All episodes
Episode 42

Bitcoin 2019: An Audio Tour featuring Jack Mallers, Lyn Ulbricht, Bitcoin TINA and More

July 19, 201987 min

This episode compiles some audio I collected walking around the Bitcoin 2019 conference in San Francisco. So, go into this one imagining you’re at Bitcoin 2019 having conversations in various corners with some great bitcoiners. I talk to Jack Maulers, Bitcoin TINA, Lyn Ulbricht, Nick Ward from Layer One BTC, Robert Breedlove of Paralax Digital, Ti Kawamoto, Steve Jeffress, Terrance Yang, Gus GG from Artolin.org and Guy Swann and myself finish it up with a reasonably drunken conversation outside our AirBnB in SF on the final night of the conference after Peter McCormack’s odd yet super fun dueling piano bar party.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Welcome to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady, and I'm sharing my journey, learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. Alright, Bitcoiners, what is up? Hope you all are well out there. Today I've got a kind of different episode for you. As most of you know, I attended the Bitcoin 2019 conference in San Francisco a couple weeks ago.

And while I was there, I was able to grab some decent audio with a mobile recorder as I walked around the conference. Now, this audio has lots of background noise of varying degrees depending on where in the venue we were, but everything is audible and understandable. So go into this one imagining you're at Bitcoin 2019 having conversations in various corners with some great Bitcoiners. I talked to Jack Mallers, Bitcoin Tina, Lyn Ulbricht, Nick Ward from Layer 1 BTC, Robert Breedlove of Parallax Digital, Ti Kawamoto, Steve Jeffress, Terrence Yang, Gus GG from Artolin.org, and Guy Swann and myself finish

Up this episode with a reasonably drunken conversation outside our Airbnb in San Francisco on the final night of the conference after Peter McCormack's kind of odd yet super fun dueling piano bar party. Hope you all enjoy this little audio tour of the Bitcoin 2019 conference.

Alright, here we go. Alright, we'll start out with this clip of a conversation from the first morning of the conference, standing with a group of Bitcoiners on the rooftop of SVN West, the conference venue, waxing poetic about the scene and getting ready to start the conference.

Winchie was maybe some of the lightning's common name. Alright, here we are on the rooftop of Bitcoin 2019. We got a group from Raleigh. Raleigh is it Rolla or Raleigh? Raleigh. What's up? Raleigh, alright.

Bootstrap Bandit. Bootstrap Bandit. And you have a paywall.link. Yeah, we're doing a lightning service now. It's paywall.link. You can kind of payment protect your content with lightning. Right on, right on. Mine's just my name, Steve Jefferson. I'm just organizer of the Raleigh Bitcoin meetup. Right on. Got the crypto economy, guys.

Actually, paywall.link, you got the got the crowd award last night for the lightning thing, didn't you? Crowd favorite, yeah. Crowd favourite. No shit, that's awesome. The blockchain capital and radar pitch competition. Yeah. That was pretty good. Congrats, man. That's awesome. I'm sorry I missed it. That's baller. Showed up after the show. Yeah. Alright.

Next to the right here. Yeah. Both of you jump on in yet. This is Ty Kaumoto representing the New York Citadel. Terrence Yang at Yang Ventures. Right on. SF. Alright, so this is a beautiful spot right here. I mean, this is insane.

Like absolutely like there's the moon right there, we got the blue sky. Describe that. Yeah. You know, this is just too good, right? Sun is shining. Bitcoin almost full moon. Bitcoin mooning. Bitcoin mooning. Yep. So crazy. Alright, so what are you guys gonna check out today? Well, I was gonna ask you how was that last night? Hanging out with all the like podcasters, all the famous podcasters in the space.

Yeah, we had a you know that thing, yeah. You already clever guy. You were the guy who's gonna be a good one. The guy came at the very last minute. I got here I got here and I asked I asked where Brady was, and he was like, Yeah man, this beef steak thing, and Pierre's here, and Stefan's here, and Matt, and everybody's like you're just going through all this people, it's like this is great.

How do I get there? It's like you can't. Yeah, okay, it's sold out. Well, you know what? Somebody was like, if somebody took out that building, then like 90% of Bitcoin podcasts would be gone. It would be just me. I'm just thinking you and Bitstein would be the ones like that. You need to inherit the Bitcoin podcast universe. No, that was cool though. You put in face with names, it's weird, you know.

You got that you get to know somebody's voice better than like you know, and then you get the like full HD interaction with their real person. It's just kind of weird. Everybody was went through that for about 30 minutes. And then we just kind of you know just ate steak, settled into a bunch of beef and a bunch of beer. And then the whiskey came out and the cigars, and it was then it was time for a lift.

I keep hearing about how great that beef was. Tommy said something about it like 16 times. How about that beef last night, man? It was good. It's like quit rubbing it in, man. Quit rubbing it in. I'm kinda hungry. I'm waiting for these food vendors over here to open up.

They're still closed. Oh yeah, man. It's kind of funny that there's a huge Bank of America building right next to us, right next to the city. This is yeah, this scene is amazing. The moon is out, the sun is shining, blue sky, Bank of America right here, it's like in the shadows. You know, it's like the sun is shining on Bitcoin, the Bitcoin moon, and Bank of America looms behind us.

Hashtag made obsolete across the street. Exactly. Exactly. We're still at 11k, so number go up, right? Number go up. Number go up. Orange coin good. Yeah, Max Keiser said that orange coin good. Did he? Oh shit. That was like Stefan's little baby meme. You know, he's like shepherded to full fruition. Now Max Keiser like drops it at Bitcoin 29.

That was originally like a B cash or insult. Yeah. You know, oh, you guys only care about price. Number go up. Yeah, right. Just took it over. Like, yeah, number go up. That's how you do it. That's how you do it, man. Just take it back. Just like we did with Maximalists. Yeah, just like we do with Maximus. That's taking it. Yeah, he's been like he's been like shepherding it on Twitter, like using it a lot.

There's been some great memes too, like Crypto Meme Central, you know, and it's a good thing. Oh, that guy's great. He's limiting it. Yeah, man.

I then took some time to peruse the art scene at the conference. And a quick shout out here to Tommy, the designer of BTC Inc. Who art designed and art directed this whole conference and did an amazing job. I appreciate the importance of art in the midst of a renaissance. And Tommy is doing great work.

Two waters that really caught my eye at the conference. One was Greg Mike at Greg Mike on Twitter, who painted a mural on the side of SBN West. And you can check out the sweet time lapse in the show notes of that mural painting. And then the augmented reality Bitcoin artist Gus Gustavo of Artolin.org, who I chatted with for a bit.

Check it out. Yeah, so tell us your name. My name is Gus Gustavo. Gus Gustavo. Yeah. He's an artist, digital artist. And I'll put in the show notes a link to some photos and video of his augmented reality bitcoin themed artwork.

It's beautiful stuff, man. How long have you been doing art? Well, I've I've been doing art all my life. I consider myself like a natural illustrator. Yeah. But this platform in particular that we are building is called Art All In O L I N. We just started working on this last year, and we've been developing the tech.

Yeah. And we have a what are you guys using to make it? What's the case? Well, we're using several stuff. The first of all, we created a Bitcoin wallet to create enhanced tokens with a counterparty protocol. Okay. So counterparty is basically a smart contract on the Bitcoin blockchain.

Right. It's way earlier than Ethereum, but it's kind of the same idea. Yeah, it's it's a smart contract to create other stuff. Among those stuff is to craft tokens, yeah. And then we with our platform we enhance those tokens to put art on those to attach some digital file into the Bitcoin transaction.

Right, and so it basically labels that art as a unique kind of like you would just write like one of ten in the bottom of a print. Exactly.

It's a way of creating digital scarcity out of memes

Or artwork. Yeah, it's really cool, man. Yeah. And why are you using Bitcoin and not Ethereum or some other blockchain? Well, because I started playing with this protocol before Ethereum was mainstream. Okay. So then it came CryptoKitties and brought a lot of attention.

Yeah. Right. But we believe that these protocols still have a lot of features. Yep. For instance, the tokens that we craft, they're more resilient and they don't have POS functions like Ladith the way it happens with the 721 tokens on Ethereum. So we believe that although it's got some friction because of fees and everything that we know, still the it it is still a little bit better in some other sense.

Yeah, so but we are we are agnostic so it's just fees then to do like the initial commit for that piece of art to the blockchain. Do you like use lightning for payments and stuff like when you're selling your art? We're we're working on that. There are some devs on the counterparty protocol trying to integrate the lighting to make it easier, but we are not there yet.

So but I mean I'm confident that it we will be there pretty soon, yeah. Yeah, and I mean does the fact that Bitcoin is I don't know, I guess more probably more decentralized than Ethereum or something like that. Does that make a difference to you? Yeah, yeah, yeah. As like a user of the blockchain? Exactly. We believe in the idea of crypto collectibles the same way that it happened with regular collectibles in the pre-history of humankind.

