Eric Meltzer: Satoshi's Treasure
Eric Meltzer, co-creator and spokesperson for the Satoshi's Treasure alternative reality game, joins Brady to talk about the hunt for $1M worth of bitcoin.
Transcript
About this transcript
Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.
Hello and welcome to a special episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're sharing our journey, learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. Okay, Bitcoiners. So yesterday, I saw this tweet from Grubles at not Grubles on Twitter.
That he had found this intriguing message sent out over the Blockstream satellite messaging service. It read in part, what you're reading is the first clue in a grand hunt. The message said that the first three keys for a great treasure would be revealed at locations around the world the following day and contained a URL, Satoshi's treasure.xyz.
And on that website, more details could be found.
The site read in part,
“A wallet containing one million USD worth of BTC has been split into one thousand keys using the splitting magic of Shamir.”
The combination magic of the same wizard can be used to reconstitute a private key with 400 of those splits.
So the Shamir's magic is a reference to an algorithm called Shamir's secret sharing scheme, which was used to break a Bitcoin private key into 1,000 pieces and require 400 unique pieces of those 1,000 pieces to be used to reassemble the private key and claim the prize.
So I was just totally taken by this idea from the very beginning. It's Bitcoin, it's a treasure hunt, and it's cryptography, it's math, it's science. It's going to be some sort of trivia type game, I'm sure as well.
I was really excited about it. And so I reached out to Eric Meltzer, who is acting as a sort of public spokesperson for the game and asked him to join me so we could learn more about the Satoshi's treasure game. So before we dive in, just a quick reminder that Dan Held will be joining me on Thursday.
His episode will be dropping Thursday night. So look forward to that one. And all right, here's my special conversation with Eric about Satoshi's treasure.
Alright, hey Eric, how's it going? Thanks for joining me today. Hey man, yeah, thanks for having me on. Yeah, absolutely. Satoshi's treasure. There's a lot of people, a lot of Bitcoiners really excited about it. Seems you're pretty excited about it too. Can you for Bitcoiners who don't know who you are?
If there's some of those out there listening, can you just give us a brief intro as to like how and when you got into Bitcoin and how you got involved with Satoshi's treasure? Totally, yeah. So I got into Bitcoin when I was living in SF. So I went to college in China and I had just gotten, I dropped out, and I went back to SF where I'm from.
And I have this friend, he's actually kind of a friend of a friend, that's what I was super close to, and he was really into a whole bunch of kind of weird investments. You know, he had bought like property in Southeast Asia, and he was he was like investing in weed stocks when like no one even had knew that was a thing. And he was kind of we're eating lunch and he's like, yeah, like this crazy thing called Bitcoin, it's super sweet.
And you guys should all go buy some, it's like dirt cheap right now. It's just like you know, end of 2012, beginning of 2013. And I went and looked it up, and at that point, Gavin Andreessen actually had a faucet where you could just get free Bitcoin. I mean, now like if you did that, of course, someone would instantly drain it, but no one did that back then because no one really thought it was gonna be worth much.
And so I got you know my first bitcoins from from Gavin Andreessen. So I always be grateful to him for that, despite you know, his later digressions from Satch's light. He's strayed a little far from the path. But but yeah, I mean, so I got into it then, and then I ended up buying some more a local Bitcoin. So I was in I was in Soma and like I met some guy in a cafe, and you know just paid him in cash for for a little bit more Bitcoin, but I didn't get a lot, and like I never it didn't really seem to me like there was gonna be a big industry around this thing.
Like it seemed kind of obvious to me that Bitcoin itself was gonna be this really fascinating and interesting thing. But that it I did I definitely didn't expect there to be like this massive industry springing up around it. And so for about a year and a half, two years after I bought the Bitcoin, I just kind of held on to it. And I would occasionally look at CoinMarketCap and there were like all these, you know, awful scam projects.
So if you if you look at CoinMarketCap from 2013, there's nothing left that used to be on that except for Litecoin. I'm not a Litecoin fan, I kind of hope Litecoin dies too. But like back then, like mega coin, feather coin, like all this stuff, and it just it kind of reinforced my belief that like there was Bitcoin, which was this really clever, you know, way to put together a bunch of technologies that had existed for a long time, but that no one had really kind of thought could be combined in this way.
