All episodes
Episode 59

Conner Brown: Economics, Government, Religion, Gaming, Scammers and Debating Bitcoin

November 21, 2019102 min

Conner Brown joins Brady to discuss evangelizing bitcoin, economics, deflation and intrinsic value, we chat about video games and the potential for the combo of lightning and video gaming, - we talk about scammers and shitcoins - and since Conner was a Policy Debater like myself - we finish up with Conner taking the for and against on some contentious bitcoin topics - which was particularly awesome so be sure to hang around for it.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. And how's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Hope you all are well today. Thanks for joining me again here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. We've got a great episode for you today with Conner Brown.

This is the third installment of a trilogy of recent Conner Brown episodes. Connor talked with Pomp a couple of weeks ago, with John Vallis last week, and this week here on the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. This one pairs well with those other two episodes. We definitely cover some new ground.

So I'm excited to share it with you. But before we dive in, a word about the sponsor of this episode. Give Bitcoin is creating a clever new way to turn your pre-coiner friends and family into well-educated hodlers. You can give them time-locked Bitcoin. It's time-locked for at least one year, and your hodler to be friends or family will receive month by month for that first year a world-class Bitcoin education.

Again, this week, just like it went down with my dad a couple of weeks ago, just yesterday, I was hanging out with my brother-in-law, playing some darts at a local bar. Bitcoin came up, and immediately I was like, you gotta check this out. I gifted him some Bitcoin with GiveBitcoin, and he you know really quickly got excited about the idea of having holding some Bitcoin, the idea that it's time-locked for a year, and the idea that he's going to be getting this world-class Bitcoin education over the next you know year or so.

And it just sort of made it easier for him, lifted that something that made it scary or intimidating for him to get into Bitcoin, which you know I think we can all understand. But somehow Give Bitcoin made him feel comfortable with just taking that, you know, initial tip over the edge into the rabbit hole. So I'll be excited to kind of follow along with his progress and watch him become a bitcoiner over the next year or so.

Yeah, it's it's pretty cool. Give Bitcoin, it works. I've seen it twice now in my daily life. The equation, the Bitcoiner, the sorry, the pre-coiner to Bitcoiner equation that they always use, give plus time lock plus educate equals Bitcoiner, seems to be working very well. In fact, today, GiveBitcoin launched officially at GiveBitcoin.io.

The beta period is over. The official site is launched at give bitcoin.io. So check it out right now. Start minting some new hodlers in your life this holiday season. All right, let's go.

Conner Brown is a law student at Stanford, and he's a relatively new Bitcoiner.

He's from the bear market class of 2018. He's been around for about a year and a half now, but he's another example of a Bitcoiner who rapidly came up to speed and began to contribute to the scene. He's a great writer, he's a great conversationalist. And in this one, we talk about evangelizing Bitcoin. We talk about economics, the ideas of deflation and intrinsic value that he's written about.

We chat about video games and the potential for the combination of lightning and video gaming. We talk about scammers and shit coins, and since Connor was a policy debater like myself back in high school and college, we finish up with Connor taking the for and against position on some contentious Bitcoin topics, which was particularly awesome.

Really a lot of fun. So I think you're gonna enjoy it. Be sure to hang around for that at the end of this episode. All right. With that, it is time to dive in. Here we go.

All right, I'm really excited to welcome Conner Brown to the Citizen Bitcoin podcast. What's going on, Connor? Hey man, thank you so much for having me. Yeah, absolutely. I'm excited about this conversation. Really enjoy your writing and the other pods you've done. You just yeah, the one with Marty Bent I listened to in preparation for this podcast, and I'll link to it in the show notes, but that was just a fantastic episode.

One of the one of my favorite TFTC episodes, I think. Yeah, no, Marty and I, yeah, we get along really well, and it was it was just good to get cosmic on that one. But yeah. Way cosmic. Yeah, it was great. All right. Well, I had a topic to start with, but we were having a bit of a conversation before we started recording, and I was like, hey, we should be recording this.

So we were talking about how this past bear market, you know, bear markets are for building and bull markets are for buying, you know, whatever. They're just trying to triage mode, trying to keep up with all the new demand. But this bear market, we've really built out this kind of inf education infrastructure and you know, kind of honed all of the all of the memes and ideas about how to communicate Bitcoin to different demographics.

Whereas like the previous bear market was really focused on like technical infrastructure, exchanges, etc. Yeah so like what are your thoughts on on where like are we ready for this next bull run? Well it's funny because I'm really probably one of the first like beta testers if you will of this new educational infrastructure because I came in gosh like a year ago or so or about a year and three months something like that year and a half and so I came in after the 2017 run up and it was like you know just flatlining at 6,000 when I first started learning about it.

And at that point like this educational stuff started to come online. We had the noted podcast putting out some really great stuff, Stephan Livera's podcasts heating up all these other podcasts started you know either you know reconciling differing opinions and kind of settling on Bitcoin or you know new upstarts like like yours and a lot of other great fantastic podcasts and there's new podcasts every day it seems like but it's been such a wild ride and there's so much fantastic content that I feel like you know it it's hard to imagine but I could see myself looking back at the older content just getting stuck for like years and

You know there's a lot of things that were just unresolved in Bitcoin but I feel like now we've kind of got this really slick on ramp to understanding the important messages, the important trade-offs that Bitcoin makes to kind of you know ward off the snake oil salesman and you know that's that's also kind of unprecedented too.

Like if 2017 was able to get that crazy while so much of the wind was taken out of the Bitcoin sales because of you know all these shit coiners, what is it going to be like when that is a much much more concentrated message and force and you know you can't you're not going to be throwing money at all these tokens.

I mean it's a very different world. So yeah, to your point, this is why I think that some of the shit coin chicanery will be more muted this time around, right? We've got this education infrastructure and police, at least I hope so. You know, there's this scammery can just is so successful.

It's kind of amazing. Like we were we had both listened to this podcast from the BBC, The Missing Crypto Queen about this one coin scam. That was wild. Yeah, and I mean that that's just totally crazy insane. If you haven't listened to it, I definitely recommend it as as a Bitcoiner. It gives a perspective and like vindication, I think, to the like the reason why we as Bitcoiners are quote unquote so toxic to these shit coin scammers, because they do so much actual damage, right?

I mean, it's insane how many lives have been ruined and will continue to be ruined by this one coin thing that is you know kind of out there in the wild now, even though it's been exit scammed for like a year now, it's still going and like growing in in India and Africa, Russia, you know, parts of Europe.

It's still like reeling people in and you know, wrecking people's lives. It's crazy. Yeah, even after the exit scam, which is really the crazy part. Like, no matter what comes out about this project, I mean, even with this podcast coming out, they still are I mean, it's just information asymmetry.

If you can touch someone first and get them hooked, then it's it's really hard to get them to go the other way and start to open their eyes. But and I and I think that also is a great example of why Bitcoin is so hard for people to initially come into contact with or open their their mind up to it because it's so hard to kind of separate these sorts of you know, just classic Ponzi schemes that everyone knows if it sounds too good to be true then it is.

And Bitcoin, when you're talking about it, at least you know, even in just like vague terms of what it does, what it hopes to accomplish in the future, it can sound very, very similar to all these other schemes that people know. Oh, there's no time in even investigating that. It sounds too good to be true, so it has to be.

And that's another thing. And I think that creates a lot of apathy towards Bitcoin because people just default to assuming that it's another one of those schemes.

Yeah, it's true. And you know, Bitcoin was mentioned quite a few times in that podcast series. And it, you know, as with most of these scams, they are writing on the credibility of Bitcoin. They always say, you know, this is going to be the next Bitcoin. Bitcoin, no one will talk about Bitcoin in two years because one coin is going to take over the world, etc.

And basically every one of these shitcoin scams you know rides on the coattails of Bitcoin, and Bitcoin's doing the hard work of actually changing you know, money and becoming our new money and changing the world in the ways that sound money will. And you know, it's it's just ripe for these scammers to come and say, Yeah, Bitcoin's gonna do it better, you can get in now, it's early.

You know, look what look at all these early Bitcoin whales that have bajillion dollars now, you know. Yeah, and it goes to the ethos of the tech industry, and you know, even the smartest people here at Stanford I see following for this type of logic so many times because their entire concept of tech is you know, you don't want to be the Yahoo, you wanna be the Google, you wanna be the second, third, fourth iteration down the line.

And that's it it's really hard for them to take that understanding of tech and be like, wait a second, money is the complete opposite. You want it to be resilient, you want it to be trustworthy, you want it to be durable, and that's very different from your rapid iteration, break it, don't worry about it type mentality in Silicon Valley, and why so many people I think around here still don't understand Bitcoin despite they're supposed to be, you know, the people that are on top of this new ch technology.

Yeah, the move the move fast and break things, Silicon Valley ethos just does not work when you're building, you know, a new protocol for the transfer of wealth over the internet. So yeah. Yeah. Well you had a tweet, just kind of switch up a little bit. You had a tweet that went viral today. It said that the hardest part of being or sorry, the hardest part of Bitcoin is not sounding like an absolute lunatic when someone asks you about it.

And this is definitely true, and why I've stopped like initiating conversations with people about Bitcoin in real life, you know, I like I have the policy of like I'm only gonna talk if you, you know, ask me about it. But even then it's still hard not to sound like an absolute lunatic. So I mean, I'm ready I'm I'm ready to sit down and sound like a lunatic with you for the next hour or so.

Yeah, I worded that tweet very specifically because it was someone who had heard that I was interested in Bitcoin and they're like, Well, what is it? What does it do? And then like, you know, you kind of give the two sentence like, oh, it's a digital gold, you can teleport it anywhere, and you know, it it has better monetary properties and other objects.

And they're like, oh, interesting. And they start asking like more questions, like, well, how is that better than the dollar or something like that? Like, I can already transport it really quickly. Why does it matter if I'm an American? And then you're just like, shit. Like, like either I just I'm just like, it's it's a lot, or I you know, because you can't really give a five-second summary of how Keynesianism has completely changed the economic calculus of the United States and the world more broadly and you know, created this dead economy, without sounding like a lunatic, but also

If you go into a lot of depth when they don't when they aren't ready for it, then you also sound crazy. So like there's really no good way to go beyond a surface level, you know, if they ask a few follow-up questions without automatically just coming into really hardcore ideology and sort of trying to jump over the mental barriers that people just naturally have to Bitcoin.

And so yeah, it's it's rough. But but the people that are open-minded to it, they're really rare, but just always the most amazing people I've found that are able to just like follow you down the logical arguments you're making. Yeah, it does work out every once in a while, and it's just a beautiful thing when someone comes up and asks you about Bitcoin, be it a friend or an acquaintance or whatever, sometimes even strangers, and it kind of it comes up, and then you end up spending an hour or two hours kind of just going down the rabbit hole with that person, leading them along the way, and then leaving them with you know several resources

To just continue their education, and that's just kind of a magical moment. Oh, it it totally is. And you know, it's it's so funny because I can also simultaneously hear someone who isn't accustomed to Bitcoin listening to what we're just saying and being like, wow, these guys are really part of a cult.

And you know, the religious aspect of it is also, you know, your your podcast with Haas was fantastic on that. It's it's weird. It's weird, man. Yeah, it's really weird. It's really weird. And it's you know, like it that those two episodes, the one with Gigi and then and then Hass were really fun for me, and I think special episodes, they kind of had this thing going on in Riga, and both of them came out with these kind of you know, much more clear thinking on this religious aspects, you know, this this religion that's really being born.

You know, and Gigi wrote on Twitter that he's starting a religion with has, you know, like this is really what they see, you know. This is like, and it's been joked about for quite a while. You know, Pierre and Michael have joked about it on Noted many times, you know, about like we should start a Bitcoin religion, the church of Satoshi, and we can get like tax breaks on all of our earnings and you know, these things.

I'm for it. I'm totally for it. Yeah, yeah, totally. It's this this secular religion based on the truth of sound money, right? Yeah. Yeah. And it's, you know, going back to that that BBC podcast series, I mean, that one coin thing is basically a religion at this point, right?

The woman who the woman who was the central figurehead of the whole thing, her name was Ruja, Dr. Rouja something, and she would host these like massive rallies or events at like you know big event centers all over the world and she'd come out in these like elaborate ball gowns and jewelry and everything and just do the like the most banal speeches about how one coin was going to change the world etc and get everyone riled up and she then exit scammed with several other you know people who are kind of the MLM elite of the world the multi-level

Marketers the best in the world that they kind of got that people recruited to really blow this thing up and yeah she is is disappeared and it's almost like they're waiting like people who are still believe believe in this thing are just like waiting for the second coming of Rouja you know and they talk about her in these reverent ways and yeah it's it's a religion is definitely formed around that and so it's not surprising right that you know a religion can form around Bitcoin and the ideals of Bitcoin the difference is you know one is based on truth and the other one is more of a cult and the cult the kind of the difference

Between a cult and a religion in my mind is like a cult is based on falsehoods right it's it's really championing these these lies and falsehoods and a religion has something that's more true to it right I think like the real the non-secular religions of the past or in and the present really had like these these really like evident or distilled truths a more morals of human civilizations and societies and so they were based on these on these basic truths of course that you know they've been bastardized and you know by by scammers by religious scammers you know throughout history but

You know at the core there there were these kind of eternal truths of how you should treat other people and how you should live your life yeah and I think Bitcoin is you know true and then we have all these shit coin scammers that are just pedaling falsehoods you know and they're cults basically. Yeah I think you're definitely right there especially in the sense that the real religions you know I think that religions are very similar decentralized protocol that you know has went through many, many iterations.

I mean the reason Christianity is so powerful, I think part of it, and this is you know just kind of me riffing here. I don't have any sort of background in religious studies, but I mean the idea of something like sacrifice right being an important virtue and you can see how a concept of sacrifice or you know deferring consumption for future investment or something like that if if you want to look at it that way can be a very very important value for creating a civilization.

And the religions that have survived and you know have iterated time and time again and survived the sort of anti fragile nature are the ones that have the best messages for cultivating a civilization that that works together or can be more productive I think I think that's an interesting way of looking at it and you can see Bitcoin doing the same thing and having the strongest antifragile narratives and possibilities so that it can kind of continue its iteration process, while these other things are more, you know, very short-term oriented, and that's why they don't have the lasting

Staying power. You know, one coin's never going to have the they're they're very fragile systems from from the beginning because they're based on a lie, like you said, it's based on you know, convincing everyone the world's gonna end in a few years, and so you have that nice upfront Keynesian investment, if you will, for future gains or something like that.

That that's obviously not sustainable, but if you build it based on a few set of very important truths, then you can have that anti-fragile nature that carries on through the years. And the best religions are probably the ones that have distilled those different messages in the best. And I think that's why you see a lot of similarities in the core teachings of a bunch of different religions on how you should live your life, because those are the ones that help people flourish the most.

Yeah, so I mean, basically a religion really comes down to the strongest memes, right? It's it's at its core, at a the a religion is formed around memes, and then the strongest ones, the ones that will prevail and like you said, are anti-fragile are the ones that the memes that are based in truth. So yeah, I think in that sense, like when you're looking at the kind of loose, broad definition of a religion, yeah, Bitcoin fits that, and it makes sense that it's going to, you know, develop into this kind of global meme, i.e.

A religion, kind of inspire people to adopt it and build and work toward this kind of Bitcoin future that we're kind of the early adopters of at this point. Yeah, totally. And I think that Bitcoin specifically is more in line with something like Taoism or a way of living your life instead of, you know, I think that's in something like Christianity, you have both the arguments about the nature of reality, what is our universe, you know, is God real, things like that.

But then you also have just like the moral virtues or the method of living your life. And that's kind of two different things. I think Bitcoin is more a religion of just like how to live versus what the meaning of everything is. And that can be filled in with whatever your preference, but the secular portion, the way you just interact with the world is just so crazy.

And I think I've seen so many Bitcoiners, and I've definitely changed my own life after learning about Bitcoin. Yeah, because of it's it does have these extremely strong memes that just reorient you to the world. Yeah, and it comes down to just really one simple truth, you know, the truth of hard money, the way money is you know supposed to function in a society, as we had discovered it thousands of years ago to you know solve the problems of barter, the coincidence of once.

And it's it's really a simple thing. It's a really simple thing, but it's a very powerful discovery, really. And now we've, you know, and speaking of speaking of cults based on lies, you know, that I call these people Keynesian cultists, and you know, they've they've been spreading falsehoods of central banking and quantitative easing and negative interest rates, monetary central planning and all that stuff.

They've created generations of default Keynesians. It's just like people walk walk around and it's just the way things are now, and they people just accept it and they default to this kind of idea. But you know, now we have Bitcoin, Bitcoin's waking people up and teaching them what mone what money really is. And I think having that real world example is critical to really, you know, like I said, waking people up.

You can kind of talk about this stuff until you're blue in the face, but you know, the Austrian, Austrian economists and some of the libertarians have tried that, you know, to no avail for decades and decades now. So I think we have this, you know, this real world instantiation of hard money is going to make a big difference in in waking people up.

So how how did you how did you wake up to all this stuff? Like, were you a default Keynesian before? Did Bitcoin wake you up? Or had you been studying money before? I feel like I don't even know if I was I think that the default Keynesianism thing, I've I've heard you talk about the that before, and the more I think about it, the more just painfully true it seems.

I feel like where I was before Bitcoin was kind of in between worlds in the sense that I felt that something was off, and I think a lot of people feel that something is wrong. That I think that people realize there's something that is not right and they can't really put their finger on it.

You know, if if this was the a the average view in probably the 60s or you know, right when we started this like massive central planning experiment in economics and infrastructure was probably like, oh, this is great, we can control our destiny. I think that over the next 50 years it's kind of morphed into this weird feeling of something being off, but not being able to articulate exactly what it is.

And we see that kind of bleeding into our politics, into our quality of life, into feeling that people are very upset but not knowing why. And I feel like that's kind of where I was in this like post-Kynesian sort of malaise where I'm just not even really caring about the broader society at that point, and I was really just considering you know, how do I succeed in my own personal life?

And yeah, the society stuff, you know, it's it's weird, it'll work itself out, I guess, but I'm just gonna like worry about my career. And Bitcoin then sort of shifted that so that I started thinking about all these much bigger ideas. And I think the central turning point for me was understanding that Bitcoin is built on, and going back to you know, the religious concepts, if you will, or these important values, it's built on the concept of humility, the idea that we don't know what the future entails, we can't predict it.

And anyone who says they know what's best for the economy or for you know, and this is like at all scales of society, even you know, between the Federal Reserve or you know, the local planning commission that says we need a massive infrastructure investment for the next 20 years to continue growth or something like that, rejecting that sort of central planning, we can predict the future approach, and saying, look, we should just instead be humble, we should recognize that we can't predict the future, and that if we try to spend way more than we have access to by

You know going into a lot of debt or printing money, that it ultimately has these sorts of bad outcomes because we're not perfect and we can't really know how these things are gonna play out. So that that really just completely opened up my mind to thinking, okay, there is actually a way out of this, and it's just a return to humility, it's a return to rejection of anyone who's claiming to prophesy as the future.

Yeah, it's it's absolute arrogance. You're right. I mean, it's a return to humility and the Keynesian conceit that you know they can manage money better than this very simple, the very simple truth of what money actually is, is is an absolute arrogance. They

Talk about so you wrote an article recently, just dropped like a couple weeks ago, about about deflation. Like, stop calling Bitcoin deflationary was the title, right? And this idea of deflation is used by Keynesians to attack the idea of using a sound money, right?

You'll you they use this phrase deflationary spiral. And the you know, the idea that like spending an investment will sort of grind to a halt because it's you know, the incentives are to hoard the money, and if it's you know strictly limited, then it just the liquidity dries up and you end up in this like mega depression or whatever.

And I have come like this there, I think there's no argument Keynesian argument that drives me more nuts than this one because it's so seems so on face absurd to me. Even when I was kind of kind of early in my understanding of Austrian economics and stuff. Because all you had to know about is the like the idea of time preference, right?

Like we all have a time preference. We're all gonna spend money on on something at some point in time, right? What the difference is we get to have this sort of like longer term thinking and longer like able to save money to invest at the right time in something that will have a better chance at being sustainable and success successful over time.

So yeah, let's let's go like talk through your article because I think it very thoroughly debunks this idea and you know takes it, takes understanding beyond that even where yeah, where do you want to dive in on the phone? I think the best place to start is just with the definition of deflation. And that's something that is sort of a rhetorical shift that I think the Keynesian or the mainstream, however you want to frame it, the idea of deflation being a change in prices rather than a change in the monetary base.

I think that's a very sneaky trick because you know, when prices are increasing or decreasing, if they're if you're using the traditional mainstream definition of it, you would say that the prices are inflating or that they're deflating. But that that's really difficult because prices can increase either because of an increase in the monetary base or because of an increase in productivity, right?

It's or or sorry, decre like the prices can change, not necessarily increase, but increase or decrease based on changes in productivity or changes of the monetary base. And because the default view is now that inflation or deflation or changes in prices are purely going to be referred to as inflation or deflation, you're kind of missing that nuance there that prices in general should be falling in an economy because we're naturally become more productive, and that we have this other effect of changing the monetary base that can kind of alter

The dynamics of prices, and you know, because our money is sort of this language we use to speak prices. And so I think that the important thing at the beginning of the article is just saying, look, we should define deflation as a contraction in the money supply so we can really separate out these causes for what's happening.

Yeah, that makes perfect sense. And I think s another concept that's like super simple that well, let me let you seem super simple on face, but it's actually very complex when you dive into it, is just the idea of prices. Like what are prices, you know? It's similar to just money itself, and they're definitely related to each other.

But yeah, so what like what is the importance of price? How does it why is it important to the way our an economy and society functions? Totally. So a price is just the way that a market comes to discover the value of an object. And you know, a price naturally is you would expect it to change as the cost of producing an object change as well.

And in a competitive market, you would see that the prices for something would fall because every year, you know, humans become better and better at producing things and developing products and trying to satisfy consumers while competing against their competitors.

And price is the way we sort of communicate that change in productivity, or we can kind of see that mapped out onto the real world. And when you have a distortion in your money in the way that you're communicating those prices, then it can really cause confusion as to what's actually happening.

Is the product becoming more difficult to produce? Or is it a change in your monetary base and you know, the sort of distortions that come from that? So prices are are very important. And I think that the fact that we do see inflation every year is something that leads to a lot of this confusion or unrest or feeling that something is wrong, because it seems counterintuitive that the thing that I've always purchased is suddenly increasing in price, and I'm having to pay more for something, and it goes against the narrative of humans progress and get better every year.

And if we do have inflation, then people begin to attribute it to the natural closest thing to the price, which is the company that's creating the product or something like that. I think that's where a lot of anti-corporate sentiment comes from. Anti-capitalism sentiment comes from.

The prices are increasing, and the only person who's increasing it is this company, therefore, companies are evil and trying to abuse me, extort me, extract my my hard-earned work or something like that, and it's unfair. So you get a lot of really simple understandings of economics because that's just the closest thing you can point a finger at, and politicians love to exploit that.

Yeah. And it's, I mean, that's basically the way that Keynesianism then sort of affects prices. It distorts them because the monetary base is being so grossly distorted that it has these downstream effects of affecting price. It's also very importantly had the downstream effect of basically separating wages from productivity, which were rising in lockstep together until we went off the gold standard in in the early 70s, and basically wages flatline and productivity continues to rise at the same rate.

So they're kind of it's kind of still kind of stealing on both ends, you know. You know, you the prices of goods are going up because the amount of money in circulation is going up, and then you know, but at the same time your wages are s are stagnant while your productivity is going up, so kind of stealing on both ends, and it's just terrible for everyone else except for the people at the top, you know.

Yeah, totally. And I think that that was a big portion, and then we also had other sort of pseudo-Kynzian or like second-order Keynesian policies around that time, and you know, starting in the 70s. And since then, you know, we started massively subsidizing higher education. We started saying everyone needs to go into debt, you know, you gotta spend some money before you can earn it, sort of mentality, and rejected you can't just start with nothing.

You have to start from negative balances by getting an expensive liberal arts degree. And you know, I think that's further harmed wages and harmed productivity because we have all these other mentalities of we need massive expenditure up front for big growth in the back end.

And you know, I think there's there's a good analogy I recently heard about this mentality of like imagine you're planning two different types of parties. The first type of party is the one where everyone brings their own beverage, and that party, the more people that show up, then the better the party gets, right?

The more people, it's more fun, it gets crazier, and you have a better time. But if you spend all the money up front and say, look, we'll provide an open bar or something like that, then the more people that show up to the party, the worse the party gets. Because you're you're putting all your expenditure up front, and you're hoping that down the line the more people will somehow make it better.

But you know, you know that because there's limited resources, that that's actually going to detract as more people start to use this thing that you've put in up front. And so this sort of shift to upfront thinking, be it student loans, infrastructure spending, all of these sorts of different pseudo-Kynesian policies magnify this this effect of moving from a sound currency as well.

Yeah, so it just creates all these little monetary premium bubbles, you know, all over all over the place. Real estate, art, education, healthcare, and those are all products and services that are sort of human intensive, right?

Products like like televisions and computers, etc. Have continued to like deflate in price and increase in performance, etc. In spite of all of this, right? So it's its efficiency in production and productivity has like outpaced this, you know, other this opposite the opposing effect so much.

But when you look at the industries where productivity doesn't really increase so quickly, and it's not exponential like it is with you know computing technologies, you get in these massive bubbles these increase over time, and you know, food supplies is the same way. Yeah, so all of this stuff has been going up in price over time, and while all of our wage wages are stagnant, and we've all had increasing debt burdens, right?

At the same time. So what about the idea that like the argument that growth will stagnate because there'll be a de you know decreased investment and spending due to hoarding Bitcoin? Yeah, so this is this is really the big one that people love to throw around and fearmonger is you know, people are just going to hoard other Bitcoins, no one is they're just all gonna, you know, Scrooge McDuck style, just take their nice swimming pool full of gold and just swim in it instead of you know spreading the wealth around or something like that.

Obviously, I think the first flaw of this thinking is the idea that Bitcoin's just gonna go up forever. It will go up until its price has been discovered and reaches equilibrium with other goods in the market. And at that point, then the people who are holding Bitcoin are going to want returns naturally. They're not just gonna want to get zero if they can invest in something that is productive and increase the returns.

So I think it's a question of timing, first of all. You it doesn't make sense to and you know, I wouldn't want to, you know, lend out my Bitcoin or invest it right now because just the idea of holding it is important in the price discovery phase. But once that's over, it seems very natural to, you know, invest it and seek those returns.

And I think the second thing on that is that there's no reason to think that spending would go down because people are still going to have needs. And you know, s saving is deferred consumption, but eventually you have needs and you have wants and you're going to consume at some point.

And especially once Bitcoin is stabilizing, then you're not gonna have that extremely strong gravitational pull that we're at right now to just save and stack sats as much as possible. But it'll sort of meet more a nudge towards saving versus like right now where it's like hard to justify spending anything compared to saving Bitcoin.

So I think that'll become more gradual. And you know, even looking at the Federal Reserve, when when they said, you know, they they did research on this and they said there was zero link between prices going down or deflation in the mainstream sense and a decrease in growth.

And I think that's completely intuitive. When people are seeing prices go down, that doesn't mean they buy less. If anything, they buy more because oh now it's affordable. Now the laptop I really wanted is is half the price, or the better TV is half the price, or something like that, and I can, you know, justify buying that or something like that.

Just because prices are going down doesn't mean people are going to infinitely defer consumption. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, it's the basic idea of time preference, you know, and the example that I use a lot is you know, it it's because it's sort of like a it's it's in like a smaller chunk, it's like a decade, right?

All of our time is limited. And so over the course of a lifetime, you're making choices again based on that, but it's sort of a large span, at least relative to the to our kind of experience of the of the world. But right now, like I have young kids, right? And so I am I have a time preference that's associated with you know the fact that these they're only gonna be kids for like a decade basically, and then they're sort of off on their own and doing their own thing with their friends and leading their own lives and making their own way.

So right now, like I have this window that I want to make sure we have a lot of you know experiences, formative experiences for for all of us, right? And so we're gonna be a lot more likely to spend on family vacations and stuff like that, you know. A lot more likely to go buy like trampolines so we can all have a bunch of fun jumping in the backyard, stuff like that, you know.

There's spending that's there's spending that's you know motivated by many, many things, and our time horizons shift you know throughout our lives, and so yeah, it it just makes sense. Like and that again, that one to me was as soon as I started learning Austrian economics, you know, spurred on by Bitcoin to do that, made perfect sense.

Like I read, I had somebody actually here in my co-working space. I started talking about Austrian economics and sound money, gold standard, etc. And you know, this this guy was very, very smart guy, you know, successful startup founder multiple times. But yeah, he just was parroting back all of these Keynesian ideas about how the you know how the Great Depression was, you know, actually the fault of gold and hoarding and all that stuff, right?

These are these ideas are all out there and prevalent to people who are well studied because it's just been the line that you know I think it's important to know too that like you know, education and academics have really helped perpetuate this misinformation, these falsehoods about about money, right?

They there's very few Austrian economists in that are you know sitting at you know nice positions with professorships at at major universities around the world. There are you know, it's probably I you know I'm not an expert, but I'm like from the way it appears and the people I've talked to, it sounds like it's sort of like nine to one or maybe even like worse than that, you know.

Yeah. Yeah, I think the reason for that is also it it's it's a question of incentives too, and it's totally understandable that this has happened, and it's it's not because these people are are evil or that they have this conspiracy to rob the world.

It's just you know the incentives line up. If if you have two different academics and one of them is saying I can predict the future, and the other one's saying, you know, it's really a lot more complicated than that, then you know, one of them sounds a lot sexier. And especially you can understand how this would rise to prominence in the academic community of you know, we're seeing these in in the fifties, sixties, seventies, these massive benefits in our hard sciences and how they're just changing our landscape and making these serious gains.

And now these other people want to come up with an economics that is mathematical, that is based on predictions and projections and that we can sort of apply these complex models and treat the world as if it is a bunch of discrete knowable variables that we can plug into nice mathematical equations and predict the future.

And man, that is so sexy. But you know, there's a reason these people are not making money off the markets and are having their salaries subsidized by students, and it's because that they can't actually predict the markets and they're having to pay for their lunch with tuition.

So I think that we can just see the way their actions aren't lining up with their words, but you can also see why their words are being taken in the way they are. And this is also true for for politicians as well. Politicians, if if you have two politicians and you have the local mayor who's saying, you know, we've gotta re-invest in our town, we have to build, build, build, we have to put up a massive new infrastructure plan.

We have to have a big, bold vision of the future, that's going to play over so much better with your local population than the mayor who says, you know, it's really hard to know what the future needs, and we should do small projects, and we should just make sure that we're building sustainably and that we can have a tax base that supports the infrastructure we're doing, and we can build new infrastructure if you know we see new people in in the right area and we think it's sustainable.

You know, one of those is much sexier. You know, you want the big bold vision. It appeals to the American ethos, it appeals to the average person, and that's why th this is these two different groups, the Keynesian academics and the Keynesian politicians are such a powerful force in society, especially in academia and politics, because those are the two places where consequences don't matter.

If an engineer builds a bridge wrong because of their hubris, then people die and the engineer's career is ruined. If an economist espouses things that don't matter, or if if a economist espouses things that are wrong or are you know leading to these terrible consequences, then you know, they're tenured, they can just, you know, come up with some other explanation for why their model was slightly off and things didn't go according to plan.

And the same with politicians. Politicians have no accountability to actually seeing that their plans are going to benefit the economy in 10 or 20 years. They just care about getting re-elected to the next term. What is the best possible way to get a short-term pop so they can get the good turnout in the next election cycle?

And it's a very broken system of incentives for economics especially. And it's it's really frustrating, but I think that at some level it is extremely fragile as well. And we're starting this long journey of sort of unraveling this thread and realizing that the system of incentives has given us has promised us the world and given us very, very little.

Yeah. Have you thought much about how this transition from this kind of fiat age to a Bitcoin age will play out? Do you think it's going to be really rocky and difficult and rough for a lot of people? Or do you think we're going to have this kind of a smooth landing in phase into a Bitcoin world?

Man, I would love a smooth landing. But the realist in me, I just feel like we're due for a serious correction in a lot of the ways that we've we've built our country and that many countries are built. And that's not going to be an easy switch.

And I think we're starting to see the beginning of that in small towns across the nations right now, especially across middle America, is is sort of this like long emergency. You know, it's it's not a sudden crisis, but you know, all of these poor investment decisions we've made, all of these towns that have gone bankrupt because they thought that they just needed one more big infrastructure project to really solve the problems of their town, you know.

Now 30, 40 years later, we're starting to see, okay, when you do that, you're setting yourself up for financial disaster. I think we're seeing the same thing now at a macro scale as well. And the results of that is the sort of long drawn-out stagnation.

And, you know, for a lot of places, this is where the opioid epidemic is hitting the hardest of a lot of just people being stuck in these in these weird places and not really having opportunities. And it is just heart-wrenching. And also you're seeing, you know, the sort of rise of populism and wanting to point the finger at someone and be angry at someone.

And I think that that's only going to escalate in the in the short to medium term just because we have all these things we just have to work through, and it's not an easy process to get through them. And you know, we've spent money that we didn't have and on unproductive things, and there's no way to sort of write that ship without breaking promises.

And that's going to make people extremely upset and feeling like they've been left behind. I think that longer term than that, it does I hope go back towards new forms of communities that are based on being prudent, that are based on you know, being reasonable about your investments and only investing on in things that you can assure you get a return on in and both like a macroeconomic sense and a smaller town sense.

I think we see more of the traditional communities that are more closely knit versus like this large isolating sort of suburban sprawl that we're sort of seeing all of these things it it's it's hard to really predict obviously but I think that we can know that what we're seeing now is unsustainable and you know the sovereign individuals is such a fantastic book for predicting all these things 30 years in advance that are just now starting to come true.

And I think that book actually gives a really great look into how these sorts of things could play out in terms of you know how how society starts to reorient from a welfare system where the least productive people are able to be subsidized at the expense of the most productive and you know we have a shift towards governments being more as a customer based model where the people are only willing to pay taxes or join or or be under a nation if they feel like

It's actually beneficial to them. Right now we don't really have that and a lot of people are actually harmed by their relationship with the government. And so hopefully that's that's a longer time frame change. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah Michael Goldstein talked about this on on a podcast on one of my podcasts, you know, six or seven episodes ago at this point, about in a Bitcoin future, it will, you know, change the incentives of government, which are completely misaligned now, like you said, that there's a and a lack of accountability and a misalignment of interests and incentives

Between voters and politicians. And he was talking about this this future where there's going to be these many, many pockets, you know, nation-state model will sort of collapse, and there'll be these many pockets of political experimentation all over the world. And you can sort of shop around for the type of political environment that you want to be a part of and kind of go and move into that one, right?

And be a part of that that way of living in that political system. And those systems will compete against each other, and that competition will lead to, you know, models of how to govern society that are more successful in the long run than you know, the way that we try to change our government now through this political process that seems to be pretty broken.

Yeah, and that's super exciting. And I think that's you know, going back to the American ideals, I think that's much more in line with the ideals of American I guess the American revolution and just sort of American values generally, as competition is this thing that is a v is creates value.

And I think that because we have this sort of broken incentive system now, we see competition being a net negative to towns and cities because they're trying to because of this default Keynesian attitude, this idea that we need massive investment up front and will reap the benefits somehow later.

That you see like you know, two local towns trying to outbid each other on how much they can subsidize the new shopping mall that comes in, and they can agree that you know the Macy's that's gonna anchor the shopping mall is gonna pay zero taxes, and you know, the you sort of see and you know, the other one says, actually, we'll re-raise, we'll build you a you know, we'll spend 20 million dollars on creating the perfect roads and infrastructure for your shopping mall.

And you know, the point being that you have competition being a net negative now because of these incentives are misaligned. And then people you know, then the average person is looking at this and saying, well, my town's bankrupt now because they're competing against each other, competition must be a bad thing, and we just need complete top-down centralized control to prevent any sort of competition.

And that's that's obviously not the answer either, as many social experiments have socialist experiments have have shown. So I hope that we can get to a system like Goldstein's talking about, where competition between city-states or whatever kind of pops up, these smaller forms of government are net positives to the value of the customers or the taxpayers, if you will.

Yeah. That makes good sense to me. And it is an exciting you know, aspect of a Bitcoin future for us. I think it it you know will create society that's a lot more human. You know, we live in this sort of paradoxical time where we have a lot a major well, we have this technology that allows us to be more connected than ever, especially with friends and family and loved ones who are far away from us in terms of space and distance, but we are also much more disconnected in our local communities

Than we've ever been before, right? Because of that fact, you know, people that stay inside more and choose to get their connection through the internet and through entertainment, etc., then kind of being out and about in their communities and meeting each other face to face. And so we're sort of in this weird time where we're separated, kind of separate, but also like able to be super connected at the same time.

And it's really weird. And I think that you know, I know I'm talking a lot about infrastructure and urban development, but I've I've just been going down this rabbit hole. I'm taking a class on local government law here with an amazing professor, and also just learning as much as I can about it and realizing how deeply the Keynesian mindset has kind of like seeped into other like you know economic adjacent mentalities, and you know, looking at traditionally how cities and towns were built as this sort of iterative, organic natural process.

You know, one person puts up a little shack, another person puts up a shack across from it, another person puts up a shack down the street, you start sort of getting this gravity of people and towns, and people start being attracting more people, and you know, maybe you start to see people because they're now kind of gathering together, property values start to go up, they can sort of iterate and add on to their little shack and get a little front porch going or something like that.

The more people that are attracted leads to, you know, now we have enough to sort of get a bucket brigade going. We can start to kind of build out the infrastructure of our town in a way that is organic and sustainable and anti-fragile. Because if you know one person goes out of business or something like that, you know, someone else sees that as an opportunity in the town and sorts of re continues that sort of development process.

And that's how we've developed for thousands of years. And we've sort of, and we can see that in the way that it the structures develop. I know Tur Demester did a good thread on how cities kind of organically developed in in Europe, places like Milan and Paris, and they're incredibly walkable.

They're very, very dense. But there's also a sense of vibrancy and community and just being able to walk around freely. Whereas the Keynesian model, you know, post-World War II was sort of we all need cars now. We all need highways through the middle of our cities.

We need roads that are very wide and running everywhere throughout the city and you know making it much more dangerous to walk around, it feels like a more isolating environment just because we've sort of taken this top-down centralized approach to development and saying we just need you know to spend a lot of money and just completely build out our infrastructure and then like plug everything else in instead of this organic development model and towns feel a lot more cold and planned and schematic

Versus you know, what is an organic, natural way of living with other people. And I really would like love to see a shift back to that. And I and I think it's really inevitable because I think we're starting to see the fragility of when you centrally plan everything and it doesn't go according to plan, then your entire town fails instead of, oh, this one person, you know, put up a business, the business doesn't make any sense.

Well, we're gonna replace that with something else more valuable on Main Street or something like that. And that's why the cities in in Europe have survived for thousands of years through multiple different government changes and all these different things, whereas towns across America are failing or becoming bankrupt. I mean, Detroit's all obviously the hallmark, but it's it's a lot of smaller communities as well that are facing similar, just really serious crises, and there's really no way out for the citizens there.

Yeah. I saw you tweet about a game that's sort of an allegory of this of this problem, this of this kind of modern society, this paradox of modern society that we're discussing now. And it's it's called Death Stranding. It just came out last week, I think. And it sounds like you've been playing it. Oh man, I can't stop.

This is the first video game I've really it's so funny. I feel like after Bitcoin, I really just put like I used to play a lot of games, and like I said, I kind of shifted from just doing whatever I thought was fun or interesting in my for myself or my career, and started just learning non-stop. And now I just played Death Stranding a lot this past week and listen to podcasts about Bitcoin, but it's been crazy.

It's it's an incredible game. And I can kind of give the general concept. The idea is we're in a society where we've we've sort of had this like post-apocalyptic world. There's been this intrusion from another dimension, and a lot of America is now just a bunch of disparate preppers, basically, that have just like retreated into their homes, have kind of holed up, and they're afraid, and they're sort of just trying to live out to the best they can in this post-apocalyptic environment.

And your character is the person who is supposed to be connecting the strands, tying everyone together, and you know, recreating a communal network of people. And it's it's such a timely game because I feel like everyone feels like America and I'm I don't know if this I'm sure it's happening in other societies as well, but as an American, you feel like people are drifting apart from each other.

Politics has become just a complete test of ethics, and there's no way to have a real reasonable discussion about what should happen. It's more just like you know, morality check, and you know, if you agree with me, then I'll talk to you. If not, then we can't have a conversation. People are increasingly polarized and retreating into smaller and smaller groups, I feel like.

And that's that's really not healthy. So this game, I think is really timely for this idea of how do you reconnect after something has gone really terribly wrong. And it and it's a beautiful game. It's it's it's really well done for a lot of video game aspects as well, but the message is really important.

That's awesome. Well while while we're on gaming, I mean, we should talk about this. Like, I mean, gaming in general is just like this exponential phenomenon. It's growing like leaps and bounds. We have like the League of Leg League of Legends World championship was this past weekend, I think, right?

The final viewership totals aren't in yet, but I did look up the 2018 League of Legends finals were watched by 99.6 million people around the world. Which is on par with the 2018 Super Bowl, you know. So that's kind of the size of it now, and it's just growing really fast.

It's still growing. The Super Bowl viewership is sort of stagnated and actually going down a little bit. So it's it's gonna blow past it. About these 2019 numbers are are well past. So it's huge, very fast-growing market. I feel like there's gonna be some, you know, opportunities for lightning to be incorporated into gaming and maybe make gaming a major adoption funnel for Bitcoin.

What do you what do you think about? Having thought much about that. I love it. I absolutely love it. I just recently met the guys that are making light night, which is basically Fortnite, but you know, incorporating lightning payments and they're also doing some other stuff with like in-game items and how they're going to be managing the scarcity of something.

So, you know, like let's say you have a really unique hat or something. If you get killed with it in game, then the other person could pick it up and you have like scarce items that are being constantly shuffled around. And you know, it they have a bunch of really crazy ideas, and I think it's awesome. And I think that that's creating a new form of gaming that we haven't really seen before, where it used to be, you know, you have social and you have ranked.

Social is like, you know, whatever happens doesn't really matter. Ranked is we're gonna collect your statistics, and if you do well, then we'll, you know, give you a higher rating or something in-game. But lightning opens up a third, even higher level, which is now we're going to do paid. So you pay your way in, and you know, if you win, then you get a payout.

So you could imagine Fortnite where everyone pays in like a dollar to play or something, and the winner gets a hundred bucks out after the battle royale or something like that. And I mean, that's just a crazy new development that's never been possible before, where right now the only way is win a massive championship or be a streamer.

And those are two very, very difficult paths to make money with video games, but you could now turn it into a competitive sport where there's money on the table, and if you're really good, even if you're some random kid in Pakistan and you are the best kid and you go to the internet cafe and you crush people in StarCraft, then now you can make a living for your family, which is really just a mind-blowing possibility that frictionless borderless payments creates.

And I think the big thing about this is is not just you can spend with lightning, but that you can receive with lightning. That that's really what hasn't been possible before is the payouts that are so fluid. It's it's always been easy to buy V-bucks or something like that, mostly speaking, but with Lightning, you can now do automatic payouts to anyone, which is just crazy, and the possibilities of that.

Yeah, it is crazy. Another one that's kind of mind-bending for me is is virtual reality, which I feel is like I mean, I have the PS4 VR, and because I've always like as a kid was fascinated with the idea of virtual reality, and like so as soon as that kind of mainstream kit came out, I was like, Yeah, I'm gonna pick that up and try it out.

And it's pretty cool. Like there's you know, it's definitely got the wow factor going on, and people come over to my house and check it out are like definitely impressed, and it kind of sucks you in. There's a couple of games that are phenomenal, and I think you know, more and more will come out as kind of you know developers and designers sort of explore this new world.

But like, you know, you can imagine, you know, kind of a future where there's the networked virtual you know virtual worlds that we can just enter into, right? And conduct conduct business and entertainment and gaming and all of that, everything basically exchange and e-commerce in this immersive virtual world.

And like you can imagine if that if we move a you know significant portion of human interaction there and try to recreate it as best as possible in this virtual world, it's networked all over all over the place. You've almost invented like teleportation to some degree, right? And then if Bitcoin is the you know native currency of the internet, even if there is still exists and persists some some form of central banking for you know the last or remaining few shitcoin fiat, you know, fiat coins out there, you know, this this

Movement of like the internet really kind of just taking and sucking in like every aspect of our lives, and then that's sort of culminates with virtual reality and virtual worlds. Like we've recreated this reality in this you know digital connected space on the internet, then you know, that's that's Bitcoin world. Like everything there is is done in Bitcoin just natively since it's the native currency of the internet.

So it's that's just like another adoption funnel, right? That that's something I've I've been thinking about lately. I know that Balajis just did a podcast on this with Peter McCormack and he was talking about telecommuting. But like basically you use VR to act as a way to migrate during the day.

You know, like let's say you're someone who's you know really struggling in Venezuela right now. Well, why not just VR teleport to some service job in the States or something like that and operate a robot in a Burger King and you know that way you don't need to have an actual robot that's actually intelligent.

You can just basically teleport someone in from another country that has you know a much lower standard of living, and you can help them and also have a much cheaper labor force that can basically telecommute. But and I think that this is definitely the trend we're seeing, and it goes back to the sovereign individual being just so incredible at predicting these things.

I was just reading it and it was talking about a lot of people characterize the internet as this information super highway, but it's to say it as that treats the internet as if it is this thing that gets us from one place to another. But really the internet is a place in itself, and that the cyber economy is going to be much larger as a as a place in in interactions and transactions with with individuals than just like connecting point A to point B.

I think right now we're still at the connection point, but with VR and the ability to sort of just massively bring the world in to all these opportunities that previously weren't possible, it just changes those dynamics so much. I mean, what does it mean when someone in Chile can VR teleport into a truck that's driving on the highway and you don't have to pay the worker, the truck driver anything or much relative to what you would have to pay an American?

And also, because it's VR, they can teleport to multiple different trucks. And they can kind of be doing a whole fleet of trucks, and whenever VR or whenever the self-driving part of the truck needs a human interaction to like you know pull over to rest stop or something like that, you just pour it into whichever truck is necessary, take care of it, and then go back to maintaining the fleet.

And it's crazy. It is really crazy when you think about well, we can just break down all these borders, and you have and also I think this is probably going to be devastating for large parts of the American economy, also. This isn't gonna come at no cost, it's going to be a flattening of you know, labor rates, and people are really going to be we're already seeing the big very beginnings of this with a gig economy and how people are being paid, you know, very little for these sorts of gigs.

But what's going to happen when the entire world can compete for a gig? When the entire world can compete to deliver you something from Postmates or something like that. All these are just like really bizarre things to think about. And it also changes the dynamics of taxation.

Whereas right now you could have a company that is physically located in one jurisdiction, but if you know more and more commerce kind of takes on this digital form, then suddenly you can have a company that doesn't have a physical set location, and you could just kind of domicile it wherever between many, many different people.

And then you are looking at going back to the idea of these competitive city states, as the firms become more global instead of all right, we have one giant headquarters in Atlanta, then you have a much better way of you firms will have will be forced to, sorry, not firms, governments will be forced to compete much more for you know creating the best tax incentive programs for whoever's choosing to domicile there because they can just leave so easily given the digital nature of the things.

So it's mind-blowing. It's hard to even begin to imagine a lot of this, and a lot of it's gonna be wrong, of course, but just the possibilities that are there. If a tenth of it happens, it's going to be just mind-bending. Yeah, absolutely. And you know, like just to on that last bit there, you know, there'll be eventually that competition will will lead to you know, governments that just don't have taxes, don't tax at all, right?

That are super minimal and persist on voluntary taxation, essentially, like, you know, we're gonna run this service you know, for the good of the people. And, you know, if we do well and better than like this private corporation at providing this service, then we will, you know, you'll you'll pay us instead, basically.

Yeah, you're basically like governments at that point just become a bundle of social services. And the only reason that you would pay them is because they can provide it more efficiently than unbundling those services and paying for them separately, which may or may not happen. It's it's hard to know. I mean, I remember when people used to get their their phone, their cable, and their internet from one person, and now it's you know, you have your Netflix, you have your cell phone, and you have your internet, and they're they're unbundled because it's you know, you can get better rates that way.

So it's hard to imagine, but I think it's just what we're in line for is if these services become unbundled, then it's it's gonna significantly change the role of governance, and we'll just create so much accountability because right now there is just no incentive.

It just comes back to incentives. There's no incentive for accountability right now when you have a monopoly of force, when you have a monopoly of space, and that people are basically stuck there, and there's not really anything you can do about it. There's no way to really escape it. As firms come become more mobile, more digital-based, and we start to see this Bitcoin alternate economy develop, then they have to compete.

They have to compete or they're gonna go extinct. And that's just gonna change the dynamics of power. And, you know, it goes back to Tur de Meester's latest piece, what the sovereign individual talks about a lot, the similarities between the reformation and Bitcoin is, you know, when the church was at its really latest stages, it was regulating every part of everyday life.

It was telling you exactly when and when you couldn't eat on on certain types of things. It was saying only on on Fridays you have to eat fish, and that was because they were being paid off from the local fishermen, and they were telling you that you can only have sex if you, you know, buy this indulgence from me, and you know, all these just massive excesses that were super harmful for people, but because they didn't have to compete, this these excesses could kind of seep into the system.

You saw them taking their tithings and packaging them up and selling them as like as basically like bonds or something like that, where they would say, Look, you give us money now, and we'll give you a share of our tithes into the future, and these like you know, just totally ridiculous practices that were happening and unsustainable practices, but it happened because dynamics of power were so misaligned, and that was through the sort of ideological perversion of what initially was a good a social good.

And so I think nation states are kind of on their last legs in the same way, and it's just a natural way of sort of shifting the incentives and changing in a way that we can sort of hold these things accountable and make them compete honestly. Yeah, it's amazing. Wow.

So that was that was wonderful. I that was super fun. I've got this idea to kind of finish up on because you and I were both policy debaters. I debated in high school. I didn't in college, but I debated all four years in high school, was part of a squad that took it very seriously, debated, you know, went traveled out of state and to big national tournaments, etc.

So did you debate in high school and or college? And can you give like listeners a little intro to the activity for those who might be unfamiliar? Yeah, so debate is very multifaceted. I debated for seven years, so four years in high school, and then three years in college, and there's there's lots of different types of debate.

So the ones that I did, I started with what's called public forum debate. And that's a two-on-two style of debate. You just take a regular you know, everyday topic. Should we, you know, impose sanctions on North Korea, something like that. It's you and a partner arguing against someone else, and the topics change every month.

I then did congressional debate, which is you pretend to be a congressman and you are debating other people trying to get your legislation passed. And then when I went to, and that was what I did in high school, when I went to college, I switched to policy. So what that and that's what you did in high school.

And policy is a very different, it it's the most I it's it's definitely the most unique style of debate and probably furthest from what a traditional understanding of debate entails. You know, you think of debate as a political debate, these people just kind of go up and they kind of argue back and forth. Policy debate is you have one topic for an entire year.

So you have something like should the US promote subsidies for green energy, right? And that's the that's the topic. And then for an entire year, you and your team and every person you're debating against is only focusing on that one thing, and you're trying to propose a plan or a government policy that would be beneficial for this topic, like yes, we should do it.

Here's the initiatives we should fund. We should fund wind energy for this amount, and then the opposite team, the side against you has to say, no, that's not right for a variety of reasons. And they can say, you know, we think this is going to be bad for our economy, very practical approaches about the direct consequences of it.

They can critique it from a philosophical stance and say it's unethical, that it is the wrong way of orienting ourselves to the world. It can get pretty intense. And you're speaking at very, very fast paces. So you're speaking at you know, hundreds of words per minute.

You have professional or at least very experienced judges who are actually trained to understand you at really high rates of speed. There's a lot of technical jargon and things like that. And it's basically like the ultimate intellectual chess match is sort of this form of debate called policy debate, which is very unique. And it's also very open source, is another really cool thing about it.

Is there's a really strong ethos of you know, steel starp sharpens steel, and that we need to as soon as you make a new argument, you post it publicly online, and then anyone else can also use that, those those arguments, the evidence, the research you compiled, and the idea is that by promoting the sort of everyone shares everything approach that we can get to the bottom of these things even better.

We can have more nuanced technical, rigorous discussion of ideas, and it's incredible. It's it's really incredible. So so that that's that's the big overview of it. Yeah, I've I've found it to be I found it to be like a extremely useful experience for a lot of things in life, but you know, as is like relevant to this podcast, like it's been really useful on Bitcoin Twitter.

Have you found the same thing? Oh, yeah. No, I mean, it's it's useful for I think just sorting out like like coming into the space and hearing everyone telling you they're right from all different camps and really just the nature of just hearing cons and arguments for everything in debate and not shying away from that really really helped me just you know stack up the arguments and figure out where the pieces lay and that that led me to Bitcoin and I think that some

People I and I think that's why Bitcoiners are drawn to it is like we just have the best arguments. We have the best logical conclusions and that's it's tough pill for a lot of people to swallow. It's the shelling point. It is it totally is yeah and I mean you went you know climbed that curve very quickly and I think you know like we said earlier part of that is the just blossom the blooming of this amazing educational content that's just freely shared on the web.

And then also you know just I think your experience with debate put those two things together and like you know you can just kind of methodically go through the arguments and the material and like you said arrive at you know this is the best logical conclusion the people presenting or like creating the evidence you know the arguments on the Bitcoin side seem to be you know more thoughtful and more rigorous about their approach, et cetera.

And yeah, that's you know, that leads you to the Bitcoin you know answer, basically. The and you, you know, the conviction just grows from there. Oh, yeah, totally. And also the fact that honestly the biggest critics or the best critics of Bitcoin are Bitcoiners themselves. Like Bitcoiners don't shy away from admitting there's problems with Bitcoin or that we need to improve it or that it has trade-offs, and we need to make sure we do those trade-offs properly, or we think about those trade-offs properly.

There's very, very intense, rigorous acknowledgement of those and discussion, and no one shies away from it. I think real toxicity is in a unhelpful sense is the people that say, I don't want to acknowledge what you're saying. I don't want to, you know, the Ethereum people that say I don't want to acknowledge the fact that sharding is continuously delayed and there's really no scaling solution to nodes that are currently costing thousands of dollars to run.

I don't want to admit that. So I'm I'm really not gonna engage you in that conversation or talk about why we made these trade-offs. I'm just kind of gonna sweep that under the rug. That's a much more disingenuous form of toxicity because you know they're not letting you even have those discussions in the first place.

Yeah, absolutely. So and just, I mean, to that point, the one of the beautiful things about debate is just this, you know, being open, this openness to being critical of on both sides and looking at, and so one of the catches is in policy debate when you're at a tournament, each round you switch sides, right?

So one round you're the affirmative, you're proposing the plan, and the negative side you know, is arguing against that plan. And then the next round it's flipped, you're negative, and the other, you know, a different team is affirmative. And so you've got to go on both sides of the of the topic, year, you know, tournament in, tournament out, all year long. And so it's a very thorough examination of that particular question, right?

So I think that that's just really cool. And it, you know, like you said, kind of translates to the way that we talk about Bitcoin and sort of you know, on the dev side, like if you go on to GitHub or onto the dev's mailing list, you'll see very rigorous and methodical examinations of both sides, you know.

Somebody will take sort of the approach to basically attack that idea, and it'll have to like either survive or you know, be be beaten down. And so and we do the same thing on Bitcoin Twitter with you know how to meme this thing and how to explain it and all of that stuff, and it it we distills down into this, you know, the best answers, right, for all of those questions.

So, and this is something I've been thinking about for a while. I think it would be awesome to get together Bitcoiners and do a sort of debate style you know, affirmative and negative on particular like Bitcoin related topics and questions. And I think it would be really fun to do it on stage sometime, maybe at like a big conference and get like four, you know, Bitcoiners out, well-known Bitcoiners, and have them kind of go at it.

I think would be super fun. So, with that in mind, though, I would love to do this with you sort of on a smaller scale right now. I've got a few topics. We'll see how many we can get to, but I thought it would be really fun to hear you take like the affirmative side and the negative side of each of these topics. Yeah, let's that that sounds really fun.

Let's do it. All right, cool. So the first topic is we should adjust Bitcoin's reward schedule to provide small eternal to provide a small eternal block reward. Ooh, that's a good one. Okay. Where do you want me to start?

Just want to do like kind of off the top of the head, extemporaneous type stuff. Yeah, yeah. So just kind of go for maybe first and then against. So again, I'll just read it again. The topic is we should adjust Bitcoin's reward schedule to provide a small eternal block reward. So I think this gets to the article that was just released by Hasu and Nick and talking about why we need a little bit of inflation at the end just to make sure that we have some level of security.

And the argument for this is that because Bitcoin's fee rate is approaching zero in terms of block subsidy, we should make sure that our security spend is high enough to secure the chain. And the argument for that is that as the network reduces its subsidy and the network increases in value.

That I'm trying to make sure I get the argument right. The argument is because we are reducing the subsidy and the network is increasing in value, it therefore becomes more profitable for miners to attack the chain because the value of the network is increasing disproportionate to the amount they're getting paid out per block, and that at some level it's good to have like a minimum inflation rate to make sure that's a smooth process.

And it's also, I think another argument would be that because of lost coins, it's good to have a nice little gradual inflation at the back end of things to always make sure that we're replenishing our supply so our money supply isn't shrinking over time. And let's see if there's any other arguments.

I think that you could also say that a little bit of an incentive that would also create a little bit less fee pressure and it would make it more accessible for people to use the base layer, because you know, if the subsidy is there, then we could maybe have it so that fees are cheaper and we wouldn't have to spend as much or worry about fees as much, and we could allow it to be a little bit better for you know people who don't have access to large amounts of Bitcoin to sort of be able to get into those those bottom level blocks, and that's important.

Awesome. That was great. All right, so flipping to the other side, why should we not adjust the reward schedule? Not addressing the reward schedule is the argument for that would be that you know, this is sort of Pandora's box. That if we change our monetary policy now, then it might be changed again in the future, and that instituting a little bit of inflation might even be better for security.

I might even grant that, but the problems that it creates and sort of allowing this to even be a topic of conversation is sort of opening the door to people later down the line saying, well, we can adjust it a little bit more. It gets back to the mindset of we can perfectly plan the future, we can plan exactly how much is needed, and because of that we want to close that off because the people that like to prophesize about the future are very appealing.

They can make very compelling arguments, but a lot of the times they're wrong because they can't predict the future, although they are very seductive. And that keeping that door closed is very important to maintain the integrity of the network and the integrity of the monetary base. I think the other thing is that is in form of inflation essentially is a tax on the people who are hodlers, and that we want to incentivize people to hodl instead of to sort of be taking riskier investments or spending disproportionately because you know they're afraid that their savings are going to be sort of inflated

Away and they need to put it into something else that's even more scarce, more secure, and that additionally, if this is a if this is something we institute, then we're going to have a natural competitor to Bitcoin come up and say, look, we're Bitcoin without the inflation. This is even better than Bitcoin, and we're going to lose the network to a competitor.

And so just the idea of competition is going to keep this honest, and we should we shouldn't allow ourselves to lose to a potential adversary in that way as well. I'd say that's the other side of it. That was great, man. Awesome. All right, let's do another one. We should take whatever measures are necessary to maximize privacy on the base layer.

