Giacomo Zucco and Parker Lewis on Swan Signal Live
Today I want to share with you an episode of a new content series I’m making for Swan Bitcoin. Every week I host a conversation with Bitcoiners live on the Swan Twitter account and YouTube channel. We call these sessions Swan Signal Live - a group of Bitcoiners hanging out and talking about the latest bitcoin news and musings about a Bitcoin future. In this episode of Swan Signal Giacomo shares his stories from on the ground in Italy, one of the epicenters of the Coronavirus pandemic, Parker Lewis breaks down the macroeconomic implications and gives us the latest updates on the reactions from the US Government and Federal Reserve. We talk about potential economic fallout and riff on some potential silver linings as well. Glad to share this with you all.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady, and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. Hope you all are staying safe out there. I'm still here, and I'm bullish as ever, and more dedicated than ever to making great educational Bitcoin content.
And now I'm able to do just that full time as head of education at Swan. Now I'm still, as I have been from the beginning, hustling on the side to bring you the Citizen Bitcoin podcast, and that will not stop. But today I wanted to share with you an episode of a new content series I'm making for Swan. Every week I host a conversation with Bitcoiners live on the Swan Twitter account and YouTube channel.
We call these sessions Swan Signal Live, a group of Bitcoiners just hanging out, talking about the latest Bitcoin news and musing about a Bitcoin future. So far, we've broadcast two episodes, one last week in the wake of that huge red candle, the big market drop, with a great crew of Bitcoiners, John Vallis, Guy Swann, Gigi, Hasma Cook, Cory Klippsten, and Yan Pritzker all joined.
And the episode that we broadcast this week with Jacques Mozuko, Parker Lewis, and Cory Klippsten, which I'm bringing you here today. Now I just made the Swan Signal feed live with a short welcome track. You can be the very first people, have the opportunity to be the very first people to subscribe to the Swan Signal feed.
You can check out Swan Signal.simplecast.com. You'll have to copy and paste the RSS feed URL into your podcast app. That's the price of being being an early adopter. The feed was just submitted to the various podcast directories, so it's winding its way through there.
And it will be available eventually at Swansignal Podcast.com. All that is pending by next week or so, maybe in the next couple of days, even all that will be set up and running. But you guys can drop that RSS URL into your podcast apps and you know be one of the first subscribers.
Now, in this episode of Swan Signal, Giacomo shares his stories from on the ground in Italy, one of the epicenters of the coronavirus pandemic. Parker Lewis breaks down the macroeconomic implications and gives us the latest updates on the reactions from the U.S. Government and the Federal Reserve.
We talk about potential economic fallout and riff on some potential silver linings as well. Glad to share this with you all. Here we go. We are coming to you live. This is Swan Signal Live, the second edition with Jacques Mozucco live from Italy.
How's it going, Giacomo? Okay. Not bad, not bad. Hi, everybody. Got Parker Lewis. I assume you're somewhere in Austin, Parker.
Camped out, bunkered in in Austin.
Yeah. Welcome, men. And Cory Klippsten from Cali. How's it going, Corey? Good to see you guys. Just under quarantine here in sunny LA. What a time, guys. What a time. I'm glad that we got this group together. Giacomo particularly is kind of in the thick of it now.
Looks like we are you know, kind of pre- Italy is giving us a bit of a preview of where we're headed in the next couple of weeks in the US. How are things on the ground there, man? So from the health point of view, they're still pretty much the same. We don't have the numbers are not that high.
That do you actually know a lot of people affected? So we personally still don't know anybody, but that's because the statistics is still scary from a new strange thing point of view, but it's not really that impactful of on a normal life. But everything else, except the virus itself is actually crazy.
The I mean, foods is starting to be a problem a little bit because right now you get fined and potentially arrested if you don't have a justification to leave your home, and they're starting to track citizens with cell phone cells. So if you now go 300 meters outside, they know it from the cell phone and you get fine or something.
And basically the point is that you are only allowed to go on the closest supermarket where you have to stay in in a in a line for about two hours, three hours, depending on in order to get food or medicines or nothing else. So the situation with food is that basically this kind of restriction on supply is basically making the supply, I mean, price cannot sky rise because it's a control market, so the typical socialist push.
And so for us it's still good because we were prepared, so we had food and out. Meat is going to become a problem soon for us because we are eating a lot of meat, because we wanted to stay healthy for this situation but it's running out and this is Italy so there is there's not a lot of meat in the shelf and the one that there is is basically finished just a few after midnight online delivery is still working but it's like a like a challenge my wife Mir she's been up at night after after midnight change of updated websites in order to get
One delivery at the end of April so it's like it it will eventually arrive but it's it's not something you can use i we see now that the gas pump they are closed but nobody can drive so that should be not the problem but yeah economic damage are are are incredible I think that in a healthy economy sustainable this will be enough for a serious chain of side effects probably bringing down a country for for many years since we were not in a healthy economy but in a debt-ridden country already half socialist inside
A fiat economy which was already about to collapse independently this will be worse so yeah the but the silver lighting is that we were nerds so we were already used to stay home so at least we are not that bored yeah thankful for remote work and thankful for the internet more than ever right now as we're quarantined to be able to maintain some human connection see some faces familiar faces and you know, support each other virtually.
So Parker Giacomo brought up there you know, the economic potential economic impacts. I mean, really the guarantee at this point, economic impacts we're seeing it play out right now. Can you give us an update on where the markets are, what the Fed actions or the actions the Fed has been taking, and maybe even just kind of play out how this this might affect the economy, you know, some some paths we might take over the next couple of years.
Yeah, so I think yeah, well, one, if you if you hear noise in the background, I've got a 70 story despite coronavirus, they're still you know putting up a skyscraper next door to my apartment, and I'm on self self-quarantine here. But yeah, so I think just you know, giving a summary of what's happened over the last week, which has been a pretty remarkable set of events.
On I guess Thursday, the Fed announced a you know a billion and a half repo program. So really what that is, that is geared towards or trillion and a half, I'm sorry, three $500 billion facilities. I believe two three months and one one month, or two one month and one three month.
