All episodes
Episode 8

EOS, Bcash, Lightning and Satoshis.Place

June 19, 201828 min

Tommy and Brady discuss the EOS mainnet failure and it's basically centralized structure; we share research that shows that 10 times more BCH coins are hodled than spent, whereas the ratio of hodled bitcoin versus spending bitcoin is 1:1; and we take a look at Satoshis.Place and why it is, yes, silly, but also important.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Welcome back to the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin. We're here sharing our journey, learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. Welcome back to Kansas, Tommy. Thank you, Brady. How was Chicago and New York and all of your very important business travel?

It was excellent. All right. Very good. So have you been keeping up then on the on the Bitcoin and crypto news? I sure have. It's been it's been pretty it's been pretty interesting just as the in particular Bitcoin continues to fight with the bottom, I guess, right? Price has been fun to watch.

We've got some other things you know happenings in the space that we should probably catch up on. Let's check in on check in on some of these these big altcoins. EOS had a had a big mainnet crash just a few days after their mainnet went live. Yeah, EOS is interesting because when you when you look at Bitcoin in terms of all the capital that was raised, it was you know close to two billion dollars and it's yeah, some some reports that it was up towards a four billion actually.

But we don't know for sure. Yeah, and it's a situation where it's as if they're going backwards. They're they're they're paying hackers to come up with what's wrong with their system. And then you compare compare and contrast, actually it's just contrast it with Bitcoin and the fact that Bitcoin just started with an idea and no capital.

And it just it's fascinating to watch EOS. Yeah, so for those of you who don't know what happens with EOS, just a few days ago on the 16th, a tweet came out from EOS Authority. You know, and the fact that there is an account called EOS Authority obviously demonstrates that it's a centralized institution, but they don't hide away from that fact.

There's there's 21 block producers that have been elected by token holders, and those 21 producers are you know the central authority, comprise the central authority. So they're sort of going for this in-between play. There's not one central bank and it's not completely decentralized.

It's sort of they're trying to go for something in between. Yeah, and it reaches a point where when when you get into it, it you sit there and say, well, they raised all this money, they've got all these bugs. It's almost like they're going at it backwards, and then you have all these different aspects like the 21 blocks that are elected, and at a certain point you have to say to yourself, is it is this really gonna end up being immutable?

Is is this going to be censorship censorship resistant? Right. Is this trustless and all the aspects that are built into what you would consider a s a stalwart type of crypto asset, it's almost you reach the point where we have it hasn't been around that long, but it's almost like you use the you know, whatever.

Okay, you sit there and go, you know, EOS, whatever. I mean, in terms of how I look at it. It's difficult to try to even follow at this point for me. Yeah, I mean it it's it's perhaps worth trying, although I am quite skeptical that 21 block producers would lead to a censorship resistant or a money supply debasement resistant, more maybe even more importantly, setup.

Right. Well, and there's gonna be a lot of things is it right on those 21. Well, exactly. And you really you sit there and look at it and just very simplistically and sit there and say well and just in terms of the fundamental structure of EOS you have to sit there and say to yourself the fundamental structure that's in place that doesn't lend itself to long-term sustainability right and so about three days after they launched the main net for EOS there was a lar a bug an alert that

Went out and the EOS authority tweeted that had an alert with transactions frozen on the EOS network globally all the block producers are aware we are on a call with the other block producers to identify and resolve this issue no timelines yet I saw a lot of jokes on Twitter go out about about proof of conference call POC well but I mean well well the other part of it too is what what's it really sound like right it sounds like a corporation or it sounds like a big bank or or you know in other words but understanding that's not necessarily that's not bad okay except that if you're you're trying to just not different well it's it's yeah it's if you're talking about a crypto asset you have to say to yourself well this this

Is just you know pretty pretty mundane actually I think I like this part right where they say root cause was due to how deferred transactions were handled fix is being released shortly by block one and it's like well what what the heck does all that mean I mean right well why do they even have to tell us that well it's just because they they don't they've got so many bugs and I don't know.

I mean they have to tell somebody something, right? Because the important people put in billions of dollars into this deal, right? Well they're they're just they're just announcing right that they that they have found a patch and a solution and they're gonna issue a patch. And you know, Bitcoin core might do the same thing if there was some kind of announc like emergency announcement that needed to be to have a lot of different things. Yeah, but they wouldn't have a conference call.

But they wouldn't have they probably wouldn't have a conference call. And there aren't only 21 block producers that need to update the software and so forth. It's almost too much fun to attack this because there's so much to attack. Yeah, the well the point being that why try a cryptocurrency that is even remotely centralized because it's just far more efficient to run a system centrally.