Yes, right, of course. Where people just start collecting stuff, right? And we believe that we are making a bet on the most resilient blockchain in the long run, a bet in the long run, because probably the tokens and the collectibles that we are crafting on the Bitcoin blockchain might have way more value in the long run.

Exactly. Than compared to another blockchain that is not so decentralized, no so not so resilient, etc. Yeah, yeah. Do you have a personal favorite? And maybe describe some of these pieces too. I think the Bitcoin bank note is pretty popular. That's my favorite. Yeah, that's the one that I made.

Right, okay. But we have a lot. Like this. It's got Dorian Nakamoto in the middle. Yeah. Yeah. And he's got some great like eyebrow movements in the AR. Exactly. Yeah, yeah. Some movement. Yeah, I like that one. But there are some other great ones. This up and down is very simple, but he's very popular as well. And the private key, the fucking keys. Yeah, yeah, right?

Yeah, it's also really hilarious. We like it. It's fucking good. I love it. Yeah, this is great, man. Alright, I appreciate your time. Thank you. Thank you, Brother. Yeah, man. Nice to meet you. Nice to meet you. Alright, next up, I was able to catch Jack Mallers after his great talk on the big stage about an underappreciated outcome of the Lightning Network.

It's very interesting. I also had a long fun conversation with his dad and stepmom, Bill and Brooke, at the conference. We can thank Bill for being a longtime hodler and probably even more so for getting Jack and Brooke into Bitcoin. Brooke actually edited Andreas Antonopoulos' talks into the texts Internet of Money One and Two, which I think are foundational for understanding Bitcoin.

And of course, Jack is leading design and development of Zap Wallet. An awesome family, awesome people. Here we go. Alright, I'm here with Jack Mallers. Yo. From Zap, Zap Wallet.

I'm a user fan. Love the UI UX and just love like the vibe of the Zap community. Thank you, man. Yeah, man. Just came off stage here at Bitcoin 2019 and gave some like a fresh talk. Like, this is new ideas that haven't been put out on the on the web yet, right? Physical settlement has gone from like cash like being settled by dudes in bars in the 1700s because their banks were too far apart from each other, to instant settlement anywhere in the globe on Lightning Network.

And that's really the miracle of Lightning Network. Can you like get into what this means? Like, I mean, it's it's kind of a mind blowing thing. I hadn't thought about it this way. Yeah, man. So I mean, clearing and settlement in finance is a massive industry within itself, right? The traditional eBay is the third party of commerce on the internet, right? There are clearing houses and firms in the Federal Reserve that sit in the middle and broker, clear and settle financial transactions, anywhere between spending money, dollars between each other, or issuing bonds and trading options, right?

Right. And the fact that there is a network that self-clears itself and it's instant and the contracts are binding to a blockchain that would back it is the most mind-bending thing, I think of all. So, although I mean, dude, zap is great. I love Zap. I love Lightning, I love everything that we spend it on, chickens and y'all's and whatever, right?

Black man, I played some upstairs. Yeah, fuck yeah, yeah. But but from the a higher level, I mean, what this means to money, I mean, in the centuries to come, is if you can physically settle value in seconds and clear it instantly, then every value transfer needs to be on whatever can accomplish that. And so lightning is a monumental advancement in money itself, and not even just for Bitcoin.

And so, yeah, that's the point I try to get across. It's really crazy. How big is this? Is the I mean, how much of the financial industry is dedicated to settlement? Is it like most of it? Is that what the purpose is? Yeah, that's that's the purpose of the industry, right? So it's just massive amounts of middlemen to achieve the final settlement.

Like what I guess people might not understand too, like, okay, let's say I make like a transaction on my credit card or my debit card. How long does it take for that to actually settle with like wherever it ends up settling? It depends, man. Days, some sometimes soon, right? Well, if the Federal Reserve is clearing it, maybe soon. Maybe days.

Right, maybe weeks. Okay. So yeah, I mean, it it is it's it's really what lightning can mean to finance and value transfer. I mean, it's I'm gonna speculate one way longer than I'm alive, right? Like this is a centuries-long project. Yeah. We I was just talking, and from the 1700s and from the 1900 early 1900s, yeah.

We're still seeing the same corporations clearing and settling finance. So with the Lightning Network, if Lightning started what, last year, two years ago, it's gonna be around for the next 200 years. Yeah. Instantly settling value, cross-border. And what's amazing about it too is the legal binding is cryptographic. It it's not through any nation-governed state, right? So the barrier to entry to be become a self-clearing participant in this network of finance is downloading free software.

For mission. And there is right, and there is no financial legal barrier. Yeah. Right? It's all cryptographic and verifiable by our phones. It's fucking awesome, man. Yeah. Anything you want to shout out about Zap, like what's the latest on the on Zap Wall developments are you guys working on right now? I got a bunch of stuff, but it's a little bit of a secret, but just keep your eyes open.

Yeah, desktop, iOS, Android. They'll all keep churning, keep getting better by the day. And then I got a major, major announcement probably within the next few months. All right, man. That's awesome. All right, thanks, man. Thanks for your time.

Next I talked with Nick Ward of Layer One BTC. Nick is a great Bitcoiner and designer who worked with me to develop the branding for this podcast, which I love. You can find some Citizen Bitcoin inspired merch at layer1btc.com. Click on the collections link for the Citizen Bitcoin collection. Of course, wearing Bitcoin gear out and about in meat spaces, probably not the best opsec, but you can rock this stuff comfortably at Bitcoin conferences, meetups, or just wear it around the house and collect them as mementos from these early days.

Not to mention, of course, it's a great way to support the pod. Alright, here's my combo with Nick. Alright, I'm here with Nick Ward from Layer1BTC.com. Designer, Bitcoiner.

How you find the conference so far, man? It's been great. It's it's nice to put some some faces to all the names that you see on Twitter and you know on the internet and finally get to talk to people in person. So that's probably the hardest part is balancing getting what you want from the talks and seeing the panels you want to see and then actually seeing the people you want to see and talking about what you need to talk about.

Yeah, you can't do it all at once. There's just so much going on. I was totally overwhelmed yesterday. Yeah, stuff. But you know, there's luckily it's two days, and then we can you know, anyone that we didn't get day one, we can meet up now. That's right, that's right. Like we, yeah, we were trying to meet up yesterday. Yeah. But then we I realized we don't need to know what each other looks like very well. Like I my my face is not out there on Twitter.

I'm gonna try to get out there a little bit more now. Since I'm totally doxing myself these days anyway. I feel like you have to go like either strict A-on or like just all out, like public to protect yourself. That was a decision for me that I feel like it was it was better like brand-wise to put a face to it.

Right. So people can connect like personally to it. Yep. So I made the decision to dox myself. Yeah. I think it was like five, six months ago. It's like, all right, well, I'll do a personal account attached to the business account and we'll see where it goes. Yeah, I think you need both sides. You need people who are gonna be like have public faces of Bitcoin as we're moving forward. And you need the anons too, because you know it's this thing like we just heard from Snowden is about privacy in a lot of ways and enabling privacy, giving privacy to the people.

Yeah, and you know, that's understandable. I mean this is an industry that obviously values privacy, whereas most others do not. It's not as important to I guess the majority of people, but for us it is. Yeah, and in fact it's the opposite. Usually like businesses, especially on the internet that are gonna make a lot of money, pri like not not having privacy is important to them.

Like that's how they make money is by doxing your ass. Right. Right. They charge they'll charge you for their services. And if they don't, that means they're just taking more information from you, right? Yeah. Like you're the product if you're not paying. That's that's the whole idea. How'd you get into Bitcoin? So in 2014, you know, my background is graphic design, web design.

I was working on a project with a couple web developers, and we had just a chat going together to work on the project. And one of them had one of I had heard about it and I had mentioned it, and one of them was able to give me a little bit of information on it. Nothing nothing too in-depth. But I've always been into like fantasy sports, sports betting. You know, I've always had sort of a gambling mentality about myself and I've always been interested in tech as well.

So it was sort of like a convergence of those two things for me. And his brief level overview of what it is, got me interested. So I got in at in like 2014, I think it was around like 800 or so. Yeah. To like to do sports betting? No, not even just as as a gamble in itself. Gotcha, okay. I was looking for quick quick gains, whatever it is, whatever happens to be.

You know, everything's didn't get too much. Easy money. Yeah. Exactly. You're all about easy money with the default Keynesian. That's right. That's right. So I had bought a couple in 2014 and I didn't really look into it, didn't really do any research about it. Didn't really grok it as people say now. But I wound up selling it like a year and a half or maybe two years later.

Probably about a year and a half later. And you know, I was out of college, I'm paying off loans, stuff like that. I need money for other things right now. Yeah. So I had gotten rid of it at that point, and then I pretty much forgot about it for like a year or two years. And then 2016-17 rolls around where we have the insane Ethereum pump and the alt market, and you know, I was I was all in there, I had a portfolio of like 30 plus coins and stuff like that.