So that happened on Thursday, and then over the course of Sunday, we decided to reduce the benchmark interest rate from a range of one to one and one and a quarter to zero to a quarter. So a full hundred basis point rate cut along with a 700 billion dollar quantitative easement program.
And the distinction between a formal QE program and the Fed's temporary repo program is that the Fed will not only be buying longer duration bonds, but they'll all actually be buying those bonds outright. So I think it's a split between of the 700 billion, I think it's between 500 billion of treasuries and 200 billion of mortgage backed securities.
And you know, in terms of you know my personal view, I think you know, from 2009 to 2014, the Fed's entirety of their, you know, QE1, two, three was 3.6 trillion. You know, my my personal perspective is that that when when the dust settles here, that you know the aggregate injections that they have to put in this time exceed what they had to do to quote quote save.
I don't think that they actually saved the market in 2008, 2009. I think that they created the setup for what's happening now. And you know I'm certainly recognizing of the fact that you know there do seem to be two kind of quote in quote out black swan events that have happened whether it be kind of the almost entire economic shutdown that's been induced by quant by coronavirus but then also happening at the same time that both Saudi and Russia have signaled to the market that they are going to not cut production and actually increase
Production that that sent the energy markets into a tailspin. But but what I think is missed or I don't want to say miss I think it's I'd say it's easy to forget that the there was a market structure issue that existed before these other two events happened to occur.
And I really view you know it it may it may be extreme to say that it's a fool by randomness situation, but I really think of it as if it was if it weren't these these two market events being kind of the impact of coronavirus or the impact of what's happening in the oil markets, that that there was a there was a large setup for something very similar to happen.
And if it wasn't this, it'd be something else. And then the Fed has has responded, I think, as we would expect them to. I think the only thing that it can do is is do what it did in 2008 and 2009. It can only set up for greater instability down the road.
May they be able to kind of stabilize things for the here and now. I think that that's you know, that there's a greater chance of that than not, but that it ultimately sets us up for a world of greater instability in the future, because what they're ultimately doing in trying to stabilize the market is create a condition where more credit can be created, and the problem actually is the debt laden and the instability created by the amount of system leverage.
So their only way to fight the fire is to create a world in which more debt can be created and existing debt levels can be sustained. That does end badly, and it likely ends ultimately in instability of currency. So you know, kind of I don't necessarily have a picked out level in terms of where I think the equity markets bottom out, but I am very focused on the credit market, so we can talk about kind of what I'm seeing in the credit markets if that makes sense.
Yeah, let's definitely do that. I want to kick back to Giacomo real quick. Giacomo, what's happening in Italy with the central bank there? I assume it's something similar, they're following cues from the US Federal Reserve. No, actually, the point here is a little bit more complex because we don't have a working central bank anymore. Bank in Italia still existed, but it just has like a regulatory functions.
The printing function are moved to the ECB, the European Center. And the ECB will follow, will follow the Fed as it did many times. There is culturally the ECB has some kind of resistance to quantitative easing, hyperinflation, because most of the organization is is driven, is is basically managed by let's let's oversimplify Germans, and German culture about that is very strict because they they remember hyperinflation pretty good, probably.
The cultural thing in Germany is a little bit the cultural standing in Germany is a little bit against hyperinflation and super intervention. There was the shift of Draghi, the Italian guy at the head of the BCE, and he was a super activist. He said, like whatever it takes, I will print, I will print.
Now there is there is Lagarde, Lagarde. Well, she's not German, obviously, but she's also pretty much conservative. So they will probably follow the United States, but slower and with a little bit more of caution. The Italian markets and basically prices of government debt collapsed a few days ago because Lagarde said that the function of she's publicly said we are not here to feel spreads between German bonds and Italian bonds.
So our function is not a function of stability, which is I mean, literally true, but then politically not really true. So there is I don't think there will be any difference at the end. The euro will be just just the same. One one main difference is that the US dollar, except for the ultimate fate of every fiat currency, which is hyperinflation, is actually fine and strong in itself, while the euro is not because the European Union itself and the monetary union after Brexit.
I mean, UK was not even in the euro, but Brexit and everything is basically creating a lot of stress on the on the Schengen. So the free trade and free movement agreement across borders was removed. So now the European Union idea is basically collapsing.
So the European money is not that wealthy as well, and so probably they they cannot force it even more by by explicitly dragging the market as fast as as in the US. But they will like when when the US did quantitative easings one and two, European unions European bank, they said we are not doing quantitative easing, but we are doing LTRO, which is basically pseudo-sterilized quantitative easing.
So they will do the same eventually. Is there a concern about an existential threat to both the euro as a currency and to the union itself? Like precipitated by this event, these events. I don't see it very, very discussed actually.
The everybody was freaking out after Brexit because of that. Everybody was it's a little bit like the discussion we were having before. Already the system was super was ready for something like this, including the precipitation of the fragmentation of European Union. So it was already priced in in a way, but this is just one of many possible triggers so just like just like market collapse after the fiat bubble centralization and later balkanization of Europe politically was already basically dreaded and feared by by many
Analysts even without these now I don't see any anybody talking about that because because everybody's just freaking out by the virus but eventually eventually the discussion will will come for sure. So Parker what are you seeing in the credit markets here and then what you know what does what is what you're seeing concern you
Hey Parker you're on you apologies I was trying to save you from the hammering in the background no worries so there there's two things that I look at there's credit volatility and you know particularly the volatility in in the treasury market where you know the you know kind of I think last week the 10 year or maybe even the week before the 10 year collapse below 50 basis points in the US and you know essentially over the course of you know 18 months dropped from 250 to 300 basis points to 50 basis points so thinking about you
Know like that that is a h highly volatile market but then in the last two weeks you know the 10 year treasury is swinging you know sometimes 30 40 basis points in a day and that sends ripple effects throughout the credit markets. And so kind of the first piece is is the credit volatility on the treasury side.
Second piece is credit spreads and the risk premiums that exist between say investment grade credit and treasuries, as well as high yield credit in treasuries. And I think that what we're starting to see, and what we can easily see is the movement in the equity markets.
We can see the actions that the Fed takes.
When I look at the high yield, it's a market that I particularly look at because it's not an insignificant market, but it's a large funding market for middle market to large cap equities.
