All episodes
Episode 37

Aleks Svetski: Why Bitcoin Matters, Why ICOs Suck, Building Amber

June 13, 201978 min

Aleks joins Brady to discuss why bitcoin matters, why ICOs suck and his expierience building Amber, a bitcoin business. Aleks is an all around great person and I had a lot of fun getting to know him a bit better in this discussion.

Transcript

About this transcript

Transcribed from the original recording with word-level timing. Automated transcription may contain errors; the audio is the source of truth. Speaker names are not inferred.

Hello and welcome back to the Citizen Bitcoin Podcast. We're dedicated to being sovereign citizens of Bitcoin, and we're sharing our journey learning Bitcoin, hoping it makes yours a bit easier. Alright, I got another great one for you today, Bitcoiners. Aleks Svetski joins me from down under to talk about Bitcoin and his Bitcoin business Amber.

Before we dive in, it's time for the regular plea for ratings and reviews. We've got 32 ratings and a lot of reviews on Apple Podcasts. These are critical to helping increase visibility of the podcast and thus to helping me bootstrap this thing. It's the single best way you can support the show right now if you find it valuable.

Alright, let's dive in. Aleks Svetski is a strong Bitcoiner, a former trader and entrepreneur who is building a business again, and this time it's a Bitcoin business.

Amber is an app that makes it easy for people to stack sats by rounding up daily purchases and dollar cost averaging. And the vision for the business is a lot bigger than where it's starting right now.

Aleks also thinks, talks, and writes a lot about Bitcoin. In this episode, we get into why Bitcoin matters, why ICOs suck, and his experience building Amber. Aleks is an all-around great person, and I had a lot of fun getting to know him a bit better in this discussion. Hope you all enjoy as well.

Here we go. Alright, hey Aleks, welcome to the podcast. How you doing, man? Thanks, Brady. I'm doing good, man. I'm I'm battling away, but I'm doing good. Yeah, man. Your schedule is intense right now, I gather.

It is. It's it's it's one of those it's one of those months where everything decides to like you know coalesce into one month. So you know, I had a I had a original co-founder. I mean he was more of an acqui hire than than a co-founder, but he he was one of those classic tech people that you that you hire can really, really, really talk the talk.

You know, we had a few blobs along the way, and then finally I just I had to rip the band aid off at the start of the year and just removing him from the business has been a drama. But I had that, then I've got then I've got some other stuff that we're that we're doing with the redevelopment and redeployment of the app, and then I've got the capital raise happening at the same time, and you know, I'm writing I am, and then I've got to get my ass over to Bitcoin 2019.

So it's like all happening inside four weeks, and it's like Jesus Christ. And you and you've got podcasts to do, man. You gotta you gotta get the you gotta do the stick to the PR schedule too, you know. Exactly, exactly. Well, okay, we're let's get into you know, just your experience as an entrepreneur with Amber in the second half of the show.

I want to spend some time talking about a couple articles that you've written. The first one is is titled Why Bitcoin Matter Why Bitcoin Matters. And it's really put together as as a presentation that you were giving at like Bitcoin meetups in and around Australia, and then you published it as a post in Hacker Noon, and it lays out exactly you know why Bitcoin matters.

I think it's really well done. And I'd love to start just by just by like going through that. I think it'd be yeah. W was was there any particular points you wanted to hit on that? 'Cause I know like it it kicked off and I think a lot of people on your show have already heard about the whole, you know, money money story and you know why that's important, etc. Were there some elements that you want to do.

Yeah, no, I like I like how how you start the article and the presentation with the idea of the societal stack and you referenced this this Bezos TED talk that I know Gigi, who I interviewed a couple episodes ago also was influenced by this video comparing the internet to electricity. And yeah, and like the what we can gather from that analogy I think is a really good start.

Yeah, man. Well look, I remember I actually remember watching that that video the first time and it was like I don't know, early mid 2018, it was sort of like as the bear market was happening and I was like, holy shit, you could replace you could replace the word internet with the word Bitcoin here and it just sounded like you talked about it yesterday.

And I really found that interesting. So so I think human beings and this is sort of what I was alluding to in that societal stack thing, is is we're we're creatures that I mean the very concept of society is is based upon this notion of collaboration.

And you can build complexity in collaboration when people can specialize. So, you know, it it kind of ties back to you know, I understanding what are what are the tools, what are the mechanisms via which human beings can cla begin to specialize and collaborate without needing to inherently know each other and you know it it goes back to this point of shared fictions which youval you know Harari talks about in his book and I know a lot of you know Bitcoiners and stuff like that you know don't necessarily agree with you know Yoval's broader terms

But he he does really drive home the point of these shared fictions or abstract notions that we're able to create as human beings in order to in order to function flexibly and in large numbers and that's sort of that element there so so if we look at this you know society as this big massive collaborative effort you know from all participants you know what what are the basic mechanisms we use to navigate and make that happen and you know fundamentally it's communication but but that's a given like it's not gonna happen without communication

And that's that's with respect to every animal so I sort of say that that's the that's the sub strata like that that's that's the that's the given but but what's the first the most important thing that sits on top of that and really it's money and a lot of people misunderstand this so like I like to call money the most misunderstood and important social construct or or shared fiction or whatever the fuck you want to call it but it it it is the most important one and you know people who are sort of you know idealistic or have heard some you know blind you know I guess leftist monkey talk about oh you know,

Money's bad or money's evil or whatever. That they they throw the baby out with the bathwater that they they they're miss they're misinterpreting what element is bad, and that's money that is able to be manipulated and have you know asymmetries built into it is inherently bad.

So in that sense, they're right. But money fundamentally, you take that out, you don't have society, you don't have anything that we have today. You don't even have communities. There's there's no way to measure the input that we're putting in. And I'll throw one last little anecdote, which which I heard the other day. I was I was at dinner down in Melbourne with with a friend of mine for her birthday, and she she had a few other girls there for you know for her birthday and stuff like that.

And I got into a conversation with one of them, and she's from Romania, and she was like, you know, we were talking about all this stuff, and then you know, she started you know doing the traditional you know, the easy thing to say, it's like oh, you know, the world's messed up, and you know, we've got people like Trump in power, and I was like, hold on, hold on, hold on.

And then I had to go on my little you know, rampage about what's actually wrong with the world, and you know, obviously, as with all of my conversations, it turned into a Bitcoin education session. Right. And by the end of it, she she mentioned something interesting. She said she was watching a show by Seth Rogan.

I haven't seen this, apparently on Netflix or something like that, where it's like a parody on Star Trek. Okay. And I mean, I haven't seen it or anything, but she she mentioned something interesting. She said on that show, they've got this kind of like the that replicator machine where they can put anything in it and it you know, replicates it, like you know, you want food, replicates it, you want, you know, jewelry replicates, or whatever, right?

And what she said, she said the only thing on that within that show, so that they're like all on this spaceship, it's this community on the spaceship or the or the civilization now and the spacefaring civilization. The only thing that this machine couldn't replicate was the input to the community or the input to the civilization to the society that the people gave, you know.

So the in other words, the work or the value that they put into it. And that right there, I was like, fuck, you know what you just described. You actually just described money. That that that is what it is. That's what it is or what it should be. Exactly. Well fundamentally, right? And then what we need, I said is it is we just need so what money does is just gives us a like a ruler, it's a fucking measuring system for that.

