All episodes
Episode 40

Basement Bulletin w/ CK: Bitcoin 2019 Conference Recap, Energy FUD, Libra

June 30, 201960 min

Christian, aka CK Snarks, member of the BTC Media team, the bitcoin half of the POV Crypto podcast, hosted us at his place in San Francisco and joined us for this Basement Bulletin episode in which we recap the Bitcoin 2019 conference, talk about this past month's crazy price action, get into Libra and an energy FUD smack down breaks out.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Hello and welcome back to another episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We are podcasting our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. I'm Brady. Hey Bitcoiners, hope you all are well, enjoying a nice weekend. I just got back from San Francisco and the Bitcoin 2019 conference, and what a great week it was.

Props to BTC Media for hosting a fantastic conference. It was amazing. For this month's basement bulletin episode, the episodes in which my friend Tommy and I recapped the month in Bitcoin with a fellow Bitcoiner. We wrapped up and reviewed the Bitcoin 2019 conference from a fellow Bitcoin podcaster's living room in SF instead of the basement of the old church that is now Tommy's home in Lawrence, Kansas.

So Christian, aka C K Snarks on Twitter, a member of the BTC Media team, and the Bitcoin half of the POV Crypto Podcast hosted us for this basement bulletin episode. Alright, let's get into it. Here we go.

All right, here we are for a basement bulletin episode, but we are not in the basement of the church in Lawrence, Kansas.

We are not. We are sitting in a beautiful with a beautiful view of the San Francisco Bay the day after Bitcoin 2019 conference, sitting here with CK. Yep, what's up, guys? From Bitcoin, BTC Media, I should say, and POV Crypto Pod, which you should check out.

It's a really fun podcast that Christian does with his friend David, and David's in Ethereum an Ethereum is what he calls himself, right? Etherean. I call him Eth heads. An ETH head. And they they have fight night episodes where they go back and forth about Bitcoin and Ethereum, and they have interview great interview episodes with Bitcoiners and Ethereans.

Good stuff to check out. We thought we'd do like a the recap of June 2019 with Christian because we kick you know finished off this month at the amazing Bitcoin 2019 conference. Man, you guys just killed it. Thank you. How long have you guys been working on this?

We announced it in January, so about half a year. Yeah. Yeah, most of 2019 was dedicated to making it happen, making it happen. So when BTC Media decided to refocus on Bitcoin, I assume that one of the main plays from the beginning was gonna be to get this conference going.

Is that true? Yeah, so BTC Media, we operate the Let's Talk Bitcoin Podcast Network, Bitcoin Magazine, and now the Bitcoin Conference. Prior to us announcing last January that we're gonna go 100% Bitcoin. We also operated a brand called Distributed, and all of our conferences were branded under Distributed.

We had a website as well as a podcast called Distributed Dialogues.

Yeah. We were doing a lot of things, and the only thing that people really cared about were and Aaron Van Wertem articles about Bitcoin magazine. And you know, it took several people to talk to management and just kind of saying, like, hey, we're all Bitcoiners, why are we doing all this extra stuff?

Yeah. But it became increasingly clear near the end of twenty eighteen that the biggest gap in the market was a company really focused on the Bitcoin market and not, you know, not all the other blockchain stuff. Right. So we felt like we were in the best position to kinda like capitalize on that and undoubtedly you know, g move forward and I wholeheartedly agree with the decision to go that direction.

Honestly the company became a way better place for me to work after that. Yeah, I bet. I mean having focus is helpful and I you know, you're you're a bit coiner, so yeah, I mean all of us are Bitcoiners. Yeah. Something incredible about our about our sales team. There's four guys in our sales team, every single person on the team runs a full node. That's what my that's that's f that's great.

Yeah. So true Bitcoin is the way it should be. Yeah, so I don't what what was the highlight of the conference for you guys? Tommy, what'd you really appreciate? Well, I just appreciated the overall comprehensive uhness of it. I mean, any anything that y you wanted to learn was there also just the fact that it was split out from the standpoint of there was a large room where they had the main panels and main talks which were more comprehensive overall topics, and then there was another area that was split out with people, it was more peer to peer where there it

Was where you could discuss or where they were discussing or having presentations on specific topics. Yeah, it was a little smaller space and people would, you know, break into conversations after the presentations down in the P2P room. That was pretty good. Right. Well, and the other the other aspect of it, just the overall venue was was the very top level, and you kinda have to visualize it, but the very top level w where the main event room was.

If you walked a ways a ways over, it was directly on the rooftop of the overall building where you could go outside, and it just so happened that it was absolutely glorious out. So it was it was wonderful from the standpoint of going out and catching the fresh air. And then additionally, there was a separate one floor down between the P2P and the main was in the main room.

There was an area where there was a lot of exhibitors that just with what I would call cutting edge or state-of-the-art type of crypto. It was primarily you know Bitcoin, but you know, solutions and services and products, which helped you be able to go and talk to people specifically about those particular you know technologies and products.

Yeah, there was a lightning enabled arcade in that area too, which I played with a little bit. Put a video up on Twitter of me playing Pac-Man via lightning, which was pretty sweet. Like it's kind of I love the you know Pac-Man's my favorite arcade game from back in the day, and whenever I see it like at a bar, I always gotta play at least one game.

And so I saw that I'm like, you know, mixing this like old tech that I loved as a kid, and then you know, they had a you know pay with lightning was well, they had a pinball machine, there was also asteroids, and there was Space Invaders, yeah, Space Invaders, which is just you know totally baller. So I mean, you know, it was great.

So the story behind how that happened was really early on the open node team reached out to us because they noticed that we were accepting Bitcoin but not lightning, and they're like, yo, we gotta we gotta fix that. We need to get you guys accepting lightning easy. And that quickly escalated to them being like, let's just set up the entire conference, like lightning enable it.

And they just kept throwing such good ideas at us. And ultimately, after a couple calls with their team, we were like, hey, like we can we can retrofit these old machines with with these little like lightning modules. Yeah. And they actually connected us with BTC socialist on t on Twitter. Okay.

And he he's an English guy, and he's just like always tinkering around with like these like little gadgets and messing with lightning. And you know, he was like, Yeah, you know, if you guys give me a ticket and you know help me get to San Francisco, you know, I can rig all this stuff up for you guys. Fantastic. And it just it just, you know, it was really just like open node being really into it, BTC socialist being into it, and us being open-minded, and you know, it it turned into something really cool.