And when I look at that index, I look at it as a general index of kind of the health of the underlying economy, or at least to see where it's trending. And when I look at that that index, and there's a there's a thousand bonds, at least in the index that I look at, you know, two, you know, to give context, when I when I would look at this, you know, two years ago when I was doing a lot of the research that I was doing on the Fed, nearly all of all of those bonds and that, you know, there's a thousand bonds in the index, and nearly every single one of them was at or close to par.
I think it was between 80 or 90 percent were were were over par, and the ones that weren't were really very close to par. Just over the course of the last week, you know, I keep tabs on it almost daily. Last week, those bonds, I think 650 of them were were above par.
Today, 74 of those bonds are above. And you see just the steady day in, day out kind of deterioration in that market. And that, you know, when we look at the equity markets and we can see the volatility, I think you know what what what we haven't yet seen is the flow through and the credit events kind of that that are directly correlated to the true underlying economic activity and that we can't really know how bad and how long term kind of this event will you know kind of will
Ultimately be until we actually see kind of the number of defaults the you know kind of the actual impairment on on the corporate side in terms of not only earnings but then kind of the restructuring that needs to happen. So you know I don't expect this to you know it's it's I reserve judgment until we actually see the impact on the economic side flow through to the companies and so you know we're already seeing you know I think people oftentimes look at the DAO and they look at the SP but the issue is credit and we're starting to see the negative and also one
Thing to keep in context and this is one of the reasons why I think that you know everything that that impacts the world is so systemic is that once the credit market starts to delever on a system wide basis it's very difficult to reverse that course it essentially feeds on itself kind of the initial economic slowdown causes GDP growth to slow but really GDP growth is driven by the expansion of the credit market and because the credit market is you know, orders of magnitude larger than the base money supply.
And so once that credit market starts to contract, then it has kind of pro-cyclical negative feedback loops on general economic activity because so much funding is dependent on that credit. So it's kind of like once dominoes start to fall, it's very hard to stop them from falling further and faster.
And that you know, I wouldn't expect things to normalize until kind of at least on the corporate credit side, the full extent of that pain is realized, and then people start to come out of on the other side of that in terms of restructuring credit because I can't, you know, give it giving a sense, and there's very, you know, there's broad macro themes, but then there's also idiosyncratic kind of sector themes, and you know, giving a sense of you know, the transport industry, at least on the high yield credit side, is trading at 80 cents on the dollar in terms of kind of the bonds in that index.
Energy is trading at 59 cents. Now, there's obviously always a range between you know, certain bonds in that index are now trading at 10 cents on the dollar, others, you know, still maybe trading you know at 90 or 80 cents. But when you look, when you look at the what's happening individually and on the aggregate, it's just you know the equity market can rebound six, seven percent tomorrow.
Once that the credit impulse is broken, it it's it's almost nearly impossible to reverse that without going through a restructuring cycle. And that doesn't happen quickly. So it's almost like I view it as you know, the pin to the grenade has been pulled and we haven't yet seen it explode.
Right. Yeah, ominous times. Jacquemo, we've been talking about this as Bitcoiners, this situation for a long time. Bitcoin was born in the 2008, 2009 economic crisis. This is the first economic crisis that we've seen Bitcoin you know, sort of be alive and operate in.
What do you think is going to happen with Bitcoin? You know, during this crisis? Do you think it comes out the other side stronger? Do you think this is an opportunity for us as Bitcoiners to really carry the light forward on you know why why Bitcoin exists and why it's important? So I think that first of all, I think that this crisis resemble much closer.
I mean, as an entity, it's giant, it's comparable with 1929, probably not even 2008. But as a as a kind, as a type, it resembles more clo closer to the crisis of 2001, just after 9-11 terrorist attack. Because that in that time the market collapsed a little bit, it was I mean a little bit much, and there was a lot of shock, shock going around.
But people overall they didn't have a lot of awareness about the intrinsic frailty of the financial system and of the problems created long term by moral hazard of banking bailout, printing money and stuff like that, manipulation of interest rates.
Well, in 2008, there was no terror terrorist attack, no virus, nothing. So when everything collapsed, people started to freak out. Like I mean, everything collapsed because it wasn't sustainable, and sure, there is a subprime mortgage problem, but it was created by by Fannie May or Freddie Mac, it was created by this financial system and government intervention.
I mean, not everybody understood the government intervention as part of the problem. Many just said it's the it's a free market, it's capitalism, the Jews or whatever. But but most smart people understood that that was a crisis in the system itself. In this case, we have a short term in which not that not as much people as we could hope for are actually understanding the position of Bitcoin better because they are leaving this crisis as something again exogenous like like 9-11.
There are terrorists there is a virus we need a government to protect us and to print money because the government must protect us from the terrorists so we need war on terror and regime changes in Iraq and now we need the war on virus and generalized lockdown and tracking people and stuff like that so the reaction is is paradoxically one people is selling as a speculative asset and savings for cash the most liquid cash possible because they want to buy toilet paper they want to buy emergency random emergency stuff
So they want to consume goods and they want to give up savings for consumed goods and Bitcoin is mostly a saving technology so it of course it suffered that just as well as gold and every other asset and also the general sentiment among people including very sadly many many bitcoiners is actually a new pandemics of fanatic statism so oh please government please save me lock me down control me I need you I'm scared so I need your your your heavenly force to save me from from evil so it's not actually
The perfect storm for Bitcoin yet in my opinion the only thing that could be a counter argument for for this, because if this argument is is true, then we may see Bitcoin just faring relatively well compared to the to the rest, and then be rediscovered when the when the scare for the virus is passed, however that happens, but eventually it will happen, either for immunization of the survivors or a vaccine or whatever, but it it will happen.
And when that happens, either people will discover Bitcoin, well, people should actually discover Bitcoin and understand the intrinsic weakness of the financial system. But one thing that could be a counter argument to what I'm saying is the halvening. We have this kind of fiat supply shock in in a positive sense, which is a negative sense, of course, at the same time of the Bitcoin supply supply shock in the negative those positive sense.
And these this this is very strange game theory. This is like 5D chess, and so I have no idea. I was just gonna bring that up, actually, the having and the narrative that will come out of the having just you know less than 60 days away, most likely at this point.