And if that ruler is always changing in size or being fucked up, we have no way to measure the underlying input into society. And I mean, this gets even more profound when you start thinking about you know Bitcoin as this thing. And I actually think the most misunderstood element of Bitcoin, or the most under underappreciated element of Bitcoin is actually proof of work because it then ties Bitcoin's guarantee to the one thing on this earth and in the universe, as far as we fucking understand, and in physics, that you cannot manipulate, duplicate, dilute, change, or whatever is energy.

So it metabolizes energy and it uses that peg to the real world, that peg to physics to ensure that the input and the energy participants in a network in the system in a civilization and society put is not fucked up, changed, messed about, etc., such that you can build a strong society above it.

So that that's that's sort of my rant. But I thought I thought that was a really interesting anecdote, and I saw the light bulbs just popping in her head. I seriously reckon she went and bought some Bitcoin afterwards. It was fucking great. That's fucking awesome. Yeah. And you know, it's like, all right, so you always hear this phrase, money is the root of all evil, right? And that's sort of the right. Yeah, but it's you're you're right that it's manipulated or centralized money that is the root of all evil, right?

Because you're and the reason it's the root of all evil is because you are literally inserting this evil, the manipulation into the root of society, like you said, right? So as you've all Harari says in Sapiens, you know, we developed as the social species and we've sort of separated ourselves from the rest of life on Earth because we've been able to communicate in these sort of abstract ways that other species can't right and we can use those abstractions and build abstractions on top of abstractions and so forth over time with cumulated shared fictions and create society and this advanced you know much more advanced society than any other species could possibly

Create right so if you have communication as the absolute sort of base of that ability then money is right above it right and it's and if you think and I think money you know and you can you can make lots of analogies for money and like a ruler I think is a good one like you mentioned but you know we could also just maybe say that it's a form of communication itself right it's kind of like communic it's communicating value across time right absolutely to each other yeah yeah absolutely and it it it it's it's crazy it's what what you just said then is one thing I'll add is that

If you poison the foundation everything else above like how how do you kill a tree do you poison the fucking leaf or do you poison the roots right and that's sort of the epidemic that we're facing now and it's not i don't want to sound like a complete gloom and doom of like oh yeah the whole world's fucked up like you know we are arguably you know everyone is doing the best they can with you know what they know and sometimes what they know is to work completely in their own self-interest in the interest of you know what they care about so so you have this constant

Struggle in society of you know people doing what they fucking think is best the problem is as we all know some people have a really bad definition of what's best so you've got this constant struggle so so it's it's not it's not that it's all fucking bad it's that that there's there's inherent problems at the foundational level which you know if if we if we solve that you know you have this cascading effect across society where where a lot of other things that spawn from a you

Know an inherently flawed foundation start to start to fix themselves yeah absolutely and that's ultimately you know why bitcoin matters or why you know at the end because it's it's fixing it's fixing that manipulation that has been at the root of society for you know all these years it's it's super profound and you know there's this Ron Paul quote that I always like to throw out to kind of explain to people about the importance of fixing money that it's the that it's half of every transaction right there's a good and a like a good or a service and then there's money that you're exchanging for that good or a service.

Right. And so it it affects every economic transaction but it's even more basic than that right that just kind of gets to its importance in the economy. It's correct it's actually you know a fundamental to our society itself and the way that governments work and the power the governments have and that manipulation that they of the money allows governments you know kinds of power that that they shouldn't have based on like the rules of a sound money right and they get or even more profoundly the rules of a of a of a free society so if if we agree with a free society right yeah that that a free society is is a good thing then you know speech

Should be free and money should be free in the sense that it should be owned by the people and it should be open blah blah blah blah blah right all the censorship resistance borderless etc etc that you know we've all heard a thousand times so it's yeah and I think that right there is what we're fighting for it's it's it's not about you know getting rich and this I mean that stuff is all great as well like you know when you've got more you know if if money is this resource when we've got more resources we've got more that we can do and choice and options and everything are very power powerful for human beings but yeah

Fundamentally what we're fighting for is is yeah the removal of the structural flaws and the integrity of the broader system and I think that's fucking important man so important. Yeah and if you go back to the American Revolution you know one of the founding principles was you know obviously a resistance of tyranny of governmental tyranny, right but yeah also, you know, in put right into the Declaration of independence, or sorry, the Bill of Rights and the Constitution is the separation of church and state, which was a fundamental

Idea in the American Russian Revolution. And that was the idea that you know the church had this centralizing sort of power over money for a long for centuries. And it had started to affect you know the independence of nations of governments, right? The church was had undue influence over the you know secular activities of citizens in any given state.

And so it was necessary to separate church and state, and also necessary because that allows freedom of thought, freedom of ideas to proliferate throughout the society. It's not just one church that this one way of thinking is the only way that's allowed. So like similarly, Bitcoin is empowering and allowing the separation of money and state, which will you know, some in a similar way spread freedom and allow freedom to exist.

And yeah, it's it's a it's just an absolutely profound revolution that we're sort of at the beginning of right now. Yeah, man, you nailed it. You nailed it. Yeah, amazing. There's there's a bit in here about the unit versus the network that I think is useful to people.

Absolutely. Yeah, and I think I think it's a kind of a I hadn't seen the structure of the system presented this way. So I thought we could just spend a few minutes going through that too. Yeah, man, for sure. So what I might do is might pull it up on my laptop quickly, yeah, just so I can touch on the points more accurately.

So I think, yeah, what I was trying to establish with that is that a lot of people, especially when they come into the crypto space, they either think you know, you can I like thinking of Bitcoin as you know that that amazing recipe and you know that that we got right the first time.

And you know, GG talks about it in his 21 lessons, you know, the Immaculate Conception and all that sort of stuff. But a lot of people come into it and they're like, oh look, proof of work uses a lot of energy, let's just take that out. It's like all right. Or you know, some people come in and they say, Oh, well, what's this unit in here for? You know, let's just take that out and let's just use the blockchain, right?

They they go off and run and do things. So what I tried to sort of represent in here is that the unit and the network are you know inextricably linked, and in order for this to function and in order for it to be not only a money, but a monetary system, or I think I called it in here a monetary operating system, or that could have been in some other writing that I did, but anyway, I what I said was that they're they're inextricably linked, but we can look at the elements of each that that we can then I can say better better

Understand how they s not only support each other, but how they set themselves up for people to use either the unit or the network element of it. But but but you're always using the whole thing, right? So the unit is the piece that we obviously send around and that's when people talk about Bitcoin, it's actually what they're mostly talking about is these units.

And the you know, I kind of listed in here the elements that it must have. If if if we're going to have an ideal money, and I think I wrote this section just before before the Bitcoin piece, but I kind of speak about if we're going to have a money and a monetary network, the units attributes should be, you know, it must be impossible or hard to counterfeit, it must be hard to produce, which comes back to that stock-to-flow ratio, and it must be scarce.

And the more scarce or the harder that limit the better. And that's sort of when we get into you know this fixed supply sort of stuff. And then on the other half is is this network. So if that unit must be a part of a larger monetary network.

And if you're going to have a network for digital money that that's owned by the people, it has to, by definition, be immutable. It has to be shutdown resistant, it has to be censorship resistant, and it must be decentralized so that it's immune from manipulation and control.

