to see more Bitcoiners discovering and appreciating this humble Bitcoin podcast. If you found value in this work, the best way to support it is to share it out on Bitcoin Twitter.
If you're listening via Apple Podcasts, you can leave a quick five-star rating and review. That definitely helps out as well. Thank you so much for your support. I'm glad you're here with me at the beginning, the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care, other Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.