Well, it's it's it's called the banking system current financial system. Well, but but it's because people try to layer this on top, you know, it's it's a it's a situation to me like like when people were sitting around they want to make it similar, right? So it's like when people are sitting around at the turn of the century saying, you know, we gotta breed faster horses. And you know, by the way, we need factories to be able to in terms of manure, we gotta pro you know we're gonna be we're gonna have so many horses, there's gonna be so much stuff going on that we need factories to be able to process more manure.

I mean, so it's kinda like they're anyway, maybe that's not maybe that's a little bit off off off the path a little bit. But the idea being being i it it's it's trying to fit it into an existing structure rather than being completely completely new as to how Bitcoin looks at it, for example, or is laid out.

Right. Yeah, there are you know some people that push back on Twitter that are like, hey, let's just try these different ideas out, right? You know, if Bitcoin maximists are are out there saying, like, look, it doesn't even, it's not it's really not even worth trying a cryptocurrency that's even vaguely centralized because we know how it's going to end up.

We've been doing that for thousands of years with central control of money in civilization. And inevitably we've ended up with, although we may have had periods of sound money control, right? Of central control of sound money, and for for periods, and those periods have been very good for the human economy because of the it was based on sound money.

But eventually that central control has led to the debasement of the currency. Whether you're talking about clipping gold in in in in Rome, right? When where we had this this you know really solid gold standard for quite some time, and then you know, one of the emperors comes along and starts clipping that gold. Well, several of them. So you end up having to go.

Right. There's many examples if you're over centuries with the Roman where they just continued to be to debase it by reducing the amount of that was smelted, the amount of actually they just kept doing it. That they were clipping. But there's a bunch of examples in Sae Fidin O Moose's book, The Bitcoin Standard, about this happening throughout history, and that's just gonna happen again with the crypto, with the money supply for these tokens.

So it just doesn't make sense to even try, given that there is a lot of work, a hell of a lot of work that goes that's involved in running and maintaining a decentralized cryptocurrency. So much work goes into it, in fact, that we have arguably one out of thousands of cryptocurrencies that are out there, we have arguably one that is decentralized enough to be debasement resistant, right?

And that's Bitcoin. Arguably one that's centralized enough to be. Well, we've mentioned before is you've got the Lindy effect, it's been around the longest by far. Right. In terms of being tested all all the way through. The other aspect of this EOS, EOS is that they raised all this money.

Okay, so you've got an aspect of it wasn't as if the billions of dollars raised was going in dollar for dollar for this new project. The idea is when this money was raised, there's a group of people that that are being the beneficiaries of this deal deal happening. So the idea at this point is they have to come up with some type of a product.

Otherwise, what did they what did they raise the money for? Yeah. So I mean that's simplistic, but it's a situation where and they've got a lot of money, they got billions and billions of dollars that they can in quote throw at to try to make it's almost like it's the reverse. In other words, they come in with a type of product or what what the idea is, and then they say, okay, we got enough cash now that we'll just we'll just keep going through going through things until we come up with something that'll work as opposed to Bitcoin, which just was started from the very bottom and just grew and grew up into what it is now organically.

All right, so so that's EOS. Let's let's move on to Bcash. There's just a little just something that I wanted to bring up that was shown by some research at chain by Chain Analysis, all right, which is the company that you know, they they do a lot of good research, but they also are working hard to make the blockchain more transparent for for the you know for government and so forth, and less less centrist resistant.

There are you know projects like Mimbo Wimble and Coinjoin that are trying to improve the fundamental privacy and fungibility of Bitcoin in reaction to companies like Chain Analysis, but they also do a lot of really good research, and BitMEX tweeted a bit of research from ChainAlysis about the Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash money supplies.

So of course with Bitcoin Cash, the investment thesis is the proposal is that they will be used, they're increasing the block size so that we can use Bitcoin cash for transactions. Correct, everyday transactions, buy coffee on the blockchain, right? And make it and be have it be very cheap, very low fees.

And so their solution was to increase the block size. But ChainAlysis has looked at the Bitcoin Cash blockchain and the Bitcoin blockchain. And what's fascinating is that on that there are ten times more Bitcoin Cash coins that are being held for investment purposes, therefore that not being spent on an everyday basis than there are coins that are being spent on everyday basis.

But what's fascinating is for Bitcoin it's more one to one. So half of the coins and the UTXOs on the blockchain are being held, and about half are being spent on a regular basis on transactions. So the investment thesis is completely turned on its head by this research for Bitcoin Cash.