And then there were just a lot of opportunists trying to sort of cash in on on what Satoshi had had pioneered. Then in like 2016, there started to be other kind of projects that I thought were like vaguely interesting. I mean, so you started like there was ETH and there was Namecoin and there were all these other things. And at that point it kind of struck me that like okay not only is there Bitcoin, there's also these other things which I find less interesting than Bitcoin, but that are also some of them are also addressing interesting problems.
And also there's going to be all this infrastructure people need to build around Bitcoin. And so I started you know kind of investing in the space more seriously at first just with my money and then really fortuitously through through a super random series of coincidences I met this guy named Li Xiaoai who is a Chinese dude who was one of the first people to sort of be involved in the in the education space in China.
And so he was at this company called New Oriental that was sort of like the caplan of China. And while he was there they had this like employee reward program where basically he was he was a lecturer there. So we had lecture people on test prep and on sort of you know how to be a good student, how to study effectively. And they had this thing where like if students gave you really good ratings, they would reward you with with more restricted stock units or like more stock options or something.
And they ended having to like cancel this program because Xiao I got such good ratings that he was like acquiring a kind of meaningful stake in the company. And they were like okay I gotta like this out. But what happened then is is New Oriental was one of the you know early Chinese IPOs it was really successful. So he made this chunk of cash from that and he found out about Bitcoin and then just plowed it all into Bitcoin.
He made this massive if I recall correctly he he actually had some applications that's conviction right there. Yeah he had massive conviction so he he he got like you know a hundred thousand a little over a hundred thousand Bitcoin at like a basis I think averaged out around seven bucks. And he just kind of held it ever since. And so he also, you know, he invested in like Zcash in the early days, Saya in the early days.
But I got to meet this guy and we just really hit it off. And so, you know, we kind of worked on some projects. I was helping them do DD for some investments. And he ended up just asking me to come on to his firm in blockchain, which is like the largest crypto fund in China as a partner. And I was, you know, I was just really stoked to work with them. They were, it's a it's a great group of people, they're really smart.
They're not I guess like they're not Bitcoin maximalists in the sense that some of my friends are, where they're like, look, everything besides Bitcoin is bullshit, but they're highly skeptical towards sort of all the non-Bitcoin stuff, which I think is like if you're an investor, a pretty pretty healthy place to be. So I really enjoyed kind of working with them. And I got I got sort of more deeply into the space during that year.
And then very recently, so like in in you know, December, I decided to spin out my own fund. And so I talked to Shallai about it. He was real supportive, and I decided to work with this girl who I've been doing a lot of co-investing with, you know, leading up to this, and names Dove Wan. So Dovey was at the end. Yeah, oh yeah, I know I know about Davey on Twitter.
Sorry, yeah, I definitely know about her on Twitter. She's doing great work reporting on the Chinese market. Debbie had no Twitter followers basically when like when we started hanging out, and now she has I think more than me, or she's like on track to have more than me. She's like extremely like just natively good at Twitter and just super hilarious, and like she's just you know, the two of us were like we're co investing so often, and finally we're just like this is this is ridiculous.
Like we work together so often, we may as well like actually work together. So now we have this fund called Primitive Ventures, and you know, primitives really we're kind of continuing the same stuff we were doing at our respective funds previously, which is you know, we're really excited about getting involved in the very earliest stage stuff. And so kind of all of this sets the stage for Satoshi's treasure where you know the two of us, and I don't know what like other other investors listening to this.
I'm curious to hear you guys' takes, but like the for the past couple months, we saw basically no deals we were excited about. And we were just like, this sucks. Like, we should just go make something cool. And the two of us always have had a bunch of ideas. And so something we've always wanted to do is like this crazy, you know, Bitcoin hunt or whatever.
But we never had a way to kind of make it make it viral in the sense that we wanted, and then also to like force people to team up and to collaborate. And so the genesis for Satoshi's treasure was actually, you know, we were as a fund, we were talking to custodians who you know who who store your crypto for you.
And the conversations were like really distressing to us because like the two of us are, you know, we're the kind of paranoid that you become after being in the crypto space for a long time. And we asked them like, okay, so what happens when some employee joins your company, you know, or a group of employees join your company and they work really well for three or four years, but actually their entire goal in joining is to completely understand all of your processes, and then at the four or five year mark, they steal the entire cold wallet and disappear into the ether.