It was way cool. There was some amazing art there as well. I'll drop a link in the show notes, and I'm forgetting his name right now. I remember his first name was Gus that I spoke with, but there's about four or five artists that have kind of a business going now where they do Bitcoin crypto related art, and this guy had some really cool augmented reality stuff.

Oh yeah. Oh man, it was so cool. And Josie too also had the augmented reality. There's a couple of that where it's just like it's a look like a normal piece of art, and then you put on the headset or you like get your phone and yeah, like all this stuff is just encoded into it. It's pretty cool. Yeah, yeah, there's a Dorian Nakamoto one bit one BTC bill, like a green bag that looks like a dollar bill, but it says one BTC and Dorian's in the middle, and you like hold it up, and then his like eyebrows start going up and down, and he's like frowns a little bit more at you and stuff.

Like it's amazing. And so Crypto Graffiti was the person who curated the entire art show, and he is a true MVP because apparently he's friends with Dorian Nakamoto, and he brought Dorian. Dorian was there, man. Dorian Nagamoto was just hanging out. I got to talk to him for a little bit. He's a Bitcoiner.

Bitcoin, yeah, he's a Bitcoiner now. He's gotten into it. He's gotten into it. Like by you know, no fault of his own, but now he's like going to conferences and like he's really he's into it. I saw Bitcoin Tina got a picture of Dorian Nakamoto and Adam back together. That's just amazing. It's it's like a work of art. It's gonna go down in Bitcoin history, I think it's like Dorian's just kind of like it looks like an album cover of some kind.

Dorian's kind of looking off to the side, Adam's back hair is going crazy like like Einstein style.

If they don't know, Bitcoin Tina is a man. Some people wonder. So yeah. Bitcoin Tina is a man. He's a man. He's done a he's on a so you folks out there following thinking bit Bitcoin Tina's a woman, he's not. Well, most of them most no, because he's done he's on an epic podcast. For a little levity, I had to throw that in there.

So this is there is no alternative. It is interesting name choice, I do have to say. And he's for an interesting man. It was really funny. New Yorker, really fun to get to meet him. Yeah, that that was probably the best part of the conference, was just you know, meeting all these people, and that's why you come to these conferences. It's not like I probably I think I saw four or five presentations I sat all the way through, and I wanted to make sure I saw kind of m my must-see list, but then I spent the rest of the time just networking and meeting people and talking and getting audio.

And yeah, I was just impressed with the that bitcoiners are a diverse group, and but one thing I think that most of them have in common is like everyone's just really curious and interesting, you know. And Bitcoiners like have other interests that they're like, you know, nerd out about.

And what I really enjoy doing was like just you know, we chat about Bitcoin or whatever, but then like what else are you into and finding out, you know, all kinds of things, man, all over the map. A lot of rabbit holes. A lot of rabbit holes up and down. Yeah, it was great. So I had a lot of fun conversations about a lot like non-big a lot of non-bit Bitcoin topics this week. It was great.

Carnivore? No, but I do eat a lot of meat. I eat mostly meat. I'm kind of keto-ish, you know. So I eat I'll eat some vegetables and stuff. I try to stay away from the breads. I'll eat, I still drink beer though. Can't I have a hard time giving up beer, man. I'm I'm a I like meat, so I'm a carnivore and fresh veggies guy.

I try to eliminate whites, processed food, sugar, stuff like that. So we're on the same page. The food was good there too, man. Yeah, actually it was so good I had the same thing twice, but I have a tendency to do that. But anyway, if it's really good, I don't want to ruin my experience by by going too far away from it.

So yeah. The barbecue was was that barbecue they had with spec or whatever you want to call it was spectacular. They had the Asian barbecue. That was good. That's what I had to. The Snowden keynote the second morning was amazing. I it was major vibe moment going on there at the end with the standing ovation for like two minutes, you know.

I think he just really knocked it out of the park. I thought the best part of the Snowden interview was David Bailey, the CEO who was interviewing him, asked him if he held Bitcoin. He didn't want to answer that, but he did say that the server that he used to publish the leaked documents, he paid for the server with Bitcoin, and I thought that was just that was a fantastic way to end the interview.

It really was. You brought it all home in. It was awesome. Well, that was but what about the interview prior to that with Eric Voorhees, right? That was that was kind of interesting as well, right? It was there's some kind. I was gonna say Eric very bold with the green shirt. Yeah, right? He he just shows up on stage with a green shirt that says Bitcoin across his chest.

Yeah. So that was an interesting choice. Right. Isn't green like the color that Bitcoin Cash was with? Yeah, that's what I thought. Yeah, interesting choice. I thought that I mean I thought it was gonna kind of be an opportunity for Eric to be like a little bit more you know, like just straight up maybe apologize for some stuff.

But I don't think he feels I guess he just I don't know if you all use it, but it's it's too cute by half. In other words, he just you know, I think Well, I just think he doesn't he doesn't think he needs to, which is fine. I agree with that. And I was talking to Francis Boulio about it on a pod that I recorded yesterday with him, and he said that he went and talked to Eric afterwards and just like alright, we're done, you know, like this water in the bridge at this point, whatever, we don't need to talk about it anymore.

It's been kind of you know, it's time to put it behind us, I guess, kind of thing. Wait, so Francis said that to Eric? Yeah, I mean interesting. And he's not saying like we're not gonna talk about from talk about it anymore from like an education perspective, like it's important to have to like talk about history and people need to be you know told about this kind of history and stuff.

But like I basically he was like eh, yeah, I'm I'm over I'm over it personally. Yeah, but I but people forget that time period though. That that two month, whatever that two or three month time period was really pretty intense with respect to this New York agreement, what those guys were attempting to try to do, okay. And it was brutal. I mean, it was it was it was brutal what they were trying to do, and it's difficult to just wave it off, you know what I mean?

Yeah, yeah. Yeah, they thought they could kind of control Bitcoin from a top down in a top-down way, and that's just not Bitcoin. It turned out to be a great thing that it happened, you know. It needed to happen, and we learned a lot about Bitcoin governance that we didn't that we didn't know for sure before until it actually happened, because he could kind of theorize about all this stuff.