So we'll be two more months into this crisis. I think we'll have a lot more information about how things are going to play out. And we'll have a narrative coming out on the financial news that Bitcoin is now roughly you know the same inflation rate as as as gold, which I think will make it look you know, first it'll remind everybody that hey, Bitcoin's still around because it's gonna make you know make the rounds.
And second, I mean, that's that number, I think is is one of those big round numbers that's not the price, but is a milestone for Bitcoin to reach. And everyone would then will also learn that in four years Bitcoin will be you know half the inflation rate of gold and become you know the scarcest monetary good that we've seen. That's fascinating to me about how that's gonna play out.
I don't understand the game theory exactly either, but I think that narrative is obviously very positive for Bitcoin. So I think it'll probably be good. Corey, you want to chime in? Where what's your take on what's going on here, man? You know, you've got a lot of experience in corporate America, you got a lot of strong network around.
What are you hearing about what's going on? Yeah, well, you guys have covered a lot of general stuff. I'm I'm kind of interested to see what happens with with global housing and to see if you know, we've often talked about this massive store of value and how people have essentially been using housing, particularly in the US, but really around the world, using housing as a place to store wealth.
And I'm very curious to see if this is the cycle where people start to not think of their house as much of a store of value when it's just a place that they live and not to expect that that asset will always increase because you know, fool me once, you know, shame on you, fool me twice.
So this I think will be the second time that people's houses that they were kind of counting on as a as a piggy bank, or maybe they're you know way over leveraged now, having essentially taken out a ton of equity you know from their house. To ground this in reality a little bit. I live now for a year after leaving Santa Monica with the second kid.
We moved out to Calabasas. At the end of my street is a giant building that was originally constructed by Lockheed Martin way back in the day, and then eventually got taken over by a company rather famous for playing a central part in the subprime crisis. So it was the countrywide national headquarters was right down the street from me.
And it's this massive building, like a fortress, and it's just empty. Still, all these years later, there's like a co-working space in one corner of it that takes up about 10% of the square footage, and it'll just never be filled. And you know, I wasn't in this community 12 years ago, you know, when when that went down, but I can only imagine the number of executives, the number of real estate agents, the number of people that you know bear those scars.
And then you also kind of like you look around. I've I've never lived in suburbia. I grew up in you know semi-urban North Seattle and then spent all my life basically in New York and Chicago before coming to LA. And I didn't really I couldn't you couldn't visualize how much people actually live by taking out the equity in their homes.
So you know, as you get get kind of plugged into a let's call it suburban community, and you know, Calabasas is definitely not a normal place, but you can really sniff out that people have like fairly normal jobs that aren't necessarily all that high paying, but they bought a house like 20 years ago, and they've got sweet cars but can never leave the house.
And you know, they probably don't own very much of their house. Like it's pretty patently obvious that a lot of these people are just kind of living and spending the equity in their homes, yeah. You know, refinancing over and over again as the rates go down, and I think that's kind of fascinating. So that's kind of point one, and then I guess the second one, you know, just kind of looking at at Bitcoin with regards to the market.
I mean, we've all noticed the massive correlation between the SP and Bitcoin over the last week, week and a half, and you know, even longer than that if you look at it, but like really close moves and a lot of people kind of front running what they expect to happen in markets because Bitcoin trades 24-7. I mean, obviously, I'm pretty known on Twitter for calling that that would happen in the short term, and then we'll see a divergence.
I'm wondering when it actually happens, and I suspect it might be sooner than people think. You know, so I'm seeing you know, Bitcoin kind of flat today and Dow way down again. And you know, I think we'll start to see a string of those days where Bitcoin is up or flat and the market you know still goes down.
So not to prognosticate at all, but it just seems too obvious, and there's too many people raising their hands, and there's too many people asking about Bitcoin, and they're not asking about Bitcoin because they saw the price drop. There's they're asking about Bitcoin because we, as Bitcoiners, you know, in the world in in general, has effectively memed Bitcoin into their brain, and they know on the back of their list, somewhere in the back of their mind, they were gonna check into Bitcoin.
You know, they know that Bitcoin is one of those things they're supposed to be checking into when everything goes to shit. Well, everything's going to shit, and a lot of people are raising their hands. I mean, I don't know about you guys, I know Brady, you've told me the same thing, and we've we've heard from a lot of people that you know last Friday probably was the most we'd heard from pre-coiners since like December 2017.
And it was literally the day after 50% drop, and most of them weren't really all that aware of the Bitcoin price drop. They were just freaked out about markets. Yeah, there's been a lot of incoming inquiry about Bitcoin in the past week or so on my end, just anecdotally speaking.
I've got a question from Joe Rogers in our telegram chat room. And if you are listening and you want to ask a question, you can ask on Twitter, just find you can DM Swan's Swan Bitcoin. You can find our telegram group, which is in the Swan feed, Twitter feed, if you want to track that down. This is from Joe Rogers.
He wants to ask ask Parker one, would you and Nik Bhatia collaborate on an explainer on repo and bonds, but also if you can just give a quick overview on how you know the repo market works. We've really just kind of been hearing about that, the norm normies and including myself have just really been hearing about the repo market for the first time in the past six months or so.
Yeah, so I mean, I think one Nik Bhatia could probably write a better primer on this than B. So I'm gonna I'm gonna I'll collaborate with Nick on it, but I'm gonna ask him to take the lead. And I'll I'll give a I'll give a high level just so that people understand kind of when when the term repo is used, what they're referring to.
When when you know, say in in the funding markets, a bank needs reserves or actual dollars, they would post treasuries as collateral and borrow dollars to fund on a very short-term basis. And as part of that lending agreement, there's essentially a repurchase agreement that would say, okay, I'm going to post my treasuries or other generally good or acceptable collateral, which are generally agency-backed, you know, securities or you know, the largest piece being treasuries.
And such that if I if I post my treasuries to you and then you give me dollars, I owe those dollars back at some point in time. And if I don't provide those dollars to you to you, then you can basically claim the treasuries, sell them in the market, and get your dollars.