They're fundamental to us being able to have a money that is, I guess, that separates money from state and that is owned by the people

And that represents you know, what the core tenets of free speech and you know, freedom and liberty actually represent. So those two things, you know, when when you start to when you start to combine them, then you have and that's why I sort of drew them out in the in the thing is two sides of a circle, you know, it was sort of the best thing I could think about when I do it.

And when you have all of those things, you have this network that does something really, really, really, really simple. It provides the function of send store receive, and it provides that as a guaranteed function.

Stop that function, nobody can manipulate that function, nobody can change that function. And you end up with a situation, and I kind of I think I likened it to the internet, which is the internet was designed after World War II for this, like I mean, the first thought experiments with the internet were designed after World War II to make communication more robust, so that if you knock out one communication tower, it doesn't knock out the entire grid, right?

So we created these mesh systems where you could route the packets of you know communication and what we were thinking back then, which became routing packets of data later, in order for robust communication to occur. And the internet's changed absolutely everything, right?

Now Bitcoin has that same sort of essence in that it routes it it's able to route value in a way that's unstoppable. So I kind of if you think about what how the internet inverted everything in the world, and people thinking like, oh man, we're not gonna build our shit on the internet, as if you're gonna build your website and your and your your business on this network that nobody controls.

No way, no one's gonna do that, right? And then you know, basically the net the convergent network effects that you have you know in in communication systems, the same as you have in monetary systems, took hold, and you know, people started to build on it, and then you know, you had the originally what were you know great companies like the Googles, the Hotmails, and all that sort of stuff of the world, they decided to build on the internet, make it more useful.

And I think that same sort of thing is going to happen on this monetary network that we're building because it gives a guarantee of the ability to send, store, and receive, which are the fundamental functions of a of a financial institution. But those functions right now are I guess how can I put it?

They're they're the purview of a few special organizations, and that inherently makes the system unfair, that inherently makes the system more fragile. It inherently creates distortions in the system. So if you can take those key functions out and make them a public good, then you what you do is you level the playing field.

That is that is equality of opportunity, not a quality of outcome, right? And then you allow the real capitalism to proliferate. You do good, you earn more, you fuck up, you lose it. And you can't change that.

So I think that is really, really, really important to understand. And I might I might tie this off unless you want to add anything there. I've got an interesting anecdote from an experiment I did the other day. If you want, and I can tie it off. Yeah, go for it, man. Go for it. That's great. I was with a friend. So I think the next article we're gonna talk about is the treasury article.

And I've and I've and I've met someone at Treasury who's you know, government worker, absolutely brilliant. I mean, she she sort of helped you know get get get that point out there to be honest. Like she she saw right through the whole thing. And I and I can't say her name, but you know, I've got a high degree of respect for her.

And we caught up and we're just playing a we're playing a thought experiment. Because you know I've I've got this mission to like every person that I talk to turn them into a Bitcoiner. I'm like a I feel like I feel like a Mormon, right? Evangelist.

Yeah, exactly. Basically, I'm so I was like, all right, let's let's play a game. Because she wanted to come and sort of question a lot of the assumptions that you know Bitcoiners have. And look, we get this in every space. Like that there's a lot of Bitcoiners who just come in and just say, Oh yeah, deflation is good, oh yeah, fixed supply is good, oh yeah, but but they don't know why, right?

Right. And you get that everywhere, right? Like that there's there's depths of understanding. And she's like, look, I just want to understand because she goes, I always hear these really, really weak arguments about you know why Bitcoin's a better monetary system from people who are just like, you know, oh it's fuck the banks, and that's basically the you know the logic behind it, right?

Or or you know, the government's corrupt, and that's the logic behind it. So so I said, look, let's let's play a game. I said, let's design if if we were going to design the best type of monetary system, so let's let's think about the attributes it would have and the attributes that money would have, and let's just list them out on a whiteboard.

And we did, I'm gonna put this into an article, so when I'm done, I'll shoot it over to you. But it was man, it was such a profound experience just watching her eyes just open as we were doing it. So we're s we're writing this shit down. We're like, okay, so she's like, Oh, I want transactions to be free. I let me actually I've got a photo of it. I'll I'll I'll say a couple of them.

It's it's hilarious because as we're writing it, I'm sitting there thinking, we're literally describing Bitcoin here. Right. And you're like, this is perfect. Yeah, I was like, so she's like, I want no transaction costs, it needs to be accessible. It should be open and permissionless, payments should be instant. You know, there should be a high degree of verifiability.

She was like, Oh, it should be neutral, so it shouldn't be inflationary or deflationary. It should be digital, digitally native. We should be separating money and the function of finance. It should be uncompromisable. That money and finance one is interesting, so I want to touch on that one. It should evolve with broad consensus, it should be free from political influence, it should be impossible to counterfeit.

It should be there should be no senior ridge, there should be very high throughput, it should be market driven, it should be liquid and deep, and it should be broadly held. And they were the things that we ended up listing. So then I said, All right, let's here's a black texture. I said, You can tick all the ones that the status quo represents.

I said, I'll get the red texture and I'll tick all the ones that Bitcoin represents. And you know, it was like two ticks or three ticks for the status quo, and all the you know, basically everything on the board was ticked for Bitcoin, and then there was only two really that we didn't agree on.

And that was the transaction cost, and then the idea of this neutral non-inflationary, non-deflationary thing. You know, there was a couple in there, like for example, throughput. I mean, that is, you know, occurring as you know, lightning network builds. So I was like, look, can can we assume that Bitcoin is can be defined as this multi-layer thing, which is Bitcoin and you know, for example, lighting topics, like, yeah, that's fine.

So I said, then well, that solves throughput, that solves you know, instant payments and all that sort of stuff. The liquidity depth and broadly held, I said, that can we agree that that's just a function of time? And she's like, Yep, sweet. So basically the only two things were the no transaction costs and the and the neutral sort of status. And we broke those down.

I said, I said, I personally don't think I said, if we want to have something that is digitally native, uncompromisable, unable to be counterfeit, etc. Etc. Etc. I said the only way we can do that is via tying that money to something in the real world, and the only thing that you can't counterfeit fuck with, compromise, etc.

In the real world is energy. So I said as a result, we need to have, and I said proof of work basically is that link. It's it's that bridge between the real world and the and the digital world. So as a result, what you need to do is you need to have a cost to a cost inside the monetary system in order for it to function.

So we ended up removing no transaction costs. I was like, sweet. And then the last one was the idea of you know non-deflationary or non-inflationary. And I don't I haven't done enough thinking about you know whether something in the middle can even exist. I don't think it can. I think that's what I was thinking of like, is that even possible?

Yeah, I don't think it is. I think it's kind of like you know, in life, you're either growing or you're dying, right? It's like the you know you don't have an in between. So yeah, that that's sort of the next piece. So I was like, you know, that that I guess that's an interesting thought experiment when when we tie it back to what I wrote about the unit and the network, and I wasn't thinking about it in that way when I was writing out why Bitcoin matters, but when I look at them, I'm like, yeah, shit, I've listed basically the same things across both.

And that that's like w when you actually have that moment, you're like, man, that this was like truly designed with like a ridiculous amount of foresight, wisdom, like it it is like it it meets everything that we as human beings could desire for money in a monetary system.