Oh, this is a good one. So, pro-privacy, the affirmative would be saying that privacy is the most important part of these networks because without privacy, we could easily see ourselves going back into the same system. If everything is completely transparent, everything is KYC'd, then you know, maybe some people are going to be good enough to protect their privacy through using Wasabi or you know, more complex privacy mechanisms, but most of the coins are going to be transparent and we're going to know who owns what.

And that that sort of pseudonymous system is not strong enough to protect it from a nation state who is willing to knock on doors and seize things until they can, you know, basically that this is a vulnerability from sort of a more totalitarian or aggressive approach to saying, well, if I know that everyone has bought coins and there's not very good privacy on the network, then maybe the US could round up 10 million coins or something like that just by knocking on doors and forcing people to hand them over or they face very serious penalties.

And so privacy on without privacy on the base layer, you could have a really similar system to the way that gold was taken from people, and that we just knocked on doors and took it, and you face the penalty. I mean, even it would have to be a little more aggressive than the way we took gold given the properties of Bitcoin, but it could happen if we know who owns what, and we know with reasonable certainty, given the pseudonymous system that the people with Bitcoin are located in these locations.

And if it doesn't completely break Bitcoin, it could make it so that one nation state or a few nation states control the majority of the outstanding supply, and that's a really serious vulnerability, and we'll get right back in the same problems we had with the gold standard. Very well done. All right, so the negative side.

The negative side, this is instituting privacy on the very base layer is something that is really not sustainable because we not not maybe not not sustainable, but not preferable because you are making a trade-off of audibility. That the real benefit of Bitcoin comes from the ability to audit that base layer to make sure that nothing fishy is happening and no inflation is being addressed.

And we can see problems with things like Zcash, where they had an inflation bug and didn't know about it, given the complete blinding of supply. And that without with if if you do create a completely blinded base layer, then you could be opening yourself up to inflation or catastrophic bug or some malicious actor, and you could never know about it, and you would have a serious auditing problem on your hands that would completely destroy the value proposition of Bitcoin.

It could be something that would take maybe years or decades to figure out until it you know completely is derailed and you don't really have an alternative. And so this entire system kind of falls apart because of inflation, and there's really no way to prevent it because you don't know about it.

And the other argument would be the problems about nation states attacking Bitcoin or attacking Bitcoiners because it is pseudonymous can be solved sufficiently with can be solved sufficiently with steps you can take on the base protocol and through secondary networks such as Lightning, which will continue to rise in prominence, and that you know there's no need to shoot ourselves in the foot now with potential auditing problems if we can achieve that same privacy on future layers and that we can sort of

Have our cake and eat it too if we're willing to be patient. Very good. That's awesome. I can tell you debated for seven years. All right, do you want to do one more? Yeah, let's go for it. I love it. Okay. All right, yeah, it sounds like you're enjoying it. Okay. This I only wrote three, so this is the last one.

And this one's sort of a layup, which is why I left it for last. But I think it will be helpful for Bitcoiners to hear both sides of this, especially you know, if you've come into the scene like in the past year, year and a half, before the block size debate, it'll be good for you to hear this both sides.

So it kind of sum it up. So the topic is we should increase base layer transaction throughput by raising the block size. So we should increase the block size because the most important aspect of a monetary system is its usability. And the more usable it is, then the more likely those network effects can sort of compound.

If we increase friction by artificially capping the block size for everyday payments, then we will lead to people who are just being turned off of it, either because they aren't willing to they aren't willing to take on those extra costs compared to lower cost alternatives in the traditional system, or they simply aren't able to access it at all because you know a dollar transaction fee means a lot to someone in a developing country.

And if we want this to really be the global cypherpunk payment system that's able to bring true economic freedom to people, then we should increase the throughput at the base layer so that we can really make it usable, magnify those network effects, and make it unstoppable because everyone just loves the frictionless nature of it.

And it it might increase the cost of some nodes, but we'll always have enough nodes. It won't increase so exponentially that the entire network is in danger that only a few thousand nodes would be enough to completely decentralize the network and keep it safe from nation states.

And that we might, you know, make it harder to run on a mobile phone, but what's more important is usability to kind of amp up those network effects and get as many people using it as possible and accelerate the process. Okay, awesome. And then the other side why we should not raise the block size, or at least not right now, not yet.

So we shouldn't raise the block size for a couple reasons. I think the first is that it creates bad incentives for mining. If you have a block that takes a long time to propagate across the network because you have you know larger block sizes, then naturally it's going to lead to a sort of perverse system of incentives where let's say the blocks become 500 megabytes or something like that, then it'll take you know maybe a significantly longer time to propagate.

And the first miner that finds the block will then get an unfair advantage where they have a head start on the next block because they just found the first one. And so you might see someone with you know 20% of the mining power getting 25% of the rewards because they're getting these continuous head starts. And the only the natural incentive for that is for people to combine and combine their hashing power into larger and larger pools to take advantage of this head start function.

Leads to mining centralization, and that's a really big problem for Bitcoin and a potential point of failure, and that we don't want that to happen. I think the other one is that while there might be increased transaction costs in the base layer, that you know, every monetary system has taken a or our current monetary system takes a scaling up a layered approach already, and that you know, Bitcoin should work the same way.

Our base layer is going to have high fees, but we're gonna have to bite that bullet in the same way that you know there's high fees and settling gold between central banks right now because we need that sort of foundational strong layer, and we can build accessible layers on top of that. But if we sacrifice security for usability in the short term, we won't have either in the long term, and that the only true way to scale in a sustainable way, while it's not sexy in the short term, is higher fees and usability, higher fees on the on the base chain and usability that comes on on higher levels.

Absolutely. And don't forget to mention that it will increase the efficiency of the base layer as well. So we'll be able to jam in a whole lot more transactions into single transactions, you know, and batch them together with Schnorr signatures, et cetera. Exactly. It creates the tragedy of the commons with an unbounded block size where the people that are node operators are basically subsidizing the people who are making all the transactions, and you definitely don't want that to happen.

And you also don't want transaction fees blocks to be so large that there's no demand or not enough demand to generate transaction fees, which is how the security of the network is going to function going into the future given the emission schedule. Absolutely. See, that was a lot of fun. I think it would be cool to put together an event at like Bitcoin 2020, for instance, and then do this live with some other Bitcoiners, it'd be a good time.

Oh, yeah. That that I think that would be a lot of fun. And I'd also like to see some Bitcoiners take an anti-Bitcoin stance. Like I want to see Pierre Richard and Michael Goldstein defending U.S. Hegemony over the dollar empire and things like that. Me too me too it'd be too much fun. And you know Pierre was a debater too so I think he'd be into it.

Yeah I know he has a background for it. Exactly. All right man this was a great time we went for over an hour and a half you know we could keep going of course but I've got to get home and I know you probably have some other things to do. So really appreciate your time man I think it was an awesome discussion. I'm really excited to get it out there and share it with everyone do you want to finish up with any words or you know tell people where they can find you or anything else that you want to say to the listeners.

You know stay humble StackSats. I think that's always good to hear but the way the best place to find me is on Twitter. My handle is at underscore Conner Brown underscore and that's Connor with an ER and not an OR at the end. So yeah and just thank you so much for having me on I really enjoyed this and as a longtime listener of your podcast it's it's really cool to finally be talking to you.

Very cool man I can't wait to meet in person and spend some time together. I assume you'll be out at Bitcoin2020 right since you're in the area right? Yes last year I missed it and I was really devastated but this year I'll be there. So yeah I look forward to meeting you. Alright sounds good man keep up the great work and thanks for your contribution to you know to defending Bitcoin out there on the battlefield that is Bitcoin Twitter.

Thanks man yeah all right take care man

All right, all right.

That was a great time. I love that debate stuff there at the end. Connor, thanks so much for joining me today, man. Appreciate your time what did y'd you all think of that? There's lots to chew on there. I'm sure plenty of questions came up for you. Let us know and let us know what you thought about the episode in general. You can tag Connor, he's at underscore Conner Brown and then an underscore trailing at the end.

I am at CitizenBitcoin. We'd love to hear from you. You can support the podcast if you're finding it valuable by sharing it on Bitcoin Twitter with your friends and family.

This holiday season with GiveBitcoin and then let them subscribe to this podcast and together we'll help you turn them into wizened hodlers. All right, before I go, my open source shout out for this week is bitcoin-resources.com.

Gigi's great Bitcoin Resources page is a compliment to his 21lessons.com and it was recently open source, which is awesome. So you can now contribute to and curate the resources on the site.

Check out the GitHub link to Gigi's project in the show notes and you can start submitting ideas, resource suggestions, submit PRs to help build up the site. All right, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Downloads