You know, kind of in those lending relationships, depending on the type of securities, they, you know, if I need nine dollars, I may have to post $10 worth of treasuries as collateral. And essentially what happened in September was there became a shortage of dollars being lent into those markets, and the repo market is a very large funding market in terms of short-term funding, and such that there were there were borrowers in demand and the dollars that had formerly been available to lend into that market, I don't want
To say disappeared, but were no longer there, and that caused a massive spike in in repo rates, which ultimately induced the Fed to come in and provide dollars directly to that market. So rather than a f I wouldn't even call it a free market, but rather than there being a truly marketing mechanism to say, okay, what where's the supply and where's the demand?
Well, the supply and demand caused rates in the repo market to increase, and don't quote me on specifics, but between two and a half to three percent on an overnight basis to 10%. So you know, approximately tripling the cost of credit to those markets. So what the Fed did in response was they stepped in to say, okay, we will lend 100 billion dollars to the repo market at X rate.
So they basically just became a price setter in the repo market. And then they subsequently had to increase the facilities that they were providing to those markets. I think between September and last Thursday, they had supplied net about 500 billion to the repo market.
And then on Thursday of last week, they announced a $1.5 trillion program. So you know, I hope that answers just kind of mechanically, you know, kind of on the front end, it's people posting treasuries and receiving cash, but then you know, under the construct of those that that provide the cash and receive the treasuries could liquidate the treasuries if if if a borrower failed to pay back, and that the Fed's response to it was to lend directly into that market rather than the market sort out what the interest rate would be because if if the interest rates were you know doubling overnight, then those markets would have completely shut down.
You're on mute, Brady. Yeah, that's crazy, man. And but that's the way you know, that's the way these this Keynesian fiat age works.
The other thing I was going to point out just because Corey brought it up in terms of in terms of the impact on housing, and I and I and I definitely agree with him that you know, people are going to have this kind of fool me once, you know, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me. And you know, I've I've written about it in the past, but it's a really like mind boggling number when you think about it.
What the Fed had to do in the last in the last crisis to essentially save the housing market to you know in their view save the banking system they they went out and bought 1.7 trillion over the course of years so it wasn't they didn't just go in the market tomorrow and buy 1.7 trillion but they had to buy 1.7 trillion in in mortgage back securities to stabilize that the housing market and there are only 10 trillion of mortgages total and I say only like the fact that trillion is even in our you know in our vocabulary is kind of a problem but but but essentially the Fed bought
One point or sorry they bought 17% of all the supply of mortgage backed securities and just in the last week when they announced their 700 billion dollar QE program they announced the plans to buy 200 billion dollars worth of mortgage and ultimately I think in their view or what they recognize is at least based on their world to worldview of solutions that in order it if they're going to be effective they have to keep the housing market propped up and there likely is no greater market that is more manipulated than housing based on you know at least individually based on its heavy dependence on credit
But then also what the Fed has done directly to manipulate the supply of credit within that space and just looking at 200 billion you know relative to all Bitcoin that will ever exist. It's $9,500, you know, $9,500 per Bitcoin and I can promise you that they're gonna need a bigger boat than $200 billion to you know stabilize the housing market this time around.
Thanks for that, Parker. Jacques, a quick question for you. This is also from Joe Rogers. Uming from our episode that we did together on Citizen Bitcoin, that you were a libertarian activist in Italy for a while. Do you see Bitcoin sort of exporting those ideals, the economic ideas of libertarianism, particularly, to the rest of the world.
It did. Now it's actually a moment of absolute counter counter movement because of what I said before. So people people scare tend to become irrational and to get into superstitions like and statism is a superstition.
And so right now it's not working very well, but but historically, yes. I actually stopped doing anything libertarian relating in public in Italy a few years ago because I started to think that the only solution was more like on an individual plane. So I moved to Switzerland as a resident in Switzerland.
I started to I started to just detach from the system. Then I got interested in Bitcoin mostly because it won it was a tool of individual of individual sovereignty, but then people that was looted into Bitcoin from the mostly from the financial point of view, so just to make make money or or because it was a new cool technology, a lot of those people started actually reading about Western economics, about libertarian ethical principles, about about the stuff that Bitcoin about Cypherpunk's ideas and all this the cultural stuff that Bitcoin is based upon.
So, yes, it did I think it did work. I think I think it it did work great i have many many a few of the friends i had in the libertarian movement did not understand bitcoin there are a few but but but really a few and many people who didn't who did got fascinated by bitcoin first then they actually switched to libertarian either ideals or analysis framework so libertarian slash Austrian because you can you can be ethically a libertarian but be absolutely ignorant about economics or you can be very very knowledgeable
Of dynamics of praxeology but not really ethically interested in libertarianism at all bitcoin is actually a very good tool that is not just an action tool it is an action tool but it's also an a learning tool so he it thought to a lot of people what is it all about of course again I'm sad to see right now a very very strong counter a lot of Italian Bitcoiners are just get are just starting to appreciate the fascism and Chinese Communist Party again but I
Think this is a temporary irrationality mostly driven by fear and eventually panic I mean panic is an evolutionary reaction that we develop for running away from lions in the savannah is not something that the last a lot after you sit down a bit, the things you keep thinking about they they they're not that scary anymore.
And so you get back reasoning again. Oh, I was on mute again. Sorry guys, no worries. If you if you want, I can I'm sorry to non-sequitur, but I dug up that chart from Funstrat from Tom Lee that basically lays out the global store of value.
I'm just gonna just show how important housing is to that market. Let me see if I can describe it real quick. Where did that go? There we go. And there it is. Share there.
So this doesn't even include currencies, so it's a little bit there's you know 30 trillion of narrow money and another 60 if you include broad money. So basically global store value is actually more like 370 trillion. Which is why when we say, you know, if Bitcoin moons and does what we think it can do, you know, the total addressable market is something like 370 trillion.
So it's not completely insane to talk about numbers like 20 trillion or 100 trillion or whatever it is. But with the existing market, real estate is such a huge part of it, which is why the Fed, you know, as Parker was saying, is gonna do everything that it can to prop up mortgages. And we've got, you know, going back to basically post-World War II, the whole system is just like, you know, save your wealth in your home, and we'll make sure that it always goes up or stays stable at least.