And when we brought this up with the custodians, they like legit laughed at us. They were like, that's ridiculous. That's like an ocean's 11 plot, you know, like no one's gonna do that. And Duffy and I are sitting there, like, of course someone's gonna do that. Like, that is straight up what happened because you're dealing with these enormous sums of money, and so your threat model has to be pretty pretty severe. And so, you know, we were just really unsatisfied with all these custodians, and so we decided we would just custody our own crypto.
And the way that we decided to do that was was by using this this cryptographic function called Shamir's secret sharing. And so for Bitcoin, there are actually better, I mean, so I think for Bitcoin, it's actually better to use a multi-sig. But for all the other assets, you know, Bitcoin is really the only cryptocurrency that has a really robust multi-sig implementation.
And so for these other cryptocurrencies, what we would do is we would take the private key and we would use Shamir's to shard that private key into a bunch of shares. And then the only way to move the crypto is by recombining the shares and we store them at a bunch of secure locations, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. So while we were doing this, I was like playing around with the with the terminal utility that allows you to do these Shamir shards.
And I was like, man, I wonder like what the most shards I can do before my MacBook just like craps the bed. And so I started just like cranking out bigger and bigger ones. And you know, the after I had it up to about a thousand, like the combination took a long time. Yeah. And I was like, man, like what if we made a game like this? And this is this is a couple months ago. And so we kind of there were a lot of details we had to work out around how we'd hide them.
There's a really tricky problem with this, which is like if you want to if you want to join a team, then you need to prove to other people that you actually have keys that they don't, but you don't want to reveal the keys. And actually a property of Shamir's property that Shamirs doesn't have, unfortunately, is it's not what's called a verifiable secret sharing scheme. So like if I show you what looks like a Shamir split, you have no way of actually verifying that it really is one.
And so we talked to a big group of cryptographers. I'm lucky enough, I have this group on Telegram called Siberia, and it's just like a bunch of the world's best cryptographers and a bunch of like interesting crypto people. The only rule in the group is that you have to be extremely polite and nice. So they're they're really used to people be an asshole, but if you say that everyone like rules lawyers and they're like, I'm not being an asshole.
So if you're like, okay, okay, you have to be like super nice, then everyone's actually you know reasonably civil. And so we went to this group and we sort of asked them, okay, like, you know, the dumb way to do this would be we run a centralized server and you can submit your keys to the server, and the server tells you, okay, yeah, that's a real key. The problem with that is A, it's like a huge honeypot. B, you're training users in a really bad behavior.
You're saying, like, hey, like submit your private keys to a known third-party servers. So we're like, is there any kind of nice way to do this where people can verify that they have a key without revealing it in a decentralized way? And Ian Myers from Zcash came up with a really sweet, what he described as a very braindead solution, which is always kind of what I want to hear from cryptographers, where it's like, this is so simple and so well tested that we're not gonna have any nasty surprises.
And so, you know, in a couple of weeks we're gonna reveal this, but basically we have a tool that users can use and they're gonna be able to use it inside an app that we're gonna release, but they can also use it manually that allows you to say, okay, I have these keys and I can prove that I have these keys at this at this period in time. And so we hope that'll allow people to like form teams much faster.
Awesome. Okay, yeah. So I was definitely gonna ask you about that, is about about being able to verify keys. And obviously, today the first three keys were discovered pretty quickly because they were all basically verified by the web server that's running your website. And there's a lot it's it's not that's not quite how it works.
So how how what happened with those first keys is there's no there's actually no server there, so it's a static HTML file. Right, right. Static HTML file is encrypted with AES256, but we deliberately chose a really simple password for each of those. So if we chose the recalled password, you wouldn't be able to do this. But we wanted to do is figure out kind of how clever people were gonna get with these things.
And so we were like, okay, if you really understand crypto, you can just do like a dictionary brute force attack on these and decrypt them without actually having to go to the locations. And I have to admit, like I assigned like a 10% probability that anyone would figure that out within the first week. Of course, someone figured it out within like the first 20 minutes. Yeah, yeah. I was in a I was in a Discord.
I was in a Discord with him when he figured out the first one and pasted a screenshot and then the passphrase. See if I can find who it was. Was it this guy John Cantrell? Yeah, it was John Cantrell. Yeah. So you message me on Twitter.
I'm I'm I'm just I'm blown away, man. I mean, people are people are so smart. Yeah, absolutely. It was amazing. And it and it took him, you know, maybe half an hour. I think. So, yeah. So I so I mean, we haven't talked about this much, but actually before we launched this big hunt, we did these two like test hunts. So we did one at MIT and we did one at USC.