It's like it's wild. It's absolutely it's genius. It's absolutely an act of genius. Yeah. And I think that that last point, the deflationary versus inflationary, like I you know, I think there are going to be lots of people who are stuck on that for a long time. And like like, you know, there's arguments against deflationary currencies and I you know, I've I am what and I coming to mention this like every podcast now, or my listeners are gonna be like starting to roll their eyes, but I'm I'm what I like to call a default Keynesian because I grew up with these ideas, d wasn't really presented with the Austrian economic like alternatives, yeah, you know, through my life, through my education.

I took economic you know, some economics classes in college, all that stuff. Never had never was even sniffed those ideas. And so yeah, the idea of like having some perpetual inflation, there's lots of coins out there that have been, you know, launched with the idea of that we're gonna have this like, you know, one and a half percent or two percent perpetual inflation or something like that.

That's gonna be kind of the ideal amount, and that's gonna be more fair because then there'll always be some new coins to distribute around to the society and they won't get hoarded and you know, locked up and all that stuff. But you know, I think the Austrian arguments against the idea of hoarding, that argument of hoarding are very sound. I mean, we all have a time preference, right? And we have one limited one limited resource, yeah, you know, and it's our time.

That's what it comes back to, dude. That's like I actually try and when I'm explaining this to people, I try and throw the word I go, I didn't give a shit if you want to define it as deflationary, inflationary, or whatever you want to call it. I go, let's not even think about that. I just said what what we need to do is if if you just think about the universe, arguably you've got you know a fixed amount of energy in the universe, and all that we're doing is that that is as that expands, we're we're going finer and finer with respect to you know how much energy we access.

So if we think about this monetary system, and what you don't want to do is you don't want to be creating extra money out of thin air, because it defeats the purpose of having a fixed measurement of the amount of work or the amount of energy or input into a society.

So I just say forget about inflationary deflationary. If you take that logic that the monetary supply should be fixed and then it should be infinitely divisible on the way down, so it's actually I think it's not even about inflation or deflation, just deflation just comes is a byproduct of the fact that this thing should be fixed, which then changes the overall incentive of the system, which is one of consume for what you fucking need, not consume blindly for no reason, and invest to actually earn and invest in things that make sense

As opposed to just chasing fucking yield for the sake of not being in cash. So the incentive completely changes, man. It's it's it's huge. Yep. And that word neutral, like, you know, I think you're right. It's not about deflationary inflationary. I think maybe the best definition for that word neutral in this context, and in the context of describing a great money is fixed.

Yeah. Yeah, yeah. I mean that's the most neutral. That's the most neutral. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. So so yeah, man, there's there's the perfect money. We've already got it. It's here. Yeah, here it is. All right. Let's spend just a little bit of time on on your article. Well, I guess it was really a submission that you sent, right, to the Australian Treasury.

Yes. So this was an argument for why the Treasury should consider regulating ICOs. Is that basically what the what the goal was? I guess it was trying to wake them up. I don't know if regulating is the right word.

I think regulation is an interesting thing, right? So so regulation is is important, but I think often what we what we as human beings and in in the current format of society do is we you know build regulation so that we have loopholes for you know people to come in and take advantage of, right?

So what what I was trying to do with this was just trying and it was myself and Rory. If you ever yeah, at high at high side crypto on Twitter, yeah, yeah, yeah. Really good guys. So we sort of wrote this to just kind of call out the bullshit in the space because we knew that like you know, Treasury put out this thing and said, Look, we don't really understand this stuff.

We want to get to understand it better, and we want to know that you know, if what if this is still occurring or if it's going to happen again, how we should deal with it because you know the rest of society has these sort of rules and guidelines to abide by if we assume that that's the definition of regulation.

You know, we should probably you know have something similar for people that are trying to raise capital via this other method. And man, I just knew that all of these lawyers, all of these rent seekers, all of these scumbags were gonna be putting submissions in to try and play down the bullshit that was going on.

And I was like, you know what, fuck this. I'm writing something and I'm going to I'm I'm I'm just gonna like bring it up to the surface. And if it gets published, great. If it doesn't get published, well, at least I tried. And that's why I was so glad that that girl who was working there actually picked it up because she was like, Thank you so much.

Like you're the you're the first person. Like I actually got a call from them and I was like, what the fuck? The government's calling me. I was like, she was like, Thank you. She says, Yours is the first submission that actually came from within the space, but was an honest overview. And like, I mean, you know, we sort of like if we go quickly through the through the points, like, you know, there is this this was non-dilutive capital raising.

Like, I read another article last year during the heat of the ICOs, and I sort of said, you know, why we did an ICO at Amber. And I could not reconcile in my mind the idea of selling someone a unit detached from the entity that you're operating, which that unit's price is a function of some random market slash exchange somewhere on the world being traded by people who don't understand anything, where with no relationship back to the underlying entity or the product that you're building.

Like it was fucking madness. So I'm sitting there looking at this thing. Like these these terms of service and stuff would even say things like this, you know, has no value, or there's no guarantee of return. You know, like it would literally say in the term service this thing has no value. Yeah, but it was just to cover their asses, but of course, all the marketing was you know talking about talking about investing and all that stuff, right?

Yeah. Exactly, man. And that's what drove me nuts, right? So it was like this yeah, hey, by the way, this is worth nothing, but hey, by the way, we'll give you a discount on the price if you buy early. So it's not, it's it's it's non-dilutive, meaning there's no equity involved at all. And it's also there's no there's no debt involved at all.

I mean, it's not like they're incurring debt on it at all. You're literally selling nothing. Yeah, they literally printed money. So my my biggest gripe with that entire space was this idea that they used the narrative that Bitcoin brought into the space, which is for the people, decentralized, incorruptible, fair, symmetric, all this sort of stuff, you know, for the little man and all this sort of that they took that narrative and they fucking bastardized it by playing by by creating a set of Ponzi schemes that were worse than what the bankers did in 2008.

Like literally, at least those fuckers that you know the shit that they did, you know, with CDOs and CDSs and everything, at least there was some you know collateralization in there somewhere. You know but but and at least it was kind of you know to an extent you know the losses were there there was losses on on a lot of sides right so this thing is literally literally the printing of money by absolute deranged morons telling people to you know to

Just we're giving you an opportunity to invest in an early stage company and give me some money and then they took the money and they either ran off or what I actually think is worse is you know at least the guys who did an exit scam they exit scammed and they're gone right the ones that kind of really pissed me off are the ones that took the money built a business and now they're got they they literally got free funding for a business from a bunch of idiots and the tokens worthless and these guys have a business that they're running and there's there's no recourse there's there's nothing that it was literally charity

So yeah man like I don't know this is sort of coming like like the whole kick kick case the SEC sues kick for a hundred million dollars their hundred million dollar ICO raise last week right I mean this is yeah this is what's their their case is basically what you've outlined in this article it it is it is it's we called it charity without a cause.

Yeah, right. Yeah the cause was making making these you know the quote unquote founders rich. Correct was that's that's a little zero, like zero skin in the game if we're gonna use a an asymptalibism, right? So there was like absolutely no skin in the game. And I and I think when I like because I remember in in you know, throughout 2017 when I was sort of, you know, initially getting the idea of Amber and what I was gonna do, I was like, oh man, you know, there's all this ICO stuff happening, and I like I actually looked into it.

I was like, man, you know, maybe we should do an ICO, there's lots of money being raised. And as I sort of looked into it and understood it, I read a few white papers, I was like, what the fuck are these people talking about? Like not only like were they completely poorly written, like there was there was there was no substance there, there was no business plan, there was no reason for a token to exist, there was no reason for a blockchain to like nothing added up.

And I honestly like I took a weekend and I said, I'm going to figure out what these ICOs are about. I read 20 white papers, I walked out about 10 IQ points dumber by the end of the week. I was like, fuck this shit. I'm gonna I'm just gonna do it the right way. And yeah, man, so so I think that this this article was to really just try and illuminate that.

So that I mean, yeah, l like you said before we started recording, is like we're about to get another wave of shit shows happening. You know, we've just got the C for the E, right? IEO. Yeah, as you know, as Bitcoin, you know, price moves up and it's in its waves of adoption, you know, there's just it just opens up a lot of room and space for the just the insanity to can to come back again.

And it will come back, and I'm hopeful, maybe naively so, but I'm hopeful that it'll be better this time, at least people will be more educated. Maybe the mass media, maybe the governments will like help out and be like, yo, these are scams, be careful, you know. Bitcoins, Bitcoin's really the only thing, the only real game in town.

There's a couple other that you might be able to take seriously, but like 99% of them are absolutely bullshit, won't go anywhere, don't mess with them. Stay away, stay far away. Like, particularly like I can I can sit there and I can stomach arguments from people about you know things like Monero or whatever, right?

Like, because you know, like what one could argue that you know those types of altcoins, the Moneras of the world, might you know have a lifespan during Bitcoin cycles, but ultimately you know a monetary network will converge to unity, so you know, even those things long term just functionally shouldn't exist.

But to I even throw ICOs in a completely different bucket than that. It's like it it is literally a non-dilutive capital raise where you know people get fleeced and all under the pretenses of decentralization and you know fighting for the little guy.

And it's that hypocrisy that I think for me drives me nuts. And yeah, look, I don't think, and like you just said, I think during this next wave it's not gonna be as stupid. Because like I think we'll look back on IC. It's probably gonna take another couple decades for a mass social stupidity like that to happen again because people need to forget, right?

We need the next generation to come in now. Hopefully you know by that time if we're if we're living in a world where where you know we've we've got a better monetary standard at least that won't happen but I think more likely what'll happen is we'll have some parallel monetary systems so then you know we'll have less stupidity on the people that opt into the Bitcoin sort of standard and we'll have another wave of madness for some other stupid technological so-called innovation at that point in time but yeah look I think this next wave is gonna be probably more sensible we're not gonna have a hundred thousand fucking X.

But hey I've been wrong in the past so who knows. Yeah man it's who knows and we've already one of the reasons I wanted to bring this back up again you know to talk about now is one you know you wrote this this great article on it and but two like we're already starting to see now that you know maybe we've hit the bottom Bitcoin's price starting to go back up the fervor is starting to rise a little bit and I'm getting you know I got a an email from a friend the other day asking about an IEO an initial exchange offering and I'm like I'm like yeah and you know and I've heard this I haven't I hadn't haven't spent any time looking into them but I've seen it on Twitter.

I've seen the IEO and you know whatever. And I read a next web article about it. Just like I'm like what's the I Googled what's the difference between ICO and IEO. The answer is nothing. The only difference is it's it's initially offered on the exchange instead of on some you know prod projects website. You know and that's it.

That's the only difference. These are the you know but these they're already trying to kind of repackage this thing into a different acronym and make it more legitimate because it's being offered on an exchange initially instead of you know a promised to be on exchange at some point. Yeah, well the least they could have done was try and come up with a slightly different acronym, right?

God damn man, scammers scammers need it scammers need a little bit more you know marketing prowess in this sense. Okay, yeah, yeah. Well the sad the sad part about it is that it you know it'll work, and I'm sure that these IEOs that are out there, if they're even happening, if they are actually happening, are are making these people money.

So anyway, yeah, so the ADSC will return, stay vigilant out there, focus on Bitcoin, and you know, just be be patient. Be patient. Well these things should prove themselves, right? You gotta prove themselves. Just you know, just be patient. All right, let's get into Amber.

And this is Aleks's startup business. It's a Bitcoin business. And you know, as you heard, he's done his due diligence. I guess you were considering I mean at some point, like, is doing an ICO a good idea for me to get amp, you know, a good way for me to get Amber off the ground, and then you spent a weekend and realized it wasn't.

Yeah, yeah, literally, literally. Yeah, yeah. Which is which I commend you on that. And I really hope that I mean that I just think that that's simple fact and as that story gets out there will help your brand story a lot. Because yeah, because there it shows integrity, it shows that you were able to, you know, like smart enough to do some due diligence and think this thing through before just diving into the to chase the easy raise, right?

Yeah, yeah. So tell us about Amber and your experience, you know, get getting this thing started up as a as a Bitcoin business entrepreneur. Thanks, man. Well, I think I'll I'll touch on a couple things you mentioned there. I want to talk a little bit about patience, but just prior to patience is that there's a lot of you know people who are like ex ICO people or people that have sort of done done some funny stuff and you know the excuse is generally oh look you know you know we didn't understand what we were doing and everybody was doing it so that's why we did it.

And I my my response to that sort of stuff usually is if if that's the case and that was your your level of understanding in building a product that in some way, shape or form was involved in Finance or FinTech, you should not be in that business in that line of business.

It's kind of like a doctor saying, Well, look, you know, I accidentally chopped this fucking, you know, his kidney out whilst we were trying to repair his knee. You shouldn't be a fucking doctor. So I think what was evidently lacking during that time and is still lacking to date is is people and I'm not blowing smoke up my own ass here, but people who can sort of understand what what what the essence of this space is and then build a business to deliver what's needed in the space at that point in

Time. So what what I like I'm in the midst of writing and I am at the moment, which is you know, the traditional word for white paper without all the fucking fluff, right? So it's it stands for information memorandum, which sort of describes the business, the opportunity, the market, the team, the technology, the go the go to market strategy, the funding, the capital raise, the breakdown.

Your pitch deck, basically, yeah. Exactly. It's the long form detailed version of the pitch deck. Yeah. And in there, I sort of argue the point that you know, I have an entire section on on Bitcoin and sort of you know why it's important, and I kind of break down the two phases of Bitcoin, which is the on-ramp phase and the utility phase.

And the on-ramp phase, like step one, which is where we are right now, is getting people to buy some Bitcoin, buy and hold some Bitcoin. That's it. That there is no point in building complex infrastructure at this point in time in the life cycle of Bitcoin and the life cycle of the broader ecosystem here.

There's no point in building things that where the predicate for using those services is holding some Bitcoin or Bitcoin being not not volatile, Bitcoin being more stable in terms of in terms of price. And you know, so so like when I hear people talking about, you know, oh there's no merchant adoption and you know, shops aren't accepting this, like not only do they not understand the life cycle of money and understand that store of value has to come before meeting exchange and all of that, but it's just w we're so far from the utility phase that it's not funny.

Like right now, the only businesses that matter, and the only businesses that make sense that are worth building are on-ramps businesses that make the ability to buy and accumulate and hold and store some Bitcoin as simple, easy, and seamless as possible. And literally that's what I wanted to do.

Like, you know, the whole amber idea spawned from me just banging my head against the wall, telling people to buy Bitcoin and then telling me, oh fuck, it's too hard. What do you mean I've got a what what's a wallet? An exchange? What? Oh how come it's taking weeks to get verified? Like all of these questions, I was like, man, this is fucked up. So I was like, we I want to make this easier.

And you know, having having had a bit of an entrepreneurial life, you know, since I dropped out of uni when I was young, I you know did my first sort of stint teaching myself to trade derivatives. And I sort of learnt you know, I got my battle scars during the during 2007 and 2008.

So, you know, I learned a lot about markets and a lot about things then. You know, then sort of ended up on the gold silver bandwagon whilst I was building, you know, a sales company and then moved into renewable energy and built a big business out of that and sort of made my first million when I was 22, 23, and then got jacked by the government because they ran out of money when it came time to pay everyone their the rebates that they were offering.

So all the companies that did a lot of installs, we ended up getting paid 50 cents on the dollar. So I sort of learnt that sort of stuff firsthand, and I was like, you know, it was it was this interesting sort of build up throughout my life. And then so sort of after that I went on this mad sabbatical and sort of started messing around with tech. I went to San Francisco for a little bit.

I hung out with the guys at Singularity University. I just sort of opened my mind there. I and then to my everlasting regret, you know, I'd heard about back Bitcoin back then when I was in San Francisco, I was like, Oh yeah, that that's cute. And I just continue to buy gold. You know, right?

And only you just put a little bit one percent of that gold portfolio I know right holy shit. I was you know and then then my my life sort of took the path of you know building building tech company so I built some you know this payroll automation software and I and I and I learned firsthand how hard it is to take something that you envision in your head right that is like so simple it's like oh yeah this is gonna help so much like that this is gonna automate the payroll process for hospitality stores blah blah and then translating that into a product and you know coaching developers and designers and everything along the

Way to like bring it to an end I was like man that this is this is way harder than people from the outside look into and say oh yeah just build an app and you'll be a millionaire right and I was like fucking so that was sort of like my first foray about you know five six years ago whatever it was into tech maybe a little bit longer actually and you know I sort of built that up I sold it off to some people and then I the next big foray was this recruitment automation product which you know I've always been a student of you know just understanding human behavior and you know I guess these the what I like to call the frameworks of psychology because I don't know how scientifically

Valid a lot of psychology is but you know the rules of thumb that you get in a lot of them are you know that they're good enough to make judgments in life with so we're trying to build all of that into this recruitment automation software and sort of built that over a couple years and that that was like really you know trial by fire you know first time we raised money putting IMs together and all this sort of stuff and I learned so much and like I remember when I first you know started looking at Bitcoin again in 2016 and then the craziness of the of the ICOs and when I contrasted like the amateurness or you know the amateur hour that the ICO space was against like you

Know the degree of diligence and the degree of information and depth we had to go through for for you know this tech company I was like what the flying fuck is going on here like this this is like this is this is kindergarten and you know they're raising 50 million dollars these these guys can barely spell for fuck's sake and they're and they're raising 50 million dollars so yeah man and that was sort of a journey and you know I sort of took all of that experience you know that I've had over the last X amount of years that really primed me not only for Bitcoin but for for running a business that you know is about you

Know innovating and about bringing a better user experience to people I sort of taken all of that and have applied it to Amber and we were sort of talking prior about books I think and we mentioned Ben Horowitz's hard thing about hard things yeah yeah what I honestly recommend that book to everybody whether you're in business whether you're not whether you're working for somebody all that sort of stuff I recommend this because there's just this notion in society that you know people who start tech companies are somehow you know either lucky or you know or they're in the right place at the right time and look luck

And timing and everything has a huge part role to play like you know I don't take that away but man the shit you've got to go through when you want to actually build something of value is is sometimes like I look at it and I'm like, what why the fuck am I doing this? I should have just bought some Bitcoin, written some fucking blogs and just shut the fuck up, you know.

Right. Go through all this crap and deal with shit all the time. And you know, investors and you know, customers, and you know, this fucking typo on the website and this and that and like a million things, like you like cause because business is business is fundamentally like this, it it's a complex thing, and anything that is fundamentally complex, which has so many variable inputs and outputs, is you know very difficult to manage and bring together, particularly in the early days, and particularly when you know you're trying to acquire

Capital in the early days via methods that are more you know ethical and appropriate, like what we did. Like we busted our ass to raise that series A, sorry, the seed money. We raised a million dollars Australian to raise that seed round. And dude, that that was the hardest raise I've ever done. Like I'm going around, you know, trying to like raise a million bucks for 20% of the company when you know there's retards who are raising 10 million in 30 seconds for for pointless tokens.

And it was it was just a which just makes it that much more impressive that you stuck to that route because you I mean you were so convinced that that was the right thing to do. And you know, I'm sure you had a ton of education to do with investors now on on what Bitcoin is and the you know the opportunity there, and just like I mean, there's so much to understand just there before you can even get to pitching your business.

Exactly, dude. I would so I finally touch on that is when I go out there, I tell people that there's I need to pitch two things. I need to pitch Bitcoin and Amber. And if any one of those aren't enticing enough, I don't get anything. But if if I nail them both, then I generally, you know, can score an investor or score an investment. So so it's it's an interesting challenge.

So so that that's sort of this the story of Amber and the challenges that come with you know building something, particularly in you know, markets that are opinionated, like you know, you fundamentally can't make everyone happy. You know, you fundamentally need to build for your market. You fundamentally need to understand what's actually happening in the market and you know, really understand the broader trend.

And like I said at the outset is that you know, we're in the on-ramp phase, and these are the businesses that matter now. So today, Amber's going to be optimized for being an on-ramp and helping people accumulate some Bitcoin. Tomorrow, as the product and the market evolves, we will build features and elements into Amber that make it feel more almost like a banking app.

Like, because I truly believe that the future of finance is applications or institutes like or institutions or I don't even like to call the word institution, let's call it applications or products or businesses like what Amber is being access points to this new monetary network in the same sort of way that that your email client is your access to SMTP, IMAP or POP3 protocol in order to send messages on the internet.

So I think that's what these you know the powers that the banks have are going to be removed from the bank, pushed at the pushed into the protocol layer on Bitcoin, and then the best access points who are going to provide the best services and the best features and the best products in order to you know use that that fundamental money and protocol are going to be the winners in this space, and they'll evolve from being on ramps to being you know utilities, and that makes sort of our long-term vision at Amber Man.

Yeah, so Amber, I don't think we've spelled out the like initial use case though, the initial feature of the app is is just dollar cost average or yeah, go ahead. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So yeah, you nailed it. So the thing you mentioned when we were first leading into this section was patience, and you know, I've I've been I've been messing around with markets for many, many years now.

So, you know, starting with derivatives and all that sort of stuff in that time, then you know, going into gold and silver and then you know trading on and off over the years. I think trading is the prop probably the biggest waste of time any person can do. It is it is like unless you're devoting your entire life to it and you know you live, breathe, and eat it, and that's what you're and you have in a 24-7 365 market, right?

Like harder than equity markets. Exactly. Unless you really believe you have some edge, which very few people do, like most people just dilute delude themselves into thinking they have an edge and they're just you know sheep to the slaughter. The best strategy is just accumulating an asset with upside over a period of time.

Like I wish, like if like for all the fucking trading that I did and for all the big wins that I've had and all the you know the cumulative losses and all the shit that I've dealt with, if I just bought fucking ten dollars worth of Amazon stock every week for the last 10 years, I'd be fucking rich. Yep. But no, I'm an idiot. You know, I decided to trade.

So I want to basically take the stupid out of people's behavior and build an app which makes it as simple as possible. So you know, we use the spare change as one element, or for people who don't want to link their bank accounts, we're releasing something in the next two weeks, which is you can just download the app, you set up your BSB and account number for direct debit.

We've managed to secure a relationship there which is bitcoin friendly, and then you set an amount and a frequency and you start to you know you might be like, Look, I just want 10 bucks on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays to go in there at sets. Exactly. And literally that's what it is. So we're changing the interface to sort of lead with sats and things like that.

But we are teaching low time preference and accumulation as the as the thing that people should be doing now, not trying to gamble, because at the end of the day, like the I don't know if you've heard of the saying time in the market is more important than timing the market, yeah, yeah.

And that is that is so true. Like, this is what the most fundamental thing everybody should be doing right now is dollar cost averaging or stacking sats or whichever way we want to frame it right now with Bitcoin. That's it. Fucking forget about the price, don't look at anything, just yeah, set stats. Stack sats and learn.

Like if you're curious, you know, and you'll become more and more curious as you have more skin in the game. So yeah, basically, your your time would be much better spent just you know, dollar cost averaging and learning about what's happening. Exactly. So so to touch on the quick on the on the learning bit and the skin in the game. So when I was when I first designed this, like my whole thing was to get people some skin in the game because just as you mentioned, there, is there is nothing like buying a little bit bit of Bitcoin to be a driver to understand Bitcoin further.

Like there, like there is nothing like that in the world. So if we can do this in a way that is low risk, like that there's an element that I want to build into Amber called learn and earn, which is kind of like what Coinbase's earn bullshit is, but except you'll be earning sats for learning about Bitcoin money, monetary history, and all that sort of stuff.

So I want to teach people the right principles and give them sats. Now, for me as a business, that you know it might sound crazy, but there's there's actually commercial sense because I believe that the more people learn about Bitcoin, the more that they're gonna buy. And you know, I'm building a cust a loyal customer base in doing so. So that that's sort of that's sort of the mission at Amber.

And it's it's it's it's a it's a big goal, man. Like my my my sort of top level goal is I want to get a million people into Bitcoin. And you know if we can do that around the world, I think we've we've made a big impact, a positive impact to the world. So what's your rollout plan? Is it only available in Australia right now?

At the moment it's only Australia, yeah, man. So we've we've we've because but being that link between you know the traditional financial system and you know Bitcoin, it it means you can you know only go jurisdictionally sort of one by one. So the rollout will be Australia first, you know, New Zealand is going to be relatively quick to set up, and that'll be kind of next in the coming months.

We'll probably go UK and Canada next. Man, I the US, I would love to do business in the US, but at the same time I'm apprehensive about moving into that sort of jurisdiction because of the clusterfuck that it is with respect to regulation there's there's cash app that i would imagine is gonna be kind of i mean, I yeah, exactly.

I see I mean I see people basically requesting these features, you know, on Twitter all the time of Cash App. I want to be able to dollar cost average i want to be able to round up my you know my transactions and put that you know like acorns amber style yeah well i think i think the benefit that and look if i was to be comfortable being acquired by anybody i would actually be comfortable being acquired by by jack and thingo like at some point in time but yeah exactly like i was telling someone they were like oh you know what if coinbase wanted to acquire you i'd be like fuck that shit i'm going in man i'm like i'm with those guys but

Yeah so but like i think the benefit that we've got as a startup so so one of the challenges jack's gonna face in the bitcoin space is that it's a public company can't make the same you know quick moves and everything although the you know that they've got capital and all that sort of stuff so what what we can do is just play to our strengths which is the ability to really listen and adjust and change and do all that sort of stuff so I'm exactly yeah man I'm I'm really looking forward like 2019 is going to be a big year for us where we're you know the plan is to really establish ourselves and really just continue with the message that we had from day one which is don't gamble don't trade accumulate and you know we

We've been true to that from day one and we're gonna continue being true to that. All right one last quick question on Amber the name did it come from that Tim Ferris podcast with Naval and Nick Zabo like where Naval's like no the so it actually so he he was the so the original name for Amber was actually stash.

Okay. And you know, the idea was you know to you know stash your cash and all that sort of stuff. And we're gonna end up having a trademark issue with the stash invest in the US, and they had some trademarks in Europe and all this sort of stuff, and we're like, fucking oh so we had to pick a new name. And we honestly, dude, we went through 1200 names, like so.

This is another anecdote of how fucking annoying doing stuff in businesses, right? So we spent four weeks fucking around with a million names. We almost called ourselves kitty. We were gonna call ourselves nibble. And we're like, man, that that just sounds too fucking shit. Because you know, like nibble and kitty being like, you know, you know, your kitty of cash or nibble like taking bits out of little bits, yeah.

Yeah, exactly. Like juvenile or something, yeah. Exactly. It just didn't sound strong enough. So we ended up going through about 1200 names because what you need to do if you're a business is you need to you know look at you know what's available from a trademark perspective, you know, in every different jurisdiction, what makes actually sense, you know, can can you build a message around the name, like is the from a domain name availability standpoint.

Does it make sense? All this sort of shit. So we had this whole matrix, and we ended up settling on four names. So it was really funny. We had we had Dorado, which sort of the meaning of yeah, exactly. So City of Gold or whatever, right? We had Rover, so one of the elements that we wanted to sort of represent in the business was you know, exploring new frontiers.

So Rover was this idea that you know kind of like the Mars rover. Then we had Amber, and sort of Amber actually for me came like I was I was researching early forms of money, and Amber was used as a form of money in the early days. I wasn't even thinking about the amber, the what how it preserves at that point in time, right?

So that was how the name originally came on there, and then and then the th the th the fourth one was really funny. It was salmon the fish, right? Uh-huh. And that one was like so Dorada had a bit of meaning, Rover had a bit of meaning, Amber had a bit of meaning, and salmon was like the one which is like fuck it, like it's got no meaning.

So it came out like one of the guys was like saying something stupid, and I was like, I'll slap you with a fish. And I was like, Oh, how about we call it salmon? Yeah, yeah, yeah. You gotta you gotta throw one of those in the final choice. Yeah, right. And literally the last two was like between Salmon and Amber, and I'm so glad fucking Amber won out, right?

Yeah, and that was it made me think of that that episode from that Tim Ferris podcast with Nick Zabo and Naval Ravikant, and Naval uses the analogy of Amber to describe proof of work, how it just proof of work deposits these layers of amber, and it gets you know stronger and stronger and larger and larger, and like every you know, transactions that are toward the you know the middle of that piece of amber are you know that much safer, right?

Yeah, and yeah, so as we as we sort of dive deeper on amber, so that was one of the other ones that came out. And then and another one that came out is that amber is something so so not only in the analogy of Bitcoin, but also in the analogy of just preserving something. So if if Amber's this place where you can accumulate and you know preserve your wealth, like that that's sort of a good story as well.

So yeah, man, like I think serendipity, you know, like I literally think that was like the stars aligned in some way, shape, or form. And I think it's a good name, it's it's easy to remember. And it's it's broad enough to be with us for a long time. I think you know if you're trying to build like what I want to do with Amber longer term is like an access point for a financial system.

Maybe stash isn't the best name. Right. Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I think Amber's a great name. All right, let's finish up with this because I know you have to get back to your entrepreneurial duties. What does a Bitcoin future look like to you in 50 years? Oh shit, yes, this question.

Yeah, it's a hard one. Yeah, it is, man. It it's like it's it's so easy to go down the cliche path, right? It's like oh yeah, we'll have a new monetary network and you know things will be more robust and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. So I don't know. I'm actually unclear as to what the world's gonna look like in 50 years.

Like I and I kind of use the analogy of you know, it's either gonna be a Star Trek future or a terminator future. We've got an opportunity now to like kind of like you know, the fork in the road is right ahead. And which way are we gonna take? Because the differentiation right now is really small, but it's gonna be quite large later on.

So I'm you know, I my personal guess is that you know, the more pragmatic side of me thinks that Bitcoin is probably gonna be a bit more of a parallel monetary infrastructure. And maybe I can use Naval had a really interesting tweet ages ago, and he was like, the future of the world is gonna be these large homogenous fucking states, authoritarian states separated by these small free jurisdictions that are protected, protected by drones, basically.

Yeah, so they're technologically advanced and sophisticated enough to protect themselves, but you know, there's this like pockets of freedom in a world full of slavery. So I don't know, and I'm ho and I and I hope that that's sort of not the way things sort of develop. But I mean the evidence and the insanity in the world that we see today sort of points to like s some really weird decisions, like you know, whether you look at China and the social credit system and you know shit that's happening all around the place.

Like it's it's it's really nuts, man. So so my hope is that you know, you we're never gonna solve everything as a society as a species and as a society, you know, things are gonna continue to evolve and develop. So so my hope is that in 50 years, you know, I mean I'm sure Bitcoin will have passed at least in you know US dollar nominal terms, you know, 10, 20, 30, 40 trillion in network value.

So I think that's definitely a given. And I think we'll have a much more sophisticated financial infrastructure and financial system, and one that, you know, so you'll so you'll have like an element of the race that is that is more functional, prudent, you know, like robust, etc.

You know, so you'll have like a I think the Bitcoiners and the Bitcoin ecosystem will become, you know, the elites of the world and elite in the good sense. Like I sort of saw Jimmy Song put up a tweet the other day saying, Oh, you know, Bitcoin's about taking away from the elites. And I was like, maybe not the elites, I think it's the rent seekers who are disguised as elites, because I think elites are very important in the world because the definition of elite is to be the best you can fucking possibly be.

And I think a system like Bitcoin gives an opportunity for people to be the best they can possibly be without being, you know, drowned by you know the shit around. So maybe this sort of battle between this legacy nation-state system and this sort of decentralized self-sovereign system that Bitcoin is going to make pot or is making possible right now and will continue to for into the you know long-term future, we hope.

And that's cool. Sort of like that that battle will sort of it maybe be, you know, maybe centuries long and drawn out and not you know, there's there's going to be a lot of and obviously a lot of incentive for nation states to preserve their power, and they have a lot of power that's you know, not necessarily monet, I mean just monetary power, but also power of force, military force and all that.

So it's gonna be it's gonna be interesting for sure. And I think this is gonna be a fight, bro. This is gonna be a fight. And I think there's no two ways about it. And like, you know, when people sort of say, oh, you know, how can you get so passionate about some you know tech thing? It's like, man, this is so much more. And you know, when when I when I look at my life and my my personal makeup, it's like, man, you know, we're gonna need people who are not only evangelists, but let's just call it soldiers on the front line who are willing to sort of continue the good fight, because if we don't, then guess what?

This whole thing's gonna be fucking 1984 dystopian, and you know, we're all gonna be, you know. I didn't want to think about that, man. It's it's it's insane. Yeah, well, we have we have a way out, we have an option and we're gonna keep working, we're gonna keep working on it. And we're in these days now where sort of we're still sort of under the radar, but we've got to be thinking about these on 50 year, you know, this kind of that's why I like to ask this question.

We gotta be thinking about, you know, 50-year time frames kind of thing here, because this is a this is a big revolutionary opportunity here, and that fork in the road that you talked about, right? Like it's you know, that that's where we are, we're at that sort of inflection point now. And so it's it's important for us while we're really like looking at all the details of the protocol and everything, and that's important too to keep our eye on on that ball.

We've also got to kind of expand our horizons and think about you know, how does this unfold over the next over the coming decades, you know, for all of us and our family and our you know, our our kids and the and future generations of humans. Absolutely, man. And that's why, you know what? I always also commend you and you know, like the people that are like Stefan and all that sort of stuff that are doing these podcasts, like bringing this information to people, man.

It's absolutely phenomenal. Like I know I dabbled with doing a podcast sort of you know last year or whatever it was, and I've and I've done a couple cool apps, but you know, my focus is on doing amber as opposed to doing podcasts. So, like, you know, what what you guys are doing with these is absolutely phenomenal, man, because you th these are the things, you know, like we all each play our part.

You know, I'm out there building an on-rap, you guys are out there educating, like it's it's it's amazing, bro. So I really really appreciate it. Really looking forward to meeting you in person in a couple of weeks, man. I'll be out in San Francisco for the conference. So I'll see you there and we'll hang out. Yeah, 100%, man. That'll be awesome.

Yeah, all right. Well, thanks for your time today, man, and keep up the great work. Bye, brother. Take care, man. You too. All right, that was some fire right there. A great episode and lots of fodder for you to continue the discussion with me and Aleks on Twitter.

Let us know what you thought by replying to my thread for this episode or just tagging us both. Aleks is at Aleks Svetski. That's at A-L E K S V E T S K I. And I am at Citizen Bitcoin. Hit us up. I would love to hear your thoughts, feedback, takes, and any questions that might have arisen for you while listening to this episode.

If you got this far in the app, chances are you appreciated it, and I'd appreciate it if you could return the favor with a rating and review on Apple Podcasts or wherever you can rate and review the pod. Alright, that's it for this week. Take care out there, Bitcoiners, wherever you happen to be in the world.

FROM THE ORIGINAL EPISODE

Episode notes

Aleks joins Brady to discuss why bitcoin matters, why ICOs suck and his expierience building Amber, a bitcoin business. Aleks is an all around great person and I had a lot of fun getting to know him a bit better in this discussion.

Citizen Bitcoin on Twitter

Citizen Bitcoin Podcast

Citizen Bitcoin Lightning Shop

Music: Moon in the Sky by Hobotek

Links from the show:

Amber

Aleks’ work on Hacker Noon

Why Bitcoin Matters by Aleks

ICO Submission to the Australian Treasury

Gigi’s 21 Lessons

Gigi’s Citizen Bitcoin Episode

Downloads