And it's kind of the underpinning of everything that we do. I was listening to Ansel Lindner's podcast this morning, his his most recent one, Bitcoin and Markets, and you know, he was basically just making the case with some good data and just a lot of experience that you know 25% of the US economy is directly related to just building and all of the different services that that splinter off of building residential and commercial real estate, and that you know, really almost everything else, because you're serving the people that make money on that.
You know, we've we've bet the farm, the condo, the house, the office building, the factory, we've bet we've bet everything in this country on continuing to build. And that's why the Fed is watching that so closely and will do whatever they possibly can to prop it up.
Parker, question for you. This is from Zender in our telegram chat. He wants to know how gold fared in the Great Depression, maybe as a analog to how Bitcoin might be seen in potential recession or depression coming up. So I haven't closely gone back and studied kind of gold during the Great Depression.
I would, you know, I did you know go back to the crisis, and I think that you know, my my perspective on it would be that you know, during the height of the financial crisis, gold sold off by 25%. Gold, you know, kind of depending on what estimates you use, a seven trillion to eight trillion dollar market.
And I think as we're seeing today, you know, virtually everything is being sold for dollars. And my my explanation for that is that it's it's you know, the market and all market participants, or not all market participants, but on the margin, an equal increasing number of participants are figuring out that they're short dollars.
So we, you know, when I look at it and I say, you know, the Fed just you know increased the supply of dollars or plans to by 700 billion, and then you can take that over the you know the amount of Bitcoin is a certain, you know, and it's a certain significantly larger dollar value than the price of Bitcoin is today.
That can be true at the same time that people are short dollars and that they need dollars. And so my expectation, I think this is consistent with Corey's view, is that in this interim period, while people are all figuring out that they still need dollars, that they're that Bitcoin is a highly liquid asset that is a source or can be a source of dollars.
And that you know, because of that, that in this interim market move, while there is kind of panic and people are trying to figure out equilibrium, people are trying to scramble to get the dollars that they didn't know they needed, but that they are starting to figure out that they don't have, it can be the case that the Fed is significantly increasing the supply of dollars when those who are short dollars are continuing to have to scramble to get them on a forced basis.
And so kind of my perspective is, and again, I don't I don't you know predict price levels of Bitcoin, whether short term or long term, all I know is that there will likely be continued pressure so long as people have a strain for dollar liquidity. But that on the other side of that tunnel, or kind of on the, you know, kind of one once we reach that point, that it it will be the single greatest thing that causes people to have to learn about Bitcoin or for Bitcoin to become intuitive to them, because it is really the function of the Fed, you
Know, overnight, you know, dictating that they're gonna there's suddenly gonna be 700 billion more dollars, and I think that that will ultimately be 4 trillion, if not more, in terms of this program, and that you know, I would expect it to be similar to gold, I guess, in short during the crisis. There was a 25% drawdown in the price of gold, and then once the those people that you know kind of needed dollars that were in the gold market were tapped out, then gold skyrocketed past where it was at the prior high.
And I would I would expect that I would expect something similar to Bitcoin that there are people that that are exposed to Bitcoin that need dollars, and but that at some point that washes out and there will be no Bitcoin for sale, and when we see that there will be a dramatic rise, and that'll be a function of kind of the market structure, the market dynamics, but then also I think of it as just as you know, kind of you know, an X and Y axis and Y axis is time.
People are active, you know, it's like knowledge distributes exponentially, and you know, what greater incentive to understand this thing Bitcoin that that oh it didn't die, it may have you know dropped significantly overnight, but but that is kind of unobstructed price discovery, and that ultimately creates health for the Bitcoin market that that everyone is maximally accountable, and that that we don't have manipulation of price, we actually have have a free market, and so I do I do view that there will be continued turbulence so long as there's a dollar liquidity crisis, which I think is what we're starting to see, but on the tail end of that, then you
Know it will be like the Phoenix rising from the ashes. What do you think about this helicopter money proposal? Do you think it can make a difference in the short term for for people or for the economy as a whole? Well, any dollars that they give me, I will buy Bitcoin with first.
And I just I think it's I think it's just like late stage, like people giving up all common sense, right? That that you know, kind of ascribing a symptom to a problem, but not really understanding the problem itself, and then applying the what they appear to be a solution, as you know, I think in what my view is actually the problem, that you know, that that the problem is debt and credit, and that the only way for the Fed, you know, if they want to deposit start depositing a thousand dollars into everybody's bank account, the only
Way for for the US government and the treasury to do that is for the Fed to finance it. So you know, if you are going to create, you know, for you know, whether whether you plan to do a tax cut or to authorize a program via Congress where you know every American gets a thousand dollars and you know Americans get 300 billion, that is one for one going to blow out the federal deficit.
And the only way that gets paid for is if when you see that they're gonna do that, you will also see that the Fed has increased the quantitative easing program from 700 billion to you know a trillion or 1.2. It'll be incremental. They'll say, Oh, we're gonna do another, you know, we're gonna expand right now.
I think they're doing 40 billion a month. They're gonna say, Oh, we're gonna be doing 80 billion a month, and they're not gonna tell you when it ends. And I really think of it as you know, it doesn't solve the problem, it is the problem, you know. So you're just doing more to it to incentivize what got us here in the first place. And I think that with what's happening in the oil market, what's happening, you know, obviously like it's significant and it's something maybe we've never seen in terms of the economic shutdown that's being driven by the coronavirus.
But that you know, what this allows is it allows like the Fed to almost like they are the arsonists and they're leaving through the back door in the middle of the night, and then they're coming back around the front as firefighters to say, ah, we're here to save the day. And that you know, kind of the news around the coronavirus and the news around what's happening in the oil markets provides them the cover to be the firefighter or to present themselves as the person that's trying to solve the problem.
And in my view, all of it is I don't I think I think it does a disservice to say that it's a distraction, but it but it certainly is a disservice to ignore that the problems already existed, and that if it wasn't these things that cause the fire to accelerate, it would have been something else down the road, and that the true underpinning of why the system is so fragile, like it shouldn't be the case that you know, even if the entire economy needed to shut down for a month or two months, it shouldn't cause a depression.