Oh man. It was it. Yeah. And you know, as you know, things pop, right? The bubble pops, everything starts going down, and I'm I'm curious, right? I'm like, why is this happening? Looking for answers, and that sort of leads you to like the only real sources of credible information and actual conc concrete concepts, yep, brings you back to Bitcoin.

Like they say all roads lead back to Bitcoin. Yep. That's that's what happened for me. Like when I'm looking for foundational truths and ideas that stand the test of time, it all brought me back to Bitcoin. Yeah, there's a massive foundation of understand what Bitcoin is and understanding what's going on. Lot of tea a lot of people you can learn from out there that super smart have thought about this a lot and have figured out how to how to communicate that.

And then when you look at the alts, it's lots of fancy marketing, great design, which I appreciate. But it's really flashy. There's but when you start digging, especially after a bubble pops suddenly like, what the hell's going on? Yeah, the substance is not there. It's the substance is there with every Bitcoin. Everything sort of becomes more clear.

Yeah. You know, in the bear market, it's kind of nice because like you don't you're not getting bombarded with all these things that sort of like cloud your vision. Right. It's like you're driving a car, and like it in a crazy boom like we had with the alt cycle in like 2016-17. It's like driving a car, and like there's fog, there's rain, you can't see anything, your your lights aren't working on your car, and you're trying to drive down a highway at 100 miles an hour, yeah, and you know, the market's not stopping for anything.

You have to go, right? Yeah. The bear market comes, skies clear up, there's no more rain, yeah. Windshield wipers start working again, right? You're driving on the road, and there's nobody ahead of you, and you're just like, oh, this makes sense now. I can see what the heck's going on. So that's sort of what it felt like to me. Yeah. And here we are now, it's this fucking thing's been pumping like crazy.

Yeah. The past week it's gone up three thousand dollars, and like we're up 13 and a half thousand. I was talking to I've been talking to Bitcoin Tina a lot here. Oh yeah. He's probably been around to talk about it. This is hilarious, but like I just keep thinking about him because you know he's been saying during this whole bear market, like, you guys have no idea, you're all wrong trying to compare the 2014, 15, 16 cycle to this one.

Everything's different now. This is an exponential technology built on exponential technologies, like he always says, it's gonna you know fucking rip your face off when it starts going and here we are. So I even I mean, even what's happening now, it's it's crazy, but if you were to ask him, I'm pretty sure he would say, Yeah, no, this isn't it. Yeah, it's gonna get even crazier. Yeah, like 100x crazier than this, right?

Yeah, yeah. That's you know, he he's talking exponential on top of exponential. And I was I was looking at some like research of like S curve adoption for like new technologies and stuff like that, and I was looking at it and I was what I was seeing like the patterns of the S curves and stuff like that. So what it sort of seems like to me is like the hype cycles that Bitcoin goes through, like every couple of years, somewhat aligned with happenings, right?

Yeah. What was interesting is it seems like we have S curves on top of S curves on top of S curve, right? That's sort of just how Bitcoin works. Each cycle is kind of like an S curve on top of an S curve. It just it just hires the it hires the foundational price support, basically. Yeah, right. So you have you increase the number of holders, and that increases the baseline of whatever the next S-curve will look like.

Yep, yep. It's pretty cool, man. Yeah. Alright, thanks for time. Thanks.

I then had the privilege of talking with Lynn Olbricht, who was there to share about the incredible injustice inflicted upon her son by the federal government. People with very directly equivalent convictions, even other Silk Road convicts received no more than a 10-year sentence. Ross received two lifetimes plus 40 years.

It's a travesty, and it was an honor to speak with Lynn, a parent who has endured this tragedy, and to witness her strong voice in standing up to this injustice.

Alright, I'm here with Lynn Olbricht, Ross's mother. And she just gave a very moving speech about Ross and read a letter that Ross wrote for Bitcoin 2019 conference attendees. And you know, this is this is a story I think that strikes the heart of a lot of Bitcoiners.

I just want to say on a personal level, you know, I'd love for you to pass on to Ross that we're all pulling for him, and we will continue to work and stick with you guys through the fight. Could you go over some of the points you made in your talk about how unfairly Ross has been treated?

Well, I mean, there's and it's really impacts all of us. I mean, the sentence itself is a horrible precedent for excessive sentencing in this country, and it's also cruel and unusual punishment, which is violation of the Eighth Amendment. But there I mentioned how the judge referenced Ross's philosophy at sentencing. That's a First Amendment problem. Okay?

We're allowed to have a philosophy, and you don't get sent to prison for life before a philosophy in this country. Right. Or you're not supposed to at any rate. And there's other violations which are on our website of the Constitution, such as the Fourth Amendment and the Sixth Amendment, and the Fifth Amendment. And there's just a lot of problems with this case, and of course that puts all of us in peril.

Ross didn't get a fair trial. He I mean, to give us a life sentence to a first-time young offender who has no criminal record, no violence whatsoever, life, double life, double life plus 40 years without parole. This is this is abominable. And it really is a frightening thing that this could happen in our country.

Yeah, and you had a great graphic up there during your talk of comparing Ross's sentence, which is you know double life plus 40 years, as you just said, insane, compared to similar, you know, convictions. And there was no sentence that was less than 10 years. More than 10 years. Or sorry, no more, yeah, no sentence more than 10 years.

Yes, that's right. And these are people involved with the Silk Road. And then you can get out into cartel leaders, even terrorists get less sentenced than Ross. Kidnappers, murderers. So, I mean, hello? You know, are we safer for for this? No, Ross is not a danger to anyone. Right. We have over 175,000 signers on our petition.

Please sign it if you haven't already, because we need more. And we have over a hundred or nearly a hundred, I should say, eminent people, individuals, and organizations saying no, this is wrong. And we and we just need to speak out for all of us, not and for the people who are in prison being sentenced very drastically like Ross.

This is we want this to really help everyone and to get him out and to make changes because this is not American, this is not our values. This is this is like a totalitarian state. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, it's terrible. Thank you so much for your time. Thank you. Appreciate you. Yeah.

I spent some quality time with Bitcoin Tina at the conference. It was great to meet him. He was at the rooftop beef steak the first night, and we had many conversations those few days. I got him to sit down with me and get some audio of his take that as an exponential technology built on exponential technologies, Bitcoin adoption will happen a lot faster than most of us think.

Here we go.

I was really excited to meet this guy. He gets me hyped up on Twitter, and I think he's got a great perspective on where Bitcoin's going.

One that is, I think, underappreciated. I am coming around to believing. And boy, it's making this this run that we're on right now is sort of reinforcing this guy's ideas. This is another the Bitcoin Tina. Welcome to the show. What's up, man? Hey Brady, how you doing? Good man. This is an awesome conference.

We're at Bitcoin 2019 in San Francisco, and the guys from BTC Media put on an amazing conference. Oh, yeah, they're killing it. And I really love this conference, and I want to make a shout out to all the guys from BTC Media and thank them so very much. We've had a really great time here. And they put on a really impressive, really wonderful conference.

And I'm so appreciative. There's one guy in particular who had a special shout out to CK Snarks, who was such a great guy, took such good care of me, and I'm so appreciative. He's a really, really, really good guy. And I remember. How about that beefsteak that CK hosted on top of his room? That's what I'm talking about. That's what I'm talking about. CK hosted it a great, but he but he really he he he just got everything, you know.

He he he just helped me make it make everything make everything easy. No, he made everything easy. He's a he's a great guy, and I really like him, and I think he's a smart guy, and I'm very appreciative. He works for VTC Media, and you can check out his podcast, POV Crypto if you get into it. It's a good one. All right, we got that shout-out in.

So give it to us. Let's hear what what you're thinking on this current price run-up and where are we headed in the next you know three to five years. Okay, well, and why is price important? Sorry. That's good. The I spoke with Marty Bent from Tales from the Crypt in January.

Great episode. Legendary. And I'll be honest that when when the market, you know, it's bad bear market, everybody knows it's a bad bear market in 2019. Excuse me, 2018, and the market broke from six to three. I was like, oh my god, you're down like 70%, and it gets cut in half in like two weeks.

I was pretty sure that looked like the end of a of a bear market to me. It looked like a liquidation. I've been trading for a lot of years, and I was pretty convinced there's a high likelihood. Although there were plenty of guys who were saying, Oh my god, we're gonna go to much lower levels. And I thought that was actually a little insane.

But you know, I don't know, I don't have crystal ball, Microsoft broke like in 2017. So I don't know what it's gonna do, but I thought it was super cheap. I mean, I think Bitcoin today is worth a minimum of the value of gold.

I think even with that further development, it's worth the value of gold based just simply on its value proposition and what it can do. Look, if you're a if you're a businessman, if you're an attorney, if you're a doctor, if you're whoever, for some reason, you know, if something happens, not even your own fault, something happens and the government comes after you and they freeze all your accounts.

What do you what are you gonna do? Who are you gonna go to get help to pay for your lawyer? I mean, just on that value proposition alone. I mean, we live in such a litigious society that lots of people should own some Bitcoin, you know, and it's not just them. I mean, there's lots of lots of people, lots of men, lots of women, lots of lots of people who should own it.

Just having money that they can control, and that's a really big deal. I think that price is the primary means of adoption of Bitcoin. I think most people don't understand it. I started looking at it in like late spring, early summer 2017, put a lot of time into it, starting to work on it.

I didn't buy my first Bitcoin. I f I first heard about it, as I mentioned previously, in like 2014 from Trace Mayer at a conference, but had basically kind of forgotten about it. I was really intrigued by it. So, like most people, I'm like most people's story, they get sort of a first you know a first contact with with Bitcoin and then they like forget about it.

Except for a few smart guys, like Max Keiser said he. Yeah, he like bought it right away. Oh, Max is smart. He's smarter than me, because he owns it at really low prices, really low prices. Although I probably if I bought it, I would have sold it a long time ago. Yeah, yeah. Like most other people I think have done. They bought it and they were thought, oh my god, I've been five times. I tripled, I tripled my money. Let me get let me get out.

And they miss they they missed the next 400, 4,000 times. Yeah, yeah. It's like, okay, well, maybe that wasn't such a good idea. And so it takes time to really learn and understand it, and I've come to a lot of different understandings over the time in that period from six to three thousand when it was feeling pretty awful actually, because it was it was hard mentally just dealing with a market drop like that.

Because really severe market drop. You know, I bought some Bitcoin at like $19,000 and 18,000. That's it. Yeah, that starts hurting, that's some pain you start feeling right there. You know, losing like 80% of your money or whatever the hell it was. I don't know, it was a lot. You know, that that's really hard to stomach, but I really believed in it, but it's still hard to stomach because it's a pretty substantial loss.

But I held on, I hogled through. And I started to understand that extreme bull and extreme bear markets are the nature of Bitcoin. And then I had seen some interesting stuff from guys named Peter Demantis and Ray Kurzweil from Singularity University explaining and talking about the nature of exponential technologies.

Yep. And I started to understand that you know the internet's an exponential technology, and Bitcoin and its ecosystem are exponential technologies built on top of an exponential technology, plus the added fact of a fixed supply, which tends to create a positive feedback loop because there's just not, you know, when the price goes up, you can't just add more into the marketplace to kind of satiate that demand.

So there's just so much to go around. And so, in order to have more Bitcoin, there's enough Bitcoin for everybody, there's just not enough Bitcoin for everybody at a given price. So I was thinking today in San Fran, I got sunburned yesterday. I'm standing outside in the sun, and I'm standing outside.

It's really crazy. My back is on fire and my chest is freezing. San Fran. It has some freaky weather. And this is really a beautiful city. I mean, this is Northern California is my God. It is one of the one of the most beautiful places on the planet. And I remember we flew in and saw those hills and saw how beautiful it was.

We were driving to the airport, looking at South San Francisco and the hills, and said, oh my God, it's so freaking beautiful. This is such a beautiful country. There's so many beautiful spots in the United States of America, and I really love this place so much. And I was like, wow, this is really beautiful. And we get into San Fran, and it I remember the Mark Twain joke.

I mean, everybody knows this joke. The coldest winter I spent was a summer in San Francisco. And I brought a fleece and I'm wearing a short sleeve shirt, and I'm standing outside because you know, I want to hear the presentations, but I'm pretty sure those are gonna be on YouTube, and I'm gonna watch them all on YouTube. But I want to meet people, and I'm I meet people talk to guys like Brady, because I don't get a chance to meet these people in in in person, and I don't want to miss that opportunity.

I mean, really getting to meet people in person is such a treat. It's it's it's just really I'm really privileged to be able to meet guys like it's been spectacular, man. I've talked to so many smart people. There's so many really, really I mean, I'm an old man, and there's so many young guys who are so fucking smart. Something that's impressed me.

We're gonna have to bleep that out. That's okay. You can say fuck it on this podcast. Yeah, they're really smart. Yeah, I something that really got me is like everyone I've met is really, really fucking toxic. Just really just really fucking mean assholes. They're all assholes. No, they're great. No, man, like everyone I've met has been everyone I've met has been so nice.

Oh my god, Pierre Rochard is like the nicest person I've ever met in my life. Pierre is awesome. I love it. Dude, Pierre is like super kind dude, and like everybody's been that way. Everyone's been really cool. And yeah, it's just yeah, funny. The podcast fraternity is like amazing. Like I love these guys. They're all they can all be like the age of my son if I had a son.

But you know, I'm an old guy. But they're great. They're great, and I love their outlook on the world, I love their energy, I love their enthusiasm. They're smart guys, they're really, really smart, and I love that. And I said on Marty's podcast, it's this that fills me with so much optimism because the energy that these guys bring.

And my goal for myself is to try to have some ideas and maybe influence through the things I say and the things I tweet to get other people to pick up on my ideas and broadcast them and make them bigger and start to understand the world the way I understand it.

Which is why I want to do this pod with Brady. Yeah, so you're saying earlier that all right, so we've got exponential technology on top of exponential technology. And you're saying earlier that you were taking a walk this morning, and something made you realize that you wanted to get this, you know, get this story out there, get this idea out there, and you can put it out there.

You think that this is gonna happen way faster than most people do. I think it's gonna happen much faster than most people think, because I think you're I think you're building, you know, an exponential technology on top of an exponential technology. The internet, smartphones, these are all exponential technologies, but they took time to develop because we had to wait for for hardware, we had to wait for telecommunications development for speed.

And we were still waiting for that, like 5G. I mean, the internet was developed in like the late 50s, early 60s, the original internet, the ARPANET. And then we didn't get the web, the user version, the user-friendly version of the of the internet until the mid-90s. That was 30 years. And then in the past 20 years, we've gone from the web has taken over the world, and then we got the mobile revolution, that's taken over the world.

So everything started happening faster and faster. And like you say, Bitcoin is technology that's gonna be able to leverage all of that technological development because it can instantly be used all over the world since it's built on top of the internet. It's gonna be a lot shorter than the 50 years it took for the internet to ramp up from the you know ARPANET to where it is today, right?

I agree with that. I think it's gonna happen much, much faster. And the design of this thing, price is 99% of adoption. People come to it because they're attracted by price. Everybody loves to make money. And money is a thing which has a universal preference.

You require specific preference for everything but money. And Bitcoin's the best money ever created. And I don't want to go into that whole discussion of money right now, but let's just talk about money itself for a second.

I don't need a specific preference for money.

Everybody knows they want money because money buys everything else. Money buys goods and services, money buys investments. I need a specific preference for stocks or real estate or art or old cars or other kinds of collectibles or gold or whatever. You know, if I want to buy, you know, a particular pair of pants or a particular pair of shoes, a shirt, everything requires specific preference, those things that you want in particular.

Money's not that money, everybody wants money because money buys everything else. And money, a good money, is by its nature a riskless asset. What does that mean? It means that

If it's a money which is fixed supply, then

It doesn't have the specific risk that all these other things have. If it's if it's a good money like Bitcoin that has a fixed supply, and then let's not go into the whole details of Bitcoin right now. This is just a little brief conversation.

Are you surprised by this run-up that we're

At, 13 7 now? Yeah, I am surprised. Yeah. I think that when I was talking to Marty in January, I was busy trying to figure out, okay, do I have enough cash to make it work? And I kind of thought so. I was looking, you know, well, maybe we'll get to 20,000 by the end of 2020.

The worst case scenario. All these doom and gloom bears, I mean, they could be right. I can't deny that they might not be right. They could be right. I think they were gonna be right, but I was pretty confident that the bear market ended for sure. I think the bear market ended in December, and then we were kind of finding a bottom.

And I knew for sure that the bear market ended, well, two things. I was pretty sure the bear market ended when we made a higher high and a higher low in Bitcoin. And I forget exactly when that was. That was sometime I think in March. Yep. And then I think like April 2nd we exploded higher by a thousand points. And then I was absolutely certain the bear market had ended. And you had to, if you had gotten out of it, if you've been scared out by the guys trying to scare you out, you better act fast because this thing could move very fast.

And I argue that all surprises are on the upside, that as people's understandings change about Bitcoin, they decide that they want to own it and they need to own it. And in time, there'll be times in the future we're not there yet, and it may not even be this cycle, but it'll be next cycle, where people start to say, sell my Bitcoin, what to buy dollars?

I don't want to buy fiat, I don't want to own fiat. I might want to buy stuff with it. I might want to buy a nice something or other with it. Whatever that something or other is, depending on what I can afford. But then people are gonna start saying I don't want to get paid in fiat. That's true. And that's when things really start turning around because that's true. But that maybe I don't know how long that'd be.

That that could be that could be further out. Yeah. But I was I was thinking back because I was taking my star to tell the story about getting sunburned yesterday. Yeah, yeah, right, right. So I got sunburned and I was bright red from getting the burn. I said I better get myself some some sunscreen.

And I was gonna go walk. Which the hills are pretty steep in San Francisco. So I looked on the app and I found a walk greens, and then I tried to play around with my app to figure out how to walk there. And like my phone's not working. I was like, what the hell is what's wrong with this thing?

And I turned off like every location service that I have, because you know, I don't want the big G chasing me. Yeah, that's just good opsic. Yeah. Only turn on that location services when you absolutely need it. Make sure you turn it off every time. So yeah, it actually is too complicated to turn everything on and turn everything on. I couldn't figure out what it was. I finally figured it out. It's just I'm sure if my kid was there, she'd have gotten it all fixed from me like 15 seconds.

Took me like five minutes. But

I was

Thinking back to the late 90s, and I don't remember when exactly. Don't hold me to this. You know, it could have been 96, 97, could have been 98, 99, I don't remember what it was. But I remember when they first started talking about mobile and there was some map company that was gonna do something spectacular or special.

And you know, we hadn't had that. I don't remember if smartphones had come out yet, or were just kind of in that transitional stage from whatever was before smartphones. What did they call those? Feature phones or something like that? I don't know what they call them. What do they call phones before the smartphones? Cell phones. Cell phones. Yeah.

And what they called it. But I say to myself, wow, I mean, look at this. Look at all this stuff we don't think about. We just take for granted. I saw this happen. I mean, I take it for granted now too, but guys like Grady, who were half my age, they're born into this.

You know, they're they they started using this stuff when it's around. They don't they didn't remember a world that was that didn't have it. And well, I have an advantage of perspective that a lot of people don't have because I think I have a pretty deep understanding of the economic aspect of Bitcoin. I mean, I don't understand the technical aspect. I mean, people explain stuff to me.

I had a wonderful conversation with a guy today who was explaining some stuff to me, and it was very interesting. But I'm not an expert in that. I have some some understanding, some knowledge. But it's just so important, you know, you look back and we again we take the stuff with the mapping so for granted.

And there are a lot of things with Bitcoin that were not there yet. You're still in that stage when I first heard about that company that was doing this thing, potentially with maps and people getting excited about what was gonna happen with mobile. But this go ran is gonna go much, much faster than that, because we're still waiting for a lot of things. There was a lot of hardware stuff and a lot of phone stuff that still had yet to be developed.

This is just software, and this is gonna go much, much, much faster because the hardware infrastructure's already built out. Right. And it just reminded me of the nature of an exponential technology and how quickly this stuff's gonna be, and how we might lose perspective on how fast things really are.

I talked to a kid on DM, and I felt really bad about this kid. I had speak spoken with him on the DM'd him Twitter. Sometime during the, you know, during that bottoming phase. And it was pretty brutal. I don't remember what I talked about with him then, but I was trying to give him my opinion on how fast things were going.

Somebody convinced this guy to sell a lot of his Bitcoin. And he wanted my opinion why I thought bear markets were going to be shorter in the future. And I started talking to him. And so in the process of talking to him, I said, So you still have your Bitcoin, right? He said, I have some. I said, what do you mean you have some?

He says, I mostly cash. I said, you gotta be kidding me. You said you're mostly cash. You only have some. When do what price did you sell this at? He said, oh, right around here. And this was like June 1st.

He said, you sold it right around here. And he said, yeah, and I didn't really actually believe the kid that he said this. He's like a 20-year-old kid. I didn't really believe him. I thought it's just like a face-saving kind of thing. Yeah. He said, you know, still in the bear market. I said, what bear market?

It's 8600. What are you talking about? We're not in a bear market. We haven't been in a bear market for months. We're in a ripped snorting bull market. It's huge. And just from June 1st, I don't know if we're gonna stay here or not. I mean, right now, look at the price. Oh yeah, today's candle is insane. We were higher, we're we're at twelve thousand four hundred seventy something right now.

We're higher, we're like twelve thousand eight hundred maybe. But now we're at 138. Oh, we are, is that wrong? Yeah, that was high. 12,400 was the bottom for today. Are you sure? No, we just had we just had a bit of a big thing. Oh, the red candle came finally. Gotcha, gotcha. That's all right. That was coming, yeah. Yeah, no, i we'll see what happens, but that's okay.

Went to 13,000. I can't remember where where we went. But 138, you went and then puked. Yeah. Well, we'll see what happens. You need to happen. It needs to happen. It just has to happen. And that's alright. We went we went lower. Went to 11, 675. But you gotta get those weak hands out.

You gotta drive them out and they'll sell. And the fiat the fiat maximalists, the traders. You don't wanna be a fiat maximalist. You're gonna lose big in the long run. Don't measure your wealth that way. It's gonna be a mistake. And I know you guys, you think you're so freaking smart. You think you know better. That's okay. You don't know better.

You'll own less Bitcoin in the long run. I promise you, you'll own much less Bitcoin. So yeah, I'm gonna make Bitcoin. I'm gonna make a lot more Bitcoin. And you'll actually be able to enjoy your life. You're gonna make much less Bitcoin. But I know you think you're better, you're smart, but you're not that much better. You're not that smart. You're not Paul Tudor Jones, you're not Stanley Druckenmiller, you're not the world's best trader.

I promise you that. Maybe one or two of you out there are, but honestly, I doubt it. And So this kid he sold a bunch of his Bitcoin. And he sold a bunch of his Bitcoin and he never I don't know what he did if he bought it back.

I said, Well, you still have a chance to buy it back, and he was pretty negative about the nature of the market, convinced that somebody told him we're going lower, so we're gonna go lower. And I would recommend like what the guys on I'm guessing Brady says it too, probably everybody says it's stacks, just stack sats.

Don't try to be don't try to be but I love stacking sats. Maybe too. Stacking sats for its great.

It's hard to know, if you had a chunk of money, you know, maybe you should put the chunk in. I'm not saying you should or shouldn't, because I don't know what the right price is to buy at. I don't know where it's going today or tomorrow or the next day. The main point is, you know, hold, just hold on to it for a long time. See it as a five, ten years. A lot of people also have to, you know, they they have to buy it a little bit at a time.

It depends on what the financial circumstances are. Particularly, particularly younger people who are earning money as they go. So look, you can be more aggressive at age of 25 than a guy who's in his 50s or 60s or 70s. And so maybe you can handle a bigger position in Bitcoin.

You can buy a little less of something and you know give up something, and that may make a big incremental difference in what you're able to do. But there are a lot of things you can do. You're earning an income. If you feel that you have a relatively secure income situation with your job and what you're making, then you can be more aggressive than if you're concerned about it, you should be less aggressive because you do have to work worry about what your what your needs are financially.

I mean you can't be stupid about this. Yeah. You want to be a strong hand, and be a strong hand means you have to be smart. You shouldn't lever, in my opinion. You shouldn't margin yourself. Being overextended makes you weak. It makes you weak. Yeah. And makes you vulnerable. I think the size of this is gonna go to levels that are really shocking.

And I And it's gonna fuck with your head. Well, it will, but I think even I think we go to twenty to fifty million dollars of Bitcoin in fifteen to thirty years, possibly faster, possibly bigger. I don't really know, but as I think 20 to fifty million dollars in today's valuation.

In today's valuation. It's amazing. As it it it absorbs the equivalent the store of value that money is the resset. Right. And a good money that it'll appreciate as global production increases over time, and that value goes into money. It goes, some of it goes to labor, some of it goes to investment, but some of it will go to the general price level of money as priced in real goods and services.

Right, and there's a store of value, like monetary premium in other assets now too, like real estate and it'll come out of those things. You'll have business innovation and risk exposure in assets like real estate and companies and stock, equities.

But I don't think you'll have the store of value. I don't think you'd be searching for where do I want to put

What I want to save. You might want to make an investment, but it'll change the whole nature of the financial landscape. I think we're in an emerging economic paradigm. And I tell this to most people, and a lot of people who think they're sophisticated financially. I'm pretty sophisticated financially. I mean, I may be less so than some, more so than others, but I have pretty good education, and I've traded and looked at markets and done a fair bit of reading over the last 35 years, and so you know, wise guys might like to say, oh, what was your education?

Well, it really doesn't matter what my education was. I've done a lot of work on it. And you don't have to listen to me or agree with me. So if you don't like what I say, just tune me out and turn me off. I mean, I don't really care. You don't have to listen to me. Yeah. I might not listen to you. And it doesn't make a difference. It's all about it's all about trying to learn what you can.

For me. I've got a I've got to go record with Francis Bouliot in three minutes. Okay. For me, if I can't. Let's hear the wrap-up. Absolutely. If I can't make sense of something, if I can't explain something that makes sense to me, there's a good chance it's wrong. It has to make sense. It has to sound right. It has to have some common sense to it. And be something that when I explained it to somebody, he said, you know, that makes sense.

I like that idea. The best ideas are not really complicated. The best are pretty simple. And I think that I think that my views on it are probably right. It doesn't mean that it's a map or roadmap for trading. It's not. But it's broad strokes of what I'm thinking, and I think it's gonna go a lot higher.

And I think that this coming bull cycle is gonna surprise an awful lot of people. Yep. And I don't know where it goes to, but I think it's gotta hit some pretty big numbers and pretty shocking numbers. And I continue to believe all surprises are on the upside. Thanks so much, Tina. Appreciate you, man.

I also met Robert Breedlove, CEO of Parallax Digital at the Beefsteak, and chatted with him throughout the conference. Robert has a great mind, has produced some epic Bitcoin Twitter threads, one of which you're going to hear about now that gets into the fundamentals of the Bitcoin protocol.

Here's my conversation with Robert. Alright, last one for Bitcoin 2019, guys. Sitting here with Robert Breedlove, founder, CEO of Parallax Digital. Met Robert Monday night on the rooftop the beefsteak.

Got to have a nice chat with him. Robert, tell us what Parallax Digital does. Sure. Thanks for having me. Yeah, man. So Parallax Digital operates some crypto asset hedge funds. Okay. And then we're also working on a digital security advisory practice. So trying to navigate and figure out the digital security space.

Right on that we think could be a big deal over the next decade or so. Where are you guys based? Based in Santa Monica. Okay. And we also have an office in Istanbul, Turkey. Very nice. Alright, man. You have produced some epic threads on Twitter. Thank you. So you gotta follow Robert on Twitter. What's your handle at? Is that Robert Breedlove? Yeah, so my last name is Breedlove.

That's B-R-E-E-D-L-O-V-E Love. My handle's at Breedlove22. Alright. So yeah, follow Robert for some amazing tweet threads. He he posted one about a week ago heading into the conference, and I thought we could run through that real quick.

Kind of get the reader's digest condensed version, and of course I'll link to it in the show notes. Awesome. Yeah, yeah, I guess so the inspiration behind the thread was I think there's a lot of jargon in the space, which tends to kind of make us a bit insular at times.

Yeah. Outside world doesn't know what we're talking about, we look like crazies. And it just seems to me like there that we should kind of take it upon ourselves to speak the common tongue a little bit more and actually explain the momentous in innovation that Bitcoin is, what it means for humanity, what it means for personal freedom and sovereignty, frankly.

I think it's very important, you know, especially for people that have been economically slided for for decades and decades. So this was like my attempt at doing that, and you know, I invite others to try and do the same. I think it's an evolving art form, and it's a very important cause. So

I'll kind of just run through the cliff's notes and please jump in with questions as we go. So when you basically when you take a look at the crypto asset universe, which includes Bitcoin and everything else, there's sort of two distinct hemispheres. Right. We have Bitcoin, which is more akin to the internet itself.

Okay. So you know, not many people realize this, but the internet is just a stack of open source protocols. So these are just the commons, if you will, that no one no single entity owns and operates, and that's what enables the internet to work. Right. This stack has four layers to it, and in the same way that the internet is an open set of protocols for moving information.

Bitcoin can be thought of as an open set of protocols for moving value. So we can actually consider it kind of the latest layer in the internet itself. On the other side of the crypto asset universe, we have all of these little projects that have basically adopted Bitcoin's technology and software because it's open source, it's freely available, to either try to compete directly with it, in the case of you know, altcoins, what have you.

Right. Or to enable or disintermediate other markets, like you may have seen with predictions markets and auger, or do say like decentralized lending with maker, things like that. So, in this space, there's Bitcoin, which already has sort of proven itself, though it doesn't really need to change a lot.

Everything else, every other altcoin crypto asset, or whatever you want to call it, we call them just alts, is essentially a venture capital style bet. Maybe one in a hundred succeed meaningfully, possibly. But it's really very important to keep in mind that very few of these projects are subjected to any real due diligence at all.

So there's there's a lot of shit out there. Right. Yep. Which is why we sometimes call them shit coins. Which is why we call them shit coins, exactly. So then you have looking at it through this lens, you can actually consider Bitcoin as owning a piece of the internet almost. It's like as if you could have owned a share of HTTP, a monetizable form of HTTP.

That's what it represents. Right. So then that it's also interesting because you know, Bitcoin is clearly a very modern technological innovation, but you don't grasp its significance and impact by looking at the tech. Right. You actually have to turn backwards and look deep into history. Like what is money, how has it evolved and changed over time?

The quick quick and dirty on money is it is conceptually remained the same. It's a technology for moving value across space and time. That is the purpose of the technology, no matter what form it comes in. But throughout history, it has evolved.

You know, ancient societies used to use stones or beads, eventually salt and cattle, and ultimately, as decided on the free market, it culminated in gold. Which eventually governments, which still is basically the prime money today. You know, all central banks all over the world hold gold and issue paper that was once backed by that gold.

So this evolutionary process, it's I use the analogy in the thread of the telecommunications tech, right? We've all in the same way that telecommunications, the singular purpose of it is to move information across space and time. Even though the actual form has evolved over time, like we've gone from cave paintings to carrier pigeons to the telegraph, to the telephone, to the smartphone, right?

Anytime that the message fidelity or the reliability or the even the mobility of that technology improves, that new form of tech becomes dominant. Right? People stop using the telegraph, start using the telephone, so on and so forth.

With money, it's sort of similar, except that the single characteristic that decides in a free market which form of money becomes dominant is called hardness. Also called soundness. And this hardness of money is quantified.

It's gonna get a little nerdy here, but just stick with me, I'll try to simplify it, by a concept called the stock-to-flow ratio. Right. And the stock to flow ratio can be thought of kind of like the inverse of inflation. Okay. So stock is the existing supply of money, right? Flow is the newly created supply. Right. So the higher the stock to flow ratio, the harder the form of money.

Right. And so if yeah, it so if the supply increases by a couple percent, like one and a half percent, like gold is usually like somewhere in that range, right? One and a half, two percent. That's that's a low stock-to-flow ratio. That is a high stock to flow. High stock to flow ratio. Low inflation. Low inflation. Yes, got it. High stock low flow, yeah.

Kind of easier way to think about it for me and some other people is if you just think of hardness as the difficulty to produce an additional unit of the monetary medium. So what is the cost to mine an ounce of gold? What is the cost to print the US dollar? Right. What does it cost to produce a bitcoin? So when we say hard money in this sense, we're talking about like difficulty really, not not like the fact that it's hard or soft or whatever, like like a like a table might be hard or something like that.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Money it physical.

Good way to do it. Yeah. And this is you know, stock to flow ratio and hardness of money is exactly why gold became dominant in the world. Gold is basically indestructible. So every ounce that's ever been mined throughout human history is still part of the existing supply. Right. So it has a very high stock, right?

It is extremely scarce in the Earth's crust and expensive to extract. Right. So it has a very reliably low flow as well. So this gives gold the highest stock to flow ratio of any commodity money that we have. Right. And it's it has an interesting competitive dynamic where almost all value in the store value market flows to one, right?

Because again, money is a technology with one purpose. Right. Moving value across time and space. If one form can provide that, can satisfy that, then all the value will accrete to it. And that's what we saw with gold. Right. The drawback with gold was the divisibility problem. Because gold is so rare, it's very impractical to pay for your morning coffee with gold coins.

Right. It's just they're too valuable. So basically, governments stepped in to solve this divisibility problem by having gold in a warehouse or in a bank in a vault and then issuing paper receipts for that gold. So this enabled people to transact much more conveniently and easily across space and time, but kept the form of money rooted in reality because it was backed by gold.

So what clearly what happened is once you've centralized gold, the banks and governments that hold it, greed got the best of them, right? As it tends to do. And they eventually issued paper receipts or bank notes in excess of their reserves. And over time, finally culminating in 1971 when Nixon completely removed us from the gold standard.

Yep. And we have just flat out fiat currency now. Right. It's based on literally nothing. Yep. And we've printed a whole hell of a lot of it since 2008. Absolutely. And since that time, the money supply has grown exponentially. We've seen inflation across the board. Because it's it's cut the roots from economic reality.

It's not rooted in economic reality. So it ends up being kind of like a hidden tax. It's like a and it decreases the value of your time over time. That's absolutely right. And it's it's a hidden tax. It's a sh you know, you call it a shadow tax. It's also frankly, it's a flat out violation of private property rights, right?

Right on. You work hard for that money, you put it in a place, you expect it to hold its value. Right. And there's someone behind the scenes that can essentially extract value from you, whether it's under your mattress, in your bank and you're safe, it doesn't matter. Right. And we've been able to see through observation that the people who benefit from the printing of this money when the central bank or you know, Federal Reserve decides to print a bunch of money, are the rich banks.

They're getting the money cheap, then it goes to rich corporations, and then so it's like it's not really benefiting people. We're not like giving it out to the poor the poor people to spend on the economy. Yeah, so this is there's a an effect called the cantalon cantillion effect. Cantillion effect. And it's essentially what you're saying those that are closest to the spigot of liquidity benefit first.

Right. Because they can print this money, they can spend it while it at its maximum value before it enters broader circulation and taxes everyone in the form of price increases. Right. So it it it is a mechanism for wealth distribution. Actually I think Travis Kling said it well. Said quantitative easing is a universal basic income for the rich.

Boom. So that is pretty good. Flips it on its head, and that's pretty much exactly what it is. Yeah. So then we this fiat currency thing's got out of control. We've been printing money like no other, which actually drives the boom and bust business cycle. 2008 was just the latest incarnation of that. And then, you know, in the wake of 2008, this open source project called Bitcoin gets released to the world.

Essentially it is programmed to be the hardest form of money that has ever existed. It has a hard cap of 21 million units, can cannot be changed, basically whatsoever. And every four years, its stock-to-flow ratio doubles. It actually increases slowly over time, but every four years it actually is programmed in the algorithm to double.

Yep. So in May 2020, on or around May 2020 next year, its stock to flow ratio will actually I think it goes to 55, which is right around what gold is, and will continue to increase beyond that. And then again, around the same time in 2024, it will double again. And then we're in completely uncharted territory.

We've never seen a monetary good with a stock-to-flow ratio higher than gold. Yeah. So kind of in a nutshell, is the bet on Bitcoin is that the competitive dynamics that have always shaped money throughout all of history will continue to hold. Yeah. And that's it. That's a pretty good bet to make. Yeah. It's once you see it from this perspective, it makes a lot of sense.

Yeah. But it is so new, you know, it's just over a decade old. And it it takes people a while to become familiar and comfortable with with new technologies. Yeah, man. Dig it. So we've spent a couple of days here talking Bitcoin, a lot of smart people around.

I've talked to a lot of people continue to blow my mind. And you are among those people. Glad to talk to you that that night was really fun. What have you taken away from this conference? What have you been thinking about a lot during this conference? You know, for the listeners out there, we Bitcoin has gone from $3200 bottom in December to today, you know, we're at the end of June, and it was pushing 14,000, I think earlier today.

Yeah. So it's it is on another one of its parabolic aggressive price advances. Which is you know, exciting, but it it just makes you think about it a lot. So it's just been interesting timing with that. But frankly, here at the event, it has been the energy.

I mean, people that are in Bitcoin are in it for what it feels like a purpose or a passion. Certainly there's you know an economic incentive there that's the drives a lot of this as well, but I think more and more people are starting to regard it as a tool for freedom and a way to reclaim sovereignty from governments and central banks.

Yeah. And you know, on balance, I think you know, Bitcoin emerging as a free market monetary alternative to literally monopoly money, you know, kind of pun intended thing. They it's an enforced legal monopoly to use their fiat currency. Right, right. Seeing a free market alternative out compete fiat currencies.

And now that technology can be used, we think applied to other things of value. Oh, that's kind of the digital security thesis, which we can talk about another day. Yeah, but the long arc of human history is bending back towards freer markets. And that's really exciting. It's beautiful, man. I mean, you know, with people have been in servitude and indentured and indebted and mistreated for a long time, and this the promise of this movement represents a shift in that trajectory.

Bitcoin is freedom, bitcoin is freedom. Absolutely. Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. All right, yeah. To finish up, I recorded some thoughts with my good friend Guy Swann of the Crypto Economy Podcast. Guy was my first Bitcoin friend, the first Bitcoiner I got to know well outside of Bitcoin Twitter.

It was a lot of fun to get to meet him in person and spend a lot of time together throughout the conference. Here we're standing on the sidewalk outside our Airbnb at like 2 a.m. On the last night of the conference, just reviewing the week and talking about Bitcoin's future.

We are standing outside our airbnb in San Francisco, California. It's the end of the Bitcoin 2019 conference. We're both kind of drunk. Thank you, Peter McCormack, for the for the beers. Not true. And the whiskey. I don't drink. I'm responsible. What a fucking conference, man.

Dude, oh my god, that was a fucking blast. It was literally, it was literally magical. I like I feel like I've been upping my game on conferences. I went to Cryptolina, then I went to magical crypto conference. Cryptolina. In Carolina, North Carolina. Yeah, the best thing, the only the only good thing about Cryptolina was Jeremy and Jameson.

I gotta hang out with the Casa crew. Alright. They rescued Cryptolina then they did, they did. There were some there was some really nonsense line. Soon. I'm hoping. That's fingers crossed for a video to get there. But then we went to MCC.

But this one, this one takes the cake right now. This one's this one's gonna be the bar going forward. Yeah, I'm very glad that we came. Legit, thank you for the place to stay. The last minute, man. Dude, seriously. I was scrambling on Sunday and we chatted about that about the shit.

We recorded it. He was like, you know, come on, man. You know, you can you could you could stay at stay at our Airbnb, and it's like, you know, let me know. Let me know if you have the plan. This all happened because Justin Moon got sick. It really did. It really did. Thank you, Justin Moon for your weak immune system.

Oh shit. Oh shit. Poor Justin's getting talk shit on. He does not even hear. Yeah, that's why it happened though, because then I called Guy. I was like, let's do this episode. Emergency back me up. Get my back. And got on, and I was like, you gotta come out, man. You gotta come out. You were the last one for Aren't you going to the conference?

Right? And it's like, okay. Yeah. So we gotta I gotta bite the bullet and just have it happen. Made it happen, man. Yeah. Got to meet so many amazing Bitcoiners. God. And you know. Shit, man. These people were so cool. So kind, so genuine, so approachable.

Every single person. Like there was not a single person that was I mean, Adam back. Just hanging out. Like, Adam back is the biggest sweetheart in the world. Amazing. Except for maybe except for maybe Pierre Rochard, who is actually like he gets That's true. I mean, that dude is fucking amazing. So genuine, so cool.

Wow. Pierre is impressed by that guy. Pierre is such a just he's just like a golden boy. It's as soon as like like he he was super nice at the lightning workshop, and that was my first actually meeting him. But he's nothing but he's nothing but smiles and like happy to meet everybody. Marty and Matt, cool, I mean just like I barely got to hang out.

Barely got to hang out with Marty and Matt, but I'm glad I got to say hey and like chill for just a minute. I got to go I gotta have another good talk with Aaron Varmortum. I'm gonna have I really want to have him on the show soon, host. Steph L Stephan Livera, man. Stefan, Stefan! He's the man. Oh my god, Stefan. Yes. He's absolutely the man. And got to meet me. I had not I had yet to speak to him in person until here.

That was a good one. We got what who else did we talk to at El Rhea? God, that was a good night. I drank too much. I forgot most of it. Oh man. Anthony. Anthony. We met Christy, the editor of Christine Andrew, Andrew Fleming.

Yes. Oh my god, dude. Everything Bitcoin magazine is doing. The guys from Wasabi. Wasabi Aviv, Av. Yes. Yes. We gotta hang out with those guys. Everything Bitcoin magazine is doing right now. Like, I'm super excited about. Yeah. Like the fact that they put this whole thing together just kind of blows my mind. Jack Mahler's is amazing.

I spent I spent like an hour hanging out with his parents tonight. You know? Like at Peter McCormack's party. Thanks again, Peter. That was great, man. Seriously that was. Oh, and you know, shout out shout out Dropbit for you know, fronting the whole thing. Lots of people. Oh, was that Drop Bit? I think it was Drop Bit that sponsored the party.

Oh, nice. Yeah. Yeah, those guys are killing it right now. Yeah. I actually hung out at their booth for a little while. Chatted with the Dropbit guys. Nice. The Nodel guys. Dude, they were my totems. They were my totem. They're absolute ballers. Every time, every time I got exhausted, I hung out with them and like Pura Vita.

Like I would just go to their booth and it would just sit down and I'd be like, alright, I'm gonna chill here for a minute. Recharge. Yeah. Jeremy Welch, we saw him tonight, man, from Casa. Yeah, where was he at the conference? I didn't see him much at the conference, but he wasn't. He he said he just showed up for the party. That was it. He just showed him to town and had a lot of people.

Like you do, you know. What were some of the best speeches you saw? I it's that was the presentations, panels, whatever. I saw I saw one with Stefan. Stefan Stephan Livera when I don't even remember the name. I don't it was the first one that he did because I missed the second one.

And then I saw one with Aaron Aaron Von Mortem on Oh good Lord, they were about Bitcoin. I missed, I literally missed. I have to go back and watch all of these on YouTube because I genuinely missed like at least three quarters of the talks.

Well, yeah, I was like I was out just talking and networking. When you're here, like you come to these conferences, not because like the panels are gonna be on the web. So when you come here and you pay the money to travel and buy the ticket and everything, the value is in walking around and meeting people in person. Yeah, I just I would get stuck. I would get stuck in a conversation, and then we'd be we'd be talking like like Alex, Alex from Lolly.

Yeah. Like we just we just that guy runs a mile a minute. Like that guy was like on like just running, and I was like, oh my god, and we just we talked for like I don't know, an hour. We gotta shout out another Alex, man, Alex Svetsky. That guy is unc just incredible, man. Svetsky. What an amazing dude. Svetsky is amazing.

Yeah. Svetsky kills me. Yeah, man. I can't believe like it was crazy to meet. It's amazing how many people like that are that were just Twitter logos for like 30 people that were just nothing but Twitter logos. And it's like, oh, like here you are in real life, and let's have a conversation.

And Brecki listened to Brecky's freaking morty live. Killed me. At the open node at the open node was hilarious. Yeah, the all the dudes from open node, man, were pretty pretty fun to hang out with. Yeah, I got to chat with the open node guys. I got a chat with two guys from Kraken.

I wish I could remember so many names. The Snowden the Snowden this morning was amazing, man. Like I missed it. From like five or six people that that was like really really good. And he was he was I was distraught that I didn't get there until like 10 o'clock. Massive standing ovation at the end. Really? Which he was like he was he like blushed and was embarrassed.

Like I was I was like, you know, that guy being shunned by his home country, getting massive love. Like a there was, you know, over a minute, probably two minutes standing ovation. No kidding. Just yeah, I must feel good. There is not there is no like it's hard to imagine that cost.

Yeah. Like particularly for what you believe in. Yeah. You know, and like I truly think that that's why it's why like 95% of us are here is because of what we believe in. And there is nobody that proved it as much as that fucking guy. That's true.

You know, yeah. Like I would have a like like I feel like I believe it to my core, but like that would tear my whole world apart to think that that was the cost that I had to pay for it. Th thinking about doing what he did and just you know, k knowing the consequences, yeah, the potential consequences.

Yeah. And like basically what he's achieved is probably the best case scenario, which is not that great for him. Legit, yeah. Yeah, seriously. Like, like it could be a hell of a lot worse. He's yeah. God, that's crazy. It's absolutely crazy. Well on a similar level, Lynn Ulbrecht wa gave a speech on the PvP stage.

And I was down there and I and I was fortunate enough to speak with her for a little bit, and that was hard. Like I did not get to speak to Lynn, which sucks. I really did want to talk to her. I didn't see her after that. Look at the Silk Road 2.0. If you look at he got nothing. Nothing. And if you look at other similar convictions, there was a slide of like another dozen similar convictions, nothing more than 10 years.

And he got two lifetimes plus 40. And how m how how how long has he been in already? Like seven? Yeah. Yeah. Like just and he's in like max security prisons and shit. Yeah. I mean, it's just terrible joke. It's a total joke. Like it's a travesty of justice. It would be hilarious if it wasn't so devastating.

Go to Freeross.org, donate some money, sign the petition. It's terrible. Yeah, but anybody anybody who's who's listened to me has not signed the petition, you suck. You gotta do it right now, right? Yeah, they're at like 180,000 signatures. She went Lynn told me today that she wants to get to 500k. So we got some work to do.

Week We got really really heavy. Really heavy, really heavy moments. But yeah, all in all, like, you know, we're we're on the verge of something massive. And I have been feeling since we talked on Sunday and got just super bullish at the end of the episode, like I've been feeling that there's we're on the verge of an inflection point in the S curve of adoption.

Last 20 years included. But the next 20 even more potently. One of the biggest shifts in just civilization. Just like how things are organized, how like what degree of control people have over their own lives.

Yeah. Like what the idea of liberty is and what it means to be sovereign. Yeah. Like the sovereign individual, that book. I still haven't finished it, but I'm about a third of the way through it and it keeps getting better. So and it keeps ringing truer and truer. And it's phenomenal how much Bitcoin applies to exactly that possibility to where we're headed in the future.

And I think we're seeing something that's just like on a on a scale of millennia is one of the most important shifts in just humanity that we've ever seen. Yeah, the pendulum is swinging back toward individual liberty. And I think that started hundreds of years ago.

I think democracy was a big step forward in that regard. Oh yeah. Have you ever read the 5,000 year leap? No. Ooh. Oh, you gotta read that one. Yeah. You gotta read that one. It's about it's about how the idea of really the idea of individual liberty and the idea of a republic that puts the individual ahead of the state was an absolute breakthrough.

And yeah, when it's in democracy, I should have said republic, I think. Is that like all of modern society is just a almost like an echo of that just extending. You gotta read the 5,000 year league. Yeah. You gotta dig into that one. Yeah, I think this is I think Bitcoin is like a continuation of this move toward individual freedom.

Yeah, without experiencing for a while now. And yeah. And Yeah, the

Idea of you know, I'm not I'm not against a state. I'm not g in in the sense of like, you know, regulations and common sense like laws and justice and this the seeking of truth in society and enforcing more morality.

I think those are staples of humanity, like of just wanting to interact with others. Right. Like it's a consequence of but with other people. The pendulum is swung toward this, you know, toward centralization of control of justice and of money to such an extreme that you know Bitcoin's gonna pull it back toward the middle and balance things again.

It takes such a powerful tool out of out of the hands of a essentially a poorly directed like like Bitcoin well just money in general. Money in s is such a fundamental. It's when we put our lives, our labor and our time on the line for what we think about the world or what our vision of the world is.

Like when I go to work or I like put my time into something that I think is valuable, that's the vision of the world that I'm trying to make. And my expenditure of capital or money is in the direct like creation of that, you know. I think it's the ultimate form of free speech because it's cheap to say things, but it is not cheap to put your money where your mouth is.

One of the absolute highlights of this week for me was getting to meet you in person, dude. Yeah, yeah, dude. We have not. We've not d give it g give give give me a hug. Bring it in. Bring it in. Bring it in. Yeah, man. Dude, this is a this is great. Absolute blast. Thank you for the housing.

You're welcome, dude. Of course. What a conference. Thank you to Bitcoin Magazine and BTC Media for putting this on. Christian, dude. Absolutely. Christian, I got to meet Christian. I got to meet Christy, Andrew, David. It got to meet David and Graham from the Bitcoin Magazine Podcast. Awesome, man.

Dude. You guys, you guys killed it, dude. That conference is amazing. Well done. Seriously. Hats off. We'll be here next year. It's in March, right? Is that what she's saying? It's not even, they don't even give me 12 months to prepare. It's gonna be in March, huh? I gotta change my schedule. I'm sure I have something planned for March.

It's my birthday month. So nice. We'll celebrate it out here, man. All right, man. Alright, let's let's go to bed. Yes, let's do it. Alright, guys. Out. Out. Alright, alright.

Guy and I were a little saucy there. We got into the I love you, man. Bitcoin's gonna save the world territory, getting a little cosmic thanks to the beer and whiskey. But it was a lot of fun to wrap up the conference that way. Let us know what you guys thought on Twitter.

I'm at Citizen Bitcoin. You can tag all these folks as well. If you have been enjoying the podcast, getting a lot out of it, I would really appreciate it if you'd rate and review the podcast on Apple Podcasts or wherever you can rate and review the pod. If you can't do that, just sharing it on Bitcoin Twitter, sharing an episode with a comment on a thought you had to contribute is a massive way to support the show.

So thanks to all of you who take time to do that. It's really important to me and I really do appreciate it. All right, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

This episode compiles some audio I collected walking around the Bitcoin 2019 conference in San Francisco. So, go into this one imagining you’re at Bitcoin 2019 having conversations in various corners with some great bitcoiners. I talk to Jack Maulers, Bitcoin TINA, Lyn Ulbricht, Nick Ward from Layer One BTC, Robert Breedlove of Paralax Digital, Ti Kawamoto, Steve Jeffress, Terrance Yang, Gus GG from Artolin.org and Guy Swann and myself finish it up with a reasonably drunken conversation outside our AirBnB in SF on the final night of the conference after Peter McCormack’s odd yet super fun dueling piano bar party.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast

Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop

Citizen Bitcoin Layer ONE merch collection

Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek

Links from the show:

(Timelapse of Greg Mike’s mural at Bitcoin 2019)[https://twitter.com/bitcoin2019conf/status/1150866230900867075]

(Artolin and Gus GG on Instagram)[https://www.instagram.com/artolin_blockchain/]

(Zap Wallet)[https://zap.jackmallers.com/]

(Bitcoin 2019 Conference Panels and Presentations)[https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLe0djdakvnFbCL9S6ft7e_knxG1utsEaB]

Downloads