But yeah, now we're gonna be able to do that. But he also had to you he also had to hand it to him to get to come back and get up on stage and do that in a large large audience with you know with his peers and what what whatever people would say that way, but you know, so I mean you gotta give him that, right? Yeah, for sure. Yep, yep. If I could add anything, I would say that Eric Lambroso is the man.

Yeah. Like every everything was phenomenal. I thought he was phenomenal. Yeah, I mean, but even before that, like every time on Twitter or whatever, like he's just such a level-headed and just honest kind of like person in Well, he's like, you know, the term equanimity, it's like he just it's that's like him, right?

It's just you know, so yep, yeah. Yeah, he called himself a Bitcoin pragmatist when he was up on the stage. He's like, I'm not I'm not a Bitcoin maximalist, I'm a Bitcoin pragmatist. Whatever works, I'm that's what I want to use. You know, and that's kind of his personal idea. It was fantastic because it was so matter-of fact, and just the way he he said it, and it was also you could just tell the way he said it is that's what he really means.

You know, it wasn't like he just sought it up. I mean, it was just like it just rolled right off his tongue, right? And it was it was great. Yeah. How do you guys feel about Bitcoin maximalism? I mean I am I guess I don't know if I would call myself a maximalist or not.

I guess I am. I mean, I do believe that you know, in monetary maximalism and technical like maximum of network protocols. So, you know, network protocols tend to converge toward one and monies tend to converge toward one. So it just makes sense that we'll get there.

I think you know, there could be a space for that, you know, there's just there's so much possibility that there could be space for some other niche chains to exist, but I think it's gonna be at you know a massive Pareto, maybe like not even pret, like more than that, maybe 99% value accrues to Bitcoin kind of thing.

99.1, 955, something like that. I think that's called the maximalist, isn't it? Yeah. So yeah, I mean it's some people, you know, I think in their head, maximalist is like 100 or nothing, bitch, you know. Like you know what I mean? And that's fine. I get that. I you know, I enjoy those people. I like conviction.

Tina. Yeah, right. I appreciate conviction. Yeah. So I think that I would probably be more in that category, but I think it's important to maintain always maintaining a level of skepticism in terms as you move forward things and continue to check through it. But as it sits right now, Bitcoin is a stalwart.

I mean, if you look at it, and you can go through, I mean, you can just start with the Lindy effect, right? You know, and just briefly, you know, that's the longer something's been around, the likelihood that it's gonna continue to be around, you know, and when you're related to technology and other other there's other areas as well. But anyway, so that you've got that, and then you get into simple, what but really aren't simple, but simple things like for the example, Bitcoin's never been hacked, right?

So you've got the situation if you go to start to compare it, for example, to ETH Ethereum, I always get caught up with Ethereum where I just put an X through it from the original situation where they where the top people rolled rolled back the chain in order to split it into Ethereum c you know, the Dow or whatever that was, that that hack.

And at that point I said to myself, well th that's automatically when you compare it to Bitcoin, it's kinda like that one's that one's out of way. And that's Ethereum's kind of the next closest one. So for me it's a situation where I'd be looking for something to come in that's a completely new technology that that leapfrogs Bitcoin, right?

Which I don't I you know, and I've done a little bit of assessment with respect to the co quantum computers and that type of thing. And I think it's and I and I am no way it's a completely anecdotal, no way no where that is, right? But I mean the idea is I think that's a long ways off. So at the end of the day I'm pretty much think, you know, Bitcoin's a stalwart, so I guess I'd be more in the category of a maximalist.

So right on man. What about you, Christian? So I definitely think from an investment advice perspective, yeah, Bitcoin all the way. Like if you get your mom to get into crypto, like I'm not ever gonna tell her to buy it. This is an investment advice perspective that's not investment advice, right? Yeah, by the way, everything on our show is does not get involved with any type of investment and you have to do your own with everything, you gotta do your own due diligence.

Sure. Yeah. I know I love when everyone whenever anyone says that just ri it's right before they're about to give investment advice. But it's I mean, I think that most people saying like everything is shit and it's all about Bitcoin, like most of the time that that's like almost strictly investment advice. But outside of that, there's just so much confusion out there.

Yeah that anyone who's like all season is over, none of that is gonna happen again, like they're completely out of touch. So I think that you know obviously Bitcoin is like like you said the solar and it's gonna win and that's you know 99% of my crypto holdings but on the flip side like you know there's people are gonna keep pumping coins there's just such a massive incentive to you know create your own coin, pump it, all that kind of stuff.

Like you know, printing money is printing money. It's awesome. Yeah. So you know people are gonna keep doing that and you know I sometimes I wear you know these Bitcoin shirts, especially if I'm going to like you know my conference or meetups or whatever, and every single time I get in an Uber, someone's like, oh do you work for Bitcoin? Yeah. Like Somebody asked me last night I was wearing a stacking sat shirt from Nick Ward's layer one BTC shop and this dude walks up to me and he's like do you work for stacking sats?

And I'm like I do. Yes, I work for stacking sats. And I was like I was I wasn't sure if he was serious for a little bit but yeah he was totally serious. So somebody out there thinks stacking sats is a company. It's just a an SF thing because everyone just wears their startup t shirts all the time. So if you're wearing a t shirt with some random phrase it's probably startup.

Right, exactly. That's pretty that's pretty cool. Yeah it's good. It's good stuff. So what else happened this month? So much so much. I mean we gotta talk about price. It's our thing we by the way I must say you got your rockets early on when you started with the Rockets and which was always great which I love which is always great but but I would I was like okay but you got it you got it this past month for sure.

Yeah, I'd like to do I always for a little while there I love to do like silly amateur TA and throw on a bunch of emojis and it would just piss time well like crack you up I guess. No, it would crack me up because I found you. Well well the thing the time used to give me lots of shit about that. Well at the just we'll just take a second, but at the time we had these charts and it was when when Bitcoin had run all the way up, and I think it was January of 2018.

I'm not exactly sure, but Bitcoin was was like 13,000, 14,000, and then it came down to 12 and was going through 10. And when it hit, I just remember this. So so I have a funny thing with stuff like this sometimes. So anyway, so it was around eight or nine thousand, and so Brady had a chart, and this is what we did our first three podcasts on YouTube, and then we found out well it weren't podcasts, they're actually YouTube's then.

We found out and we released them as as podcast to lists on on audio, and then we ended up switching over. But it was one that we were doing where we showing people the charts on YouTube. And Brady, when it came down to around eight or nine thousand going forward, Brady put rockets, you know, to head back up to like ten or eleven or whatever. He had like seven or eight rockets, and to his point, I don't know what was confound me or annoy me or whatever.

I was like, I was like, dude, okay, listen, there's there's two ways this is gonna work. We're gonna have to show, we're gonna have to actually show what do you think in the because he was really good at doing the different levels, right? So on the downside, what are we looking at? And on the upside, so on the rockets, okay, you know, you don't we don't really know, right? So that's all that's the backstory on that, but that was a thing.

But you're right. So finally the rockets finally kicked in this month, and we digress. We went from 8500 June 1st uh-ish to God, where do we peek at or during the conference? Almost we almost touched 14, didn't we? Yeah, and now it's below 11. Now we're yeah, we have a giant red candle in the day. The B 19 pump. Oh, it's a 10-7.

Look at that. The V19 pump is over. Yeah, yeah. So it's June 27th, so. Bitcoin 2019 PR team freaking killed it and drove pushed Bitcoin up almost 100%. Yeah. We manipulated the market for the conference. Yeah, he was like some kind of David Bailey put together some bot.

Like what was it? What was the name of that bot? Williebot or something like that? What was the name of that bot? Yeah. That that was Carpellis Carpellis used for MountGucks. The Willy bot. The Willy bot, yeah. It's true. Yeah, Willie bought 2.0. Yeah, WillieBot 2.0 came out, and now we've retraced most of that. Yeah, maybe. But that retraced fast. We're still up you know, 3k.

Well, two and a half. That's okay with 10k Bitcoin. You gotta this is this is a this is the actually we're talking about this because you know that run-up was insane. You get you're just waiting for the red candle to come. It's a matter of time. Well, you said that. You said that several times. And Bitcoin, when it's on bull runs, goes on 30% pullbacks. That's what it does. So we touched.

But it was great for the conference because occasionally when there was a little breakout or whatever, they would just put they would put on the screen. Yes. The Bitcoin price, and it was going up and everyone. Oh, it was so much fun. It was great, it was perfect timing. Huge, tremendous vibrational energy going on. It was a good time to buy a model with some BTC. Yeah. Yeah, did you buy one?

I did, but I bought it before the conference, so you know I thought we were gonna be at a I think I bought it at like right when we were touching 9K, got rejected around 9K, bought it up there, and I was like, ah, that was a good spot to buy, but no. I definitely I gave them some nice BTC value for my nodel.

I think I bought my knotty around 3k Bitcoins. Yeah, it was a buy and replace, so you know, no harm, no foul for me, but still yeah, they they they got some quality sats. That's awesome, man. Good price point on the sats. Selling stuff for BTC during the bear market is awesome. Yeah, it's true.

It's true. So yeah, this is gonna be where it looks like we're getting maybe this 30% pullback almost in in one day. And it'll be interesting to see where we go from here. But I think we're gonna stay above 10k now. Since we ran all the way up to 14. So let's see if that's gonna be the floor. Crazy though.

The bear market is, I guess, you know, obliterated at this point, right? VJ Boyapati put out a thread this month about the differences between bull and bear markets. And basically, you know, there are several great points that are all definitely linked to it, but one the it kind of boils down to you know, in a bear market, good news doesn't help.

It doesn't do anything to the price, right? And in a in a bull market, bad news isn't doesn't do anything to price either. Just kind of like riding the waves of traders at this point. I don't know. You guys think you guys think we're at we're done with the with this with this bear market? Are we gonna like go sideways now for a while after this crazy run off the bottom?

Well, I think the most interesting thing is someone recently posted the Google trends information on buy Bitcoin, and there's very little movement there, which kind of indicates that retail's not paying attention to that. And I guess I would kind of think back, I'm class of 2017 Bitcoiner.

So trying to think back to you know when I started paying attention to Bitcoin in 2017, and it was around the 3k mark. At that point, it was already 3x the previous all-time highs. So I think it's pretty reasonable to assume that retail's really not gonna like fully get excited about this until we're well above previous all-time highs.

So it'd be like 18, half, 19, 20,000, whatever in there. Yeah, it's gonna be 20 or whatever. If it's 3x, maybe you know, if it's 60k, 60k, that's probably people I can't imagine 60k Bitcoin without just insane mania. I don't know. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't know.

Yeah, it's it's very interesting to kind of see this rocket take off and really, you know, things are still kind of, you know, not much has changed really in terms of like, you know, the public narrative or interest. Yeah, and so I'm looking at the trends chart right now for five years. And we're at about the same point that we were in May of 201 May of 2017.

And then from there we sort of we're just sideways on the Google trends for another five, six months, and the mania on in terms of trends Google transfers didn't really start until November. October, November time. And then it just really went nuts. So according, you know, if if we follow the same trend again this time, like I don't know, it it might take 100k before the retail like start starts really kicking in.

I don't know. Yeah, well, I what 10K did it last time, triggered it last time. I'm gonna throw this subject out, and this might be for another podcast, so I don't want us to dive down the rot rabbit hole on this piece, but the one I don't know, okay, in terms of you usually I'll take a pretty strong position on this, but I don't know. One of the things I've been increasingly thinking about is that the time period where we've been in with Bitcoin relative to the global economy and the overall global global financial markets and just general economy and that whole bucket, we have not had any type of downturn whatsoever in that particular

Market. In other words, there's been no, I think this is true statement. There's been no recession since Bitcoin really kind of kicked it, started and kicked in. There's been no recession. Well, it's been 100% QE. Right. So right. Well, well, you right. Among other well, QE, which threw like negative, you've got 13 trillion in negative yielding debt now globally.

And then you've got a situation where there, even if you use the metrics for calculating GDP within a you know, a specific country, and global GDPs used, but it's it's you know, it's it's a method where they come up with adding all that up. But the idea is what happens in a recessionary downturn.