It it like it it's it probably will if it doesn't, you know, it likely will cause a financial crisis, you know, possibly even a depression. And that that that that's only the case because the system is set up in such a fragile structure. And that I think a world of Bitcoin will ultimately, you know, you know, be a world that's that's that's more stable, more anti-fragile, and that would be able to deal with something like this in a way that didn't result in you know mass unemployment just because everyone you know socially distanced for for a month or two months.
Jacques Moore, are you back? Yeah, I'm back and now the audio is fine. Okay, great. I've got a question for you from Twitter. How do you think the stability of the European Union versus the United States will play out in the coming years?
Well, I don't think that it's I mean it's even comparable. I think that it would be very surprising to have the European Union to remain the same after this. Again, I said it before, even without this this specific crisis, the Brexit process initiated some kind of fragment irreversible fragmentation process.
So everybody was was actually predicting the UK becoming like a Zambia after the after Brexit. It didn't happen. They they were doing pretty well after this. And I think that due to the fact that apparently Boris Johnson is is less crazy than others, they will probably do economically better after this this coronavirus crisis.
So it would be clear that there is there is not a strong reason to stay inside. This crisis will just accelerate that when people have time to metabolize it. Well, in the United States, I on the other hand, I would be surprised if any process of secession can actually succeed.
I would be pleasantly surprised. I mean, I look nothing I look forward to nothing more than might like to move in an independent Texas or New Hampshire, but w without federal agents being able to come to come in. But that's that sounds a little bit politically realistic yet.
So I would if we talk about dreams, then yes, every every national state will actually just disintegrate into my micro city states like Hong Kong after this. If we want to be realistic, European union Europe European Union is probably over. While the United States are probably going to resist until we move to some really unforecastable and unin un inimageable scenarios.
Let's lighten this up a little bit. What are what are some really positive things that may come out of the this whole coronavirus thing in particular? And you know, I'm thinking about things like you know, a lot of us realizing that we can get work done remotely, and therefore, you know, people just escaping from you know desk slavery in cubicle hell, because it's just so obvious that things can be done a different way.
So that's one thing I think may take hold. You've got a lot of people like like our friend Daniel Prince, who's done like the world schooling homeschooling thing. You know, a lot of parents are experiencing, you know, my my wife and daughter right now are on on Zoom in in my daughter's room, just doing their hour in the morning kickoff with their class, and they just kind of like see everybody and say hi and then get some work to do for the rest of the day.
You know, so maybe schools get affected. Maybe this is the thing. Our buddy Uti obviously going nuts with with Bitcoin VR and all these meetups. Maybe this is the thing that really makes everybody really take a second look at VR, which wasn't quite ready five or six years ago, with the fact that there are headsets now that you can be untethered and don't get too hot on your face, and you can wear them for an hour or two and not really bother, doesn't bother you that much.
Brady, I know you and I just ordered our Oculus quests, and I'm gonna start messing around and stuff. So like those three things I think you know may be huge positives for society. What else are you guys looking at that might be silver linings in this in this whole situation? So, yeah, I would like to add to this.
In a way, I fully agree because if you look at some parts of this crisis, it looks like the cypherpunk dream made the reality. Basically, everybody's interacting only online, and when they do interact offline, they will be wearing masks because so unrecognizable. So it's it's a cypherpunk paradise.
One of the so I agree, especially for schooling. I mean, I think that mass schooling was both seriously unhealthy for for the for the physical health because of I mean it's not just coronavirus, every kid in the world is basically bringing home any kind of disease from these massive forced patri dishes that are modern state schooling.
So a lack of a collapse of trust in school in mass schooling, state-driven mass schooling is very good. And for work that that's true as well. A lot of people just spending entire lives inside the gray office without understanding the point of mobility interaction and the internet itself.
So I think that the if on one side there is more status fanatism going on, the on the other side there is a lot of thinking about the fact that we can do things differently, especially about working and schooling. Another positive effect is that everything we can do now online is only due to the fact that everything else may be collapsing.
I mean, the stock market is collapsing, the that our freedom is collapsing, the our our ability to get food is collapsing, but the internet is is surprisingly fine. But that's not necessarily something that we can take for granted. So I think that many many people will think okay, now that we know that everything we gave for granted can actually be taken away.
What about the internet? Are we really sure? I mean, we were scared about the internet being censored one year ago, but now if even that can get censored, then now it's really a tragedy. So people can become more more aware that we really need to find ways to protect the internet, to decentralize the internet a bit, to make the internet resilient to crisis, which is fundamental because right now everything we need is just a few a few like DNS providers shutting everybody down, and we are completely completely insulated from the world.
So it's it's really important to be concerned about the health of the internet, and in general, there is a healthy distrust. I mean, there should be, there is not yet because people are scared, but there will be irreversible damage to the reputation of experts and academic, academic gurus. Like those people, like the government-appointed experts, they started to tell people like OMS.
I mean, those clowns spent two months to saying people that it was just a flu, and everybody spreading panic was actually a troll that needed to be censored from from going to supporting full facious measures, and in between they just told everybody to not use masks because magically from a from a droplet transmissive diseases, masks are useless.
So the level of obvious idiocy coming from from yeah, I say the OMS because it's Italian, from WH and from similar clown circles, I think it's becoming quite obvious, and people is realizing that they don't know what to believe, but they're starting to understand what not to believe, which is already a good step.
It's I'm seeing that at the micro level too. Obviously we had something going down in the US which was ludicrous, which was mask related, which was all of the media and the government saying you don't need a mask because it's not gonna protect you, but we also need them for our healthcare workers. And it's like literally the same sentence, the same headline, and it just caused all this cognitive dissonance for people.
So that was that was ridiculous. Obviously, you know, a virus doesn't float around by itself, so it doesn't matter if the virus can get through the mask, it's usually in a droplet, and even a bandana is gonna stop that droplet from getting in your mouth. So really stupid and patently false. The other thing, kind of on the on the micro level, and I don't know if this is good or bad for society, but people are realizing that their friends and people in their social circles that they thought were expert on different things, don't know what the hell they're talking about.
I don't know how many friends I've had that have said, like, you know, what do you know? You're not a doctor. My doctor friend says blank. And like, obviously, I don't know if it's Bitcoiners' love for macro, Taleb, you know, just kind of like generally seeking truth or just being plugged into the hive mind of Twitter all day every day.
But you know, most Bitcoiners, you know, obviously had this right from you know, late January, or at least by early February. And so it's it's starting to be there, there's a way that people are learning to find truth, and it's based on the signaling that we get from you know, really smart people being good at judging, and this is again a very sort of like you know, telebian, but also kind of a Rumsfeldian approach, which is like know what you know, but also know what you don't know, and be able to figure out and be able to judge when someone you're talking to or listening to or reading probably
Does know. And that's what I think a lot, it's a skill that a lot of people are developing, and I think people in the macro investing world have always been pretty good at it, and I think Bitcoiners are getting really, really, really good at it because you're your skin in the game owning Bitcoin and having to find truth and develop a sense for what is true that is counter to what you are being told at all times by experts in the mainstream media and all of your friends is basically creating this this force of humans that have a way of learning and a way of
Discovering truth and insisting that there is a truth and that it's not all you know relative. That's probably like the best the best training ground you can have for this situation what about She Parker any silver linings Bitcoin it's always Bitcoin I think that I think that this is ultimately going to cause people in a in an accelerated basis to have to question you know kind of very core assumptions that and I kinda I view it as every time
There's an announcement about a 1.5 trillion dollar repo program or a 700 billion dollar QE program whether it's the Fed the ECB whatever the however they want to term it that increasingly the you know on an accelerated basis central banks are going to have to do that and each time that they do it's going to cause people to wake up about their money and to get more and more people interested in learning like why this thing Bitcoin exists why it hasn't died and that the net result of that will be a much more stable much more resilient world and like one of the things that I
Find almost baffling is how many people when this stuff happens like there's like an instant reaction to look to the government to do something.
You know, it's like, like
We've become conditioned to rely on government to fix a problem or that there's some expectation that like government should fight disease and it's like you know I've I've seen stories about how you know there were there were universities that you know wanted to you know work on their own testing kits for you know their own vaccines or viruses and like they were told to defer to the CDC and it's like wait what you know why is that you know why why can't you know on a decentralized basis people figure it out?
And so I think that you know kind of on the economic side it will force people to on a on an accelerated basis to learn about Bitcoin. And then I think just in terms of a response mechanism, it's gonna train people that like the government, at least as it is intended or was intended, is not supposed to fix all your problems.
It's you know generally supposed to do as few things as possible. And that that has been a trend that has not gone our way. And I think that kind of responses, what you know, again, whether it be on the monetary side or the fiscal side to what happens here, will cause people to realize that no, like we are resilient, we can figure things out, and that we'll actually come up with better solutions if if it's a market of you know, whether it's the United States, 325 million people trying to all solve that rather than a few people kind of in windowless rooms trying to come up with you know singular solutions for everybody.
Yeah, that's one that's that's big for me, is just you know, reminding us that communities can work, you know, that's local local is good. Just an example, like in our in our neighborhood, there's already lots of planning going on through Facebook groups and other you know similar online groups for community gardens and you know people we live we live in a town of about 100,000 people, it's a college town, but the neighborhood we live in is actually like sort of we have a bunch of big yards and stuff.
It's right, it's right across the river from downtown, but it's it's an interesting neighborhood. It's like urban but also a little rural feel to it. So people are coming together to like plan on growing food and bringing in some like chickens and livestock to co-raise together to provide protein. It's it's interesting.
And for instance, yesterday, this is just another little anecdote. You know, everybody's for St. Patrick's Day, looks forward to hanging out and partying and there's a big parade usually in the in this town, and you know, all of that stuff was canceled. We're all self-quarantined. So that like everyone came with the idea that we're gonna put shhamrocks in the windows, like homemade shamrocks in the windows.
And over a hundred and fifth in this neighborhood did that, participated, and people were out on walks, you know, on their own, still practicing social distancing, but able to kind of feel some connection with our neighbors. So I think that that's going to be a big silver lining for coming out of this for sure. That and just the like you said, Parker, the fact that you know Bitcoin's gonna move, I think, in people's minds away from this, you know, speculative asset to a serious alternative to what we're seeing play out in the in the fiat regime.
So all right, guys, we're at about time that we had scheduled and want to be mindful of your guys' time. I really appreciate you joining us, Parker and Giacomo. I think it was a great conversation, and I think it's really important now more than ever for Bitcoiners to be out there and talking and kind of carrying this light forward and bringing the community together to kind of do that collectively.
So thanks, guys, appreciate it. Yeah, thanks for having us. Thanks. Hi. All right, that's what you all can expect from the Swan Signal podcast. Hope you all enjoyed it. I'd love to hear what you think.
You can DM me or tweet at me at CitizenBitcoin. You can also tweet at SwanBitcoin. I'll see either one of those.
It's a different format than Citizen Bitcoin's one-on-one interviews and discussions,
And I think it's a really good complement to it. You know, one Swan Signal hangout discussion and one Citizen Bitcoin one-on-one episode a week. Should be a great combo for you. Hope you subscribe to both. Of course, the early bird RSS feed URL is up at SwanSignal.simplecast.com.
That'll be out on all the podcast platforms over the next few days. We'll have a better URL for it as well. But you know, it's early adoption, so it takes a little bit of extra work. Copy and paste that RSS URL into your podcast app, and you'll be among the first subscribers to Swan Signal in the entire world. Alright, we will be back to our regularly scheduled programming next week, and that's it for this week.
Take care of their Bitcoiners wherever you happen to be in the world.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
Today I want to share with you an episode of a new content series I’m making for Swan Bitcoin. Every week I host a conversation with Bitcoiners live on the Swan Twitter account and YouTube channel. We call these sessions Swan Signal Live - a group of Bitcoiners hanging out and talking about the latest bitcoin news and musings about a Bitcoin future.
In this episode of Swan Signal Giacomo shares his stories from on the ground in Italy, one of the epicenters of the Coronavirus pandemic, Parker Lewis breaks down the macroeconomic implications and gives us the latest updates on the reactions from the US Government and Federal Reserve. We talk about potential economic fallout and riff on some potential silver linings as well. Glad to share this with you all.
Citizen Bitcoin Layer One merch collection
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek
Links from the episode: