All episodes
Episode 64

Andreas M. Antonopoulos: Money as a System of Control, Decentralization vs Centralization, Base Layer and Lightning Tech

December 23, 201961 min

In this episode Andreas and I talk about the early PC and Internet era and why it is often analogized to bitcoin’s evolution, we talk about how money has become coopted by governments drunk of Keynesian ideology, how money is used as a system of control and how bitcoin fixes this. In the second half of the discussion we talk tech - first base layer tech and then Lightning. We finish up with Andreas’ vision of a bitcoin future.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. I'm Brady and I'm sharing my journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. How's it going out there, Bitcoiners? Thanks for joining me again today here at the dawn of the Bitcoin Renaissance. Happy holidays to you if and however you celebrate this time of year.

I've got Andreas M. Antonopoulos on the show today, and he drops plenty of fire as usual. And we get into Base Layer and Lightning Tech as well.

I am excited to share it with you all, but first, let's check in with GiveBitcoin, the company helping bring this episode to your ears.

So we're in the thick of the holiday season now, coming down to crunch time for gifts to give your friends and family. Why not add Bitcoin to your list? With GiveBitcoin, it's super fast and simple to give the gift of Bitcoin. Give Bitcoin is especially useful for those friends and family you know will need some help becoming first class Bitcoin citizens.

By time-locking your gift for a year, give Bitcoin helps new coiners avoid common pitfalls like being scared into selling the bottom by Bitcoin's notorious volatility or falling prey to the siren songs of shitcoin scammers.

As part of the deal, you are hiring GiveBitcoin's roster of outstanding Bitcoin educators to walk your recipients step-by-step along the path to becoming a full-fledged, self-sovereign Bitcoiner.

So go to give bitcoin.io slash Brady to send the gift of Bitcoin and support the podcast today. That's right, I've got a new audio-friendly ref URL. You can go to give bitcoin.io/slash brady to give the gift of Bitcoin today. And a couple quick shout-outs before we get going.

First, my merch partner Nick Ward and Layer One BTC. I asked Nick if he would work up a couple new shirts for the Citizen Bitcoin Collection, including the Unfuck the Money shirt, a fun and biting critique of this default Keynesian age while still being OPSE friendly. Check out the collection at Layer1BTC.com.

In the menu click partners and then Citizen Bitcoin. Layer one is a great Bitcoin only business and sales of the merch do support the pod. And finally, the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network. If you're listening to this podcast for the first time on LTBN, welcome to you. On this podcast, you can expect fun and engaging discussions that draw out unique insights and stories from the best and brightest Bitcoiners in the world.

I hope to be a part of your Bitcoin journey moving forward. And thank you to the Let's Talk Bitcoin Network for including Citizen Bitcoin. You can follow them on Bitcoin Twitter at the LTB Network and subscribe to the LTBN feed for more great Bitcoin content all in one place, including the Let's Talk Bitcoin Podcast, which started the network itself with today's guest, Andreas Antonopoulos.

And without further ado, let's get going.

Andreas Antonopoulos needs no introduction here. I'm sure we've all binged his YouTube videos, podcasts, and books at some point in our Bitcoin journeys. In this episode, Andreas and I

Talk about the early PC and internet era and why it is often analogized to Bitcoin's evolution. We talk about how money has become co-opted by governments drunk on Keynesian ideology. We talk about how money is used as a system of control and how Bitcoin fixes this. In the second half of the discussion, we talk tech.

First, we talk base layer tech, privacy, etc., and then lightning. We finished up with Andreas' vision of a Bitcoin future. It was an awesome discussion. Really excited to share it with you all. All right, it's time to dive in. Here we go.

I'm excited and honored to have the original Bitcoin educator himself, a man every Bitcoiner has learned from, a man who was definitely fundamental to inspiring my Bitcoin journey. Andreas, welcome to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. How are you doing today? I'm doing great. Thank you for having me on the show. Yep, thanks for taking time to join me today.

I'm really excited for this discussion. So I want to start at an early age for you. I gather from other interviews you've done that you've been defying authority from a very young age. You ran a pirate radio station in Greece when you were a kid. Can you tell us that story and where do you think that spirit of irreverence, a spirit which I think is a great virtue and underappreciated, where do you think that spirit comes from?

Yeah, I've I've always had a complicated relationship with authority, let's put it that way. And that spirit absolutely and almost certainly came from my mother, who also her entire life had a complicated relationship with authority, with norms, traditions, and expectations that society had of her.

And yeah, that that influenced me tremendously as I was growing up. And it transferred into a lot of my worldview of political ideology and personal behavior. So when I was in in Greece as a teenager, I ran a pirate radio station.

But of course, the reason I ran a pirate radio station was not to fight the authoritarian system of radio oppression. It was much, much simpler than that. I was a lonely kid who wasn't popular, wasn't athletic, and I was fascinated by electronics computers and loved music.

So together with a couple of my friends, we tried to figure out how we could become more social with the skills we had. And at the time the radio bands in Greece was a wasteland of public Greek radio, armed forces radio, Air Force radio, and playing patriotic band music, folk music and crap.

And so we scavenged electronics, radios, TVs, we got vacuum tubes and hand built. Yeah, hand-built radio station from first principles of how to construct a radio, and we transmitted.

The funny thing was because it was all handbuilt analog electronics, we'd start transmitting at 100 megahertz, and every 15 minutes or so we'd go up by about half a megahertz on the FM dial, because as the copper coils and electronics warmed up, the whole radio station would start drifting up in frequency.

So you know, it was it was a fun time. I learned a lot more from that activity than I ever learned at school. That's amazing. I, you know, I love to like you geek out about the early PC era and the internet. I was j definitely in the same boat as you. It was a time in my life that I get very sentimental about.

I think about it a lot. The late 80s, early 90s as a youngster. I had 2400 bod modems, BBSs, Usenet, IRC, all that, yeah, all that wonderfully clugy tech. You really had to like earn your way to gaining an ability to use that stuff. Yeah, even more so in Greece. I bet. I bet. What was your first computer and what do you look back on with fondness from those early PC internet days?

Another gift from my mother, who was a technophobe in the true sense of the word. She wasn't just averse to technology, she was terrified of it. And yet somehow she managed to notice that for me it was a lifelong fascination that I had this thing about taking things apart and putting them back together.

And in 1982, on a trip to London, England, she bought me a ZX81 Sinclair personal computer that you connected to your TV that had 1k of RAM or something ridiculous like that.

I then upgraded to a Spectrum, Sinclair Spectrum, a classic computer of that era when it first came out, and I taught myself how to program, and it changed my life completely in a in a way that still reverberates today. I found my passion. I found the thing I loved the most in the world at a very early age.

I was very lucky. So I was about 10 and a half years old, taught myself how to program. And yeah, then I bought my first modem from money I earned by teaching other people how to program in private lessons as a young teenager, managed to get on the internet and then built a business around it.

In fact, I built a bulletin board system and then one of Greece's first proto ISBs, UUCP, Usenet, FIDO, and finally TCPIP and SMTP mail, and tried to bootstrap the proto internet in Greece. That's awesome. What's one app that you built back then that you really remember?

You know, I think the first programming I did was building games. And you've got to realize that at the time this was on a computer that had no permanent storage. So if I wanted to play a game, I had to write it from source code. And in order to make it performance enough, that meant machine code and play it, and then as soon as I unplug the computer or turned it off, it's gone, and I have to start again.

So a lot of investment for very little payoff, which was computing at that time. Yeah, I remember like painstakingly managing the 640k of conventional memory that those early Windows computers are limited to, just like run a single game. Right. Good stuff. So I that early internet and PC era reminds me of where we were with Bitcoin just a few years ago.

But Bitcoin's come a long way in the past few years. There's you know much better exchange infrastructure, the accelerating maturation of the lightning network. Definitely had some major UI UX improvements, hardware wallets, multi-sig vaults, like cost and unchanged, making multi-sig cold storage much easier. We even had you know, quote, you've got Bitcoin, you've got shit coin stamped into the US congressional record.

I saw the United Nations are accepting Bitcoin Ethereum donations for you know a major huge United Nations industry or agency. So in that analogy to the development of that of the early internet and the web, where do you think we are now? And can you talk about the last two or three years of Bitcoin's development?

Yeah, it's it's funny when you hear naysayers say, well, in the in the first decade of the internet, it was much further along than Bitcoin is. And but they randomly pick a starting point for the internet of when they thought it became or started.

They're like, well, in the first decade between 1993 and 2003, the internet got much further. That wasn't its first decade, you idiots. That was its third decade. Right, right, right. Its first decade was 1970 to 1980. And not much happened.

In its second decade, not much happened either. So I think we're actually progressing much faster with Bitcoin. There are some areas in which the technology is moving very fast. There are other areas in in which we're moving much slower. And I do think that the greatest kind the slowest moving part of this entire space is the user interface.

Just like the web was constrained by the speed at which browsers developed and the user interface and user experience at the browser level, you can write as many protocol enhancements as you want, but unless someone takes them and puts them into a user interface that's easy to use and understand. And in the case of Bitcoin, easy to use securely, then it hasn't happened.

As far as the users are concerned, it doesn't exist.

And we're seeing that in the whole crypto space, not just Bitcoin. The fastest you can go is as slow as the user interface. And so I think we really need to find better ways to monetize development of wallets and build a better interface around wallets.

We've made enormous progress, of course, but we still got a long way to go. Yeah, absolutely. I think Lightning is really helping speed that along. The Lightning wallets I've used are significantly better in terms of the user experience. And there's some recent developments like Jack Mahller's Olympus that allows you to go from fiat to Lightning, Bitcoin on Lightning in a matter of seconds.

That UX is pretty impressive. Yeah, I think Lightning has some fundamental UX challenges that are much harder to overcome. And those challenges have motivated designers who don't need to work at the consensus layer, and the consensus layer of lightning moves a lot faster, if you like, in terms of the protocol and interoperability.

It's incentivized a lot of these wallet developers to try harder for the UX. Because Lightning is complicated. You have asymmetric channel channel balances, you have off-chain versus on-chain balance, and you have channel management, all of all three of which need to effectively disappear from the user's experience in order for the system to become a lot more usable.

So we're beginning to see the first wallets now that effectively hide all of that detail using some very cool tricks like splice in, splice out transactions, where every on-chain transaction is also an off-chain transaction, and vice versa. And automatic channel management, liquidity renting, and various other techniques to make it a lot easier to bootstrap a lightning wallet.

But the good news is that while the complexity of Lightning can be hidden by the UX, the benefits it gives you shine right through. The things that are difficult for newbies in Bitcoin, things like confirmation and fees and delays and unconfirmed transactions disappear completely in Lightning, and instead what you get is near instantaneous, completely settled, fully confirmed transactions in a matter of a second or less.

And at no fees or such small fees that you can barely count the numbers or pronounce them correctly. And a much, much smoother experience. Of course, with with Lightning, you begin to see it competing very effectively with credit card transactions.

My favorite thing is that the banks have actually regressed in a in a big way with their chip and pin technology. So now you get this incredible experience where you go to pay with a credit card and you stick your your chip card into the reader and it goes, please do not remove. Right. Do not remove.

Yeah. Do not remove. Do not remove. And then it goes, bing bing, remove, remove, remove, remove, remove. Yeah. It's it's really funny. But the whole experience now has dragged out into six, seven seconds, which in a supermarket line is is terrible, right?

And now you see a lightning experience is actually faster than that. So it's it's taken some of the some of the difficulties in the user experience of Bitcoin and actually turned them into massive strengths while hiding some of the additional complexity very effectively. I think we're going in a great direction with that.

And we'll see. It's not going to be the only solution, but it's going to be one of many, and I think it's a very effective solution. Yeah. I didn't mean to get to lightning so early, but I'm I'm just so curious about lightning and love studying it so much that it's hard for me to talk about Bitcoin and not shift to lightning really early. So we'll talk a little bit more about lightning tech and kind of get into the you know the weeds a little bit there later on, but let's take it back to just the basics to money.

I like to say that Bitcoin unfucks the money. And before Bitcoin, I honestly had like no idea what money really was or why or how money was so fucked up. Bitcoin is this you know practical instantiation of what money is in its natural state. It it's what money was before it's co-opted by governments who are drunk on Keynesian ideology.

And so Bitcoin is teaching so many of us, including me, what money really is. For those listening who haven't kind of taken this Bitcoin red pill yet, I'd love to hear you place Bitcoin in the kind of the historical arc of money and banking. Where did money come from? How has it evolved? And you know, and how did Bitcoin or how did money in its natural state get co-opted?

And then finally, how does Bitcoin unfuck the money? Yeah, great questions. I think but being being able to not know what money is or how it works is an indication of privilege of living in a country or state where the government isn't actively trying to rob you, kill you, and oppress you, and your banks are not directly linked to organized crime, only indirectly.

But that's a reality that a lot of us didn't share growing up. So my reality growing up in Greece was untrustworthy government, corrupt and broken banking system, devaluation, inflation, crisis, bank runs throughout my childhood.

And that's the same experience of billions of people around the world who had to know that money was broken because they didn't have the luxury to pretend it wasn't. What is Bitcoin in this context? It's going back to some of the original properties of money.

There's this incredible panic among the moneyed elite and controllers of money today that if people have peer-to-peer untraceable bearer money that they can exchange anywhere, anytime without surveillance, the world will go to hell in a handbasket.

Yet, of course, the reality is that we've had peer-to-peer, bearer, unforgeable, untraceable, and surveillance-proof money for thousands of years,

Literally thousands of years. That's how money always was. And it's only this recent dream that emerged in the 1970s of totalitarian surveillance and money as the only way to keep society safe, which of course ends up having the side effect of condemning billions of people to poverty and exclusion from the system, which only leads to greater danger for everyone, and makes a system that is very fragile.

That dream is recent. It's funny because in all of the conversations you have or you see with Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies in the mainstream media, cryptocurrency and Bitcoin is presented as this radical experiment, this radical monetary experiment, this radical privacy experiment, this radical capitalism experiment.

Not only is there nothing radical about it, but in fact what is radical is what is currently happening in the banking system. What is radical is the fact that after the final decoupling from gold in 1970 and the emergence of the totalitarian financial surveillance model of the International Monetary Fund and SWIFT and KYC and AML and all of these regulations that put a stranglehold on commerce, we then went on this wild journey

Where the monetary experiments have kept getting more and more and more radical. When I studied economics at the university, just as a minor elective course, I remember clearly the discussion about how interest rates could never go negative because that would even approach the zero bound.

Because if they went below a certain threshold of about 1%, that would lead to a deflationary trap from which no country has ever emerged that would destroy the economy. And yet, here we are now, the greatest radical monetary experiment, 30 plus central banks around the world in the negative range for interest rates, with the most massive amount of direct stimulus, the economy that has ever been contemplated over the last 10 years, injecting trillions and trillions and trillions of dollars into economies that are walking dead, that are

Zombified, and pretending that this is somehow normal. And we're the radical ones who believe that commerce and freedom of transaction is a fundamental human right, that privacy in every form, but including financial privacy is a human right, that everyone in the world should have access to an open, borderless, neutral, immutable, censorship resistant system of money that just does commerce, that is not concerned with geopolitics nationality, the games of nation states and

Their surveillance and power goals and manic dreams of control, and instead is concerned purely with enabling free and open commerce transaction and the building of a future for billions of people around the world who have been excluded from the current fragile, radical financial system.

That's what Bitcoin represents to me. It's actually sanity in a world that has quite clearly lost its mind when it comes to finance. Yeah, it is a radical position right now. And in this another thing I like to say is that we're living in this default Keynesian age where that's just the way things are now. And you know, at most universities, we're not taught about Austrian economics or sound money or those ideas that are that are talked about in that school of economics.

Yeah. I certainly wasn't mentioned to me at all. You know, there's a there's a few holdouts, a few universities here and there, but it's like 99% don't even touch those ideas. So yeah, it's it's a radical position to advocate for money in its natural form in this environment. As George Orwell says, at a time of universal deceit, speaking the truth is a revolutionary act.

And that's the bottom line. We are speaking the unspeakable, thinking the unthinkable, at a time when things that have no basis in history, that have no experimental validation, that where the goalposts keep shifting with these ideas that never have any substance behind them, are the norm.

And they're the norm and accepted wisdom everywhere, and they're accepted as not just the way things should be, but almost in this revisionist history as the way things have always been and a bedrock of modern free market capitalism, how it's always been how it always will be.

And that's not it's simply not true. That's not how things have been. And we have departed from all norms of economic thought. I'm not even an economist, but it doesn't take a lot of reading to notice that something is seriously out of whack. Yeah, it's just, I mean, money is so much simpler than these people make it out to be, you know.

And they they have these reams and reams of academic papers that justify these Orwellian practices to take control of the money, and you know, and we're gonna get into this idea of you know money as a system of control that you talk about a lot in the Internet of Money 3, and congratulations on the publication of that, by the way.

Thank you. It dropped about a week ago, and you know, I've listened to the audio versions of one and two many times during my rabbit hole journey. I've skimmed through number three over the past few days. And while Internet of Money One and Two touched on these subjects too, this volume seems to be more broadly focused on the ideas of the principles of Bitcoin, its potential effects on geopolitics, global economics, privacy, human rights, etc.

There's a lot in the book about money as a system of control, a way to co-opt all of these all of these aspects of modern-day human life. So you kind of just touched on the surface of this idea, but can you talk a bit more about money as a system of control? Yeah, so one of the talks I did is called Money as a system of control.

And it came to me when I was thinking about the purpose of money, and it's three fundamental functions, which are store of value for long-term investment or saving of wealth, medium of exchange for transactions, transactional aspects of money, and units of account as a measuring stick, if you like, of value against which you have this universal metric that can be used.

Now, it dawned on me that not only have we seen the introduction of a new feature of money, which is money as a system of control, as a mechanism to apply censorship, control, and power over the participants in the economic system, but also to do surveillance.

How, in practice, this fourth feature of money fundamentally undermines and breaks the other three. We have to make a choice. And the choice is between recognizing the fundamental importance of money as the as the mechanism for commerce for trade among people, for allocating resources and value in an open and free society, for strengthening the bonds between people in a society, the functions that are provided by store value, medium of exchange units of account, and how these features

Are undermined directly when we try to twist money and turn it into a weapon of control, subjugation, power, surveillance. The idea that society is only safe when you have total control over who sends, who receives, and for what purpose of every single financial transaction that happens within a society.

That level of control, total control, is a totalitarian fantasy. And by totalitarian I mean fascist is fundamentally fascist in its nature. The idea that society can only be safe if you have strong ethical guidance from an authority that decides what is good and what is bad and has complete visibility into everybody's life.

It's fundamentally fascist. And of course, free societies used to reject the ideology of fear that said that the only way we can be safe and free is if we are neither free nor safe. War is peace, freedom is slavery, etc.

And yet here we are, even in Western societies, even in free societies or formerly free societies, it is now accepted wisdom that the only way to remain safe and free is to give up all of our privacy when it comes to financial affairs to some nebulous group of people who clearly are incorruptible and perfectly good.

Because if you build a system of control like that, the worst thing that could possibly happen is that it somehow tends to attract the very very types of sociopaths who not only get to hold those levers of power and therefore escape the consequences, meaning they take themselves out of surveillance by taking over the mechanism of surveillance.

They take themselves out of the control of society by taking over the mechanisms of control of society. But then these very people, as sociopaths that they are, will be attracted to the ability to control everybody else's life. That's a very dangerous recipe. And yet it's become norm.

I think we're that system at the same time is one that is increasingly fragile. It leads to massive economic exclusion, it leads to poverty, it devastates the ability for social and economic mobility for people to do better and grow their their future and invest in in smart things.

It undermines all of the fundamental features of money that's one of the talks in the Internet of Money 3 which I have to say is a is a much more how do I put this spirited manifesto of privacy and against surveillance and totalitarian attitudes compared to the Internet of Money 1, which was a much more introductory optimistic view of the Internet of Money.

Internet of Money 2, which was a much more a vision of the future and all of the cool things we can do with this. And then Internet of Money 3 also goes into a bit and this is the alternative we if we if we don't do this right. With a touch of dystopia hopefully a wake up call that this this this stuff is important.

We need to fight for it. Yeah I agree with that completely. We have really a veil of freedom, merely a veil of freedom, a shadow of it now and it's it's so insidious this control of money, this co-opting of power through the control of money, because it's kind of hidden. It's money is half of every transaction between humans it's so it's it we but we don't really see it happening, right?

It's kind of happening behind the scenes but it's it's happening literally with every single transaction that we make. So I see that the separation of money and state is really a moral imperative, right? We have to fight for it. It seems like Bitcoin is a revolution of historical magnitude. It is and yes not in its technology but in the in the foundational principles of its architecture because what it does is it fundamentally undermines this centralization of power and control by stripping out all of the intermediaries and making it a true peer-to-peer mechanism.

And of course that's the aspiration, right? And as a as a real world technology with real world actors, agents, software developers, miners, etc. The reality falls short of the aspiration. And so when the reality falls short of the aspiration, you can look at the gaps and go, okay, we're failing.

Or you can see the other side and say, compared to what else is coming, we're actually succeeding in a tremendous way. And what we have to do is double down, strengthen our principles, refocus on what this really means and why it matters, and make the investment in time, creativity, passion, voice, principles, ethics, in order to bring forth a better future that we really believe should exist.

That means that we're going to have to fight the fact that people will ridicule, attack, demonize, and eventually potentially physically attack and try to suppress this system. It's already happening around the world. It's going to get ugly and it's a fight worth fighting for because the alternative is is truly terrifying.

We are going to move into a future of purely digital money where cash will be eradicated. There's no question about it. The only question now is which form of digital money will it be? Will it be centralized controlled surveillance money organized by an unholy alliance of the state and private corporations that are not subject to any of the norms of society, the laws, the policies, the due process, the civil rights, that you know we have fought so hard and our ancestors fought so hard to get.

And deliver essentially this this corporal fascist digital currency that is 100% the system of control, or do we live in a world where we have money f for by and of the people that is not controlled by anyone, where it takes consensus with everybody you want to interact with as to which rules you follow?

The answer of course is we're gonna have both. And a lot of people are gonna make the wrong choice. And not everyone is going to avail themselves of the opportunity or be able to defend their rights and to choose to use the open borderless system. And some people are gonna have to break the law to do so.

Because when when the law is unjust, then it's no longer it's no longer reflecting the consent of the governed. So we've got this very difficult period ahead, but this is a fight worth fighting. And I think that's one thing, the point you just made that's encouraging about the prospects for Bitcoin and this revolution that we're fighting, is that we've seen open source beat the centralization of innovation you know, particularly in in software, I think is probably the most you know outstanding example.

Do you think that that then applies to Bitcoin and money, this open source money eventually beating out the centralized version of money? Beating out no, I think the measure of success would be is there an ability to choose the path of freedom, even if others don't, even amongst islands of centralization and control that emerge from people making bad choices.

Just like you know, we now have the internet, which is, if you want, the largest repository of free access to human knowledge that has ever existed, and Facebook, Google, Apple, and the NSA. And both of those are the internet.

And one of them birthed Bitcoin. So as controlled and surveilled and under the thumb of central authority as it was, there is a little black swan incubator in there that was able to birth Bitcoin. And Bitcoin will berth other things. And it will be running in parallel with Libra and Digi DigiFedcoin and whatever other monstrosities are built by centralized institutions.

And a lot of people, a lot of people you care about, a lot of your relatives and friends, are going to happily walk straight into the mall of corporate statist and ultimately fascist surveillance money because it will be convenient as they do today with signing on to Facebook on their mobile devices and giving up all of their privacy and all of the other companies that do the same thing in the surveillance capitalism model.

But the goal is not for everybody to make the right choice. The goal is to have the choice available and to make it practical and possible for those who care, those who need those who wake up to take that choice. Do you think we can ever make Bitcoin as convenient as those centralized solutions?

No, absolutely not. That's the essence of centralization versus decentralization. It is always faster and more efficient to have a central point of control. Dictators make the trains run on time. Always. The problem is some of those trains go to concentration camps and you can't get off.

That is the essence. Freedom is messy, it's inefficient, it is confusing, it has no simple answers, it involves a lot of debate, it involves constant argument over principles. And it would be much simpler to just let somebody else make those decisions by giving you easy, palatable answers.

And they will make sure the trains run on time and everything is done efficiently, including the killing. Wow, yeah. And if that's not you know, invocation to fight for for this alternative, then I don't know what is. Okay, well, I think we'll stop that portion of the interview right there. Mike dropped that. I'd like to move into talking tech, the more technical aspects of Bitcoin.

So I thought maybe we could just start with the base layer. What is your stance on base layer privacy? So what what privacy-related proposals do you support? Which do you think have the best chance at making it into the protocol? Well, there's a number of privacy is a multifaceted capability which involves defense in depth or layered defense, which means that you can't achieve privacy by adopting one technology.

And it's not a static thing because privacy is an arms race, just like security, against adversaries who are actively trying to undermine your privacy. So you can s you can win small battles in privacy, but it never ends. And it takes every possible trick, technique, weapon, if you like, in order to continuously fight for your privacy.

That means privacy of the network layer, it means privacy of the transaction layer, it means cryptography for addresses, cryptography for values of transactions, it means various services that allow you to obfuscate the statistical correlation between inputs, outputs, and transactions.

And it means obfuscating the origin of network transactions. So to put names to all of those, confidential transactions, CoinJoin, Dandelion, Schnorr signatures, Taproots, TapScript, Zero Knowledge Proofs, Bulletproofs, Range Proofs, etc.

All of these techniques together need to be used in order to achieve stronger privacy. Not perfect privacy. That's not really achievable, but then again, that's not necessary. What we need is stronger privacy across the board for more people rather than perfect privacy for a few and zero privacy for everybody else.

I'm excited about some of the new technologies that are coming along.

This is a golden age of cryptography and cryptographic research. It's the golden age of zero knowledge proof research. There are more cryptographers working on more projects that are open source and published today than ever before. Part of the reason for that is because we've monetized the science and research of cryptography by cryptographically securing the money.

Easiest way to monetize something is to use money for it. So as soon as cryptography became money, it became viable to do research in cryptography at a whole other scale. And we are truly in a golden age of that research. There are some trade-offs. And we're beginning to realize that some of these trade-offs may be difficult.

For example, one of the trade-offs we have is the trade-off between complete strong secrecy of the amounts in a transaction versus the ability to independently audit and verify the monetary base and monetary rules of a currency.

So if you do zero-knowledge proofs around the values in a transaction, and there is a bug in those zero-knowledge proofs, you can introduce inflation in the monetary supply. So there may be a tiny bit of a conundrum or trade-off, if you like, between complete privacy of transaction amount and the ability to maintain a sound monetary policy.

Right. That could prevent Bitcoin from adopting some of these technologies. Yeah, the sound monetary base is very, very important to most Bitcoiners. The consensus seems to be that the 21 million limit and absolute supply is more important than introducing confidential transactions and the like on the base layer.

Maybe, yes. And that's a that's those kinds of trade-offs are the reason why we have multiple different chains currencies and tokens, is because these are real trade-offs where you can't just have both sides and not have to give something up.

And so there may be other currencies, other systems, other chains that find the privacy confidentiality more compelling than the monetary base.

Right. And we can find shortcuts and optimizations.

For example, by moving a lot of the transactions onto a second layer, we kind of get a lot of the privacy without having to sacrifice the auditability of the base chain. These are interesting questions and trade-offs. And I'm glad that we live in a time when we can not only ask these questions, but then test the answers in production on real large adversarial networks with real money at stake.

Yeah. I'd like to talk about that dynamic though, that the way that we govern the changes to the protocols. And I know forks are part of that, part of the way that we that we govern disagreements, right? But can you talk also about the way the balance between miners, full node operators, and developers that results in changes to the base layer?

How we decide upon those. Yeah, so I've previously spoken about the five constituencies of consensus. And the five constituencies that I identified, and that obviously there are no hard lines here. It's it's just a general framework. There is overlap between a lot of these. Miners or the implementers of consensus of the consensus algorithm, which might in another system be stakers, not miners, but same concept, software developers, exchanges, which represent the interface between fiat and each

Cryptocurrency, wallets or users, and merchants. So wallets, merchants, and exchanges represent the economic backbone of the network. They represent the economic activity. Developers represent, if you like, almost the legislature.

They write the rules. But then those rules are actually enforced by the consensus implementers, miners or stakers. So that separation of powers between these broad three cons constituencies, which can be broken more down into five different constituencies, have to work together.

Anyone who tries to assert power without the support of the other constituencies is quickly punished by the system in game theoretic outcomes that are not pleasant, sometimes not pleasant to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars, as we've seen demonstrated.

Funny thing is here, anybody can claim to have power as long as they don't try to assert it in isolation from the other constituencies.

The moment they try to do that, that power not only evaporates, but they pay a very big price. So the miners control everything as long as they don't do anything in opposition to everybody else, in which case they control nothing and lose lots of money in the process. The developers control everything and think they have all the power as long as they don't try to exercise it in isolation of everybody else, in which case they lose all of that power, etc., etc., etc., one at a time.

At the end of the day i think the strongest constituency of consensus is of course the economic activity none of the rest matters

You can write software that nobody uses and you can mine chains that nobody uses. And you will not be able to sell your coins because there's no economic activity. Ultimately, these systems are backed by the economic activity of their participants. And ultimately, those participants hold the most power simply by choosing to engage in this system versus a different system.

Miners want to mine the chain users want to use. Developers want to build on the network that users are wanting to use.

Yes, exactly. Without users, without economic activity, the currency has no value. The game theory of the consensus doesn't work, and the developers are wasting time writing poetry and code that nobody reads. Okay, let's talk a bit about Lightning. You're working on a new book called Mastering Lightning with Ola Lula Asung Takun and he's better known as Roast Beef among Bitcoiners and Renee Picard.

You guys are writing this openly on GitHub, which is very cool. So how's the how's the book coming along? It's been delayed. Unfortunately, some things in my personal life and other things have delayed it by about four months. I'm going to be doing some catch-ups starting up in January in order to make up for lost ground. I don't foresee that we're going to be delayed in our final delivery.

It's just going to take a lot more work.

But yeah, as with my previous books, open source from day one, collaborative community development, hopefully with lots and lots of collaboration from the community in Lightning space.

And when it's released, which is currently planned for the around this time of the year, just before the holidays in 2020, the book will be released under Creative Commons non-commercial non-derivative license, which means anyone can read it for free, can share it with others, and a year after it's published under that license, we change the license to a more permissive CC by SA, which means attribution share like Creative Commons license.

At that point, people can do voluntary translations, they can repackage it, mash it up, even commercially reprint it or reproduce it, sell it, share it, you know, put it to song, whatever they want. And we've already I've already done that with Mastering Bitcoin, first and second edition.

And in the next month, I'm open sourcing Mastering Ethereum fully because it's now been a year since its publication. So that's going to soon hit the completely open license. And I'm continuing to do that with my next book. I really admire that you do that. I think you're you know living those open source principles, and it's a good example for everyone.

Well, I mean here's the thing. All of the work that I've done has benefited from the very beginning from a very young age from the massive, massive contributions of hundreds of thousands of other people who gave their work to the Creative Commons and made it available for others to build upon.

Absolutely. So nothing nothing I do isn't standing on the shoulders of giants who came before me. And I think it's imperative when you work in this space and you're building value on top of the open culture of other people's work that you must give back. Otherwise, a one-way street of taking without giving is is fundamentally unethical, but it's also fundamentally self-defeating.

Right. You're actually incentivized to open things up because you produce a better product and it's you know it's it's free marketing. And people will pay to support that work and for convenience of a printed copy or a copy on your Kindle, etc. Yep, absolutely. Yeah.

All right. So Rusty Russell recently, I think just a couple weeks ago, merged multi-part payments, also known as AMP or atomic multipath payments into the Bolt spec. So can you explain explain briefly what multi-part payments are and why they might be a big deal for Lightning.

Yeah, so the first is so first of all, Lightning is a moving it's a moving target, right? It's a Lightning Network is a network that involves several different implementations for at last count implementations of the client that have a base layer of interoperability based on some standards called BALT, basis of Lightning Technology.

It's an acronym, of course. And these represent the base layer of interoperability. And in fact, Lightning clients and Lightning wallets can implement things that are not in the standard, which is one of the tremendous advantages that Lightning has, which allows us to move much faster.

They don't have to be in lockstep because they're not operating on the consensus layer. So wallets can implement new features, try them out, if and they're opt-in. Anybody wants can use them or not. And the first version of the bolts and the first kind of production version of the Lightning Network allows you to route payments along a single set of interconnected payment channels, a single path.

And that has one significant disadvantage, and the disadvantage is that in order for your packet to be able to, or your payment to be routed across a specific path. Every point in that path needs to have sufficient capacity.

And because the capacity is constantly changing, you may have to try two or three times before you find a path that has capacity when you're...

When your payment arrives at that particular point in the path.

That also means that it incentivizes the creation of fewer but larger payment channels, so that they can handle payments that are big enough. There was an artificial limit imposed on channels at 16 million satoshis at first, which was the maximum channel you could make.

So 500-600 US dollars worth of capacity, which also means that's the maximum amount of payments you can route through the system, because it has to go as a single payment over a single channel with max capacity available for you.

Now, what Atomic Multipath does is it allows you to split a payment and have parts of the payment travel across different paths and then get reassembled the same way that IP packets

Split your data into multiple packets, transmit it over independent routing paths, and then it gets reassembled at the other end into a sequence. The really important part of AMP or atomic multipath payments is the A, the atomic.

What atomic means in computer science terms is all or none. Either all of the paths go through, or none of the paths go through, and no one in the middle can steal one of the paths or one of the payments or have a partial payment where the recipient gets some of it but not all of it.

And that's critical. It takes a bit of complex engineering, but it's possible. It will allow us to have a lot more channels with smaller balances, yet be able to route a lot bigger payments with a l with a lot higher chance of success through the network, even for very large payments.

And I think that's going to be exciting. I mean, we're opening a whole new frontier in Lightning with this technology. Yeah, it's been pretty frustrating to have an invoice for let's say five million Satoshis, but you well, let's say yeah, you have 15 million Satoshis in your Lightning wallet, but you don't have any channels that are five million Satoshis, so you can't make the payment.

So this will this will solve that problem. Absolutely. And it's more like payments as packets, like you said, more akin to the TCP IP. Yeah, that's correct. And it's and it's only one of half a dozen very, very exciting developments that are being built on top of the Lightning network that address many of the different difficulties or challenges with the first implementation of Lightning.

For example, trampoline payments, where you don't have the final route to a node, but instead you use an intermediary node as your destination, and then that node has a final route to your destination node. So you can split the routing in half rather than having the source of the payment have to make up the entire route to the destination, you can have the source and the destination contribute parts of the route bouncing off, hence the name trampoline, a node in the middle of the path where the two routes meet.

And that also increases privacy because the source may only know the route to the trampoline node and not know what route goes from there to the destination. Mm-hmm.

Technologies like HODL invoices, which are invoices that can be delayed, where the other party doesn't have to be online in order to receive a payment, but that can be held for a short period of time, giving a node the opportunity to wake up to perhaps do a notification, sync with the network, accept the payment, and maybe even go back to sleep.

So fixing some of the difficulty with maintaining always on nodes. Unsolicited payments where someone can send you a payment without having received an invoice, which allows you to do that kind of asymmetric pay that we're familiar with in Bitcoin, where you can just push money to someone without them initiating and all of that with all of the other benefits of Lightning, high degrees of privacy, near instantaneous settlements, and very fast, very small, very low cost transactions.

So, you know, Lightning is moving much faster than people realize, and it's a full-time job just to keep up to date with what's happening in the space.

Have you looked into the spectrum protocol? I talked to Giacomo Zucco about this a couple months ago. It's like a layer three protocol for token issuance built on top of Lightning. Yeah, I've I've looked into it a bit. I kind of predicted early on that we would see the emergence of layer three and above. Lightning acts as a platform where we can build a number of application layer protocols on top of it, as well as additional routing protocols on top of it.

I anticipate we're going to see bridge protocols that connect Lightning Network with other layer two networks like Plasma, Raiden, Cosmos, etc. Yeah, to really create an intranet of blockchains. But I also expect that we're going to see application layer protocols just like HTTP on top of TCP for specific applications, and Spectrum is one of them, to do tokens and who knows what else.

Okay. Well, I'd like to wrap up with this question for you. In those moments when you allow yourself to indulge in some fun speculation and daydreaming, what does a Bitcoin future look like to you in the relatively distant future, like 50 years or so? I'd like to think that we realize the Internet of Money, that we create a broad, open, interoperable platform on which thousands and thousands of applications can run.

Not just applications of money, but applications of governance, applications that are financial and non-financial in nature, but fundamentally applications of trust that allow us to build complex interactions in societies that are now truly global at a scale that we've never done before.

And to me, the Internet of Money and this technology that Bitcoin started represent an opportunity to create a more scalable set of fair and transparent institutions that allow us to build more robust, inclusive and open societies across the entire globe that scale for the challenges of the twenty twenty-first century and beyond to a level that today's institutional mechanisms that are eighteenth century industrial society artifacts no longer scale.

And our you know, many of the problems we see in the world today are because of a failure to scale of the institutions of society that the eighteenth century gave us. And now we need to do better. So I'm hoping that that's the outcome. Applications of trust on a global network of trust that is the new internet of money.

It's a beautiful vision. All right, Andreas. I had an incredible time talking with you today. It's really a highlight for me and for my work on this podcast. Thanks again for your time and for your work. It's been an absolute pleasure to be on the show. And thank you for inviting me and have a great one. Take care, Brady. Thanks so much, Andreas.

You take care as well.

All right, that was a special episode for me. I hope you all enjoyed it as well. Thank you, Andreas, for your time. I hope you all will let us know your thoughts, your questions about the episode. Let us know if you had a favorite bit or something you disagree with on Bitcoin Twitter. Andreas is at Aantinab, at A-A-N-T-O-N-O-P, and I am at Citizen Bitcoin.

And that's really the best way to support the podcast as well, sharing it on Bitcoin Twitter and also with your friends and family. The podcast website is citizenbitcoin.world. Also support the pod by checking out layer one btc.com for that unfuck the money shirt. It is pretty rad. If you have any questions for me, please feel free to reach out.

My DMs are open on Twitter. I'm at CitizenBitcoin on Telegram and Keybase. And my email address is citizenbitcoin at PM.me. This week's open source shout out is Mastering Bitcoin Second Edition. Yes, Andreas's seminal book about how this whole thing works is available on GitHub. 140 Bitcoiners have contributed to the book via GitHub.

You can check it out at GitHub.com slash Bitcoin Book slash Bitcoin Book. Next up, just before New Year's Eve, expect a year in review basement bulletin episode with my buddies Tom Pearson and Guy Swann. We'll start the new year with drops from a couple Bitcoin authors, Yan Pritzker, author of Inventing Bitcoin, and Chiara Bickers, author of the new book Bitcoin Clarity.

Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

In this episode Andreas and I talk about the early PC and Internet era and why it is often analogized to bitcoin’s evolution, we talk about how money has become coopted by governments drunk of Keynesian ideology, how money is used as a system of control and how bitcoin fixes this. In the second half of the discussion we talk tech - first base layer tech and then Lightning. We finish up with Andreas’ vision of a bitcoin future.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast

Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop

Citizen Bitcoin Layer One merch collection

Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek

Links from the episode:

GiveBitcoin

Citizen Bitcoin merch at Layer One

The Let's Talk Bitcoin Network

Andreas on Twitter

Andreas' website

Downloads