I mean, it could be you could take the position that in a recessionary downturn, that would be great for Bitcoin. On the other hand, you could take the position, I'm just saying, I'm just throwing this out here, and again, I preface by saying I didn't want us to go to the back. Let's just do it. Let's actually like this topic. Yeah, let's dive down it. Okay, so so the idea so the idea, so the so the idea is is that you sit there and say, well, is what's gonna happen are are the core holders or just within the market of Bitcoin, is it gonna be a situation where some people are gonna have to liquidate holdings to get cash because you're in a downturn?

I mean, just basically. So, you know, what is it? Or is it a situation because of all the QE and because all the stuff with fiat and everything that's going on, because of that whole aspect of it, is it actually going to strengthen, or more people are gonna look at it. Like it gets into the other category that I'm jumping over to now, which is folks used to say, okay, it's time for me to buy gold or silver, right?

I need to get some hard assets, right? Just because that's typically how people look at it in a downturn that we'll be talking about. And maybe Bitcoin becomes the new one for that. So so start saying, hey, you know, we need to get into some hard assets and digital, we consider the Bitcoin to be a digital hard asset, a store of value, the new gold or silver.

So I'll just I just threw that out there. Yeah, go ahead. Yeah, go ahead, Christian. So I totally agree. I think that in a economic downturn, we're gonna really find out a lot about what the true Bitcoin market is. Is it this a speculative market still? Or what percentage of this is you know speculative market versus what percentage of this is people actually using this as digital hard money.

So I think it's gonna be interesting. My personal prediction is that if there is a downturn, like immediately, like if things are dumping, Bitcoin will dump. But I actually am pretty confident that after some some nice dumping that people who need Bitcoin will actually start coming into Bitcoin.

So and you can kind of see recently that you know, with recent Fed announcements about QE and stuff like that, both Bitcoin and gold pumped very similarly and moved very similarly. So, I mean, I don't know, I don't want to like extrapolate that too far and come up with too many assumptions, but that kind of indicates to me that there at least is a portion of people that are buying into this digital golden narrative and are viewing Bitcoin as a hard money rather than you know just magical internet money or whatever.

So I'm optimistic, and I do think that Bitcoin has enough liquidity for people to use it as a useful store of value, money, whatever. Yeah. Especially depending on how desperate their situation is. Yeah. I think the recession might be farther off than we think it might that that it might be.

I think the QE st I mean you can they can still lower interest rates again and they can pump some more QE into it and keep this thing going for another couple of years. I think Trump might bully them into doing it. You know, like so I think the recession might be a little farther off actually. But if it does come sometime in the next like year or two, gold or Bitcoin haven't in May twenty twenty will bring the stock to flow ratio of Bitcoin down to almost equal to gold basically.

I think it's better than gold after the happening. I think is it or is it is it the same now and it's gonna be better after the happening. I think I think we have one more is better right now. Yeah gold's better right now. So I think this happening brings it down to like about the same. So it'd be like a it's a good good observation. Two and a half three percent inflation rate basically I think after this after this coming happening.

And didn't you say that gold inflates at what one and a half percent? Yeah or something. It's referenced through Bitcoin it's in the Bitcoin standard and he referenced it. But yeah it's been over the last several decades it's like one and a half percent and it's never exceeded two percent in terms of the you know the volume coming in. Yeah.

So that's kind of the inflation factor. Well the other just real quick on the idea of when this would hit and this is this is U US based. And I want to make sure we understand, we understand we all understand this is a global economy, but if you look at the US you have a situation right right now where we're almost into July.

And the Fed has room to cut, to your point. And we're going into an election year, right? So typically if you look historically, you don't end up with a recession in in a in an election year in twenty twenty. So really if you're if you're gonna take a call on it is a predictor, okay, or a bet.

The idea is most likely recession's probably not gonna occur if one does until after November of twenty twenty. So you really pushed into first quarter of twenty twenty-one. Right. Okay. And that's just a Tommy world observation, right? Tommy world. Tommy world in my little world. So I have to say that it seems like I've talked to a decent amount of people that aren't necessarily involved in Bitcoin, but they're very involved in the markets.

And a lot of people are like 2020 is a target for when things turn bearish to them. Yep. Personally, I think that we like Huey is I kinda agree with you. I don't think QE is pending anytime soon. If anything, it looks like they're ramping it up again.

Yeah. But one talk that I actually was able to catch at the conference, and I think it was one of the most interesting ones, was Brandon Bernstein's macro conditions for Bitcoin. And it's gonna be available online next week, so you guys who weren't at the conference can actually see it. But Brandon pretty much just broke down what's happening globally and is concluded that it's extremely bullish for Bitcoin.

Yeah. So it was really a fantastic talking about it. Yeah, that was good. It was really fantastic, and you know, he really just put numbers behind, you know, what a lot of us are kind of you know, I guess assuming anecdotally. Yeah, definitely gonna check that out. I that's one that I missed. And we'll have to watch it on YouTube.

But I looked up the numbers. So right now the Bitcoin inflation rate per annum is three point seven six percent, and after the next halving it'll be one point eight percent, so that brings it pretty close. Pretty close to pretty much right around the same, let's just gold. So then 2024 it'll be half the inflation rate of gold, right? So that's just yeah, that that that's if you don't buy the digital gold narrative, you know, when it's finally equal, like inflation rate's finally equal to gold next year, then you sure as hell will when I mean why well you actually the narrative ends then.

It's not digital gold anymore, it's better. It's it's just Bitcoin. And it's better than gold. It's you know, so now I think that the digital gold meme fits because we're about to get to the same inflation rate as gold, and then twenty twenty-four, no, doesn't fit anymore because it's not gold, you know, it's even better. It's it's how you know twice as good as gold.

And just can keep getting better and better. One of my favorite talks is our good friend Brandon Quittem's talk. He was on the P2P stage. I didn't I did catch that one, yeah. Yeah, and my favorite part at the end was he had a slide that said broke digital gold, woke digital mold. Digital slime mold. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

So I thought that was hilarious. And personally, I actually I think that the digital gold meme is good, but I do think it does handicap Bitcoin. I think Bitcoin is a lot more than just digital gold. Absolutely. Yep, that's true. It's just one of the aspects, one of the memes that fits.

And you know, speaking of Brandon, there's just so many analog ways to analogize Bitcoin, you know. Digital gold is one of them. Mycelium and Mushrooms is one of them. Slime mold is another, which is of course a reference to like his article, which I'll link to the show notes, you gotta check out this graphic if you haven't.

But this he tells a story about these scientists in Tokyo who were trying to find the most efficient way to design their subway tunnels, right? Is that that that's what it was? Yeah. So they put some slime mold in the stations in the subways, and they mapped out over over time the growth of the less than 24 hours.

Yeah, yeah, right? Is that is that all it took? Yeah, you put they put like their favorite food in each station. Yeah. And they found yeah, just let them let them go. It's crazy. And so the network that this slime mold developed was even more like some significant percentage more efficient than the human design subway network in Tokyo.

Which is crazy. And it's the point being that these sort of organic decentralized networks are a fundamental part of nature, and that Bitcoin is is kind of following these natural laws to be extremely efficient. Yeah, if I can add anything to that, I honestly think that Bitcoin mining is something that people don't talk about nearly enough because Bitcoin mining finding the very cheapest electricity in the world is going to create an incredible network of energy production facilities that are gonna completely revolutionize the world grid.

Like this is something that people just don't talk about. But that by itself. We agree, we agree with you because we've covered that quite we've we've looked at that quite and the fact that a lot of it comes from from taking renewable energy that would be wasted and making it more efficient, right? Yeah. Like Bitcoin mining is the opposite of wasteful.

Bitcoin mining is actually the most efficient thing possible. There you if you are not efficient, you are gonna go out of business, you're gonna be out competed. And let's just like not even like let's forget sound the like the repro the you know the cascade effect from sound money. Right. Like the cascade effect from you know having a you know incentive mechanism that's effectively bootstrapping this energy production network, like that is gonna change all of our lives drastically and quick.

Yeah, I mean if if you look at human civil like the advancement of human civilization, a lot of it is is due to our ability to consume energy and leverage energy to be more efficient to produce things more efficiently and smartly and intelligently.

And that's why we have technology. And that's what yeah, so the more energy that we have available to the human civil civilization, the more possibility is is available to us. It's amazing. Yeah, I mean, just to kind of add on to that, like we've net there is no shortage of energy in the universe.

Like we can't even capture one, you know, one millionth of a percentage of the energy that the sun is supplying by itself. Right. So like this incentive to capture the cheapest energy possible is just it I can't like maybe this is just me getting cosmic, but I just cannot overstate, you know, how how incredible that's gonna be.

Yeah, and it just flips the FUD arguments directly on its head. No, it's not a terrible thing. It's actually an incredible thing. It's actually going to be wonderful for a human civilization to in for Bitcoin the more Bitcoin or the more energy Bitcoin mining uses the better. Like that's the argument. You just turn it on the wall.

Well, right. And the other part of it is as I understand it, and I didn't double check this for the source, but 74% recently, 74% coin shares did a yeah, 74% of Bitcoin mining, the energy comes from renewable sources, which is I think fundamentally hydroelectric power, most likely, and then you kind of go from there, right?

But the idea is it's in a hydroelectric power case, it's energy that would have that's just gonna be wasted, right? So how is that not efficient and fantastic, right? But you get the you get the narrative in the mainstream media that that they say, okay, wait a minute, how much energy is it?

And then they start comparing it to the consumption with a country, and it's completely apples and oranges, right? And then if you actually bring up to somebody, I waited a couple times on one on this energy because I've gotten into this on energy. And when you actually say to somebody that's negative Bitcoin because of the energy consumption, and be thinking that Bitcoin's a bad actor because it's it's not it's not efficiently utilizing energy, when you actually bring up that 70% from renewable that would you know, it's it's like a showstopper.

Yeah, they're not sure what to say then to you, because it's like, well, you know, hey, and I said this can continue from the standpoint of how Bitcoin's generating, so you know, that's actually a good thing, right? And there's they've got what's the term cog cognitive dissonance? Or whatever. There's insane cognitive dissonance in this phase and in the money space. So anyway, but that was just my point with that.

So and it's fantastic following on what Christian said. Yeah. And let's just assume that CoinShares is 50% exaggerated. Right. There's still 35% of renewable energy. Yeah, even if it's 15 or 20%. Exactly, exactly. So yeah, I mean maybe we're just super biased, but But we're not if I think if you just follow like kind of like logical steps in progression, you know, it it's difficult to see, you know, how it doesn't point to more and more efficient energy capture.

Here's a good question for you. What what was your initial impression of energy FUD coming into Bitcoin in 2017? Like did it concern you? I would say like so my journey into discovering Bitcoin and kind of like navigating all the confusion was very interesting. It took me about a month to become like a pretty hardcore Bitcoiner.

That's not that long. No, it like I don't know if I could pat myself on the back or something, but it was just like I got in when there's just so much hype, and I'm kind of naturally skeptical. So I kind of bought into the hype, and then I was like, wait, let's just like is there anyone saying something negative about this stuff? Like there has to be someone saying negative stuff about this.

And then I actually quickly discovered Ansel Lindner's show and then Tone Vaz's crypto scam. Yeah. And that like really refocused me. And then I kind of like fell down the maximalist rabbit hole and you know, started kind of like you know learning about Bitcoin more in depth. And I know within that first like six months I saw that like that website that kind of goes through all the energy fud.

And I'm a millennial person, I care about the environment. You know, I'm going backpacking and all that stuff. You know, I really, you know, am I would considering myself an environmentalist to some degree. So it did scare me. But again, like once you go beyond like what's that initial like headline and you kind of dig into it and you start learning about how the grid actually works and where mining is going it it's kind of difficult to it's difficult to buy into the arguments because they're just so weak.

Right. They're just so weak. And I don't know if you any of you guys have listened to the recent Tales for the Crypt with Marty and the CEO of BTC media, David Baylor. I have the snow, yeah. Yeah, it's a fantastic episode. But one of the best things that David said was that Bitcoin shows you its warts to begin with. Right. Whereas most investments, you know, they're putting this shiny marketing face out and then you have to do some digging to find you know what's actually wrong with it.

Bitcoin presents everything that's wrong with it on the surface and as you dig, then you really discover it gets better and better and better. Yeah. So I think that is very true with the mining it's very true with the monetary policy. It's very true with many aspects of Bitcoin 10 minute block time, all that stuff. It just seems like oh how does this thing gonna scale?

And then you realize that it's really like doing things so fundamentally and executing you know on such a granular level that it is quite incredible. It is it's amazing. And I think I went through I was concerned about the energy stuff too that was kind of like the one hangout that I still had about it in 2017.

The last FUD that I was susceptible susceptible to I would say and I think the thing that really want to make the world a better place. Hey, that's why, you know, that it's climate change is is used as a sort of a cluge, a clut a bludgeon to like in a in a lot of a lot of respects, you know that like there's serious people talking about it and taking it seriously, but it it is used that way for a reason because it affects people, like people care.

Yeah. And you can get people to pretty worked up, you know, from using it. So anyway, yeah, so then I think safeing, the Bitcoin standard gets into it. When you realize like the possibilities of what Bitcoin can do for human society, it's cheap.

It's cheap. Like, let's use a lot of energy. And then you realize, like you just brought, you know, brought up the next level is you know, you realize like the more energy we use is actually the better is better because like the more energy we have access to as a as a civilization, especially if it's the next layer, renewable energy, you know, and right?

And it's incentivizing the development of those technologies, those technologies are gonna become more efficient, and we just won't have to use fossil fuels anymore, which is good. That's a good thing. That'll be a good development, and Bitcoin's gonna speed that along. So not only are we, you know, using this energy in an absolutely like justified way, it's because of the profound like changes that Bitcoin can bring around, but it's also incentivizing improvement of our energy grid, you know.

So it's just win win win when you finally like peel all those energy fud layers back. Yeah. That was a good that was a good rant. I like that. Energy fud is always is always good to talk about. That's my number one thing I try to squash. Always squash the energy fud. It's a big one, yeah. It triggers no coiners so hard, and it is just could not be further away from the truth.

Yep, yeah, absolutely. Well, I mean, it comes to a simple premise of you know, look at these guys are stealing all the energy from everybody else. Okay, it's gonna take the entire country of France and they're gonna be doing that. People are like, oh my god, this is you know, and they don't even peel back, right? So I'm a I'm a big skeptic. I've also spent a lot of time as an engineer.

In plants, manufacturing plants that required extensive amounts of energy in order to operate them. For example, like steel plants. So for me, I have a visualization as to how how this how this type of stuff works when energy is utilized, and I it's it I know it sounds kind of kinda corny, but I have like a little bit of a framework with that, right?

So I mean I was skeptical. Oh well, Brady will tell you this. I was kind of skeptical from the beginning, you know, from the beginning on that. So what else we got on the list? We've gone through oh a couple of new lightning wallets I wanted to shout out. I did use them this week. I used one this week. But and I'm gonna have to use the other one very soon.

But Lightning Labs put out a lightning wallet. It's on Android iOS, it's an alpha release. It worked great for me. I bought some sats on Cash App on the train from the Oakland Airport. You sure go across the bay and withdrew to the Lightning app wallet, and it automatically puts your funds on Lightning for you.

It worked for me every single time. I think it's the transition. We couldn't use lightning to buy a clipper card though, right? No, we did not, yeah. But I did buy some beer, I bought a coffee, I played some Bart doesn't have that yet. I bought some I bought some art. I got 10 transactions here. All of them went through. You know what's sad? Lightning's working.

You're just gonna be looking at all the sats you spent on this random crap. And you're like, man, that one sat game of Pac-Man is turning into like a thousand dollar game of packet. Yeah, totally, it's true. It's true. You know, it's for the cost. It's for the costs. I don't I don't spend spend many sets, but I'm gonna have to reload and like yeah, so you know, I don't know.

It's it's for the cost. It's for the cause. I don't mind. So although I mean watching lightning progress is really incredible to me, but I'm actually still like pretty I'm not really convinced that lightning is gonna be immediately useful. Yeah. Just because I think the days of spending Bitcoin are still pretty far away from us. Yep, I tend to agree with you.

I'm very interested to see the development of earning Bitcoin in the next few years. I think that like that's the next paradigm shift is you know, going from mining Bitcoin to buying Bitcoin now to earning Bitcoin, and that's like the next stage of creating a circular economy. So I'm very interested in the project products and projects that are helping people earn Bitcoin.

Really interested in like Bitcoin as a universal reward point. I think that is a killer app for Bitcoin for sure. So like Lolly's doing that, Pi is doing that, although don't recommend Pi. See it looks like they I would not install it. They'd track you have to turn on location services and put it in your bank and all this stuff that you know I'm just not comfortable with.

But yeah, a lot of people are trying to like, you know, essentially utilize Bitcoin's liquidity and network effects in order to, you know, create a better rewards point, more liquid rewards point. So yeah, I'd much rather have some sats than like airline miles or something, you know what I mean? Yeah, yeah, totally. Although, hey, I've definitely gone some free flights, so yeah, they work out pretty well for you.

Maybe that's a bad example, but yeah. That's how we got here, right? Only a moderately shitty shit coin. Yeah, that's true. Yeah, I agree with you. And I think I mean there's there's lots of reasons why we're still pretty far away from people, you know, kind of spending sats in a in a like of the masses spending sats because first of all, it's it's it's not money yet.

Like it's not treated legally as money in a lot of jurisdictions, it is in a few. That's changing slowly. But you know, if we want to do it here, you gotta you know 15% if you've allowed you to held those stats for a yeah taxes. Yeah, otherwise it's at your income tax rate. That's that's a massive one that doesn't get talked about nearly enough. Like that's a massive disincentive to spend.

So speaking of news, I actually feel like if Libra launches, because it's not gonna it's a basket of currency, so it's not gonna be fully stable. I actually think that that could help with that legislation because now there's all these kind of like massive tech interests in changing how that works. But yeah, you No, you're a mind reader because I just was saying because it was within the month and I didn't want us to go on down the rabbit hole, but it's like it's like Christian's a mind reader because I was getting ready to just say we should mention it.

Well, Libra did happen this month, so we should probably mention it. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, go for it, man. No, just just the whole just the whole concept of I like to call it face plant, you know, coming up with with with Libra, right? And the and the global coin and just you know, diving into that. The quick my quick view on that is I don't think it ends up being a competitor for for for Bitcoin in terms of the way it's laid out.

So and it's you know, so anyway. Yeah. Will do you think the government will treat Libra like it does other cryptocurrencies, and it's there'll be like a commodity treated as a commodity or like subject to capital gains taxes? So David, the co host of POV crypto with me, he wrote an article about how Libra is kind of like the new central bank, and all these private companies are saying, haha, CO8 or sovereign money.

Uh-huh. Actually I kind of agree with that. It's a good analogy. It's kind of like, you know, these tech companies and these networks are almost turning into their own sovereign entities. And I just think that is incredibly validating and bullish for Bitcoin. Because Bitcoin's the real deal. Bitcoin's the open source version. And I just fundamentally believe that open source over proprietary every time.

Yep. So I think I too. I've heard several people say that that Libra's like AOL, you know, it's like the walled garden approach, you know, the closed proprietary approach. Or if you want to compare it to the protocols would be like like like the OSI protocols that were like developed as a as competition to the open source TCP IP protocols when the internet was being developed, and those were all, you know, like IBM and all the big companies were on on board this big coalition, they're like, you know, putting together this open stand open standards initiative, and it was the protocols that were gonna be the build the internet, and that didn't win.

That didn't win. I've also got the open source, you know, permissionless Napster TCP IP protocols one. Oh yeah. I mean, the day that they announced it, Maxine Waters, you know, called Facebook in for a hearing. So I actually did a tweet, I was like a short story about decentralization versus centralization. Right. So that was awesome.

Yeah, and the European central bank also are like in several governments in Europe, you know, like oh, we're on it, we're on it, let's regulate, let's regulate. Yeah, I mean, Libra is really much, much more of a competition towards crappy. Well, central banks, yeah, PayPal, that's the thing it's really payments more payments related, right?

So that's really what they're kind of. PayPal's on the on the Libra train. They're one of the things. Okay, so they're on there to be. Yeah. Well, and then just to get technically specific with what's you've got Libra, right? And you've got these big outfits are paying at least 10 million, right? So you've got now I don't know whether that in terms of upside for them, what whether if you pay the 10 million, you get the license.

Can you sell your is that like a token that can be sold as a corporation if you stake into that? Can you sell that to get value? Because what I'm trying to get at is is there any value with this global coin or Libra coin? It's similar to like with Bitcoin, because I think the global coin, right, which is going to be the currency for Libra, right? There's no upside in that, right?

Because that's pretty much going to be just a stable. They're not calling it global coin, are they? Libra.

They're calling it Libra. Well, isn't it Libra and then there's a coin called GlobalCoin?

No, the coin is called Libra. The wallet is called Calibra. Calibra, yeah. Okay, so I thought really weird the naming. Okay, that's so that's my I thought there were three levels. I thought there was calibra Libra, and then they were gonna call the coin global coin. No, the coin coin is called Libra. Okay, all right. I learned I learned something today. There was something out there about it being called global coin.

I think it was like a rumor for a while or something, or maybe that was a name. I well, I picked this up. Milt Dem had a had a good a good media post on Libra coin, which is really quite good. And it was it was in it was early, so it was in there, and I maybe I that was a good one. Jameson Lopez. Maybe I misread it. Yeah, Jameson dropped that fast, man.

Yeah, he read through their white paper and kind of just threw in his commentary, which is you know, quite valuable. Jameson's a beast. Jameson's phenomenal. Yeah. Man, the world is gonna get crazier before it gets any more safe. Yeah, no, that is that is for sure. That's for sure. Every day, I just like kind of like I mean, they there's a saying that, you know the future is here, it's just not evenly distributed.

And living in San Francisco, being in the cryptocurrency space, yeah. You know, people are riding around on little electric skateboards and one wheels and all this stuff, and like, man, like we are in the future. Yeah, there were VR headsets all over the conference yesterday, people passing around looking at stuff, you know.

Like the things you can just do with a cell phone in your pocket now. I just man, like I just can't help but you know, try to extrapolate like what is the next 10 years gonna look like. Yeah, it's gonna be unimaginable. It's a great time to be alive. Orange coin good, green paper bed. Yes. I love that. Is that I think that's probably that popped up this month, too.

Yeah, yeah. Alright, dude. Thanks for your time, man. Thanks for your work. Thanks for having us and hosting us twice now. Looking up over the bay, by the way, we should tell it looks so it's a little fog has to go off a little bit, but it's gorgeous. I gotta shout out though. Christian had us over for on his on his rooftop of his building here for the beefsteak Monday night that was amazing.

Is having us over here now to record this episode. Very gracious host, man, very cool dude. Yeah, I'm glad I got to meet you, man. Yeah, well thanks for thanks a lot for coming. My pleasure. And if I could add anything to the end, if you liked Bitcoin 2019, if you didn't go and you were FOMOing hard, Bitcoin 2020 is already live.

It's gonna be next March back in San Francisco. Tickets are currently $20.20. We're only accepting Bitcoin. So if you go to Bitcoin Twenty Twenty Conference.com, you can get that early bird ticket for super cheap. It's gonna be bigger and better. Man, that is a steal right there. That is a good way to spend some Bitcoin.

That's worth it. All right. Spend and replace. Good job, that's fun. Thanks. Good out.

High fives all around.

All right, big thanks to Christian for hosting and joining us for the June twenty nineteen basement bulletin episode of the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. That was a fun way to wrap up the conference. Let us know if you have any feedback, questions, or issues that arose for you while listening. You can tweet at Christian at C K underscore Snarks, S N A R K S.

Tommy is at Kennan's Call, C A N N O N S C A L L, and I am of course at Citizen Bitcoin on Bitcoin Twitter. If you find this podcast to be valuable to your Bitcoin journey, please take a moment to leave a rating review whenever you can, wherever you can.

It is the best way to help me bootstrap this thing right now. That's it for this one. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Christian, aka CK Snarks, member of the BTC Media team, the bitcoin half of the POV Crypto podcast, hosted us at his place in San Francisco and joined us for this Basement Bulletin episode in which we recap the Bitcoin 2019 conference, talk about this past month’s crazy price action, get into Libra and an energy FUD smack down breaks out.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast

Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop

Citizen Bitcoin Layer ONE merch collection

Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek

Links from the show:

Christian on Twitter

POV Crypto Podcast

Bitcoin 2019 Conference

Bitcoin 2020 Conference

Downloads