And it was from much of the. So I saw that on the how'd that go? How how did that go? I mean, the same thing happened that happened here where we thought it was gonna take people like hours and hours to solve the hunts, and in reality, it took them like less than an hour, and the winning teams were really sophisticated. So like they actually they found a bunch of clues, but then they actually bought clues for like a smaller amount of Bitcoin from other teams that weren't as successful.
And so the winning team, you know, was able to like end the hunt very quickly. And that happened. So it happened at MIT, and we were like, yeah, whatever. Like MIT students are really smart, and also they they know about like Schenears and stuff. But we're like at USC, especially because it was a lot of non-engineering students, we did not expect them to solve it as fast as they did. But it turns out like people are really good at Googling, and when you have a lot of people working together on a team, you know, it just gets it gets crazy fast.
Yeah. So you and Dovey and Primitive are basically the main drivers behind the game. And you're and then you've just like brought in some people to consult on how to do the crypto, and I assume, you know, kind of to be geographically distributed to help out with with certain geocaching. I don't know. I mean, I don't know how we don't want to talk about this too much for two reasons.
One is like it's kind of an obset thing. The other is like, I think eventually people are gonna figure out everyone who's involved with this because people are great at that. But I kind of like that as like a sub-mystory, you know, it's like a metagame mystery. So like if people want to like try to figure out who else helping out with this, that's great. You know, primitive provided a bunch of the funding, and then we also have a bunch of really awesome investors besides primitive.
And you know, it's mostly people who when we told them about this idea, because initially we weren't gonna like raise any money for it. We told them about this idea, and they were like, that's so cool. You gotta let me like contribute. And so we basically just let a bunch of our friends, you know, toss in some Bitcoin as well. And it's you know, it's it's it's I think people have a hunger for like mystery and fun.
And so much of what happens in crypto these days to me is like kind of a boring, it's a boring version of what this all got started around, right? And like in 2013, 2012, 2013, 2014, there were a lot of interesting small puzzles, and there was much more sort of like a cypherpunk ethos to the space. And it sort of bums me out that that's become a little bit diluted, and I really want to bring that back in a big way.
Yeah, so would you say that that's the main goal of the game then for primitive and you like personally? Yeah, yeah. I mean, dude, the main goal of this game is to provide something that's like a complete alternate reality from like the boring reality we all have to live in. And we're gonna do a lot of really crazy stuff to that effect.
The secondary goal is just I think a lot of people, even who've heard about Bitcoin, don't actually understand why Bitcoin is cool. And I think it's a lot of the stuff that's just hiding in plain sight. Like it's not, you know, we don't really need to like change anything about the protocol. Like, we thought about you know, could we do this game using fiat? And this game would be like infinitely more difficult in fiat.
So, first of all, like, you know, one of the things we decided from the very beginning is that no country is gonna have enough clues to win. So, like any team that wins is gonna have to be international or is gonna have to spend a lot of money on plane tickets. And if we did that with fiat, I mean, we'd be spending this entire year like figuring out, okay, what's the stripe of Korea? Like how do you how do you do this?
Like, how do you send people money? And then we have to get a whole bunch of licenses and it'd just be a nightmare. Whereas with Bitcoin, it's like literally you just get all that stuff for free. And because Bitcoin, of course, is a cryptographically secure currency, it's like you can do stuff like Shamir's, and you can do stuff where you know, us as a company, we're not sending anyone any Bitcoin. You know, they're just gonna find the clues and take it and that's it.
Yeah, so the Bitcoin prize is on the blockchain right now. So we initially we were gonna like you know, show people the wallet and sign a transaction from it, and then someone came up, someone on the team came up with a really clever idea where basically like finding the wallet is itself one of the clues. And so like over the next couple of weeks, there'll be some clues that point people to the wallet and they'll be able to be able to find it and kind of verify that.
I will say, so so one thing that we actually we really want to emphasize is that like there's a lot of ways in which this game is trust minimized. So like you don't have to trust us, for example, that we're gonna send you any Bitcoin. You don't have to trust us that like you know, these these that that we actually use Shamirs or whatever. One thing you do have to trust us on, and this is just sort of an artifact of the cryptography, is there's actually no way for us to prove that the Shamir's keys that are out there actually correspond to the wallet.