Well, Bitcoin Cash keeps trying, but it's you know it's it's B cash. I mean this is just you know, this is just like kind of a final nail in the coffin to me, and it's data right here. It's it's your chain is not being used for what it it has, you know, it's an its investment case that's proposed to be used for.

So we're looking we'll post a link to this in Yeah, so it's t so that just to summarize ten times more Bcash coins are held for investment purposes rather than for transactions. 10 10x. So this whole ongoing well it's coming up on a year, right?

Well it's like 10 months. This whole ongoing situation with Bcash and what they were supposed to be all about is not is not happening. Well and it just not even close to happen. Yeah, and it just goes to show that there's not enough demand for cheap daily use on the Bitcoin blockchain.

Not yet. Not yet. And maybe there will be someday, but we haven't gotten to that point yet. And yes, I do understand that there were business models that were disrupted because they were based on cheap transaction fees for Bitcoin. I get that. But those business the people who created those business models knew that at some point there could be a fee market developed.

That that idea was not unheard of or undiscussed back in in the early days of Bitcoin. And so I would argue that they should have you know anticipated that this might happen, and they probably did, and they were probably arguing for block increases a long time ago. But their business models just weren't allowing them to be patient enough for the Lightning Network solution, which it just makes so much more sense at as a solution for payments.

One-to-one piece of the case. Well, it's looking like it, and it continues to get billed out and lightning continues to progress very well. Yeah. So let's talk a little bit about an interesting development in Lightning as as a say as you've segued us nicely into it. So have you seen Satoshi's place? I know you've been traveling, but Satoshi's dot place.

I know enough about it to be dangerous, but you probably be do a better job explaining it at this point. So I think that's actually what to use an old school term neat. It is pretty neat. It's it's neat. So this has been done before. That's not very woke saying, you know, neat, right?

Neat is broke, right? Not woke. You know, we gotta embrace our H. At least I know about no at least I know about woke and broke. You're pretty hip with the lingo there, Tommy. It's Twitter will help you out with that on that front. So this has definitely been done on the web before. There was, I remember it was initially done I don't know, it was probably 15 years ago at this point.

Somebody sold one million pixels for one dollar a pixel and made a million dollars. Yeah, it was some kid, right? Some kid, right? Yeah, who was who was actually pretty pretty intelligent about that. You think about it. So this is following along, following that lead from internet history, and there is a site on the web where there are a million pixels for sale, but each pixel is one Satoshi as opposed to one dollar.

So and each time you overwrite a pixel you can oh on on satoshis.place, it costs another Satoshi. So I can hook up my lightning wallet to Satoshi's. I can paint on this canvas, or I can use a program or an app.

So have you started if you have you painted anything yet? I have. I but I did it in the first couple of days where I was just I was just using these painting tools and did you put a citizen bitcoin up there? No, I haven't put anything about citizen bitcoin up there, but I gotta figure out how people are pasting these these nice images now. They're programmatically drawing on the on the screen.

I haven't I haven't done it, I haven't figured that one out yet. Yeah, there's yeah, there's different stuff on here. There isn't any World Cup soccer stuff on there. I'd figure somebody would do that and there's it's all crypto focused nobody's put a Tesla up there on fire or anything so I think there's just a kind of a couple of comments about Satoshi dot place a couple of observations and why it's important this is a test it's kind of a silly sort of silly test but it's that's how well I wouldn't just call it element it's elementary a basic right yeah yeah it's more in a scheme of things you use an grade analogy

It's like a second grade thing first or second grade type of thing right but so is crypto kitties right crypto kitties was kind of silly and kind of elementary oh my god right crypto but let's compare the two is anybody still breeding those things like you know the idea was you breed you breed the you breed the kiddies and then like some of them sold for like a lot of money there are there are still some people that are in there but those are the kitty bag holders that are left I think it's but it was going pretty well when I was snowboarding in the in the winter time my my snowboard instructor was into those and he actually was doing pretty well which I tried to tell him to kind of to back off but you know how that goes.

Yeah well in any case it it was launched as you know sort of a test of the Ethereum network a game on the Ethereum network and it very quickly as it gained usage it ramped up to 4000 daily users right 4000 which is nothing like that's a blip right it's 4000 sounds like a decent amount I don't know it sounds like a decent amount too as far as as far as internet you know based apps go.

Yeah, that's 40,000 is tiny. Yeah, like the idea that that's yeah, that's and it and if Ethereum wants to be the world computer underwhelming. Yeah, if Ethereum wants to be a world computer and run all these dApps, you know, they're gonna have to be able to sustain more than one 40,000 user app, right? Yeah, because it crashed it or something, didn't it?

It crashed it, right? Yeah, and so that's the other issue with Ethereum, too. I mean, we've already kind of talked about it. And Ethereum, it wasn't there was no Raiden network yet. At that point. What's that mean, Ray? It's sort of the equivalent of the Lightning Network, it's payment kind of payment channels and off-chain scaling stuff and sharding and all that stuff.

So there's there's proposed. So we just so people sharding is just another technique to try to improve improve Ethereum. We can just leave it at that for now. Yeah, it's a way to just so people know what he means by the scheme to scale Ethereum. So anyway, yeah, those those scaling solutions, level two solutions weren't there yet.

CryptoKitties wasn't using a level two solutions, but this is a good comparison to why you need to scale on on a level two solution and not on chain. Even Ethereum, which has natively on chain can do more transactions per second than Bitcoin's main chain. CryptoKitties overwhelmed it very quickly.

But on Lightning Network, these transactions that have taken place on Satoshi's dot place now are not having any visible effect on the main chain. Yeah. And they're happening instantly and securely on the Lightning Network. And this is why the Lightning Network is the solution for scaling.

It allows us to go from you know a few transactions per second on Bitcoin on the main chain or whatever the number is, six or something, to millions of transactions per second. Exactly. And that's where we need to be. That's the kind of scale we need to get to. And the thing is and the idea the idea would be with with Lightning Network, and we've talked about this before, but just the network effect.

So in terms of the S curve, Lightning is right at the it's at the very beginning of it. So the idea is that it's gonna continue to grow exponentially, or at least user TK41P just painted four 749 pixels. And we're looking just just now as we were talking here.

Oh, we did want to mention quickly before we move on, right? About Ethereum. Yep. And Ethereum being declared that it's not a security, right? And we covered we covered that in episode nine, and right and at that point, we I think the takeaway with us is is that there was one part and it was primarily me that was basically saying how it was laid out, it was centralized and the way it was a pre-mine and the way it was all and it was I think it was a ICO that it was likely a security.

And then Brady made a really good point from the standpoint of how the how the Ethereum's been built out since then, so it's decentralized enough that it may not be deemed a security. So our view as and jump in here, Brady, if I our view on Ethereum was that that we took the position in the middle, we kind of said we weren't gonna take a position one way or the other, because you could argue both sides, and I think we were kind of leaning towards it may it may not be deemed a security.

At least Brady convinced me to come off my point of oh yeah, it's just to be clear, I think it should be a deemed a security, but looking at the reality of the situation and what was going on, it it seemed likely that it may be declared not a security.

Yeah, we're both on the SEC might be. And I think the other the other part of this, the reason we're bringing this up is just to tie into also the original way we started with citizen Bitcoin is that we're just trying to learn and improve, prove how we look at this and provide information and education to our listeners and to the people inv involved with us on this.

So why do you think that they ended up saying that Ethereum is probably not a security? I think that there was tremendous lobbying from Silicon Valley and others that were able to get to the right people to explain their position. And I think that's the that's the main reason. Yeah, that's it. That's what I said. It was an intense lobbying effort.

And the bottom line is because of the decision made by most in Silicon Valley to just jump on Ethereum as the way to go. And I and this is just my opinion, might be your opinion as well, Brady. But the idea is when you looked at Bitcoin, there wasn't as many ways to do, I just use the term do deals and figure out ways to set things up to provide an investment or investment thesis for people and be able to jump in as a as a as a partner or or a person providing a certain deal, so to speak, or or app to

Be able it's it was easier to do deals and make money using Ethereum as your base rather than Bitcoin. Bitcoin's more difficult with doing that. Yeah, I mean, side the side side chain technology wasn't really available in the past few years. And Bitcoin, you know, the community wasn't ready for that to start happening yet, which was wise.

And I think I think it made sense. So yeah, friends in high places help. I think it probably should have been declared a security. I think it's okay that it didn't, it's not declared a security. Let's let's see what happens. I think it's okay the SEC has decided to let Ethereum breathe a little bit. Things built on top of Ethereum are securities, right?

Right, right. So they're not sufficiently. So the bottom line is if you really look, I think our view on it is that it at the end of the day whether it's probably a benefit to crypto assets that it got set that way. All right, let's let's take a quick look at at Bitcoin. The price. The price is hanging in there.

We're at 6700 now. We just bounced off of the bottom zone, and looks like we might be forming what's what chartist technical anal analysts call a triple bottom. We have this zone that's sort of made from this, you know, about 5800 range to about 6500 range.

And that bar, that zone, has been touched now three times from between February 6th and the first the first entrance, and then again in in early April, and then again this past couple of weeks. Yeah we've had yes right, and then the other part of it is is if you know if you're a technical charts guy, okay, which I'm I'm really not.

I mean, I think it's a tool, okay, and it's it works sometimes, but I mean it makes a lot of but I mean from a technical standpoint, right? If I if I understand correctly, hitting a triple bottom like that and maintaining it, in other words, hitting the bottom and coming back out is is considered to be very positive. The other thing that I'd also like to mention is recall either recall or could be new information for our listeners.

When Bitcoin was was going through that big run-up about a year ago, the idea of getting to about I think it's 5850 or 50500 5900 was a very very important number because that's when the overall bitcoin universe hit 100 billion in in overall cap market cap or size and the reason that was important is because institutional investors weren't allowed or or available below 100 billion so what does that mean well that really helped right but what it also means on this bottom it

Could be a situation where their support we don't know exactly where that would be coming from but the idea is if this would if this bitcoin would go through on the downside that 5800 and let's say for example it went to 3500 just to be kind of critical yeah the market cap would be somewhere in the range of 60 billion at that point at that point you have additional pressure once it go be because all of a sudden the institutional folks over would would this would be noted and they'd probably have to sell their positions over a certain period of time just as an anecdote so might be looking at a triple bottom which can't which more oftentimes than not is a bullish signal

And maybe there's something to that floor of 5800 the 100 billion dollar market cap because institutions are trying to keep it above there so they can maintain their investment in Bitcoin so that's all good but we don't know but I mean it's something that Brady brought up to me and I think it's I think it's a really really good point and from look looking at this chart it does seem like there's at least a floor baked in here from the standpoint of let's say around 6,000, it looks like a floor's been been set in here.

But we don't know, okay. It's just it seems to make logical sense. We'll see what happens. And you know, these these down times where Bitcoin's not getting so much attention is good for development. And it lays the foundation for the next run and the next set of users to come into the system.

So this is all productive time. Yeah, and it all it also washes out people that don't understand the technical aspect of it and don't understand how powerful it is and how important it is from that standpoint because that's just good from our perspective. So if you if you believe in this technology and its potential, you just hodl on and maybe even add and use this time to learn.

Yeah, hodl and add. Yeah, and maybe add on if you can. And if you can. And use this time to learn, use this time to teach, use this time to build. And I think we'll we'll stop there for the time. Do you have a particular World Cup team that you want to watch? Oh yeah, the World Cup's been a lot of fun. Pick somebody.

I'm pulling for Sweden as a sentimental favorite. That's where my family's from. They won their first round, first match, so that's that was awesome. I also am enjoying watching Iceland, and then kind of realistically speaking, for the top teams, I would love to see a Ronaldo Messi final, so Argentina Portugal final, which is possible. I think that'd be really fun.

Just you know, they're they're sort of aging out and they're kind of coming to the on the downs the downslope of their careers, it would be fun to watch the two. That would be good. I actually I didn't think yeah, I'm I'm I've got a Sweden angle too. I didn't think about that because I'm I'm half sweet. I'm not full, you're full, right? I'm half I'm I'm half Sweden. You're pretty much. Close to it.

Yeah, and so that that doesn't, but I think overall I'm I'm I'm with Spain. So I'm going with Spain. All right. Well, enjoy the sports ball. And if you if you're into that sort of thing, take care everyone, and we'll see you on the feed in a week or two. Thanks everybody.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Tommy and Brady discuss the EOS mainnet failure and it’s basically centralized structure; we share research that shows that 10 times more BCH coins are hodled than spent, whereas the ratio of hodled bitcoin versus spending bitcoin is 1:1; and we take a look at Satoshis.Place and why it is, yes, silly, but also important.

Links from the show below.

Fascinated by bitcoin? Confused? Overwhelmed? We feel you. Follow us for useful breakdowns of news, the social & economic implications of bitcoin and breakdowns about how the system works. We are dedicated to being sovereign citizens of bitcoin and we’re sharing our journey learning bitcoin hoping it makes yours a bit easier.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter: https://twitter.com/citizenbitcoin

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast: https://citizenbitcoin.simplecast.fm/

Citizen Bitcoin on Medium: https://medium.com/@citizenbitcoin

Links from the show:

EOS mainnet failure: https://www.ccn.com/eos-blockchain-grinds-to-halt-as-software-bug-freezes-transactions/

Chainalysis research about ratio of BCH tokens held as a store of value, versus a medium of exchange compared to the BTC ratio: https://twitter.com/BitMEXResearch/status/1004995365202886656 https://blog.chainalysis.com/reports/money-supply

Ethereum is declared not a security, helps to have friends in high places: https://twitter.com/AnselLindner/status/1004435205988503552

Satoshi’s Place: https://satoshis.place/

Downloads