So that's just something where it's like if you if you don't trust us, so if you if you think like we're out here like scamming and there's there's you know there's no real Bitcoin, then like you shouldn't play because there's there's sort of no cryptographic way we can get around that. And then another sort of parallel would be a lot of work to go through for. Yeah, I mean, there's just there's just no way to do it.
So we thought it like it would be it'd be really cool if there was, but there's just no way to prove, you know, with without actually revealing the keys that they that they actually correspond to that wallet. That said, you know, I think there's a lot more for us to gain by running this correctly than trying to scan people and like if we're gonna scan people I just go do a stupid ICO for like Eric or something like a really like you know elaborate elaborate scam.
The other the other place where you have to trust people though and initially we kind of thought this was a bug and we were thinking like is there a way around this but now I think it's like totally a feature is that if you form a team the team's gonna collect all these keys and then once you get 400 keys you can assemble a private key. But at that point whoever is like actually doing the combination they could just like run off and not pay everyone else out on their team.
And so teams have to come up with a way to like trust each other. And there are actually are in this case cryptographic methods where you can sort of secure this using an MPC that the Zcash guys have been talking about. Or there's you know or like everyone can just get together in a room. So like you know you're team one and you have some massive party you know somewhere accessible to everyone and you combine the keys in person or I we're really curious to see sort of like how that plays out.
Yeah that'll be really fascinating. There's definitely been some discussions in in the couple of Discords that I'm in that are talking about this about about the game on how to organize on that front already so is the app that you guys are releasing going to help with any of that like kind of like managing the keys that you have discovered totally yeah so the app basically so the app the app when it when it when we first launch is gonna be really simple it's just basically gonna give you clues and it's gonna allow you to store keys and it's gonna allow you to combine keys and then it's the final thing that it's gonna allow you to do is is this nice scheme that Ian came up with for us using Peterson commits will allow you to prove that
You have keys to other people. And then there's a whole bunch of other really awesome stuff we're gonna build. So like we're gonna build ways to like sell keys to each other, we're gonna build ways to trade keys, we're gonna build team organization stuff. But at the beginning, you know, it's gonna be this very simple setup. So there'll probably be like a couple of teams that might be kind of toward the top and leading.
And once there's like a way for like two or three or you know, however many teams to combine to get 400 unique keys, then the incentive might be there for those teams to go ahead and like combine their collected keys and just declare it over at that point, which would be really interesting.
Absolutely, yeah. And so so we're really curious about you know, we've we've talked to a couple of people that like study game theory, and the game always like blows their mind. And what typically happens, we'll have this conversation and they're like, oh yeah, yeah, I get it, it's pretty simple. And then like they'll call me back in like two days and be like, dude, dude, dude, this is like so weird. And like, look at all this crazy stuff that could happen with all these like pathological situations.
So, like one thing that we think was is kind of interesting is like imagine if you have two teams that have 190 keys and they both get approached by someone that has 10 keys that are unique to both of them, and that person says, Look, I'm gonna give you these keys, but I want half the pot. If you don't give me half the pot, I'm gonna go to this other team. And so like I don't know what would happen in that in that scenario.
It's it's it's it's really, you know, who knows. That's amazing. So it sounds like, I mean, with with the like planned features for the app and everything, it sounds like you guys are expecting this game to take a while. Like, so what's the I and I know there's kind of a planned pace, right? Like every Sunday there's gonna be clues that are released on the website.
Do you have an idea like how long you expect the hunt to take? I really I really don't know. So we're gonna there's there's gonna be some some things that I can't talk about at all in detail, but that are probably going to increase the size of the prize pool. And it sort of depends on how fast those happen.
We think we've figured out a way to make this a sustainable thing so that there can be sort of recurring games, almost like we almost think of it sort of like the Olympics, where like every year, every couple of years, there's like a new hunt, and it might get bigger and bigger each time. And so the pace of the game will kind of be dictated by that. And then it's also dictated by like there's some clues that I think are really, really, really hard, and I might be wrong.
Like they might be much easier than I think, because people are extremely, extremely smart and very dedicated. So are you planning to release a certain number of clues every weekend? Yeah, I mean we've got we've got an idea now, but I think that might change. And adjust it. We might adjust it. There's also like, since we've been chatting with our friends who run, you know, other apps or other games and stuff, like a lot of people have talked to us about wanting to sort of partner with us to have Satoshi's keys inside of their experiences.
And I think that's really cool. But we have to be careful. So it's like there's some cases where that would make the game much better if we put a key inside a really awesome game. And there's other cases where it would make the game really lame if we're like, hey, you have to go like buy some Nestle's chocolate or something to find a key. So you know, we're we're we're kind of being careful on that, but I think that might also affect the pace quite a bit because it gives us a lot more bandwidth to be releasing keys quickly.
Right, right. So aside from the like the three keys that are out there already, have any others been hidden out there in the real world or on the internet at this point or actually there are there are a couple of other keys that are out there. I think they're extraordinarily hard to find. Okay. Pretty surprised if anyone finds them before we start putting clues out.
They are they are out there. And then yeah, there's there's a couple of funny Easter egg clues as well. You know, like I'm trying to decide if I should tell anyone about this or not. I guess I guess we can talk about this. So like, you know, we have we have business cards for everyone that's working on the project. And a cool thing about Shamir is is that if you have if you have a Shamir's split, so like imagine we take a Bitcoin wallet and we split it into ten pieces.
I can then take one of those pieces and then split that even further. Because Shamir's doesn't care what it's working on, it's just any string. Sure. So we actually have one key that we split into another like you know, six or seven keys, and then each of our business cards has like one QR code on it. And so if you can collect all of our business cards, you can find a key. So you know, if you guys if people see us in real life, you know, ask us for a card, we'll give you one, and you can you can maybe get a key that way.
That's awesome. That's awesome. So the sign-up page on the site asks for an email and phone number, and obviously like there's some Bitcoiners have been like, oh that's that's a privacy red flag. Are is there gonna be some kind of advantage for players who decide to give you guys that information? Or will the same clues and data be available on the website?
Yeah, so the we made the phone number optional. Initially it was like we required both of them, and then a lot of people were like unhappy with that, and so we were like, yeah, we should, you know, make that an option that in case you just want to like so right now there's three options, right? You can you can totally give us nothing, which is super which is fine, and like you can just monitor the site frequently. You can give us your email and then you'll you'll get emails every time a new clue goes out.
Or you can give us your phone number and you'll get texts as well. The thing about texts is like we can do kind of some cool stuff with that. So I'm not gonna like anyone who doesn't want to give us their numbers, it's totally fine. If you do, you might be getting some clues that don't appear on the site necessarily. Yeah. And there might be some some other kind of games that occur over text messages.
Right on. What do you like what is the distribution of like clues that require physical world presence versus clues that are online? Do you think like roughly I think it's gonna it's gonna be you know 20 or 30% offline and then the rest online.
Okay. We might play around with that. We're very much in like experimentation mode with what kind of keys or what kind of you know clues work well and are fun and which ones aren't. Totally, yeah. Something that like so I come from like I've been playing these alternate reality games for you know since I was a kid, and I really love them, and like we did, you know, something we did with the game is like that the people that are working on this game made like a library of all the different ARGs that were out there and all the clues that they've done.
And one of the things we noticed was that for a lot of my favorite ARGs, they were can't they became a little bit like kind of elitist, where like if you're if you're someone that's like played a bunch of these before and you have a lot of math knowledge or programming knowledge, you might be able to like just be way ahead of everyone else. And that became very discouraging for other people playing the game. And so something that we really want to make sure of is that like there's sort of no matter no matter who you are, if you're like really good at anything, there's gonna be some way to use that skill to get clues.
There definitely will be some clues that like don't require any programming knowledge, don't require any knowledge of what Bitcoin is, and are just like you know, you have to go somewhere very remote, or you have to, you know, be able to solve a humanities problem or a poetry problem or something like that. I love it. That's great. And I think that's a really good idea to make the game more interesting to a wider audience for sure.
So what what are some of your favorite ARGs that you played? So there was there's there's one that the nine inch nails did called Year Zero, that I thought was really great. They it was very much online offline. They had online clues. They had one clue that that that always you know really blew my mind where like it was a sound at the end of one of their songs, and it it just sounded like a very brief, like static blip.
And then if you put it in a spectrum analyzer, it showed you this like creepy hand descending from the heavens, which was kind of one of the motifs in their game. And you had to like actually, you know, get a spectrum analyzer, put it in log mode, and then you could see that. And they had, you know, they had an actual like offline concert that got busted up by fake riot cops. I mean, it was just it was super sweet.
So I was I was very much into that one. You know, Halo had one called I Love Bees that was great. I've been like William Gibson is probably my favorite sci-fi author of all time. And I love bees had this what I felt was a very Gibson-esque clue set where you had to like go find payphones in real life, and then the payphones would ring and you could talk to this like AI that you were building.
So I thought that was really great. The other one that I almost hesitate to describe as an ARG was there was this game called Cicada 3301 that had incredibly difficult clue. And there was a lot of speculation that it was like an NSA recruitment effort and that anyone who won, you know, got inducted into some secret agency or something.
I didn't even get close to like the final rounds. I actually I thought I was doing really well, and then I like talked to a friend that is actually good at this stuff, and he was like, nah, dude, you know, just at the first the first levels. Oh my gosh. Yeah, yeah. So all of those, all those have been inspirations. You know, I think with any of these games, you have to understand that like anytime you do something offline, it's only gonna be a tiny fraction of your users that actually get to participate in that thing.
But that even the users that don't get to participate can can hear about it and can see it, and it definitely enhances the game for them as well. So sort of the way we think of a lot of these offline things is that like they are contributing to the story, sort of the meta story of the game itself. Yeah, absolutely. Well, I'm super excited about participating.
And it's gonna suck up some of my time, which I probably don't have to devote to it, but it's gonna happen anyway, and it's just gonna add to Bitcoin's gravity pull in general. For a lot of Bitcoiners' lives. Yeah, I mean, so something we think about when we think about Bitcoin in this is like I think Bitcoin wins when Bitcoin is like super boring and mundane.
So like when Bitcoin is like as exciting as like pork bellies, then like Bitcoin has truly won. Right. And so for us, we're like, we don't talk about we're not like, oh, this is a Bitcoin game. It's like it's just a treasure hunt. And it turns out that like Bitcoin is by far the best form of money, especially for an application like this. And so, like, of course we use Bitcoin, of course we don't use dollars. I like it. Yeah, that makes sense.
All right, any other sorry, go ahead. I mean, I think I think what I what I what I'd close with is you know, we sent out the first clue using the Blockstream satellite, and I kind of I you know I corresponded with a bunch of blockstream people before we did that to kind of understand how that should work. And when we sent the when we sent it out, we actually sent out the clue a little bit in advance of like a media embargo.
And so we were kind of worried that someone would have like found the clue and started talking about it before the media had a chance to report. And there was this one guy in particular, this guy, Dr. Goss, who's like this he's a Bitcoiner, he's been kind of monitoring the satellite for a long time, and he tweets out cool stuff that he finds. And so he ended up finding it a little later, and he was like super excited about it, and he DM'd us and stuff.
And then he tweeted something out yesterday that I thought was like super moving and is like perfectly captures what we're trying to do with this game. So he said, Life is an epic adventure where our experiences shape who we are. I have a feeling Satoshi's treasure will be the type of epic adventure that leaves many people changed for the better, and one person or party better and wealthier. Life is as much about the journey as the destination.
That's that's like totally what this is about. So I absolutely love it. That guy gets it. I absolutely love it. Yeah, and it's, you know, I've got this kind of idea about how Bitcoin markets itself and it's kind of ingenious incentive structure. One of the things it incentivizes is this kind of just decentralized organic marketing machine or education machine where there's every new wave of adoption.
There's these group, this cohort that that comes out to, you know, d donate their time to create content about how to learn Bitcoin. And that's the way that's the same thing. Yeah. No, no, go ahead. I was just gonna say this I think is a great a perfect example. And one that I think will be hugely could be hugely successful successful and bring a lot of attention to Bitcoin.
Right. I mean I think I think that's something that a lot of people don't understand until they've kind of been looking at Bitcoin for a long time, is that like, you know, Bitcoin does not have a CEO, Bitcoin does not have a marketing department. And what's you know, what's really important is that Bitcoin doesn't have a whole bunch of people that pre-mine all the Bitcoin and are just holding it. And so what that what that leads to is this really fascinating scenario where I can contribute time to making people more aware of Bitcoin without feeling like I'm a chump that's like just making money for someone else.
Yeah, totally. No ICO gets that, right? Because like I don't want I'm not gonna go like you know, tell everyone how sweet someone else's ICO is. Like that's just I feel like a chump doing that. Whereas with Bitcoin, like that that dynamic isn't there, and I think that's super powerful. Yeah, I mean I have very little Bitcoin compared to you know, a lot of whales that are out there and even non-whales, even people that are just because you know, I got I got in later than most people that are in right now, and have only been in Bitcoin for a couple of years, and so you know, and that'll change and I'll become, you know, over time as as more and more people get in, that just kind of changes.
But I don't feel like you said, I don't feel like a chump that I'm just making here making a bunch of money for Bitcoin whales, you know, because the potential is so you know, so massive, both like financially speaking, but also like just socially and benefits for society in general. And so, you know, all of those incentives line up to create these you know new waves of people that market Bitcoin you know, without even realizing that that's what they're doing.
Yeah, and this is just a great example of it. And so I think it's you guys have done a great job rolling it out so far, and I'm excited to watch it gain steam. So something something I'm curious to hear your take on. We're not we haven't decided whether we're gonna do this or not. But there's there's something you can do on Bitcoin, so you can time lock Bitcoin where you can make it so a given Bitcoin transaction or given Bitcoin UTXO is not spendable until a certain amount of blocks have elapsed.
And initially we were thinking we might just time lock the entire prize. So it's like you want all this Bitcoin, but you are forced to hold it. We decided not to do that because it's it's a little risky. Like there's you know, it's like if someone gets it and it's time-locked, and then the time lock ends up being really not beneficial for them, they might be annoyed. And there's also kind of weirdness around like if there's some massive protocol change in the meantime, it can be dangerous.
But I think we are gonna have some like mini games and mini hunts in the in the hunt where like you what you receive is Bitcoin, but it's Bitcoin that you're forced to hold for like at least a year or at least two years. Yeah. I'd be down with that. I think that's cool. I mean, a year or two years is not a massive time frame, you know. Why my question would be like, why would you want to do that?
Especially if it's just for a couple of years. So I've I've I've given I've given Bitcoin to a lot of people, like very, very small amounts. And I've noticed, and my friend Dan, you know, I don't know if you know like Dan Held from from I'm actually recording a podcast with him on Thursday evening. So I'm gonna talk to him. I really like him. So he's someone that spent a ton of time thinking about Bitcoin and thinking about sort of where Bitcoin's going.
And something that he pointed out to me was that like I should just stop doing that. Because like when you give no coiners Bitcoin, what they inevitably do is just sell it. Yeah. And it's just that you didn't you didn't accomplish anything. And so I think what's cool is if you give someone time locked Bitcoin, yeah, then inevitably what happens is like, god damn it, like I still don't like Bitcoin. And then they're like, but I have this Bitcoin. They're like, I should go check on what the price is. And then they're like, they they become Bitcoiners, like it infects them, and there's nothing they can do about it.
Totally if you give Bitcoin away, it's nice to give it give away time-locked Bitcoin. So I think that's that's kind of what we'll to save the save them from themselves because it's it's hard to hold on to that Bitcoin when you don't understand what's going on and you're kind of you're new to the game. Exactly. Yep. Yeah. I gotta actually have to run to a meeting.
But thanks so much for having me on. This was a good idea. I really appreciate your time, Eric. Sorry, I just like talk and talk and talk about this stuff. As you can tell, I'm just super excited about it. Yeah, I can tell you're excited about it. It's gonna be a lot of fun. Yeah, thanks for thanks for joining me and good luck with with everything rolling it out over the next few months. Thanks a lot, man.
Happy ending. Take care. Alright, so what'd you all think of that? Pretty awesome, right? It's gonna be a lot of fun to watch unfold, and I'm definitely going to be following along. And as a bonus for those of you who stuck around for the whole episode, I'm announcing here and now for the first time publicly that Marty Bent, Matt O'Dell, and myself are organizing a Satoshi's treasure team.
The Dread Pirate Roberts Avengers. The DPR Avengers will be donating 10% of any prize we win playing Satoshi's treasure to the free Ross Fund. We're looking to build a geographically diverse team of people with varied knowledge and skills, especially in cryptography and coding, but also skills with puzzles, alternative reality games, researching Bitcoin, history, science, humanities.
Fill out a short form at TinyURL.com slash DPR Avengers to let us know if you're interested.
There will be a limited number of team members just to keep things manageable for us,
So please don't take it personally if you don't get an invite.
There's going to be a lot of teams out there forming. Probably some will merge over the course of the game in the quest to achieve 400 unique keys. So that's it for this special episode of the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. Take care out there, bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.
No passages match. Try a shorter phrase.
Episode notes
Eric Meltzer, co-creator and spokesperson for the Satoshi’s Treasure alternative reality game, joins Brady to talk about the hunt for $1M worth of bitcoin.
Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop
Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek
Links from the show: